1. The Nature and Frequency of Famines
From what has been said in the previous chapter, it will be apparent that during our period production followed a generally uneventful course, responding to, but not creating, developments in demand, and impeded from time to time by administrative interference, or by the occurrence of famine. The results of administrative interference will be considered later ; in this chapter we have to examine the frequency and the effects of famine, and the subject requires careful study because a change in the implication of the familiar word has given rise to ideas which rest on an erroneous foundation. At the present day the "famines" which are spoken of in India are emergencies in which the State has recognised the existence of unemployment on a scale which, in the absence of a general poor-law, requires special measures of relief. The famines which we read of in the chronicles of the seventeenth century were not work-famines but food-famines in the strictest sense, times when it was not a question of obtaining the means to pay for food, but of getting food at all ; and the attempt sometimes made by popular writers to use these materials for a comparison of the frequency of famines at different periods is vitiated from the outset by this change of meaning. On the one hand, there have been no extensive food-famines in India for many years ; on the other, we have no systematic record of work-famines before the middle of the last century, and no valid conclusion could be drawn from the fact (if it were a fact) that work-famines are now more common than food-famines were in former times. Further, it can easily be shown that the record of food-famines in the published chronicles is incomplete, because we find several mentioned in the Dutch and English commercial correspondence of which no other account is known. To take one instance, I can trace no Indian record of famine between the years 1632 and 1650, but the Dutch tell us of heavy mortality in Golconda in 1635, the weavers on the East Coast were dying of hunger in 1646, and a year later a part of Rajputana was “wholly depopulate” owing to the same cause. Abandoning, then, any attempt at direct comparison, I have constructed a list of the years lying within our period in which production is known to have been seriously impeded through deficiency of agricultural produce, whether food or raw materials.
It cannot be asserted that this list is complete. The Batavia Journals, which are exceptionally valuable as sources of such information, are wanting or imperfect for several years, particularly between 1647 and 1660, and the missing records may have contained details of dearth or famine which would not be found elsewhere. Even, however, if the commercial records were available throughout the period, they would not cover the whole of India, but only those portions with which the merchants maintained relations: Bundelkhand, for instance, which is a tract peculiarly liable to vicissitudes of season, is altogether outside their scope; and the same is true of the Punjab, which, before the construction of the modern canal-system, must have resembled Bundelkhand in many important features. We may say, then, that production was certainly interfered with in the years shown in the following list, but we should not be justified in saying that the years not entered in it were prosperous throughout the whole of India. It will be noticed that recorded dearths are more numerous in the second half of our period than in the first; the difference may possibly be significant, but it is more probable that it results from the extension of the foreign merchants’ connections, and, in the case of the Dutch, from improvements in the system of recording events, the Journals which have survived for the 'forties being much fuller than those relating to the years before 1630. The list is as follows :
1614–15 (?).—The Emperor Jahangir records a pestilence in the year ending in March 1616, which was attributed by some authorities to the effects of drought, the country having suffered from want of rain for two years in succession. The area affected by the pestilence was the Punjab as far east as Delhi, and presumably the drought was localised in the Punjab. The description does not indicate the precise years in which the rains were deficient.
1618–19.—Writing from Masulipatam in 1622, a Dutch factor accounted for his small purchases of slaves by the comparative prosperity of the times, saying that, according to his information, the large supplies obtained four years previously were due to the extreme dearth and famine in Pulicat and the vicinity, when many hundreds of deaths occurred; but conditions had changed, supplies of rice were ample, and at the moment no large number of slaves could be procured. This information points to a severe famine on the Coromandel coast in 1618 or 1619. The historian M. de Faria y Sousa records of the latter year that dearth and famine destroyed many people; the exact locality is not indicated, but the reference is clearly to Southern India. Methwold, who left the East Coast in 1622, writes of such extreme want and famine in some parts of the territory of Vijayanagar "that parents have brought thousands of their young children to the seaside, selling there a child for 5 fanams of rice." I take these three accounts to refer to one calamity, a disastrous famine about the year 1618–19.1
1630.—The terrible calamity following on the failure of the rains in this year is described by various Indian, Dutch, and English authorities. Its effects on the economic condition of the country are examined in detail in the next section.
