ADMINISTRATIVE
CHAPTER I
THE GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
The subject of this chapter is the growth and character of the British administration in India, but the preliminary paragraphs will give some idea of the general nature of the Hindu and Muhammadan governments which ruled the country in former times.
During the long ages preceding the Muhammadan supremacy, the social organization of the Hindus passed through gradual stages of development and decay such as are incident to all human institutions. No description could be given which would apply at once to the early conquerors and settlers on the banks of the Indus, to the Hindu kingdoms which during a later age occupied the bulk of the Indian Peninsula, and to their successors in the days of their decline. For the present purpose it will suffice to select a central epoch, and the period which is illustrated by the code of Manu will be the most suitable. Scholars assign to this code in its present form a date lying between the second century before and the second century after Christ. It is a metrical recension of an older prose code, which formed one of a number of similar works composed by the founders of different schools for repetition by their students. After the death of Alexander the Great, Chandra Gupta Maurya, grandfather of the famous Asoka, reigned over the whole of Northern India from Bihār to the Punjab for some twenty years ; and although the metrical code was prepared at a somewhat later date, it probably portrays fairly closely the state of society which prevailed when this great monarch ruled. Additional light has been thrown on this period by Arrian, Strabo, and other Greek writers, and especially by Megasthenes, the ambassador of Seleucus—who had succeeded to the eastern portion of Alexander’s empire— at the court of Chandra Gupta.
The system of government described in the code is an absolute monarchy, and the boldest poetical figures are used to describe the power and glory of the king1. His main functions are declared to be to restrain violence and to punish evildoers. The manner in which he should pass the day is laid down with some minuteness. He is to rise in the last watch of the night, make the morning sacrifice, hold public audience, consult with his ministers in some lonely place from which women and talking birds are carefully excluded, take exercise, bathe, dine, transact personal and family business, give some time to relaxation, review his troops, perform his religious duties at sunset, receive the reports of his emissaries, withdraw to his private apartments for supper, and, after indulging for some time in music, retire to rest. The court was maintained with some magnificence, and the Greek writers describe gorgeous processions and raiment. The king is to appoint seven councillors to assist him in the administration, and one learned Brāhman distinguished above them all. He is also to employ suitable persons for the collection of the revenues, and an ‘ambassador,’ who appears to have fulfilled the functions of a minister of foreign affairs. The administration is to be conducted by a chain of civil officers, rising from heads of single townships or villages to heads of 1,000 villages. The villages enjoyed a large measure of local autonomy, according to the immemorial custom of the country. The code of Manu refers to the village community, but gives little indication of its great importance. Megasthenes found the system in full force, and each little rural unit seemed to the Greek an independent republic. Every considerable town had its superintendent of affairs, whose duty it was to check the abuses to which the local officers were (it is said) prone. Megasthenes mentions that India was divided into 118 kingdoms. The Hindu kings must have waged frequent war, for a considerable portion of the code of Manu is filled with maxims and instructions regarding military organization and foreign politics, and large armies were maintained. According to Megasthenes, Chandra Gupta had an army more than twice as large as that which now defends the whole of the Indian Empire, and well furnished with elephants and war-chariots. The country was divided into military divisions, each maintaining a body of troops under an approved leader. The arts which may be employed against enemies are four—presents, sowing divisions, negotiations, and force of arms : the wise, it is said, prefer the two last. The king is to regard his nearest neighbours as hostile, the powers next beyond these natural foes as friendly, and all more remote powers as neutral. Great importance is attached to spies, both in foreign politics and in war. The laws of war and conquest were remarkable for their humanity. The revenue consisted of a share of the produce of land, taxes on commerce, a small annual imposition on traders and shopkeepers, and a forced service of a day in each month by artisans and labourers. The degree to which the actual administration conformed to the model presented by the code of Manu must have depended largely on the character and ability of the king. The accounts given by Greek and Chinese travellers and writers show that the people were on the whole contented and well governed.
The greatest and last among the Muhammadan dynasties which ruled Hindustān was the Mughal house of Tīmūr; and the greatest of the Mughal sovereigns was Akbar, who reigned from 1556 to 1605 and consolidated under his sway a vast territory extending from Kandahār to the farther confines of Bengal and from the Himālayas to the Deccan. A detailed account of Akbar's court and government has been preserved in the Ain-i-Akbarī or Institutes of Akbar, written by his friend and minister Abul Fazl; in other contemporary histories; and in the descriptions given by Europeans who visited the court of ‘The Great Mogul.’ The court itself was maintained on a scale of the most costly magnificence. No scene in India conveys a more vivid impression of oriental splendour than the panorama from the palace of Fatehpur Sīkri near Agra, for some time Akbar's capital. The splendid halls, the spacious courtyards and stables, the beautiful houses of the queens, the graceful mosque, and the numerous other edifices devoted to business or pleasure must, in their prime, have formed a residence well worthy of a great king. ‘The good prince,’ says Abul Fazl, ‘refuses not his attention to the most trivial points,’ and this principle was carried out to the full in the management of Akbar's stupendous establishment. The Ain-i-Akbarī contains details regarding the government of every department of the court. The treasury, the jewel office, the mint, the harem, the camp equipage, the department of the water-cooler, the kitchen, the fruitery, the perfume office, the wardrobe, the library, the picture gallery, the armoury, and the stables are all the subject of precise and minute rules.
Religious toleration, and a desire to conciliate and include within his system the Hindu population, were the key-notes of Akbar's government. For the purpose of administration the empire was divided into fifteen sūbahs or provinces. To each province was appointed a governor in whom was vested, under the emperor, the supreme civil and military authority. Akbar's revenue policy was based on ancient Hindu customs, and much of it survives to this day. 'He first executed a survey to measure the land. His officers then found out the produce of each acre of land, and settled the government share, amounting to one-third of the gross produce. Finally, they fixed the rate at which this share of the crop might be commuted into a money payment. These processes, known as the land settlement, were at first repeated every year. But to save the peasant from the extortions and vexations incident to an annual inquiry, Akbar's land settlement was afterwards made for ten years. His officers strictly enforced the payment of a third of the whole produce, and Akbar's land revenue from Northern India exceeded what the British take (from a much larger area) at the present day1.' The settlement was made under the direction of Akbar's great Hindu minister, Rājā Todar Mal. The principal local revenue collector was the amalguzār. He was a magistrate and police officer as well as a revenue official, and had to concern himself with all matters affecting the well-being of the peasantry. His duties as described in the Ain-i-Akbarī bear a striking resemblance, on a small scale, to those of the Magistrate and Collector of a modern British District. He is instructed to consider himself the immediate friend of the husbandman, to be diligent in business and a strict observer of truth. It is his duty to punish 'the crafty and disobedient' who are not amenable to admonition, and he must not be satisfied with receiving a pecuniary fine in exculpation of murder or other capital offences. He is to endeavour to bring waste lands under the plough, and may allow some remission of the general rate of collection in order to promote the cultivation 'of such articles as will produce general profit and utility.' He is to assist the needy cultivator with loans of money to be repaid at convenient periods. The local treasury is entrusted to his care, and he must send the receipts to head-quarters as soon as they exceed a certain sum. He has to take charge of the effects of absentees and of those who die without heirs, and must report the circumstance to the governor. He is required to make a monthly report on the condition of the people, the market price of goods, and all occurrences of interest.
Every considerable town was in the charge of a magistrate styled the kotwāl, who was the head of the police and supervised all branches of the local administration. Outside the towns there was no regular police force, but the villages had their hereditary watchmen. Apart from the magistrates justice was administered by a court, composed of an officer named the mīr-adl ('lord of justice') and a kāzī learned in the Muhammadan law. The latter conducted the trial and stated the law; the former, who appears to have been the superior officer, passed judgement.
Aurangzeb, the sixth of the Tīmūr dynasty, was the last of the great emperors of Delhi. His bigotry did much to undo the work of Akbar's wise and tolerant policy, and his reign witnessed the rise of the Marāthā power. On his death, in 1707, the empire of the Mughals fell into disorder and decay and, after a period of universal strife, was replaced by the empire of the British.
The history of British India falls, as observed by Sir C. P. Ilbert in his Government of India, into three periods. From the beginning of the seventeenth to the middle of the eighteenth century the East India Company is a trading corporation, existing on the sufferance of the native powers and in rivalry with the merchant companies of Holland and France. During the next century the Company acquires and consolidates its dominion, shares its sovereignty in increasing proportions with the Crown, and gradually loses its mercantile privileges and functions. After the Mutiny of 1857 the remaining powers of the Company are transferred to the Crown, and then follows an era of peace in which India awakens to new life and progress. It is not the function of the present chapter to enter into the details of this history. But political institutions cannot be rightly understood without some study of their growth; and in India the development of the administrative system has followed so closely the course of territorial acquisition that it will be necessary to pass in brief review the salient incidents of the rise of British power.
On September 24, 1599, a few years before the deaths of Queen Elizabeth and Akbar, the merchants of London resolved to form an association for the purpose of establishing direct trade with the East. On the last day of the sixteenth century (December 31, 1600), the Queen granted a Charter incorporating George, Earl of Cumberland, and 215 Knights, Aldermen, and Burgesses, by the name of the ‘Governor and Company of Merchants of London trading with the East Indies.’ The Charter conferred on this company a monopoly of the trade with all countries lying between the Cape of Good Hope and the Straits of Magellan. For a century and a half the pursuit of trade was the object of the Company’s existence. Its monopoly was continued by successive Charters of the Stuart monarchs, as also by Cromwell, and its powers were extended to meet the needs occasioned by the growth of its enterprise and the establishment of its settlements. Trading relations were instituted with Masulipatam on the east, and Surat on the west, coast in the years 1611 and 1612. Madras was rented from a local Rājā in 1639. Bombay was ceded by Portugal to the British Crown as part of the dower of Catherine of Braganza in 1661, and granted in 1668 to the East India Company to be held of the Crown ‘as of the Manor of Greenwich in free and common soccage.’ Leave to trade with Bengal was obtained from the Mughal emperor in 1634; the factory at Hooghly was established in 1640; and Calcutta owes its foundation to the events of 1686, when Job Charnock was forced to quit Hooghly by the deputy of Aurangzeb and settled farther down the river. The Revolution of 1688 imperilled the position of the old or ‘London’ Company. It had to struggle for its privileges with a new ‘English’ Company, and after several years of contention the two were amalgamated by Lord Godolphin’s award of 1702 as the ‘United Company of Merchants of England trading to the East Indies.’ From this period the Company’s status was regulated by Acts of Parliament instead of by Charters from the Crown.
