The Early History of India

Appendix M

The Christians of St. Thomas

The Early History of India, Vincent A. Smith, 1924 · from page 260 · about 6 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

In this Appendix I confine myself to the limited task of justifying the propositions in the text. It is out of the question to discuss fully the problems connected with the legend of St. Thomas and the origin of the ancient congregations of the 'Christians of St. Thomas' in Southern India. The following books are cited under the names of their respective authors:—

  • (1) Mackenzie, G. T.—'History of Christianity in Travancore', 3rd ed., in The Travancore State Manual, 1906, vol. ii, pp. 114– 219.
  • (2) Rae, G. Milne.—The Syrian Church in India. (Blackwood, 1892.)
  • (3) Medlycott, Bishop A. E.—India and the Apostle Thomas. (Nutt, 1905.)
  • (4) Richards, W. J.—The Indian Christians of St. Thomas. (Bemrose, 1908.)

The seven churches founded by St. Thomas are enumerated by Richards (p. 77) as (1) Kotta-kāyalil, (2) Gōkamangalam, (3) Niranam, (4) Chayil, (5) Kurakēni, (6) Quilon, (7) Palūr. Mackenzie gives the same list, with some variation of spelling, except that he substitutes Maliankara for Kurakēni. Rae (p. 361) gives the list as (1) Cranganore, (2) Quilon, (3) Palur, (4) Parur, (5) South Pallipuram1 or Kokamungalum, (5) Neranum, (7) Nellakkul, called also Chael or Shail. Richards is responsible for the statement that

'One of the seven churches founded by St. Thomas was at a place named Chayal in the eastern hills of Travancore. It has long been abandoned, owing to wild animals, but the ruins remain, and would repay antiquarian research' (p. 91).

I cannot explain the discrepancies in the lists, or say anything more about the alleged ruins at Chayal (alias Nellakkul, Chael, or Shail).

St. Thomas is believed to have ordained priests from two families: namely, one at Shankarapuri, which died out, and the other at Pakalōnmattam, which survived into the nineteenth century, and supplied archdeacons in the Portuguese and bishops in the Dutch period (Mackenzie, p. 137; Richards, p. 76).

'There is no doubt,' Mr. V. Nagam Aiya observes, 'as to the tradition that St. Thomas came to Malabar and converted a few families of Nambudiris, some of whom were ordained by him as priests, such as those of Sankarapuri and Pakalomattam.1 For in consonance with this long-standing traditional belief in the minds of the people of the Apostle's mission and labours among high-caste Hindus, we have [it] before us to-day the fact that certain Syrian Christian women, particularly of a Desom called Kunnamkolam, wear clothes as Nambudiri women do, move about screening themselves with huge umbrellas from the gaze of profane eyes as those women do, and will not marry, except perhaps in exceptional cases and that only recently, but from among dignified families of similar aristocratic descent. This is a valuable piece of evidence of the conduct of the community, corroborating the early tradition extant on the coast.' (Manual, II, 122.)

Mr. Aiya goes on to notice the Malabar version of the Abbanes story of the Acta, which is given more fully from a Malayālam manuscript by Richards (p. 72).

The martyrdom of St. Thomas at any place may be doubted, because an early writer named Heracleon, cited by Clement of Alexandria (c. A. D. 200), states that Thomas was not martyred (Medlycott, p. 120). The Roman Catholic writers, of course, impugn the statement of Heracleon, but anybody is at liberty to believe it if he chooses to do so.

The earliest testimony to the existence of a Christian Church in Socotra, derived from Persia, is that of Cosmas Indicopleustes, who wrote in A. D. 535. About a thousand years later (1542), St. Francis Xavier found nominally Christian congregations in the island, who claimed descent from the converts made by St. Thomas. The belief that Theophilus, the missionary sent out by Constantine about A. D. 354, visited Socotra appears to be erroneous (Medlycott, pp. 136, 138, 196–201).2 Bishop Medlycott is, I think, right in holding that Theophilus visited Malabar and found Christians in that region.

Historical traditions of India and Ceylon when read together seem to carry the evidence for the existence of the Church in Malabar back to the third century. We learn from the Ceylonese chronicle, the Mahāvaṁśa (ch. xxxvi), composed about the beginning of the sixth century, that in the reign of king Gothakābhaya or Meghavarṇābhaya, whom Geiger places in A. D. 302 –15, a learned Tamil heretic overcame an orthodox Buddhist theologian in controversy and gained the favour of the king, who placed his son under his tuition. The Mahāvaṁśa represents the victor in the disputation as being a monk named Sanghamitra, ‘versed in the teachings concerning the exorcism of spirits and so forth’. Mr. K. G. Seshar Aiyar interprets this statement as meaning really that the successful controversialist was a Hindu, and identifies him with the famous Śaiva saint Māṇikka (or Māṇi) Vāśagar.1 The Tamil lives of that personage affirm that the saint actually converted the king of Ceylon towards the end of his career. That king may be identified with Gothakābhaya, and it is possible that the author of the Mahāvaṁśa may have misrepresented the Śaiva Hindu Māṇikka Vāśagar as Sanghamitra, a Buddhist heretic.

However little credit we may be disposed to give to the story about the conversion of the king of Ceylon, or to the identification of that king with Gothakābhaya of the Mahāvaṁśa, I see no reason for hesitating to believe the Indian tradition that Māṇikka Vāśagar visited Malabar and reconverted two families of Christians to Hinduism. The descendants of those families, who are still known as Manigrāmakars, are not admitted to full privileges as caste Hindus. Some traditions place the reconversion as having occurred about a.d. 270. If that date be at all nearly correct, the Malabar Church must be considerably older. So far as I can appreciate the value of the arguments from the history of Tamil literature, there seems to be good independent reason for believing that Māṇikka Vāśagar may have lived in the third century. Some authors even place him about the beginning of the second century.2 If he really lived so early, his relation with the Church in Malabar would confirm the belief in its apostolic origin.

Notes

  1. 1. 'Palli' in the name Pallipuram means 'church' or any non-Hindu place of worship.
  2. 1. Richards spells ‘Pakalōnmattam’. Aiya (Manual, II, 122) writes ‘Pakalomattam’, while Mackenzie (ibid., p. 137) writes ‘Palomattam’. Probably the first form is correct.
  3. 2. The statement at the top of p. 136 (Medlycott) that the story of the mission of Theophilus refers to Socotra, is a slip, contradicted on pp. 196, 201, and with good reason.
  4. 1. Tamilian Antiquary, vol. i, no. 4, p. 54. The writer does not cite the statement in the Mahāvaṁśa correctly. The Tamil legend is given ibid., p. 66, and in Pope, Tiruvāśagam, p. xxxi. There is a fine metal image of Māṇikka—a presumably idealistic portrait—shown as fig. 161, p. 263 of South Indian Images by H. K. Sastri (Madras Government Press, 1916).
  5. 2. T. Ponnambalam Pillai, quoting various authorities, in Tamilian Antiquary, vol. i, No. 4, pp. 73–9; see also ibid., pp. 53–5; and Mackenzie, p. 138. The notion that the tradition about the origin of the Manigrāmakars has anything to do with Manicheans is untenable. Dr. Pope, shortly before his death, expressed his acceptance of the opinion that Māṇikka lived not later than the fourth century (Tam. Ant., ut supra, p. 54).