III.
ADMISSION OF EDUCATED NATIVES INTO THE INDIAN CIVIL SERVICE.
(A Memorandum respectfully submitted for the consideration of Sir Stafford Northcote, May 2, 1868.)
“There is only one other point included in the Bill which I must mention, and it is one of considerable importance and interest. I am sorry I do not see the member for Brighton in his place, who has given a notice with reference to the subject—it relates to the admission of the natives into the Civil Service of India. It was always felt by the old Court of Directors, by the Indian Council, by all the Home authorities, and, indeed, by the Indian authorities also, that it was most desirable, as far as possible, to make provision for the employment of the natives of India; but the difficulty has been in what way it could be accomplished. When the member for Brighton brings forward the motion for which he has given notice, that competitive examinations should be held in India, I shall feel it my duty to state the reasons why I cannot assent to that proposal. I do not think it would be at all suitable to the condition of India, that the Civil Service should be thrown open to anybody who can pass the best competitive examination among the natives of India; for, although I am a strong advocate for competitive examinations in this country, I do not think they apply to such a country as India, where you require, not the cleverest men, but various other qualifications, which you are not so well able to test by competitive examinations.—Extract from Sir Stafford Northcote’s Speech in the House of Commons, 23rd April.
It is said in the above extract :—
“ It was always felt by the old Court of Directors, by the Indian Council, by all the Home Authorities, and, indeed, by the Indian Authorities also, that it was most desirable, as far as possible, to make provision for the employment of the natives of India; but the difficulty has been in what way it could be accomplished.”
This comes rather strange, at this time of day, in the thirty-fifth year of a statute, and tenth year of a Royal Proclamation, as if proving that those suspicious natives, who regarded the statutory and Royal promises as never intended to be fulfilled, were in the right. Or otherwise, why should there have been any difficulty ? Parliament and our gracious Sovereign have declared that race or creed should make no difference between her Majesty’s subjects, and why should not, then, the natives of India have been, or be even now, allowed a door similar to that by which the English enter the service ?
Further :—
“ For although I am a strong advocate for competitive examinations in this country, I do not think they apply to such a country as India, where you require, not the cleverest men, but various other qualifications, which you are not so well able to test by competitive examinations.”
I do not suppose that Sir Stafford Northcote does not require cleverness as one of the necessary qualifications. And next, it does not appear how, if those “ various other qualifications ” cannot be tested by compe titive examination in the natives, they can be tested in the Englishmen.
How is the cleverness to be tested ? Competition is the means adopted for the English candidates. Why should it not be for the natives? No doubt it is the opinion of some that competitive examinations are useless. Be the worth of that opinion what it may, you have adopted the system, and till you abolish it, there is no reason why it should not be equally applicable to all candidates. However, be the test of cleverness that Sir Stafford Northcote may consider best what it may, it is necessary that, whatever that test may be, it should be clearly laid down, so that the natives may know what is required of them, endeavour to qualify themselves accordingly, and may get admission if so qualified. Next comes the question of the “various other qualifications” which Sir Stafford says are necessary. These may be divided in two classes, personal and adventitious. Every one will admit that besides education and integrity, there must be also in the servant, tact, judgment, good temper, zeal, industry, and general administrative powers. I do not suppose that Sir Stafford requires that a candidate must first show that he is a Canning, a Lawrence, or an Elphinstone, before any opportunity is given him. About ability and integrity, I have given ample testimony to show that the educated natives, and even others (according to Sir F. Halliday and others) now in the public service, have generally proved themselves able and trustworthy. As to tact, judgment, &c., the very fact of the success and efficiency with which these servants have performed their duties, is sufficient to prove that these servants must have shown those other qualifications, or otherwise they could not have performed their duties with efficiency. How are these qualities tested in the English candidates? and why should there be any other method adopted for the natives of India, especially when they have shown, by actual service, so far as limited opportunity is afforded them that they possessed the “other qualifications” also. If it be said that out of those employed in the public service only few have shown any very great administrative abilities, it is simply because they had very, little opportunity. If they cannot rise above the deputy-collectorships, or assistant-commissionerships, how can they show whether any of them have great abilities and qualifications? But even under every drawback, in the very narrow opportunity the natives have had, some “ capital administrators” have risen among them. We know what is thought of Sir Salar Jung, or Sir Dinkar Rao, or Sir Madava Rao by Government officials themselves.
Sir Richard Temple, in his letter on the Comparative Merits of British and Native Rule, says : “ Further, in justice to native rule, it should be said that within the century of our supremacy, there have not only been good sovereigns who are too well-known to require mention here, but also good ministers, really capital administrators” (the italicising is mine), “ who have adorned the service to which they belong ; such as Purnea of Mysore, and Tantia Jogh of Indore, in the past, and Sir Salar Jung of Hyderabad, Sir Dinkar Rao of Gwalior, Sir T. Madava Rao of Travancore, in the present.” The latter have not merely been declared as able administrators, but have been for that reason considered deserving of being knighted by our sovereign.
