II.—England's Duties to India

Essays, Speeches, Addresses and Writings, Dadabhai Naoroji, 1887 · from page 26 · about 50 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

(Read before a Meeting of the East India Association,
London, May 2nd, 1867.)

Gentlemen,—I propose to discuss the following three questions—Is the British rule in India a benefit to India and England? If so, what are the best means to make it endure the longest time possible? Are such means adopted?

The political condition of India before the consolidation of the British rule was the usual Oriental despotism, with all its regular attendants of disorder, want of law, want of security of property and life, and general ignorance. True it is that now and then monarchs appeared who made the welfare of the country their anxiety and duty. Well may India rejoice in some great names. But it cannot be denied that India was for a long time politically a degraded nation. The intrigues and murders in the families of the many rulers in the different parts of India, their imbecility and their utter incompetence to understand their duties towards their subjects, left the people of India without that powerful political aid which is so vital to the growth and welfare of any nation; added to this, the constant internal wars between the dif ferent rulers completed the obstacles to healthy development. War, oppression, and exaction may be said to have been the normal political condition of India.

In their moral condition the natives of India have been equally unfortunate during centuries by the influence of an ignorant priesthood, superstition, and some unfortunate institutions, such as suttee, lifelong widowhood, female infanticide, &c. Materially, India was at a standstill. The agriculturist tilled the soil, reaped the crop, lived upon it and died, just as his forefathers did thousands of years ago. The artizan worked on in the same ancestral way and line. There was utter stagnation and gradual retrogression. All desire to progress and improve, to develop the resources of the country, had completely died out; on the contrary, the wisest course was that of our “ancestors.” The division into castes and distinct professions checked any growth of genius and talent, and prevention from foreign travelling checked any expansion of ideas and general knowledge. On its intellect all the above baneful causes had their full effect. The literature of thousands of years ago is the literature of which the modern Hindu is proud. He can only point to his Kalidas and his Panini, his Ramayan and his Mahabharata, his Veds and his Menu’s Institutes.

Contrast with this the results of British rule. Law and order are its first blessings. Security of life and property is a recognized right of the people, and is more or less attained according to the means available, or the sense of duty of the officials to whom the sacred duty is entrusted. The native now learns and enjoys what justice between man and man means, and that law instead of the despot’s will is above all. To the enlightenment of the country the results of the univerities and educational establishments bear witness. In place of the old general darkness and ignorance thousands of natives have derived, and millions will derive hereafter, the benefit of the highest degree of enlightenment which man has attained. In material progress it can be easily seen what impulse will be given to the development of the natural resources of the country by railways, canals, public roads, &c., and, above all, by the introduction of English enterprise generally. The social elevation of the people, their rescue from some of the most horrible rites ever known to mankind, and the better sense of domestic, social, and religious duties awakened in them, are boons of the highest importance to a nation sunk for centuries in a debasing superstition. The last but not the least of the benefits which India is deriving at the hands of the British is the new political life they are being inspired with. They are learning the most important lesson of the highest political condition that a nation can aspire to. The freedom of speech which the natives are now learning the necessity of, and are enjoying, and with which the natives can now talk to their rulers face to face for what they want, is another invaluable blessing.

Such, gentlemen, is the picture the Englishman presents to the natives of India, and asks whether the British rule is not a benefit and a blessing to their nation. Unfortunately, this question is sometimes asked in the manner in which the artist in ‘Punch’ asked the candid opinion of his friend, by first giving the friend a hint that whoever found fault with his picture should deserve to be knocked down. The answer naturally in such a case can be easily conceived. But there are Englishmen, both here and in India, who ask this question in all sincerity of purpose, who in a spirit of true patriotism on the one hand, and true philanthropy on the other, desire a candid reply as much for England’s as for India’s sake, and the candid answer is sometimes given. Various are the replies, according to the feelings, the interests, and the knowledge of the answerers, and the points of view from which they look upon the matter.

To those who are overthrown and who have lost their power, the question strikes as an impertinence. They are not in a mood to understand all this benefit and blessing, but, smarting under their fall, reply with a bleeding heart, “Blessing, indeed! Rulers of millions, we are now either beggars or rebels,”—a reply given unfortunately in lines of blood in some of the deplorable events of 1857.

Those who still retain more or less power and state, either real or nominal, and who have now commenced to understand the effects of English rule so far as they are concerned, say :—“It is true that Englishmen always proclaim their justice, honesty, and fair play, but what guarantee is there that their acts will always accord with their words?” The cases of several annexations and of Mysore are a strange commentary upon these professions. These princes naturally wish to be satisfied that the English are really just, that they would always subordinate might to right, and that in their dealings with them honesty and not “empire” would be their guiding principle.

The mass of the people, even up to the present time, understand but little the “benefits.” To them the existing Government has always been the sircar; whether it was Mahommedan, Hindu, or British, has not mattered much. They can hardly be expected to understand and appreciate the various benefits in all their different aspects. They see them yet but dimly: in fact, they are often hopelessly puzzled if an attempt is made to edify them by a lecture on the benefits of the British rule. The poor labourer has hitherto had his simple criterion. If he is able to earn and enjoy his little without disturbance, and has his creed tolerated and his feelings not hurt, all is right with him, and his ideal of a happy political condition is realized, no matter who rules over him. If, on the contrary, any causes bring starvation to him, or outrage his religion or his feelings, all is wrong with him, and he curses his Raj, be it English, Mahommedan, or Hindu. But the fusion which railroads are now gradually effecting, and the various questions with reference to labour and the ryots now coming under public discussion, are, however, now teaching this hitherto apathetic and ignorant mass some new political lessons, and creating a new national life: with what result in the future will depend upon the character and conduct of their present British teachers. At present their ideas of benefits, or otherwise, of the British rule are confined to the conduct of the officials of their district. These officials are all sircar, all “Mabap.” They can make the British Raj beloved or hated as they like.

