I have gone into the expenditure of an average family in this detail because a thorough understanding of the social habits and method of life of the people is essential before the statistics and the classifications which were the result of the economic investigations made in Faridpur can be understood. The object of these investigations was first to find out the condition of the family by examining the condition of the homestead and its inmates and then to determine the income of the family partly by cross-examination of the adults and partly by computation from the amount of land which each cultivator's family possessed and the selling value of the crop which it could produce. The investigation was carried out by men (Bengalis who were mostly university graduates) who had already been several months in the locality, had made a survey field by field of the village and had prepared a paper describing the fields, soil, area, rent and rights for every tenancy belonging to every cultivator. They therefore knew much about the productive capacity of the soil and much about the habits of the villagers. They were directed to pay more attention to what they saw than to what they heard, and only after they had seen the condition of the family by a visit to its homestead to enquire into its resources, to tabulate its income and to enter its classification.
In classification four standards were adopted: ‘comfort’, which implied a condition in which the material necessities of life could be fully satisfied; ‘indigence’, which implied a condition in which the family had just sufficient to keep itself alive and no more; and two classes intermediate between these extremes, one labelled ‘below comfort’, in which the income and material conditions approximated more nearly to those of families living in comfort than to those of families living in indigence, and the other labelled ‘above indigence’, in which the income and material conditions approximated more nearly to those of indigent families. The officers were expressly told that ‘where they find an agricultural family well-fed, well-housed and well-clothed, this is comfort; the material necessities are fully satisfied: where they find a family thin and ill-developed, their garments old and worn, their huts ill-thatched and tumbled-down, this is starvation. In most cases the evidence of the eye is decisive, but there are those of a miser’s nature who live poorly but possess much, and others of a spendthrift nature who live well but end in ruin. The local knowledge of the officer is more than ample to warn him of such cases.’ After inspection of the homestead and its inmates and after detailed cross-examination, the officers filled up a form, which was designed to express in money the income which the family obtained from every source, including for example how much a cultivator’s family derived not only from the sale of crops, but from the sale of dairy produce, bye-products, fruit and timber.
In estimating the income of cultivators only what they actually sold or earned was brought into the account, such of their crops as they retained for consumption in the family being ignored. The classification of the family and the enumeration of its members, adults and children, male and female, would enable a calculation to be made subsequently of the quantity which was necessary for the subsistence of the family at the standard at which it was living and the cash value of that quantity at current prices. Most cultivators in Faridpur have some subsidiary occupation. The amount which they earn by these occupations was also shown in different columns of the form. There was little difficulty in obtaining data as to the incomes of cultivators and little difficulty in filling up the form with a considerable degree of accuracy. The knowledge which the officer had acquired in his long stay in the village, the survey which he had made of all the land in the village and the information which was at his disposal as to the yield of the different crops enabled him to check very completely the statements of the cultivator. It was only in the columns which dealt with the sale of dairy produce, bye-products, fruit and so forth that any real difficulty was experienced. The cultivator had never kept account of these things, and his habit is to sell small quantities at a time. It was therefore exceedingly difficult to estimate his total sales in a year. The officer usually solved this difficulty by making no entry in the column at all, so that for the district as a whole the total income derived from these sources was greatly under-estimated. But the amount so obtained was so small a proportion of the total income of each family that this deficiency in the statistics had little ill effect upon the general average of accuracy. There was also a column for indebtedness. The figure in this column was obtained from the statements of the cultivators, supported as far as possible by an examination of the bonds which they had executed. The whole question of indebtedness is dealt with in a separate chapter, but the entry was of some value in the task of classification and of assessing the family income. On the one hand a family which was heavily in debt could not be classified accurately as living in the standard of comfort, although to all outward appearance it might seem to be of that standard; on the other hand in checking the statements of the cultivator as to his income the knowledge of a large debt was of some assistance in detecting exaggerations. These were less infrequent than might be expected. The ordinary man, whether in India or in any other country, is not in the habit of over-estimating his income, more especially when he is talking to a Government official; there are obvious risks of taxation which inculcate the virtue of discretion. But it was found that the spendthrift in Bengal had lost his caution as much in this respect as in the consumption of his resources. It was rather a matter of pride with him to exaggerate his income and also to exaggerate his debts, and whenever the debt was said to be large the officers soon learnt to examine the statements of the spendthrift with great care.