It cannot be fairly urged that natives have not in them elements of success and greatness if they get the opportunity. It must also be re- • membered that, notwithstanding thousands of English civilians during the past century, the great names cannot be counted by scores ; and these were, of course, attained according to opportunity and ability of the individuals. More cannot be, and ought not to be, expected from the natives. If a certain method is adopted for the selection of the Englishman, there is no reason (except for some exceptional circumstances to which I shall refer hereafter,) that a different one should be adopted for the natives.
The adventitious qualifications are those of caste, or riches, or birth. I certainly do not wish to say a word against the proper respect and position due to these in state or society. But to say that for public service any of these is absolutely necessary, is not only unreasonable, but detrimental to the State. It may be said that Hindus of high caste may not respect those of lower castes in the service. Is it for the British to maintain and encourage such distinction and feeling ? or is it the mission of Britain (and to which several of the comparers of the British and native rule referred with pride) to teach the natives of India that before law the high and low are equal, and that merit, and not caste, will carry the day. However, be this as it may, is it a fact that the higher caste people will not respect power and merit in a person of the lower caste? Are the Gaikwar, and Scindia, and Holkar of high caste? Are there not several princes and nobles, and men high in public service, or wealthy, who are not of high caste; and are they for that reason treated with less respect than if they had been Brahmins or Kshutrees?
Again, among the Mahomedans there can be no such distinction and disinclination arising from ‘caste.’ In connexion with this question of caste, there is one exceptional circumstance, to which I shall refer hereafter.
The same remarks apply to riches. No doubt, when a man rises, whether from a low caste, or from poverty, there will be many found, quite as much in this country as in any other, who would first look down upon him with superciliousness, and call him an upstart; but when he is in power, or influence, and has stamped his character, we know how those very sneerers will turn round and admire the ‘self-made man.’ Is it for the English rulers to teach the people of India that riches are the passport to service and honour? I cannot persuade myself that Sir Stafford meant riches as a necessary qualification, that a young man may be a mediocre, or a dunce, and yet, if he is born with a silver spoon in his mouth, he is qualified to serve the State; while another, no matter whatever his personal qualifications may be, is to be cast aside because his father is a poor man, and maintains his family by honest industry. Riches shall always have its due influence and respect, but that it should be a necessary qualification for State service will, I dare say, be not seriously urged by any. Is birth, again, a necessary passport for respect by the people? As the present matter relates to India, I would draw my illustrations from that country. What birth could the late Sir Jamshedjee Jeejeebhoy boast of, and yet is there a man more universally respected and admired than he? Are not the natives of India proud of that name? Did the late Hon. Shumbhoonath, to whose high character and qualifications the Governor-General and the Chief Justice of Calcutta have borne high testimony— claim high birth? He was a " self-made man," and yet we learn on the highest authority that he was respected by his countrymen.
In fact, it is only human nature, whether here or in India, that the man of merit, and in power, will command respect, be his origin humble or high, or rather the humbler origin will command the greater admiration. Mountstuart Elphinstone says, the first Nawab of Oude was a petty merchant, the ancestors of Holkar were goatherds, and those of Scindia slaves, the first Peshwa a village accountant.
Many other highly respected natives can be named who have not claims to high birth, or at most of a generation or two, and that under British auspices.
Are the natives so far an exception to human nature, that while a Disraeli becoming a Premier may be admired and praised, not only in the United Kingdom, but all over the world, more than if he had been born with a coronet on his head, the people of India would be so lost to a feeling of natural pride in similar cases, that they would be sorry to see any among themselves rise from the ranks? I am certainly the last person not to allow to birth its due. It has its advantages to the political and social condition of a country, which it is impossible to ignore. It is, therefore, highly desirable that this element should have its due strength and position in society. But it must not be forgotten that there is no family of birth but that it had an humble origin. When a family has once risen, it is capable of doing a great deal of good (if it has the will and ability), acting from a certain vantage-ground of position and influence, which the one which has yet to raise itself does not possess. But if free scope is not given to others, who have energy of character and nobility of soul and intellect, and thus fresh blood is not introduced from time to time, the aristocracy of a country may gradually sink. It will suffer the worst consequences of “caste,” as capacity and character are not the monopoly of the high-born. Every age, while proud of those that left their marks in former times, must leave, and very properly aspires to leave, its own mark also, and this mark of one Disraeli is worth a great deal more than that of other equally good and great men born with power and influence. Such a result, however, can only be possible when there is a fair field for all. These remarks apply to India with special force, as I shall show hereafter, when treating of the few exceptional circumstances connected with the question of Indian Civil Service.
