The occurrence of the Madras famine of 1877 induced Lord Lytton's Government to create new resources for Famine Relief and Insurance. New taxes were imposed; the annual famine grant was fixed at Rx. 1,500,000; and a pledge was given to the people of India that the proceeds of the taxes would not be expended for any purpose other than that for which they were imposed. "The simple object was in fact to provide so far as possible an annual surplus of one and a half crores for famine relief or famine insurance expenditure. To the extent to which in any year the amount was not spent on relief, it was to be spent solely on reduction of debt, or rather upon avoidance of debt which is the same thing. Such avoidance was to be effected by spending the money on productive public works, the cost of which would otherwise have been met by loans." 1
The pledge was broken soon after it was given. In the budget of 1878-79 the grant was made; but in the budget of 1879-80 it was suspended. There was a strong protest from the public in India; and the Secretary of State in his despatch of 23rd December 1880 took exception to Sir John Strachey's argument that, whether the public accounts showed surplus, equilibrium or deficit, the new taxes must prevent debt by the amount they yielded, and therefore fulfilled the conditions under which they were imposed. The merging of the proceeds of taxes, imposed under a distinct pledge, in the general revenues of India, was felt to be a violation of the pledge; and it was decided in 1881 that the full grant of one and a half crores (Rx. 1,500,000) should always be entered in the budget under the head of Famine Relief and Insurance, with sub-heads for (1) Relief, (2) Protective Works, and (3) Reduction of Debt.
It will thus appear that "the original policy of devoting the whole of the grant, less actual cost of famine relief, to reduction or avoidance of debt had been changed by the acceptance of the view that a large part of the grant might be better applied to what are called Famine Protective, as distinct from Productive Public Works."1 But even this new and modified purpose of the famine grant was not strictly adhered to. In fifteen years down to 1895-96 the famine grant, at a crore and a half annually, was 22½ crores (Rx. 22,500,000) while the expenditure for the purposes set forth above was only Rx. 17,644,185, thus :
| 1. Spent on actual famine relief | Rx. 320,664 |
| 2. On protective irrigation works | 1,813,841 |
| 3. On protective railways | 6,550,931 |
| 4. Interest upon Indian Midland and Bengal Nagpore Railways | 3,631,450 |
| 5. Reduction and avoidance of debt | 5,327,299 |
| 17,644,185 |
It is obvious that the money spent under the fourth heading, i.e. in paying interest on Indian railways, cannot come under the purpose of the Famine Grant as originally defined. Excluding that sum, the total money spent in fifteen years fell short of the grant by over eight millions of tens of rupees. The history of the Famine Relief and Insurance Grant is an illustration of the truth that the interests of the people are but imperfectly safeguarded under the present system of administration.
With the best of intentions, British administrators in India have repeatedly drifted into errors or forgotten their pledges, because the people themselves have been carefully debarred from any real share in the administration. So true is the maxim laid down by John Stuart Mill that "it is an inherent condition of human affairs that no intention, however sincere, of protecting the interests of others, can make it safe or salutary to tie up their own hands."
The large sums spent in famine relief in 1897 and in 1900 will probably bring up the total of famine expenditure to the total of the grant; but it is necessary to lay down specific rules for the future expenditure of the grant. In the first place, the construction of protective railways should now be abandoned, because the Famine Commissioners, appointed in 1898, have stated in their Report that most of the necessary protective railways have now been constructed, and that there is a possibility of others being constructed as productive works.1 In the second place, the interest upon the Midland and Bengal Nagpur Railways should not be charged to the famine grant, and the sanction given by Lord Randolph Churchill, Secretary of State for India, to this irregular proceeding in 1885 should now be revoked.1 The whole of the famine grant of Rx.1,500,000 should thus be set free, and should be devoted entirely (1) upon actual famine relief; (2) upon protective irrigation works; and (3) on the reduction of debt. When there is no famine, a million tens of rupees should be spent annually on protective irrigation works, and the remaining half a million should be used as a sinking fund to reduce the enormous public debt of India.