Queen Elizabeth’s Charter empowered the Company to assemble and hold court for the purpose of making laws for its government, and vested the direction of its affairs in a Governor and twenty-four persons who were elected annually. By the end of the seventeenth century this constitution had developed into the General Court of Proprietors and the Court of Directors. Every holder of £500 stock had a vote in the Court of Proprietors, and the possession of £2,000 stock was the qualification for a Director. The Directors were still twenty-four in number, and were still elected annually by the Proprietors, who could also overrule their proceedings, a power which they exercised towards the close of Warren Hastings’ administration by maintaining him in office in the teeth both of the Directors and of resolutions of the House of Commons1. At the close of this period the factories and affairs of the Company on the east and west coasts of India, and in Bengal, were administered, at each of its principal settlements of Madras (Fort St. George), Bombay, and Calcutta (Fort William), by a President (or Governor) and a Council consisting of the senior servants of the Company. Power was exercised by the President and Council collectively, and orders were issued in accordance with the votes of the majority. The three ‘Presidencies’ were independent of one another and subordinate only to the Directors in England. The servants of the Company were classified, beginning from the lowest rank, as writers, factors, senior factors, and merchants. Promotion was usually by seniority. Salaries were extremely small, but large fortunes were made by private trade, supplemented occasionally by less honourable means.
In the middle of the eighteenth century, when the East India Company first began to play a part in the political affairs of India, the Mughal power was tottering to its fall, and the great Marāthā confederacy, the chief officers of the empire, the old Hindu princes, and newly-risen soldiers of fortune were warring incessantly for the mastery of its possessions. The emperor still nominally held the greater part of Northern India, but over most of this territory his authority was but a shadow of past dominion. Ahmad Shāh, the Afghān, wrested the Punjab from him in 1752 ; and this country remained under Afghān rule until, some fifty years later, it was conquered by Ranjīt Singh and his Sikhs. Rohilkhand, the country lying in the angle between the Upper Ganges and the Himālayas, had been appropriated by daring adventurers, known as Rohillas, from the Afghān hills. The viceroys of Oudh and Bengal had converted their provinces into virtually independent kingdoms. The Rājputāna States had fallen under the supremacy of the Marāthās, who levied at their pleasure large contributions from the Rājput chiefs. The Marāthās had by this time become the foremost power in India ; and, although their empire had not yet reached its fullest limits, they had already spread across the Peninsula from the west coast to the confines of Bengal, and from the Tungabhadra in the south to the Jumna in the north. In the Deccan the most powerful ruler, outside the Marāthā territories, was the Nizām-ul-mulk, another Mughal viceroy who had shaken off the control of Delhi and whose successor still rules at Hyderābād. His nominal subordinate, the Nawāb of the Carnatic, ruled over the territory on the east coast which now forms the principal part of the Madras Presidency. In the south of the Peninsula were various Hindu principalities, of which the largest was Mysore, under a Hindu prince of ancient family, destined to fall ere long into the power of Haidar Alī, a Muhammadan adventurer. Such was the position of the main actors in the drama. None of them had an assured dominion, and their boundaries changed incessantly with the varying chances of war.
In this hotbed of strife the Company found the rôle of the peaceful trader impossible to maintain. When the central authority could no longer afford it protection, it had to arm itself against the caprice or the covetousness of the local potentates, and also against the rivalry of the French. It was the action of the French in the Carnatic which first drove the British to take an active share in the struggle for power which convulsed the South of India. Dupleix, the Governor of the French possessions, realized the possibilities resulting from the decline of the Mughal empire, and conceived the idea of founding a European dominion, by taking part in the war of factions and supporting the cause he espoused with native troops armed and disciplined in the fashion of the West. He pursued this policy with such skill and success that he established his nominees at Hyderābād and in the Carnatic, and secured a paramount influence in this part of India. The British, finding themselves in danger of being driven from their establishments on the east coast, were compelled to support the cause of rival candidates. The further course of the struggle, the brilliant part which Clive took in it, and the causes of the French failure, cannot be recounted in this place. The crucial point is that when, in 1761, Pondicherry was captured by Sir Eyre Coote and the power of the French finally overthrown, the East India Company was left in a position of political and military ascendancy and had to accept the responsibilities and duties of this new situation.
The forward policy of the British in Northern India likewise arose indirectly from rivalry with the French. Alarmed by the prospect of a declaration of war in Europe, they began to strengthen the defences of Fort William, in face of a prohibition from Sirāj-ud-daula, the Nawāb of Bengal. It was this encroachment upon his rights of sovereignty, combined with other causes for displeasure, that induced the Nawāb to march upon Calcutta with a large army. He took the town and perpetrated, or suffered to take place, the tragedy of the Black Hole. In the war which followed Clive routed the Nawāb at Plassey (1757), and at once secured the virtual mastery of the richest province in India, thereby transferring the centre of the Company's power from Madras to Calcutta. In imitation of Dupleix's system, a puppet Nawāb was set up and maintained by the Company's troops. The plan worked badly, and a period of misgovernment culminated in the invasion of Bengal by the Nawāb Wazīr of Oudh, who carried in his camp the titular emperor of Delhi. He was defeated by Major Hector Munro at Buxar, on the Ganges, in the year 1764. Clive, who had returned to India after an absence of some years, then obtained from the emperor the Dīwāni or administration of the revenues of Bengal, Bihār, and Orissa, which carried with it the exercise of civil jurisdiction, though the Nizāmat, or criminal jurisdiction, and police powers remained with the Nawāb. The management was, however, left under native control until 1772, when the Company 'stood forth as Dīwān' and took over the direct administration of the revenue, which was soon followed by the assumption also of criminal jurisdiction. The full rights of territorial sovereignty over Bengal thus passed to the Company. The victory of Buxar carried the British arms to Allāhābād ; Oudh was at their mercy ; and Clive saw clearly, and stated explicitly, that the whole Mughal empire lay within their grasp. But neither he nor the Company was willing to entertain so vast a scheme of conquest ; and they therefore restored the territories on the northern side of the Ganges to the Nawāb-Wazīr of Oudh, and concluded a treaty with that prince which helped to secure peace on the Bengal frontier for a period of forty years.
The period of Warren Hastings' rule (1772–85) was one of great peril for the British dominion in India, as in other parts of the world. Britain was at war with all the great maritime powers—France, Holland, and Spain—and with her own colonies in North America. In India she had to face Haidar Alī, who had by this time carved out a great kingdom in the south of the Peninsula, and also the formidable Marāthā power. Both were in league with the French, who endeavoured, as in America, to cut off the British forces from their home base. But the English fleet succeeded in keeping the command of the sea; and when Hastings resigned the Governor-Generalship in 1785, ten years' war had left the British with their position unshaken. The only new territories acquired during this period were the domain of the Rājā of Benares, adjoining the Company's possessions in Bihār, and Salsette island in the neighbourhood of Bombay. In the north the Rohilla War had strengthened the frontier against the Marāthās, by transferring Rohilkhand from its Afghān rulers to the Nawāb Wazīr of Oudh.
Lord Cornwallis succeeded to the Governor-Generalship in 1786. He came out with the instruction and the desire to pursue a pacific and moderate policy. In 1784 an Act of Parliament had declared that 'to pursue schemes of conquest and extension of dominion in India are measures repugnant to the wish, the honour and policy of this nation.' But no Act of Parliament could stay the march of events. Lord Cornwallis found Tipū Sultān, the son of Haidar Alī, scheming with the French and with every other power which he thought could aid him to retaliate on the British. The Marāthās were at the height of their power, and disturbed or menaced the peace of every State in India. Sindhia had gained the chief place in the confederacy and had carried his conquests far into the north. The Oudh government was becoming weak and inefficient, and that State was falling more and more completely under British protection. Cornwallis succeeded in avoiding actual hostilities with the Marāthās, but Tipū Sultān forced a war on him by an unjustifiable attack on Travancore, a State under British protection. He was defeated in 1792 by the allied forces of the Company, the Nizām, and the Marāthās, and was stripped of a large part of his dominions, including several districts added to the Madras Presidency.
From 1792 to 1798 the British maintained a rigid attitude of non-interference, with the result that the Sultān of Mysore and the Marāthā chiefs augmented their military forces and extended their territories at the expense of their neighbours. In April, 1798, Lord Mornington (afterwards Marquis Wellesley) landed in India and during seven years pursued a very different policy. He determined to establish the ascendancy of the British power over all other States in India by a system of subsidiary treaties, so framed as 'to deprive them of the means of prosecuting any measure or of forming any confederacy hazardous to the security of the British empire, and to enable us to preserve the tranquillity of India by exercising a general control over the restless spirit of ambition and violence which is characteristic of every Asiatic government1.’ He executed his plan with complete success; and when he left India, the Punjab, Sind, and Nepāl were the only territories which remained completely outside the paramount British influence, while the area of direct occupation had also been greatly enlarged. Events had been hastened by the Napoleonic wars. Tipū Sultān, who still retained a seaport on the Malabar coast, entered into negotiations for an alliance with France, and received into his capital a small body of French volunteers. War was declared against him; he was slain in the storm of Seringapatam and his territories were confiscated. A portion was given to our ally, the Nizām of Hyderābād; the present State of Mysore was restored to the ancient Hindu dynasty by which it is now ruled; and the rest was incorporated in the Madras Presidency. In 1801 the Carnatic, which had for many years been in complete dependence on the Company, was brought under direct administration. Thus in a few months the Madras Presidency developed from some scattered districts into the great Province now known by that name. The state of confusion in Oudh, and the danger to be apprehended in this direction from the Marāthās, necessitated a resettlement of affairs there. The Nawāb ceded all his frontier districts, including Rohilkhand, and the revenue of this territory was taken as an equivalent for the subsidy payable for the troops employed in the defence of this State. This annexation confronted the British and the Marāthā chief Sindhia along the whole line of the latter’s possessions in Northern India. The Marāthā confederacy, which extended from Malabar almost to the Himālayas, was now the only power which seriously threatened the British dominion. But the great chiefs and the Peshwā (the titular head of the confederation) were at strife among themselves. Sindhia was the most important of the chiefs and held possession of the Mughal emperor’s person. Lord Wellesley intervened on behalf of the Peshwā. War broke out in 1803, and after a well-contested series of engagements the Marāthās were defeated and sued for peace. A British force was stationed at Poona, the capital of the Peshwā; and in the north a large tract of territory was ceded to the Company which, with the districts already acquired from the Nawāb of Oudh, now goes to form the greater part of the Province of Agra.
Lord Wellesley's policy had been carried out in despite of the Directors, and when he left India another period of reaction set in. The British, retiring within their borders, declared that they would abstain from interference in the affairs of the Native States. But they had already assumed the position of paramount power, and it was impossible that they could remain uninterested spectators of the violence and anarchy which soon filled all India outside their immediate jurisdiction. Lord Hastings' endeavours to restore order and to put down the hordes of freebooting Pindāris resulted in another Marāthā war (1817–18), which finally broke up the confederation and extinguished the power of the Peshwā. A large tract of country was annexed in Western India, thus giving to the Bombay Presidency a territorial importance similar to that already possessed by Bengal and Madras. At the same time the Saugor and Nerbudda territories, which now form a part of the Central Provinces, were taken from the Marāthā Rājā of Nāgpur. A tract along the Himālayas had previously been won from Nepāl, while the principality of Coorg, in the south, was annexed, as the result of misgovernment, in 1834.
