I. Rents
Indian rents have had a history very different from that of rents in Europe. Throughout the periods of native rule for which we have historical data, the prevailing custom was for the cultivator to deal direct with the representative of the state, and the whole of the economic rent passed straight from one to the other. Even when there was an intermediary, and when that intermediary enjoyed to a greater or less degree the other incidents of proprietary right, he seldom received any substantial share of the profits of cultivation, and such dues as he might intercept would more fittingly be classed as fees or perquisites than as rent in the proper sense of the term. As the several Provinces passed under British rule, the Government at first continued the native practice of taking as land revenue the whole, or nearly the whole, of the economic rent. When the intermediaries were few or weak the Government dealt direct with the cultivator; and it still does so in what are called the ‘ryotwāri’ areas, which include Bombay, Burma, Assam, and the greater part of Madras. Where, on the other hand, the intermediaries were numerous and powerful, as in the zamīndāri tracts of Bengal and the United Provinces, the Government dealt with those intermediaries, leaving them to collect the rents from the cultivators and, when paying the proceeds to the state, to retain a small proportion, generally 10 per cent., for their own use. It is from this percentage that the payments now representing the net rental have developed, and the development has been along two main lines of expansion. In Bengal the Government demand, representing at the time of its assessment 90 per cent. of the economic rent, was fixed in perpetuity in 1793; but the extension of cultivation, and the rise in the value of produce, since that date have been so considerable that the Government revenue at the present day is estimated to absorb no more than 25 per cent. of the economic rental, leaving 75 per cent. to be enjoyed as a net rent by the landlords or other parties who now stand between the cultivator and the state. In the other Provinces the Government demand has not, as a rule, been fixed in perpetuity, and is liable to revision at intervals of twenty to thirty years1; but owing to the gradual influence of Western views regarding the character and political value of proprietorship in land, the state has by degrees reduced its share of the profits from 90 per cent. to a maximum of about 50 per cent., leaving the remainder as a substantial net rental in the hands of the persons whom it has recognized as landowners. The peculiarity of Indian rents lies therefore in this fact, that whereas in most countries the land revenue is an assignment from the rent made by landowners to the Government, in India the net rent is, historically speaking, a relinquishment of part of the profits of land by the Government to the landowners.
During the first half of the nineteenth century, while the incidence of the land revenue was still high and land of much less value than now, the rent question, though frequently discussed, was not looked upon as one of special urgency. But as population increased and the competition of tenants for land became more keen, it was felt that some system should be prescribed by law to guide the landlords and the courts in matters of enhancement and eviction, and with this object Act X of 1859 (India) was passed for the regulation of rent questions in Bengal, Agra, and the Central Provinces. In dealing with the tenants this Act reproduced and crystallized a distinction which had, in a vague and indeterminate manner, governed the treatment of cultivators under the native régime. It may be said generally that under native rule the cultivator was never ousted from his holding so long as he paid the dues expected from him; and although there was nothing in law or theory to prevent the indefinite enhancement of such payments, the cultivators were so few and so valuable that in practice the enhancements seldom exceeded the full economic rent. In addition, however, to the cultivators so treated, there was always a class of men who were on a more temporary footing—men who came from outside villages or constantly wandered from place to place; and it was felt that as regards these men the same customary obligation did not apply. The Act of 1859 accordingly divided the tenants, on the above lines, into ‘occupancy’ and ‘non-occupancy,’ and gave to the former a greater degree of protection than to the latter. In distinguishing the two classes the principle of prescription was followed as the best practical guide, and the continuous cultivation or holding of land for twelve years was declared to entitle the tenant to a ‘right of occupancy’ in the land so cultivated or held.
A similar distinction was preserved in various local Acts passed subsequently to 1859, but as time went on the protection thus afforded to tenants was found to be inadequate. The inquiries of the Famine Commission in 1880 showed that in many tracts the rents were too high; that the cultivators were by the conditions of their life debarred from other means of subsistence; and that the pressure of high rents entailed a great deal of unnecessary poverty, and consequent inability to withstand the attacks of famine. The subject had meanwhile attracted special attention in Bengal, where the whole question was threshed out with great thoroughness and no little acrimony, and a Bengal Act representing the result of these inquiries was passed in 1885. This Act has been accepted in many respects as the standard of rent legislation for India, and, along with the recommendations of the Famine Commission of 1880, has led to the gradual revision of the rent legislation of other Provinces. In Oudh, where the land is mainly owned by large proprietors in an exceptionally strong position, and in the Punjab, where the owners are small farmers and only half the land is let to tenants, the Provincial legislation has certain local peculiarities; but in Bengal, Agra, and the Central Provinces, though the specific provisions of the laws differ, there is a general similarity in their outline.
The position of rent legislation in India at the present time may be briefly described as follows:—In all the Provinces above mentioned the law recognizes the two main classes of tenants already referred to, occupancy and non-occupancy1. As regards the qualification for occupancy rights, a twelve-year rule is now followed only in Bengal and the Province of Agra. In Oudh rights of occupancy were granted to certain classes of ex-proprietors only, and in the Punjab they can be claimed on certain specified historical grounds, but not on mere lapse of time. The twelve-year rule was in force in the Central Provinces till 1884, but was in that year superseded by a provision which allows the purchase of occupancy rights by an ordinary tenant at two and a half times the annual rental. In the Province of Agra, where the old rule of prescription is still retained, special precautions have been taken to prevent the deliberate shifting of tenants by the landlord to defeat their claims, and the tenant's continuous possession is held not to be disturbed by re-distribution or exchange of holdings. In Bengal a further step has been taken, and every tenant who has continuously held land in a village for twelve years has a right of occupancy in all land that may at any time be held by him in that village.
Landlord's improvements, or an increase in the area of the holding, are everywhere accepted as proper grounds for enhancement. An occupancy tenant's rent can generally (subject to certain restrictions) be enhanced by contract, but in some Provinces the interposition of a Government officer is in any case required. When an enhancement is made on suit or application, it is subject to certain prescribed limitations. The Act of 1859 allowed enhancement up to the prevailing standard of occupancy rents in the neighbourhood, or up to the limit indicated by a rise in the value of produce; and this, with some later modifications, is still the rule in force in Bengal and the Province of Agra. In the Central Provinces enhancements not exceeding 25 per cent. may be made if the rent fixed at the last land-revenue settlement was less than the full rent assessable, or if there has been a rise of prices since the settlement. In Oudh a rise of prices is not taken into consideration, but in enhancements regard is had to the prevailing occupancy standard, or to a certain proportion of the prevailing non-occupancy rates in the neighbourhood. In the Punjab neither of the old rules of 1859 is now followed, and the occupancy rents are limited to a standard based on the land revenue and varying from one-eighth to three-fourths in excess of the assessment. In all Provinces where the land revenue is subject to periodical re-assessment, the rent can be altered at the time of the revenue settlement; otherwise an occupancy rent once fixed is unalterable (except on the ground of change of area or landlord's improvements) for a further period of five, ten, or fifteen years as the case may be, the term being shortest in Oudh and longest in Bengal.
