Appendix A

Extracts from Col. Baird Smith's Report on the Famine of 1860-61.

An Essay on the Economic Causes of Famines in India, Satis Chandra Ray, 1909 · from page 59 · about 16 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

Extracts from Col. Baird Smith's Report on the Famine of 1860-61.

Para. 36.—. . . . To my own mind I confess it appears clear that no misapprehension can be greater than to suppose that the settlement of the public demand on the land is only lightly, or as some say, not at all, connected with the occurrence of famines. It lies in reality far nearer to the root of the matter, because of its intimate and vital relation to the everyday life of the people, and to their growth towards prosperity or towards degradation, than any such accessories as canals, or roads, or the like, important though they unquestionably are. It is no doubt quite true that not the best settlement system which mortal intellect could devise would cover the skies with clouds, or moisten the earth with rain, when the course of nature had established a drought. But given the drought and its consequences, the capacity of the people to resist their destructive influences is in direct proportion—I would almost say geometrical proportion—to the perfection of the settlement system under which they are living and growing.

Para. 62.—Such, then, having been the general results of the protracted fixity of the public demand, the security of titles, the general moderation of assessment, the recognition and careful record of rights, and the reasonably equable distribution of the burden of land taxation, which were the main characteristics of the settlement of 1833—45, the inference seems irresistible that to intensify and perpetuate these results we must proceed still farther in the same healthy and fruitful direction. The good which has been done by partial action on sound principles is both a justification and encouragement to further advances, and entertaining the most earnest conviction that State interests and popular interests would be alike strengthened in an increasing ratio by this step. The first, and as I believe, the most important remedial measure I have respectfully to submit for consideration is the expediency of fixing for ever the public demand on the land, and thus converting the existing settlements in the first great subdivisional section of the tract of country now under reference from settlements for long periods into settlements for perpetuity. I limit this to the first subdivision at present simply for convenience. The second subdivision is much mixed and still, in part at least, in a state of transition, unsuited to the adoption of the course which can safely be recommended for the first. But if it should hereafter appear that the same principle can be extended beyond the limits of the first subdivision . . . . its beneficial influence would there be the same.

Para. 64.—It may be supposed that a great sacrifice of public revenue is involved in the conversion of a perpetually fixed demand on the part of Government. It is to be observed, however, that (with a single exception to be noticed separately) the recent tendency of the measures of Government has shown a different conviction and indicated a belief that its interests are best secured not by general enhancement but by a general lightening of its demand on land. The latest orders under which settlements now in progress are conducted prescribe a reduction of the proportion of the rent or the net produce, hitherto appropriated as Government revenue, from 66 to 50 per cent. ; and I have no doubt that is a most wise and prudent step, sure to justify itself before many years pass away. It is scarcely possible, indeed, that a tax on rent which, even at its minimum, absorbs half that product and presses exclusively on a single section of the community, can be permitted to increase. The tendency will, I believe, be quite in the opposite direction ; and, instead of desiring to raise the moderately assessed districts to the level of the highest, the best revenue authorities will probably seek to lighten the pressure on the latter, and in this manner, rather than by the converse process, to equalise the burden generally. Such an equalisation would lead to a universal increase in the wealth of the agricultural classes. The price of land would rise gradually from four or five years’ purchase of the Government revenue to ten or twelve times that standard. Capital would, in time, accumulate in other hands than those of money-lenders, or the scarcely taxed native commercial classes in general. The land would enjoy the benefit of such accumulations, and as a necessary consequence of the increased prosperity of that class, which must always be the very core of native society, and with the strength or the weakness of which the social fabric, generally, must always have the acutest sympathy, trade and commerce and general wealth would not only increase, but, as years passed on, the community must grow stronger and stronger, and the risk of its collapsing under any such calamities as that we are now considering would gradually become less and less. Assuming, then, that the results of the measure would, in some degree at any rate, realise these anticipations, it seems unreasonable to suppose that an intelligent and powerful Government could fail to participate in them. Its intelligence would direct it to the least offensive and most effective means of sharing in the general prosperity, and its power would insure the fair trial and ultimate success of those means. There would be no real sacrifice, therefore, I believe, but, on the contrary, a marked increase of public resources from the creation of the increased private prosperity to which it is conceived that a perpetual settlement of the public demand must lead.

Para. 79.—It will be understood, then, that in advocating a perpetual settlement of the public demand on the land as a means of strength and growth to the community in the famine tracts, I contemplate no interference whatever with the existing rights of the soil. The full enjoyment of these is guaranteed to their proprietors by the most solemn and repeated sanctions. But I anticipate that under the free action of the laws which mould and form societies, much, if not all that is obstructive and objectionable in the influence of those rights, will gradually disappear. The steady gravitation of capital to the land, of which the evidences are already unquestionable; the tendency to aggregation rather than to minute subdivision of the soil of which proofs are discernible; the growth of wealthy communities such as I have indicated in speaking of the influences of canal irrigation, with many other points,—all indicate the direction in which society is moving; and I am sure that, such being the case, the safest and best policy as regards its internal action is simply to leave it alone, and let it assume its natural forms and conditions, with the smallest amount of external interference that is consistent with good and efficient administration. Sudden or magical strides in improvement are neither expected from fixity of demand nor are they possible. But that the principle is sound and its action satisfactory have been proved by thirty years of trial. The time for the next step in advance is therefore now believed to have arrived; and what is expected from its adoption is only an acceleration of that growth and progress of which, I believe, I have given sufficient proof, and a steady, though more rapid, strengthening of the community in its most vital relations to resist such calamities as have already swept over it, and must be expected to sweep over it again.

