Chapter II

The Domestic Budget

The Economic Life of a Bengal District, J. C. Jack, 1916 · from page 55 · about 22 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

It will be convenient to examine the expenditure of an average family before recording the statistics of its income. The population of Faridpur, so far as it came under review in the course of our investigations, was found to consist to the extent of 77 per cent. of peasants and other agriculturalists and to the extent of only 23 per cent. of those who were not engaged in the cultivation of the soil. In the matter of expenditure, or what may be better described as the family budget, the distinction between these two classes is vital. The peasant grows his own food and is for the most part able to feed himself and his family; moreover, in many other ways he obtains from his surplus land, his trees, or his live stock materials which are useful to him and save expenditure. The non-agriculturalist on the other hand buys everything. As a result—and this is a truism thoroughly understood in every agricultural country—the peasant is always better fed than the non-agriculturalist who has nominally the same income. In Faridpur the two classes were kept rigidly apart in our investigations; all incomes and all calculations of the domestic budget of the peasant were expressed partly in cash and partly in crops as a basis of estimation, while those of the non-agriculturalist were expressed wholly in cash.

To deal with the agricultural population first, normal domestic budgets were collected from a large number of budgets drawn up with great care by every officer independently after personal enquiry. The officer was directed to examine the condition of the families in his village and to select several examples of families who were in the most comfortable circumstances and several examples of families who were in the most indigent circumstances. He was then directed to enquire of the peasant the amount which the family consumed of the different food-stuffs which were grown on its fields. The daily consumption also of rice, salt, and oil by the families was watched where this was possible, and an average daily rate of consumption per head was calculated. The peasant was closely questioned as to the kind, quantity and price of all food and of all other necessaries which he bought in a month or a year, his statements being tested by the sum which he had actually spent in the previous year. Generally speaking, averages obtained over so large a number of families selected by different enquirers in many different centres must give very fair results. Any one who has conducted such enquiries will know what pitfalls are in the way. Personal idiosyncrasy makes havoc of the most careful attempts at uniformity and in the spending of money moralists and economists alike deplore the latitude allowed to personal idiosyncrasy. In some items there was in the nature of the case considerable difficulty in striking an average of expenditure; thus, house repairs were an item which had to be taken into account, but as they were not necessary each year an estimate had to be made on the basis of spreading the cost of the occasional repairs over the number of years during which the repairs would last. Medical expenses were an item even more difficult to estimate, and here the estimation was done on an average taken direct from the budgets of the past year. In many parts of the country where large marshes or countless streams are found, boats take the place of cattle for the conveyance of produce; in the standard budgets the initial cost of such boats was spread over their probable period of employment. In a similar way the cost of cattle was spread over their average duration of life. Rent, which otherwise might have been a great difficulty, was obtained with absolute accuracy from the Record of Rights. It should be added that luxuries were not included in these domestic budgets. By this means jewellery was entirely eliminated. It may reasonably be urged that jewellery of some kind is a necessity and not a luxury to women, but it must be clear that the amount expended on it, being entirely a matter of personal taste or caprice, cannot possibly be estimated in a calculation of this kind. In addition there is the fact that almost every cultivator deposits his savings with his wife in the form of jewellery, so that expenditure on jewellery is less a part of his annual budget than a measure of his annual profit. Entertainment, although it might be accounted a luxury in the conditions of Europe, could not be so regarded in Bengal. In the house of a Hindu certain ceremonies and entertainments are obligatory on such domestic occasions as births, marriages, and deaths; and although not by religion obligatory in the same way upon Muhammadans, yet socially it is practically impossible for a Muhammadan to bury a member of his family without some expense or to marry a child without considerable expense. Some allowance for entertainment was clearly necessary in any true budget, but again taste and caprice enter so largely into the amounts spent by different families that an average became extremely difficult to estimate.

Very great labour was devoted to the preparation of domestic budgets by over two hundred officers who made a close scrutiny of the habits and expenditure of more than two thousand families for the purpose. It was found that expenditure tended to amount in all families in a similar degree of prosperity to identical totals, thereby making it possible to draw up model budgets with considerable accuracy. These model budgets were of great value in the tabulation of the resources of the agriculturalists, as they permitted the cash equivalent of all food grown on the family fields and consumed by the family to be calculated, and thereby the annual income of each agricultural family to be expressed in cash. It would have been impossible to estimate the cash value of crops retained for consumption by each individual agricultural family, and it was not attempted. Instead, all agricultural families were classified according to their degrees of prosperity and the model budgets used to assess the cash value of the food which the family would require to justify the classification.

