1. Trade with Western Europe at the Opening of the Seventeenth Century
We have now to examine the outstanding commercial development of our period—the establishment of new markets for Indian goods in England, France, and the Netherlands. In order to realise the position at the opening of the seventeenth century, it is convenient to think of Europe as consisting of three commercial regions, which for descriptive purposes may be called Russian, Mediterranean, and Atlantic. With the first of these regions we are scarcely concerned; a limited amount of Indian trade passed north-westwards by the Caspian and Black Sea routes, and we read occasionally of schemes for developing traffic on the Volga so as to bring Eastern goods to London from the Baltic seaports; but this traffic did not become practically important, while I have found no indications of any noteworthy variation in the volume of trade with Russia itself. The Mediterranean region had for long obtained Eastern goods by way of the Red Sea and the Persian Gulf; up to the close of the fifteenth century these routes served also the Atlantic region, but the high cost of transit imposed narrow limits on the trade, and the Eastern goods reaching the countries on the Atlantic sea-board were practically confined to spices, drugs, and curiosities. The opening of the route by sea to Lisbon necessarily resulted in a change of organisation. The Atlantic countries were served more cheaply and efficiently by the new route, which also competed in the Mediterranean markets, and while Eastern goods continued to be distributed from the Levant, the monopoly of the overland traders had passed away; during the sixteenth century distributors could look to Lisbon as well as to Aleppo or Alexandria, and the advantages of water-carriage were usually decisive in the case of those markets which were situated near the former centre.
The Portuguese did comparatively little to develop the commercial position they had thus secured. It is true that, as has been explained in the last chapter, they established trade to West Africa and Brazil in cotton goods brought from India, but there are no signs that they introduced any new Indian commodities into the wholesale markets of the Atlantic region of Europe; the vessels leaving Lisbon for the northern ports carried mainly spices and drugs, or the products of the Farther East, and during the sixteenth century we hear nothing of the extensive consumption of indigo, saltpetre, and calico which is the outstanding feature of our period. The Western markets benefited by larger and cheaper supplies of the goods already in demand, but, so far as the available records show, that was the total result of the intervention of the Portuguese. It is, however, impossible to speak with precision of the details of the Lisbon trade, because its secrets were jealously guarded, and I have not been able to find any official statistics of the quantity or value of the goods imported, or of their distribution among the various consuming markets; on the latter point we can only say in general terms that the bulk of the cotton goods went to Morocco, Brazil, or the Guinea coast of Africa, while most of the pepper and other spice was carried on Dutch vessels to Antwerp, Amsterdam, or other seaports in Northern Europe.
A rough idea of the volume of goods brought to Lisbon at the opening of the seventeenth century can be formed from two lists preserved in the Public Record Office in London, which purport to give the cargoes arriving in the years 1602 and 1603, or very shortly before the Dutch and English established factories in India.1 The source of the figures given is not stated, but it is reasonable to assume that they were obtained surreptitiously, and they may contain substantial errors of detail; at the same time their contents agree generally with contemporary descriptions of the trade, and the following summary of them gives a view which on the whole is probably not far from the truth :
| Article. | Unit. | 1602. (2 carracks.) | 1603. (4 carracks.) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Spices . . . | Quintal (=130 lb.) | 9851½ | 25,582½ |
| Indigo . . . | ” | 17½ | 809 |
| Other goods detailed by weight . . | ” | 889 | nil |
| Silks . . . | Chests | 303 | 931 |
| Calicoes . . . | Chests | 86 | . . |
| ” . . . | Large bales | 273 | 959 |
| ” . . . | Small bales | 146 | 5,314 |
| Together with musk, ambergris, precious stones, and China dishes, enumerated by varying units. | |||
These quantities represent in each case the total of the year’s trade, and they include much that came from countries farther East than India. Excluding the goods of obviously foreign origin, the Indian merchandise may be shown as follows :
| Article. | Unit. | 1602. | 1603. | Probable Source. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pepper . . . | Quintal | 7598 | 21,349 | Malabar coast. |
| Ginger * . . . | ” | ? | . . | |
| Cardamoms . . | ” | 82 | . . | South India. |
| Indigo . . . | ” | 17½ | 809 | Gujarat or Agra. |
| Carnelians (laqueca) | ” | 27 | . . | Gujarat. |
| Ebony . . . | ” | ? 55 | . . | Possibly South India : more probably East Africa. |
| Calicoes . . . | Chests and bales | All | All | All coasts of India. |
| Precious stones . | . . | ? | ? | Not identifiable : probably some diamonds and pearls from India. |
The chief difficulty in interpreting these figures is to form even a rough idea of the quantity of cotton goods which they represent. In the list for 1602 these goods are shown separately under the name calicoes, but there are no means of ascertaining the sizes of the bales or chests, and one can only conjecture that the bulk of the consignment consisted of coarse goods for Brazil or West Africa, while, despite the description, the chests probably contained articles of higher value, such as muslins or coloured goods, for Portuguese use or retail distribution.1 The list for 1603 is hopeless in this respect, for the large number of chests and the very large number of bales are all lumped together as “calico cloth, stuffs, silks, etc.,” and, assuming the figures to be correct, an indefinite proportion of the total may have consisted of silk goods from the Farther East, or of miscellaneous commodities packed in chests or bales. Taking these uncertainties into account, the most that can be said is that at this time Lisbon was receiving from India very large quantities of pepper, mainly for distribution to the northward, large quantities of cotton goods, the bulk being probably the coarse stuffs in demand in Africa and South America, and small quantities of indigo, carnelians, cardamoms, and perhaps ebony and ginger, along with some pearls and diamonds.
During our period the great bulk of the trade to Western Europe passed from the Portuguese to the Dutch and English, but, with the exception of one item, the transfer of agency did not affect the interests of India. The exception is the export of pepper from Malabar. In the sixteenth century practically all the pepper brought to Lisbon was the produce of this region, shipped at Cochin or neighbouring roadsteads under arrangements made by the Portuguese with the various local rulers. The pepper produced in Sumatra, Java, and other places farther East was not handled by the agents of the Portuguese royal monopoly, while, so long as the shipping was exclusively Portuguese, it could not be brought to Western Europe without their knowledge.1 The Dutch and the English, as we have already seen, brought pepper mainly from Java and Sumatra; their attempts to enter the Malabar market were not at first successful, but the Portuguese export thence was hindered by their activities, and thus the trade to Western Europe was for a time partially lost to India. The adjustment could be rapidly effected, since a crop of pepper is secured in three or four years after planting; the yield in Java and Sumatra increased in response to the larger demand, and probably there was a corresponding decrease in Indian production, though no records exist in which the fact would naturally be mentioned.
The temporary decline in exports from Malabar was not due to any unwillingness on the part of the Dutch or English to handle its produce. The unsuccessful efforts of the Dutch to establish trade at Calicut have already been mentioned; and it is noteworthy that, when they found Calicut unsuitable, they attempted to export Malabar pepper from the East Coast, but the cost was excessive, and the trade did not develop. In the same way the English, after their early disappointments at Calicut, endeavoured to establish Surat as a pepper-market where they could obtain supplies for Europe, but many difficulties were experienced, and the cost proved to be twice as high as at Bantam, which in the year 1630 was definitely selected as the chief source of supply for England. Five years later, however, a large consignment was bought at Goa as a result of the friendly relations established with the Portuguese, and admission to the Malabar trade was by degrees secured; from 1640 onwards we find both Dutch and English buying on the Malabar coast and also in the Konkan seaports. Just at the end of our period, an English factory was established in Calicut, and a few years afterwards the Dutch secured possession of Cochin, so that the prospects of the trade were again favourable, but there can be little doubt that Indian producers had suffered for a time through the development of alternative sources of supply. Against this temporary loss to the income of the country must be set the gain resulting from the trade in indigo, saltpetre, calico, and other goods, which is described in the remaining sections of this chapter.
2. Volume of the Export Trade to Western Europe
It is by no means easy to arrive at an accurate idea of the volume of the new export trade to Western Europe. There are, as we shall see, occasional uncertainties regarding the extent of the English share, but the chief difficulty arises from the system of shipping adopted by the Dutch, and from the form in which the facts of it were placed on record. Speaking broadly, the Dutch preferred to centralise their trade, and goods from both sides of India, as well as from the Islands, China, and Japan, were assembled at Batavia, to be despatched thence to Europe by the annual fleets. During our period the cargoes of these fleets were not usually entered in the Batavia Journals, and unless their details have been preserved in records still unpublished, it is now impossible to calculate the quantity, or the value, of the Indian goods which they contained. The Journals give, it is true, most of the cargoes despatched from India to Batavia, and from these entries it is possible to arrive at the approximate quantities of such commodities as indigo or saltpetre, which were exported only to Europe; but this method fails us in the case of cotton goods, since it is impossible to distinguish the bales intended for Europe from the much larger quantity exported for the Asiatic trade. To take one example, a cargo despatched from Masulipatam for Batavia in November 1642 consisted of 597 bales of cotton goods, 297 bales of indigo, 498 bales of crude and 538 sacks of refined saltpetre, together with some yarn, wheat, iron, and gunpowder. The last three items were clearly destined for Batavia or other places in Asia. The yarn is doubtful, but from the word used in the description I think this particular consignment was intended for use in the Batavia dockyard; the indigo and saltpetre were certainly destined for Europe, but the attribution of the large consignment of cotton goods is purely a matter of conjecture. We can thus arrive at an idea of the quantities in which some particular commodities were exported, but not of the volume of the total trade.
There is, moreover, another complication. The practice of concentrating trade at Batavia, though it was usual, was not invariable; from time to time Dutch ships left both sides of India for Europe direct, and their cargoes were not, as a matter of fact, placed on record in the Batavia Journals. We know of direct sailings from the Coromandel coast at intervals from 1615 onwards, and from Surat from about 1623.1 In 1620 the Company authorised direct sailings from the latter port; in 1626 the practice was prohibited so far as Coromandel ports were concerned; and two years later the prohibition was extended temporarily to Surat. Later on direct shipping from the latter port was resumed, but I have found no complete record of the extent; even, therefore, if we could calculate accurately the goods sent to Europe by way of Batavia, we should still be liable to underestimate the total by the amount of the unrecorded direct sailings. These considerations make it advisable to approach the subject by an examination of the English trade, where the complications are less serious; in this case direct shipping from the East Coast began late in our period,1 and up to 1648 we can take the despatches from Surat to represent approximately the total volume of the English trade, though particular consignments may for one reason or another have been sent from Coromandel by way of Bantam.
In regard to this trade, it is important to realise that a large proportion of the goods reaching London were re-exported to other European markets. Judged by modern standards, the population of England was at this time very small, and consumption was accordingly limited; but neighbouring countries, and especially France, with a relatively large population, looked to London for their supplies, and for calico in particular the French demand went far to determine, as we shall see, the nature of the goods for which London indented on India. When, therefore, we speak of the English trade, the expression must be understood as referring to a large proportion of the consumption throughout Western Europe.
The English export trade from Surat passed through several phases. Up to about 1620 the cargoes can be described as indigo and miscellaneous goods. In the next decade the trade in calico developed with remarkable rapidity. From 1630 to 1637 the great famine left its mark on the cargoes despatched; but from 1638 to about 1653 exports were substantial, though not progressive, the principal articles being calico, indigo, and yarn, while saltpetre, pepper, sugar, ginger, shellac, and a few other items also appear. After 1653 the English Company was for a short time almost out of business; the trade was thrown open to private vessels, and no estimate of the goods carried by them appears to be possible. Finally, the years from 1657 onwards were marked by a great increase in the Company's activities, following on its success in raising new capital in London. The last decade of our period is also characterised by a rapid change in the relative importance of the East and West Coasts. The establishment of trade in Bengal, the discovery that Madras calicoes were better suited to European markets than those of Gujarat, the decay of the indigo trade for which Surat was the principal seaport, and the defects in the Gujarat administration—all these causes combined to bring the East Coast into the prominence which it was to retain for many years.
