IX.—Poverty of India, Part I

Essays, Speeches, Addresses and Writings, Dadabhai Naoroji, 1887 · from page 160 · about 95 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

IX.

POVERTY OF INDIA.

Part I.

(Read before the Bombay Branch of the East India Association on Monday, February 28th, 1876.)

While pointing out in these notes one of the unfavorable results of the present system of British administration, I do not for a moment mean to ignore the very bright side of British rule, and the many blessings of law and order which it has conferred on India. On the latter subject I have already expressed my sentiments on several occasions.

My object at present is to shew in greater detail what I have already stated before, that, under the present system of administration, India is suffering seriously in several ways, and is sinking in poverty. In my humble opinion, this is the question, or rather the most serious question, of the day. Whether I am right or wrong will be for you to judge, after hearing what I have to say. If I am right, I shall have discharged a duty as a loyal subject to urge upon our rulers to remedy this most serious evil. If, on the other hand, I am shown to be wrong, none will rejoice more than myself; and I shall have equally done a duty, as a wrong feeling of a serious character will be removed.

These notes were written two to three years ago. I lay them before you as they are. If necessary, I shall consider hereafter any modification that the light of subsequent events may suggest, either in confirmation or refutation of the views expressed in them. There will be a few repetitions from my former papers, but they are necessary in order to make these notes complete. I have endeavoured to avail myself as much as possible of the weight of official or other great authorities, and facts from official records; hence I shall have more quotations than might be thought suitable in an address before an audience; and my notes may prove dull, but I only hope they may be found of some importance to atone for such dulness. I may propose here that any discussion upon the notes may be deferred till they are all read, and my whole argument placed before you, or otherwise there will be confusion in the discussions.

Total Production of India.

In July 1870, I made a rough estimate, in my paper on “The Wants and Means of India,” placed before the East India Association, as follows :—

“ The whole produce of India is from its land. The gross land-tax is put down for 1870-71 a little above £21,000,000. Now, I suppose I shall be within the mark if I say that Government takes for this land-tax, on an average, one-eighth of the gross produce, if not more. This gives for the gross production of the country, say, about £168,000,000 ; add to this—gross opium revenue about £7,000,000 ; gross salt revenue, £6,000,000 ; gross forest, £600,000. The total, thus, of the raw produce of the country amounts under £182,000,000, to be on the safe side, let us say £200,000,000 to include the produce of half a million tons of coal, of alienation lands, or anything else there may be. Now, the population of the whole of British India is nearly 150,000,000 ; giving, therefore, less than 27s. a-head for the annual support of the whole people.”

I then further raised the production from £200,000,000 to £300,000,000, to include the value of manufacturing industries, excise on spirits, and a large margin for any omissions, making 40s. a head for the gross production of India as a high estimate.

Since then I have endeavoured to work out the same problem directly, as far as the official data I could get enabled me to do so.

Parliament requires a yearly report of the moral and material progress of India ; and a Statistical Committee is formed at Calcutta to supply the necessary information. This Committee has prescribed certain tables to be filled up by the different Governments in their administration reports.

The Central Provinces and Burmah reports are the only two complete in their agricultural tables as far as practicable. Four others (Madras, North-West Provinces, Punjab, and Oudh) give them imperfectly. Bengal and Bombay gave the least, or none, up to 1869-70. For what I could not get from the reports, I applied to the India Office, which naturally replied they could not give what they did not get from India. It will be seen, therefore, that I have been obliged to work out the production under much difficulty. Not only is the quantity of information insufficient, but the quality even of such as is given is defective. For instance, in the tables of prices of produce in the different districts of the Central Provinces, in order to get an average the prices are added up together, and the total is divided by the number of the districts. This principle is generally adopted by the returns made by all the Governments with respect to average of produce or prices. The principle, however, is altogether fallacious. In taking the average of prices, the quantities of produce sold at the different prices are altogether lost sight of. In the same way, in taking the average produce per acre, the the extent of land yielding different quantities is overlooked.

The result, therefore, is wrong, and all arguments and conclusions based upon such averages are worthless. Taking the instance of the Central Provinces in the administration report of 1867-8, the average price of rice is made out to be Rs. 2-12-7 per maund, when in reality the correct average will be only Rs. 1-8 per maund. Again, the table for the produce of rice per acre gives the average as 579 lbs., when in reality it is 759 lbs. Now, what can be the worth of conclusions drawn from these wrong averages? These averages are not only worthless, but mischievous. It is a pity that, with large Government establishments, more accurate and complete information should not be given. I sincerely trust that future reports will not only work averages upon correct principles, but also work out the total production of their respective provinces. Then only we shall know the actual condition of the mass of the people. All ‘I thinks’ and ‘my opinions’ are of no use on important subjects. The whole foundation of all administration, financial and general, and of the actual condition of people, rests upon this one fact—the produce of the country, the ultimate result of all capital, labour and land. With imperfect materials at command, and not possessed of the means to employ a staff to work out all the details as they ought to be, I can only give approximate results.

On the question of taking proper averages and supplying complete information, I addressed a letter, in February 1871, to the India Office, which I have reason to believe has been forwarded to the Governments in India. I hope that some attention will be paid to the matter. As a specimen of the correct principle of averages, I have got worked out table A of the averages of price and produce of some of the principal productions of the Central Provinces. From this will be seen that the correct average price for rice is Rs. 1-8, instead of Rs. 2-12-7, as stated above; also that the correct average of produce is 759, and not 579 lbs., of rice per acre. I have explained, in the following calculations for the different provinces, the mode I have adopted for each. Though working with insufficient and defective materials, and without the means and time to work out details, I have endeavoured to calculate above the mark, so that, whatever my error, it will be found on the safe side, of estimating a higher produce than the reality.

The principle of my calculations is briefly this. I have taken the largest one or two kinds of produce of a province to represent all its produce, as it would be too much labour for me to work out every produce, great and small. I have taken the whole cultivated area of each district, the produce per acre, and the price of the produce; and simple multiplication and addition will give you both the quantity and value of the total produce. From it, also, you can get the correct average of produce per acre and of prices for the whole province, as in this way you have all the necessary elements taken into account.

Central Provinces.

The total area of cultivated land (table 2, Fiscal of Report, 1867-8— an average good season year) is 12,378,215 acres. The price of produce per acre, as worked out in table A for the important articles rice, wheat, other food-grains, oil-seeds, and cotton, is Rs. 11-13--5—say Rs. 12.* The total value of agricultural produce will be acres 12,378,215 × Rs. 12 = Rs. 14,85,38,580. To this is to be added the produce of Sumbulpore; but the acreage of that district is not given. Making some allowance for it, I increased the produce to, say, Rs. 16,00,00,000, or £16,000,000, for a population of 9,000,000.

I have lately met with an unexpected confirmation of my views. The Times of India Summary of 6th June 1873 takes from the Englishman some particulars from Mr. Pedder's reply to the Viceroy's circular on local funds. Mr. Pedder makes out, as the value of produce in the Nagpore district, about Rs. 8 per acre, and my estimate of the whole of the Central Provinces is Rs. 12 per acre. I do not know whether

TBL-009 · FOLIO 184Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Acres.Rs.
Rice2,938,3284,18,43,575
Wheat3,313,6773,51,77,956
Other Food Grains4,197,5164,70,63,760
Oil Seeds697,1001,04,42,854
Cotton643,39050,28,838
Total......11,790,01113,95,56,983

I take the above averages of the towns to represent their whole districts, and then the average of the six districts to represent the whole of the Punjab in the following calculation (wheat first sort is taken to represent all produce) :—

TBL-010 · FOLIO 185Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Districts.Irrigated Land.Produce per Acre.Total Produce.For Re. 1.Total Value.
DelhiAcres. 200,955lbs. 1,100lbs. 221,050,500lbs. 43Rs. 51,40,709
Umballa96,328„105,960,8004324,64,204
Lahore447,295„492,024,500411,20,00,597
Sealkote394,227„433,649,700411,05,76,821
Mooltan505,750„556,325,00031½1,76,61,111
Peshawur...249,144„274,058,4004166,84,351
Total...1,893,699...............5,45,27,793

The average value of produce per acre of the irrigated land of the six districts will, therefore, be Rs. 28-7-9.

I now apply this to all irrigated land of the Punjab.

Total irrigated acres are 6,147,038, which, at Rs. 28-7-9 per acre, will give Rs. 17,69,73,224 as the total value of the produce of irrigated land of the Punjab for 1867-8.

I now calculate the value of the produce of unirrigated land (wheat first sort is taken to represent all produce) :—

TBL-011 · FOLIO 185Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Districts.Unirrigated Land.Produce per Acre.Total Produce.For Re. 1.Total Value.
DelhiAcres. 307,090lbs. 600lbs. 184,614,000lbs. 43Rs. 42,93,348
Umballa856,701„514,020,600431,19,53,967
Lahore557,882„334,729,2004181,64,126
Sealkote425,440„255,264,0004162,25,951
Mooltan118,684„71,210,40031½22,60,647
Peshawur456,661„273,996,6004166,82,843
Total...2,723,058...............3,95,80,882

The average value of produce of one acre of unirrigated land of the six districts is Rs. 14-5-3. Applying this to the unirrigated land of the whole of the Punjab, the result will be as follows :—Total unirrigated acres 14,810,697, at Rs. 14-5-3 per acre, will give Rs. 21,51,99,427 as the value of the produce of all unirrigated land of the Punjab for 1867-8.

Adding up the value of the produce of irrigated and unirrigated land, the total will be Rs. 39,21,72,651. From this I deduct 10 per cent. for reasons stated above, which will leave Rs. 35,29,54,800 for a population of 17,593,946, or say £36,000,000 for a population of 17,500,000.

North-West Provinces.

I take the figures of 1867-8, being an average good season. The subsequent ones, 1868-9 and 1869-70, have been bad.

The administration report does not give the distribution of chief crops, but I find in the Statistical Reporter of the Indian Economist (page 136) of 15th March 1871, a table of the crops for 1868-9. From this it will be seen that, out of a total of about 22,000,000 acres, rice, jowari, bajri, wheat, and barley make up—

TBL-012 · FOLIO 186Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Rice2,479,874
Jowari and Bajri4,302,890
Wheat and Barley7,257,873

Acres 14,040,637 or nearly ⅔

As I cannot get the prices of all the above kinds of produce except wheat and barley, if I take wheat to represent all, I shall be above the mark.

In the administration report of 1868-9 there is a table given of prices of wheat and barley. I take the prices for the months of April, May, and June as those of the good season of 1867-8. The subsequent prices are affected by drought. I should have preferred to take the prices for January to June 1868; but the table does not give the earlier months. These prices are of some of the chief markets only, so that, taking the prices to represent the whole of the respective districts, and then taking the average of these few districts to represent the whole of the North-West Provinces, the result will be much higher; so, as in the case of the Punjab, I deduct 10 per cent. as some correction for these errors of excess.

The prices given in the report of 1868-9, pages 29, 30, are as follow :— “The following table gives the prices at the close of each month for the year in the chief markets of the provinces. The figures denote seers and chittacks. . . . . .

TBL-013 · FOLIO 187Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Districts.WHEAT.My Remarks.
April.May.June.Average.
S.C.S.C.S.C.S.C.lb.oz.
Saharunpore... ...226251425142411496The report does not say which seer this is.
Meerut ... ...26027027826135310Formerly 1 seer is given
Moradabad... ...26102510240258½511equal to 2·057 lbs.
Bareilly ... ...2510278250260520(Parliamentary Return No. 29 of 1862, page 5.)
Muttra ... ...240...240240480I take this seer = 2 lbs.
Agra ... ..230230240235461016 chittacks = 1 seer.
Cawnpore ... ..2302302202211456The report also does not say whether these quan-
Allahabad ... ...1841801701712358tities were got for one
Mirzapore ... ...1801801701710¾356rupee, but it evidently
Benares ... ...1751851801715½3514appears to be meant so.

