My Lord,—In continuation of my previous letters on Land Settlements in the Central Provinces, Madras, Bombay, and Bengal, I take the liberty of submitting to Your Excellency this final letter on Land Settlements in Northern India. The land system in the N.W. Provinces differs somewhat from that in Oudh, and these systems again are somewhat different from the Punjab system ; but there is a general resemblance in the systems prevailing in all these three Provinces of Northern India. For in all these Provinces the cultivators generally pay their rents to landlords ; and the revenue payable by landlords to the Government (except where it is permanently settled), is liable to revision and enhancement at each recurring Settlement. I shall, therefore, with a view not to prolong this correspondence, endeavour to compress my remarks and suggestions with regard to all the three Provinces of Northern India within the limits of this letter.
2. Acquisition of the North-Western Provinces.— The North-Western Provinces came under British Rule at different dates. (a) Benares and some adjoining districts were acquired from the Nawab of Oudh by the treaty of 1775, and were permanently settled in 1795. In this respect they resemble the permanently settled tracts of Bengal, of which I have spoken before, and I shall have no further remarks to make of these districts in the present letter. (b) Allahabad and some adjoining districts were ceded by the Nawab of Oudh in 1801. (c) Agra and some other districts were conquered by Lord Lake in 1803. Some less important tracts were added in subsequent years.
3. Early Mistakes in Land Revenue Settlements.— It may easily be imagined that mistakes were made by administrators who first endeavoured to settle the land revenues. It was the custom in the last days of the Mahomedan rule to fix the State-demand at a very high figure, and then to realise as much of the nominal demand as was possible from year to year. The mistake made by British administrators was to adhere to this high nominal demand, and then to try and realise the whole of it. Some British administrators saw this mistake, and one collector, Mr Dumbleton, wrote that the Settlement of 1802 “pressed beyond a reasonable demand,” and also complained that the severe rates of the Nawab’s government were stereotyped by the British rulers, “without the same elasticity in realising.” (Baden-Powell’s “Land Systems of British India,” vol. ii. p. 14.)
4. Early Settlements, 1802 to 1822.—Proclamations were issued in 1802, that a Settlement would be made for three years; to be succeeded by another Settlement for three years; and this was to be followed by a third Settlement for four years; after which a Permanent Settlement would be concluded. But before the expiry of the total period of ten years, the views of the rulers had changed, and the idea of a Permanent Settlement had been abandoned. Two fresh Settlements were made for five years each, i.e. down to 1822. In the meantime, Mr Holt Mackenzie submitted his famous Minute, which led to the passing of Regulation VII. of 1822.
5. Regulation VII. of 1822, IV. of 1828, and IX. of 1833.—The three successive Regulations were passed within eleven years, but the mistake of over-assessment was not altogether rectified, and the State-demand was fixed at two-thirds of the rental by the last Regulation. Settlements were accordingly made between 1833 and 1849, and the country remained in a state of perpetual poverty. A terrible famine visited the North-Western Provinces in 1837, and desolated the whole country from Allahabad to Delhi, though it was most intense in the Doab, and in the neighbourhood of Agra. The Government revenue was permanently decreased in most districts after the famine.
6. “Saharanpur Rules” of 1855.—It was not until 1855 that the exorbitant State-demand of two-thirds of the rental was reduced to one-half the rental by the famous “Saharanpur Rules.” This is now the general rule in Northern India, and has given considerable relief to the people. When a famine again visited Northern India in 1860, it was less severe than the preceding one; and Colonel Baird Smith, who inquired into the causes and effects of the famine, declared that its comparative mildness was due to the moderate demands of the State. Colonel Baird Smith recommended a Permanent Settlement of the land revenue for the improvement of the condition of the people. The recommendation received the approval of Lord Canning and of the Secretary of State for India in 1862; but the proposal was long kept in abeyance, and was, at last, unfortunately abandoned in 1883.1
7. Act XIX. of 1873, and the Present Method of Settlements.—The revenue law was much simplified by Act XIX. of 1873, which repealed about fifty Regulations or parts of Regulations, and eight Acts. The assessment of rents, too, which had hitherto been made by Settlement Officers after elaborate calculations and on somewhat theoretical grounds, resulting in much harassment to cultivators and gross inequality of incidence, was now much simplified. The healthy rule was at last adopted, in 1886, that the rents actually received by landlords, as shown in village rent rolls, should be received as the basis of assessment, with necessary corrections. "We do not," says Sir Antony Macdonnell, in his evidence before the Currency Committee, "for the purpose of assessing the Government revenue, make a basis of our own; we proceed on the basis of actual facts, which have been brought into existence by the operation of the ordinary law of rent, and the arrangement which the landlord has made with his own tenant" (Minutes of Evidence, vol. i. p. 211). It will thus be seen that though the North-Western Provinces have not obtained a Permanent Settlement, which would have led to some accumulation of capital and promotion of industries in the country, yet the worst blunders of the early land-settlements have been rectified one by one. In 1855 the revenue was fixed at one-half the rental; in 1873 the Land Revenue Act was simplified; and in 1886 the harassing process of settling rents on theoretical grounds, which still unfortunately prevails in some other parts of India, was abandoned, and the actual rental of the country was accepted, with necessary corrections, as the basis of assessment.
