The Madras Agency

The English Factories in India, 1655–1660, William Foster, 1921 · from page 252 · about 47 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

That Europeans resident in the East staked life and health against the chance of making a fortune is a familiar fact; and how heavy was the toll thus paid is shown by the deaths, already recorded, of Agent Gawton in Bengal (1658), of Agent Garway in Persia (March, 1659), and of Christopher Oxenden and President Wyche at Surat (April and May, 1659), besides many others of less eminence. To this roll we must now add the name of Henry Greenhill, the Company’s Agent on the Coromandel Coast.

His death took place at Madras on 4 January, 1659, from dropsy; ‘haveing infurtiated his corpus magnum with an overplus of beverage, and so being tapt for it, hee dyed the next morning’ (O.C. 2688). He was interred in the usual burying-ground (part of the Company’s Garden, in the north-western angle of the native town), the site of which is now occupied by the Madras Law College. The huge tombs in this enclosure having provided shelter for the French during the siege of Madras in 1758, they were dismantled, many of the stones being transferred to the compound of St. Mary’s Church in the Fort. One of these, built into the wall of the external staircase of that church, still preserves the memory of Henry Greenhill. It bears a shield and crest (a drawing of which is given in Mrs. Penny’s Fort St. George, Madras, p. 194) with a Latin inscription1 which is largely identical with the one commemorating Francis Breton at Surat. As the Rev. William Isaacson was chaplain at each place at the time of the burial, we may confidently ascribe the wording to him.

Greenhill, who had gone out in the humble capacity of an attendant on the captain of a ship, is said to have left a fortune of over 40,000l., all made of course by private trading. His domestic arrangements in 1643 are described at p. 76 of English Factories, 1642–5; and from what is there stated we may infer that he was not legally married and that his consort was of either Portuguese or Indian extraction—probably the former. As no provision was made for her in his will, she may be assumed to have predeceased him. This will (P.C.C., 94 Nabbs), dated 1 January, 1659, mentions a daughter Mary (married to John Gurney: see English Factories, 1646–50, p. 337) and three sons, George, Thomas, and Henry, none of whom was yet of age. It includes bequests to Edward Winter, Richard Minors, Thomas Chamber, the Rev. William Isaacson, Seshādri Nāyak, the French padres in Madras (60 pagodas), and the soldiers of the garrison (100 pagodas). John Gurney (son-in-law) and John Greenhill (brother) are named as executors, and Chamber and Isaacson as overseers. The will was proved in England by John Greenhill on 26 May, 1660, but the estate took many years to realize. In March, 1675, administration was granted to James Innes, nephew and attorney of Mary Vincent,1 daughter of the testator; and in January, 1714, both Innes and Lady Vincent being dead, a fresh grant was made to Greenvill Greenhill, son of Thomas (also dead) and grandson of the testator.2 About 1680 the will had been the subject of a lawsuit, the aforesaid Thomas alleging that it was a forgery, but he lost his case (Historical MSS. Commission’s Eleventh Report, part ii. p. 216). Finally, on 16 June, 1731, we find a petition presented to the Court of Directors on behalf of Thomas Greenhill (an infant), praying for relief on the score of the services of his great-grandfather, Henry Greenhill, and of his great-uncle, Sir Matthias Vincent. The result is not recorded; but we may well believe that the Directors felt themselves to be under no obligation on either count.

On the death of Greenhill, Thomas Chamber1 assumed the post of Agent, and held it until he was dismissed three years later. His first business was to complete the lading of the Blackamoor and Love. The former sailed for England in the middle of January, 1659, and the latter departed at the beginning of February. Having thus exhausted the stock of goods suitable for England, he could not send home the Merchant’s Delight as well; so she was dispatched early in February on a voyage to Bantam, whither the Marigold had preceded her. The Anne and the Mayflower had started for Persia on 18 January (Madras to Bantam, 6 Feb.).

In his correspondence with other factories, Chamber appears to have been very lax. More than two months after Greenhill’s death the factors at Vīravāsaram had had no direct news from Madras of that event, and wrote (11 March) that it seemed as if ‘all the factory is dead with him’; they had bought some saltpetre, but were without instructions as to the quantity expected from them that season.2 Five days later, Daniel sent a similar complaint from Petapoli, stating also that he had no funds in hand; while on 26 April the Masulipatam factors wrote to Madras that they had been forced to borrow ’to stop the mouthes’ of their creditors and were looking anxiously for a supply of money. Cash, however, was equally scarce at Fort St. George, where the expenditure necessary for the dispatch of so many ships to England and elsewhere had practically exhausted their funds. As shown by a letter from Maurice Thomson, Governor of the Company, dated 29 January, 1659,3 the Committees at home were under the impression that there was a stock of about 15,000l. on the Coast and a like amount in Bengal, and that it was unnecessary, therefore, to send out more in each ship than would suffice to provide for her return cargo; but the accounts received in England probably included many outstanding debts of doubtful value. Moreover, part of the money was in the hands either of Edward Winter at Masulipatam or of William Blake in Bengal, they having been employed in making the investments in 1658; and since they had been omitted from the list of factors to be employed on behalf of the New General Stock, they were in no hurry to hand over any balance in their custody. Further, when the Anne and Mayflower returned from Persia in May and June respectively, it was found that Buckeridge had made but a slight return for the stocks sent in those vessels. The arrival of these two ships with little money on board increased Chamber’s anxieties; they could not be left lying idle, and so he decided to send them to Achin, providing cargoes by borrowing still further at Madras and Masulipatam (Madras to Bengal, 11 June).