But the reply which most concerns the rulers as well as the future of India, is that of the educated and the thinking portion of the natives. They admit fully the force of the question. They acknowledge the benefits to their fullest extent, and express gratitude. But they say all this is true, but it is not the whole truth. The picture has another side also. Security of life and property we have better in these times, no doubt, but the destruction of a million and a half lives in one famine is a strange illustration of the worth of the life and property thus secured. In the shape of "home charges" alone there has been a transfer of about 100 millions of pounds sterling, exclusive of interest on public debt, from the wealth of India to that of England since 1829, during the last thirty-six years only. The total territorial charges in India since 1829 have been about 820 millions. Supposing that out of the latter sum only one-eighth represents the sum remitted to England by Europeans in Government service for maintenance of relatives and families, for the education of children, for savings made at the time of retiring, the sums expended by them for purchase of English articles for their own consumption, and also the sums paid in India for Government stores of English produce and manufactures—there is then another 100 millions added to the wealth of England. In principal alone, therefore, there is 200 millions, which at the ordinary interest of 5 per cent. will now make up above 450 millions, not to say anything of the far better account to which an energetic people like the English have turned this tide of wealth. This addition to the wealth of England of 450 millions is only that of the last thirty-seven years.* Now with regard to the long period of British connection before 1829, the total of territorial charges in India from 1787 to 1829 amounts to about 600 millions. Taking only one-tenth of this for remittance for purposes mentioned above, there is about 60 millions in principal, which with interest to the present day, added to the acquisitions previous to 1787, may fairly be put down for 1150 millions.† Thus there are some 1600 millions, if not more, added to the wealth of England from the Indian territorial source; but, to avoid any possibility of over-estimate at all, say 500 millions, an amount not far short of all investments for railways in this country. From commercial returns also it can be shown that during the last fifty years only, England has made no commercial return to India and China for above 300 millions of imports independent of interest, or, in other words, kept this amount as the price of her rule in India.* England thus derives at present the benefit, in the shape of interest alone (not to say anything of commercial and manufacturing profits) of the above 500 millions, some 25 millions a year. In addition to this, the tribute in its hundred shapes continues to flow, and brings to England some 10 millions a-year more, or say 8 millions; England, therefore, is benefiting from its Indian connection to something like 33 millions a year, at an exceedingly low estimate. Besides this extraordinary accession to the wealth of England, India finds at present provision and career, to the exclusion of her own children in both respects, for about 12,000 from the middle and higher ranks of the people of this country, and above 60,000 from the lower ranks, affording much relief to the professions and industries of this country.† Then, there is the political debt of nearly 100 millions as the result of the British rule.

It is easy to speak of the elasticity and irrepressibility of the English revenue, and the honesty of the English taxpayer, and to contrast these favourably with those of India; but it is not borne in mind that out of the revenues raised in India, nearly one-fourth goes clean out of the country, and is added to the resources of England. Were it not for the opium revenue, so fortunate for India, though one cannot be sure of its morality, the condition of India would have been by this time not a very enviable one.

With regard to the expansion of the commerce of India under British rule, the question is whether India has profited by it. The British rulers may claim credit if it can be shown that India has derived some commercial profit from its commerce after paying the price for the British rule.

The foreign invaders of former times had their plunder once for all. They returned to their country laden with spoils, and there was an end of the evil. India by her industry perhaps soon made up the gap in her national wealth. When all other foreign invaders retained possession of the country, and became its rulers, they at least became of the country. If they plundered the rich and screwed the ryot, the wealth was still in the country. If individuals were plundered or oppressed, the country remained as rich as ever. But entirely different has been the case with the foreign rule of the British. In former times the country received blows and bruises here and there, but her vital blood was not lost. The natural action of her constitution sooner or later cured the wounds.

But now, as the country is being continually bled, its vitality and vigour must get low, unless permanent improvements already made, or future development of her material resources, shall restore it to its former health. In point of security of life also, can it be said that there has been less loss of it during the British connection than for the same period previously?

There is again the almost total exclusion of the natives from a share and voice in the administration of their own country. Under former rulers there was every career open for the talented. For the voice of a few small boroughs Parliament has been wrangling for years, while the Indian budget of over 40 millions is voted before scarcely a dozen honourable members, and without a single voice to represent the millions who pay the taxes. Why should not 200 millions of your fellow-subjects who contribute so largely to your wealth and prosperity, and who form an integral part of the British empire, have a few representatives in the Imperial Parliament to give their voice on imperial questions?

Such is the reply of the educated and thinking. They admit all the benefits, but urge that if India is now deriving the benefit of law and order, England has also had the benefit of India having enormously contributed to her wealth, and of having rendered her one of the mighty powers of the earth. As the reply and feelings of the educated and thinking are of the greatest importance to the rulers, I think it necessary here to show that the opinions I have expressed above are not simple creations of my imagination. I shall cite hereafter a few instances out of many of the expression of these views from the native papers.

