THE COAST AND BAY, 1660
While materials for the elucidation of the history of the factories directly under the Surat President are fairly abundant for 1660, there is a striking dearth for that year of documents relating to the Madras and Bengal Agencies. The records kept at the several factories of consultations and of letters received or sent during this period have all perished; and we are left dependent upon the Surat records (which include copies of letters dispatched to the Coast or to the Bay) and upon a scanty number of documents scattered through various collections. The Original Correspondence series, for example, contains for 1660 only two documents originating at the Coast settlements and only five from Bengal. Fortunately, however, it includes also a letter from Madras to the Company of 11 January, 1661, which reviews briefly the events of the previous year; and this, combined with the letters from Surat (which reflect the contents of those received from the Coast), and occasional contributions from other series, will enable us to give a summary of the principal events.
In Bengal the campaign against Shāh Shuja was pressed with vigour and carried to a successful conclusion. Early in the year Mīr Jumla crossed the Ganges above Rājmahāl and effected a junction with Dāūd Khān. Their forces were five times the number of Shuja's army, and the latter was slowly forced back eastwards. On 8 February Prince Muhammad, the son of Aurangzeb, changed sides once more, returning secretly to the Imperialist camp, only to spend the rest of his life as a state prisoner. Mīr Jumla took possession of Mālda on 6 March, and a month later succeeded in forcing a passage over the Mahānanda. This proved decisive. Shuja fled to Tanda, and thence to Dacca. Recognizing that his position was hopeless, he decided to take refuge with the King of Arakan; and on 6 May he left Dacca by boat for Chittagong. His subsequent fate was for long a mystery, but there seems to be little reason to doubt that he was killed by the Arakanese in February, 1661 (Dagh-Register, Batavia, 1661, p. 115). Mīr Jumla was rewarded with the title of Khānkhānān or commander-in-chief (ibid., p. 6).
We must now resume the story of the English negotiations with Mīr Jumla. The settlement made with Winter, including the purchase from him of his Winter Rose, excited no small indignation at Surat, and on 25 February, 1660, the President and Council addressed the Masulipatam factors in severe terms.
The deliverye of the Nabobs junke uppon a promise, when you have all written formerly that his [Winter’s] word is not to be beleived in any thinge, yet a buisnesse of such consequence as the wellfare of all our friends in the Bay and priveledges of the Honorable Company is to depend uppon a bare promise. You will say the junck is not in Metchlepatam ; but wee say you are to blame that shee is not, and the only cause of all theis troubles and disputes. Had you followed order, you need not have taken any mans word . . . for had you seised on the vessell, as ordered, and the rest of Mr. Winters, as also the estate of interloopers (among the rest his), then the Honorable Companies affaires had not beene hindered. Therefore wee positively enorder you to seize on the jounck at arrivall, and deliver it upp ; as also what estate shall returne on it of Mr. Winters, that the Honorable Company may be the lesse dammaged in the Bay, or a recompence taken for such expences as are caused there by reason of his detaininge and imployinge the jounck . . . giving us an exact accompt of it, that wee may acquaint our masters of yours and our proceedings. The reason they themselves will be sensible soone enough of : their losse in the Bay, caused by Mr. Winters action, as appeares by a letter received from the Agent the 22d. currant, complaininge of the Nabobs discourteous entertaininge him, and the reason is what mentioned.
The (non-extant) letter from Agent Trevisa, referred to above, was dated 26 December, 1659. On 24 February, 1660, the Surat Council replied, acquainting him that Winter had promised the redelivery of the junk, and adding :
Wee are very sensible of the troubles you are involved in. The courts of these princes affoardes nothinge elce. Remedye is not in our handes. What the event of warre is, Providence only produceth. . . . As to his [Mīr Jumla’s] unreasonable demands of the lading of her, it is to noe purpose to enlarge. . . . If his power be soe greate with this newe Kinge, for only this injurie done him to continue his practice of abuses to you and losses to the Honourable Company, notwithstanding our petitioning the King for right, and intention to send a person of qualitye to treate with [the] Kinge on this buisnesse, wee say, if theis courses will not prevaile, that wee may injoy our priveledges in the Bay and trade freely as formerly, wee shall then soone enorder your leavinge of the place; and wee shall also to the northward doe the same, if constrained, and then act much more to the benifit of our masters, first, by seizing on their shipping, spoiling both those that goe to sea and in harbour; which in the next place will constraine them to seeke a peace, for the poore weavers, being such multitudes, without trade at sea cannot live. Therefore our advice is, if that possibly you cannot agree with the Nabob on reasonable tearmes (and that which wee meane by reasonable tearmes is, not to pay for any lading, but to deliver the shipp and present him a piscash of vallue something extraordinary of what hath beene formerly given to a person of his qualitye), for a little more or less of that nature to conclude, and not to prejudice the Honourable Company soe farr in their estates as to pay for the folly of another (for wee cannot but resent his calling of us pirates, and hope our worthy masters will give us power to teach such unmannerly persons better: had wee heard it, wee should have given him answeare, but shall be patient and put it in the front of affronts, to remember it and seek remedye), wee shall suddainly advise the Kinge, and (according as the tymes produce event, for warres are uncertaine) so take hold of opportunityes to proceed to the assisting of you with our advice and help att courte... hoping that, having the armye removed, the way will be open to carrye the saltpeeter from Puttana to the port.
A letter from Surat to Fort St. George of 27 February, 1660, mentions the receipt of one from Trevisa, dated 12 January, ‘wherein he adviseth us of the agreement made with the Nabob’. Some details of this are given in a letter from the Bengal Agent to the factors at Bantam, 24 February, 1660.
