The English in Bengal

The English Factories in India, 1661–1664, William Foster, 1923 · from page 392 · about 21 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

During this year the factories in the three provinces of Bihār, Bengal, and Orissa, viz. Hūgli, Balasore, Kāsimbāzār, and Patna, continued under the charge of William Blake, subject to the general superintendence of the Agent and Council at Madras.

Blake’s action in making Bridges his principal assistant had excited some resentment among the senior factors, such as Ken, Charnock, and Sheldon; and at the close of 1663 the first named, whose contracted period of service had come to an end, handed over charge at Patna to Thomas Stiles and prepared to depart for England, without waiting for Blake’s permission (Hūgli Records, vol. i. p. 21). As he was understood to intend returning by way of Surat, his action was reported (in a letter of 18 March) by Winter and his colleagues to the President, ‘in expectation that he may receive some check or other from you’. Oxenden in reply (19 May) strongly reprehended Ken’s ‘deserting the Companies service’ and laid it down that no factor could leave without permission. As a matter of fact, Ken remained in Bengal for the rest of the year as a private person, and went home at its close with the sanction of the Fort St. George Agent.

Charnock, who had also decided to return to England, was persuaded by Blake to stay at least a little longer. In a letter of 23 February he agreed to remain until the end of September, on condition that he was made the head of the Patna factory; and he was accordingly appointed to that post.

The Madras letter referred to above mentions some ‘mischance that happened about Thomas Pratt at Decqua’ [Dacca], which had brought upon the English the displeasure of the Nawāb, Dāūd Khān. The reference is elucidated by Manucci (Storia do Mogor, vol. ii. p. 102), from whose account it appears that Pratt’s servants became involved in a quarrel with some soldiers, whereupon the latter attacked the house. Pratt fired upon the assailants, doing great execution, with the result that they decamped; and then, fearing the results of his action, he put a few goods on board a vessel and fled. Manucci’s further statement, that Pratt thereupon took refuge in Arakan and was there put to death by the King, is incorrect. That incident took place in 1667. A Dutch letter from Hūgli, written on 24 October, 1664 said that Pratt and four more Englishmen had reached Rājmahāl in a sloop mounting four guns, his object being to offer to the new Nawāb his services in building ships and making cannon (Dagh-Register, Batavia, 1664, p. 560). In a consultation held at Hūgli on 11 July, the English factors confirmed a previous order of 9 June, stopping Pratt’s pay and allowances until he had given satisfaction ‘for what layd to his charge’; but presumably this decision was rescinded later, for the Madras letter of 12 January, 1665, mentions that Blake ‘is forced to continue Mr. Pratt at Decca at greate charge’.

The death of Mīr Jumla, whose parwāna had protected the English traders against all claims for customs duties, had naturally led to some questioning of their right to this exemption, particularly as they themselves based it upon an old farmān from Shāh Jahān, which had not been confirmed by the reigning Emperor. As we have seen, the Bengal factors had for some months been hoping that the general farmān which the Surat authorities contemplated obtaining from Aurangzeb would include a grant of exemption from customs dues in Bengal and would in addition free the English from the annual present of Rs. 3,000 which had been made for many years. On the strength of this expectation, permission had been obtained to defer for three months the payment of this contribution for 1663; but at the expiration of that period the Governor of Hūgli took steps to enforce payment, and Robert Elwes, who was in charge of the factory there, was ‘imprisned in the Durbar’ until he gave security to pay the amount within five days. Accordingly at a consultation held on 4 February, it was resolved by Blake, Bridges, and Elwes to discharge the liability immediately.

A more serious matter of debate at that consultation was the news of the approach of a new Governor for Bengal. Discredited as he had been by Sivāji’s successful attack on his camp, the removal of Shāista Khān from the command of the army in the Deccan had been deemed imperative, and Aurangzeb had seized the opportunity of the vacancy in the eastern provinces to transfer him thither (December, 1663). The English factors considered it advisable to take the earliest opportunity of securing his favour, and they therefore resolved

That Mr. Blake proceede suddainly up to meete the said Nabob in Rogamaull,1 and that he carrye up with him severall things considerable for a pressent, to be disposed of to the Nabob etc. emminent persons as he shall then finde convenyent to be given to each; by which he may be able to mediate and endeavor to redress abuses received and, if possible, to procure an order to command the Governer of this place from making any demands in the future for that annuall payment of 3,000 rupes; and further that he may endeavor to procure this Nabob[s] generall perwanna for a free trade, as formerly granted by his predecessors, throughout the above mentioned provinces.