The first phase of the English trade may be illustrated by the exports of the season 1618–19 as set out in the invoice of the Royal Anne, which left Surat in February with a cargo valued at 720,000 mahmudis (Rs. 2,88,000), composed of the following goods :1
| Ma. | Ma. | |
|---|---|---|
| Indigo : Sarkhej | 351,600 | |
| Biana | 278,700 | |
| 630,300 | ||
| Calico | 77,000 | |
| Fancy cotton goods and samples | 7,600 | |
| Gumlac | 3,000 | |
| Sealing wax | 200 | |
| Turmeric | 150 | |
| Precious stones and miscellaneous | 1,750 | |
| 720,000 |
together with some indigo-dust, not valued, and some foreign goods captured from the Portuguese.
It will be noticed that the value of indigo was seven-eighths of the whole, and the quantity of this commodity was over 200 tons in weight.2 The demand for indigo is in fact the outstanding feature of this phase of the trade, and that the Dutch merchants agreed with the English is shown by the fact that they had already begun buying largely on the East Coast, while the Surat cargo sent by them to Batavia in 1622 consisted mainly of indigo, and earned the censure of the Governor General, who was at the moment more anxious for cotton goods to support the spice trade farther east. No other English ship was despatched in the season of 1618–19, and in 1619–20 again only one ship sailed with a similar cargo valued at 560,000 ma., or say 2¼ lakhs of rupees. We may take, therefore, 2½ lakhs of rupees as indicating roughly the standard of the English trade in this phase.
The primacy of indigo did not last for long. The discovery was quickly made that calicoes could be sold in large quantities in Western Europe, and by the middle of the next decade they had taken their place alongside of indigo as one of the two main foundations of the trade. No invoices of this decade appear to have survived, but in 1625 the merchants at Surat were arranging to provide Indian goods to the value of about 1,500,000 mahmudis (6 lakhs of rupees), or double the value of the cargo of the Royal Anne. The most striking feature of the list is the entry of over 200,000 pieces of calico, about fifteen times the quantity provided six years before, but it is marked also by the appearance of saltpetre, and by the attempt to secure pepper, to which reference has already been made. This larger scale of trading was maintained and further extended in the season of 1627–28, when four vessels carried goods of the value of £160,000, and the quantity of calico provided was greater than in any previous year; while the cargoes of six ships despatched in 1628–29 were valued at £104,500. The figures of these two seasons include the value of silk shipped from Persia and some other re-exports, so that it would not be correct to regard them as the measure of Indian trade, but we are, I think, justified in saying that during this decade a standard of 6 lakhs of rupees was attained.
This phase of the export trade was terminated abruptly by the famine of 1630, and, during the years of disorganisation which succeeded it in Gujarat, cargo was procured only with great difficulty by the extension of buying operations to other parts of India. The normal economic life of Gujarat was restored by about 1637, and the general course of trade in the years which followed can be learned from the invoices of cargoes sent in three successive seasons, which happen to have been preserved among the records at the India Office.1 These documents, which are very lengthy, may be summarised as follows :
| 1638–39. (Royal Mary and Swan.) | 1639–40. (Discovery.) | 1640–41. (Crispian.) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total value of cargo | 1,405,200 | 816,200 | 1,189,100 |
| Of which Indian goods | 959,500 | 398,300 | 419,000 |
| „ re-exports | 445,700 | 417,900 | 770,100 |
| Detail of Indian goods— | |||
| Cotton goods | 412,400 | 198,300 | 205,200 |
| Cotton yarn | 53,800 | 20,200 | 2,100 |
| Indigo | 362,300 | 118,900 | 206,200 |
| Saltpetre | 17,000 | 5,500 | ... |
| Pepper | 101,200 | ... | ... |
| Sugar | 8,000 | 46,700 | ... |
| Ginger | 3,300 | 8,700 | ... |
| Miscellaneous | 1,500 | ... | 5,500 |
| Detail of re-exports— | |||
| Persian silk | 409,900 | 417,900 | 728,200 |
| Bantam sugar | 3,100 | ... | ... |
| „ pepper | ... | ... | 39,900 |
| Aloes, myrrh, etc. | 2,700 | ... | 2,000 |
| English goods returned unsold. | 30,000 | ... | ... |
The Royal Mary and the Swan carried all the exports of the season of 1638–39, and the Crispian was the only vessel despatched in 1640–41, but in the intervening season the London sailed in addition to the Discovery. The invoice of the London has not survived, and the figures showing the value of her cargo are not clear, but they have been read as about 368,000 ma.; the quantity of Persian silk included was disappointingly small, and we may conjecturally add 250,000 ma. to the figure for Indian goods carried on the Discovery, giving about 650,000 ma. for the total Indian exports of this season. In these seasons, then, the trade may be put at 3¾, 2½, and 1¾ lakhs of rupees: the details in the invoice show that the cargoes of 1638–39 were bought at unusually high figures, and we cannot put the standard of these years at more than 2½ to 3 lakhs, or say half of that which had been reached before the famine. Even this reduced volume of trade was, as we shall see in a later section, drawn from a largely extended area; the economic life of Gujarat had been restored, but with a diminished population and a lower level of technical efficiency; and, while the local weaving industry was reviving, the bulk of the calico purchased for Europe was now the produce of Sind and Northern India.
For the next sixteen years I cannot trace any marked development in the Company's exports from Surat. In the seasons 1642–43 and 1643–44, the total cargoes were valued at about 1,200,000 and 920,000 ma. respectively, while in 1647–48 the value was 1,100,000 ma., and in 1648–49 almost the same figure was reported. Less Persian silk was now being carried, so it is probable that these figures represent a larger total of Indian goods than were carried in 1638–40; but this level was not maintained, the values in the following seasons to 1652–53 being only 574,000, 530,000, 740,000, and 507,000 ma. respectively, and these did not apparently include any large proportion of re-exports. From 1653–54 to 1657–58, the value of the Company's trade was greatly reduced, and figures for private vessels are not available, but there are good reasons for thinking that the total exports may have increased, because the Indian markets were temporarily disorganised by the competition of buyers. These conditions disappeared in the year 1658, when the Company was at last provided with adequate capital and had secured a renewal of its monopoly: the goods exported by it during the last three seasons of our period were valued at about 1,150,000, 1,400,000, and 450,000 ma. respectively; and since re-exports were still comparatively unimportant, it may be said that the standard of 1638–40 was by this time substantially exceeded, though that of the years before the famine of 1630 had not been fully recovered.
In order to complete the survey of English trade on the West Coast, it is necessary to mention the exports despatched by Courteen's Association between 1635 and 1647, but no very substantial addition need be made on its account to the figures already given for these years; comparatively few of the voyages undertaken were successful, much of the produce carried to England was obtained from sources outside India, and the Indian exports consisted mainly of pepper and saltpetre, which do not add largely to values, though they would make a material difference in regard to tonnage.
English exports to Europe from the East Coast and the Bay of Bengal become important only from the year 1649; the values for 1649–50 and the three following seasons may be put at Rs. 50,000, Rs. 96,000, Rs. 85,000, and Rs. 1,30,000, or say a standard of about a lakh of rupees yearly, only a small proportion of which represents re-exports. No estimate can be given for the years from 1654 to 1657, when trade was practically open, but there is no doubt that exports increased materially, the main efforts of the individual traders being directed to this side of India. I have found no complete figures of the trade for the few remaining years of our period, but the business of the Company was largely increased. The indent for 1658 amounted to £35,000, or about 3 lakhs of rupees, and those for subsequent seasons indicate that this scale was maintained, though the totals of the investments are not stated. Bringing together, then, the various estimates which have been offered, we get the following figures for the total value of Indian goods exported to Europe in English vessels; the estimates are very far from being precise, and they are put forward only to indicate in the most general terms the extent of the trade which came into existence during our period.
[Table
| Period. | From West Coast. | From East Coast and Bengal. | Total. |
|---|---|---|---|
| About 1620 | 2½ | .. | 2½ |
| „ 1628 | 6 | .. | 6 |
| „ 1640 | 2½-3 | .. | 2½-3 |
| „ 1643–48 | 3½ | .. | 3½ |
| „ 1649–53 | 2 | 1 | 3 |
| „ 1658–60 | 5 | 3 | 8 |
The volume of the Dutch trade cannot be estimated on similar lines, and the most that can be said with certainty is that, at any rate from about 1625 onwards, it was larger than the English. Produce from the East Coast was going to Holland, either direct or by way of Batavia, from about 1615, or for more than thirty years before this branch of trade was actively developed by the English : in Surat the Dutch soon caught up and surpassed the English, who were first in the field; while their despatches from Vengurla at any rate exceeded the exports carried by Courteen's Association, and in Bengal their predominance is indisputable from the outset. Their commercial supremacy may come as a surprise to readers familiar only with ordinary text-books of Indian history, but it is a commonplace to those who have studied the records of the period; and while the Dutch reports and journals are marked by frequent sneers at the poverty and inefficiency of their English competitors, the English correspondence is characterised by grudging and envious admiration of the Dutch. It will suffice for the present purpose to give a few illustrations from the latter sources, which obviously carry the greater weight. As early as the year 1622, the principal English factor at Pulicat wrote that "the Dutch in their glory laugh in their sleeves at our present miseries, and much disparaged the sufficiency [efficiency] of Mr. Duke, which is table talk amongst them, and of our small means at present in Masulipatam, as also in this place; which is very true, and not in a tenth part comparable to theirs; which is much noted among these people." Ten years later, similar views were being expressed from a much wider area, and, to borrow Mr. Foster's summary of the records of 1630–33, "we find the English merchants complaining of the competition of the Dutch, whose skill and prudence, backed by immense resources, had given them an indisputable supremacy in the Eastern trade. . . . We find them competing vigorously with the English Company's servants in India and Persia, outbidding them for silk, indigo, and piece goods, and beating them too in the sale of European and other commodities." Similarly, Mr. Foster says of the years 1637–41: "we have abundant evidence of the predominant position occupied by the Dutch; and this not only in respect of naval and military power, but also in ordinary commerce. Despite the vast sums spent in waging war against the Portuguese and garrisoning their many fortresses, they could still find money enough to outdistance their English rivals, even in Persia and India." The same story is told throughout the remainder of our period. In 1644 we hear from Surat that "the Dutch in these parts only prosper and flourish: who by their industry, patience, and infatigable pains and unalterable resolutions purchase [obtain] what they please"; and in the same year Madras reported that "the Dutch are grown so potent that they have almost gotten the whole Coast trade into their own possession." Ten years later Bengal tells the same story—the English short of capital, and unable to transact "any business which may be thought in the least proportionable to the great and vast trade of the Hollanders here"; and this remark is substantially applicable to the closing years of our period alike in Gujarat, on the Coromandel coast, and in Bengal.
A full discussion of the causes of Dutch predominance would take us too far,1 but we can safely accept the English admissions as proof that their competitors excelled in commercial efficiency as well as in material resources. Their greater command of capital is beyond question: almost throughout our period the agents of the English Company were hampered seriously by lack of funds, while the Dutch were as a rule adequately provided, and were occasionally in a position to lend their balances on interest. Further, their monopoly of the spice trade and of the markets of China and Japan enabled them, as we have already seen, to employ their capital to the best advantage : they could meet the large Indian and Persian demand for cloves, mace, or nutmegs, and they could direct a stream of gold and silver from China and Japan to any part of India which offered a remunerative trade. In doing so, they derived great benefit from a sound system of commercial administration; the Governor General in his Council at Batavia exercised very wide powers throughout the East, and constituted the heart and the brain of the whole organisation, while for the greater part of our period the various English presidencies or agencies were more or less at loggerheads, differences of opinion might have to be referred home, and the decision might arrive long after the mischief was done. No student of the contemporary records can fail to be impressed by the ruthless efficiency of the Dutch commercial machine.
Some idea of the magnitude of the total Dutch investments in India can be formed from the figures recorded occasionally in the Batavia Journals of the value of cargoes (gold, silver, and goods) despatched to the country from Batavia and Taiwan. In the years about 1635, before Gujarat had recovered from the immediate effects of the famine, the annual investment exceeded one million guilders, equivalent to about 9¼ lakhs of rupees at the conventional rate of exchange. Between 1641 and 1645 the values were about doubled, ranging round 18 lakhs of rupees, while at the close of our period they had risen to about 30 lakhs. These figures represent the values of cargoes entered in the Batavia accounts, and are not directly comparable with figures for the English investment, which are given in terms of prices on the Indian coast; but they are worth citing as showing that Dutch business was not only large but progressive. It may be added that the detailed figures bring out the growing importance of Bengal and the East Coast: in the earlier years the investment was about equally distributed between Surat and Coromandel, but at the end of our period Surat received barely a quarter of the total.
