Appendix H

Speech of the Hon. Sir Harnam Singh

Famines and Land Assessments in India, Romesh Chunder Dutt, 1900 · from page 140 · about 3 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

My Lord,—The Finance Member proposes to show future unappropriated balances from the famine grant under the heading of Reduction or Avoidance of Debt. I do not clearly understand in what respect this would be an improvement upon the former heading of Reduction of Debt. The heading proposed will, to my mind, be as puzzling as the former one. We are told that in a normal year in which ordinary revenue and expenditure balanced, the Government of India instead of raising a loan of three crores for public works would be able to reduce the three crores by the unappropriated balance, say, a crore of the famine grant. Could not the same result be obtained by investing the unappropriated balance in a separate fund which may be called the Famine Fund, and appropriating a certain definite portion, say, one crore, in aid of public works if they are of a protective, i.e. famine, character ? It seems to me that in the Budget Estimate for the coming year, a rather sanguine view has been taken of our sources of revenue. These sources do not appear to me to be so elastic as they are taken to be. I would call the attention of Your Excellency to the rate of increase of revenue during the last three years. The first year was a year of drought; in the second year the pressure of famine had considerably diminished, but the Province had not recovered its normal condition, the third year was a year of plenty, the arrears of revenue were to a great extent realised, and the Province showed a large increase of revenue. I find from the last Punjab Administration Report that the increase during that year was due partly to a rise in the income from fluctuating land revenue occasioned by favourable seasons and good canal working, and partly to large receipts on account of nazarana and sales of land on the Chenab Canal. In the second year, there was an increase of about eighteen lacs, and in the third year, as compared with the previous year, there was an increase of about twelve lacs. If the large receipts on account of nazarana and sales of land in the third year be taken away from these twelve lacs, the increase shown would be considerably diminished. I am inclined to think, my Lord, that the realisations of the third year were abnormal, and that the Budget Estimate ought not to have been based on the collections of this year. In 1897 there was only an increase of eighteen lacs as compared with the previous year, and this increase might be taken as a standard; but then it must be considered that the produce of the land would be greatly diminished after a second famine within a period of three years. The mortality of the agricultural cattle will be considerable; those which were spared at the first famine will not be spared at the second, and an adequate supply of fresh cattle will be difficult to be obtained in the coming year, large tracts of land will be lying waste, and revenue realisations are sure to be affected. What I have said with regard to the Punjab applies, mutatis mutandis to other Provinces affected with famine. My Lord, what has been observed by the Hon. Mr Bose in regard to the Revenue Settlement in his Province deserves careful consideration by the Government of India. I am bound to admit that in my Province the Government has been very liberal, and no one can reasonably complain of heavy assessment. I am sure that in this the Hon. Mr Ibbetson will bear me out. I would, however, point out, in the interest of both landlord and tenants, that it is desirable that the Revenue Settlement should be of at least thirty years’ duration. I am strongly of opinion that when a district is properly surveyed, rights recorded, and lands classified, it should not be disturbed again with the view of increasing the revenue demand at the expiry of the settlement period unless sufficient reasons, such as extension of cultivation and appreciable rise in prices of food-grain, are shown.