There is no doubt that the influence and enlightenment of the educated being not only entirely the creation of the English rule, but even of the English type, the educated class is grateful for the boon and thoroughly loyal. True it is that historical acts of patriotism, the staunch and deep-rooted patriotism of Englishmen—how they would fight to the last man before allowing an inch of their soil to be conquered by a foreigner, how as it were by the mere wave of the magic wand, to the call of patriotism, 200,000 volunteers suddenly sprang from the ground for the defence of their country—perplex the educated in India, and their patriotism is put to a severe trial. But notwithstanding this perplexity, the educated or thoughtful patriot of India believes that his best patriotism consists in wishing the continuance of the British rule, as he hopes from the high sense of honour and duty of the Briton the future true welfare and regeneration of his country. For instance, while entertaining the views about the drawbacks arising from the present rulers belonging to another country, ‘The Native Opinion,’ an English paper conducted by educated natives, gladly avows that under English rule educated natives hope their country will doubtless progress, though slowly.* ‘The Rastgoftar,’ a vernacular paper, asks ‘‘What better means than education can be shown for not only the good and the prosperity of the people, but love and loyalty towards the Raj?† Contrasting the European and native rule, the same paper says, ‘‘The rule with which the subjects are distressed and dissatisfied, cannot last long. The chief reason why most of the natives like English rule better is, that the Government always strive and desire to promote the happiness of the people.’’‡ ‘The Bombay Samachar,’ a vernacular paper, in the course of an article recommending strongly this Association to the support of the natives, remarks, ‘‘that it is not at all wise to fight the present sircar and to raise the flag of independence.’’§ ‘The Hindoo Patriot,’ an English paper conducted by natives, says, ‘‘No educated native will prefer any other rule to British rule. England has done to India an amount of good which no other conquering nation has been able to do. So long as this fact is remembered, no feelings of disloyalty can exist in the mind of the Indian.’’‖ Besides the inference from the above extracts, I can venture to assert, from my own knowledge, that the loyalty of the educated is undoubted, and it is the more necessary that their views should be known and attended to by the rulers. I give you now the few extracts promised above, to show that the reply I have sketched before to the question of the benefits to India from the British rule, is not merely my own creation. Referring to ‘‘the state of India, the taxes collected in which are partly spent elsewhere,’’ the ‘Native Opinion’ says:—‘‘Native·art and trade languish day by day, money becomes more and more scarce, and a general feeling is generated of despondency and despair of all future prosperity for the country and the race. . . . . But our would-be economists ‘about town’ would not let the people of India into the dangerous knowledge that their country has to pay a ‘tribute’; nor would they like to lead England out of the unpleasant delusion that India is to her an unmitigated source of weakness and loss. It is true England gives a Government which we could secure at the hands of few other nations (though it may be a form of mere hyperbole to say that India ‘is indebted for all the prosperity and wealth it possesses to its annexation to the British Empire,’ for before that connection was formed, classic Ind was not the poorest country in the world, and it was her riches, and not poverty, which has tempted one and all of her conquerors, and the company of traders especially, hitherward); but that is no reason why the price of the boon should be pitched so high, or why nothing should be done which fairly could be to lighten the drawback.’”* The ‘Rastgoftar,’ in alluding to the home charges, says:— “Though the subject is an old one, yet it is of extreme importance. Up to this day, by England’s dragging away the wealth of this country, Hindustan is crushed down.”† The ‘Suriodaya,’ a vernacular paper, has several articles on the duties and shortcomings of the British rule, in the course of which, in giving its opinion as to the undesirability of any other foreign power displacing the British rule, it says, in illustration :—“ A fox having got entangled among some creepers, a swarm of flies pounced upon him to suck his blood. A crow asked the fox whether he might drive away the flies. ‘No,’ replied the fox, ‘these flies are now satisfied, and if you drive them away another hungry swarm would take their place.’”‡ The paper further expresses a hope that England may now be satisfied with what it has acquired, and not covet more, and let the natives have a fair share in the government. The ‘Bombay Samachar’ thinks “the ryots are not so well off now as they once were.”§ More than twenty years ago, to my knowledge, a small band of Hindu students and thoughtful gentlemen used to meet secretly to discuss the effects of British rule upon India. The home charges, and the transfer of capital from India to England in various shapes, and the exclusion of the children of the country from any share or voice in the administration of their own country, formed the chief burden of complaint. These gentlemen were otherwise very well disposed. They were no would-be agitators. They were, and have been, peaceful and good citizens and subjects, and have since been either efficient Government servants, or have followed successfully some independent profession. They were discussing the matter, I think, more to mourn over the event than for any active purposes. At least, they were brooding over it gloomily. The ‘Hindu Patriot,’ comparing Algeria with India, says:—“He (Napoleon) has proclaimed the eligibility of the Arabs for all military offices of the empire, and all civil offices in Algeria. The policy of the British Government in India has been rather illiberal in this respect.

Until a few years since the civil service of India was a close monopoly; and even now, when apparently all invidious distinctions have been swept away, the monopoly exists in practice. . . . Indeed, the Mahommedan government, which was admittedly a tyrannical government, was in this respect a more liberal one than that under which we now live. Some of the Hindus filled, during the reign of the Mussulman kings, the highest civil and military offices in the empire."* The 'Indu Prakash,' a Marathi and English paper, in complaining about the examination for the civil service being confined to England, says :—" In fact, if an honest experiment is to be made whether the natives are capable of the highest qualifications for government, there is no way but to open the civil service examination in India. . . . This is the only way of trying the experiment. And if England really governs India as a sacred trust, and is really to be an exception to the general historical truth that even the best government of a foreign people is a curse to the subject race, she cannot but adopt it."† Alluding to the establishment of a Parliament in Egypt, the 'Native Opinion' says :—" India under Britain must not be left behind the country of the Pharos under Ibrahim Patcha."‡ If necessary, I think I can give a volume of extracts from various vernacular and English papers conducted by natives, corroborative of my statements that the educated are thoroughly loyal, and that they feel strongly the loss of wealth to the country, the great necessity for developing its resources, and the exclusion of natives from a reasonable participation and voice in the affairs of their own country. I hope the short, imperfect sketch I have given above will give some idea of the present thoughts and feelings of different classes of natives. I have endeavoured to give as faithful an account as I possibly could from my own personal knowledge, as well as my reading on the first question.

Now arises, therefore, the important second question I have given at the outset : What are the best means to secure to India the benefits of the British rule for the longest time possible, with the greatest benefit to India as well as to England, and with satisfaction to the people of India? The question has been treated in various ways. First, it is urged by some that India is conquered by the sword, and must be retained by the sword. This I may call the policy of the sword. Second, some advise to treat the natives kindly, but never to give them any share in the administration: or, the policy of kind despotism. Third, equality among all her Majesty's subjects and honesty with the princes of India: or, the policy of justice and honesty.

The first policy simply amounts to this—that England may keep India as long as it can by a strong grasp, and India may drive out England as quickly as it can. No prophet is required to foretell the ultimate result of a struggle between a discontented two hundred millions, and a hundred thousand foreign bayonets. A drop of water is insignificant, but an avalanche may sometimes carry everything before it. The race is not always to the swift. A disaffected nation may fail a hundred times, and may rise again, but one or two reverses to a foreigner cannot but be fatal. Every failure of the natives, adding more burdens, will make them the more impatient to throw off the foreign yoke. Besides, there are some other European nations who, I suppose, would be but too glad to see the British rule in India in such plight. Suppose that England is able to hold by the sword for ever, But is it the infamy of perpetual tyranny and inglorious avarice that is the highest aspiration of the British nation, or the regeneration of a nation and the progress and happiness of mankind? But I shall not do the British people an injustice by discussing seriously this narrow-minded and short-sighted policy. It is utterly contrary and repugnant to the genius and character of the English nation that it could or would, be a tyrant. It could, or would, no more inflict a despotism over others than it would submit to it itself. It is this circumstance, in fact, which is the principal, if not the only consolation to the natives of India against all the drawbacks of the foreign rule.