From the Sutlej to the Brahmaputra no power was left to challenge the predominance of British rule, and henceforth the north-western and eastern frontiers became the chief spheres of political and military activity. In 1824 depredations on the Bengal frontier first brought the Burmese into collision with the Government of India. The war which followed ended in the acquisition of Assam, Arakan, and Tenasserim. In the north-west Russian progress into Central Asia brought another great nation within the sphere of Indian politics. Two Native States extended along the British border from the Arabian Sea to the Himālayas. To the south Sind was ruled by Muhammadan Amīrs; to the north the military and religious brotherhood of the Sikhs occupied the Punjab. Sind was conquered by Sir Charles Napier in 1843 and the British frontier pushed on to Baluchistān. The Sikhs were a formidable military power and had contended successfully with the Afghāns. In the anarchy and confusion which followed the death of Ranjīt Singh, 'the Lion of the Punjab,' the Sikh army crossed the border (1845) and invaded British territory. After a series of desperate engagements they were driven back across the Sutlej, and for two years the State was administered under the general protection and superintendence of the Indian Government. In 1848 the military classes rose in insurrection, and after a second hard-fought campaign were finally overthrown. The Punjab was annexed by Lord Dalhousie in 1849, and since then the border line has run between British India and Afghānistān. The wars with Afghānistān, which belong to the external politics of British India, need not be noticed here. The only territory acquired beyond the Sulaimān range on the north-west frontier is the minor Province of Baluchistān, which includes the military base of Quetta first occupied in 1876. The Kurram valley, which was first occupied during the Afghān War (1878–80), was finally taken over at the request of the Tūri inhabitants in 1893 ; and the Wazīristān tract has been brought under British political administration by gradual stages, beginning in 1892.
In 1852 Pegu was annexed, as the result of the second Burmese War, to become, with Arakan and Tenasserim, the Province of Lower Burma. In 1853 the Nizām of Hyderābād made over certain districts called the Berārs to be held in trust as payment for the forces maintained for his protection, and the British occupation of these has recently (1902) been confirmed by a perpetual lease from the Nizām. Nāgpur lapsed in 1854, on the death of its Rājā without heirs, and became the nucleus of the Central Provinces. The kingdom of Oudh was annexed in 1856, to protect its people from continued misgovernment and oppression. In 1857 came the Mutiny ; and in the following year the government of India was formally transferred from the Company to the Crown, while accompanying the transfer the Queen's celebrated Proclamation promised maintenance of the rights of Native Princes, enjoined the strictest religious neutrality, and notified that 'so far as may be, our subjects of whatever race and creed [shall] be freely and impartially admitted to offices in our service the duties of which they may be qualified by their education, ability, and integrity duly to discharge.' From this time onwards the history of India is mainly concerned with administrative improvement and the development of the arts of peace. Beyond the advance on the north-west frontier above referred to, the only important addition made to the empire since the Mutiny is the large province of Upper Burma, acquired by conquest in 1886.
One noticeable feature of the history of British India, which is apparent even from the rough sketch just concluded, is that the tide of conquest never turned against the Company. Once it had taken a province under its direct administration it was able to ensure permanent peace to the inhabitants, however distracted might be the condition of those parts of India which had not been brought under its sway. From this most important circumstance it followed that the building up of the administrative system proceeded almost without interruption from the days of the Company's earliest conquests.
We can now deal with the evolution of the Government of India as at present constituted, and of the subordinate administrations, and shall then touch on the system of control exercised by the Home Government. Finally a brief account will be given of the civil service, the internal administration of the Provinces being left to the next chapter.
The system of government by mutually independent and unwieldy councils1 of the merchants at the Presidency towns gave rise to grave abuses: it was hardly adequate for the management of the local affairs of a large trading corporation, and became impossible as soon as the Company was called upon to fill a more important rôle. Clive's victories, and the grant of the rich Province of Bengal, fixed public attention on India; and at the same time the financial affairs of the Company fell into disorder, while its servants, the 'Nabobs,' returned home with large fortunes amassed, it was rumoured, in the most unscrupulous manner. Parliament intervened. Several inquiries were held and statutes passed; and finally, in the year 1773, during the administration of Lord North, was enacted the Regulating Act, 'for the better management of the affairs of the East India Company as well in India as in Europe.' The reforms instituted in the Home Government by this and subsequent Acts belong to a later portion of this chapter. In India a Governor-General and four Councillors were nominated to administer the Presidency of Fort William (Bengal), and the supremacy of that Presidency over Madras and Bombay was for the first time declared. The subordinate Presidencies were forbidden to wage war or make treaties without the previous consent of the Governor-General of Bengal in Council, except in case of imminent necessity2. The Governors of these Presidencies were directed in general terms to obey the orders of the Governor-General-in-Council, and to transmit to him intelligence of all important matters. But the then isolated situation of the three Presidencies rendered the control of the Bengal Government more theoretical than real, as was shortly proved by the embarrassing action of the Bombay authorities in the Marāthā troubles of 1775-82. Other provisions of the Act were directed against the prevailing abuses, and private trade and the receipt of presents were forbidden to the servants of the Company.
Pitt's Act of 1784, which established the Board of Control in England, vested the administration of each of the three Presidencies in a Governor and three Councillors, including the Commander-in-Chief of the Presidency army. At the same time the control of the Governor-General-in-Council over Madras and Bombay was somewhat extended, as it was again by the Charter Act of 1793; but distance still secured for the subordinate Presidencies the continuance for some time of much of their independence of action, and its final curtailment was due as much to the British possessions becoming contiguous, and to the development of means of communication, as to mere injunctions of subordination to the central Government. The extension of territorial possessions which took place during Lord Wellesley's administration (1798–1805) carried the Company a long step forward in the course of its transition from a trading corporation to a ruling power. At the same time the monopoly which was needed in the time of Elizabeth to enable British trade to organize itself against foreign rivals in a distant and little-known country had become unsuited to the times, and the general body of merchants clamoured to be admitted to the commerce of the East. The Company fought hard for its privileges, although it is at least doubtful whether its trade profits as distinguished from its territorial revenues were considerable. It was not, however, strong enough to stay the march of events, and the Charter Act of 1813 withdrew the monopoly except with regard to tea and the China trade. Twenty years later the Charter Act of 1833 directed the Company to close its commercial business with all convenient dispatch. The Company thus became a purely political and administrative body, holding its territories in trust for the Crown. The same Act vested the direction of the entire civil and military administration and the sole power of legislation in the Governor-General-in-Council, now for the first time styled 'of India,' and defined more precisely the nature and extent of the control to be exercised over the subordinate Governments. These consisted as yet only of Madras and Bombay; but the Act provided for the creation of a Presidency of Agra, which was constituted, in a modified form, as the Lieutenant-Governorship of the North-Western Provinces, in 1836. Later, in 1854, a Lieutenant-Governor was appointed to Bengal (including Bihār and Orissa), which had hitherto been administered directly by the Governor-General1. The Government of India then assumed its present character of a general controlling authority.
Three years later came the Mutiny, and in 1858 an Act was passed transferring the government of India from the Company to the Crown. This Act made no important change in the administration in India, but the Governor-General as representing the Crown became known as the Viceroy. He is appointed by Royal Warrant, and usually holds office for a term of five years. The designation 'Viceroy,' although it is that most frequently used in ordinary parlance, has no statutory authority, and has never been employed by Parliament. It originated in the well-known Proclamation of 1858, which announced the assumption of the government of India by the Crown, and in so doing referred to Lord Canning, who had already been appointed Governor-General by the retiring Board of Directors, as the 'first Viceroy and Governor-General.' None of the Warrants appointing Lord Canning's successors refers to them as 'Viceroys;' and the title, which is frequently employed in Warrants of Precedence, in the statutes of the Indian Orders, and in public notifications, appears to be one of ceremony, which may most appropriately be used in connexion with the state and social functions of the Sovereign's representative, for the Governor-General is the sole representative of the Crown in India. The salary of the Viceroy is 2½ lakhs of rupees per annum.
The Governor-General-in-Council is responsible for the entire administration of British India and for the control exercised in varying degrees over the Native States. The actual work of administration is, however, divided between the Government of India and the Local Governments. The Government of India2, that is to say the Governor-General-in-Council, retains in its own hands all matters relating to foreign relations, the defences of the country, general taxation, currency, debt, and tariffs, posts, telegraphs, and railways. Ordinary internal administration; the assessment and collection of the revenues; education; medical and sanitary arrangements; and irrigation, buildings, and roads fall to the share of the Provincial Governments. But in all these matters the Government of India exercises a general and constant control. It lays down lines of general policy and tests their application from the administration reports, which are as a rule annually submitted to it, of the main departments under the Local Governments1. Besides the controlling officers for departments which it directly administers, such as Railways, Post Office, Telegraphs, the Survey of India, and Geology, it employs a number of inspecting or advisory officers for those departments which are primarily left to the Local Governments, including Agriculture, Irrigation, Forests, Medical, Education, and Archaeology. Not only does it receive, and when necessary modify, the annual budgets of the Local Governments; but every new appointment of importance, every large addition even to minor establishments, has to receive its specific sanction, with the practical result that no new departure in administration can be undertaken without its preliminary approval. There is, moreover, a wide field of appeal to the Government of India from officials or private persons who may deem themselves aggrieved by the action of a Local Government; and outside Madras and Bombay the approval of the Governor-General is necessary to the appointment of some of the most important officers of the Provincial administration.
The major Provinces have their own budgets; and shares of certain items of revenue raised in the Province, the chief of which are land revenue and cesses, excise, stamps, forests, and income-tax, are definitely assigned to the Local Government. Such assignments were formerly only for a period of years, usually five, at the end of which the arrangements might be revised by the Supreme Government; but it is now intended to make them more permanent, and arrangements to this effect have already (1906) been concluded with most of the Local Governments. The more important Provinces possess legislative councils; but the scope of these is strictly limited to local matters relating to the Province, and their Acts require the approval of the Governor-General.
The supervision over most of the important Native States in India rests directly with the Governor-General-in-Council. In some cases, however, historical associations have left relations with important States, such as Travancore, Kolhāpur, and Patiāla, under the Local Governments, which also deal with minor States whose territories are enclosed in, or contiguous to, their Provinces.