The administration reports give no table of produce per acre of different crops. I adopt the same scale as given in the case of the Punjab, for the following additional reasons :— *Captain Harvey Tuket’s estimate in the year 1840, from 2,000 experiments, of which 512 were for wheat, made by the Government of the North-West Provinces, gives the average produce of wheat per acre at 1,046 lbs. The late Mr. Thornton, formerly Secretary to that Government, has recorded that, judging from his own experience, he should say that 1,200 lbs. per acre was a high average for irrigated land, and 700 lbs. for that of which a considerable portion is dry.† Mr. Maconochi, in his recent settlements of Oonah (Oudh), gives for irrigated land—

1st class 21 bushels=1,218 lbs. (at 58 lbs. per bushel) 2nd „ 16 „ = 928 „ 3rd „ 9 „ = 522 „

and for unirrigated land—

1st class 11 bushels=638 lbs. 2nd „ 9 „ =522 „ 3rd „ 7 „ =406 „

Taking second class as representing the bulk, the average for irrigated land may be considered as 928 lbs., and for unirrigated 522 lbs. From all the above particulars it will be seen that the estimate I have adopted, of 1,100 lbs. per acre for irrigated and 600 lbs. for unirrigated land, is something above a fair average. A settlement officer of the North-West Provinces, in a letter to the Indian Economist of 15th February 1871 (" Agricultural Gazette," page 171), sums up all that is known to him on the subject of the produce of wheat per acre in those provinces. It will be too long an extract to insert here ; but, making allowance for the " mischievous fallacy " of all official documents alluded to by this writer, about which I have already complained to the India Office and which vitiates averages for a number of years or places, I think the average I have adopted above is something more than a reasonable one. When administration reports will give, as they ought, correct particulars for each district every year, accurate estimates of the actual produce of the provinces could be easily made. I give the calculations below. The table of cultivated land, given at page 45 of the appendix to the administration report of 1867-8, does not give the irrigated and unirrigated extent of land separately for the Moradabad, Tarrae, Mynpoorie, Banda, and Ghazipore districts.

I find that the totals of irrigated and unirrigated land bear nearly the proportion of two-fifths and three-fifths respectively of the whole total cultivated land. I assign the same proportion to the above districts in the absence of actual particulars.

TBL-014 · FOLIO 188Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Wheat.
Districts.Irrigated Land.Produce per Acre.Total Produce.For 1 Re.Total Value.
Acres.lbs.lbs.lbs.oz.Rs.
Saharunpore160,0581,100176,063,80049635,65,849
Meerut577,346„635,080,60053101,17,26,444
Moradabad806,930„787,623,0005111,73,83,069
Bareilly344,662„379,128,20052172,82,174
Muttra332,542„365,796,20048089,22,837
Agra434,106„477,582,60046101,02,43,058
Cawnpore397,396„437,135,60045696,33,842
Allahabad345,624„380,186,4003581,07,09,476
Mirzapore198,823„218,705,30035661,82,481
Benares238,971„262,868,100351475,01,549
Total...3,836,518............9,31,50,779

The average value of the produce of one acre will be Rs. 24-2-8.

Applying the average of the above districts to the whole of the irrigated area of the North-West Provinces, the result will be—acres 10,045,050 × Rs. 24-2-8 = Rs. 24,38,93,814.

In a similar manner, the total value of the produce of unirrigated land, as represented by wheat, will be as follows :—

TBL-015 · FOLIO 189Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Districts.Unirrigated Land.Produce per Acre.Total Produce.For 1 Re.Total Value.
Acres.lbs.lbs.lbs.oz.Rs.
Saharanpore621,382600372,829,20047675,50,960
Meerut453,694”272,216,400531050,76,288
Moradabad484,158”290,494,80051156,88,992
Bareilly768,283”460,957,80052188,53,920
Muttra406,153”243,691,80048050,76,912
Agra374,976”224,985,600461048,25,424
Cawnpore436,636”261,981,60045657,73,696
Allahabad644,594”386,756,4003581,08,94,544
Mirzapore614,658”368,794,8003561,04,25,280
Benares202,818”121,690,800351433,92,064
Total...5,007,352............6,75,58,080

The average value of wheat per acre of unirrigated land is therefore Rs. 13-4-9.

Applying this average to the whole unirrigated land of the North-West Provinces, we get—acres 14,132,111 × Rs. 13-4-9 = Rs. 19,06,42,177. The grand total of the value of the produce of irrigated and unirrigated land will be—

TBL-016 · FOLIO 189Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Irrigated10,045,050acres=Rs.24,38,93,814
Unirrigated14,132,111„=„19,06,42,177
Total24,177,161„=„43,45,35,991

Deducting 10 per cent. for reasons stated above, the remainder will be Rs. 39,10,82,392 for a population of 30,086,898, or say £40,000,000 for a population of 30,000,000.

BENGAL.

The administration reports till 1869-70 give no information required by the Statistical Committee, except the area of districts in square miles and acres (report 1869-70). For information for cultivated area, distribution, produce of crops and prices, I have to look out elsewhere, or make a rough estimate.

First with regard to the extent of cultivated land, I adopt the following plan as the best I can. The total area of the North-West Provinces is about 50,000,000 acres, of which about 25,000,000 are cultivated. The population of those Provinces is, by the late census of 1865, about 30,000,000, so we have the total area 5 acres to 3 persons, and of cultivated area five-sixths of an acre per head. Now, assuming Bengal to be at least as thickly populated as the North-West Provinces, and the total area, as given in the administration report of 1869-70 (appendix, page xxi.), being about 105,000,000 acres, the population of Bengal will be about 63,000,000 ; and I am encouraged to adopt this figure instead of 36,000,000 of the report of 1869-70, as the Englishman of 25th June 1872 states that the census of Bengal, as far as the figures are made up, lead to an estimate of about 65,000,000. Again, as in the North-West Provinces, I allow five-sixths of an acre of cultivated land per head, and take, therefore, 54,000,000 acres of cultivated land for a population of 65,000,000.

With regard to produce, coarse rice is the chief produce of Bengal, and in taking it to represent the whole produce, I shall be near enough the mark. For the produce of rice per acre, I take a table given in the report of the Indigo Commission (Parliamentary Return No. 721, of 1861, page 292), in which produce of paddy per beegah is given for a number of districts. The rough average, without reference to the quantity of land in each district, comes to about 9 maunds per beegah.

The maund I take is the Indian maund of 82 lbs. The quantity of produce per beegah given in the table is evidently for rice in husk ; for, though not so stated, this would be apparent by comparing the money values of these quantities given in the same table, with the prices for 1860 given in the table at page 291.

The beegah I find explained, at page lxi. of the same return, at about one-third of an acre. Thacker's Bengal Directory for 1872, page 2, gives the following table for “ Bengal square or land measure” :—

TBL-017 · FOLIO 190Diplomatic CSV
1 chittack = 45 square feet or 5 square yards.
16 „ = 1 cottah = 720 sq. ft. or 80 sq. yds.
20 cottah = 1 beegah = 14,400 „ or 1,600 „

This gives a little more than 3 beegahs to an acre.

Mr. Cowasjee Eduljee, the manager of the Port Canning rice mills and lands, thinks, that for an average of all lands, or say for standard land, 7 maunds of paddy per beegah will be a very fair calculation. I take 8 maunds. Mr. Cowasjee further says, as the outturn of his mills, that paddy yields 55 per cent. of rice at the outside.

For the price of rice I take the season 1867-8. I take the rough average of the weekly prices given in the Calcutta Gazette for the months of January to March 1868, as fairly representing the effect of the season of 1867-8. This average is taken by simply adding up the prices and dividing by the number of districts, and not on the correct principle of taking the quantities of the produce of each district into account (as in specimen table A I have given for the Central Provinces). The average, therefore, which I have adopted, must be much higher than the actual one, and will require some reasonable deduction. I shall deduct only 10 per cent. as some correction for this, and to make up for any error in the produce per acre. Besides, the prices given in the Gazette are retail prices, and are therefore higher than the prices all over the country; so my deduction of 10 per cent. will be but a very small correction for all the errors of my rough calculation. I cannot get the extent of cultivated land for each district. I give below the calculations. Since writing these notes, I have seen the late census report, which gives the population as 66,856,859, or say 67,000,000. The approximate area of cultivated land will be, say, five-sixths of 67,000,000 or 56,000,000 acres. The produce per acre, taken as 24 maunds paddy per acre, will give about 13 maunds of clean rice, or 1,066 lbs.—say 1,100 lbs. The total produce of 56,000,000 acres will be 616,000,000 lbs., which, at 58 lbs. per rupee (as obtained by the rough average of the weekly prices of the three months of January, February, and March 1868), will give Rs. 1,06,00,00,000, or £106,000,000. Deducting 10 per cent. will give £95,400,000, or say £96,000,000 for a population of 67,000,000. This will amply cover the higher price of some of the articles, such as silk, indigo, cost price of opium, tea, &c. or any double crops, &c. The percentage of these products is a small one; the total value for all these will be under 10 per cent. of the whole produce, while the average of price I have taken for rice as representing the whole produce of the presidency will be found much above the actuals. On the whole, I cannot help thinking that the total value of all productions of the Bengal Presidency will be found much under, than above, my estimate. It is very desirable, however, to get a correct result, and the Statistical Committee or Agricultural Department should give it.

Madras.

I take the administration report of 1868-9 as I have not been able to get an opportunity of studying that of 1867-8. Besides, as prices have not much altered, the later report is the better. I am obliged to ascertain the produce per acre from other sources: the report does not give this information. I take paddy to represent the produce of wet and cumboo for dry land, as they form the bulk of the produce of the country.

Mr. H. Newill, the Director of Settlements for South Arcot, in his letter of 27th August 1859 (Selections of the Madras Government, No. 14 of 1869, Appendix Y, from page 142), gives an elaborate table of produce per acre of the principal grains, as ascertained by a large number of experiments and general enquiry; and the result of his investigations gives, for the different classes of soils, the following produce, from which 5 per cent. is to be deducted for numerous ridges for regulating irrigation channels, exterior boundaries, &c. :—

TBL-018 · FOLIO 193Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Produce of Wet Land per acre for “Good Crop” first grade Land.
DescriptionValue assigned
for good
of Soils.Crops per acre.
H.C. (Bazar Huris Cullum.)
145
240
335
430
528
640
735
830
928
1030
1125
1220
1318
14 1515
Average...30

Deducting 5 per cent. for ridges, &c., 30 — 1½ = 28½ H. C. For second grade land, deduct 15 per cent., which will give 24¼ H. C. For third grade deduct 20 per cent., which will give 22·8 H. C. For bad seasons Mr. Newill deducts 10 per cent. more, which I do not; so that the produce calculated by me is for “good crop,” or in “good season,” as in all other cases. Taking second grade as the bulk of the land, I take 24¼ H. C. as the average of all wet land.

For dry land for cumboo (page 150), Mr. Newill gives the produce per acre as follows :—

TBL-019 · FOLIO 193Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Descriptions ofDescriptions ofDescriptions of
Soils.Soils.Soils.
H.C.H.C.H.C.
1216171112
2187151210
3178131310
416912149
5141014158
Average...13 11⁄15
say14 H. C.

The next thing necessary is to ascertain the correct average price. I take the average price as given in the administration report (calculated on the wrong principle referred to by me before), bearing in mind that the correct average, as worked out according to specimen table A, would be very likely found lower. Again, taking the rough average of first and second class paddy, the price comes to Rs. 180 per garce; and as second class paddy must be the bulk of the produce, the correct average price in this respect also must be lower. In taking, therefore, Rs. 180 per garce, some reasonable allowance will have to be made. I shall make it only 10 per cent. for all kinds of excess. It is too much work for me to calculate as in table A.

Wet land under cultivation (except South Canara and Malabar, where areas under cultivation are not given) is for 1868-9, 2,957,748 acres at 24 1/4 H. C. produce per acre (and 133 1/3 H. C. = 1 garce*) will give 511,490 garces, which, at Rs. 180 per garce, will give Rs. 9,68,53,500—the total value of the produce of wet land.

Dry cultivated land (except South Canara and Malabar) is 13,560,329 acres, and with produce at 14 H. C. per acre (and 133 H. C. = 1 garce), will give 1,427,403 garces. I take the rough average price as given in the table—Rs. 188 per garce— in the administration report of 1868-69. This will be an over-estimate, as quantities in each district are not taken into account. The total value will be—1,427,403 garces at Rs. 188 = Rs. 26,83,51,764. Total produce of wet and dry lands will be Rs. 36,52,05,264; adding 10 per cent. for South Canara and Malabar, the total for all the Madras Presidency will be a little above Rs. 40,00,00,000. From this is to be allowed 10 per cent. as a correction for errors of high averages, which will leave, say, £36,000,000 for a population of 26,539,052 (Parliamentary Return No. [C 1841870]), or say 26,500,000.

Bombay.

