Chapter V

Taxation

The Economic Life of a Bengal District, J. C. Jack, 1916 · from page 113 · about 32 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

The incidence of taxation in any country is always an interesting but a difficult subject of enquiry. The enquirer is beset by pitfalls on all sides. Taxation assumes many forms and he cannot judge their relative severity; he must know the income of the country and he has no accurate statistics to help him. In some of the more civilized countries of the world attempts have been made recently by economists or statisticians to estimate the annual income, by which is meant not the value of the annual production but the sum of the annual incomes of every individual in the State. These estimates are very much in the nature of guesses, as must always be when a large part of the capital is invested in corporations or in foreign countries and when no return is made of lesser incomes. In England, where the income-tax applies to all forms of property and covers a reasonable proportion of the people, these estimates are probably more nearly correct than in countries where there is no income-tax to act as a guide to the estimator; but even in England trained statisticians differ in their estimates of the total income so widely that some place it at £1,600,000,000, others at £2,400,000,000. If the estimate of income is uncertain the burden of taxation on that income is still more difficult to assess. A large part of the revenue of every country is derived from customs duties, of which political economists have as yet failed to measure the effect. There is sound authority for the opinion that the buyer pays the duty, sound authority for the opinion that the seller pays the duty, and as sound authority for the opinion that the duty is paid partly by the buyer and partly by the seller in proportions varying in every country and in every article of commerce. It is difficult, therefore, to estimate the burden which such duties place upon the country. Apart from customs duties all countries differ in the proportions of their revenue which they derive from indirect sources, such as excise, stamps and commercial undertakings, and from direct taxation. Any comparison, therefore, between country and country must be subject to so many qualifications that at the best it can be only a rough guide; yet, in judging the pitch of taxation in India, it is impossible to avoid a comparison with other countries, if the burden of that taxation is to be measured by the ordinary reader. To say, for example, that taxation amounts to sixpence in the pound conveys nothing as a measure of burden to a foreigner, unless he rapidly makes a mental calculation of how much in the pound the taxation in his own country represents.

In Faridpur it is easy to estimate with considerable accuracy the burden of taxation. If the figures of income which have been compiled are at all correct, one of the two difficulties which face the estimator has been completely solved. The other difficulty, the revenue gathered, which is not easy to calculate for any division such as a county in European countries, is in India made comparatively easy by the fact that the district is the unit in which revenue is assessed and collected. It is only in the customs duties, which are collected at the port of entry, and in widespread commercial undertakings, such as State Railways, that there is any doubt.

In Faridpur the revenue collected under various heads is divided between three authorities, the greater part being allocated to the Imperial or Central Government and the lesser part being divided between local bodies and the local police force. The details of this revenue in the last year for which statistics are obtainable are given in round figures: land revenue (the Imperial Land Tax) 600,000 rupees or £40,000; stamps, chiefly judicial, 780,000 rupees or £52,000; income-tax 60,000 rupees or £4,000; excise and opium 180,000 rupees or £12,000; miscellaneous 120,000 rupees or £8,000. The whole of this revenue, amounting to 1,730,000 rupees or about £116,000, is allocated to the Central Government. The local rates, which are expended entirely within the district, amounted to 195,000 rupees or £13,000, while the local police-tax amounted to about 300,000 rupees or £20,000. This tax is assessed and collected by the village officials, and spent on watch and ward within the village. These figures represent the whole amount of revenue collected by the central or any local authority in the district. The large item of stamps reflects the extraordinary enthusiasm of the people for civil litigation, as four-fifths of this sum was collected in the shape of fees upon documents used in the law courts. The land-tax is a legacy of the Permanent Settlement and has never been varied for over 120 years. When originally imposed it nominally represented 91 per cent. of the rent paid by the cultivators of the soil, the remaining 9 per cent. being retained by the agents who collected the rent. There seems reason to believe, however, that it really represented a much smaller proportion of the rent and that the landowners who collected it retained a much larger proportion than was intended. In any case, the effect of the Permanent Settlement was to convert tax-collectors into landlords and to assure to them the natural increase in value which peace and growing prosperity and population would confer upon the land. Had the Permanent Settlement not been effected the whole of this increase would have become land-tax payable to the Central Government; it now goes to the landlords, who have thereby secured about 2,400,000 rupees or £160,000, their profits from the land having increased sixfold since the Permanent Settlement was concluded, while the land-tax remains at the same figure, £40,000, at which it was fixed 120 years ago. The local rates are imposed by the local authority and are assessed upon the rent paid by the cultivating classes, or in the two small towns upon property. They are very light, and represent to the cultivator an income-tax of less than 1 per cent. (about 0·3 per cent.) and to the landlord an income-tax of about 3 per cent. In the small towns the property-tax is assessed very capriciously and amounts in the average to 1½ rupees or 2s. per head of the population, equivalent to an income-tax of about 2 per cent. or less. The local police-rate, which is not collected in the towns, is in effect an income-tax on every family throughout the rest of the district. It is levied very unevenly, but it appears to represent in the average a tax of 0·3 per cent. upon income.

