1. The Commercial Position of India at the Opening of the Seventeenth Century
In order to understand the commercial operations of the Dutch and English, whose gradual extension over India has been recounted in the last chapter, it is necessary to possess a general idea of the main lines of the trade into which they sought an entry. At the opening of our period, Indian goods were not in great demand in Western Europe. The principal item of the direct trade was Malabar pepper, the produce of a very small part of the country; Europe wanted pepper, but not necessarily the pepper of Malabar, and the extensive export from this region depended rather on the nature of the Portuguese organisation than on the slight differential advantage enjoyed by Indian producers.1 Indigo was used in the Mediterranean area, but only to a small extent in Western Europe; the trade in cotton goods was, at the most, retail, and the same description may be applied to such other merchandise as was carried westwards. The Indian demand for European goods was of still less importance, and, speaking generally, Western Europe and India were not employed to any great extent in satisfying each other's needs. The position in Asia was very different, for there Indian cotton goods were indispensable; the clothing demand of Southern Asia kept the weavers of Gujarat and the East Coast busily employed; and Indian connections were necessary for profitable commerce in Eastern waters.
The most conspicuous feature of Indian foreign commerce was the absorption of the precious metals. This was no transient phenomenon: it had disturbed the minds of the financiers of the Roman Empire, much as it arouses anxiety in some quarters at the present day; and Sir Thomas Roe's epigram that Europe "bleedeth to enrich Asia" undoubtedly represented the contemporary Western view. The absorption of gold and silver was favoured by the laws in force in India, but in any case it must have resulted from the economic conditions which prevailed. Indian producers were eager to sell their wares, and, except in a few special cases, there were no official restrictions on exporters. On the other hand, the masses of Indian consumers were too poor to buy imported goods, the market for which was limited to the wealthy, but numerically unimportant, upper classes; the demand for foreign commodities, though it was not altogether negligible, was very far from being equivalent to the goods exported, and so it came to pass that, in the words of William Hawkins, "India is rich in silver, for all nations bring coin, and carry away commodities for the same; and this coin is buried in India, and goeth not out."
An enumeration of the principal imports is sufficient to indicate the narrow limits of the Indian markets. Spices and dye-woods, horses and elephants, raw silk, ivory, coral, and a few other materials, copper, lead, tin, zinc, and quicksilver in quantities which nowadays seem absurdly small, together with luxury goods and miscellaneous articles valued mainly for their novelty,—these were the commodities chiefly in demand, and merchants who were not in a position to provide them had to offer silver or gold if they desired to purchase Indian produce. It is important for our present purpose to note that Europe supplied few of these goods. Some quicksilver reached India from Lisbon and by way of the Red Sea, though China also sent supplies; lead was brought from Europe, and also coral, superior woollen cloth, silks, velvets, and other fabrics, wines and spirits, glass and mirrors, delicacies for the Portuguese residents, and a variety of miscellaneous goods; but the bulk of the imports came from Asia, so that European merchants who desired to trade with India were faced by the initial difficulty of providing remunerative outward cargoes.
As regards exports, if we look at India as a whole, the quantity of cotton goods stands out as by far the most conspicuous feature of the trade, though particular seaports depended in part on certain other articles. The Malabar ports, for instance, exported large quantities of pepper, and very little else: Cambay 1 and the adjacent seaports shipped indigo and much other merchandise; rice and sugar were sent out from Bengal; Pegu took quantities of dyed yarn from Coromandel; and among other articles exported may be mentioned the minor spices, such as ginger, cardamoms, and turmeric, various drugs, lac, pearls, and diamonds. In the case, however, of all the exporting regions except Malabar and Bengal, cotton goods were the foundation of the trade, and a few details are necessary to enable us to appreciate the conditions in which this business was carried on. Most of the consuming markets may be described as conservative, demanding goods of recognised kinds, and refusing to purchase unfamiliar products; and the producing regions in India had specialised to meet the needs of those markets with which they were in communication. The goods exported were thus highly diversified, and, since the descriptions in current use were drawn from several languages, the nomenclature employed in the trade is extraordinarily confusing to modern readers. It is possible, however, to reduce the multiplicity of names to a very simple classification, and I shall speak of the exports as calicoes, muslins, and dress or fancy goods.
Calicoes were produced in almost all parts of the country, and were designed primarily for Indian wear, but they were also exported in considerable quantities. They consisted of plain cotton cloth, and could be obtained unbleached, bleached, or dyed in various colours. As a rule they were made in pieces of from 12 to 15 yards long by less than ¾-yard broad, and these were known in the Gujarat market as dutties or baftas,1 but wider pieces, spoken of by the merchants as broad baftas, could be obtained from some centres of the industry. Sales were ordinarily made by the piece, or by the "corge" of twenty pieces, but in a few localities calico was woven in much longer pieces, and sold by length; the longcloth of the Coromandel coast was the best known, but long pieces were also produced in Northern India, where they were known to the merchants as guzzees (doubtless from gaz, an Indian yard). The export of calico to various parts of Asia was of old standing, but during the sixteenth century the Portuguese had developed an extension of the trade to West Africa, and also to their possessions in Brazil. The demand of these two markets was nearly identical, because the settlements on the coast of Brazil were populated largely by African slaves; the calico exported to them was usually described as Guinea cloth, but they consumed also some fancy goods, which appear in the commercial correspondence under such names as Guinea stuffs, slave-clouts, or negro cloth.
The distinction between calico and muslin is one of degree, and in a few cases it is doubtful whether a particular textile should be classed as a fine calico or a coarse muslin. Speaking generally, muslins were thinner in texture and lighter in weight than calicoes; they were suitable for wear in hot countries, and they appear to have been exported chiefly to Persia, Arabia, and Egypt. The Portuguese developed a trade in these goods to North-West Africa, where they were in demand as girdles and turbans, but it is not clear to me how far this development represented new business for India, and how far it was merely a diversion of trade from the older route by way of Egypt. The manufacture of muslin was to some extent localised, notably in Bengal and in the Deccan, though thin cloths could also be obtained in some other regions.
Dress and fancy goods, including pintados,1 chintzes, handkerchiefs, short dyed pieces of calico, goods woven with patterns, and cloths with an intermixture of silk, were in great demand in the Eastern markets, each of which had its peculiar tastes or fashions. As William Finch wrote in the first commercial report sent to England from Surat,2 "To write of clothing for Priaman [Sumatra] and Bantam with the Maluccos, etc., were infinite, they being of so many sorts and of such different prices": Dr. Terpstra enumerates 42 descriptions of goods handled by the Dutch in their earliest years on the Coromandel coast; about 30 distinct entries appear in the invoice of an English ship which sailed from Surat for Java in the year 1619; and about 150 titles are indexed as cotton goods in the first ten volumes of English Factories. For our present purpose, however, it is unnecessary to attempt the identification of all these goods: it is sufficient to know that the varying tastes of different markets were met, some from Gujarat, others from Coromandel, and others from both sides of India; and that, while the demand for particular descriptions may have been small, the aggregate trade in dress and fancy goods was of very great importance to the country.
