England’s Debt to India

Appendix E

Comparative Statement of Salaries in India and the United States

England’s Debt to India, Lala Lajpat Rai, 1917 · from page 351 · about 9 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

The President of the United States, who ranks with the great royalties of the world in position, gets a salary of $75,000 without any other allowance. The Prime Minister of Japan gets 12,000 yen, or $6,000. The Viceroy and the Governor General of India get 250,000 rupees, or $83,000, besides a very large amount in the shape of various allowances. The cabinet ministers of the United States get a salary of $12,000 each, the Japanese 8,000 yen, or $4,000, and the Members of the Viceroy’s Council $26,700 each. In the whole Federal Government of the United States there are only three offices which carry a salary of more than $8,000 a year. They are:

TBL-073 · FOLIO 392Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
The President of the General Navy Board$13,500
Solicitor General10,000
Assistant Solicitor General9,000

All the other salaries range from $2,100 to $8,000. In the State Department all offices, including those of the secretaries, carry salaries of from $2,100 to $5,000. In the Treasury Department, the Treasurer gets $8,000, three other officers have $6,000 each. All the remaining officials get from $2,500 to $5,000. In the War Department there are only two offices which have a salary of $8,000 attached to them: that of Chief of Staff and that of Quarter Master General. The rest get from $2,000 to $6,000. In the Navy Department besides the President of the General Board mentioned above, the President of the Naval Examination Board gets $8,000 and so does the Commandant of the Marine Corps. All the rest get from $6,000 downwards. In the Department of Agriculture there is only one office carrying a salary of $6,000. All the rest get from $5,000 downwards. The Chief of the Weather Bureau, an expert, gets $6,000. In the Commerce Department four experts get $6,000 each, the rest from $5,000 downwards. These are the annual salaries.

In Japan the officials of the Imperial Household have salaries ranging from $2,750 to $4,000. Officials of the Higher Civil Service get from $1,850 to $2,100 a year; the Vice-Minister of State, $2,500; Chief of the Legislative Bureau, $2,500; the Chief Secretary of the Cabinet, $2,500; and the Inspector General of the Metropolitan Police, $2,500; President of the Administrative Litigation Court, $3,000; President of the Railway Board, $3,750; President of the Privy Council, $3,000; Vice-President of the Privy Council, $2,750, and so on. All these salaries are yearly.

When we come to India we find that the President of the Railway Board gets from $20,000 to $24,000, and that two other members of the Railway Board get $16,000. Secretaries in the Army, Public Works, and Legislative departments get $14,000. Secretaries in Finance, Foreign, Home, Revenue, Agriculture, Commerce, and Industry departments get $16,000. The Secretary in the Education Department gets $12,000; Joint Secretary, $10,000; Controller and Auditor General, $14,000; Accountant General, from $9,000 to $11,000; Commissioner of Salt Revenue, $10,000; Director of Post and Telegraph from $12,000 to $14,000.

Among the officers directly under the Government of India there are only a few who get salaries below $7,000. Most of the others get from that sum up to $12,000. The fact that the population of the United States consists of people of all races and that there is a constant flow of immigration makes the work of administration very difficult and complex — far more so than the administrative problems in India.

PROVINCIAL ADMINISTRATION

The United States Government has under it 48 States and Territories. Some of them are as large in area, if not even larger than the several provinces of India. The Governors of these States are paid from $2,500 to $12,000 a year. Illinois is the only State paying $12,000; five States, including New York and California, pay $10,000; two, Massachusetts and Indiana, pay $8,000; one pays $7,000, and three pay $6,000. All the rest pay $5,000 or less. There is only one territory under the United States Government, the Philippines, which pays a salary of $20,000 to its Governor General. In India, the Governors of Madras, Bombay, and Bengal each receive $40,000, besides a large amount for allowances. The Lieutenant Governors of the Punjab, the United Provinces, Behar and Burma get $33,000 each besides allowances. The Chief Commissioners receive $11,000 in Behar, $18,700 in Assam, $20,700 in the Central Provinces, and $12,000 in Delhi. The Political Residents in the Native States receive from $11,000 to $16,000, besides allowances. In Japan the Governors of Provinces are paid from $1,850 to $2,250 per year, besides allowances varying from $200 to $300.

The provincial services in India are paid on a far more lavish scale than anywhere else in the world. In Bengal the salaries range from $1,600 for an assistant magistrate and collector to $21,333 to Members of the Council, and this same extravagance is also true of the other provinces.