1635.—The Dutch factors at Surat reported that provisions were unprocurable throughout the whole kingdom of Golconda, and that the mortality from famine was heavy. The report reached Batavia in March 1636, and may therefore be taken to indicate a failure of the rains in the previous year. The extent appears to be somewhat exaggerated, since no reports of intense famine were received from the East Coast, though rice was difficult to obtain in Masulipatam, and the supply of raw cotton on the coast was still deficient in the following autumn. Probably there was severe famine in the western districts of Golconda, whence news would naturally reach Surat, and some scarcity on the side of Masulipatam.
1640.—Early in 1641 the Dutch reported deficiency of rain near Pulicat and Madras, so that provisions had to be imported by sea. From the subsequent reports from the coast, it does not appear that the famine became acute.
1641.—The season appears to have been unfavourable to the cotton crop in Northern India, for the Dutch reported that piece-goods had risen seriously in price owing to the scarcity of cotton. Cotton was scarce in Ahmadabad also during the summer of 1642, so that the previous season was probably unfavourable in Gujarat as well as in the north.
1642–43.—In January 1643 rice was reported to be very scarce and almost unprocurable owing to extraordinary drought in the neighbourhood of Pipli (Orissa). The winter rains of 1642–43 failed in Bengal.
1645–46.—This was a time of intense famine on the southern section of the Coromandel coast. The few letters of 1645–46 extant from the English factors do not mention a failure of the rains of 1645, but that this had occurred is shown by a letter written at Achin in October 1646, which reported the arrival from Negapatam of a cargo of starving slaves, and news through them of “ a very strong famine for 13 months past . . . insomuch as the people give themselves for slaves to any man that will but feed them.” The rains of 1646 also failed, and by January of 1647 the position on the coast was desperate. Heavy mortality was reported from Pulicat, S. Thomé, and Madras, “ so that all the painters1 and weavers are dead ”; rice sent from Surat was sold at “ great rates ”; and the famine continued until the rains of 1647. In October of this year the factors at Madras reported that the famine had then lasted two years, so that the earlier failure was not confined to the Negapatam country; they added that half the people in the kingdom were dead, and referred to “ the stench of the dead carcases that lieth most fearfully to behold in all places that we go, as well as the noise of the dying people, which can be no less terrors to the hearers thereof.”
1647.—This year the rains failed in parts of Rajputana, and “ occasioned a famine, insomuch that those parts are, either by mortality or people’s flight, become wholly depopulate and impassable.”
1648.—A recurrence of the famine on the Coromandel coast was so imminent that arrangements were made to forward rice from Surat, but a plentiful fall of rain came in time to remove the danger.
1650.—The Surat factors reported that “ this year there hath very little rain fallen in all parts of India, and since the middle of July little or none, so that corn is risen in many places already [October] to double the price, and a dearth is extremely and generally feared.” This drought was widespread, being experienced in Oudh as well as Gujarat, and crops were short “ almost all India over,” but apparently its intensity was not great, for we have not the familiar records of mortality or voluntary enslavement.
1658.—Want of rain in this season had doubled the price of all sorts of provisions in Surat by February 1659, but the calamity was heavier in Sind, for in September of that year it was reported that famine and disease “ hath swept away most part of the people,” and the Surat factors sent grain to Lahari Bandar to be distributed to the weavers so as to keep them alive.
1659–60.—Scarcity was experienced on the East Coast in the summer of 1659, as the result of deficient rainfall, aggravated by the demand for supplies for armies in the field. A letter written in October 1659 from Masulipatam says that people were dying daily from want of food, and famine continued on the coast into the year 1661. The want of rain had also been experienced in Gujarat, where in April of 1660 prices were very high, while in Sind famine still raged, “ the living being hardly able to bury the dead.” The historian Khafi Khan writes of the Hijra year 1070 (which began in September 1659), that want of rain, combined with war and movements of armies, made grain very scarce and dear; that many districts lay entirely waste, and that crowds of people made their way to the capital. Scarcity was reported also from Negapatam in the far south, so that our period closes with a calamity of unusual extent.