Some relief was afforded by the arrival of the Samaritan (Captain Thomas Clark) from England and Guinea early in July, bringing 10,000l. in gold, half of which, however, was earmarked for Bengal. This vessel was told off to accompany the Anne and Mayflower to Achin, as the Dutch were threatening to debar the English from trading there, on the pretext that the Queen had made them an exclusive grant. The Madras Merchant (commanded by Cobham Doves), which reached Madras from England at the beginning of August,1 was sent on to the Bay of Bengal; while the Merchant’s Delight, which had returned from Bantam in July, was also ordered to the Bay. She was followed by the Merchant Adventure, which had been dispatched from home in January, 1659, under the command of Robert Tindall. The Katherine (Captain Jarvis Russell) arrived from England early in August, and the Discovery (under John Gosnoll) about a fortnight later; both proceeded to Masulipatam to take in cargoes, the one for Macassar and the other for Jambi, for which place she sailed on 17 September. To Masulipatam came also (24 Sept.) the Marigold, which had returned from Macassar to Madras in August, and (20 Oct.) the Merchant Adventure, which had been driven back from Bengal. The Anne, from Achin, got into the roadstead on 25 October, and four days later the Samaritan, from the same port, announced her arrival at ‘Emeldee’ (see English Factories, 1637–41, p. 314 n.), after a vain struggle to reach Bengal.

There was thus a considerable assemblage of vessels at Masulipatam and its neighbourhood when on 19–20 November a furious cyclone fell upon them. From all sides came reports of great damage. The Petapoli factors wrote on 22 November :

For this three or four dayes past wee have had the violentest stormes that hath hapned since our arrivall into India, insomuch that it broke up severall trees in our garden by the rootes.

Three days later their colleagues at Vīravāsaram reported that

The mansion house wee bought of Mr. Winter suncke all at one end a foot into the ground, which gave way under it by reason of the excessive moysture; and thereupon part of the wall on one side fell downe, and another part of the wall much washed away, being only sun-dryed bricks; so it is at present unhabitable, and wee fear irreparable without much charge.

In addition several of the outhouses had also fallen. At Masulipatam (letter of 25 Nov.)

Halfe the Companies home is fallen to the ground; not any house in all this towne escapeing without some manyfestacion of the violence of the weather.

Still greater havoc had been wrought at sea. Of the English vessels, the Samaritan ran ashore between Masulipatam and Madapollam and was totally wrecked, with the loss of nine lives. The Merchant Adventure was driven on ‘the point of Due’ (i.e. Diu or Divi Island), but was saved by the cutting away of her masts and managed to get back into the road. The Marigold and the Katherine were driven out to sea, but escaped with considerable damage and the loss of their cables and anchors. The Anne was missing for some time, having last been seen scudding before the gale with her mainmast gone; but she managed to live out the tempest and to crawl, badly damaged, into the roadstead at Madras.

On 5 December, 1659, the Mayflower reached Masulipatam from Achin with a poor cargo. On the 14th the Merchant’s Delight arrived from Bengal, as did also the Madras Merchant about a month later. Both these vessels were sent on to Madras, the former to complete her lading for England; and thither went the Mayflower and the Marigold, also destined for home. The Merchant Adventure was ordered to proceed from Masulipatam to Achin.

Such was the commercial history of the Agency during the year. Of political events we hear nothing, except for a reference in a letter to Bengal of 8 August to the relief afforded by the rains, which had mitigated the previous scarcity and had brought down the price of grain. This scarcity had been partly due to ‘the feeding of two great armys neare us’—presumably the troops of the King of Golconda and of the Rāja of Chandragiri respectively; and the effect of these disturbances is seen in the fact that for much of the cotton goods sent home in 1659 it was necessary to go to Porto Novo and Pondicherri. Concerning the relations with the former ruler we have more information. Under date of 17 June, 1659, the Masulipatam factors wrote to Fort St. George:

The Dutch have lately presented the King of Gulcondah with large piscashes; and if wee are not furnisht with a considerable one to present him with, wee gather (by what wee have already observed in our affaires) that his firmand formerly granted us by him wilbe slighted by his Governour, and wee cannot but thereby expect grand obstruccions in the Companies affaires.

And on 6 July they wrote in a similar strain to Surat :

There wilbe a necessity of our presenting the King of Gulcondah with a pishcash, in regard his firmand, by which wee have such large fredomes allowed us, specifies that he is to have an anuall pishcash of soe many Persian horses and Europe comodityes, which have not beene presented him these many yeares; so that, if there be no course taken, the Companies priviledges here wilbe infringed; the which a present may yet renew.

A week later, however, they were able to make (to Madras) a more satisfactory report. In view of the abuses received from the local officials

Wee desired Mr. Cropley (then being at Gulcondah) to make an addresse to the King with our letter; and by him wee have received a firmand from the King that there shalbe no molestacion made in the Companies trade and that his Governours shall assist us in all things. Wee hope this firmand will not any wise retard the designed present to the King, but rather hasten it.

The reply from Surat has not been preserved; but in a letter to Masulipatam of 13 October, 1659, the President and Council wrote:

In our last wee licenced you to present the King of Golcundah, to procure what more priviledges wanting, and that your present be with as much frugallity as necessity will permitt.

Whether the present was sent to Golconda does not appear; but in a letter to Madras of 14 January, 1660, the Masulipatam factors said:

The King of Gulcondahs cheife Braminy [Brahman] is sent downe hither by His Majestie to settle the country in these parts. At his first comeing he was mett by us and the Dutch, and after [we were?] civilly enterteyned by him and [he?] doth uphold our priviledges. The Dutch lately entreated him to come to their house; which he did, and there they piscashed him to the value of 1500 pagodas old (as wee are credibly informed). He expects that wee must doe the like; which cannot be denyed, and [we?] feare it will cost our honourable employers four or five hundred pagodas old.

The fact that the Dutch gave three times as much as was expected from the English is an index to the value of their commerce as compared with that of their rivals, and a further proof of how flourishing their trade was at this period.