My last unto you was the 28 November.... At that time I were going for the laskar, to treat with Merjumbler, the Great Kings generall, about a junke Agent Greenhill and Mr. Winter tooke from him about four years since, and being in great power [he] has troubled the affaires of the Bay, to the dishonour of our nation and losse of our honourable employers; we haveing been deteind in his army and our factory common to the will of every rogueing officer, soe that [I] wer forst to goe to the laskar and conclude the busines with Merjumbler; which, after my being 30 and odd daies with him (in which time there were severall fights betwixt the Great Kings party and the Prince of Bengala, whose armies lay very nigh each other, soe that many men wer slayn), [I] brought it to this conclusion, that his junke is to be returned him, and all things else which [it] shall be made appeare the Agent etc. upon the Coast took from him; referring the busines for the ending thereof to his friend at Metchlepatam, called Taptap, and I to Mr. Wm. a Court and Mr. Wm. Jersip [Jearsey], and that they weer to end it in four months. This bussines hath cost me much trouble, as well as other friends heer, and our nation much villified about that business; soe as I thought [I] should have got noe liberty till he had received satisfaction of all his demmands. But (thanks be to God) it proved otherwise. So [I] have got his dustick,1 in which he confermed the former privilidges we enjoyed, which were granted to us by the old King and the Prince; the former of which Oram Sha, his sonne, who now sitts Great King, has imprisoned, and the latter, the Prince of Bengala, Oram Shaw[s] brother, [is] likely to be beaten out of his cuntrey. But, however, them privilidges our nation formerly had here are confirmed, and [I] hope will not be deminished for the future.... The warrs in these countrys and troubles of Meerjumbler hindreth our saltpeter coming from Pattana; so that the small stock sent us hither this yeare [I] was forst to lay out for this years kintillidge to a small matter. Soe that for any busines wee have (except that formerly mentioned) [we] may keep evry day holly day; but I beleeve our masters will resent it, when [they] have knowledge thereof.... Newes we have none, more then the warr is not yet concluded, but hopes [it] may suddenly, which God grant....
In a letter from Surat to Madras of 10 May, 1660, exception was taken to the exclusion of Johnson, the Chief at Masulipatam, from the negotiations, and he was ordered to be substituted for one of the two arbitrators nominated by Trevisa. Evidently the business was protracted in the usual oriental fashion, the demands made on the part of the Nawāb being, according to a letter of 19 May from Masulipatam to Bantam, 'upwards of 20,000 pagodas, besides the denying of payment of 32,000 pagodas which hee owes the Company'. At last the Surat factors wrote to Trevisa (21 June), expressing their dissatisfaction with the trend of the negotiations.
Therfore are resolved and have concluded that, if the Meirjumla will be satisfied with the retourne of his vessaile as shee is now, well repaired and made fashionable at the expence of much money, it shall be delivered, and hee, waving all other demaunds or disputes, give us a full discharge, sufferring us to trade quietly without affronts or abuses.... If the Nabob will not be satisfied with this... but shall proceed to molest you in your trade or abuse you in your persons, wee hope, being forewarnd, you are forearm'd, and ready to leave the country, that so wee may proceed against the Moores in another manner of language. . . . And should they seiz on all the Companies estate with you, yet doe you all endeavour to leave the country, though you loose all the estate; for wee shall soone recover it.
A week later Andrews and his colleagues wrote again to Bengal, announcing their intention of making representations at court, and desiring a full statement of the factors' grievances.
Meirjumla, wee suppose, will deceive you, and [wee] beleive that hee will not be satisfied but with what wee cannot give. That therfore wee may the better back our intended purpose of using force for our right, [wee] desire that you furnish us with what just aggreivances you lie under, what abuses have been offerred. And state the business of the customes so fully that wee may understand it; as, for example, whether by graunt from the former King you were to pay none, or whether 'tis only the courtesie of the Governour, and for how long time you have not paid it, etc. As for the anchoradg of our shipping, wee will not allow of the payment of any, because in no port under this King is any demaunded, nor in any other port in this part of the world where wee trade are wee so dishonoured; and therfore upon no consideration will wee submitt to pay an unworthy custome. If it hath been the practice formerly in open trade, yet the Honourable Company are not to be so dealt with.
This shows that the Bengal factors had become involved in another dispute over the question of their exemption from customs, and as to their payment of anchorage dues.
A letter from Trevisa of 4 July, 1660, acquainted the President and Council that Mīr Jumla, dissatisfied with the result of the conference at Masulipatam, had stopped English trade at Kāsimbāzār. When this news arrived (26 Aug.), Andrews was still contemplating the use of force for obtaining the redress of grievances; but, as negotiations were pending at court, which might secure a favourable settlement, he urged Trevisa (29 Aug.) to proceed cautiously in the matter.
The shipps appointed to your port will be with you before these arrive, and something acted also. Wee can only desire you to take such care that the saltpeeter may be brought downe and what now bought not left up in the country; which must be for the present to stop Meirjumla's mouth with a present, and that something larg, as also promises of restoring his vessaile, and that without faile. You may also give him good words to cause a hope from him of the rest; but give no promise of things you nere meane nor there is no reason to performe. It may be, they seing shipping so large to arrive (and also, if possible, brought up the river), 'twill affright them into complyance, because now also they may have occation to desire your assisstance to stop the flying Prince1; which you may promise largely, but have a great care of giving any thing under your hand; and there be many wayes to escape such a promise fairly, for hee will bee certainly out of your way, and if hee flyes to sea, excuses are enough. Wee can say no more then this: you must piscash, and peice the foxes skinn to the lyon. And if you find, when your business is done (that is, the saltpeeter etc. goods downe), that hee shall persist in his unreasonable demaunds and not be content with what wee have rehersed, you must follow what formerly advised. Call downe your factors; keepe your selves together, ready to be out of danger; to that purpose keepe a sloope by you to be ready on all occasions and well victualled. This is all wee can advise at the present. For the loss of the trade, wee must redeeme hereafter as wee can; for if this Governour stays here, wee are not to stay, and without doubt must break also.