The season 1867-8 was a favourable one (Bombay administration report, 1867-8, page 59); that for 1868-9 unfavorable (report for 1868-9, page 65). I take the former to ascertain the produce of a fair good season. I am sorry that the administration reports give no agricultural information. I therefore take the necessary particulars from other sources. The Revenue Commissioner's reports for 1867-8 give the total area under cultivation for the Northern Division at 5,129,754 acres and 1,263,139 beegahs, in which are included for grass and fallow land 611,198 acres and 226,708 beegahs. The actual cultivated land will, after deducting this, be 4,518,556 acres and 1,036,431 beegahs = 609,842 acres, or total acres 5,128,398. Out of this bajri, jowari, rice, and cotton make up nearly two-thirds, or above 60 per cent., as follows :—

TBL-020 · FOLIO 195Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Acres.Beegahs.
Bajri985,42756,857
Jowari676,377224,210
Rice616,80294,306
Cotton519,058319,572
2,797,664694,945=408,791 acres, or total acres 3,206,455.

Similarly for the Southern Division, out of the total acres, 13,985,892, jowari, bajri, rice, and cotton make up above 60 per cent., as follows :—

TBL-021 · FOLIO 195Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Acres.
Jowari4,906,073
Bajri2,715,719
Rice...504,015
Cotton704,629
8,830,436

I take, therefore, these four articles to represent the produce of the whole presidency, though this will give a higher estimate. Neither the administration nor the Revenue Commissioner's reports give produce per acre or prices. I take these two items as follows. From Selections of the Bombay Government, Nos. 10 and 11 of 1853, I get the following estimate of produce :—

TBL-022 · FOLIO 196Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Produce per Acre in Pounds.
Selection.Districts reported upon.Bajri with Kuthole.Jowari with Kuthole.Sathi, or Coarse Rice.Kupas, or uncleaned Cotton.Remarks.
No.Page.lbs.lbs.lbs.lbs.
X.15Prant of Husore—7001,020Cleaned Cotton as per experiments made under order of Mr. Saunders, Resident of Hyderabad, in Bassein district of Berar—average of 8 acres giving 31¾ lbs. of clean Cotton and 83½ lbs. of Seed. (Agricultural Gazette of India of 21st August 1871, page 3.) This would give 82 lbs. for 305 lbs. of kupas.
Morassa & Bayar Pergunnah in Ahmedabad Collectorate ...6801,020 Jowari in fal-low-land.
106Dushkroee pergunnah, Greatest ... Least ...1,700 2701,500 2101,360 410410 200
XI.15Dholka— Greatest ... Least... ...1,700 2701,500 2101,360 410410 200
Rough average.924856912305

The above averages belong to a fertile part of the Northern Division ; so that if I put down 900 lbs. for bajri, jowari, and rice per acre, and 80 lbs. of cotton for the whole of that Division, I shall be making a high estimate.

The next thing to settle is the prices. I take them from the Government Gazette weekly prices for the months of January to May 1868, as fairly representing the effect of the average favorable season of 1867-8. These are retail prices of the chief markets of the respective districts, and it will be necessary to deduct 10 per cent. to make a fair average for the whole of the Division. For cotton I take the export prices from the Prices Current of the Bombay Chamber of Commerce for January to May 1868. This gives an average of Rs. 181 per candy. The export prices I have taken represent more than the average value of the whole crop of the presidency, as the above average is for Fair Dhollera and Bhownuggur, which necessarily give a higher figure than the average of all the different varieties. Again, the bulk of the cotton is not ‘fair,’ but ‘midfair;’ so, to make a fair allowance for all these circumstances, I take the price for 1867-8 as Rs. 170 per candy of 784 lbs.

The Southern Division.—As a whole, this Division is not as fertile as the Northern. I shall take, however, only 50 lbs. less for bajri, jowari, and rice; and for cotton I take 60 lbs. per acre—a high average for the whole of the Division; for Mr. J. B. Smith, M.P., in his paper of 1857 read before the Society of Arts, quotes Mr. Vary, the then late Superintendent of Government Cotton Experiments in Sattara and Sholapore, to the effect that “40 lbs. per acre per clean cotton is considered a fair crop.” For rice, I take Rutnagherry as exceptional in its produce. If I give 1,700 lbs. per acre for the whole district, it will be a high average.* I take the prices from the Government Gazette in the same way as for the Northern Division, and a similar reduction of 10 per cent. will have to be made. I give below a table worked out in the manner described above:—

Rice—

TBL-023 · FOLIO 197Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Rice—
Acres.Produce, maund of 82 lbs.
822,2189,197,713, giving an average of 917 lbs.

Jowari and Bajri—

TBL-024 · FOLIO 197Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Jowari and Bajri—
Acres.Produce, maund of 82 lbs.
9,476,68744,557,600, giving an average of 385 lbs.

Now, the year 1869-70 is reported to have been an average favourable season, in which case my adopting 900 lbs. for the Northern and 850 for the Southern Division for all grains, is very much higher than the real average. For cotton the figures are acres 1,937,375, maunds 3,264,464, giving an average of 1·68 maunds or 136 lbs. It is not stated whether this is cleaned or seed cotton. Any way this cannot be correct. It is, however, remarked by the official who supplies these statistics—“The figures in table iii., giving the weight of produce, are not, it is feared, very reliable, but now that attention is being given to the subject, they will become more so every year.” I earnestly hope that it will be so; correct statistics of this kind are extremely important.

TBL-025 · FOLIO 198Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Bajri.
Collectorates.Cultivated Area.Total Produce (at 900 lbs. per Acre).Price per 1 Re.Total Value.
Acreslbs.lbs.Rs.
Ahmedabad...129,365*116,428,50033·634,65,134
Kaira150,841135,756,90030·045,25,230
Surat27,21724,495,30025·59,60,600
Khandeish711,447640,302,30027·62,31,99,359
Tanna.................................
Total...1,018,870...............3,21,50,323
(850 lbs. per Acre.)
Poona834,325709,176,25034·72,04,37,356
Ahmednuggur1,152,316979,468,60034·32,85,55,936
Kulladghee240,165204,140,25064·4†31,69,880
Rutnagherry...............
Belgaum76,22864,793,80059·210,94,489
Dharwar14,10811,991,80069·01,73,795
Sattara...398,573338,787,05052·964,04,292
Total...2,715,715...............5,98,35,748
TBL-026 · FOLIO 198Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Jowari.
Collectorates.Cultivated Area.Total Produce (at 900 lbs. per Acre).Price per 1 Re.Total Value.
Acres.lbs.lbs.Rs.
Ahmedabad...119,679107,711,10042·425,40,356
Kaira44,53640,082,40042·49,45,339
Surat178,839160,955,10027·159,39,302
Khandeish465,198418,678,20040·41,03,63,322
Tanna ...109,00026·8336
Total...808,262...............1,97,88,655
(850 lbs. per Acre.)
Poona1,487,8161,264,643,60049·52,55,48,355
Ahmednuggur852,232724,397,20045·61,58,85,903
Kulladghee1,162,582988,194,70070·01,41,17,060
Rutnagherry........................
Belgaum426,542362,560,70066·054,93,344
Dharwar511,389434,680,65083·851,87,120
Sattara...465,509395,682,65052·675,22,487
Total...4,906,070...............7,37,54,269

Rice.

TBL-027 · FOLIO 199Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Rice.
Collectorates.Cultivated Area.Total Produce (at 900 lbs. per Acre.)2nd Sort price per 1 Re.Total Value.
Acres.lbs.lbs.Rs.
Ahmedabad ... ...31,90228,711,80014·020,50,843
Kaira ... ... ... ...51,44346,298,70012·237,94,975
Surat ... ... ... ...108,34897,513,20011·2786,52,458
Khandeish ... ... ...12,08110,872,90020·15,40,940*
Tanna ... ... ... ...468,499421,649,10020·1†2,09,77,567
Total...672,273605,045,700... ...3,60,16,783
Poona ... ... ... ...108,643(850 lbs. per Acre.) 92,346,55022·241,59,754
Ahmednuggur ... ...28,92224,583,70012·319,98,674
Kulladghee ... ...5,4964,671,60020·92,23,521
Rutnagherry ... ...130,403221,685,100 (1,700 lbs. per Acre.)27·082,10,559
Belgaum ... ... ...70,88960,255,65029·020,77,781
Dharwar ... ... ...91,84078,064,00027·128,80,590
Sattara ... ... ...67,82057,647,00022·425,73,527
Total...504,013539,253,600......2,21,24,406

Cotton.

TBL-028 · FOLIO 199Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Cotton.
Collectorates.Cultivated Area.Produce per Acre.Total Produce.Price per Candy.Total Value
Acres.lbs.lbs.Rs.Rs.
Ahmedabad ... ... ... Kaira ... ... ... ... Surat ... ... ... ... Khandeish ... ... ... Tanna ... ... ... ...707,0418056,563,2801701,22,64,997
Poona ... ... ... ... Ahmednuggur ... ... Kulladghee ... ... ... Rutnagherry ... ... ... Belgaum ... ... ... ... Dharwar ... ... ... ... Sattara ... ... ... ...704,6296042,277,74017091,67,367

Summary.

TBL-029 · FOLIO 200Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Northern Division.
Acres.Rs.Rs.Rs.
Bajri ...1,018,8703,21,50,323
Jowari ...808,2621,97,88,655
Rice ...672,2733,60,16,783
8,79,55,761 — 10 % =7,91,60,185 1,22,64,997
Cotton ...707,041......
Total...3,206,446Rs....9,14,25,182
TBL-030 · FOLIO 200Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Southern Division.
Acres.Rs.Rs.Rs.
Bajri... ...2,715,7155,98,35,748
Jowari ...4,906,0707,37,54,269
Rice ... ...504,0132,21,24,406
15,57,14,423 — 10 % =14,01,42,981 91,67,367
Cotton ...704,629... ... ...
Total ...8,830,427Rs....14,93,10,348
TBL-031 · FOLIO 200Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Average per acre, Rs. 17. Total Cultivated Area.
Acres.Rs.
Northern Division...5,128,221at Rs. 28·51 =14,62,05,580
Southern " ...13,985,892at " 17 =23,77,60,164
Total... Rs.38,39,65,744

This gives for the whole of the Bombay Presidency the total value as Rs. 38,39,65,744, or say £40,000,000, for a population of 11,000,000.

About two or three months ago I came across an unexpected confirmation of my calculations. I was able to get from my friend Mr. Nowrojee Furdoonjee a few notes from Colonel Prescott's reports on the settlement of Akleshwar Taluka—I suppose an average Gujerat taluka. Colonel Prescott has made the value of gross produce (excluding straw) about Rs. 24 per acre. Why, my estimate for the whole of the Northern Division is above Rs. 28 per acre.

Oudh.

The administration report does not give the agricultural tables, but they are given in the revenue report. Wheat forms the most important produce in Oudh, as in the North-West Provinces. I take it to represent the whole produce. In the revenue report ending 30th September 1868, the average produce per acre is given as 892 lbs., say 900 lbs.

Now, in Oudh, irrigated land is nearly within 10 per cent. of unirrigated land. I shall give the above produce per acre for both, as the table also gives this as the average of all land. The year 1867-8 was somewhat below an average good season, and the prices, therefore, higher than they would be for an average good season year. I take them, however, as they are. The average for wheat, first quality, is given at Rs. 1-9-7 per maund of 80 lbs., and for second quality Rs. 1-8-4—the average will be about Rs. 1-9. As a small correction for the prices being of an inferior season, the average being on the usual wrong principle, and the second quality being the largest quantity, I shall deduct only 10 per cent. The total cultivated area is 12,486 square miles, or 7,991,040 acres. The total produce, at 900 lbs. of wheat per acre, will be 7,191,936,000 lbs.; and the total value, at the rate of Rs. 1-9 per maund of 80 lbs., will be Rs. 14,04,67,500. This, less 10 per cent., will be Rs. 12,64,20,750 or say £13,000,000 for a population of 9,500,000.

TBL-032 · FOLIO 201Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Summary.
Provinces.Value of the Produce of Cultivated Land.Population.Produce per head.
£Rs.
Central Provinces16,000,0009,000,00018
Punjab36,000,00017,500,00021
North-West Provinces...40,000,00030,000,00014
Bengal96,000,00067,000,00015
Madras36,000,00026,500,00014
Bombay40,000,00011,000,00036
Oudh13,000,0009,500,00014
Total...277,000,000170,500,000

Such is the produce of India for a good season year, in which any second crops will be fully included. I have not taken the produce of grazing-land, or straw or kurby, though the cattle required for cultivation and stock need not only all these grazing-lands, but also a portion of the produce of the cultivated land, such as some grains, fodder, and other produce. From the above total of £277,000,000 it is necessary to deduct for seed for next year, say, only 6 per cent., that is, allowing sixteenfold for produce of land. The balance will be about £260,000,000 as the produce of cultivation, during a good season, for human use and consumption for a year. If the Government of India would calculate this production correctly, it would find the total a good deal under the above figures.