In the assessment of non-cultivators the whole income of the family was expressed in money. Most of them also receive it in money, but servants, temporary labourers (such as carters), boatmen and the like, are often paid partly in food or in kind. In such cases the produce, whether food, grain or fibre, was converted into its money equivalent before being entered into the form. It is probable that the statistics of income of the non-agricultural classes are less accurate than the statistics of income of the agricultural classes. This is especially likely in small towns or populous villages in which the non-agricultural element was large. All except the fishermen and the unskilled labourers were very cautious in their statements and very prone to minimize their profits or earnings. The officer, on the other hand, had no means except the evidence of his eye to check the statements, as his duties brought him into touch exclusively with the classes who possess land and he did not see as much of the non-agricultural classes or hear as much about them. In dealing with the respectable classes (bhadralok), these disadvantages were perhaps outweighed by the fact that the officer was of the same class himself and naturally knew more about their sources of income and scale of expenditure than about those of the lower classes. He learnt a good deal also in social intercourse with these families. In assessing the incomes of traders, shopkeepers and weavers it is probable that his estimates are least accurate. Here he had only the evidence of his eyes as a check upon the statement of the persons concerned, while it is a commonplace in India that men of these classes are most cautious in giving information. There is however one satisfactory feature in this lack of accuracy—the error is on the side of an under-statement and not of an over-statement. It is certain that the income of these classes is greater than the amount shown in the statistics, but this error would not necessarily enter into the classification which was made, as always, preponderantly upon the evidence afforded by the eyes.
A word should be added to explain the treatment in these statistics of families supported by absentees. This very characteristic feature of Bengal life is extremely common amongst the respectable classes, not unknown amongst the cultivators and frequent amongst non-cultivators of the working classes. The father of a family will go into service elsewhere or pursue the trade of boatman, shopkeeper or fisherman, remaining away from his home for long periods of time, during which he will send monthly remittances for the support of his family. He may remain for years in another district, in a distant town or even in a neighbouring town, but he will not set up house there and bring his family to live with him. Throughout the whole period the family will live in the old homestead in the village, and he will see them only for a few days in the year when he obtains a holiday. This custom is prevalent amongst all classes of the community, but it has the greatest vogue amongst the respectable classes. Clerks, lawyers and Government officials, who spend their lives in the head-quarters town, very rarely bring their wives and still more rarely their children to the town to live with them. This custom is no doubt partly due to the difficulties and expense of conveyance, especially of women who have never travelled, but among the ‘respectable’ classes the joint-family system must be reckoned to be the main reason. The individual may reside elsewhere, but the wife and children must be left in their real home, the bosom of the joint-family. In modern times the joint-family of the old pattern has shown a tendency to break up, but in the lifetime of the father the old home is usually still the abode of the sons and their families, although the father himself may be a lawyer in the head-quarters town, living alone in lodgings and sending the bulk of his earnings to support the family, while some of the sons may also be clerks or Government officials in distant or neighbouring towns. All these sons will leave their families in the old home under the care of their own mother and contribute with the bulk of their earnings to the support of the joint-family. It is by no means uncommon to find such a family with ten or more adult women and many children of different degrees of kinship under the care of a single man, probably one out of many sons, who has no other business in life than their management and no visible income of his own. The forms were so arranged as to include such cases, the family in the village being treated for purposes of classification as in possession of the income which they actually enjoyed, although it was earned by absent members of the family. In the town the income of the absent member was taken as the amount which he retained for his own support, and the bulk which he sent home to his family was excluded from consideration.
The total population which was brought under economic review proved to be 1,861,183, included in 342,108 separate families. Of this population 1,429,630 (or 77 per cent.) were agricultural, and the remainder (or 23 per cent.) non-agricultural. The average agricultural family was somewhat larger than the non-agricultural. Of cultivators 256,681 families were enumerated, each on the average containing 5·6 persons, while of non-agriculturalists 85,427 families were enumerated, each containing five persons. In the total there were 103 males to every 100 females, and 60 per cent. of the population was classified as adult. The line of division between adults and children was, however, taken as fifteen years, as a child arrives at maturity much sooner in the East than in the West and is often married and responsible for a family at that age besides undertaking the full work of a man or woman. The number of children, as would appear from a comparison with the census figures, is too small. This discrepancy is no doubt due to the fact that many young girls were entered as women or omitted altogether. They are kept in the house and not allowed to come out before strangers. The officers therefore could not see them, and as the officers were young men any questions on the subject would have been received with suspicion.
