Chapter VI

— Finance

The Imperial Gazetteer of India, Vol. IV, The India Office, 1907 · from page 160 · about 86 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

Two simple facts give the key to the special conditions of Indian finance. More than 90 per cent. of the population is rural and subsists mainly by agriculture. The total value of Indian imports and exports rose in the sixty years ending with 1903–4 from 28 to 246 crores of rupees1. Although the population of India still consists in the main of a poor peasantry, great strides have been made in the development of her resources, and her national wealth is growing apace. This economic progress has been accompanied by an enormous rise in the revenues and expenditure of the state. The gross revenues of India amounted to 21 crores in 1840, to 43 crores in 1860–1, to 70 crores in 1880–1, and to 113 crores in 1900–1. These figures are given merely by way of general illustration: the acquisition of new territory and changes in the system of finance and accounts rob them of any claim to form a basis for accurate financial comparison. The expenditure incurred from these growing resources represents a complete revolution in the condition of the country. Since the days of the Mutiny, India has been equipped with the apparatus of a modern civilized state. The courts of justice, the police, and the jails have been enormously improved. The emoluments of all classes of native officials have been raised, and an increasing share in the work of administration has been transferred to them. A wide system of public instruction has been developed; some three thousand hospitals and dispensaries bring medical relief within reach of the people; and large sums have been spent in improving the sanitary condition of towns and villages. Great systems of railways and irrigation works have been constructed, and the post office and telegraph departments have been brought to a high pitch of efficiency2. These are some of the most important changes which have taken place, but they by no means exhaust the tale. In many other directions measures have been carried out to improve the administration and benefit the people; and though much yet remains to be done, the general progress made during the last half-century is sufficiently striking.

It may be asked whether so great and wide an activity, involving so large an increase of expenditure, is consistent with the condition of a country the bulk of whose inhabitants are admittedly poor and unable to bear an incidence of taxation such as prevails in modern Europe. There need be no hesitation in answering this question in the affirmative. The growth of revenue which has made the expenditure possible is due to increasing prosperity and better management, and not to the imposition of new burdens on the taxpayer. There is no considerable source of Imperial taxation now in existence which had not already been imposed in 1860, and in most cases the increase in the total receipts has accrued in spite of reductions in the rate of assessment. The incidence of the land revenue on the area of cultivation has been much diminished; the rate of import duties is smaller, and practically all export duties, except that on rice, have been abolished; the salt duty, the only obligatory tax paid by the masses, has been lowered for practically the whole population; the present income-tax is at a less rate, and has a higher minimum limit of assessment, than that imposed in 1860. The large increase in the excise revenue is mainly due to enhanced duties accompanying a better administration and a more successful suppression of illicit manufacture and sale. Municipal and rural rates are the only taxes which are to some extent of a later origin than 1860. The total municipal taxation amounted in 1902–3 to about 3½ crores, the whole of which is not of post-Mutiny origin. Municipal taxes or their equivalent existed in some places at an earlier date, and a portion of the present municipal taxation consists of items transferred from the Government account. Taking into account the reductions effected in 1905–6 and 1906–7, rural rates now amount to about 3½ crores, and some portion of this was already paid in 1860 in the form of voluntary and other cesses. The rural rates are included in the general accounts, and practically the only taxation outside those accounts is that levied for municipal government.

Apart from the growth of the revenue, it may occasion surprise that the total (about £85,000,000 in 1904–5) should exceed half the amount of the Imperial receipts in so wealthy a country as the United Kingdom. But in making a comparison between India and England there are several circumstances of great importance to be taken into consideration. The population of British India is more than five times that of the United Kingdom, and the Indian accounts include the figures of eight large Provinces, each of which is a kingdom in itself. The Government of India performs many functions outside those which ordinarily fall to the state in England. In addition to governing the people, it holds in large parts of the country the position of a landlord; it is also a great proprietor of railways, irrigation works, and forests, and a manufacturer of salt and opium; it provides a large portion of the expenditure on national education and medical relief; and it undertakes many duties which in England are performed by private persons or bodies. Furthermore, it must be remembered that, apart from the 3½ crores of municipal rates, the Imperial accounts of India include, as stated above, practically the whole extent of taxation, while in the United Kingdom the local rates form a heavy addition to the general burden. But India could not have afforded her present scale of expenditure were it not that she is fortunate in deriving more than half her income from sources other than taxation. The land revenue, the largest item of all, represents a charge on agricultural profits which would in Western countries be appropriated by private landlords, and the fact that in India it is paid to the Government does not alter its nature. A large but varying sum is derived from opium consumed in China; and the forests, the railways, the irrigation works, the post office, the telegraphs, and the mints all contribute their quota. The direct taxation of the Mughal empire, raised as it was from a smaller population and cultivated area, and when the purchasing power of the rupee was considerably higher than it is now, was heavier than that now levied by the Indian Government1.