The partial specialisation of the export trade can best be shown in tabular form, and I have set out in the following statement the names of the chief ports in each of the recognised coastal regions, the staple goods which they exported, and the directions in which those goods were carried. The information given in this table is, of course, far from complete; it is probable that nearly every ship carried a variety of goods other than those which I have specified, and that many of the seaports despatched occasional ships in other directions, but the general course of ordinary trade was that which I have shown, up to the time when alterations were brought about by the activities of the Dutch and English merchants :
| Coastal Regions and Chief Seaports. | Principal Exports. | Destination. |
|---|---|---|
| Sind— Lahari Bandar. | Calico. | Persian Gulf; coastwise to Goa. |
| Gujarat— Cambay, Gogha, Diu, Surat. | Cotton goods, yarn, indigo. (Also pilgrim traffic.) | Red Sea; Persian Gulf; Achin; coastwise to Goa. |
| Konkan— Chaul, Dabhol, Rajapur. | Chiefly calico and fancy goods; some pepper. (Also pilgrim traffic.) | Red Sea; Persian Gulf; coastwise to Goa. |
| Goa— Goa (Bhatkal, decayed). | Transhipment; few local exports. | Persian Gulf; East Africa; Lisbon; Malacca and beyond; Ceylon. |
| Malabar— Calicut, Cochin; several minor ports. | Pepper. | Cochin to Lisbon, and to Ceylon and Malacca. Calicut and minor ports to Red Sea. |
| South Coast— Quilon, Tuticorin, Negapatam. | Calico, pepper. | Mainly coastwise; Negapatam to Malacca and beyond. |
| Coromandel Coast— South— S. Thomé, Pulicat. | Fancy goods, calico and muslin, yarn. | Malacca and beyond; Achin; Pegu and Tenasserim; coastwise to Goa and Malabar. |
| North— Masulipatam. | Calico and muslin, fancy goods, yarn. | Malacca and beyond; Achin; Pegu and Tenasserim; Persian Gulf; coastwise, north and south. |
| Gingelly Coast— Vizagapatam, Bimlipatam. | Provisions (rice and oil-seeds). | Chiefly coastwise. |
| Bengal— Hooghly, Pipli, Balasore, Chittagong. | Provisions (rice and sugar), muslin. | Pegu and Tenasserim; Malacca and beyond; Achin; extensive coastwise trade. |
In addition to the exports by sea, a small amount of traffic existed on the two land routes leading westwards by way of Kabul and Kandahar. The European merchants did not enter directly into this commerce, but it was probably affected to some extent by the competition of their shipping. Thus the indigo carried to the Levant by land from Agra, or by sea and land from Gujarat, came into competition in Mediterranean markets with the same commodity carried by way of Surat and London or Amsterdam, and it is probable that the volume of the land trade was reduced, though it was certainly not extinguished, during our period. The route to Kandahar was affected from time to time by political conditions. Early in the century the number of camels passing annually was said to be about 3000, representing a total export of 500 tons or a little more, but the number increased fourfold about the year 1615, when the hostilities between the Portuguese and the Moguls interrupted the traffic by sea from Gujarat to Persia. About thirty years later we find trade diverted from land to sea by the Mogul-Persian war over the possession of Kandahar, while some incidental remarks in letters from the factors in Persia suggest that the two routes were more or less in competition for the markets in the interior of that country, and that, apart from temporary fluctuations due to hostilities, the English and Dutch activities may have resulted in the transfer of some portion of the northern trade to the sea-route. The question is, however, obscure, and the volume of trade concerned is in any case too small to make it worth while to go into the matter in detail; the important developments of Indian commerce took place on the sea, and we may confine our attention to the business transacted on the coast.
2. The Provision of Purchasing Power
The sketch of Indian foreign commerce which has just been given makes it easy to understand that European merchants who wished to buy Indian produce were confronted at the outset with the problem of providing purchasing power in the markets of Gujarat and Coromandel. The Dutch quickly learned, as we have seen, that Indian cotton goods were needed for the spice trade which they had come to the East to develop, but they had still to discover how to pay for the Indian goods which they required. When the English came to Surat to buy indigo and calico for Europe, the same question arose. The establishment of the trade in Persian silk raised it again, for the silk had to be paid for either in Indian produce, or in goods, such as spices, which Indian produce was needed to procure. Commodities of minor importance, which Europe required from the Far East, had likewise to be bought mainly with Indian goods; and, speaking generally, Europe had to provide purchasing power in India for practically all the goods required, not merely from India itself, but from all quarters of the Asiatic seas. The obvious course was to carry out European goods for sale in India; but when it was found that the Indian demand for commodities was far too small to meet the cost of Europe's needs, three other expedients presented themselves—to carry out the precious metals, to raise funds by borrowing in the Indian market, or to employ capital in Asiatic trade and remit the profits to Europe in the form of spices or other Eastern produce. These different courses were tried with varying success, and the commerce which developed during our period was the result of their combination.
The lesson that the Indian demand for commodities was insufficient was quickly learned. Dutch and English merchants carried out consignments of almost every article produced in quantity in Western Europe, but disappointments were numerous, and after a short experience many items disappeared from the outward cargoes, while of those which were saleable the quantities were strictly limited. Iron, for instance, could not yield a profit except by accident, tin could not ordinarily compete with the produce of the Malay Peninsula, while to offer linen in the centres of cotton-production was evidently a hopeless business. When experience had once been gained, the cargoes sent out from Europe became for a long time almost stereotyped, with variations only in the quantities of particular items: apart from stores and treasure, the ships carried merely some pieces of woollen cloth, some lead, some quicksilver and vermilion, coral brought from the Mediterranean and ivory from the coast of Africa, some sword-blades or cutlery, and any fancy goods which were considered to be saleable, the total value being, as has been said, altogether insufficient to purchase the spices, calico, indigo, silk, and other merchandise which Europe required from Asia.
The initial experience which established the impossibility of selling European goods in sufficient quantities demonstrated also that an adequate supply of the precious metals would overcome all difficulties, since India was always ready to sell goods for cash. Export of gold and silver was, however, condemned by the theories which prevailed among the statesmen and financiers of Western Europe, theories which had a solid basis in the conditions of the time, and which were reinforced by a large mass of popular prejudice. Merchants who desired to export treasure could indeed argue with Thomas Mun that such exports would be advantageous if they resulted in a subsequent influx of greater amount; but the popular prejudice was not removed by such contentions, and its existence had to be taken seriously into account. The English Company could export gold or silver only up to the limit authorised by its charter or sanctioned by the Privy Council from time to time, and it was bound to conduct its business in such a way as to make good the export by sales of Eastern produce in other European countries, but the existence of these restrictions did not suffice to protect it from criticism. In 1618 the Moneyers of the Tower petitioned regarding the scarcity of silver, which they alleged to be due to the exports of the Company; in 1620 complaints on the subject were examined by the Privy Council; next year the Company was ordered to consider how silver might be brought more plentifully into the kingdom; in 1622 there was a war of pamphlets on the subject; and in 1624 the outward-bound ships were detained owing to a debate in the House of Commons, when the feelings of the members were sufficiently intense to produce what would now be called a "scene." In view of such experiences, no surprise will be felt that the Company should have taken all possible steps to minimise the need for exporting treasure, and in fact a considerable chapter of its early history relates to its efforts to sell English goods in other parts of Asia, since the Indian market would not take them. The instructions issued to the factors in Java in 1609-10 urged the need for pressing sales, especially of woollen goods and other English products, "whereby we may be able to drive a trade without the transportation of money, which is the chief scope of our desires"; while in 1628 the profit brought by ivory was described by the Surat factors as inadequate, "if your continued desire to lessen the transportation of coin did not occasion our advice for all commodities that will yield their prime cost." These attempts, however, met with little success, and all that could be done was to make the best possible use of so much gold and silver as could lawfully be sent out.
In this matter the Dutch Company appears to have been situated on the whole somewhat more favourably : at least, the English merchants urged in a representation to the Commons that "neither the Hollander, Venetian, nor Genoese are so curious to forbid exportation of money," and it is improbable that the memorialists would have ventured on this statement if it had not possessed a substantial basis of fact. The Dutch Company probably benefited in this matter from its wide basis; the merchants who composed it were the dominant power in the State, and could hope to carry their projects through, while at this period the Parliament in London was but little subject to the influence of the English adventurers. The difference was, however, one of degree, and the influence of monetary theory, or prejudice, on the transactions of the Dutch Company is apparent in the records of the period, as when a merchant at Surat urged that trade should be pushed at Agra on the specific ground that no money would be required, or insisted that the money to be obtained by trading to Mocha was essential to the prosperity of their business in India. The practical result was to limit the operations of both Companies, and, as in the case of Mocha, to set them seeking for means of expansion outside the limits so imposed.
One of these expedients, the borrowing of capital in India, was practised at times by the Dutch, and more frequently by the English; but the amount available was limited, and consequently the rate of interest was high.1 Between 1625 and 1650 the rate paid in Surat ranged about 12 per cent; in the next decade it fell, and we read of transactions as low as 6 per cent, but the fall was temporary, and in 1659 offers of 9 per cent brought out very little capital. On the East Coast the ruling rate was probably nearer 18 per cent, but from about 1630 to 1640, when the English merchants' credit was low, they were charged from 24 to 36 per cent: at Agra we read of rates between 9 and 24, in Sind 15, in Bengal 36, and on the Konkan coast 13½ per cent. Such rates were crippling to enterprise, and we need not wonder that both Companies, after experience had been gained, decided against trading with funds borrowed in India; the large resources of the Dutch enabled them for a long time to dispense with the practice altogether, but the recurring difficulties in raising capital in London made it necessary for the English Company to authorise borrowing in India under strict limitations, and for their factors to exceed these limitations occasionally, in order to keep their trade alive. The necessity was, however, always irksome, and this method of providing purchasing power was in fact too costly to be used except in emergency.
3. The Companies' Asiatic Trade
One course remained to supplement the inadequate cargoes of European goods and treasure, and that was to employ part of the available capital regularly in Asiatic trade, conducting operations so as to provide the purchasing power required in India, and remitting to Europe the profits earned but not the capital itself. The advantages to be gained in this way were stated forcibly by Sir Thomas Roe, who told the Directors in London that the cargoes they were then sending out would “never drive this trade: you must succour it by change”; and who shortly afterwards urged that trade to the Red Sea would suffice to finance the whole of the Company’s Indian business. This course was followed largely by the Dutch, and to the extent of their smaller opportunities and resources by the English; and it accounts for what is at first sight a puzzling phenomenon—that merchants who came to buy Eastern goods for Europe should devote so much of their energies to the conduct of purely Asiatic trade, carrying all sorts of merchandise from one Asiatic port to another, and dealing largely in markets which had little to offer for shipment to Europe.
