(The following paper, which had been previously circulated among the Members, was taken as read, in a Meeting at the Society of Arts, London, Wednesday, July 27th, 1870. Sir Charles Trevelyan, K.C.B., in the Chair.)
Gentlemen,—After the able paper of Mr. Prichard, and the calm, earnest, and thoughtful address with which we have been so kindly favoured by Sir Bartle Frere, I intended to plead some justification for troubling you to meet a fourth time upon the subject of finance. I think, however, that now I need not offer any apology, as the occasion of this meeting will give us the opportunity of knowing the views of our Chairman, of whose long experience and ability you are already well aware. In order that he may have sufficient time for his address, I circulate this paper beforehand, so that all the time saved in its reading will be turned to much better account by him. I propose the following question : Is India at present in a condition to produce enough to supply all its wants ?
I shall first see what its wants are.
1st. Sufficient food, clothing, and shelter for the whole population, to keep it in a healthy condition.
2nd. Sufficient to provide for all its social wants, arising from various social duties and positions.
3rd. A sufficient saving by each individual, and of the wealth of the nation generally every year, to meet any unforeseen contingency of natural calamity.
4th. Means for improvements or new public works.
5th. Means to pay for the high price of foreign rule, which causes a great and continuous drain in consequence of the amount withdrawn from India to the extent of 10,000,000l. annually.*
The first four wants are common to all nations ; but the fifth want is peculiar to India. It is one of the principal elements of disturbance which causes our financial troubles. The whole question of the existence of a foreign rule depends upon this peculiar circumstance. No foreign rule can maintain itself unless it manages to enable the country to produce not only sufficient for the ordinary wants of a civilized nation, but also for the price of the foreign rule itself. If the foreign rule fails to produce this result, its existence is naturally felt as a crushing burden to the nation, and either starvation, decimation, and poverty, or rebellion against the foreign rule, is the inevitable consequence. If therefore our British rulers desire to perpetuate their rule, and I sincerely trust they may be able to do so for a long time to come, with benefit both to England and India, they must look this question in the face. Let them distinctly ask themselves whether India is at this moment producing enough for all its ordinary wants and the 10,000,000l. or so more that must be remitted to England every year for the price of the English rule. It is no use blaming the Finance Minister or the Viceroy if they are required to supply all these wants while India is not producing enough for the purpose, for they cannot produce something out of nothing.
One would think that India, on account of this one circumstance of having to remit some 10,000,000l. clean out of the country, was heavy weighted enough in its race for prosperity. But in addition to this, it has 100,000,000l. of national debt. If the whole interest of this debt were being retained in India, it would not be a matter of so much consequence economically, but out of the total registered debt of India some 15,000,000l. are held in this country, besides the loans raised here of about 30,000,000l. This makes an annual interest of about 2,000,000l. to be remitted to this country. Again, of the registered debt of India, which is about 60,000,000l., nearly 30,000,000l. are held by Europeans, so that a portion of the interest on that amount is also transferred to this country. There are besides 600,000l. for interest on East India Company's stock. Thus, then, there is another item of about 3,000,000l., besides the 10,000,000l. sterling for the price of the English rule, which India has to produce every year over and above its ordinary wants. Moreover, I shall take the total item at 12,000,000l. to be on the safe side, or even 10,000,000l. Again, during the past twenty years while the railways have been building, the present generation has been put to the strain of providing some 30,000,000l. in the shape of guaranteed interest for railways. Of this about 14,000,000l. have been recovered from railway income. But what we have to bear in mind is that the burden of providing these 30,000,000l. was first thrown upon the present generation when it could least afford to do so, for the benefit of the future.
But there is not an end to all yet. The present generation has been compelled to spend within the last twelve years in what are called “original ordinary public works,” somewhere above 30,000,000l., independent of repairs amounting to about 9,000,000l., and all this heavy outlay at the sacrifice of the present generation for the benefit of the future, or as if all these public works were only to last for the year when they are built!
Such is the strain to which the present generation has been put, and now I ask, Can any one prove that our English rulers have, while putting on such heavy burdens, enabled India to produce enough to meet these wants? or has India been to some extent starved to meet these requirements? If so, is it an act of justice to the present generation to crush them so heavily for the benefit of the future, instead of arranging matters in such a way that the present and the future should be made to contribute in the proportion of their capabilities and their benefits?