The result of this mission is given in a letter from Hūgli to Surat of 21 June. Blake,

After one month giving his attendance at coart continually, and with no little charge, solliciting the Nabob, obteyned his perwanna,1 wherein he grants us the privilidges we enjoyed in the Princes [i.e. Shāh Shuja’s] and his predecessors times; which we having gotten, did conceive our masters affaires might be carried on without receiving any molestation from him or his governers, but we soone after found the contrarie. In the month of May last we received a generall letter from Mr. Charnock in Pattana, wherein he advized us of the arrivall of Shester Cauns droga [agent: dārogha], with commition to buy 20,000 maund of saltpetre; also with orders to forbid the Dutch and the English from giving out any monyes to the petre men; and presently he hindred our weigheing and receiving of what petre we had formerly given out monyes for, putting his seale on severall places where it lay…. Daily persons run away that are the Companies debtors; so that he writes the trade is quite spoyled, and that by reason of the drogas abuses to the petre men the Nabob will not be able to procure any quantity. Concerning these abuses we have severall times complayned to Shester Caun and used all meanes for a remmedie, but can procure none. He one while demands of us 20,000 maund petre, pretending he hath occation for said quantity to carrie on the Kings warrs; now, upon our late complaints, in reply tells us possitively that he will not suffer us to weigh, buy, or bring downe any petre, unless we give him a writing enjagin[g] our selves not to sell any goods or silver that our ships may bring into this countrey unto any person but to him, and the price must be what his agents thinke or make; and then doth not say we shall have liberty to buy that commodity as formerly, but that he will furnish us with it. The stop of said trade hath been neere two months, being the only time to get in petre…. If Your Worship doth not procure a remedy for these abuses from the King, the trade of these parts will be quite lost. This Nabob is a person most adicted to covetiousnesse, and it is verrily beleeved that he will engross all goods in which he conceives a bennifit may be had…. News here [we] have not any, save this Nabob is preparing to make warr on Arracan, and demands English and Dutch men to serve him in said warrs, and doth expect to be furnished. So dishonnerable and covetious a person never came into these parts for a Governor.

This letter was sent by way of Patna, where Charnock (3 July) added his own account of the situation. He said that Shāista Khān’s intentions were

To get this whole trade of peeter into his own hands, and so to sell it againe to us and the Dutch at his own rates, he well knowing the ships cannot goe from the Bay empty. But he is not likely to get above mds. 4 or 5,000 this yeare. His droga hath so abused the merchants that they are allmost all runne away. He pretends that all the peeter he buyes is for the King. It was never known he had occasion of more then mds. 1,000 or 1,500 yearely for all his warrs. . . . Here appeares dayly nothing else but grosse affronts and dishonour. . . . Mr. William Blake visited the Nabob at Rajamall and procured his dustuck long since; but it is of no value in this place, only in Bengall. . . . Dowet Caune [Dāūd Khān] Nabob is returned from Dacka, and at present remaines here. Sester Caunes sonne is gone in his roome, and hath received an overthrow by the Mogoos1 in those parts.

Charnock added that, if supplied with the necessary funds, he could procure 25 or 30,000 maunds of saltpetre yearly, whereas hitherto 18,000 had been the limit.

The Surat President and Council had already informed the Bengal factors, in a letter of 30 April, that the Company had vetoed the proposed mission to Delhi for the purpose of procuring a general farmān from the Emperor; though in a subsequent communication (19 May) to Madras they added that ‘wee watch a fitt time to petition the King for his phirmaun of favour to the Nabob in the Bay’. On receipt of the letters of 21 June and 3 July, they wrote again (3 September) to Hūgli, regretting their inability to make any move in the matter of the farmān and suggesting fresh representations to the Company.

Wee very well know your Nabob Shasta Ckaun and his covetious, gripeing disposition. It is no new practice that hee is now upon, but what hee hath all along dishonourablely acted. Hee monopolized his owne bazarr that followed his owne campe in the Decann warrs. . . . Wee once was troubled with him at Ahmadavad, when hee used us at the same rate. But curst cowes have short horns. Hee stayes not long any where. Wee are informed hee is worse then outed already, and wee pray and hope it is true that the King hath taken off all his revenue, that was upwards of 50 lack of rupees yearely, which hee increased to four score by his extortions. . . . Wee have it credibly reported that the King hath been soe much agrivated by his sonns dishonorable being worsted at Dahka that order is gon out to leave him but one lack of rupees for his future maintaineance yearely1; which will cut his combe soe close that hee must bee forced to disband apace to confine himselfe to his close order, although it is said hee hath a great treasury about him. . . . All are of oppinion heere that this degradeing will cause him forsake the world and turne fuckeer, and that hee will not except what the King hath appointed him. . . . Hee is the Kings uncle, in which relation hee is soe sleightened that hee dares doe more then the King himselfe. Wee are very confident, could wee procure a phirmaun upon him, it would not at all alter him, but hee would persist in his exactions. It seems the Dutch have the same usage with us, notwithstanding theres soe lately procured and then sent thither, a costly peece of paper to no purpose.