It will be observed that this expedient contained the germ of what came to be known as the “colonial system,” but if effect had been given to the views of Coen, the great Dutch Governor General, that system would have been introduced in its fullest development almost from the outset. In the memorandum of instructions which he left for his successor in the year 1623, Coen urged not merely the prosecution of Asiatic trade, but the investment of all the available capital in the principal means of production (“many thousands” of slaves), and the development of the Company’s possessions, “so that the returns for our native country be made out of the gains of the inland trade and the ordinary revenues,” and the need for annual importations of capital might finally disappear.1 Some development of production on these lines was in fact carried out by the Dutch in the Moluccas, Java, and Formosa, but the Company in Holland vetoed Coen’s more ambitious projects, and during our period their agents in the East depended mainly on the profits of Asiatic trade. The English had at this time no territorial possessions in Asiatic waters, so that in their case the question of a definite colonial policy did not arise.
Seeing that the main object of entering the Asiatic trade was to increase the quantity of gold and silver available for disbursal in India, the lines chosen by both Dutch and English were naturally those by which these metals could be most readily obtained. Some of the islands, such as Sumatra and Borneo, yielded small quantities of gold, and in them we find the factors buying gold with Indian goods, the gold on arrival in India exceeding the original cost of the goods by the profits of two voyages. The supplies of treasure obtained in this way were not negligible, but they counted for little compared with what could be obtained from the Red Sea, and from China and Japan. We have seen already that the European merchants were drawn to the Red Sea trade by the fact that it was conducted largely for cash; spices and Indian goods sold at Mocha returned ducats and other coins for employment in India; and the persistence of the merchants in face of the serious obstacles they encountered is the best evidence of the importance attached by them to this branch of their undertaking. It was, however, from Japan and China that the largest supplies were drawn, and the practical monopoly of trade with these countries enjoyed by the Dutch was, next to their control over the Spice Islands, the most important commercial factor in their success.
Japan at this period produced large quantities of silver, which was willingly paid away for those commodities which the country required. The Portuguese had become familiar with the fact during the sixteenth century, and it was emphasised in the letter which William Adams addressed to his “unknown friends and countrymen” in the year 1611, in the course of which he wrote: “You shall understand that the Hollanders have, here, an Indies of money; for they need not to bring silver out of Holland into the East Indies. For in Japan there is much silver and gold to serve their turns in other places where need requireth in the East Indies.”1
Experience furnished abundant proof of the truth of this statement, so far at least as silver was concerned,1 and the Dutch learned that they could supply their requirements, provided that they could find suitable goods for sale in the Japanese markets. The taste of these markets was, however, distinctive. European goods sold only in small quantities, and Indian cotton goods were bought merely as curiosities, while the demand for spices was not extensive; the way to obtain silver from Japan was to bring raw silk, hides, and skins. The latter goods were to be had mainly in Siam, where Indian cotton goods were readily vendible, and a large business was developed on these lines—cotton goods from India to Siam ; skins and some hides, thence to Japan ; and silver from Japan to India. Later in our period, Indian skins also were handled, as will be shown in a subsequent section, but the main supply for Japan continued to be obtained in the Siamese markets.
The chief demand of Japan was, however, for raw silk. The supply of this commodity was at first in the hands of Chinese merchants, and the Dutch soon learned that the direct China trade was protected by the Emperor for political reasons: they could not therefore openly bring silk from China itself, but they could, and did, bring it from Indo-China, where they obtained it in exchange for Indian cotton goods, and for spices or other articles previously bought with the same commodities. Persian silk was also offered, but this trade did not develop, and the greatest success of Dutch enterprise in this direction was the opening of the Japanese market to the raw silk of Bengal. I have not been able to trace the details of this achievement, because the Batavia Journals are missing for the important years. A sample appears to have been sent as early as 1641, for in that year the factors reported that Bengal silk was found to be unsuitable for the Japanese market, being too coarse and uneven, and also too dear. No further mention of a trade is made in the Journals up to 1646, but when the series is resumed in 1653, the trade is found to be in full swing, a cargo sent to Japan in that year consisting mainly of Bengal silk, and subsequent entries tell the same story. There is no trace of any such trade in the sixteenth century, and the opening of this new market for Bengal must be attributed definitely to Dutch enterprise.
While Japan thus furnished silver, China and Indo-China contributed gold, which merchants were able and willing to give in exchange for pepper, sandalwood, dyewoods, and other Asiatic commodities, practically all of them bought with Indian cotton goods. The Dutch settlement at Taiwan in Formosa was the centre of this trade, and the factory in Japan was under the control of its Governor, who thus became responsible for the main supply of treasure, both gold and silver, to the Indian markets. In the latter half of our period, a large proportion of the requirements of the Dutch in India was supplied by direct shipments from Taiwan, gold being taken to the Coromandel coast, silver to Gujarat and Bengal, and their demand for remittances from Europe was correspondingly reduced.1 Their business had thus been transformed ; beginning by the direct purchase of spices for Europe, they were led gradually to engage in nearly every important line of commerce throughout Asiatic waters, and their operations were directed to pouring treasure into India, because Indian goods were obtainable in sufficient quantities only in exchange for gold and silver. The English merchants pursued the same course as far as possible, but their exclusion from the Farther East deprived them of the opportunities which the Dutch turned to such good advantage, and throughout our period their share in Asiatic trade was much less important ; their principal business was the development of the direct trade between India and Europe, while their rivals were at least equally successful in this trade, and at the same time were able to undertake a much larger proportion of the distribution of Indian goods, and thereby penetrate the commerce of the whole of Southern Asia.1
4. Changes in the Course of the Import Trade
Regarded from the Indian standpoint, the results of the activities which we are examining fall into two classes : on the one hand, the Dutch and English merchants established a new direct trade between India and Western Europe, while on the other they produced certain modifications in the course of the old-established commerce of India with other parts of Asia and the East Coast of Africa. In the remaining sections of this chapter, I shall examine firstly the changes in the import trade from all sources, secondly the changes in the export trade to other Asiatic countries, and thirdly the effect of these changes on the Indian shipping industry ; the establishment of the export trade to Western Europe is a development of sufficient importance to require a separate chapter.
So far as imports are concerned the changes to be recorded are very slight. There is no evidence that any important new want was brought into existence, or that any large increase occurred in the consumption of foreign goods, while it is doubtful whether, on balance, Indian consumers in the mass were better served than before.1 Increased exports were paid for almost entirely in gold or silver, and the only new feature—the import of copper from Japan into Northern India—appears to represent not an increase in consumption, but an attempt to make good the failure of some of the local sources of supply. The chief interest of this change arises in connection with the currency, and its discussion may be postponed for the present: apart from it, the commercial correspondence of the period shows only that India's old needs continued to be met, in some cases rather more cheaply, in others at a somewhat higher cost, sometimes from new sources, but usually from the old, and that the upper classes enjoyed additional facilities for gratifying the prevailing taste for more or less costly novelties. The English merchants described these novelties as “toys,” and the phrase is appropriate to this branch of their business.
This “toy” trade requires our attention, for, while it was neither extensive nor particularly remunerative, it was a commercial necessity of the period. Foreign merchants were helpless without the good will of the authorities; no request could be preferred without an appropriate present; and the fashion of the moment required that presents should consist largely of “toys.” The Companies in Europe had therefore to keep their merchants supplied with articles suitable for this purpose; the far-Eastern markets had also to be ransacked; and the topic recurs constantly in the commercial correspondence of the time. Some of the “toys” imported were intended to be sold for use as presents, while others were to be offered by the merchants themselves, but in either case the source of the demand was the taste of Indian rulers and their courtiers. A few examples will suffice to illustrate the nature of this demand. The first English report regarding the trade of Mogul India, which was drawn up at Surat in the year 1609, after enumerating the regular imports—woollen goods, quicksilver and vermilion, lead, tin, ivory, coral, and sword-blades— goes on as follows :
Of new drinking glasses, trenchers for sweetmeats, but especially looking-glasses of all sorts and different prices (but not small baubles) some reasonable quantity would be sold to good profit, and I verily suppose that some fair large looking-glass would be highly accepted of this King [Jahangir], for he affects not the value of anything but rarity in everything, insomuch that some pretty newfangled toys would give him high content, though their value were small, for he wants no worldly wealth or riches, possessing an inestimable treasury.
