Appendix A

Proportion of Revenue and of Rent to Produce

Famines and Land Assessments in India, Romesh Chunder Dutt, 1900 · from page 103 · about 13 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

Major Wace on the proportion of Land Revenue to Produce in the Punjab

"Commencing in 1849 with a standard of one-third of the produce, a period of low prices, combined with other considerations affecting the welfare of a newly-conquered and previously much-oppressed country, compelled us to reduce that standard successively to a fourth, and a sixth; and after having done this from the year 1860, a period of high prices has set in under which undoubtedly our assessments absorb very much less than the standard share of the produce on which they were framed."

Note.—"The Financial Commissioner desires to observe that though the Lahore and Amritsar Divisions and one or two other districts were assessed between 1860 and 1872 on a standard of one-sixth produce, the standard now observed (e.g. in the late assessments of the Mooltan, Derajat and Delhi divisions and Jhelum districts) is one-half assets, i.e. one-half the customary rents, which as a matter of fact are usually produce rents."—Report of the Famine Commission of 1878, Appendix, vol. iii. p. 365.

"If all the influences which I have above described be duly weighed, especially the effect of increased cultivation and of rising prices towards lightening the incidence of leases fixed for twenty or thirty years, we shall find reason to admit that the assessment in most years probably now absorbs only one-tenth of the whole produce of the land which pays it (the term produce being understood in its fullest sense).—Ibid., p. 365.

Sir Antony Macdonnell on the proportion of Land Revenue to Produce in the N.W. Provinces

“I should say that the fair average share of the gross production taken by the landlords in rent would be about twenty per cent., and I think, as a rule, the Government takes less than half of that. I should say the Government assessment of land revenue in the North-West Provinces is represented by about eight per cent. of the gross produce.”—Evidence taken by the Indian Currency Committee (1898), part i. pp. 211 and 212.

TBL-009 · FOLIO 128Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Mr Toynbee on the proportion of Land Revenue to Rent in Bengal
Division.Government Revenue.Gross Rental.
Rupees.Rupees.
Burdwan, . .79, 74, 8911, 85, 40, 026
Presidency, . .51, 16, 5231, 42, 35, 364
Rajthahye, . .48, 65, 8401, 59, 30, 574
Dacca, . .39, 71, 3991, 91, 25, 288
Chittagong, . .12, 43, 74959, 58, 881
Patna, . .80, 26, 1643, 73, 48, 552
Bhagulpore, . .31, 60, 9411, 15, 05, 324
Orissa, . .17, 36, 84540, 19, 130
Chota Nagpur, .3, 01, 10237, 15, 796
Total, . .3, 63, 97, 45413, 03, 78, 935

—Report of the Famine Commission of 1878, Appendix, vol. iii. p. 387.

[The proportion of Land Revenue to Rent from these figures is approximately twenty-eight per cent.].

Mr H. L. Dampier on the proportion of rent to the produce in Bengal.

“In the discussions which took place with regard to determining the proportion in which the profits should be divided between landlord and tenant, the British Indian Association, representing the large landholders, were very anxious that some rule should be presented, and proposed to accept twenty-five per cent. of the average gross value of the produce as the landlord’s share. This would probably be considered as, generally speaking, a very favourable arrangement for the ryot by those who hold that the ryot is entitled to retain nothing more than the wages of his labour and the legitimate profits of his stock; and as a fact, where rent is paid in kind, the landlord takes half, and even nine-sixteenths, of the crop; nevertheless the discussions brought out that twenty-five per cent. on the gross value of the produce would be a larger share than the landlords are now receiving in some parts of the country, and would press hardly on the ryots.”—Report of the Famine Commission of 1878, Appendix II., p. 72.

TBL-010 · FOLIO 130Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Proportion of Rent to Produce in Bengal. Figures com- piled from Hunter's "Statistical Account of Bengal"
District.Produce per Acre.Rent per Acre.Proportion of Rent to Produce.
£s.d.£s.d.
24 Perganas . . { (a)5200180} 18·7 per cent.
(b)220090
Nadiya . . { (a)330076} 13·8 „
(b)0136030
Jessor . . (a)313609012·3 „
Midnapur . . (a)315009012·0 „
Hugli . . { (a)3120110} 29·4 „
(b)1100090
Howrah . . { (a)3800180} 25·0 „
(b)200090
Bankura . . { (a)21700143} 25·5 „
(b)1146090
Birbhum . . { (a)4300180} 22·7 „
(b)1160090
Dacca . (a)4130010611·2 „
Backerganj . (b)116005815·7 „
Faridpur . (b)110003912·5 „
Mymensing . . { (a)5200180} 17·3 „
(b)2140090
Noakhali . . (a)35009013·8 „
Tipperh . . { (a)31200180} 24·5 „
(b)1183090
Dinajpur . . (b)116009025·0 „
Rajshahi . . (b)113009027·2 „
Pabna . . (a)315009012·0 „
Gaya . . { (a)31200180} 21·1 „
(b)2105090
Manbhum . . (b)112009028·1 „
Balasor . . { (a)100060} 28·1 „
(b)0120030