An undated postscript to a letter of 29 September, 1660, from Surat to Madras says:
This day wee received letters from the Agent in the Bay [of] 16 August, which advise us that all trade is stopped at present in the Bay, and that Mier Jumbla hath commanded the Agent upp to him, who hath sent Mr. Kenne. What the issue will be, as yet knowe not. There is allready provided in Pattana, Cassambazar, etc., 1200 tonns saltpeeter. Soe you see what shipping will be required to fetch it of, and what ladinge there will be. Soe that, if you can furnish them with a little money extraordnary, their buisnesse will be done, notwithstanding their rumour of warre.
A copy was also enclosed of an answer made (1 Oct.) to a protest received from Winter's representatives in Masulipatam. In this the Surat Council acknowledged that they had authorized the factors to seize Winter's house in that town ('which since wee understand is effected'), as also any estate of his that might be found on board the Nawāb's junk.
A further Surat letter of 3 November, 1660, replies to one (undated) from Trevisa, which mentioned an impending visit to Mīr Jumla. The Council express a hope that the latter will not persist in his demands; if he does, and the factors have to quit Bengal, they are invited to repair to Surat. Apparently Trevisa had found himself compelled to make the customary annual present in lieu of customs, for the Surat letter continues :
You doe very ill to continue the ill custome begunn by interloopers, of soe greate presents to petty governours as 3,000 rupees— as much as wee give to the Kinge. Beside, wee have advised wee will not pay anchouradge, nor doe wee in any porte wherein wee trade.
The only other reference discoverable as to the course of the negotiations with Mīr Jumla is contained in the Madras letter of 11 January, 1661, already mentioned, which says that Trevisa has reported that ‘their buisnes is like to runn well with the Nabob’; also that 15,000 maunds of saltpetre are awaiting shipment in Bengal.
Here we cease following the dispute with Mīr Jumla (in which both Bengal and Masulipatam were concerned), and return to examine the course of events at Madras.
After dispatching to England, in January, 1660, the Marigold, Merchant's Delight, and Mayflower,1 Agent Chamber and his Council had at their disposal the Anne and the Madras Merchant; while they also expected back, some time in the summer, the Katherine from Macassar. Of the two ships immediately available, the Madras Merchant was sent at the beginning of February to Gombroon, where after a tedious voyage she arrived on 11 May; she returned to Madras in the middle of July, bringing a cargo invoiced at nearly 8,300l.; and she was then sent on to Bengal. Meanwhile the Anne, which had been badly damaged in the cyclone of the previous November, had been dispatched in February, 1660, to Kottiar Bay (now called Trinkomali Bay), on the north-east coast of Ceylon, there to make the necessary repairs. By agreement with the merchants who had freighted her for a voyage to Achin, she called on her way at Porto Novo to procure calicoes for trade with the natives, and she was instructed to procure betel-nuts in return, which she was to leave at Porto Novo on her way back to Madras. The sequel is told in the letter from the latter place to the Company of 11 January, 1661.1
After her arrivall to that port and had landed the freighters goods, shee mended the greatest part of her defects that could be outwardly discerned, with the timber and knees that they cutt in the woods adjacent. And Capt. Knox with his men were treated by the countrey people with noe small courtesy ; for dureing their stay in said place (which was about 4 months) they were dayly presented, both on shoare and board, with cowes, bufflowes, deere, hoggs, antelopps, fowle, and all sorts of fruite ; in recompence of which the countrey people were soe free that they would receive nothing, but still (as is said) pressing one guift upon another on the comander and ships company. Which was but a meere baite and delusion to entrapp Capt. Knox and his men ; for by his indiscretion, sufferring soe many of his men to be on shoare at one tyme, the Chingulaes (the natives of that countrey) under pretence to goe up to the King of Candy to fetch a letter and present for us, surprized Capt. Knox, Mr. John Loveland, and 15 more of the ships company ; and it is a wonder a greater number were not taken, for sometymes so many of his men were permitted ashoare at once that there were not above three or four aboard to keepe the ship. A few dayes after their apprehension, Capt. Knox had liberty to write a note to Mr. John Burford, pilott of the ship, to saile away with the ship without any longer stay. It is now about 9 months since their surprizall, and can heare nothing of them ; but have remitted them letters of creditt to furnish them with necessaryes and redeeme their persons, if it may be done with money. It hath bin a usuall thing for ships to goe in there and refresh and trim, both of ours and the Danes, for not farr off (or close by) the harbour there is a Christian towne ; and in the yeare 1648 Capt. Charles Wylde and Mr. John Burford, with Mr. Grimstone in the Seaflower, in their voyage to Bantam, stayed there many dayes, and many of their men travelled up in the countrey more then 30 miles.2 Nor was it knowne that those people were enemyes to any nation except the Dutch. Captaine Knox had warning given him from us, by Mr. Vassell and others of the Persian Merchants men, whome he was desired to enquire after. Wee doubt not but to force the freighters to make good their condicions, but they alledge withall that 40 of their men, as well as their goods, that went upon the Anne are likewise in custody ; but gives us great hopes that all will very suddenly be redeemed.
It was the 20th day of May that the Anne returned backe to Porto Novo, where and in this place shee tooke in 445 bales of goods on accompt freight and 30 bales of yours to fill her up, and so departed towards Achaene the 16th day of August, according to the contract aforemencioned.
Later on in the letter Chamber and his colleagues say that, according to report, the Dutch have since built a fort at Kottiar, ‘being the best harbour in India’. Mr. D. W. Ferguson, who first published the above letter in his Captain Robert Knox (1896–7), states, from the Ceylon records, that the Dutch, fearing that the incident was the outcome of a plan on the part of the English to occupy Kottiar, sent thither a detachment of troops, but withdrew them on finding that their rivals had no such intention.
Thus commenced the captivity of the two Knoxes, father and son, which has been rendered famous by the account published by the latter in 1681.