Students of Jahangir’s Memoirs will agree that this picture is substantially correct; the Emperor paid rather more attention to intrinsic value than the writer indicates, but it was novelty that he thought of most. The Dutch factor, van Ravesteyn, told the same story a few years later, reporting that all manner of curiosities should be sent, “particularly for the Great Mogul,” pictures of landscapes and great personages, “mirrors as tall as a man with frames wrought with festoons,” “fine greyhounds and some strong dogs which will tackle tigers,” and so on; while he described the Emperor as “an amateur of all rarities and antiquities.”
The merchants naturally did their best to gratify the taste of the Emperor, on whose favour they depended for the success of their enterprise, but they soon found that there were difficulties in the way. The Imperial Princes, and also the officials at Surat, were eager to obtain the credit of presenting any “toys” likely to prove specially acceptable to the Emperor; with this object they insisted on searching imported goods, and taking over what they wanted, at a price fixed by themselves; and not a little of the friction between the authorities and the merchants can be traced to this competition for the advantage of presenting an unusually attractive gift. Sir Thomas Roe tells at length how the presents sent to India in 1617 were seized by Prince Khurram (Shahjahan), and forwarded to the Emperor in his name. Two years later the English merchants succeeded in conveying a certain picture to Court without the knowledge of the Prince, in whose jurisdiction Surat then lay; when the matter became known, the Prince “enraged that he had received no notice in the roll from hence [Surat], chabacktt the haddee [horsewhipped the Imperial messenger] that went up with the goods,” and “by express farman commanded the like as well to the Governor, Jumull Khan, as Isake Beg and the Customer, or, disliking the whip, are enjoined each 1000 rupees penalty.”1 The writer of the letter added that these authorities put the blame on the English, and threatened rigorous search to prevent such smuggling in future; and he anticipated that the resulting damage to business would exceed the benefits to be obtained by the sale or gift of twenty such pictures. In this case, Prince Khurram doubtless wanted the picture to present to the Emperor, but after he ascended the throne his own tastes became manifest: in his reign presents had to be costly as well as novel, and the Batavia Journal of 1643 has a curious tale of the Dutch efforts to convey unobserved to the Court a large copper lantern, of the outrageous conduct in regard to it of Prince Dara Shukoh, and of Shahjahan’s delight when the lantern was at last exhibited. The immediate result was the grant of a distinctly favourable concession for trade, and a request from the Emperor for a few lacquered palankins from Japan.
In the Mogul Empire, then, a steady supply of “toys” was necessary throughout our period. The demands of the king of Golconda were not less insistent. The presents given by the English in order to obtain the concession known as the “Golden Farman,” which was granted in 1634, were valued at over 6000 pagodas or say 20,000 rupees, and some versions of the farman indicate that the expectation of receiving “rarities” was part of the consideration for its grant.2
The Dutch were equally alive to the necessity, and in 1643 we are told that their present was worth 10,000 pieces of eight (say Rs. 20,000), consisting of elephants, horses, copper candelabra weighing nearly five hundredweight, and sandalwood and spices in abundance. The King's tastes were, however, wider than this list suggests, and in 1639 the English factors wrote that they might have anything in reason which they wanted in return for a present, which would not cost much money, consisting of "Persian horses, English mastiffs, Irish greyhounds and water spaniels; fair large looking-glasses; a piece of fine scarlet; crimson and violet satins; our King's Majesty's picture, large, in Parliament robes; a good buff coat; an excellent perspective and multiplying glass; a large pair of globes; and a suit of fine light armour, if possible musket-proof." The writers recognised that this proposal might sound unreasonable, but they urged that, whether the capital employed were large or small, presents must be given, "else no living among these people." The taste of the Hindu authorities in the south did not differ materially from that of the Moslems. The nayak who admitted the English to Armagon desired indeed the gift of so useful an article as a cannon, but this was to be supplemented "with some toys of worth," as velvet, damask, and taffeta, a Japanese writing-desk, and any "English toys" that might be available; while the liberal terms offered to the English at Madras were explained by the grantor as due in part to his desire for good horses from Persia, and in part to his hope of facilities for purchasing "hawks, apes, parrots and such like baubles" from Bengal. Throughout India, then, and indeed throughout the Eastern seas, this taste for novelties was a matter to be taken seriously into account, and the necessity must be allowed for in any estimate of the activities of foreign merchants; an ample provision of carefully selected "toys" was in the seventeenth century what judicious publicity is now, not a direct source of profit, but an indispensable preliminary to securing profitable business.
5. Changes in the Asiatic Export Trade
In regard to the export trade from India to other parts of Asia and to East Africa two distinct questions arise, relating respectively to the extension of existing commerce and to the opening of new lines of business : we have to inquire whether the activities of European merchants resulted, firstly, in an increase in sales in markets which were already open, and secondly, in a development of sales in regions to which Indian goods had not previously been exported in noticeable quantities. The first question is not easy to answer. A recent writer 1 dealing only with English activities, and examining them over a longer time, has suggested that more cotton goods must have been carried to Asiatic markets, but I have not been able to find positive evidence of such an increase during our period, and general considerations appear to me to indicate the necessity for caution in regard to this question.
Looking first at the most important aggregate of markets, those which were served through Malacca and the Java ports, there is no doubt that the quantity of cotton goods handled by the Dutch increased progressively. The statistics available are unfortunately incomplete, because, while the Batavia Journals purport to give the contents of each cargo despatched from India, there are in fact numerous blanks in the record, due in some cases to the disappearance of the Journals themselves, and in others to the neglect of individual compilers. Taking years for which most of the figures have been preserved, and making rough allowances for those items which are missing, the number of bales of cotton goods carried to Batavia by the Dutch was probably somewhat as follows :
| Period. | Bales exported annually from | Total. | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coromandel. | Gujarat. | Bengal. | ||
| 1625 | 1700 | 800 | ... | 2500 |
| 1641–44 | 2500 | 1000 | Samples only | 3500 |
| 1657–61 | 4000 | 1200 | 500 | 5700 |
Too much stress must not be laid on these figures, which include various conjectural elements, but they suggest in a general way that, starting from the time when merchants of other European nations were excluded from the Far East, the Dutch had by the close of our period doubled their exports from Coromandel, and increased their exports from Gujarat by one-half, while they had also begun to export from Bengal. There are no signs of a similar development of English trade in these markets, and the conditions which prevailed render any large expansion of their business improbable : the question therefore is whether the increased Dutch exports represent new business or merely a change in carrying agency. On this question direct evidence is wanting, but the following considerations are relevant. In the first place, the Dutch figures include a large proportion of the goods which they sent to Europe, America, and Africa by way of Batavia, and consequently the increase in Asiatic trade is at any rate substantially less than the figures suggest. In the second place, the Indian carrying trade was certainly declining during these years, if we regard as Indian the vessels owned by Portuguese ;1 it is certain, then, that the whole increase shown by the figures does not represent new business for India, and it is quite possible that the whole of it represents only a change in carrying agency. In the third place, it seems to me to be open to question whether the markets under consideration could have absorbed a large proportionate increase of cotton goods. We hear of no new developments in this direction, for the Dutch supplied markets which had previously been provided from India, and which had been adequately served first by the Arab traders and then by the Portuguese. These markets were by nature conservative; the bulk of the consumers were very poor, and in order to establish a large increase in consumption it would be necessary to prove either an increase in population or a rise in the prevailing standard of life. Whether such developments occurred during our period is a question which I have not attempted to study in detail, but until it has been investigated, it appears to me that it would be unsafe to reckon on any large expansion in exports of cotton goods as the result of the far-Eastern activities of the Dutch : some expansion may have taken place, but the information which is available is consistent with stationary markets, in which nothing but the nationality of the carriers was changed. It would indeed be possible to argue that decrease is as probable as expansion. We have seen already that in some of the Eastern markets cotton goods served as the medium of exchange, and there is some evidence that in the sixteenth century they were employed also as a store of value, though they were obviously unsuitable for that purpose, and must have been liable to rapid deterioration.1 The records of Dutch commerce show that during our period the use of coin was making headway in these markets, and the demand for cotton goods would tend to decline as the practice of hoarding gold or silver developed.
Turning to the other Asiatic markets for cotton goods, the disappointments, already mentioned, of the Dutch and the English in Pegu furnish fairly strong evidence that trade was not expanding in that region, while Arakan was certainly unprogressive. Nor can I find any evidence to show that the Red Sea trade developed materially during our period. It is possible that shipments to the Persian Gulf may have shown some increase in connection with the financing of the silk trade, but most of the English exports, if not all, probably represent merely a change in carrying agency or a transfer of business from the land route ; and taking all the Asiatic markets together, the most that can be said in the present state of our knowledge is that, while there are no signs of a decline, there are no definite grounds for asserting that any proportionately large expansion occurred in the off-take of Indian cotton goods.