The extortions to which the factors were obliged to submit were evidently not exaggerated in these documents. Sheldon and Powell wrote from Kāsimbāzār on 23 June that a sum of 5,672 rupees had been forced from them on account of the late Nawāb’s claims against Trevisa. At a consultation held at Hūgli on 11 July it was decided to give 500 rupees to ‘Mirza Sied Jelleldee’ [Mīrza Sayyid Jalāluddin], the new Governor, besides presents to his officers; and also to direct Powell to go up to Rājmahāl to meet the saltpetre boats from Patna and to pay whatever sum might be requisite to obviate their stoppage there. It was further decided to remind Shāista Khān of his promise to Blake that he would write to the Emperor to remit ’the annually exacted present of 3,000 rupees’. Bridges and Stiles (who had been recalled from Patna) were ordered to Balasore to meet the ships expected from the Coast.

The ships that reached Bengal this season brought a letter from the Company, dated 16 December, 1663, advising the factors of the steps taken to supply them with stock, and urging the speedy dispatch of the ships on their return voyage. Hopes were expressed that Blake had reduced expenses, that the trouble with Mīr Jumla had been composed, and that Trevisa’s accounts had been cleared.

Wee having contracted with our shipps to saile up the river of Gangees, wee conceive the factory of Ballasore will bee altogither unecessary and uselesse, and therefore wee supose that factory is already disolved; but if not, let it bee done with all expedition.

And for the factory of Cassambazar, wee have noe greate encouragment to continue the same, finding our taffataies to cost us deare, and little advance made in the sale. At our factory of Pattana wee also conceive it needlesse to continue a constant residence, but rather that some persons bee sent upp in the most propper seasons for the procury of saltpeeter. . . . Wee desire that all our factories may bee reduced, and a setled residence only kept at Hughly, that soe our expences may bee drawne into a narrow compasse and noe extravagant charges put upon us.

A reminder was given that the Company expected to hear regularly from the subordinate factories; and the letter concluded with a complaint of the large amount of wastage in the last consignment of saltpetre.

In forwarding this letter, the Madras Council (4 July) expressed a doubt whether it would be found possible to withdraw from either Patna or Kāsimbāzār. Trevisa having gone home, the settlement of accounts with him might be left to the Company.

But this puts us in minde of the long dispute aboute the Nabobs junck; but hope that his sonne hath forgott it, or at least that a full end of that is now made, and that the 15,000 rials of eight which Mr. Blake received of Mr. Chambers is (as formerly enordred) brought into the Companies cash with the interest thereof from the time it was received. The Company doth expect a full accompt of that buissinesse at the retorne of the shipping; therefore pray . . . let us understand the true state of it, that soe accordingly wee may treate with Mr. Chamber concerneing his goeing home for England.

Blake was warned to leave open, for perusal at Madras, any letter he might address to the Company, and to do his best to prevent private goods being put on board the ships for England. ‘Wee understand that there is noe hopes for your haveing a phirmaund for your parts. However, if it bee absolutely necessary, you were best to insert it in yours to the Company, with your reasons for it.’ Bridges was ordered to come to Madras,1 in order to take his place in Council, Gifford being about to go home. Some ‘spotted deere’ were requested, for transmission to England for presentation to King Charles.

A month later a fresh letter was addressed to Blake from Madras complaining of his silence. As Sheldon’s time was expired, permission was given to him to go home; but Blake was blamed for his discourtesy to him, which was the chief cause of his quitting the service. Powell was to succeed Sheldon. Since the ‘remaynes’ in the Bay amounted to 50,000 pagodas, apart from the money received from Chamber, the full sum ordered by the Company to be remitted to Bengal had not been sent.