The total length of railways in India up to the end of 1898-99 was 26,059¼ miles, of which 22,491 miles were open for traffic. The net loss to the State, i.e. to the people of India, from these railways, after deducting all their earnings and returns, was Rx. 57,734,761 up to the end of 1898-99. It is apparent from these figures that railways have been overdone in India— overdone in consideration of the resources of the country. Nearly all the lines needed for famine protective purposes have been completed, and it is reasonable, therefore, to hope that no future lines shall be undertaken by the State either as protective works or as productive works, and that the profits of no future lines shall be guaranteed out of the public revenues. If there is a reasonable chance of profits from new lines in any part of India, private capital and private enterprise will undertake them. If there is no reasonable chance of profits from fresh lines, to construct them out of Indian revenues, or to guarantee profits out of the proceeds of taxes, is to sacrifice the interests of the people of India to the interests of speculators and capitalists.1
What India wants now is an extensive system of irrigation, and we have already suggested that a crore of rupees, out of the crore and a half of the famine grant, may be annually spent on protective irrigation works. "It appears to us," write the members of the Famine Commission of 1898, "that most of the necessary protective railways have now been constructed, that there is a possibility of others being constructed on their merits as productive works or as feeders to the trunk lines of railway without assistance from the famine grant, and that under existing circumstances greater protection will be afforded by the extension of irrigation works."1
In 1869, Colonel Strachey, then Inspector-General of Irrigation Works in India, submitted a report after an inquiry ordered by the Secretary of State for India. He stated in the report that in Madras 3,000,000 acres, being about one-fourth of the whole cultivated area, were irrigated; that in Bombay there were few irrigation works deserving special service, except in Sindh; that in the Punjab, 800,000 acres were under irrigation; and that in the North-Western Provinces a similar area was irrigated.
Irrigation works are now classed into three classes :
- I.—Productive Works.
- II.—Protective Works.
- III.—Minor Works.
Productive Irrigation Works.—The capital outlay on productive irrigation works up to the end of 1879-80 was Rx. 20,298,000. The capital outlay up to the end of 1896-97 (including one purely navigation work) was Rx. 31,252,948. The capital expenditure during seventeen years was, therefore, only eleven million tens of rupees, but, deducting from this a sum paid by the Government to the Madras Irrigation Company, the actual capital outlay during the seventeen years has been only Rx. 540,000 per annum. The area irrigated in 1878-79 was 5,171,497 acres. The area irrigated in 1896-97 was 9,448,692 acres. The net return on the capital outlay in the year 1896-97 was 6·35 per cent., showing that, financially, the productive irrigation works have been a success.
Protective Irrigation Works.—The capital outlay on protective irrigation works up to the end of 1896-97 was Rx. 2,099,253, out of which Rx. 1,698,424 has been charged against the Famine Insurance Grant. The total area irrigated by these works in 1896-97 was 200,733 acres, not including 123,087 acres irrigated by the Swat River Canal. Interest is not charged against protective irrigation works, as the cost of construction is met from revenues.
Minor Irrigation Works.—The irrigation effected by what are called minor works is of the very greatest importance. Many of them are old irrigation works constructed by Hindu and Mahomedan rulers, or more recently by district boards or public-spirited individuals, and have been taken over by the State. Some of the old works are of great size, irrigating several hundred thousand acres ; others are small works, which are numerous in Madras ; and about one-half the total irrigated area in that province is irrigated from such works.
Not only are these minor works exceedingly beneficial to the country, but their financial returns too are also very satisfactory, because the British Government did not spend any capital on the construction of most of them. The total expenditure incurred on these minor works during the seventeen years ending 1896-97 was over eight crores. The revenue attributable to works of this class exceeded the expenditure by over six crores. The total area irrigated by minor works in 1896-97 was 7,442,990.
Taking all the three classes of works together, the total area irrigated in India in 1896-97 is shown below :—
| Acres. | |
|---|---|
| By productive works | 9,448,692 |
| By protective works | 323,820 |
| By minor works | 7,442,990 |
| Total area irrigated | 17,215,502 |
The figures given above, which have been taken from the Report of the Famine Commission of 1898, show the area of land now under irrigation and the satisfactory financial results of the irrigation works hitherto undertaken. But the figures do not represent the entire financial value of these works. They show the direct proceeds of water-rates collected, either separately, or with the land revenue as in Madras, but they do not indicate the extent to which the land revenue itself is made stable by irrigation works ensuring the prosperity of agriculture. The Famine Commissioners very rightly urge, “that the value of these works should not be judged too strictly by the financial results, and that due credit should be given to the works, even if it cannot be reduced to a quantitative form, not only for the stability of the revenue assessed on the lands dependent on them, which may be small, but also for their great value in such a country, in all seasons of drought, to the people of the neighbourhood, as well as to those whose crops are actually secured.” 1
Far above financial considerations should be reckoned the duty of the State to protect agriculture and to save the lives of the people in a country so dependent on water as India. The painful experience through which we are passing in the present year must convince the Government of India of the necessity of storing water in every part of the country for the saving of crops in years of drought, for the saving of cattle, and for the saving of human lives. The canal system may not be practicable on high table-lands and in hilly country, but embankments and bunds constructed across slopes would convert large dry areas into perennial lakes capable of irrigating thousands of acres in the surrounding country. This was very clearly explained by Mr Samuel Smith, M.P., in his speech in a recent debate in the House of Commons, and this was also forcibly urged by the Hon. Rai Bahadur B. K. Bose in his recent speech in the Viceroy's Council.