The second policy scarcely deserves better treatment than the policy of the sword. It is not possible in human nature that two hundred millions of people—a people who have known power, wealth, and civilization, government, laws, literature, and art, long before they were dreamt of in these islands; whose genius has given the world the most intellectual play yet discovered, and who are still unsurpassed in the application of art to manufactures—would quietly remain contented as merely something better than helots, and would be dead to all high aspirations and noble ambition. The expounders of this, as well as the first policy, forget that it is the thought that under British rule lies the hope of a political and mental regeneration, that so well conciliates and reconciles the thinking portion of the native community, and turns their patriotism towards loyalty to the British rule. I appeal to the common-sense of Englishmen, whether a nation is more likely to be long reconciled and grateful to benefactors or despots, even though kind. Declarations of policies like these, though futile, create unnecessary dissatisfaction and distrust in the minds of the natives. The short-sighted persons who make them little know the amount of mischief they do, and the obstacles they throw in the way of peaceful and rational submission to government, and in promoting the sentiments of loyalty which at present is naturally a delicate plant, requiring the utmost care of the rulers to foster and strengthen it. If such policy were actually pursued, India must continue to sink lower in degradation in a worse degree than under former rules or invasions, and the boast of benefits of British rule would only become a mere hypocrisy and delusion, and the rule itself a curse. Each such utterance creates the necessity of thousands of English bayonets. I must however pause, and not do the British people an injustice by discussing this policy any more than the first. Fortunately both for England and India these and such other policies do not find an echo in the British people. They have been and shall be idle words, with the only result of doing now and then some unnecessary mischief.

The third policy, the policy inaugurated by the great and good statesman Lord Stanley, and proclaimed to the people and princes of India in the name of our gracious Sovereign, is the hope of India and anchor of England. You can scarcely conceive the enthusiasm and heartiness with which this proclamation was welcomed by those who understood it. A new day dawned to them, full of brightness and hope. It is, gentlemen, fortunate and congratulatory that at the present stage of the British rule the policy to be pursued by England towards India is not a vexed question, at least so far as the actual rulers are concerned. The Sovereign and the ministers have finally decided that all-important point, to their great glory and to the satisfaction of the people of India. It is gratifying and hopeful to find that the statesmen who rule and the thinkers who guide the policy of this country have distinctly seen and clearly enunciated that India should be ruled for India's sake; that the true and only tower of strength to the English rule is not a hundred thousand English soldiers, but the willing consent and grateful loyalty of the people themselves; and that when the time comes for a separation, and which I trust is far distant, the world may rejoice in a glorious chapter added to its history, of the regeneration of an old, but long unfortunate race, and India may for ever remember gratefully the benefactors who restored her to more than her ancient splendour and civilization. There is no doubt in my mind that since the "Stanley policy" has been proclaimed, every true patriot of India wishes a long continuance of the present rule. For he knows well that it is by this means only that law and order, political elevation, intellectual development, and material prosperity shall be attained; that the greatest misfortune that can befall India, and plunge it again into anarchy after having already paid such heavy price for the benefit of the British rule, would be the withdrawal of the British sovereignty. She will have suffered all the evils of a foreign rule without deriving any of its benefits, which are yet but in the seed, and require time to grow and fructify. They hopefully look to a bright future.

The only right policy having been thus decided and proclaimed in the name of the sovereign, the third question arises, whether the best means are being adopted to fulfil it, to win the loyalty and attachment of the Indian subjects and princes. I am afraid as much is not done hitherto as is desirable and practicable towards the accomplishment of this great object. The difficulties thrown in the way of according to the natives such reasonable share and voice in the administration of the country as they are able to take, are creating some uneasiness and distrust. The universities are sending out hundreds and will soon begin to send out thousands of educated natives. This body naturally increases in influence. The native papers are mostly in their hands. Their loyalty is as yet undoubted. The native press is beginning to exercise a large influence on the mass of the people. The educated class are becoming their natural leaders. The education, as I said before, is thoroughly English, and therefore highly favourable to the English rule. The isolation of thousands of years is now being broken through. Calcutta, Bombay, Madras, and other places of importance, now freely and fully exchange ideas. A common language among the educated is forging strong bonds of nationality. The railways are producing a similar effect on the mass of the population. They see and know more of each other, and so at least politically their sympathies are growing stronger towards each other. In short, whatever may be the effect in other matters, the nation is now gradually becoming assimilated for political purposes, either for good or for evil, as the rulers may choose. The time is come when the rulers should seriously consider the question. As you now sow, so will you reap hereafter. It is high time that some decisive steps should be taken to turn the strong current of the gratitude and loyalty in the rising generations to the support of the British rule, and to give a greater vitality and force to the opinion now more or less prevailing, that the true patriotism of the native consists in his desire for a long English rule. Once this is achieved, once the leaders of the mass are with you, what shall there be to fear, or what will require the 80,000 or 100,000 bayonets ? The loyal heart is a stronger weapon than any that the hand of the tyrant will ever forge. It is therefore necessary that some reasonable scope should be now given to their just and legitimate aspirations. Such timely concessions given with grace and without asking, will carry with them a force of gratitude, which cannot be attained by yielding to pressure and with a bad grace. All unnecessary obstacles should be removed. Something needs be done, by which those natives who have talents and attainments may be able to enter the various services, with only as much trouble as Englishmen are put to. The problem is clear, and there is no use shirking it. Either the educated natives should have proper fields for their talents and education opened to them in the various departments of the administration of the country, or the rulers must make up their minds, and candidly avow it, to rule the country with a rod of iron. The question has been however, to everybody's satisfaction, and to the great honour of the rulers, answered, by opening the competition for the civil, judicial, and other services to all her Majesty's subjects. The examinations being conducted, however, in this country is a virtual exclusion of the natives. By all means, these youths say, make your standards as high as you think proper, but let us have fair play. Let the disregard of creed or colour be not a mockery and delusion, putting us to unnecessary and improper disadvantages. They ask that the examinations for a portion, however small at first, of the appointments for the services should be held in India. If it be considered that a native would be better for a visit to England before entering the services, they would be, I think, quite willing to submit to that necessity after their nomination. In the case of the civil service, the selected candidates can be required to complete their studies and undergo their " further examination" in this country.

