I.—India's Interest in the Genenal Election (1886)

Essays, Speeches, Addresses and Writings, Dadabhai Naoroji, 1887 · from page 292 · about 200 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

INDIA'S INTEREST IN THE GENERAL ELECTION (1886).

(Before a meeting of the members of the Bombay Presidency Assiocation, held in the rooms of the Association on Tuesday evening, the 29th September 1885. Mr. (now Sir) Dinsha Maneckji Petit in the chair.)

The Hon. Dadabhai Naoroji proposed :—"That the following candidates, on account of their services and opinions publicly expressed by them on Indian questions, are deserving of the support of the Indian people :—The Right Honourable Mr. John Bright, the Marquis of Hartington, Mr. J. Slagg, Sir J. Phear, Mr. L. Ghose, Mr. W. Digby, Mr. W. S. Blunt, Mr. S. Keay, Mr. S. Laing, Captain Verney, and Mr. W. C. Plowden. That the views regarding Indian questions publicly expressed by the following candidates cannot be approved by the people of India, and these candidates cannot be accepted as representing Indian interests :—Sir Richard Temple, Mr. J. M. Maclean, Mr. A. S. Ayrton, Sir Lewis Pelly, and Sir Roper Lethbridge." He said :—I speak to the motion which is placed in my hands with a deep sense of its importance. Hitherto it has been, and it will be so generally, that the English people can mostly derive their information about India from Anglo-Indians, official and non-official, but chiefly from the former. But there are Anglo-Indians and Anglo-Indians. Some, but their number is small, have used their eyes rightly, have looked beyond the narrow circle of their own office, have sympathised with the natives, and tried to understand them and to find out their true wants and aspirations. Unfortunately the larger number of Anglo-Indians do not take such wide views, or such interest in the natives as would enable them to judge rightly of the actual condition of India. Now when we consider of what extreme importance it is to us that the people of England should have correct information of our condition and wants ; how almost entirely we have to depend upon the people and Parliament of England to make those great reforms which alone can remove the serious evils from which we are suffering, it is no ordinary necessity for us that we should take some steps, by which we may inform the great British public, on which sources of information they could rely with any confidence. As I have said, the number of those who have the necessary true experience and interest in the natives is very small. It is extremely necessary that such should be pointed out by us. We also find that several Englishmen visiting India, as impartial observers, without any bias or prejudices, have often formed a more correct estimate of the position and necessities of India than many an Anglo-Indian of the so-called experience of twenty or thirty years. Even some, who have not been here at all, form fair and just estimates. It is not always that we can approach the British people in a way so as to secure the general attention of the whole nation at the same time. The present occasion of the new elections is one of those rare occasions in which we can appeal to the whole nation, and especially in a way most useful for our purpose. It is in Parliament that our chief battles have to be fought. The election of its members, especially those who profess to speak on Indian matters, requires our earnest attention, and we should point out clearly to the electors, which of those candidates who make India a plank in their credentials, have our confidence. We do not at all intend to influence the electors in any way in matters of their choice of the representatives that suit them best for their local politics. What we desire to impress upon them is, that so far as the important element of the deliberations on Indian questions is concerned, we desire to name those candidates who are deserving of our confidence and support, and on whom we can rely as would fairly and righteously represent our real wants and just rights before Parliament. It is with this object that I ask you to adopt the resolution before you. The first name in our resolution is the bright name of The Right Honourable Mr. John Bright. Now I do not certainly presume that I can say anything, or that our association can do anything that can in the least add to the high position Mr. Bright occupies. What I say, therefore, is not with any view that we give any support to him, but as an expression of our esteem and admiration, and of our gratitude for the warm and righteous interest he has evinced on our behalf. I would not certainly take up your time in telling you what he is and what he has done. His fame and name are familiar to the wide world. I may simply refer to a few matters concerning ourselves. Our great charter is the gracious Pro clamation of the Queen. That proclamation is the very test by which we test friends or foes; and it is Mr. Bright who first proposed and urged the duty and necessity of issuing such a proclamation, at a time when the heads of many were bewildered and lost, in his speech on the India Bill in 1858. I should not tarry long on the tempting subject, for if I went on quoting from Mr. Bright's speeches, to show what he has done more than a quarter of a century ago, asking for us what we have been only latterly beginning to give utterance to, I might detain you for hours. I must, however, give you a few short extracts, showing both the earnestness and the intense sense of justice of the man. "The people of India," he said, "have the highest and strongest claims upon you—claims which you cannot forget—claims which if you do not act upon, you may rely upon it that, if there be a judgment for nations—as I believe there is, as for individuals—our children in no distant generation must pay the penalty which we have purchased by neglecting our duty to the populations of India." In his speech of 1853, on the occasion of the renewal of the E. I. Company's charter, referring to the miserable condition of the masses of India, he said:—"I must say that it is my belief that if a country be found possessing a most fertile soil and capable of bearing every variety of production, and that notwithstanding, the people are in a state of extreme destitution and suffering, the chances are that there is some fundamental error in the government of that country." When, may I ask, will our rulers see this "fundamental error?" I have purposely confined myself to his older utterances so far, that we may fully appreciate the righteous advocacy at a time when our own voice was feeble and hardly heard at all. You will allow me to make one reference to his later words, and you will see how he is yet the same man and the same friend of India. In his "Public Letters," in a letter written by him last year to a gentleman at Calcutta, he says :—" It is to me a great mystery that England should be in the position she now is in relation to India. I hope it may be within the ordering of Providence that ultimately good may arise from it. I am convinced that this can only come from the most just Government which we are able to confer upon your countless millions, and it will always be a duty and a pleasure to me to help forward any measure that may tend to the well-being of your people." The Marquis of Hartington also occupies a position to which we can hardly add anything. But as we have during his State Secretaryship of India observed his disposition towards a due appreciation of and fulfilment of the noble principles of the proclamation, and his emphatic identifying himself with the righteous Ripon policy at a time of crucial trial—during the excitement of the Ilbert Bill—we cannot but take this opportunity of expressing our thanks and our confidence in him. To assure you the more fully of this duty upon us, you will permit me to read a few words on this very topic from his speech of 23rd August, 1883. After pointing out the insufficiency of the administration, and the inability of India to afford more for it, he said :—"If the country is to be better governed, that can only be done by the employment of the best and most intelligent of the natives in the service. There is a further reason, in my opinion, why this policy should be adopted, and that is, that it is not wise to educate the people of India, to introduce among them, your civilization and your progress and your literature, and at the same time to tell them, they shall never have any chance of taking any part or share in the administration of the affairs of their country except by their getting rid, in the first instance, of their European rulers." I cannot refrain myself from expressing my deep regret that we are not able to include in our present list a name that stands pre-eminently high as one of our best friends—I mean Mr. Fawcett. But I trust you will allow me to give a few short extracts, as a warning and a voice from the grave, of one who had the welfare of the poor and dumb millions at heart. Though he is dead his spirit may guide our other friends, and our rulers. I give these extracts as specially bearing on the present disastrous move of imposing a permanent additional annual burden of some two to three crores of rupees upon us, and on the whole Indian problem. With reference to the Afghan policy he said in 1879 :—" It cannot be too strongly insisted upon that in the existing financial condition of India, no peril can be more serious than the adoption of a policy, which, if it should lead to a large additional expenditure, would sooner or later necessitate an increase of taxation. . . The additional taxation which must be the inevitable accompaniment of increased expenditure will bring upon India the gravest perils." Again—"The question, however, as to the exact proportion in which the cost of pursuing a forward policy in Afghanistan should be borne by England and India respectively will have again to be considered anew, now that it has become necessary to renew hostilities in Afghanistan." These words apply with equal force to-day when we are threatened with a large unnecessary additional burden. On the subject of the whole Indian problem, he said:—"Although there is much in the present financial condition of India to cause the most serious apprehension, yet there is one circumstance connected with it which may fairly be regarded as a most hopeful omen for the future. Until quite lately, India was looked upon as an extremely wealthy country, and there was no project, however costly, that India was not supposed to be rich enough to pay for. Now, however, juster ideas of the resources of the country and of the condition of the people prevail. The recurrence of famines. . . . have at length led the English public to take firm hold of the fact that India is an extremely poor country, and that the great mass of her people are in such a state of impoverishment that the Government will have to contend with exceptional difficulties if it becomes necessary to procure increased revenue by additional taxation.” “Without an hour’s delay the fact should be recognised that India is not in a position to pay for various services at their present rate of remuneration. A most important saving might be effected by more largely employing natives in positions which are now filled by highly paid Europeans, and from such a change political as well as financial advantages would result.” “The entire system in which the Government of India is conducted must be changed. The illusion is only just beginning to pass away that India is an extremely wealthy country.” “The financial condition of India is one of such extreme peril that economy is not only desirable but is a matter of imperative necessity.” “No misfortune which could happen to India could be greater than having to make her people bear the burden of increased taxation.” “In order to restore the finances of India and prevent them drifting into hopeless embarrassment, it is absolutely essential that the policy of ‘rigid economy in every branch of the public service’ which has been recently announced by the Government should be carried out with promptitude and thoroughness.” This policy was announced by the Conservative Government, and now all this is forgotten and the Conservative Government are proposing to burden us with additional expenditure of two or three millions, or may be more! We cannot too strongly protest against this. In all the extracts I have read you will perceive the kind of policy which our friends have urged, and this test, or as I may shortly call, the Royal Proclamation policy, is the principal one by which we may discriminate friends from those who either from ignorance or narrow-minded selfishness advocate a different policy. Judging by this test, I may say that all the other names in the first part of the resolution are fairly entitled to our confidence and to an appeal from us to the constituencies to return them to Parliament as far as our interests are concerned. Their writings show that they have a good grasp of our position and wants. I may refer to Mr. Slagg’s views and efforts to abolish the India Council. Nothing can be more absurd than that in the nineteenth century and in England itself, the first home of public and free discussion upon all public matters, there should exist a body to deliberate secretly upon the destinies of a sixth of the human race! It is an utter anachronism. Mr. Slagg’s laudable and persistent efforts to get an inquiry into the Government of India promises to be successful. Messrs. Slagg, Digby, Keay, Blunt, and Verney's writings show that they understand us and have done us good service. About Mr. Lal Mohun Ghose I need not say more than that he is the only one through whom the Indians will now have a chance of speaking for themselves. I have every hope that he will do justice to himself, and fulfil the expectations which India has rested on him by honest and hard work for the welfare of his country. We must feel very thankful to the electors of Greenwich for giving him such welcome and sympathy as they have done. They have shown remarkable liberality, vindicated the English spirit of justice and philanthropy, have held out a hand to us of equal citizenship, and nobly confirmed the sincerity of the Royal Proclamation, by their action as a part of the English nation. Mr. Laing has, I am afraid, some incorrect notions about the balance of the trade of India, but we know that he understands India well and will continue to be useful in promoting our welfare. Sir John Phear and Mr. Plowden are known to us for their sympathies with us. Sir John Phear's book "The Aryan Village," shows much sympathetic study of the country and its institutions, and he proved our friend at the time of the Ilbert Bill. He said :—"We have a higher duty to India than to consult the prejudices of this kind of a few thousands of our own countrymen, who are there to-day, but may be gone to-morrow. We have to govern that vast empire in the interest of the millions who constitute the indigenous population of the country." Mr. Plowden says, with reference to Lord Ripon's policy :—"I know it to be just, I know it also to be honest and earnest, I believe it to be sound and thoroughly practical." I next come to our second list. As I have already said, we do not ask the constituencies not to return them if they are suitable to them on other grounds. We only ask that whatever weight the electors may give to their other qualifications, they would not take them as fair exponents or trustworthy interpreters of India's wants and just wishes, and as favouring us by electing them. With regard to Sir R. Temple I need say nothing more than that he endeavours to produce the wrong and mischievous impression upon the minds of the English people that India is prosperous and increasing in prosperity, in the teeth of the early and latest testimony of eminent men and in the teeth of facts. Mr. Fawcett told that the illusion was passing away, while Sir Richard keeps it up ! I do not advert to some of his acts in India, such as the strange contrast of 2 lbs. rations in Bengal and the disastrous 1 lb. ration famine policy here, probably to please higher authorities—his high-handedness, his treatment of the local funds, &c. &c. I confine myself to an utterance or two of his after leaving India. It is strange that a quarter of a century ago Mr. Richard Temple was able to take and express a remarkably intelligent view of the Indian problem. In connection with the Punjab he expounded the causes of Punjab's poverty and revival in his report of 1859 in these significant and clear words :—“ In former reports it was explained how the circumstance of so much money going out of the Punjab contributed to depress the agriculturist. The native regular army was Hindustani, to them was a large share of the Punjab revenue disbursed, of which a part only they spent on the spot and a part was remitted to their homes. Thus it was that year after year, lakhs and lakhs were drained from the Punjab, and enriched Oudh. But within the last year, the native army being Punjabee, all such sums have been paid to them, and have been spent at home. Again, many thousands of Punjabee soldiers are serving abroad. These men not only remit their savings, but also have sent quantities of prize property and plunder, the spoils of Hindustan, to their native villages. The effect of all this is already perceptible in an increase of agricultural capital, a freer circulation of money and a fresh impetus to cultivation.” Now, gentlemen, am I not justified in saying that it is strange that what Mr. Richard Temple of twenty-five years past saw so intelligently, about Punjab, Sir Richard Temple of the present day does not or would not see about India, whence, not merely “ lakhs and lakhs” but hundreds and hundreds of lakhs—thirty hundred or so lakhs are drained to England. He cannot, it appears, now grasp the problem of India as he did that of the Punjab. I cannot undertake to explain this phenomenon. What may be the reason or object? He alone can explain. As he is presently doing mischief by posing as a friend, I can only say “save us from such a friend.” We cannot but speak out, however unwillingly, that Sir Richard Temple is not a safe and correct guide for the people of England for India's wants and wishes. While Bright in '53, Lawrence in '64 and '73, Fawcett in '79, the London Punch's grand cartoon of Disillusion in '79 pourtraying the wretched Indian woman and children, with the shorn pagoda tree over their heads, begging alms of John Bull, Hunter in '80, Baring in '82, deplore the impoverishment of the masses of India, Sir Richard in a fine phrenzy talks in '85 “ of their homes becoming happier, their acres broader, their harvest richer.” “ India is prospering, that there is no lack of subsistence, no shrinkage of occupation, no discontent with the wages at home, and in consequence no searching for wages abroad.” And yet some light-hearted people coolly talk of sending him as a Viceroy here ! No greater misfortune could befal to India ! About Mr. Maclean I need not say much as you are all well aware, that he has been throughout his whole career in India a thorough partisan and an avowed and determined anti-native, with a few rare intervals of fairness. He can never be a fair and trustworthy interpreter of our views and wishes. He off-handedly says in his letter in the Bombay Gazette of 9th June last : "Mr. Slagg recited the usual rubbish about the deplorable poverty and overtaxation of the Indian people." So you see, gentlemen, who Mr. Maclean is. He is a great man before whom the views of such persons as Bright, Fawcett, Lawrence, the Punch, and Baring are all mere rubbish ! Mr. Ayrton's whole policy can be summed up in a few words—treat natives gently, but give them no posts of power or responsibility, have no legislative councils with non-official element, and if you have, put no natives in them. He says :—" The power of governing must remain, as it had hitherto been, solely and exclusively in the hands of British subjects going out of this country." " Why were we to teach the natives, what they had failed in discovering for themselves, that they would one day be a great nation." This un-English narrow-mindedness and purblindness is the worst thing that can happen to England and India both, and according to it all that the best and highest English statesmen, and even our Sovereign have promised and said about high duty, justice, policy, &c., must become so many empty words, hollow promises, and all sham and delusion. My personal relations with Sir L. Pelly at Baroda were, as you know, friendly, but the reason of his name appearing in this list, is that he was an instrument of Lord Lytton's Afghan policy, and that as far as his views may have coincided with the Lytton policy, he cannot fairly represent our views against that policy. About Sir Roper Lethbridge, I was under the impression that when he was Press Commissioner, he was regarded as one sympathising with the natives. But when the day of the crucial trial came, the Ilbert Bill and the Ripon policy, he was then found out that his views were anything but what would be just, fair and sympathising towards the natives of India. In addition to the names I have mentioned, I am required to mention Sir James Fergusson, and I cannot but agree to do so though with some reluctance. I have personally much respect for him, and I do not forget that he has done some good. In the matter of the native princes he enunciated a correct principle some eighteen years ago when he was Under-Secretary of State for India. Presiding at a meeting of the East India Association, 1867, he said :—" It is earnestly to be hoped that the princes of India look upon the engagements of the British Queen as irrevocable," and I believe he consistently carried out this principle when here with the princes of this Presidency. We cannot also forget that when acting upon his own instincts he did good in matters of education and social intercourse, and nominated to the Legislative Council our friends the Hon. Budroodeen and the Hon. Telang as representatives of the educated class, retaining also the Hon. Mandlik. You can easily conceive then my reluctance to speak against him, notwithstanding some mistakes and failures in his administration as Governor under official misguidance. But when I see that after his arrival in England he has made statements so incorrect and mischievous in results, in some matters most vital to India, it is incumbent upon us to say that he does not know the true state of India. Fancy, gentlemen, my regret and surprise when I read these words from the latest Governor of Bombay :—" At the present time her (India's) people were not heavily taxed, and it was a great mistake to suppose that they were." This is a matter of easy ascertainment, and the heaviness of taxation is repeated by acknowledged eminent men. Here are a few figures which will tell their own tale. The income of the United Kingdom may be roughly taken at £1,200,000,000 and its gross revenue about £87,000,000, giving a proportion of about 7½ per cent. of the income. Of British India the income is hardly £400,000,000 and its gross revenue about £70,000,000, giving 17½ per cent. of the income, and yet Sir James tells the English people that the people of India are not heavily taxed, though paying out of this wretched income, a gross revenue of more than double the proportion of what the people of the enormously rich England pay for their gross revenue. Contrast with Sir James's statement the picture which Mr. Fawcett gives in his paper in the Nineteenth Century, of October, 1879 :—"If a comparison is made between the financial resources of England and India, it will be found almost impossible to convey an adequate idea of the poverty of the latter country * * an consequently it is found that taxation in India has reached almost its extreme limits." Again he says : "It is particularly worthy of remark that the Viceroy and Secretary of State now unreservedly accept the conclusion that the limit of taxation has been reached in India, and that it has consequently become imperatively necessary that expenditure should be reduced." (The italics are mine.) Now, gentlemen, mark this particularly. When in 1879 the Conservative Viceroy and Secretary of State had, as Mr. Fawcett says, unreservedly accepted that the limit of taxation had been reached in India, the gross revenue was only £65,000,000, while the budgetted revenue of the present year is already £72,000,000, and we are now threatened by the same Government with an addition of £2,000,000 or £3,000,000 more permanently. This is terrible. Change the entire system as Mr. Fawcett says, substitute far the present destructive foreign agency, the constructive and conservative native agency, except for the highest posts of power, and you can have a hundred millions or two hundred millions with ease for purposes of government or taxation. This is the difference between Fawcett and Fergusson. Both are gentlemen, but the former speaks from careful hard study, the latter without it. Mischievous as such statements generally are, they are still more so when delivered before a Manchester audience, who unfortunately yet do not understand their own true interests, and the interests of the English workmen. They do not understand yet that their greatest interest is in increasing the ability of the Indians to buy their manufactures. That if India were able to buy a pound worth of their cotton manufactures per head per annum, that would give them a trade of £250,000,000 a year instead of the present poor imports into India of £25,000,000 of cotton yarn and manufactures from all foreign countries of the world. Sir James, I think, has made another statement that all offices in India are occupied by the natives except the highest. I am not able to put my hand just now upon the place where I read it. But if my impression be correct, I would not waste words and your time to animadvert upon such an extraordinary incorrect statement, so utterly contrary to notorious facts. Why, it is the head and front, the very soul of all our evils and grievances that the statement is not the fact or reality as it ought to be. This is the very thing which will put an end to all our troubles, and remedy all our evils of poverty and otherwise. Let Sir James bring it about, and he will be our greatest benefactor and England's best friend. In concluding, I may lay down a test for our appeal to the electors, that whichever candidates are not in accord with the Royal Proclamation, and with the lines of the Ripon policy, they are those whom we ask to be not regarded as trustworthy and fair interpreters of our views and wishes. The resolution has Mr. Blunt's name in the first list and Mr. Aryton's in the second. This will show that we are not actuated by a spirit of partisanship. Whoever are our real friends, be they Liberal or Conservative, we call them our friends. Differences of opinion in some details will no doubt occur between us and our friends, but we are desirous to support them, because the broad and important lines of policy, which India needs, such as those of the Proclamation and the Ripon policy, and the broad and important facts of our true condition, are well understood and adopted by those friends for their guidance in their work for the welfare of India. (Applause.)

II.

THE ELECTION SPEECHES IN ENGLAND.*

(Before various meetings in support of his candidature as the Liberal candidate for the Holborn Division of Finsbury in the General Election of 1886.)

1

THE HON. DADABHAI NAOROJI'S GREAT SPEECH.†

(At a meeting of the Electors of the Holborn Division, held on the 27th June 1886, in the Town Hall, Holborn. Mr. W. Percy Bunting in the chair.)

Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji, (on rising to address the meeting, was received with prolonged cheering, the audience rising and waving hats and handkerchiefs,) said: I really do not know how I can thank you from the bottom of my heart, for the permission you have given me to stand before you as a candidate for your borough. I appreciate the honour most highly. I will not take up more of your time on this point, because you may believe me when I say that I thank you from the bottom of my heart. It is really and truly so. (Cheers.) Standing as I do here, to represent the 250,000,000 of your fellow subjects in India, of course I know thoroughly well my duty; for if I am returned by you, my first duty will be to consult completely and fully the interest of my

Queen. The best years of my life have been spent in mercantile pursuits in this country. With English life and English politics I am familiar; I have voted at British Elections; I have worked for Liberal Candidates. Now, by your favour, I aspire to a seat in the British Parliament.

In my own country I have been largely concerned with important affairs. I was Prime Minister of the Kingdom of Baroda. I have done my share of municipal work in the Town Council and Municipality of Bombay. At this moment I am a Member of the Bombay Legislative Council. On the condition of my country I have frequently written, having given special study to economic questions affecting my countrymen; I have not the less given my best attention and consideration to subjects gravely affecting the welfare of my English fellow subjects.

I am a Liberal in politics, prepared to support the great measures of Social Reform, including a change in the Land Laws affecting dwellers alike in town and country, which have been announced by the Great Leader of the Party.

Upon the momentous issue now before the Electors of Great Britain and Ireland, I am at one with Mr. Gladstone in his noble-hearted and heroic effort to satisfy the just aspirations of the Irish people to control their own affairs while yet remaining a part of the great British Empire. The Irish problem must be solved.