This provisional conclusion may be extended to the other goods which India ordinarily supplied to the rest of Asia, for in regard to none of them can I point to any evidence proving, or even suggesting, any considerable expansion. The position is different in regard to the opening of new lines of business, for here the activities of the Dutch produced definite results in the sale of Bengal silk, and probably of Coromandel skins, to Japan, as well as in the export of slaves, provisions, and other commodities required for their Asiatic settlements.
As has been explained in a previous section, the export of silk to Japan dates from somewhere about the year 1650, though the details of its establishment have not come to light. In May of 1653 there is a record of a consignment of 300 bales, while two months later a vessel left Batavia with a cargo consisting principally of Bengal silk. The Journals for the next three years are missing, but in 1657 we read of a consignment of 452 bales, and also of a small vessel laden entirely with silk; in 1659 a cargo was despatched of 662 bales, but part of it was the produce of Indo-China, while two other vessels carried mainly Bengal silk; and in 1661 a single consignment is recorded of 1010 bales. The bales of silk handled by the Dutch at this time averaged just under 150 lb., while the price approved by the English Company in 1659 was Rs. 90 to 100 per maund (probably of 74 lb.); on these figures, the value paid to the producers for 1000 bales would be about two lakhs of rupees yearly, a substantial figure when judged by contemporary standards of commerce. I have found no suggestion of any opposition to this export on the part of Indian dealers, and since opposition to export of raw materials was offered in the case of certain other goods,1 it is reasonable to infer that production was extended to meet the new demand.
Up to the year 1643, I have found no record to show that skins from the Coromandel coast were carried to Japan, though small supplies were going to Batavia for local consumption. In 1644 samples of these skins, which had been forwarded to Siam, were reported on favourably by a Japanese merchant engaged in the trade of that country, and from this year onwards we find the Dutch exporting regularly to Japan. The importance of the trade during our period was much less than that of silk; I have not found figures to indicate its extent, but probably it would be measured in thousands rather than lakhs of rupees.
Apart from silk and skins, the recorded developments in the Indian export trade to other Asiatic countries were connected chiefly with the activities of the Dutch in Java and the Spice Islands. The Dutch were engaged in establishing a new city at Batavia as their Asiatic capital, and at the same time they were reorganising the economic life of the Spice Islands; they drew largely on India for the material requirements of these enterprises, and we find the Coromandel ports in particular sending consignments of a large variety of goods, such as iron and steel, sacks and sacking, leather, salt, and even roofing-tiles, which were not readily obtainable in Java; but their main needs were two, population and foodstuffs, and it will be sufficient to examine the trade under these two headings.
At the outset, Batavia was a capital without a population. The Dutch themselves were few in numbers, and the hostility of their neighbours was sufficient to prevent any large influx of settlers from the vicinity; a letter written from Batavia in the year 1626 says that the natives had abandoned all parts previously inhabited, and that from paradise the country had become a wilderness. A supply of inhabitants had therefore to be organised, and, as might be expected from the conditions prevailing at the time, the skilled craftsmen, shopkeepers, market-gardeners and the like were obtained from China, while the East Coast of India furnished general labourers and domestic servants. The Chinese came of their own accord, and lived in Batavia as free men under a “captain” of their own nation; the Indians, on the other hand, were purchased on the coast from dealers of their own nation, and were imported as commodities in Dutch vessels.
The problem of the Spice Islands was also to a great extent one of population. Some of the islands had suffered terribly from a long period of disorder, and the drastic methods of pacification enforced by the ultimate conquerors, among them the wholesale deportation of the irreconcilable elements, contributed to reduce the population to an extent which hampered the supply of spices to the markets of the world. The necessary reorganisation was effected by settling a small number of Dutch families in the islands and providing them with sufficient slaves, mostly of Indian origin, to supply spices in the required quantities; and an idea of its thoroughness can be formed from the fact that in the year 1636, the population of the Banda Islands included only 560 natives out of a total of 3842; the balance was made up of 539 Dutch, 834 free foreigners, and 1912 imported slaves, the great majority of whom must have been Indians.
From about 1620, therefore, the Dutch requirements from India were, first, a large initial supply of slaves, and then a steady stream of reinforcements to make good the wastage, which may fairly be assumed to have been heavy; in fact the record of the census which has just been quoted states that, owing to the change of climate, imported slaves, "Bengalders, Arakanders, Malabars, etc.," were greatly affected by sickness on their arrival in the islands. The supply was obtained by ordinary commercial methods: there is nothing to suggest that the Dutch merchants practised either force or fraud, and we find them buying regularly from Indian dealers after obtaining the permission of the authorities.1 The records of the numbers shipped are very incomplete, but it appears from the Batavia Journals that about the year 1625 the annual number might exceed 1000, by how much I cannot say, while from 1640 to 1660 it may have been somewhere about 500. Even if we take the value of an efficient slave at the high figure of fifty rupees, the transactions do not look very important from the commercial point of view, and the real interest of the trade lies in the light which it throws on fluctuations in economic conditions in India. Thus slaves were plentiful in Pulicat at the time of the famine of 1618, but by 1622 rice was cheap and slaves were for the moment hard to procure. The supply then revived, but shortly after the great famine of 1630 business was brought to a standstill, and the bulk of the trade was transferred to Arakan. In 1634 the factors at Pulicat reported that slaves were unprocurable owing to the great mortality which had occurred, while ten years later we hear from the same place that buyers still met with very limited success, the reason assigned being in substance that the surplus population had been disposed of by death and voluntary enslavement during the famine, so that no volunteers now came forward, and the Indian dealers could obtain slaves only by occasional kidnapping. At Arakan trade was more or less continuous from about 1635 to almost the end of our period. Bengal was afflicted by no serious famine during these years, and slaves, brought in from that region by dealers as well as by pirates, appear usually to have been available in moderate numbers, though the trade, like everything in Arakan, was hampered by the capricious interference of the King and his ministers: sometimes we hear of the sudden institution of a state monopoly, sometimes of a claim to pre-empt any slave skilled in handicraft, sometimes of an unexplained prohibition; but factors employed in Arakan must have expected such interruptions, and subject to them the trade was carried on, though not, I think, to the full extent of the demand. Towards the close of our period, there are signs of a revival of the Coromandel trade, for, after a gap in the series of the Batavia Journals, we hear in 1661 that the glut of slaves in Negapatam was beginning to diminish, and that a recent scarcity in the Tanjore country had affected the supply in that neighbourhood; on the other hand, the Arakan market was at this time unsatisfactory, owing partly to heavy mortality, and partly to the Bengal frontier being closed through hostilities.
Apart from the temporary prohibition in Arakan, which, whatever the cause, was certainly not due to humanitarian ideas, I have found only one instance of the refusal of Indian authorities to sanction the purchase of slaves. This was in the year 1643, when a nayak, or chief, rejected a Dutch request for leave to buy up to 1000 slaves yearly on the ground that the sale of human beings was not only a scandal but a sin. That this humane attitude was not universal is indicated by the fact, recorded in the same entry in the Batavia Journal, that the servants of another nayak were just then trying to sell two Dutch cabin-boys who had run away and fallen into their master's hands; in 1661 a ship belonging to the king of Golconda carried 300 slaves to Achin; and a perusal of the successive reports on the subject will show that the trade was regarded, by Indians as well as by Dutch, precisely as any other branch of commerce. The share taken in it by the English factors was naturally small, because their masters had no Asiatic territory to develop; Bantam occasionally asked for a few domestics from India, but as time went on the English needs appear to have been met chiefly from Madagascar or other islands. The Portuguese were more active, and we read of occasional consignments by them from both coasts of India, but this was not a new feature of our period, for the general trade was familiar in the sixteenth century; such development as occurred was due to the special needs of the Dutch in Batavia and the Spice Islands.