I have next to add for annual produce of stock for consumption, annual value of manufacturing industry, net opium revenue, cost of production of salt, coals and mines, and profits of foreign commerce.

Salt, opium, coal, and profits of commerce will be about £17,000,000. For annual price of manufacturing industry or stock, I have not come across full particulars. The manufacturing industry in the Punjab—where there are some valuable industries, such as shawls, silks, &c., to the total estimated value of the "annual out-turns of all works"—is put down as about £3,774,000. From this we deduct the value of the raw produce; and if I allow this value to be doubled by all the manufactures, I shall be making a good allowance. Say, then, that the value of the industry is about £2,000,000, including the price of wool; the manufactures of other parts of India are not quite as valuable. Therefore, for the population of all British India, which is about ten times that of the Punjab, if I take £15,000,000 for the value of manufacturing industry, I shall not be far from the mark. The total for Central Provinces for 1870-1 for all manufactures is about £1,850,000. There are no very valuable industries, allowing, therefore, £850,000 for the value of the industry for a population of 9,000,000. In this proportion, the total value for India will be about, say, £17,000,000. For the annual produce of stock and fish for human consumption as milk or meat, I can hardly get sufficient data to work upon. I hope Government will give the particulars more fully, so that the annual production of stock for consumption, either as milk or meat, may be known. I set it down as £15,000,000 as a guess only.

All this will make up a total of about £307,000,000. I add for any contingencies another £30,000,000, making at the utmost £340,000,000 for a population of 170,000,000, or 40s. a head for an average good season. I have no doubt that, if the Statistical Department worked out the whole correctly and fully, they would find the total less. Again, when further allowance is made for bad seasons, I cannot help thinking that the result will be nearer 30s. than 40s. a head. One thing is evident—that I am not guilty of any under-estimate of produce.

Adding this additional £63,000,000 in proportion of population, that is to say 7s. 5d. per head, the total production of each province will be as follows:—

TBL-033 · FOLIO 203Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Per head.
s.d.
Central Provinces435
Punjab495
North-West Provinces355
Bengal375
Madras355
Bombay795
Oudh355
Average...400

Necessary Consumption.

I now consider what is necessary for the bare wants of a human being, to keep him in ordinary good health and decency. I have calculated production chiefly for the year 1867-8. I shall take the same year for ascertaining the necessary consumption. Surgeon S. B. Partridge, Government Medical Inspector of Emigrants, in a statement dated Calcutta, 26th March 1870,* proposes the following as a scale of diet to supply the necessary ingredients of nourishment for the emigrant coolies during their voyage, living in a state of quietude :—

TBL-034 · FOLIO 203Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Rice Diet for One Man.For Flour Diet.
ozs.ozs.
Rice20·0Flour16·0
Dhal6·0Dhal4·6
Preserved Mutton2·5Preserved Mutton2·5
Vegetables4·27Vegetables4·27
Ghee1·0Ghee1·5
Mustard Oil0·5Mustard Oil0·5
Salt...1·0Salt1·0
Total...35·27Total...29·77

The administration report of Bengal for 1870-1 gives, in appendix 11 D2, the following “scale of provisions for ships carrying Indian emigrants to British and foreign colonies west of the Cape of Good Hope.” “Daily Allowance to each statute Adult [Children above two and under ten years of age to receive half rations].

TBL-035 · FOLIO 204Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Class.Articles.oz.drs.Remarks.
Grain ...Rice ... ...200(Four kinds of dhals make up this quantity.)
Flour ... ...160
Dal { for rice-eaters.60
{ for flour-eaters.40
Oil ... ...Ghee { for rice-eaters.10Half an ounce extra allowance of ghee to each adult for every day that dried fish is supplied.
{ for flour-eaters.18
Mustard Oil ...08
Meats, &c. ...Preserved Mutton28In lieu of preserved mutton to be supplied at scale rate dried fish for two to three weeks. Fresh mutton (sheep) one week.
Vegetables ...{ 1 oz. pumpkins or yams { 2 oz. potatoes { 2 oz. onions...50In lieu of fresh potatoes, a sufficient quantity of preserved potatoes to allow 2 ozs. twice a week to each adult, or about five weeks’ supply at scale rate.
Garlic .. ...00½
Curry Stuff, &c. ...Mustard Seed ...00½
Chillies ...00½
Black Pepper ...01½
Coriander Seed ...02
Turmeric ...04
Tamarind ...08
Salt ... ...08
Narcotic ...Prepared tobacco07
Leaf ... ...03Or in lieu of firewood, its equivalent in coal for half the quantity.”
Firewood ...20

Besides the above, there is an allowance for dry provision to be used at the discretion of the surgeon, for medical comforts, medicine, instruments and appliances for hospital and dispensary. Again, for confirmed opium-eaters or ganja-smokers, the surgeon superintendent is to see a proper quantity supplied. Surgeon Partridge’s scale is absolutely necessary to supply the necessary ingredients of nitrogen and carbon; not the slightest luxury—no sugar or tea, or any little enjoyment of life, but simple animal subsistence of coolies living in a state of quietude. I have worked out below the cost of living according to Surgeon Partridge’s scale for the year 1867-8 at Ahmedabad prices. The scale in the Bengal administration report provides curry-stuff and narcotics in addition, which I have not calculated in this table, though it can hardly be said that they are not necessaries to those poor people.

TBL-036 · FOLIO 205Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Cost of necessary living at Ahmedabad prices, on 30th January 1868, as given in the "Bombay Government Gazette."
Rice, second sort, 20 oz. per day, or 37½ lbs. per month, at 15 lbs. per rupeeRs.280
Dhal 6 oz. per day, or 11¼ lbs. per month, at 20 lbs.* per rupee"090
Preserved mutton 2·50 oz. per day, or 4 lbs. 11 oz. per month, at 6½ lbs.† per Rupee..."0117
Vegetable 4·27 oz. per day, or 8 lbs. per month, at 20 lbs.‡ per rupee"065
Ghee 1 oz. per day, or 1 lb. 14 oz. per month, at 2 lbs. 1 oz. per rupee"0110
Mustard Oil 0·5 oz. per day, or 1 lb. 8 oz. per month, at 6 lbs.§ per rupee"040
1 oz. per day, or 1 lb. 14 oz. per month, at 38 lbs.‖ per rupee"0010
Per Month...Rs.5210

The annual cost of living or subsistence only, at Ahmedabad prices, is thus Rs. 62-2.

The following is an estimate of the lowest absolute scale of necessaries of a common agricultural labourer in the Bombay Presidency annually, by Mr. Kazee Sahabudin :—

Food—

TBL-037 · FOLIO 205Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Food—
1½ lbs. Rice per day, at Rs. 2 to Rs. 2-8 per maund of 40 lbs., say...Rs.288
Salt, including waste, about 1 oz. a day"10
¼ lb. Dhal..."90
Vegetables ..."00
Food-oil ..."50
Condiments, chillies, &c. ..."00
Tobacco ..."50
Rs.488

Clothing—

TBL-038 · FOLIO 206Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Clothing—
3 Dhotees a yearRs.30
1 pair champal (shoes)„012
½ a turban„18
1 Bundee (jacket)„10
2 Kamlees (blankets)„18
1 Rumal (handkerchief)„02
1 Rain-protector„04
TotalRs.82

The dress of the female of the house—

TBL-039 · FOLIO 206Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
The dress of the female of the house—
1½ Saree (dress)Rs.312
1 Cholee (short jacket)„012
Oil for head„18
Bangrees (glass bangles)„06
½ Champal (shoes)„04
Extras„10
TotalRs.710

The old members of the family will require as much.

Lodging—

TBL-040 · FOLIO 206Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Lodging—
Hut (labour taken as his own)Rs.250
Hut repairs (bamboos, &c.), per annum„40
Oil for lamp, per day„00½
Barber, per month„01
Domestic utensils per annum„012

Say altogether Rs. 12 to Rs. 15 for the family.

Taking one-quarter less, for reasons stated further on, to calculate the cost per head of family, the result will be—

TBL-041 · FOLIO 206Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
FoodRs. 36
Clothing„ 6Without any provision for social and religious wants, letting alone luxuries, and anything to spare for bad seasons.
Lodging„ 3
Rs. 45

The report of the Bombay Price Commission gives the following particulars of the wants of the lowest servants of Government (pages 85, 86), supplied from the Poona District :—

TBL-042 · FOLIO 207Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Quantities per month.Cost per month in 1863.Remarks.
Seers.Rs.a.
Rice1218It will be observed
Bajri1214that simple living and
Toor Dhal, &c.4012clothing are here exhi-
Ghee0¾010bited, and nothing is
Vegetables…06taken into account for
Oil …1¼06support of dependent
Firewood ……08members of family, ser-
Salt101vants, religious and
Mussala…02other domestic ex-
Chillies …0½02penses.
Milk408
Betelnut-leaves…08
Rs...611
TBL-043 · FOLIO 207Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Clothing— Cost per Month.
TurbansRs.08
Dhotee„010
Puncha„02
Rumal …„00½
Coats …„03
Waistcoat„02
Shoes...„01½
Total... Rs.111
Grand Total...Rs.86 per month.

For Poona the above scale is calculated to cost Rs. 6-11 per month, or Rs. 80-4 per annum, at the high prices of 1863, while my estimate, according to Surgeon Partridge's scale for 1867-8, is Rs. 5-2-10 per month, or Rs. 62-2 per annum—nearly 24 per cent. less, as prices have gone lower. For clothing, the estimate for 1863 is Rs. 1-11 per month, or Rs. 20-8 per annum, while Mr. Shahabudin's estimate is only Rs. 8-2 in 1868. Even allowing for fall in prices, Mr. Shahabudin's estimate is lower, and calculated on a very low scale for an agricultural labourer in the poorest districts, while that of 1863 is for the lowest class of Government servants. Upon the whole, therefore, the estimate given for 1867-8, as for the bare necessaries of a common agricultural labourer, is evidently under the mark.

Lately I found the following in the “Statement of the Moral and Material Progress of India” for 1871-2 :—“The best account of the Bombay peasantry is still probably that by Mr. Coats, written fifty years ago. The clothes of a man then cost about 12s., and the furniture of his house about £2.”—(Parliamentary Return No. 172 of 28th April 1873.)

I have not been able to work out the details of cost of living in other parts of India. For the present I give the following approximate comparison for 1867-8 :—

Jails.

TBL-044 · FOLIO 208Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Jails.
Provinces.Cost of Living.Cost of Clothing.Total.
Rs.a.p.Rs.a.p.Rs.a.p.
Central Provinces25805803100
Punjab236031302730
North-West Provinces...188035021130
Bengal*283038031110
Madras†492731595324
Bombay4113051004770
Oudh... ... ...... ... ...... ... ...

Now, the Bengal Census Report of 1872, page 109, of the appendix, gives the percentage of population according to age as follows :—

TBL-045 · FOLIO 208Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Males.Females.
Not exceeding 12 Years.Above 12 Years.Not exceeding 12 Years.Above 12 Years.
18·831·315·734·2The Census of the N. W. Provinces gives nearly the same result. Above 12 years’ adults, 64·4 per cent. ; under 12, 35·6 per cent. (see Administration Report for 1871-72, page 55 ; Census Report, vol. I, page 31).

The total adults, that is, above 12 years, are 65·5 per cent., and infants or children under 12 years 34·5 per cent., which gives the proportion of 2 adults to each child, or 1 child to every 3 persons.