These figures represent the total investment in Asiatic and European trade taken together. The indications which are available of the extent of the Dutch export trade to Europe are too vague to justify anything like a definite estimate of the proportions in which the total should be distributed; but taking into account the facts regarding particular commodities which are examined in subsequent sections, it is safe to say that at the close of our period the Dutch handled a larger volume of European trade than the English. If, then, English purchases for Europe are correctly represented by the figure of 8 lakhs of rupees annually, including all expenditure on putting the goods on board, then the total exports of both nations to Europe were probably worth at least from 18 to 20 lakhs in the currency of the period, or from 80 to 90 lakhs in terms of modern purchasing power.1 No material addition to this figure need be made for the exports handled by the Danes or the Portuguese; the former did not attain large dimensions during our period, while the latter had become almost negligible by its close. Nor is any large allowance required for the value of what was known as private trade— that is, of goods belonging to individuals shipped on the Companies' vessels; it bulks largely in the English records, but probably an addition of from 5 to 10 per cent to these estimates would suffice to cover all classes of trade outside the figures on which they are based.
3. Indigo
From the development of the export traffic as a whole, we now pass to examine the trade in particular commodities, and among these indigo is fairly entitled to the first place. I have not been able to find an account of the introduction of this product into Western Europe. A blue dye was required by the woollen industry, which occupied so prominent a position in that region, and originally the need was met by the use of woad; but towards the close of the sixteenth century woad was giving place to indigo, and the struggle between the two dyes resolved itself largely into a question of the price at which the Indian product could be obtained. The Portuguese carried indigo to Lisbon in moderate quantities, and the prospects of the trade were such as to induce the king of Spain to monopolise it in the year 1587; the result of this step does not appear to be on record, but the figures already quoted show that the export was only 20 cwt. in 1602 and 940 cwt. in the following year. I have found nothing to indicate the ultimate destination of these Portuguese exports; I suspect that they were mainly used in the western Mediterranean area; but even if they were carried northward, there is no doubt that at this time the standard of price and quality in the London market was set by Aleppo rather than Lisbon. The tendency to refer to the Aleppo standard is obvious in the early English correspondence: in 1609 a factor was chosen by the Company for his expert knowledge of “indigo, silk, and other Turkey goods”; a few years later another factor reported that his purchases in India were “as good as ever I saw in Aleppo”; and when Thomas Mun set out to calculate the value of the Company’s trade with India, he took the Aleppo price as the basis of his estimates. The figure of 4s. 4d. a pound used by him would represent something like 8s. in London, and this price was in fact ruling for the produce of Northern India in the year 1609.1
Whatever the original source of supply, it is clear that indigo was the commodity chiefly sought by the first European buyers in India. The Dutch factors who reached Surat in 1601 wrote of it as the most important local product; their successor van Deynsen was arranging to buy indigo in the year 1607; the report sent home from Surat by William Finch in 1609 gives indigo the place of honour among possible exports; and the instructions sent out from England by successive fleets furnish ample proof that at this time the Company relied more on indigo than on anything else for the development of the Indian trade. In Sir Thomas Roe's phrase, it was the "prime commodity."
At this period the crop was widely grown in India, and we hear of production at various places in the Gangetic plain, in Sind, in Gujarat, in the Deccan, and along the East Coast; but as a rule the product was intended for local consumption, and exporters at first recognised only two commercial descriptions—Sarkhej and Lahori. The town of Sarkhej, which lies a few miles from Ahmadabad, the chief market of Gujarat, was then an important centre of production, much of its produce being exported to the Persian Gulf. Some of the indigo known as Lahori came from the Gangetic duāb, but most of it was the produce of a small tract of country near Biāna, or Bayāna, lying about fifty miles south-west of Agra, and now within the limits of the Bharatpur State; it had for long been exported by the overland route, and had acquired the name of Lahori in the Aleppo market from the fact that the caravans were made up in Lahore. The indigo produced in the neighbourhood of Biana was adapted to overland transit, being comparatively pure, and it is often spoken of as "round" from the fact that it was made up in balls. The Sarkhej product was prepared in the form of cakes, and is spoken of as "flat"; its distinguishing feature was an admixture of sand, so that about three pounds of Sarkhej were equivalent to two of Lahori. The Court Minutes, however, contain some indications that the use of "round" indigo in England was in some cases attended by technical difficulties, and this fact, along with the distance of Biana from the coast, sufficed to put the two kinds on a footing of substantial equality so far as sea-transport was concerned; Lahori commanded the higher price in Europe, but it cost more to put on the market, and the variation in Indian prices was the principal factor in determining the quantity of each brand to be exported in any particular year.
Foreign buyers then looked in the first instance either to Ahmadabad or to Biana. We find Finch buying in the latter market in 1610, and Withington at the former three years later, while the Dutch, who arrived in Surat in 1616, were in 1618 seeking indigo in Agra, and thenceforward the two markets were familiar to the factors of both nations. The cargo sent to London in 1619 consisted, as we have seen, chiefly of indigo, and about three-fifths of it (by weight) came from Sarkhej, against two-fifths from Biana. Exports from both places continued throughout the rest of our period, but the dye was bought also at various other centres, the Dutch being especially active in the search for possible sources of supply. The English bought some quantities in Sind after the year 1636, while in 1645 the Dutch were buying in the Deccan country above Vengurla, and they attempted without much success to procure supplies in Chittagong, but their chief enterprise was the development of export from the East Coast. As early as 1613, before the Dutch had secured access to Gujarat or Biana, stress was laid on the importance of Masulipatam as a source of supply; the cargoes from this port enumerated in Appendix B include from 650 to 1000 cwt. of indigo, and exports on about this scale were maintained for many years; but throughout our period Surat remained the principal port of despatch. English exports from the East Coast were not important in these years.
It has been said above that the consumption of indigo in Western Europe was mainly a question of price: the following figures will give an idea of the change resulting from direct importation:1
| Period. | Biana. | Sarkhej. | Sind. | Coromandel. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| s. d. | s. d. | s. d. | s. d. | |
| c. 1609 . . | 8 0 | 5 0 | Not on the market. | |
| 1620–30 . . | 5 6 to 6 0 | 4 0 to 4 6 | „ | „ |
| c. 1646 . . | 4 0 | 3 4 | 3 4 | 1 3 |
| c. 1655 . . | 6 0 | 4 0 | .. | 1 5½ |
The drop about 1646 is attributable to the disturbance of the market caused by the civil war in England; excluding this period, it will be seen that the effect of the direct trade was to reduce the price of Biana indigo by 25 per cent or more, with a somewhat smaller proportionate reduction in the case of Sarkhej, and the difference sufficed to produce a large increase in consumption. The direct imports to Lisbon in 1602 and 1603 were, as we have seen, 20 and 940 cwt. respectively. In 1619 the imports to London exceeded 4300 cwt., while over 1000 cwt. reached Amsterdam in that year from the East Coast. In the next decade the English ships carried less, the standard of the years 1625–28 being from 2000 to 3000 cwt., but by this time the Dutch were busy at Surat as well as Masulipatam, and, though figures for their trade are not available, it is probable that on the whole there was an increase rather than a reduction in the total quantity exported. Passing over the years when the trade of Gujarat was disorganised owing to the famine, we find that at the end of the next decade English exports show a further fall, the invoices already summarised showing 1480 cwt. for 1638–39, and barely 1000 cwt. for 1640–41; but here again the fall in English trade was more than counterbalanced by the expansion of the Dutch. The figures of their trade during those particular seasons are not available, but their indent for 1639 was 3400 cwt.; in the calendar year 1641 they exported to Batavia over 4200 cwt.; and in 1642 they handled the remarkable quantity of over 8000 cwt., a figure which appears to mark the culmination of the trade.
A few figures extracted from the English invoices of this period may be given to illustrate the effect of variations in prices on the sources from which indigo was obtained :1
| Source. | Exports in cwt. | Average Price in Rupees per cwt. paid on the spot. | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1638–9. | 1639–40. | 1640–41. | 1638–9. | 1639–40. | 1640–41. | |
| Biana | 385 | 70 | 927 | 106·3 | 93·3 | 76·4 |
| Sarkhej | 1060 | 661 | 75 | 90·6 | 58·1 | 56·6 |
It will be noticed that in the first year the price of Sarkhej indigo was abnormally high, very little below that of the superior quality : it would have been better to buy in Biana during this season, but the high level of prices in Gujarat seems to have taken the factors by surprise when it was too late to alter their arrangements. In the next year the price of Sarkhej fell heavily, and the bulk of the consignment was bought there ; while in 1640 the fall in price extended to Biana, and the factors were thus enabled to comply with the Company's wishes by despatching a largely increased supply of the superior quality.
The last decade of our period is marked by a great decline in the quantity of indigo exported. I have not found complete figures for the Dutch trade in any of these years, but individual consignments were smaller than previously, the commodity is mentioned in fewer cargo-lists, and I think there can be no doubt that their exports were substantially reduced. As regards the English trade, we find that the commodity commanded " despicable rates " about 1649 ; the Company was discouraging supplies in 1651, and asked for only 200 bales in 1653; under the influence of a largely expanded capital, the indent for 1658 was raised to 800 bales; but in 1660 the quantity required was small and the price strictly limited.1 The decline was not due to reduction in the European demand, but rather to the competition of supplies from America, which was destined eventually to bring the trade from India to an end. Indigo was reaching Spain from America at least as early as the year 1587, and a large consignment is recorded in 1628. Five years later we hear that a supply had reached London from Guatemala, while in 1645 we find the English Company issuing orders for a reduction of the export from Surat on the ground that the West Indies were producing large quantities of the dye, which, it is important to note, was better made than that which came from India. These competitors had an advantage in distance as well as in manufacture; the Indian trade, after fluctuating for a time, shrank to small dimensions, and came to an end in the year 1729, to be re-established subsequently in other parts of the country.2
Even in its best days the trade in indigo was not carried on without difficulties and drawbacks. In Europe there was the fall in prices to which reference has already been made, while in India accidents of season, interference by the authorities, and the tendency to adulteration all required to be taken into serious account. As to the accidents of season, it is sufficient to mention that in 1631 the Gujarat supply was entirely cut off as a result of the great famine, while the Biana crop was spoilt by excessive rain in 1621 and again in 1640, was destroyed by locusts for three seasons about 1625, and was much damaged by drought in 1646. Official interference was a common source of complaint. In 1618 a Dutch factor reported that the Governor of Ahmadabad had demanded a lakh of rupees from the industry before he would give permission to start the annual manufacture. In 1632 Shahjahan granted a monopoly of the trade throughout the Empire, which brought business to a standstill for the time. In 1644 oppressive government in Sind had left the people "neither will nor means" to grow the crop. In 1647 we read of a "new custom" at Ahmadabad, under which the "indigo men . . . bought their liberty to sell their commodity"; and various other instances could be cited to show that the production and sale of indigo was regarded as furnishing an opportunity for administrative exploitation. Lastly, the practice of adulteration was widely prevalent, particularly in Gujarat,1 where the amount of sand added in manufacture appears to have varied with the demand for the commodity. In 1640 the factors at Surat wrote that a consignment had been "basely sophisticated," and that it was difficult to check the practice while competition among buyers was keen; the Governor of Ahmadabad had, however, taken the matter up, and had imposed the penalty of death on any one detected in adulterating. A temporary improvement was recorded, but fresh official action was required in 1645, and led to a serious decline in production, while in 1650 extended buying by the Dutch resulted in an unusual amount of fraud. The force of the objection in European markets to this practice can be realised if we remember that expenses of transit were more than double the prime cost; but official control was spasmodic, and there seems to be little doubt that adulteration was one of the factors which contributed to the eventual loss of this valuable trade.