Perhaps the most convenient method of illustrating the standards which were adopted for the classification of families will be to examine in detail the amounts which were finally adopted as equivalent to the expenditure of an ordinary family living in comfort and of an ordinary family living in indigence or just above the margin of starvation. In both cases the basis of the calculation was a family of five, consisting of two adult males, one adult female, one male and one female child. In the classification, as will be explained later, there were two more classes, ‘below comfort’ and ‘above indigence’, which were intermediate between the two selected for examination; but it is unnecessary to reproduce here the details of the normal budgets of these classes, as they were naturally between the two extremes.

TBL-001 · FOLIO 63Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Item of Expenditure.Amount spent annually by a family in comfort.Amount spent annually by a family in extreme indigence.
£s.d.£s.d.
Food :
Rice800400
Salt2820
Oil .8040
Spices2814
Fish68—
Vegetables10020
Milk and Butter (ghi)4020
Other necessaries :
Kerosene oil2814
Tobacco and Molasses2810
Betel Nut4014
Clothes1134120
Household utensils1414
Petty house-repairs6820
Furniture4020
Miscellaneous :
Rent113460
Local taxation2010
Medical treatment6820
Purchase of cattle108(hire)20
Purchase of boat14—
Thorough house-repairs10850
Domestic festivals and entertainments10050

The total is £3 6s. 8d. (or fifty rupees) per head in families in comfort and £1 6s. 8d. (or twenty rupees) per head in families in indigence. It will be observed that the proportion of the total budget spent upon food by families in comfort is 58 per cent. and by families in indigence 69 per cent.

It has already been mentioned that a cultivator obtains many things from his land and live stock which the non-cultivator has to buy. As a result he gets more of all these things for the same price than the non-cultivator. This is obviously true of the food which he grows on his own land. When he gets in his harvest he puts aside the whole amount of the crop which is required for the family subsistence for a whole year, making a generous estimate of the quantity required, and he does not sell the surplus immediately but only as he requires money for other purchases. In a normal year, when the crop is good, he and his family will always fare generously, eating as much as each wants. After a poor harvest he does not usually stint himself in the matter of food until late in the year, when the food supply is visibly beginning to run out. It will be understood that rice forms the staple article of diet and that except on rare occasions the only ‘flesh’ which the ordinary cultivator eats is fish. He may and Muhammadans usually do keep a supply of live stock, fowls, ducks and two or three goats, but he rarely eats them and he never kills his cattle for the table. In addition to rice, vegetables, milk, oil, ghi (the native butter) and pulses form part of the daily diet. The cash equivalent of what the family eats of the minor articles of diet in a year has been taken at the sum which a non-cultivator would pay in buying them; although a cultivator would obtain them at cost price and therefore at somewhat less, yet he will compensate for this in consuming more. The cost of rice for ‘comfort’ is reckoned upon a consumption of one maund (82 lb.) of unhusked rice per head per month, at a price of 2s. 8d. (two rupees) per maund, which was the average price then ruling in the local markets. This is really more than the average individual will consume. The Famine Commission, in considering the daily subsistence, took three-quarters of a ser (1½ lb.) per head of husked rice as the amount required to keep a family of the cultivating classes physically fit. One maund of unhusked rice is equivalent to 27½ sers of husked rice as estimated by the cultivators themselves and is therefore about 20 per cent. more than the standard which the Famine Commission adopted. Very careful enquiries go to show that while adult males will eat one ser of husked rice a day, adult females will eat less than half a ser and small children about half a ser. A prosperous family of five would therefore in all probability eat considerably less than the five maunds per month which is adopted in the scale.