The census of 1911, which was taken three years after this economic investigation, enumerated a population of 2,122,000 in Faridpur. This number included the persons, mostly foreigners, living in boats in the big rivers on the day of the census, who were not included in our investigations, as well as the natural increase in the population in three years. Making allowance for these additions, it appears that in our investigations less that one person in ten was omitted. Omissions were to be expected in such enquiries ; but the fewness of the omissions shows that the investigation for all practical purposes covered the entire district.
The total annual income of the agricultural population was ascertained to be rupees 71,326,876, equivalent to £4,755,125. This amounts to rupees 280 or £18 13s. 4d. for each family, or rupees 50 (£3 6s. 8d.) for each individual. The annual income of the non-agricultural class was somewhat larger. This difference was due to the fact that the class is not homogeneous, as it includes on the one hand all forms of industrial labour, skilled and unskilled, and on the other hand all the clerical and learned professions and the landowners. Amongst the latter the average income is very much higher than the average income of cultivators. Traders and shopkeepers differ in their incomes very greatly, containing amongst their numbers some of the wealthiest families in the district, but in the average being little better off than the ordinary cultivator. The total annual income of the non-agricultural population was ascertained to be rupees 25,051,479 or £1,670,098 and the average income to be rupees 293 or £19 11s. per family and rupees 58 or nearly £4 for each individual. The average income of both classes together amounted to rupees 282 per annum or 7s. 3d. per week for each family.
It will be convenient to deal with the population in future by families, as the most important part of the investigation was the allocation of each family to one of the four economic classes, according as its circumstances exhibited or approximated to a condition of comfort or a condition of physical want. As has been explained this classification was based upon the apparent condition of the family as revealed by personal inspection rather than upon any calculation of income, but the average incomes which the mass of figures yielded for the four classes corresponded very fairly with the totals of the normal domestic budgets which had been arrived at by an examination of expenditure in selected families in the four economic conditions. Of the population examined 167,139 families, or very nearly half the total population, were classified as living in circumstances of comfort, 96,294 families, or more than half the remainder, as living in a condition which although below comfort was yet above hardship, 63,969 families, or 18½ per cent. of the total population, as in straitened circumstances although out of the reach of physical want, and 14,706 families, or 4·3 per cent., as struggling in the grip of want. The income of the average family in these four classes was ascertained to be :
Comfort (49 per cent.) : Rupees 365 per annum or 9s. 4d. per week.
Below comfort (28 per cent.) : Rupees 233 per annum or 6s. per week.
Above indigence (18½ per cent.) : Rupees 166 per annum or 4s. 3d. per week.
Indigence (4⅓ per cent.) : Rupees 115 per annum or 3s. per week.
In the average these figures of income probably represent correctly the facts, although the income of indigent families is often so precarious and so largely made up of charity as to be impossible of exact calculation.
No useful purpose is attained by continuing to examine the economic condition of the people as a whole when the manner of life of the agricultural and the non-agricultural sections is so different. In the first place, the cultivators are a homogeneous class ; none are really wealthy and those who are exceptionally prosperous and produce far more than is needed to maintain them in comfort are as few as those who are living in a condition bordering on physical want. In the non-agricultural group, on the other hand, all economic conditions are represented, the wealthy landowner with an enormous income, the lawyer with a large and lucrative practice, the Government official with a fixed and comfortable income, the miserly moneylender with large profits, the prosperous shopkeeper with his fluctuating returns, and at the other end of the scale the weaver working desperately for a subsistence in a declining market, the anxious fisherman with a precarious catch, the struggling clerk and doctor, the petty trader with his uncertain profits and the rude unskilled labourer earning when in work far more than his simple needs require. In the second place, the statistics collected from the two classes were collected in a different manner. The classification of non-cultivators, although dependent at bottom upon observation, was necessarily largely influenced by the statements of earnings provided by the individual, whereas the cultivator's homestead with its live stock and its store of grain was a sufficient clue to his economic condition, and his statements were really only of importance in recording the crops which he sold and his earnings from subsidiary employments. In these circumstances the classification of cultivators can be accepted with much greater confidence and requires fewer qualifications and exceptions than the classification of the non-cultivators.