The list which has now been given makes depressing reading, and if the defects in its sources are borne in mind, the conclusion appears to be justified that the Indian climate in the seventeenth century was very much what it is to-day. I do not think that the record of the years from 1640 to 1650, imperfect as it may be, has been exceeded in the course of any decade in modern times; and without attempting a detailed comparison, we may say that local dearths were frequent, while acute or widespread famines occurred sufficiently often to influence the calculations of merchants and producers. The difference lies rather in the results which followed. The cost of transporting grain long distances by land was, as we have seen, prohibitive, and consequently a local shortage of food could not be met by importation; people might die in thousands, as on the East Coast in 1647, though there were ample supplies in other parts of the country, and the economic life of the area affected might be broken up through mortality and migration in a way which the modern railway-system has rendered impossible. At the present day the effect of a local shortage is spread over a large area, and its intensity is thereby reduced, because food can be imported in sufficient quantities, so that the very idea of a food-famine has been banished from all but the few tracts still inaccessible to the merchant: during our period, food-famines on varying scales might be expected in any season, and their present unfamiliarity makes it desirable to explain in some detail the economic consequences which followed in their train. The records of the famine of 1630 are sufficiently copious to make this possible, and the next section will be devoted to their examination.
2. The Famine of 1630–31
The immediate cause of the great famine was the failure of the rains in the year 1630. The failure occurred in the central parts of India. The Gangetic plain was not affected, and Peter Mundy's account of his journey northward from Surat shows that most of Malwa had escaped. The chronicler of the reign of Shahjahan says that no rain whatever fell in the Mogul provinces of the Deccan and Gujarat, while there was a deficiency in bordering countries. English letters from the East Coast show that the calamity extended right across India, and a merchant who visited Masulipatam in July 1631 wrote that "the major part of both weavers and washers are dead, the country being almost ruinated." Towards the south, we know that the drought was experienced in Armagon, but no information is on record as to the country beyond. Sind also was affected, but the letters written thence in 1635 suggest that the distress cannot have been very intense, because no traces of it are mentioned such as were still visible in Gujarat. The detailed information which has survived relates chiefly to this latter province, and for the present our attention may be confined to it.
The rains had been somewhat unsatisfactory for the three previous seasons, but not to such an extent as to affect commerce very materially, and in April of 1630 prospects were considered to be favourable. The monsoon, however, failed, and the immediate results can best be stated in the words of the Dutch senior merchant van Twist, who included an account of the famine in a short description of Gujarat, first printed at Batavia in 1638, and subsequently reissued in Amsterdam.1 His description is written in a dry and matter-of-fact style; it is a business document, drawn up by a man who knew the country well, and whose ability is indicated by his selection not long after for duties of great responsibility; the horrors described in it derive additional emphasis from this setting, while their occurrence is amply confirmed by the more fragmentary English narratives, as well as by the rhetoric of the Moslem chronicler.
So little rain fell, says van Twist, that the seed sown was lost, and no grass grew. Cattle died. In towns and villages, in fields and on roads, men lay dead in great numbers, causing such a stench that it was terrible to use the ways. For want of grass cattle fed on the corpses ; men took the carcases of beasts to eat ; some in desperation went about searching for bones which had been gnawed by dogs. . . .
As the famine increased, men abandoned towns and villages, and wandered helplessly. It was easy to recognise their condition : eyes sunk deep in the head, lips pale and covered with slime, the skin hard, with the bones showing through, the belly nothing but a pouch hanging down empty, knuckles and knee-caps showing prominently. One would cry and howl for hunger, while another lay stretched on the ground dying in misery ; wherever you went you saw nothing but corpses.