[The proportion of rent to the produce from these figures is an average of twenty per cent. And if twenty-eight per cent of the rent is taken as Government revenue, the proportion of revenue to the value of gross produce is 28/100 × 20/100 = 5·6 per cent.]

Proportion of Rent to Produce in Bengal. Resolution of the Bengal Government, dated Calcutta the 6th August 1883

Para. 8. “ . . . The proportion of the gross produce which should be taken by Zemindars or Government as rent or revenue has been the subject of discussion and minute inquiry in connection with the Tenancy Bill. In the earlier stages of that discussion it was considered that one-fourth of the gross produce was an equitable maximum by which to limit the landlord’s demands. It never was pretended that all landlords were justified in claiming one-fourth of the produce as rent, or that the proportion should be looked on otherwise than as the farthest limit which under circumstances most favourable to the landlord his claims might reach. This one-fourth limit, however, was only provisionally accepted by this Government. It was always recognised that the point was one which required careful investigation ; and accordingly it was made the subject of special instructions to the officers who were appointed last year to test the feasability of constructing Tables of Rates in various portions of Bengal and Behar. The result of the information collected by these officers was to induce the Lieutenant-Governor to advocate the substitution of one-fifth for one-fourth of the gross produce in the Tenancy Bill now before the Legislative Council of the Government of India.” . . . (Signed) A. P. Macdonnell, Secretary.—Selections from the Correspondence, Despatches, etc., of Khurda Settlement, vol. iii. p. 225.

Madras Board of Revenue on the proportion of Land Revenue to Produce in Madras

TBL-011 · FOLIO 132Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Madras Board of Revenue on the proportion of Land Revenue to Produce in Madras
Districts Settled.Percentage of Assessments to the Value of the Gross Produce at Commutation Rates.
Dry Lands.Wet Lands.
Cuddapah20, 13, 1222
Kistna15, 1821
Nellore1823
Cuddapah, 3 Taluks15, 1416, 17
Kurnool16, 13, 1716, 17, 18, 19
Chinglepat1520
South Arcot1531
Trichinopoly1328
Tinnevelly...25
Salem12, 1317, 21

Colonel Anderson on the proportion of Land Revenue to Produce in Bombay

"My impression is that we are safe in saying that in fair land in the general run of seasons, with ordinary cultivations and average prices, the assessment absorbs less than one-eighth of the gross produce,1 and in poor land under the same conditions a very much smaller proportion."—Report of the Famine Commission of 1878 Appendix, vol. iii. p. 393.

Proportion of Land Revenue to Produce in Bombay.

Extracts from Mr Vaughan Nash's Letter to the Manchester Guardian of the 2nd May 1900

"I wanted to know how the cultivators were faring in the villages round Nandurbar, and the following notes of a talk I had with a group of farmers by the well at the village of Nagbode will show that the battle with famine is a hard affair even for the men of substance:—

"Mathan, a man of thirty, owned five bullocks last year. Three died from want of water, one was killed by the Bheels, and one was left. The survivor was trying to get on its feet at the moment we began our conversation, and Mathan went to help it up--by the tail. Mathan farms sixty acres, but had no produce this year. The land is mortgaged, and he is living now as a labourer. With no water and no bullocks, he can do nothing on his own land. Last year, after paying 116 rupees for land revenue (on eighty-four acres), 100 rupees to a money-lender, and some barley to two servants, he had 70 rupees left for himself, his son, and two daughters; his wife is dead. He has been called upon to pay his revenue this year, but has not done so.

"Murar the Patel, a young man, farms sixty acres, but there has been no produce this year. The farm is mortgaged to the extent of about 3000 rupees. He estimates his last year's produce at 375 rupees, of which he paid 104 rupees to Government. He had to buy four bullocks for 100 rupees, and pay 40 rupees for servants, and was therefore unable to pay anything to the money-lender. The other expenses of cultivation amounted to nearly 60 rupees. He kept the rest for himself, his wife, uncle, and two children. He has been served with notice of assessment. He had six bullocks, and has lost four.