8. Acquisition of Oudh.—Oudh was annexed by Lord Dalhousie in 1856, i.e. after the land revenue administration had been reduced to system in the N.W. Provinces, and it therefore escaped some of the worst blunders made in earlier years. The landlords of Oudh were called Talukdars, and out of 23,543 villages in Oudh, 13,640 were settled, in 1856, with Talukdars, and 9903 with Village Proprietors.
9. Settlement after the Mutiny of 1857.—After the Mutiny of 1857 all lands were confiscated by the Government by a proclamation in 1858. This summary and somewhat alarming procedure was much criticised in England, and then the estates were reconferred on the Talukdars, with a provision for protecting the rights of subordinate tenants, which provision was entered in the sanads or title-deeds which were afterwards issued. The assessment of the estates of six (reduced to five) loyal Talukdars had been made permanent; the other estates were settled between 1860 and 1878 for thirty years.
10. Acquisition of the Punjab.—A portion of the Punjab, between the Sutlej and the Ravi, was annexed after the first Sikh war in 1846. The remainder was annexed after the second Sikh war in 1849. And Delhi and some other districts were transferred from the North-Western Provinces to the Punjab after the Mutiny in 1858. A Board of Administration was formed for the Punjab in 1849; it gave place to a Chief Commissioner a few years later; and after the Mutiny, and after the transference of Delhi and other districts into the Punjab, a Lieutenant-Governor was appointed for the Punjab in 1859.
11. Settlements in the Punjab; Rates of Assessment.—Mistakes, similar to those which had been made in the early Settlements in the N.W. Provinces were made in the Punjab, and British administrators endeavoured to realise the rates at which lands were assessed under the Sikhs. Major Wace said, in his evidence before the Famine Commission of 1878, that “commencing, in 1849, with a standard of one-third of the produce, a period of low prices, combined with other considerations affecting the welfare of a newly-conquered and previously much-oppressed country, compelled us to reduce that standard successively to a fourth and a sixth.” Even this standard applied only to Lahore and Amritsar Divisions, settled between 1860 and 1872; in later Settlements, one-half the customary rents was accepted, as in the N.W. Provinces, as the Government revenue (Appendix III. to Famine Commission’s Report, p. 365). A Land Revenue Act (XXXIII. of 1871) was passed for the Punjab in 1871, and this has been replaced by the present law, Act XVII. of 1887. There are a large number of petty landlords in the Punjab, who cultivate their own lands; and in the Famine Commission’s Report (1879) it is stated that fifty-four per cent. of the cultivated area is held by cultivating landlords, and forty-four per cent. by tenants.
12. Assessment Rules.—Rules were formulated, under the Revenue Act of 1871, that the Government revenue should not exceed the “estimated value of half the net produce of an estate, or, in other words, one-half of the share of the produce of an estate ordinarily receivable by the landlord in money or in kind.” This rule has been reaffirmed and explained by the subsequent rules passed under the Revenue Act of 1887, two of which are quoted below :—
“(1) The general principle of assessment to be followed is that the Government demand for land revenue shall not exceed the estimated value of half the net produce of the estate.”
