The Early History of India

Appendix A

The Age of the Purāṇas

The Early History of India, Vincent A. Smith, 1924 · from page 22 · about 5 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

H. H. Wilson, misunderstanding certain passages in the Purāṇas as referring to the Muhammadans, enunciated the opinion that the Vishṇu Purāṇa was composed in or about A. D. 1045. The error, excusable in Wilson’s time, unfortunately continued to be repeated frequently, although refuted by patent facts many years ago.1 The persistent repetition of Wilson’s mistake renders it desirable to bring together a few easily intelligible and decisive proofs that the Purāṇas are very much older than he supposed.

Albērūnī, who wrote his scientific account of India in A. D. 1030, gives a list of the eighteen Purāṇas ‘ composed by the so-called Rishis ’, and had actually seen three of them, namely parts of the Matsya, Āditya, and Vāyu. He also gives a variant list of the eighteen works, as named in the Vishṇu Purāṇa.1 It is, therefore, certain that in A. D. 1030 the Purāṇas were, as now, eighteen in number, and were regarded as coming down from immemorial antiquity when the mythical Ṛishis lived.

Bāṇa, the author of the Harsha-Charita, or panegyric on King Harsha, who wrote about A. D. 620, carries the proof of the antiquity of the Purāṇas four centuries further back. When he went home to his village on the Sōn river, in the country now known as the Shāhābād District, he listened to Sudṛishṭi, who read ‘with a chant’ the Purāṇa described as pavanaprokta which may be identified with either the Vāyu or the Brahmāṇḍa.2 Dr. Führer believed that he could prove the use by Bāṇa of the Agni, Bhāgavata, and Mārkaṇḍeya Purāṇas, as well as the Vāyu.3

Independent proof of the existence of the Skanda Purāṇa at the same period is afforded by a Bengal manuscript of that work, ‘written in Gupta hand, to which as early a date as the middle of the seventh century can be assigned on palaeographical grounds.’4

The Purāṇas in some form were well known to the author of the ‘Questions of Milinda’ (Milindapañha) as ancient sacred writings grouped with the Vēdas and epic poems. Book I of that work, in which the first reference occurs, is undoubtedly part of the original composition, and was almost certainly composed earlier than A. D. 300.5

Many other early quotations from, or references to, the Purāṇas have been collected by Bühler, who points out that ‘the account of the future kings in the Vāyupurāṇa, Vishṇupurāṇa, Matsyapurāṇa, and Brahmāṇḍapurāṇa seems to stop with the imperial Guptas and their contemporaries’.6 Bühler speaks of ‘future kings’, because all the historical statements of the Purāṇas are given in the form of prophecy, in order to maintain the appearance of great antiquity in the books, which in their oldest forms were undoubtedly very ancient.

Mr. F. E. Pargiter in his valuable work, The Dynasties of the Kali Age (Clarendon Press, 1913), has succeeded in obtaining more definite results. He suggests that the Bhavishya Purāṇa in its early form was the original authority from which the Matsya, Vāyu, and Brahmāṇḍa Purāṇas derived their dynastic lists. The Vāyu and Brahmāṇḍa were originally one, and have become differentiated. The versions of the lists as now found in the Matsya, Vāyu, and Brahmāṇḍa Purāṇas ‘grew out of one and the same original text.’ But the Matsya version is in some respects the best of those three, notwithstanding that it includes additions of later date. The Vishṇu and Bhāgavata Purāṇas are later condensed redactions, and the Bhavishya in its existing form, which has been freely corrupted and interpolated, is worthless for historical purposes. Those purposes are served chiefly by the Matsya, Vāyu, and Brahmāṇḍa. There are clear indications that the Sanskrit account of the dynasties as it now stands in these three works is an adaptation of older Prākrit ślokas, or verses; and there is some reason for suspecting that the most ancient text was originally written in the Kharoshṭhī script.

Mr. Pargiter holds that the first compilation of the historical matter may have been made in the reign of the Āndhra king, Yajñaśrī, about the end of the second century after Christ; that the first certain compilation was made in the original Bhavishya Purāṇa about a. d. 260; that the Bhavishya account was revised about a. d. 315–20 and inserted in MS. e Vāyu; that the same account was again revised a few years later, about a. d. 325–30, and inserted in the other Vāyu MSS. as well as in the Brahmāṇḍa, so that those Purāṇas have preserved the contents of the Bhavishya at the date last named. The Matsya version seems to preserve the Bhavishya text in a slightly earlier stage, dating from about the last quarter of the third century.

Keith traverses all Pargiter’s theories, and holds that bhavishya simply means ‘in the future’.1 Pargiter maintains his view as to the interpretation of the word in a reply to Keith.2 J. Kennedy discusses the historical value of the Puranic tradition, and gives Pargiter credit for weaving it into a ‘consecutive and intelligible whole’.3

Mr. Pargiter’s treatise is based on the collation of sixty-three MSS., and deserves careful study. It cites other authorities fully.

I may add that Purāṇas in some shape were already authoritative in the fourth century b. c. The author of the Arthaśāstra ranks the Atharvaveda and Itihāsa as the fourth and fifth Vedas (Bk. I, ch. 3); and directs the king to spend his afternoons in the study of Itihāsa, which is defined as comprising six factors, namely, (1) Purāṇa, (2) Itivṛitta (history), (3) Ākhyāyika (tales), (4) Udāharaṇa (illustrative stories), (5) Dharmaśāstra, and (6) Arthaśāstra (Bk. I, ch. 5).

Notes

  1. 1. e. g., it recurs in the latest, 22nd, edition of Sir W. Hunter’s book, A Brief History of the Indian People, 1897, p. 103.
  2. 1. Sachau’s translation, vol. i, iii, p. 205. pp. 130, 131, 264.
  3. 2. Cowell and Thomas, trans., p. 72.
  4. 3. Trans. VIIth Or. Congress, vol.
  5. 4. J. R. A. S., 1903, p. 193.
  6. 5. S. B. E., vol. xxxv, pp. 6, 247.
  7. 6. Ind. Ant., vol. xxv (1896), p. 323.
  8. 1. J. R. A. S., 1914, pp. 1021–31.
  9. 2. Ibid., 1915, pp. 516–21, and pp. 141–7, 328.
  10. 3. Ibid., 1915, pp. 507–16.