Men deserted their wives and children. Women sold themselves as slaves. Mothers sold their children. Children deserted by their parents sold themselves. Some families took poison, and so died together ; others threw themselves into the rivers. Mothers and their children went to the river-bank, and drowned themselves hand in hand, so that the rivers flowed full of corpses. Some ate carrion flesh. Others cut up the corpses of men, and drew out the entrails to fill their own bellies ; yes, men lying in the street, not yet dead, were cut up by others, and men fed on living men, so that even in the streets, and still more on road-journeys, men ran great danger of being murdered and eaten. . . .
Terrible tragedies were seen every day. Even a heathen might wonder and pity when he learned that a mother had killed and cooked her only son : much more might a Christian conscience, when it was known that husbands had eaten their wives, wives their husbands, children their parents—but it would be tedious to describe everything in detail. Many hundred thousands of men died of hunger,1 so that the whole country was covered with corpses lying unburied, which caused such a stench that the whole air was filled and infected with it. Some of our Dutchmen, coming from Ahmadabad, found some people sitting at a little fire where hands and feet were cooking, a terrible thing to see. Even worse was it in the village of Susuntra, where human flesh was sold in open market. This terrible divine punishment fell chiefly on the poor, who had nothing in store.
The narrative then gives the details of prices, which have been examined in a previous chapter, and passes to the season of 1631, when the rains were at first promising, and prices began to fall. But, continues van Twist, the improvement did not last, and it was seen that the punishment was not yet over. The Almighty sent locusts, rats, mice, and other vermin, which wrought great damage to the young crops: then continuous heavy rain when the crops were ripening caused much grain to perish in the fields; flooded rivers caused even greater loss in towns, villages, and country; and prices rose higher than ever. Thus famine lasted throughout the year, and pestilence and fever followed, so that scarcely a healthy man could be found. The dead lay scattered in the streets. Corpses lay for days in the houses, because men could not be paid to carry them out. Wood could not be had for the pyres, and unburnt corpses were buried or thrown into the river. May the Almighty protect all Christian lands from such terrible calamities!
The main features of this narrative will not come as a surprise to students of Indian famines of the type now obsolete. The break-up of family life, loss of agricultural capital, aimless wandering, voluntary enslavement, deaths from suicide or sheer starvation, cannibalism—all these could be illustrated from both Indian and foreign accounts of similar calamities. It will be noticed that van Twist has nothing to say of State measures of relief, but from Indian narratives we can form some idea of their nature and extent. Public kitchens were opened, taxes were remitted, and money was allocated for gratuitous relief, but the facts on record show that the effect of these measures was trifling, and from the nature of the case they could not counteract the actual deficiency of food which was the dominant factor in the situation; they might operate to improve the distribution of such stocks as were available, but they could not bring grain into the country, and though their inadequacy may be obvious, it is not easy to suggest what more could have been done. Casual references in letters of 1631 and 1632 show that the English merchants had ordered large quantities of grain from Persia, but the course of shipping imposed narrow limits on supplies from that source; Sind was itself affected; the Malabar coast ordinarily imported a large proportion of its food; the East Coast was starving; and it appears to be at the least doubtful whether the best and most humane administration in the world could have organised imports by sea sufficient to meet the situation. There was surplus grain in the north, but the cost of carriage by land was, as we have seen, exceedingly heavy, and it is hard to see how pack-animals could have moved through country without fodder or water in numbers adequate to the emergency.