The protection accorded to a non-occupancy tenant is of course less than that above described, but his rent is not, except in the Punjab, left entirely to the discretion of the landlord. The Bengal Act allows a tenant who sues against enhancement to have a fair and equitable rent fixed for him on the basis of the prevailing rates, and the law in the Province of Agra allows a similar privilege to tenants who have held on a seven years' lease. In Oudh an enhancement, whether agreed to on contract or awarded on a suit, may not exceed 6¼ per cent. of the existing rent, and the corresponding limit in the less developed Central Provinces is 33 per cent. A special feature of the law in the Central Provinces is that an officer re-assessing revenue is required to fix the rents of all non-occupancy tenants; and a general revision of rents on a somewhat similar system can, if necessary, be set in motion by the Government in the Province of Agra and in Bengal. A non-occupancy rent once fixed is generally protected from further enhancement for a term of five or seven years.
An abatement of rent can be adjudged, generally speaking, on conditions inverse to those permitting of judicial enhancement, and in cases when a Government officer is invested with general powers to fix fair rents he necessarily has the power to reduce rents which are excessive. In some Provinces the courts possess, to a certain extent, power to remit rent when the produce has been injured or destroyed by natural causes; and in the temporarily settled Provinces a suspension or remission by Government of its revenue entails, or is conditional on, a corresponding suspension or remission of the rent.
Lastly, as regards the recovery of arrears, the general tendency of modern legislation in India is to reduce the landlord's summary powers of recovery, while simplifying the procedure of recovery through the courts. The special processes of ejectment and distraint are now subjected to considerable safeguards against possible oppression. As a general rule, both occupancy and non-occupancy tenants can be ejected for arrears; but the ejectment must be by notice or suit, and the procedure must be in accordance with the conditions laid down by the legislature. In Bengal and the United Provinces the landlord has also a remedy by distress, but his powers are far less extensive than they were under the old Bengal Regulations. The distraint is confined to the crops of the holding in arrear; reaping and threshing may not be interfered with; the arrear for which distraint is made must be of recent origin; and the distraint must either be made through a court or reported at once for the court's information. In the Central Provinces and the Punjab there is no actual power of distraint; but in the former Province crops can be attached pending a decree for the arrears, and in the latter, if the produce be already attached, the rent can be recovered therefrom.
The above represents briefly the present condition of the law regarding rents in Northern and Central India1. In the ‘ryotwāri’ areas, where the Government deals directly with each occupant of land, and where large proprietors have either disappeared or never existed, the land is cultivated to a much larger extent by the landholders themselves and rents are far less prevalent. The fact that the Government revenue generally falls far short of the economic rent has, however, led to a certain amount of subletting in the ryotwāri areas; and although in most of these Provinces the legislature has hitherto exercised little or no interference in rent matters, the increasing tendency to sublet gives rise to the presumption that the position of sub-tenants in ryotwāri tracts will before long be subjected to more detailed control than has hitherto been the case.
Speaking generally, the legislative provisions already discussed deal primarily with cash rents. The original form of rent in India is, however, a kind-rent, taken, as a rule, in the form of a share of the grain heap. The inconveniences connected with this primitive phase of rent led to various developments, such as the division of the standing crop by appraisement, or the payment of the landlord’s share of the grain at a stipulated price-rate; or, if the crops were difficult or inconvenient to divide, a cash rate per acre would be paid on them, or a cash rate per acre might be taken on the entire holding; or, finally, a lump sum in gross would be assessed on the tenancy as a whole. The payment of rent in kind is, however, still exceedingly common in all parts of India. Generally speaking, it is prevalent in tracts where the country is yet undeveloped, or where the crops are liable to extreme variations of out-turn, or where the tenants are much depressed; but there are marked exceptions to these general statements, and the adoption of a cash or produce basis for rental is largely a matter of custom. The produce system has both disadvantages and merits: it opens the door to much fraud, uncertainty, and oppression; but on the other hand, it apportions the rent exactly to the produce, and thus avoids the severity with which a fixed cash rent must fall upon a tenant in years of scarcity. Where kind-rents prevail, many of the questions with which the rent laws concern themselves disappear from view. Enhancements and abatements, for instance, due to changes in area, to improvement and deterioration, or to the rise and fall of prices, adjust themselves automatically. Otherwise, and with some necessary modifications, the provisions of the rent laws apply generally to produce-rents as well as to those in cash; and there are usually special conditions providing that disputes about the division or appraisement of the crop shall, on the application of one of the parties, be decided by a revenue officer, and that under certain circumstances a kind-rent may, by the same agency, be converted into one in cash. There are no general statistics regarding the expansion or contraction of the area under kind-rents; but it is usually believed that, taking India as a whole, the system of cash rents is slowly gaining ground concurrently with the general development of the country.
Detailed statistics regarding rent are not, as a rule, available for any but small areas, and in Bengal they are almost entirely wanting. The following table collects the chief data of interest for the zamīndāri Provinces according to recent returns :—
| Bengal. | Agra. | Oudh. | Punjab. | Central Provinces. | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Average area held by proprietor (in acres) . . | 59 | 16 | 71 | 16 | 335 |
| Average area of tenant's holding (in acres) . . . | * | * | * | 2.8 | 11.8 |
| Percentage of total cultivated area held by tenants . . | * | 78.9 | 87.8 | 54.1 | 77.1 |
| Percentage of rented area held by tenants enjoying occupancy or equivalent rights . | * | 45.4 | 6.3 | 19.9 | 59.5 |
| Percentage of grain-rented area to total rented area . | * | 6.2 | 19.8 | 56.6 | * |
| Incidence of cash rents per cultivated acre (in rupees) . | 3.5 | 4.2 | 5.2 | 3.7 | 0.7 |
The figures require certain reservations and explanations which need not be entered into here; but they may be accepted as showing with sufficient accuracy the general conditions connected with rent in India. With reference to the incidence of the cash rental, it may be observed that the rent of protected tenants is in some Provinces maintained by law at a standard below that of tenants-at-will, while in other Provinces it is not so restricted, and may even, owing to the occupancy tenants' possession of the best lands, be higher than the prevalent non-occupancy rate.
As to the incidence of the rents generally, this may be said to depend on the interaction of three forces—custom, competition, and legislation. In the early days of British rule custom was everywhere paramount, and even now the influence of competition is comparatively restricted. A rise of prices, for instance, even in unfettered tenancies, does not necessarily entail a concurrent rise in rents : the rental in such cases rises, as a rule, considerably after prices and by no means in exact conformity with them. The rent legislation of India has this special characteristic, that it starts from a basis of custom and, while accepting the legitimate influence of competition, seeks to confine that influence within reasonable limits. It aims not so much at the curtailment of advantages naturally accruing to landlords, as at the maintenance of rights already conferred on tenants by custom. Custom is therefore still, to a large extent, the foundation of Indian rents, and the presumptions of unfettered competition, which pervade the standard economic conceptions of rent, can only be applied with large reservations to existing conditions in India.
