Preface

The History & Economics of Indian Famines, Alexander Loveday, 1914 · from page vii · about 3 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

The following attempt to sketch the history of past famines in India had its origin in an essay which was awarded the Le Bas Prize in 1913. But, with the permission of the adjudicators, I have made considerable alterations both in scope and method. In order to estimate in any way adequately the value of the work performed by the British and preceding governments in their struggles against those natural calamities to which India is periodically subject, it is necessary to consider not merely the actual details of relief organisation, or of works of protection against droughts, but also the economic evolution of that country, and the extent to which that evolution has influenced this work, or been modified by it. It has therefore been deemed advisable, after tracing the history of famines in the first four chapters, to extend the radius of the inquiry and outline some of the main features of the agricultural and industrial changes which have taken place in India within the last century. With this object in view Chapter V. has been completely reconstructed. It is in intent neither a criticism nor, strictly speaking, an historical account, but rather an attempt to discover and trace the growth of those forces which have modified the economic life of India, and affected the treatment of her “calamities.” Comparatively slight use has been made of statistics, because the accuracy of older records and estimates becomes more and more questionable as history recedes into the dimmer light of the past; and it is scarcely possible to calculate at any given date the allowance which should be made for this element of doubt. On the other hand special care has been taken to verify any statements taken from works other than official publications, and when such verification has proved impossible the fact is made clear either in the text itself, or in footnotes. But the official publications themselves present certain peculiarities, which seem to demand a word of preliminary explanation. It is the inevitable result of every foreign dominion, however excellent in itself, that it should suffer violent and continual opposition. Only to a limited degree can it base its power on public opinion and consent. But tacit, qualified, and uninspiring as the sympathy of its subjects must be, it is as essential to success and more negatively powerful than the force of the sword itself. In a democratic government the opposition is constitutionalised; in a bureaucratic or despotic, it is revolutionary. Placed, as it is then, between the paramount necessity of winning such sympathy as it can on the one side, and of defending itself against the attacks of its critics on the other, it is inevitable that the government of India should mingle something of the spirit of a party pamphlet in certain of its official publications. To bear in mind when reading its reports that, in some instances, it has attempted to prove a case as well as to state facts is no reflection on the sterling honesty of that government.

My sincerest thanks are due to Mr. W. C. Macpherson, C.S.I., for most kindly reading through the essay and giving me many invaluable criticisms. But while expressing my very real sense of obligation to him, I must add that he read the essay in a comparatively early stage of its development, and that he should in no way be held responsible either for the views expressed, or any errors which may have crept into it since. I have also to thank Mr. J. D. Anderson and Father C. Joppen, S.J., for various suggestions, and my brother and sister for reading through the manuscript.

St. Peter's College, Cambridge, 1913.