Contents

Famines and Land Assessments in India, Romesh Chunder Dutt, 1900 · from page v · about 19 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

Preface . . . . . . . v

Famines in India . . . . . 1

First Letter to Lord Curzon: The Central Provinces . 21

Second Letter to Lord Curzon: Madras . . . 30

Third Letter to Lord Curzon: Bombay . . . 42

Fourth Letter to Lord Curzon: Bengal . . . 54

Fifth Letter to Lord Curzon: Northern India . . 65

Famine Insurance Grant, Railways and Irrigation . 78

Fallacies Concerning the Indian Land Tax . . 94

Appendix A. Proportion of Revenue and of Rent to Produce . . . . . 103

„ B. Incidence of Land Revenue per Acre . 113

„ C. Enhancements in the Central Provinces . 114

„ D. Speech of the Hon. P. M. Metha, C.I.E. . 116

„ E. Speech of the Hon. A. Charlu, C.I.E. . 122

„ F. Speech of the Hon. B. K. Bose, C.I.E. . 129

„ G. Speech of the Hon. the Maharaja of Darbhanga . . . . 137

„ H. Speech of the Hon. Sir Harnam Singh . 140

„ I. Proposal of a Permanent Settlement in Northern India . . . 143

„ J. Proposal of Do. in the Central Provinces . 157

„ K. Proposal of Do. in Madras . . . 164

„ L. Proposal of Do. in Bombay . . . 172

Appendix M. Sir Louis Mallet's Minute . . . 177

„ N. Sir Louis Mallet's Further Minute . 187

„ O. Lord Salisbury on Indian Land Revenue . 194

„ P. James Caird on the Condition of India . 202

„ Q. Mr Sullivan on Indian Land Revenue . 206

„ R. Mr Rogers on Settlements in Madras . 212

„ S. Land Revenue under Hindu Rule . . 224

„ T. Land Revenue under Mahomedan Rule . 235

„ U. Royal Commission on Indian Expenditure : Evidence of Lords Northbrook, Ripon, Lansdowne, Wolseley and Roberts, Sir H. Brackenbury, Sir E. Collen, Lord Cromer, Sir H. Colvin, Sir D. Barbour, Mr Jacob, Sir H. Waterfield and Messrs Wacha, Gokhale, Iyer and the Hon. Surendra Nath Banerjea . 245

„ V. Indian Salaries Return . . . 286

„ W. Cost of Foreign Wars Charged to India . 294

„ X. Letter on Land Assessments in India . 294

„ Y. Letters on Indian Expenditure . . 300

„ Z. Paper on the Co-operation of the People in Administration . . . . 308

PREFACE

In December last I had occasion, in the course of my Presidential Speech at the Lucknow Congress, to draw attention to the fact of the over-assessment of agricultural holdings in some provinces of India, and the consequent impoverishment of cultivators and agricultural labourers, who form four-fifths of the population of India. I pointed out that while in Bengal and Northern India, where cultivators paid rents to private landlords, the rents were comparatively moderate, in Madras, Bombay and the Central Provinces, where the Government assessed the soil, the assessments were excessive and the people were poorer and more resourceless. And I also stated that in the famines of 1877, 1897 and 1899, the parts of India which were over-assessed had suffered most severely.

The question has naturally received a great deal of attention both in England and in India within the last six months. In England an important debate took place in the House of Commons in April last, and Mr Samuel Smith, M.P., in referring to my statements, spoke the simple truth when he said that the best remedies for famines in India were the moderating of rents and the extension of irrigation works. And Lord George Hamilton, Secretary of State for India, while doubting the accuracy of my statement about moderate rents in Bengal, admitted that in the Central Provinces the assessment might have been too severe.1 In India, also, during the discussion of the annual Budget in the Viceroy's Council, all the Indian members of the Council pleaded in favour of moderate assessments, long leases, and irrigation works,2 and Lord Curzon promised to bestow his careful consideration to the subject. And during the discussion of the Provincial Budget of the North-West Provinces and Oudh, Sir Antony Macdonnell, the Lieutenant-Governor of those Provinces, was good enough to refer to my statements, and pointed out that in Northern India the policy of the Government during the present century has been to gradually moderate the land revenue demand.

The attention bestowed on the question by these high and responsible officials promises the most beneficent results, and the terrible and wide-spread famine of the present year raises the question of land assessments in India above the sphere of party controversies and invests it with a grave and national importance.

If lands have been over-assessed in some provinces of India, if the revenue demand has been raised too suddenly and too high, if the population of the country has thereby been rendered resourceless and incapable of helping themselves to any extent in years of drought, —no class of men will be more anxious to remedy the evils than British administrators who have devoted themselves to the great task of improving the material condition of the people of India. It is in the hope of rendering some help in the great work which they have undertaken, and of removing some of the deep-seated causes of poverty and indebtedness among the cultivators of India, that the present work is published.