The same cause accounts for the development in the export of food-grains: the new populations had to be fed, and, in the absence of adequate local supplies, India was the most obvious source on which to draw. It is not clear to me whether in the sixteenth century the Spice Islands taken as a whole were self-supporting in the matter of food, but, if they were, it consisted largely of sago, and the reorganisation effected by the Dutch necessitated the provision of increased quantities of rice, together with some wheat and pulse, to meet the requirements of the settlers and imported slaves. These supplies were shipped regularly from Batavia, but owing to the hostility of its neighbours the city could at first count on little in the way of local produce, and thus it became a centre of the grain-trade, importing from India and elsewhere to provide for its own consumption as well as for the needs of its dependencies. The extent of the imports cannot be precisely stated, because, though the subject was sufficiently important for detailed record in the Journals, the arrivals are stated in terms of varying and uncertain units, a junk-load of rice, so many thousand baskets of paddy, and so on; but in the year 1632, the total imports cannot have been less than 2000 last, equivalent to about 3125 tons weight,1 and representing a substantial fraction of the total tonnage leaving India. In this particular year, however, India's share in the trade was small, and speaking generally it may be said that the grain-trade, like the slave-trade, is an index to the economic condition of the country. In ordinary times the bulk of the supplies for Batavia came from the Coromandel coast and, by way of Arakan, from Bengal; but Siam, Indo-China, and even Japan also contributed, and since seasonal causes might affect one or other of these sources, the problem of supply was difficult, and in the early years there were occasional dangers of famine. The Coromandel coast furnished supplies regularly up to 1630, but the effect of the disastrous drought of that year was to cut off this source, and the trade was not re-opened until 1634. Meanwhile the supply from Arakan had been organised, and thenceforward Coromandel and Bengal shipped rice regularly, and occasionally sent smaller quantities of wheat and pulse. The trade must be regarded as beneficial to the eastern side of India, because it afforded an outlet for surplus produce, while the authorities were quick to prohibit export at times when no surplus was available. It may be added that from about 1660 Dutch exports to Ceylon come into some prominence, but this cannot be regarded as a new feature in Indian commerce, Ceylon having been traditionally dependent on the mainland for food.
Before leaving the Asiatic markets a few words may be said of the rise of the tobacco trade, the only development I have traced in which the impetus did not come from European merchants. The crop had been acclimatised in Gujarat towards the end of the sixteenth century, and in 1623 we find the commodity figuring among the exports from Surat; but it was undesirable as freight, owing probably to the bulk of the bundles of dried leaves, and it appears to have been handled mainly by local merchants or by way of private trade. The crop had also reached the Coromandel coast, and Methwold, writing of his experiences about the year 1620, recorded exports to Mocha and to Arakan, while some years later we hear of the dried leaf being carried to Bengal and Pegu.
6. The Indian Shipping Industry
We have seen that, owing to the need experienced for taking an active share in the Asiatic trade, Dutch and English vessels were employed on the principal export routes from India, and that, while some new business was created for Indian producers, much of the additional cargo-space was devoted to established traffic; the inference is obvious that the existing carrying agencies must have been injuriously affected by the operations of the new competitors. So far as the Portuguese ship-owners are concerned, this inference is incontestable. After the fall of Hooghly, their commerce in Bengal practically disappeared, while from their other settlements in India we hear only of progressive impoverishment and decay. At the beginning of the century the Portuguese share of the export trade was certainly large, and, while it is not possible to speak definitely as regards quantity, it is probably correct to say that most of the Dutch and English business in the Asiatic carrying trade was acquired at their expense. On the West Coast, Surat prospered while Goa declined; in Coromandel, Pulicat and Madras superseded S. Thomé and Negapatam; while in Hooghly, the business lost by the Portuguese eventually passed mainly to the Dutch.
The position of Indian ship-owners, other than Portuguese, is not so simple, for in their case the effect was not uniform, and it is desirable to examine the question separately for Gujarat, Coromandel, and Bengal. In regard to Gujarat, the most striking change is the decay of the coasting trade to Goa, which was carried on largely by Indian vessels sailing under Portuguese protection. At the beginning of the century either two or three of the large coasting fleets (known as kāfila) sailed during each season, each fleet consisting of from 200 to 300 vessels, convoyed by war-frigates ; the capacity of the cargo-boats averaged perhaps from 40 to 50 tuns, and their lading consisted partly of cotton goods, indigo, and other merchandise for export from Goa, partly of grain and other commodities for consumption on the West Coast. The decay of this trade was rapid. In 1621 van den Broecke wrote from Surat that the Portuguese coasting trade was already ruined, and that only two fleets, each of from 40 to 50 vessels, had sailed during that year, carrying nothing but provisions ; a year later he put the total number of vessels at from 60 to 80 for the season ; while Pelsart tells us that in 1626 only 40 vessels reached Cambay from Goa, and that their cargoes were of little value. After this, we hear little of these large regular coasting fleets ; the Portuguese were at times unable to provide war-vessels for escort, while the seasonal blockade of Goa, maintained for several years by the Dutch, rendered a change in organisation necessary, and we read only of a few boats at a time evading the blockade, and slipping into Goa with the provisions of which the city often stood in urgent need. Gujarat business must have suffered through the enforced reduction of consumption on the West Coast, due partly to this blockade and partly to the impoverishment of the Portuguese, but so far as exports to foreign countries were concerned, the change was if anything advantageous, because the Dutch and English ships carried direct to Europe, or to the Eastern markets, the goods which had formerly been sent for transhipment at Goa. While, therefore, the owners of coasting boats were undoubtedly affected by the change, it was of little significance for producers or merchants, since the loss of business with Goa was more than compensated by the new direct trade.
Apart from the coasting trade, the routes in which Gujarat was most interested were those to Achin, Persia, and the Red Sea. Achin was important mainly as a distributing centre for cotton goods, and as such it came into competition with the Dutch at Batavia and the English at Bantam, while it was visited occasionally by the ships of both nations; unless, therefore, a large increase in the total off-take can be established, it is reasonable to infer that Gujarat ship-owners suffered by competition on this route. Their business was not, however, wholly lost, for we hear of their ships in the port throughout our period, and as late as 1661 the cargoes brought by them were sufficient to glut the market. For considerable periods also the Dutch were at a disadvantage in this trade. Before the year 1632 they were charged higher duties than the Indian traders, but in that year satisfactory terms were arranged, and equality secured. Friendly relations appear to have continued for the next decade, but after the Dutch had secured possession of Malacca they endeavoured to divert trade from Achin to their new settlement. The result of these endeavours is somewhat obscure, but they affected the relations between the Dutch and Achin, for in the 'fifties a state of war was in existence, and the trade was then chiefly in the hands of Indians; but at the close of our period the Dutch were at last realising their project of monopolising the local pepper trade, which would naturally enable them to dominate the whole commerce of Achin. So far, then, as our period is concerned, the facts which are on record suggest the inference that Gujarat ship-owners, though affected by competition, retained a substantial share of the trade on the route to Achin.
Turning to the sea-route to Persia, it is fairly clear that at the outset of our period most of the Gujarat goods were carried in Portuguese vessels, for the bulk of the arrivals at Ormuz from Western India came either from Goa itself or from ports such as Lahari Bandar, Chaul, and Diu, where most of the shipping was owned by Portuguese. After the fall of Ormuz there are indications that Indian owners were attracted to its successor Gombroon, for ships from Surat are recorded there from time to time. They were, however, placed at a disadvantage by the fact that the Portuguese at Muscat still endeavoured to collect from Indian vessels the tolls which had previously been levied at Ormuz; but the guard-vessels employed for this purpose were not in a position to interfere with Dutch or English ships, which were consequently preferred by Indian merchants sending goods to the Gulf. The fall of Muscat removed this difficulty, and it is probable that by the end of our period Indian shipping to Gombroon and beyond was at least as numerous as in the time of Portuguese domination.
The Red Sea route was, however, the most important of all, so far as Surat was concerned, and it was here that competition was most seriously felt, or at least most bitterly complained of. Opposition was excited by the mere suggestion that an English ship might be sent to Mocha; and when in the year 1618 the suggestion became a reality, the hostility aroused in Surat resulted in a boycott of the English merchants, and a petition to Prince Khurram, then in charge of the administration of Gujarat, urging that the Red Sea trade should be reserved for Indians, while all other routes might be open to the English. The Prince took the local view, and told the English that unless they were contented to have unrestricted trade with all places but Mocha, they might leave the country, an answer which closed the matter for the moment. By this time, however, the Dutch had become alive to the attractions of the trade, and under orders from Batavia began to press it energetically; while for the English the question was merged in a larger dispute with the Surat authorities, which came to a head in 1622, and was only settled in 1624.1 The agreement which was then made contained no restriction on trade with the Red Sea, and I have not come across any later record of active opposition, but I do not think that we should be justified in inferring that the Surat ship-owners were satisfied; it is more probable that they realised the determination of the Dutch and English to pursue the trade, and decided to submit to the inevitable. However that may be, from about this time forward we meet European as well as Indian vessels on this route; I have found nothing to suggest that the volume of trade was expanding, and it is reasonable to infer that Indian ship-owners lost some portion of their former trade.
The facts appear then to establish some injury to Surat ship-owners on two out of the three principal export routes as well as in connection with the coasting trade to Goa, but it would be a mistake to regard this injury as progressive. The effects of competition were acutely felt between 1620 and 1630, and must have been intensified after the famine of the latter year, when the supply of goods for export was for a time almost cut off ; but a recovery ensued, and in 1644 the English merchants reported that ships owned by Moslems had become so numerous " that for procury of employment they submit to any, however contemptible, freightments," a remark which indicates that cargo-space was increasing, though not necessarily profits. In 1660 again we are told that Indian ships were multiplying so fast that " whereas in Surat ten years past there were but 15, or so, there is now 80, and the most part of great burthen " ; and, while some part of this increase may be accounted for by concentration at a single port, the evidence of recovery appears to be incontestable.