The other sources of revenue of government in India are all indirect. They are either customs and salt duties, or the profits of State railways and of commercial departments such as forests and the post office. There is no means of estimating what burden they impose upon different parts of the country. In calculating what portion of them is borne by the district of Faridpur it is fairest to assume that they press equally upon every family in India. In the total they amount to a sum of 2s. 4½d. per head of the population.

We are now in a position to examine the total taxation borne by the people of Faridpur :

TBL-006 · FOLIO 121Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Per head of population.
s.d.
Paid to the Central Government:
Customs duties and excise17
Salt3
Profits and State Railways6½
Miscellaneous profits and receipts1
Stamps6
Income-tax½
Land-tax4½
Local Rates1½
Village Taxation2¼
Total38¼

The total is really a little less; but owing to the absence of detailed figures, I have not been able to separate excise from customs duties. The yield of excise and opium is very small (only 1½d. per head of the population) in an abstinent district like Faridpur, much smaller indeed than in India as a whole.

It may be assumed that the revenue from all sources amounts in Faridpur to about 3s. 6d. (Rs. 2 A. 10) per head of the population. A calculation on the same basis shows that the revenue demand in Bengal is only half what it is in any other province in India, although in all probability the income per head of population is greater than in any other province. The economic statistics which have been reviewed reveal an average income per head of 52 rupees or £3 9s. in the district. The total revenue demand is, therefore, about 5 per cent., or a shilling in the pound.

The Bengali delights to compare his country with England in all matters economic, although in truth there is no country in the world with which Bengal is less suitable for comparison. Great Britain is so preponderantly an industrial country that only one-seventh of the population is dependent upon the land for a livelihood; in Bengal the industrial population is insignificant and four-fifths of the population are directly supported by the land. In Great Britain five out of every six persons live in towns larger than any town in Faridpur, whereas in Faridpur only three persons in a hundred live in towns at all, and those towns are in everything except the name merely overgrown villages. Nevertheless the comparison should be made, as it will serve to exhibit more clearly than any other means the incidence of revenue in Bengal. The comparison is the more valuable because the proportion of revenue derived from tax and non-tax sources is approximately the same, thus :

TBL-007 · FOLIO 122Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Percentage of total revenue derived from
Customs and excise.Stamps.Profits.Direct taxation.
Great Britain .3851839
India . .36101440

In the comparison I have adopted as the total income of Great Britain the latest estimate of the best statisticians, £2,000,000,000, or £45 per head of the population. The comparison is as follows:

TBL-008 · FOLIO 123Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Great Britain.Faridpur.
£s.d.£s.d.
Total revenue of the central government (tax and non-tax) per head of population317034½
Total revenue (tax) of the local authorities per head of population3003¾
Income per head of population4500390
Incidence of revenue upon income :
Central revenue8½ per cent.8½ per cent.
Local „6⅔ „ „¼ „ „
Total „15¼ „ „8¾ „ „

It is more profitable to compare an agricultural district like Faridpur with the agricultural countries of the civilized world. It is impossible, however, to obtain sufficient information to complete the comparison. Most of the reference books which are obtainable give the figures of revenue without sufficient explanation, and many omit the details of local taxation altogether. The burden of the revenue upon the average income is, however, the real criterion. Unfortunately, no estimate of the total or average income in any of these countries is available. All that it is possible to say is that it is universally admitted that the average income in Great Britain is greater than in any of the countries selected for comparison and very much greater than in most of them.