Whether a suitable military career should also be opened to the natives or not is a very important question, but I shall at present content myself with quoting the views of 'The Hindoo Patriot,' which I think deserve consideration. In the same article, “ Algeria and India,” which I have quoted from before, 'The Patriot' says,—" In India the higher ranks of the civil service are to some extent open to the natives, but as regards the military service, the natives can only enlist themselves as privates. The aristocracy of Northern and Western India are born warriors, and they thirst for a military career, but the rules of the military service are such that their wishes cannot be gratified, and consequently they are condemned to a life of inglorious idleness, and discontent if not disaffection prevails in many parts of the empire. The British Government professes to rule us with justice and liberality, but their professions have been only partially made good. It is said that the British Government fear to throw open the higher ranks of the military service to the native aristocracy, lest they should turn their strength against the ruling power. If there be such a fear it is an idle fear. No educated native will prefer any other rule to British rule. England has done to India an amount of good which no other conquering nation has been able to do, and so long as this fact is remembered, no feelings of disloyalty can exist in the mind of the Indian. England has held and she is capable of holding, India at the point of the bayonet, but certainly no one will desire that she should continue in this attitude."

The question of the native army is a matter requiring careful consideration. I shall, however, remark that in my humble opinion, considering the exigencies of the vast interests of the British empire, and of the political relations in Europe and America, and the desire of some of the Powers to possess India, Britain can hardly do without confiding in a native army, and depending to a great extent upon the loyalty and gratitude of the leaders of native opinion. The English have come to India as merchants, and not as conquerors. The native army has been chiefly instrumental in the creation of the British Indian empire, and I feel that, with proper treatment of India, the same native army will maintain the empire they have contributed to create.

For the gradual improvement of the people at large, and to prevent the utter starvation that now and then overtakes millions of human beings, the least that the British people can do is to lend back to India the wealth derived therefrom, in order to develop its resources. The English people are bound by duty as well as interest to do all they can for India. Every penny invested in the development of that vast and naturally rich portion of the British empire will be repaid a hundredfold in a hundred different ways. The greater the prosperity of India, the greater will be the benefits of the commercial and political relations of the two countries. If strenuous and great efforts are not made to develop the resources of the country and thereby ameliorate the material condition of the mass of the population, one of two results will naturally follow—either, under incessant depletion, the patient may die of sheer exhaustion, or may rebel. If there is a nation on earth—and there is one—on which India has a claim for charity in the time of distress, or of assistance, with capital for the development of its material resources by means of railways, roads, works of irrigation, &c., it is England. But the great misfortune of India, is that the British public know very little of their duties towards India, and care less. Efforts are often made to keep them under the delusion that India is a source of weakness. Surely this is a very great joke. Thirty-three or more millions pounds a year, and provisions found for sixty thousand Englishmen as soldiers, and above ten thousand as civilians and officers, is a source of weakness indeed! How many European nations, or what other nation on earth, would not but be too glad to be subjected to such a source of weakness ? During my pretty long residence in this country, I have observed that the English public as a body are very ignorant, and even to some extent misled, on Indian matters; but that whenever any subject is fairly and fully put before them, their decision is certain to be on the side of fair play, justice, and honour. It is painful to observe the utter indifference of the British public towards Indian matters, and the delusion of the natives when they think that an article in an overland paper is an expression of the public opinion of England. Fond are the hopes they cherish, and how grateful and satisfied do they feel, when they read a few words of kindness and of a just policy in these papers. But what is the actual state of affairs? The destinies of two hundred millions is not a subject of sufficient importance to attract and keep to their places a dozen members of Parliament, and the Secretary of State felt it necessary to make an apology last year to the few members who were present for entering into some details. Here is his apology. He said, “I am quite conscious of the reluctance with which the House listens to details so little affecting their own constituents : still, as it has imposed on the Indian Minister the task of making the statement, I think it my duty to make it tolerably complete.” Of course, as the thirty-three millions or more a year are not directly handed over the counter to these constituents, these details do not affect them! One gentleman, high in office, asked me last year whether the educated natives of India took any interest in Indian politics! I hope the day is not distant when the Parliament, press and people of this country will do their duty towards India, when they will fully understand and recognize the benefits derived by the British nation from their Indian connection and the responsibility arising therefrom. I must confess, with feelings of great pleasure and satisfaction, that the commencement is already made. The formation of this very Association, the names on its lists, and the more frequent appearance than heretofore of Indian topics in the leading journals of this country, though unfortunately sometimes misleading, are hopeful signs. If this Association will make the British nation familiar with the single fact, that India has contributed not a little to its prosperity, and that they owe and incur serious responsibility as its present rulers, it will have conferred a lasting benefit on India and earned its deepest gratitude. I repeat here, that the rulers ought to study more sincerely and earnestly the condition of the mass of the population. The rulers, as well as the whole British people must strain every nerve to save them from destruction which always stares them in the face. Vast public works of productive character ought to be undertaken with the assistance of loans from this country and this country, under proper precautions for the safety of their investments, should regard India, both for the interests of Britain as well as those of India, as the best field for investment and enterprise. I need not trouble you with statistics here, but you ought to know, or at least those that care to know do so well enough, how important India is as a commercial connection, and how vastly the present commerce may be enlarged and developed to the benefit of both sides by a proper development of its material resources. We are thankful for the sixty millions you have already lent us, and the twenty millions more you are to lend for the railways already projected. Of this eighty millions, however, you have already derived the benefit of above twenty millions having been spent already in this country. We trust you will continue to give your utmost aid to India, and you will find that you will have both the pleasure of having performed a duty and the profits of a goop investment.

There is another means which ought, I think, not to be neglected, of binding closer the ties of good feeling between the English and the Indians. Whenever there is any call of distress from India, Englishmen should respond to it generously and with sympathy. Each such instance will produce lasting good. I am sorry to see that the course adopted in England with reference to the Orissa famine has reasonably produced an unfavourable effect in India. The ground urged here for not doing anything was and is, that the Indian Government ought to do all that was necessary. Now this simply means that England, the mismanagement of whose officers is the cause of the disaster, should stand with hands folded, and that the relief must be provided from the taxes paid by the natives of India, and that additional burdens should be laid upon them for the purpose. I do not at all mean to absolve the Indian Government from the blame of that defect in her administration by which they have not adopted means to prevent such disasters, by providing the necessary works of irrigation and by taking proper precautions to mitigate the horrors of a famine when expected to occur; but the worst of the matter is that the administrators are Englishmen selected by England, and the failure in the due performance of their duty is visited on the poor Indians, first by allowing famine to overtake them, and then taxing them to relieve it, and to make up deficits of revenue; and all this is done as if for the purpose of making the Indian Government do their duty. Certainly, if by making the Indian Government do their duty it was meant that the bungling English officials in the administration were made to pay from their own pockets for the relief, the reason urged by Englishmen here would mean something. As it is it simply means, we won't help you, you must help yourselves. I am sure the people here have not thus intentionally withheld their help, but they have acted under a misapprehension, which I also had at first thoughts shared; and unfortunately a very unfavourable impression has been produced in India. Of all the benefits that you can confer on the poor mass of India, help in their distress comes most home to them. Such benefits are remembered for ever, and such sentiments of gratitude are worth hundreds of legions to the British rule. I sincerely hope that England will always be ready to hold out a helping hand to India in distress, and thereby create a community of feeling and good-will towards each other to their mutual benefit.