II. Prices and Wages
Retail Prices
No records exist of prices in the interior of the country except for the staple food-grains and salt, which are the articles most commonly bought and sold. Since 1873 these prices have been reported in fortnightly returns from most Districts, and have been regularly published in the Gazette of India. From these, and from earlier local returns, a compilation of each year's prices is made, which has, since 1884, been published annually in the official publication entitled Prices and Wages in India, the record of prices commencing with the year 1861. For previous years the information becomes more and more incomplete the farther back the inquiry is carried, and is not wholly to be depended on, though various official records exist of prices in such periods. Thus, in a report on wages and prices during the years 1858–70, published in 1871 by the Government of the United Provinces, a statement, obtained from merchants’ books, is given of the price of wheat at Bareilly from 1805, at Ghāziābād from 1831, and at Sahāranpur, Muttra, and Alīgarh from 1840. Old prices are also obtainable from settlement reports and local gazetteers. The Bombay Gazetteer gives prices of millet at Broach from 1782 in broken periods, and continuously from 1810; at Bhaunagar from 1783, with but few omissions; and for several other places from the early years of the nineteenth century. These prices, with those of rice in Kanara and Madras, from 1824 and 1811 respectively, were averaged, and illustrated with a series of diagrams, by Mr. Chambers, Meteorological Reporter for Western India, in a paper, written in April, 1886, on the variations of prices in the Bombay Presidency, which examines the possible connexion between price variations and the periodicity of sun spots. Similar variations over a long series of years, starting from the early part of the nineteenth century, were given in tabular and diagrammatic form by Mr. Pedder of the India Office, in a memorandum on prices embodied in the Parliamentary Blue Book exhibiting the ‘Moral and Material Progress of India’ in 1882–3, the grains selected being in this case bājra (Pennisetum typhoideum), jowār (Andropogon sorghum), wheat, and rice, at four typical marts. The salient feature of all these price statements is the same: namely, the immense variation of prices between years of good and bad harvests which resulted from the absence of trade and communications, except in the maritime Districts of Western India, which were opened to trade in very early times and where the fluctuations were consequently within much narrower limits. The isolation of many Districts before the opening up of the country by railways and roads deprived them of any outlet for their surplus in times of plenty, and in periods of scarcity or. famine made them depend wholly on their own supplies. Thus, an abundant harvest produced prices which, according to modern standards, seem extraordinarily low, while a failure of the crops meant a range of prices proportionately much higher than can now be reached, or caused heavy mortality from starvation. Among several examples of the levelling effect on prices of improved communications, Mr. Pedder cites the following case. In 1838 there was a severe famine in the United Provinces, and the price of wheat at Agra rose to 13½ seers1 per rupee, while at Khāndesh the price of jowār was as low as 61 seers. In 1861 and 1869 there were again famines in the United Provinces and no failure in Khāndesh. But the railway had meanwhile brought Khāndesh into direct communication with Agra, and when the price of wheat in Agra was 14 and 12 seers per rupee the price of jowār in Khāndesh rose to 16 and 12½ seers.
Other noticeable features are the tendency of prices to fall during the first half of the nineteenth century, and the marked rise which occurred about 1860, and which is attributed by Mr. Pedder to the great economic change introduced by the rapid growth of the export trade and the expansion of the circulating medium. Under native rule such limited trade as existed was mainly carried on by barter, and a large portion of the receipts and disbursements of the Government was in kind. The introduction, with British rule, of money payments to and by Government, the growth of trade, and the general increase of prosperity and production arising from peace and a settled administration, caused prices to drop until a rise was brought about by a large influx of silver, which allowed the currency to expand in a greater degree than the duties thrown on it.
In comparing early prices with those published from 1861, it must be remembered that the former, which are generally taken from settlement reports, are the harvest prices obtained by the cultivator, while the latter are the retail prices paid by the consumer. The harvest prices, besides being necessarily far lower than the retail figures, are no guide to the average price of the year, for the crop is often sold to a banker, grain-dealer, or merchant who has made advances and bargained for its purchase beforehand, at a price not likely to be unfavourable to himself. The grain trade as it now exists is quite a modern development, resulting from the establishment of ampler means of transport and communication; yet it is a common fallacy to compare modern prices, which approach to one level at all places accessible by railway, and which in times both of plenty and of acute famine are real commercial quotations, with the purely local figures formerly recorded in isolated tracts, where a bumper harvest produced nominal prices, and a complete failure, with the usual accompaniment of intense famine, made grain practically priceless.
In considering the course of retail prices from 1861, it will be convenient to take the seven principal food-grains for which a complete record exists. In tabulating the figures, the average of the District prices for each Province, or part thereof, where the grain is largely grown for food, is taken from Prices and Wages in India and formed into a general average; for although this method is doubtless open to some criticism, limitation of space compels its adoption. The grains and the Provinces are: Rice (common)—Bengal, Assam, Lower Burma, Madras, United Provinces, Central Provinces. Wheat—Punjab, United Provinces, Central Provinces, Bengal (Bihār), Bombay. Barley—Punjab, United Provinces, Bengal (Bihār). Jowār (Andropogon sorghum)—United Provinces, Punjab, Central Provinces and Berār, Bombay, Madras. Bājra (Pennisetum typhoideum)—United Provinces, Punjab, Madras, Bombay. Rāgi (Eleusine coracana)—Madras, Mysore, Bengal, Bombay. Gram (Cicer arietinum)—Punjab, United Provinces, Bengal (Bihār), Central Provinces, Bombay, Mysore.
Maize, arhar (Cajanus indicus), and kakun (Setaria italica) have been omitted, as the records of prices for these are more or less incomplete in the earlier years. Salt is also left out, as its price is chiefly regulated by the varying rate of duty and the cost of transport.
Prices are expressed, according to the usual Indian method, in terms of the number of seers sold for a rupee; and to avoid misleading conclusions by those accustomed to think of money prices, it is advisable to note that not only do money prices vary inversely to quantity prices, but that the percentages of the rise or fall of prices according to the two methods of notation are quite different. Thus, if the number of seers obtainable for a rupee is halved, i.e. decreases by 50 per cent., the money price is doubled, i.e. rises 100 per cent.; but if the quantity price becomes 50 per cent. more, that is cheaper, the corresponding money price is only 33 per cent. lower.
In the table on the next page, which gives averages for each quinquennium between 1861 and 1900, and for the three years 1901–3, quantity prices are used except in the last column, which states the variations in the estimated price of all grains from the price of a standard period. These variations are in inverse ratio to the quantity prices, and thus represent with approximate accuracy the course of money prices.
Allusion has already been made to the general rise of prices which took place about 1860. With the suppression of the Mutiny and the transfer of the administration to the Crown, there commenced a new era of commercial and industrial activity, as the resources of the country were developed by the construction of roads and railways, the improvement of harbours, and the extension of irrigation. A momentous event of this period was the American Civil War of 1861–5: this, by causing a cotton famine, gave an immense stimulus to the extension of cotton cultivation in India, which while the war lasted brought large profits to the cultivator and the merchant. The influx of the precious metals which began about the time of the Mutiny was thus still further stimulated, and a great rise
| Average for the Years | Rice. | Wheat. | Barley. | Jowār. | Bājra. | Rāgi. | Gram. | General average. | Variation in moneyprice index, the price of 1871-5 being = 100. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1861–5 . | 20·0 | 22·4 | 36·6 | 26·5 | 24·8 | 28·7 | 26·0 | 26·4 | 94 |
| 1866–70 . | 16·1 | 16·2 | 27·1 | 21·9 | 19·9 | 26·5 | 18·4 | 20·9 | 119 |
| 1871–5 . | 18·2 | 19·7 | 29·0 | 26·8 | 23·0 | 33·5 | 23·6 | 24·8 | 100 |
| 1876–80 . | 14·5 | 16·9 | 27·3 | 21·1 | 19·3 | 20·4 | 19·9 | 19·9 | 125 |
| 1881–5 . | 16·9 | 19·9 | 30·9 | 28·5 | 25·0 | 28·0 | 25·6 | 25·0 | 99 |
| 1886–90 . | 14·7 | 16·3 | 24·7 | 21·5 | 19·6 | 26·9 | 19·8 | 20·5 | 121 |
| 1891–5 . | 12·7 | 14·9 | 22·7 | 20·1 | 18·0 | 22·3 | 18·5 | 18·5 | 135 |
| 1896–1900 | 11·7 | 12·1 | 18·4 | 16·5 | 15·3 | 18·3 | 13·5 | 15·1 | 164 |
| 1901–3 | 11·6 | 14·5 | 21·9 | 20·6 | 19·1 | 20·5 | 16·5 | 17·8 | 139 |
of prices ensued, from about the second year of the war, throughout the cotton-growing districts of Western and Central India, extending in a less degree to other parts of the country. Prices were also raised by the famine of 1861 in the Upper Doāb of the Province of Agra and the neighbouring districts of the Punjab and Rājputāna, and by the scarcity in Cutch. A uniform level of prices was, however, still far from being established; for in 1861, while wheat was nearly 39 seers to the rupee in the Central Provinces and 26 seers in Oudh, it was less than 19 seers in the Province of Agra and only 16 seers in Bombay. So also in 1862, when rice was 29½ seers per rupee in Bengal, it was less than 18 seers in Burma and not quite 14 seers in Madras. On the collapse of the inflation caused by the American War, prices would probably have fallen but for the great Orissa famine of 1866, which extended into Bengal proper, Bihār, and parts of Madras. Another notable famine, that of 1869, affected Western Rājputāna and parts of Northern India, and the extension of scarcity west and south produced a rise in the price of food-grains in Bombay, the Central Provinces, and Hyderābād.