To my mind a measure of Irish Self-Government, embodying the principles of Mr. Gladstone's Manifesto to his Constituents, far from disintegrating the Empire, as some wrongly allege, is, in my humble opinion, calculated to produce a real and lasting union between Great Britain and Ireland in place of the sham, or worse than sham, union which at present exists. Further, I am of opinion that when Ireland gets her own Parliament, the material advancement of the Irish people will be ensured.

It is with especial pride and pleasure that I, an Indian, address a Metropolitan Constituency as a candidate for the suffrages of the Electors. I remember that it was a neighbouring Constituency to your own that elected my friend Henry Fawcett, when he was rejected by Brighton, and retained him as its representative until his lamented death.

I will not, here and now, set forth the features of Indian Reform which I hope to be privileged, by your kind favour, to advocate in the House of Commons. In due course I hope to take counsel with you on these matters.

I pray you, members of the race which rules India, to remember the condition of that Empire, and to give me the opportunity of serving my countrymen in Parliament.

By favour of the Executive Committee of your Liberal Association, I have the opportunity of appealing to the Electors of your Borough, and I appeal to your generous spirit, which is always prepared to do what is good and right, to give me your votes, enable me to enter Parliament, and there demonstrate the pressing need of my country and countrymen for a consideration of Indian affairs from their standpoint. At the same time I need hardly add that I should give my best and fullest attention to the interests of my constituents.

The time for fighting is short. I may not be able to see all the Electors before the day of polling; but by public meetings, and in other ways, I hope to be able to make myself acquainted with you, and to lay my views in detail before you.

I am, Gentlemen,

Your obedient servant,

DADABHAI NAOROJI.

NATIONAL LIBERAL CLUB,

June 19th, 1886.

The following was the result of the ballot :—Colonel F. Duncan (C) 3651; Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji (L) 1950. constituents. I do not want at present to plead the cause of India. I am glad that that cause has been ably and eloquently pleaded by our worthy chairman, by Mr. Wilfrid Blunt, and by Mr. Bryce. But the time must come, if I am returned, to lay before you the condition of India—what little we want from you, and with little we are always satisfied. For the present, therefore, I would come to the burning question of the day—the Irish Home Rule. (Loud cheers.)

“Consistent with Justice.”

The question now before you is whether Ireland shall have its Home Rule or not. (“Yes, yes.”) The details are a different question altogether. I will therefore confine myself to those particular points which affect the principle of Home Rule. The first thing I will say is something about Mr. Gladstone himself. (Loud cheers.) Grand Old Man he is—(renewed cheers)—and not only all England, but all India says so. (Vociferous cheers.) He has been much twitted that he is inconsistent with himself—that he has said something some time ago and something different now. But those that can understand the man can understand how very often a great man may appear inconsistent when in reality he is consistent in the best and highest sense of the word. That is, he is consistent with truth, justice, right, and has the courage of his convictions. Mr. Gladstone thought something at one time, but as circumstances changed, and new light came, and new power was wielded by the Irish people, he saw that this change of circumstances required a reconsideration of the whole question. He came to the conclusion that the only remedy for this discord between two sisters was to let the younger sister have her own household. (Cheers.) When he saw that he had the courage of his conviction, the moral courage to come forward before the world and say, “I see that this is the remedy: let the English nation adopt it.” And I have no doubt that they will adopt it.

“Incompatible with Tyranny.”

I have lived in this country actually for twenty years, and my entire connection in business with England has been thirty years, and I say that if there is one thing more certain than another that I have learned, it is that the English nation is incompatible with tyranny. It will at times be proud and imperious, and will even carry a wrong to a long extent; but the time will come when it will be disgusted with its own tyranny and its own wrong. (Cheers.) When once an Englishman sees his mistake he has the moral courage to rectify it. (Cheers.) Mr. Gladstone, then, has represented your highest and most generous instincts, and I have no doubt that the response from the country, sooner or later, must come to the height of his argument and of his sentiment. The greatest argument against Home Rule is that it will disintegrate the Empire. Now, it has been a surprise to me how this word Empire has been so extraordinarily used and abused.

The Nonsense of Disintegration.

What is the British Empire? Is it simply Great Britain and Ireland? Why it exists over the whole surface of the world—east, west, north, south—and the sun never sets upon it. Is that Empire to be broken down, even though Ireland be entirely separated? Do you mean to say that the British Empire hangs only upon the thread of the Irish will? (Laughter.) Has England conquered the British Empire simply because Ireland did it? What nonsense it is to say that such an Empire could be disintegrated, even if unhappily Ireland were separated! Do the colonies hold you in affection because Ireland is with you? Is the Indian Empire submissive to you because you depend upon Ireland? Such a thing would be the highest humiliation for the English people to say. (Cheers.) The next question is, Will Ireland separate? (“No.”) Well, we may say that because we wish it should not; but we must consider it carefully. Let us suppose that the Irish are something like human beings. (Laughter and cheers.) Let us suppose them to be guided by the ordinary motives of humanity. I put it to you fairly whether Ireland will separate or not. I say she will not.

Home Rule—Home Life.

What will Ireland be after it has this Home Rule? It will simply have its own household, just as a son who has come of age wishes to have a home in which his wife may be supreme. Ireland simply asks its own household independence, and that does not in the least mean that the Empire is disadvantaged. The Imperial concern is in no way concerned in it. Just as, I and my partner being in business, I leave the management of the concern to him. I have confidence in him. I know he would not deprive me of a single farthing; but as a partner in the firm I am not compelled to live with him, nor to submit myself to him for food and clothing, and the necessaries of life. You do not mean to say that, because Ireland has a separate household, therefore she will also be separated from the Imperial firm, and that they would have no connection with each other? The British Empire still remains, to be shared by them.

The Analogy of the Colonies.

Take the Colonies. They have their own self-government, as Ireland asks, but there the position of the colonies ends. Ireland, with this Parliament granted to it, will be in a far higher position than the colonies are. Ireland will be a part of the ruling power of the British Empire. She and England will be partners as rulers of the British Empire, which the colonies are not. And if the Irish separate, what are they ? An insignificant country. If they should remain separate, and England and America, or England and France should go to war, they would be crushed. There is a saying among the Indians that when two Elephants fight the trees are uprooted. (Laughter.) What could Ireland do ? It would not be her interest to sever herself from England, and to lose the honour of a share in the most glorious Empire that ever existed on the face of the earth. (Loud cheers.) Do you then for a moment suppose that Ireland will throw itself down from the high pedestal on which it at present stands ? It supplies the British Empire with some of its best statesmen and warriors. (Cheers.) Is this the country so blind to its own interests that it will not understand that by leaving England it throws itself to the bottom of the sea ? With England it is the ruler of mankind. I say therefore that Ireland will never separate from you. (Cheers.) Home Rule will bring peace and prosperity to them, and they will have a higher share in the British Empire. (Cheers.) Depend upon it, gentlemen, if I live ten years more—I hope I shall live—if this bill is passed, that every one of you, and every one of the present opponents of Home Rule, will congratulate himself that he did, or allowed to be done, this justice to Ireland. (Cheers.)

A People “Valiant, Generous, and Tender.”

There is one more point which is important to be dealt with. I am only confining myself to the principle of Home Rule. Another objection taken to the Bill is that the Irish are a bad lot—(laughter)—that they are poor, wretched, ungrateful, and so forth. (“Who said so?”) Some people say so. (“Salisbury,” and cheers and hisses.) We shall see what one says whom you have entrusted with the rulership of two hundred and fifty millions of people—I allude to Lord Dufferin, himself an Irishman. (Cheers.) What does he say ? How does he describe Ireland ? I may shoot the two birds at once by referring to his description of the country as well as of the people. He says that Ireland is a lovely and fertile land, caressed by a clement atmosphere, held in the embrace of the sea, with a coast filled with the noblest harbours of the world, and “ inhabited by a race valiant, generous, and tender, gifted beyond measure with the power of physical endurance, and graced with the liveliest intelligence.” It is not necessary for me to say any more about a people of that character. I think it is a slander on humanity and human nature to say that any people, and more especially the Irish, are not open to the feelings of gratitude, to the feelings of kindness. If there is anything for which the Irish are distinguished—I say this not merely from my study of your country, but from my experience of some Irish people—that if ever I have found a warm-hearted people in the world, I have found the Irish. (Loud cheers.)

A People “ Accessible to Justice.”

But I will bring before you the testimony of another great man, whom, though he is at present at variance with us on this question of a separate Parliament, we always respect. It is a name highly respected by the natives of India, and, I know, by the Liberals of this country. I mean John Bright. (Hisses and cheers.) What does he say ? “ If there be a people on the face of the earth whose hearts are accessible to justice, it is the Irish people.” (Cheers.) Now, I am endeavouring to take all the important points brought forward against this Home Rule. Mr. Gladstone proposes that they should give a certain proportion of money to the Imperial Exchequer. Their opponents say, “ Oh, they will promise all sorts of things.” Now, I want this to be carefully considered. The basis of the most powerful of human motives is self-interest. It is to the interest of Ireland never to separate from England.

Not Tribute, but Partnership.

I will now show you that this, which is called a tribute and a degradation, is nothing of the kind. Ireland would feel it its duty to pay this It is not tribute in any sense of the word. Ireland is a partner in the Imperial firm. Ireland shares both the glory and the profit of the British rule. Its children will be employed as fully in the administration and the conduct of the Empire as any Englishman will be. Ireland, in giving only something like £1 in £15 to the Exchequer will more than amply benefit. It is a partnership, and they are bound to supply their capital just as much as the senior partner is bound to supply his. They will get the full benefit of it. Tribute is a thing for which you get no return in material benefit, and to call this tribute is an abuse of words. I have pointed out that those great bugbears, the separation, the tribute, and the bad character of the Irish are pure myths. The Irish are a people that are believed by many an Englishman to be as high in intellect and in morality as any on the face of the earth. If they are bad now, it is your own doing. (Cheers.) You first debase them, and then give them a bad name, and then want to hang them. No, the time has come when you do understand the happy inspiration which Mr. Gladstone has conceived.

Home Rule—The Golden Rule.

You do know now that Ireland must be treated as you treat yourselves. You say that Irishmen must be under the same laws as Englishmen, and must have the same rights. Very good. The opponents say yes, and therefore they must submit to the laws which the British Parliament makes. I put to them one simple question. Will Englishmen for a single day submit to laws made for them by those who are not Englishmen? What is the proudest chapter in British history? That of the Stuarts. You did not tolerate the laws of your own Sovereign, because you thought they were not your laws. (Cheers.) You waged civil war, regardless of consequences, and fought and struggled till you established the principle that the English will be their own sovereign, and your own sons your own legislators and guides. You did not submit to a ruler, though he was your own countryman. Our opponents forget that they are not giving the same rights to the Irish people. They are oblivious of this right, and say Ireland must be governed by laws that we make for her. They do not understand that what is our own, however bad it is, is dearer to us than what is given to us by another, however high and good he may be. (Cheers.) No one race of people can ever legislate satisfactorily for another race. Then they object that the Saxon race is far superior to the Celtic, and that the Saxon must govern the whole, though in the next breath they admit that the one cannot understand the other. (Laughter.) A grand patriarch said to his people thousands of years ago, “Here is good, here is evil; make your choice: choose the good, and reject the evil.” A grand patriarch of to-day—the Grand Old Man—(loud cheers)—tells you, “Here is the good, here is the evil; choose the good, reject the evil.” And I do not say I hope and trust, but I am sure, that the English nation, sooner or later, will come to that conclusion—will choose the good, and will reject the evil.

A Word About India.

I only want now to say one word about my own country. (Loud cheers.) I feel that my task has been so much lessened by previous speakers, that I will not trouble you much upon this point. I appeal to you for the sake of the two hundred and fifty millions of India. I have a right to do so, because I know that India regards me—at least, so it is said—as a fair representative. I want to appeal to you in their name that, whether you send me or another to Parliament, you at once make up your minds that India ought to have some representation—(cheers) —in your British Parliament. I cannot place my case better than in the words of an illustrious English lady, whose name for patriotism, philanthropy, and self-sacrifice is the highest amongst your race—Miss Florence Nightingale. (Loud cheers.) She writes to me in these words:—

Miss Florence Nightingale to the Electors of Holborn.

“London, June 23, 1886.—My dear Sir,—My warmest good wishes are yours in the approaching election for Holborn, and this not only for your sake, but yet more for that of India and of England, so important is it that the millions of India should in the British Parliament here be represented by one who, like yourself, has devoted his life to them in such a high fashion—to the difficult and delicate task of unravelling and explaining what stands at the bottom of India's poverty, what are India's rights, and what is the right for India : rights so compatible with, indeed so dependent on, loyalty to the British Crown; rights which we are all seeking after for those great multitudes, developing, not every day like foliage in May, but slowly and surely. The last five or eight years have made a difference in India's cultivated classes which has astonished statesmen—in education, the seeds of which were so sedulously sown by the British Government—in power, of returning to the management of their own local affairs, which they had from time immemorial; that is, in the powers and responsibilities of local self-government, their right use of which would be equally advantageous to the Government of India and to India (notwithstanding some blunders); and a noble because careful beginning has been made in giving them this power. Therefore do I hail you and yearn after your return to this Parliament, to continue the work you have so well begun in enlightening England and India on Indian affairs. I wish I could attend your first public meeting, to which you kindly invite me to-morrow; but alas for me, who for so many years have been unable from illness to do anything out of my rooms.—Your most ardent well-wisher, Florence Nightingale.” (Loud cheers.)

India's Appeal.

Well, gentlemen, in the words of this illustrious lady, I appeal not only to you, the constituents of Holborn, but to the whole English nation, on the behalf of 250 millions of your fellow subjects—a sixth part of the human race, and the largest portion of the British Empire, before whom you are but as a drop in the ocean; we appeal to you to do us justice, and to allow us a representative in your British Parliament. (Loud and prolonged cheers, the audience rising in great enthusiasm.)

2

THE HON. DADABHAI NAOROJI AT THE STORE-STREET HALL.

(Before a large number of Electors in the Store-Street Hall on Monday night, 28th June 1886. Mr. Newton Wilson in the chair.)

The Hon. Dadabhai Naoroji, in the course of his speech, said he thanked them most sincerely for the honour they had done him in allowing him to stand for their constituency. (Hear, hear.) The chairman had very kindly said something about him, and he would not trespass much upon their patience by dwelling more upon that point. He would only say that he stood before them representing 250,000,000 of their fellow-subjects in India, and he stood before them as a fair representative of India. He appealed to the people of England to allow a single voice or two to be heard in the British Parliament on behalf of these 250,000,000 people, yet he did not forget that his first duty would be to the constituency itself, and he should feel it his duty, if returned, to represent the interests of the constituency to the fullest extent before even representing the interests of India. He was not altogether a stranger in this place. The first time he had ever put his foot in this country was in 1855, and he had been altogether more or less a resident in this country since. He had resided in England during the past twenty years, only going to his own home at short intervals. Under these circumstances he could claim fairly on one hand to represent his own countrymen, and on the other hand he hoped he should fulfil his duty to his constituents if he was honoured with their representation in the House of Commons. (Loud cheers.) He could tell them that the Indians felt a keen interest in this question of the election of Indians in the House of Parliament here. Two or three days ago, on the wings of lightning, a message from that vast assemblage —a telegram to the people of this country—stating that they were watching, with keen interest, the candidature of the Hon. Dadabhai Naoroji and Lalmohun Ghose, and a desire was keenly felt and universally expressed for their success, and much gratitude was felt to Holborn for supporting the candidature of Mr. Naoroji, and also that a public meeting, expressing confidence, would soon be held. (Cheers and applause.) That telegram had been despatched from India since it was known that Holborn had honoured him with their acceptance. This was not the time or the place for him to enter into the wants of India, which his countrymen were desirous he should represent in the House of Commons. This was the time to consider a far more immediately urgent question—the question of Home Rule for Ireland. (Cheers and applause.)

After dealing at length with the question, the speaker went on to say one word no behalf of his own country. Miss Nightingale had written him a letter in which she appealed to the English nation on behalf of India, and expressed her pleasure at the success of the meeting in the Holborn Town Hall, and her ardent hope that the electors of Holborn would return Mr. Naoroji to the House of Commons. Lord Ripon had also written him a letter since the meeting in the Town Hall, congratulating him on the success of that meeting, and expressing the hope that he would be returned; a fact which would give great joy to his compatriots in India. (Cheers and applause.) The speaker concluded by making an earnest appeal on behalf of the five millions in Ireland and 250,000,000 of India, and resumed his seat amid cheers.

3

THE HON. DADABHAI NAOROJI AT THE OLD FRIENDS' HALL.

(Before a Meeting of the Electors of the Holborn Division in the Old Friends', St. Martin's Lane, on Tuesday night, 29th June 1886. Mr. J. P. Murrough in the chair.)

The Hon. D. Naoroji, on rising, was received with rapturous applause. After some few preliminary remarks the speaker said, amid cheers, that England had shown herself to be the friend of struggling nationalities all over the world, and it was a great pity that when she came to Ireland she should stop there. He did not think, however, that England would stop at the case of Ireland, which had now spoken with a firm voice her demand for Home Rule. Much had been said that this question had not been formally brought before the country, but times and circumstances produced the man fit for the purpose. A great deal had been made of the heated expressions of the Irish members when the battle was raging. No doubt words had been uttered which in cooler moments would be heartily condemned, but when men were in the thick of the fight they did not care how or where they hit. (Cheers.) Now, however, in peaceful moments, a better tone and temper prevailed. It was an Irish poet who said that failure was rebellion, and success patriotism. Well Mr. Gladstone had converted rebellion into patriotism, and the rebels of yesterday were the patriots of to-day. (Cheers and applause.) He had no doubt whatever in his mind, that the Irish people would justify the confidence of the Grand Old Man—(cheers)— and the English people at the present juncture would also, he believed, justify the confidence to be placed in them to return him to power to do this great act of justice for Ireland. (Loud cheers.) On the motion of Mr. Campbell, a vote of confidence in the Hon. D. Naoroji's candidature was unanimously passed. A vote of thanks to the chairman brought the proceedings to a close.

4

the hon. dadabhai naoroji at the phœnix hall.

(Before a crowded meeting of the Electors in the Phœnix Hall, Hatton Hall, on Wednesday night, 30th June 1886. Mr. T. Johnston in the chair.)

Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji, who was received with ringing cheers, thanked the electors for the kind reception they had accorded to him. He had come there from a distant land, which under the dispensation of Providence, was ruled by a race distinguished for its love of liberty and justice, and he appealed to that race that they should grant that liberty and justice to India which they so highly esteemed themselves. He had received a telegram stating that on the previous day a meeting had been held in Bombay, thanking Holborn and Deptford for having chosen as Liberal candidates Mr. Lalmohun Ghose and the Hon. Dadabhai Naoroji. It was also stated that meetings were being held throughout the length and breadth of the Bombay Presidency, in which the most lively interest was exhibited in the elections for these two constituencies. He could assure them that it was not for the simple ambition of placing the letters M.P. after his name that he sought their suffrages, but because he wished to continue a worker in the good cause. If he were honoured with their representation, he could assure them he would do justice to their choice. (Hear, hear and applause.) During his whole life he had always made it a point to work for the amelioration of the poor, distressed and ignorant, and he hoped to pursue that course to the end of his days. He would consider it to be the crowning work of his life to get into the British Parliament to endeavour to serve 250,000,000 of his countrymen, and of their fellow subjects in India. After stating his opinion of the Irish question, the speaker said it would be for the people of England to choose the good and reject the evil. (Hear, hear.) The good was to do justice to Ireland, and by doing that they would be rejecting the evil. (Loud and prolonged cheers and applause.)

5

THE HON. DADABHAI NAOROJI AT THE TOWN HALL.

(Before a crowded meeting of the Electors on Friday, July 2nd, 1886, in the Town Hall, Holborn. Mr. Eve, B. L., in the chair. This meeting was a most enthusiastic one.)

Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji, (who was received with loud and prolonged cheers and applause, which lasted for several minutes), said :—He had had before the honour of addressing them in that hall. He referred to the object of his standing before them, viz., to ask for justice for India ; and he was not going to dwell longer on the point, except to read to them the substance of three telegrams he had received from that country. The National ·Telegraphic Union, which represented all parts of India, had sent a telegram to Holborn and Deptford to assist Lalmohun Ghose and himself in getting seats in Parliament, and also thanked them for accepting their candidature. On the subject of Home Rule he had already addressed to them certain arguments, but he would now take up the thread of those arguments, and answer certain objections. He would not enter into details, for the simple reason that the principle of a measure should be first agreed upon, and if they agreed in adopting the principle it was time enough to discuss the details, but if the principle was not agreed upon, it would be simple waste of time discussing the details. (Hear, hear, and applause.) He had, therefore, dwelt upon the consistency of the moral courage of Mr. Gladstone in acceding to the demands of the expressed wish of the Irish people. In sending his message of peace to Ireland, amid the turmoil by which he was surrounded, he had kept his temper and pursued the even tenor of his way, confident·in the strength and of the righteousness of his cause. He did his utmost to meet the views of his party, which proved how great and good a man he was. There were persons who called themselves Unionists, but really it was the Gladstonians who were the Unionists, and the opposition was the sham Unionists, becausc the Union they were defending was a sham union, and not one of hearts and affections. (Cheers and applause.) They could not say there had been a real union during the past eighty-six years, or that it had produced any good result. (Hear, hear, and applause.) The union between the two countries had really been brought about by the basest corruption ; in fact, so mean were the ways by which it was brought about, that Lord Cornwallis was so utterly disgusted that he said, “ Would to God that I had never put my hand in this dirty business.” (Applause.) Were they afraid that Empire would be broken up simply because Ireland had a Home Rule Government ? In India there was a number of native states which possessed Home Rule, the only connection that they had with the British rule being that they paid a small tribute to the British authorities. These native states proved a strength to the British Empire, for in 1857, at the time of the Indian Mutiny, these states formed contingents to restore peace to the country; and again, at the scare of Russian invasion, these states, thoroughly independent, came forward ready to assist the British forces in repelling that invasion. A great deal was said about the exclusion of the Irish members, and that taxation should not go without representation; but if the Irish people, whose right it was to be represented in the Imperial Parliament of their own free will, wished to forego that chance, why should others complain? (Hear, hear, and cheers.) Speaking of the opposition to the measure expressed by certain persons in Ireland, the Speaker said that all classes, after the passing of the Bill, ought to unite in doing the best they could for their country; and the gentlemen who had spoken on behalf of the Protestant Home Rule Association had shown there was no danger whatever in their minds on the score of persecution of the minority. He had not the least doubt in his mind, although in the present excitement opposition of this kind might be raised by those who enjoyed certain privileges, still the time must come when these very gentlemen would be foremost in taking advantage of the privileges conferred upon Ireland, and would be glad that they had been conferred upon her. He had not the least fear that any one in Ireland would have reason to complain of the effect of opening a new Parliament there. (Hear, hear.) At one time Home Rule was synonymous with rebellion, but the Irish leaders had managed their affairs in such a way that it was now synonymous with patriotism. The time had come when the greatest statesman of the age held out the hand of fellowship to them, gave them a message of peace, and they thankfully accepted the offer made to them and said now will begin the regeneration of the country. They showed that if they knew how to fight they also knew how to make peace. Having shown this capacity on their part, they might rely upon it they would justify the confidence which Mr. Gladstone was willing to put in them. Much was said about the curtailment of the powers of the Imperial Parliament. Mr. Bright said that any laws which Parliament passed they could also repeal. Some said if the Irish had a Parliament they would enact laws which would be oppressive and contrary to the wishes of the English people, and which would end in civil war. Suppose the Irish were so foolish to do such a thing, as Englishmen, had they never known what civil war was—they who refused to take the laws from their own sovereign, and said they would not have them, as they were not made by the people themselves. They should not forget that love created love, confidence produced confidence, thistles produced thistles, and evil was never productive of good except Providence turned it in some way or other. They had had no confidence in the Irish. Lord Salisbury, in speaking before the Worshipful Company of Grocers, said, “In respect to institutions and property, we have again and again the fact forced upon us that confidence will create far greater riches than by confiscation can ever be gained. If you destroy confidence, no confiscation will repay you.” He would only ask the same thing from Lord Salisbury. Let them have confidence in the Irish, and the Irish would rise and prosper. One of the great arguments used against the Irish was the outrages and murders and assassinations that took place there. But did they suppose that a nation who, in physical endurance, was as good as any on the face of the earth, and whose mental calibre distinguished them amongst men, did they think they would take a blow without giving another. It was absurd to expect such a thing. He did not want for a moment to justify the outrages or any violence that might have taken place in Ireland, but he would say in the nature of things, they could not expect any other result. Those who opposed the measure because there were outrages committed in Ireland, were using that as a shift, because they had no other argument. See what Mr. Bright says :—“The first thing that ever called my attention to the state of Ireland was the reading an account of one of these outrages. I thought of it for a moment, but the truth struck me at once, and all I have ever seen since confirms it, when law refuses its duty, when Government denies the right of the people . . . those people are driven back from law and from the ways of civilization to that which is termed the law of nature, and if not the strongest, the law of the vindictive.” After referring to the decision of the population in Ireland, he said he hoped that the measure would be accepted with gratitude, and that it would be given not only as a matter of justice, but of reparation of the past. By giving this boon to Ireland, England would add to its history a brighter chapter than any it at present contained. Their greatest man had been inspired to do that act. Let them feel that inspiration and help him in the struggles which he was now undergoing, carrying him on their shoulders to victory, and not only would they earn the blessing of five millions of Irishmen, but they would also earn the blessing of fifty times five millions of the inhabitants of India.* (Cheers.)

6

GREAT RECEPTION MEETING IN BOMBAY.

(Before the public meeting of the inhabitants of Bombay called by the Bombay Presidency Association at the Framjee Cowasjee Institute on Sunday, the 13th February 1887, to pass a vote of thanks to the Hon. Dadabhai Naoroji and Mr. Lal Mohun Ghose for their exertions on behalf of India at the Parliamentary elections of 1886 in England. Mr. (now Sir) Dinshaw M. Petit in the chair.)

The Hon’ble Dadabhai Naoroji (amidst long and immense cheering), said :—Mr. Chairman, Ladies and Gentlemen,—I feel extremely obliged by the very kind reception you have given to my friend Mr. Ghose and myself, and for the confidence you have reposed in us. Such hearty acknowledgments of my humble services and of my friend’s arduous exertion cannot but encourage us largely in our future work. (Cheers.) As natives of India, we are bound to do whatever lies within our power and opportunities. In undertaking the work of trying to get a seat in Parliament, the first question that naturally arose was whether it would be of any good to India and whether an Indian member would be listened to. The first thing, therefore, I did on arriving in England was to consult many English friends, several of whom are eminent statesmen of the day and members of Parliament. I was almost universally advised that I should not hesitate to try to carry out my intentions, that it was extremely desirable that there should be at least one or two Indians in Parliament to enable members to learn the native view of questions from natives themselves. (Cheers.) That if I could by any possibility work way into the House, I would certainly be doing a great service not only to India, but to a large extent to England also. (Cheers.) Several fundamental important questions of policy can be fought out and decided in Parliament alone as they depend upon Acts of Parliament, and Parliament is the ultimate appeal in every important question in which Government and the native public may differ. To get direct representation from India was not at present possible. An indirect representation through the liberality and aid of some British constituency was the only door open to us. I undertook to contest Holborn under many disadvantages. I was just occupied in making acquaintances and feeling my way. I had no time to find out and make the acquaintance of any constituency; I was quite unknown to the political world, when of a sudden the resolution came on upon me. The Liberal leaders very properly advised me that I should not lose this opportunity of contesting some seat, no matter however a forlorn hope it might be, as the best means of making myself known to the English constituencies, and of securing a better chance and choice for the next opportunity. That I could not expect to get in at a rush, which even an Englishman was rarely able to do except under particularly favourable circumstances. I took the advice and selected Holborn out of three offers I have received. I thus not only got experience of an English contest, but it also satisfied me as to what prospects an Indian had of receiving fair and even generous treatment at the hands of English electors. The elections clearly showed me that a suitable Indian candidate has as good a chance as any Englishman, or even some advantage over an Englishman, for there is a general and genuine desire among English electors to give to India any help in their power. (Cheers.) I had only nine days of work from my first meeting at the Holborn Town Hall, and sometimes I had to attend two or three meetings on the same day. The meetings were as enthusiastic and cordial in reception as one's heart could desire. Now the incident I refer to is this. Of canvassing I was able to do but very little. Some liberal electors, who were opposed to Irish Home rule, intended to vote for the conservative candidate, but to evince their sympathy with India, they promised me to abstain from voting altogether. Unknown as I was to the Holborn electors, the exceedingly enthusiastic and generous treatment they gave me, and that nearly two thousand of them recorded their votes in my favour, must be quite enough to satisfy any that the English public desire to help us to have our own voice in the House of Commons. (Cheers.) Letters and personal congratulations I received from many for what they called my "plucky contest." Lord Ripon —(cheers)—wrote to me not to be discouraged, as my want of success was shared by so many other liberals as to deprive it of personal character; that it was the circumstances of the moment, as it turned out, that worked specially against me, and he trusted I would be successful on a future occasion. Now it was quite true that owing to the deep split among the liberals in the home rule question, it was estimated by some that I had lost nearly a thousand votes by the abstention of liberal voters. In short, with my whole experience at Holborn, of both the manner and events of the contest, I am more than ever confirmed in my opinion that India may fairly expect from the English public just and generous treatment. (Cheers). I have no doubt that my friend Mr. Ghose—(cheers)—with his larger electioneering experience of two arduous contests, will be able to tell you of similar conviction and future hopefulness. There is one great advantage achieved by their contests, which in itself is an ample return for all the trouble— I mean the increasing and earnest interest that has been aroused in the English public about Indian matters. From everywhere you begin to receive expressions of desire to know the truth about India, and invitations come to you to address on Indian subjects. The moral effect of these contests is important and invaluable. (Hear, hear.) A letter I received from an English friend on the eve of my departure for India this time fairly represents the general English feeling I have met with. Nothing would give him, he says, greater satisfaction than to see me sitting in the House of Commons—(cheers)—where I would arouse in the English representatives a keen sense of England's responsibilities, and show them how to fulfil them. (Cheers.) For the sake of England and of India alike, he earnestly hoped that I might be a pioneer of this sacred work. My presence in the House of Commons was to his mind more important than that of any Englishman whom he knew—(cheers) —though that seemed saying a good deal. With these few remarks I once more return to you my most hearty thanks for the reception you have given us, and it would be an important credential as well as an encouragement in our further efforts. (Loud cheers.)

III.

1

THE FIRST INDIAN NATIONAL CONGRESS

(Held in the Gokuldass Tejpal Sanscrit School, Gowallia Tank, Bombay).

First Day's Proceedings (28th December 1885).

Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji said :—I had no thought of speaking on this resolution,* but I see I must say something. There is a notion running under some remarks, that if a Conservative Government appoints a Committee, it will not be a good one. I do not think there is any good reason for that assumption. The Conservatives are not so bad as that they will never do a good thing, nor are the Liberals so good that they never did a bad thing. In fact we owe good to both, and we have nothing to do with them yet as parties. We are thankful to either party that does us good. The Proclamation is the gift of a Conservative Government. I have some experience of a Parliamentary Committee and that Committee, a Liberal one; and yet under the Chairmanship of a gentleman like Mr. Ayrton, you cannot be sure of a fair hearing. On the other hand, a fair minded Chairman and similar members, be they Conservatives or Liberals, would make a good Committee, and give a fair inquiry. Much depends upon the Secretary of State for India. If he is a fair minded person and not biassed in any particular way, you will have a fair Committee. If we are asking for a Parliamentary Committee, we need not be afraid of asking one from a Conservative Government. A Secretary of State like Sir Stafford Northcote (Lord Iddesleigh) will give a fair one, and we should not assume that the present Secretary will not give a good one. We should only desire that Anglo-Indians may not be put in it, or only a few such in whom Natives have confidence. In such an inquiry Anglo-Indian officials are on their trial, and they should not be allowed to sit in judgment upon themselves.

From the remarks already made, there appears to be an undecidedness, whether to ask for a Committee, or for a Royal Commission. And there seems also a notion underneath, that if we were not satisfied with the one we could ask for the other. Now we must bear in mind that it is not an easy thing to get a Parliamentary Committee or a Royal Commission, and that you cannot have either whenever you like. Do not suppose that if we have a Committee or a Commission and if we say we are dissatisfied with its results, we would at once get another for the asking. We must make up our minds definitively as to what we want and what would be the best thing for us. You should not leave it open whether there should be a Committee or Commission. Whichever you want, say it out once for all. In dealing with Englishmen, make up your minds deliberately, speak clearly, and work perseveringly. Then and then only can you hope to be listened to, and get your wishes. You must not show that you do not know your own mind. Therefore, know your own mind, and say clearly whether you desire a Parliamentary Committee, or a Royal Commission. It is evidently the desire here, that a full and impartial enquiry by fair and high minded English statesmen, with an adequate number of Natives on the enquiring body, should be carried on in India itself. If so, then we must remember that a

Parliamentary Committee can consist only of members of Parliament, and can sit in the Parliament House only. For our purpose to lay bare the actual conditions of India, an inquiry in India, in all departments and in the whole condition of India—material and moral—is absolutely necessary. No enquiry in England, and that with the evidence of Anglo-Indians chiefly—who themselves are on trial, and who would not naturally condemn their own doings and work—can ever bring out the truth about India’s true condition and wants, and necessary reforms. We, then irresistibly come to one conclusion, that an enquiry in India itself is absolutely necessary, and that such an enquiry can be conducted by a Royal Commission. Only let us clearly say our mind that we ask for a Royal Commission. Do not let there be any doubt about what we do really want. If I am right in interpreting your desire, then I say let there be no vague general resolution, but say clearly and distinctly that we require a Royal Commission.

Second Day’s Proceedings (29th December 1885).

The Hon’ble Dadabhai Naoroji (Bombay), in supporting the resolution,* said :—I am glad my friends, the Hon’ble Mr. Telang and the Hon’ble Mr. S. Iyer, have relieved me of much trouble, as they have anticipated a deal of what I had to say, which I need not repeat.

We asked for representation in the Legislative Councils of India. It is not for us to teach the English people how necessary representation is for good government. We have learnt the lesson from them, and knowing from them how great a blessing it is to those nations who enjoy it, and how utterly un-English it is for the English nation to withhold it from us, we can, with confidence and trust, ask them to give us this. I do not want to complain of the past. It is past and gone. It cannot be said now that the time is not come to give us representation. Thanks to our rulers themselves, we have now sufficiently advanced to know the value of representation and to understand the necessity that representation must go with taxation, that the taxed must have a voice in the taxation that is imposed on them. We are British subjects, and I say we can demand what we are entitled to and expect still at British hands as their greatest and most noble institution and heritage. It is our inheritance also and we should not be kept out of it.

Why, if we are to be denied Britain's best institutions, what good is it to India to be under the British sway ? It will be simply another Asiatic despotism. What makes us proud to be British subjects, what attaches us to this foreign rule with deeper loyalty than even our own past Native rule, is the fact that Britain is the parent of free and representative government, and, that we, as her subjects and children, are entitled to inherit the great blessing of freedom and representation. We claim the inheritance. If not, we are not the British subjects which the Proclamation proclaims us to be—equal in rights and privileges with the rest of Her Majesty's subjects. We are only British drudges or slaves. Let us persevere. Britain would never be a slave and could not, in her very nature and instinct, make a slave. Her 'greatest glory is freedom and representation, and, as her subjects, we shall have these blessed gifts.

Coming to the immediate and practical part of our demand, I may say that it will be to Government itself a great advantage and relief—advantage, inasmuch as it will have the help of those who know the true wants of the Natives, and in whom the Natives have confidence, and relief so far that the responsibility of legislation will not be upon the head of Government only, but upon that of the representatives of the people also. And the people will have to blame themselves if they fail to send the right sort of men to represent themselves. I think Government has now reason rather to thank than repel us for demanding this boon which, if granted, will, on the one hand, make government easier and more effective, and, on the other, attach the people to British rule more deeply than before.

Our first reform should be to have the power to tax ourselves. With that and another reform for which I shall move hereafter, India will advance in material and moral prosperity, and bless and benefit England. The proposal about the right of interpellation is very important,— as important and useful to Government itself as to the people. The very fact that questions will be put in the Council, will prevent in a measure that evil which at present is beyond Government's reach to redress. Government will be relieved of the odium and inconvenience which it at present suffers from misunderstanding and want of opportunities of giving explanation. The British Parliament and public, and the British Government in all its departments, benefit largely by this power of putting questions in Parliament, and the same will be the result here. There will be, in the circumstances of India, one essential difference between the British Parliament and the Indian Legislative Councils. In Parliament, the Government, if defeated, resigns, and the Opposition comes into power. That cannot be done in India. Whether defeated or not, Government will remain in power. Moreover, the Secretary of State for India will have the power to veto, and no harm can happen. If the Government, either Provincial or Supreme, disregard the vote against it, and if the Secretary of State support the disregarding Government, there will be, as a last remedy, the Standing Committee of Parliament as the ultimate appellate body to decide on the point of disagreement; and thus Parliament will truly, and not merely nominally as at present, become the final controlling authority.

We are British subjects and subjects of the same gracious sovereign who has pledged her royal word that we are to her as all her other subjects, and we have a right to all British institutions. If we are true to ourselves, and perseveringly ask what we desire, the British people are the very people on earth who will give what is right and just. From what has already been done in the past we have ample reason to indulge in this belief. Let us for the future equally rely on that character and instinct of the British. They have taught us our wants and they will supply them.

After some discussion, Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji said:—Before the Hon'ble Mr. Telang replies, I may ask to be allowed to say a few words. I may just explain what an important thing this Standing Committee will be. During the East India Company's time, Parliament was entirely independent of it. Parliament was then truly an effective appellate body. It took up Indian questions quite freely and judged fairly, without the circumstance of parties ever interfering with its deliberations. If there was a complaint against the Company, Parliament was free to sit in judgment on it. What is the position since the transfer of the government to the Crown? The Secretary of State for India is the Parliament. Every question in which he is concerned becomes a Cabinet question. His majority is at his back. This majority has no concern in Indian matters further than to back the Government, i.e. the Secretary of State for India. All appeals, therefore, to Parliament against the Secretary of State become a mere farce. M. P.s are utterly discouraged from their inability to do any thing. And the Secretary of State becomes the true Great Mogul of India—a despotic monarch. His will is his law. Nor can the people of India influence him, as their voice is not represented in Parliament. Thus, that tribunal can scarcely exercise any effectual check over his despotism. The present legislative machinery, from the Local Councils upwards, is simply a device to legalise despotism and give it the false mask of constitutionalism. The tax-payers have no voice in the imposition of the taxes they pay, and Parliament has not the ability to prevent the levy of unfair or oppressive taxation. The ultimate controlling authority seems helpless to control anything! Now if we have complete representative legislation here, and if we have a Standing Committee in Parliament, we shall have both the voice of the taxed on the one side and effectual control of Parliament on the other. Such a Standing Committee will naturally be independent of all parties. Its decision will be no defeat of Government. It will be simply a final decision on the point of difference that may have arisen between the representatives of the people in India on the one hand, and the Government on the other, on any particular question. India will thus have an effectual parliamentary control.

It is said we should propose something as a substitute for the present India Office Council. The resolution now before the Congress makes this unnecessary. The Council, when it was established, was considered to be protective of Indian interests. It has not proved so. When it suits the Secretary of State, he screens himself behind that Council. When it does not suit him, he flings the Council aside. We have no means of knowing what good at all is done by the Council. Its irresponsibility and its secrecy are fatal objections to its continuance. Such a thing in the government of an empire of 200 millions of people and under the British is an utter and an inexplicable anachronism. Moreover, the majority of the Council consists of Anglo-Indians. These, sitting in judgment on their own handiwork, naturally regard it as perfect. Having left India years ago, they fail to realise the rapid changes that are taking place here in our circumstances, lose touch with us and offer resistance to all progress. Times are now changed. The natives, I may say, have come of age. They can represent directly their wishes and views to the Government here, and to the Secretary of State. They do not require the aid of this Council at the India Office for their so-called representation or protection.

I may here remark, that the chief work of this the first National Congress of India is to enunciate clearly and boldly our highest and ultimate wishes. Whether we get them or not immediately, let our rulers know what our highest aspirations are. And if we are true to ourselves, the work of each delegate present here will be to make the part of India where he happens to live devote itself earnestly to carrying out the objects resolved upon at this Congress with all due deliberation. If, then, we lay down clearly that we desire to have the actual government of India transferred from England to India under the simple controlling power of the Secretary of State, and of Parliament, through its Standing Committee, and that we further desire that all taxation and legislation shall be imposed here by representative Councils, we say what we are aiming at. And that under such an arrangement on Council advise to the Secretary of State is necessary. Neither is a Council needed to attend to the appellate executive work. There is a permanent Under-Secretary of State who will be able to keep up continuity of knowledge and transact all current business. There are, besides, Secretaries at the head of the different departments as experts. I do not deny that at times the India Office Council has done good service. But this was owing to the personality and sympathy of individual men like Sir E. Perry. The constitution of the body as a body is objectionable and anomalous. When the whole power of imposing taxation and legislation is transferred here, the work of the Secretary of State will be largely diminished. It will only be confined to general supervision of important matters. Whatever comes before him for disposal will be set forth by the Government from here fully and fairly in all its bearings. No Council will be needed to aid him in forming his judgment. Thus no substitute is required for the India Office Council. It is enough for us to formulate the scheme, now submitted for your consideration, as one which India needs and desires, viz., representative Legislative Councils in India, with full financial control and interpellatory powers. And we shall not need to trouble much the authorities in England.

Third Day's Proceedings (30th December 1885).

The Hon'ble Dadabhai Naoroji, in moving the fourth Resolution,* said :—The Resolution which I am proposing does not in any way involve the question whether the distinction between the covenanted and uncovenanted services should be abolished or not. That is a separate question altogether, and in fact, if my resolution is adopted that question will become unnecessary or very subordinate. The resolution which I propose to you is of the utmost possible importance to India. It is the most important key to our material and moral advancement. All our other political reforms will benefit us but very little indeed if this reform of all reforms is not made. It is the question of poverty or prosperity. It is the question of life and death to India. It is the question of questions. Fortunately, it is not necessary for me on this occasion to go into all its merits, as I hope you are all already well aware of my views and their reasons, or it would have been very difficult for me to lay before you all I should have had to say without speaking for hours. There is an additional good fortune for me that what I want to propose was already proposed a quarter of a century ago by no less an authority than a Committee of the India Office itself. The report of this Committee gives the whole matter in a nutshell from the point of view of justice, right, expediency and honest fulfilment of promises. And the reasons given by it for the covenanted civil service apply equally to all the other services in the civil department. I do not refer to the military service in this resolution, as that is a matter requiring special consideration and treatment. To make my remarks as brief as possible, as we are much pressed for time, I shall first at once read to you the extract from the report of the Committee consisting of Sir J. P. Willoughby, Mr. Mangles, Mr. Arbuthnot, Mr. Macnaughten, and Sir Erskine Perry. The report, dated 20th January 1860, says :—

“2. We are, in the first place, unanimously of opinion that it is not only just but expedient that the Natives of India shall be employed in the administration of India to as large an extent as possible, consistently with the maintenance of British supremacy, and have considered whether any increased facilities can be given in this direction.

“3. It is true that, even at present, no positive disqualification exists. By Act 3 and 4, Wm. 4, C. 85, S. 87, it is enacted “that no Native of the said territories, nor any natural born subject of His Majesty resident therein, shall, by reason only of his religion, place of birth, descent, colour or any of them, be disabled from holding any place, office or employment under the said Company.” It is obvious therefore that when the competitive system was adopted it could not have been intended to exclude Natives of India from the Civil Service of India.

“4. Practically, however, they are excluded. The law declares them eligible, but the difficulties opposed to a Native leaving India, and residing in England for a time, are so great, that as a general rule, it is almost impossible for a Native successfully to compete at the periodical examination held in England. Were this inequality removed, we should no longer be exposed to the charge of keeping promise to the ear and breaking it to the hope.

"5. Two modes have been suggested by which the object in view might be attained. The first is by allotting a certain portion of the total number of appointments declared in each year to be competed for in India by Natives and by other natural-born subjects of Her Majesty's residents in India. The second is, to hold simultaneously two examinations, one in England and one in India, both being, as far as practicable, identical in their nature, and those who compete in both countries being finally classified in one list according to merit by the Civil Service Commissioners. The Committee have no hesitation in giving the preference to the second scheme, as being the fairest, and the most in accordance with the principles of a general competition for a common object."

Now according to strict right and justice the examination for services in India ought to take place in India alone. The people of Australia, Canada and the Cape do not go to England for their services. Why should Indians be compelled to go to England to compete for the services, unless it be England's despotic will. But I am content to propose the resolution according to the views of the Committee for simultaneous examinations, both in England and India, and the reasons that apply to the Civil Service apply equally well to the other services in the Civil Department, viz., Engineering, Medical, Telegraph, Forest, and so on.