Warren Hastings' Council consisted of four members named in the Act of 1773. They were to hold office for five years1, and the patronage was then to vest in the Company. Pitt's Act of 1784, as already stated, reduced the number of members to three, including the Commander-in-Chief. In 1793 the number of ordinary members was fixed at three, and the addition of the Commander-in-Chief was made conditional on special appointment. The Charter Act of 1833 added a fourth member to assist in legislation; but he was not authorized to take part in executive business until 1853. The disordered condition into which the finances fell after the Mutiny made it necessary to secure the services of an expert from England, and in 1861 a fifth member was in consequence added to the Council. In 1874 power was given to appoint a sixth member for public works purposes only; but this power was not always exercised, and in 1904 the restriction limiting it to public works purposes was removed. The present Council (1906) consists, therefore, of six ordinary members, and the Commander-in-Chief may be, and in practice always is, appointed an extraordinary member. The ordinary members are appointed by Royal Warrant and usually hold office for five years. Three must have been for at least ten years in the service of the Crown in India, and one must be a barrister of England or Ireland, or a member of the Faculty of Advocates of Scotland, of not less than five years' standing. The salary of a member of Council is limited to Rs. 80,000 per annum, and that of the Commander-in-Chief to one lakh.
The Council originally worked as a consultative board, all questions being decided by the votes of the majority. The difficulties which arose from this procedure during the administration of Warren Hastings, who was constantly thwarted and overruled by an adverse majority led by Philip Francis, are well known. When Lord Cornwallis was appointed Governor-General in 1786, he made it a condition that his powers should be enlarged. An Act was therefore passed authorizing the Governor-General to override the majority of his Council, and to act on his own responsibility in matters of grave importance. This condition was repeated in subsequent enactments and is still in force. But the circumstances which prevailed in the time of Warren Hastings never recurred, and this special power of the Governor-General has hardly ever been exercised. Under the board system of administration initiated by Lord Cornwallis, the Council acted in the capacity of advisers only, offering opinions on the cases put before them but exercising no individual responsibility. The appointment of special members for law and finance was a departure from this system. As the amount and complexity of business increased, it became more than a single board could manage; and in the time of Lord Canning the work of the various departments was distributed among the members of the Council, only the more important cases being dealt with by the Governor-General or the Council collectively. This procedure was legalized by the Councils Act of 1861, a clause in which empowers the Governor-General to make arrangements for the convenient dispatch of business, any act done under orders so passed being deemed the act of the Governor-General-in-Council.
The Charter Act of 1793 and later enactments make special provision for the absence of the Governor-General from his Council. In such a case, a member of the Council may be appointed President, to exercise the powers of the Governor-General at meetings of the Council; and the Governor-General, by an order made in Council, may be vested with authority to exercise alone, at his discretion, any of the powers which ordinarily are exercised by the Governor-General-in-Council. Until some years after the Mutiny these provisions were frequently used, and the Governor-General was absent from Calcutta during the greater part of his term of office. Some of the Secretaries accompanied him, and much of the important work of the country was done without the Council. This procedure became increasingly inconvenient and gradually fell into disuse. The last occasion on which a President was appointed was when Lord Dufferin visited Burma after the annexation of the Upper Province. The ordinary meetings of Council may, under the Charter Act of 1833, be held at any place fixed by the Governor-General-in-Council. In practice meetings are held during the winter in Calcutta and during the summer in Simla; and the Governor-General is absent from his Council only for short tours, during which, in these days of rapid postal and telegraphic communication, no special arrangements are required.
Under the system inaugurated by Lord Canning the business of the Government of India is conducted in a manner analogous to the cabinet administration of a European country. The members of the Council correspond to Ministers in charge of departmental portfolios, and a large measure of control is exercised by the Governor-General over all branches of the service. The Government is divided into the Departments of Foreign, Home, Revenue and Agriculture, Legislative, Finance, Public Works, Commerce and Industry, Army, and Military Supply. The Governor-General himself administers the Foreign Department; the Revenue and Public Works Departments form together the charge of a single official; and each of the other Departments is under one of the remaining ordinary members of Council. Until 1905, the Home and Revenue Departments were in charge of a single member, always selected from the Indian Civil Service. The Financial member is sometimes a financier of special experience selected in England, and sometimes a member of the Indian Civil Service. The Legislative member is a lawyer, and the Military Supply member an officer of the British or Indian army. The Commander-in-Chief, as extraordinary member, takes part in the deliberations of the Council, and also holds charge of the Army Department. At the head of each Department is a Secretary to the Government, assisted by a staff of Deputy, Under, and Assistant Secretaries, varying in number with the amount of business which the Department transacts. The position of the Secretary is comparable with that of a permanent Under-Secretary of State in England. Under the rules for the disposal of business, the papers regarding any subject which comes up for consideration are prepared by the Department concerned and submitted to the member in charge. In minor cases the member passes orders; all important matters, and especially cases where two Departments differ in opinion or a Local Government is overruled, are referred to the Governor-General and orders are passed either by him or by the whole Council. Questions raising large issues of general policy, or requiring legislation by the Government of India, are always settled in Council. The Council usually meets once a week, but special meetings may be called at any time. The meetings are private, and the decisions arrived at are termed Orders in Council. The Secretary of the Department to which each case belongs attends during its discussion and records the order. If there is a difference of opinion the vote of the majority prevails, subject to the power of the Governor-General to overrule the Council in exceptional cases.
The existing division of business among the various Departments (excluding the two Departments of Army and Military Supply, which were reorganized in 1906) was made in 1905, when the addition of a sixth ordinary member to the Council involved an extensive redistribution of portfolios. At that time the Departments were the Foreign, Home, Revenue, Legislative, Financial, Public Works, and Military. The Military, Legislative, and Foreign Departments were not affected by this change, but the others were rearranged in connexion with the creation of a new Department of Commerce and Industry. The Revenue and Agricultural Department was separated from the Home and now has its own member of Council, who also administers the Public Works Department. The latter was relieved of railway business by the new Department of Commerce and Industry and the new Railway Board, and now retains only irrigation, roads and buildings, and miscellaneous public works.
The Foreign Department transacts all business connected with external politics, with frontier tribes, and with Native States in India. It also controls the general administration of Ajmer-Merwāra, the North-West Frontier Province, and British Baluchistān. The most important external relations of the Government are connected on the north-west frontier with Afghānistān and Persia, and farther afield with the coast of Southern Arabia, and in the north and east with Tibet, China, and Siam.
Besides the territories under the direct sovereignty of the Crown, India includes nearly 700 Native States, which cover an area of about 770,000 square miles and contain a population of 64,000,000 inhabitants1. They differ from one another greatly in size and importance. The Nizām of Hyderābād rules over an area of 83,000 square miles; there are petty chiefs in Kāthiāwār whose territory consists of a few acres. The expression Native State does not imply that the territory is governed by a chief who is of the same race or religion as the people of the State. The Nizām of Hyderābād is a Muhammadan ruling over a people mainly Hindu, while the Hindu Mahārājā of Kashmīr governs a population that is principally Muhammadan. Nor again, outside Rājputāna, are the ruling houses generally of ancient origin ; few go back beyond the eighteenth century and the troublous times that followed the break-up of the Mughal empire. In early days the most important of these States were allies or rivals of the Company and made treaties with it on terms of equality ; but as the British Government gradually succeeded to the paramount power of the Mughal empire it acquired the suzerainty wherever it did not assume the direct rule. Prominent recognition was given to this principle when, on January 1, 1877, the Queen of England was proclaimed Empress of India. The powers of the chiefs differ greatly according to the history and importance of their States, being regulated partly by treaties or less formal engagements, partly by sanads or charters, but mainly by usage. ‘The maximum of sovereignty enjoyed by any of their rulers is represented by a prince like the Nizām of Hyderābād, who coins money, taxes his subjects, and inflicts capital punishment without appeal. The minimum of sovereignty is represented by the lord of a few acres in Kāthiāwār, who enjoys immunity from British taxation and exercises some shadow of judicial authority1.’ Even in the largest States the Government of India exercises an extensive authority. It retains exclusive control over all external relations ; it assumes a special responsibility for the safety and welfare of British subjects and of the subjects of foreign powers ; and the guarantee it affords to the native ruler against the risk of being removed by insurrection involves a corresponding guarantee to his subjects against oppression and misgovernment, a responsibility which has sometimes to be exercised by curtailing the powers, and occasionally by the deposition, of an unworthy chief. In all considerable States the paramount power is represented by a resident Political Officer with a staff of subordinates. The most important of these are the Residents in Hyderābād, Mysore, Kashmīr, Nepāl, and Baroda, and the Agents to the Governor-General for the groups of States known as the Rājputāna and Central India Agencies2. The officers of the Political department form a graded service, which is recruited mainly from the Indian Civil Service and the Indian Army.
With regard to the internal administration of the Provinces above mentioned (Ajmer-Merwāra, &c.), the Foreign Department exercises the same general functions of control as are exercised over ordinary Provinces through the Home Department. The Foreign Department further deals with questions of ceremonial, and with matters relating to the Indian Orders. It supervises the Imperial Service troops and the Imperial Cadet Corps, and also the Chiefs' colleges, which will be noticed in the chapters on Army and Education.
The Home Department is concerned with the work of general administration, and deals with internal politics, law and justice, jails, police, education, hospitals, public health, municipalities and local boards, ecclesiastical matters, the administration of the Arms Acts, and a number of other subjects. These matters fall primarily within the jurisdiction of the Local Governments; and the work of the Home Department consists, therefore, to a large extent in controlling the Provincial administrations, while it more directly administers the penal settlement of Port Blair in the Andaman Islands, to which convicts sentenced to transportation are sent. It has also to perform much direct work of a miscellaneous character. The superior officers of several departments of the administration under Local Governments belong to Imperial services, such as the Indian Civil Service, which are under the general control of the Home Department. The work of the Ecclesiastical department is shared between the Supreme and the Local Governments. The Charter Acts of 1813 and 1833 provided for the appointment of Bishops at Calcutta, Madras, and Bombay, and conferred on them ecclesiastical jurisdiction and power to admit to holy orders. The Bishop of Calcutta is also Metropolitan in India. Bishops have been appointed to other dioceses such as Lahore, Rangoon, Lucknow, and Nāgpur; but these do not derive their authority from Act of Parliament, and their official status as regards salary, leave, and pension is that of a senior chaplain. Government chaplains are maintained, or allowances are granted to other clergymen, to provide the ministrations of religion to British-born subjects of the Crown, and especially to soldiers and their families, whether Anglican, Presbyterian, Wesleyan, or Roman Catholic1. The authority of the Governor-General-in-Council over the Law Officers of the Supreme Government is exercised through the Home Department, which also controls the Imperial Library in Calcutta and the Imperial Record Office, and exercises a general superintendence over all operations for the preservation of ancient monuments and archaeological exploration.