The land question in India is generally considered an intricate subject by public men in England, and is therefore avoided. But the main features of the Indian systems are so simple that they are easily explained and are as easily grasped. It is only necessary to remember that the land systems are different in the different provinces of India, and if we examine the system in each province separately, the main facts will appear exceedingly simple, and we shall obtain a clear and comprehensive idea of the conditions of the agricultural life of an agricultural nation.

In Bengal the cultivators of the soil pay rents to private landlords, and the revenue payable by landlords to the Government has, in most parts of the province, been fixed for ever by the Permanent Settlement of 1793. The rents paid by cultivators to landlords generally do not exceed one-fifth or one-sixth the gross produce, and the revenue obtained by the Government represents five to six per cent. of the gross produce.1

In Northern India also the cultivators of the soil pay rents to private landlords. But the revenue paid by landlords to the Government has not been permanently fixed (except in some districts), and is resettled at each recurring settlement. Generally speaking, settlements are made once in thirty years, and about one-half of the rental of landlords is claimed by the Government as revenue. The rents paid by cultivators to landlords represent, on an average, about one-fifth the gross produce, and the revenue collected by the Government represents eight to ten per cent. of the gross produce.1

In Bombay the cultivators, generally speaking, pay the revenue direct to the Government, there being no intervening landlords, and the revenue is resettled usually once in thirty years. Lands are assessed according to their situation and productive powers, and also with an eye to their fiscal history, and no endeavours are made to take a fixed and definite proportion of the produce as revenue. It was once believed that the land revenue represented about one-eighth the gross produce, but at the present time it is generally between twenty and thirty-three per cent. of the gross produce.2

In Madras also the cultivators pay the revenue direct to the Government, except in some tracts where the revenue is paid by landlords and is permanently fixed. The revenue obtained from cultivators direct is fixed at each recurring settlement, and settlements are often made for shorter periods than thirty years. One-half of the nett produce of the soil, i.e. of the value of the produce after deducting the cost of cultivation, is claimed by the State as revenue; and there is a rule in force that this demand shall not in any case exceed onethird or two-fifths of the gross produce. On an average, the State demand represents twelve to twenty per cent. of the gross produce for dry lands, and sixteen to thirty-one per cent. of the gross produce on wet lands.1

Lastly, in the Central Provinces, the cultivators pay rents to private landlords, and landlords pay the revenue to the Government. But unlike Northern India, rents in the Central Provinces are not settled by the landlords and cultivators among themselves, but are fixed by Government officers at each recurring settlement; and the revenue demand is not one-half the rental but sometimes goes up to sixty per cent. of the rental. At the last settlement, effected after 1890, the revenue was very largely enhanced, approximating to, and even exceeding, a hundred per cent.2 in some districts. Complaints made at the time were disregarded, but the famines of 1897 and 1900 disclose the wretched condition to which the cultivators have been reduced. And from the statement made by the Secretary of State for India, quoted before, there are reasons to hope that the assessment will be revised, and the mistake committed will be rectified, as soon as the present famine is over.

Such, briefly, are the different land systems in the different provinces of India.3 It will be found that the incidence of the land revenue varies considerably in the different provinces. And it is significant that the provinces which have suffered most severely from famines within the last twenty-five years, i.e., in 1877, 1897 and 1900, are the provinces where the demand payable by cultivators is fixed by the Government, and the land revenue is unduly high.

Nearly forty years ago, after the severe famine of 1860, Lord Canning, then Viceroy and Governor-General of India, recommended the extension of the Permanent Settlement to all parts of India; Sir John (afterwards Lord) Lawrence supported the recommendation, and two Secretaries of State for India, Sir Charles Wood and Sir Strafford Northcote, approved of the proposal. It was known then that the proposal involved some sacrifice of the prospective rise in the land revenue of India, but Sir Strafford Northcote was prepared to make the sacrifice with the object of improving the material condition of the people, and of confirming the loyalty of the landed classes in India to the British Rule.1 Twenty years of uninterrupted peace within the natural frontiers of India, and of devoted loyalty on the part of the people, weakened instead of strengthening this very laudable desire on the part of their rulers, and the proposal of a Permanent Settlement was finally rejected in 1883. I have always considered this an unfortunate decision for the people of India. The extension of the Permanent Settlement would have led to some accumulation of capital which is now the crying need of India; it would have improved the condition of landlords and cultivators alike; and it would have made them more resourceful, and more able to help themselves in years of drought and failure of harvest. I had occasion to express this opinion during the famine of 1897 1 and I still hold the same opinion.