The next question is, What does India produce? I do not presume to be able to answer this question completely. My chief object in this paper is to set the friends of India here to discuss this vital question. If anybody can satisfactorily show that India is producing sufficient for its wants, none shall be more glad than myself. I shall be glad because I have as much desire to see the British connection with all its moral benefits continue for a very long time, as that India should not be starving and in distress. Now let us see what the economical condition of India is.
I am obliged under the pressure of the current work of our Association to prepare my paper at much disadvantage, and am therefore not able to place all such figures before you as I might otherwise have done. I am compelled to content myself at present with those ready at hand.
In the United Kingdom the imports of the ten years 1858 to 1867 are (including bullion, &c.) 2,640,000,000l., and exports 2,110,000,000l. These imports include all remittances, such as interest on or repayment of loans to foreign countries and India, and say, a good deal above 100,000,000l. of political remittances from India. On the other hand, we have to deduct from exports about 80,000,000l. of railway loans and other public loans during the period raised for India, as also any loans remitted to foreign countries. I omit taking minor items into account. Upon the whole, I think it will be admitted that the non-commercial exports must be greater than the non-commercial imports. In other words, the actual excess of the commercial imports over commercial exports must be a good deal more than the difference of the figures I have given above, i.e. 2,640,000,000l. minus 2,110,000,000l., equal to about 530,000,000l., giving something like 25 per cent. profit on the amount of exports. In order to be quite within limit, I suppose no one will object if we put down the commercial profits of any nation to be 15 per cent. or even 10 per cent. Such is the economical condition of the United Kingdom. I may just remark here, whether it is not unjust or mistaken to make any comparison between the position of the finance ministers of England and India. The former has a highly prosperous country, in which nearly the whole revenue of 70,000,000l. returns back to the taxpayers themselves, and which is further aided by the political remittance of some 10,000,000l. a-year from India, while the latter has a poor country, of which the whole revenue of 50,000,000l. does not return to the taxpayers, but some 10,000,000l. of it go clean out of the country.
Let us further see how the Colonies are faring—for instance, Australia and Canada. The imports of Australia, including bullion, &c., during the same ten years (1858-67) are 309,000,000l., and exports (including bullion, &c.) 268,000,000l., leaving excess of imports over exports of about 41,000,000l. The imports of Canada (including bullion, &c.) are 148,000,000l., and exports 120,000,000l., leaving excess of imports 28,000,000l.
This shows how the Colonies are prospering; while under the same British rule, as I shall show hereafter, India is “ very poor.”
Let us take the United States before examining Indian figures. The total imports for the years 1868 and 1869 are 381,000,000 dollars and 463,000,000 dollars, while the corresponding exports are only 341,000,000 dollars and 365,000,000 dollars.
Now with regard to India, I again take the ten years 1858-67. Before I give the figures for these years, it must be borne in mind that, as I have shown in my paper “ On England’s Duties to India,” England has down to the year 1858 derived from India during the connection of the two countries as the price of English rule, at the lowest computation, without adding anything for interest or booties or bribes of former times, more than 200,000,000l. This amount on the one hand has fructified in the hands of the energetic and enterprising people of this country,—I cannot venture to say how many fold,—and on the other hand diminished so far the productive power of India. This drain has to be made up by some wise, statesmanlike policy of our rulers. Leaving this, however, for the present alone, and taking India as it is, we find that even with the help of opium and the productive benefits of the railways, as well as irrigation and other works, increased land under cultivation, &c. &c., in short, with everything you may name as having contributed to increase production, the total exports (including treasure) for the years 1858-67 are 456,000,000l., and the imports (including treasure) are only 419,000,000l.! But even this amount of imports (short as it is of exports by some 37,000,000l., or about 4,000,000l. a-year) includes about 72,000,000l. of railway loan and other public-debt loans raised during these ten years, and the whole profits of the cotton trade during the American war. Were it not for this railway loan, &c. &c., which to some extent modified the effect of the political remittances, in what a sad condition would India have been now!
India’s exports say, are about 50,000,000l. a-year at present. Now can this sum earn enough of profit to pay 10,000,000l. a-year of the political remittance, and leave something to be added to its capital? As it is, the opium revenue which is paid by China makes up some 7,000,000l. for the political drain, and the rest must be withdrawn from the production of every year, reducing the productive capital so much.