Of agricultural families, 49½ per cent. were classified as living 'in comfort', 28½ per cent. 'below comfort', 18 per cent. 'above want', and 4 per cent. 'in want'. It is clear that the agricultural wealth of the district is divided with considerable fairness in such a way that the great majority of the cultivators have a reasonable share. This is no country of capitalist farmers with bloated farms and an army of parasitic and penurious labourers. The average income per head was calculated at rupees 60 for those 'in comfort', rupees 43 for those 'below comfort', rupees 34 for those ‘above want’, and rupees 27 for those ‘in want’, as compared with averages of rupees 50 and rupees 20 in the model budgets for comfort and extreme indigence. It is true that these figures of average income are largely the result of a calculation which is explained in the Appendix ; but they agree remarkably well in the three lower classes with average incomes of non-agriculturalists which were based throughout upon information, so that it is clear that the estimates of consumption afforded a very accurate basis for the calculation. The general accuracy of the figures of income is also proved, as will be shown later, by a valuation of the total agricultural produce of the district. In both cases the testimony to the accuracy of the figures is independent, as the model budgets were prepared before any tabulation of non-agricultural income or of crop statistics was begun.
Although the main dependence of the cultivators is upon agriculture there is a great deal of subsidiary employment. Much of this is of a very trivial kind and involves a very small addition to the annual income, but altogether 44 in every hundred families obtain some additional earnings in this way. Subsidiary employment is not at all confined to the poorer classes, as in every hundred families 44 of the comfortable, 41 of those below comfort, 47 of those above want, and 55 of the indigent engage in subsidiary employment. I am not able to give any details of these employments nor of the total amounts earned by them, as these statistics were unfortunately left behind in India. Menial and domestic service, fishing and weaving were the most common of them. They do not include agricultural labour for hire, of which separate statistics were kept. There was naturally a very great deal of this in a country in which the jute crop is so prominent, but the hired labourer in the English sense does not exist in the district. At harvest time, as already described, a considerable proportion of all cultivators work for hire, some even engaging labour to cut their own crops and going off themselves as labourers to cut the crops of other people. Similar arrangements are not uncommon in the steeping and stripping of the jute fibre. The proportion of agricultural labourers amongst the poorer families was naturally much greater than amongst the richer, but not by any means to the extent which might have been expected. The participation of the richer is no doubt due largely to the good wages obtainable for labour on the jute crop; while many of the most comfortable cultivators are employed in harvesting the crops of neighbouring districts to which the prejudice against work for hire on the village fields under the eyes of the neighbours does not extend. Of the cultivators in comfort 22 per cent., of those below comfort 31 per cent., of those above want 36 per cent., and of the indigent 37 per cent. were enumerated as engaged in agricultural labour. It is probable that amongst all these there were none who were exclusively agricultural labourers, that is to say, labourers in the English sense of the term. All had their land, some perhaps very inadequate in amount, but others only inadequate because the family contained at the time an undue proportion of young children. The landless labourer so common in England is unknown in Faridpur and very rare anywhere in Eastern Bengal. The proportion of the indigent supported by agricultural labour is not larger mainly because this class consists of old men who are unfit for the work and of families whose breadwinner has died before his time.