From taking the cost of adults per head to be a, and cost of the mass per head to be x, and supposing that, out of 34 per cent. of children under 12, only 17 per cent. cost any thing, say one-half of the adult (though the Bengal provision is half for children from two to ten years), while the other 17 cost nothing at all, the problem will be—

66a + 17a2 + 17 × 0 = 100x

x = 74½a100, or say 75a100 or ¾a, i. e., the cost outside jail, or for the whole mass per head, will be about three-fourths of inside the jail, allowing the jail for adults only. Thus, taking the cost of 3 persons in the jail, or of 3 adults, to 4 persons outside, or of the mass, it comes to this :—

TBL-046 · FOLIO 209Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Production per Head.Three-fourths of Jail Cost of Living, or Cost per head outside Jail.
Central Provinces ... ... ...Rs. 21½ or say Rs. 22Rs. 23
Punjab ... ... ... „ 24¾ „ „ 25„ 20
North-West Provinces ... ... „ 17¾ „ „ 18„ 16
Madras ... ... ... ... „ 17¾ „ „ 18„ 41
Bengal ... ... ... ... „ 18¾ „ „ 19„ 23-12
Bombay ... ... ... ... „ 39¾ „ „ 40„ 35
Oudh ... ... ... ... „ 17¾ „ „ 18

It will be seen, from a comparison of the above figures, that, even for such food and clothing as a criminal obtains, there is hardly enough of production even in a good season, leaving alone all little luxuries, all social and religious wants, all expenses of occasions of joy and sorrow, and any provision for bad season. It must, moreover, be borne in mind that every poor labourer does not get the full share of the average pro_ duction. The high and middle classes get a much larger share, the poor classes much less, while the lowest cost of living is generally above the average share.

Such appears to be the condition of the masses of India. They do not get enough to provide the bare necessaries of life.

On the subject of necessary consumption, I shall be very glad if some members of this Association, or others who possess or can ascertain the necessary information, will supply it, as I have not been able to make such minute and extended enquiries myself as I could wish.

DEFICIT OF IMPORTS COMPARED WITH THE EXPORTS OF INDIA.

The total imports and exports of the United Kingdom for the years 1858 to 1870 are—

TBL-047 · FOLIO 210Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Imports£3,608,216,242 (including Bullion)
Exports£2,875,027,301 ( " " )

This shows an excess of imports over exports of £733,188,941, i. e., the imports are above 25 per cent. greater than the exports.

This excess is to be increased to the extent of about £125,000,000, the balance of loans to India included in the exports, less interest on these loans included in imports of about £60,000,000, and by such further amounts as may be made up by balances of loans and interests with foreign parts. As England is the greatest lending country in the world, the ultimate result of excess of commercial imports over commercial exports will most probably be above, rather than under, £733,000,000, or 25 per cent. of exports. At all events, it will not be less than 15 per cent.

For British North America, the total imports and exports, including bullion, for the years 1854 to 1868, are—

TBL-048 · FOLIO 210Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Imports£200,257,620
Exports£154,900,367

This shows an excess of imports over exports of £45,357,253, i. e., the imports are about 29 per cent. more than the exports, subject to a modification of the extent to which it has received from, or given loan to, foreign parts. As far as I can see, it is a borrower, and the excess to that extent will be lesser.

For Australia, the total imports and exports, including bullion, for the years 1854 to 1868, are:—

TBL-049 · FOLIO 210Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Imports£443,407,019
Exports£384,503,081

The excess of imports over exports is therefore £58,903,938, i. e. the imports are 15 per cent. more than the exports, subject to modification, as in the case of British North America, for its foreign debt. These figures show that the normal condition of the foreign commerce of any country is generally such that for its exports there is always a return in imports equal to the exports, plus profits. On an average, commercial profits may be taken at 20 per cent. Indian merchants generally insure by sailing vessels 25 per cent. more, and by steamers 15 per cent., for profits, as by steamers the same capital may be turned over oftener. If I take general commercial profits as 15 per cent., I shall be quite under the mark.

Now we must see what the case is with India. The exports of India for the years 1835 to 1872 being about £1,120,000,000, the imports, with an addition of 15 per cent. to exports for profits (of about £168,000,000), should be about £1,288,000,000. Besides this, India has incurred to foreign parts a debt of about £50,000,000 for the public debt, and about £100,000,000 for railways, during the same period.

Now, on the other hand, in return for the exports, plus profits, of £1,288,000,000, and £150,000,000, of the loans, India has actually imported, during the last 38 years, from 1835 to 1872 (not, as would be the case in a normal condition, £1,430,000,000, but) only about £943,000,000, leaving a balance of about £500,000,000, which England has kept back as its benefit, chiefly arising from the political position it holds over India. This is without including any interest at all. Towards this drain, the net opium revenue contributed by China amounts to about £141,000,000. The balance, of about £360,000,000, is derived from India's own produce and profits of commerce. The profits of commerce are, say, about £168,000,000. Allowing, then, the whole opium revenue and the whole profit of commerce as having gone towards the drain, there is still a deficiency of nearly £200,000,000, which must have gone out of the produce of the country. Deducting from this £200,000,000 the interest on railway loans remitted to England, the balance still sent from the very produce of the country is about £144,000,000. Strictly speaking, the whole £200,000,000 should be considered as a drain from the very produce of the country, because it is the exhaustion caused by the drain that disables us from building our railroads, &c., from our own means. If we did not suffer the exhaustion we do, and even then if we found it to our benefit to borrow from England, the case would be one of a healthy natural business, and the interest then remitted would have nothing to be deplored in it, as in the case of other countries, which, being young, or with undeveloped resources, and without much means of their own, borrow from others, and increase their own wealth thereby, as Australia, Canada, the United States, or any other native-ruled country that so borrows. However, as matters stand at present, we are thankful for the railway loan, for in reality that, though as a loan (with the profits during the American War), has revived us a little. But we are sinking fast again. Allowing for the railway interest as a mere matter of business, and analysing the deficit of imports, or drain to England, as only about £453,000,000, the following is the yearly average for every five years :—

TBL-050 · FOLIO 212Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Years.Yearly Average. £
1835 to 18395,347,000
1840 „ 18445,930,000
1845 „ 18497,760,000
1850 „ 18547,458,000
1855 „ 18597,730,000
1860 „ 186417,300,000
1865 „ 186924,600,000
1870 „ 187227,400,000

Now, can it be shown by anybody that the production during these 38 years has been such as to leave the same amount per head every year, and surplus besides to make up the above £200,000,000 taken away from the produce of the country, in addition to opium revenue and profits of commerce ? In that case it will be that India is no better off now, but is only in the same condition as in 1834. If it can be shown that the production of the country has been such as to be the same per head during all these years, and a surplus greater than £200,000,000 besides, then will it be that any material benefit has been derived by India to the extent of such excess of surplus over £200,000,000. It must, however, be remembered that, in the years about 1834, the condition of the people had already gone down very low by the effects of the previous deficits, as will be seen further on from the official opinions I have given there.

The benefit to England by its connection with India must not be measured by the £500,000.000 only during the last 38 years. Besides this the industries of England receive large additional support for supplying all European stores which Government need, and all those articles which Europeans want in India from their habits and customs, not from mere choice, as may be the case with natives. All the produce of the country, thus exported from sheer necessity, would otherwise have brought returns suitable to native wants, or would have remained in the country, in either case, to the benefit of the produce or industry of India. Be it clearly borne in mind that all this additional benefit to English industries is entirely independent of, and in addition to, the actual deficit between the export plus profits and imports. Everything I allude to is already included in the imports It is so much additional capital drawn away, whether India will or no, from the industry of India to the benefit of English industry. There is again, the further legitimate benefit to England of the profits of English firms there carrying on commerce with India, the profits of the shipping trade, and insurance. The only pity—and a very great one too—is that the commerce between England and India is not so large as it should and can be, the present total exports of India to all the outside world being only about 5s. a head, while the exports of the United Kingdom are about £6 10s. a head, of British North America about £3 a head, and of Australia about £19 a head, including gold (and exclusive of gold about £11 a head). Again, what are imports into India from the United Kingdom, including treasure, Government stores of every kind, railway and other stores, articles for European consumption, and everything for native consumption and use ? Only less than 3s. a head, as below :—

1868.. £31,629,315 1869...£35,309,973 1870...£30,357,055 1871...£28,826,264 — Say £32,000,000, on an average, for a population of about 225,000,000, or less than 3s. a head.

What a vast field there is for English commerce in India ! Only £1 a head will be equal to nearly the whole . present exports of the United Kingdom to all parts of the world. There is one further circumstance against British-Indian subjects, which will show the actual drain from the produce of the country of more than £200,000,000 as borne by British India. The exports from India do not all belong to British India; a portion belongs to the Native States. These States naturally get back their imports equal to their exports, plus profits— less only the tribute they pay to British India, of only about £720,000 altogether per annum, of which even a portion is spent in their own States. No account can I take here of the further loss to India (by famines) of life and property, which is aggravated by the political exhaustion. It is complained that England is at the mercy of India for its loan of some £200,000,000, but let it be borne in mind that, within the next few years, that sum will have been drawn by England while India will continue to have its debt over its head.

The figures of the deficit previous to 1834 I cannot get. I hope the India Office would prepare a table similar to this for this previous period, in order that it may be ascertained how India had fared materially under British rule altogether.

The effect of the deficit is not equally felt by the different presidencies. Bengal suffers less than the others on account of its permanent settlement. I do not mean that as any objection to such settlement, but I state it merely as a fact.

The Court of Directors, in the year 1858, deliberately put forth before the Parliament and public of England the statement (Parliamentary Return No. 75 of 1858) that “the great excess of exports above imports is being regularly liquidated in silver.” Now, is it not India’s misfortune that not one man in the India Office pointed out how utterly incorrect, misleading, and mischievous this statement was?

Now, Mr. Laing makes the following statement before the present Finance Committee:—“Question 7660 of 2nd Report—Would it not be correct to state that the difference between the value of the exports from India, and the imports into India, which now amount, I think, to the sum of about £20,000,000, represents the tribute which India annually pays to England? Answer.—No, I think not; I should not call it a tribute when there is a balance of trade of that sort between the two countries. There are many other countries which are in the same condition of exporting considerably more than they import from one particular country, and the balance of trade is adjusted either by other payments which have to be made, or by transactions through third countries, or finally by remittance of bullion.”

First of all, the question was not about India’s commerce with any particular country, but about all its exports and imports. And next, taking his answer as it is, it is altogether incorrect and inapplicable to India, as must be evident from the facts I have already laid before you.

Next comes Mr. Maclean. He is reported to have said before this Committee something to the effect that, if we compare India, for instance, with the United States, which can hardly be called a country that is being drained of its natural wealth, we will find that the excess of exports over imports in the United States is very much greater than the corresponding excess in India. Now, let us see what the facts are. I have prepared a table, and have taken the figures from the year 1795— the earliest I could get. From the totals I have excluded the years 1802-6, 1808-14, 1818-20, because the imports for them are not given, and the years 1863-6 for reasons well known (the American War). The result till 1869 (I cannot get later authentic figures) is not, as Mr. Maclean says, that “the excess of exports over imports in the United States is very much greater than the corresponding excess in India,” but that the excess of imports over exports is about $493,000,000 till 1847, and £43,000,000 from 1848-69, excepting the years I have mentioned above; and if all the necessary modifications from various other circumstances be made, the excess of the imports will be found necessarily much greater. In fact, the United States are no exception to the ordinary laws of political economy, in a country where the rule is a native, and not a foreign, one. I have made up my tables from Parliamentary Returns.

The deficits of £500,000,000 in imports, do not, as I have already explained, show the whole drain; for the English stores, whether Government or private, are all already included in the imports, nor is any interest calculated. With interest, the drain from India would amount to a very high figure.

This drain consists of two elements—first, that arising from the remittances by European officials of their savings, and for their expenditure in England for their various wants both there and in India; from pensions and salaries paid in England; and from Government expen diture in England and India: and the second, that arising from similar rem ittances by non-official Europeans. Over the first we have no control, beyond urging upon our rulers that the present system of administration is a n unnatural one, destructive to India and suicidal for England. For the second, it is in our own hands what its extent should be. It is no blame to these European gentlemen for coming here to seek their fortunes—and in fact we had need for them to some extent; but if we are blind to our own national interests and necessities, and if we do not support, encourage, and preserve in every possible way, every talent, trade, industry, art, or profession among the natives, even at certain sacrifices, the fault is our own, and we deserve to be, and shall be, impoverished. In complaining, therefore, about the vast drain from India, and our growing impoverishment, it must be borne in mind that, for a certain portion of it, we have to thank our own blindness to our national interests, but for a large portion the cause is the present system and policy of Indian administration.

We may draw our own inferences about the effects of the drain, but I give you below official opinions on the subject, from early times to the present day, for each presidency.

Bengal.

Sir John Shore, in 1787, says in his famous minute (appendix to 5th report, Parliamentary Return No. 377 of 1812):—

“129. Secondly, it is a certain fact that the zemindars are almost universally poor. . . . . Justice and humanity calls for this declaration.

