In the foregoing chapters I have discussed such information as I have been able to collect regarding the economic conditions which prevailed in India during the reigns of Jahangir and Shahjahan. The task remains of estimating the changes which took place during this period, and of attempting a rough balance-sheet, which may go some way towards answering the questions whether the national income was increasing or diminishing, and whether its distribution was approaching to, or receding from, modern standards of equity. At first sight, the outstanding facts are the appearance in India of agents of the great commercial companies formed in Holland and England, and their gradual penetration into all the most productive regions of the country; but on a closer examination the economist, while recognising the eventual significance of those phenomena, is led to attach greater immediate importance to the administrative changes of the period, which intensified existing defects in the system of distribution, and thereby brought about a marked and cumulative reaction on productive industry. On the one hand, India benefited by an increase in the efficiency of the marketing agencies at her disposal, but on the other she suffered from the intensification of the economic parasitism which was destroying her productive energies: some localities, and some classes of producers, profited by the new external facilities, but the country taken as a whole was being impoverished by the operation of internal forces; and in my judgment there can be no question that the final balance is on the adverse side of the account.
Among the external agencies at work, the Dutch Company was much the most important. On the eastern side of India Dutch enterprise secured the initiative, and maintained its predominance throughout our period: in the west it quickly surpassed the results attained by the English, who had there the advantage of priority. From the Indian point of view, the presence of two competing organisations was undoubtedly beneficial. The English merchants during our period realised very scanty profits after allowance has been made for the heavy losses incurred from time to time, but they succeeded in retaining a position in Indian trade, and it was mainly through their efforts to do so that the country was saved from the grip of a commercial monopoly such as the Dutch established in some other parts of Asia.
The conditions which prevailed in India were such as to prevent any large development of the import-trade. The masses of the people were too poor to be interested in such foreign goods as were then available: the middle classes were few in number, and were debarred from ostentatious expenditure by the fear of official rapacity; while the market offered by the Courts and their dependant nobles was small in volume, and was governed mainly by fashion or caprice. Indian consumers benefited where there was competition among importers, but suffered where a monopoly was established, and payment for most of the new exports was taken in the precious metals. The additional imports of gold and silver were not, however, in excess of the absorptive capacity of the country taken as a whole, and they produced no marked change in the general level of prices, though the sudden extension of trade in Bengal resulted in that market being brought more nearly on a level with the conditions prevailing elsewhere on the coast.
On the export side, the main result of the Dutch and English activities was to secure new and extensive markets for Indian producers of indigo, calico, saltpetre, raw silk, and a variety of other items of less individual importance. Indian merchants had made no effective attempts to exploit these markets, while Portuguese activities during the preceding century had produced only limited results: the large consumption of Indian silk in Japan, and of Indian calico and saltpetre in Western Europe, are definitely new facts of commerce, while the increase in the use of indigo in the latter region was so great that it may fairly be placed in the same category. Some allowance must indeed be made for a temporary decline in the export of pepper, but this loss cannot be regarded as equivalent to more than a small proportion of the new trade. The direct advantage accruing to India was confined to particular localities, which were enabled to dispose of an increased amount of material, and to find remunerative employment for certain classes of the people; the increase in the income of these localities may be described without exaggeration as substantial, but it could scarcely make a large difference if it were spread over the whole population of the country.
The insistent Indian demand for the precious metals led the European merchants to take a large share in the Asiatic carrying-trade. It is possible, but in my opinion it is unlikely, that their activities in this direction resulted in a large proportionate increase in the existing export-trade to other parts of Asia; it is certain that they resulted in important changes in the shipping industry. The burden of these changes fell mainly on the Portuguese ship-owners, who lost most of the business they had acquired in the course of the preceding century, but Indian owners also were injuriously affected to an extent which differed in different regions, but was probably greatest in Gujarat; on the other hand, Indian exporters benefited by the provision of a more efficient carrying-service, the charges for which were kept down by active competition.