I have before alluded to the necessity of turning the current of the present loyalty of the educated natives to account, and retaining and strengthening it by giving them some share in the administration of their country. Besides such exclusion, what these natives feel most is their exclusion from any representative voice in the government of the country. They are taught how their fellow-subjects in England fare, and they feel and smart under the contrast of their position. This is a subject requiring much discussion and consideration, which I cannot embrace in this paper. I may in short say here that, though I do not think the lower classes of the population even understand and much less care for a representative government, and that there are not as yet the necessary elements and qualifications for the introduction in its integrity of the representative system for the whole country; still I think some reasonable concessions should be made. I know with what feelings of lively satisfaction was welcomed the admission of natives to the legislative councils as the earnest of better things to come, and how Sir Charles Wood's name was spoken of with gratitude. Some arrangements might be made to have a few representatives from India to the Imperial Parliament, and for local legislation at least those members of the legislative councils who are supposed to represent the presidency towns, might be elected by those towns instead of being selected by Government. These towns can now furnish very respectable constituencies. Such steps taken in time will go far to consolidate the British rule, and increase the loyalty of the people.

The subject of education is of great importance. I am glad to see that Government is fully alive to its value as the best means of elevating the nation and of securing to the British rule sincere gratitude and loyalty. The impulse, however, is given; the higher classes of natives are gradually perceiving the value and necessity of education ; and before long I hope to see good results. For the education of the mass of the people, however, there is much room for more strenuous and greater efforts.

The last thing, though I think it is not the least, I have to say about the policy towards the "people" of India is kind treatment of and ordinary courtesy towards them. The natives have had enough of abuse and reviling. It is time that this thoughtless course should cease, especially on the part of those who are men of influence, position, and authority. The natives are as much human beings as others. They feel as others feel. It is not possible that you should call them liars and rascals, and yet expect that they should love you any more than you would in similar circumstances. Some of the horrors of the mutiny had some cause in the kind of conduct for which a lady, the author of the "Gup," in the Temple Bar Magazine, "felt the keenest sympathy." The 'Bombay Samachar' characterizes this "Gup" as real gup (falsehood). The natives, gentlemen, have their shortcomings, no doubt, but they deserve your pity and assistance, and not your abuse and your kicks. The servants and other people about Englishmen in India form their own opinions, and are influenced by such opinions in times of emergency. The meanest worm when trodden upon dashes its head against your foot. Of all dangers, those that arise from the outraging the feelings of a nation are the most to be dreaded, and the most disastrous in their results. Nowadays a large number of Englishmen from the lower classes, as mechanics, &c., go to India, and sometimes present not a favourable picture of English morals and manners, and furnish the natives with materials for retaliation of any abuse directed against them. This circumstance also renders it highly necessary for Government not to fail in maintaining its high character for honesty and sincerity, and preserve that spell of higher morality and superior intelligence which has hitherto so deservedly commanded the admiration and confidence of the natives.

The princes of India, I think, are not quite in a satisfied state of of mind. The various annexations, and till very lately the special pleadings about and the uncertain fate of Mysore, have produced a feeling of distrust in the honesty of the British, and it will require some efforts to restore confidence. The late decision of Lord Cranbourne not to annex Mysore, and his lordship's views expressed in the last year's budget speech on English policy in India, will go far to restore this confidence, and his lordship's name will be remembered by the natives with respect and admiration, notwithstanding his decision about Mysore being based on policy instead of justice, and notwithstanding his few unfortunate remarks in the budget speech unnecessarily irritating and painful to the natives, which Lord W. Hay appropriately replied to. It is of no use now my discussing the justice or otherwise of former annexations,—that we can leave to the verdict of history,—but it is very necessary to satisfy the present princes that, whatever doubt they may reasonably or unreasonably have of the past conduct of Britain, hereafter the policy of honesty towards them will be strictly carried out. Towards these princes there is another duty to perform. The British Government should take all possible care, by good advice, influence, and rewards, to encourage them to introduce improved systems of government into their territories, and more particularly to bring up their successors in a way to fit them for their onerous and responsible duties.

These are the various duties before the British nation. The task is as good as it is great. Let them, true to their nature and genius, apply themselves courageously and honestly to it, and conjointly, with no little benefit to themselves, let them add to their name the glory of the benefactors of a great nation and of mankind.

The business of this Association will be to assist in the accomplishment of this great work. Those Englishmen who have retired from India owe as much filial duty to India as to England, to the mother who has provided for them as to the mother who gave them birth, and right well I hope will they perform that duty by assisting in the labours of this Association.

Before concluding, I wish to address a few words to my countrymen. Great as are the duties of England and the work before this Association, greater still are the duties and work to be performed on their part. They must show the same earnestness, perseverance, patriotism, and self-sacrifice, the same respect for law and order as the English do, if they deserve and desire to attain the same political condition as Englishmen, and a reasonable share and voice in the government of their country. They must show the same enterprise and forethought in the development of the resources of their country as Englishmen do, if they desire and deserve to be as prosperous as Englishmen. They should also readily support English gentlemen of rank and influence who have now come forward to advocate their cause through this Association, and in the exercise of their constitutional right, in a constitutional way, persevere in their representations to the Imperial Parliament till their reasonable demands are accorded. I have no reason to doubt that my countrymen will show themselves possessed of these qualifications. The existence and conduct of the British Indian Association, the warm interest which educated and thinking natives are now evincing in the welfare of their country, and the growing native enterprise, are sufficient to inspire hope and confidence. If they should, however, contrary to all expectations, show themselves to be blind to their own interests, they should at least not do hereafter the injustice to complain that Englishmen in this country do not at all care for them. No one will be to blame or sorry if they do not get what they do not struggle for and show themselves to deserve.