During the month of July, 1660, no less than four ships reached Madras from England, the Truro (captain, George Swanley) and the Barbadoes Merchant (under Charles Wylde) arriving on the 6th, the East India Merchant on the 16th, and the Concord1 on the 25th. Of these, the first two had been dispatched in August and December, 1659, respectively, but had been delayed by having to call at the Guinea settlements on their way; the other two had sailed in March, 1660. The Smyrna Merchant had started with them, but, as already related, had been lost on an island in the Mozambique Channel, with practically all her cargo. She had on board nearly 10,000l. in silver, and to the value of 2,270l. in goods.
By these vessels the Agent and Council received letters from the Company dated 23 June and 8 November, 1659, and 22 February, 1660. In the first of these, after giving directions for the disposal of the Truro, the Committees said :
All sortes of callicoes are here very much declined in price; soe that, although the rest of this ships cargazoon must be made up in that comoditie, wee know not well how to order you in what sortes to furnish them; . . . but being wee find that long cloth and sallampores are at present most requestable, wee desire that the remainder of this ships tonnadge may be compleated in those sortes. . . . And if you also send us to the quantitie of 1000 pieces of moores, wee hope they may come to a reasonable markett. In our letter of 31 December, 1657, to you directed, you may find that it was our desires, if any particuler ships, such as should not from us, the East India Company, be consigned unto you, should arrive upon the Coast and there endeavour to carrie on a trade, that you would to the uttmost of your power by all meanes possible oppose and hinder the same; and wee now againe renew our said desires, earnestly requiring you that if any such shipping (to whomsoever they may appertaine) shall come unto your partes, that you doe not in the least measure countinance them, but use all waies that may be to frustrate and circumvent their designes; and upon all occasions of this nature to advise with our President in Surratt, and take his directions how to proceede in puting in execution the power which is given unto us by our charter, of which he hath the coppie. Wee question not your care and faithfullnesse herein, and therefore [leave?] it unto your dilligent and due performance.
Similarly, the letter of 8 November, 1659, was chiefly occupied by directions for the dispatch of the Barbadoes Merchant to Macassar and Bantam and for her lading for England on her return. The Committees were much perturbed by the absence of news of the Love, which had left Madras in February, 1659, and had, as afterwards appeared, perished on her homeward way. They roundly blamed the Agent and Council for delaying her by ordering her to call at Porto Novo for part of her lading; and they hinted a suspicion that this was done purposely to prevent her from reaching England as early as her consorts, 'in which ships some of you were interessed'. The third letter (22 Feb. 1660) also contained several complaints, including one of the behaviour of the Bengal factors in supplying saltpetre to private ships, such as the Virgin and the Thomas and William, while sending none in the Blackamoor (1659), on the plea that Shāh Shuja had seized that commodity for his own use. Fault was also found with the Madras factors for venturing as much as 10,636l. worth of goods in one ship (the Marigold), and for the future they were ordered not to exceed the amount allotted by the Company by more than 1,000l. in any one vessel.
That you have prevailed with Mr. William Isaackson for his longer stay with you, wee are therewith content, not doubting but that during his abode with you it hath and will bee his endeavour and studie to promote the glory of God and to instruct our people in the knowledg and feare of the Almightie.
The dispatch was then advised of a set of the polyglot bible presented by Mr. Thomas Rich (see p. 324). This was, however, put aboard the Smyrna Merchant, and must have been lost with that vessel. The next paragraph intimated that the adventurers in the defunct United Joint Stock had been paid the equivalent of 5,472 new pagodas, which was the amount fixed by valuation for 'the stores and moveables . . . tourned over . . . to this present Stock'. Noting that some of the survivors of the Persia Merchant have been engaged to serve in the garrison of Fort St. George, the Committees expressed a hope that the number of soldiers maintained would be limited strictly to what was absolutely necessary. It was then remarked that the letter received by the Blackamoor was signed only by Chamber and Trevisa (who was not actually employed at Madras).
Wee require for the future that all such letters as shall bee directed unto us bee subscribed joyntly by our Agent and two or three of our factors that are asistants in Counsell with him, that they may come as the joynt act of them all, and not as the act of our Cheife only. Wee also require that all letters that shall bee received from, or sent to, any place whatsoever bee comunicated unto our said factors, and that they have a view and inspection into all our bookes and into the manadgment of all our affaires, that so they may thereby bee in a capacitie upon all occasions to carry on our businesse with the more discretion and advantage unto us.
After ordering the more punctual transmission of the Agency accounts, &c., the letter continued:
Wee have received information that there is liberty given to some perticuler persons to quoyne gold out of our Fort; which wee cannot allow off, being it not onely tends to our disadvantage, but may also bee a meanes to falcifie and debase the quoyne. Therefore wee require you that all such gold as shall come to your hands bee all quoyned within our Fort and noe part thereof permitted to bee quoyned in any other place. And that also you keepe a perticuler and true accompt thereof in your bookes, that wee may at all times see what advance arriseth unto us by the same.
Particulars were then given of the cargoes of the ships, followed by directions for the disposal of the latter. The Truro and Barbadoes Merchant, it was hoped, would bring from Guinea gold to the value of about 25,000l.; and so the total amount at the disposal of the factors ought to be amply sufficient to provide all the goods for England. Greenhill's death was noted with resignation.
And wee also take notice that Mr. Thomas Chamber doth tender us his service for his successor; which for the present wee accept of, hoping that this next yeares shipping will give us better sattisfaction then wee had the former, and that Mr. Chamber will faithfully and industriously imploy himselfe to the manadgment and carrying on of our affaires to our better advantage, for wee cannot but exceedingly blame him for his verie great indiscretion in sending our ship Love so late to Porto Nova, which ship is not yet arived.
After some further details about ships and goods, the Committees went on to say :
Wee have received information that there are certeine paintings [i.e. chintz] made at the Coast, which will sell in the Bay at about 30 per cent. proffitt. If any such bee, wee desire that you procure some of them, to the value of about 500l., and send them thither to make tryall of the marketts.