“(3) In estimating the net produce of cultivated lands of any class, whether occupied by landowners themselves or by tenants, the rents paid in money or in kind on an average of years by ordinary tenants-at-will for such lands in the assessment circle to which the estate belongs, shall be the principal guide.”
It is important to note that while the principle fixing the Government demand is the same in the Punjab as in Madras, viz. one-half the net produce, the practice is widely different. In the Punjab the usual rent is accepted as the net produce, and the revenue is therefore about half the rental, as in the North-West Provinces. In Madras the net produce is calculated by an elaborate process which is inaccurate in results, and is unjust and oppressive to the cultivators.
13. My Lord, I have in the preceding paragraphs briefly described the land revenue systems and rules of the North-West Provinces, Oudh, and the Punjab; and I crave permission to indicate in a few words the modifications and the safeguards that seem to be called for. I will not, in the present letter, recommend the extension of the Bengal system of Permanent settlement to Northern India; I will merely suggest improvements which are consistent with the systems prevailing in Northern India, and which will not in any way affect the principle of those systems.
14. Fair Rents and Secure Tenures for Cultivators. —The protection of the cultivators is the first object of the Government, and this object is imperfectly secured under the present laws. Sir A. Macdonnell said before the Currency Committee: "Whenever we find a rent-roll which we consider unstable or excessive, we reduce the rental for the purpose of assessment as between the landlord and the Government; we make no interference as between the landlord and his tenant" (Minutes of Evidence, Part I. p. 211). It is necessary to consider whether such "unstable or excessive" rental should be permitted, and whether a maximum limit of rents in proportion to the gross produce should not be laid down by law in case of ordinary cultivated lands. Some years ago the British Indian Association of Calcutta, representing the large landholders of Bengal, proposed to accept twenty-five per cent. of the gross produce as the landlord's share, as appears from Mr Dampier's evidence before the Famine Commission of 1878 (Appendix II. p. 72). And when the Bengal Tenancy Bill was framed in 1883, it was proposed to lay down one-fifth the gross produce as the maximum rent. Again, in the Punjab Administration Report of 1898-99 I find that " over two thousand notices (to eject tenants) were issued in Hissar. Most of these were in Sirsa; they show that the people are preparing for the coming Settlement by ejectment of such tenants as might claim to be occupancy tenants." This, I submit, is another case which requires attention, and I venture to hope that the Government will so modify the law as to extend occupancy rights to all settled tenants in Northern India.
15. Fair Revenue and Long Settlements.—The principle on which Land Revenue is fixed in Northern India, viz. at one-half the rental, is fair, and Settlements are generally made for thirty years in Northern India. It is desirable that these rules should be made universal in their application in all parts of India, to prevent frequent harassment of the people. Each Settlement generally secures a large enhancement on the revenue, as will be seen from the figures given below, and it is necessary
| District. | Increase of Revenue due to resettlement. |
|---|---|
| Budaun . | 27·4 per cent. |
| Garhwal . | 53·2 " |
| Unao . | 19·8 " |
| Partapgarh . | 31·7 " |
| Rae Bareli . | 24·8 " |
| Sultanpur . | 24·2 " |
| Lucknow . | 21·5 " |
| Hardoi . | 25·5 " |
| Sitapur . | 28·9 " |
| Bari Banki . | 30·8 " |
| Fyzabad . | 29·0 " |
| District. | Old Revenue. | Increase of Revenue due to resettlement. |
|---|---|---|
| Montgomery | Rs. 408,981 | Rs. 163,058 |
therefore to inquire minutely if this is not partly due to undue and excessive enhancements of the rental secured by landlords. There is always the risk of landlords trying to obtain such enhancements of the rental, after they have submitted to an enhancement of the revenue at a new Settlement.