In the present work, however, I have not thought that it will serve any useful purpose to repeat the same recommendation. I have not, in these pages, recommended the extension of the Permanent Settlement to all the provinces of India. On the contrary, I have considered it more useful to suggest such protective measures as are consistent with the different systems prevailing in the different provinces. I have suggested no changes in the prevailing systems, but I have urged that, under each provincial system, some protection against undue and uncertain enhancements should be given to the cultivators of each province. And above all I have urged the acceptance of that proposal which was made by Lord Ripon, when the scheme of a Permanent Settlement was abandoned, that in districts which have been surveyed and settled the Government demand from the cultivators should not be enhanced except on the equitable ground of a rise in prices. This will afford some security to cultivators, while it will leave a door open for the future increase of the land revenue.

In the five Open Letters to the Viceroy of India, which form the principal portion of this work, I have endeavoured briefly and clearly to explain the fiscal history of the five great provinces of India and the condition of the cultivators of the soil in those provinces. I do not claim to have placed any new facts before the Government; on the contrary, the Government has undoubtedly many sources of information not available to me, and a comprehensive and minute knowledge of many facts and figures not known to me. The only claim which these Letters have to the consideration of the British administrators and of the British public lies in the fact that they are based on a life-long study of the actual condition of the Indian cultivator in his village, and that they seek to describe the real and deep-seated causes of his chronic poverty and indebtedness, and that they represent the views and opinions of the best informed, the most thoughtful, and the most moderate section of my countrymen. For these reasons they will, I venture to believe, receive the consideration of a Government which seeks by all possible means to know the views of the people themselves ; and they will probably also interest the British public who are now keenly anxious to remedy, as far as is humanly possible, the causes of the recurring famines in India. There is no doubt these famines are directly caused by the failure of the annual rains over which man has no control ; but it is equally certain that their intensity and their disastrous effects can be to a great extent mitigated by moderating the land tax, by the construction of irrigation works, and by the reduction of the public debt and the expenditure of India.

The suggestions I have made in the following pages are, I believe, moderate and practicable, and do not contemplate any change in the different land systems which prevail in the different provinces of India. For the sake of convenience I will sum them up below :

(a) Where the State receives land revenue through landlords, and the revenue is not permanently settled, we ask that the “ Saharanpur Rules ” limiting the State-demand to one-half the rental may be universally applied.

  • (b) Where the State receives land revenue direct from cultivators, we ask that the rate may not exceed one-fifth the gross produce of the soil in any case, and that the average of a district, including dry lands and wet lands, be limited to one-tenth of the gross produce, which is approximately the revenue in Northern India.
  • (c) Where the State receives land revenue direct from cultivators, we ask that the rule laid down by Lord Ripon, of permitting no enhancements at recurring settlements, except on the ground of an increase in prices, be universally applied.
  • (d) Where the land revenue is not permanently settled, we ask that settlements be made not oftener than once in thirty years, which is the general rule in Northern India and Bombay.
  • (e) We urge that no cesses, in addition to the land revenue, be imposed on the land except for purposes directly benefiting the land ; and that the total of such cesses may not exceed six and a quarter per cent. (one anna in the rupee), in any province of India.
  • (f) We urge that now that the protective railway lines have been completed, a million tens of rupees be annually spent out of the Famine Insurance Grant on protective irrigation works ; that these works be undertaken, as recommended by the Famine Commission of 1898, “ without expectation of direct return ” from the outlay ; and that the cultivator be left the option of using the water when he requires it, and paying for it when he uses it.

(g) And lastly, we urge that in the case of any difference between cultivators and Settlement Officers in the matter of assessment, an appeal be allowed to an independent tribunal not concerned with the fixing and levying of the land tax.

It will be obvious to every reader that it is not possible to improve the condition of the Indian cultivator without granting him some security from uncertain demands and harassing claims which are a ruin to agriculture and a bar to all improvements. And it will be also obvious that the security contemplated in the above rules, and the limitations on land revenue prescribed therein, are not possible without some check on the growing and ruinous expenditure of the Indian Government. We cannot moderate the revenue demand without moderating the expenditure ; we cannot give relief to the overtaxed cultivator without economy and retrenchment. This is a subject which I have not touched upon in the present work, because it is so vast and so important that it requires to be dealt with fully in a separate work.

The Royal Commission on Indian expenditure has just brought out its Report with minutes of the valuable evidence it has recorded.1 The British Parliament has not yet had time to consider this Report, and we will not anticipate the verdict of the British nation. But one thing which very painfully strikes the Indian reader is that, among all their many valuable suggestions, the majority of the Commissioners have not strongly and adequately insisted on a reduction of the public expenditure in India and of the annual drain from India. Such a reduction is absolutely necessary in the interests of the Indian people, and without such a reduction India cannot be saved.

