Chapter II

— Prehistoric Antiquities

The Imperial Gazetteer of India, Vol. II, The India Office, 1908 · from page 89 · about 22 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

KNOWLEDGE of the condition of mankind in the dim ages of the past which lie beyond the ken of history or tradition is attainable only by scientific interpretation of the scanty material relics of human workmanship—the tools, weapons, tombs, and pottery—which survive from those remote times. Archaeologists are agreed that the successive stages of nascent civilization in the prehistoric world are best distinguished by noting the degrees of progress in the metallurgic arts.

The period during which iron was, as it now is, in familiar use is known as the Iron Age. The next preceding period, when implements now commonly made of iron were made of bronze, is called the Bronze Age. The still earlier period, when men knew not the use of metals, but were compelled to rely for all purposes of war, the chase, and domestic industry upon rude instruments of wood, bone, or stone, is designated the Stone Age.

In many countries two subdivisions of the Stone Age are clearly to be distinguished. The earlier, termed the Palaeolithic or Old Stone Age, is characterized by chipped stone implements, rude in form, and frequently associated with the remains of extinct animals. The later, termed the Neolithic or New Stone Age, is characterized by the prevalence of a higher type of implements, commonly ground or polished, and associated with remains of the fauna now existing. The palaeolithic men were ignorant of the potter’s art and built no sepulchres. During the neolithic period, pottery, at first hand-made, and afterwards turned on the wheel, was in constant use, and the dead were honoured by elaborate tombs, frequently built of massive stones.

By imperceptible gradations the Neolithic passes into the Bronze, and the Bronze into the Iron Age, but between the Palaeolithic and the Neolithic Ages a great gulf seems to be fixed. Most parts of Europe, Western Asia, and Egypt certainly passed in prehistoric times through all these four ages, or stages of civilization ; but the course of evolution has often been less regular, and many examples of abrupt transition from the Stone Age to the Iron Age might be cited. Numerous savage tribes were recently, and some, perhaps, still are, ignorant of the use of metal, and have remained in the stage attained by the ancestors of the civilized races many thousands of years ago. In India generally the Bronze Age is missing, and the transition from polished stone to iron was effected directly, but in some parts of the country tools and weapons were made of pure copper before iron came into ordinary use.

The first clearly recognized discovery in India of an implement belonging to the Stone Age was made by Mr. Le Mesurier in 1861. Since that date numerous writers have accumulated observations, and a considerable mass of material for a systematic account of Indian prehistoric antiquities is now in existence, but the task of writing such an account has not yet been undertaken. The officers of the Archaeological Survey, with the notable exceptions of Mr. Alexander Rea and the late Mr. A. C. Carlleyle, have been too much occupied with the study of historic monuments to devote attention to the obscure relics of a more remote past, and the observations on which a treatise descriptive of prehistoric India might be based remain buried in the pages of technical periodicals.

The following sketch, which must necessarily be brief, may perhaps be of service by stimulating interest in the subject, and indicating the lines of future research.

The geological evidence in India, as in Europe, indicates the existence of a wide gap of untold centuries between the remains of palaeolithic and those of neolithic men. Between the Neolithic and the Iron Ages no such gap exists. In the prehistoric settlements of the Deccan Mr. Bruce Foote has observed that these two stages of civilization overlap, and has thus obtained direct evidence that the people of the ancient Iron Age were direct descendants of their stone-using predecessors. Many of the existing tribes and castes are no doubt descended from the neolithic peoples, but there is no evidence of continuity between the palaeolithic men whose remains are found in the river gravels and any subsequent element of the population.

Only two cases in India seem to be known where stone implements have been found in fossiliferous beds associated with the remains of extinct animals. Mr. Hacket was fortunate enough to discover a well-made ovate instrument of chipped quartzite at Bhutra in the Narbadā Valley (about N. lat. 23°), lying in undisturbed post-tertiary gravels containing the bones of Hippopotamus namadicus and other extinct mammals. Mr. Wynne obtained an agate flake from similar gravels in the Godāvari Valley (G. I., p. 386; pl. xxi, 1, 2). Most of the implements which must, for geological reasons, be classed as palaeolithic, have been found in laterite deposits, which are, unfortunately, destitute of fossils. Mr. Bruce Foote has been very successful in detecting rude implements, usually of quartzite, in beds of detrital laterite—a ferruginous rock overlying gneiss—in Southern India, and has traced their distribution over an area comprising eight degrees of latitude (N. lat. 10° to 18°). They are especially numerous near Madras city, and in the neighbourhood of Ongole in Guntūr District. More systematic search will probably reveal them in many other localities. Implements similar in form and material, but apparently of neolithic age, have been obtained by several observers in large numbers among the Kōn ravines of South Mirzāpur (N. lat. 24° 25′).