It would be unjust, therefore, to blame the Mogul administration for failure to avert a calamity which, in the circumstances of the time, must be regarded as inevitable; but it may be pointed out that the measures actually taken were not only inadequate but tardy, and that the leaders of the people acted in a manner likely to aggravate rather than mitigate the distress. The authority for these statements is Peter Mundy, who, after describing his observations on the route from Surat to Burhanpur, lays stress on the fact that no course was taken to remedy the evil, "the rich and strong engrossing and taking perforce all to themselves." The same observer points out that relief from the north was hopeless, because the Mogul armies at Burhanpur lay across the route by which grain must come; and though the country near Sironj was well stocked with food, "poor Gujarat was never the near[er], where there was most need, it being all sent to Burhanpur to supply the King's lashker" [army]. This last obstacle was, however, temporary: by the end of 1631 the banjāras, or grain-carriers, were coming through, the sea-trade was helping, and from this time forward it appears that the needs of the reduced population were not too great to be provided by the ordinary course of trade, though at prices still far above the normal.
The immediate effect of this calamity on industry and commerce may be illustrated by a few facts gathered from the English correspondence of the period. By October 1630, the impending scarcity of indigo was realised at Surat, and arrangements were on foot to buy in Agra instead of Ahmadabad. In the same month special precautions were found necessary to protect provisions on the way to the ships from "assault by the poor starved people of the country." In November, Masulipatam reported scarcity of cotton goods, and a fall in the price of gold and other imports; while the factors at Surat had for the moment the rare experience of having more funds than could be invested owing to the shortage of cotton goods and indigo, were suggesting importation of rice from Macassar, and were reducing the rations allowed on the English ships. Spirits had by this time become unprocurable because the distillers had "departed into the parts of more hoped plenty, as are many thousands besides, as well weavers, washers, dyers, etc., that puts us almost into despair of a competent lading for the succeeding year's home returns." In December, Armagon reported that the inferiority of cloth was due in part to a fourfold rise in the price of cotton, and on the last day of the year Surat wrote that the artisans were abandoning their habitations in multitudes and perishing in the fields. Gold was falling in price because the poor were selling, while the rich could not buy; the yield of indigo in Gujarat was about one-twentieth of the normal, and nothing but old refuse was available in the market; cotton and yarn were doubled in price; the roads were unsafe owing to bands of desperate robbers, and even messengers ran the risk of being murdered. The famine, together with the war in the Deccan, had "disjointed all trade out of frame."
Early in the new year we hear of the increased cost of land transport; there is a warning not to pass saltpetre through the inland customs as sugar, lest it should be detained as provisions and the fraud be discovered; and the ships coming from England were advised to lay in rice on the voyage; but by this time the factors were perhaps resigned to the situation, and the correspondence is scanty. In June the rains promised well, and activity was renewed; cloth was coming in at Broach and Baroda "with the help of a ser of corn delivered out to the weavers on every piece brought," and there were hopes of making up some sort of a cargo for England. In September, however, the cost of indigo and cotton goods was found to be prohibitive, while food prices were at the highest point (about 6 lb. of grain for a rupee), and agues, fevers, and pestilential diseases prevailed in every house. The English merchants did not escape, for in October every one except the President was either dead or sick, and the President died in the following month. Gujarat, “the garden of the world,” was turned into a wilderness, with few or no cultivators or artisans; indigo was rotting on the ground for want of men to gather it; and the places which had yielded fifteen bales of cloth in a day could now produce barely three bales in a month. A Dutch factor writing at this time saw no hope of trade for three years to come, and the year 1631 closed in desolation.
Early in 1632 the tide of distress began to recede. It will have been apparent from van Twist's description that the calamities of 1631 were more local than those of the previous year; supplies were therefore available from less remote areas, and prices began to fall as grain arrived from outside. The worst of the misery was over, but the restoration of industry and commerce was a matter of years. Its slow progress may be traced in the reports of the English merchants. By February 1632 wheat was procurable at Broach, but the supplies at Surat were engrossed by the Governor and one or two traders. Ample rain fell this year on the East Coast, and there are no complaints regarding the season from Surat, but at the end of the year indigo, cotton goods, and other commodities were still very dear, while imports were almost unsaleable. Prices in November 1633 were so high as to offer no hope of profit in England, while in October 1634 India offered little or nothing on which to found a profitable trade. Prices on the East Coast were also too high for business, but a return to normal conditions was expected as the result of the good crops of that year. In December the factors at Surat wrote to the Company that the losses were incalculable, and that they could not see how to restore the trade; and they estimated that at least five years were still necessary for recovery. The rains of 1634 had, however, been exceptionally good, artisans were returning, and the cities were becoming repopulated. What follows has been quoted in part in the last chapter, but it will bear repetition.