The following table has been compiled from the latest statistics available for the period before the war. The figures for the revenues of the central governments all refer to the financial year preceding the outbreak of the war (1913–14). The figures for the revenues of the local authorities refer to that year

TBL-009 · FOLIO 124Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Revenue per head:Sources of revenue (central).
Country.Of central authority.Of local authority.Total.Customs and Excise.Stamps.Profits.Direct taxation.
per cent.per cent.per cent.per cent.
£s.d.£s.d.£s.d.
France4160112068037172323
Italy215011031603693124
Denmark211021041205191624
Sweden24011604005482216
Holland310211051204471633
Japan12012011404462624
Faridpur34½3¾38¼36101440

(Denmark, Japan) or the year previous (Italy, Sweden, Holland) or the year 1910 (France). The revenues of the central governments have been so distributed under the four heads as to present as uniform a classification and as clean a division as the data and the diverse practice of the several countries permit.

The astonishing feature about this comparison is the extraordinarily low rate of revenue in India. If it be urged that a high revenue and even a relatively high revenue in European countries is really a smaller burden upon the people owing to their larger resources than a low revenue in Asiatic countries, the case of Japan still remains to be explained. The rate of revenue in Japan is nine times as large as the rate in Bengal, but he would be a bold man who dared assert that the resources of the two countries bear a like proportion. There seems sound reason to believe that the income of a country district in Japan is really less and not more than the income of a district of Eastern Bengal, as wages appear in every occupation to be at a lower level. Civilized government is not a cheap thing, and the recognized law is that the poorer the country the greater the cost of its government. India is an amazing exception. It will be observed that Bengal, as illustrated by the figures collected for the district of Faridpur, is incontestably the most lightly taxed of civilized countries in the world. It is probable that there is no other in which the burden of taxation is not twice or three times as great as it is in Bengal. If it be urged that Faridpur is an exceptionally prosperous district and no guide to the conditions in the rest of Bengal, it may at once be answered that, on the contrary, it is the poorest district agriculturally in the whole of Eastern Bengal and that the cultivators and the general population of all the neighbouring districts on the south, east and west are certainly better off. Without a complete investigation this statement is not capable of absolute proof; but it is noteworthy that Bakarganj, the district on the south, which has the same proportion of the population dependent upon agriculture for a livelihood, produces crops which are twice as valuable to sustain a population which is very little more.

Cheap government is not necessarily good government, but it is certain that the people of Bengal, although they pay only one-half or one-third of the people of other countries for their government, get very little less in return. To any unprejudiced student of conditions in Europe and conditions in India it must be clear that any weakness or inefficiency in the administration of India is exclusively in local administration. There is not a single country in Europe nor a civilized country in Asia which does not pay far more heavily than India for its central government and which obtains in return superior service. The Indian bureaucracy has supplied India with cheaper railway communications than any possessed by European countries, has provided for her the greatest irrigation works in the world, has created a judicial system which will bear comparison for fairness and expedition with any system elsewhere, has maintained order and the security of life and property in the most unlikely conditions, has grappled successfully with widespread failure of crops, the most difficult problem which any government has ever been called upon to face, and has attempted of late years the stupendous labour of providing an ignorant and densely-populated country with a modern system of education and a modern system of sanitation. It has done all this at a cost which is an infinitely lighter burden upon the resources of a poor country than any of the governments in Europe has placed upon the resources of a rich country.

It is only when the eyes are turned upon local administration that the backwardness of India is apparent in comparison with Europe. Apart from the hardly-civilized nations in the Balkans or decadent countries like Spain and Portugal, the states of Europe provide for all their inhabitants elementary education, insist upon effective sanitation, supply good roads and means of communication, good lighting, and the numerous other material concomitants of modern civilization. In most, if not in all, countries this is done at the expense of local authorities by means of taxation which is neither imposed nor handled by the central government. It has not always or usually been done at the wish of the inhabitants or at the instance of the local authorities, but it has generally to a great extent and always to some extent been done at the direction of the central government through the agency of the local authorities. For this purpose the local authorities have provided themselves or have been provided with ample funds. An examination of the figures already given will show that none of the more progressive countries in Europe raises less than a quarter of its revenue by direct taxation through local authorities for expenditure upon local needs. The figures given for Faridpur will show, on the other hand, that the sums raised in Bengal by the local authorities or for local needs are insignificant and do not amount to a tenth part of the total revenue of the country. With such inadequate means it is impossible that local administration can bear any comparison with local administration in Europe.