In the early part of 1659 occurred a quarrel between Masulipatam and the two neighbouring factories of Petapoli and Vīravāsaram as to their mutual relations. Petapoli or Peddapalli— now represented by Nizāmpatam—lay about thirty-six miles to the south-west of Masulipatam, while Vīravāsaram (‘Verasheroon’) was situated some forty miles to the north-east of the same port; and both À Court and Daniel complained that the Masulipatam factors sent agents to buy up saltpetre and calicoes ‘under our noses’, thus raising prices and discrediting their authority (letter of 8 Jan.). They also objected to the funds for the whole group being sent from Madras to Masulipatam for distribution at Johnson’s discretion, and to the requirement that their accounts should be passed through the Masulipatam books. They contended that the intention of the Company was that the three factories should be absolutely distinct; and À Court in particular was much aggrieved at finding himself deprived of that independence which (as he declared) he had been led to expect. An appeal was made to the President and Council at Surat, who in reply upheld the existing arrangement. Writing to À Court on 23 March, 1659, they regretted the differences that had arisen

through your mistake in not knowing that your factory and Pettipole are subordinate to that of Metchlepatan. . . . It was ever, and it ought to be understood, that all those factoryes about Metchlepatan are to have there accompts entered into Metchlepatan bookes, and the Agent etc. to write to Metchlepatan what the Company requires from those parts; which is to be distributed by those there to the severall factoryes, and to supply them with mony as the Companies occations require. If those of Mechlepatan should send to those places where you are buying cloth, they doe very ill . . . and wee hope those at Mechlepatan understands the Companyes business better.

With a view, possibly, to removing this friction, another letter from Surat (25 April) ordered the transfer of Johnson to Madras as Accountant (on the plea that Thomas Shingler, who had provisionally succeeded to the post, was without the necessary experience), and appointed À Court to replace him at Masulipatam, and Daniel to take charge at Vīravāsaram. À Court proceeded accordingly to Masulipatam, but Johnson refused to surrender his position until further instructions, declaring that the Company’s business was in too unsettled a state (letter to Madras, 30 July); and on reconsidering the matter, the Surat Council wrote (11 August) that they had decided to leave Johnson at Masulipatan. To make amends to À Court, they later on appointed him to be Second at Fort St. George, while Shingler was to go to Petapoli (letter to Madras, 12 October), Daniel taking charge at Vīravāsaram, as before proposed. À Court took his passage for his new post in the Mayflower, which left Masulipatam in the middle of January, 1660. The Madras Council had already acquired a third member in the person of William Gifford. He had come out in the Love to be Fourth at Fort St. George; but in January, 1659, he had been dispatched to Bantam, &c., in the Marigold. From this voyage he returned in August, and thereupon resumed his post on the Council.

Concurrently with the dispute concerning status, there was some trouble early in 1659 over an order received from Madras that the northern factories were to keep their accounts in new pagodas instead of old. This letter is no longer extant; but the reason given is stated to have been that the home authorities would then be in no danger of confusing the two kinds. To this À Court and his Vīravāsaram colleague rejoined (8 January, 1659) that the change would provide no remedy, ‘for, in respect of the variablenes of the exchange, your new pagoda is as irreconcileable with pagodas of 12 fanam old as of 15 fanam old’. Possibly (they added) the real reason was a hope that the new pagoda would be made current in all the factors’ dealings at Vīravāsaram; but the natives in remembrance of the late irreguler minting at Verashar[oone], are generally averse from accepting our new pagodas; so that they will not yeild with us so much as at Metchlepatam by half a fanam, nor so much as those of the Dutch stamp; and the more wee seeke to obtrude them upon them, the more shie they would be, unles wee should farme the towne, as the Dutch doe Policull.1

Since new pagodas were never used in their dealings, the factors contended that it would be misleading to enter these as though they were made in that species. Apparently the arguments thus employed convinced the authorities at Madras; for in a letter of 29 March the Vīravāsaram factors express their satisfaction at receiving permission for all three factories to keep their accounts as before in old pagodas.

Before quitting the subject of this group of factories, some notice may be taken of three letters written from Vīravāsaram on 24 December, 1658, 29 December, 1659, and 12 January, 1661, by one of the Company’s servants, William Smyth, to his father, John Smyth. In 1876 these letters were in the possession of Mr. Reginald Cholmondeley, of Condover Hall ; but his collections have since been dispersed, and the present ownership of these interesting documents is not known. We quote, therefore, from the account of them given in the Fifth Report of the Historical MSS. Commission (Sessional volume no. 40 of 1876, p. 360), omitting a few passages relating to matters with which we are not here concerned.

In the first the writer says that the country agrees with him very well, ’ it being at present not much hotter than with you in the midst of summer ; but we are in the autumn, and therefore must expect it hotter. . . . I am placed in the healthiest place in all India, or 1 the coast of Cormondell. It is an inland town, some 40 English miles from the metropolitan port and factory, which is called Metchlupatam. This country is level for 100 miles and more, not one hill to be seen. Abundance of wild fowl ; the chiefest of our diet all the year long is wild ducks and such like. Mr. Acourt, our chief, and Mr. Seymour, our second, do very well agree, which is the life of our trade. . . . Had I a good cloth coat with a large silver lace, which is all the wear here and the badge of an Englishman ; and on the contrary without it and other things answerable to it, not esteemed nor regarded. The chiefest thing needful is a good hat. . . . This country is a very cheap place of residence, were it not for the state and multiplicity of servants we strangers are constrained to keep ; all men being respected according to his train and habit. We have at present belonging to our factory near 70 persons, to whom we covenant to pay between 4s. and 5s. sterling per month each, they finding themselves all provisions and necessaries. These servants are allowed, when they travel or are sent abroad on our business, 2d. per diem, which is the rate we give to all day labourers and porters we usually employ to carry burdens 50, 60, or 100 miles outright, which is the usual conveyance we make use of for all sorts of goods. . . . All sorts of provisions are extreme cheap. The usual rates of beast 2 is from 5s. to 8s. (He says they can rarely get them, because the people believe that their souls go into calves, cows, etc.) Goats and sheep in great plenty from 6d. to 10d. apiece ; hens, 2d.’ 3

In the second letter he says that he has written twice since leaving England, the last time by the William and Thomas, which, as the Dutch say, foundered in the sea near the Cape of Good Hope. He says : ‘I find not India to answer to mine and other men’s expectations…. It is as difficult a thing to get a livelihood as in any other country, especially if a man have but a small beginning…. The last night I received news that I was in mention to go for Acheene in commission with one Mr. Ralph Conyngsby, a very accomplished gentleman and formerly a student in one of the Inns of Court.’

In the third letter it appears that he started for Acheene, but they were driven down to Bay Bengalla, where their ship was cast away and their goods much damaged. In the month of June last Mr. Roger Seymour, second of Verasherone, was drowned while attempting to pass a river on horseback.