Lastly, if aught in this paper appear to be as appealing to the fears of the British rulers, I at once disclaim any such intention on my part. I have simply tried to give as faithful a representation as I could of the views and sentiments of the natives as far as I know, and am desirous that the important question of the practicability of the long continuance of the British rule with satisfaction to the natives of India may be fully and dispassionately discussed in all its bearings. If I am shown to be wrong in any statements, nobody will be more happy than myself to correct it.

APPENDIX A

TBL-001 · FOLIO 73Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Year.Charges in India.Charges in England.*
££
1829-3013,536,0001,715,000
1830-3112,947,0001,446,000
1831-3212,935,0001,476,000
1832-3312,896,0001,227,000
1833-3412,245,0001,293,000
1834-3512,706,0002,162,000
1835-3613,000,0002,109,000
1836-3711,806,0002,210,000
1837-3811,987,0002,304,000
1838-3913,030,0002,615,000
1839-4014,103,0002,578,000
1840-4114,261,0002,625,000
1841-4214,719,0002,834,000
1842-4315,307,0002,458,000
1843-4415,688,0002,944,000
1844-4515,551,0002,485,000
1845-4616,263,0003,044,000
1846-4716,557,0003,065,000
1847-4816,472,0003,016,000
1848-4916,687,0003,012,000
1849-5017,170,0002,750,000
1850-5117,117,0002,717,000
1851-52†17,366,0002,506,000
1852-5323,816,0002,697,000
1853-5425,292,0003,262.000
1854-5526,007.0003,011,000
1855-5626,599,0003,264,000
1856-5726,316,0003,529,000
1857-5835,078,0004,492,000
1858-5943,590,0006,051,000
1859-6044,622,0005,042,000
1860-6140,408,0005,394,000
1861-6237,245,0005,209,000
1862-6336,800,0004,943,000
1863-6438,087,0004,777,000
1864-6539,452,0004,802,000
1865-6640,615,0004,982,000
Total...£818,276,000£116,047,000
Add ... ... ...102,284,000‡
218,331,000In Principal.
Add Interest at 5 per cent., about ...270,000,000
Total... ...£488,331,000{ Rough estimate of the wealth derived by England during the last thirty-six years.

APPENDIX B.

TBL-002 · FOLIO 74Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Years.Charges of India.*
1787-88 1788-89 1789-90 1790-91 1791-92 1792-93 1793-94 1794-95 1795-96 1796-97 1797-98 1798-99 1799-1800 1800-1 1801-2 1802-3 1803-4 1804-5 1805 6 1806-7 1807-8 1808-9 1809-10 1810-11 1811-12 1812-13 1813-14 1814-15 1815-16 1816-17 1817-18 1818-19 1819-20 1820-21 1821-22 1822-23 1823-24 1824-25 1825-26 1826-27 1827-28 1828-29£ 5,275,000 5,599,000 5,898,000 5,678,000 5,845,000 6,317,000 6,639,000 6,503,000 7,012,000 7,641,000 8,254,000 9,786,000 10,111,000 11,653,000 12,547,000 12,594,000 15,052,000 15,000,000 15,000,000 15,000,000 15,000,000 15,000,000 15,000,000 15,000,000 15,000,000 15,333,000 15,340,000 15,887,000 16,858,000 17,025,000 17,763,000 19,404.000 19,183,000 19,590,000 19,648,000 20,055,000 21,046,000 22,086,000 24,057,000 23,323,000 23.932,000 21,594,000This Table, as well as those in Appendix A, includes interest on public debt. Should it be considered that such interest must be treated as for money actually paid by English capitalists, an allowance made from the total result of this Table to the extent of £200,000,000 will be more than sufficient. Taking the booty and various other unascertainable sources, the total result may fully amount to above £1,500,000,000. Appendix C confirms this result from commercial returns. Nearly.
Total ...£596,528,000
59,652,000One-tenth, for purposes mentioned at * in Appendix A.
Add, say ...800,000,000Interest till 1866.
Add, say ...300,000,000For acquirements by England before 1788, say £10,000,000 in principal, which, with interest to 1866, will be above £300,000,000.
Add ... ...488,331,000Total of Appendix A.
1647,983,000Rough estimate of the amount of benefit derived by England from India as the result of English rule.

APPENDIX C.

The following Tables, from 1814 to 1858, are taken from the Parliamentary Returns of 1859, No. 38, Sess. 2. From 1859-65 from No. 15409 of 1866 :—