Coming to the Judiciary, we find that Justices of the Supreme Court of the United States get a salary of $14,500 each, the Chief Justice getting $15,000; the Circuit Judges get a salary of $7,000 each, the District Judges $6,000. In the State of New York the Judges of the Supreme Court belonging to the General Sessions get from $17,500, and those of the Special Sessions from $9,000 to $10,000 each. City Magistrates get from $7,000 to $8,000 each. In India the Chief Justice of Bengal gets $24,000; the Chief Justices of Bombay, Madras, and the United Provinces, $20,000 each. The Chief Judges of the Chief Court of the Punjab and Burma get $16,000 each, and the Puisine Judges of the High Courts the same amount. The Puisine Judges of the Chief Courts receive $14,000. In the Province of Bengal the salaries of the District and Session Judges range from $8,000 to $12,000. District Judges of the other provinces get from about $7,000 to $12,000. The Deputy Commissioners in India get a salary in the different provinces ranging from $6,000 to $9,000 a year. The Commissioners get from $10,000 to $12,000. In Japan, the Appeal Court Judges and Procurators get from $900 to $2,500 a year. Only one officer, the President of the Court of Causation, gets as much as $3,000. The District Court Judges and Procurators are paid at the rate of from $375 to $1,850. It is needless to compare the salaries of minor officials in the three countries. Since the Indian taxpayer has to pay so heavily for the European services engaged in the work of administration, it is necessary that even the Indian officers should be paid on a comparatively high scale, thus raising the cost of administration hugely and affecting most injuriously the condition of the men in the lowest grades of the Government service. The difference between the salaries of the officers and the men forming the rank and file of the Government in the three countries shows clearly how the lowest ranks in India suffer from the fact that the highest governmental officials are paid at such high rates.

THE POLICE

In New York City, the Chief Inspector gets $3,500 a year; Captains, $2,750; Lieutenants, $2,250; Sergeants, $1,750, and Patrolmen, $1,400 each. In Japan the Inspector General of the Metropolitan Police gets $2,500. The figures of the lower officials are not available, but the minimum salary of a constable is $6.50 per month, besides which he gets his equipment, uniform and boots free. In India, the Inspector Generals get from $8,000 to $12,000, Deputy Inspector Generals frcm $6,000 to $7,200, District Superintendents of Police from $2,666 to $4,800, assistants from $1,200 to $2,000, Inspectors from $600 to $1,000, Sub-Inspectors from $200 to $400, Head Constables from $60 to $80, Constables from $40 to $48 per year. We have taken these figures from the “Indian Year Book” published by the Times of India, Bombay. We know as a fact that the Police Constables in the Punjab are paid from $2.67 to $3.33 per month, that is from $32 to $40 per year. The reader should mark the difference between the grades of salaries from the highest to the lowest in India, as compared with the United States and Japan. While in India the lowest officials are frightfully underpaid, the highest grades are paid on a lavish scale. In the other countries of the world this is not the case.

educational department

In the United States (we quote the figures of New York City), the lowest school teachers get a salary of $720, rising to $1,500 a year. In the upper grades salaries range from $1,820 to $2,260. Principals of elementary schools receive $3,500, and assistants $2,500. In the High Schools, salaries range from $900 to $3,150, in Training Schools from $1,000 to $3,250. Principals of High Schools and Training Schools receive $5,000 and the same salary is paid to the District Superintendents. The Commissioner of Education in New York gets $7,500. In Japan the Minister of Education, who is a Cabinet Member, gets $4,000, and the lowest salaries paid to teachers range from $8 to $9 per month. In the United States, college professors make from $5,000 to $7,000 per year. In Japan they range from $300 to $2,000. Coming to India, we find that while the administrative officers and even the college professors get fairly high salaries, the teachers in the schools are miserably underpaid.

conclusion

We don’t believe there is a single country in the world where the difference between the remuneration allowed to the highest and the lowest officials is so disproportionally marked as in India. Yet we find that there is a tendency still further to increase the salaries of the high officials, European and Indian, while even very slight increase in the salaries of the underpaid lowest servants of the State are most grudgingly given. Moreover, the high officials get allowances almost equal in amount to their salaries. This is not true in the case of the lower officials. The fact is that the British Government in India does not attach enough importance to the common man; his needs are often overlooked in the desire to please the high officials and keep them contented. Considering that every man in India is supposed to have a family, the condition of the lowest officials is most miserable, in some cases almost necessitates corruption. The Government of India must know this, yet they do nothing to remedy the state of affairs. A rise in prices is claimed as a good ground for raising the salaries of the highly paid civilians, but the same weight is not attached to that reason when the question of increasing the salaries of the lower grades arises.

The figures relating to military services in India are not available, but we know that the above remarks and comparisons have as much force in the case of the Military Service as they have in the ones we have cited above.

PROPORTION OF INDIANS IN HIGHER SERVICES — LATEST FIGURES

Total of appointments with a salary of Rs. 200 a month or upward ($66) 11,064. Held by Indians, 42 per cent.

Total of appointments with a salary of Rs. 500 per month ($166) = 4,986. Held by Indians, 19 per cent.

Total of appointments on Rs. 800 per month or above = 2,501. Held by Indians, 10 per cent.

Notes

  1. Note. Note. The Royal Commission on Public Services has actually recommended a substantial increase in the salaries of European officials by the incorporation of what was temporarily allowed to them as exchange compensation allowance, in their salaries as also otherwise.