A letter from Winter and Sambrook at Madapollam to Hūgli, dated 8 October, replying to one of 7 August, contains the following passage :

You say there is an absolute necessity to furnish the Nabob with a sloope and men, and it will bee a greate furtherance to our masters buisinesse both this and the next yeare ; which if it bee soe and the Nabob will not bee sattisfied without it, you must endeavour to gett men and a sloope to assist him. But wee would have you to agree with him in paper written that, if hee should, by his invadeing the King of Arraccans cuntrey, disenable those people to pay us our debts, wee haveing a trade with them, that then hee should bee obliged to see us sattisfyed (which wee conceive to bee but reasonable) ; and hee must allow the charges of the sloope and menn. Wee take notice that the Moores threaten to demollish our factoryes, as alsoe the Dutch and Portugall buildings ;1 by which may bee seene that they doe not much desire our stay in their countrey.

On 4 October, Blake, Bridges, and Elwes addressed a letter to Surat, complaining further of the abuses received from Shāista Khān, who

One day, upon receipt of a gift, will grant a person priviledges by giving him his perwanna ; but no sooner gone from court but he, with them about him, find a meanes to make said invalid ; by which he is forced to a further charge, if he will keep in favour. . . . What salt peter this yeare sent down was by this Nabob stopped at Rajamall, and caused an expence of 2,600 rupees and upwards before wee could procure its inlargement.

It was hoped that the Company, on hearing of these troubles, would reconsider its decision not to seek for a farmān from the Emperor.

The report that you had, that the Dutch had withdrawn their factory, [we] suppose proceeded from a difference they had with the Governour of Ballisore, who, upon complaint of some boatmen, caused a Dutch writer1 to be made fast and drubb’d; upon which for a certaine time they withdrew from said factory and one at Piply, a place adjacent and under the same Governour; then with a sloop rid within the barre of Ballesore, pretending that they would stopp his shipps and what belonged to him. But they effected nothing; only, by their complaint to the Nabob of Orixa, got said person to be put out of his government of Pipley. The Dutch here are not free from troubles, but carry on their businesse with much difficulty and charge, which their vast trade can beare. Wee conceive no abuse will occasion their deserting of these parts, in that Japan etc. depends on the commerce or commodities which they carry from hence.

We know from a list of packet (O.C. 3036) that the Rebecca carried home a letter to the Company from the Bengal factors, dated 8 December, but no copy of it has survived. The only document of that date now extant is a note from Stiles at Balasore to Blake, apologizing for his past behaviour and begging to be allowed to stay. On the next day, by the Morning Star, Stiles sent a letter to the Company, explaining that his apology had been forced from him by Blake, under a threat that otherwise he would be deported to Madras. He defended his past conduct and made charges against Blake and Ken.

The letter from Madras to the Company of 12 January, 1665, contained several passages relating to affairs in Bengal. Concerning the claim on account of Mīr Jumla’s junk nothing further had been heard.

All his papers are gon to the King. What the effect of there examination may bee [wee] know not. Nothing to bee feared to call the business to mind againe so much as a writeing which Mr. Trevisa gave in the Honourable Companyes name to give the Nabob sattisfaction for his shipp by such a tyme; and this is gon among his papers very probable, but hope it’s miscarryage, and then wee beleive there will be an end of that business. The 15,000 ryalls which Mr. Chamber deposited in Mr. Blake his hands on that accompt wee have enordered to bee brought into Your Worships cash, with interest at one per cent. per moneth from the tyme it was received by him.

Shāista Khān’s exactions and abuses were next narrated.

Your Worships must consider that these people are growne more powerfull then formerly, and will not bee so subject to us as they have byn, unless they bee a little bitten by us, that they may understand, if they impeede us by land, it lyeth in our power to requite them by sea. They accounted us formerly very powerfull there; but they looke not upon us nowadayes after that rate, and begin to slight our passes and say tis sufficient so they have but the Dutches. In fine, ’tis Mr. Blakes opinion that your affaires will bee quite ruined if this Nabob lives and reigneth long; and the same will bee here, unless they bee made to know that wee are able to right our selves when wee receive an injury.

Blake had built three boats to carry goods between Balasore and Hūgli;

Which now stands Your Worships in greate stead, for the countrey boats the last yeare were most of them spoyled with the storme, and the rest made use of for the Nabobs accompt; and the commanders of all the shipps refuseing to go up the river. Capt. Godolphin, goeing downe first, did not prosecute his intentions and resolutions to breake the ice; which if hee had, in probabillity the rest would all have followed. But hee intended to carry his shipp into Ballasore to remaine there while [i. e. until] the monsoones were over; but that little forewards Your Worships affaires. So that Mr. Blake feares the shipps will bee later this yeare then formerly, for want of conveyance. Therefore now Your Worships may see you cannot depend on the promises of commanders in England, and that hence forewards they must either be obliged by charterparty or elce Your Worships owne shipps must first venture.