During 1871–5 prices were not seriously disturbed by any calamity except the Bihār famine of 1874; and although large purchases of grain were then made by the Government, and scarcity prevailed in the adjoining Districts of the United Provinces, the disturbance of prices was not widely felt. In view, therefore, of the generally normal character of the seasons, and the fact that its middle year (1873) is that from which the great change in the relative values of gold and silver commenced, this quinquennium has been selected as the most suitable standard with which to compare the price levels of other periods. The quinquennium 1876–80 embraces the great famine of 1877–8, which affected an immense tract in Southern and Western India and extended, with diminished intensity, into the north. Great quantities of rice were sent from Bengal to the famine districts, and the price of food-grains rose to a very high level throughout India.
The export trade in wheat, which had begun in a small way after the opening of the Suez Canal in 1869, received a check during the years 1878–80; but it revived in the following year, and in 1881–2 reached an extraordinarily high level with a total of nearly 1,000,000 tons. The export trade in rice, which expanded greatly in 1872–3, was on a large scale throughout the decade under consideration, and showed greater contraction in 1874, the year of the Bihār famine, than in the Deccan famine three years later.
The period 1881–90 is noticeable for a remarkable change. Speaking generally, all crops except rice were good or abundant during the years 1881–5, though there was scarcity in a portion of the Punjab in 1884, and distress in parts of Bengal and Madras in 1885. The rice crop was bad between 1883 and 1885, owing to drought and floods, but wheat was plentiful, and the average price for all grains was low. The dependence of prices on the variations of the seasons is thus, as formerly, clearly marked; but this explanation hardly suffices to account for so great a rise in prices as occurred during the last five years of the decade, for the 1889 famine in Ganjām (accompanied by distress in the Orissa States and scarcity in Bihār) was only of local importance, and prices had already reached their highest point in 1888. The export trade in food-grains was no larger than in the previous five years; and unless the harvests were generally poor, though not sufficiently so to cause noticeable scarcity, some reason for the rise other than diminished supplies must be found. There is, of course, a direct connexion between the volume of the currency and prices, but in the case of retail prices this connexion is so obscure that it cannot be traced with any certainty. Still it is a fact that from the time this general rise of prices occurred there were heavy imports of silver, and the active circulation was increased by a large addition to the coinage.
The high prices ruling during 1886–90 were still further raised in 1891–2 by prolonged drought, causing scarcity and distress in Madras, the Bombay Deccan, Bihār, and Upper Burma. A strong Indian demand for rice was coupled with large exports, and at the same time there was an unprecedented export of wheat owing to failure of the crops in Europe, so that Indian prices reached almost to famine levels. With better seasons prices cheapened; but the lowest point reached in 1891–5 was still above the average level of the previous quinquennium and, as in that period, the importation of silver for coinage, until the closure of the mints in June, 1893, was on a large scale.
The next quinquennium (1896–1900) includes two periods of intense and widespread famine. The failure of the crops caused famine over a very large part of India in 1896–7, and the central and western regions were again desolated by the famine of 1899–1900. The effect was to raise the price of food-grains in all parts of the country to the highest levels on record. Wheat exports were reduced to insignificant proportions during the first famine, and were practically extinguished in the year following the second. But in spite of the large supplies of rice absorbed by the famine areas, a very extensive export trade in that article was maintained throughout; and in 1898–9, the year preceding the second famine, the export of rice, wheat, and other food-grains was larger than in any previous year except 1891–2, the aggregate exceeding 3,000,000 tons.
During the years 1901–3 the harvests have been good and prices have fallen steadily. The levels are still comparatively high, but the decline is as rapid as could be expected in view of the effects of the last two famines, and the depletion of stocks which must take years to replace. Rice, of which the exports have greatly increased during the last two years, remains extremely dear; and it has been evident for some time that the supply of this cereal, which is perhaps the most largely consumed food-stuff in India, has not kept pace with the growth of the demand. Wheat in India proper, like rice in Burma, is being grown more extensively for export, and the recent revival of the foreign demand has produced exports bearing a far larger proportion to the consumption than in the case of rice. Each of the last two famines caused a large reduction of the area under wheat, and though its cultivation is rapidly expanding, the deficiency has not yet (1905) been made up. Of rice it may be said that present prices are as high as the famine prices of former years; but it would be incorrect to apply this statement to food-grains in general, for the price of wheat has fallen, and all the commoner grains which are the staple food of the poorest classes have cheapened remarkably between 1901 and 1904. Recent prices are, it is true, higher than the average of the first half of the forty years dealt with in the table on page 458; but allowance must be made for the gradual levelling of prices throughout Districts, Provinces, and the country at large which has followed the multiplication of the means of intercourse. The chief factor in determining the price of food-grains has been, and will continue to be, the out-turn of the crops; for as India is dependent for food on its own resources, a considerable deficiency of the supply, either actual or anticipated, must always send up prices, and it is an economic law that the increase of price is in much greater proportion than the deficiency in supply which causes it. The increase of population, and consequent pressure on the land, would operate, through the law of diminishing returns, towards a permanent increase in the price of food even though the area under cultivation expanded in the same proportion; and the demand for export has undoubtedly influenced the price of rice and wheat directly, and through them the price of the commoner food-grains. Thus, a remarkable fall in the price of food-grains in the United Provinces in the year following the severe famine of 1896–7 was assigned by the local officials to the small export demand for wheat. The steadying of prices by increased facilities of transport must, as already stated, result in raising the general level. Another general cause which would produce a higher range of prices is an inflation of the currency; and it is at least a noticeable coincidence that at the periods from which prices took an upward turn, namely, from about 1860 and again from about 1886, there was a great influx of silver and a large addition to the coinage.
The effect of the increasing price of food on the condition of the labouring classes is discussed in the section dealing with wages.
Wholesale Prices
The wholesale prices of commodities recorded in Prices and Wages in India relate to a few of the principal articles of import and export. There is no record, except of quite recent date, for the markets of the interior, and the earliest quotations are for prices at Calcutta in 1843. Until 1861, moreover, the list of articles is very imperfect; and, as in the case of retail prices, it is convenient to commence with that year, which marks the beginning of a new era of commercial and industrial activity.