“What I am unable to make out,” said Mr Bose, “is why the question of having storage tanks has never attracted attention. It cannot be said there is nothing in the country to suggest the utility of such works. We have many such tanks, made mainly in pre-British days, in what is known as the lake region of the Central Provinces. Here an irrigation tank is an irregular sheet of water, its banks formed by hills, and its dyke shaped out by spurs from them thrown athwart the hollow. The largest of them has a circumference of seventeen miles. By two short bunds the waters of scores of hills have been impounded into a lovely lake, which spreads its fertilising streams over large areas of surrounding cultivation. Where the crude, untrained village headman succeeded, British scientific skill is bound to attain greater success. In a question like this I speak with great diffidence, but I believe that the tracts of high lands and valleys which abound in the Central Provinces would, if looked into, furnish suitable sites for several such tanks. Two or three of them have been made of late years to supply drinking water to municipal towns, but their importance for irrigation does not appear to have received consideration.”1
Besides such artificial lakes, it is possible to multiply wells for irrigation purposes throughout the country. “Whatever field there may be,” says the Famine Commission of 1898, “for many years to come for the construction of protective irrigation works of the ordinary kind, i.e. canals or storage works, there are probably more tracts liable to periodical drought in which the desired protection may be afforded with greater certainty or at less financial risk by the construction of wells, by means of State advances which would be only partially recoverable, the irrecoverable portion of the advance being a final charge against the Famine Insurance Grant. . . . It is open to consideration whether when wells have to be sunk through rock with uncertain results, it might not be worth while for the State to share part of the cost in view of the protection afforded, if water is eventually found. It is also open to consideration whether the State might not bear the cost of scientific aid in the shape of boring operations to ascertain whether or not a supply of water will be forthcoming if the well is sunk. We have been informed that in the North-Western Provinces operations of this nature have been conducted in a more or less systematised method, and that the result has not been unsuccessful.”1
It is abundantly manifest from these observations of representative men like the Honourable Mr Bose, who know the country, and of the Famine Commissioners who have thoroughly inquired into facts, that there is ample scope for constructing storage lakes and wells where irrigation by canals is impossible. If the same activity which has marked the extention of railways in India within the last thirty or forty years had been manifested in irrigation works in the Central Provinces, Gujrat and the Deccan, the present famine would have been less extensive in its area, and less disastrous in the loss of cattle and the loss of human lives. Another mistake which has been made in the past is to look only to the direct financial results of the irrigation works constructed, as shown in the proceeds of water rates and increased land revenue. It is a mistake, because these rates do not represent the saving which is effected by arresting famines, by securing crops, and making land revenue stable in years of drought. And it is also a mistake, because a too close attention to the direct proceeds of the irrigation works diverts attention from the duty of the State, both as a Ruling Power and as the Superior Landlord in India, from the duty of saving the lives and promoting the agriculture of the people of India, irrespective of financial considerations. The pronouncement of the Famine Commissioners is clear and emphatic on this point also: “As the State in India,” they say, “is generally in the position of superior landlord, there are special reasons why the Government should undertake without expectation of direct return works peculiarly protective of agriculture, such as irrigation works.”1
The most recent instance in which this mandate has been violated is the imposition of a compulsory water rate within all wet areas by an Act passed by the Madras Government in the present year. For the last forty years and more, water rates have been optional; the cultivator who chooses to use canal water pays for it, and the cultivator who does not use it does not pay.