At first, want of education and integrity was urged, and very justly too, as a bar to the service of the state. Committees of Parliament repeatedly questioned witnesses with regard to these necessary qualifications. And, up to the present time, it was considered that, if these qualifications could be proved to be possessed by the natives, their eligibility to high service in the State, and their right to similar treatment with Englishmen, would be complete. When, however, not only in abstract discussion or theory, but by actual facts of service rendered with efficiency and integrity, these qualifications are proved, “other qualifications” now come to light, to be necessary for the natives of India, as if those other qualifications were not as equally necessary for the English servants; as if those “other qualifications” were, in the case of the English candidates, proved by competition alone; and as if the test of these other qualifications in the Englishman will not be made as much in his actual service as in the case of the native.
It is proposed that the uncovenanted service be made native. Then the question naturally arises, do not these uncovenanted offices also require those “various other qualifications?” If they do, and if the natives can be supposed to possess them, so as to be fit for the uncovenanted service, on what grounds can they be debarred from competing for the covenanted service, and showing in actual service, as they would do in the uncovenanted service, that they possess the “various other qualifications” also?
There are, in the case of India, as I have said above, some exceptional circumstances, and it is, I fully admit, necessary to bear them in mind, and to make proper provision for them. These are political and religious.
If India wants England to rule it for a long time, for its own regeneration and benefit, it stands to reason that the English service must be in the majority, and that certain places of high executive power should remain in their hands only. Let the English boldly and straightforwardly say that, for the interests of both countries, as they must be the predominant people, they must have the larger share in the service; and let them say that two-thirds or three-fourths of the service must be English; that, moreover, all positions of the highest executive power, such as Governors, Executive Councillors, and any such others, which must be distinctly described, must remain at the disposal of the Government, and, if necessary, for Englishmen only. Such a straightforward avowal, though it may, perhaps, prove a little distasteful to some natives, will at least command their respect and also the acquiescence of all reasonable natives. Both the rulers and the subjects will know clearly their position, and mutual satisfaction, contentment of the natives, and sure stability of the British rule will be the result.
The next special circumstance is that the survivors of the old power displaced by the British should be as far as practicable drawn into the service, and made to feel an interest in the British rule, or at least to be reconciled to their change of fate. For this purpose, it would be no doubt an important act of policy, to make some arrangements by which the scions of these old great families might be brought into the service. If it be contended that such scions would not condescend to stand competition with other people (whether it may be desirable or not, as far as possible, to encourage such a feeling), as such a feeling does exist, and will for a generation or two naturally exist; and as, at the same time, the exceptional circumstances of the case require that some concession be made to them, if these scions otherwise follow the advice of the rulers and qualify themselves for the service, let a portion of the one-third or one-fourth of the service that may be fixed upon to be native be reserved for such appointments, at the discretion of the Viceroy. But there is no reason whatever that, because some exceptional provision of this nature is required to be made for these scions, the just rights of the whole population should be kept in abeyance. There is another very important reason, both arising from policy as well as justice, that the rising educated generation should be enlisted in the cause of the British rule. The higher classes in general, and especially those who have lost power, have still kept themselves aloof from educating their sons, and are hardly quite reconciled to the loss of power and influence they have sustained. There is no blame to them in this state of affairs. They do not see quite yet what they have to do with English learning, or what its character is. What they understand as learning is their Shastras or their Koran, and other Oriental literature, and this learning they are accustomed to leave to the Brahmin or Molvi. When they want the advice of learning, they can have it from these depositories. In such circumstances it is a puzzle to them, when they think about it at all, what English learning may be, and why they should want it. Moreover, the want of a career adds to their indifference. If some such plan as I have suggested before can be adopted, by which these scions can be drawn into English service, and made to feel their interest in its continuance, no doubt it will be a great advantage. I do not mean to cast the least suspicion on the probable loyalty or gratitude of the fallen great of the past, and admit fully the necessity of reconciling them to the revolution in their fortunes. It would not be, however, surprising if the good feeling towards the British rule ended with this reconciliation, and did not develop into thorough loyalty or deep gratitude. They may consider that the share given to them in the administration was their due, and an act of policy. Be this view right or wrong, at least. several of the comparers of the British and native rule have expressed in no encouraging terms, the present or possible feeling of these fallen great. Supposing, however, this view to be wrong, and as I sincerely hope and believe the native chiefs and noblemen, when they are once led to understand and feel an interest in the English rule, would prove loyal and grateful, a foreign government like the English in India cannot afford to depend upon this contingency only. This government also needs an aristocracy, a native power,—an influence of its own creation. It only stands to reason that those who would owe their rank, position, in short their all to the British Government, and who would strongly feel their interest in the preservation of the order of things in which they rose, would naturally be its best supporters, both from gratitude and interest. A power of no mean order is now rising in the State. Say what you will, the native press does, and will exercise its influence. It gradually passes into the hands of the educated, and the talent of the country. The feeling of loyalty in this body is at present undoubted. The sentiment that they owe their education and elevation as men to the British is very strong, and it is high time that, by reasonable concessions, they must be enlisted in the English cause. They understand and appreciate the genius and spirit of the British rule most, and they are its best exponents at present. Enlist this rising power created by yourselves on your side, and, coupled with a bold system of public works for the prosperity of the mass, you may well defy any internal revolution or external invasion. The opening therefore of the competition in India, and making the native feel an equality with his English fellow-subjects, instead of the humiliation of a conquered people, and thereby making them sure of a proper share in the administration, has now become not only an act of justice, but of great state policy. It would be a great pity to let this power feel dissatisfactior and brood over its wrongs. It will afterwards be useless, when mischief arises, to charge the natives with ingratitude. You cannot destroy a power, whether physical or moral. You can only regulate it. If you stop a current, it will overflow its barriers. If you stop a moral force, it will as surely break through its barriers.