Next they answered an application for permission to engage certain men as factors.
As touching those three young men, James Noell, Robert Dearing, and Shem Bridges,1 whome you recommend to us, wee cannot as yet give our consent to interteyne them, being wee sent out from hence sufficient for the suply of all our factories, with an overplus ; yet if, at the ariveall of our next shipping, wee shall find that if by mortallitie there will bee any want of factors, wee shall then either suply you from hence or enorder their enterteynment. In the meane time wee doe expect that those whome wee have heere interteyned, and for whome wee have taken good securitie, bee preferred in our imployment.
By the fleet were sent ten men, engaged at from 14s. to 25s. per month, who were intended to be employed as soldiers in Fort St. George.
The optimistic estimate made in this letter of the resources placed at the factors' disposal must have jarred upon Chamber and his Council when contrasted with the actual facts. Apart from the loss of the Smyrna Merchant (the cargo of which, however, had been destined for Bengal, not Madras), the gold brought from Guinea by the Truro and the Barbadoes Merchant totalled only 17,500l. instead of 25,000l. ; and out of this 15,000l. was to be spent in providing cargoes for those vessels to carry to Jambi and Macassar respectively. The East India Merchant was to be sent to Bengal with her lading intact; while the Concord, which brought only about 8,300l. in all, was to go to Persia with a cargo costing 4,000l. or 5,000l. However, there was nothing to be done but to make the best of the situation. The gold was taken ashore and coined into new pagodas (of 10s. apiece), a supply of which was then sent to Masulipatam for the provision of goods. The Barbadoes Merchant proceeded at once to that port, and early in January, 1661, sailed for the South Seas. The Truro departed also for Masulipatam, and thence on 7 September for Jambi. The East India Merchant sailed for Masulipatam and the Bay of Bengal on 26 July, and was followed by the Concord on 6 September. On 9 August the Katherine reached Madras from Macassar and Bantam with a poor cargo, and was sent on to Masulipatam to lade for England. The Anne, on her return from Achin, proceeded to the same port with ‘a freight of ellephants’. She returned to Madras on 20 December, but in such a condition (owing to lack of men and stores) that she was declared unfit for a voyage to England. The Agent and Council thereupon recorded a protest against the captain and owners for their failure to carry out the conditions of their charter-party, and at the time of writing to the Company in January, 1661, they expected that the ship, which was still in the road, ‘at last must fall into Your Worships hands’. The Concord returned from Bengal to Madras on 9 January, 1661, and was thereupon ordered to Persia, in accordance with the Company’s instructions.
These facts were communicated to the home authorities in the letter from Madras of 11 January, 1661, already cited, which also answered the criticisms and directions contained in the Company’s letters received in July, 1660. Into most of the excuses and explanations offered we need not enter, but one or two passages may be quoted as being of special interest.
Wee could never yett learne that any quantity of paintings would sell in Bengalah. It is true some Portugalls that goe downe, for an adventure, will carry a corge or two of sarassees, which probably may goe off amongst their women. Therefore forbore to buy any till wee shalbe further advised from our freinds in Bengalah.
Regarding the alleged illicit coinage at Madras, the factors said :
It is impossible that any gold should be coyned in your towne of Madraspatam but what is stamped in your Fort. The merchants may melt their gold and have essayes taken without ; which is all. Otherwise, by your lawes the offenders wilbe as criminall as if any should presume in London to coyne out of the Tower. Wee have heard indeed that some have attempted to counterfeite your stampe about the parts of Metchlepatam ; but the falce coyne was soone discovered by the people, for though the gold was of the same weight and finenes as yours, yet it would not produce in payment soe much by 10 per cent. as your owne pagodas, of such repute is the Honourable Companies moneys in these countreys.
A promise was given that the accounts should be sent home punctually in future. The present year's books would have been made up earlier, but for the death of John Ellis, the accountant at Masulipatam. The decease of other factors (such as William Pearce and Roger Seymour), and the dispatch of some as supercargoes in various vessels, had occasioned such a shortage of staff that the Agent and Council had been constrained to engage James Noell and Shem Bridges as assistants at Madras and John Burnell as assistant at Vīravāsaram, referring to the Company the salaries to be given to them. After some details about shipping, mention is made of the departure for Surat of Captain Roger Middleton, the commander of the garrison of Fort St. George ;
Which wee easily graunted, being faine a little before to restraine his person upon some misdemeanours. In his stead wee placed Mr. William Hull, who hath since ended his dayes of a languishing sicknes commonly called the barbeers.1
With regard to shipping for England, the East India Merchant and the Truro (which had evidently got back from Jambi) were under orders to leave Masulipatam for home by 15 January, 1661 ; the Madras Merchant was expected shortly from Bengal, and 'wee shall not be long in dispeeding her' ; and the Katherine was ready to start with the letter from which the above quotations have been taken. The last-named vessel, in spite of the Company's criticisms on a similar arrangement in the case of the Love, was to call at Colone,2 Pullecherry, and Porto Novo, to gleane in such goods as are there provided ; for there is a necessity now of imploying all places in these parts, for the continuance of the famine hath caused our freinds in and about Metchlepatam to remitt us part of the moneys that wee had consigned them, for that but little cloth of full demencions was there to be procured.1 And wee doubt not but you will find the goods that are provided here and at Porto Novo to be equall in goodnes at least with those of other places ; which is very good reason for our giveing your merchants imployement, aswell here as at Porto Novo, as far as our meanes will extend; which otherwise would be taken up by the Dutch and would be no easy matter to bring your trade againe into that posture as now it is.
This letter, which is signed by Chamber, À Court, and Gifford, reached the Company on 22 July, 1661.