The immediate effects of European activities were thus local and partial. It is unquestionable that they brought substantial economic benefit to growers of indigo and cotton, to weavers, to producers of silk and saltpetre, to the land-transport industry, and to export merchants, classes of much greater importance in the aggregate than the pepper-growers, ship-owners, and ship-builders who may have been adversely affected by their operations; there was thus a substantial balance of advantage for India, but not, in my opinion, of such magnitude as to represent a proportionately great increase in the total of the national income. Further, there was the gain resulting from the establishment of a new business organisation, by which Indian producers were brought into close relations with the markets of Western Europe; in the latter portion of our period there was a practical certainty that whatever India had to sell would be offered in London, Paris, and Amsterdam, while the competition between the Companies usually sufficed to secure reasonable prices to the sellers. The development of external relations had thus brought substantial benefit at the moment, and a promise of greater benefit to come.
On the other hand, the internal forces in operation were wholly injurious. The demands made by the various Governments on producers were so large that there is no exaggeration in the statement that administrative activities were the most important factors in the distribution of the national income. Speaking generally, their effect was to leave to producers very little, if anything, above the minimum required for their subsistence, and to offer the surplus in rewards to energy or ingenuity exerted in unproductive ways. In the south of India the administrative system operated steadily in this direction throughout our period, and here the changes to be recorded are comparatively slight: pressure on producers tended to intensify, because the local authorities had the strongest motives to discover every possible form of income, and to increase their demand to the utmost on those forms which were already familiar; but the system itself was unchanged, and even at the opening of our period its severity was such that a great increase of pressure could have led only to starvation or rebellion. In the north, on the other hand, there was a definite change in system. Akbar's financial institutions, which, judged by modern standards, were severe, but not necessarily inequitable or destructive in their operation, gave way under his successors, and the direct demand on production was largely increased, while the simultaneous deterioration in administrative methods resulted in a steady approximation to the conditions which already prevailed in the south. The effect of these changes is shown by direct contemporary evidence to have been a diversion of energy from productive to unproductive pursuits, a process which was necessarily cumulative in its effects, and which is to my mind the outstanding economic fact of the half-century. Almost throughout India the tendency was to reduce the reward of production to a point where it ceased to offer an adequate incentive, to attract brains and energy to the struggle for a share in what had been produced by others, and thus to lead the way towards the national bankruptcy which eventually occurred.
Such are the conclusions which I have drawn from the evidence which has been examined. The question has still to be asked whether the account is substantially complete, or whether other important developments may have occurred of which the evidence on record gives no hint. So far as the departments of production and transport are concerned, this question can be answered with practical certainty. The records of the Dutch and English commercial activities cover practically the entire field; the possibilities of every commodity and every means of transport were discussed and tested by competent men, not governed by routine, but energetically exploring every course which might yield a profit; and it does not appear to be possible that any development of real economic importance can have been overlooked. The same conclusion is certainly true of the consumption of imported goods, the trade in which fell mainly into the foreign merchants' hands; the need for curtailing the use of the precious metals urged them to foster the import-trade in every possible way, and the small results known to have been secured may safely be taken to cover the whole ground. The possibility remains of unrecorded changes in the Indian consumption of Indian goods. The Dutch and English had not yet entered largely into the internal trade by land, though they were familiar with most branches of the coasting trade, and it is conceivable that internal changes might have occurred without finding a record in their correspondence. It is difficult, however, to conjecture any important changes of this kind; I have found no suggestions of them in chronicles or journals of the period; there are no signs of any marked alteration in the standard of living; and the spending-power of the people was in any case so small that the presumption is altogether against the occurrence of anything of the sort. We may infer that some weavers, saltpetre-makers, or indigo-growers found themselves in a position to eat rather more food, or to spend rather more on clothes and metals; we may infer in the same way that large numbers of peasants found life harder; but there do not appear to be grounds for travelling further into the region of conjecture.