I may here remind you that in addition to the Act of 1833 referred to by the Committee, we have the solemn promises contained in the Proclamation of our gracious Sovereign. The fact is told to us in unmistakable language:—"We hold ourselves bound to the Natives of our Indian territories by the same obligations of duty which bind us to all our other subjects; and those obligations, by the blessing of Almighty God, we shall faithfully and conscientiously fulfil." And then they declared her gracious promise specifically on this very part of the services:—"And it is our further will that, so far as may be our subjects, of whatever race or creed, be freely and impartially admitted to offices in our service, the duties of which they may be qualified, by their education, ability and integrity, duly to discharge." This gracious proclamation and the promises contained therein were made known in 1858. And the India Office Committee showed, in 1860, in what way these promises could be fulfilled, so as to relieve the English nation from "the charge of keeping promise to the ear and breaking it to the hope." With the Act of Parliament of 1833, the solemn promises of 1858, of our Sovereign before God and man, and the declaration by the India Office of the mode of fulfilling those promises in 1860, it is hardly necessary for me to say more. Our case for the resolution proposed by me is complete. As a matter of justice, solemn promises and even expediency, I would have ended my speech here, but my object in proposing this resolution rests upon a far higher and a most important consideration. The question of the extreme poverty of India is now no more a controversial point. Viceroys and Finance Ministers have admitted it. The last official declaration by Sir E. Baring is complete and unequivocal. In his budget speech of 18th March 1882 he said :—" It has been calculated that the average income per head of population in India is not more than Rs. 27 a year; and though I am not prepared to pledge myself to the absolute accuracy of a calculation of this sort, it is sufficiently accurate to justify the conclusion that the taxpaying community is exceedingly poor. To derive any very large increase of revenue from so poor a population as this is obviously impossible, and, if it were possible, would be unjustifiable." Again, in the discussion on the budget, after repeating the above statement regarding the income of Rs. 27 per head per annum, he said :—" But he thought it was quite sufficient to show the extreme poverty of the mass of the people. In England the average income per head of population was £33 per head; in France it was £23; in Turkey, which was the poorest country in Europe, it was £4 per head. He would ask Honorable members to think what Rs. 27 per annum was to support a person, and then he would ask whether a few annas was nothing to such poor people." With this emphatic and clear opinion before you, I need not say more. The question is what is the cause of this poverty? I have shown in my papers on the poverty of India, and in my correspondence with the Secretary of State for India, that the sole cause of this extreme poverty and wretchedness of the mass of the people is the inordinate employment of foreign agency in the government of the country and the consequent material loss to and drain from the country. I request those who have not already seen these papers to read them, for it is utterly impossible for me to go through the whole argument here. It will be, therefore, now clear to you that the employment of Native agency is not merely a matter of justice and expediency, according to the views of the India Office Committee, but a most absolute necessity for the poor, suffering, and starving millions of India. It is a question of life and death to the country. The present English rule is no doubt the greatest blessing residing in England for a time, are so great, that as a general rule, it is almost impossible for a Native successfully to compete at the periodical examination held in England. Were this inequality removed, we should no longer be exposed to the charge of keeping promise to the ear and breaking it to the hope.

“5. Two modes have been suggested by which the object in view might be attained. The first is by allotting a certain portion of the total number of appointments declared in each year to be competed for in India by Natives and by other natural-born subjects of Her Majesty’s residents in India. The second is, to hold simultaneously two examinations, one in England and one in India, both being, as far as practicable, identical in their nature, and those who compete in both countries being finally classified in one list according to merit by the Civil Service Commissioners. The Committee have no hesitation in giving the preference to the second scheme, as being the fairest, and the most in accordance with the principles of a general competition for a common object.”

Now according to strict right and justice the examination for services in India ought to take place in India alone. The people of Australia, Canada and the Cape do not go to England for their services. Why should Indians be compelled to go to England to compete for the services, unless it be England’s despotic will. But I am content to propose the resolution according to the views of the Committee for simultaneous examinations, both in England and India, and the reasons that apply to the Civil Service apply equally well to the other services in the Civil Department, viz., Engineering, Medical, Telegraph, Forest, and so on.

I may here remind you that in addition to the Act of 1833 referred to by the Committee, we have the solemn promises contained in the Proclamation of our gracious Sovereign. The fact is told to us in unmistakable language:—“We hold ourselves bound to the Natives of our Indian territories by the same obligations of duty which bind us to all our other subjects ; and those obligations, by the blessing of Almighty God, we shall faithfully and conscientiously fulfil.” And then they declared her gracious promise specifically on this very part of the services:—“And it is our further will that, so far as may be our subjects, of whatever race or creed, be freely and impartially admitted to offices in our service, the duties of which they may be qualified, by their education, ability and integrity, duly to discharge.” This gracious proclamation and the promises contained therein were made known in 1858. And the India Office Committee showed, in 1860, in what way these promises could be fulfilled, so as to relieve the English nation from “the charge of keeping promise to the ear and breaking it to the hope." With the Act of Parliament of 1833, the solemn promises of 1858, of our Sovereign before God and man, and the declaration by the India Office of the mode of fulfilling those promises in 1860, it is hardly necessary for me to say more. Our case for the resolution proposed by me is complete. As a matter of justice, solemn promises and even expediency, I would have ended my speech here, but my object in proposing this resolution rests upon a far higher and a most important consideration. The question of the extreme poverty of India is now no more a controversial point. Viceroys and Finance Ministers have admitted it. The last official declaration by Sir E. Baring is complete and unequivocal. In his budget speech of 18th March 1882 he said :—" It has been calculated that the average income per head of population in India is not more than Rs. 27 a year ; and though I am not prepared to pledge myself to the absolute accuracy of a calculation of this sort, it is sufficiently accurate to justify the conclusion that the taxpaying community is exceedingly poor. To derive any very large increase of revenue from so poor a population as this is obviously impossible, and, if it were possible, would be unjustifiable." Again, in the discussion on the budget, after repeating the above statement regarding the income of Rs. 27 per head per annum, he said :—" But he thought it was quite sufficient to show the extreme poverty of the mass of the people. In England the average income per head of population was £33 per head ; in France it was £23 ; in Turkey, which was the poorest country in Europe, it was £4 per head. He would ask Honorable members to think what Rs. 27 per annum was to support a person, and then he would ask whether a few annas was nothing to such poor people." With this emphatic and clear opinion before you, I need not say more. The question is what is the cause of this poverty ? I have shown in my papers on the poverty of India, and in my correspondence with the Secretary of State for India, that the sole cause of this extreme poverty and wretchedness of the mass of the people is the inordinate employment of foreign agency in the government of the country and the consequent material loss to and drain from the country. I request those who have not already seen these papers to read them, for it is utterly impossible for me to go through the whole argument here. It will be, therefore, now clear to you that the employment of Native agency is not merely a matter of justice and expediency, according to the views of the India Office Committee, but a most absolute necessity for the poor, suffering, and starving millions of India. It is a question of life and death to the country. The present English rule is no doubt the greatest blessing India has ever had, but this one evil of it nullifies completely all the good it has achieved. Remove but this one evil, and India will be blessed in every way and will be a blessing to England also in every way. The commerce between England and India will increase so that England will then be able to benefit herself ten times more by India's prosperity than what she does now. There will be none of the constant struggle that is at present to be witnessed between the rulers and the ruled—the one screwing out more and more taxes, like squeezing a squeezed orange—inflicting suffering and distress, and the other always crying itself hoarse about its inability to provide them owing to extreme poverty. By the removal of the evil—India will be able not 'merely to supply a revenue of £70,000,000, but £170,000,000, with ease and comfort. England takes over 50 shillings a head for her revenue, why may not India under the same rule be able to take even 20 a head? Indians would easily pay £200,000,000. I should stop now. I hope you will see that this resolution is of the greatest possible importance to India, and I implore every one of you present here to-day to strain every nerve and work perseveringly in your respective localities to attain this object. With regard to the second part of the resolution, the uncovenanted services, the same reasoning and necessity apply. A fair system of competition, testing all necessary qualifications—mental, moral and physical—will be the most suitable mode of supplying the services with the best and most eligible servants, and relieve Government of all the pressure of back door and private influences, and jobbery.

The subject of the age of candidates for the Civil Service examination needs no lengthened remarks from me. It has been only lately threshed out, and it has been established beyond all doubt that the higher age will give you a superior class of men, whether English or Native. I conclude, therefore, with the earnest exhortation that you will all apply yourselves vigorously to free poor India from the great evil of the drain on her resources.

If the British will once understand our true condition, their conscientious desire to rule India for India's and humanity's good, will never allow the evil to continue any longer. Lastly, I hope and trust that our rulers will receive our representations in their proper spirit. We sincerely believe that the good we propose for ourselves is also a good for them. Whatever good they will do to us cannot but in the very nature of things be good to them also. The better we are in material and moral prosperity, the more grateful, attached and loyal we shall be; the worse we are, the less our gratitude and loyalty shall naturally be. The more prosperous we are, the larger shall be their custom ; the worse we are, the condition will be the reverse. The question of our prosperity is as much the question of the prosperity of England and her working man. England's trade would be enriched by £250,000,000, if with our prosperity each unit of the Indian population is ever able to buy from England goods worth only £1 per annum. What is wanted is the fructification in our own pocket of our annual produce. I repeat that it is my hope and trust that our rulers may receive our prayers in their right spirit and do us all the good in their power, for it will redound to their good name, honour and everlasting glory. Let us have the Royal Proclamation fulfilled in its true spirit and integrity, and both England and India will be benefitted and blessed.

With these observations I beg to propose the Fourth Resolution.

The Hon'ble Dadabhai Naoroji, in reply to the discussion, said :—I am glad I have not much to reply to. The appreciation of the importance of the resolution is clear. My remarks will be more as explanations of a few matters. I had much to do with the passing of the clause for granting to us the Statutory Civil Service. It is an important concession, and we have to be very grateful for it. I need not here go into its history. The statesmen in England who gave us this were sincere and explicit in the matter. Whatever complaint we have, it is with the authorities here. First of all, after the clause was passed, the Government of India entirely ignored it and did nothing to give it effect for 6 years! It was only when pressure was applied to it from England, into the details of which this is not the time or place for me to enter, that the necessary rules were at last prepared and published. These rules have been so drafted that they may be carried out in a way to bring discredit on the Service. And whether this is done intentionally or not, whether the subsequent objectionable action upon it was also intentional or not, I cannot say. But the most important element in the carrying out of this clause was partially or wholly ignored, and that has been the real cause of its so-called failure,—I mean educational competence, ascertained either by suitable competition, or proved ability, was an absolutely indispensable condition for admitting candidates to this Service. It is just this essential condition that has been several times ignored or forgotten. Let therefore your efforts be devoted strenuously, not against the clause itself, but against the objectionable mode in which the nominations are made. The Bengal Government has moved in a satisfactory direction, and its example should be followed by all the Governments. It will be the height of folly on our part to wish for the abolition of this Statutory Civil Service—excepting only when simultaneous examinations are held in England and India giving a fair field to all, as proposed in the present resolution. In this fair competition, Eurasians, or domiciled Englishmen, in fact all subjects of Her Imperial Majesty, will have equal justice. I understand that the Eurasians and domiciled Anglo-Indians come under the definition of what is called "statutory Natives." It is only right that those whose country is India should be considered as Natives, and should enjoy all the rights and privileges of Natives. United action between the Natives and Eurasians and domiciled Anglo-Indians will be good for all. What is objectionable is, that Eurasians and domiciled Anglo-Indians blow hot and cold at the same time. At one moment they claim to be Natives, and at another they spurn the Natives and claim to be Englishmen! Common sense must tell them that this is an absurd position to take up and must ultimately do them more harm than good. I desired that there should be cordial union between all whose country is, or who make their country, India One of the speakers remarked that the employment of Natives will be economical. This is a point which I am afraid is not clearly understood. The fact is that the employment of a Native is not only economy, but complete gain to the whole extent of his salary. When a European is employed, he displaces a Native whom nature intended to fill the place. The Native coming in his place, is natural. Every pie he eats is therefore a gain to the country, and every pie he saves is so much saved to the country for the use of all its children. Every pie paid to a foreigner is a complete material loss to the country. Every pie paid to a Native is a complete material saving to the country. In fact, as I have already endeavoured to impress upon you as earnestly as possible, it is the whole question of the poverty or prosperity of the country. We should of course pay a reasonable price for English rule, so that we may have the highest power of control and supervision in English hands, but beyond that is simply ruin to India and not such a benefit to England as she would otherwise have, were India a prosperous country. Our friend there expressed some doubt about the necessity of going to England. I say without the least hesitation that the candidate himself as well as the service will be vastly benefitted by a visit to England The atmosphere of freedom and high civilization which he will breathe will make him an altered man—in character, in intelligence, in experience, in self-respect and in appreciation of due respect for others. In short, he will largely increase his fitness and command more respect in his responsible service. I mean, of course, in the resolution that the expenses of such visits to England by the candidates who have successfully passed the different examinations for the different services in India, should be paid from the public revenue. It may be made clear in the resolution, by adding "at the public expense."

I conclude with my most anxious and earnest exhortation to this Congress, and to every individual member of it, that they should perseveringly strain every nerve to secure the all important object of this resolution as early as possible. Once this foreign drain, this "bleeding to death," is stopped, India will be capable, by reason of its land, labour and its vast resources to become as prosperous as England, with benefit to England also and to mankind, and with eternal glory to the English name and nation.

2

SECOND INDIAN NATIONAL CONGRESS

(Held on the 27th, 28th, 29th and 30th December, in the Rooms of the British Indian Association and the Town Hall, Calcutta).

INAUGURAL ADDRESS OF THE HON. DADABHAI NAOROJI, PRESIDENT OF THE CONGRESS.

(Before the Public Meeting of the inhabitants of Calcutta, held in the Town Hall on the 27th December, to receive the Delegates from different parts of India. Dr. Rajendralal Mitra, LL.D., C.I.E., in the chair. At this Meeting Hon. Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji was appointed the President of the Second Indian National Congress.)

I need not tell you how sincerely thankful I am to you for placing me in this position of honour. I at first thought that I was to be elevated to this proud position as a return for what might be considered as a compliment paid by us to Bengal when Mr. Bonnerjee was elected President of the first Congress last year at Bombay. I can assure you however that that election was no mere compliment to Bengal, but arose out of the simple fact that we regarded Mr. Bonnerjee as a gentleman eminently qualified to take the place of President, and we installed him in that position in all sincerity as the proper man in the proper place. I now see, however, that this election of my humble self is not intended as a return of compliment, but that, as both proposer and seconder have said, you have been kind enough to select me because I am supposed to be really qualified to undertake the task. I hope it may prove so, and that I may be found really worthy of all the kind things said of me; but whether this be so, or not, when such kind things are said by those who occupy such high positions amongst us, I must say I feel exceedingly proud and am very grateful to all for the honour thus done me. (Loud cheering.)

Your late Chairman has heartily welcomed all the delegates who come from different parts of India, and with the same heartiness I return to him, and all our Bengal friends on my own behalf and on that of all the delegates from other provinces, the most sincere thanks for the cordial manner in which we have been received. From what has been done already, and from what is in store for us during our short stay here, I have no doubt we shall carry away with us many and most pleasant reminiscences of our visit to Calcutta. (Cheers.)

You will pardon me, and I beg your indulgence when I say that when I was asked only two days ago to become your President and to give an inaugural address, it was with no small trepidation that I agreed to undertake the task ; and I hope that you will extend to me all that indulgence which my shortcomings may need. (Loud cheers.)

The assemblage of such a Congress is an event of the utmost importance in Indian history. I ask whether in the most glorious days of Hindu rule, in the days of Rajahs like the great Vikram, you could imagine the possibility of a meeting of this kind, where even Hindus of all different provinces of the kingdom could have collected and spoken as one nation. Coming down to the later Empire of our friends, the Mahomedans, who probably ruled over a larger territory at one time than any Hindu monarch, would it have been, even in the days of the great Akbar himself, possible for a meeting like this to assemble composed of all classes and communities, all speaking one language, and all having uniform and high aspirations of their own ?

Well, then, what is it for which we are now met on this occasion ? We have assembled to consider questions upon which depend our future, whether glorious or inglorious. It is our good fortune that we are under a rule which makes it possible for us to meet in this manner. (Cheers.) It is under the civilizing rule of the Queen and people of England that we meet here together, hindered by none, and are freely allowed to speak our minds without the least fear and without the least hesitation. Such a thing is possible under British rule and British rule only. (Loud cheers.) Then I put the question plainly : Is this Congress a nursery for sedition and rebellion against the British Government (cries of no, no) ; or is it another stone in the foundation of the stability of that Government (cries of yes, yes) ? There could be but one answer, and that you have already given, because we are thoroughly sensible of the numberless blessings conferred upon us, of which the very existence of this Congress is a proof in a nutshell. (Cheers.) Were it not for these blessings of British rule I could not have come here, as I have done, without the least hesitation and without the least fear that my children might be robbed and killed in my absence ; nor could you have comè from every corner of the land, having performed, within a few days, journeys which in former days would have occupied as many months. (Cheers.) These simple facts bring home to all of us at once some of those great and numberless blessings which British rule has conferred upon us. But there remain even greater blessings for which we have to be grateful. It is to British rule that we owe the education we possess ; the people of England were sincere in the declarations made more than half a century ago that India was a sacred charge entrusted to their care by Providence, and that they were bound to administer it for the good of India, to the glory of their own name, and the satisfaction of God. (Prolonged cheering.) When we have to acknowledge so many blessings as flowing from British rule—and I could descant on them for hours, because it would simply be recounting to you the history of the British Empire in India—is it possible that an assembly like this, every one of whose members is fully impressed with the knowledge of these blessings, could meet for any purpose inimical to that rule to which we owe so much ? (Cheers.)

The thing is absurd. Let us speak out like men and proclaim that we are loyal to the backbone (cheers) ; that we understand the benefits English rule has conferred upon us ; that we thoroughly appreciate the education that has been given to us, the new light which has been poured upon us, turning us from darkness into light and teaching us the new lesson that kings are made for the people, not people for their kings ; and this new lesson we have learned amidst the darkness of Asiatic despotism only by the light of free English civilization. (Loud cheers.) But the question is, do the Government believe us ? Do they believe that we are really loyal to them ; that we do truly appreciate and rely on British rule ; that we veritably desire its permanent continuance ; that our reason is satisfied and our sentimental feelings gratified as well as our self interest ? It would be a great gratification to us if we could see in the inauguration of a great movement like this Congress, that what we do really mean and desire is thoroughly and truly so understood by our rulers. I have the good fortune to be able to place before you testimony which cannot be questioned, from which you will see that some at least of the most distinguished of our rulers do believe that what we say is sincere; and that we do not want to subvert British rule ; that our outspoken utterances are as much for their good as for our good. They do believe, as Lord Ripon said, that what is good for India is good for England. I will give you first the testimony as regards the educated classes which was given 25 years ago by Sir Bartle Frere. He possessed an intimate knowledge of the people of this country, and with regard to the educated portion of them he gave this testimony. He said : ‘And now wherever I go I find the best exponents of the policy of the English Government, and the most able co-adjutors in adjusting that policy to the peculiarities of the natives of India, among the ranks of the educated natives.’ This much at least is testimony to our sincerity, and strongly corroborates our assertion that we, the educated classes, have become the true interpreters and mediators between the masses of our countrymen and our rulers. I shall now place before you the declaration of the Government of India itself, that they have confidence in the loyalty of the whole people, and do appreciate the sentiments of the educated classes in particular. I will read their very words. They say in a despatch addressed to the Secretary of State (8th June 1880): ‘But the people of India accept British rule without any need for appeal to arms, because we keep the peace and do justice, because we have done and are doing much material good to the country and the people, and because there is not inside or outside India any power that can adequately occupy our place.’ Then they distinctly understand that we do believe the British power to be the only power that can, under existing circumstances, really keep the peace, and advance our future progress. This is testimony as to the feeling of the whole people. But of the educated classes this despatch says: ‘To the minds of at least the educated among the people of India—and the number is rapidly increasing—any idea of the subversion of British power is abhorrent, from the consciousness that it must result in the wildest anarchy and confusion.’ (Loud cheers.)

We can, therefore, proceed with the utmost serenity and with every confidence that our rulers do understand us ; that they do understand our motives, and give credit to our expressions of loyalty, and we need not in the least care for any impeachment of disloyalty or any charge of harbouring wild ideas of subverting the British power that may be put forth by ignorant, irresponsible or ill-disposed individuals or cliques. (Loud cheers.) We can therefore quietly, calmly, and with entire confidence in our rulers, speak as freely as we please, but of course in that spirit of fairness and moderation which becomes wise and honest men, and in the tone which every gentleman, every reasonable being, would adopt when urging his rulers to make him some concession. (Hear, hear.) Now although, as I have said, the British Government have done much, very much for us, there is still a great deal more to be done if their noble work is to be fitly completed. They say this themselves; they show a desire to do what more may be required, and it is for us to ask for whatsoever, after due deliberation, we think that we ought to have. (Cheers.)

Therefore, having said thus much, and having cleared the ground so that we may proceed freely and in all confidence with the work of our Congress, I must at once come to the matter with which I should have commenced had I not purposely postponed it until I had explained the relations between ourselves and our rulers; and that is the most happy and auspicious occasion which the coming year is to bring us, viz., the Jubilee of our good Queen-Empress' reign. (Loud cheers.) I am exceedingly glad that the Congress has thought it right to select this as the subject of the initial resolution, and in this to express, in humble but hearty terms, their congratulations to our Gracious Empress. (Cheers.) There is even more reason for us to congratulate ourselves on having for half a century enjoyed the rule of a Sovereign graced with every virtue, and truly worthy to reign over that vast Empire on which the sun never sets. (Loud cheers.) That she may live long, honoured and beloved, to continue for yet many years that beneficial and enlightened rule with which she has so long reigned, must be the heartfelt prayer of every soul in India. (Prolonged cheering.)

And here you must pardon me if I digress a moment from those subjects which this Congress proposes to discuss, to one of those which we do not consider to fall within the legitimate sphere of its deliberations.