Before entering on a more detailed description of the financial system it will be convenient to give in brief outline an account of the more important incidents which have attended its growth and influenced its character. The financial administration of the Company during the first half of the nineteenth century was not marked by great sagacity, and was embarrassed by the need for maintaining a large army and by numerous and costly wars undertaken for the consolidation and protection of the empire. Between 1814 and 1875 there were twenty-eight years of deficit and only fifteen years in which the revenues exceeded the expenditure. Constant borrowing was needed to meet this heavy drain, and the Government debt rose between 1834 and 1857 from 40 to 60 crores, the whole of which was for ordinary and military expenditure. The total deficit in the year of the Mutiny and the two following years amounted to over 30 crores, and in 1859–60 the expenditure on the army and military police absorbed half the revenues. A considerable augmentation of salt, customs, and stamp duties brought little relief, and the financial position occasioned the gravest alarm.

In this crisis Mr. James Wilson, the first Finance Minister of India, was sent from England1. His advent inaugurated a new financial era. The accounts system was put in order, great reductions were made in the cost of the army and military police, and economies were effected in all branches of the administration. The military charges alone were reduced by 6 3⁄4 crores in three years. At the same time the revenues were increased by an income-tax imposed as a temporary measure for a period of five years. With skilful management the finances showed an exceedingly rapid recovery. Equilibrium was restored after two years, and the next four years were on the whole prosperous. The customs tariff was reformed, and the general rate of import duties reduced from 10 to 7 1⁄2 per cent., while in 1865 the five years of the income-tax came to an end.

Then followed a period, extending roughly from 1866–7 to 1869–70, in which the financial authorities had to struggle to keep pace with the demands made on all sides for funds for improved administration. Every branch of the service was in need of more or less costly extension and reform, and the one item of improved barrack accommodation was estimated to cost 11 crores. The situation was aggravated by a general rise in prices and wages, and by two severe famines—the Orissa famine of 1865–7 and the prolonged drought of 1868–70 in the United Provinces and Rājputāna. The finances were not equal to the strain, and the first three years of the period showed a total deficit of more than 6 crores. The income-tax was reintroduced in 1867–8 in the form of a licence tax, and its scope and rate were changed from year to year to meet the varying circumstances of the times. In 1870–1 it reached its maximum of a general tax of 3⅛ per cent. on all incomes, including those derived from the land. In the same year a most important measure was introduced in the interests of economy and good administration. The Local Governments had possessed, hitherto, practically no control over their own revenues, and the grants for the services in each Province were made annually by the Supreme Government. There was hardly any limit to the amount of money that could be usefully spent in every part of India, and the local administrations were naturally impressed more by their own needs than by the financial embarrassment of a central and distant Government. In these circumstances, as Sir Richard Strachey (to whom the credit of the remedial measures undertaken is largely due) wrote, ‘the distribution of the public income degenerated into something like a scramble, in which the most violent had the advantage, with very little attention to reason; as local economy brought no local advantage, the stimulus to avoid waste was reduced to a minimum, and as no local growth of the income led to local means of improvement, the interest in developing the public revenues was also brought down to the lowest level1.’

To remedy this grave defect Lord Mayo introduced the system of making a fixed grant to each Local Government for the administration of the Provincial services, requiring it to provide for any additional expenditure by the exercise of economy and the imposition, where necessary, of local taxes. The change had the desired effect; economies were effected without loss of efficiency; small local cesses were imposed in several Provinces; and the Supreme Government was relieved of a portion of the annually increasing drain on its resources. Other measures taken to augment the revenues were a revision of the stamp duties in 1867–8, and an increase in the rate of salt duty in Madras and Bombay (where it was much lighter than in Northern India) in 1869–70. The customs tariff was revised, and a number of articles were exempted from import duty at the cost of some loss of revenue. The year 1869–70 resulted in a practical equilibrium of the finances, and the two following years showed a large surplus, the growth of the revenues having at last overtaken the demands for fresh expenditure. In 1871-2 and 1872-3 the Government was able to make large reductions in the income-tax, and at the end of the latter year it was altogether abolished.