The third special circumstance to be considered with regard to India is the position of the people of some of the lowest castes, whom the higher castes do not touch even. Government has from a wise policy of toleration thought proper not to hurt the feelings of the natives, by compelling association of these people among them, so in all Government schools these people are not allowed admission. In missionary schools there is no such prohibition. The consequence is that some of them may offer themselves at the door of the examination room. Now, however unwilling Government may be to cast out any man for his caste, the same consideration which has induced it to exclude them from Government schools must prevail also for their exclusion from the service ; at least for some time, because this exclusion will not last long. On the one hand, the educated rising generations are gradually divesting themselves of such social bans ; and on the other, new influences, the rail and steam, are effectually breaking down these unfortunate distinctions.
Lastly, there is some provision necessary to be made for several meritorious persons already in the service. They cannot now enter the covenanted service by competition. If powers properly defined, so as not to be suffered to be a dead letter, be allowed to the Viceroy, these meritorious servants may also be admitted into the covenanted service, within the limit that may be allotted for the native service, in addition to promotions in the uncovenanted service. With the exception of the above-stated four exceptional circumstances, I do not know that there is any other to be specially provided for, and there is no reason that, beyond this, any difference should be made in the mode of admission of the English and native subjects of her Majesty into the covenanted service. The strangest part of the whole thing is, that on the one hand we are told that competition is not applicable to India, and, on the other, we have taunts thrown into our teeth by others, that we wish to escape competition, and to get into the service without passing the ordeal to which Englishmen submit. While competition is here declared to be inapplicable to India, the Lieutenant-Governor of Bengal finds it necessary to adopt it, to some extent, as a first step for the subordinate service.
As Sir Stafford has not stated what the “other qualifications” are to which he alluded, I am obliged to work in the dark at present. I therefore earnestly request in simple fairness that no adverse decision be come to on Mr. Fawcett’s resolution, so that a fair opportunity be given to discuss the merits of Sir Stafford’s objections and provisions at the second reading of the bill.
The reply of Sir Stafford Northcote to the deputation which waited on him in August last, was an approval of our two prayers, and I hope that this approval may now be carried into effect.
Notes
- . It is sometimes said that intellectual education is not enough. Now it is a mistake to suppose that the education of the English schools and colleges of India is only intellectual. With the exception of not teaching the principal dogmas of Christianity, their education is as moral as can possibly be. The whole range of the English literature in which the native is educated is full of the high moral and religious tone of the nineteenth century. It is giving very scanty credit to this literature, and to the efforts of English educationists, that the result is not poductive of moral good, but thanks to both such is not the fact.
- . In a note, Sir Richard Temple, with natural pride, says that both Sir Salar Jung and Sir T. Madava Rao owed to British training. Why, excepting some faults, both of omission and commission, it will be difficult to deny that almost all good that India now enjoys is owing to British rulers, or their presence, advice or example. The real question now to be studied from time to time is, how far does any native state approach the English standard, and how far the English rule in India approaches the English rule in England.
- . The father of Baboo Dwarkanath Mittra, the present Judge of the Bengal High Court, was a clerk at Rs. 5 per month; Baboos K. M. Chatterjee and S. Sirkar, both occupying high positions in the service, began as cooks. Baboo Digumbur Mittra, lately a member of the Legislative Council of Bengal; Pundit Vydiasagur, late Principal of Sanscrit College; the present Principal of the same College; Molvi Abdool Lalif, lately a member of the Legislative Council of Bengal; Moonshi Ameer Ally, also a member of Council, and several other worthies of Calcutta, claim no high birth. The father of Mr. Maneckjee Cursetjee, the second Judge of the Small Cause Court of Bombay, was a “self-made man.” Messrs. Dosabhoy Framjee and Nana Morojee, Magistrates of Bombay, are highly respected.