This method has answered well enough in practice; the mass of cultivators voluntarily use canal water for the protection of their crops, and the financial returns from irrigation works have been satisfactory, as has been shown before. But local governments have, in their anxiety to secure financial profits, needlessly endeavoured from time to time to make that compulsory which is voluntarily paid without objection,— to make that an irritating tax on the people which the people have regarded and paid as a fair return for benefits obtained. As long ago as 1869, the Government of India submitted the “Northern India Canal and Drainage Bill” to the Secretary of State for India, and proposed to make the irrigation rate compulsory. The late Duke of Argyll, then the Secretary of State for India, declined to accord his sanction to the measure and recorded his reasons in his letter of the 11th January 1870, the main portion of which is quoted below.1 Another proposal made in 1879 in connection with the Bombay Irrigation Act, that all lands commanded by the water of canals should be taxed, was similarly rejected by the then Secretary of State for India. And now, in a year of distress and famine in India, the Government of Madras has thought it fit to pass an Act which, in the opinion of the late Duke of Argyll, would either throw on the cultivators the loss consequent on unsuccessful speculations undertaken by the
how prone to become excessive guaranteed expenditure always is ; and under the provisions of the Bill all expenditure on Government canals would be guaranteed.
4. To this alone there would be no objection if the guarantee were given voluntarily. But here the guarantee is to be extorted compulsorily. The inhabitants of a district are not to be asked beforehand whether they desire irrigation or not. The Government alone is to judge whether irrigation is desirable. It alone is to decide arbitrarily whether an irrigation work shall be constructed ; but the landholders, and not the Government, are to be responsible in the event of the latter's committing an error of judgment. There is little analogy between a plan like this, and that under which county cesses are levied in England and Ireland, for those by whom these cesses are imposed, besides being themselves cesspayers, represent theoretically, if not really, the great body of cesspayers who are assumed consequently, to have given their assent by proxy. The outlay to which they are subjected has been undertaken by them voluntarily, and in the event of its proving unproductive, they have no pretext for considering themselves aggrieved.
5. These considerations would, in my opinion, go far towards neutralising any recommendations which the proposed enactment might otherwise possess, but I am greatly in doubt whether it is really calculated to serve any useful end. To force irrigation on the people would be not unlikely to make that unpopular which could otherwise scarcely fail to be regarded as a blessing, and which, as all experience shows, Indian agriculturists, if left to themselves, are sure duly to appreciate, sooner or later, and seldom later than the first season of drought that occurs after irrigation has been placed within their reach.
(Signed) Argyll. Government,1 or would force them to pay for water for which they have no use, or would lead to excessive expenditure under the vicious system of guaranteed profits.
No reason exists for making the water rate compulsory in Madras; for productive irrigation works are paying at the rate of 6·35 per cent. on the capital sunk in all India, and at the higher rate of 7·14 in the Province of Madras.1 No object is gained by forcing on the people the benefits of a system of which they have availed themselves voluntarily as a blessing, and which they will detest as a curse when it is needlessly forced on them. No increase in the total revenue can be expected, for in Madras lands are already over-assessed, and responsible administrators will find it necessary, before long, to lighten the burden in that Province and not to add to it. And no endeavours to make the system of irrigation works really useful to the cultivators are likely to be made when the canal officers are sure of their returns in the shape of a compulsory tax over the entire area supposed to be benefited by those works. The blunder made in Madras is likely to spread in other parts of India; and instead of a voluntary rate which the people are willingly paying everywhere in India, they will find that irrigation means another and an odious tax on their limited savings.
The Act passed by the Government of Madras is another instance of an administrative blunder due to disregarding the opinions of the people; and it is another illustration of John Stuart Mill's maxim, quoted before, that "it is an inherent condition of human affairs that no intention, however sincere, of protecting the interests of others, can make it safe or salutary to tie up their own hands."
Notes
- 1. Report of the Famine Commission of 1898, p. 324.
- 1. Report of the Famine Commission of 1898, p. 325.
- 1. Report of the Famine Commission of 1898, p. 330.
- 1. Lord Randolph Churchill's sanction runs as follows :— "Great objection has been taken, both by former Secretaries of State and by the Select Committee of the House of Commons last year, to the proposal to appropriate as interest any portion of the Famine Insurance Grant, the declared object of which was to keep down debt. I recognise, however, that the circumstances of the present time are of a special character, and could not have been contemplated either by my predecessors or by the Parliamentary Committee. . . . I therefore authorise you to charge against the Famine Insurance Grant the amount payable during the next five years, an interest on capital raised by companies for the purpose of constructing any of the lines which are mentioned by your Government as being, in your opinion, needed for the protection of the country against famine, but which you are not at present able to construct through State agency." Subsequently, after the lines had been opened, it was agreed, in 1890, that the charge against the Famine Insurance Grant should be, not the guaranteed interest, but the net loss on the railways, including that interest. It is needless to add that the people of India, to whom a pledge had been given when the taxes were imposed, were not consulted when these various orders were passed about the application of their proceeds.