The Department of Revenue and Agriculture, which had been created in 1871 and abolished in 1879, was reconstituted in 1881 in pursuance of the recommendation of the Famine Commission. Its main functions were then described as the administration of the land revenue, agricultural inquiry, agricultural improvement, and famine relief. The state, in India, has by immemorial custom a claim to a share in the produce of all lands, and the land revenue is the largest asset of the Government. To simplify the assessment of the land revenue, to ensure equity and moderation in the demands of the state without undue sacrifice of its interests, to give security of tenure to tenants, and to improve agricultural credit, are a few of the many problems which demand the constant attention of this Department on its revenue side. Not less serious and important are the responsibilities which rest upon the Department in the control of operations for the prevention and relief of famine. These matters are however primarily dealt with by the Local Governments, and the functions of the Department in respect thereto are mainly of a controlling and directing character.
The organization of economic and scientific investigation and of measures of agricultural improvement forms another important branch of the work of the Department. The Famine Commissioners of 1878 laid much stress on the institution of scientific inquiry and experiment, designed to lead to the gradual increase of the food-supply of the country and to the greater stability of agricultural out-turn. It was considered desirable, however, first to organize and develop the local establishments by which village records and agricultural statistics are maintained, and so to acquire a stable basis of ascertained fact before scientific inquiry was undertaken on an extensive scale. Considerable progress has now been made in the carrying out of this policy; and in recent years it has been found possible to undertake measures for the organization and improvement of the machinery for agricultural inquiry, and for the development of the industrial and economic resources of the country. This policy, so far as it has up to the present time been developed, embraces many fields of inquiry, in which the work of investigation is carried out by various subordinate departments working under the general direction and control of the Department of Revenue and Agriculture. Some of these departments, though not all, were transferred to the Department of Commerce and Industry in 1905. The Survey department carries on geographical, topographical, and scientific surveys, and in some Provinces the cadastral survey which forms the basis of the land revenue assessment. The Meteorological department, in addition to meteorology proper, undertakes solar and astronomical observations. The Botanical Survey deals with systematic and physiological botany and the economic and agricultural uses of plants. The conduct of inquiries and experiments for the improvement of agricultural methods is entrusted to an Inspector-General of Agriculture, assisted by a staff of experts who work in consultation with the Directors of Agriculture in the several Provinces. Measures for the improvement of the breeds of horses1, ponies, mules, and cattle, and for the prevention of horse and cattle disease, are entrusted to the Civil Veterinary department, whose officers are distributed among the Provinces. There is a fully equipped bacteriological laboratory, and several schools and colleges for the training of native veterinary assistants. The Forest department provides an efficient system of conservancy in the large Government forests. The administration of the forests in each Province is in the hands of the local authorities; but the Supreme Government, assisted by an Inspector-General, has a large share in developing the system and principles upon which the science of forestry is practically applied.
The Finance Department deals with the general administration of Imperial and Provincial finance; with questions relating to the salaries, leave, and pensions of public officers; and with currency and banking. It supervises and controls most of the sources of ‘separate revenue’—opium, salt, stamps, excise, and assessed taxes, though the local management of these is generally in the hands of the subordinate Governments; and it administers the Mint. A separate branch, styled the Military Finance department, has been constituted to control the Military Accounts department, and to deal with all matters concerning the financial administration of the army. As already stated, expenditure on the ordinary Provincial services, and a corresponding share of the general revenues, have been made over, within certain limits, to Local Governments; but the expenditure connected with the army, the public debt, and other Imperial objects is directly controlled by the Supreme Government. One executive department manages the civil accounts of both the Supreme and the Provincial Governments. At the head of this department is the Comptroller and Auditor-General, in whose office all the accounts of the country are brought together and compiled. Subordinate to him are the Provincial Accountants-General, who keep the accounts of Imperial receipts and expenditure within their Provinces, and also the accounts of the Local Governments. At the head-quarters of each District is a Government treasury, which receives the revenues and makes local payments. The Public Works accounts are kept by a separate department, which is to some extent under the supervision of the Comptroller-General and is attached to the Public Works Department. The Comptroller-General is also the Head Commissioner of Paper Currency, and in this capacity exercises functions similar to those performed by the Bank of England. The Government of India has Mints at Calcutta and Bombay in which silver and copper pieces are struck, and in which coinage is also undertaken for some Native States and certain of the Eastern Colonies.
The Commerce and Industry Department was formed in 1905, to relieve the ever-increasing pressure of work in the Government of India, and to facilitate the disposal of questions affecting the trade and manufactures of the country by bringing them together under a single Department. At the same time a Board of three members was appointed, to which most of the railway business hitherto dealt with in the Public Works Department was transferred. The Commerce and Industry Department deals with such railway matters as are still reserved for the decision of the Government of India, and is the medium of communication between the Government and the Railway Board. It has taken over from the Home Department work connected with the administration of the Factories, Petroleum, and Explosives Acts. Postal business, customs, statistics, printing and stationery, and everything relating to ports, shipping, and trade generally have been transferred to it from the Finance Department. The Post Office is an Imperial department, presided over by a Director-General under whom are the Post-masters-General of the Provinces. In 1905 a scheme was sanctioned for the constitution of a special Customs service, which will be directly under the Department. The preparation of statistics is controlled by a Director-General of Commercial Intelligence, who has still more important functions as an intermediary between the Department and the mercantile public. Other functions directly connected with trade are the administration of the Merchandise Marks Act for the protection of trade marks and descriptions, and the various Merchant Shipping Acts. The branches transferred from the old Public Works Department include telegraphs and collieries. The Telegraph service is an Imperial department, managed by a Director-General directly subordinate to the Commerce and Industry Department. The Revenue and Agriculture Department has made over to it all labour questions, including the regulation of emigration to foreign countries and to the tea districts of Assam ; the control of the expert mining staff, which provides for the inspection of mines and secures due compliance with the requirements of the law in regard to their working and the safety of the miners ; matters relating to geological inquiries, economic products and arts ; and the administration of the Patents office.
The Legislative Department, which may be said to correspond to some extent with the office of the Parliamentary Counsel in England, is responsible for all matters connected with the conduct of legislation in the Council of the Governor-General, including the drafting of enactments and the publication and revision of the statute book, and through it legislation in the Councils of the Local Governments is supervised and guided. It assists the other Departments of the Government of India with advice on questions of legal construction and principle, and it has to be consulted before any statutory rules having the force of law are issued.
Since 1905, all business connected with Public Works (excluding railways) has been dealt with by a Secretary under the member in charge of Revenue and Agriculture. The superior engineering establishment is divided into two services, Imperial and Provincial. The former has hitherto been recruited mainly from the Royal Indian Engineering College at Cooper's Hill and from the corps of Royal Engineers ; the latter from the Roorkee and other engineering colleges in India and from the upper subordinate staff. The establishment employed on irrigation, and on buildings and roads (including miscellaneous works), is subdivided by Provinces and is under the Local Governments. The main roads are usually in charge of the Provincial Public Works departments, and local roads are made and repaired by municipalities and local boards. An Accounts branch audits and compiles the entire Public Works expenditure, and is recruited partly in Great Britain and partly in India.
Supreme authority over the army is vested in the Governor-General-in-Council, and the chief executive officer is the Commander-in-Chief in India. There were formerly separate armies for the Bengal, Madras, and Bombay Presidencies ; but as India developed into a united country with a central Government, this system became more and more inconvenient, and was gradually modified, and at last abolished by an Act of Parliament passed in 1893 and carried into effect in 1895. Up to 1906 all Government business connected with the Army, the Volunteers, and the Royal Indian Marine was transacted through the Military Department, corresponding in a certain measure to the War Office in England. In that year important changes were made in the administration, and the Military Department was replaced by the two Departments of Army and Military Supply. The former of these is in charge of the Commander-in-Chief, and deals with cantonments, volunteers, and all matters concerning the army, except business allotted to the Department of Military Supply. The latter disposes of matters connected with the procuring and custody of stores, ordnance, and remounts, besides administering the Indian Medical Service, the Royal Indian Marine, and Marine Surveys. All officers of both Secretariats, and the departments attached to them, belong ordinarily to the army. In addition to his control of the Army Department, the executive business of the army is primarily the province of the Commander-in-Chief, the principal officers of whose staff are the Chief-of-the-Staff, the Adjutant-General, the Quartermaster-General, and the Principal Medical Officer of His Majesty's Forces. The army is at present distributed into five great territorial divisions, namely, the Northern, Eastern, and Western Commands (each under a Lieutenant-General), and the Burma and Southern India divisions1. Each division is again divided into brigade commands, while the actual quartering of the troops is in stations which vary greatly in size and importance. These stations, or cantonments as they are called in India, are specially governed by the 'Cantonments Act,' which is administered by a staff of military cantonment magistrates who, in all military or executive matters connected with the troops, are under the officers commanding the stations.
British India, or the territory under the control of the Governor-General-in-Council, is divided into eight large Provinces and five lesser charges, each of which is termed a Local Government. The eight major Provinces are the old Presidencies of Madras and Bombay; the five Lieutenant-Governorships of Bengal, the United Provinces of Agra and Oudh, the Punjab, Burma, and Eastern Bengal and Assam; and the Chief Commissionership of the Central Provinces. The minor charges are the North-West Frontier Province, British Baluchistān, Coorg, Ajmer-Merwāra, and the penal settlement of the Andaman Islands. The Provinces of Madras and Bombay comprise the territories which were originally attached to those Presidencies. Sind was added to the latter Province a short time after its conquest in 1843. The splitting up of the Presidency of Fort William into the Provinces of Agra (styled the North-Western Provinces) and Bengal, each under a Lieutenant-Governor, has already been mentioned. The Punjab, after its annexation, was first governed by a Board of administration and afterwards by a Chief Commissioner. After the Mutiny, Delhi and the neighbouring country was transferred to it from the North-Western Provinces, and it became a Lieutenant-Governorship in 1859. On the annexation of Oudh in 1856 a Chief Commissioner was placed at the head of the executive government, and in 1877 this charge was merged in the Lieutenant-Governorship of the North-Western Provinces. The latter name had become meaningless after the annexation of the Punjab, and the official title of this part of India has recently been changed to the 'United Provinces of Agra and Oudh.' Burma was the next to be created a Lieutenant-Governorship. Arakan, Tenasserim, and Pegu were at first ruled by separate Commissioners under the immediate control of the Government of India. In 1862 they were amalgamated into the Province known as British Burma and placed under a Chief Commissioner. Upper Burma was added to the Chief Commissionership on its conquest in 1886, and the whole Province was thenceforward styled Burma, and was raised to the status of a Lieutenant-Governorship in 1897. The Central Provinces were formed into a separate administration, under a Chief Commissioner, in 1861, by detaching the Saugor and Nerbudda territories from the North-Western Provinces and uniting them to the districts which had lapsed on the death of the Rājā of Nāgpur in 1854. Assam, on its annexation in 1826, was added to Bengal; in 1874 it was detached and placed under a Chief Commissioner. In 1905 Assam, with a large portion of Bengal, was constituted a new Lieutenant-Governorship, under the style of ‘Eastern Bengal and Assam.’ The North-West Frontier Province was created in 1901. It comprises certain Districts which were detached from the Punjab in order that the Government of India might exercise more direct control over the frontier questions to which they give rise, with a number of adjoining border tracts over which our direct influence has been extended since 1892. British Baluchistān was formed into a Chief Commissionership in 1887. The petty principality of Coorg, annexed as already stated in 1834, is administered by the Resident in Mysore. The Agent to the Governor-General in the Rājputāna States is Chief Commissioner of the small British territory of Ajmer-Merwāra, the greater part of which was obtained by cession from the Mahārājā Sindhia in 1818. The Superintendent at Port Blair, which has been a convict settlement since 1858, is also Chief Commissioner of the Andaman and Nicobar Islands. Berār (formerly known as the Hyderābād Assigned Districts) still appertains to the Nizām, but has been administered by the British Government through the Resident at Hyderābād since 1853, and was recently taken over on a perpetual lease, the Nizām receiving an annual payment of 25 lakhs from its revenues. Since October, 1903, it has been attached, for administrative purposes, to the Central Provinces.