It has been asserted that this Congress ought to take up questions of social reforms (cheers and cries of yes, yes), and our failure to do this has been urged as a reproach against us. Certainly no member of this National Congress is more alive to the necessity of social reforms than I am; but, gentlemen, for everything there are proper times, proper circumstances, proper parties and proper places (cheers); we are met together as a political body to represent to our rulers our political aspirations, not to discuss social reforms, and if you blame us for ignoring these you should equally blame the House of Commons for not discussing the abstruser problems of mathematics or metaphysics. But, besides this there are here Hindus of every caste, amongst whom, even in the same provinces, customs and social arrangements differ widely,—there are Mahomedans and Christians of various denominations, Parsees, Sikhs, Brahmos and what not—men indeed of each and all of those numerous classes which constitute in the aggregate the people of India. (Loud cheers.) How can this gathering of all classes discuss the social reforms needed in each individual class? What do any of us know of the internal home life, of the customs, traditions, feelings, prejudices of any class but our own? How could a gathering, a cosmopolitan gathering like this, discuss to any purpose the reforms needed in any one class? Only the members of that class can effectively deal with the reforms therein needed. A National Congress must confine itself to questions in which the entire nation has a direct participation, and it must leave the adjustment of social reforms and other class questions to class Congresses. But it does not follow that, because this national, political body does not presume to discuss social reforms, the delegates here present are not just as deeply, nay, in many cases far more deeply, interested in these questions than in those political questions we do discuss, or that those several communities whom those delegates represent are not doing their utmost to solve those complicated problems on which hinge the practical introduction of those reforms. Any man who has eyes and ears open must know what struggles towards higher and better things are going on in every community: and it could not be otherwise with the noble education we are receiving. Once you begin to think about your own actions, your duties and responsibilities to yourself, your neighbours and your nation, you cannot avoid looking round and observing much that is wrong amongst you; and we know as a fact that each community is now doing its best according to its lights, and the progress that it has made in education. I need not I think particularise. The Mahomedans know what is being done by persons of their community to push on the education their brethren so much need; the Hindus are everywhere doing what they can to reform those social institutions which they think require improvement. There is not one single community here represented of which the best and ablest men do not feel that much has to be done to improve the social, moral, religious status of their brethren, and in which, as a fact, they are not striving to effect, gradually, those needful improvements; but these are essentially matters too delicate for a stranger's handling—matters which must be left to the guidance of those who alone fully understand them in all their bearings and which are wholly unsuited to discussion in an assemblage like this in which all classes are intermingled. (Loud cheers.)

I shall now refer briefly to the work of the former Congress. Since it met last year, about this time, some progress, I am glad to say, has been made, and that is an encouragement and a proof that, if we do really ask what is right and reasonable, we may be sure that, sooner or later, the British Government will actually give what we ask for. We should therefore persevere, having confidence in the conscience of England, and resting assured that the English nation will grudge no sacrifice to prove the sincerity of their desire to do whatever is just and right. (Cheers.)

Our first request at the last Congress was for the constitution of a Royal Commission. Unfortunately the authorities in England have not seen their way to grant a Royal Commission. They say it will upset the authorities here ; that it will interfere with the prestige and control of the Government here. I think that this is a very poor compliment to our rulers on this side. If I understand a man like Lord Dufferin, of such vast experience in administration, knowing, as he does, what it is to rule an empire, it would be impossible for him to be daunted and frightened by a commission making enquiries here. I think this argument a very poor one, and we must once more say that to the inhabitants of India a Parliamentary Committee taking evidence in England alone can never be satisfactory, for the simple reason that what the Committee will learn by the ear will never enable them to understand what they ought to see with their eyes if they are to realize what the evidence of the witnesses really means. Still, however, it is so far satisfactory that, notwithstanding the change of Government and the vicissitudes which this poor Parliamentary Committee has undergone, it is the intention of Parliament that under any and all circumstances a Committee shall be appointed. At the same time this Committee in futuro ties the hands of the authorities here to a large extent and prevents us from saying all we do really want.

Another resolution on which we must report some progress was to the effect that the N. W. Provinces and the Punjab ought also to have Legislative Councils of their own. We know that the Government has just given a Legislative Council to the N. W. Provinces, and we hope that this progress may extend further and satisfy our wishes as to other provinces also.

The fourth resolution had regard to the Service question. In this matter we really seem to have made some distinct progress. The Public Service Commission is now sitting, and if one thing more than another can prove that the Government is sincere in its desire to do something for us, this appointment of such a Commission is that thing. You perhaps remember the words which our noble Viceroy used at Poona. He said ; ‘However, I will say that from first to last I have been a strong advocate for the appointment of a Committee or Commission of this sort, and that when succeeding Governments in England changed, I have on each occasion warmly impressed upon the Secretary of State the necessity of persevering in the nomination of a Commission. I am happy to think that in response to my earnest representations on the subject, Her Majesty's present Ministers have determined to take action. I consequently do not really see what more during the short period I have been amongst you, the Government of India could have done for that most important and burning question which was perpetually agitating your mind, and was being put forward by the natives as an alleged injustice done to the educated native classes of this country in not allowing them adequate employment in the Public Service. I do not think you can point out to me any other question which so occupied public attention or was nearer to the hearts of your people. Now the door to inquiry has been opened, and it only remains for you, by the force of logic of your representations and of the evidence you may be able to submit, to make good your case; if you succeed in doing so, all I can say is, that nobody will be better pleased than myself. In regard to other matters, which have been equally prominent in your newspapers and your addresses, and which have been so constantly discussed by your associations, I have also done my best to secure for you an ample investigation.’

There we have his own words as to his intentions and the efforts he made to get this Commission. This should convince us of his good faith and sympathy with us. When I think of Lord Dufferin, not only as our present Viceroy, but bearing in mind all we know of him in his past career, I should hesitate to believe that he could be a man devoid of the deepest sympathy with any people struggling to advance and improve their political condition. Some of you may remember one or two extracts which I gave in my Holborn Town Hall speech from Lord Dufferin’s letters to the Times, and I cannot conceive that a person of such warm sympathies could fail to sympathise with us. But I may say this much that, feeling as I naturally do some interest about the views and intentions of our Viceroys and Governors, I have had the opportunity of getting some information from friends on whom I can rely and who are in a position to know the truth; and I am able to say in the words of one of these friends that ‘the Viceroy’s instincts are eminently liberal, and he regards with neither jealousy nor alarm the desire of the educated classes to be allowed a larger share in the administration of their own affairs. Indeed he considers it very creditable to them that they should do so.' As Viceroy he has to consider all sides of a question from the ruler's point of view, and to act as he thinks safe and proper. But we may be sure that we have his deep and very genuine sympathy, and we may fairly claim and expect much good at his hands.

But yet further I would enquire whether the intentions of the Secretary of State for India and of the other home authorities are equally favourable to our claims. The resolution on its very face tells us what the intention of the Secretary of State is. It says : ' In regard to its object the Commission would, broadly speaking, be required to devise a scheme which may reasonably be hoped to possess the necessary elements of finality, and to do full justice to the claims of natives of India to a higher and more extensive employment in the Public Service.'

There we have the highest authority making a declaration that he desires to do full justice to the claims of the natives of India. Now our only reply is that we are thankful for the enquiry, and we hope that we may be able to satisfy all, that what we ask is both reasonable and right.

As another proof of the intentions of our British rulers, as far back as 53 years ago, when the natives of India did not themselves fully understand their rights, the statesmen of England of their own free will decided what the policy of England ought to be towards India. Long and important was the debate ; the question was discussed from all points of view ; the danger of giving political power to the people, the insufficiency of their capacity and other considerations were all fully weighed, and the conclusion was come to in unmistakable and unambiguous terms, that the policy of British rule should be a policy of justice (cheers), the policy of the advancement of one-sixth of the human race. (Cheers.) India was to be regarded as a trust placed by God in their hands, and in the due discharge of that trust they resolved that they would follow the 'plain path of duty,' as Mr. Macaulay called it ; on that occasion he said, virtually, that he would rather see the people of India free and able to govern themselves, than that they should remain the bondsmen of Great Britain and the obsequious toadies of British officials. (Cheers.) This was the essence of the policy of 1833, and in the Act of that year it was laid down : 'That no native of the said territories, nor any natural-born subject of His Majesty resident therein shall, by reason only of his religion, place of birth, descent, color or any of them be disabled from holding any place, office or employment under the said Company.' (Prolonged cheering.) We do not, we could not, ask for more than this; and all we have to press upon the Commission and Government is that they should now honestly grant us in practice here what Great Britain freely conceded to us 50 years ago, when we ourselves were too little enlightened even to ask for it. (Loud cheers.)

We next passed through a time of trouble, and the British arms were triumphant. When they had completely surmounted all their difficulties, and completely vanquished all their adversaries, the English nation came forward, animated by the same high and noble resolves as before, and gave us that glorious proclamation which we should for ever prize and reverence as our Magna Charta—greater even than the Charter of 1833. I need not repeat that glorious proclamation now, for it is engraven on all your hearts (loud cheers); but it constitutes such a grand and glorious charter of our liberties that I think every child as it begins to gather intelligence and to lisp its mother tongue, ought to be made to commit it to memory. (Cheers.) In that proclamation we have again a confirmation of the policy of 1833 and something more. In it are embodied the germs of all that we aim at now, of all that we can desire hereafter. (Cheers.) We have only to go before the Government and the Commission now sitting and repeat it, and say that all we want is only what has already been granted to us in set terms by that proclamation, and that all we now ask for is that the great and generous concessions therein made to us in words shall actually be made ours by deeds. (Loud cheers.) I will not, however, enter into further details, for it is a subject on which I should be led into speaking for hours, and even then I should fail to convey to you an adequate idea of all that is in my heart. I have said enough to show our rulers that our case is complete and has been made out by themselves. (Cheers.) It is enough for me therefore to stop at this point.

Another resolution is the improvement and enlargement of the Legislative Councils, and the introduction into them of an elective element, but that is one on which my predecessor in the chair has so ably descanted that I do not think I should take up more of your time with it. I need only say that in this matter we hope to make a further advance, and shall try to place before our rulers what we consider a possible scheme for the introduction of an elective element into the Legislative Councils. I need not say that if this representation is introduced, the greatest benefit will be conferred upon the Government itself, because at present whatever Acts they pass that do not quite please us, we, whether rightly or wrongly, grumble and grumble against the Government, and the Government only. It is true that we have some of our own people in the Councils. But we have no right to demand any explanation even from them; they are not our representatives, and the Government can not relieve themselves from any dissatisfaction we may feel against any law we don't like. If our own representatives make a mistake and get a law passed which we do not want, the Government at any rate will escape the greater portion of the consequent unpopularity. They will say—here are your own representatives; we believed that they represented your wishes, and we passed the law. On the other hand with all the intelligence, all the superior knowledge of the English officials, let them come as angels from heaven, it is impossible for them to enter into the feelings of the people, and feel as they feel, and enter into their minds. (Cheers.) It is not any disparagement of them, but in the nature of things it cannot be otherwise. If you have therefore your representatives to represent your feelings, you will then have an opportunity of getting something which is congenial and satisfactory to yourselves; and what will be satisfactory to you must also be satisfactory to and good for the Government itself. (Cheers.)

This brings me also to the point of representation in Parliament. All the most fundamental questions on which hinge the entire form and character of the administration here are decided by Parliament. No matter what it is, Legislative Councils, the Services,—nothing can be reformed until Parliament moves and enacts modifications of the existing Acts. Not one single genuine Indian voice is there in Parliament to tell at least what the native view is on any question. This was most forcibly urged upon me by English gentlemen who are in Parliament themselves; they said they always felt it to be a great defect in Parliament, that it did not contain one single genuine representative of the people of India.

One of the questions which will be placed before this Congress and will be discussed by them, is the deep sympathy which this Congress feels for the poverty of the people. It is often understood and thought that when we struggle for admission into the Services it is simply to gratify the aspirations of the few educated. But if you examine this question thoroughly, you will find that this matter of the Public Services will go far to settle the problem of the poverty of the Indian people. One thing I congratulate myself upon. I don't trouble you with any testimony about the poverty of India. You have the testimony of Sir Evelyn Baring given only a couple of years ago, who told us in plain terms that the people of India were extremely poor, and also of the present Finance Minister who repeats those words. But amongst the several causes which are at the bottom of our sufferings this one, and that the most important cause, is beginning to be realized by our rulers, and that is a step of the most hopeful and promising kind. In the discussion about the currency, the Secretary of State for India, in a letter to the Treasury of the 26th January 1886, makes certain remarks which show that our rulers now begin to understand and try to grapple with the problem; and are not, ostrich-like, shutting their eyes to it. I was laughed at when I first mooted the question of the poverty of India, and assigned as one of its causes the employment of an expensive foreign agency. But now the highest authority emphasizes this view. The Secretary of State, in the letter just referred to, said: 'The position of India in relation to taxation and the sources of the public revenues is very peculiar, not merely from the habits of the people and their strong aversion to change, which is more specially exhibited towards new forms of taxation, but likewise from the character of the Government, which is in the hands of foreigners, who hold all the principal administrative offices, and form so large a part of the army. The impatience of new taxation which would have to be borne, wholly as a consequence of the foreign rule imposed on the country and virtually to meet additions to charges arising outside of the country, would constitute a political danger, the real magnitude of which, it is to be feared, is not at all appreciated by persons, who have no knowledge of, or concern in, the Government of India, but which those responsible for that Government have long regarded as of the most serious order.'

We may be sure that the public conscience of England will ask why the natives of India, after a hundred years of British rule, are so poor; and as John Bull, in a cartoon in Punch is represented as doing, will wonder that India is a beggar when he thought she had a mint of money.

Unfortunately this idea of India's wealth is utterly delusive, and if a proper system of representation in the Councils be conceded, our representatives will then be able to make clear to these Councils and to our rulers those causes which are operating to undermine our wealth and prosperity, and guide the Government to the proper remedies for the greatest of all evils—the poverty of the masses. All the benefits we have derived from British rule, all the noble projects of our British rulers, will go for nothing if after all the country is to continue sinking deeper and deeper into the abyss of destitution. At one time I was denounced as a Pessimist, but now that we have it on the authority of our rulers themselves that we are very poor, it has become the right, as well as the duty, of this Congress to set forth its convictions, both as to this widespread destitution and the primary steps needful for its alleviation. Nothing is more dear to the heart of England—and I speak from actual knowledge—than India's welfare; and if we only speak out loud enough, and persistently enough, to reach that busy heart we shall not speak in vain. (Prolonged cheering.) There will be several other questions brought before the Congress at their Committee meetings during the next three days, and I am sure from the names of the delegates, as far as I am informed, that they will prosecute their deliberations with all possible moderation. I am sure that they will fully appreciate the benefits of the rule under which they live, while the fact that our rulers are willing to do whatever we can show them to be necessary for our welfare, should be enough to encourage all in the work. I do not know that I need now detain you with any further remarks. You have now some idea of what progress has been made in respect of the matters which were discussed last year. I hope we may congratulate ourselves next year that we have made further progress in attaining the objects alike of the past year's resolutions and those we may this year pass. I for one am hopeful that, if we are only true to ourselves, if we only do justice to ourselves and the noble education which has been given to us by our rulers, and speak freely, with the freedom of speech which has been granted to us, we may fairly expect our Government to listen to us and to grant us our reasonable demands. (Loud cheers.)

I will conclude this short address by repeating my sincere thanks to all of you for having placed me in this honourable position, and by again returning thanks to our Bengal brethren on behalf of all the delegates whom they have so cordially welcomed here.

(The President resumed his seat amidst the most energetic and prolonged cheering; throughout, the speech was interrupted, at the close of almost every period, by the most enthusiastic cheers, showing how thoroughly the speaker's words were going home to the hearts, not only of his brother delegates, but of the vast crowd of educated listeners that thronged every portion of the great hall.)

At the close of the second National Congress (30th Dec.) Mr. Dadabhai said :—In responding to the vote of thanks, which you have so kindly accorded to me, I hope the meeting will allow me to say that my expectations as to the admirable conduct of this large assembly have been thoroughly fulfilled and more than fulfilled. I am only speaking tamely I fear when I say that from first to last nothing could possibly have been more honourable to our country than the conduct of all concerned or than the spirit that has pervaded the entire assemblage. In the heat of argument, under that greatest of all stimuli, patriotic enthusiasm, not one word, I believe, has escaped a single speaker that he need wish unspoken. Kindness, courtesy and a spirit of cheerful mutual concession have pervaded our proceedings, which, but for this, could never have reached this happy and successful termination. (Loud cheers.) You are pleased to thank me, but it is for me rather to thank you, for had it not been for the noble spirit in which each and all of you have co-operated in the work and for the support which you have so heartily afforded me in respect of every proposition which has come before the Congress, I could never have succeeded in thus bringing to a successful close the important business that devolved upon us. (Cheers.) I heartily, therefore, thank you one and all for having enabled me to perform my duty and for having made it so easy for me to do it. (Loud cheers.)

There is, however, just one point to which I ought perhaps to refer more particularly, and that is, to the spirit of fairness and moderation and respect towards the Government which has characterized your proceedings from the beginning to the end. I need hardly say how gratified I have been to observe how thoroughly all have seemed to be imbued with that spirit. Not only is it to our interest that it should be so, but it is what the Government, after all they have done for us, have a just right to expect from us. (Cheers.) And I only hope that the example which this great assemblage has set in this respect will be followed not only at all future meetings of the Congress, not only by all and every Association throughout the country, but also by the entire Indian Press, some members of which, under the influence of the bad example too often set to them by a portion of the Anglo-Indian Press, have at times, it must be confessed, transgressed in this respect. (Hear, hear.) If we really desire to be respected, if we wish our request to be attended to, if we honestly expect that the English nation will do its duty towards us, we must prove ourselves worthy by showing that we are never unreasonable, never violent, never uncharitable. We must shew that we are earnest, but temperate, cognizant of our own rights, but respectful of those of others; expecting the fairest constructions of our own acts and motives, and conceding these to those of others; that, in a word, whatever our status in life, high or low, rich or poor, we have become gentlemen in the highest sense of the word. Unless we are and can prove ourselves gentlemen in this highest, noblest sense, I do not know that we are worthy to receive the concessions for which we are pressing. (Loud cheers.) I do not think I need trouble the Congress with any further remarks. I will simply say once more: I thank you. I thank you for myself, for the honour you have done me in choosing me as President, and for the generous kindness with which you have upheld me in the performance of the responsible duties of that high position, and I thank you on behalf of all your countrymen—on behalf of posterity—for the noble manner in which, at this great Congress—which history will not readily forget— you have upheld the credit, the character, the dignity of our beloved India. (Long and enthusiastic cheering.)

III.

MISCELLANEOUS SPEECHES AND ADDRESSES.

THE INDIAN CIVIL SERVICE.

(Before an evening Meeting of the East India Association, at London, Tuesday, August 13th, 1867. Lord Lyveden in the chair.)

1

In proposing for your adoption this memorial,* I am glad that I have a very easy task before me, unless I create some giants of my own imagination to knock them down, for on the principle of the memorial I see on all hands there is but one opinion. Beginning with our gracious Sovereign, she has emphatically declared with regard to the natives of India (in a proclamation dated the 1st of November, 1858), “We hold ourselves bound to the natives of our Indian territories by the same obligations of duty which bind us to all our other subjects, and those obligations, by the blessing of Almighty God, we shall faithfully and conscientiously fulfil." Then, referring to this particular point, the proclamation goes on, "It is our further will, that so far as may be, our subjects, of whatever race or creed, be freely and impartially admitted to offices in our service, the duties of which may be qualified by their education, ability, and integrity duly to discharge." That being the gracious declaration of the will and pleasure of our Sovereign, let us pass next to the opinion of Parliament upon the subject. The opinion of Parliament has been all long decisive upon this matter. As far back as 1833, in the Act of that year, it was distinctly declared, "That no native of the said territories, nor any natural born subject of his Majesty, resident therein, shall, by reason only of his religion, place of birth, descent, colour, or any of them, be disabled from holding any place, office, or employment under the said Company;" and on every occasion when Parliament has had the matter before it, there has scarcely been any possible with the people of the country. He thought that they ought to take a lesson from such a circumstance, and if they were to do their duty towards India they could only discharge that duty by obtaining the assistance and counsel of all who were great and good in that country. It would be absurd in them to say that there was not a large fund of statesmanship and ability in the Indian character.' —(Times, 25th May, 1867.) With these friendly and just sentiments towards the people of India we fully concur, and therefore, instead of trespassing any more upon your time, we beg to lay before you our views as to the best mode of accomplishing the object.

"We think that the competitive examinations for a portion of the appointments to the Indian civil service should be held in India, under such rules and arrangements as you may think proper. What portion of the appointments should be thus competed for in India we cannot do better than leave to your own judgment. After the selection is made in India, by the first examination, we think it essential that the selected candidates be required to come to England to pass their further examinations with the selected candidates of this country.

"In the same spirit, and with kindred objects in view for the general good of India, we would ask you to extend your kind encouragement to native youths of promise and ability to come to England for the completion of their education. We believe that if scholarships, tenable for five years in this country, were to be annually awarded by competitive examination in India to native candidates between the ages of 15 and 17, some would compete successfully in England for the Indian civil service, while others would return in various professions to India, and where by degrees they would form an enlightened and unprejudiced class, exercising a great and beneficial influence on native society, and constituting a link between the masses of the people and their English rulers.

"In laying before you this memorial we feel assured, and we trust that you will also agree with us, that this measure, which has now become necessary by the advancement of education in India, will promote and strengthen the loyalty of the natives of India to the British rule, while it will also be a satisfaction to the British people to have thus by one more instance practically proved its desire to advance the condition of their Indian fellow-subjects, and to act justly by them.