No sooner, however, was equilibrium restored than fresh difficulties beset the administration, and the years 1873-4 to 1876-7 were fraught with financial embarrassment. The special obstacles which had now to be encountered were famine and a falling exchange. In 1873-4 the first note of serious alarm was sounded in connexion with the decline in the gold value of silver which was destined to be for so many years the crux of successive Finance Ministers. In that and the three following years exchange fell by a total of 2½d. in the rupee, increasing enormously the cost of making remittances to England to meet sterling payments. At the same time the Bihār famine of 1873-4, and the Deccan famine of 1876-8, cost the Government over 16 crores in special expenditure and loss of revenue. In consequence of these calamities each of the years 1873-4, 1876-7, and 1877-8 showed a large deficit. No fresh taxation was however imposed, and the only important fiscal change was a reduction in the rate of general import duties from 7½ to 5 per cent.

We now come to the period of great financial reforms introduced by Sir John Strachey and completed by Sir Evelyn Baring (Lord Cromer). They cover the period 1877-8 to 1882-3. The programme of reform included the resettlement on a wider basis of the system of Provincial finance, a scheme for meeting the periodical loss due to famine, the equalization of the salt duties, and the abolition of the general import duties. Each of these matters is discussed either in a later portion of the present chapter or in chapter viii, and only a general view need be given here. In the Provincial settlements of 1870-1 a fixed sum had been made over to each Local Government to defray the cost of Provincial services; a share in the revenues was now substituted for this fixed grant. This gave a margin, which might be increased by careful management, with which to meet growing expenditure. The settlements were made liable to periodical revision, and the system thus established has existed to the present time. The object of the famine policy of Lord Lytton's Government was to obtain an annual surplus of 1½ crores of ordinary revenue over ordinary expenditure, which should be applied in ordinary years to the reduction or avoidance of debt, and thus to provide for the losses and expenditure incident to famine without crippling the resources of the state. A careful investigation of revenue and expenditure showed them to be almost in equilibrium; and the additional funds needed for the famine reserve were provided by diminishing to the extent of 40 lakhs the assignments for Provincial expenditure, by a licence tax on the trading classes (estimated to yield 70 lakhs), and by fresh cesses on land (estimated to yield 50 lakhs). In 1878–9 the duty on salt in Northern and Southern India was equalized at the rate of Rs. 2–8 a maund, which in March, 1882, was reduced to Rs. 2. This reform was of the greatest importance, not only because it largely reduced the tax for 148 million people, but as enabling the Government to abolish the great customs line which had previously divided India into two parts. A duty which had been levied on sugar carried across the customs line from the North was also abolished. In 1878 and 1879 the import tax on coarse cotton cloth, which operated as a protective duty in favour of Indian as against English goods, was removed and a number of other articles were placed on the free list. In 1882 the general import duties were altogether abolished. The expediency of this course was questioned at the time, and it will be seen shortly that, when fresh financial trouble overtook the Government, the duties had to be reimposed. These important changes in the fiscal system were not carried out during a time of financial ease. In 1877–8, the first year of the period, famine still raged in Southern India. During the following three years the Government had to meet the heavy expenditure of the Afghān War, which amounted to over 16 crores, exclusive of a contribution made by England, while in 1878–9 there was a further fall in exchange. These causes resulted in considerable deficits in 1877–8, 1879–80, and 1880–1, but the following three years were prosperous and in each of them the reorganized fiscal system yielded a considerable surplus. The revenue surrendered under the heads of salt and customs was far greater than the new revenue derived from the enhancement of the Provincial rates (landcesses) and the licence tax, but the result justified the confidence placed in the continual growth of the ordinary revenues. In 1876–7 the gross revenue was about 58½ crores; in 1882–3 it amounted to over 70. Allowing for loss of revenue in the former year in consequence of the famine in Southern India, the improvement is equal to about 10 crores. In 1882–3 the Provincial settlements came up for revision; and the financial position was so good that it was found possible to increase the assignments for Provincial services, and to reduce taxation in the United Provinces, where economic progress had not been satisfactory, by abolishing the patwāri cess (for the maintenance of village revenue officers) at a cost of 24 lakhs. A portion of this tax was reimposed in 1889-90, but again remitted in 1906-7.