What has already been written will show that throughout the district fish is consumed by all classes every day. But the fish is generally caught by the consumer and so infrequently bought that ruling prices could not be discovered in the markets. This was so great a difficulty in preparing budgets expressed in money that it was thought advisable to eliminate from them all fish caught by the family and to include only such fish as is purchased. It will be understood that this is a very small proportion of the whole supply. It is possible for any cultivator in any part of the district, except at the height of the dry weather in the east and more particularly the north-east, to take a fishing-rod, walk perhaps a mile to the nearest stream and catch fish for the consumption of his family. As a result, fish is normally a daily article of diet in every family, but in addition to the fish which each catches for his own consumption it is common for a certain amount to be bought, either when the family has been otherwise employed and has had no time for fishing or when fish of a better quality is desired. As may be imagined, fish is very cheap in all the markets, indeed a halfpenny will purchase sufficient for a meal for a whole family. The sum included in the budget represents approximately the quantity which an average family purchases in a year. Probably this differs in different parts of the district, according as water remains in the rivers for all or only part of the year, but in practice in those parts in which water disappears from the stream-beds fish is eaten in less quantity, as the means of internal communication are not sufficient to transport it from a locality where water remains to a locality where the streams have dried up.

To Europeans the sum of money spent on milk may appear very small. The Bengali does not drink milk in any large quantity and the cultivator makes the amount which is supplied by his cattle sufficient for his needs. It is only near towns that anybody keeps milch kine. Tobacco is usually grown by the cultivator on the land near his homestead, but in recent times it has become the custom to purchase cigarettes. The women and children of cultivators smoke as well as the men, but this practice is not universal, as in some parts of the district only the male adult smokes. The amount allowed is what a family appears to spend in a year when no tobacco is grown. The expenditure on household utensils is merely the renewal of cheap earthenware jars and pots as they break. Under the head of petty house-repairs, the value of the materials only is allowed for, as the labour is always supplied by the members of the family. In thorough house-repairs the labour is also supplied almost exclusively by the family, although occasionally expert thatchers are employed. As the houses are usually walled with mat, roofed with thatch and floored with dry mud, the repair of houses by the family involves no great difficulty and no very heavy labour. With the exception of wooden beams, the cultivator usually obtains all the material for the repair of his house from his own land and garden. It was necessary, however, to value this material and the sum mentioned in the scale is that which a non-cultivator would ordinarily pay for raw materials for the repair of a similar house. The cost of cattle has been calculated on the assumption that one plough and two plough-cattle will meet the wants of a family of five. As the effective life of the cattle is ten years and the cost of each about forty rupees, this estimate is equivalent to an annual charge of eight rupees (10s. 8d.). Cattle are not fed with oilcake, but are allowed to graze on the somewhat scanty grass, on catch-crops occasionally grown in the cold weather and on the straw of the rice-crop. No money is actually spent upon their up-keep, nor is a valuation necessary as the straw has no selling value except in the near neighbourhood of the few towns. Nearly every family living in comfort possesses a small boat, usually a dinghy, which is somewhat like a large dug-out and somewhat like a canoe. It is usually about 15 feet long and between 2 and 3 feet in beam, costs twenty rupees, i.e. £1 6s. 8d., and has a life of twenty years.

The estimate for domestic festivals and entertainment is very rough and is based on the assumption that the lifetime of a generation is thirty years, during which there will be one birth, one marriage and one death per head of population. In a family of five there will be five of each such events, estimated to cost 5 rupees for a birth, 25 rupees for a death and 42 rupees for a marriage, or a total of 72 rupees for each member, which must be spread over thirty years and is so equivalent to an average charge of twelve rupees per year, the remainder of the sum set down in the table being a small allowance to cover the cost of the minimum amount of hospitality. It must be remembered that an Indian village affords no means of spending money on amusements. At the most an occasional strolling band of players may with luck invade the neighbourhood of the village for a week in every other year. It is impossible to take friends or family to the theatre or the picture-palace or out to tea because in the whole district there are no theatres, picture-palaces, or tea-shops. It is impossible for the peasant even to ‘treat’ his friend, as there are no inns or public-houses at which liquor can be purchased and the convivial habits of Europe are no part of the social life of the East. Friendliness, when shown at all, is shown by inviting a man to have a pull at the family hookah, which costs the host nothing. Members of the family and other friends will occasionally visit a homestead and be entertained, but an entertainment of this simple kind is not a recognized method of social intercourse in a Bengal village. When a cultivator wishes to entertain his friends and has the means, he either waits for an occasion such as a domestic event in his family or else he entertains magnificently, asking all his neighbours without exception, feeding them sumptuously and spending several times more than he can conveniently afford.