An item of domestic interest at this period is a squabble which occurred over the proceedings of the Roman Catholic priests who were domiciled at Madras, viz. Ephraim de Nevers and Zenon de Baugé, the former of whom had been there since 1642, and the latter since 1652. In the early days of the settlement, by reason of its security and the opportunities it afforded for trade and employment, it had attracted many Portuguese half-castes from San Thomé ; while the garrison of Fort St. George was largely recruited from this class. The consequent necessity of making some provision for their spiritual welfare had led the English authorities to welcome the advent of Father Ephraim, especially as both he and his later colleague were French Capuchin friars, who refused to acknowledge any authority over them on the part of the Portuguese hierarchy in India or the Inquisition at Goa. The fact that many of the English factors—including, probably, Cogan, Winter, Greenhill, and Chamber—found wives among the Portuguese inhabitants naturally increased the sympathy with which the Fathers were regarded ; while Father Ephraim's sanctity and learning earned him the respect of all. The influence wielded by the two ecclesiastics naturally roused the professional jealousy of the English chaplain, the Rev. William Isaacson, who found no difficulty in working upon the Protestant susceptibilities of some of the more recently appointed factors—themselves not indisposed on other grounds to put a spoke in Chamber's wheel— with a view of appealing to the equally fervid Protestantism of the Committees at home. As Chamber was notoriously sympathetic towards the Fathers, the design was sedulously kept from his knowledge; and it was perhaps for the same reason that Isaacson remained in the background, merely attesting two of the allegations, and leaving the letter to be signed by À Court, Shingler, Gifford, Daniel, and Thurscross. It complains that
there are severall persons whoe are falne from our congregations, haveing bin seduced by two French mendicant fryers whoe, by the assistance of the English, formerly built them a church in the heart of Your Honours towne, and by the encouragement of your present Agent dare boldly performe their idolatrous rites and ceremonies, to the greate scandall of our nation that suffers them. For, first, they are allowed, at the buryall of their dead, to march before the corps with bell, booke, candle, and crosse, to the greate discontent of those that knowe not how to remedy it, liveing under the arbitrary governement of one man, which will not advise with his Councill in matters which concerne the govvernement of Your Honours towne. In the second place, if any Christians belonging to our congregation are visited with any sicknesse, they will bee soe bold as to intrude into our Minister's office of visiting them. . . . to seduce them, if they can. . . . Thirdly, they have likewise in the night gone to Englishmen's howses (when they have bin upon their duty in the Fort), whose wives are newly delivered, to baptize young infants, pretending them to bee very weake, which hath bin found false. . . .
The Company was therefore implored
To free us from these two idolatrous fryers; for it is certaine, soe long as they are permitted to reside in this place, whatsoever Minister Your Honours shall send out shall finde but litle comfort in his labours, and as litle respect from him that now reignes in this place.
A warning is given, however, that,
If Your Honours please to condiscend to this our reasonable and conscionable request, it will bee necessary to send out your positive commands, like the lawes of the Medes and Persians, not to bee altered or contradicted by any power in this place. Wee are bold to give this caution, by reason that Agent Chamber hath declared publiquely that the fryers shall not bee turned out soe long as hee stayes in this place. . . .
This document1, which was dated 24 January, 1660, was intended to be presented to the Company by Isaacson, who was then about to return to England; but in the following month a copy of it was transmitted to the President at Surat. Andrews, who was probably not sorry to have an opportunity of administering a reproof to his colleague at Madras, thereupon wrote (10 May, 1660), advising the receipt of a petition
concerning your countenauncing of Papistry and lycensing of fryers in the Honourable Companies towne of Madras, as permitting their saying of Mass in a church built for that purpose, when you have none built to serve God in a better manner. Wee cannot but take especiall notice of it; and doe require you, upon receipt of this, that such practices be no more, but that you tourne the padres out of towne, sending them to their owne jurisdiction; for tis not to serve God with a face and a face, but singly, as wee profess so to act. Wee shall strictly enquire how you observe this our order, for wee will not suffer their residence on no pretences.
To this Chamber replied that the residence of the padres at Madras had been approved by President Merry (1649–52), and that their services could not be dispensed with, in view of the large Portuguese population and the number of soldiers of that nation employed in the Fort; adding some reflections on the part played by Isaacson in the matter. The Surat Council retorted (31 Aug.) that no President had power to disannul a positive prohibition on the part of the Company; while, as for the other reasons alleged:
Wee doe not read or heare, nor can conjecture, any benefitt, either how or where it accrews to the Company by permitting such a medly of nations in the towne and as many superstitions and paganismes. . . . Sure wee are that the Honourable Company will allow no Popish priests in the towne. And there is no necessity for it; for the mustezas that reside with you are not beneficiall to the Company. You say that they are part of your guard. Wee suppose that they are not so gratis; if not, then English may as well be entertaind as they. In fine, wee shall not be censorious . . . and [wee] conclude that if you cannot live without the mustezas (for Portugalls there are none, as wee are informed, or few at the least), there must be a submission at present; but if the Honourable Companies trade may be there drove, and the Fort and government secured without them, wee absolutely conclude they are, upon receipt of these, to be dismissed the towne and their church converted into a place for more true worshipp, contenting them for it. If the mustezas will stay without them, they may; if not, wee cannot judge it loss to the Honourable Company. . . . ’Twill be better for persons that profess the Protestant religion . . . to serve God in some publique place (and in such a place as that mention’d in towne), that so strangers may see and heare wee doe it orderly, reverently, and decently . . . [and] that those that serve God in the Popish way may doe it out of towne and by themselves.
Then follow some scriptural allusions to sheep and goats and to tares growing amid corn, and the Agent and Council are bidden to
Take notice the Dutch sufferr none : the Portugalls themselves sufferr none : nor the Moores sufferr no churches in any of their jurisdictions.