Statistics were kept of cultivators who buy part of their food. They were required in order to obtain correct figures of income, for the sum spent in buying food had of course to be deducted when a valuation of all food consumed by the family was added to the other income or earnings of the families to find the total income. The figures also were of interest for other reasons. Fifty years ago the cultivator in Eastern Bengal grew the whole of his food upon his own land, or, if his land was not adequate for the purpose, worked as a hired labourer in harvesting for others and obtained as his wages part of the crop which he had harvested. Since the introduction of jute, however, and its wide extension throughout Eastern Bengal, some of the cultivators have given up the growing of their whole food supply on a calculation that it would be more profitable to grow jute and buy grain. It is probable that no cultivator has ceased altogether to grow his own food. Although nearly all the land of Eastern Bengal is suitable for the rice crop, only a portion of it is suitable for jute; and it is rare that the whole holding of any cultivator is fit to grow jute. Nowadays the cultivator tends to grow jute on all the land fit for the purpose and to grow rice and other food crops only on the remainder. If that remainder is insufficient to supply the family requirements in food, he prefers to buy rather than to reduce the amount of land under jute. Of late years the price of jute has usually been so remunerative that even in the worst years he has had more than sufficient to purchase the food necessary, but the price of jute fluctuates very considerably and in some years there has been a very small margin. At the beginning of the present war the jute market collapsed completely, with the result that for the first time for many years the cultivators in Eastern Bengal were short of money with which to buy their food ; and it is probable that it will be many years before they again become so trustful as to grow less food than the family needs for the consumption of the year. On the statistics 41 per cent. of all agricultural families bought food grain, spending by their own statements an amount which was equivalent in the average to about two months' supply of the family consumption. It is possible that some families in the north of the district have not enough land to grow their own food supply in any case and will not be able to supplement the deficiency completely by ordinary agricultural labour. In such a family some members usually take service or go as boatmen ; but the number of families in which this is necessary is certainly very small and may be neglected.
It is possible with these figures to estimate the number of families in the district who feed themselves off their own land, the number who can only feed themselves by supplementing their own crops with the earnings of hired labour and the number who voluntarily omit to grow the whole of their food supply owing to the superior profit of sowing land with jute. In every hundred families it would appear that 35 feed themselves entirely off their own land, 25 need to work as labourers for complete support and 40 buy grain because they either prefer to grow jute or are unable to feed themselves, but certainly far more often because they prefer to grow jute.
Statistics were also kept of the number of families who sell crops. These were returned at 215,612, or 80 per cent. of all agricultural families. The remaining 20 per cent. would be exclusively the poorer class of the agricultural community. The value of the crops sold was returned at rupees 16,955,724, or rupees 80 for each family. This sum represents certainly less than half of the total agricultural produce and considerably less than half of the annual income of the family expressed in cash. However, as most cultivators sell their produce in driblets, it is doubtful if their statements of totals are very accurate.
From the total figures of food production in the district it is possible to test by independent evidence the accuracy of the calculation of the total income of the agricultural classes. These figures were compiled after a detailed survey of every field in the district and are therefore as accurate as it is possible to make them. The prices at which the produce is valued are the prices which were ruling at the time when the economic investigation was made and which were used not only in preparing standard budgets but also in converting the food supply of the family into its money equivalent. The figures may be therefore accepted as a trustworthy test of the accuracy of the economic information. If the value of the total production and the total income of the agricultural classes approximately agree, it may be taken that the classification by economic condition has been well and truly made, as the chief part in the estimation of their income was the valuation of the food supply which was necessary to keep the family in that condition in which it was observed to be. The figures are :—
| Crop. | Acreage. | Net value per acre of crop after deduction of cost of cultivation. | Total net value. |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rs. | Rs. | ||
| Rice | 1,074,000 | 37½ | 40,275,000 |
| Other food crops | 176,000 | 25/ | 4,400,000 |
| Oil seeds | 44,000 | 20/ | 880,000 |
| Jute | 160,000 | 75/ | 12,000,000 |
| Betel and sugar-cane | 13,000 | 60/ | 780,000 |
| Miscellaneous | 35,000 | 10/ | 350,000 |
| Grasses | 40,000 | 20/ | 800,000 |
| Fruit and garden produce | 69,000 | 8/ | 552,000 |
| Total in round figures | Rs. 60,000,000 | ||
The net value is naturally not the same in all parts of the district, being less than the amount adopted in this valuation in the north and more in the south of the district. The statistics of income of the cultivating classes, which included receipts by the sale of live stock and dairy produce and the very considerable earnings obtained from subsidiary employments, give a total income of rupees 71,300,000, which agrees very well with the valuation of the annual produce.
In dealing with the non-agricultural population I am much handicapped by the absence of detailed figures of income and classification for the families engaged in each occupation. These statistics have unfortunately been left in India. The non-agricultural population contains such very diverse elements that it is very misleading to consider only the total figures for the whole. More than one-third of the whole consists of the class locally known as ‘bhadralok’ or the respectable, and includes landlords, clerks and professional men, another third consists of the industrial population, one-fifth of traders, and one-tenth of domestic or menial servants. No valuable information can be expected from statistics which are so comprehensive as to embrace landlords and fishermen, clerks and coolies in the same set of figures. In the absence of separate statistics a few comments on the different elements must be made.