Most of these remarks naturally refer to those families who live in comfortable circumstances. The indigent never entertain except when they are compelled by the rigid social code which ordains this method of advertising domestic events in the family. In other respects the difference between the standard of living of an indigent and a prosperous cultivator lies in a reduction in the amount expended on each item of the budget and not in the cutting out of any item altogether. Except in the marshes, the poorer families do not keep a boat, and they save largely in all the smaller items of expenditure, in their purchase of cattle and clothes and in the cost of house repairs. In the important matter of the consumption of rice the scale which was adopted assumed that an indigent family eats only half as much as a prosperous family. An adult male will starve if his daily allowance of rice falls below half a ser. It was found after careful examination and enquiry that the food-scale in this standard really provides sufficient margin to prevent starvation, more especially when it is remembered that the poorest can catch fish as easily as the comfortable. In other words a cultivator possessing a realized income of the amount indicated will be able to support his family without resort to begging. They will be ill clothed and ill housed, but they will not be underfed; that is to say, although they will not receive sufficient nourishment to maintain their bodies at the greatest strength of which they are capable, yet the nourishment will be sufficient to enable them to continue at work and to perform their ordinary duties. In practice there is no such thing as starvation for a cultivator in the Bengal Delta, because if a man does not earn enough to buy his food, he can always beg it. The agricultural peasant is very generous and will always give the poor a full meal. What may be described as the cultivator's margin of starvation is therefore such an income as will just lift him above the necessity of begging for his food and no more, but in clothes and housing will maintain him in a very miserable manner. In a Bengal village the destitute never look starved, although they may have no cattle, their houses may be ramshackle and broken-down, their clothes thin and ragged. On this account it is impossible to attempt any comparison with the destitute in the western world. In any agricultural community utter destitution is unknown; but in Bengal the misery of comparative destitution is mitigated by a mild climate and by social custom which enjoins none but the simplest clothing. With few exceptions, those families which will be found in chronic need in any Eastern Bengal village will on enquiry prove to be either widows left with a family of young children or old people who are past work and who have no relatives to support them. At certain seasons of the year a few other families may lack a full meal and may even resort to begging for it, but once the harvest is gathered they live again, eating as well as their more prosperous brethren and showing their poverty only in the quality of their houses and their clothes.

The domestic budget of a non-cultivator of the working-classes was found to be little different from that of a cultivator. It includes no more items and for all practical purposes does not vary greatly in the amount expended on each item. In past centuries, as is well known, Indian society was divided into functional groups. Each village was industrially self-sufficient, the industrial work being allotted to certain families, each family performing one task and one task only and no outsider being allowed to compete. But the caste system was never adopted by the Muhammadan and lost its hold upon converts from Hinduism, so that it has been gradually breaking down in Bengal for more than two centuries. In Farīdpur the population is two-thirds Muhammadan and only one-third Hindu; it is not therefore to be expected that functional groups should play any important part in industry. The non-agricultural community is not in any case of great importance, as it amounts to only 23 per cent. of the population, of which as much as 10 per cent. is employed in service or supported by the rent of land which it owns, 6 per cent. is engaged in trade and only 8 per cent. is employed in industry. Of this 8 per cent. only 3 per cent. could by any stretch of the imagination be called skilled labour, the remainder consisting of coolies employed to some extent on roads and earthwork, but chiefly as porters in the markets, towns, steamer and railway stations. In other words, Farīdpur is not only preponderantly but exclusively an agricultural district, that part of the population which is not engaged in the production of crops being almost exclusively engaged in services of different kinds to the agricultural community.