Isaacson is defended against Chamber’s strictures and pronounced to be ‘ a quiet, sober peacemaker, and painfull in his calling ’. To this letter Chamber returned no immediate reply. He had already demanded an explanation from Isaacson of his share in the petition. The latter replied on 10 August, 1660,1 recalling a conversation between the Agent and several of the factors (Isaacson being present), in which Shingler had urged the expulsion of the padres and Chamber had replied that this should not be done while he retained his authority. Isaacson averred that thereupon Shingler drew up the document in question and submitted it to him, who made some additions which he promised to attest before delivering the letter to the Company. Isaacson then gave some instances of intrusion of the priests into what he deemed his sphere, and finally referred the Agent to the writers of the letter in regard to other points. À Court had already, in a letter addressed to the Company (6 Aug.), recorded a change of opinion. He said that, when still ‘ a stranger ’ to the town, he had accepted the statements of Isaacson and others ; but
Haveing, since my aboade here, succeeded soe well in my complaints to the Agent against the exorbitant proceedings of the two French fryers that hee hath forbidden, and they have promised to forbeare, any more processions and carrying of crosses about the streetes, or endeavour the seducing of any from our congregations, or to doe any thing ells that may give a scandall or offence, otherwhere then within their owne church walls; and being well informd that Your Worships guarison would bee disfurnished and your towne depopulated, in case such liberty should bee denyed to exercise their religion privately with their padrees, I can doe noe lesse then certify Your Worships thereof.
Shingler followed on 16 August, avowing a similar change of views; and so did Daniel from Vīravāsaram (3 Oct.). Finally (23 Oct.), Gifford, the only other signatory remaining in the country, while sturdily declaring that he adhered to the contention that the padres ought not to be countenanced ‘within a Protestant’s jurisdiction’, agreed that it would be both unjust and inexpedient, now that they had promised to confine their ceremonies to their own church, to take any steps to expel them. Thus the matter was left until the following year.
We have seen (p. 302) that in 1659 the Masulipatam factors had asked for some Persian horses for presentation to the King of Golconda in order to obtain a confirmation of the Company’s privileges. Four were accordingly obtained from Gombroon for this purpose, but Chamber took them out of the vessel, on her reaching Madras, and sold them, declaring that they were too lean for presentation. The Surat Council censured his action, but could do nothing except write to Persia for a further supply. Another matter in connexion with Masulipatam which excited the attention of Andrews and his colleagues was the fact that English private traders were enjoying without payment to the Company that freedom from customs duties which had been granted to the latter. On 10 May, 1660, they wrote to Madras:
There is a business worth consideration in Metchlepatam, which hath not been much taken notice of; and that is, the custome of that place. The Honourable Company with the expence of bloud and treasure hath procured (as in other places, so there) many privilledges, which they have a great deale of reason to enjoy themselves, and not every perticular person without any consideration or acknowledgment. Therfore wee desire you seriously to consider of it with Mr. Johnson, Chiefe of the place there resident, and to retourne us your answere.
A suggestion of this sort was not likely to be palatable to the Coast factors, who were all on friendly terms with the private merchants still trading there in defiance of the Company. The reply from Madras was evidently unsatisfactory, for on 31 August the Surat Council wrote :
Wee are not unacquainted that the Honourable Companies privilledges in Metchlepatam cost enough ; but wee are ignorant of any license given those you tearme free men to stay or trade there. Our letters testifie it, and wee know of none wee have writ in a clandestine way. It may be you accuse us of your practice ; but tis as slight as your advice to Mr. Johnson on that subject, to acquaint us with more of that subject if hee knowes it. You say you have enough, when you have writ nothing. Soe that wee our selves have wrote to him, not to trouble you about it.
Andrews did not pursue the subject with the Masulipatam factors. Possibly this was due to a fear that, if he pressed the matter, his own private trading, which was notorious, might in retaliation be brought to the notice of the home authorities.
As regards Bengal, there is little to add to what has already been said concerning the fortunes of that Agency. A letter of some interest was received from the Company by the East India Merchant about August, 1660. This was dated 22 February, 1660, and answered a missing letter from Hūgli of 3 December, 1658. It noted the complaints made by the factors against William Blake and promised to investigate these upon Blake's arrival in England. It approved the engagement of James Pickering and Thomas Gifford as factors, whose salaries would be settled on hearing from the Agent a report as to their abilities.
Wee have concluded to reserve unto our selves the increasing and confirming of sallaries ; and therefore, whereas you say that your hopes are that, as you shall come into greater places of trust, your sallaries shall bee advanced accordingly, wee doe hereby assure you that wee shall bee verie readie and willing to gratifie all such our servants whome wee shall find faithfull and industrious in the manadgment and discharge of those affaires with which they shall be intrusted.
In reply to a representation that 300l. per annum was insufficient to defray the household expenses of the four factories, ‘ because provisions are now three times as deare as formerly ’, the Committees desired a detailed account, on receipt of which the matter should be reconsidered. After some mercantile details, mention is made of a threatened closure of the mint.
If the Governor of Ballasore shall put downe the mint, and will not permitt you to coyne any monies, if you conceive you may find redresse by exhibiting your complaint thereof (or of any other greviances) to the Prince, you may proceed accordingly; otherwise you must submitt.
A request for some Hūgli stuffs suitable for Guinea was followed by the announcement that the longstanding dispute over Henry Cherry's interloping voyage to Persia had been settled at home with Cherry's executors and others interested; William Pitt's share (208l. 17s. 10d.) was accordingly to be paid him in Bengal at the rate of 5s. per rial of eight. Still answering the Hūgli letter, the Committees next observed:
If it bee necessarie that a sloope bee provided to goe up to Hughly [i. e. from Balasore] as a convoy from the rovers, wee give our consent thereunto. And for our shipping goeing up into the river of Gangees, thereby to reduce the Governor of Ballasore to better freindship and breake off his demaund for anchorage, wee also aprove thereof and recommend its prosecution unto you. But wee would willingly that a tryall might first bee made with shipping of small burthen, before you venture on such great shiping as the Smirna Merchant or the like. However, if upon consultacion with the masters and the experiences which you have made of the depths of the river, you shall conclude it to bee feaceable and without hazard, wee leave it unto your discretions. If the procuring of a new phirmaund from the Prince bee of such consequence unto our affaires as you inferr it to bee, wee hope, if you have or shall obteyne the same, you have or will take espetiall care that all convenient priviledges which may bee advantagious unto us shall bee therein inscerted and confirmed, and that also you have bin and will bee as good husbands for us, in all perticulers, as may bee.