It would perhaps be unfair to select for more detailed comparison any of the richest and foremost countries in Europe—Great Britain, Germany, or France—but it will not be at all unfair to take Italy, where the circumstances and character of the people are not very dissimilar from those in Bengal, where almost as large a proportion of the inhabitants is supported by agriculture and where the poverty of the country has always been a great obstacle to the efficiency of its government. Moreover in the matter of modern government Italy starts with no great advantage in the point of time over India. If the condition of India until the middle of the nineteenth century was chaotic, the condition of Italy at the same period was even more chaotic; if modern administration may be said to start in India after the Mutiny of 1857, modern administration in Italy may with equal justice be said to start after the reunion in 1859. The two countries are therefore eminently fit for comparison.

It so happens that a very competent enquirer published lately an analysis of income and taxation in a typical Italian village in an agricultural part of the country. He did not estimate the sum of the annual incomes of all the villagers, but he estimated the value of the total agricultural produce and he calculated the amount of taxation imposed by the central and local governments and by the village council. As regards the taxation of the central government he confined himself to the land-tax, which appears to represent only 10 per cent. of the revenue raised by the central government in Italy. In writing an official report upon the preparation of a Record of Rights in the district of Bakarganj, adjacent to Faridpur, I had occasion to use this analysis for the purpose of comparison. Bakarganj came very well out of the comparison, the net income of the cultivator being equal to that of the Italian cultivator who pays six times as much in taxes. The writer of the article remarked of life in the Italian village : ‘the people are vegetarians, not from choice but from necessity. They cannot afford to eat meat nor even eggs ; they cannot afford to eat wheat bread but eat maize porridge and maize bread, vegetables and fruit, and what the cow produces.’ This is for all practical purposes a description of the food of the people of Faridpur without the comfortable addition of fish in abundance to the daily diet. The houses of the Italian peasants are, no doubt, stronger, but that is due to the greater severity of the climate ; they do not contain as much floor space, although they are much better furnished. The clothes of the peasant are made of better cloth and are far less scanty, but this again is due to the difference of climate ; they must be warmer or the peasant will perish, but in return he has to content himself with one or two suits. The writer remarks that the Italian population has scarcely any money at all for such indulgences as jewellery and spends very much less upon marriages and similar domestic ceremonies. On a close comparison of taxation in the Italian village with taxation in the Bakarganj village, it appeared that while the Italian land-tax was three times as large, the local authority took twice as much, and the village council took seventeen times as much from the Italian peasant as from the Bakarganj peasant. In other words, what the Bengal peasant spends on marriages and jewellery, the Italian peasant is compelled by his government to spend on roads and lighting, on sanitation, on a good water supply, on medical attendance and on education. The economic enquiry in Faridpur has enabled even closer comparison to be made of the burden of taxation in both countries; but the results are very much the same. The Italian peasant surrenders one-third of the produce of the soil in land-tax or in local and village taxation; the Faridpur peasant less than one-twentieth. It is true that he has to pay in addition rent to his private landlord; but this amounts to less than a tenth of the produce of the soil and in any case does not reach the public exchequer.

Not all of this disproportion in the burden of taxation is due to the acquisition of those material benefits which are the principal feature of western civilization. It is clear that the system of administration in Italy is far more expensive than in India and, if a foreigner may judge, it is considerably less efficient. Railways in Italy are no more numerous and are much worse managed than they are in India, while light lines to serve village needs, such as are common in the best-governed European countries, are conspicuous by their absence in Italy. Civil justice is dilatory, criminal administration admittedly inefficient, and the police bear no very high reputation. But in the provision of local conveniences Italy is immeasurably more advanced. It is true that Faridpur is backward even for Bengal. Trunk roads are few and bad, there are no village roads of any sort although they are urgently wanted; doctors are fewer and less well qualified than in neighbouring districts, although fever and other diseases have taken such a heavy toll in some parts of the district as to reduce the population materially; finally, in the matter of education and its extension into the villages and amongst the cultivators, Farīdpur appears to be the most backward district in Eastern Bengal. It is only necessary, however, to compare the conveniences supplied to every agricultural village in Italy with the conveniences supplied to even the best-managed villages in Farīdpur to see that in the matter of local administration there is much room for improvement; in truth, in local administration every village in Italy is better managed than even the head-quarters town in Farīdpur. The Italian village has good roads and good lighting, good water and efficient sanitation. All children, both boys and girls, receive elementary education. A doctor and a midwife are provided free for the benefit of the villagers.