The vessel referred to in the last paragraph was the Muskat Frigate (formerly the Winter Rose), which sailed for Achin, with Smyth on board, in May, 1660, and was wrecked off Balasore as here described. This is recorded in a letter from Madras to the Court of 11 January, 1661, which mentions also that Seymour ‘was drowned neare Emeldee in passing over a river’. These dates prove that Smyth’s letter was written in January, 1661, and not a year earlier, as stated in the Commission’s report. The error is due, of course, to the compiler of the latter omitting to convert the date from the Old Style to the New.

Smyth’s allusion to the difficulty he found in getting a livelihood (his salary was only 25l. per annum) shows that he had either insufficient capital or little opportunity to indulge in private trade. Others were more fortunately situated, and such of their private letters as have found their way into the India Office archives contain many references to this absorbing topic. Thus Daniel writes from Masulipatam to Thomas Davies at Hūgli (17 January, 1659), promising to buy chintz for him and regretting the loss of a consignment of sugar from Bengal. He refers to the disposal of some ‘Long Lane comodities’1 of his which are in Davies’s hands, and adds: ‘Pettepolees a brave, healthy, pleasant place, but affords nothing of private trade.’ Johnson, in a letter to James Pickering at Patna (8 March), alludes to some ‘paintings’ [chintz] which he is to send him later, and says that he has advised Chamberlain to dispatch a vessel to Masulipatam with rice, butter, wax, and sugar, ‘here being much feare of a famine this yeare ‘.1 The Petapoli factors write (16 April) that they have been using their own money to buy saltpetre for the Company’s purposes, and that they expect compensation for so doing, seeing that, if they had employed it in bringing corn from ‘Due [i.e. Divi] Island’, they could have made 15 or 20 per cent. profit in a month. The scarcity which was offering the English merchants such chances of gain seems, by the way, to have been as bad in the districts round Masulipatam as at Madras. ‘Wee have at present’, say the Masulipatam factors on 13 October, ‘soe great a famine in these parts, the people dying dayly for want of food, that wee cannot have goods brought in as wee expected.’

The apprehensions excited by the news from Masulipatam (p. 187) of Mīr Jumla’s renewed demand for the surrender of his junk were increased by the consciousness that the Madras factors’ share in the transaction was sternly reprobated in England. We have already quoted (p. 178) the views of the Committees of the United Joint Stock on this point, and we may now cite those of the Committees of the New General Stock, as expressed in a letter dated 13 September, 1658, and sent by the Samaritan :

By letters [not extant] from Mr. Revington etc. in Surratt, dated the 26 January, 1657[–58], directed to the Company, hee giveth notice (amongst other passages) how the gennerall affaires of India as then stoode since the death of the Mogull; from which wee gather that there is a probabillitie of a long contention and warr betweene the four sonns of the deceased Mogull, and consequently a great hinderance and disturbance to trade, not only in those partes of India but also with you and in the Bay; which wee are sorry to heare but know not how to remeddy. The Nabob, wee also understand, is imprisoned by Orange Zeebe for practizing with the King of Gulcondah to start a broyle and come in for a share of the crowne.2 Wee hope, upon the arriveall of this newes unto you … it will cause the Nabobs partie to raise their seidge and leave you at libertie and more securitie to manadge our affaires; and it is our desire unto you that in the future you carry your selves in such inoffensive waies that noe just cause may be given to any partie to put the like or any other trouble upon you, or losse upon the Company, as hath succeeded by your unadvised seizure of the said Nabobs jounck and engaging us in a broyle; which (as wee are informed) was occasioned by some particuler differences which arose betweene the Nabob and your selves about some jewells which were pawned unto you by the Nabob and your seizing on his ellephants. Soe that the quarrell was your owne and not ours; and therefore it is just and reasonable that what dammage hath been susteyned by the Company ought to be made good by you; they having noe quarrell nor pretence upon the Nabob, but desire love and peace with all princes and governours; and soe therefore require you that upon any occasion of difference that may hereafter happen betweene any parties, that you continue as newters and side with neither.1

Evidently Chamber was at a loss what to do in this dilemma. He appears to have made an attempt to shift the responsibility on to the shoulders of Winter by sending him a formal order to surrender the junk to the Nawāb’s representative at Masulipatam. Winter complied, but straightway took possession of it again (Trevisa to Bengal, 8 July, 1659),2 relying, it would seem, upon a letter of 22 July, 1657, in which Greenhill and Chamber had authorized him, if molested, to seize any of the Nawāb’s vessels (Winter to Madras, 15 August, 1659).

Soon came a further complication. Aurangzeb had dispatched Mīr Jumla to Bengal to conduct the campaign against Prince Shuja, and one of the Nawāb’s first acts, after occupying Bihār, was to stop the English from procuring saltpetre at Patna, pending satisfaction of his claims. On this being reported to Surat, the President and Council wrote to Madras (3 June, 1659), ordering that full restitution should be made without delay, and adding that they had advised Mīr Jumla that these directions had been given. Winter, in a letter to Madras of 12 July, declared that he had offered to restore the junk to Johnson, on condition of being compensated for all that he had spent upon her; but without authority from Chamber, Johnson would have nothing to do with the business, as he had contended all along that it did not concern the existing Stock.

The Nabobs agents are incessantly demanding the juncke of us. Wee still disclaime the accion, it belonging not to this Companies accompt and utterly disowned by them.

Thus wrote the Masulipatam factors to Surat on 15 June, adding that Winter justified his title to the junk by a bill of sale in his possession, signed by Greenhill and Chamber. Two days later they reminded the last-named that he had sent them no positive order to demand or receive the junk from Winter, or to recover from him the 1,500 old pagodas which he had undertaken to pay for her. Chamber still endeavoured to place the blame on Winter, alleging (letter to Bengal, 20 July) that he had undertaken, when buying the junk, to secure the Company from all resulting damages (an assertion which Winter hotly denied); as for making any payment to Mīr Jumla, he declared that this would only encourage him to advance fresh demands, for ‘he will be never contented’.

