I
To the Editor of the "Manchester Guardian"
Sir,—I have read your remarks on the Report of the Royal Commission on Indian Expenditure with the greatest interest. India has waited for the report of this Commission for five years, and the people of India, who have enough trouble and misery of their own, expect that in the matter of foreign wars and foreign complications England will at least deal justly and even generously by the people of India. Judging from the substance of the report which has already appeared in print, the recommendations made by the majority of the Commissioners are full of the worst forebodings for India. Permit me to refer only to one or two heads.
Under the head of "Apportionate of Charges" it is recommended that India should contribute one-half of the military charges of Aden, one-half of the cost of the Persian Mission, £12,500 for the China establishments, £10,000 for the Zanzibar and Mauritius telegraph subsidy, and also the present Euphrates Tigris subsidy. The amount under each of these heads is comparatively small; but is it just on principle to saddle India with any portion of the cost of maintaining British power and influence in different parts of Asia and Africa? Does England saddle Cape Colony or Natal with the cost of Ashanti or of any of the British establishments in West Africa?
Under the head of “Indian Troops out of India” we are told that a part of the cost of employing Indian troops out of India should be borne by India, if she has a distinct and special interest at stake. And then we are told that India has a “direct and substantial interest” in keeping open the Suez Canal and in the maintainence of order in Egypt; a “modified interest” in Zanzibar and the African islands in the Indian Ocean; a “direct and substantial interest” in Persia, the Persian Gulf, and the coast and islands of Arabia; a “direct and substantial interest” in Afghanistan and parts of Central Asia; a “direct and substantial interest” in Siam, and a “modified interest” in China and the Malay peninsula. Does this mean that the resources of India, which are scarcely enough for her civil and military administration, will continue to be drawn upon by England in her various complications in different parts of Asia and Africa? Does this mean that the richest country in the world will continue to tax the poorest and most miserable peasantry on earth, not only for their own warfare, but also for the maintenance of England’s influence and empire in portions of two continents? The principle that India is responsible for keeping the path from England to India clear is a principle which would be considered outrageous if it was applied to any of the colonies. The Australian colonies are as much interested in the Suez Canal, the Arabian and Persian coasts, and in the Malay peninsula, as India. Has any Royal Commission or Colonial Secretary suggested that the Australian colonies should be saddled with the cost of maintaining British influence in these places? Sir Henry Fowler said last night at Wolverhampton: "Why am I standing here to defend the (Transvaal) war? Because it is a war not for the obtaining of the franchise, not for the rights, sound and strong as they were, of the Outlanders, but because it is a war for nothing less than British supremacy in South Africa. That supremacy means our Indian Empire." If the recommendations of the majority of the Royal Commission were accepted and followed out to their logical conclusion, would not the Indian Empire be charged for this South African War, which is necessary, according to Sir Henry Fowler, for maintaining the Indian Empire? Would not the Indian Empire be charged for the maintenance of the British army and the British fleet, and of the British Power generally, because they are all necessary for maintaining the Indian Empire? Where will you draw the line when you once depart from the old and equitable and sound maxim that India shall pay for troops maintained for her protection in India—not for troops and establishments and wars outside India? The army now maintained in India is not for her protection only, but for England's Asiatic and African possessions. Considering the large portion of the Indian army now employed in South Africa, the question was raised, not long ago, by Sir Henry Campbell-Bannerman whether the whole of the army now stationed in India should be paid for from the Indian revenues. I do not find that this question has been dealt with in the report of the majority of the Royal Commission. While the majority of the Commissioners are anxious to define India's interests on the Nile and the Tigris, in Zanzibar and the Malay peninsula, I do not find that they are anxious to define England's Imperial interest in the army now stationed in India. I write this in regret and in sorrow—a sorrow which will be universally felt by my countrymen when they read the substance of the report which has been published.
“God help the people of India,” said Mr Donald Smeaton, a member of Lord Curzon's Council to Reuter's Agent at Bombay the other day; “Great Britain and Ireland owe a debt to the Indian peasant, a debt of millions upon millions.” We know that India annually remits to England a sum estimated between twenty and thirty millions sterling for home charges, pensions, interest, and the like. We know that the people of India are virtually debarred from the higher posts in India, except a very small percentage, and that fifteen millions sterling are annually paid to European officials employed in India, and sending all their savings to Europe. We know that our ancient industries like weaving and spinning and dyeing have been killed by European competition, and that the land is so heavily taxed in many provinces that the peasant cannot save in good years for years of bad harvest. We know that an army is kept in India, and paid for by India, sufficient for England's Imperial requirements over the best parts of Asia and Africa. We know that our finances are adjusted by Executive Councils in India and in England, in which the people of India have no seat, and that in the taxation of India we have no voice.