The distinction between palaeolithic and neolithic antiquities should be based rather on the nature of the situations in which they are respectively found than on the style of workmanship, which is a very unsafe guide. The implements from the Kōn ravines and those with which the great monoliths of Stonehenge were dressed, although both of neolithic age, are quite as rude as those found in the Madras laterite, which must undoubtedly be classed as palaeolithic, and are far inferior to many of the finely chipped implements from the river gravels of France and England, to which a very remote antiquity is assigned.

Ossiferous caves, like those which in Western Europe have yielded innumerable relics of palaeolithic times, seem to be unknown in India.

Bone implements, so common in Europe, are in India very rare. Mr. Carlleyle excavated a serrated fish-bone, perhaps an arrow-head, from Gangetic alluvium in Ghāzīpur District, lying below a stratum which contained polished neolithic tools (A. S. R., xxii, 102).

All that is known at present about palaeolithic man in India may be summed up in the brief statement that rude stone implements found in laterite beds and ossiferous gravels south of parallel 25° of north latitude reveal the existence of a race of men contemporary with animals now extinct. Even the skulls and skeletons of these men, who made no pottery and built no tombs, have disappeared. The geological problems connected with the implement-bearing beds of India require investigation much fuller than that which they have yet received.

Implements of the neolithic period abound in India. They have been observed in the Peninsula from the extreme south to parallel 18° of N. latitude ; and all along the southern border of the Gangetic Valley in the Vindhyan and other ranges which separate the plains of Northern India from the Deccan the soil ‘teems’ with them. Mr. Cockburn notes that he picked up fifty chert knives and two broken celts in a field near his house at Bāndā in Bundelkhand, and that he does ‘not remember ever having gone out on a search for implements to return unrewarded.’ In Bengal and the Punjab stone implements seem to be rare. Only two finds of celts from the latter Province are recorded, but when carefully searched for others will doubtless be found. The antiquities of the Punjab, historic and prehistoric, have received scant attention. The hills at Rohrī on the Indus in Sind yield copious supplies of singularly large and perfect flakes of nummulitic flint, as well as of the cores from which the flakes were struck. The Rohri implements, of which many specimens may be seen in English museums, are probably of neolithic age. Examples of neolithic implements have been found at a few sites in the Gangetic alluvium, as well as among the hills and deserts of Rājputāna, and probably exist in every Indian Province.

The various forms of the Indian implements on the whole are identical with those familiar to European antiquaries ; but a shouldered celt with an edge like that of a carpenter's plane, which is common in the Irrawaddy Valley of Burma, and occasionally occurs in the hilly regions of Western Bengal, seems to be unknown in Europe.

The so-called ‘pygmy flints,’ believed to be of neolithic age, which are now known to occur in England and other countries, were first discovered by the late Mr. A. C. Carlleyle in 1867–8 at a pass in the Vindhya Hills about thirty miles south-south-west of Allahābād. Subsequently the same explorer obtained thousands of these tiny implements in Baghelkhand, Rewah, and the southern parts of Mirzāpur District. The richest treasures of this class were found under shallow deposits of earth or sandy gravel on the floors of caves or rock-shelters, associated with the ashes and charcoal of hearths and lumps of ruddle or haematite. Rude paintings made with ruddle on the walls and roofs of the caves seem to be coeval with the implements. A few specimens were found in tumuli containing entire skeletons and coarse pottery. Mr. Carlleyle does not state whether the pottery was hand-made or turned on the wheel. The little implements, which vary in length from half an inch to an inch and a half, comprise delicately made arrow-heads, crescents, and sundry pointed and rhomboidal forms. The material is frequently chalcedony. Exactly similar miniature implements occur at several stations in England, and in the valley of the Meuse in Belgium. The numerous specimens excavated by the Rev. R. A. Gatty from sand-drifts at Scunthorpe in Lincolnshire are remarkable for their extremely minute size, the smallest being no more than three-sixteenths of an inch in length. The Scunthorpe sites appear to be, like the Vindhyan ones, the floors of dwellings. The occurrence of these miniature implements in immense numbers on the sites of huts indicates that they must have served purposes of ordinary life; but what those purposes were it is difficult to determine. Most probably they were used by being fitted into wooden holders and handles of various kinds, and so made to serve a great variety of functions. In some parts of Australia the natives still employ, or recently employed, minute flakes of flint as arrow-heads, knives, &c., by fitting them to wooden holders with the aid of strongly adhesive resin. The manufacture of the ‘pygmy flints’ evidently extended over a long period, and there is reason to believe that the earlier examples go back to the beginnings of the Neolithic Age. It is possible that they are the memorials of the survivors of palaeolithic men, working as the slaves or dependents of the more advanced neolithic races1. If this view should find support, the common belief that a great gap divides the palaeolithic from the neolithic period will require modification.