As regards the reduction of the number of factories in Bengal,

Since the commanders refuse to go up the river Ganges, Mr. Blake tells us there is an absolute necessity of keepeing Ballasore, as also for the vend of your Europe comodities and procury of such goods by Your Worships required. Pattana also must bee resided in, in regard of the debts that are standing out, which requireth a constant attendance for the recovery thereof, as also for the quickening the saltpetre men in their business; so that wee confess wee cannot indeede conceive how it should be done, unless they made an agreement with some greate man to furnish them yearely with so much, and they write us none can doe it but the Nabob; which is the verey thing hee desires to engrosse, as hee hath done the salt, and then would hee force us and the Dutch to pay what hee pleased. Cassambazar can never bee reduced to Hughly. The weavers will not bee perswaded to go thither; so that, according to the encouragement that Your Worships shall receive from Mr. Sheldon this yeare, you may either absolutely desolve or continue it.

The Bengal factors had reported that they could supply blue and green taffetas; but it was feared that the colours would not stand, and they would cost a rupee more each piece. It was possible to convey goods from Agra to Hūgli by water, and thence overland in twenty days; but as to whether this route would be better than the land route to Surat, no opinion could be given. Blake had declared that the Bengal trade was ruined. He had also complained of shortage of stock, but this was due to Buckeridge’s advice.

Mamood Ammy Caun,1 sonn to the Mierjumballa, hath now obteyned the governement of his father in Bengalla (as advised from Pattana), and suddainely will come thither. There is no hopes of getting free the 3000 rupees yearely paid at Hughly, the Nabob haveing that for his rents, and never will bee cleared unless complained of to the King.

Blake had accused Sheldon of spending money on building without his approval, though he confessed that this was ‘verey necessary’, and permission to do anything that was really needed had been obtained from Madras.

As already noted, Ken and Sheldon went home in the fleet. Charnock had changed his mind, and remained in Bengal. From a note appended to a list of packet (O.C. 3047), we learn that James Calthrop and Hackett Jones had ‘deceased in Bay Bengalah’ during the year.

In addition to the particulars already noted, the Dutch records of the time give evidence of the large private trade carried on by Blake and other English factors. They also corroborate what has been said above about the covetousness of Shāista Khān and his constant endeavours to extract money from all and sundry. His scheme for monopolizing the foreign commerce appears to have been dropped when he removed from Rājmahāl to Dacca, where his energies were absorbed in the task of freeing the province from the incursions of the Arakanese—a task in which, as we have already seen, he was demanding the assistance of the English and the Dutch. Evidently he was expecting more from the latter than from the former, for he dispatched an envoy to Batavia about the matter, carrying a letter and a present to the Governor-General.

NOTE.

The present volume supplies an answer to the question asked in a note on p. 33 of its predecessor, as to the identity of the ‘Raja de Carnatica’ mentioned by Tavernier. From p. 242 (supra) it seems clear that the Rāja of Ikkeri was intended.

Notes

  1. 1. According to the Batavia Dagh-Register, 1664 (p. 257), Shāista Khān entered Rājmahāl on 8 March (O.S.).
  2. 1. No copy has been traced.
  3. 1. Maghs (Arakanese). For some time they had ravaged Eastern Bengal, and their chastisement was the chief duty that lay before Shāista Khān and his son, Buzurg Umaid Khān.
  4. 1. According to the Dagh-Register, 1664 (p. 554), the Arakan flotilla had attacked the Mogul boats in the Dacca river and had destroyed 160 of them. Aurangzeb was so enraged at the news that he ordered the Nawāb and his son to be deprived of part of their revenues; but this was soon countermanded.
  5. 1. As already noted (p. 373), this order was afterwards annulled by the Councillors at Masulipatam.
  6. 1. A Dutch letter from Hūgli of 17 October (Dagh-Register, 1664, p. 593) says that the Governor had informed them of Shāista Khān’s order that the Europeans must be content with earthern dwellings in place of stone. The Portuguese were obliged to pay 1000 rials for having erected a church without permission ; while the English, who had built a stone gateway to their factory, had to compound for 600 rials. The Dutch were resisting, but expected to have to bribe either the Nawāb or the Governor.
  7. 1. Arent Kroesbeek: see Batavia Dagh-Register, 1664, pp. 15, 135, 553, 594.
  8. 1. Muhammad Amīn Khān. There was no truth in this rumour (which is mentioned at p. 558 of the Dagh-Register).