To illustrate the course of wholesale prices in tabular form, it is most convenient to substitute for the actual price of each article the percentage of its variation from the price of a given period which is reckoned at 100. The year selected is 1873, from which time the gold value of silver and of the rupee began to decline, and the price ruling in March of that year is the actual datum. The variations from this standard, calculated on the mean of the prices of January and July in each year, of certain principal imports into Calcutta are shown in the following table :—
| Grey cotton shirtings. | Cotton yarn, grey. | Cotton yarn, orange. | Copper braziers. | Iron, flat. | Average or index number. | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1861–5 | 146 | 145 | 154 | 99 | 63 | 121 |
| 1866–70 | 125 | 119 | 111 | 85 | 69 | 102 |
| 1871–5 | 94 | 94 | 96 | 94 | 88 | 93 |
| 1876–80 | 77 | 83 | 82 | 86 | 64 | 79 |
| 1881–5 | 77 | 75 | 81 | 76 | 58 | 74 |
| 1886–90 | 79 | 71 | 81 | 72 | 62 | 73 |
| 1891–5 | 73 | 69 | 77 | 76 | 65 | 72 |
| 1896 . | 72 | 73 | 80 | 82 | 71 | 76 |
| 1897 . | 70 | 66 | 80 | 81 | 74 | 74 |
| 1898 . | 64 | 59 | 67 | 82 | 74 | 69 |
| 1899 . | 73 | 57 | 62 | 95 | 78 | 73 |
| 1900 . | 84 | 66 | 71 | 110 | 83 | 83 |
| 1901 . | 86 | 73 | 86 | 111 | 79 | 87 |
| 1902 . | 80 | 66 | 78 | 97 | 70 | 78 |
| 1903 . | 79 | 73 | 80 | 92 | 70 | 79 |
These articles, though few in number, represent in the aggregate a large share of the total import trade, and each is typical of a large class. Thus, the three forms of cotton represent all cotton manufactures, which constitute more than one-third of the total imports. Copper is an article of great importance in the domestic economy of the people; and the price of iron, of which an insignificant quantity is produced in India itself, regulates the cost of all manufactures thereof, including machinery, whether imported or made in the country. The price of imports generally, as represented by these articles, fell by 21 per cent. between 1873 and 1903, while the fall in cotton goods was from 20 to 27 per cent., and in iron 30 per cent. It must, however, be noted that iron is subject to great variations in price, and copper is so much the subject of speculation that its price, too, is unstable. Cotton, also, is often subject to special influences; and its very high price between 1861 and 1870, or more particularly from 1863 to 1867, is due to the cotton famine caused by the American Civil War, while the effects of shortage of supply and speculation have caused an advance of price in recent years.
The variations of other typical imports, for which prices are not available for the whole period from 1861, are shown below :—
| 1871-80. | 1881-90. | 1891-1900. | 1901-3. | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sugar (Mauritius) | 98 | 80 | 70 | 59 |
| Coal (Welsh) | 80 | 61 | 67 | 77 |
| Kerosene (American Chester) | ... | ... | 101 | 115 |
The variation for kerosene is based on the price of January, 1888, and the prices are for imports at Calcutta, while the prices of sugar and coal are those for imports at Bombay. Sugar has grown to be one of the principal imports into India, and the great volume of the supplies during the last seven years, originated by the influx of beet sugar, has brought down prices. The import trade in kerosene has nearly doubled since 1888, but has recently received a check through the working of the oil-fields of Burma and Assam. Of late years, too, the development of its own coal-fields has made India almost independent of imported fuel; hence foreign coal is no longer an article of much consequence in the import trade.
The table on the following page shows the variations from the prices of March, 1873, of some of the principal exports from Calcutta and Bombay, the figures being, as before, deduced from the mean of the January and July prices in each year.
The average price or index number shows on the whole remarkable stability; but this is the result of a notable rise in rice, jute, and linseed, which counteracts a fall in the other articles, the decline being particularly heavy in the case of tea, indigo, and cotton yarn.
The great rise in the price of rice is in agreement with the evidence of retail prices. In the case of wheat the explanation of the decline in the export price, while the retail price has risen, is that the price at Calcutta in 1873, which is taken as the datum for calculating variations of export prices, was extremely high even for that centre, as the index for 1872 is 77, and for 1871 only 59. The wheat trade was then in its infancy, and the cost of transport often made the price at the ports double that in the wheat-growing districts from which retail prices have been taken. As railway communications developed and prices in the interior rose, freights to
| Calcutta. | Bombay. | Average or index number. | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rice (Ballam). | Wheat (Doodiah). | Linseed. | Jute, picked. | Jute, gunny-bags. | Tea, pekoe. | Indigo. | Cotton, raw (Broach). | Cotton yarn *. | Cotton cloth *. | ||
| Average. 1861–5 | 94 | 81 | 88 | 107 | 100 | ... | 95 | 123 | ... | ... | 98 |
| 1866–70 | 130 | 97 | 106 | 113 | 108 | ... | 102 | 111 | ... | ... | 110 |
| 1871–5 | 118 | 84 | 103 | 127 | 103 | 106 | 132 | 87 | 90 | 93 | 104 |
| 1876–80 | 159 | 98 | 103 | 147 | 92 | 103 | 105 | 84 | 81 | 83 | 105 |
| 1881–5 | 124 | 83 | 93 | 126 | 103 | 75 | 110 | 87 | 76 | 80 | 96 |
| 1886–90 | 137 | 83 | 104 | 164 | 111 | 65 | 86 | 89 | 75 | 77 | 99 |
| 1891–5 | 168 | 89 | 119 | 190 | 108 | 61 | 98 | 83 | 70 | 77 | 106 |
| 1896 . | 168 | 102 | 96 | 191 | 103 | 60 | 105 | 85 | 75 | 77 | 106 |
| 1897 . | 218 | 141 | 96 | 194 | 97 | 52 | 84 | 77 | 73 | 77 | 111 |
| 1898 . | 184 | 95 | 91 | 156 | 82 | 57 | 76 | 68 | 61 | 76 | 95 |
| 1899 . | 146 | 81 | 99 | 170 | 88 | 42 | 57 | 59 | 52 | 70 | 86 |
| 1900 . | 155 | 111 | 142 | 197 | 108 | 46 | 74 | 85 | 61 | 73 | 105 |
| 1901 . | 184 | 106 | 156 | 193 | 104 | 33 | 65 | 84 | 67 | 87 | 108 |
| 1902 . | 195 | 95 | 150 | 186 | 94 | 40 | 65 | 83 | 66 | 84 | 106 |
| 1903 . | 163 | 87 | 116 | 199 | 97 | 50 | 61 | 83 | 67 | 81 | 100 |
the ports were greatly reduced, and thus a fair stability of prices was maintained. Another noticeable feature is the failure of the export price to respond as fully as the retail figures to the deficiency of supplies caused by the drought of 1899, which was practically as serious as that caused by the great drought three years previously. The reason for this would seem to be that the later crop failure was more in Central and Western India than in the districts of Northern India, from which supplies for export are so largely drawn ; and the fact that the export of wheat in 1900–1 practically ceased must be partly attributed to the lower prices ruling in Europe. The dependence on foreign prices of crops grown for export is also apparent in the case of rice, for the rise at Rangoon in recent years is not nearly so great as at Calcutta, and the variations, which are often the result of speculation, are quite unconnected. Thus while the index numbers at Calcutta during the three years 1901-3 were 184, 195, and 163, at Rangoon they were 122, 118, and 151.