In addition to this, India has to suffer another economical disadvantage, which in Mr. J. S. Mill’s words is this:—
“ A country which makes regular payments to foreign countries, besides losing what it pays, loses also something more by the less advantageous terms on which it is forced to exchange its productions for foreign commodities.”*
It cannot be therefore wonderful, under such circumstances, that Lord Lawrence should have recorded his deliberate opinion in his minute of the 26th March, 1864, that “India is, on the whole, a very poor country. The mass of the people enjoy only a scanty subsistence. They are impatient of taxation, except where it is of that peculiar nature to which they have long been accustomed. The tendency of new modes of taxation is to irritate and even to oppress. We ought to avoid, so far as may be practicable, such fruitful causes of discontent.” In the year 1864 when Bombay went mad with the cotton prosperity and revelled in fictitious share-wealth—when the imports of India were the highest, say 50,000,000l. (though even then less than exports by 16,000,000l.), the highest official in India, the Viceroy himself, declares that “India is, on the whole, a very poor country, and the mass of the people enjoy only a scanty subsistence,” and Mr. Grant Duff, the highest Indian official sitting in the House of Commons, so late as 10th May last (after all the progress made by the help of such railways and other public works as have been already constructed), asks the House, in reply to Mr. Lawson's motion about opium, whether it would be tolerable to “grind an already poor population to the very dust?” Can it be then a matter of any surprise that the very first touch of famines should so easily carry away hundreds of thousands as they have done during the past twelve years? I appeal to the British nation whether such poverty should be the result of their rule in India, or whether this is to be their mission in that country? I say it as much in the interest of Great Britain as in that of India, that if the British people and Parliament do not pay their most serious attention to India, and repair the impoverishing effect of a foreign rule by the importation of large foreign capital, I am afraid they will have an Indian difficulty in time, far more serious and disastrous to the natives than any they had ever to deal with. But, moreover, we must also remember that the opium revenue may at any time slip through our fingers, and unless great efforts are made to increase the quantity and improve the quality of cotton, I am afraid that trade will also fail us when most needed, for America is making great exertions to regain its lost ground. It has already produced 3,000,000 bales, is likely to give 3½ next year, and hopes to produce 5,000,000 before five years are over. How great is the necessity that our British rulers should take every care!
Let us see whether we can apply another test regarding the poverty of India.
The whole produce of India is from its land. The gross land-tax is put down for 1870-71 a little above 21,000,000l. Now I suppose I shall be within the mark if I say that Government takes for this land-tax on an average one-eighth of the gross produce, if not more. This gives for the gross production of the country, say about 168,000,000l.; add to this, gross opium revenue about 7,000,000l.; gross salt revenue, 6,000,000l.; gross forest, 600,000l. The total thus of the raw produce of the country amounts to under 182,000,000l. To be on the safe side, let us say 200,000,000l. to include the produce of half a million tons of coal, of alienation lands, or anything else there may be. Now the population of the whole of British India is nearly 150,000,000, giving therefore less than 27s. a head for the annual support of the whole people. But unequally distributed as this produce must be, viz. 10,000,000l. remitted to this country, the rich and middle classes keeping a larger proportion for their share, and provision for a large administrative and military expenditure, what a “scanty subsistence” indeed must remain for the “very poor” mass! I am sorry I have not time at present to work out this test of the total production of India fully; I take it at present very roughly.
Some may say that I had not taken excise revenue into account. It or other manufacturing industry does not affect the estimate of raw produce. The manufacture of spirits and drugs from which this excise is derived is for 1870-71 about 2,250,000l., and if I make this to represent 10,000,000l. of value added to the production of the country, I shall be above the mark. As to other manufacturing industries of the country, we know that the exports of manufactured goods do not make up 2,000,000l., and the inland manufacturing industry is limited and confined to a low stage. If therefore I raise the total production from 200,000,000l. to 300,000,000l., I shall be, I think, making a high estimate. This makes 40s. a head for the gross production of India. Add 75,000,000l. more if you like, and make the gross production 50s. a head; and what is that after all! The people of the United Kingdom pay above 48s. a head for revenue only. While the imports of the United Kingdom are above 9l. a head, those of India are not 9s. a head.