The matter still dragged on, and at last the Surat Council sent a letter to Fort St. George (12 October), peremptorily ordering that the junk should be handed over, and that any money it might be necessary to pay to the Nawāb should be recovered from Greenhill’s estate; if Winter had paid for the vessel, the amount was to be refunded to him; if he refused to surrender her, possession was to be taken by force. This part of the programme could not in any case be carried out, for Winter had sent the junk on a voyage to the eastwards; and no attempt was made to adjust matters in other respects. Chamber was evidently in a defiant mood; perhaps because the Surat letter had hinted an intention to hold him personally responsible. At the beginning of November he and his colleagues wrote to the Bengal factors that nothing could be done until they knew the Nawāb’s utmost demands, in order that the settlement might be final; and advising them to warn him that, if he took any action there to the prejudice of the Company, ‘you had power to vindicate your selves as Agent Greenhill hath done’. This truculent tone seems to have been adopted on the strength of rumours that Mīr Jumla had met with disaster in his military operations; but these reports were untrue, and to the recipients of the letter, acutely conscious of the power of the offended Nawāb, such advice, tendered from the security of Fort St. George, must have seemed a bitter mockery. Strangely enough, the Surat Council, though better informed as to the course of events in Bengal, acquiesced in the shelving of the question. Writing to Madras on 20 December, they said that they could give no directions about negotiating further with the Nawāb ‘till wee heare from our friends in the Bay’. One reason for this suspension of action seems to have been a fear of a double settlement—of Mīr Jumla extorting satisfaction from the Bengal factors, while restitution was at the same time being made upon the Coast.

Meanwhile Winter’s position as a private individual competing with the Company’s servants in their trading operations had led to a sharp correspondence between the Surat Council and Agent Chamber, whom they suspected of favouring Winter, and who certainly showed no readiness to take any steps against him. We have already noted the determination of the Company to put an end to competition of this kind, and the measures which the President and Council had accordingly taken at Surat and other places under their immediate jurisdiction. They were not less vigorous in dealing with offenders elsewhere; and in the case of Winter they were stimulated by complaints from Masulipatam that he was impeding the factors’ operations at that port. On 11 August they addressed a remonstrance to the offender, admonishing him in a not unfriendly tone ‘to forbeare such unhandsome actions’, and expressing a hope that on reflection he would adopt a more reasonable attitude. A letter sent at the same time to Madras was more vigorous in its language.

If Mr. Winter doe not forbeare, uppon a civell warning, then (as premencioned) we order you to ceize uppon him and his estate, sending him home to England, there to answer these his misdemeanours. And this wee require you not to faile of, as you respect the Companies commands and warrant that whatsoe’re you, or any other of their servants, act of this nature, they will beare them harmless (which are the words of their commission unto us and you); which we hope you will not faile in performance, for ’tis insufferable that the power of a single person of the same nation should affront and impede the Companies affaires, as we are credibly informed he doth.

Winter himself seems to have been by no means desirous of coming into conflict with the Company’s representatives. He was still anxious to go home, and was well aware that trouble might await him there, if he pushed matters too far. Writing on 15 August to Madras, he took up the attitude of a much maligned individual. The trouble at Masulipatam, he said, was all due to the unreasonableness of the factors there. For himself, as soon as objection was made to his taking goods on freight in one of his vessels, he had at once dispatched her as she was, after vainly offering to abandon the voyage if Johnson would take over the goods at prime cost. The Company’s factors were quite at liberty to appropriate any merchandise bought by him other than that for which he had made advances ‘before the new Companies tyme’. It was true that he had seized and punished some defaulting debtors; but no one had authority to prevent him from thus recovering what was justly due to him. He protested that hitherto he had done his best to avoid friction with the Company’s servants; now, however, since the Masulipatam factors had treated him so badly, he was determined to stand upon his rights.

Meanwhile the resentment of the Surat Council at the silence of the Fort St. George Agent had been sharpened by the receipt of a private letter (dated 4 July) from Trevisa and À Court at Masulipatam, in which a suspicion was hinted that Chamber had some dark design against the Company’s interests. Their information came, they said, from

a person of creditt, newly come from Madrasse, that desires not to be named, though [he] will be ready to testifie when call’d therto. Hee tells us that Mr. Shingler and the rest of the Companies servants there are soe narrowly watched, and soe many of their letters intercepted, that they dare not write the truth of their minds to their freinds; but many times, when the Agents packetts goe, they put in letters quite contrary, to cleare themselves of suspition. And though Mr. Shingler, in several letters to us and others of his freinds, hath written that he hath had of late a better correspondence with the Agent then formerly (which we know was soe bad that not only he, but all the new factors there, desired to be dismist and would have returned for England by last shipping), and though in a generall letter to his freinds here (whereof you have coppie from Metchlepatam) he writes that he had taken care of the goodownes [i.e. warehouses] and was willing to continue there in that employment, yet this relator (whom Mr. Shingler writs us to beleive) saith that Mr. Shingler bid him tell us by word of mouth that he is still soe much abused by the Agent’s not giveing him any employment at all, and checking him if he enquire into any thing of the Companies affaires, saying he is too inquissitive, that, unlesse it be remedied, or he removed, he will be utterly unserviceable to the Company. And this relator confirmes, upon his knowledge, that neither Mr. Shingler nor any other of the Companies servants know more of their affaires then himselfe (who is a freeman 1), excepting that Mr. Shingler sometimes sees the letters; but that all the businesse is man’ged by blackes and the Agents particular servants; which servants (in a generall letter from Maddras by last shipps) are nominated and recomended to the Company for imployment there. By which, and his unwillingnesse to entertaine a Second of Your Worships election, whom he cannot pretend to keepe from businesse for unacquaintedness (as he doth Mr. Shingler, though an experienced merchant), it seemes he meanes to act all in private. And I, Jonathan Trevisa, remember that, upon discource of the new commers, he said, in hearing of mee and of the abovesaid relator, that he could doe the businesse by blackes without their helpe. Next, whereas Captain Midleton, being comander of the garrison souldiers, ought to have respect and obedience from those that [are] under him and countenance from those that are above him, this relator saith that the Agent upon severall petty occasions gives him (in publique to) the scornfull appellacion of Sirrah; wherby he looseth much of the awe that is due from souldiers to their comander. We speake not this out of any particular favour to the said Captain (for we could heartily wish he could better carry himselfe then we heare he doth), but out of a doubt that, he being enured to such slavish termes, he may not be able to command his men, nor be in a capacity to resist such attempts as we have some cause to doubt may be made to the Companies prejudice.2 There are some other circumstances which concurr to our jealousy [suspicion], but we forbeare to touch farther at present on this unpleasant string; desiring Your Worship to keepe this private, and make such use thereof as may seeme best to your more approved judgment.