"Laxmann has eighty-four acres; his crops have failed; he has lost four out of eight bullocks; three are in a condition to work, and one is at the point of death. He is indebted on his personal security for 700 rupees. He had nothing left for paying the money-lender last year after payment of the Government assessment— 105 rupees—expenses of cultivation, etc.

"Nathu farms thirty-nine acres. His crops failed, and five bullocks out of six have died. After paying the Government 60 rupees last year there remained only 40 or 50, and he had to go out to labour to keep his wife and five children. His farm is mortgaged for 700 rupees.

"Three of these sons, with two others, Annaji and Zuga, had taken the bit of garden round the well, lent to them rent free by an absentee cultivator, and were doing their best with it, but they did not see how they could hold on for more than another month. They have no grain at home, and some of the cooking pots have been sold.

“A bullock cart came by, and some farmers from Sarvala, a village eight miles off, seeing us talking, pulled up to ascertain what it was all about. Would they be willing to say how things were going with them? I asked through the interpreter. They made no objection.

“Gutal farmed 225 acres, and had no crops. He had 100 beasts last years, bullocks, buffaloes, and two horses, and has lost seventy. Last year’s crops were worth from 1000 to 1200 rupees. He paid 500 rupees to the Government and 500 for labour, and borrowed money for maintenance.

“Dulladha owns 135 acres, and has lost fifteen cattle out of his stock of twenty-two. After paying assessment—350 rupees—last year, and the expenses of the farm, he was able to pay his way with his family working on the farm. His ancestral debt is 5000 rupees, and up to last year he has paid interest on it in money or in kind.

“The third Sarvala man was in good circumstances, and his companions discreetly moved away after explaining that his maternal uncle had left him great riches, and such was my own embarrassment that I forgot to take down his name. The prosperous nephew owns 300 acres, but this year there was no produce, and out of 120 beasts, 20 remained, the others having died for want of fodder.

" The three had been served with notices of assessment. I did not see the actual notice, but the following is a literal translation of the Mahratti from a copy of which I have since obtained :—

NOTICE.

A. B., Inhabitant of Village ........................................................................................... Taluka ............................................................................................ District ........................................................................................... You are informed that the land marginally noted and the assessment marginally noted are in the revenue records. The assessment for instalment of year, being Rs. , was due on , and you have not paid it yet. This notice is therefore given to you that if the instalment of Rs. , and the notice fee, , total , is not paid within ten days from the date of this notice stricter measures will be taken according to the law, and the whole assessment for the current year will be recovered at once, and you will be liable to pay as fee on account of the non-payment of instalment. Date........................................................................

Cold comfort this for people who are brought as low as the peasants of France before the Revolution, who have ruin and hunger as their daily portion, while plague and cholera stand over them ready to strike. To them appears the Government of the British Empire in the likeness of the broker's man. The Government may explain that what it wants is to get the money from those who can afford to pay, and especially from the ‘bunya’; to which I would reply that recovery from the ‘bunya’ will in nine cases out of ten only increase the burdens of the cultivator, that it is difficult to discriminate between those who are able to pay and those who are not, and that even if the selection could be managed with a certain rough justice, the sight of Government beginning to distrain—I hear of ‘examples’ being made as I travel about the country —will break what little is left unbroken in the hearts of the people, and lead them to suppose that their own homes and lands are going to follow."

General Summary

TBL-012 · FOLIO 137Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Land Revenue
Bengal5 to 6 per cent. of gross produce
North-West8„„„
Punjab10„„„
Madras12 to 31„„„
Bombay20 to 33„„„

Notes

  1. Note. Report of the Famine Commission of 1878, Appendix III., p. 394.
  2. 1. The rate is much higher now. For the proportion in the settled districts of Madras is between twelve and thirty-one per cent. ; in Bombay the assessment per acre of cultivated land is higher than in Madras ; and the proportion of produce taken as revenue must therefore [p. 109] be higher. Recent calculations made by myself, and by other observers who have made inquiries on the spot, show that the proportion of produce taken as revenue in Bombay is generally between twenty and thirty-three per cent. of the gross produce of fields. The figures given by one such observer, Mr Vaughan Nash, who made inquiries in the present year (1900), will be found in the next page. Figures from official crop experiment reports will be found in p. 323.