There is an opinion, which is generally held in England and by the educated class in India and has been emphasized in some recent books on India by people insufficiently informed of the facts, that India as a whole and in every part is overtaxed. This view will not bear a minute's scrutiny in Farīdpur in the light of the information which has been so laboriously gathered. The truth is that Bengal at least is more lightly taxed than any other civilized country in the world; and not only more lightly taxed, but far more lightly taxed. This comparison with one of the civilized countries in Europe serves to bring out the conditions by which taxation has been kept so low. It is due certainly in part to extreme economy and extreme efficiency in the central government, but it is also due to great neglect in local administration. Such neglect is in great measure the result of the circumstances of British rule in India. It is impossible for alien rulers to force material benefits upon a people which has not learnt to desire them, unless they can be introduced without any heavy increase in taxation. There would undoubtedly be grave discontent in every Faridpur village if village taxation were increased at one bound to the Italian level, even though the villager obtained in return all and more than all the material benefits which the Italian villager has secured. There is no doubt, however, that he would be prepared to pay without grumbling some increase in taxation if he could obtain in return some of the more obvious advantages, such as roads, good water, or medical attendance. The chief obstacle to an increase in village taxation has hitherto been the opposition of the central government owing to its ignorance of the incidence of existing taxation upon the income of the people. Although all governments in India have known for some time that India, and more especially Bengal, bears a very light burden of taxation, yet they have never had in their possession any accurate or detailed statistics with which to measure and to demonstrate its incidence. On the other hand, a considerable body of Indian opinion and a considerable number of uninstructed Englishmen have urged the view in and out of season that taxation in India is excessive and a disproportionate drain upon the resources of the people. Unless proof were available of the real incidence of taxation it was difficult in the face of such views held by influential parties to attempt any increase in local burdens. It was easier to leave the villager in the nakedness, which he hardly discerned, than to clothe him with modern conveniences at the risk of an agitation. Moreover in the absence of clear proof there was always the uncomfortable possibility that the pessimists might be right and the resources of the villagers so small as to make even the existing taxation excessive. The truth is that in Bengal not only is all taxation exceptionally light, but local taxation in particular is an insignificant burden upon the resources of the people, that the provision of local conveniences and material benefits is in consequence very inadequate, but that it cannot be improved unless larger sums are placed at the disposal of the local authorities.

The existing local taxation amounts in its yield to the local authorities to a rate of rather over a penny in the pound or about ½ per cent. on the total income of the population of the district. The amount actually paid by the taxpayers is probably double this rate owing to the extortion, corruption and waste which accompany the existing methods of assessment. One-sixth of the population is omitted from assessment, and the assessment upon the remainder is uneven and capricious. In truth, the present resources of the local authorities could be doubled by a reform in assessment and collection without increasing the rate at which the present taxes are collected.

The local rates are of two kinds, collected and assessed by different agencies and devoted to different objects, the district rate which is known as the Road and Public Works Cess, and the village rate which is known as the Chokidari Tax. The district rate is levied upon the agricultural classes only, although the services upon which it is spent, roads, water-supply and the like, equally benefit the non-agricultural classes. It is a tax of 6 per cent. assessed upon rent, half being paid by the landlord and half by the tenant. In other words, it is intended that the cultivator should pay a penny, the landlord a penny, and that the local authority should receive twopence, the landlord paying in the whole sum after gathering the tenants' penny from his tenants. In actual practice, however, the landlords habitually collect the whole tax from the cultivator, not only the amount which he ought to pay, but the amount also which they ought to pay; and they very often collect more than this amount and obtain a profit on the transaction. The assessment of the rate is a very cumbersome and costly process. The amount which each tenant or cultivator pays is proportionate to his rent and is therefore collected automatically by the landlord; but the amount which each landlord ought to pay is a lengthy calculation, which is made by the local authorities only at long intervals. In the intervening periods additional taxation due from increase in rent (which is a constant feature in Bengal) goes to the pocket of the landlord and not to the local authority.