- 1. See evidence of Mr S. Jacob before the Royal Commission on Indian expenditure, Appendix U.
- 1. Report, p. 330.
- 1. Report, p. 346. See also Jacob’s Evidence, Appendix U.
- 1. Speech in the Viceroy’s Legislative Council, 28th March 1900. See Appendix F.
- 1. Report, p. 354.
- 1. Report, p. 330.
- 1. To His Excellency the Right Honourable the Governor General of India in Council. My Lord, India Office, 11th January 1870. Para 1. I have had under consideration in Council, the “Northern Indian Canal and Drainage Bill, 1869,” copy of which was enclosed with your Excellency’s Legislative Despatch, No 22, of 18th October last. You have already been informed by telegram that great objections are entertained by me to Section 56 of the Bill, which declares that “if at any time, not less than five years after the commencement of irrigation from any canal, the average net revenue in the three next preceding years realised by the Government from the use of the water thereof, and including all sources of income dependent on such canal, and deducting all charges for maintenance and management and working, properly debitable to the revenue account of the same, shall not amount to a sum equal to seven per cent. on the capital expended on the said canal, the local government may charge on the lands irrigable by the water of such canal, but not paying any water rate therefor, such a yearly rate or rates as shall, when added to the net yearly estimated income, reckoned as aforesaid, produce a total amount as nearly as may be, equal to seven per cent. on the capital aforesaid.” 2. I will now explain in what my objections to this section consist. 3. The object of the provision in question is to enable Government to secure itself against pecuniary loss in the event of a canal proving a financial failure. Such failure might ensue from three causes. A canal might not be able to supply for irrigational purposes the expected quantity of water, or, the expected quantity being available, cultivators might decline to avail themselves to the expected extent, or excessive costliness of construction might, in order to render a canal remunerative, necessitate the imposition of higher rates than cultivators could afford or would voluntarily pay. In the first case, under the proposed enactment, the loss consequent on Government having engaged in an unsuccessful speculation, would fall, not upon itself, but upon the cultivators, whom it had disappointed. In the second, cultivators would be forced to pay for water for which they had no use, or, at any rate, were not disposed to use, possibly, no doubt, from imperfect appreciation of the value of irrigation, but quite possibly also from a perfectly intelligible desire to have part of their land under dry crops, instead of all under wet. With regard to the third, none can require less than your Government to be reminded
- 1. Instances have occurred in the past in which the Government has thrown on the cultivators the loss sustained by unsuccessful speculation. The following extracts from Sir George Campbell's “ Memoirs of my Indian Career ” relate to one such incident which took place in Bengal : “ Sir Arthur had succeeded in forming a large private company in England to establish a great system of irrigation in Orissa ; and much progress had been made with the works when there came this famine, which seemed to justify the project. Still, looking to the rarity of rain failure, and the facilities for importing grain, if measures were taken in time, we greatly doubted if such extensive works would ever pay. We suggested a liberal treatment of the company—the offer of assistance in the way of loans, etc.—but we strongly advised the Government not to purchase the works, as had been suggested. A little time after, however, that happened which usually happens when British capitalists have put their money in losing concerns in India, people in London bullied and abused the Government to get the concern taken over, and eventually they were successful. The Government paid out the Company in full, with an additional bonus, and have since expended a great deal more, making upwards of three millions sterling. From that day to this, the concern has hardly ever paid its working expenses, much less a farthing of interest on the capital.”—Vol. ii. p. 161. “The success of the local cess (Road Cess) induced the Government of India, a few years later, to urge upon the Government of Bengal the imposition of a further provincial cess (Public Works Cess). . . It seemed to me that the Government of India sailed a little near the wind in respect of my pledges, in that the fund (Public Works Cess Fund) was, to a large extent, applied to recoup their own bad bargains, to which the Government of Bengal had in no degree assented. I had protested against the purchase of that most losing concern, the Orissa Irrigation Company.”—Vol. ii. p. 213.
- 1. Report of the Famine Commission of 1898.