Dealing briefly with the other articles given in the table, the recent rise in the price of linseed, followed by an abrupt fall due to greatly increased supplies, represents the course of prices for this article in European markets. Jute, like all monopolies for which there is a great demand, has risen much in price, while gunny-bags have recently shown a downward tendency. The great fall in the price of tea is due to production in excess of the demand; and in the case of indigo to the loss of its monopoly through the discovery and largely increasing manufacture of a chemical substitute. The trade in cotton and its price have been subject to wide fluctuations owing to variations in the supply and demand. In the third year of the American War the index rose as high as 229, and in 1899, when the crop was a failure and American cotton was extremely cheap, it fell to 59. The latest rise, following on the gigantic speculation in American cotton, is not shown in the table; but the price of January, 1904, gives an index of 103, and during the same month the figures for yarn and cloth are 74 and 85 respectively. The increase under cotton manufactures has not been proportionate to this rise in the price of the raw material, and the profits of the Indian spinning mills were for a time greatly reduced by the low price of yarn.
The prices of cow-hides at Calcutta and of skins at Madras show the following variations, the standard figure (100) being here the price in 1879 :—
| 1871–80. | 1881–90. | 1891–1900. | 1901–3. | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hides, raw | 93 | 121 | 166 | 193 |
| Skins, tanned | 105 | 125 | 139 | 138 |
The prices of hides and skins are influenced by the seasons, as a serious drought leads to heavy mortality of stock. Up to 1879 the quality of hides for which prices were quoted was rather inferior, so that the rise shown by the index is exaggerated. During the last three years hide prices have been steadily rising.
The question remains whether any conclusions can be drawn as to the operation of general causes which have tended to raise or depress prices. It has been noticed in regard to retail prices that from about 1886 there was a rise which was not attributable to bad harvests, and the same effect may be discerned in the prices of imports and exports from 1887. The import prices of the commodities mentioned in the tables on pages 462-3 are of course regulated by gold prices, or by the relation of gold to silver prices which is expressed by exchange. So also the export prices, especially of those articles principally produced for export, follow gold prices when exported to countries with a gold standard ; and it should be noted that in 1873, the year taken as the standard level, gold prices were excessively high, and that they then declined pretty steadily until 1887, when a temporary rise set in. But the peculiar nature of the chief products of India has also to be taken into account ; for some, like jute, indigo, rice, and tea, are either monopolies or have a preponderating influence on world prices, while others, like wheat and cotton (though both these have recently come to the front in an unusual degree), are often of very secondary importance. Further matters to be considered are the rapid growth of trade, the lowering of inland and ocean freights, and the gradual development of a backward country. Still, with all these reservations, the conclusion seems justified that the contraction in the volume of the currency which must have resulted from the suspension of rupee coinage during the three years following the closure of the mints, and the very limited re-coinage operations of the next three years, caused a sensible reduction in the general level of prices during the years 1898 and 1899. The remarkable cheapening of both the retail and wholesale prices of food-grains in the year immediately following the great famine of 1896-7 also gives support to this view.
Wages
The official District returns of wages date only from 1873. The wages reported are of unskilled and skilled labour, the types of the former being the agricultural labourer and the domestic servant (as represented by the syce or horse-keeper), and of the latter the common artisan, whether mason, carpenter, or blacksmith 1. General tendencies are broadly delineated in the figures; but for exact comparisons they are untrustworthy as, owing to the absence of instructions in regard to the precise nature of the information to be given in the returns, and the widely differing systems of engaging and remunerating labour throughout India, it is impossible that uniformity of method should have been observed in different Districts and Provinces. In some cases, too, it is evident that apparent changes in the same District are due to different methods of estimating wages.
As regards agricultural labour, the system of payment in kind is still widely prevalent. Occasionally the labourer may be a bondservant, for traces of the old system of agricultural bondage still remain, and in this case he gets a regular subsistence with small perquisites. Ordinarily a farm labourer is fed, or gets a certain fixed ration of grain, in return for regular service. He receives perquisites in the shape of an occasional piece of cloth, an advance or small gift to meet marriage expenses, and sometimes a small cash wage, and he may be housed by his employer. Casual hiring may be for a particular season or operation, as for the harvest, or for a daily wage; but in most rural tracts the remuneration is wholly or partly in grain, or a cash wage is supplemented by one or two free meals. In some cases the remuneration given for certain agricultural operations is a percentage of the crop. The regularity of employment also differs greatly, and in several Districts labourers are regularly without work for three or four months, so that their average earnings must be calculated on what they receive during eight or nine months of the year. In many parts, also,
cent. were field labourers, and about 1 per cent. were growers of special products or engaged in estate management, &c. In addition to these, about 2½ per cent., who mentioned some other form of employment as the chief source of their livelihood, were also partially agriculturists; and another 6 per cent., who were shown as “general labourers,” were doubtless in the main supported by work in the fields. About 15 per cent. of the population are maintained by the preparation and supply of material substances; and of these more than a third find a living by the provision of food and drink, and a quarter by working and dealing in textile fabrics and dress. Domestic and sanitary services provide a livelihood for only 4 per cent. of the population; and commerce, the learned and artistic professions, and service under Government for barely half as many each. In cities, as might be expected, the functional distribution is very different from that in the country as a whole: the proportion of persons dependent on agriculture falls from two-thirds to one-twelfth; the number engaged on the preparation and supply of material substances rises from one-seventh to two-fifths; one-eighth derive a livelihood from commerce, and nearly as many from personal and domestic services; one-eleventh from unskilled labour, and one-fourteenth from Government service.’ landless labourers are not numerous, and those who work for hire supplement by wages the income derived from a small plot of land. Village artisans and domestic servants are also commonly paid in kind, and the former often possess land. There appears to be a desire on the part of employers to substitute cash for grain wages as the price of grain rises; but, speaking generally, cash wages are still commonly paid only in the vicinity of towns or industrial villages, and by large employers of industrial labour.
The official returns do not, as a rule, discriminate between rural and urban areas, nor, if they give the cash equivalent of wages in kind, do they state how the conversion is made. The following changes in the record have, however, been detected : namely, from gross wages including food to net cash wages ; from daily wages for casual hire, which are multiplied by 30 and represented as monthly wages, to the rate for monthly hire ; from agricultural rates to town rates ; from the average of several small town or village rates to a city rate ; and from single to combined wages for a man and his wife working together. Confusion is also caused by combining under one head the wages of the mason, the carpenter, and the blacksmith, for their remuneration is far from equal ; and in some cases it would seem that the word ‘common’ has been read as applying only to the mason, and that wages have been returned for the carpenter or the blacksmith, and more particularly for the latter, at a scale far above the average of the trade. In these circumstances it is impossible to state with precision the percentage of variation in wages during the last thirty years. Inquiries are now being made as to the possibility of a more accurate record.