Mr. Bruce Foote has recorded interesting brief descriptions of the sites of several neolithic settlements and implement factories in Southern India. The implements were polished on gneiss rocks, which exhibit grooves 10–14 inches long, and nearly 2 inches deep. The pottery found in abundance at these settlements is described as being all wheel-made, and ‘of very high class for Indian pottery,’ although not to be compared with Etruscan or Greek ware. Stone beads also occur, as well as pieces of haematite, used apparently for the manufacture of pigment. A systematic account of the neolithic settlements in the South is much to be desired.

The ‘cinder-mounds’ of Southern India, of which about a dozen are known, for the most part in the Bellary District of Madras, present a puzzling problem. Mr. Sewell gives plausible reasons for believing the great mound at Nimbāpur near the ruined city of Vijayanagar to have been the scene of the awful sacrifices of women, up to the number of five hundred at a time, which used to be offered at royal funerals as late as the sixteenth century. Mr. Bruce Foote, on the other hand, maintains that all the ‘cinder-mounds’ are of neolithic age, and is supported in his opinion by the fact that the Būdigunta mound, which is certainly the result of wholesale holocausts of animals, actually yields neolithic implements. Possibly the ‘cinder-mounds’ may extend over a very wide range of time. The problem of their origin cannot be solved until they have been systematically surveyed and explored.

The class of prehistoric objects known as ‘cup-marks’ and ‘ring-marks,’ described by Sir J. Y. Simpson, with special reference to Great Britain, in his work on Archaic Sculpturings upon Stones and Rocks, is well represented in India. This branch of archaeology has been chiefly studied by Mr. H. Rivett-Carnac, C.I.E., whose publications give full details, and discuss the various theories propounded in explanation of the markings, which are probably to be referred, for the most part, to neolithic times.

The ruddle, or haematite, drawings discovered by Carlleyle in the caves of the Vindhyan Hills have been referred to as being probably in part coeval with the neolithic ‘pygmy flints.’ Similar drawings, which depict hunting scenes, occur in the Kaimur Hills. Carlleyle, unfortunately, never published any detailed account of his discoveries. The primitive form of the weapons delineated on the walls of the Kaimur caves supports the hypothesis that the drawings are of neolithic age (J. R. A. S., 1899, p. 89). On sheltered surfaces the stain produced by ruddle may last for an indefinite number of centuries, and it is quite possible that the drawings in the Kaimur caves may be 3,000 years old, or even more.

In prehistoric, as in modern India, various methods for the disposal of the dead were adopted. The men of palaeolithic times probably abandoned their dead in the forests, as the Oritae of Gedrosia (Makrān) continued to do in the days of Alexander the Great. In the Neolithic Age burial was perhaps the rule, and it seems certain that the practice of burial is older than that of cremation.

Examples of sepulchres which can be referred with confidence to the neolithic period are rare in India, where most of the megalithic tombs belong to the Iron Age. The stone implements from the Kōn ravines in South Mirzāpur, already mentioned, are associated with neolithic interments. Another certainly neolithic cemetery near the town of Mirzāpur was visited by Mr. Cockburn, who was present at the excavation of two graves. The grave fully excavated was 6 or 8 ft. deep, enclosed in a stone circle about 12 ft. in diameter, and contained the skeleton of an adult male of large size, lying north and south on a thick stone slab. A flat dish of ‘glazed’ pottery was placed at the head of the skeleton, and a similar vessel lay at each corner of the tomb, which also contained ‘a long narrow lachrymal vase of green glass about 7 inches long1.’ In the second grave opened two stone hammers and sundry flint flakes were found.