“130. . . . I do not, however, attribute this fact to the extortions of our Government, but to the causes which I shall hereafter point out, and which will be found sufficient to account for the effect. I am by no means convinced that the reverse would have taken place if the measure of our exactions had been more moderate.

“131. Thirdly, the Company are merchants, 'as well as sovereigns o the country. In the former capacity they engross its trade, whilst in the latter they appropriate the revenues. The remittances to Europe of revenues are made in the commodities of the country which are purchased by them.

“132. Whatever allowance we may make for the increased industry of the subjects of the State, owing to the enhanced demand for the produce of it (supposing the demand to be enhanced), there is reason to conclude that the benefits are more than counterbalanced by evils inseparable from the system of a remote foreign dominion.

“135. Every information, from the time of Bernier to the acquisition of the Dewani, shows the internal trade of the country, as carried on between Bengal and the upper parts of Hindustan, the Gulf of Moros the Persian Gulf, and the Malabar Coast, to have been very considerable. Returns of specie and goods were made through these channel, by that of the foreign European companies, and in gold direct for opium from the eastward.

“136. But from the year 1765 the reverse has taken place. The Company's trade produces no equivalent returns, specie is rarely imported by the foreign companies, nor brought into Bengal from other parts of Hindustan in any considerable quantities.

“141. If we were to suppose the internal trade of Hindustan again revived, the export of the production of the country by the Company must still prevent those returns which trade formerly poured in. This is an evil inseparable from a European government.”

Page 194.—“A large proportion of the rents of the country are paid into the Company's treasury, and the manufactures are applied to remit to England the surplus which remains after discharging the claims on this Government, and to augment the commerce and revenue of Great Britain.”

Lord Cornwallis' minute on land settlements, dated 10th February 1790, says:—“The consequence of the heavy drain of wealth from the above causes (viz., large annual investment to Europe, assistance to the treasury of Calcutta, and to supply wants of other presidencies), with the addition of that which has been occasioned by the remittances of private fortunes, have been for many years past, and are now, severely felt, by the great diminution of the current specie, and by the languor which has thereby been thrown upon the cultivation and the general commerce of the country.”

The East India Company, on finding the provinces of Bengal and Behar continuously deteriorating, caused a long and minute survey of the condition of the people. This survey extended over nine years, from 1807 to 1860. The reports, however, lay buried in the archives of the India House, till Mr. Montgomery Martin brought them to light. He sums up the result of these official minute researches in the following remarkable words (vol. I., page 11):—“It is impossible to avoid remarking two facts as peculiarly striking—first, the richness of the country surveyed ; and second, the poverty of its inhabitants.”

Before proceeding further, I must first say that the drain to which these great men have referred was much less than at present. I give the figures in Mr. Martin's words (page 12):—“The annual drain of £3,000,000 on British India has amounted in 30 years, at 12 per cent. (the usual Indian rate) compound interest, to the enormous sum of £723,900,000 sterling. . . So constant and accumulating a drain, even in England, would soon impoverish her. How severe, then, must be its effects on India, where the wage of a labourer is from two-pence to three-pence a day?”

In volume III., page 4, &c., alluding to the nine years' survey, Mr. Martin says that the obscurity to which such a survey was consigned was to be deplored, “and can only be accounted for by supposing that it was deemed impolitic to publish to the world so painful a picture of human poverty, debasement, and wretchedness”; and Mr. Martin draws many other painful conclusions.

Coming down to later times, Mr. Frederick John Shore, of the Bengal Civil Service, has left us the following account of the condition of the people in 1837 (vol. II., page 28) :—" But the halcyon days of India are over; she has been drained of a large proportion of the wealth she once possessed, and her energies have been cramped by a sordid system of misrule to which the interests of millions have been sacrificed for the benefit of the few." " The gradual impoverishment of the people and country, under the mode of rule established by the British Government, has" &c. &c. . . . . . . . .

" The English Government has effected the impoverishment of the country and people to an extent almost unparalleled."

For the manner in which the cotton industry of India was destroyed, see note at page 37 of the same volume. In his concluding remarks (vol. II., page 516), Mr. Shore says:—" More than seventeen years have elapsed since I first landed in this country ; but on my arrival, and during my residence of about a year in Calcutta, I well recollect the quiet, comfortable, and settled conviction, which in those days existed in the minds of the English population, of the blessings conferred on the natives of India by the establishment of the English rule. Our superiority to the native Governments which we have supplanted; the excellent system for the administration of justice which we had introduced; our moderation ; our anxiety to benefit the people—in short, our virtues of every description—were descanted on as so many established truths, which it was heresy to controvert. Occasionally I remember to have heard some hints and assertions of a contrary nature from some one who had spent many years in the interior of the country; but the storm which was immediately raised and thundered on the head of the unfortunate individual who should presume to question the established creed, was almost sufficient to appal the boldest.

" Like most other young men who had no opportunities of judging for themselves, it was but natural that I should imbibe the same notions ; to which may be added, the idea of universal depravity of the people, which was derived from the same source."

After stating how his transfer to a remote district brought him into intimate contact with natives, how he found them disaffected towards British rule, and how this conviction in spite of himself was irresistible, he says :—" This being the case, an attempt to discover the reasons for such sentiments on the part of the native population, was the natural result. Well-founded complaints of oppression and extortion, on the part of both Government and individuals, were innumerable. The question then was, why, with all our high professions, were not such evils redressed? This, however, I was assured, was impossible under the existing system; and I was thus gradually led to an enquiry into the principles and practice of the British-Indian administration. Proceeding in this, I soon found myself at no loss to understand the feelings of the people both towards our Government and to ourselves. It would have been astonishing indeed had it been otherwise. The fundamental principle of the English had been to make the whole Indian nation subservient, in every possible way, to the interests and benefits of themselves. They have been taxed to the utmost limit; every successive province, as it has fallen into our possession, has been made a field for higher exaction; and it has always been our boast how greatly we have raised the revenue above that which th e native rulers were able to extort. The Indians have been excluded from every honor, dignity, or office which the lowest Englishman could be prevailed upon to accept.

“Had the welfare of the people been our object, a very different course would have been adopted, and very different results would have followed; for again and again I repeat it, there is nothing in the circumstance itself, of our being foreigners of different colour and faith, that should occasion the people to hate us. We may thank ourselves for having made their feelings towards us what they are.”

In vol. I., page 162, Mr. Shore says:— “The ruin of the upper classes (like the exclusion of the people from a share in the government) was a necessary consequence of the establishment of the British power; but had we acted on a more liberal plan, we should have fixed our authority on a much more solid foundation.”

Colonel Marriot, at the East India Association meeting in July last, referring to Bengal, said:—“But he had no doubt that he accurately quoted the words of the present Lieutenant-Governor of Bengal in saying that the mass of the population is probably poorer, and in a lower social position, than any in India.”

The “Material and Moral Progress” for 1871-2 (page 100) says that “the Calcutta missionary conference had dwelt on the miserable and abject condition of the Bengal ryots, and there is evidence that they suffer many things, and are often in want of absolute necessaries.”

Bombay.

Mr. Saville Marriot, ‘one of the Commissioners of Revenue in the Deccan,’ and afterwards a member of council, says in 1836, in his letter to Sir R. Grant:—“You will readily conceive that my opinions are the result rather of practical experience than deductions drawn from scientific views. . . . . . . . . .”

“For many years past I have, in common with many others, painfully witnessed their decline [the peoples]; and more especially that part of the community which has emphatically been styled the ‘sinews of the State’—the peasantry of India. It is not a single, but a combination of causes, which has produced this result. Some of these are, and have been from the beginning, obvious to those who have watched with attention the development of the principles of our rule in relation to such as have been superseded, become blended with our system, or are opposed to it in practical effect. Others are less apparent, and some complex; whilst another class of the decline may possibly be involved in obscurity.

“It is a startling but too notorious a fact, that though loaded with a vastly greater absolute amount of taxation, and harassed by various severe acts of tyranny and oppression, yet the country was in a state of prosperity under the native rule when compared with that into which it has fallen under the avowedly mild sway of British administration. Though, in stating the subject, I have used the expression ‘a vastly greater absolute amount of taxation,’ yet I would beg to be understood as being fully aware those terms must be treated in a qualified sense, since it is manifest that, relatively viewed, a smaller numerical amount of taxation may, with reference to the means of payment, be, in point of fact, more burdensome than a much larger one where the resources are more adequate to the object. But, in the particular case in point, it is, I believe, ability which has diminished; and that, too, to many grades below the proportionate fall in the pecuniary amount of fiscal demand. To the pecuniary injurious result are also to be added the many unfavorable circumstances inseparable for a time from a foreign rule. In elucidation of the position that this country is verging to the lowest ebb of pauperism, I would adduce a fact pregnant with considerations of the most serious importance, namely, that of late years a large portion of the public revenue has been paid by encroachment upon the capital of the country, small though that capital is in itself. I allude to the property of the peasantry, which consists of personal ornaments of the precious metals and jewels, convertible, as occasions require, to profitable purposes, and accommodations in agricultural pursuit, most frequently in the shape of pawn, till the object has been attained. I feel certain that an examination would establish that a considerable share of this and other property, even to cattle and household utensils, has been for ever alienated from its proprietors to make good the public revenue. In addition to this lamentable evidence of poverty, is another of equal force, to be seen in all parts of the country, in the numerous individuals of the above class of the community wandering about for the employment of hirelings, which they are glad to obtain even for the most scanty pittance. In short, almost everything forces the conviction that we have before us a narrowing progress to utter pauperism."*

Mr. Marriot in another place (page 11) says:—"Most of the evils of our rule in India arise directly from, or may be traced to, the heavy tribute which that country pays to England."

And with regard to this tribute, he quotes the Chairman of a Court of Proprietors held on the 28th February 1845, as follows:—"India paid to the mother-country, in the shape of home charges, what must be considered the annual tribute of £3,000,000 sterling; and daily poured into the lap of the mother-country a continual stream of wealth in the shape of private fortunes." To this should be added all earnings of Europeans, except what they spent in India for Indian supplies; which would show that there is something far beyond even private fortunes which is continuously poured into the lap of England.

Mr. Marriot goes on to say :—"It will be difficult to satisfy the mind that any country could bear such a drain upon its resources without sustaining very serious injury. And the writer entertains the fullest conviction that investigation would effectually establish the truth of the proposition as applicable to India. He has himself most painfully witnessed it in those parts of the country with which he was connected, and he has every reason to believe that the same evil exists, with but slight modification, throughout our Eastern empire."

Again says Mr. Marriot (page 17):—"A different state of things exists in the present day on that point; and, though the people still, and gratefully so, acknowledge the benefits they have derived from the suppression of open violence, yet they emphatically and unanswerably refer their increasing penury as evidencing the existence of a canker-worm that is working their destruction. The sketch which I have given shows a distressing state of things; but lamentable as it may appear, I would pledge myself to establish the facts advanced, and that the representation is not overdrawn."

Mr. Robert Knight says:—"Mr. Giberne, after an absence of fourteen years from Guzerat, returned to it, as judge, in 1840. 'Everywhere'— he told the Commons' Committee on Cotton Cultivation in 1848—'he remarked deterioration,' and 'I did not see so many of the more wealthy classes of the natives. The aristocracy, when we first had the country, used to have their gay carts, horses, and attendants, and a great deal of finery about them, and there seems to be an absence of all that. . The ryots all complain that they had had money once, but they had none now.'"

In a private letter, dated 1849, 'written by a gentleman high in the Company's service,' and quoted in a pamphlet in 1851, the decay of Guzerat is thus described:—"Many of the best families in the province, who were rich and well to-do when we came into Guzerat in 1807, have now scarcely clothes to their backs. . . . . . .

Our demands in money on the talookdars are more than three times what they originally paid, without one single advantage gained on their parts. Parties, from whom they have been compelled to borrow at ruinous rates of interest, enforced their demands by attachment of their lands and villages; thus they sink deeper and deeper in debt, without the chance of extricating themselves. What, then, must become of their rising family?'"*

Lieutenant A. Nash, after giving a table of the prices of grain from 1809 to 1838 in Indapore (Bombay Government Selections, No. 107, New Series, page 118), says:—"The table is chiefly interesting in showing the gradual diminution in the price of corn from the days of the Peishwas to our own. By comparing the prices at the commencement with those at the end of the table, and then reading the list over, this circumstance will become apparent." I give this table in my notes on prices. its relations with England. Millions are drained to England ; and till the reversing cause of the retaining and return of wealth in some way does not come into operation, the evils of the drain cannot be remedied. And what is the condition of a labourer now ? Here is the Punjab Government’s own answer in the administration report for 1867-8 (page 88). After stating the rates of unskilled labour as ranging from two annas (three-pence) to five annas (seven and a half pence) per diem and alluding to a considerable rise in rates in places affected by the railway and other public works, where labour in any shape commands higher remuneration than formerly, the report says :—“ It may be doubted whether the position of the unskilled labouring classes has materially improved.”