"We need not point out to you, sir, how great an encouragement these examinations in India will be to education. The great prizes of the appointments will naturally increase vastly the desire for education among the people." opposition to the principle enunciated by this memorial. Again, up to the latest day, during the past three or four debates in Parliament which have taken place this year, we have seen the same principle emphatically declared ; even in last night's debate we find the same again brought forward in a prominent way by some who are friends to India, and who also wish well to England. While we have this testimony on the part of our Sovereign and Parliament, we find that the press upon this matter at least is unanimous. So far back as 1853, in commenting upon the petition presented by the Bombay Association, I find a large proportion of the press here admitted the justice and truth of the complaints made by the natives of India, as to the exclusiveness adopted in the civil service at the time, and urging that the natives should be to a suitable extent introduced into the enjoyment of the higher places of responsibility and trust. And recently, in commenting upon the debates that have taken place in Parliament, which I have just referred to, the press has been equally unanimous in reference to this subject. As far as Parliament and the press are any indication of the opinions of the people, we can say the people are at one on this subject. As far as my personal knowledge is concerned, during the twelve years I have been here, or while I was in India, I must confess that I have always found every Englishman that I have spoken to on the subject, admitting its justice, and assuring me that England will always do its duty towards India. I have been sometimes told that some civilians, perhaps, do not like it but I should not do the injustice to say that I recollect any instance in which such an opinion has been expressed to me. The testimony of all eminent men in the Indian service is in favour of giving all necessary facilities for the admission of natives of India to the civil service, as well as that of all those eminent statesmen here who have made India their study. The interest that the natives feel in this subject I need not at all enlarge upon ; that can be at once conceived by their presence here ; the interest they would feel in the Government of India by having the responsibilities of that administration on their own heads, speaks for itself ; and at the same time the strength it would give to the British rule is also a matter of the greatest importance. Lastly, I find that the present Government itself has emphatically declared on this point. In the words I have quoted in the memorial, Sir Stafford Northcote has distinctly stated, “ Nothing could be more wonderful than our empire in India ; but we ought to consider on what conditions we held it, and how our predecessors held it. The greatness of the Mogul empire depended upon the liberal policy that was pursued by men like Akbar availing themselves of Hindu talent and assistance, and identifying themselves as far as possible with the people of the country. He thought that they ought to take a lesson from such a circumstance, and if they were to do their duty towards India, they could only discharge that duty by obtaining the assistance and counsel of all who were great and good in that country. It would be absurd in them te say that there was not a large fund of statesmanship and ability in the Indian character.” With such complete testimony on the principle of this memorial,

I think I was quite justified in saying at the beginning that my task was a very easy one. This last extract; again, enables me to dispose of another point, namely, as to the capacity of the natives of India for administration and for high education. I may at once leave that alone, because at this time of day, after the education which has been received by the natives of India, after the results as shown by the university examinations, and with the actual facts of the efficiency of the services rendered by the natives of India, whenever they are employed in any office of responsibility and trust, it would be simply ridiculous on my part to try to prove to you their capacity for administration and for study, and their high character. The importance and justice of introducing natives of India into the administration to a proper extent, has been urged by various eminent men at different times before committees of the Houses of Parliament. If I had considered it necessary, I could have collected a volume of such extracts. I need only glance at this point, namely, the assistance which the Government of India would derive from the native element being introduced into it. With the best intentions, Englishmen cannot understand the natives of India as a body; their feelings, their ways of thought, and their original education, are so different, that with the best intentions on the part of Englishmen, they very often fail in pointing out the exact remedies for any complaints made by the natives; but if the natives of India were introduced to a proper extent into the administration of the country, naturally their own countrymen would have more sympathy with them. Those native administrators would know where the exact difficulties were, and many of the problems of the present day, to grapple with which all the energies of our English administrators are taxed in vain, would be solved most easily. We would then have the sympathy of the natives with the British rulers, and one of the results of such a concession to the natives would be gratitude on their part, which would form a strong foundation for the upholding of the British rule in India. And when I advocate that which would have a tendency to uphold the British rule in India, it is not for the sake of the English, but for the sake of the natives themselves. They have every reason to congratulate themselves on being under the British rule, after the knowledge they have now derived, and are every day deriving, of the benefits of it. I come, then, to the practical part of the memorial itself. At present the arrangement is that the civil service examination is open to all British subjects; and under that arrangement, no doubt, the natives of India can come here, and they have come here, and undergone the competitive examination (one has passed, and is now serving in India). But if we refer back to the gracious words of our Sovereign, that the natives of India be admitted "freely and impartially," the question naturally arises whether under the present arrangement that declaration and that assurance is practically given effect to. The difficulty on the face of it is this, that the natives are put to the disadvantage of coming over here and remaining here for several years. The risk of losing a sum of money which perhaps they cannot afford, is in itself a disadvantage sufficient to require some change in the arrangement. But, supposing even some few were willing to come here and to compete in the examination, it is not desirable that only those few should be admitted into the civil service; the interests of the civil service require that those serving in it, whether native or English, should be of the highest talents. We do not want those having the longest purses only, but what we want is—in the words of Sir Stafford Northcote—the assistance and counsel of all who are great and good in the country; and we cannot attain that object unless we have a competitive examination which would enable all the best men of India to compete for appointments in the Indian civil service. Such are the men who ought to be introducd into that service. Therefore, putting aside all the disadvantages that the native is put to in coming over to this country, and which are in themselves sufficient to require that some alteration should be made in the present arrangement, the very best interests of the service require that some competition should take place in India whether at an earlier stage or at a later stage; and that a selection should be made, not only of those who can afford to spend a few thousands to come here, but of those who possess the best talent among the people. I have nothing more to say than to refer to the plan I have suggested in the memorial, and I have left it as general as possible, because, with the evidence before us of the interest which Sir Stafford Northcote has taken in the subject, and the emphatic manner in which he has expressed his views as to the necessity and justice of introducing the native element into the service, I can, with the utmost confidence, leave any of the details that would be best suited for the purpose to himself. The natives of India are willing to submit to any standard ; if they could not come up to the standard required by the service, it would be their own fault, and nobody would have any right to complain ; but as long as they can assert that they would be able to stand any standard of examination which they may be reasonably subjected to, it is only just and proper that they should have the opportunity given them. Take, for instance, the case of the fair trial given to the natives for acquiring high education. There were no B.A.s or M.A.s before. The universities being established, we know the result, that the natives have fully vindicated their intellect. And they only ask a fair trial for the civil service. I am desirous, that instead of taking up more of your time, the members present should discuss this fully, and I therefore conclude as I began with the words of our Sovereign, “ In their prosperity will be our strength, in their contentment our security, and in their gratitude our best reward;” and my only prayar is, that a reward nobler than that which has ever been attained by any nation, or any individual, may be earned by our British rulers.

In the proposal made by me, the examination takes place in India, just as it takes place here ; the candidates that pass in India are exactly on the same footing as what are called selected candidates in England. After passing the competitive examination, there are what are called further · examinations here, and it is for those further examinations here that I wish those natives to come here, which would be no hardship on them ; the utmost sacrifice which they might be required to make, if the Government would not assist them, would be the voyage home ; if the Government would pay that, then there would be no hardship, because, as soon as they come here they begin to prepare for their further examination ; they get the first year 100l., and the second year 200l., and then, if they show the necessary proficiency in the subjects they are required to study, there is no competition and no rejection afterwards ; they have only to show that they have spent two years in the necessary studies, having in view the special duties required of them in India ; so that there is no risk of their being rejected. The competitive examination in India would be what it is here, and after they passed that they would be admitted as selected candidates. As I am on my legs, allow me to add to what I have already said, that there is no practical difficulty in what is proposed. The whole thing is embraced in the rules published by the Secretary of State for India every year ; the Secretary of State for India has only to decide as to what proportion of natives it would be advisable to introduce into the civil service, and then to send out instructions to the local government to institute examinations of the same character and under the same rules that are followed here, under which examinations the candidates would be selected; the number may be five or ten, or I should be satisfied if there were two for Bengal and one for each of the other presidencies. Those examinations would take place there under the same rules and the same arrangements under which they take place here. The best on the list would become the selected candidates, and when once they became selected candidates there would be no risk of failing in the competition. There are no practical details to propose ; the arrangement of the whole thing is already practically carried out. The simple question for the Secretary of State to decide being, what proportion of the appointments should be competed for in India, it would be, I think, more proper on the part of this Association to leave that to Sir Stafford Northcote and the Council. They are best able to judge as to that, and I have every confidence that they would do that which is right. The manner in which justice has been done in the case of Mysore, makes me perfectly confident that we have a Government not only willing to make professions, but willing to do what they profess. As I did not contemplate that any details should be proposed, except simply that a certain proportion of appointments to be decided on by the Secretary of State should be competed for in India, the managing committee, to whom this proposal was referred, thought wisely that we might at once go to the whole Association itself, and we have done so. If the Association are inclined to adopt the proposal of the noble chairman, of referring the matter back to a committee, I do not say anything against it, but there is nothing to be considered ; the whole thing is ready cut and dried. There are only two points to be decided by Sir Stafford Northcote : first, whether a certain number of appointments should be competed for in India or not, and next, what proportion of the appointments should be so competed for. With regard to the various remarks which have been made by Mr. Hodgson Pratt, I agree with the full force of them. When he, some years ago, was anxious to promote the plan of bringing over to England young men to be educated, I endeavoured to contribute my humble mite to that endeavour. All I say upon the remarks he has addressed to you is this, that he attaches a little too much importance to an independent body of natives in India who had received their education in England, and who would spread themselves in all the different departments of life, being the only means by which the tone of society, and the status of the whole population would be raised; for we must not forget that, attaching to the administration of the country itself, there are responsibilities that must be incurred; and when a native is introduced into the administration he eomes under a responsibility which an outsider cannot appreciate. If we had only a body of independent educated natives we should have nothing but agitation; there would be no counterpoise to it, there would be no men trained under the yoke of responsibility, who would tell them that there were such and such difficulties in the way of the administration. I have considered this matter very carefully for a long time. I have taken the utmost possible trouble to induce my friends to come over here for their education, and most of the twenty-five who have been referred to are under my care. I have taken that responsibility, because I feel strongly upon the point. I have taken that guardianship for the past twelve years with no little anxiety to myself, but I am glad to say that those young men have behaved most admirably, never having given me cause to complain, and the character that has been given of them, whether by the gentlemen with whom they have been residing, or by the professors of their college, has been that they have been very steady and very good. But in this way we cannot get the best talent. Therefore, I hope that it will not be considered by the Association that I have brought forward this question inconsiderately and immaturely. I do not see the necessity of troubling a committee to go into it again. Here I have my proposal in some detail:—"First Examination for the Civil Service of India, to be held in India." (I would be satisfied even with a few to begin with; I suggest five.) "Five candidates shall be selected every year as follows: —2 from Bengal, 1 from Bombay, 1 from Madras, 1 from the North-west Provinces and the Punjaub. The examination shall be held in each of the above territories, under the instruction of the local government, in the subjects, and according to the rules adopted from time to time by the Civil Service Commissioners for the first competition examination in England. The highest in rank shall be deemed to be selected candidates for the civil service of India. The selected candidates shall, within three months of the announcement of the result of the examination, proceed to England, and the local government shall pay the passage money. After arrival in England these selected candidates shall be subject to the rules and terms for the subsequent 'further examination,' &c. like the selected candidates of England." If it is necessary for a plan to be attached to the memorial, here is one. I admit the force of the remark made by Mr. Hodgson Pratt, that mere education in colleges and universities is not enough, that there are other qualifications necessary. But though I do not agree with those who say that the education given in India does not raise the moral as well as the intellectual character of the pupil, still I purposely make it essential that those natives who are selected for the service should come over to England for those two years, in order that they may acquire all the benefits in England which Mr. Hodgson Pratt so ably described. As to the competitive system, it must be recollected that it has been established as being the best system that can be adopted for arriving at the qualities and capabilities of a man. If the Council think that there ought to be a standard of proficiency at the oar or at cricket, let them establish such a standard; I daresay the natives of India would be quite prepared to try a hand at bowling or at the oar with the natives of England; only, let every one be put on an equal footing. We no longer select men for the service in India according to the system of patronage; we know how that system worked in former times—how proprietors joined together to get their nephews in. I do not refer to past grievances; let the past be the past, we have enough to be thankful for; we select our best men in the best way in our power, by a competitive examination, and though, in a competition of 200 for 50 or 60 situations, there is some chance of an incompetent man getting in, by cramming or by some accident, still, where there is a competition of 100 or 1,000 for only one or two places, the chances are infinitesimally small that anybody who does not possess the highest order of intellect will be able to take those prizes. I beg to submit to our President, with very great deference, that the proposal I have made has been carefully considered. I have consulted several gentlemen who are deeply interested in the matter, and I hope our noble President will support me in approving of this memorial, with the addition which Sir Herbert Edwardes has made, to which I have no objection; it gives the memorial a wider scope, and meets the other difficulty which our noble President suggested as to the expense. It is desirable, instead of simply allowing a few young men to enter the Civil Service, that we should also carry out a comprehensive principle of giving some opportunity to natives of entering upon other independent departments. I fully agree that the assistance proposed by Sir Herbert Edwardes' amendment should be held out to the youths of India; we want the best talent of the country brought here; therefore, I propose that Sir Herbert Edwardes' addition should be embodied in the memorial. Our noble President has said that this memorial does not properly come within the province of this Association. With every deference, I beg to differ from his Lordship. The very basis upon which this institution has been formed is, as expressed by the second rule, the promotion, by all legitimate means, of the interests and welfare of India generally. If the object and purpose of the Association is simply to supply information, I do not see that the Association can do any very great good; but if the Association takes up one subject after another, considerately and carefully, as our noble President suggests, and does actual practical good to the various interests of India, the Association then will have fulfilled its mission of bringing India and England together, doing justice to India, informing the people of this country of all that is necessary to be known by them in relation to Indian matters, and suggesting to them what they, in the situation in which Providence has placed them, as rulers of India, ought to do towards India. If the Association has not been formed to attain those objects, I do not see what good it can do. We may read papers here and have a pleasant discussion on them, and go away with the feeling that we have had a very successful meeting; but if we are to end there, what good shall we have done? What is the object of all our discussion? It is to take such practical steps as may influence the people of this country, and as may influence the Government to rectify existing evils, the rectifying of which would have the effect of consolidating the British rule in India, to the great benefit of both England and India.

2

EXTENSION OF LORD RIPON’S VICEROYALTY.

(Before a public meeting called by the Bombay Branch of the East India Association for the purpose of memorialising Her Majesty the Queen, praying for the extension of the Viceroy’s (Lord Ripon) term of office, on the 17th February 1883, at the Framji Cowasji Institute.)

Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji, who was received with much applause, said that he had been asked to say a few words, and he would tell the meeting what Lord Ripon was as a man. This was clearly shown in his speech at Lahore, where he told his audience that he ruled this country, not as a ruler, but as a friend. (Cheers.) The Viceroy also said that he wanted India to be politically educated, and that he was prepared for all sorts of failures. He further said that they should not pull up the plant every time, in order to see how far the roots had gone, as that would be the best way of destroying the plant. He was determined that his scheme of local self-government should not suffer from any negligence of officials, upon whose minds he had impressed that experience was the best school in which to learn political or moral wisdom. (Cheers.) The Viceroy had boldly and fully carried out what he said in practice. He considered that it was only by experience that public spirit could be aroused among the people of this country, and that they could become a nation of men, instead of being merely subservient slaves. (Cheers.) He (Mr. Dadabhai), who had been considered a pessimist, was glad to say that Lord Ripon was destined not only to be the saviour of the country, but to be the greatest patriot of England. (Cheers.) Because if England performed the great duty of raising this great nation of 250 millions of people to political elevation and civilization, assuredly she ought to be grateful to the man who had achieved such a noble object. (Cheers.) Here was a man, kind and beneficent, of a clear and comprehensive intellect, and firm in carrying out whatever he wanted to be done. When they had such a man, let them do their utmost to secure his services for as long a time as possible. What grasp must this man have who had taken the bull by the horns, who had understood the wants of India so thoroughly that every word he uttered showed that he understood the natives from their own standpoint, and tried to meet their wants in conformity with their habits and ways! (Cheers.) The Viceroy was justly of opinion that the people should grow naturally and gradually to strength and perfection. The speaker prayed that the Viceroy might long be spared to rule over them, and that Her Majesty might allow him to consummate the good he had done. (Loud cheers.)

3

RETIREMENT OF LORD RIPON.

(Before the public meeting of the native inhabitants of Bombay in honour of Lord Ripon, on his retirement from the Viceroyalty, convened by the Sheriff in the Town Hall, on Saturday, the 29th November 1884. The Hon'ble Sir Jamsetjee Jeejeebhoy, Bart, C.S.I., in the chair.)

Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji, who was received with loud and prolonged cheers, in supporting the resolution,* said:—Mr. Chairman and Gentlemen,—All India from one end to the other proclaims the righteousness and good deeds of Lord Ripon. There are not many persons among the thousands that have assembled here, or among the hundreds of thousands of this city or among the millions of this Presidency, who have not his great services by heart. (Cheers.) It will be useless for me to waste any time in a reiteration of them. I shall touch upon what strikes me as the brightest stars in the whole galaxy of his deeds. The greatest questions of the Indian problem to my mind at present are, our material and moral loss, and our political education for self-government. For the former, the first great achievement of the Ripon Government is a courageous and candid acknowledgment that the material and educational condition of India is that of extreme poverty. After this bold and righteous recognition, England will feel bound to remedy this great evil. (Cheers.) Lord Ripon's Government has, however, not remained satisfied with their acknowledgment, but has laid the foundation of the remedy by resolving that Indian energy, Indian resources, and Indian agency must be developed in every way and in all departments with broad and equal justice to all. For the second—our political education—nothing can be a more conclusive proof of the success of his measures in that direction than the sight of the great and national political upheaving in the ovation that is now being poured upon him throughout the length and breadth of India. And we ourselves are here to-day as the proof of the success of our political education. (Cheers.) We are to propose a memorial to Lord Ripon. But what will hundred such memorials be to the great monuments he has himself raised to himself ? As self-government, and self-administration and education advanced, for which all he has raised great new landmarks, his memory shall exist at every moment of India's life, and they will be the everlasting monuments, before which all our memorials will sink into utter insignificance. It was asked in St. Paul where Wren's monument was. This, St. Paul itself, was his monument, was the reply. What is Ripon's monument? It will be answered India itself—a self-governing and prosperous nation and loyal to the British throne. Canning was Pandy Canning, he is now the Canning the Just, of the British historian. The native historian with admiration and gratitude, and the English historian, with pride and pleasure, will point to Ripon, as Ripon the Righteous, the maker and benefactor of a nation of hundreds of millions. (Loud cheers.) But by far the greatest service that Ripon has done, is to England and Englishmen. He has raised the name and glory of England and the Englishmen, and rivetted India's loyalty to the British rule. Deep and unshakeable as my faith is in the English character for fairness and desire to do good to India, I must confess during my humble efforts in Indian politics, I was sometimes driven to despair, and to doubt my faith. But Ripon has completely restored it to its full intensity, that England's conscience is right and England will do its duty and perform its great mission in India, when she has such sons, so pure of heart and high in statesmanship. (Cheers.) I pray that our sovereign give us always Viceroys like Ripon. The good deeds of Ripon are sung all over the land by from the prince to the peasant. I am informed that addresses will flow from the poor agriculturists when Lord Ripon arrives here, and I have the pleasure of reading to you a letter to me from a prince. This is what H. H. the Thakore Saheb Bhagvatsingjee of Gondul says :—"I am happy to note that a movement is being set on foot in Bombay to perpetuate the memory of the retiring Viceroy, Lord Ripon. He has a strong hold on the loyalty and affection of our people, with whose vital interests he has identified himself. So the movement of which you are a promoter has my best sympathies. As a slight tribute of my admiration for the noble Lord Ripon, I beg to subscribe Rs. 3,000 to the Ripon Memorial Fund." (Cheers.) For the sentiments of his Highness the Jam Saheb Vibhajee of Jamnuggur, you can judge best when I tell you that he with his Kuvar Jasvatsingiee has subscribed Rs. 10,000 to the Ripon Memorial. The Thakore Sahebs of Rajkote and Katosan have also subscribed. My friend Mr. Hurkissondas has just this moment received a telegram from H. H. the Thakore Saheb of Limree, the Hon. Jesvatsinghjee, subscribing Rs. 5,000 to the Ripon Memorial. A deputation from the great meeting of Sholapore, which was presided over by Mr. Satyendranath Tajore, has attended here. Also another deputation from Khandeish. Well, gentlemen, these two months will be an epoch and a bright page in Indian history, and we shall be for ever proud that we had the good fortune to have had a share in honouring the great name of Ripon. (Loud and prolonged cheers.)

4

THE FAWCETT MEMORIAL MEETING.

(Before the public meeting of the inhabitants of Bombay, held in the Town Hall, on the 2nd September 1885, convened by the Bombay Presidency Association for the purpose of taking steps to raise a memorial to the late Professor Fawcett. His Excellency Lord Reay, Governor of Bombay, in the chair.)

Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji, who was greeted with loud and prolonged cheers, said :—Your Excellency, Ladies and Gentlemen,—I beg to propose that a committee be formed to take necessary steps for collecting funds for the memorial, and for deciding what form the memorial should take, Mr. P. M. Mehta, the Hon. K. T. Telang, Messrs. D. E. Wacha, R. M. Sayani, and Vundrawandas Purshotumdas acting as honorary secretaries to the fund. I take this proposition in hand with more grief than delight. I knew Professor Fawcett personally, and I know what loss we have suffered. There is a great deal that is always made public and appreciated by the public as far as it is known, but there is a great deal that is done by good men which never sees the light of publication, and which consequently is never appreciated. I give my personal experience of the worth of this great man, which will show you that, whereas in a public way he has done a great deal of good, he has also privately and behind the scenes been proved as useful a friend of India as ever any man has been. To give my own personal reminiscences of one or two incidents, I can tell you that when I appeared before the Finance Committee in England in 1873, I had perhaps the rashness of writing a letter beforehand of what I wanted to give my evidence upon. What I said there, somehow or other, did not suit Mr. Ayrton, the chairman of the committee, and he hindered and hampered me in every way. Before I went to the committee I saw Mr. Fawcett, who was always sympathising with us, and I laid before him the notes which I wanted to submit to the committee. He considered them very carefully and told me that that was the very thing that ought to be brought to the committee. But, strange to say, that when I went before the committee Mr. Ayrton chose to decide that that was just the thing that was not to be brought before the committee. On the first day I was hardly able to give evidence of what I wanted to say. But the next day, when it came to Mr. Fawcett's turn to examine me, in a series of judicious and pointed questions, he brought out all that I had to say in a brief and clear manner. You will see from this that although such little incidents scarcely become public, they are in themselves not without their value. He did, in fact, an invaluable service in enabling a native of India to say all that he wanted to say, whether it was right or wrong. Here is an instance of the justice and fearlessness with which he wanted to treat this country. (Cheers.) Fancy a noble commanding figure standing on the floor of the House of Commons respectfully listened to by the whole House, pleading the cause of hundreds of millions of people whom he had not seen, pleading as effectively as any of India's own sons could ever do (cheers), holding like unto the blind deity of justice the scales in his hands even between friends and foes in small matters and in great. (Loud cheers.) That is the blind man we have assembled to-day to honour. You can easily perceive how many a time, as I saw him pleading our cause, I felt a sort of awe and veneration as for a superior being. (Cheers.) In his speeches he never stooped to catch a momentary applause, but he always spoke in sober language words of wisdom—words that sprang from his inner conviction—that in their turn carried conviction to every one around him. (Cheers.) We are told that where good men stand the ground becomes holy. Here his influence and his words reach and permeate the whole atmosphere, and whoever breathes the atmosphere catches something of that goodness and that sincerity towards nature and God. He was one of those men who not only in the senate stood firm and bold and dealt out even justice to friend and foe alike, but on the stumping platform too he was the same considerate man, who never uttered a word to sink into the vulgar crowd, but always tried to raise them to a level higher and better than they were before he spoke. He himself, we know, had grappled the subject of Indian problems with perfect clearness and in all their details. He learned from Anglo-Indians, but he subsequently became the teacher of all Anglo-Indians. He told them that the time was coming when the policy of the British administration should be entirely changed, that the way in which British India was governed was not the way in which it was fit to be governed by a nation of Englishmen. He understood and always declared that he belonged to a nation to whom India was confided in the providence of God for their care and help. He felt himself to be one of that nation, and he felt the instinct of Englishmen to do that only which was just and right, and to receive the glory derived from the advancement of civilization and by the raising of mankind instead of trampling them down under foot. He felt that duty as an Englishman, and he earnestly and devotedly performed that duty as far as one man of ability and earnestness could ever do. (Cheers.) We are now threatened with a permanent addition to the expenditure of some two millions. Do those statesmen who make such a propos a at all think of what they are about? Fawcett's voice from the grave now rises once again, and we are reminded of his words in connection with the Licence Tax. He said that if such an odious and unjust tax had been imposed, it was because no better one could be substituted in its place, and he further stated that when the time came for them to impose another tax, the Government would be reduced to great straits, and they would have to impose a tax as must end in disaster and serious peril. (Cheers.) The statesmen who are now thinking of imposing the additional burden of expenditure must bear in mind the words of this great man, ponder over them, and carefully consider how far they can impose further burdens on the extremely poor people of India. (Cheers.) When I say the people are extremely poor, the words are not mine, but those of Mr. Fawcett and many other eminent statesmen. I do not want to detain the audience any longer, but I will only say the man is dead, but his words will remain; and I only hope that he will inspire others to follow in his footsteps and to earn the blessings of hundreds of millions of the people of this country. (Loud and prolonged cheers.)