Captain Cole found two fragments of stone implements associated with piles of pottery, evidently wheel-made, in a cemetery comprising fifty-four tombs at Māshalli in the Kolār District of Mysore. No metal object was discovered in this cemetery, which must be referred to a late period of the Neolithic Age (I. A., ii, 86). At Daosa, in the Jaipur State of Rājputāna, Mr. Carlleyle observed rude stone implements in cairn tombs (A. S. R., vi, 107, pl. ii).

The tombs at Pallāvaram near Madras city are earthen mounds covering terra-cotta coffins, which are of two kinds, oblong and pyriform. The former, about 6 ft. in length, were used for females, who were buried in the extended position. The latter, about 2¼ ft. in height, were used for males, who were buried in the contracted position. Large quantities of pottery, apparently wheel-made, were found in these tombs, but no objects of either stone or metal1.

Oblong terra-cotta sarcophagi, standing on short legs, similar to those used for the interment of females at Pallāvaram, have been discovered at various places in the Madras Districts of Chingleput, Nellore, South and North Arcot, sometimes associated with iron implements. The Pallāvaram examples may be of neolithic age. The Indian oblong sarcophagi are practically identical in form with similar objects found at Gehrāreh near Baghdād (I. A., v, 255). This fact is one of many indications connecting archaic Indian civilization with that of Babylonia and Assyria, which suggest tempting ethnological speculations.

Megalithic tombs in great variety of form abound throughout Madras, Bombay, Mysore, and the Nizām’s Dominions. They generally contain iron implements, and are evidently of very various ages, some being truly prehistoric and of remote antiquity, while others may be described as modern. The examples in the Nīlgiri Hills, explored by Mr. Breeks, extend over many centuries down to 1596, which is the date (Saka 1518) of a Tamil inscription on one.

The fine bronze vases and other ornamental objects found in the more ancient tombs on the Nīlgiri Hills evidently date from the early centuries of the Christian era, when the Kurumba, or Pallava, power commanded an extensive sea-borne trade. The bronze used is a malleable alloy, composed of copper (70·11) and tin (29·89 per cent.)

The human remains found in the megalithic tombs have been sometimes buried, but, perhaps, more frequently cremated. Occasionally, a single sepulchre contains traces of cremation as well as of burial.

Examples of urn-burial, not of cremated ashes, but of the whole body, occur at places as wide apart as Brahmanābād in Sind and Tinnevelly District at the extremity of the Peninsula. Large jars, narrow at the neck and pointed at the bottom, were used, and the body must have been reduced in bulk either by dissection or by pounding before it could be passed through the narrow neck. Similar jars occur in Babylonia, where they were coated with bitumen on the inside. The Indian examples substitute for the bitumen a black smear, or false glaze, prepared from the juice of the Abutilon indicum.

The great cemetery at Adichanallūr, in Tinnevelly District, partially explored by Mr. Rea, covers an area of 114 acres, and it is estimated that about 1,000 urns are buried in each acre. The presence of a few stone implements indicates that parts of this necropolis may be very ancient, but most of the tombs contain iron implements and bronze ornaments of comparatively recent date. Mr. Rea’s collection made at this site includes seven gold ornaments, which very rarely occur in Indian tombs. The artistic and ethnological problems suggested by the discoveries in Tinnevelly District still await discussion.

India, as already observed, had no Bronze Age ; that is to say, weapons and tools now made of iron or steel were very rarely made of bronze. That material was ordinarily employed only for vases, lamps, and other ornamental purposes, and did not come into common use until long after iron was familiar. But there are clear indications that in a considerable portion of Northern India tools and weapons made of practically pure copper were in use for a time, and the facts fully warrant the assumption that a Copper Age intervened between the Neolithic and Iron Ages.

‘The most important discovery,’ observes Sir John Evans, ‘of instruments of copper as yet recorded in the Old World is that which was made at Gungeria in Central India’ in 1870. The treasure, which was found carefully packed in a pit near Gungeria, a village in the Bālāghāt District of the Central Provinces (about N. lat. 22°), consisted of 424 copper implements, weighing 829 lb., and 102 thin silver plates, weighing 6 lb. The copper articles include ‘bar-celts’ more than 2 ft. long, and ‘flat celts’ of very primitive forms. Twenty-one of these implements are in the British Museum, and no two of them are identical in shape. The specimen with the most widely splayed edge closely resembles an Irish bronze celt in the Franks collection, and a copper one in the National Museum of Ireland ; while other examples recall Babylonian, Egyptian, and even Peruvian patterns. On the whole, they resemble Irish specimens more closely than those of any other country.