The villages fill but slowly, yet it betters with them also ; and if the excessive tyranny and covetousness of the governors of all sorts would give the poor people leave but to lift up their heads in one year's vacancy from oppression, they would be enabled to keep cattle about them, and so to advance the plenty which the earth produceth that all things would be much more abundant, and there would be no want but of time to make the children capable to exercise the functions of their fathers.
This last phrase is noteworthy : one of the most lasting effects of such famines was the lowered level of skill resulting from the death of expert peasants and workmen, and the cotton goods of Gujarat suffered in reputation owing to this cause for many years. The gradual recovery proceeded unequally in different places ; by September 1635 steps were taken to re-establish factories at Ahmadabad and Baroda, but Broach was still “ not well peopled with weavers,” and a separate establishment there was considered useless.
The recovery of commerce is marked by a letter of December 1635, when the Surat factors reported that prices were steadily falling owing to the cheapness of grain and the return of inhabitants, and that they had decided to borrow enough capital to make a fresh start ; Gujarat could not, however, supply all they wanted, and they were extending their field of operations to Sind and Northern India in order to obtain sufficient goods. In January 1636, freight-goods for Persia were being offered by Indian merchants, and the correspondence about this time begins to record activity of the kind which had prevailed before the famine. By March the price of grain was below the old normal, and in April food-grains and raw cotton were sent from Surat to Masulipatam, where the effects of the Golconda drought of 1635 were being experienced. Baroda was now making good cloth in some plenty, but Broach was “ broken,” for, as a letter written in September says, “ the people are fled and dead, and now want of employment makes men afraid to return.” The correspondence of the year 1637 throws little light on the progress of events, but in December of 1638 a factor wrote that the country had recovered from famine, goods were to be had in abundance, and the prospects of commerce were very encouraging. We may say, then, that Gujarat was again prosperous by 1639, but with a reduced population, and a loss of skill, which was still affecting the quality of cotton goods and other manufactures. In the last respect, however, steady improvement was noticeable, and even Broach was beginning to make some progress : there remained the loss of reputation abroad, and the advantage which Gujarat had gained by priority in European markets had definitely passed away.
No detailed account can be given of this famine in the Deccan, since European factories did not exist there, but there are indications that the calamity was comparable in intensity to that which fell on Gujarat. The Badshahnama, which was written about the year 1650, classes the four Deccan provinces along with Gujarat as constituting exceptions to the general conditions prevailing in the Mogul Empire. The author gives figures to show that in the first twenty years of Shahjahan's reign the Imperial revenue had increased largely, but that these five provinces were stationary or even showed a decline in yield ; and he expressly attributes this fact to the famine of 1630-32. When Prince Aurangzeb became Viceroy of the Deccan in 1653, he found that, though the revenue demand had been reduced, it was still excessive, and the country, so far from contributing to the Imperial treasury, could not even pay for the local administration in his charge. The Deccan, therefore, remained impoverished for at any rate a generation.
This lengthy review of the progress and results of the famine of 1630 is justified by the frequency of similar events in the history of India. The extent and the intensity of famines varied within wide limits, but all that we know leads to the conclusion that their effects were similar in nature though they differed in degree. When once an actual insufficiency of food is known, or even suspected, to exist, and where adequate imports are impossible, it is certain that the people will endeavour to migrate, and in the circumstances of the time the attempt to migrate could result only in that "aimless wandering in search of food," which had become so traditional that, even in the present century, its first symptoms were regarded as the surest index to the need for immediate relief.1 The economic life of a village, a town, or a district, when once broken up by migration, disease, and death, could not quickly be renewed, and there are no signs in the literature of the period of such constructive measures of relief as would have been required to accelerate the process. Those wanderers who had survived would naturally return on the advent of a favourable season, and the old life would gradually be restored, but the recovery was a tedious business at the best, and, as we have seen in Gujarat, it might be delayed further by "the tyranny and covetousness of the governors." The loss of capital, particularly the peasant's working animals, the decline in the level of skill and knowledge, and the disrepute accruing in foreign markets are the features which concern the economist most directly: the attention of the social historian will be drawn rather to the waste of life and the intensity of human misery recurring so frequently on varying scales.