In order to form an idea of the benefit derived by India from the increase in the consumption of indigo in Western Europe, it is desirable to arrive at an estimate of the proportion borne by exports to the total production. A rough idea of the production in the chief exporting areas can be formed from estimates given from time to time by the factors engaged in the trade. The yield of the Sarkhej product was estimated at 8000 maunds (of 33 lb.) in 1628, which seems to have been a somewhat unfavourable year, while in 1634 the quantity expected was 9000 maunds. In 1638–39 a factor speaks of a general report of 40,000 maunds, but I take this to be loose and exaggerated ; 1 in 1641 the Dutch estimated the yield as 12,000 maunds (37 lb.) ; and in 1644 the English estimate was 6000 maunds, of which one-sixth was required for local consumption, and the Dutch and English requirements were under 3500 maunds, the supply being described on this occasion as far from plentiful, owing to a bad market in the previous year. On these figures it appears reasonable to put the standard of production at somewhere about 10,000 Gujarat maunds, or say 3000 cwt., though high prices ruling in a favourable season might be expected to secure a larger crop. In Northern India the normal yield was estimated in 1626 as about 16,000 maunds (of 55 lb.), but at the moment it was 10,000 maunds or less,2 owing to the effect of the calamities already mentioned. In 1633, when production had recovered, the yield was barely 15,000 maunds ; of this quantity one-third was true Biana, while the rest came from Hindaun and other localities, but much of it was up to the standard required for export. Ten years later, a Dutch report says that the yield, which was then poor, used to be 3000 bales (approximately 12,000 maunds, or 6000 cwt.), so the produce of this region may be put at from 6000 to 8000 cwt., and, taking Gujarat and the north together, somewhere about 10,000 cwt. were available when the export trade was at its height. Out of this the English and Dutch requirements cannot be placed above 5000 to 6000 cwt., or say something over one-half of the commercial crop, and the margin available for other buyers was substantial, though in the exceptional year 1642 the Dutch must have bought a much greater proportion. As regards the East Coast, an English estimate of the year 1640 puts the available supply at from 400 to 500 candies, or about 2000 cwt., while the Dutch exports were usually less than 1000, and those of the English were small. The yield of the principal area in Sind was 2000 maunds (probably 66 lb.) ; so that the total available for export from India was of the order of from 12,000 to 14,000 cwt., in addition to a large quantity suitable for local consumption. I have found no facts to indicate the yield per acre at this period ; but if we may assume that it did not differ greatly from the figures (15-20 lb.) of the present century, we arrive at an area of from 75,000 to 100,000 acres in the exporting tracts.1
The figures which have just been given are important as showing that there was a wide scope for competition in the trade, and that it would be a mistake to regard the Dutch and English buyers as monopolising the markets ; taken together, they were the most important purchasers, but as a rule they competed keenly with each other, and also with merchants from Persia and other countries, who bought for Asiatic consumption and for export to Eastern Europe overland. This latter trade was by no means extinguished, though its volume was probably reduced. The Dutch records mention that in 1641 indigo was still going by land from Agra, while the English Court Minutes of 1643 state that the quantity coming by way of Basra was reducing prices throughout Europe, so that we are justified in regarding the trade as competitive throughout; much of what was brought to London was re-exported to the continent of Europe; and while Aleppo might be unable to compete in London, its effect must have been felt increasingly as indigo was carried from London farther East. From the nature of the case, it is impossible to calculate the quantity bought by Asiatic merchants, but various references in the commercial correspondence show that their activities had a pronounced effect upon the market. Pelsart has left a vivid description of the Armenian buyers, "racing over the country from village to village, with greedy eyes like guests who think there is not enough food on the table to go round, reaching for every dish, and jostling the other guests"; and he complained that their eagerness to buy forced up prices out of all proportion to the extent of their individual purchases. In 1644 the Surat factors reported a fall in the demand for Persia, Mocha, and Basra, the effect of which was such a decline in prices "that the planters1 are almost beggared thereby, and therefore do annually more or less reduce the wonted quantities made by them." Again, in 1649, the factors explained that, though it would be more advantageous for them to buy at Biana in December or January, when the indigo would be thoroughly dried, they were forced to deal earlier in the season because the Asiatic merchants would not wait. While, therefore, the producers in Gujarat and in the Biana country looked primarily to foreign markets, they were not as a rule in the hands of a single group of customers: Dutch and English, Persians, Moguls and Armenians, were all in competition; and even when the European buyers combined for a season, they could not hope to dictate prices without reference to the Asiatic demand. The benefit available for producers was thus substantial while the trade retained its importance, but any attempt to measure it is rendered difficult by the fact that some of the indigo carried by sea to London or Amsterdam passed on to markets formerly served by the Aleppo route, and consequently does not represent a real addition to the former demand. The total of Dutch and English exports about the year 1640 would absorb the produce of from 30,000 to 40,000 acres, and after making a conjectural deduction for the proportion which would otherwise have come by way of Aleppo we may say that perhaps somewhere about 20,000 acres were cultivated to meet the new demand of Western Europe. On the basis furnished by Akbar's assessment rates, an acre of indigo in Northern India was worth about Rs. 20 in the currency of the time (equivalent to Rs. 140 in modern purchasing power), while an acre of ordinary food-grains was worth about Rs. 5 ; the Dutch and English purchases may, therefore, have increased the income of the manufacturers by some such figure as three lakhs of rupees, a trifle when spread over the whole country, but a very substantial sum for the limited areas in which it was expended. To this has to be added the expenditure on packing, handling, and carting, which, in the case of Biana indigo at least, was relatively considerable.
4. Saltpetre
The export of saltpetre may be definitely described as a new feature of Indian commerce. I have found no suggestion that the commodity entered into Asiatic trade during the sixteenth century : its bulk rendered its transit overland impracticable ; and if Portuguese vessels carried it to Europe, the quantity handled was, as we shall see, very small. The origin of the trade must be sought in the military history of Europe. Saltpetre was an essential constituent of the gunpowder of the period, and for a time the European demand was met by local supplies. The substance is a by-product of human and animal life under conditions which are now regarded as insanitary, but which prevailed widely during the seventeenth century, and indeed to a much later date ; and the necessary supplies were obtained by methods similar to those which are still practised in India, the product being washed out of the contaminated soil. By the beginning of our period, the progress of the art of war, and the prevalence of its practice in Europe, were outrunning these local supplies, and the discovery that practically unlimited quantities of saltpetre were available in India was a very great advantage to those belligerent nations which were in a position to obtain it by the ocean route.
The first reference I have found to the export of saltpetre occurs in a letter from the king of Spain, written in the year 1605, and directing the viceroy of Goa to send home ten or twelve casks of saltpetre yearly until further orders. The letter lays stress on the scarcity of saltpetre in Portugal, and says that for some years past it had been the custom to order its supply from India, so that export may have begun at the end of the sixteenth century; but the quantity spoken of is very small, and the requisition was official rather than commercial in its nature. About this time Spain was in serious difficulties over the supply of what are now known as munitions, and space on the homeward carracks was requisitioned without reference to the business aspect of the transaction; in 1613, and again a year later, Goa was ordered to make regular despatches of timber for shipbuilding, a commodity which no merchant would have handled on this route, and the demand for saltpetre must be regarded mainly as evidence of Spanish needs.
The commercial initiative was taken by the Dutch shortly after their settlement on the Coromandel coast. I have not traced the actual beginning of their trade, but a report written in the year 1617 indicates that the factors were already interested in saltpetre, and the invoice of the Naerden, which is given in Appendix B, shows that a substantial quantity was exported in 1621, after which year purchases become a normal topic of the commercial records. The English Company followed the lead given by the Dutch. The scarcity of saltpetre in England is reflected in various entries in the Court Minutes. As early as 1617, the Company had great difficulty in securing a supply of gunpowder owing to this cause: in 1624 the Commissioners of the Navy urged that saltpetre should be brought from India, as was already being done by the Dutch; and, later in the same year, the Company were told that they must make their own powder and fetch their own supplies of saltpetre. The Company apparently ordered a supply from Surat in the year 1620, for an abstract of a report sent home in 1621 states that none was to be had in that neighbourhood; but four years later Captain Weddell reported that the Dutch were shipping it as ballast, and that the English were arranging to procure supplies, which were ordered in the first instance from Ahmadabad. These supplies reached London at the end of 1626, and the English trade may be regarded as established in that year.
Saltpetre was obtained from various parts of India. The Coromandel coast was, as we have seen, the first region to be exploited; a little later Gujarat and Agra come into the list, and then some of the Konkan ports; but these sources became of less importance when at last the buyers obtained easy access to Bihar, first from the Orissa ports, and then more effectively from Hooghly. Up to about 1650 the volume of the trade was moderate, and I have not found any instance of the English exports rising to 50 tons' weight in a season; we hear of 45 tons in 1625, of about 33 tons in 1639, of 300 to 400 bales (less than 40 tons) in 1643 and 1648, and of 20 to 25 tons in 1644. The quantities carried by the Dutch were certainly much larger, but it is difficult to calculate them with precision, because some of the cargoes are given in terms of units of uncertain size; assigning probable values to these, the exports between 1630 and 1650 would appear to have ranged between 200 and 300 tons, and perhaps the latter figure may be taken as the standard of the combined trade. Up to this time, indeed, saltpetre did not rank with indigo or calico as a primary object of commerce, because, at the prices paid for it on the coast, the profit to be gained was comparatively small, and the shipping space available was devoted by preference to goods which yielded a larger return: saltpetre could be profitably exported only because it could be stowed loose among the baled goods as "kintledge," to use the expression current at the time.1
The establishment of Dutch and English factories at Patna was followed by a remarkable expansion of the trade, increased facilities for supply coinciding apparently with an enhanced demand in Europe. In 1653 the English Company ordered 200 tons : figures for the following years are doubtful, but the commodity was much sought after by private ships; and on the restoration of the Company's monopoly the annual quantity to be shipped from Bengal was fixed at 800 tons. I take "tons" in these two cases to indicate measurement and not weight, so the figures are not directly comparable with those given above, but the expansion of the trade is obvious ;1 and it was shared by the Dutch, who in the year 1661 shipped the very large quantity of 1480 tons' weight. Thus, at the close of our period, saltpetre ranked definitely as a primary object of commerce, while less than twenty years before it had been a makeweight; and while formerly it had been obtained in small quantities from various sources, its production for export was now localised in Bihar. The explanation of these facts is to be found in the low prices prevailing in this region. The figures on record are too scanty to furnish the basis of an exact comparison between the costs in different centres of production, but occasional quotations scattered through the English correspondence and the Batavia Journals suggest that the cost of a maund of 74 lb. at Patna was about the same as for a maund of 37 lb. at Ahmadabad, or just half the price, while the greater distance of the former place from the port of shipment was more than neutralised by the fact that continuous water-carriage was available. Taking the cost price at Patna, it appears that at the close of our period the trade brought roughly somewhere about a lakh of rupees yearly to Bihar, while about the same amount was spent in charges between Patna and the ships, a substantial gain to the locality, though only a trifling addition to the income of India taken as a whole.
The trade was subject to frequent interference on the part of the authorities, but no objection could fairly be taken to the ostensible ground, that the available supply was required for local military purposes, while in practice the prohibition of export could usually be evaded by not unreasonable bribes, or by false declarations to the tax-collectors. A different ground of interference came up unexpectedly in the year 1646, when Prince Aurangzeb, then Viceroy of Gujarat, forbad export on the ground that gunpowder made from Indian saltpetre might be used against some Moslem power, but the transfer of the prince to another government quickly removed this obstacle; and in any case Christians of the period could have little right to object to his action in view of the fact that not very long before the Portuguese supply of horses to Bijapur had been challenged by ecclesiastics at Rome on precisely similar grounds. Apart from official interference, the only difficulty attending the trade seems to have been the supply of suitable vessels for the refineries. The commodity was in any case bulky, and needed refining in order to remove the impurities, but the Indian methods of evaporation, in which earthen vessels were used, were found to be unsatisfactory, and appliances made of copper could not be obtained locally. In 1641 the Dutch on the Coromandel coast wrote that their cauldrons were worn out, and requested Batavia to send sheet-copper for repairs and to order a new supply of cauldrons from Holland; while eleven years later the English found that suitable copper and pans could not be got in Hooghly or Balasore, and decided to divert to this purpose appliances which had been sent out for making sugar in connection with an abortive scheme for a colony in Madagascar. The obstacle was thus easily overcome, and at the present day its interest lies in the light which it throws on the supply of copper in India.
5. Cotton Goods
The trade in cotton goods between India and Western Europe has passed through several distinct phases in the course of the last three centuries, and it is important that students of the subject should concentrate their attention on the facts of that particular period in which they are interested. The period with which we are dealing does not cover the remarkable change in European fashions which occurred in the second half of the century. Up to the year 1660 there was practically no demand for muslin or prints as apparel: such dress-goods as were carried westwards were destined almost entirely for Africa or America, where the trade had been established by the Portuguese; and we are concerned in this section mainly with the adoption of Indian calico to meet European household needs—tablecloths, bed-linen, napkins, or towels—and to a very small extent with the use of Indian coloured or fancy goods as hangings or for decorative purposes.