TBL-003 · FOLIO 75Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Years.Importations into United Kingdom from India, Singapore, and China.Exports from United Kingdom to India, Singapore, and China.Exports from United Kingdom of Bullion to India and China.
Official Value.Declared* and Official Value.The exports to and imports from India (including Ceylon), Singapore, and China, are taken together in these Tables, because the remittances to this country are not only made from India direct, but through other places also. The actual commercial balance between China and the United Kingdom should be considered as squared except so far as the amounts disbursed for Government purposes in China, which are not charged to India; but these amounts will be too small to affect the general conclusion that the balance, as shown in this Appendix, represents the amount retained by England as her territorial benefit from India.
££
18146,298,3862,251,282Bullion exports before 1843 seem to be small amounts, and cannot be found in any returns I have seen.
18158 038,7363,166,961
18168,310,6973,203,518
18177,687,2783,679,973
18187,337,6893,852,308
18197,537,5632,780,516
18207,562,6473,632,062
18216,233,5714,596,652
18225,108,0413,889,294
18236,918,5403,822,161
18247,312,3553,738,987
18256,282,6593,549,207
18267,410,5364,400,786
18277,751,3554,896,311
18288,247,1714,809,261
18297,744,2864,213,981
18307,555,6334,344,704
18317,814,1143,798,240
18328,154,3383,882,771
18337,812,6043,867,211
18348,590,2933,838,114
18359,559,6624,841,233
183612,449,1656,297,695
183711,617,9944,748,943Note for next page.
183810,454,8125,495,152(a) Balance of imports over exports, or the amount in principal retained by England during the last fifty years on account of the British rule in India, and for which Britain has made no commercial return to India. If, however, all the further deductions suggested in note† (next page) could be made, this balance may fairly go much above £250,000,000. There is, moreover, another error which, if it could be properly corrected, would increase the balance still a great deal more. It will be seen in the Table that there are some figures given as “official values.” Now, from the instance given
183910,919,7956,209,571
184010,472,5227,656,313
Real Value.
184113,447,8327,347,032
184213,543,6256,710,890£
184313,707,0268,910,354319,252
184416,348,28411,005,86888,841
184516,938,4039,831,38847,346
184616,271,7029,095,70716,495
184718,314,5797,824,3837,844
184817,011,1947,393,7318,185
184918,594,9739,460,17116,006
185020,007,92810,423,621240,125
185122,941,16610,703,1211,606,265
185221,360,62610,445,2703,227,734
185325,088,09610,524,1035,107,949
Carried forward
Real Value.Real and Declared ValueReal Value.below, table (a)*, it will be seen that in these "official values," somehow or other, the imports are greatly undervalued, and the exports overvalued. So it is evident that could those "official values" be converted into real values, the balance of imports over exports during the last fifty years will be far above £300,000,000, perhaps £400,000,000, say £350,000,000. These £350,000,000, with interest, will be above £1,000,000,000, while all before 1814, with interest, still remains to be added. My adoption of £500,000,000 may not be one-third of the actual benefit already derived by England.
£££
185422,098,65311,601,7483,272,920
185523,505,31112,624,6675,650,557
185628,795,17214,613,92910,984,141
185732,542,94016,167,91618,296,600
185824,450,27421,910,2445,088,850
185927,021,80527,523,61016,003,267
186027,759,15025,566,4078,124,236
186135,203,64123,558,6087,279,839
186251,150,76720,284,14110,710,209
186368,150,99727,572,8038,817,656
186473,213,18727,857,7997,555,442
186554,719,07127,000,0003,808,260
923,368,844491,420,718116,338,019
7,842,381{ Deduct Bullion exported by Government in the years 1857-62.
108,495,638
7,594,624{ Add 7 per cent. for charges and profits.
£116,090,262
19,075,312{ Deduct stores exported for Government purposes as far as they can be made up from returns of "Charges in England" from 1829 to 1865.
472,345,406
17,622,172{ Deduct railway stores exported, which are paid from the loan. Return No. 7066 of 1865.
454,723,234+ Balance of commercial exports.
113,680,808{ Add 25 per cent. for charges for transit to the place of destination and profits to the exporter.‡
116,090,262Add bullion exported as per above Table.
Deduct684,494,304{ Total commercial exports, including transit, charges, and profits to India and China.
£238,874,540(a)(See preceding page).
TBL-004 · FOLIO 76Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
* Table (a) from Appendix (A) of Second Customs Report of 1857 :—
Official Value.Real Value.
Years.Imports into the United Kingdom.Exports from the United Kingdom.Imports into the United Kingdom.Exports from the United Kingdom.
££££
1854124,136,018243,879,892152,389,053115,821,092
1855117,284,881258,414,653143,542,850116,691,300
1856131,937,763291,929,377172,544,154139,220,353
1857136,215,849286,194,531187,646,335145,419,872

APPENDIX D.

The present yearly benefit to England from the annual Indian revenues may be roughly estimated in the following manner :—

TBL-005 · FOLIO 77Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Parliamentary Return.*European Employés.European Employés.Salaries paid in India, about
Description.No.
No. 116 of 1860 ...{ Covenanted Civil Servants. † }1,775£ 2,250,000{ Exclusive of furloughs in England.
No. 201—VI. of 1858{ Uncovenanted Civil Servants, including Indo-Britons, are 3082, of whom say Europeans are . . . }500250,000{ Taking an average of £500 a-year.
No. 201—IX. of 1858Indian Navy .30570,000
No. 251—I. part II, Grant, No. 3 of 1866.{ Officers . . . Army . . . }8,231 67,1215,000,000 1,150,000{ Exclusive of furloughs
Total . . ....£8,720,000
Half of the salaries may represent transfer to England for support of families, relations, &c., for education of children, for savings, and for purchase in India and England of British goods for consumption in India ... ...£4,360,000
Add Home charges, about ... ... ...5,000,000
Total ... ... ...£9,360,000

If to this total be added purchases in India of Government stores of British manufactures, the amount of annual transfer to England may be fairly taken above £10,000,000; but, to make allowances that may be necessary, such as for interest paid in England for public debt, and to avoid any over-estimate, I have put down only £8,000,000 in the paper.

Notes

  1. *. Appendix A.
  2. †. Appendix B.
  3. *. Appendix C.
  4. †. Appendix D.
  5. *. 2-12-66
  6. †. 7-1-67
  7. ‡. 27-1-67
  8. §. 15-1-67
  9. ‖. 18-12-65
  10. *. 30-12-66
  11. †. 23-12-66
  12. ‡. 9-9-66
  13. §. ‘Native Opinion,’ 27-1-67.
  14. *. 2-65
  15. †. 27-3-67
  16. ‡. 3-2-67
  17. *. From Parliamentary returns of Indian accounts.
  18. †. The charges in India from 1829 to 1851-52 are exclusive of charges for collecting stamp duties, land, sayer and abakaree revenues and customs, and costs and charges of salt, opium, &c.
  19. ‡. One-eighth of charges in India as representing—1st. Remittances to England by European employes for support of families, relatives, &c.; for education of children; for savings; and for purchase of goods for their own consumption. 2nd. Purchases by them, in India, of articles of British manufacture and produce for their consumption in India. 3rd. Purchases in England and India of articles of British manufacture and produce for Government stores not included in Home charges.
  20. *. From Parliamentary returns of Indian accounts.
  21. *. Exports of British goods are “declared values,” and exports of foreign and colonial goods are “official values.” [p. 49] + From this the following unascertainable items also require to be deducted to ascertain the exact commercial exports as between two independent countries :— 1st. Goods of British exports purchased from merchants in India, Singapore, and China, for Government consumption. 2nd. Goods of British exports consumed by European employés of Government in these countries. 3rd. Exports of stores by Home Government to China and Singapore. 4th. Railway stores of British manufactures purchased in India.
  22. ‡. The imports into the United Kingdom include transit charges and profits. In making a fair comparison with exports it is necessary, in order to square the commercial accounts of two countries, that addition should be made to exports also for transit, charges and profits; 25 per cent., I think, will be a very fair average allowance for the purpose.
  23. *. I cannot obtain any later returns.
  24. †. This includes Governors, Judges, Bishops, and Chaplains.