The good times which followed Sir John Strachey's reforms were not of long duration. In 1884-5 the finances were in practical equilibrium, notwithstanding depression in the wheat and rice trade (affecting railways and customs), and an unusually heavy outlay on opium production; but two of the following four years showed a heavy deficit, and in the remaining two a small surplus was secured only by partially suspending the famine insurance grant. This deterioration resulted from a heavy fall in exchange, increased military expenditure, and the annexation of Upper Burma. Exchange fell by 3d. in the rupee, and every fall of a penny meant an additional expenditure of over one crore. In 1885 occurred the Panjdeh incident on the Russo-Afghān border and the conquest of Upper Burma. The imminent danger of war with Russia involved an outlay on military preparation of two crores, and the Burmese War cost 60 lakhs. In neither case did the matter stop with the initial expenditure. The progress of a great European power towards the borders of India made it necessary to reconsider the military position. The army was increased and larger sums were spent during several years on strategic railways, fortifications, and other works on the frontier. The restoration of order in Upper Burma, and the administration of the Province, also entailed a large net outlay until, after several years, the newly acquired territory began to develop and its revenues to expand. The arrangements so carefully elaborated during Lord Lytton's viceroyalty broke down under the strain of this accumulated expenditure, and recourse was had to fresh taxation. In January, 1886, the licence tax was converted into a general tax on non-agricultural incomes in excess of Rs. 500 per annum, and in 1887-8 it was found necessary to enhance the salt-tax from Rs. 2 to Rs. 2-8 a maund, and to impose an import duty on petroleum. The additional revenue thus obtained amounted to about 2½ crores. At the same time rigid economy was enforced in the civil administration, and a special Committee was appointed to investigate the directions in which expenditure might be reduced. Partly owing to the savings which it suggested, the revision of the Provincial finances in 1886-7 resulted in an addition to the Imperial resources of 64 lakhs a year. These measures sufficed to restore equilibrium, and, with a recovery in the rate of exchange, three years of financial prosperity followed, during which surpluses were secured notwithstanding continued heavy expenditure on military equipment and defences.

These prosperous times were quickly followed by a crisis in the calamitous history of exchange. In the three years 1892-3 to 1894-5 exchange fell from 1s. 3d. to 1s. 1d. In June, 1893, the Indian mints were closed to the free coinage of silver, and the Government embarked on the currency policy which has given to India what is practically a gold standard and a stable rate of exchange at 1s. 4d. to the rupee. The finances could not hold out against the enormous losses which resulted from the fall of exchange, and the years 1892-3 and 1893-4 showed a growing deficit in spite of rigorous economy and the resumption, at the resettlements of 1892-3, of a portion of the growing revenues of the Provincial Governments. In March, 1894, it became necessary to reimpose a general import duty at the old rate of 5 per cent. Cotton goods were in the first instance excluded from the lists of dutiable articles; but the financial position becoming worse in the course of the year, the exemption could no longer be maintained, and in December they were made liable to the 5 per cent. tax, a countervailing excise duty being at the same time levied on the produce of Indian mills. The new duties increased the revenue by about 3 crores.