As regards the southern portion of the Coromandel coast, I have found nothing to show that Indian-owned shipping was important at the beginning of our period. The chief centres, Negapatam and S. Thomé, were definitely Portuguese, and in this region the principal change was the transfer of exports from these seaports to Pulicat and Madras. The coasting trade to Cochin and beyond was also in Portuguese hands until the reduction of their power caused by the activities of the Dutch, when it passed to Indian shippers, but the impoverishment of the consuming markets suggests that the resulting gain cannot have been very great. Farther north, the position is not altogether clear, but at Masulipatam at least the bulk of the shipping was at first in Indian hands, and while I have found no record of complaints such as were heard in Surat, I think it is probable that the local shippers suffered for a time. About the year 1640 the position was altered by the chief officials of Golconda, who insisted on preferential treatment for the ships which they owned. In due course preference was converted into monopoly, and about 1647 we hear that goods could be sent to Persia, Basra, Mocha, and (a little later) to Pegu only on these ships, most of which belonged to the famous Mir Jumla, at that time the Chief Minister of the kingdom. The monopoly appears to have been discontinued after the transfer of his allegiance to the Mogul Empire, for in 1661 we find that the Dutch and English were again competing for freight to Persia, but for the latter portion of our period Indian ships certainly secured the most profitable part of the export trade of this region.
In regard to Bengal, the evidence already summarised appears to justify the inference that up to about 1630 the bulk of the small export trade was in the hands of the Portuguese. It did not pass immediately to the Dutch and English, who at first handled few goods other than those intended for the new markets which they were developing, and for a time Indian ship-owners appear to have gained ground at Pipli and Balasore, from which ports as many as 26 foreign sailings were recorded in the season of 1643–44. After this year there was a sudden decline, due mainly to the attacks of the Danes in prosecution of their war with Bengal; while the establishment of the Dutch at Hooghly enabled them to handle exports for Asiatic markets in increasing quantities, and by the end of our period their share in the trade was certainly substantial.
Taking then the Indian-owned shipping as a whole, and excluding from that term the vessels owned by Portuguese inhabitants of India, we may say that during our period it lost ground definitely, but not progressively, in Gujarat, gained ground but failed to retain it in Bengal, and possibly lost on balance in the Coromandel ports. The Dutch handled all or nearly all of the new Asiatic trade which they had created, and the Dutch and English between them took over an undetermined but substantial portion of the trade which had existed before their arrival in India. It is safe to infer that those Indian merchants who were also ship-owners suffered by the change, but the inference cannot be extended to Indian merchants as a whole, or to any class of Indian producers with the exception of shipbuilders;1 on the contrary, we are justified in concluding that Indian merchants benefited by a service at once cheaper and better, and it is possible that some portion of the advantage may have accrued indirectly to producers. The attitude of merchants in inland cities may be gathered from the fact that, at the time when Surat was actively opposing the admission of English ships to the Red Sea, Ahmadabad was asking the English to carry goods on freight to Mocha, Persia, and elsewhere; and after more than twenty years' experience of the business, the English at Surat reported that Indian merchants chose Dutch or English in preference to Indian vessels. That freights were lowered as the result of competition is shown in the same report; Indian owners were then not only quoting low rates but offering to bear a share of the customs duties or other incidental payments, and throughout our period the efforts of the Dutch to outbid the English furnished a guarantee against excessive charges. Indian merchants were frequently in a position to pick and choose, since cargo-space was available in excess of needs; in 1647, for instance, the English at Surat complained that they could not find employment for their ships owing to Dutch competition, while Dutch vessels were sailing half-laden or in ballast. The greater security offered by European vessels followed necessarily from the conditions which existed. The essence of Indian navigation was adaptation to stable seasons and avoidance of bad weather; the ships were weakly built, and their crews must often have been found wanting in experience during emergencies. The Dutch and English ships were built to stand bad weather, their crews were trained in the storms of the North Sea and the English Channel, and men who had brought a ship safely round the Cape could be relied on to face the worst accidents of Indian waters.1 Further, European ships were ordinarily better armed, and could defy attacks of pirates, against which Indian ships were almost helpless; while, as has been said already, the Portuguese customs boats left the Dutch and English alone. The preference shown by Indian merchants was therefore justified; and while those of them who owned ships must have suffered from reduced freights, and presumably from shortage of cargo, the larger number, whose business required only the transit of goods, found it possible to transact their business more cheaply and with a greater degree of security.
AUTHORITIES FOR CHAPTER III
Section 1.—Most of this section is condensed from the account of Indian foreign commerce given in Chapter VI. of India at the Death of Akbar, where detailed references will be found. The European demand for Indian goods is discussed more fully below in Chapter IV. The classification of cotton goods is drawn from the Dutch and English commercial records, but it is not, so far as I know, to be found set out in any of them. For names of fancy goods, see Terpstra's Koromandel, Appendix I., and English Factories, i. 62, 63; a long list of goods is given in Hobson-Jobson (s.v. Piece-goods), but it is compiled from later sources, and omits a large number of the names frequently used during our period. For changes in the land trade, see Court Minutes, April 7, 1624, and December 29, 1643; and English Factories, viii. 207, 261 ff.
Section 2.—The account of the import trade is based on a large number of isolated statements in the English and Dutch commercial records. The position in regard to export of the precious metals is discussed fully in Cunningham (The Mercantile System): Mun's treatise is in Purchas, I. v. 732; the limitations in force in England can be traced in the Calendar S.P.; and the hostility to the E.I. Company in Court Minutes (June 12, 1618; January 12, 1620; March 8, 1624, etc.). The instructions issued in 1609–10 are in First Letter Book, 319, and the report of 1628 in English Factories, iii. 196. The greater freedom of the Dutch is asserted in Court Minutes, April 16, 1624; chapter ix. of van der Chijs indicates the position in Holland in the early years; the instances of the Dutch merchants' consciousness of the limitations are taken from Terpstra's Surat, Appendices XI. and XIII.
Section 3.—Roe's views on Asiatic trade will be found on pp. 346, 348 of his Journal. Coen's Instructions are abstracted in Calendar S.P., 1622– 1624, No. 243; their significance is brought out by Elias, ii. 38, 74, 91. Agricultural development in the Dutch possessions is frequently mentioned in the Dagh Register. For the Sumatra gold-trade, see Letters Received, i. 74, 79; iv. 24; and for Borneo, idem, iv. 219.
The Japanese demand for goods is indicated by the abstracts of cargoes given regularly in the Dagh Register; the unsuitability of cotton goods for this market is emphasised in Letters Received, iii. 238 ff.; the offer of Persian silk is in English Factories, vi. 116. For Indian skins in Japan, see Dagh Register (Siam), November 14, 1644, and subsequent abstracts of cargoes sent to that country; for silks, Letters Received, iii. 242, 245, and Dagh Register, passim. The earliest mention of the silk-trade from Bengal to Japan is in idem, April 21, 1641.
Section 4.—The examples of the toy-trade given are taken from Letters Received, i. 33; Terpstra's Surat, 49, and Appendix VI.; Roe, 383; English Factories, i. 111; iii. 134; vi. 183, 184; and vii. 81; Dagh Register (Gujarat), April 27, 1643; the list could easily be amplified.
Section 5.—The cargoes of silk for Japan are compiled from the Dagh Register, beginning with an entry of May 21, 1653; the value is taken from English Factories, x. 276. The early references to the export of skins are Dagh Register, November 29, 1640, April 23, 1642 (Coromandel), and November 14, 1644 (Siam).
The Dutch requirements in Batavia and the Spice Islands are regular topics in the Dagh Register; the desolation of the country round Batavia is taken from Calendar S.P., 1625–29, No. 255. For the pacification of the Islands, see idem, 1617–21, No. 1108, and 1622–24, Nos. 193, 243; Hague Transcripts, III. M4; as well as frequent references in the Dagh Register, where the census of Banda is given under the date October 6, 1636.
The facts regarding the slave-trade are taken from numerous entries in the Dagh Register, supplemented by Hague Transcripts, I. 162, and English Factories, ii. 85; v. 326; vi. 226; vii. 120; and viii. 54 n. The traffic in food-grains is also a regular topic in the Dagh Register; for an instance of prohibition, see the entry of January 6, 1645 (Arakan). The tobacco trade is referred to in English Factories, i. 211; iii. 286; iv. 105; etc.; Methwold, 1004; and Dagh Register, e.g. October 6, 1636, November 27, 1640, and April 26, 1643 (Coromandel).