16. The Imposition of Cesses.—The difficulty of realising direct taxes in India, principally on account of the poverty of the people, has induced the Government to raise such taxes from the land, along with and in addition to the land revenue. In Bengal, cesses are levied from landlords and cultivators for roads, and for public works ; in Northern India cesses are levied for Roads, Schools, Post Office, Dispensary, Famines, Patwaris, and Chowkidars, amounting to eight and a quarter per cent. on the rental ; and in the Central Provinces such cesses come up to twelve and a half per cent. on the rental. These cesses are assessed on the rent, and paid by landholders with the land revenue ; and when the land revenue is enhanced at settlements, the cesses advance automatically. It will be clear to Your Excellency that the object of fixing the revenue at fifty per cent. of the rental is entirely lost if another eight or twelve per cent. on the rental is added under the name of cesses. The “ Saharanpur Rules,” which reduced the land revenue from sixty-six and two-thirds per cent. to fifty per cent. of the rental, are thus reduced to a dead letter, and the object of fixing a moderate land revenue is defeated, if the land is once more assessed with various cesses. There may be some reason for assessing the land for works which directly benefit the land, like roads and wells, but there is no reason or justice in assessing the land for schools and dispensaries. The total of cesses in Bengal is one anna in the rupee, or six and a quarter per cent. of the rental, and this rate should be fixed as the maximum total of all cesses imposed on land, leviable only for works benefiting the land. If a moderate assessment of the land be essentially necessary for the well-being of a nation of cultivators, it is absolutely necessary to guard against indirectly raising that assessment to a material extent, or for purposes not directly calculated to benefit the land.
17. In the last place, I desire, my Lord, to say only one word about the Land Alienation Bill, now under the consideration of the Indian Government. I shall not anticipate the decision of the experienced administrators who are giving their attention to the matter, nor shall I venture to express an opinion how far some provisions of the nature may be needed in some localities as a temporary measure of relief. All that I wish to urge is that no permanent relief can be given to the cultivators of India by taking away from the marketable value of about the only property which they possess. In Bengal such proposals were under consideration in 1883 and again in 1896, but it was wisely decided that good rent laws and light rental were the soundest means to save the cultivators from the grasp of money-lenders, and within my experience, good rent laws and light rental have to a great extent freed the cultivators of Bengal from indebtedness within the last thirty years. The cultivators in Northern India, the Central Provinces, and the Deccan, are not less thrifty and frugal than Bengal cultivators, and the same result which has been achieved in Bengal can be produced elsewhere through the same means, viz., light rental and good rent laws, protecting the cultivators from undue and uncertain enhancements.
18. For the sake of convenience I desire briefly to summarise the proposals which I have made in the five letters, of which this is the last; and as these proposals embody the views of my countrymen generally, I feel convinced they will receive Your Excellency's consideration.
(a) Where the State receives land revenue through landlords, and the revenue is not permanently settled, we ask that the “Saharanpur Rules” may be universally applied, and the State-demand be limited to one-half the rental.
(b) Where the State receives land revenue direct from cultivators, we ask that the rate be limited to a maximum of one-fifth the gross produce of the soil.1 In Madras the old rule demanding one-half the net produce as revenue is supplemented by a rule limiting the revenue to one-third the gross produce, and this has led to over-assessment in that Province. Having regard to the rates of rent and revenue in all Provinces of India, we ask that the old rule of demanding one-half the net produce be supplemented by a rule limiting the revenue to one-fifth the gross produce, wherever revenue is paid to the State direct by cultivators.
(c) Where the State receives land revenue direct from cultivators, we ask that the rule laid down by Lord Ripon, of making an increase of prices the sole ground of enhancement at the time of re-settlements, be universally applied.
(d) Where the land revenue is not permanently settled, we ask that Settlements be made not oftener than once in thirty years.
(e) We pray that no cesses be imposed on the rental of the land except for purposes directly benefiting the land; and that the total of such cesses assessed on the rental may not exceed six and a quarter per cent. (one anna in the rupee) in any province of India.
(f) We pray that where the Government provides water for irrigation, the cultivator may be left—as he has been during the last forty years—the option of paying for the water if he choose to use it, and that no compulsory water-rate be imposed.
(g) And lastly, we pray that in the case of any difference between cultivators and Settlement Officers in the matter of assessment, an appeal be allowed to an independent tribunal, not concerned with the fixing and levying of rents and rates.
12th May 1900.
Notes
- 1. See Appendix I.
- Note. Administration Report of the Punjab, 1898-99, pp. 23, and Statistical Table XV.
- 1. The maximum of one-fifth the produce should not be exceeded in the case of any single holding. The average land revenue for a whole district, including wet and dry lands, should be limited to one-tenth the produce, as in Northern India.