The silver plates comprise circular discs and figures of a bull’s head with horns (or ? ears) turned down, probably intended for attachment to sacred objects. Notwithstanding the presence of silver in this unique hoard, the probability is that a remote date must be assigned to both the copper tools and the silver ornaments. The Irish copper celts, many of which are almost identical with Gungeria specimens, are assigned to the period between 2,000 and 1,500 b.c., and it is quite possible that the Indian copper implements and weapons may be as old as the Irish. Silver, although perhaps unknown in the South before 600 or 700 b.c., may have been introduced into the North by land routes at a much earlier period. So far as is known, the metal was never produced in considerable quantity from Indian mines; it has always been an important item in the list of imports. Copper, on the other hand, is widely diffused in India, and the sites of ancient mines are known. The reddish ayas of the Veda cannot have been either iron or bronze, and must have been copper. The copper implements of the Gungeria hoard, and the fine celts, swords, and spear-heads of the same material, found from time to time in the Cawnpore, Fatehgarh, Mainpuri, and Muttra Districts in the Gangetic Valley, were probably made of Indian copper.

The approximate date of the introduction of a knowledge of iron into India cannot at present be determined. This metal, which was in common use in Egypt in the seventh century b.c., does not appear there much before 800 b.c. This latter date may be the anterior limit for the appearance of iron in Southern India, which was in communication with Egypt from very early times, while still severed from Northern India by an almost impassable barrier of mountain and forest. But in Babylonia iron was known from remote antiquity, and it is possible that the people of Northern India may have been familiar with the metal long before it became common in the isolated South. At the time of Alexander’s invasion (326 b.c.) the armed nations of Northern India were far superior in the art of war to the other nations of Asia, and were as well versed in the use of iron and steel as the Greeks themselves. Quintus Curtius mentions that the chiefs of the Punjab presented Alexander with 100 talents of steel (ferrum candidum). The Greek accounts of Indian civilization as a whole imply that the nations of the Punjab and Sind in the fourth century b.c. had long emerged from the conditions involved in the use of stone or copper tools and weapons. The Iron Age in Northern India may well go back to 1500 or even 2000 b.c.

VINCENT A. SMITH.

SELECTED REFERENCES

Indian Antiquary (I.A.). Walhouse, iv, 12, ‘Archaeological Notes, Miniature and Prehistoric Pottery’; ibid., 302, ‘Bronze Antiquities in India.’ Vanstavern, ibid., 305, ‘Notes on the Antiquities found in parts of the Upper Godāvari and Krishnā Districts.’ Garstin and Walhouse, v, 159, 255, ‘Dolmens in the Coromandel Coast.’ Caldwell, vi, 80, 279, ‘Explorations at Korkeï and Kāyal,’ ‘Sepulchral Urns in Southern India.’ Branfill, x, 1, ‘On the Sāvandurga Rude Stone Cemetery, Central Maisūr.’ V. A. Smith, xxxiv, 229, ‘The Copper Age and Prehistoric Bronze Implements of India.’

Journal of Asiatic Society of Bengal (J. A. S. B.). Rivett-Carnac, 1877, pt. i, ‘Rough Notes on some Ancient Sculpturings on Rocks in Kumaon’; 1879, pt. i, 1, ‘Prehistoric Remains in Central India’; ibid., 17, ‘The Snake Symbol in India’; 1883, pt. i, 221, ‘On Stone Implements from the N.W.P.’ King, 1877, pt. i, 179, ‘Notice of a Prehistoric Burial-place with Cruciform Monoliths, near Mungapet in the Nizam's Dominions.’ Branfill, 1880, pt. i, 8, ‘Rude Megalithic Monuments in North Arcot.’ Foote, 1887, pt. ii, 259, ‘Notes on some recent Neolithic and Palaeolithic Finds in Southern India.’ Cockburn, 1894, pt. iii, 21, ‘Flint Implements from the Kon Ravines of South Mirzapore.’ Bodding, 1901, pt. iii, 17, ‘Stone Implements in the Santāl Parganas.’