North-West Provinces.

Colonel Baird Smith’s report on the famines of the North-West Provinces (Parliamentary Return No. 29 of 1862), referring to the famine of 1837, says :—Page 57.—“ From the time of our earliest acquisition of any part of these up to 1833, our fiscal system, notwithstanding some improvements on the native method which were gradually introduced, had been thoroughly bad.” Page 59.—“ Speaking in general terms, therefore, native society in the N. W. Provinces had to face the calamity in 1837, debilitated by a fiscal system that was oppressive and depressing in its influence. · · · In India we all know very well that when the agricultural class is weak, the weakness of all other sections of the community is the inevitable consequence.”

I have not come across Mr. Halsey’s report on the assessment of Cawnpore, but I take an extract from one given in the Bombay Gazette Summary of 21st June 1872, page 12:—“ I assert that the abject poverty of the average cultivator of this district is beyond the belief of any one who has not seen it. He is simply a slave to the soil, to the zemindar, to the usurer, and to Government. · · · I regret to say that, with these few exceptions, the normal state of between three-fourths and four-fifths of the cultivators of this district is as I have above shown. It may appear to many to be exaggerated, and, from the nature of the case, it is of course impossible to produce figures in support of it ; nevertheless, it is the result of my personal observations, and I feel confident the result of the whole discussion will be to prove I have not overstated the truth.”

The figures I have given of the total produce of the North-West Provinces proves by fact what Mr. Halsey gives as his observations Hardly 27s. per head—say even 30s.—cannot but produce the result he sees.

Central Provinces.

Here is the latest testimony about the people. Mr. W. G. Pedder says*:—"Who [the people], if an almost universal concensus of opinion may be relied on, are rapidly going from bad to worse under our rule, is a most serious question, and one well deserving the attention of Government."

Lastly to sum up the whole, here is Sir John Lawrence (Lord Lawrence) testifying so late as 1864 about all India:—"India is, on the whole, a very poor country; the mass of the population enjoy only a scanty subsistence." And Lord Mayo, on the 3rd March 1871, says, in his speech in the Legislative Council:—"I admit the comparative poverty of this country, as compared with many other countries of the same magnitude and importance, and I am convinced of the impolicy and injustice of imposing burdens upon this people which may be called either crushing or oppressive.

"Mr. Grant Duff, in an able speech which he delivered the other day in the House of Commons, the report of which arrived by last mail, stated, with truth, that the position of our finance was wholly different from that of England. ‘In England,’ he stated, ‘you have a comparatively wealthy population. The income of the United Kingdom has, I believe, been guessed at £800,000,000 per annum; the income of British India has been guessed at £300,000,000 per annum. That gives well on to £30 per annum as the income of every person in the United Kingdom, and only £2 per annum as the income of every person in British India.

"I believe that Mr. Grant Duff had good grounds for the statement he made, and I wish to say with reference to it, that we are perfectly cognizant of the relative poverty of this country as compared with European States."

So here is a clear admission by high authorities of what I had urged in my paper on the "Wants and Means of India," and what I now urge, that India's production was only about 40s. a head.

And now in the year 1873, before the Finance Committee, Lord Lawrence repeats his conviction that the mass of the people of India are so miserably poor that they have barely the means of subsistence. It is as much as a man can do to feed his family or half feed them, let alone spending money on what may be called luxuries or conveniences. Mr. Grant Duff asked Mr. Lawson, so late as in May 1870, in the House of Commons, whether he meant to "grind an already poor population to the very dust."

The following picture about England itself under similar circumstances, may, I hope, enable the British people to realize our condition. The parallel is remarkable, and the picture in certain portions life-like of the present state of India. Draper's "Intellectual Development of Europe," 5th edition:—Page 365.—"In fact, through the operation of the Crusades, all Europe was tributary to the Pope (Innocent III.) • • • • • • • • A steady drain of money from every realm. Fifty years after the time of which we are speaking, Robert Grostale, the Bishop of Lincoln and friend of Roger Bacon, caused to be ascertained the amount received by foreign ecclesiastics in England. He found it to be thrice the income of the king himself. This was on the occasion of Innocent IV. demanding provision to be made for three hundred additional Italian clergy by the Church of England; and that one of his nephews—a mere boy—should have a stall in Lincoln Cathedral." Page 397.—"In England—for ages a mine of wealth to Rome—the tendency of things was shown by such facts as the remonstrances of the Commons with the Crown on the appointment of ecclesiastics to all the great offices, and the allegations made by the 'Good Parliament' as to the amount of money drawn by Rome from the kingdom. They asserted that it was five times as much as the taxes levied by the king, and that the Pope's revenue from England was greater than the revenue of any prince in Christendom." Page 434.—"It is manifest by legal enactments early in the fourteenth century. • • • • • By the Parliamentary bill of 1376, setting forth that the tax paid in England to the Pope for ecclesiastical dignities is fourfold as much as that coming to the king from the whole realm; that alien clergy, who have never seen, nor cared to see, their flocks, convey away the treasure of the country." Page 477.—"The inferior, unreflecting orders were in all directions exasperated by its importunate unceasing exactions of money. In England for instance, though less advanced intellectually than the southern nations, the commencement of the Reformation is perhaps justly referred as far back as the reign of Edward III., who, under the suggestion of Wickliffe, refused to do homage to the Pope; but a series of weaker princes succeeding, it was not until Henry VII. that the movement could be continued. In that country, the immediately existing causes were, no doubt, of a material kind, such as the alleged avarice and impurity of the clergy, the immense amount of money taken from the realm, the intrusion of foreign ecclesiastics." Page 478. —"As all the world had been drained of money by the Senate and Cæsars for the support of republican or imperial power, so there was a need of like supply for the use of the pontiffs. The collection of funds had often given rise to contentions between the ecclesiastical and temporal authorities, and in some of the more sturdy countries had been resolutely resisted."

The result of this drain from England to Italy was the condition of the people, as pictured at pages 494-5, than which nothing could be more painful. Mr. Draper says :—" For many of the facts I have now to mention, the reader will find authorities in the works of Lord Macaulay, and Mr. Froude on English History. My own reading in other directions satisfies me that the picture here offered represents the actual condition of things.

" There were forests extending over great districts ; fens forty or fifty miles in length, reeking with miasma and fever, though round the walls of the abbeys there might be beautiful gardens, green lawns, shady walks, and many murmuring streams. The peasant's cabin was made of reeds, or sticks, plastered over with mud. His fire was chimneyless—often it was made of peat. In the objects and manner of his existence, he was but a step above the industrious beaver who was building his dam in the adjacent stream. Vermin in abundance in the clothing and beds. The common food was peas, vetches, fern-roots, and even the bark of trees. The population, sparse as it was, was perpetually thinned by pestilence and want. Nor was the state of the townsman better than that of the rustic ; his bed was a bag of straw, with a fair round log for his pillow. It was a melancholy social condition when nothing intervened between reed cabins in the fen, the miserable wigwams of villages, and the conspicuous walls of the castle and the monastery. Rural life had but little improved since the time of Cæsar ; in its physical aspect it was altogether neglected.

"England, at the close of the age of faith, had for long been a chief pecuniary tributary to Italy, the source from large revenues have been drawn, the fruitful field in which herds of Italian ecclesiastics had been pastured. · · At the beginning of the sixteenth century, the island was far more backward, intellectually and politically, than is commonly supposed."

We see, then, to what condition the people of England were reduced under the Italian drain. India cannot but share the same fate under similar causes, unless England, as she sincerely means to do, adopts the necessary precautions and remedies to prevent such results.

Before I close the subject of the drain and its consequences, I direct your attention to a few facts connected with the subject of railways, and such other useful public works. You are well aware that I strongly desire these works, but I cannot shut my eyes to the following facts :—

America, for instance, requires money to build a railway, takes a loan and builds it—and everybody knows it is immensely benefited. I need not read to you a chapter on political economy why it is so. I need only say every man employed in the construction of that railway is an American ; every farthing, therefore, that is spent out of the loan remains in the country. In the working of the railway, every man is an American ; every farthing taken out of the produce of the country for its conveyance remains in the country ; so whatever impetus is given to the production of the country, and increase made in it, is fully enjoyed by the country paying, out of such increase in its capital and production, the interest of the loan, and in time the loan itself. Under such ordinary economical circumstances, a country derives great benefit from the help of loans from other countries. In India, in the construction of the railroad, a large amount of the loan goes towards the payment of Europeans, a portion of which, as I have explained before, goes out of the country. Then again, in the working of the railway, the same drawback, leaving therefore hardly any benefit at all to India itself, and the whole interest of the loan must also go out of the country. So our condition is a very anomalous one—like that of a child to which a fond parent gives a sweet, but to which, in its exhausted condition, the very sweet acts like poison, and as a foreign substance by irritating the weak stomach makes it throw out more, and causes greater exhaustion. In India's present condition, the very sweets of every other nation appear to act on it as poison. With this continuous and ever increasing drain by innumerable channels, as our normal condition at present, the most well-intentioned acts of Government become disadvantageous. Sir Richard Temple clearly understands this phenomenon, as I have already shown. But, somehow or other, he seems to have now forgotten what he so clearly pointed out a score of years ago. Many a time, in discussing with English friends the question of the material drain generally, and the above remarks on railways, irrigation-works, &c., I found it a very difficult task to convince. Fortunately, a great authority enunciates the fundamental principles very clearly and convincingly, and I give them below, hoping that an authority like that of the late Mr. Mill, will, on economical principles especially, command attention.

I give a few short extracts from Mill's 'Political Ecomony,' chapter V. :—

“Industry is limited by capital.”

“To employ industry on the land is to apply capital to the land.”

“Industry cannot be employed to any greater extent than there is capital to invest.”

“There can be no more industry than is supplied by materials to work up, and food to eat. Yet, in regard to a fact so evident, it was long continued to be believed that laws and governments, without creating capital, could create industry.”

“While, on the one hand, industry is limited by capital, so on the other every increase of capital gives or is capable of giving, additional employment to industry, and this without assignable limit.”

“A second fundamental theorem respecting capital relates to the source from which it is derived. It is the result of saving. All capital, and especially all addition to capital, are the result of saving.”

“What supports and employs productive labour is the capital expended in setting it to work and not the demand of purchasers for the produce of the labour when completed. Demand for commodities s not demand for labour.”

“The demand for commodities determines in what particular branch of production the labour and capital shall be employed. It determines the direction of labour, but not the more or less of the labour itself, or of the maintenance or payment of the labour. These depend on the amount of the capital, or other funds directly devoted to the sustenance and remuneration of labour.”

“This theorem—that to purchase produce is not to employ labour; that the demand for labour is constituted by the wages which precede the production, and not by the demand which may exist for the commodities resulting from the production—is a proposition which greatly needs all the illustration it can receive. It is to common apprehension ‘a paradox.”

These principles applied to the particular case of India, amount to this :—Poor India has not even to support its absolute want, even were the whole production employed in supporting labour. But as this is not the case,—as there must be some portion of the produce consumed unproductively in luxuries,—the share for the support of labour for reproduction becomes still more scanty ; saving, and therefore addition to capital, being altogether out of the question. Moreover, not only is there no saving at the present rate of production, but there is actual continuous yearly abstraction from this scanty production. The result is an additional evil consequence in the capability of labour deteriorating continuously, for “industry is limited by capital”—so the candle burns at both ends,—capital going on diminishing on the one hand, and labour thereby becoming less capable, on the other, to reproduce as much as before. The last theorem of Mill is a clear answer to those who say that, because the railways open up a market for the commodities, the produce of the country must increase. I need only repeat the “demand for commodities is not demand for labour,” and that “industry cannot be employed to any greater extent than there is capital to invest.”

If these principles are fairly borne in mind, and the element of the drain from India fairly considered, the gradual impoverishment of India, under the existing system of administration, will cease to appear a paradox.

The Moral Drain.