All the Local Governments alike are under the superintendence and control of the Governor-General-in-Council. They must obey orders received from him, and they must communicate to him their own proceedings. This subordination is derived partly from Act of Parliament, and partly from the delegation of authority by the Governor-General to Lieutenant-Governors and Chief Commissioners. But each Local Government, including a Chief Commissioner, is the executive head of the administration within the Province; and important differences exist between the status of the several classes of Local Governments. By custom, all appointments to Local Governments, except that of a Chief Commissioner, are for a term of five years.
The two Provinces of Madras and Bombay occupy a superior position, as representing the old Presidencies1 of the same name, which were once altogether independent of Bengal. The civil administration of each is vested in a Governor-inCouncil, whose powers and duties are regulated by Act of Parliament. The Governor is appointed by the Crown, being usually a person of rank and experience in England. The Council consists of two members, likewise appointed by the Crown, who must have served for at least twelve years in India, and who always belong to the Indian Civil Service. In Bombay one member is usually, but not of necessity, chosen from the judicial branch of the service. The Governor possesses the same power as the Governor-General to overrule his Council in cases of emergency, and the distribution of business follows the same general plan as in the Council of the Governor-General. So long as separate Presidency armies were maintained, the Commanders-in-Chief at Madras and Bombay were also members of Council. But on the amalgamation of the Indian army in 1895, consequent on a statute passed two years earlier, this adjunct of the Councils disappeared, and the Governors-in-Council lost the direct functions of military government which they had before enjoyed. They still retain the right of communicating direct with the Secretary of State. Another privilege of the Governors is that they are extraordinary members of the Governor-General's Council, if meetings of that Council should happen to be held within their Presidency. Like the Governor-General, they are addressed as Your Excellency, and they are escorted by a body-guard. The maximum salaries, as fixed by Act of Parliament, are Rs. 1,20,000 for a Governor, and Rs. 64,000 for a member of Council.
All the other Provinces may be regarded as fragments either of the old Bengal Presidency, or of territory at some time under the direct administration of the Governor-General. But those under a Lieutenant-Governor have a status somewhat different from those under a Chief Commissioner, being constituted under Act of Parliament. With the rapid growth of British dominion, it was early recognized that the effective administration of the newly-acquired territories annexed to Bengal was beyond the powers of the Bengal Government, especially when that government was responsible for superintending the administration of the whole of India. Accordingly, the Charter Act of 1833, which altered the style to Governor-General of India, directed the creation of a new Presidency of Agra, to be administered by a Governor-in-Council, and also empowered the Governor-General to appoint one of the members of his own Council to be Deputy-Governor of Bengal. The new Presidency of Agra was never fully constituted, chiefly because of financial difficulties; and two years later an amending Act empowered the Governor-General to appoint instead a Lieutenant-Governor for the North-Western Provinces, and to declare and limit his authority. A similar procedure was proposed in the next and last Charter Act (of 1853), which authorized the constitution of Bengal into a separate Presidency, under a Governor, and also the creation of one new Presidency, but provided that in each case a Lieutenant-Governor might be appointed in the meantime. It is under this statute that the Lieutenant-Governorship of Bengal was created in 1854, and the Chief Commissionership of the Punjab raised to a Lieutenant-Governorship in 1859. Fresh powers to constitute Lieutenant-Governorships were given by the Indian Councils Act of 1861, which enables a Legislative Council to be created for any Province not already possessing a Council, and a Lieutenant-Governor to be appointed to such Province. Under this statute the Chief Commissionership of Burma was raised to a Lieutenant-Governorship in 1897, and the new Lieutenant-Governorship of Eastern Bengal and Assam was constituted in 1905. Lieutenant-Governors are appointed by the Governor-General, subject to the approbation of the Crown. They must have served for at least ten years in India. The extent of their authority may be declared and limited by the Governor-General-in-Council, with the sanction of the Secretary of State. Their maximum salary (Rs. 1,00,000) is fixed by Act of Parliament.
Chief Commissioners stand upon a lower footing, being delegates of the Governor-General-in-Council, appointed without any reference to Act of Parliament. In theory the whole of British territory in India, which is not within the Presidency of a Governor-in-Council or the Province of a Lieutenant-Governor, is under the immediate authority and management of the Governor-General-in-Council, who is competent to give all necessary orders and directions respecting its administration. A Chief Commissioner, therefore, is regarded as administering his Province on behalf of the Governor-General-in-Council, who may resume or modify the powers that he has himself conferred. In early times the title given to such a delegate of administrative functions was Commissioner, as in the case of Mountstuart Elphinstone when appointed to administer the territories in the Deccan conquered from the Peshwā in 1818. The style of Chief Commissioner1 was first used in 1853, when John Lawrence was appointed head of the executive government in the Punjab, in substitution for the former Board of administration under a President. On the annexation of Oudh in 1856 the administration was similarly entrusted to a Chief Commissioner; and shortly after the Mutiny the Central Provinces (in 1861) and British Burma (in 1862) were organized on the same basis. More recently, recourse has been had to an Act of Parliament (of 1854), which empowers the Governor-General-in-Council, with the sanction of the Secretary of State, to take any territory in British India under his immediate management, and then provide for its administration. It was under this statutory provision that Assam was separated from Bengal in 1874, and the North-West Frontier Province from the Punjab in 1901. However constituted, a Chief-Commissionership is a Local Government; and though the Governor-General does not divest himself of any of his inherent powers, the Chief Commissioner is, according to Indian law, the person authorized to administer executive government. Parliament has expressly recognized Chief-Commissionerships in the Act of 1870, which empowers a Governor-in-Council, a Lieutenant-Governor, or a Chief Commissioner to propose draft regulations for ‘scheduled’ districts. Chief Commissioners are appointed by the Governor-General, with no statutory restrictions on his discretion. In practice, the powers entrusted to the Chief Commissioner of the Central Provinces are as wide as those exercised by a Lieutenant-Governor, the main distinction being the absence of a Legislative Council. The salary of a Chief Commissioner is Rs. 50,000; but in the case of the Central Provinces, this has recently been raised to Rs. 62,000, in consideration of the addition of Berār to his Government.
The evolution and existing functions of the Indian Legislatures will be dealt with in a separate chapter. But it must be noted here that the original method of legislation, up to 1834, was by Regulations issued by the executive Councils of Fort William, Fort St. George, and Bombay. Some of the early Regulations were in many respects complicated and intricate, and it was soon realized that they were not suited to all the Indian races. The various territories subsequently embodied in the North-Western Provinces were, on their annexation, included in the Bengal Presidency and governed under the Bengal code ; but the less advanced Provinces acquired at a later time were generally ruled in accordance with simpler codes, based on the spirit of the Regulations but modified to suit the circumstances of each special case. The Provinces were thus distinguished into ‘regulation’ or ‘non-regulation,’ in accordance as they were originally administered under Regulations framed under the Charter Acts or under the less formal codes1. But, with development in material progress and in legislative activity, the distinction between the more advanced non-regulation Provinces and their regulation sisters has practically disappeared, except as regards certain differences in administrative arrangements which will be explained in the next chapter ; and so far as legislation is concerned the contrast is no longer between the old regulation and non-regulation areas, but between backward tracts for which the Government of India can still legislate executively and the rest of British India where the machinery of a Legislative Council is required2.
It has already been stated that the affairs of the East India Company were originally managed in England by the Court of Directors and the General Court of Proprietors. The Regulating Act of 1773 did not interfere with this system, but made some alterations in the voting qualifications of the Proprietors and in the tenure of office of the Directors, who were to hold office for four years, one-fourth being renewed annually. The subsequent controversies which centred round the administration of Warren Hastings convinced the nation that it was essential for the state to assume the supervision of Indian affairs. Pitt's Act of 1784 established a Board of Control, with full power and authority to direct all operations and concerns relating to the civil and military government and revenues of India. The Board was to consist of not more than six Privy Councillors, including one of the Secretaries of State and the Chancellor of the Exchequer. The number was gradually reduced, and the Board's powers were virtually exercised by its President (the lineal precursor of the Secretary of State for India), who after 1841 was the sole member. The Board was given ample powers for the control of the Company's administration. It had full access to the records and correspondence of the Court of Directors, and was supplied with copies of all dispatches to and from India. No order could be sent to India without being first submitted to the Board, which had power to make any alteration it deemed fit. The Board also had the power of requiring the Directors to prepare dispatches on any specified subject, and (in case of default) of ordering the Directors to send out to India in their name any dispatches drawn up by the Board itself. A Secret Committee of the Court of Directors (consisting in practice of the Chairman and Deputy Chairman) was bound to transmit, as from itself, all ‘secret’ orders issued by the Board. In like manner ‘secret’ dispatches from India were received by the Secret Committee and delivered to the Board without being seen by the other Directors. These regulations transferred the substance of authority from the Company to the Crown; but as all orders still purported to issue from the Court of Directors, the importance of the change escaped general recognition. The fact that the initiative remained with the Directors left to them considerable influence in the conduct of ordinary affairs. Patronage continued to be vested in the Court, though its nomination of Governors-General, Governors, and Commanders-in-Chief had to receive the approval of the Crown1. So long also as the Company retained any commercial powers, these were exercised without any reference to the Board of Control.
The Governor-General-in-Council was forbidden, without the express authority of the Court of Directors or of the Secret Committee, to make war except for the protection of our own territories and those of our allies, or to make fresh treaties guaranteeing the integrity of any Native State. It was the practical ignoring of these provisions by Lord Wellesley, under the stress of circumstances, which caused so much friction between himself and the Directors.