5 DINNER TO HON. MR. DADABHAI NAOROJI BY THE RIPON CLUB.

(Before the Members of the Ripon Club at a dinner given in honour of Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji on his departure to England. Sir Jamsetjee Jeejeebhoy, Bart., C. S. I., in the chair.)

The Hon. Dadabhai Naoroji, who was greeted with loud cheers, said :—Sir Jamsetjee and friends,—I cannot but feel the greatest gratification at the honour you have done me. I value this compliment as one of the highest I can receive. Age brings with it its gratification or the reverse for the past. The individual may be able to judge truly or imperfectly of his own conduct, the true test is the verdict of his fellow countrymen. (Cheers.) If such as the present is the verdict of my countrymen, however extra sweetened it may be with the feeling of kindness towards me, I cannot but feel gratified that I have in my humble way been of some use to my country, and such a feeling is the highest reward I can possibly wish for and enjoy. I remember distinctly what feelings had actuated our first small band of workers who devoted themselves earnestly to the task of social, political, and other reforms. It was his, that educated as we had been at the expense of our country, the deep debt we owed to the British rulers being the instrument and projectors of our intellectual elevation, and having been the few fortunate recipients of such a blessing in the midst of millions of our fellow-countrymen, it was a most serious duty devolved upon us to repay our rulers and our country with loyal and grateful service in every way it may be in our power to do so. This has been all along our animating spirit, and with such reward as I, one of them, have this day received, an emphatic approval is given through me to the workers in the service of their country. It is sometimes said by some, to suit their purpose, that the educated natives do not represent their countrymen. But what is the real state of the case? It is only the educated that can at all and do represent the wants of the dumb millions. It is the educated only who on the one hand can understand the advanced civilization and ideas of our rulers, and on the other hand, the ideas and wants and wishes of their countrymen. It is the educated only that can become the true interpreters, and the connecting link between the rulers and the ruled. (Cheers.) And, moreover, it is the educated and intellectual only that can as in all countries, not England excepted, lead the van of all progress and civilization, and whom the rest of the people follow. The few earnest and talented have always, will always, be the leaders of mankind. My elevation to the membership of the Legislative Council naturally leads me to say that while sincerely thanking you for your good words, I cannot but feel that the situation is one of most onerous responsibility. To legislate for a people, whose weal or woe depends upon such legislation, is one of the highest as well as the most responsible of human duties and functions, and I shall consider myself very fortunate if I even partially succeed in this duty. As to all my past to which you have alluded in such exceedingly kind terms, I can only say I thank you most heartily. The work in which I have had my share with such persons as our much lamented friend Nowrozjee Furdoonjee, and many others, has, I trust, done something for our social and political advancement. (Cheers.) The progress has, no doubt, been yet small, but it is hopeful. If we are true to ourselves, and earnestly and single-mindedly work for the welfare of our country, all other circumstances are in our favour. Education is advancing though slowly, the mass of the people are beginning to be leavened with and awakened to civilizing influences. All India is beginning to work in concert like the National Congress held here last year. And above all we have rulers who above all others are pre-eminently the nation of progress, political advancement, freedom and human civilization. The highest ambition to which every true patriot of India should aspire is to desire the continuance of the British rule for a long, long time to come, and to strengthen it with every possible effort and true loyalty. (Loud cheers.) This is the very reason why we should not hesitate to lay ourselves freely before our rulers in order that, understanding our wants clearly, our rulers may be enabled to see their way to do what may be necessary. One thing I am assured of in the English character. Oppose and have a stand up fight with an Englishman. He may beat you or you may beat him. When the fight is over, he will respect you the more for your manliness, because he is himself manly and appreciates manliness in others. (Cheers.) You know well I have not a little exercised my birthright of English grumbling, and yet as long as it is believed by any Englishmen to be genuine and from pure motives, I have received from such nothing but expressions and treatment of attention and respect, however much they may have differed from my views. In our present rulers we have this remarkable hopeful feature. The English nation is at bottom a nation of conscience and fairness, with an instinct to do what is right and necessary. That they may take longer than we should desire at times to meet our wishes, but in the end, we may be perfectly assured, will be done what is right and just. This, then, is a most important circumstance in our favour, in any exertions we may make for the welfare of our country in all its multifarious needs. Our work till now may have been like all beginnings slow, but if properly persevered in with continuous force, it must at last be crowned with success. Persevere should be our motto, no matter how often we may be disappointed. (Cheers.) And when the rising generation sees how even such humble efforts as mine, in conjunction with those of others, are appreciated and rewarded by such public recognition as the one you have given me, it cannot but be a great encouragement to the younger generation to move in the same path. Taking, therefore, the honor you have done me in this double aspect, I feel highly gratified not only for my own sake, but for the further good this demonstration will do to younger and fresh workers in the cause of the general welfare of our country. I repeat my most sincere thanks for the honour you have done me this evening. It is a compliment which I shall cherish all my life and with all my heart. (Loud and prolonged cheers.)

The Hon. Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji then proposed the toast of the chairman. He said :—Our worthy chairman stands at the head of our community. (Cheers.) He belongs to a stock of which we as Parsees are proud all over the world. (Cheers.) Wherever the name of Sir Jamsetjee is known, the Parsees have a free and pleasant passport. (Cheers.) I have experienced that myself many a time in England. It was enough to say that I belonged to the community of Sir Jamsetjee. (Renewed cheers.) Apart from the worth and high position of the family, Sir Jamsetjee was one of those men who always cordially and heartily joined in all things which conduced to the welfare and well-being not only of our own community but to mankind at large. (Loud and prolonged cheers.)

6

INDIA AND THE OPIUM QUESTION.

(Before a conference which took place at the offices of the Society for the Suppression of the Opium Trade, Broadway Chambers, Westminster on Monday afternoon, October 15th, 1886, to have a frank interchange of opinion with the Hon'ble Dadabhai Naoroji, M. L. C., and other Indian gentlemen on the subject of the opium trade with special reference to its Indian aspects.)

Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji said—I have listened to the remarks of the gentlemen with very great interest, for the simple reason that I am almost of the same opinion. The best proof that I can give to you, not only of my own mere sentiments, but of my actual conduct in respect to opium, is that when I joined a mercantile firm in 1855, it was one of my conditions that I should have nothing whatever to do with opium. That is as far back as 1855. In 1880, in my correspondence with the Secretary of State on the condition of India, one of the paragraphs in my letter with regard to the opium trade is this; and I think that this will give you at once an idea of my opinion :—

" There is the opium trade. What a spectacle it is to the world ! In England no statesman dares to propose that opium may be allowed to be sold in public-houses at the corners of every street, in the same way as beer or spirits. On the contrary, Parliament, as representing the whole nation, distinctly enacts that 'opium and all preparations of opium or of poppies,' as ' poison,' be sold by certified chemists only, and 'every box, bottle, vessel, wrapper, or cover in which such poison is contained, be distinctly labelled with the name of the article, and the word "poison," and with the name and address of the 'seller of the poison. And yet, at the other end of the world, this Christian, highly civilized, and humane England forces a 'heathen' and 'barbarous' Power to take this 'poison,' and tempts a vast human race to use it, and to degenerate and demoralize themselves with this 'posion !' And why ? Because India cannot fill up the remorseless drain ; so China must be dragged in to make it up, even though it be by being 'poisoned.' It is wonderful how England reconciles this to her conscience. This opium trade is a sin on England's head, and a curse on India for her share in being the instrument. This may sound strange as coming from any natives of India, as it is generally represented as if India it was that benefited by the opium trade. The fact simply is that, as Mr. Duff said, India is nearly ground down to dust, and the opium trade of China fills up England's drain. India derives not a particle of benefit. All India's profits of trade, and several millions from her very produce (scanty as it is, and becoming more and more so), and with these all the profit of opium go the same way of the drain—to England. Only India shares the curse of the Chinese race. Had this cursed opium trade not existed, India's miseries would have much sooner come to the surface, and relief and redress would have come to her long ago; but this trade has prolonged the agonies of India."

In this I have only just explained to you what I feel on the matter personally. With regard to the whole of the important question, which must be looked at in a practical point of view, I must leave sentiment aside. I must, at the same time, say that this opinion of mine that the opium revenue must be abolished is a personal one. I do not put it before you as the opinion of all India. I state it on my own responsibility. There is a great fear that if the opium revenue were to cease, the people of India would be utterly unable to fill up the gap in the revenue. They feel aghast at the very suggestion of it, and they go so far as to say that the opium revenue cannot be dispensed with. I just tell you what is held there, so that you may understand both sides of the question thoroughly. Therefore you have not the complete sympathy of the natives of India in this matter, and you will find, perhaps, several members of the Indian press expressing their opinion that they could not dispense with the opium revenue. In fact, Mr. Grant Duff, in answer to some representation from your Society, or somebody interested in the abolition of the opium trade, has asked, in 1870, whether they wished to grind an already poor population to the dust. So that he showed that even with the help of the opium revenue India was just on the verge of being ground down to the dust. This, then, is the condition in which India is situated. The question is how to practically deal with it. Before you can deal with any such subject it is necessary for you to take into consideration the whole Indian problem—What has been the condition of India, and what is the condition of India, and why has it been so? Mr. Dadabhai then cited official authorities from the commencement of the present century up to the present day, including that of the late and present Finance Ministers, that British India had been all along "extremely poor." He pointed out the exceedingly low income of India, viz. only Rs. 20 per head per annum, as compared with that of any tolerably well self-governed country; that a progressive and civilizing government ought to have increasing revenue; but India was utterly unable to yield such increasing revenue. He explained how, comparatively with its income, the pressure of taxation upon the subjects of British India was doubly heavier than that of England; that of England being about 8 per cent. of its income, and of British India about 15 per cent. of its income; that England paid from its plenty, and India from its exceedingly poor income, so that the effect on British Indian subjects was simply crushing. He pointed out that while the trade with British India was generally supposed to be very large, it was in reality very small and wretched indeed. He illustrated this by some statistics, showing that the exports of British produce to India was only about 30,000,000l., of which a portion went to the Native States of India and to part of Asia, through the northern border, leaving hardly a rupee a head worth for the subjects of British India. This certainly could not be a satisfactory result of a hundred years of British rule, with everything under British control. A quarter of a century ago, he said, Mr. Bright had used these remarkable words: “I must say that it is my belief that if a country be found possessing a most fertile soil, and capable of bearing every variety of production, and that, notwithstanding, the people are in a state of extreme destitution and suffering, the chances are that there is some fundamental error in the government of that country.” Mr. Dadabhai urged that the Society should find out this fundamental error, and unless they did that, and made India prosperous, they could not expect to gain their benevolent object of getting rid of the opium revenue except by causing India to be ground down to dust by increased taxation in other shapes. This of course the Society did not mean, thus they ought to go to the root of the evil. India was quite capable of giving 200 instead of 70 millions of revenue, if they were allowed to keep what they produced, and to develop freely in their material condition; and in such a condition India would be quite able to dispense with the curse of the opium revenue. Mr. Dadabhai then proceeded to point out what he regarded as the cause of the poverty of British India. He cited several authorities upon the subject, and showed it was simply that the employment of a foreign agency caused a large drain to the country, disabling it from saving any capital at all, and rendering it weaker and weaker every day, forcing it to resort to loans for its wants, and becoming worse and worse in its economic condition. He explained at some length the process and effect of this fundamental evil, and how even what was called the “development” of the resources of India was actually thereby turned into the result of the “deprivation” of the resources of India. In pointing out a practicable remedy for all the evils, he said he did not mean that a sudden revolution should be made; but the remedy which had been pointed out by a Committee of the India Office in 1860 would be the best thing to do, to meet all the requirements of the case. After alluding to the Act of 1833 and the great Proclamation of 1858, a faithful fulfilment of which would be the fulfilment of all India's desires and wants, he said that the Committee of the India Office to which he had referred had recommended that simultaneous examinations should be held in India and England, and the list be made up according to merit; and he added to this scheme, that the successful candidates of the first examination should be made to come over to England and finish their studies for two years with the successful candidates of England. This was the resolution of the National Indian Congress which met last Christmas in Bombay. It was also necessary that some scope should be given to the military races to attach them to the British rule. If this fair play and justice were given to the natives in all the higher Civil Services, and if some fair competition system were adopted for all the uncovenanted and subordinate services, India would have fair play, and free development of herself— would become prosperous, would be able to give as much revenue as a progressive and a civilizing administration should want, and then only would the philanthropic object of the Society be fully achieved. Otherwise, if India continued as wretched as she was at present, there was no chance of the object being attained except by great distress to the Indian themselves and grave political dangers to the British rulers, or the whole may end in some great disaster. Mr. Dadabhai was glad that British statesmen were becoming alive to this state of affairs, and the highest Indian authority, the Secretary of State, fully shared his appreciation of the position, when he wrote to the Treasury on the 26th of January last; “The position of India in relation to taxation and the sources of the public revenue, is very peculiar, not merely ... but likewise from the character of the government, which is in the hands of foreigners, who hold all the principal administrative offices, and form so large a part of the army. The imposition of new taxation, which would have to be borne wholly as a consequence of the foreign rule imposed on the country, and virtually to meet additions to charges arising outside of the country, would constitute a political danger, the real magnitude of which, it is to be feared, is not at all appreciated by persons who have no knowledge of, or concern in the government of India, but which those responsible for that government have long regarded as of the most serious order.”

7

ENGLAND'S BEST WAY OF RETAINING INDIA.

(Before a Meeting at the Manchester Athenæum in November 1886. Mr. Samuel Ogden, President of the Institution, in the chair.)

Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji said that he, with many other native Indians, had been afraid that in the desire to make money, Manchester had altogether forgotten the duty of alleviating and humanising peoples all over the world. From all he had seen and heard, he believed so no longer, but that Manchester was true to its old traditions, and had still the old desire to be fair and just to everybody. He believed the appeal he had to make would not be unheard in this great city. (Applause.) After 100 years of British rule, he would ask the question, was India prosperous? That great empire was anything but prosperous, but was, on the other hand, one of the poorest countries in the world. Its annual production was not half even that of Turkey. The income of England was £38 per head per annum, France £25, United States £33, South America £6, India hardly £2. And this after one hundred years of British rule! The time had come, then, for Englishmen, as rulers of India, to try and understand the position of their empire, and remedy the evils of which he spoke. As to taxation, there was an utterly fallacious idea that India was lightly dealt with. But the fact was that India, on the £2 per head income, paid 18 per cent. in taxes for Government purposes, while in England the percentage was only 8. What were the reasons why India, which in his opinion was capable of paying the same rate of taxation as England, now felt so greatly the strain of that taxation? The reasons were various. One of the chief of them was the fact that India was as yet in effect under foreign rule, whereas our rule should assimilate as nearly as possible to native rule. So long as England went on draining the country of its material resources through this foreign agency, so long would the poverty of India continue. Every year from 20 to 30 millions was taken from the country in this way. Not only that, but English servants, after acquiring experience in administration, were withdrawn when they could be of most use, were pensioned and came home. This was a moral evil as great even as the material. And now with regard to taxation had come the last straw. India had to remit 17 millions of money every year to England for what were called “home charges.” But the rate of exchange had fallen from 2s. to 1s. 4d., and the result was the amount of produce which the Government had to send would have to be increased to the extent of seven or eight millions in order to make up the sum. It meant an increase of taxation on the natives to that extent. But it was impossible to grind a farthing more out of them than at present. The Government themselves confessed that the state of affairs would be an evil in any country; in a country such as India it was pregnant with danger. He agreed that the condition of affairs was becoming dangerous to the rulers themselves. The fact was that unless there was a great change, the people must either die off or English rule must be overthrown. It must be one or the other. He was convinced, as the Indian people were convinced, that as soon as the state of affairs was properly understood, England would do fairly and justly. It had been the boast of England that she helped every struggling nationality to have self-government, to be free, to enjoy political rights which God has bestowed on Englishmen. Let England do the same for India; let her perform the promises contained in the solemn proclamation of 1858 made by the Queen. India wanted self-administration and self-legislation, and with this blessing conferred the Empire would be knitted to England with a gratitude and loyalty worth more to this country than 500,000 soldiers. (Applause.) How was it to be done? The question was answered by the proclamation he had referred to. Let the Indian Civil Service be open, as the Queen had promised it should be. It was practically banned and barred to all but a few Indians who were able to come over to England to pass the examinations. The solution he proposed was the carrying out of a recommendation given by an Indian Committee—that the Civil Service examinations should take place in India and England simultaneously, and the result be according to merit. (Applause.) Mr. Dadabhai proceeded to refer to the economic position of the country and to advocate various reforms. India did not take goods from England to the extent of 1s. 6d. per head. It ought at least to be £1 per head; with some of our colonies English trade was £20 or £30 or £40. The natives were naturally industrious and productive, and if allowed to become prosperous, England would be unable to supply all their wants. (Applause.) The economic condition of India was utterly unnatural, and at the bottom of it all was the simple fact that foreign rule was a curse, and that our rule in India ought to approximate to native rule.

8

THE POLITICAL CONDITION OF INDIA.

(An address before the Members of the Reform Club, King's Street, October 1886. Mr. H. Lee in the chair.)

Mr. Dadabhoy Naoroji, who was received with applause, assured his hearers that in standing before any audience in England on an Indian platform the appeal he made was not simply to any particular party, or any particular class, but was the appeal of the whole people of India to the whole people of England. He appealed as much to the Conservatives as to the Liberals on all subjects connected with India. The Manchester people were interested in it not only as belonging to the English nation or as governing India, but at the same time they had a particular and intimate interest in India, commercially and economically. The two subjects, the political condition and the economic condition of India were so intimately interwoven with each other, that without giving some, explanation of the one the other could not be clearly understood. He took up the subject of the political condition of India in order that when that was clearly understood its economic and commercial position could be properly appreciated. The best thing he could do was to place before them not only his own individual opinions, but the views and opinions expressed last Christmas at a National Indian Congress held at Bombay. That Congress was attended by delegates from all parts of India, representing all the principal associations of India. Those who attended formed a portion of the picked educated classes of India. Before entering on the subject of the opinions formulated by that Congress, he must at the outset acknowledge very emphatically and clearly that great and important blessings had been conferred on India by the British rule. (Applause.) There was no question that since the accession of the British rule India had been completely changed in its whole character, physically, morally, socially, and intellectually. (Applause.) There was no doubt that from one end to the other of India security of life and property was the British rule. There was no doubt whatever that through the instrumentality of the British Government the Indian people had had education given to them, and the enlightenment of the West had been communicated to them, and for that they could never be too thankful. Sufficient information had, he believed, been given on the good England had done to India, and he would, therefore go on to consider what they required at England's hands in the future. He did not mean to speak in any spirit of cavil or complaint. He spoke with thankfulness for the past and hopefulness for the future. It was for the future, therefore, that he placed before them what the people of India, and the educated people of India particularly, desired at their hands. He proceeded to quote from the published statements of eminent Anglo-Indians in support of the view that the educated natives were the deservedly trusted guides of the people. Any idea of the subversion of British rule was said to be abhorrent to the educated natives, from the consciousness that it must result in the wildest anarchy and confusion. It was men who entertained such views as these that met in Congress to consider the condition of India and place boldly, and at the same time with the utmost loyalty, their wishes and needs before the British public. A subject which engaged the careful attention of the Congress was the difficulties placed in the way of natives holding civil appointments in India. In 1833 it was enacted that no native of India should by reason of his colour decent, or religion, be incapable of holding office. That promise had been renewed, but as yet very little had been done to make it an accomplished fact. In the opinion of the speaker this reform in the Civil Service was intimately connected with the economic condition of India, and he appealed to England, and to Lancashire in particular, to do their utmost to secure to the natives of India a fulfilment of the solemn promises made to them years ago, in the confident belief that thereby they would be not simply gratifying the aspirations of educated Indians, but conducing in a marked degree to the prosperity of our great dependency and to the augmentation of our trade with that country. As affairs now stand the people in the Native States were better off than those in British India, because in the former countries all that was raised in taxes was spent among themselves and went back to them, whereas in British India a sum of £17,000,000 was annually raised and remitted to this country. Of course the people of India did not want to upset the Civil Service arrangements all at once. They simply pleaded for air play and to have their educated youths allowed to compete on equal terms with Englishmen for the offices at the disposal of the Government of India. India was poor, it was impossible to tax her more, and so she would inevitably remain until her own people had a fair share in the task of government. If they would consider this question carefully, they would see in what direction they had to work in order that they might make India their best customer. The next resolution he wished to bring to their notice was with regard to the Legislative Councils. The constitution of those Councils was such that the natives had no voice in whatever was done for them, in the laws passed for them, in the taxation imposed upon them, or in the manner in which that taxation was spent. India, after being for such a long time under British rule, and after being educated for nearly half a century, had a sufficient number of people who were prepared to understand that taxation must go with representation. England did its utmost to help, either morally or materially, every struggling community to acquire freedom and to acquire constitutional government. Unfortunately she had not been as liberal towards her own possession—what had been described as “the brightest jewel in her crown.” If a proper representation was introduced into those Legislative Councils, Government itself would be relieved of a great deal of odium and a great deal of trouble, because whenever any law was passed by them with the representative voice of the people themselves, Government would necessarily be relieved of having done anything without consideration for the views and sentiments of the natives themselves. Another great change needed was that a system of interpellation should be introduced into those councils. This was a right which the natives of India expected at the hands of the British people, because if India could benefit at the hands of the British people it was by being elevated to the political level of the British people. Up to the present time the British had degraded themselves to the level of the Asiatic despotism, for their rule had been merely an absolute rule. The will of the Government was the law of the land, or rather the will of the English people as expressed in Acts of Parliament was the law of the land. Owing to the want of a few native members in Parliament, a great deal was done that was injurious to the people of India, and an urgent necessity existed for having a few native members to represent the native side of questions in Parliament. Whether the time would ever come when representatives would come from all parts of the world to sit in the British Parliament he did not know, but he thought they had good grounds on which to appeal to a few English constituencies to enable one or two natives of India to sit in the House of Commons and present to Parliament the native side of Indian questions. Another institution needing reform was the India Office Council. That was a Council which deliberated in secret, and which assigned no reasons for the conclusions to which it came. That Council ought to be either abolished or altered, because it was an anachronism, it was inherently defective, and it was naturally likely to do more harm than good. Another question which required to be dealt with was that of the customs duties, but that again was intimately bound up with the question of the prosperity of India. The most important question after all that they had to consider was to find out why India was so poor, and if they only discovered the reason, and applied the true remedy, they would have as great a benefit as ever any nation had offered to another. (Applause.)