Beyond the positions of deputy-collectors or extra-commissioners, or similar subordinate positions in the Engineering, Medical, and all other services (with a very few somewhat better exceptions), all experience and knowledge of statesmanship, of administration or legislation, of high scientific or learned professions, are drained away to England, when the persons possessing them give up their service and retire to England.

The result, in Sir T. Munro’s words, is this :—“The consequence of the conquest of India by British arms would be, in place of raising, to debase the whole people.”—(Life of Sir T. Munro, page 466, quoted in Mr. Torrens’ “Empire in Asia.”) For every European employed beyond absolute necessity, each native capable of filling the same position is displaced in his own country. All the talent and nobility of intellect and soul, which nature gives to every country, is to India a lost treasure. There is, thus, a triple evil—loss of wealth, wisdom, and work to India—under the present system of administration. Whether the power of education which the British rulers are raising with the glorious object of raising the people of India, and which is day by day increasing, shall be a bulwark or weakness hereafter to the British rule, is a question of great importance. As matters stand at present, in the words of Sir Bartle Frere—"And now, wherever I go, I find the best exponents of the policy of the English Government, and the most able coadjutors in adjusting that policy to the peculiarities of the natives of India, among the ranks of the educated natives." Of the future who can say? It lies in the hands of our rulers whether this power they are raising shall continue to be their "coadjutor," or become their opponent. The merit or fault will be entirely their own.

Sir J. Malcolm says :—"We are not warranted by the History of India, nor indeed by that of any other nation in the world, in reckoning upon the possibility of preserving an empire of such a magnitude by a system which excludes, as ours does, the natives from every station of high rank and honorable ambition. Least of all would such a system be compatible with the plans now in progress for spreading instruction. . . . . . If we do not use the knowledge which we impart, it will be employed against us. . . We find in all communities, bold, able and ambitious individuals who exercise an influence and power over the class to which they belong, and these must continue enemies to a Government, however just and humane in its general principles, under which they are neither trusted nor employed.

. . High and aspiring men can find no spot beyond the limits of our authorities, and such must either be systematically watched and repressed as enemies of our power, or cherished and encouraged as the instruments of its exercise ; there is no medium. In the first case, the more decidedly we proceed to our object, the better for our safety ; but I should, I confess, have little confidence in the success of such a proceeding. As one head of the hydra was lopped off another would arise; and as well might we strive to stem the stream of the Ganges, as to depress to the level of our ordinary rule the energies and hopes which must continually arise in so vast and various a population as that of India."*

. There can be but one conclusion to the present state of affairs—either the people will become debased, as Munro thinks; or dead to all true wisdom, experience, honour, and ambition to serve one's country, or use their knowledge of it against the very hand that gives it. As Sir J. Malcolm observes—"If these plans [of spreading instruction] are not associated with the creation of duties that will employ the minds which we enlighten, we shall only prepare elements that will hasten the destruction of our empire. The moral evil to us does not thus stand alone. It carries with it its Nemesis, the seeds of the destruction of the empire itself."

Pressure of Taxation.

In Lord Mayo's speech of the 3rd March 1871 (Times of India Summary of 8th April 1871), he endeavours to refute the assertion that Indian taxation is ‘crushing.’ His Lordship on this point has made several assumptions which require examination. I shall therefore first consider whether the conclusion drawn is legitimate, and whether all necessary elements of comparison have been taken into account.

I have already shown that the production of India is hardly 40s. a head, and that Lord Mayo has adopted that estimate as being based on good reasons by Mr. Grant Duff. After admitting this fact, Lord Mayo compares the taxation of India with that of some other countries. In doing this, he deducts as land revenue (whether rightly or wrongly will be seen hereafter) the opium, tributes, and other small receipts from Indian taxation, and then compares the balance with the taxation of other countries. I do not know whether he has made similar deductions from the taxation of the latter. The result of his comparison would appear to be that, while India pays only 1s. 10d. per head of taxation per annum, Turkey pays 7s. 9d., Russia 12s. 2d., Spain 18s. 5d., Austria 19s. 7d., and Italy 17s. per head per annum. The conclusion drawn is that the taxation of India is not ‘crushing.’ What idea His Lordship attaches to the word ‘crushing’ I cannot say, but he seems to forget the very first premise that the total production of the country is admitted to be 40s. per head. Now, this amount is hardly enough for the bare necessaries of life, much less can it supply any comforts, or provide any reserve for bad times; so that living from hand to mouth, and that on "scanty subsistence" (in the words of Lord Lawrence), the very touch of famine carries away hundreds of thousands. Is not this in itself as ‘crushing’ to any people as it can possibly be? And yet out of this wretched income they have to pay taxation!

His Lordship has, moreover, left out a very important element from account. He is well aware that whatever revenue is raised by other countries—for instance, the £70,000,000 by England—the whole of it returns back to the people, and remains in the country; and therefore, the national capital, upon which the production of a country depends, does not suffer diminution; while, with India, as I have already shown, the case is quite different. Out of its poor production of 40s. a head, some £25,000,000 go clean out of the country, thereby diminishing its capital and labour for reproduction every year, and rendering the taxation more and more crushing.

I shall now consider what would have been the fairest way of making the comparison of taxation. Every nation has a certain amount of income from various sources, such as production of cultivation, minerals, farming, manufactures, profits of trade, &c. From such total income all its wants are to be supplied. A fair comparison as to the incidence of taxation, will be to see the proportion of the amount which the Government of the country takes for its administration, public debts, &c., to the total income. You may call this amount taxation, revenue, or anything you like; and Government may take it in any shape or way whatsoever it is so much taken from the income of the country for the purposes of Government. In the case of India, whether Government takes this amount as land-tax or opium revenue, or in whatever other form, does not matter, the fact remains that out of the total income of the country, Government raises so much revenue for its purposes which otherwise would have remained with the people.

Taking, therefore, this fair test of the incidence of taxation, the result will be that England raises £70,000,000 out of the national income of some £800,000,000, that is, about 8 per cent., or about £2 10s. per head from an income of about £30 per head; whereas the Indian Government raises £50,000,000 out of the national income of £340,000,000, that is, about 15 per cent., or 6s. per head out of an income of 40s. per head.

Had His Lordship stated the national income and population of the countries with which he has made the comparison, we would have then seen what the percentage of their revenue to their income was, and from how much income per head the people have to pay their 7s. to 19s. 7d. per head of taxation, as quoted by His Lordship.

Further, if, in consequence of a constant drain from India from its poor production, the income of the country continues to diminish, the percentage of taxation to income will be still greater, even though the amount of taxation may not increase. But, as we know the tendency of taxation in India has, during several years, been to go on increasing every year, the pressure will generally become more and more oppressive and crushing, unless our rulers, by proper means, restore India to at least a healthy, if not a wealthy, condition. It must, moreover, be particularly borne in mind that, while a ton may not be any burden to an elephant, a few pounds will crush a child; that the English nation may, from its average income of £30 a head, be able to pay £2 10s. per head, while, to the Indian nation, 6s. out of 40s. may be quite unbearable and crushing. The capacity to bear a burden with ease, or to be crushed by it, is not to be measured by the percentage of taxation, but by the abundance, or otherwise, of the means or income to pay it from. From abundance you may give a large percentage with ease; from sufficiency, the same burden may just be bearable, or some diminution may make it so; but from insufficiency, any burden is so much privation.

But as matters stand, poor India has to pay not the same percentage of taxation to its income as in England, but nearly double; i.e., while England pays only about 8½ per cent. of its national income for the wants of its Government, India has to pay some 15 per cent. of its income for the same purpose; though here that income per head of population is some thirteenth part of that of England, and insufficient in itself for even its ordinary wants, leaving alone the extraordinary political necessity to pay a foreign country for its rule.

Every single ounce of rice, therefore, taken from the “scanty subsistence” of the masses of India, is to them so much starvation, so much more crushing.

Lord Mayo calls the light taxation of the country, which he calculates at 1s. 10d. a head, as a happy state of affairs. But that, in so lightlytaxed a country, to get a 6d. more per head without oppression should tax the highest statesmanship and intelligence without success, is in itself a clear demonstration that there must be something very rotten in the state of India, and that the pressure of taxation must have already arrived short of the proverbial last straw that breaks the camel’s back.

The United Kingdom pay a total revenue of about £2 10s. per head. India’s whole production is hardly £2 a head; it pays a total revenue (less net opium) of hardly 5s. a head, and is unable to pay a shilling more. Why so? Short of only representation, India is governed on the same principles and system as the United Kingdom, and why such extraordinarily different results? Why should one prosper and the other perish, though similarly governed?

I take this opportunity of saying a few words about the recent telegram that Lord Salisbury had instructed the Indian Government to abolish the duties on cottons, as the matter is closely connected with the subject of my paper. The real object, says to-day's Times of India, is to "nip in the bud" the rising factories in India—the ostensible reason assigned is free trade. Now I do not want to say anything about the real selfish objects of the Manchesterians, or what the political necessities of a Conservative Government may be under Manchester pressure. I give credit to the Secretary of State for honesty of purpose, and take the reason itself that is given on this question, viz.—free trade. I like free trade, but after what I have said to-night, you will easily see that free trade between England and India in a matter like this is something like a race between a starving, exhausting invalid and a strong man with a horse to ride on. Free trade between countries which have equal command over their own resources is one thing, but even then the Colonies snapped their fingers at all such talk. But what can India do? Before powerful English interests, India must and does go to the wall. Young colonies, says Mill, may need protection. India needs it in a far larger degree, independent of the needs of revenue, which alone have compelled the retention of the present duties. Let India have its present drain brought within reasonable limits, and India will be quite prepared for any free trade. With a pressure of taxation nearly double in proportion to that of England, from an income of one-fifteenth, and an exhaustive drain besides, we are asked to compete with England in free trade? I pray our great statesmen to pause and consider these circumstances.

Notes

  1. *. The table A is too large for insertion. Summary. Average, Rs. 11-13-5 per acre.
  2. *. The “Agricultural Gazette of India” of the Indian Economist, 15th August 1870, No. 1.
  3. †. See also Parliamentary Return No. 999 of 1853, page 471.
  4. *. 24 Madras measures = 1 Huris Cullum. 133 1/3 Huris Cullum = 1 Madras Garce. (Selection of the Madras Government, No. XIV. of 1869, page 16.)
  5. *. The Statistical Reporter of the Indian Economist of 22nd January 1872 gives a table, on official authority, of the total produce of the Bombay Presidency. The figures given for Rutnagherry are evidently wrong. For 113,296 acres the produce of rice is given as 10,110,964 maunds of 82 lbs., which will be above 7,200 lbs. per acre. The best land may produce as much as 3,000, but 7.200 lbs. is simply out of the question. In the Pardy settlement (Indian Economist of 15th July 1871, page 330) an acre of rice, “in embanked land receiving full supply of water for a crop of rice,” is put down as producing 3,400 lbs. Even in Bengal and Burmah—rice-producing countries—there is no such production as 7,000 lbs. per acre. For the rest of the presidency (excepting Canara), the total produce is given as follows:—
  6. *. Gujerat in Northern Division; the cultivated area is given partly in acres and partly in beegahs. The beegahs are converted into acres, as 1·7 beegahs = 1 acre.
  7. †. Bhagalkote price is taken.
  8. *. Average of Tanna and Alibaug.
  9. †. Price at Dhoolia being not given, I have taken the same with Tanna.
  10. *. The Indian Economist of 15th October 1870, Statistical Reporter, page 45.
  11. *. There are three kinds of dhal—Oorud, Moong, and Toor. I take an average.
  12. †. I don't find price of preserved mutton. I have taken of mutton.
  13. ‡. No price is given for vegetables. I take it the same as dhal.
  14. §. No price of mustard-oil is given. I have taken for teel, which is the cheapest among the four kinds of oil given in the table.
  15. ‖. This is the price of common sea salt, which would require to be taken more than a ¼ oz. to make up for the ¼ oz. of good salt required. Also there is some wastage or loss.
  16. *. Administration Report of Jails for 1871, page 39 of appendix.
  17. †. This appears to be a very large expenditure. Besides, the average is taken on the wrong principle, without taking the number of the prisoners in each district into account. The correct average will be above Rs. 50.
  18. *. Mr. Marriot's pamphlet re-published in 1857, page 13. The italics are mine.
  19. *. Mr. Robert Knight's paper read before the East India Association, 3rd March 1868.
  20. *. Times of India Summary of 6th June 1873.
  21. *. Malcolm's "Government of India," page 174.