The effect of this letter is seen in the stern language in which Andrews and his colleagues addressed the Madras Agency on 7 September, 1659 :

Wee are not ignorant of the abuses and hinderances of the Companies affairs on the Coast of Corromondell; therfore doe now enorder you speedily to remedy them. And you would doe best to proceed in order, which, begun at home, will the better goe abroad and serve for example unto the rest. What the goverment of the Fort hath beene, we are not ignorant of, nor what it should be. That it hath beene very disorderly is too apparent; what it should be, all wise men know. First, that, as the feare of God is the begining of wisdome, soe to begin with His service in practice, which as in particulars will demonstrate it selfe, soe in the generall. That noe business which concernes the Honourable Company but be acted by the Agent and Councell, not by one but with the joint consent of all. Wee doe it here, and desire you to follow it there; that as others signe the letters besides the Agent, soe they may know what goods are bought and sould for accompt of the Honourable Company; for the Agent is not absolute, and therfore we expect you that you should act according to reason, not will.

. . . Our masters will have little cause to approve of your wisdomes, when you take soe little care of their affaires that it appears plainly you favour others and your owne more then theires; which we desire you suddenly to remedie, least we doe it in a way will not please you. For as it behooves us, and [we] are comanded, soe we shall act, and will not be frighted with greate wordes, or bribed with any gaines, to abuse our trust and dishonour our honourable employers. The reason of our thus writing is the constant complaints of all cheifes of factories of Mr. Edward Winter, as also your countenancing of him; or elce how dare he come to the Fort with two shipps lading of goods, to dispose as he pleaseth, to the prejudice of our masters proffitt by the making sale of soe many comodityes (that are forbidden by them) unto comanders of shipps, as marriners? . . . They have by their comission given the President, comanded the priveleidges graunted them in their charter to be preserved; which is by the keeping, as maintaining, the whole trade of India unto and by themselves. The former being hindered and themselves abused by diverse of our nation that are resident in your parts, we require you to see this their commission performed; to force all such to forbeare tradeing in any comodityes which are named in the Honourable Companies contracts; likwise that noe persons, masters, or pilates, or others more or less capable of the marriners art, be permitted to serve any person or persons but the Honourable Company in their shipping or on their occasions; and that, if any shall disobey this command of our masters, graunted unto them, as by former charter, soe in this new charter, by the supreame authority of our nation, then you are to ceaze on their shipps and estates, sending them home to give accompt of their actions to the Honourable Company. A declaracion we have sent unto you, and another unto Metchlepatan, desiring you to read it in a place of concourse, that all our owne nation and others may understand the contents, and afterward paste it upp in a publicke place that none may plead ignorance.

Feeling that it was hopeless to expect effective assistance from Chamber, Andrews and his colleagues sent at the same time instructions to the Masulipatam factors to seize Winter and his estate.

We are not ignorant of the sway that Mr. Edward Winter carries in your partes. Therfore, upon the receipt of these, advize with the most of secrecy which may be the best way to intrapp him; for we feare by force he will not be overpowered, you not being able to make so much. Therfore it must be done by surprizall on board shipp; and to encourage all commanders and officers of shipps to assist you, you may shew them this clause of our order, acquainting them (as we doe you) that whatsoe’re you act of this nature, or as hereafter is advised, the Honourable Company have warranted both us and you (as them) harmless and indempnified. . . . As we would have you in this affaire to proceed with secrecy, soe to all elce use justice and follow order; for we suppose, he being seized on and without dispute sent home (acquainting our masters with his crimes, leave him there to answer), the rest will fall in peeces. We have writen to the Agent to take care of our masters affaires as to the generall of interlopers, that they be suppressed; but this we commend unto you, hoping that by your dilligence and courradge you will bring it to pass; and have ordered the Agent to give comission to all comanders of the Companies shipps to seize on all English merchants or marriners trading in India, not being the Honourable Companies servants and without our pass. The same we shall practice here.

A declaration was enclosed for publication; but this was not to be done until after the apprehension of Winter, ’least he be forearmed as well as forewarned’. They went on :

We are resolved none shall drive any trade there to the prejudice of our masters, if all the power we can make will prevent it. The reason formerly that it was not put in practice was the hopes that men would be rationall and conforme themselves to the orders of superiors; and therfore till now have been silent. If Agent Chambers doth not obey our orders in this particular, advise us, and we shall quickly remedye it.

A postscript explains that only Winter and his estate should be sent home. In the case of others their goods should be seized, but not their persons, ‘unless met at sea’, when they should be taken out of any vessel and carried home with their goods.

These instructions met with no better success than the orders sent to Rājāpur for the apprehension of Revington. We may well believe that the Masulipatam factors felt some repugnance to use deceit against a fellow-countryman with whom they were on more or less friendly terms; while probably an excuse was found in the want of opportunity and a hope that the dispute would be settled in a more amicable fashion.

Apparently the Fort St. George Agency had already taken some action before the receipt of the reiterated instructions from Surat; for on 28 September the Masulipatam factors, writing to Madras, reported that, in obedience to Chamber’s orders, they had stopped Samuel Cropley and Francis Yardley, two of the interlopers, from making a voyage to Pegu. They objected, however, to seizing Cropley and sending him to Madras, as they had been instructed to do, since it would be unfair to treat him so rigorously, while leaving Winter unmolested.