These are some of the burdens we bear in India, and these are some of the causes of the famines from which we periodically suffer. Will Englishmen add to them the burden of paying for British forts and armies, British establishments and wars in various parts of Africa and Asia—from the Suez Canal to Zanzibar, from the Tigris to the Malay Peninsula? Will the English conscience reconcile itself to thus proceeding in a year when eighty millions of people are affected by the worst famine that India has ever known, and five millions are actually attending relief centres? After the famine of 1770, and the desolating wars of Warren Hastings, the great minister Pitt brought in his India Bill in 1784 to give us a better Government. Is there no statesman in England at the present day who will give us a new India Bill, moderating land tax, reducing expenditure, opening up the higher services to the people of India, and giving them some control over their finances? Is there no Englishman of this generation who will stand up for justice to India?—I am, &c., Romesh Dutt. 21st April 1900.
II
To the Editor of the "Manchester Guardian"
Sir,—Your correspondent "E. W. B." takes exception to certain statements which I made in my letter published in your issue of the 24th April, and calls those statements “misleading.” Permit me to point out that I have not in this or in any other letter made any statement which I am not prepared to prove. “Mr Dutt,” your correspondent writes, “lays special stress on the fact of so much money going out of India in the shape of interest, loans, &c. Just so. But he does not say how much capital was spent on those undertakings.” The Blue-book on Indian railways can surely supply this information to your correspondent. I produced that Blue-book before the Currency Committee in November 1898, when I was examined as a witness, and showed that the railway system has caused a net loss of over fifty millions to the Indian revenue—i.e., to the Indian people; that it was still causing us an annual loss of about two millions; and that this loss was greatly owing, not to the construction of the main lines needed for famine protection purposes, but to local lines constructed for special interests, and often under pressure from capitalists in this country. It is this practice which I protest against. No sane man objects to paying interest on capital spent; but every reasonable man objects to adding to India's indebtedness by the construction of fresh lines under guarantee of profits from the Indian revenues when the people of India do not ask for those fresh lines, do not want them, and cannot afford to have them. An endeavour should be made in times of peace to reduce India's public debt, and thus to reduce the money which goes out of India as interest. England's debt was reduced by over one hundred and sixty millions within forty years after the Crimean war; my complaint is that Indian financiers are not reducing but continually adding to our public debt.
“He refers,” writes your correspondent, “to the millions paid to European officials, who send all their savings home. He says nothing of the pensions to the natives.” On this point also your correspondent might have obtained information from a Parliamentary return issued in 1892. Out of 39,000 officials in India who receive upwards of 1000 rupees a year, 28,000 are Englishmen, and 11,000 are natives. The 28,000 Englishmen receive fifteen millions sterling annually, and the 11,000 natives receive three millions only. No sane man objects to the employment of high English officials in India. We need their services, and we appreciate their work. But with the progress of education in India we desire, and we demand, a larger share of the high appointments in our own country; and my complaint is that we are debarred from our proper share at the present moment, not through our unfitness, but through exclusiveness and selfishness on the part of those who have so long virtually monopolised these high appointments.
“Mr Dutt demands,” writes your correspondent, “a fuller representation of the people in the making of laws. Mr Dutt must know well that India is not as yet ripe for this.” I have nowhere contended that India is yet ripe for a Parliament, but I do contend that under existing circumstances representative Indians should have a larger share than they now have in the making of laws and the control of finances. Lord Curzon and every provincial governor have spoken in the highest terms of the ability, the patriotism, and the moderation and sense of responsibility with which Indian members of Councils have dealt with the most intricate Indian questions. And yet what share of power is given to these Indian members? Absolutely none. Every important bill is first drafted by officials, sanctioned by the Secretary of State for India, and then placed before the Council. Whatever the Indian members may say or do, the Government passes the bill if it desires to do so. The Sedition Bill was passed against our unanimous opposition; the Calcutta Municipal Bill was passed against our unanimous opposition; the Madras Irrigation Bill has lately been passed against our unanimous protest. And at the present moment, when eighty millions of the people of India are affected by a famine unprecedented in its extent and its intensity, Indian members in the Viceroy's Council have asked—and so far asked in vain—for the moderating of rents and for fixity of tenure as was recommended by Lord Ripon in 1882. The iron is entering deep into our hearts; we are feeling every day that we are not allowed the smallest influence or real share in the administration of our own country.
Your correspondent has a few kind words to say about me personally, and I am grateful to him for them. I am sure he does not wish to mislead your readers, as I am unconscious of any desire whatever on my own part to mislead. I am sure your correspondent will on reflection come to the conclusion that the time has now arrived for some real share of the work of administration being conceded to the people. India cannot continue to be ruled as in the days of Wellesley and Dalhousie; the Indian Empire cannot prosper unless some trust, some confidence, some real share of work is reposed in the people. We do not ask for ready-made European institutions for India, but we ask for some gradual, slow, cautious progress, some real endeavour to enlist our co-operation and to accept our advice and help. The most moderate, the most thoughtful, the most loyal of Indian leaders, feel grieved that under the present Government there has been no single move in that direction; every important move has been reactionary and truly retrograde.—I am, &c.,
Romesh Dutt.
2nd May 1900.