The respectable classes belong almost entirely to the three highest Hindu castes—Brahmin, Kayasth and Baidya—with a few Muhammadans of birth, breeding, or education. Nearly one-half (12,771 families) are landlords who support themselves partly or wholly upon the rents paid by their tenants, another quarter (6,935 families) are maintained by the professions, law, medicine or the priesthood, and the remainder (7,629 families) are clerks, either in Government employ or in the employ of landlords or traders. The ‘bhadralok’ is a very important class in Eastern Bengal, containing every man of education and influence and nearly every man of wealth in the district along with a considerable substratum of excessive poverty. Very careful statistics about them were collected and a very careful classification was made of their economic condition; but the results, which were valuable and interesting, are not available. Generally speaking, the ‘bhadralok’ lives in a condition of considerable comfort upon an average income which is much higher than the average in any other class of the community, although this is very largely due to the big incomes which the more successful enjoy. On the other hand, too large a proportion of the class lives in grinding poverty.
The landlords divide about four million rupees a year between them; the share of each in an equal division would not be sufficient to place him greatly above the standard of ‘comfort’ amongst cultivators. A considerable proportion are, however, wealthy men, and of the remainder many are partly maintained by some subsidiary employment, one or other of the sons earning a living in a profession and contributing the bulk of his earnings to the support of the family left at home.
Clerks are ill-paid in any country, although clerks in Government service in Bengal are far better paid than their fellows in most of the countries of Europe; clerks in shops and in trade, on the other hand, are generally very poorly paid. The salaries of clerks and agents in the employ of landowners are always miserable, but this class has from time immemorial supplemented its pay by exactions on a generous scale, with the help of which it has succeeded in maintaining itself as one of the most flourishing sections of the community. The agent of a landlord whose pay is 3 rupees a month will rarely be content with less than 30 or 40 rupees a month obtained by these peculiar means and a superior agent whose salary may be 5 or 10 rupees a month will usually have a real income of 100 rupees or more. This prosperity is ill-deserved, as the class is as a whole ignorant, disloyal to its employers, prone to swindling, selfish and rapacious to an incredible extent.
Amongst the professional men the priests are a very ill-paid class, and the Brahmin priest has fallen on very evil days; formerly he lived in comfort in the odour of sanctity, now he struggles along in an atmosphere which is little removed from contempt. Doctors make a moderate but not excessive income, if they are well qualified; but the ignorant get very little custom. The number of doctors in the district is singularly few, so that they would undoubtedly make an excellent living, if people generally had any faith in their capacity. As it is, most of the inhabitants prefer to die rather than go to a doctor. The lawyers are the spoilt children of Bengal life. They make an income entirely disproportionate to their abilities; thus an able lawyer will make five or ten times as much in a year as an equally able doctor, and even an incapable lawyer will make a better income than most capable members of other professions.
Amongst traders the money-lenders are commonly affluent, as is the habit of their kind; but the ordinary trader in general has a hard struggle; only those in the larger markets who engage in rice, oil or general trade, or the middlemen in the jute trade make large profits. Indeed, the general condition of trade in Faridpur is one of stagnation owing to the lack of easy means of communication. In the north-west so few roads exist that during the season when the rivers have dried up the transport of produce is almost impossible, which has all the more depressing an effect upon general trade since it is at this period of the year that the reaping of the main harvest has put money freely into the hands of the population. How great an effect easy communications have upon local prosperity is displayed with peculiar emphasis in this district. In the south-west all trade is carried by water, as the rivers and streams are very numerous and serve every village throughout the year. If a traveller walks through the northern part of the district in January or February and on to the south-west, he cannot fail to be struck by the contrast between the two. The one region shows no visible signs of prosperity and appears to be completely stagnant, the other is full of movement, the markets are crowded and ply a thriving trade, the rivers and streams are full of boats at all hours of the day and the people generally show every sign of alertness and prosperity.