The chief objection to the rate is, however, the exemption of the non-agricultural classes, weavers, fishermen, labourers, clerks, shopkeepers, and the like. There can be no reason for exempting these classes from payment, for such benefits as the activities of the local authority confer upon the villagers are shared equally by all, and the tax is in no respect used to help agriculture alone or to further only the interests of the cultivators. Careful enquiries were made into the amount which the cultivator actually pays, and it was found that it represented a penny in the pound upon his income. If the existing rate upon rent were converted into a penny in the pound upon income and applied to all non-agricultural as well as to all agricultural classes, the yield would be 400,000 rupees, or about three times as much as at present, the cultivator would pay no more than he does at present, the landlord would not escape or make a profit, and the non-cultivator would pay equally with the cultivator and would not obtain the benefits conferred by local administration for nothing.

The chokidari tax, or village rate, is assessed and collected in an entirely different manner. It is assessed in a rough and ready fashion by the headman of each village as a tax upon income with a maximum limit, and is spent upon the provision of village police. The total yield in Faridpur is equivalent to less than a penny in the pound upon income (0·3 per cent.), but the assessment is very capricious. Upon an investigation, which was most carefully made, of the amount paid by each family, and a comparison with the income of that family, it appears that generally speaking the poorer classes pay double as much as the richer classes, and too many of the latter escape altogether. The number of families in really good circumstances who escape too lightly or altogether was astonishing, especially amongst Hindus, while on the other hand at least half of the families who were found to be living in a condition very little removed from actual want were assessed to the rate. Were the average tax now realized from the poorer half of the population (½ per cent.) applied to the richer half and no exemptions permitted, the yield would be about 64 per cent. more than at present, while the rate on the poorest families would be considerably reduced.

During our economic investigations the incidence of local taxation was examined most carefully. The amount paid by each individual family was compared with the income of the family. It is reasonable to assume that the information which was collected can be trusted. The substance of that information is that the burden is not equally borne by all sections of the community, that all non-agricultural families and the richer cultivators escape too lightly, and that the local authorities receive less than half of what has been paid. The total yield to the local authorities is about four lakhs of rupees, although the total amount paid on account of the two taxes appears to be about eight lakhs of rupees. A rate of 1 per cent. upon income, or 2½d. in the pound, appears to be the scale upon which the poorer half of the cultivators is actually (not nominally) taxed. If the road cess were abolished and the chokidari tax were converted into a local tax upon income at this rate and applied to all classes of the community, the yield in Faridpur would be over ten lakhs of rupees or 2½ times the existing yield. It will be observed that the increase would be obtained without alteration in the scale on which the poorer cultivators are at present taxed; but entirely by assessing the richer cultivators and all non-cultivators at the same scale.

I venture to make these suggestions because it is clear that greater expenditure on local administration will soon in Bengal become an urgent necessity. Before fresh taxation is proposed or considered, it is desirable that the incidence, yield and possibilities of existing rates of taxation should be accurately measured. Were these suggestions adopted, the cess upon rent abolished and the chokidari tax converted into a 1 per cent. tax upon all incomes, no new machinery for collection would need to be devised. The new tax would be collected, as is the chokidari tax, by the headmen of the villages, who do their work as well as any work of this kind is done in Bengal and much better than the landlords. There can indeed be no dispute that the headman is the most efficient agency for the collection of local rates. The assessment of these rates is an entirely different matter, which should not be left to the headman. It is true that the headman at present assesses the chokidari tax, but Table IV appended to these pages will show how capriciously he makes the assessment. He has sufficient local knowledge for the purpose, but is not sufficiently independent of local influences. It will not be disputed perhaps that to have made detailed investigations into the income of nearly 350,000 families warrants a claim to some knowledge of the difficulty of the task. I have no hesitation in saying that investigations into income are very easy to conduct in the simple circumstances of an Indian village. The value of the results depends chiefly upon the fairness of the investigator. It is essential that officers of superior position 1 should be employed who would be certain to combine the requisite knowledge and intelligence with the requisite freedom from local influences. It is the single mind which is most needed to make an accurate estimation, as it is in truth impossible for a man of ordinary intelligence to make any serious error in estimating the income of the ordinary family. In nine out of every ten families the intelligent observer can in a very short time make a guess which will be nearly accurate of the income of each family. It is only in the incomes of the comparatively rare misers or spendthrifts that any mistake is likely to be made, and the assessor would always have the headman and the principal villagers at hand to warn him. Taxation on the gross income of the family is, however, unequal in any community and is in Bengal very unequal owing to the great differences in the size of the family. A family which contains several young children cannot be assessed with fairness in the same manner as a family which consists entirely of adults, although the income of both may be the same. In some villages the headman, in assessing the chokidari tax, solved this difficulty by dividing the income by the number of persons whom it supported and arriving at an income per head. This was certainly a fairer means of assessing the tax, which by a natural development might be converted into an ideal method. The cost of maintenance of a woman or a young child is only half the cost of maintenance of a male of fifteen years or more. If each woman or young child were counted as only half a person in the calculation of the income per head, the result would be to obtain an artificial income per head of the population which would roughly correspond in every family to the amount per head available for expenditure. A tax upon this artificial income per head, deduced as it would be from the actual income of the family and its actual constitution, would equalize the burden of the rate in a way which no other system can possibly attempt. In the towns of western countries, where no one knows anything about his neighbour's business, such a system of taxation would probably be impossible; but in an Indian village, where every man knows the affairs of his neighbours almost as well as his own, so little can be hidden that an intelligent officer employing this system could, without any great difficulty, assess the proportions of the tax so that it would impose an equal burden upon every family in the village.