Extract from a Minute by the Hon. Mr. E. Maltby, dated the 24th December, 1861.

I am strongly in favour of a permanent assessment for the following reasons: (1) Experience has clearly shown that the great essentials to the prosperity of the ryots are a moderate and fixed assessment, security of possession, and freedom from all interference or annoyance on the part of the native revenue servants, by declaring that so long as they pay a known demand, and no more, they cannot be molested. This end will not be attained if fluctuations of price can enhance Government demand, specially when the means of ascertaining those fluctuations are so imperfect.

Extract from a Minute by the Hon. Mr. Cecil Beadon, dated the 13th March, 1862.

In this way, without making any undue sacrifice of its land-revenue, which even now perhaps forms more than a fair or safe proportion of the imperial income, we should confer upon the whole of India the inestimable boon of a fixed settlement, fraught with all the advantages which Bengal has derived from Lord Cornwallis' Settlement, but free from its defects; we should give to every occupant of land the most powerful inducement that human nature knows to increase the value of his property, and we should lay the foundation of great and even increasing prosperity, giving wealth and contentment to the people, and security and financial ease to the Government.

Extract from a Minute by the Hon. Mr. Samuel Laing, dated the 7th April, 1862.

We do not exist as a Government merely to get the largest revenue we can out of the country, or even to keep the mass of the people in a state of uniform dead level, though it should be a tolerably happy and contented one as a peasant tenantry under a paternal Government.

If we give a permanent settlement, as Mr. Beadon proposes, we lay the foundation for a state of society, not perhaps so easily managed, but far more varied and richer in elements of civilisation and progress. . . . . I have no objection to fix what is now a fair rent for land in cultivation as a permanent rate, and take my chance of getting back, by indirect taxation, whateve: revenue I may want owing to a general alteration in money-value arising from the general growth of wealth and prosperity. But I do not think the State should give away, for next to nothing, any considerable mass of land of fair quality, which it is morally certain that a few years of good government and improved communications will bring into cultivation.

Extract from a Minute by Mr. W. Muir, dated the 5th December, 1861.

Looking now to the benefits which may be anticipated in the improvement of property, I notice first the periodical check which the prosperity of the country receives under the present system whenever a settlement approaches near its termination. As the assessment of the coming settlement is to be fixed in reference to the extent of cultivated area and value of the produce, it is the natural object of every proprietor to make these appear as small as possible. Hence, not only is the expenditure of capital on new improvements stayed, but the state of existing prosperity actually depreciated. The proprietor refrains from cultivating the usual breadth of crop; he narrows the area of land under irrigation; he postpones the sowing of valuable staples. It is quite natural that he should do so. The present sacrifice will be amply made up, if even a small diminution of Government demand is thereby obtained. Penalties are threatened for such procedure. But so long as human nature is what it is, penalties will be fruitless, and every fresh settlement upon existing assets will tend to this result.

Leaving out of view the few last years of a temporary settlement, it must be admitted that the effect of a determination of the assessment for 20 or 30 years has been found eminently beneficial in ensuring improvement. Colonel Baird Smith's report bears ample testimony that it is so; almost every district in these provinces is an unequivocal witness to the same truth. The security of a long settlement stimulates industry and encourages the expenditure of capital, for the profits of the period are certain to replace the capital, and to yield a handsome return besides. But it is also certain that the inducements to investing capital in the improvement of the land would, in most cases, be greatly strengthened by fixing the demand in perpetuity. When any large disbursement is now contemplated, it is perfectly natural for the proprietor to hesitate. He will reflect whether it is, after all, worth his while to sink Rs. 1,000, say, in a well which shall add Rs. 200 to his rental, seeing that in consequence of this increased profit he may be sure that at the next settlement Rs. 100 will be added to the assessment of his estate. Had the settlement been permanent, there would, in such a case, have been no doubt about the matter; where the settlement is temporary, the project is, in all likelihood, cast aside.

Extract from a Minute by the Lieut.-Governor of the North-Western Provinces, dated the 27th May, 1862.

I do not in the least doubt that the gradual and cautious concession of a guarantee of permanency to the settlement of land-revenue in the North-Western Provinces, generally, will be productive of all the advantages which Col. Baird Smith and Mr. Muir, in even greater detail, have depicted. Judging by the effects of settlements for long periods, it may be safely anticipated that the limitation of the Government demand in perpetuity will, in a much larger degree, lead to the investment of capital in the land. The wealth of the agricultural classes will be increased. The prosperity of the country and the strength of the community will be augmented. Land will command a much higher price. The prospective loss which the Government will incur by relinquishing its share of the profits, arising from extended cultivation and improved productiveness, will be partly, if not wholly, compensated by the indirect returns which would be derived from the increased wealth and prosperity of the country at large.