Before our period opened, the nature of Indian cotton goods appears to have been known in Western Europe mainly through small quantities arriving by the overland route, and the high cost of transit is a sufficient explanation of the very limited consumption. Europe produced linen for domestic use, and tapestry for decoration; calico and chintz could not compete with these goods on their merits, and could secure a market only by offering an advantage in point of price; and this offer was not possible until they were brought all the way to Europe by sea. The Portuguese did not take advantage of their opportunities in this respect, and consequently at the beginning of the seventeenth century Western Europe constituted a large but wholly undeveloped market for cotton goods. The possibilities of the situation were realised mainly through the activities of the English Company, for, as we shall see further on, the Dutch took little share in opening up the new market, though they entered it when it was an established success. The main reason for this attitude is probably to be found in the conditions ruling in the European linen-industry. England did not produce linen on a large scale, so that imports of calico would not compete seriously with home industry, while sales of calico abroad "brought money into the country," and were therefore regarded with favour by the prevailing mercantilist opinion. Holland, on the other hand, possessed an important linen industry, and it is improbable that the merchants who constituted the Dutch Company should have pressed for imports which would enter into competition with a staple product of their country, and one which some of them must have handled in the course of their ordinary business. Allowance must also be made for the fact that the monopoly of spices and the far-eastern trade kept Batavia amply furnished with remunerative cargo for Europe, while for the English merchants in India the problem of filling the homeward ships was often difficult; indigo by itself would not suffice to "drive the trade," and it was important to develop a market in Europe for the cotton goods procurable in such quantities in India. These considerations afford sufficient explanation of the fact that the story of the opening of the market must be traced mainly in the English records.
The English Company was alive to the possibility of trade in cotton goods from the time when it decided to establish mercantile relations with India. The nature of the anticipated demand can be studied in the instructions sent out by successive fleets from the year 1607 onwards, but for the present purpose it will be sufficient to refer to William Finch's commercial report sent home from Surat in 1609 as giving the views formed on the spot by a competent English buyer, who knew what he had to look for. Finch refers first to the different qualities of baftas,1 the fine makes of Broach, and the coarser goods of other centres; then to semianoes, "broader than the calico, and as I suppose more fitter for England than the baftas," a phrase which indicates that he used calico and bafta almost as identical terms; then come dutties, and then bairamis, the latter “ resembling Holland cloths,” these four types representing calico in the general sense of the word. Next he mentions a slighter stuff, or muslin, called serribaff, as probably suited to the North African trade, and a calico of extra width made somewhere near Cape Comorin, which would “ sell well in England for sheeting ”; and he adds that higher qualities than “ these country linens ” could be got if required. He then suggests some other goods for the African trade, and pintados (the Portuguese word commonly used to describe goods with patterns in colours), as being likely to sell profitably for quilts and for fine hangings; also quilts ready-made of white calico, and of calico dyed red or blue. This completes his enumeration of the cotton goods suitable for export to the West—muslins for Africa, calico of various sorts and some coloured goods for household use in England—and he passes on to the clothing trade with Java and Sumatra.
Trade sprang up very much on the lines indicated in this report, and we may take the first recorded English shipment from Surat as an example of the exports in the initial phase. The table on the following page shows the cotton goods taken by the Royal Anne to England in the year 1619; the prices are given in mahmudis, the current coin of Gujarat, which was taken at 2/5 of a rupee, and they include cost of transit to the ship’s side.
It will be observed at once that several of the items in this list are sample consignments, and that the main export was of calico of the ordinary type, baftas broad and narrow, dutties, and semianoes, or three out of the four descriptions recommended by Finch ten years previously. It will also be noticed that there might be substantial variations in the average prices of different consignments bearing the same description, and this point is of real importance to an understanding of the trade. There was, as yet, nothing like a fixed standard of quality: individual artisans wove very much as they chose, and buyers had to pick single pieces to suit their needs. Speaking generally, the best pieces were chosen for England, and the inferior goods sent to Java for the Eastern markets; and I take it that this is what is meant by contemporary
| Description. | No. of Pieces. | Value. | Average Price per Piece. |
|---|---|---|---|
| Calicoes— | Ma. | Ma. | |
| (a) Baftas— | |||
| 1. "Gingames" | 40 | 276 | 6·9 |
| 2. Broad | 8 | 120 | 15·0 |
| " | 5302 | 33,195 | 6·3 |
| " | 1000 | 6,777 | 6·8 |
| Extra-broad (?) | 1 | 24 | 24·0 |
| 3. Narrow | 980 | 3,680 | 3·8 |
| " | 20 | 55 | 2·7 |
| " | 1997 | 9,950 | 5·0 |
| 4. For table napkins | 80 | 218 | 2·7 |
| 5. "Watchetts" (i.e. blue) | 20 | 160 | 8·0 |
| Coloured | ? | 3,584 | ? |
| "Watchetts" | 200 | 635 | 3·3 |
| (b) Duties— | |||
| 1. Not described | 290 | 1,066 | 3·7 |
| " | 480 | 2,190 | 4·6 |
| 2. Dholka | 400 | 1,291 | 3·2 |
| (c) Semianoes— | 2330 | 14,075 | 6·0 |
| Fancy Goods and Doubtful Descriptions * | |||
| Sundry stuffs | 200 | (?) 187 | (?) 0·9 |
| " Reeses " | 275 | 1,150 | 4·2 |
| " Sahum " | 50 | 431 | 8·6 |
| " Necanies " | 420 | 1,320 | 3·1 |
| " Eramies " | ? | 177 | ? |
writers when they speak of buying " fine " goods for England. They do not mean the finer qualities of Indian cloth, the muslins and other thin goods suited for tropical wear, but worthless as household linen; they mean merely the best pieces of calico suited for the purposes for which they were buying.
The demand for calico increased with remarkable rapidity. The shipment of 1619 totalled about 14,000 pieces (each ordinary piece being from 12 to 15 yards in length): the goods ordered in 1625 exceeded 200,000 pieces; in 1628 the actual consignment consisted of nearly 1000 bales, which would represent 150,000 pieces or more; while in 1630, when the Gujarat famine was about to bring this phase of the trade to an abrupt conclusion, the Company ordered 100,000 to 120,000 pieces of calicoes, together with small quantities of fancy goods. The large imports attracted the attention of King James I., who in 1623 asked the Deputy Governor of the Company how they were disposed of, and was informed that “much of it is very useful and vends in England, whereby the prices of lawns, cambrics, and other linen cloth are brought down; for the rest, England is now made the staple for that commodity, which having first served His Majesty’s dominions, the overplus is transported into foreign parts in the nature of a home-bred commodity. The king approved exceedingly thereof, and said that this was the ready way to bring treasure into the kingdom.” Less than two years later, the Governor informed the Company that the sale of Surat goods had much improved, and that the foreign demand for calicoes was so great that from 100,000 to 200,000 pieces could be disposed of in a short time if they were available. The sudden large demand could not be met immediately by Gujarat alone, and buyers were sent to those places in Northern India where the staple goods appeared to be fitted for the London market. The places where we hear of factors being specially sent are Patna and Samana, but purchases were also made in Agra of calico woven in other localities, chiefly in Oudh. Patna was soon abandoned, while we hear of buyers at Samana on various occasions up to the year 1627, but the Company’s final verdict on its products was unfavourable, and the indent sent out early in 1630, which has already been quoted, specified only Gujarat calico, and explicitly forbad “ Agra goods,” including semianoes.
The famine, however, made it impossible to comply with these orders, and it became necessary to extend the sources of supply. In 1635 instructions were sent to Agra to buy “ derriabauds, kerriabauds, and echbaryes,” 1 and the two former, the produce of the Oudh towns of Dariyabad and Khairabad, quickly came into prominence, along with a cloth known as mercooli, which was manufactured largely in western Oudh. In the year 1640 a factory was opened in Lucknow, primarily for the supply of Dariyabad goods, those of Khairabad having been condemned, but this prohibition was not continued, and we find both makes on sale in London during the 'fifties. In 1641 the Company expressed a preference for these northern goods; mercoolis were preferred to the broad baftas of Baroda or Broach, Dariyabads were “well accepted of,” and Gujarat baftas were to be sent only if the northern supply fell short. The London market was thus definitely opened to the weavers of Northern India.
The entrance of the English Company into the trade of Sind has been described in a previous chapter. The first buyers sent there in 1635 were instructed to inquire chiefly for calico suitable for England, though chequered stuffs for Guinea and cloth for the Java markets were also to be sought; the local calicoes were well reported on by the buyers, and were found acceptable in England, where their sale continued at intervals up to the close of our period, but the quantity available was limited by the conditions prevailing in the locality.
The first attempt to supply London with calico from the East Coast appears to have been made in the year 1621, but sales were unsatisfactory, and the effort was not continued. The subject was revived by the Surat factors in 1630, and the idea was taken up by the Company when the failure of the Gujarat supply became known in England. There was, however, great delay in complying with the indents sent out from London, and in 1636 the factors were severely reprimanded for having provided only £1269 worth of calico against orders for £32,500 given in the previous five years. The result of this reproof is seen in a large consignment sent home by way of Surat in January 1639; nothing seems to have been sent in the following winter, but in 1640 a substantial supply reached Surat, too late for room to be found for it in the ships, and the invoice of that year's cargo shows only a single bale of longcloth sent as a sample, “ because it is the first fruits of your new fort at Madraspatam.”
The result of these extensions to new areas of supply can be seen in the invoices of the English cargoes despatched from Surat in 1639 and 1640, when the immediate effects of the famine had passed away. The number of pieces of cotton cloth exported stands as follows :—
| Source. | Season 1638–39. | Season 1639–40.1 | Season 1640–41. |
|---|---|---|---|
| East Coast | 18,225 | ... | 25 |
| Bengal | 6,700 | ... | ... |
| Gujarat | 38,883 | 13,660 | 18,918 |
| Agra | 2,823 | 12,122 | 23,550 |
| Sind | ... | 28,507 | 11,360 |
| 66,641 | 54,289 | 53,853 |
All the Agra and Sind goods shown in these figures were calico, as were most of the Gujarat pieces, but these latter included also consignments of “ Guinea stuffs,” that is to say, fancy goods in stripes or checks suitable for sale in West Africa. The supplies from the East Coast and Bengal forwarded in January 1639 were more diversified, though calico predominated, and a scrutiny of the detailed invoice suggests that the buyers in these regions were still uncertain what to offer the London market, so that this may be regarded as a trial consignment. Nothing further need be said regarding the goods from Bengal, which did not become really important as a source of supply for European markets during our period, but a brief description is required of the principal Coast calicoes, which came rapidly into favour. The names of these take varying forms, but they may be written as percalles, moorees, salempores, and longcloth. Percalles (8 yards by 1) were on the whole the highest grade, though the best moorees (9 by 1¼) were of about equal value. In the same way, fine salempores (16 by 1) ranked with ordinary moorees, but ordinary salempores were of the same quality as longcloth (30-40 yards long, and a yard or slightly more in width), stout calico well suited for household use. Longcloth was the chief calico made on the Coast. It is apparently identical with what was called Guinea cloth by the Portuguese and the Dutch, but it was sold in the East as well as in the West, either plain, dyed, or figured (pintado). By the close of our period it had become the most important calico in the London market.1
The figures given for 1638–39 and 1640–41 represent the whole English trade of those seasons, and there is an obvious decline from the standard of over 100,000 pieces yearly attained ten years earlier. The setback was due to the famine in Gujarat. Some time was taken in opening up the alternative sources of supply, and while Gujarat alone could not meet the demand in point of quantity, the quality of its produce showed a marked deterioration, which threatened to ruin the European market. Thus in 1638 the Company wrote that since Indian calicoes had so declined in quality and increased in price, demand for them was at a standstill, and they were being superseded by cloth made in other countries; while three years later it was stated that the loss of reputation caused by the inferior quality of previous consignments was not yet recovered, “for calico here stands upon these terms, that if it may not be afforded to undersell the Germany, Scotch, and French linens, then they will not sell to any considerable quantity; and then one of the main pillars of the Surat trade is overthrown.” Calico in fact came into direct competition with goods manufactured in Western Europe, and the market consequently depended entirely on considerations of price and quality.