Notice was then taken of complaints from Persia regarding unsuitable goods sent thither in the Anne: an order for the supply of cowries for England was given: and reductions were made in the demands for sugar and cotton yarn. Finally, particulars were given of the cargoes of the ships sent for Bengal.
A few communications originating in the Bengal Agency itself have been preserved. Henry Aldworth, who was then alone at Patna, wrote to Trevisa on 12 July, 1660, promising to dispatch about 15,000 maunds of saltpetre to Hūgli shortly, and desiring the Agent
To send Meerejumlers dustuck soe soone as may bee, because [I] have none heere. The Dutch have nine pattelloes1 of petar, with some 25 in 26,000 maunds, which have beene at Pun Pun1 some 16 daies, which will in three or four daies more leave this place and goe for Hugely, there dustuckes being now, I thinke, all ready. . . . Here is one No-sery Cawne,2 that is come from the King and is goeing too bee Governour of Kateck [Cuttack (Orissa)]. . . .
Here, as elsewhere, we find the Dutch well ahead of our countrymen in the amount of business they were doing.
We have also two private letters from Richard Chamberlain, written at Hūglī 15 and 17 December, 1660. The first, to some correspondent in London (possibly the Governor of the Company), is full of the difficulties experienced at Patna owing to want of money. The second, addressed to Alderman John Robinson, contains an outspoken criticism of Agent Trevisa.
Our books of accompts have bin here with him this nine months, and still remayne unregistred. A greater procrastinator I never mett with. His owne books I dare say he is ignorant off, and ashamd to shew them. Wee doe our duety when [wee] deliver them here; but when hele send them home wee knowe not. . . . His abillityes as to the place hee hath undertaken [are] farr short; and if ever Your Worship etc. exspect a good and ample accompt of your buisnes, hee must bee supplyed with an able sollid man for his second, that may carry it one, for hee himselfe never can. He is the carelessest man, both in his books and papers, as ever I saw; nothing but confusions, blottings, etc. Every thing thats acted is like himselfe. He is as fitt for the employment hee hath undertaken as I am to bee King of this country.
Chamberlain, however, was not the only colleague of Trevisa who had reason to be dissatisfied with his conduct. Halstead had far more cause for complaint. The difference between him and the Agent seems to have arisen from the latter refusing (most unreasonably) to recognize Halstead as his Second until he should be formally confirmed in that post by the Company. As stated in a letter from Halstead (3 July, 1660), their disputes culminated in a scuffle, in consequence of which Halstead was put in irons and kept in confinement for some months
upon pretence I threw him downe, when as himselfe was the peace breaker, by endeavouring to kick me out of his chamber for noe other reason then delivering my opinion upon a necessarie occation Trevisa seems to have reported Halstead's misdemeanour to Surat in a letter of 21 April, 1660, and the President and Council replied on 28 June, fully approving of strong action being taken against any factor who should presume to rebel against his superior. On the third of the following month Halstead made a piteous appeal to Ken, Chamberlain, and Charnock to secure for him a trial or release. The sequel appears from another letter written by him at Kāsimbāzār on 13 September, in which he says that Trevisa set him at liberty ‘with as much reason as committed, that is, without counsell or advice, only upon a suddain motion and dictate of passion’; wherefore, thinking it impossible that he can live contentedly with Trevisa, he makes a humble appeal to President Andrews to be transferred to a post in some other Agency or else sent home.
One small piece of information has been preserved in the Dagh-Register, 1661 (p. 240). This is that Trevisa, in August, 1660, went up from Hūgli to Dacca in a small vessel manned by six or seven English sailors, and that these men were detained by Mīr Jumla and employed in his service. The object of the Agent's visit is not stated.
Notes
- 1. More accurately, a parwāna. For its terms see the appendix (p. 416).
- 1. Shuja. Both the Dutch and the English were pressed to lend vessels to cut off his escape (Dagh-Register, Batavia, 1661, pp. 6, 43).
- 1. According to a letter from Madras to Bantam (11 March, 1660), the first of these sailed on 24 January, carrying Winter and his family, and Henry Thurscross ; the second had started on the 12th idem, with Blake and his family; the third left on the 29th, having on board John Gurney and his family and the Rev. William Isaacson.
- 1. O.C. 2865. There is a copy in Factory Records, Fort St. George, vol. xiv (p. 5).
- 2. See English Factories, 1646–50, p. 138, and my article on Wylde in the Geographical Journal for July, 1914.
- 1. A log of the voyage forms no. lxviii of the early Marine Records.
- 1. Afterwards (1668–9) Chief in Bengal.
- 1. A species of paralysis, thought by some to be connected with beriberi.
- 2. Presumably Covelong (Kovalam). 'Pullecherry' is, of course, Pondicherri.
- 1. A letter from Masulipatam to Bantam of 24 July, 1660, expresses great doubts whether goods will be forthcoming for England, ' the countrey, through the last great storme and the daily abuse of governours to the poore, being so much ruined that the fourth part of goods formerly procureable is not now '.
- 1. It has been printed in full by the Rev. F. Penny in The Church in Madras (vol. i. p. 27), and by Col. Love in Vestiges of Old Madras (vol. i. p. 181).
- 1. The letter is printed in full by the Rev. F. Penny (op. cit. vol. i. p. 28).
- 1. The patela was a large flat-bottomed boat used on the Ganges.
- 1. Pūn Pūn, 8 miles south of Patna, on the river of the same name.
- 2. Nāsiri Khān, better known as Khān Daurān (Sarkar's Aurangzib, vol. ii. p. 45).