On 12 October another letter, rather milder in tone, was addressed from Surat to Madras, dealing not only with Winter’s liability in the matter of Mīr Jumla’s junk, but his delay in settling accounts with the Company for the 1658 investment. This outstanding debt Chamber was directed to realize

By faire or foule means; not to pro and con to noe purpose; for though might in justice is not to overcome right, yet right and might joined are to gett possession of their owne…. In short we finde Mr. Winter by report on all hands not to be suffered to remaine in the country any longer, upon any pretence of debts he saith he hath to gett in, but that he suddenly cleare the Honourable Companies accompts of both Stocks and goe home fairly without being forced; for ’tis he only that encouraged others to the practice of trade in the country, soe much to the loss of our masters.

In a postscript, dealing with a Madras letter just received, it was laid down that for the future none but the Company’s ships were to be allowed to trade to Achin, Bantam, or elsewhere.

You suffering noe private man’s shipp of our nacion whatsoever to voiage to and fro, neither to the ports the Honourable Company trade not unto, as well as where they doe; nay, not suffer Bannians or Moores [vessels] (except the Kings) to trade at the ports the Company doth, to their prejudice. The Dutch doe not, and why wee? Tis our practice here, and twill be the better for our masters proffitt that you doe it there also.

To the Masulipatam factors Andrews and his colleagues wrote the following day :

Wee hope what desired of you jointly in reference to Mr. Winter is executed; and then ’twill not be enough for him to say the Honourable Company must stay till his jounke come from Acheene, but his estate shall make good the Honourable Companies loss, that can be proved he hath caused; and not to thinke to brave it out with nonsence, or those about him that can write sence; for he being once sent out of the country, all the rest will follow, and shall.

To Winter himself, who had evidently sent a conciliatory reply to the previous letter from Surat, the President and Council wrote (13 October), acknowledging that his explanations were ‘in the generall civell and plausible’, but declaring that the evidence before them left them no option but to conclude that ‘the Honourable Company have noe greater enimy then yourselfe, according to your power’. They did not wish to be hard upon him but the instructions from home were imperative and they must obey them.

By 29 November it was known at Surat that the instructions sent to Masulipatam regarding Winter had not been carried out. Writing thither, the Council said :

We are sencible that what we have enordered concerning Mr. Winter and other interlopers must not be acted rashly; as also of your delaies and disobedience; which required you, after receipt of our letter, to consult and contrive how our intencion might be executed, and not put off till we know not what and whose ships arrive ; in the meane time you, Mr. Johnson, feasting with him on board the Adventure. Such practices of shewing two faces, one to us here and another to him there, to our masters prejudice, we shall soone remedie ; if you the sooner conforme not yourselves unto what is desired, and that all his ships, or any other that are belonging to any English out of the Honourable Companies service, are not the sooner seized on, we will send some that shall doe it ; not only their ships and estates at sea, but their estates on shoar also. Let them trade either to Pegu, Maldivas, or any other place in India, ’tis the Companies order they should be seized on for their use ; and without disputing, we once more require you to act it, being ’tis noe more then their charter warrants them to comand to be executed.

But Winter had already decided to contest no longer. On 2 November he wrote to Madras, requesting permission to carry home his wife and estate in one of the Company’s ships, he paying freight on the usual terms and being assured that the Company would not interfere with his goods on arrival ; if room could not be found in this season’s ships, he desired leave to fit up one of his own vessels for that purpose against the following year, and an assurance that he should not then be hindered from leaving, nor molested on reaching England. Such an assurance could not be given, and Chamber appears to have returned an unfavourable reply to Winter’s other requests, though the Masulipatam factors, who had now become reconciled to him, urged compliance with his demands, as a good way of getting rid of him. However, in the early part of January, 1660, Winter embarked in the Marigold and proceeded to Madras, where he soon came to terms with the Agent about the money due from him on account of the 1658 investment. This arranged, he was allowed to continue his voyage to England in the same vessel, paying for his passage and the freight of his goods. He had already, it seems, promised the Masulipatam factors that the Nawāb’s junk should be surrendered to them on her return to that port. Thus the long dispute came to an end, so far as the factors in India were concerned.

Besides the Marigold, the Merchant’s Delight and the Mayflower sailed for England from Madras in January, 1660. We know that they carried three letters from the Agent and Council to the Company, but none of these is extant. The two former vessels reached home the following August; the fate of the third is related in a subsequent chapter.

The long dispute had left a soreness between the Madras factors and their superiors at Surat, as is evidenced by sundry passages in a letter from the President and Council, dated 20 December, 1659:

Wee take notice of the proffession you make of observance, but withall [are] sensible in what manner it is; which wee shall endeavour to remedye. . . . Wee see plainly how you worke togeather for the worst and not for the best. Private designes, pretend what you will, puts aside those which might take place to the Honourable Companies advantage. . . . Twas not the dating of a letter that troubled you, but twas the telling you of what was truly informed us, and hope you will reforme.

Evidently Chamber and his colleagues had insinuated that Andrews, while pressing for the vigorous enforcement elsewhere of the Company’s orders regarding interlopers, was tolerating the employment of Englishmen in private vessels at Surat; for the letter continues :

Wee have not any shipp here belonging to any English, or wherein to our knowledg any English have share; only three vessells that are our brokers, unto which wee have spared some English to sale them, but now intend to take them all out, haveing occasion to use them for the Companies service more immediatly.

Another clause in the Madras letter had equally given offence:

You say wee should vindicate the honour of the Presidencye. Wee shall not returne you answeare in your owne dialect, but resolve to send the clause home unto the Honourable Company to vindicate us; for wee resent it as tis, being you are so confident to bid us to be more cautious that have the command of all factoryes of English sent out by the Honourable East India Company.

The letter concluded with some home news just received :

Wee are advised of strange alterations in England, as that the Protectour is deposed and confined, allowed 20,000l. per annum; his mother 8,000l., and the Lord Fleetwood made Generall of the armye; the old Parliament reinstated, and acting as presently after the Kings death. This wee have rumours on. When tis confirmed, shall acquaint you.