The next phase of the trade is marked by the growing importance of the East Coast, which was soon to supersede Gujarat as the principal source of supply for Western Europe. After the consignment of 1638–39, which has been mentioned above, there appears to have been an interruption in the exports from this region, for in 1644 the Company wrote that they had received nothing but one bale of longcloth in five years. In 1646, however, goods from Madras had reached England, and sold to advantage; while in 1650, at a time when European markets were depressed, it was recorded that sales consisted chiefly of goods from Coromandel, which “are now preferred before any of the Surat clothing, because they are best fit for French and other foreign sales.” It may be said, then, that the trade entered on the new phase about the year 1646, when the supplies from Gujarat, Agra, and Sind began to be supplemented regularly from the East Coast.
I have not succeeded in finding figures to show the volume of exports during the next ten years, but the instructions for purchases at various centres suggest that trade was not expanding beyond the standard of 1640. It is clear, however, that exports rose largely during the years when trade was practically open, for when the Company’s monopoly was restored the English market was found to be greatly overstocked. The quantities ordered for supply during the year 1658 were as follows:
| From Surat— | ||
|---|---|---|
| Mercoolis | 10,000 | pieces. |
| Narrow baftas | 10,000 | „ |
| Broad baftas | 5,000 | „ |
| Sind calico | 10,000 | „ |
| Dariyabads | 10,000 | „ |
| Dungaree 1 | 10,000 | „ |
| Other calico | 8,500 | „ |
| 63,500 | „ | |
also 1000 pieces of chintz, and 300 chintz quilts.
| Longcloth, 20,000 pieces, equal to | 50,000 | standard pieces. |
| Salempores | 20,000 | „ |
| Others (including some muslin) | 14,000 | „ |
| 84,000 | „ |
Allowing for the extra size of the longcloth, it will be seen that the total demand was for about 150,000 standard pieces, but that considerably more than half was to be provided on the East Coast. The needs of the market proved to have been overestimated, and a year later the indent on Surat was reduced to one-fourth of the quantity previously ordered, or say 16,000 pieces, and this reduction was repeated for the year 1660, on the ground that the market was glutted, and calicoes would scarcely fetch their prime cost. Our period therefore closes with a demand for calico on this side of India only about one-tenth of that which had been reached thirty years previously. The business of the East Coast, however, was satisfactorily maintained, for the indent for 1659 specified over 90,000 standard pieces, viz. longcloth equivalent to 50,000, together with 30,000 salempores and 11,000 of other descriptions; and at the same time a standing order was given to provide roughly 100,000 standard pieces of the same descriptions for future years. Madras had thus definitely replaced Surat as the chief source for supplying the London market.
The story of the Dutch exports to Europe can be told more shortly. Before the year 1620 they were already carrying cotton goods round the Cape, but the exports were almost wholly of the type required for Brazil and West Africa. The Portuguese monopoly of trade in these regions had passed away; the Dutch were rapidly acquiring a predominant position in them; and their exports at this time represent a continuation of the business established by the Portuguese in the course of the previous century. In the next decade this trade began to be supplemented by small consignments of goods suitable to the European market, and the first large order I have noticed was one for 16,000 pieces of calico, which was placed in the year 1634. The European trade increased in the next few years, and its extent can be seen in the indent despatched from Holland in 1639, which may be summarised as follows : 1
| 1. Guinea cloth | 500 bales. |
| 2. Other calico— | |
| Semianoes (Punjab) | 1,000 pieces. |
| Ambertees (Bihar) | 1,000 „ |
| Broad baftas (Gujarat) | 5,000 „ |
| Narrow baftas (Gujarat) | 4,000–5,000 „ |
| Dariyabads (Oudh) | 2,000 „ |
| Salempores (East Coast). | 3,000–4,000 „ |
| Moorees and Percalles (East Coast) | 9,000–11,000 „ |
| 25,000–29,000 „ | |
| 3. Various muslin and fancy goods— (East Coast and Bengal) | 8,000–11,000 „ |
As I have said above, Guinea cloth appears to be identical with longcloth, and 500 bales of it would represent the equivalent of nearly 20,000 pieces of calico of the standard length. The total demand was thus for about 60,000 pieces, a small proportion of which consisted of muslins and fancy goods. I have found no later details of the Dutch trade up to the close of our period, but there is nothing to suggest a large extension before 1670 ; after that year the development was rapid.
The value to Indian weavers of the new export trade can be measured by the prices paid for calico on the spot, excluding the relatively high charges for preparing, packing, and transit to the ship. I have not found any evidence to show that the prices paid changed permanently during our period, though they fluctuated from time to time. Calico bought in Agra and Sind cost from one to two rupees per piece of the ordinary length, while the price in Gujarat was about half a rupee more. The invoice rates for longcloth work out to somewhere about two rupees for the standard length ; salempores had a wider range of value, but the qualities most largely bought cost approximately two rupees for the piece ; so that the English annual demand of something over 100,000 pieces represents payments to weavers of somewhere about two lakhs of rupees. To this must be added the value of the Dutch exports, and the total value of the trade may perhaps be taken roughly at three lakhs or somewhat more, apart from the disbursements for bleaching and dyeing when required, and also for packing and carriage to the seaboard. As in the case of other exports, the price paid was distributed among a particular class of artisans in a few localities, and the benefit derived by them from the new trade must have been substantial.
Various obstacles were encountered from time to time in the establishment of the export of calico to Europe, some of them due directly to the administration, and others arising out of the conditions prevailing in the industry. Official interference was a frequent cause of complaint: sometimes new taxes, or new extortions, might disorganise operations for the time, and sometimes the looms might be monopolised to provide cargo for an official speculation; but such incidents are illustrative of the general working of the administration rather than of interference with a particular branch of trade. Of greater significance for our present purpose are the difficulties of the second class. The weaving industry within reach of the seaboard was organised, or it may be more correct to say had developed, to serve the specific purpose of providing cloth for particular Asiatic markets, and buyers for Europe had to adapt themselves to the arrangements which they found at work. Thus they had to follow the existing practice of giving advances against future delivery, but they had not the same facilities as Indian merchants for gauging the credit of individual debtors, and the question of security was attended by various difficulties. One remarkable expedient is disclosed in the grant of terms for the settlement at Madras, in which the nayak undertook that "if the English first acquaint us before they deliver out any money to the merchants, painters,1 weavers, etc., . . . and take our word for their sufficiency and honest dealing, then do we promise, in case those people fail in their performances, to make good to the English all such sums of money as shall remain upon their accounts, or else deliver them their persons, if they shall be found in any part of my [sic] territories." Such a State guarantee of credit was, however, an exceptional arrangement, while its practical value might be open to question; and three years after this grant the factors at Madras admitted that the Company had suffered grievous losses by trusting "poor painters and weavers." "But experience," they added, "tells us it cannot be altogether avoided, unless we had one prime merchant (as have the Dutch) who secures all. Such a one we had some time with us," but they explain that he found the business unprofitable and gave it up. Shortly after this, we have a complaint that the English were unable to get weavers to work, because the Dutch, who had ample resources, had bound all the artisans by advances, and thus obtained temporary control of production. It must not, however, be supposed that the distribution of advances enabled buyers to get precisely the quality of cloth they wanted. European consumers were not entirely satisfied with goods manufactured to meet Asiatic tastes, and throughout most of our period we read of efforts to secure some alteration in length, or breadth, or number of threads, but these efforts frequently met with little success. Where purchasers were not competing, weavers might be willing to carry out instructions, as at Nasarpur in Sind, where no difficulty was experienced in increasing the number of threads in the warp, there "being no buyers but us"; but so long as the weavers had a choice of possible customers, they preferred to make the familiar goods in the familiar way. Similarly there were great difficulties in securing the degree of uniformity which was demanded by distributors in Europe. Not only individual pieces, but entire consignments, might be found to fall short of expectations in regard to length, or breadth, or number of threads: in 1638 the Company complained that a consignment was "like a pedlar's pack, not fit for a merchant's foreign export, but for a town retail trade "; and five years later they commented on deficiencies in length, urging the need for so much uniformity that "we may know what we sell, and the buyer what he is to receive." The conditions of production were, however, obviously incompatible with any real standardisation, and so long as India retained a practical monopoly of the industry the defect had to be borne, but there can be little doubt that it became a serious handicap as soon as competition had to be faced.
6. Other Commodities, and General Remarks
The commodities which have now been discussed—indigo, saltpetre, and calico—formed the basis of the new commercial relations between India and Western Europe in the sense that a remunerative trade could not have been maintained without them; but when ships were once placed on the route, an opportunity was afforded of exporting other goods, and the European factors made an exhaustive study of India's possibilities, as the result of which various secondary commodities were brought to the distributing markets of London and Amsterdam. Some of them were quickly discarded, others came gradually into favour, and a few words may be said regarding four items, raw cotton, yarn, sugar, and silk.
The early history of the cotton industry in Western Europe is somewhat obscure, but it is clear that at the opening of the seventeenth century raw cotton was in some demand in England and neighbouring countries, partly for use in preparing candlewicks and other articles in ordinary consumption, partly for the manufacture of the cloths known as fustians, which usually consisted of flaxen warps with cotton wefts. Supplies of raw cotton came regularly from the Levant, where mechanical appliances existed for pressing the fibre into compact bales suitable for sea transport. The factors at Surat were anxious to take a share in this trade, and on more than one occasion asked that presses of the kind used in Turkey should be supplied, but their requests were not complied with, and the bulk of unpressed bales was obviously too great in proportion to value for them to occupy space which could be filled with goods like indigo or calico. Accordingly no regular trade developed during our period, but cotton was occasionally shot loose into the hold to fill the spaces between the bales, while small quantities were sold regularly in London after having served to pack more valuable goods.
Yarn was a commodity much better suited for sea transport, and a regular trade in it developed. The earliest consignments were not indeed welcomed in England, but in 1622 factors were buying yarn suitable for wefts for fustian ; in 1628 the English consignment from Gujarat amounted to 525 bales, and two years later the Company wrote that 600 or 700 bales might be sent annually, provided that more valuable goods were not available. Meanwhile the Dutch had established a small but regular export from the Coromandel coast, as can be seen from the invoices summarised in Appendix B, while they were also buying in Surat, though not at first on the same scale as the English, their annual requirements about 1630 amounting to 150 bales. Their demand rose during the next decade to about 400 bales, while the English shipment in 1638–39 amounted to about 300 bales. For the remainder of our period the Dutch trade was maintained at somewhere about 500 bales yearly, taking both coasts together, but the English trade declined. In 1641 the Company reduced their demand to 100 bales; they disliked the commodity, but authorised the purchase of this amount in order not to disappoint English workmen, who, they wrote, had of late found many uses for Indian yarn.1 Ten years later, only 75 bales were shipped, while in 1653 the indent was for 150 bales, but the general expansion of trade in 1658 extended to yarn, and the demand rose again to about 500 bales. The quality shipped varied within very wide limits, and I have not found definite information as to the grades chiefly handled by the Dutch, but 50 rupees is perhaps a fair average price for a bale (of about 160 lb.), and on this basis the total export may be valued at a maximum of half a lakh.
The trade in yarn was marked by a curious incident in the year 1630, when the English purchases in Gujarat were at their maximum: the weavers feared that their industry would suffer through the export of their raw material, and a regular boycott was organised in Broach, the English being called upon to choose between buying cloth and yarn. There is no sign of similar opposition in subsequent years, and I take the incident to indicate merely that the English buyers had gone ahead too rapidly for the stocks available at the moment; India could produce all the yarn that was wanted, but a sudden large increase in demand might involve hardship to local consumers until production could be extended to meet it.