Extracts from a Minute by Sir John Lawrence, Bart., G.C.B., K.C.S.I., dated the 5th July, 1862.

I consider that such a measure would produce great practical results, while, if it were not financially beneficial, at any rate it would entail no appreciable loss on the State, and would prove a much greater boon to the mass of the proprietors than the power of redeeming their assessments. While the land-revenue of India is, as I have said, one of the most ancient institutions of that country under all the native governments of which I have any knowledge, it has been more or less a grievous burthen on the agriculturists; and the only mode by which this pressure was alleviated was by special alienations of it, in whole or in part, in favour of particular families or individuals.

I recommend a perpetual settlement because I am persuaded that, however much the country has of late years improved, its resources will be still more rapidly developed by the limitation of the Government demand. Such a measure will still further encourage the investment of money in the land, and will give still greater security to the land-revenue itself, which in years of great calamity, occurring every now and then, has suffered largely, though the loss has been more or less of a temporary character. It is also very desirable that facilities should exist for the growth of a middle class in India connected with the land, without dispossessing the present yeoman and peasant proprietors. There are many men of much intelligence, spirit and social influence among these classes who are yet so poor that they find it difficult to maintain a decent appearance. It is no remedy for this state of things to confer great and exclusive benefits on a few individuals, specially when these very benefits are conferred at the expense of the rest of the community. What is really wanted is to give the intelligent, the thrifty, and the enterprising among them the opportunity of improving their own condition by the exercise of such qualities; and this can be best done by limiting the public demand on the land. When such men acquire property and are in a thriving state, they are almost certain to be well affected to the Government, and will use their influence, which will generally be considerable, in its favour.

Further, it may be observed that although it will always be wise to maintain the land-revenue in its integrity as the mainstay of the State, there can be no valid reason why India should not yield a considerable revenue from indirect sources; though it cannot reasonably be hoped that such revenues will suffice to replace the land-revenue if once given up or largely reduced in amount. On the contrary, a moderate and fixed demand on land, by stimulating industry, will gradually but certainly, enable capital to be accumulated, and give the agriculturists the means with which to purchase taxable articles. There can be little doubt that much of the increase which has arisen from such taxation of late years has thus been created. In the Punjab, the general relief which the country obtained by the reduction of the excessive land assessment, and the abolition of the numerous duties in the shape of Octroi, transit duties, and import and export duties, enabled the people to pay an additional excise on salt. The income from that one source of revenue gradually increased from about £40,000 per annum in 1848 to upwards of £200,000 in 1858; while the duty itself was only raised 25 per cent., viz., from 3s. on the maund of 80 lbs. to 4s.

Moreover, as the period of inquiry approaches, the agriculturists, with the view of evading a true estimate of the qualities of their lands, throw much land out of cultivation; they cease to grow the most profitable kind of crops; they allow wells and water-courses to deteriorate, and the like. Such practices are equally, perhaps more, damaging to themselves than to the State; but they tend to keep back the improvement of the country.

Extracts from a Despatch from the Secretary of State to the Government of India, dated the 9th July, 1862.

That this general improvement will be accelerated by a permanent settlement Her Majesty's Government cannot entertain any doubt. A ready and popular mode of investment for the increasing wealth of the country will be provided by the creation of property in land, and all classes will benefit by the measure. On the agricultural population, the effect will be, as pointed out by Col. Baird Smith . . . the elevation of the social condition of the people, and their consequent ability, not only to meet successfully the pressure occasioned by seasons of distress, but in ordinary times, to bear increased taxation in other forms without difficulty; the feeling of ownership, or, in other words, the absolute certainty of the full enjoyment of the reward for all the labour and capital which they may invest in the land will be sure to call out all their energies for its improvement. Her Majesty's Government confidently expect that a people in a state of contentment and progressive improvement will be able, without difficulty, to contribute to the revenue in other ways to such an extent as more than to compensate for the disadvantages of foregoing some prospective increase of that from land.

The course of events which has been anticipated is, indeed, only that which has taken place in every civilised country. Experience shows that in their early stages nations derived almost the whole of their public resources in a direct manner from the produce of the soil; but as they grew in wealth and civilisation, the basis of taxation has been changed, and the revenue has been in a great degree derived indirectly by means of imposts on articles which the increasing means of the people, consequent on a state of security and prosperity, have enabled them to consume in greater abundance. I am aware that it has been stated as an objection to promoting such a course of things in India, that in most European countries the advantages of this change have been mainly appropriated by the large landowners ; but it must be remembered that in India, and specially in the districts under the ryotwari settlement, the great bulk of the agricultural population are the proprietors, subject only to the payment of the assessment, of the land which they till ; and that, consequently, the benefit of a permanent settlement would be enjoyed, not by a narrow and limited class, but by the majority of the people.