Proceedings of Asiatic Society of Bengal (Proc. A. S. B.). Le Mesurier, 1861, 81, ‘Note on Twelve Stone Hatchets or Celts from Jabalpur’ (the earliest distinct notice of prehistoric implements in India). V. Ball, 1867, 136, ‘Stone Implements found in India’ (list of localities known to date, with references). Bloomfield, 1870, 131, ‘Silver and Copper Objects found near the village of Gungeria.’ Mockler, 1876, 172, ‘Ancient Dwellings and Tombs in Beluchistan.’ V. Ball and Foote, 1888, 192, ‘Ancient Stone Implements in India.’

Journal of Royal Asiatic Society (J. R. A. S.). Walhouse, 1875, 17, ‘Megalithic Monuments of the Coimbatore District.’ Bidie, 1887, 693, ‘On Prehistoric Cemeteries in Southern India.’ Sewell, 1899, 1 (see 1900, 402), ‘The Cinder-Mounds of Bellary’; 1902, 165, ‘Prehistoric Burial Sites in Southern India.’ Cockburn and V. A. Smith, 1899, 89, ‘Cave Drawings in the Kaimūr Range, N.W.P.’

Journal of Bombay Branch of Royal Asiatic Society (J. Bo. R. A. S.). Meadows Taylor, iii, 179; iv, 380, ‘Megalithic Monuments in the Shorapur District.’ (See also Trans. Royal Irish Academy (Tr. R. I. A.), vol. xxiv, for 1865, and Journal of Ethnological Society (J. E. S.), i, 157.)

Journal of the Anthropological Institute (J. A. I.), xxix (N. S. ii), 271. Crooke, ‘Primitive Rites of Disposal of the Dead, with Special Reference to India.’

V. Ball, ‘On the Forms and Geographical Distribution of Stone Implements in India’ (App. B of Jungle Life in India, 1880, condensed from Proc. R. I. A., second series, vol. i, 1879).

Carlleyle, notes in Cunningham's Archaeological Survey Reports (A. S. R.), vi, 107; xxii, 97–117; and MS. communicated by Rev. R. A. Gatty. A. Rea, ‘Prehistoric Antiquities in Tinnevelly’ (A. S. R., Annual Report for 1902–3 and 1903–4).

Anderson, Catalogue and Handbook of the Archaeological Collections in the Indian Museum, Calcutta (Cat. I. M.), Pt. II.

Bruce Foote and Sir W. Elliot in Intern. Congress of Prehistoric Archaeology, Norwich, 1868 (Longmans, 1869).

Memoirs of Geological Survey of India (Mem. G. S. I.), x, 44. B. Foote, ‘Stone Implements in Laterite.’

Markham, Memoir of the Indian Surveys, 1878, second ed., p. 248 (summary of results to date).

Medlicott and Blanford, Geology of India (G. I.), pt. i, 440, pl. xxi (numerous references).

Breeks, An Account of the Primitive Tribes and Monuments of the Nīlagiris, London, 1873. B. Foote, Catalogue of the Prehistoric Antiquities in the Government Museum, Madras (Cat. M. M.).

Evans, The Ancient Stone Implements, &c., of Great Britain, second ed., 1897 (Evans, Stone). Ancient Bronze Implements, &c., of Great Britain and Ireland, 1881 (Evans, Bronze).

Notes

  1. 1. Special references for ‘pygmy flints’ are :—Evans, Ancient Stone Implements, 2nd ed., pp. 276, 325, fig. 232, D, E, F. Gatty, article in Man, Feb. 1902; and MS. notes of the late Mr. Carlleyle. De Pierpoint, ‘Observations sur de Très Petits Instruments en Silex’ (Bull. Soc. Anthrop. de Bruxelles, tome xiii, 1894–5). V. A. Smith, ‘Pygmy Flints’ (Ind. Ant. 1906). The British Museum possesses an excellent set of Vindhyan specimens. The Pitt-Rivers Museum at Oxford and the National Museum at Dublin also have sets from Mr. Carlleyle’s collection.
  2. 1. The pottery probably was not really glazed. The ancient Indian substitute for glazing was a smear produced from the juice of Abutilon indicum. Glass was known in Egypt and Babylonia from a very early date. Mr. Peters found specimens at Nippur which are assigned to the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries b.c. (Nippur, p. 134).
  3. 1. Mr. Rea’s report (illustrated) in Proc. Madras Govt., Public, No. 1135, dated Aug. 11, 1887. The discovery is noticed in J. A. S. B., 1888, pt. ii, p. 48.