Section 6.—The impoverishment of the Portuguese settlements is a common topic at this period; see, e.g., Pyrard (translation), ii. 203; della Valle, i. 157; English Factories, v. 221, vi. 230, etc.; and, some years later, Master, ii. 84, and Bowrey, 191. The kafila is described by various writers, such as Pyrard (translation), ii. 245, or Jourdain, 173; for its decay, see the letters quoted in Terpstra's Surat, Appendices XI. and XIII., and Pelsart, 7, 8. Conditions of shipping in Achin can best be studied in the Dagh Register, from October 29, 1625, onwards. For shipping at Ormuz, see Terpstra's Surat, Appendix XXI., Dagh Register, passim, e.g. September 17, 1645 (Surat), and English Factories, v. 118, 126; vi. 276. The story of the Red Sea route is scattered through the Dutch and English records; the early opposition is narrated in Letters Received, vi. 227, and English Factories, i. pp. xi ff., 174 ff.; ii. pp. xviii ff.; xxix ff.; and iii. pp. i ff., 27 ff.; while the Dutch entry into the trade is recounted in Terpstra's Surat, c. X. For the recovery of Surat shipping, see English Factories, vii. 142, 208 ; viii. 37 ; and x. 301.
The change in the Coromandel coasting trade is mentioned in Renneville, vii. 494 ; the early position at the northern ports is stated in Schorer, ff. 3-6 ; the later monopoly at Masulipatam, in English Factories, vii. 55 ; viii. 83 ; and ix. 12, 19 ; its disappearance is indicated in Dagh Register, May 11 and 16, 1661. For the volume of shipping at Pipli, see idem, April 3 and June 1, 1644 (Coromandel). For examples of the keen competition between Dutch and English shipping, see English Factories, viii. 173, 205. The Indian preference for European ships is indicated in idem, i. 301, vii. 142. Van Twist (c. xliv.) among other writers refers to the weakness of the Indian ships and the defects of their armament.
Notes
- 1. Records of sales in London show that Malabar pepper usually brought 1d. or 2d. a pound more than the produce of Sumatra; vide Court Minutes, December 18, 1646, September 20, 1648, and passim. The transit of pepper to Portugal was a royal monopoly, which towards the close of the sixteenth century was farmed. The farmers had their agents in Goa, and pepper from Java or Sumatra would have had to be carried to Goa and sold to these agents at their monopoly price; the extra expense involved was sufficient to render business unprofitable (Houtman, i. 105).
- 1. Strictly speaking, Cambay was not a seaport, because sea-going vessels could not approach it. Its exports were either carried to Goa by coasting boats, or else taken in harbour-craft to Gogha or Diu, and there loaded on the ships.
- 1. "Dutties" doubtless represents dhoti, the Hindi name for a loin-cloth; bafta is a Persian word meaning "woven," but in the markets of Gujarat it had acquired the specific signification of calico of rather better texture than dutties.
- 1. For pintados, see above, p. 32.
- 2. The report, which is given in Letters Received, i. 28, bears no signature, but Mr. W. Foster is undoubtedly correct in attributing it to Finch (Early Travels, 123 n.).
- 1. The figures quoted in the text are annual rates calculated from the monthly rates given in English Factories and the Dagh Register. That they were not above the ordinary market rate may be inferred from the statement of a Dutch factor that the high officials in Golconda lent money at four per cent per mensem, but charged five per cent to people known to be in difficulties (Account of Golconda in Begin ende Voortgangh, Renneville, vii. 510). The writer of the Batavia Journal for 1641, when recording that no debts carrying interest remained due on the Coromandel coast, added the pious aspiration, "God grant that the Company may in future trade on its own capital!" (Dagh Register, December 26, 1641, Coromandel).
- 1. The quotation is taken from the English abstract of the instructions given in Calendar S.P., 1622–24, No. 243; the Dutch word here rendered “ inland ” is frequently used in contemporary records to denote what I have called Asiatic trade as distinct from the Company’s original business of carrying goods to Europe. Coen’s presentation of the case for a colonial policy can be read in de Jonge, III. 269 ff.
- 1. Adams is a striking figure of the period. According to his own account, after he had served in the Mediterranean trade for several years, he became [p. 65] desirous to study the Dutch traffic to the East, and in 1598 entered Dutch service as steersman on a fleet which set out for the Indies by the South American route. The voyage was disastrous, and eventually Adams landed in Japan ; he was for a time in prison, but won the Emperor's favour, received an allowance, and settled down in the country. When Dutch merchants reached Japan about the year 1610, it was Adams who conducted their business at the Court, and later on he acted for the English merchants, eventually entering the service of the East India Company. The letter quoted in the text is printed in Purchas, I. iii. 125, and also in Letters Received, i. 42; for his assistance to the Dutch, see Renneville, vii. 149.
- 1. I have found no record of gold coming from Japan to India in large quantities during our period. Export seems to have begun in the year 1665, after the supply from the mainland had been disorganised through the loss of Taiwan ; an entry in the Dagh Register for 25th April of that year mentions that the export of gold had been sanctioned by the Emperor of Japan, and from this time on we read of more or less regular consignments to the Coromandel coast. Writing at the end of 1640, the English factors at Surat referred to the " Japan silver and China gold" of the Dutch (English Factories, vi. 279).
- 1. In 1640, for instance, the indent on Taiwan for Surat and Coromandel was 2,000,000 guilders, while in the following year Surat alone asked for 1,000,000 guilders (Dagh Register, December 6, 1640, July 31, 1641). About this time the indent on Holland for all the Dutch needs in the East was about the same sum as Surat alone asked from Taiwan (Realia, iii. “ Vaderlandse Geld Eysch ”).
- 1. In 1658 the English Company broke new ground in regard to the supply of the precious metals by buying up the Guinea Company, with a view to shipping African gold-dust, and also ivory, direct to India, but the story of this measure lies outside our period (English Factories, x. 141, 206, 398).
- 1. Illustrations of this statement will be found in the examination of the course of markets in Chapter V. The prices of such goods as quicksilver or cloves show violent fluctuations; consumers benefited at some periods, but at others they suffered, and it is scarcely possible to strike the balance of loss and gain.
- 1. “Haddee” is āhadi, the title borne by the Mogul corps of gentlemen-at-arms (Ain, translation, i. 249). “Chabacktt” is obviously derived from chabuk, a horsewhip, an implement in some favour with Mogul administrators, as may be seen from various records, e.g. Fryer's description of the Surat custom-house (i. 47).
- 2. The text of the Golden Farman is not extant, and the three translations show some discrepancies. The contemporary version speaks of “rarities” being brought for the King; the version of 1670 also mentions “rarities,” but that of 1676 has “goods” or “good things.” The earliest [p. 71] version suggests that the original text probably contained the word tuhfa, which at that period would bear the meaning of "rarities" or "toys." The three versions are printed in English Factories, v. 14 ff.
- 1. C. J. Hamilton, The Trade Relations between England and India, p. 110.
- 1. The carrying trade is discussed in the next section of this chapter.
- 1. Barbosa (ii. 199) recorded that in Amboina every man toiled to hold so great a pile of Cambay cloths that, when they were folded and laid on the ground one on the other, they formed a pile as high as himself.
- 1. The opposition to the export of yarn from Gujarat is referred to below (Ch. IV. sec. 6).
- 1. On this point reference may be made to an English letter from Pulicat in English Factories, ii. 102 ff. The writers were on bad terms with the Dutch, and they insist on the evils resulting from their trade in slaves, but they admit that steps were taken to minimise these evils. For the price of slaves, see idem, iii. 10, where an English factor was authorised to pay "20 rials and upward," or say Rs. 40 to 50, for ordinary labourers: the earlier reference shows that the Dutch demand had raised prices to about this level from the former standard of Rs. 15 to 20.
- 1. For the weight of a last of rice, see Appendix D.
- 1. The transactions in question are referred to below in Chapter VIII.
- 1. It may be inferred from the facts given in the text that Indians built fewer vessels on the West Coast, though not on the East, during our period than at the close of the sixteenth century. The decline appears, however, to have affected mainly the Portuguese industry. Nearly all their trading vessels for Asiatic waters were built in India: the Dutch and English occasionally bought Indian vessels (see, e.g., English Factories, v. 43 and viii. 91), but their larger ships came from Europe, and during our period they had scarcely begun to build in India as a regular practice. The developments in the delta of the Godavari recorded by Bowrey (p. 102) may have originated during our period, but I have found nothing to show that they had become important.
- 1. The best evidence of the superiority of European navigators is found in the frequency of their employment on Indian-owned vessels: Dutch steersmen in particular were in great demand, though Englishmen were also sought for (see, e.g., English Factories, ix. 14).