The cost of such an assessment by government officers of the class indicated would not be prohibitive, nor in fact need it be more than the cost of the assessment as made at present. It has been found that enormous sums are spent in revaluing a district under the present system for the purpose of the cess upon rent. The amount spent on such revaluations spread over every year during which they are in force would suffice to maintain a staff of a superior grade of officials able to assess the whole district on a basis of income once in every five years. Two advantages would be certain to accrue, an increase in the sum placed at the disposal of the local authorities, which would be more than twice as large as the sum which they have now at their disposal, and an equal distribution of the burden over all classes of the community. These advantages are worth securing, the more so that they do not involve any heavier burden upon the poorer classes. The taxation of 1 per cent. on income is not only very small in itself, but is also very considerably less than the amount paid for purposes of local administration by the inhabitants of the two small towns in the district. They are constituted as municipalities under the Municipal Act and for the upkeep of roads, lighting and conservancy they levy a property tax. It is a commonplace that this tax is most unequally assessed. The richer and professional classes generally escape with a very light assessment, the poorer and trading classes making up the deficiency. In the average the taxation in the two towns appear, as far as can be judged, to be equivalent to an income-tax of 21/2 per cent. or 6d. in the pound upon income. This is borne by the inhabitants without any grumbling, although it is, as will be observed, three times as heavy as the taxation in force in the rural parts of the district.

There can be no question that a universal income-tax, which embraces every income and varies with the size of the family, is the ideal form of taxation for any country. It has two supreme fiscal merits in that it is certain in its demand and in its yield and that it keeps pace with every change in the value of money. When prices are rising, its yield automatically increases, thus avoiding the necessity of disturbing the peace by changes in the method or the rate of existing taxation. It has also one great political merit in that it exhibits the taxable capacity of the country in the most accurate and unmistakable way. It reveals the national income and converts a calculation of the burden of taxation into a simple sum in proportion. In a country like India which is ruled by an alien government, whose fiscal policy dare not admit an error and whose every action is scrutinized by cold and critical eyes, these merits have an altogether exceptional value. The most pressing need of Indian administration in these days is accurate economic information in such a form that while it will enable all measures to be framed on a basis of ascertained fact, it will also be available to rob the critic of his sentimental stock-in-trade. Such information is best supplied by the univeral income-tax. To establish a universal income-tax is an undertaking from which the strongest governments have quailed. The Bengal administrator is happy in that it is already in existence, waiting only for development and modification to become an ideal fiscal instrument.

The collection of the economic information of which these pages attempt to give an analysis was not, however, undertaken for the purpose of advancing theory or suggesting reform. It was an attempt to tabulate the economic resources of the district. It may be as well to conclude with a brief summary of the broad results. If the statistics are trustworthy, the average income per head in the district of Faridpur is 52 rupees, the average debt 11 rupees and the average taxation 2¾ rupees. As the population of the district was 2,122,000 at the census of 1911, the total income of the inhabitants of the district would be 11 and their total debt 2⅓ crores of rupees.

Notes

  1. 1. In our investigations members of the Subordinate Executive Service and Settlement Kanungos were employed.