Notes

  1. 1. Reproduced in Col. Love’s Vestiges of Old Madras (vol. i. p. 172). Apparently the concluding portion should run: Satis est, viator, te haec non nescire; lachrymam modo impende unam et abi. Probably part of the inscription has been broken away.
  2. 1. It was already known that Matthias Vincent (Chief in Bengal, 1677–82) had married (about 1668) some one of the name of Mary. From the particulars now given it is evident that she was the daughter of Henry Greenhill and widow of John Gurney. The fact that one of the charges against Vincent was that he allowed Romish priests to visit his wife strengthens the supposition that her mother was Portuguese.
  3. 2. It was doubtless under this grant that payment was made for certain property of Greenhill’s at Madras which had been taken over for the Company’s use (see Love’s Vestiges, vol. ii. p. 55).
  4. 1. His connexion with the Company had begun in December, 1640, when he was appointed purser’s mate of the Mary. He had been taken ashore as a factor on the Coast some six years later. According to a letter from Roger Middleton, the commander of the Madras garrison (Love’s Vestiges, vol. i. p. 174), Chamber claimed to be a Welshman. ‘He is worth 50,000l., as I am credibly informed, yet a batcheler.’ On 8 March, 1659, however, a Masulipatam letter gives as the latest news: ‘Mr. Chambers his espousing of Capt. Bowyers widdow.’ This lady was probably the relict of John Boyer, master of the Expedition, who had committed suicide at Vīravāsaram in June, 1655 (see p. 33). In Greenhill’s will he mentions a debt to ‘Anne Boyer, widow’, and leaves Chamber (besides 100 pagodas for a ring) a hogshead of sack for his wedding.
  5. 2. They mentioned that, as their own house was past repair, they had purchased one from Edward Winter for 120 pagodas. They also requested a supply of pens and paper, as otherwise they would be forced to write ‘in kedgians’ (i.e. on cadjans, or palm leaves, in native fashion).
  6. 3. This letter contains an exhortation to the Madras factors ’to have a speciall care that you [p. 255] and all under your comand and factoryes doe labour to feare the everliveing God, to sanctify his Sabboths, to spend your tyme in prayer, readeing, singing of psalmes, and holy conferences, and to be such patternes of faith, patience, meekenes, humility, and love to all with whome you converse etc., that so the God of love and peace may abide with you ‘. It is to be feared that the pious Governor would have been much scandalized if he could have read some of the private letters that were passing between the Company’s servants, as quoted elsewhere in the present volume.
  7. 1. She brought a letter from the Company, dated 28 January, 1659, which stated that her captain had been directed to call on his way out at Negapatam, Tranquebar, and Porto Novo, in order to buy pepper, which was to be left at Masulipatam for shipment to England. Any vacant space in the returning vessels was to be filled with rice, turmeric, gum-lac, ‘bowgees’ (see p. 188), or cotton wool. For the same purpose the Bengal factors had been directed to keep Masulipatam supplied with saltpetre; also with sugar, which would sell there at a profit of 50 per cent. In order to provide a regular supply of cotton goods for [p. 256] England, authority was given to procure each year on the Coast 20,000 pieces of longcloth, 40,000 of salampores, 5,000 of ‘moores’, 2,000 of white ginghams, and 4,000 or 5,000 of ‘percallas’, of the dimensions and prices stated. The factors were also to send home all the cinnamon they could get.
  8. 1. Pālakollu, in Narsāpur tāluk, Godāvari District, a few miles south-east of Vīravāsaram. The Dutch established themselves there in 1652, and, according to Streynsham Master (Diaries, vol. ii. p. 164), rented the town for 2,000 old pagodas per annum.
  9. 1. Probably a slip for ’ on ‘.
  10. 2. Here Smyth is using the farming term for fatting-cattle
  11. 3. In calculating these wages and prices he is apparently taking the fanam at 8d., answering to the book-rate of 10s. for the old pagoda.
  12. 1. Long Lane, Smithfield, was noted for its trumpery wares.
  13. 1. Incidentally he mentions that one of his companions is having recourse to divination to discover the whereabouts of some missing property: ‘Last night they stole his jack [-pot] and cheese out of roguery, and hee now a conjuring for it.’
  14. 2. On the verge of the outbreak of the civil war, Mīr Jumla, who had been co-operating with Aurangzeb in the campaign against Bījāpur, was recalled to the imperial court, doubtless in order to prevent him from assisting that prince in his suspected designs upon the Crown. As his family were in the Emperor’s power, the Nawāb was afraid of openly disobeying the command; and so he arranged with Aurangzeb that the latter should forcibly prevent him from going. He was accordingly arrested, on a charge of intriguing with Golconda and Bījāpur, [p. 264] and was kept in nominal confinement at Daulatābād until Aurangzeb had succeeded in making himself Emperor (Jadunath Sarkar’s History of Aurangzib, vol. i. p. 361).
  15. 1. The Company, with a shrewd eye to business, sent out by the Samaritan to Madras 15 iron guns, 2 mortars, and 800 shells, to be sold ‘to our most proffitt’, as they imagined that the wars in India would cause a great demand for such things.
  16. 2. See also a memorandum on the dispute over the junk, now in the O.C. series (no. 2873). This is unsigned and undated, though the mention of Chamber’s knighthood shows that it was written after March, 1666. Col. Love has printed it verbatim (with a few omissions) in his Vestiges of Old Madras (vol. i. p. 184).
  17. 1. A European inhabitant of Madras, trading on his own account or employed in the local shipping. Several of these had been hitherto tolerated by the Company, in imitation of the Dutch system at Batavia, by which special privileges were given to colonists.
  18. 2. Writing to the Company on 30 September, 1659, Andrews and his colleagues said : ‘Mr. William a Court from Verasherone hath advised us of the feare that Agent Chambers may not only (as hee doth) correspond and maintaine private traders, but, if hee be impeeded in his course, agree with Mr. Winter to keepe the Fort against all other English. Therfore wee [p. 269] (as formerly premencion’d) have given order to prevent it, and send home Mr. William a Courts letter for Your Honours perusall and consideration; hopeing that Mr. Winter, who so impudently abuses your servants there, by himselfe and by his brother and servants, and hinders your trade at sea and ashore by his vessailes, may on the next years shipping give an accompt of his actions unto Your Honours.’ À Court’s letter seems to have been dated 1 July, 1659 (see O.C. 2837).