This dual system of government, which vested large powers in the Court of Directors subject to the supreme authority of the Board of Control, lasted until 1858. For some time previously the anomaly of the system had been recognized, and it was felt on all sides that a change was inevitable, though the Company fought hard for its privileges. The Charter Act of 1853, when renewing these privileges for the last time, enacted that they should continue only ‘until Parliament shall otherwise provide,’ instead of for a fixed term of twenty years, as on former occasions. It was, however, the catastrophe of the Mutiny which enforced the conviction that the administrative functions of the Company must cease to exist, and that the Sovereign must stand forth as the sole source of government, both in India and in England. The legislative measures required to accomplish this change are contained in the Act of 1858, which transferred the government, territories, and revenues from the Company to the Crown, declared that India was to be governed by and in the name of the Sovereign, authorized the appointment of an additional Principal Secretary of State, and created the Council of India. Immediately on the passing of this Act, Queen Victoria issued a Proclamation ‘to the Princes, Chiefs, and People of India,’ notifying that she had taken upon herself the government before administered in trust for her by the Company1, appointing the Governor-General (Lord Canning) to be her first Viceroy, and announcing her acceptance of all treaties and engagements made by the Company with the Native Princes of India. A further recognition of this transfer of government, and of the peculiar position held by the Crown in India, was made in 1876, when the Sovereign was empowered by Act of Parliament to make an addition to the royal style and title appertaining to the ‘imperial’ crown. Queen Victoria thereupon assumed the title of Empress of India, and a proclamation to that effect was made in a Darbār held at Delhi on January 1, 1877. Since that time it has been customary in India to use the style ‘Queen-Empress’ and ‘King-Emperor,’ though there appears to be no definite authority for the practice.
Under the Act of 1858, the Secretary of State is the constitutional adviser of the Crown in all matters relating to India. He is appointed, like other Secretaries of State, by the delivery to him of the seals of office. He inherits generally all the powers and duties which were formerly vested either in the Board of Control or in the Company, the Directors, and the Secret Committee in respect of the government and revenues of India. He has the power of giving orders to every officer in India, including the Governor-General, and of directing all the business relating to the government of India that is transacted in the United Kingdom. Every order or communication sent to India must be signed by him, or in his absence by some other Secretary of State1, and every dispatch from India must likewise be addressed to him. Of these wide powers and duties many rest on his personal responsibility; others can be performed only in consultation with the Council, and for some of these the concurrence of a majority of members of Council is required. The Secretary of State may act without consulting the Council in all matters where he is not expressly required by statute to act as ‘Secretary of State in Council.’ In particular, appointments by the Crown are made on his advice. In the ordinary course business not specially reserved is conducted in consultation with the Council, and with the active assistance of its members, subject to his general direction. Every official communication proposed to be sent to India must be laid before Council, unless it falls under either of two reserved classes. One of these is the class of communications which were formerly required to be sent to India, by the authority of the Board of Control, through the Secret Committee of the Court of Directors, and these are consequently still known as ‘secret’ communications. They are concerned chiefly with the making of war or peace, negotiations with foreign powers, and relations with Native States. All such papers, whether proposed to be sent to India or received from India and marked ‘secret,’ may be withheld altogether from the knowledge of Council. The other class of communications which the Secretary of State may send to India on his own responsibility are those which he may decide to be ‘urgent’; but he is required to place on record his reasons for such decision. No matter for which the concurrence of a majority of Council is necessary can be treated as either ‘secret’ or ‘urgent.’ In ordinary business, for which the concurrence of a majority of Council is not required, the Secretary of State is not bound to follow the advice of the Council. Of the matters for which the concurrence of a majority of members of Council present or voting at a meeting is expressly required, by far the most important is the making of any grant or appropriation of the revenues of India, for expenditure in India and elsewhere. In practice, a general authority is delegated to the Government of India to sanction any new appointment the pay of which does not exceed Rs. 250 a month, and any revision of establishment which does not involve an additional expenditure of more than Rs. 25,000 a year.
The Council of India, as originally constituted by the Act of 1858, consisted of fifteen members, of whom eight were to be appointed by the Crown and the remainder elected by the Court of Directors from among themselves. The tenure of office was ‘during good behaviour,’ and future vacancies among elected members were to be filled by election by the Council. This constitution has been amended by subsequent legislation. All the members are now appointed by the Secretary of State; the ordinary term of office is for ten years, which may be extended for a further term of five years ‘for special reasons of public advantage’; the number of members may be reduced to ten1, at the discretion of the Secretary of State; at least nine of the members must have served or resided in India for ten years and must not have left India more than ten years before their appointment; a member is disqualified from sitting or voting in Parliament. The Secretary of State has a special power of appointing not more than three members, ‘having professional or other peculiar qualifications,’ to hold office for an unlimited term; but this power has not been exercised for many years.
The function of the Council is to conduct, under the direction of the Secretary of State, the business transacted in the United Kingdom in relation to the government of India and the correspondence with that country. The Council must meet at least once in every week, and five members must be present to constitute a quorum. The Secretary of State is President, with power to vote and give a casting vote; and he may appoint a Vice-President2 to exercise his powers in his absence, but all acts done in his absence require his sanction in writing. Every official communication proposed to be sent to India, except those reserved as ‘secret’ or ‘urgent,’ and every order relating to India which is proposed to be made in the United Kingdom, must either be submitted to a meeting of Council, or else must be placed for seven days on the Council table for the perusal of members before being issued. The Council have a similar right to see every official communication received from India, except such as are marked ‘secret.’ In financial matters, as already mentioned, and in a few other less important cases, no action can be taken without the concurrence of a majority of the members of Council present or voting at a meeting. In all other cases, where the Secretary of State is not bound to defer to the opinions of the Council, the necessity for consulting it serves mainly as a guarantee for deliberation. For the more convenient transaction of business the Secretary of State is empowered to divide the Council into committees, and to arrange what departments of business shall be transacted by the several committees, under his own general direction. The existing committees of Council are seven in number, entitled— Finance, Political, Military, Revenue and Statistics, Judicial and Public, Public Works, and Stores.
The Act of 1858 further authorized the creation of the establishment of the Secretary of State in Council, commonly known as the India Office. The original members of the establishment were taken over from the Board of Control and the East India House. Their number and their salaries were subsequently fixed by an Order in Council, required to be laid before Parliament; and no variation can be made except by the same procedure. The Secretary of State, in virtue of his office, has two Under-Secretaries, one permanent and the other parliamentary, to whom some of his minor duties are delegated. There is, in addition, an Assistant Under-Secretary, who is also Clerk of the Council. For each department of business, corresponding to the committees into which the Council is divided, there is a Secretary and Assistant-Secretary, with a staff of clerks. The Store Department is under a Director-General. Other departments are those of the Accountant-General, the Registrar and Superintendent of Records, and the Director of Funds. The Medical Board for the examination of officers of the Indian services, the Legal Adviser and Solicitor to the Secretary of State, and the Librarian may also be mentioned. Appointments to the establishment are made by the Secretary of State in Council; but ‘junior situations’ must be filled in accordance with the general regulations governing admission to the Home civil service. Somewhat outside the establishment stands the Auditor, whose appointment by the Crown must be countersigned by the Chancellor of the Exchequer, and who nominates his own assistants. But the salary of the Auditor and his assistants, as well as the salaries, pensions, and other charges of the entire establishment of the India Office, are defrayed from the revenues of India.
Parliament is supreme over India, as over all the dominions of the British Crown. Apart from those attributes of sovereignty which are derived from the royal prerogatives or which may have been inherited from the Mughal empire, the general constitution of the government, both in India and in England, has been created and regulated by Act of Parliament. The functions of the Governor-General, especially in relation to his Council and his control over the subordinate Presidencies, the powers of all local legislatures and the restrictions on those powers, the constitution and jurisdiction of the several High Courts, the very existence of the Secretary of State and his Council—all alike are based upon statutory enactments. Certain general statutes apply to India, even when India is not specifically mentioned. But in the ordinary course the legislation of Parliament for India is confined to Acts amending the political constitution and Acts empowering the Secretary of State to raise money by loan. The revenues of India are not under the control of Parliament, though they may not be applied to defraying the expenses of military operations beyond the frontier without the consent of both Houses, except for preventing or repelling actual invasion or under other sudden and urgent necessity. Inasmuch as the Home charges are entirely defrayed from the revenues of India, the salary of the Secretary of State and the expenses of his establishment are not included in the annual estimates voted by the House of Commons. It is, however, provided that detailed accounts of receipts and disbursements, in India and in England, shall be laid before Parliament annually, together with a report exhibiting the moral and material progress of the country. The Home accounts are further subject to examination by an independent Auditor, whose report has likewise to be presented to Parliament every year. Finally, in accordance with constitutional practice, the Secretary of State, as a minister of the Crown, is responsible to criticism, and if occasion should arise to censure, in either House of Parliament; and this responsibility is shared with the Cabinet, of which he is always a member.
Mention has already been made of the writers, factors, and merchants of the East India Company, of whom the Indian Civil Servants of to-day are the direct descendants. Neither their training nor their pay was adequate to the administrative work which, from the time of Clive onwards, they were called on to perform. Clive and Warren Hastings both introduced measures for the reform of the administration, but to Lord Cornwallis is due the honour of having reorganized the service on a footing worthy of its task. By the influence of his own upright character, and by the establishment of a liberal scale of salaries, in substitution for the official pittances which had previously been augmented from the profits of permitted private trade and sometimes by more questionable means, he succeeded in establishing that high standard of integrity which is essential to the good government of the country. Nominations to the Covenanted Civil Service were made by the Directors; and the Charter Act of 1793 reserved to that service, as a precaution against jobbery, the principal civil offices in India under the rank of member of Council. The service came to be called the ‘Covenanted Civil Service’ from the covenants into which its members were required to enter, and by which they bound themselves not to trade, not to receive presents, to subscribe for pensions, and so forth. In contradistinction to the covenanted civilians all other civil servants were said to belong to the ‘Uncovenanted Service,’ but these terms have become obsolete.
In 1800 Lord Wellesley established a college at Fort William for the instruction of young civil servants on their arrival in India. The Court of Directors did not approve of Lord Wellesley’s college; and in 1805 they established a college of their own, at Haileybury near Hertford, at which nominees for the civil service had to go through a two years’ course of special training before proceeding to India. Nominations to the Covenanted service remained in the gift of the Directors until 1853, when the right was withdrawn by Act of Parliament and the appointments were thrown open to public competition. The first examination was held in 1855, and in 1858 the college at Haileybury was closed. The limits of age, and other subsidiary conditions of the competitive examination, have been changed from time to time, but it has always remained open to all natural-born subjects of the Crown. The age limits are at present from twenty-one to twenty-three1, and the selected candidates undergo a year’s special training in England, which they are encouraged by the grant of an allowance to spend at a University. On arrival in India, the young civilian is posted to the head-quarters of a District to learn his work, and is given the powers of a magistrate of the lowest class. After passing the prescribed examinations, mainly in law, languages, and revenue procedure, he becomes a first-class magistrate and is eligible for promotion to higher grades. The Act of 1793, which reserved the principal civil appointments to the Covenanted Civil Service, was not applied to the non-regulation Provinces, and even in the regulation Provinces public exigencies occasionally required outside appointments to be made. The Indian Civil Service Act of 1861 legalized these irregular appointments, and scheduled the posts which were in the future to be reserved to covenanted civilians. This statute is still in force, but it has been modified in one important particular which will shortly be explained.