Conditions in the world’s sugar trade have changed greatly since the seventeenth century. The commodity was not, as it now is, an article of general consumption in Western Europe, but must rather be classed as a somewhat expensive luxury. The European beet-sugar industry had not come into existence, and the principal sources of the supply of cane-sugar were China and India in the East, and Brazil and the Antilles in the West. During our period the Dutch controlled the great bulk of the trade from China and America, besides handling most of the exports from India; and since much of the Indian product was inferior in quality and relatively costly to export, it did not at first secure any large share of the European market. Indian sugar was of three main types: the coarse product known as jaggery,1 which was not handled by exporters, a white sugar of fine grain known as “powder sugar,” and large crystals, more thoroughly refined and much more costly, which the merchants knew as “ candy.” An irregular trade with England in the two latter classes was maintained by the factors at Surat: sometimes the Company asked for a supply, at other times they prohibited it, and on at least one occasion it was loaded merely to fill the ship; the quantity sent varied greatly, but it was rarely important, and the factors more than once advised that indents should be made on Bengal, where the commodity was both better and cheaper. The Dutch do not appear to have taken an active part in the Surat trade, but when circumstances became favourable, they developed a substantial business on the other side of India. By the year 1636 they were exporting Bengal sugar from Masulipatam, and in the 'forties their business showed a great expansion, the quantity to be sent annually to Batavia at this period being somewhere about 500,000 lb. Later records are imperfect, but I judge that this export was not fully maintained, either because it was too much for the market, or because the European demand was being met from other sources. The English Company was slow to develop a trade in sugar from Bengal. It was talked about for years, and an investment was ordered in 1651–52, but the first sign of extensive business is an order sent out in 1659 to buy 700 tons, a large amount whether the ton be taken as a weight or a measure. This order was reduced a year later, but the history of the English trade lies outside our period, during which the volume of the total exports was too irregular to justify any estimate of its value to producers.
The trade in silk from Bengal to Europe also lies outside our period. Western needs were met first from China, and afterwards from Persia; when the Dutch at last secured a regular footing in Bengal, their exports were, as we have seen, directed mainly to Japan; and I have not found records to show if any progress had been made in developing the European market before 1660. The story of the English trade begins in 1657, when the Company was at last adequately provided with capital, and a sum of £3000 was ordered to be invested in Bengal raw silk, while in the following year authority was given for regular purchases of 100 bales, worth about 20,000 rupees in all.
It will be apparent from the facts which have been brought together in this chapter that in regard to the export trade to Western Europe the first half of the seventeenth century was a period of prolonged experiment. Late in its first decade, we have the Dutch on the East Coast and the English on the West, just beginning to learn by experience what goods could be bought and sold. Ten years later the Dutch had discovered indigo and saltpetre, but the indigo they were buying was nearly the worst, and the saltpetre nearly the dearest, which India could supply. The English, on the other hand, had established the trade in good indigo, and were laying the foundations of the still more important export of the calicoes of Gujarat. By the middle of the half century, Surat appeared to be firmly established as the principal port for Europe; the East Coast was contributing little, and Bengal was still unknown ground to European buyers. The famine of 1630 brought about a startling change, and large parts of India were prospected afresh in order to supplement the inadequate supplies from Gujarat. The superior efficiency of the Dutch merchants gave them a long lead in Bengal, but it was utilised in the first instance mainly for Asiatic developments, and it was only after 1650 that the eastern side of India took a prominent place in European trade. That place was earned partly by the suitability of the Madras calicoes, partly by the cheapness of Bihar saltpetre, partly by the supplies of silk and sugar in Bengal. Gujarat retained its former eminence only in regard to indigo, but this trade was already declining under the stress of American competition, and the political conditions resulting from the rise of the Maratha power were about to prove an additional handicap to the port of Surat, which had at first outdistanced all competitors.
As has already been pointed out, the direct benefit accruing to India from the new export trade was confined to relatively small areas, but in them it was substantial, in that it increased the demand for goods which producers were ready to supply. Indirectly the position of the whole country was changed by the opening up of new commercial relations with the progressive markets of the West. In the previous century the Portuguese had made a poor use of their opportunities for commercial development; but the Dutch and English companies approached India from a different standpoint, employed very different methods, and secured much greater results. Through their agency, Indian goods became familiar in Amsterdam, London, Paris, and other markets; the tastes of consumers were made known in the areas of production; and the East was searched systematically for commodities which might command a profit in the West. A new business organisation was thus brought into existence, and while its initial achievements were by no means negligible, its possibilities in the future were almost unlimited.
One feature of this organisation calls for a word of comment, because it could not easily be paralleled among civilised countries at the present day. In modern business it is the seller who does most of the work. When a country sets out to secure a new market, the enterprise is shared by manufacturers, financiers, and official agents; the market is invaded, often at heavy initial expense; and goods are brought to the doors of those who are expected to buy. India made no such efforts to secure the markets of Western Europe. Indian producers and merchants were eager to sell, and welcomed the foreign buyers who came among them, but their part in the development was passive. We hear nothing at this period of Indians going to Europe to push their goods, or pressing sample consignments on the foreign buyers; in this case the buyers did the work, and it followed necessarily that the large profits accruing from transportation were not shared by India. Had only one European company been engaged in the business, it would thus have been in a position to operate on strictly monopolistic lines, and I think it may fairly be said that in this respect India was fortunate. During our period some of the countries farther to the East learned by experience what a monopoly meant to the merchants of Holland; but in India the competition of the weaker English company usually sufficed to secure to Indians a fair price for what they sold.
AUTHORITIES FOR CHAPTER IV
Section 1.—The general position of European markets at this period can be studied in Cunningham, vol. II. Reference to the lists of Portuguese cargoes is given in the footnotes; for the secrecy on the subject of their trade, see (e.g.) Renneville, i. 25; for the inferiority of Indian ginger, Linschoten, c. 64. The annals of the Malabar pepper trade must be traced in English Factories and the Dagh Register; the facts stated in the text are taken from English Factories, iii. 62, 90, 92, 157, 327; iv. 9; v. 148, 314; vi. 24; vii. 138; and x. 220. The Dutch attempt to export pepper from the East Coast is mentioned in idem, i. 303; some details of it will be found in Appendix B.
Section 2.—The Dutch cargo taken as an example is given in Dagh Register (Coromandel), November 3, 1642. For Dutch sailings to Europe direct, see Appendix B, Hague Transcripts, II. 50, 72, 95; III. F5; and numerous entries in Dagh Register. The early Dutch interest in indigo is mentioned in Terpstra's Surat, 84, 85. The English exports up to 1630 are taken from English Factories, i. 206; iii. 90, 92, 208, 217, 295, 333. The cargo of the London (1639–40) is referred to in idem, vi. 232, 233 n.; exports from 1642 onwards in idem, vii. p. xix; viii. 197 n., 256, 295; ix. pp. ix, 41, 149; x. 158, 215, 335. For the period of open trade, see idem, x. 44, 57, and passim; the activities of Courteen's Association are described in the introductions to successive volumes from v. onwards; for exports from the East Coast, see idem, viii. 271; ix. 20, 102, 154; x. 141, 255, 275; and Letter Books, ii. 13-17, 196. The admissions of Dutch superiority are quoted from English Factories, ii. 121; iv. p. xxxvii; vi. p. xlv; vii. 191, 217; viii. 304; and x. 56, 258, 409. The figures quoted for the Dutch investment in India have been abstracted from the entries in the Dagh Register for the years named.
Section 3.—The English trade in indigo during our period is summarised by Mr. Foster in Journal Royal Society of Arts, LXVI. 362. For the Portuguese monopoly, see Couto, X. ii. 572. The references to the Aleppo indigo market are taken from First Letter Book, 285; Letters Received, ii. 214; and Purchas, I. v. 734. A remark in Hague Transcripts, II. 52, shows that indigo was still reaching England and Holland from the Levant in 1621. The prices quoted are taken from Mr. Foster's paper, supra. For the primary importance of indigo, see Terpstra's Surat, 18; de Jonge, II. 495; Letters Received, i. 28; First Letter Book, 285, 308, 328; Roe, 447. The production and manufacture of indigo in the north is described at great length by Pelsart, but the French translation is inadequate, and the original should be referred to. The best account of the Sarkhej industry is in the Gujarat Report. For the export qualities, see (e.g.) English Factories, iii. 63; vi. 58; Pelsart, 4, 5; for their use in England, Mr. Foster's paper, supra, and Court Minutes, July 2, 1634; and for earliest purchases in India, Purchas, I. iv. 429, 483, and Terpstra's Surat, 75. Sind purchases are mentioned in (e.g.) English Factories, vii. 202 and viii. 29; Vengurla, in Dagh Register, September 17, 1645, and passim; Chittagong, in idem, February 13, 1637. For indigo on the East Coast, see the invoices in Appendix B; also Hague Transcripts, I. 69, and Dagh Register, October 8, 1626, and frequently after that date.
The quantity of indigo exported to England in 1619 is taken from English Factories, i. 61; for the standard of the next decade, see idem, iii. 92, 208. The Dutch exports are compiled from entries in the Dagh Register; their indent for 1639 is in Hague Transcripts, II. 114a. For the effect of price-changes on purchases, see English Factories, vi. 111, 273; and for the decline after 1650, idem, viii. 253; ix. 29, 82, 196; and x. 322; also Letter Books, ii. 1-3.
The first reference I have seen to American exports of indigo is Purchas, III. v. 958; see also Cambridge Modern History, iv. 706. Later references are Court Minutes, January 18, 1633, October 24, 1645; and English Factories, x. 322. As regards interference with trade owing to accidents of season, see (e.g.) English Factories, vi. 278; viii. 62; and Pelsart, 5; and for official action, Terpstra's Surat, Appendix VII.; English Factories, iv. 324 and passim (the monopoly); vii. 203 (Sind); and viii. 143 (Ahmadabad). For adulteration, see idem, vi. 273; vii. 5; and viii. 12, 31, 33, 303.
The estimates of production in Gujarat are taken from English Factories, iii. 232; v. 73; vii. 136; and Dagh Register, May 20, 1641; in Agra, Pelsart, 5; English Factories, iv. 325; and Dagh Register (Surat), June 13, 1644; on the East Coast, English Factories, vi. 262; and in Sind, idem, v. 129. The persistence of the overland trade is referred to in Dagh Register, May 20, 1641; Court Minutes, December 29, 1643; and English Factories, vii. 136, and viii. 253. Purchases by Asiatic merchants are referred to in idem, vii. 136, and viii. 243; the quotation from Pelsart is taken from f. 6 of the Dutch MS. The assessments made by Akbar on the crop are in Ain (translation), ii. 99 ff.
Section 4.—Portuguese exports of saltpetre are referred to in Lisbon Transcripts, I. 10, 15, and IV. 931; the instances of other non-commercial exports are taken from idem, II. 371, and III. 465. The earliest mention I have found of the Dutch trade on the East Coast is in Hague Transcripts, II. 30; see also idem, I. 162, and the Dagh Register from November 20, 1624, onwards. For the saltpetre supply in England, see Court Minutes, October 31, 1617; February 20 and December 29, 1624; May 20, 1625, and passim; for the beginnings of the English trade, see idem, January 5, 1627, and English Factories, i. 251; iii. 83, 90. The quantities exported are taken from idem, vii. 94, 175, and viii. 203; the figures for 1639 are in Original Correspondence, 1656 (enclosure). The use of saltpetre as ballast is mentioned in English Factories, iii. 208; vi. 94; and vii. 94, 175. For the English trade in Bengal, see idem, ix. 196, and x. 7, 276: the figures for the Dutch trade have been compiled from the Dagh Register.
The instances of interference with the trade are taken from English Factories, iii. 270; iv. 143; and viii. 34, 53, 79, 108, 203. The parallel of the horse trade is recounted in Couto, VIII. 235. The supply of refining plant is referred to in Dagh Register, February 19, 1641, and November 29, 1645 (Coromandel); also English Factories, ix. 95.
Section 5.—The consumption of cotton goods in England is dealt with incidentally in Baines and Daniels. For the nature of the initial demand on India, see First Letter Book, 131, 148, 255, 308, 328, etc.; Finch's report is in Letters Received, i. 28 ff. The table of exports in 1619 is compiled from English Factories, i. 61, 62; the figures for 1625 and 1628 are idem, iii. 92, 208; and the indent of 1630 is idem, iv. 8. For the English market at this period, see Court Minutes, August 6, 1623, and March 30, 1625; and for purchases in Northern India, see English Factories, i. pp. xxi ff., 212; iii. 141 and passim. For the change in trade after the famine, see English Factories, iv. 97, 158; v. 146, 278, 341; for Sind, idem, v. 118, 129, 164; and for the East Coast, idem, i. 343; ii. 336; iv. 64, 228; v. 218; and vi. 295. The exports of 1638–41 are abstracted from the invoices attached to Original Correspondence, 1656, 1725, and 1761. The description of Coast goods is based mainly on Letter Books, vol. II. 13-17, 196-197; and on details in the Dutch invoices abstracted in Appendix B. The decline in quality of Gujarat calicoes is referred to in English Factories, vi. 56, 311. The growth of the East Coast trade can be traced in the latter volumes of English Factories; see especially vii. 173; viii. 164, 297; and x. 61, 200, 307, 322. The detailed figures given for this period have been extracted from Letter Books, vol. II. 1-3, 13-17, 21-24, 196-197.