If I am wrong and if somebody will show that India does produce equal to her peculiar wants, none shall be more glad than myself. If Lord Lawrence and Mr. Grant Duff are right, then the question must be carefully considered how the remedy is to be provided. If India does not produce what it needs, the evident reply is, Make India produce more. If Mr. Grant Duff's desire, expressed in the same speech I have alluded to, of making “the already poor” India “one of the most prosperous portions of the earth's surface,” the only remedy is—increased production. England is bound to do this for the consolidation of its power in India, as well as to fulfil its beneficent mission of making India what Mr. Duff desires. I think Sir Bartle Frere's proposition is the most suitable remedy; that large public works are absolutely necessary, that the necessary capital must be supplied by this country, and that in order that this capital be used without waste and judiciously, Parliament must enquire from time to time how it is employed. Moreover, as long as the Supreme Legislature of India is not composed of a sufficient number of independent and representative members to examine every item of the Budget every year, as is done here by the House of Commons, the control of Parliament and investigation, not only for the application of such funds, but for the whole general administration of India from time to time, is absolutely necessary. I do not mean the slightest reflection upon the officials of Government, but it is only human nature that when one has the fear of being called to account, he will take greater care in his work.
Mr. Mill says, in his ‘Political Economy,’* “In countries where the principle of accumulation is as weak as in the various nations of Asia, where people will neither save, nor work to obtain the means of saving, unless under the inducement of enormously high profits, nor even then, if it is necessary to wait a considerable time for them, where either productions remain scanty, or drudgery great, because there is neither capital forthcoming nor forethought sufficient for the adoption of the contrivances by which natural agents are made to do the work of human labour; the desideratum for such a country, economically considered, is an increase of industry, and of the effective desire of accumulation. The means are, first, a better government, more complete security of property, moderate taxes, and freedom from arbitrary exaction under the name of taxes; a more permanent and more advantageous tenure of land, securing to the cultivator as far as possible the undivided benefits of the industry, skill, and economy he may exert. Secondly, improvement of the public intelligence, the decay of usages or superstition which interfere with the effective employment of industry, and the growth of mental activity, making the people alive to new objects of desire. Thirdly, the introduction of foreign arts, which raise the returns derivable from additional capital to a rate corresponding to the low strength of the desire of accumulation and the importation of foreign capital, which renders the increase of production no longer exclusively dependent upon the thrift or providence of the inhabitants themselves, while it places before them a stimulating example, and by instilling new ideas and breaking the chains of habit, if not by improving the actual condition of the population, tends to create in them new wants, increased ambition, and greater thought for the future. These considerations apply more or less to all the Asiatic populations, and to the less civilized and industrious parts of Europe, as Russia, Hungary, Spain, and Ireland."
Now India has not only all these requirements, but also those of a foreign rule, which renders her case still more urgent for suitable remedies.
Again, Mr. Mill has shown that production depends upon natural agents, labour and capital.
Now let us see how matters stand in India.
Natural agents we have in any quantity in the waste land, in the capability of much greater production in the lands already under cultivation, with any quantity of water if properly utilized, not to say anything of its vast mineral and other undeveloped resources. The utilization of the waste land is a great necessity, but how can it be utilized or improved, cultivation introduced, and all the facilities of communication supplied without labour and capital, and without Government paying the best attention to the matter? Labour we have enough if famines are not allowed to carry away hundreds of thousands, and emigration checked by the supply of work at home. More than a quarter of a million of ablebodied men have emigrated during the years 1858-67. The natives of India are not very fond of emigration if they can find work at home. At all events this is a fact, that during the three years 1862, '63, and '64 of the cotton prosperity of the Bombay Presidency, not one man emigrated from that part, but a commencement has again set in. But land and labour are both useless unless we have sufficient capital: Mr. Mill distinctly proves that industry is limited by capital, that law and government cannot create industry without creating capital. Capital, then, is the great and imperative want of India, as much for the existence of the foreign rule as of the people themselves. Next we may consider the requisites described in the long quotation given above :—1st. "Better government, more complete security of property" (these we have). As to "moderate taxes,"—when the mass of people enjoy only "scanty subsistence," what taxes can be moderate? On the subject of "proper tenure of land," &c. &c., I shall not speak at present, as the great doctors of land tenure disagree, and it is too important and wide a subject to be treated off-hand. 2nd. "Improvement of public intelligence," &c. &c. This is increasing, but if Government showed confidence in the great importance of this element, they would and ought to do far more than what they have done. 3rd. “The importation of foreign arts,” &c. &c., “the importation of foreign capital,” &c. This last is the most vital point. If sufficient foreign capital is brought into the country, and carefully and judiciously laid out as suggested by Sir Bartle Frere, all the present difficulties and discontent will vanish in time. But that by any tinkering or legerdemain we can create something out of nothing is simply impossible. The Calcutta correspondent of the ‘Pall Mall Gazette,’ of 18th inst., quotes Mr. Hunter (the author of ‘Rural Bengal’ and the editor of the ‘Imperial Gazetteer,’ now being compiled) as saying in his yet unpublished statement about the necessity of the Gazetteer, “No country ever stood in greater need of imported capital than India in its transition stage.” The railways and other public works, though few, are the hope of future good, and far more is necessary in the same direction.