The low standard of life, and the small spending-power of the people, are, however, facts established by direct evidence, and perhaps the best way of bringing this study to a conclusion will be to attempt a reduction to its lowest terms of the economic system from which these facts emerge. Let us imagine, then, a self-supporting community, consisting of five producers, each securing about the same income, and one non-producing consumer, whom we may describe either as a policeman or as a parasite. A simple sum in arithmetic shows that, in order to secure equality of income in this community, each producer should surrender one-sixth of his income to the parasite or policeman. If now, in place of a rule of equality, we introduce the revenue system as it worked under Shahjahan, so that each producer surrenders one-half instead of one-sixth, then the income of the policeman or parasite will be five times that of each individual producer, and, provided that the conditions of his existence are in other respects tolerable, there will be an exceedingly strong temptation for each producer to secure his place. If we multiply this community by some figure of the order of 4 millions,1 we get something very like the economic skeleton of the India of our period. The bulk of the peasants and artisans of all classes lived on practically the same level, and, while there must have been individual differences due to skill or fortune, we are justified in assuming that they diverged from the norm to about the same extent on either side, so that we can think of the mass as homogeneous. The proportion of "parasites" to producers cannot of course be determined accurately, but the figure I have taken seems to me to be probably an over-statement.1 Neither cities nor armies had greatly increased during our period, for local advances are offset by retrogression elsewhere, and there is no doubt that peasants formed the bulk of the population, while the proportion of artisans was at any rate substantial; and, without attempting to secure numerical exactitude, it is safe to say that a relatively large number of producers contributed half their gross income to the support of a relatively small number of economic parasites. The latter class was not, however, economically homogeneous, for it extended from the greatest noble to the humblest slave; in point of fact, most of the parasites lived on substantially the same plane as the producers, and it was only the small minority which engaged actively in the struggle for the surplus product. There was thus a very large income to be divided between a very small number of competitors, and, since saving resulted only in confiscation at death, the dividend was usually spent as quickly as it accrued. The conditions thus rendered inevitable the extravagant luxury of the nobles which struck foreign observers so strongly, and the dissipation of the surplus income of the country in unproductive channels. The humbler parasites, while living on the same plane as producers, were in some important respects substantially better off. If, for instance, seasons were bad, the peon's wages might buy less food, but the peasant might see his wife and children sold into slavery; and the general result of the administrative changes which occurred during our period was to increase this disparity to a point where the producer's life ceased to be worth living. He bore the brunt of the struggle with natural forces, but he could hope to retain no appreciable portion of the spoils, which were employed in maintaining a few parasites in luxury, and a much greater number in a life of comparative security.
The unproductive population was to be found mainly in towns or camps, while production was carried on chiefly in the villages, so that, from a somewhat different standpoint, the economic system of our period may be regarded as operating to provide the urban population with subsistence below cost. The harvest-glut is still a familiar fact in India : a disproportionate amount of the season's produce has to be marketed within a few weeks in order to provide for necessary payments in cash ; and forced sellers have to be content with lower prices than would be obtainable in a market to which they were not compelled to come. At the period we are considering, this recurring glut must have been much more acute than now,1 because the proportion of produce to be sold was much larger, while the penalties attaching to default were much more severe. At each harvest, then, there was an urgent demand for coin, and the merchants who held coin in stock could practically make their own terms. They had, however, to turn over their stock of produce in time to be in funds for the next harvest, and, since the urban population was proportionately small, this condition secured to them supplies of food and other produce at less cost than if the markets had been free. The cheapness of food in Indian towns was one of the first facts to strike foreign visitors, who were usually content to attribute it to the fertility of the country ; but there can be no doubt that the working of the revenue system was a factor of at least equal importance in transferring to the towns a large proportion of the profits earned in the villages.
Such was the economic system which at the close of our period was drawing towards collapse. Weavers, naked themselves, toiled to clothe others. Peasants, themselves hungry, toiled to feed the towns and cities. India, taken as a unit, parted with useful commodities in exchange for gold and silver, or in other words gave bread for stones. Men and women, living from season to season on the verge of hunger, could be contented so long as the supply of food held out : when it failed, as it so often did, their hope of salvation was the slave-trader, and the alternatives were cannibalism, suicide, or starvation. The only way of escape from that system lay through an increase in production, coupled with a rising standard of life, but this road was barred effectively by the administrative methods in vogue, which penalised production, and regarded every indication of increased consumption as a signal for fresh extortion. The period of which I have written is characterised primarily by the extension and the intensification of those methods : the story of the century which followed is the story, first of the eventual collapse, and then of the gradual change, which was in time to render a new economic system possible.
Notes
- 1. That is to say, about 20 to 25 million households, which I take to be about the standard of the population of India at this period.
- 1. The figures of the census of 1911 give a proportion of about one "parasite" to nine producers, as against the assumed ratio of one to five.
- 1. The statement in the text is correct whether revenue was paid in cash or in grain. The treasury required silver, and, while in some provinces receipts of grain may have been disbursed for local needs, much of it must have been sold in order to provide silver for remittance, and in fixing prices merchants would take that fact into account. The regulations of the period contemplate cash payments as the rule, but there were probably local exceptions.