Extracts from an article by Mr. Manohar Lal, B. A. (Cantab), late Minto Professor of Economics in the University of Calcutta, published in the Indian Journal of Economics for July, 1916:
“The average income per head has remained the same (that is $10 a year) during the last thirty years and more. . . . It is a fact that deserves careful study at the hands of all students that with signs of growing prosperity everywhere, with an undoubted advance in the whole apparatus of industrial life, the average Indian income has remained stationary. How far this fact involves that a vast proportion of our population can have taken no share in the general urban rise in India, and in view of the undeniable fact of large increases in prices how far it probably has entailed some depression in the economic status of her masses — these are enquiries that must present themselves to every student of economics in the country, and thoughtful Indians have not been able to interpret their bearing in a sense favourable to the country’s prosperity. · · · · · ·
“Poverty, grinding poverty, is a tremendous fact of our economic, and therefore national, position, and it is to the mind of the present writer an immeasurably more potent fact than even the ignorance and illiteracy that prevails among our masses. This poverty exposes us to the havoc of disease and pestilence, famine and plague and it makes advance at every step difficult."
Mr. Monohar Lal then compares the food budget of an English workingman’s family, that of a railway carriage washer with that of an Indian field labourer as given by Mr. Keating, an Englishman, in his very careful work on rural economy in the Deccan and observes :
“ It is a picture of literal starvation mentally, and all but so physically ; it can represent the life of no unit of civilised humanity.”
Further on, summarising the present situation, he remarks :
“ Indian population grows, her earning power per head is stationary, such increase in her industries as has taken place is nothing compared to the growth of her population. The inference is irresistible ; life in India continues on the lowest plane, untouched by all the movements and progress that is in the air.”