Hitherto I have spoken on the supposition as if the whole present administrative and military expenditure were reasonable and necessary.
But our Chairman had said in his Budget speech of April, 1863, “I agree with those who are of opinion that with proper economy 12,000,000l. may be taken as the standard of the expense to be incurred in India for the military force of all arms, even supposing it to be maintained at its present establishment. . . . The great interests of our nation in India require that the estimate of the Indian army should at least undergo the sifting to which the War Office estimate is subjected before it is laid before Parliament.”
And now in December, 1869, as Mr. Nowrozjee Furdoonjee has pointed out to us, His Grace the Duke of Argyll says, “The necessity of effecting every practicable reduction of expenditure was fully apparent to me when my financial despatch of 2nd January last No. 62, was written. In that despatch I called your attention to the military charges, and stated the grounds on which I consider that those charges should be reduced to at least the scale of 1863-64, and that it might be possible to bring the whole military charges in India, including stores, a million and a half below the present amount.” Mr. Grant Duff also says, “Its (army's) weakest part was its enormous cost” (Speech, 3rd August, 1869).
The Hon. Mr. Strachey, in his speech on the 28th April last, in the Supreme Legislative Council, traces the causes of the present financial difficulty to the circumstance, “that although the growth of the revenues has been very great, the growth of expenditure has been still more rapid. . . . I think it clear that the increase has gone on at a far greater rate than was either right or necessary ;” and he gives in proof the reductions made within six or seven months of the discovery of the financial difficulties. He further says, "Our financial system requires radical and fundamental changes."
His Excellency the Viceroy, in his speech of the same day, says, "If I am asked whether I think the main principles of future budgets should be the same as the present, I would frankly confess that I do not think so, and agree with Mr. Strachey that there is great room for improvement."
About the waste of every sort in the public works department we have heard enough, especially in Sir B. Frere's address.
There is another point of view from which the question of State expenditure may be seen. In the year 1856 the total expenditure was less than 32,000,000l. For the year 1870-1 the estimate is some 49,000,000l. I leave out the provision for "ordinary" original works from revenue, for there is nearly universal condemnation of that plan.* The increase of expenditure is therefore some 17,000,000l. Now the question is this: In order that India should be able to find 17,000,000l. a-year of more revenue, how many times 17,000,000l. must its production have increased to make such increase of State expenditure justifiable?
Can any one show that there has been even so much as four times 17,000,000l. of more production than that of 1856, so as to allow Government to take 25 per cent. of it for the use of the State? Moreover, what a hardship it is that of this addition of 17,000,000l. more than 3,000,000l. are made up by salt revenue!
During the period of this increase of 17,000,000l. of expenditure, what a loss there has been of life and property, and therefore of the power of production, by the mutiny and by famines; and what a mercy it is that railways, irrigation works, and the windfall of cotton profits have to some extent counteracted their evil effects and made up to some extent the political drain. But will it be seriously contended that the progress of production has been such as to justify an annual increase of 17,000,000l. of State expenditure in 1871 over that of 1856?
I hope, therefore, that I have shown that the only salvation for India is large irrigation works, railways, and roads, and other public works of necessity, and parliamentary inquiry from time to time into the administration. Till the commercial exports are sufficiently large to pay from their profits the price of the foreign rule,—or in other words, till the amounts of the commercial exports and imports will be equal, leaving the profits on the exports to be retained by England for the price of its rule,—India cannot be said to be producing enough for its wants; and it will be only when the commercial imports begin to exceed commercial exports, that it will be making any addition to its wealth by the instrumentality of the British rule.