Retrenchment is said to be one of the great principles of the Liberal Party in Great Britain; Retrenchment is the first principle of the popular party in India. Educated, moderate, and loyal Indians, who have studied Indian problems and Indian facts carefully, and are animated by a sincere desire to support and help British administration in India, feel that no permanent improvement in the condition of the people is possible without some reduction in the public expenditure. But unfortunately, this Retrenchment Party in India, if I may so call it, has no control over administration, and is debarred from influencing the administration. The Finance Minister and the officials generally in India are, no doubt, aware of the importance of economy; but the vital and absolute necessity of retrenchment does not come home to them as it does to the people; it is not a question of life and death with them as it is with the people. And so it happens that the Expending Party,1—I use this phrase without any reflection on British administrators,—is permanently in power in India; the Retrenchment Party is never in power and has no control over the administration; and no adequately strong endeavour has been made in India to reduce expenditure. The Famine Commissions of 1878 and 1898 did not adequately grasp this point ; and the majority of the Royal Commission on Indian Expenditure have failed to deal with it adequately.

In Great Britain the public debt was reduced by over a hundred and sixty millions within forty years after the Crimean War ; in India the public debt was not reduced, but went on increasing during the same period, even if we leave out the expenditure on railways. There was no determined endeavour made in India, as was made in Great Britain, to decrease the nation's liabilities ; there was no effort made to reduce that annual drain from the Indian revenues which necessarily impoverishes the country and the cultivating population. We hear constantly of the elasticity of the Indian revenues and the recuperative power of the Indian people ; the famines of 1897 and of 1900 are a terrible answer to such consoling but unsound and untrue representations.

The great military expenditure of India, too, is not only ruinous but absolutely inequitable. Retired viceroys of India and high military authorities have told the Royal Commission that to saddle India with the expenditure of wars outside India is unjust, illegal, and inequitable ; that to maintain at the cost of India a vast force required for Great Britain's Imperial purposes is unfair.1 Let us honestly endeavour to connect cause and effect ; and let those who feel for the millions of voiceless cultivators who crowd round relief centres at each recurring famine, or die on the roadside and in obscure villages, bring it home to their minds that famines in India are greatly due to that policy of saddling India with the cost of vast armaments and wars which she should not bear, and which she cannot bear.

Indian witnesses have also urged before the Royal Commission the unfairness of virtually excluding Indians from high appointments in their own country, which they are fitted to hold. They referred to the Parliamentary Return of 1892, showing that of all the appointments of the value over a thousand rupees (£67) a year, the people of India were permitted to hold a small proportion aggregating to about three millions sterling, while appointments aggregating to about fifteen millions sterling a year were reserved for Europeans.1 And they pleaded that this was a source of material loss and of moral degradation which neither the august Sovereign of India nor the British people wished to perpetuate.

These are subjects which I have purposely excluded from the scope of the present little volume. I desired to make it an easy handbook on the land question of India, on the condition of the cultivators and the incidence of the land tax, and on the reforms needed to make agriculturists more self-relying and resourceful, and famines less frequent and less fatal. But the reader will undoubtedly perceive that limitations cannot be placed on the revenue-demand without retrenchment in expenditure, and without a readjustment of the financial relations between Great Britain and India on those lines which are considered fair and equitable for the British colonies.

A greater danger than the Mutiny of 1857 not only threatens, but has actually overtaken India, in the impoverishment of the people and the frequency and intensity of recent famines. And the highest type of courage and of statesmanship, such as was evinced by a Canning and a Lawrence in the past, will be needed once more to save the empire,—to moderate rents and taxes, to reduce debt and expenditure, to deal with India as England deals with her colonies in financial matters, and to associate the people of India in the control of their finances and the administration of their own concerns.

Romesh Dutt.

University College, London, 20th June 1900.

Notes

  1. 1. "Mr Dutt seemed to think that in the Central Provinces the Government of India were exacting an exorbitantly high land revenue. He was very reluctant to dogmatise as to what was and what was not a reasonable land revenue, and he should be very sorry to say that in the past they might not here and there have placed the land assessment too high."—Report of Lord George Hamilton's speech in the Times of the 4th April 1900.
  2. 2. See Appendices D to H.
  3. 1. See Appendix A.
  4. 1. See Appendix A.
  5. 2. Ibid.
  6. 1. See Appendix A.
  7. 2. See Appendix C.
  8. 3. I have treated Northern India as one province though it really comprises two provinces under two separate Adminstrations, one for N. W. Province and Oudh, and the other for the Punjab.
  9. 1. See Appendix I.
  10. 1. "England and India," Chatto & Windus, London, 1897.
  11. 1. Extracts from the evidence of some great authorities on Indian matters have been given in Appendix U of the present work.
  12. 1. See evidence of Sir Auckland Colvin and Sir David Barbour in Appendix U.
  13. 1. See evidence of Lord Northbrook, Lord Ripon, Lord Lansdowne, Sir Henry Brackenbury, and Sir Edwin Collen in Appendix U.
  14. 1. See Appendix V.