9 DINNER TO HON. MR. DADABHAI NAOROJI BY THE NORTHBROOK CLUB.

(At a dinner given to the Hon. Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji by the Northbrook Indian Club, London, on the 4th November 1886, to bid him farewell on his return to India. Lord Ripon in the chair.)

Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji declared himself unable to find adequate terms in which to express the feelings by which he was overwhelmed on that occasion; but whether it was modesty on his part or not, he would tell the truth and declare the intense satisfaction and pride which the honour he was receiving that evening gave him. When a native of India was thus honoured by two of the greatest and best Viceroys India had ever had—(loud cheers)—he might fairly indulge in pride. Reference had been made to his connection with Baroda, and, in connection with that matter, he wished to acknowledge the deep debt of gratitude he owed to Lord Northbrook for justice done him irrespective of his being a native of India. But it was a characteristic of England and of the English race that whenever they thought a man had done good and useful work, they had their esteem and respect ready for him whoever he might be. The generosity of the spirit in which his services had been received was enhanced by the fact that if there was one man more distinguished than others for grumbling at some fault of British rule, that man was himself. But, knowing the good purpose he always had in view, they did him honour in spite of his grumbling. And to whom was due the glory of the fact that he was able to stand before them in this way as an honoured guest ? That glory was their own : it belonged to the British rule. Had it not been for the education he had received at the blessed hands of the British rulers, he would not have been with them then speaking of his gratitude that night. And for this one circumstance alone—for the enlightenment it had bestowed upon them—England was entitled to the everlasting gratitude of the people of India. Nor was this all that England had done for India. She had raised up a descending nation and had endowed it with a new political life. For the past the natives of India had every reason to be grateful to the British rule ; and while England sent out such Viceroys as the good Mayo, the just Northbrook and righteous Ripon, British rule would assuredly command the loyal devotion of India. Of the good work which it had accomplished no better illustration could be found than the National Indian Congress, held last year at Bombay. India had never, in her whole historical career, seen such a phenomenon as that. It was only possible under free and enlightened British rule. The pick of the educated natives from all parts of India met together and spoke out with the freedom that they owed to the British rule. That was a unique phenomenon and it gave some idea of the good work which had been already done. For all the kind things his lordship had said he was very grateful, but, he would repeat the glory was their own. When he received the education he had passed through, when he imbibed the illustrious literature he had been introduced to, he could not but be so influenced that the guiding rule of his life became the debt he owed to his country and to his Sovereign. He was endeavouring to repay that debt in some measure by trying to make himself useful to both sides. He concluded with an earnest reiteration of the pride with which he received the honour done him.

10

OUR RESPONSIBILITIES IN INDIA.

(Before the members of the North Islington Liberal Club, Holloway Road, London, November 1886. Mr. Newton Wilson in the chair.)

Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji, in commencing his address, said the question of the evening was not one he associated with any particular political party, but he appealed to the whole British people. The first aspect of the subject he would speak upon was with regard to the constitution of the Civil Service. On this matter the whole political and economic condition of India depended. As far back as 1833 a solemn promise was made to every subject of the throne in India, that religion, descent, or colour, should be no bar to office or employment in the East India Company. Lord Macaulay said he was proud of having been one of those who framed the Bill, which included so noble and benevolent a clause. In 1858, after the close of the unhappy mutiny, the promise was repeated in the most solemn manner in a declaration of the Sovereign. Since then some attempt had been made to leave the service open for competition, but it had been only in a partial manner without any really faithful interpretation of the proclamation. The Duke of Argyll, Mr. Bright, the late Mr. Fawcett, Lord Ripon, Lord Hartington, had all at different times acknowledged this fact. Had the promises been fulfilled in the spirit in which they were made, the condition of India would have been better and brighter, and more especially in a commercial sense would the country have been 100 times better. What was commercially the connection between England and India ? England sent goods to India worth from 13d. to 2s. per head per annum, after a connection of more than 100 years. After our having full economic and political control during all these years, had the relations between England and India been of different character ? Was India prosperous ? That great empire was anything but prosperous, was, on the other hand, one of the poorest countries in the world. Its annual production was not half even that of Turkey. The income of England was £38 per head per annum, France £25, United States £33, South America £6, India hardly £2. And this after one hundred years of British rule ! The time had come, then, for Englishmen, as rulers of India, to try and understand the position of their Empire, and remedy the evils of which he spoke. As to taxation, there was an utterly fallacious idea that India was lightly dealt with. But the fact was that India, on the £2 per head income, paid 18 per cent. in taxes for Government purposes, while in England the percentage was only 8. What were the reasons why India, which, in his opinion, was capable of paying the same rate of taxation as England, now felt so greatly the strain of that taxation ? The reasons were various. One of the chief of them was the fact that India was as yet in effect under foreign rule, whereas our rule should assimilate as nearly as possible to native rule. So long as England went on draining the country of its material resources through this foreign agency, so long would the poverty of India continue. Every year from 20 to 30 millions were taken from the country in this way. Not only that, but English servants, after acquiring experience in administration, were withdrawn when they could be of most use, were pensioned, and came home. This was a moral evil as great even as the material. And now with regard to taxation had come the last straw. India had to remit 17 millions of money every year to England for what were called “ home charges.” But the rate of exchange has fallen from 2s. to 1s. 4d., and the result was the amount of produce which the Government had to send would have to be increased to the extent of seven or eight millions in order to make up the sum. I meant an increase of taxation on the natives to that extent. But it was impossible to grind a farthing more out of them than at present. The Government themselves confessed that the state of affairs would be an evil in any country ; in a country such as India it was pregnant with danger. He agreed that the condition of affairs was becoming dangerous to the rulers themselves. The fact was that unless there was a great change, the people must either die off, or English rule must be overthrown. It must be one or the other. He was convinced, as the Indian people were convinced, that as soon as the state of affairs was properly understood, England would do fairly and justly. It had been the boast of England that she helped every struggling nationality to have self-government, to be free, to enjoy political rights which God had bestowed on Englishmen. Let England do the same for India; let her perform the promises contained in the solemn proclamation of 1858 made by the Queen. India wanted self-administration and self-legislation, and with this blessing conferred, the Empire would be knitted to England with a gratitude and loyalty worth more to this country than 50,000 soldiers. (Applause.) How was it to be done? The question was answered by the proclamation he had referred to. Let the Indian Civil Service be open, as the Queen had promised it should be. It was practically banned and barred to all but a few Indians who were able to come over to England to pass the examinations. The solution he proposed was the carrying out of a recommendation given by an Indian Committee—that the Civil Service examinations should take place in India and England simultaneously, and the result be according to merit. (Applause.) He proceeded to refer to the economic position of the country, and to advocate various reforms. India did not take goods from England to the extent of 1s. 6d per head. It ought at least to be £1 per head; with some of our colonies English trade was £20 or £30 or £40. The natives were naturally industrious and productive, and would become so if allowed to, because prosperous England would be unable to supply all their wants. (Applause.) The economic condition of India was utterly unnatural, and at the bottom of all it was the simple fact that foreign rule was a curse, and that our rule in India ought to approximate to native rule. (Applause.)

11

ON POLITICAL REFORM.

(At the third Annual Dinner of the Elphinstonians at the Elphinstone Institution, December 18, 1886. The Hon. Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji in the chair.)

The chairman returned thanks for the exceedingly kind manner in which they always received the toast of his health. Referring to the letter on the subject of the Public Service Commission which had appeared that morning in the English dailies, Mr. Dadabhai said they need not concern themselves much about such creakings for this reason, that the Government themselves were perfectly satisfied about the goodness of the motives by which the people of India were actuated in their action. The Government of India in one of their despatches to the Secretary of State had distinctly stated that as far as the educated portion of the people of India was concerned, and their number was rapidly increasing, the idea of the subversion of British rule was utterly abhorrent to them. (Cheers.) Such being the testimony given to them from the highest quarters, they need not feel much concern at any misrepresentations, or misconstruction or misapprehension of their motives. Mr. Pherozeshaw had very well pointed out that their progress, political, economical, social and educational, depended entirely upon the continuance of the British rule. If they were now urging what they considered to be their claims, it was the best proof possible of the liberal policy of Government which had enabled them to understand those claims and ask for them ; and since the Government had put them in this position, it was not possible for them to misunderstand their motives, and to think that the people of this country could ever be so ungrateful, or so devoid of all appreciation of their own self-interests as to wish for the subversion of British rule. (Cheers.) Nay, when they asked for any claims, or desired any reforms, the Government would see in it the people's desire for their own good, as well as their sincere desire for the greater stability of the British rule. (Hear, hear.) In his resolution on the Public Service Commission, the Secretary of State had stated that he wanted the Commission to devise a scheme which should have some reasonable elements of finality in it, and should do full justice to the claims of the natives of India. With such a clear and straightforward avowal of the motives of Government in this matter, there could be no room for any misapprehension, and it would be the people's own fault, if they did not now come forward and say firmly, loyally, and respectfully that such and such were their claims which in their opinion would do full justice to their desires and requirements. The Charter of 1833 was given to them of their own free will by the Government, without any agitation on the part of the people. At that time, it was felt by statesmen, as rulers of hundreds of millions, to be their duty to decide on what basis the British rule should rest in India. A debate took place in Parliament, in which Macaulay, Lansdowne, Ellenborough and other eminent men took part, the question with all its pros and cons was fully discussed, and the result was that it was deliberately laid down that the admission of natives into the public service should be entirely irrespective of considerations of caste, creed or colour, but should solely depend upon the fitness of the individual. The Charter of 1833 was ultimately confirmed by our gracious sovereign in most emphatic and solemn terms, stating that all Her Majesty's subjects would be treated alike and would be held equally dear to the sovereign. (Hear, hear.) With these assurances before them, it was not for them to be whining and complaining that the Government was going to deprive them of what they had already got. All they had got to do now was to come forward and ask the Government plainly and distinctly to fulfil the solemn promises repeatedly made to the people. The question would then naturally arise—which would be the most effective way of carrying out those promises? It fortunately happened that soon after the Proclamation of 1858 was made known, a committee of the India Office sat upon this very subject, and after a careful consideration, they decided that the best method of carrying out the spirit as well as the letter of the Act of 1858 would be to hold examinations for the public service simultaneously in England and in India. That was the fairest solution of the difficulty. Now that the whole thing lay clearly cut out before them, all that they had to do was to place it before the Commission, asking that the decision arrived at by the Committee of the India Office should be acted upon. He would not go on that occasion into the question of the reform of the Legislative Councils, because at present the most important and burning question, as Lord Dufferin had properly called it, which had agitated them for a long time, was that of the admission of natives into the service of their country. (Cheers.) Rather than blame Lord Dufferin, they should be thankful to him for the share he has taken in this matter, and it was now for the educated portion of the community to say what they wanted the Government to do for the benefit of the country. (Cheers.)

12

THE INDIAN CIVIL SERVICE.

(Before a meeting of the East India Association, at which Mr. A. K. Connell read a paper on "The Indian Civil Service," July 1887. Mr. John Bright in the chair.)

Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji said : Mr. Chairman, Ladies and Gentlemen, —My first impulse was not to send up my card at all, but after attending this meeting and hearing the paper that has been put before us, it is necessary that I should not put myself in a false position, and as I disagree with a portion of this paper, it became necessary that I should make that disagreement known. The third part of the paper is the part that is objectionable ; and it seems to me it is a lame and impotent conclusion of an able and well-considered beginning. For me to undertake to reply to all the many fallacies that that third part contains, will be utterly out of the question in the ten minutes allotted to me ; but I have one consolation in that respect—that my views are generally known, that they are embodied to a great extent in the journals of this Association ; that I also direct the attention of Mr. Connell and others to two papers that I submitted to the Public Service Commission, and that I hope there are two other papers that are likely to appear in the Contemporary Review * in the months of August and September. These have anticipated, and will, I trust, directly and indirectly answer most of the fallacies of Mr. Connell's paper. I would, therefore, not attempt the impossible task of replying to the whole of this paper, but I wil make a few remarks of a different character altogether bearing upon the vital question before us. This question of the services is not simply a question of the aspirations of a few educated men ; it is the question of life and death to the whole of British India. It is our good fortune that we have in the chair to-day the gentleman who put a very pertinent question, going to the root of the whole evil, as far back as a third of a century ago. Mr. Bright put the question in the year 1853. He said : "I must say that it is my belief that if a country be found possessing a most fertile soil and capable of bearing every variety of production, and that notwithstanding the people are in a state of extreme destitution and suffering, the chances are that there is some fundamental error in the Government of that country." Gentlemen, as long as you do not give a full and fair answer to that question of the great statesman—that statement made a third of a century ago—you will never be able to grasp this great and important question of the services. It is not, as I have already said, a question of the mere aspiration of a few educated men. Talking about this destitution, it is a circumstance which has been dwelt upon in the beginning of the century by Sir John Shaw. Lord Lawrence in his time said that the mass of the people were living on scanty subsistence. To the latest day the last Finance Minister, Sir Evelyn Baring, testified to the extreme poverty of the people, and so does the present Finance Minister. The fact is that after you have hundred years of the most highly-paid and the most highly-praised administration in that country, it is the poorest country in the world. How can you account for that? Grasp that question fully, and then only will you be able to see what vast interest this question of the services means. Then I come to the pledges that have been given. Here are open honorable pledges. The statesmen of 1833 laid down distinctly, in the face of the important consideration—whether India should be allowed ever to be lost to Britain. They weighed every circumstance, and they came to the deliberate conclusion which was embodied in the Act that they passed. But then you had not the experience of that fear of the risk of losing India. Twenty-five years afterwards you actually experienced that very risk; you actually had a mutiny against you, and what was your conduct then? Even after that experience, you rose above yourself; you kept up your justice and generosity and magnanimity, and in the name of the Queen, and by the mouth of the Queen, you issued a Proclamation, which if you “conscientiously” fulfil will be your highest glory, and your truest fame and reward. Gentlemen, take the bull by the horns. Do not try to shirk this question. If you are afraid of losing India, and if you are to be actuated by the inglorious fear of that risk, let that be stated at once. Tell us at once, “We will keep you under our heels, we will not allow you to rise or to prosper at any time.” Then we shall know our fate. But with your English manliness—and if there is anything more characteristic of you than anything else, it is your manliness—speak out honestly and not hypocritically, what you intend to do. Do you really mean to fulfil the pledges given before the world, and in the name of God, with the sanction of God and asking God to aid you, in the execution of that pledge—do you mean to stick to that pledge or to get out of it? Whatever it be, like honest Englishmen, speak out openly and plainly. “We will do this” or “We will not do this.” But do not expose yourselves to the charges—which I am not making, but your own members of the India Council have made—of "keeping the promise to the ear, and breaking to the hope." Looking at the time I cannot now enter into all the different and important considerations that this paper raises, but I simply ask you again this question, whether like honest Englishmen such as you are, in a manly way, you say the thing and do it. If you mean to fulfil these pledges honestly, do so; if you do not mean to fulfil them honestly, say so, and at least preserve your character for honesty and manliness. Mr. Connell had in the first part of his paper laid down as emphatically as he could the principles upon which the English nation is bound to act, and the third part of the paper he has done his utmost to discredit the whole thing, and to say how not to do it. But he forgets one thing: that the pledge you have given, you have never given a fair trial to: if you only give a fair trial to that pledge, you will find that it will not only redound to your glory for ever, but also result in great benefits to yourself; but if India is to be for a long time under your rule with blessing, and not with a curse, it is the fulfilment of that pledge which will secure that result. Ah! gentlemen, no eternal or permanent results can ever follow from dodging and palavering. Eternal results can follow only from eternal principles. Your rule of India is based not on sixty thousand bayonets or a hundred thousand bayonets. But it is based upon the confidence, the intense faith like the one that I hold, in the justice, the conscience and the honor of the British nation. As long as I have that faith in me, I shall continue to urge and plead before statesmen like Mr. Bright, and before the English nation. Fulfil your pledge honestly before God, because it is upon those et ernal principles only that you can expect to continue your rule with benefit to yourself and benefit to us. The reply to your (President's) question, Sir, about the fundamental error is then this. A foreign rule ca n never be but a curse to any nation on the face of the earth, except so far as it approaches a native rule, be the foreigners angels themselves. If this principle is not fairly borne in mind, and if honest efforts are not made to fulfil your pledges, it is utterly useless for us to plead, or to expect any good result, or to expect that India will ever rise in material and moral prosperity. I do not mean to say a word against the general personnel of these services, as they are at the present time they are doing what they can in the false groove in which they are placed; to them there is every honor due for the ability and integrity with which most of them have carried on their work; but what I say is this. This system must be changed. The administration must become native under the supreme control of the English nation. Then you have one element in India, which is peculiarly favorable to the permanence of your rule, if the people are satisfied that you give them the justice that you promise. It is upon the rock of justice alone that your rule stands. If they are satisfied, the result will be this. It is a case peculiar to India : there are Mahomedans and Hindus ; if both are satisfied, both will take care that your supremacy must remain over them ; but if they are both dissatisfied, and any paltering with justice and sincerity must produce that result. They will join together against you. Under these circumstances you have everything in your favor ; in fact, the divine law is that if you only follow the divine law, then only can you produce divine results. Do good, no matter what the result is. If you trifle with those eternal and divine laws, the result must be disastrous. I must stop as the time is up.

Notes

  1. †. It was a very crowded meeting of the Electors of the Holborn Division, and on the crowded platform were Mr. Bryce, M. P., Under-Secretary for Foreign Affairs, Mr. Wilfrid Blunt, Mr. B. Molloy, M. P., the Rev. Stewart Headlam, Mr. Hodgson Pratt, Major Evans Bell, Mr. W. Martin Wood (late editor of the Times of India), and others. Letters from Lord Ripon, Mr. Charles Harrison, Mr. Samuel Smith, M. P., Professor Hunter, M. P., Lord Hobhouse, Mr. John Slagg, Mr. Chesson, Mr. Arnold Morley, M. P., and others, warmly approving of the candidature of Mr. Dadabhai, were read. Lord Ripon wrote :—"I have learnt with much pleasure that you contemplate offering yourself as a candidate for a seat in parliament at the approaching General Election. Your intimate acquaintance with the feelings and wishes of the people of India, particularly in the Bombay Presidency, would enable you to give very valuable assistance in the discussion of Indian questions in the House of Commons. Your experience in the Bombay Council would be useful to you, and I am quite sure that your election to parliament would give great satisfaction to your compatriots in India."
  2. *. At a fully attended Meeting of the Executive Committee of the Holborn Liberal Association, held on Friday, the 18th of June, 1886, it was unanimously resolved —"That this Meeting, having heard the political views of The Honorable Dadabhai Naoroji, earnestly commends him to the Electors of Holborn as a fit and proper person to represent the Liberals and Radicals of the Borough in Parliament."—Thos. Johnson, Chairman. Harry T. Eve, Hon. Sec. The following is Mr. Dadabhai's Manifesto to the Electors of the Holborn Division of Finsbury. Gentlemen, I am greatly honored by an invitation to contest your Borough as the Liberal Candidate. To many of you I am a man of strange name and race. This fact must plead as my excuse for a few remarks about myself. I am an Indian subject of the
  3. *. In the above meeting the following resolution was passed—“That this meeting of Holborn electors having heard the expression of the Hon. Dadabhai Naoroji’s political opinions, cordially accepts him as the Liberal candidate for this borough, and pledges itself to use every legitimate effort to secure his return.’
  4. *. Resolution.—That this Congress earnestly recommends that the promised inquiry into the working of the Indian Administration here and in England should be intrusted to a Royal Commission, the people of India being adequately represented thereon, and evidence taken both in India and in England.
  5. *. Resolution.—That this Congress considers the reform and expansion of the Supreme and existing Legislative Councils, by the admission of a considerable proportion of elected members (and the creation of similar Councils for the North West Provinces and Oudh, and also for the Punjab) essential ; and holds that all Budgets should be referred to these Councils for consideration, their members being moreover empowered to interpellate the Executive in regard to all branches of the administration ; and that a standing committee of the House of Commons should be constituted to receive and consider any formal protests that may be recorded by majorities of such Councils against the exercise by the Executive of the power, which would be vested in it, of overruling the decisions of such majorities.”
  6. *. “That in the opinion of this Congress the competitive examinations now held in England, for first appointments in various Civil departments of the public service, should henceforth, in accordance with the views of the India Office Committee of 1860, ‘be held simultaneously, one in England and one in India, both being as far as practicable identical in their nature, and those who compete in both countries being finally classified in one list according to merit,’ and that the successful candidates in India should be sent to England for further study, and subjected there to such further examinations as may seem needful. Further, that all other first appointments (excluding peonships and the like) should be filled by competitive examinations held in India, under conditions calculated to secure such intellectual, moral, and physical qualifications as may be decided by Government to be necessary. Lastly, that the maximum age of candidates for entrance into the Covenanted Civil Service be raised to not less than 23 years.”
  7. *. “We, the members of the East India Association, beg respectfully to submit that the time has come when it is desirable to admit the natives of India to a larger share in the administration of India than hitherto. ‘‘To you, sir, it is quite unnecessary to point out the justice, necessity, and importance of this step, as in the debate in Parliament, on May 24 last, you have pointed out this so emphatically and clearly, that it is enough for us to quote your own noble and statesmanlike sentiments. You said—‘Nothing could be more wonderful than our empire in India; but we ought to consider on what conditions we held it, and how our predecessors held it. The greatness of the Mogul empire depended upon the liberal policy that was pursued by men like Akbar, availing themselves of Hindu talent and assistance, and identifying themselves as far as
  8. *. That this meeting, representing the various native communities of Western India, desires to place on record the deep sense of gratitude entertained by them for the eminent services to India rendered by the Marquis of Ripon during his administration as Viceroy of India.
  9. *. These papers will be found at the end of this book.