AUTHORITIES FOR CHAPTER VII
Section 1.—The references for the list of famines are as follows:—For 1614–15, Elliot, vi. 346; Tuzuk, i. 330. For 1618–19, Hague Transcripts, I. 162; Faria y Sousa, iii. 298; and Methwold, 993. For 1635, Dagh Register, March 22, June 10, and October 31, 1636. For 1640, idem, March 31, 1641. For 1641, idem, December 26, 1641; June 20, November 3, 1642. For 1642, idem (Coromandel), February 15 and October 16, 1643. For 1645–46, English Factories, viii. 46, 54 n., 68-74, 163, 198. For 1647, idem, viii. 157, 192. For 1648, idem, viii. 246, 259. For 1650, idem, viii. 322, ix. 10, 29, 82. For 1658, idem, x. 196, 210. For 1659–60, idem, x. 257, 263, 306, 401, 407; Dagh Register, January 13, February 17, and May 16, 1661; Elliot, vii. 263.
Section 2.—For the extent of the famine of 1630, see English Factories, iv. passim; Mundy, ii. 55 ff.; Elliot, vii. 24. Its story is scattered all through English Factories, iv.; van Twist's narrative is c. III. For relief measures, see Elliot, vii. 24; Etheridge, 39, 63; Mundy, ii. 49, 50, 56. The account of effects on industry and commerce is compiled from English Factories, iv.; and of the gradual recovery, from idem, iv., v. The facts regarding the Deccan are taken from Badshahnama, ii. 710, and Sarkar's Aurangzeb, i. 170 ff.
Notes
- 1. Mr. Loveday shows 1623 and 1628–29 as years of famine (Appendix A of The History and Economics of Indian Famines), but these entries are not correct. His authority for the former year is Etheridge, p. 40; Etheridge wrongly took 1623 as the equivalent of the Hijra year 1040 (which really began in July 1630), and the events which he attributes to 1623 in fact occurred in the great famine of 1630. Etheridge (p. 63) is also the authority for 1628–29, but the facts which he records under it are clearly the same as those which he gives under the Hijra year 1040, and should be assigned to 1630. The seasons of 1628 and 1629 were not favourable, and the yield of indigo had been reduced (English Factories, iv. 20); in the latter year the rains began late and were unduly heavy at the close (Hague Transcripts, I. 298); but the commercial correspondence gives no hint of anything like a famine, and in April 1630 both Dutch and English merchants were busy and hopeful.
- 1. “ Painters ” is the term ordinarily used to denote the producers of pintados, or painted cottons.
- 1. The title-page of van Twist's pamphlet shows that he had been senior merchant in Ahmadabad, Cambay, Broach, and Baroda. He is mentioned incidentally in the Dagh Register from 1631 onwards: in 1636 he was sent on a special mission to the Court at Bijapur; and not long afterwards he was appointed Governor of Malacca, where he died. I have not seen a copy of the Batavia issue of his pamphlet, but the title-page of the reprint in Begin ende Voortgangh states that it was reproduced from the edition printed at Batavia in 1638. The English narratives of this famine have been brought together in Mundy, ii. Appendix A; they appear also in English Factories, iv. Abdul Hamid's account is translated in Elliot, vii. 24.
- 1. This number is not to be taken literally, but rather as an idiomatic expression signifying that the mortality was incalculable.
- 1. See the Report of the Indian Famine Commission, 1901, p. 14.