As might be expected in such circumstances most of the non-cultivators are the brothers, sons, and grandsons of cultivators and exhibit no differences from them in domestic customs or their standard of living. There are only two industries of any importance in which the workers have been for several generations engaged in the same occupation and might therefore be expected to have a different standard. These industries are fishing and weaving, both of which are hereditary amongst Muhammadans as amongst Hindus, probably because the forefathers of the Muhammadans were converts from Hinduism. However, in neither industry is the number of those engaged sufficient to justify any separate treatment of their standards of living. Generally speaking, it may be said that weavers are thrifty folk and reach the same standard of comfort as a cultivator at considerably less than the same expense. The fishermen are those who fish in the Ganges for the market and are a very rough class, being comprehensively described in the words used by the Spanish Ambassador of the English peasantry in the reign of Henry VIII: ‘They live like pigs, but they fare as well as the King.’ The homestead of the fisherman is usually a miserable affair and ill furnished, his clothing is adequate but coarse, his food is always sufficient. A good deal of the unskilled labour is imported from neighbouring districts and does not need description, as it only stays in the district for short periods of the year and spends most of its time at home. The rest of the non-cultivating classes who work with their hands live in every respect at the same standard and in the same way as the cultivators from whom they sprang. This applies also to Muhammadan traders, to most of the smaller Muhammadan landowners and to Muhammadan clerks who are generally sons of the most prosperous cultivators and whose habits and standard of living conform in all respects to those of their fathers.

Amongst the Hindus, however, landowners, clerks, professional men such as doctors, lawyers and priests, form a class apart. They are of the three higher castes in the Hindu caste system and have for centuries lived in a different manner from the ordinary population. They have more wants and more ways of spending their money; they eat less but better food with greater variety; their houses are built on a different plan and are better furnished; their clothes although the same in cut display more variety in quality and colour. A budget for such classes will show great differences from the budget of the working classes in the proportionate amounts spent upon food, furniture, medical treatment and clothes. Muhammadan landowners, lawyers, doctors, and the like of good family will show a similar but not equal divergence in the proportion of their expenditure devoted to particular items. Another class which has a standard of living of its own, different on the one hand from that of the working classes and on the other hand from that of the ‘respectable’ classes, is the Hindu shopkeepers, who are often also workers in metals and the like. Their families tend to be numerous, they keep several servants, their houses are large, well built and well furnished, they expend a certain amount upon the education of their children and much larger sums than the working classes upon domestic events.

These classes were never sufficiently numerous to make it worth while to draw up separate budgets, more especially as the variations in income within the classes were very great and the scale of expenditure was different near towns and in the interior. Some attempt was made to deal exhaustively with the ‘respectable’ classes, but it was not very successful. The great difficulty was the joint-family system, in which parents live with all their sons and sons’ children and often with nephews and cousins. Thus there were families forty strong, twenty strong and five strong, and the task of reducing such divergencies to a common level could only be attempted by an officer who knew the whole district and had the figures of all such families at his elbow.

For comparison with the budgets of the cultivators I append domestic budgets drawn up for an ordinary non-agricultural family of the working class. A family of the same size is adopted and the average income per head works out at the same figure. These budgets must, however, only be taken as rough guides. It is really impossible to average the expenditure of fishermen, weavers, coolies and small traders; but the number of each group was so small in comparison with the total population of the district that it did not seem worth while to select sufficient families from each to enable budgets to be drawn up for each separately. In comparison with cultivators a larger proportion of the expenditure is upon food; but it is probable that this does not represent greater quantity or better quality. The bulk of the food is bought, but non-cultivators fish as cultivators do, although they probably buy more fish in the year than the cultivator. Some rent land and grow food crops upon them by hiring labour; most grow tobacco and vegetables on homestead lands, many keep a cow to give them milk and butter and grow thatching grass and a bamboo clump in their gardens to supply materials for the repair of their huts. The budgets are as follows:

TBL-002 · FOLIO 75Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Amount spentAmount spent
Item ofannually byannually by
Expenditure.a family ina family in
comfort.extreme indigence.
£s.d.£s.d.
Food:
Rice800400
Salt2820
Oil8040
Spices5020
Fish10030
Pulses10030
Vegetables4020
Milk and ghi (butter)6020
Other necessaries:
Betel nut4010
Kerosene oil286
Tobacco and molasses50
Clothes1134134
Household utensils3020
Annual petty house repairs10030
Rent7826
Local taxation206
Medical expenses15026
Furniture100
Thorough house repairs10050
Domestic festivals and entertainment15050