Of that section of the population which is engaged in industry there is little to be said. It amounts altogether only to 8 per cent. of the total, and of this small proportion not one in three could by any stretching of the term be described as skilled. The great majority of unskilled labourers work as porters, or on earthwork on the roads or the numerous ponds. They earn good money, at busy times as much as one rupee a day and generally between 15 and 20 rupees a month. They are very ignorant and have few wants and a low standard of living, so that as a body they may be described as in a very comfortable condition. Weaving, which used to be a vigorous industry, has been killed partly by the importation of foreign or factory-made cotton goods and partly by the ravages of malaria, which has always made great inroads upon the colonies of sedentary weavers. A very large number of weavers have bought land and become ordinary cultivators. Of those who still continue to weave the most prosperous are Muhammadans, who show more enterprise than Hindus. The total number of families who mainly depend upon the industry is now only 4,200, whose total income was reported at 721,765 rupees, providing in the average for each family considerably less than the amount necessary to maintain a standard of comfort. Fishermen who fish for the market are congregated in small colonies along all the large rivers. They number 6,506 families with a total annual income of 1,298,983 rupees, which give an average somewhat higher than the average income of the weaver, but considerably lower than the average income of the cultivator. They are however a class with few desires to satisfy and they have a standard of comfort which is considerably lower than the standard of the cultivator. Generally speaking, they succeed in feeding themselves and their families as fully as their hearts desire.
Domestic and menial servants are chiefly employed by shopkeepers, landowners and the educated, but also to some extent by the more prosperous cultivators and traders. In comparison with the rest of the community they are probably better paid than the same class in Europe.
All classifications and figures of income for the non-agricultural population as a whole are somewhat fallacious owing to the mixture of such diverse elements ; but a comparison with the agricultural population is not without interest.
| Agricultural. | Non-agricultural. | |
|---|---|---|
| In comfort | 49½ | 47 |
| Below comfort | 28½ | 27 |
| Above want | 18 | 20 |
| In want | 4 | 5½ |
It will be seen that the condition of the non-cultivator is generally worse than the condition of the cultivator. If the ‘bhadralok’, the moneylenders and the large traders were eliminated, the non-cultivator would come far worse out of the comparison. The average individual income in the several economic groups is substantially the same in the two classes, the excess in the income of the ‘comfortable’ non-cultivator being entirely due to the inclusion of the landlords and successful traders and ‘bhadralok’ in the group. The figures of income per head are :—
| Annual average income of a cultivator. | Annual average income of a non-cultivator. | |
|---|---|---|
| Rs. | Rs. | |
| In comfort . | 60 | 80 |
| Below comfort | 43 | 42 |
| Above want | 34 | 31 |
| In want | 27 | 24 |
The statistics collected were, as I have already mentioned, less trustworthy for the non-agricultural population than for the agricultural, but they reflect in the main the lessons which ordinary observation teaches. It is unfortunate that owing to the absence of detailed figures it is impossible to separate the successful from the ordinary members of each economic group; thus, in trade, had the larger traders in the great markets been separated in the statistics, the economic condition of the ordinary trader would have been apparent. Similarly, had the incomes of the larger landowners been separated the struggle for subsistence of the great majority would have been open to view. However, the figures sufficiently illustrate the dominant feature of economic conditions in Faridpur—that the whole community really depends upon agriculture for its livelihood. All the richest families in the district are parasites upon agriculture, the landowners who live on rents and give no service in return, the lawyers who live on litigation and help the peasant to waste his profits, the moneylenders who live on the necessities of the poor and the goldsmiths who cater for their extravagance. Apart from the produce of the soil, there is little indeed to support life in Faridpur. Jute is the only valuable export, and the import trade is very dull. A large trade passes through the district, but none of it is handled by its inhabitants. Weavers might be removed without any substantial loss to the prosperity of the district. Indeed, fishermen alone add anything appreciable to the produce of the soil. Not only is agriculture the whole of the economic life in Faridpur, but, as is proper, it has the best of that life, for the produce of the soil is not unfairly divided amongst the cultivating community. If inequality is the rule of life, at least there is in Faridpur amongst the peasants no undue proportion of families who are very poor, while amongst the great majority inequalities of income are not too greatly emphasized. Amongst that small non-agricultural population which does not depend upon the soil for its living conditions are much more unequal. A considerable proportion is far richer than even the most affluent of the cultivators; the great majority is certainly poorer than the mass of the cultivators; and there is a large minority very much poorer still, who have only a few unfortunates as counterpart in the agricultural world.