There is one important way to contribute to India's wants, in which England, as a good manager, can give to India the benefit of its credit and moral power without taxing the English public a shilling. If England guaranteed the public debt, a saving will be made in the interest which India has now to pay on it. I propose, however, that this saving be not allowed to remain in the pockets of the Indian taxpayers, but be used in paying off the debt itself. The consequence will be that the whole debt may be paid off in a limited period, without England being required to contribute a single shilling 'from its own revenue. I cannot on this occasion treat of the moral duty of England to give this help, or enter into the subject at any length.
In Sir B. Frere's speech on Mr. Prichard's paper, he first tells us that elastic as the Indian revenue is, its requirements are still greater, and then he wants us to find out new sources of revenue. I venture to submit, with every deference, that what the anxiety of the Finance Minister or any Indian statesman should be, is not so much to discover new sources of revenue as new sources of production or prosperity. There is no royal road to prosperity or finance. Blood cannot be got out of stone. When prosperity is fairly secured revenue will take care of itself, and the Finance Minister, as in this country, will have to be embarrassed, not with deficits, but surpluses.
Sir Bartle does not see much objection to the present guaranteeing system. I agree with Mr. Fitzwilliam that it is objectionable in principle and not very effective in practice. I do not think the railway builders have much right to throw stones at the so much condemned public works. I am very sorry this question of guaranteed railways versus State railways was not fairly fought out at the Society of Arts upon Mr. Andrew's paper. I am morally certain that there has been great waste in the construction of the guaranteed railways; but it is enough for us to know that such is the opinion of Mr. Juland Danvers, who ought to know. By all means let there be private enterprise, but it must be real and not sham enterprise. Mr. Sumner Maine's proposal, mentioned to us by Sir Bartle, of the association of Government and private enterprise in works in which Government control is necessary, so that each takes its risks and profits according to its share, is a fair proposal. This plan is very well adapted to supply the element of "self-interest," the want of which Sir Bartle so clearly showed to have a great deal to do with the evil of waste. We shall then also have the full benefit of the knowledge and experience of business men as directors on behalf of the private shareholders, for if anything went wrong, the shareholders will soon call them to account.
Now, with regard to the thoughtful scheme of Sir Bartle Frere,* I give it as a note, with only two alterations from myself, which are in italics.
For the alteration in No. 2 I shall give my reason in the words of the despatch of the Indian Government, of 9th March, 1865, on irrigation: “ Practically the charge of interest on the money sunk until the work is in a condition to pay, is just as much a part of the first cost as the direct outlay on the construction. There is no reason whatever for regarding such an interest charge as a burden on the revenues, and it may with perfect propriety be paid from the loan. The only essential point is to be assured that all the works undertaken shall, in the end, at least bring back to the State the interest on the capital expended on them, and with a proper system of management we do not doubt that this may be always accomplished.”
As for my second alteration, I rather think that in the case of the reproductive works, the repayment of capital should be provided for from the income only of the works and not from revenue. However, taking the scheme as it is, the principle of my alteration is that if on the one hand you should not burden posterity, it is also necessary that you should not be unjust to the present generation, especially because the benefit of all these works will be enjoyed more by the future than the present. I don’t think, therefore, that I am asking anything unreasonable to distribute the burden over less than two generations in the one case and four in the other. When, last October, I said something to the same effect at our meeting on the occasion of Mr. Hyde Clarke’s paper, I was little prepared to find that Nemesis was pursuing the Indian Government so rapidly for their injustice to the present generation. Sir Bartle’s propositions appear very large to some persons, but they forget the large size and population, and therefore the large requirements of India. In the United Kingdom, with only 30,000,000 of population, 500,000,000l. are invested in railways, not to say anything of other works. I express this much of difference of opinion from Sir Bartle Frere, with every deference. Mr. Maclean says the income-tax as a war-tax is useless in India, and Government must depend upon its credit. He is right in the case of a rebellion; but in that case, if Government will not be able to collect the income-tax, it will not be able to collect any tax. In the case of a foreign invasion, however, if the English rulers have done their duty by the people, they, in their turn, will submit to any reasonable burden when necessary; and if the public debt is guaranteed as I have proposed, the credit upon which he depends most will be much improved. On the subject of the income-tax I shall not say more, as I hope we shall have the benefit of our Chairman's views, who, as you are aware, once sacrificed himself on this very account.