The Dutch trade with Brazil and West Africa is discussed in Elias, ii. ch. vii. For their export of cotton goods to Europe, see Appendix B, and also Letters Received, iv. 34; English Factories, i. 41, 44; ii. 336; Terpstra's Surat, 76; Hague Transcripts, I. 163, 318; II. 52, 114a; III. F5.
Interference with trade is recorded frequently; the instances given are from Dagh Register, May 20, 1641; English Factories, v. 296, and viii. 118, 234. The remarks on advances and security are taken from idem, vi. 156, and vii. 46, 164, 191. For defects and improvements, see idem, iv. 3; vi. 57; vii. 126; viii. 117; Court Minutes, September 6, 1658; and Dagh Register, May 20, and September 3, 1641.
Section 6.—The English demand for cotton is dealt with by Daniels, 2 ff. For requests for baling-machinery, see English Factories, iii. 212; v. 206; and for export of raw cotton, idem, iii. 62; iv. 9. Sales are recorded in Court Minutes, passim. The facts stated regarding the English yarn trade are taken from English Factories, i. 58; ii. 157, 185; iii. 209; iv. 22; vi. 312; viii. 254; ix. 42, 196; Letter Books, ii. 1-3, 13-17. The extent of the Dutch trade has been as usual reached by compiling the figures of cargoes given in the Dagh Register; see also Hague Transcripts, I. 318, and II. 114a.
For the sugar trade at this period, see Elias, i. 71. Exports from Surat are mentioned frequently in English Factories, e.g. i. 51; iv. 4, 9, 323; vi. 58; viii. 255. The Dutch trade on the East Coast has been compiled from the Dagh Register, beginning with October 31, 1636. For the English trade in Bengal, see English Factories, vols. viii., ix. passim. There are occasional references to the silk trade in the earlier vols. of English Factories, but as a commercial proposition the history begins with x. 188.
Notes
- 1. These lists are classified as "State Papers, Foreign. Portugal: vol. 3; Nos. 7 and 10," and are noted as Nos. 309 and 327 in Calendar S.P., 1513– 1616; I am indebted to Miss E. Salisbury for their transcription.
- *. The origin of the 1277 quintals of ginger carried in 1602 cannot be determined. The European markets preferred Chinese to Indian ginger, and probably some, if not all, of this consignment was from the former country.
- 1. There are some grounds for thinking that, while the bales handled by the Portuguese were of varying sizes, they were on the whole smaller, perhaps much smaller, than the standard of later Dutch and English cargoes. The account given by Linschoten (c. 92) of the way the carracks were loaded shows a very large number of individual small consignments, in fact what might almost be called parcel traffic; while della Valle (p. 60), writing under Portuguese inspiration, commented on the great size, “as big as a Roman coach,” of the bales handled by the Dutch and English. The bales carried in the carracks should not therefore be thought of in terms of the bales discussed in Appendix D, but their actual size is a matter of conjecture.
- 1. There is a curious story in the journal of the first Dutch voyage (Houtman, i. 105), to the effect that the Portuguese had contemplated buying up the Java pepper, but that the Emperor of China had paid them to leave the trade open to his subjects. The editors of the journal treat this story as a joke, but there may be some substratum of fact; there was occasional friction between the Portuguese at Macao and the Chinese officials, and it is quite possible that a threat to cut off the supply of pepper by diverting the Java crop westwards may have been used as a diplomatic counter in negotiations with Canton. What is certain is that, until the Dutch reached Java, the produce of the island went chiefly to China.
- 1. In Appendix B I have given abstracts of some of the earliest cargoes carried to Europe from India, taken from the original invoices in the Dutch records.
- 1. The Bonito, which sailed in 1649, was "apparently the first ship to go home direct" from Madras (English Factories, viii. p. xxx). Direct sailings from the East Coast had been talked about before Madras was founded, but I cannot find that the project was ever put into execution.
- 1. The figures given in the text are compiled from the invoice printed in English Factories, i. 61 ; here and elsewhere I have rounded the figures, which in the original are detailed to fractions of a pice. The mahmudi was at this time worth 2/5 rupee. It is advisable to treat Indian trade by seasons rather than calendar years, because it was in fact seasonal ; the whole of a year's exports from Surat might be despatched either in December or in January according to circumstances. The lists of sailings given in English Factories (iii. p. xxxiv and vii. p. xix), being drawn up by calendar years, suggest that trade was more irregular than it really was ; thus three ships are shown in 1639, two in 1640, and none in 1641, whereas in fact two sailed in 1638–39, two in 1639–40, and one in 1640–41.
- 2. The weight of three out of four consignments of indigo is given, but the fourth is shown only in terms of packages. I have calculated the weight of these on the assumption that the price paid per maund was about the same as for the corresponding consignment where the weight is given.
- 1. These invoices are appended to Nos. 1656, 1725, and 1761 in the Original Correspondence at the India Office : I am indebted to Miss L. M. Anstey for their transcription. The figures given in the text have been rounded.
- 1. Some further particulars on this topic are given in Appendix A.
- 1. Here and in other passages where the term is used, " modern purchasing power " denotes the value of the rupee disclosed by official statistics for the quinquennial period 1910–14. The latter part of this period included times of scarcity, and for prices of agricultural produce I use the years 1910 to 1912 inclusive. It is too early yet to attempt a definitive estimate of the normal value of the post-war rupee; the process of adjustment was in any case bound to be slow, and the recurrence of bad seasons has prolonged the period of obscurity. The standard I use may be stated in concrete form as 12½ ser of wheat for a rupee in the country between Agra and Lahore.
- 1. I have been unable to trace any authority for the common statement that the use of indigo was prohibited in England during the first half of the seventeenth century, and it appears to be negatived by the fact that patents for processes involving its use were being granted at this time. Mr. William Foster conjectures that the statement may have arisen out of a confusion between indigo and another dye, logwood, the use of which was in fact prohibited by Parliament. (Journal, Royal Society of Arts, lxvi. 362.)
- 1. The figures in the text are taken from Mr. William Foster's paper in Journal, Royal Society of Arts, LXVI. 362-3. The very low price of Coromandel indigo is noteworthy; the fact that produce of such a low grade could be handled commercially may be explained by the absence of high charges for land transport, as it was grown in villages near the seaports on the East Coast.
- 1. The exports of 1638–39 included about 35 cwt. from the East Coast, which, added to the figures in the table, give the total, quoted above, of 1480 cwt. for this season. No indigo from the East Coast was shipped in the two following seasons by the English.
- 1. The usual net weight of a bale of indigo was about 220 lb. for Biana and 150 lb. for Sarkhej, so that the indent of 1653 would represent about 400 cwt. at most. Of the indent of 1658, half was Lahori and half Sarkhej, so the total would be a little over 1300 cwt.
- 2. It is perhaps worth mentioning that the Dutch had already made efforts to supply indigo from other parts of Asia, from Siam, Formosa, and Java. Various entries in the Dagh Register (e.g., May 20, 1641; November 14, 1644; December 1, 1645) show that the two former countries proved disappointing; I have found no record of positive results in Java during our period, but the dye was already manufactured in that island at the date of the first Dutch voyage (Houtman, i. 122).
- 1. Adulteration was by no means unknown in Biana, for Pelsart (f. 4) enters into minute details regarding the precautions to be taken by buyers, but it does not seem to have been an open scandal, as it was in Gujarat.
- 1. This estimate was put forward by a factor on his defence (English Factories, vi. 91) ; after excusing himself for certain past transactions, he winds up his letter by holding out better hopes for the future, with the " general report " that 40,000 maunds of indigo would be available. Such an estimate should not rank with the others quoted in the text, which were recorded in the ordinary course of business.
- 2. These figures are taken from Pelsart's full and detailed account of the indigo trade. There are some discrepancies between the Dutch MS. and the printed translation ; the former gives in all 2500 bales, while the figures in the latter total 2200 bales. The bale is given as 4 maunds (of 55 lb.).
- 1. The standards used by the Indian Statistical Department at the present time are 18 lb. per acre for the United Provinces and 20 lb. for Bihar. No standard is fixed for Bombay, where the crop is not now grown on an appreciable scale (Estimates of Area and Yield of Principal Crops, Table II.). There is nothing definite on record to show the yield per acre in Gujarat during our period ; I suspect it was somewhat less than in Northern India, but the indications are too slight to justify any conclusion.
- 1. It may be advisable to point out that "planters" means here either the peasants who grew indigo, or the capitalists who financed them; the European indigo-planter had not yet appeared in India.
- 1. In the same way pepper was ordinarily carried loose among the bales, and raw cotton was sometimes stowed loose. Kintledge, or kintlage, is [p. 121] defined in the Oxford English Dictionary as material used as permanent ballast, but the factors in India employed the word commonly in the sense of anything carried loose in the hold for a single voyage.
- 1. As explained in Appendix D, it is often difficult to say whether "ton" indicates weight or measure, for the use of the word to denote 20 cwt. was not yet definitely established, though it was gaining ground at this period. From various figures given in the Dutch records it is possible to calculate the number of pounds taken as equivalent to a last; the different equations agree very closely, and give something between 1800 and 1900 pounds (avoirdupois) as the weight of a tun (half a last) of saltpetre; on this basis 800 tuns' measurement would represent between 600 and 700 tons' weight.
- 1. As explained in a former chapter, bafta was the commercial name for ordinary Gujarat calico; semianoes, the calico made at Samana in Northern India; dutties, the loin-cloths in common wear. Bairamis would be of rather better quality if they resembled hollands, but would be calico rather than muslin; the name covers a wide range of texture. Serribaff was one of the muslins for which the Deccan was famous.
- *. Some reeses had a pattern of the type known in England as dimity. Necanies were striped calico. Eramies may have been cloth of the type worn by pilgrims to Mecca (Ihram). I have found no description of sahum.
- 1. Dariyabad lies midway between Lucknow and Fyzabad; Khairabad is a short distance north of Lucknow. I have found no description of “ Echbaryes,” but it has been conjectured that the word denotes some cloth favoured by, or named after, the Emperor Akbar; it was made chiefly in Oudh, sometimes at least in the neighbourhood of Jalalpur, near Fyzabad.
- 1. One invoice for this year is missing, and the total export was probably larger than the figures here given.
- 1. The descriptions in the text are based on contemporary commercial documents, which must be accepted for our period in preference to the later authorities and conjectures given in Hobson-Jobson. Moorees, described there (p. 707) as blue, were occasionally dyed, but were usually shipped brown or bleached. Percalles were not spangled robes (p. 708) but pieces of plain calico. Salempores were not usually chintz (p. 784), though, like all calico, they might be printed. The derivation of such names offers a wide field for conjecture, but indents and invoices are safer guides to the nature of the commodities.
- 1. Dungaree was cloth of a very low grade (Hobson-Jobson, s.v.). It appears in the Dutch invoices as used for packing the bales of other goods.
- 1. This indent is in Hague Transcripts, II, 114a. Ambertees were calico produced near Patna ; they are described in English Factories, i, 162. The other descriptions have already been explained.
- 1. Painters were the artisans who made pintados, or "painted" cotton cloth.
- 1. I have not been able to ascertain what developments in the English industry occurred about this time, but it was certainly progressive, and it is possible that Indian yarn was being found suitable for warps, so that the manufacture of pure cotton goods may date from this period, though evidence of the fact has not yet been discovered. Professor Daniels has shown the untenability of the old view that pure cotton goods were not made in England till late in the eighteenth century, but the date when their manufacture began is still uncertain. (Daniels, 21 ff.).
- 1. Jaggery, or gur, still the commonest form of sugar in India, is a compost of crystals and molasses produced by the indigenous processes of manufacture. The white sugars were extracted from this compost by elaborate and tedious processes of refining.