Another difficulty in dealing with wages, apart from the want of uniformity in the reports, is that an average wage for India generally, or for a single Province, has little meaning, as wages vary greatly according to locality. Thus, in Bengal wages are high in the east, where the peasantry are prosperous and considerable affluence prevails ; they reach a lower level in the central Districts, except where the prevalence of malarial fever has checked the growth of population1; and in the congested Districts of Bihār they sink very low. Bengal is not peculiar in this respect, for a low and non-progressive scale of wages will be found in all parts of India where agriculture is the chief occupation and the density of the population causes pressure on the means of subsistence. But wherever a demand for labour has been created by large undertakings, such as railways or canals, wages have risen. The establishment of mills and factories in many towns throughout the country, and the development of mining and other industries, have exercised a similar influence, illustrating the economic theory that wages depend mainly on the demand and supply of labour. It follows that high prices do not always involve high wages. In fact, the most direct connexion between prices and wages in India, and that which takes effect most rapidly, is the reduction of wages in times of scarcity, when food is also inordinately dear. The failure of the crops destroys a large portion of the fund used in paying wages, and the numbers seeking employment are greatly enhanced, so that those who find it often obtain in return the barest subsistence. When, however, a rise in the price of agricultural produce is due to a larger demand, and extra profits are thus obtained by the cultivator or landowner, wages may and do rise. The great boom in cotton during the American Civil War, and the profitable cultivation of jute in Eastern Bengal, are examples of this. As to payments in kind, in so far as the labourer receives the same quantity of grain, his real wages are unaffected by a rise in its price, unless he can save a portion and thus make a profit by selling it; but it must be borne in mind that, in the case of casual labour, remuneration in kind, like a cash wage, is affected by competition. In the Central Provinces, which have suffered during the last decade from two great famines and several bad seasons, there is a tendency for wages paid in grain to decrease, either in actual amount or by change from superior to inferior kinds of grain.
Although for purposes of accurate comparison the statistical data are seriously defective, they will serve for a rough indication of the course of wages. From a comparison of the Provincial averages which are summarized in the Appendix (pp. 472–4), it would appear that between 1873 and 1903 the wages of the three classes of labour—namely, the agricultural worker, the domestic servant (as represented by the syce), and the artisan— have all risen far more in Bengal, Assam, and the Punjab than in other parts of India, the indicated rates of increase being, for agricultural labour, 39 per cent. in Bengal, 41 per cent. in Assam, and 49 per cent. in the Punjab; and for artisan labour 48 per cent. in Bengal, 65 per cent. in Assam, and 50 per cent. in the Punjab. This establishes a relation between wages and the normal cost of living, for the staple food of Bengal and Assam is rice, the price of which has risen more than that of any other food-grain, and the price of all food-grains has also risen remarkably in the Punjab1. In Burma, where wages are very much higher than in India, there has been little advance. Similar stagnation is characteristic of Bombay, which started with a high level, while in Oudh, where wages have always been low, they appear to have fallen. Except in the case of agricultural labour, Madras shows a greater rise than the Central Provinces, the reported range for the three classes being an increase of from 6 to 13 per cent. in the Central Provinces, and from 10 to 15 per cent. in Madras. In every Province except Madras the smallest rise, or the greatest fall, is in the wages of horse-keepers, who are not, however, a very representative class. The common belief that the wages of skilled labour have advanced more than those of unskilled work is not altogether corroborated by the District returns for artisan labour, for this result appears in only three Provinces— Bengal, Assam, and Madras. The evidence of various records of wages in industrial establishments is also conflicting on this point, and therefore inconclusive, unless reservations are made as to particular kinds of employment and degrees of skill. A factor to be reckoned with is the very low standard of comfort prevailing among the working classes, and their unwillingness to accept better circumstances when coupled with conditions that are not wholly congenial. This it is which explains the general difficulty of obtaining a sufficient supply of labour for tea gardens, collieries, or factories. Prejudices are, however, disappearing, and of late years a great improvement has taken place in the mobility of labour. Besides the emigration to foreign countries and the tea districts which is regulated by law, there are large and constantly increasing migrations of labourers, by sea and land, to other countries and Provinces, or from District to District within the same Province2. These periodical movements are largely for the performance of agricultural work, but are none the less beneficial in relieving the pressure in densely populated agricultural districts, where the remuneration of the labourer is often but a scanty subsistence. As this process proceeds, and the supply of labour for industrial employments adjusts itself to the growing demand caused by the development of the country, the condition of the Indian labouring classes must constantly tend to improve.
Evidence of progress already made in material prosperity is furnished by the increased consumption of salt (5 seers per head in 1903 against 3·6 in 1871), by the large development of the excise revenue during this period (see Vol. IV, chap. viii), and by the great increase in savings banks deposits (chap. viii of the present volume). Reference may also be made to chap. xxiv of the India Office Report on the Moral and Material Progress of India, 1901–2, which contains an abstract, prepared from memoranda compiled by the Local Governments, of the economic condition of the people in the principal Provinces during the preceding decade. Marked though that decade was by very severe famines and by the visitation of plague, the results generally show satisfactory progress, save in the Central Provinces and in the Bombay Presidency proper, which suffered most severely from famine during this period.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Rents
C. D. Field.—Landholding and the Relation of Landlord and Tenant in various Countries. (Calcutta, 1885.)
R. F. Rampini and M. Finucane.—The Bengal Tenancy Act VIII of 1885, with Notes and Rulings, &c. (Calcutta, 1886.)
Also the Tenancy Acts of the various Provinces, and most of the works quoted at the end of the chapter on Land Revenue (Vol. IV, chap. vii).
Prices and Wages
The annual publication of the Director-General of Statistics, entitled Prices and Wages in India.
F. Chambers.—Variations of the Prices of Staple Food-grains in the Bombay Presidency. (Bombay, 1886.)
J. E. O'Conor.—Indian Price and Wage Levels, 1861 to 1873 and 1874 to 1887. (Calcutta, 1887.)
J. A. Robertson.—Variations in Indian Price Levels since 1861, expressed in Index Numbers. (Calcutta, 1905.)
Chapter xxiv of the Report on the Moral and Material Progress of India, 1901–2 (India Office).