We have had now much discussion both here and in India. We have seen how very various are opinions on the subject of the present condition of India and its administration, and we see now more clearly than ever that Parliament should step in and make a searching inquiry in to the whole matter, for Parliament after all is the fountain head, and Parliament I hope will not shrink from doing its duty to a nation of 200,000,000.
As Mr. W. Tayler's proposal completely embraces the scope of this paper, as well as of former ones, the discussion would be best begun by Mr. Tayler moving his resolution after the Chairman's address is finished.
We have Sir Bartle Frere's weighty opinion, that Parliament should be asked to institute inquiry into the conduct of the Administration. Our Chairman has expressed to me a similar opinion, and we have Mr. Fawcett expressing his belief that “there never was a time when the finances of India more urgently required the keen and scrutinizing investigations of the House of Commons.”
This inquiry I think will do as much service to the Indian Government itself as to the people of India, if not more.
Notes
- *. "Home charges" (exclusive of railways) are nearly 8,000,000l., and out of about 9,000,000l. paid in India to English employés of all classes, I take only 4,000,000l. as remitted to England as savings, for education of children, for support of families, for English goods for their consumption, English manufactured stores purchased by Government in India, &c., making a total of 12,000,000l., including interest paid in England on public debt of about 2,000,000l., leaving 10,000,000l. as assumed by me. (I have treated this subject at some length in my paper "On England's Duties to India," 'East India Association Journal,' vol. i., No. 1.)
- *. Mill’s ‘Political Economy’, vol. ii., p. 178, 3rd ed.
- *. Vol. i., p. 230, 3rd ed.
- *. The Right Hon. Mr. Massey in his Financial Statement of 9th April, 1868, says in reference to works like barracks, trunk roads, &c. :—"But if the question lay between new taxation and providing for these works wholly or partially by loan, we put it to the Secretary of State whether it would not be the preferable course to borrow, rather than strain the resources of the country by additional taxation for the mere purpose of constructing great works, of which posterity would reap the benefit." Mr. Laing's opinion we already know from his letter to 'The Times.' And also the opinion of 'The Times' itself in the several able and forcible articles that have lately appeared in it. In India the opinion has been general during the recent discussions, that barracks, roads, and such "ordinary" works, must be constructed by terminable loans. Sir B. Frere's opinion on this subject, as you are already aware, is decisive against depending upon revenue.
- *. Propositions for providing the capital required for public works in India:— 1. The capital required for public works in India, undertaken by the Government, is not to be restricted to the sum which can be annually spared from current revenue, but is to be provided from loans to be raised in the following manner. 2. Commissioners to be appointed by Parliament, and empowered to raise by loans in England, under authority and with the consent of the Secretary of State in Council, a sum not exceeding millions. The interest on such loan to be paid by the Secretary of State in Council from the revenues of India, which in the case of reproductive works shall be paid after any portion is completed and in a working state, and in proportion to that portion, and the money to be applied to the execution of public works in India undertaken by the Government. 3. Commissioners to be empowered to advance the money so raised to the Government of India, or to the local governments and administrations on the conditions hereinafter mentioned. 4. The local governments and administrations to which advances may be made to be the following:— The Governments of Madras. ” ” Bombay. Lieutenant-Governor of Bengal. ” ” North-West Provinces. ” ” Punjab. The Chief Commissioner of British Burmah. ” ” Oude. ” ” Central Provinces. ” ” Mysore. The Commissioner of Sind. 5. The Commissioners to certify— 1st. That in the case of each advance, they have received copies of the working plans and estimates, or contract specifications sufficient to [p. 110] indicate clearly the limits of the work to be done, and to satisfy them that there is a reasonable prospect of the work specified being executed with the aid of the sum applied for. 2nd. That they have received an assurance of the loan required for the work being repaid by the authority to which the sum has been advanced, with interest sufficient to cover all expenses, within a period not exceeding years, but not less than forty years for “ordinary” works, and not less than eighty years for “extraordinary works,” and that they are satisfied with the security given for such repayment. 6. The Commissioners to make an annual report to Parliament, specifying the sums raised, applied and repaid under these rules, up to the 31st December in each year, with the following particulars— (a) The Government or Administration to which money has been advanced. (b) The names of the works for which the advance was required, and the total sum which each work was estimated to require, and, in each case, the total sum advanced, expended, and repaid up to the end of the year preceding. (c) The nature of the security given for punctual repayment. (d) An enumeration of projects on behalf of which loans have been asked for and refused, with the reasons of refusal in each case.