It is not always fully realized to what a large extent the administration of India is conducted through the agency of natives of the country, and how small is the number of European officials. Roughly speaking, about 1,200 Englishmen, including military officers and others, are employed in the civil government of 230,000,000 people and in the partial control of 60,000,000 more1. In the time of Lord Cornwallis the native agency was notoriously inefficient and corrupt, and his reorganization of the public service entrusted all offices of importance to Europeans. The spread of education, and the example and control of British officials, have worked a change in the native civil service which is one of the most satisfactory results of British rule. With the growth of their efficiency and probity the natives of the country have been given an ever-increasing share in the task of government, and they now fill by far the greater number of the executive, magisterial, and judicial posts. The change has been brought about in several ways. With the development of the country and the advance of civilization the administrative staff has of necessity been greatly increased. These new posts have fallen in the great majority of cases to natives of the country; and the proportion of Europeans, except in the highest branches of control, has been reduced until their numbers have become relatively insignificant. This change was expedited by a rule, adopted in 1879, that appointments made in India carrying a salary of Rs. 200 a month and upwards should ordinarily be reserved to natives of India1, and that no appointment might be made in contravention of this rule without special sanction. And while Europeans have thus been excluded from all appointments except those specially reserved to them, the natives of the country have been admitted to a considerable share in the higher offices. The introduction of the competitive system in 1855 threw the Indian Civil Service open to them; but owing to the religious and other difficulties attendant on a voyage to England, the number of Indians who have entered the service by this means has been neither large nor representative of India generally. Accordingly, an Act of Parliament passed in 1870 provided that duly selected natives of India should be eligible for any of the offices heretofore reserved to the Indian Civil Service. The regulations for giving effect to this Act were the subject of prolonged correspondence and were not issued until 1879. They established what was called the ‘Statutory Civil Service.’ The principal features of the scheme were nomination by the Local Governments, subject to the approval of the Government of India and the Secretary of State; employment of the selected officer within his own Province; and the ultimate transfer of one-sixth of the total number of Indian Civil Service appointments to the Statutory Civilians. The new system, however, failed to prove a success. The higher classes did not as a rule come forward, and many of the candidates chosen were young men who, but for this opportunity, would have been content to enter the subordinate service. During the seven years following the introduction of the system about sixty persons were appointed under it. It was then abandoned in favour of the plan proposed by the Public Service Commission which sat in 1886–7 under the presidency of Sir Charles Aitchison, at that time Lieutenant-Governor of the Punjab. On the advice of this Commission the Civil Service was divided into three branches: the Indian Civil Service, recruited in England; and the Provincial and Subordinate services, recruited in India from among natives of India. The members of the Indian Civil Service are no more numerous than to enable them to fill the majority of the highest offices, with such number of less important posts as provides a course of training for the younger men; the Provincial services, styled the Bengal Civil Service, the Madras Civil Service, and so on, enjoy the remainder of the important executive, judicial, and administrative appointments; and the Subordinate services comprise the holders of minor posts. From the time of the introduction of this system the terms 'Covenanted' and 'Uncovenanted' services were abolished. Admission to the Provincial services is regulated by rules framed by the Local Governments and approved by the Government of India. Sometimes it is by nomination, sometimes by examination, and sometimes by promotion from the Subordinate service. Many of the Provincial and Subordinate service officers are graduates of Indian Universities. The members of the Provincial service are, like the former Statutory Civilians, eligible for offices heretofore reserved for the Covenanted service. Lists of the posts open to them were published in 1892–3: they included ninety-three superior appointments (to which some additions have since been made), such as Collectorships, Deputy Commissionerships, and superior Judgeships in the Provinces to which they belonged. The natives of India have, on the whole, shown greater ability in the discharge of judicial than of administrative functions, and their special talents have been recognized by appointment to some of the highest judicial posts.
Another striking change which has taken place in the Civil Service of India is the creation of numerous specialized departments and appointments, which have already been referred to in connexion with the various Departments of the Government of India. When public education and the development of the country were in their infancy, the control of almost all branches of the administration was vested in members of the Covenanted service. After the consolidation of the British power had been effected, and the Government had set itself to the task of improving the administration, educating the people, and constructing roads, railways, and irrigation works, a demand arose for officers of special training and experience of all kinds. Various departments were from time to time created, which now share with the general civil service the multifarious duties which are performed by the Government in India. Among the larger of these services are the Public Works Department, the Survey of India, and the Postal, Telegraph, Education, Police, Salt, Sanitary, Jails, and Civil Medical departments. The same principles regarding the employment of natives which govern the general civil service have been applied to these other departments. Everywhere the European element, consisting in most cases of officers appointed in England, is confined within the limits essential for efficiency and guidance. The extent to which European agency is employed varies with the nature of the work, being greater where special knowledge and acquirements are needed of which the supply in India is still deficient, or where, as in the case of the Police, a large measure of European control is essential.
Bibliography
R. C. Dutt.—Civilisation in Ancient India (Calcutta, 1899). Rhys Davids.—Buddhist India (1903). ‘Story of the Nations.’ S. Lane-Poole.—Mediaeval India (1903). ‘Story of the Nations.’ Sir A. C. Lyall.—Rise of the British Dominion in India (1894). Sir W. Hunter.—Indian Empire (1896). A Brief History of the Indian Peoples (1904). Sir C. P. Ilbert.—The Government of India (Oxford, 1898). Sir G. Chesney.—Indian Polity (1894). Sir J. Strachey.—India (1903). Sir W. Lee-Warner.—The Protected Princes of India (1894). The Citizen of India (1900). Marquis de la Mazelière.—Essai sur l’Évolution de la Civilisation indienne (Paris, 1903). Rulers of India Series (Clarendon Press). Reports on Moral and Material Progress of India (India Office).
Notes
- 1. Northern India in the pre-Maurya period also contained a number of aristocratic republics, of which an interesting account is given in chap. ii of Prof. Rhys David’s Buddhist India; but in these too the supreme power gradually became hereditary and absolute.
- 1. Hunter's Indian Empire, 3rd edition, pp. 351–2.
- 1. By Pitt’s Act of 1784 the Court of Proprietors was deprived of the power of revoking or modifying any proceeding of the Court of Directors which had received the approval of the then newly-constituted Board of Control, and it became practically only an electoral body.
- 1. Wellesley Despatches, quoted in Sir Alfred Lyall’s British Dominion in India, chap. xiv.
- 1. The members of these councils varied from twelve to sixteen in number, and were usually appointed (as above mentioned) by seniority.
- 2. Pitt's Act of 1784 gave a similar control to the Court of Directors with reference to the Governor-General-in-Council, vide p. 36.
- 1. Here, too, the original intention, never carried out, was to have a Governor-in-Council.
- 2. Also termed the Supreme Government, in contradistinction to the subordinate Provincial administrations.
- 1. The Local Governments also submit monthly copies of all their printed proceedings to the Government of India.
- 1. 'It is believed that this temporary enactment is the origin of the custom under which the tenure of the more important offices in India, such as those of Governor-General, Governor, Lieutenant-Governor, and member of Council, is limited to five years. The limitation is not imposed by statute or by the instrument of appointment, and rests only on custom.'—Ilbert, The Government of India, p. 47.
- 1. Excluding Nepāl, the area and population of which are very problematical. The census statistics, which showed an area of 679,393 square miles, and a population of 62,461,549, under Native States, did not reckon therein the Shan States of Burma, the Khāsi and Jaintiā Hills, or Manipur, which were all included in the British totals; nor did the census operations extend to Bhutān.
- 1. Ilbert, The Government of India, p. 142.
- 2. The Rājputāna and Central India Agents have under them subordinate Residents and Agents who are appointed to the component States of the Agencies.
- 1. The policy of the British Government in respect to the natives of India has always been one of the strictest religious neutrality. Missionary bodies act entirely on their own responsibility and with their own funds; and though their schools are eligible for educational grants, these are entirely for the purpose of secular instruction and may be obtained on similar terms [p. 24] by schools of any religion. It may be added that the large endowments left by former native rulers for the up-keep of Hindu and Muhammadan worship have been scrupulously maintained by the British Government.
- 1. Horse-breeding for army purposes in Northern India and Bombay is now carried on under the supervision of the Army Remount department.
- 1. It is proposed to attach the Southern India (Secunderābād) division eventually to the Eastern Command.
- 1. The term ‘Presidency’ is still used in official documents. In common usage, it is frequently applied to the seat of government, including Calcutta.
- 1. This style was apparently adopted to distinguish the head of the administration from the Financial and Judicial Commissioners who were [p. 33] appointed at the same time. The title of Commissioner was appropriated to subordinate officers in charge of considerable areas or Divisions subdivided into Districts.
- 1. The regulation Provinces are Bengal, Madras, Bombay, and Agra.
- 2. See chap. v, Legislation and Justice.
- 1. The Court of Directors could moreover recall these officers at its discretion, and exercised this power in the case of Lord Ellenborough, despite the disapproval of the Board of Control.
- 1. The territories under the government of the Company had already been declared to be held in trust for the Crown in the preamble to the Charter Act of 1833.
- 1. In constitutional theory, the five Principal Secretaries of State form a single office, and consequently each one of them is competent to perform the functions of any of the others.
- 1. At present (1906) the number of members of Council is eleven.
- 2. Each member of Council, in order of seniority, is customarily appointed to serve for a year as Vice-President.
- 1. The age limits will be from twenty-two to twenty-four with effect from 1906.
- 1. Excluding the 864 civil charges ordinarily held by members of the Indian Civil Service, ‘and excluding also all posts of minor importance, nearly all of which are held by natives, there are about 3,700 persons holding offices in the superior branches of the executive and judicial services, and among them there are only about 100 Europeans. . . . Native officers manage by far the greater part of the business connected with all branches of the revenue and with the multifarious interests in land. Natives dispose of the greater part of the magisterial work. The duties of the civil courts throughout India, excepting the courts of appeal, are almost entirely entrusted to native judges. . . . With possibly the exception of England, there is no country in Europe in which judicial and executive officers receive salaries equal to those given in the (superior) Native Civil Service of India.’ Sir J. Strachey, India (3rd edition), pp. 83–4.
- 1. Natives of India include, for this purpose, persons of European descent born and domiciled in the country.