APPENDIX
Average Monthly Wage, in Rupees and Decimals of a Rupee, of—
| Province. | AVERAGES. | Percentage of rise between 1873 and 1903*. | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1873–5. | 1876–80. | 1881–5. | 1886–90. | 1891–5. | 1896–1900. | 1901–3. | ||
| Bengal | 5·0 to 5·3 | 5·2 to 5·7 | 5·5 to 6·0 | 6·0 to 6·6 | 5·8 to 6·5 | 6·3 to 7·3 | 6·5 to 7·1 | 39·3 |
| Assam | 6·5 to 6·8 | 7·7 to 8·5 | 7·0 to 7·9 | 6·5 to 7·2 | 7·1 to 8·2 | 8·0 to 9·4 | 8·0 to 10·7 | 40·6 |
| United Provinces : | ||||||||
| Agra | 4·1 | 4·2 | 3·8 to 4·1 | 4·3 to 4·4 | 4·4 to 4·8 | 3·9 to 4·4 | 4·1 to 4·7 | 22·7 |
| Oudh | 3·2 to 3·4 | 2·9 to 3·3 | 2·8 to 3·1 | 3·4 | 3·2 to 3·7 | 2·8 to 3·5 | 3·0 to 3·7 | – 2·0† |
| Punjab and Frontier Province | 5·3 | 5·8 | 6·2 | 6·6 | 6·7 | 7·5 | 8·0 to 8·1 | 49·4 |
| Madras | 4·0 | 4·3 | 4·3 | 4·3 to 4·6 | 4·1 | 4·2 | 4·3 | 9·8 |
| Bombay | 7·5 to 7·8 | 7·1 to 7·6 | 7·4 to 8·1 | 7·4 to 7·8 | 7·6 to 8·0 | 7·1 to 7·5 | 7·6 | 11·6 |
| Central Provinces | 3·9 | 4·3 | 4·3 to 4·4 | 3·8 to 4·1 | 4·2 to 4·6 | 4·1 | 4·4 | 12·5 |
| Burma | 16·6 to 17·3 | 17·2 to 19·0 | 14·3 to 15·1 | 15·3 to 16·5 | 14·0 to 14·7 | 14·5 to 15·2 | 14·1 to 15·1 | 8·5 |
| Average for all India | 6·2 to 6·4 | 6·5 to 7·0 | 6·2 to 6·6 | 6·4 to 6·8 | 6·3 to 6·8 | 6·5 to 7·0 | 6·7 to 7·3 | 20·6 |
| PROVINCE. | AVERAGES. | Percentage of rise between 1873 and 1903*. | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1873-5. | 1876-80. | 1881-5. | 1886-90. | 1891-5. | 1896-1900. | 1901-3. | ||
| Bengal . . . | 4·9 to 5·2 | 4·8 to 5·4 | 5·2 to 5·8 | 5·2 to 6·0 | 5·4 to 6·3 | 5·9 to 6·6 | 6·0 to 6·8 | 32·0 |
| Assam . . . | 6·9 to 7·3 | 7·6 to 8·4 | 7·5 to 8·6 | 7·2 to 8·4 | 7·9 to 9·7 | 8·1 to 10·2 | 8·0 to 9·7 | 30·2 |
| United Provinces: | ||||||||
| Agra . . . | 4·5 | 4·4 | 4·4 to 4·7 | 4·7 | 4·7 to 5·2 | 4·5 to 5·1 | 4·6 to 5·2 | 15·6 |
| Oudh . . . | 4·4 to 4·5 | 4·3 to 4·6 | 4·2 to 4·3 | 4·2 | 4·4 | 4·0 | 4·0 | —9·3† |
| Punjab and Frontier Province | 5·5 | 6·0 | 6·4 | 6·3 | 6·2 | 6·5 | 7·0 to 7·1 | 22·5 |
| Madras . . . | 5·8 | 5·8 | 5·6 | 5·8 to 6·0 | 6·2 | 6·4 | 6·3 | 11·9 |
| Bombay . . . | 8·5 | 7·8 to 8·2 | 8·1 to 8·9 | 8·3 to 8·7 | 8·4 to 8·9 | 7·9 to 8·4 | 8·7 | 1·9 |
| Central Provinces . . | 5·6 | 5·6 | 5·7 to 5·8 | 5·2 to 5·7 | 5·6 to 6·4 | 6·0 | 5·6 | 6·4 |
| Burma . . . | 11·3 to 13·0 | 11·7 to 12·9 | 12·4 to 12·9 | 13·0 to 13·5 | 13·7 to 14·2 | 13·1 to 14·5 | 12·1 to 13·4 | —5·6† |
| Average for all India . | 6·4 to 6·7 | 6·4 to 6·8 | 6·6 to 7·0 | 6·6 to 7·1 | 6·9 to 7·5 | 6·9 to 7·5 | 6·9 to 7·4 | 9·5 |
| PROVINCE. | AVERAGES. | Percentage of rise between 1873 and 1903*. | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1873-5. | 1876-80. | 1881-5. | 1886-90. | 1891-5. | 1896-1900. | 1901-3. | ||
| Bengal . . . . . . . | 7·6 to 11·6 | 7·7 to 11·3 | 8·0 to 12·0 | 8·6 to 12·8 | 9·0 to 14·1 | 10·2 to 14·6 | 11·4 to 15·3 | 47·6 |
| Assam . . . . . . . | 12·0 to 16·9 | 12·8 to 17·2 | 14·1 to 26·5 | 13·9 to 32·5 | 14·1 to 35·0 | 13·3 to 34·6 | 13·5 to 32·7 | 64·9 |
| United Provinces : | ||||||||
| Agra . . . . . . . | 9·8 | 8·9 | 8·2 to 9·3 | 8·4 to 10·6 | 9·7 to 10·8 | 8·8 to 9·6 | 8·9 to 10·3 | 1·6 |
| Oudh . . . . . . . | 7·1 | 7·4 to 7·9 | 7·6 to 8·1 | 7·5 to 10·1 | 8·7 to 10·4 | 6·9 to 7·4 | 6·8 to 7·4 | -2·6† |
| Punjab and Frontier Province | 12·7 | 14·1 | 14·8 | 15·7 to 16·1 | 16·4 | 18·5 | 18·5 to 20·2 | 50·1 |
| Madras . . . . . . . | 12·7 | 13·0 | 13·7 | 13·3 to 13·9 | 13·6 to 15·2 | 13·6 to 15·6 | 13·5 to 15·4 | 15·5 |
| Bombay . . . . . . . | 19·1 to 23·8 | 19·3 to 23·3 | 19·9 to 24·2 | 20·4 to 25·0 | 19·2 to 24·7 | 18·7 to 25·5 | 17·7 to 22·8 | -3·3† |
| Central Provinces . . . . . | 12·4 | 13·0 to 14·4 | 14·4 to 15·3 | 12·0 to 13·9 | 12·2 to 15·5 | 11·8 to 12·8 | 12·9 to 13·7 | 12·6 |
| Burma . . . . . . . | 25·2 to 31·3 | 27·5 to 34·5 | 29·7 to 32·5 | 28·8 to 30·4 | 24·3 to 27·6 | 26·6 to 31·1 | 27·3 to 32·6 | 6·9 |
| Average for all India . . . | 13·2 to 15·4 | 13·8 to 16·1 | 14·5 to 17·4 | 14·3 to 18·3 | 14·1 to 18·8 | 14·3 to 18·9 | 14·5 to 18·9 | 19·4 |
Notes
- 1. See Vol. IV, chap. vii, Land Revenue.
- 1. Other classes of tenants are also recognized in several Provinces, under the names of tenure holders, tenants at fixed rates, absolute occupancy tenants, &c., at one end of the scale, and sub-tenants at the other; but the bulk of the rent legislation is concerned with the two classes mentioned in the text.
- 1. In portions of the Madras Presidency also, where there are large proprietors holding under a permanent land-revenue assessment, such proprietors are bound, by an Act passed in 1865, to enter into mutual written agreements with their tenants as a preliminary to the grant of assistance by the courts in distraint, eviction, &c.; and the courts, in dealing with suits to enforce such written agreements against a tenant, are enabled to adjudicate on enhancements of rent. An improved and more elaborate Rent Act for Madras is at present (1905) under consideration.
- *. Information not available.
- 1. A seer is about 2 lb.
- *. The percentages here are on the price of January, 1874.
- 1. As regards distribution of employment, the following passage from Vol. I, chap. ix, which summarizes the ‘occupation’ figures of the 1901 Census, may be conveniently repeated here: ‘Nearly two-thirds of the population in 1901 relied on some form of agriculture as their principal means of subsistence: 52 per cent. were either landlords or tenants, 12 per
- 1. In Burdwān, for instance, wages are very high.
- 1. Throughout the greater part of India the purchase of food is by far the chief necessary expense which the labourer has to incur. His hut and his scanty clothing cost him very little, and sticks and cow-dung supply his demand for fuel.
- 2. For information as to migration see Vol. I, chap. ix, Population.
- *. Whereas the preceding columns give averages, this column represents the actual difference between the first year (1873) and the last year (1903) of the series.
- †. Decrease.
- *. Whereas the preceding columns give averages, this column represents the actual difference between the first year (1873) and the last year (1903) of the series.
- †. Decrease.
- *. Whereas the preceding columns give averages, this column represents the actual difference between the first year (1873) and the last year (1903) of the series. † Decrease.