This brings us to the end of the period of exchange difficulty. During the next five years the value of the rupee rose steadily, and in 1899-1900 reached the 1s. 4d. rate which was the goal of the Government policy. The period from 1895-6 to the present time (1906) has been one of financial prosperity and commercial and industrial growth, marred by two widespread famines of exceptional severity and a terrible visitation of plague. The first famine occurred in 1896-7 and the second in 1899-1900. On the first occasion the direct expenditure on famine relief exceeded 7 crores, and on the second occasion 9 crores, while the indirect losses due to remission of land revenue and miscellaneous causes amounted to an even greater sum. The inhabitants of some Provinces underwent extreme suffering, but in almost all parts the recovery with better seasons was extraordinarily rapid, and during the past few years the country has, on the whole, enjoyed economic and financial prosperity. In 1897-8 extensive military operations undertaken against the tribes on the north-west frontier cost nearly 5 crores. The two years 1896-7 and 1897-8 showed a total deficit of 7 crores, but every subsequent year, including the two years of famine, yielded a considerable surplus. It was not necessary to impose fresh taxation; and the only important fiscal changes made during the period were the reduction of the duties on cotton cloth from 5 to 3½ per cent., the exemption of cotton twist and yarn, and the imposition of a countervailing duty to protect Indian refined sugar against the competition of bounty-fed beet sugar imported from Europe. From 1897-8 onwards the revenues have mounted up year by year, and the gross revenue of 1901-2, which showed a surplus of nearly 8 crores, exceeded by more than 16 crores the gross revenue of the prosperous year 1895-6. In 1902-3 the Government was able to remit 2 crores of arrears of land revenue due to the famine, and to provide special grants for minor irrigation works, for education, for public works, for medical requirements, and for Provincial administrative purposes, while the year closed nevertheless with a surplus of 5½ crores. The absence of Indian troops in South Africa and China resulted, between 1899-1900 and 1902-3, in a large saving of military expenditure. On the other hand, the lessons taught by the Boer War have made it necessary to incur considerable outlay on equipment and transport.

The financial position for 1903-4 justified, for the first time since 1882, a liberal remission of taxation. The salt-tax was reduced from Rs. 2½ to Rs. 2 per maund, and the payers of income-tax were relieved by freeing all incomes of less than Rs. 1,000 per annum from the operation of this tax. These remissions of taxation amounted to 1·8 crores, and further special grants were made for public works. A concession, announced at the Delhi Darbār of January, 1903, was also made to Native States which had borrowed money from the Government of India for famine purposes. The interest on these loans was remitted for a period of three years. In addition to the above remissions, 2·6 crores were granted to Provincial Governments for various purposes. Nevertheless the surplus of 1903-4 was about 5½ crores, and that of 1904-5 exceeded 6 crores.

In 1905-6, the salt-tax was further reduced from Rs. 2 to Rs. 1½ per maund; the famine cesses imposed in Northern India in 1877-8 were remitted; and large grants were made to Local Governments for police, education, and agricultural development, as also for subventions to local boards. Nevertheless, the revised estimate for that year shows an actual surplus of 3·4 crores, of which 74 lakhs was applied to reduction or avoidance of debt. The budget for 1906-7 makes additional provision for increased expenditure on police and education, while at the same time local taxation has been reduced by the abolition of cesses levied for the payment of village officials, and for the maintenance of the District post system, now transferred to the Imperial postal service. But the year is estimated to close with a surplus of 1·3 crores.

Moreover, the years 1904–5 to 1906–7 marked the introduction of a revised system of financial settlements which will be referred to later on.

The growth of the different items of revenue and expenditure is illustrated by the second and third tables at the end of this chapter. They cover an interval of twenty-seven years, between 1876 and 1903, and the figures for 1903–4 and 1904–5 have been added for comparison. It is difficult to extend the survey over a longer period, because changes introduced in 1884–5 in the manner of exhibiting loss by exchange were not applied to the accounts of years prior to 1876–7. For the sake of simplicity the figures are shown net: that is to say, expenditure incurred in collecting the revenue is deducted from the gross receipts under each revenue heading, and departmental receipts are deducted from the gross outlay under each expenditure heading.

The revenue statement is divided into the two main heads of taxation and receipts other than taxation. At the beginning of the period 1876–1901 taxes yielded 38 per cent., and at the end 50 per cent., of the total net revenue. This calculation excludes the net receipts from the commercial departments—railways, irrigation, post office, and telegraphs—which are shown by minus entries (in italics) in the statement of net expenditure. Taking the gross revenue, the share realized from taxation proper is now about 26 per cent., whereas in the United Kingdom about five-sixths of the gross revenue is derived from taxation.

The land revenue throughout the greater part of Bengal, and in portions of the United Provinces, Madras, and Assam, has been fixed in perpetuity; elsewhere it is subject to periodical revision. The revision is made by Districts, and the ordinary term of a settlement is thirty years in Madras, Bombay, and the United Provinces, and twenty years in the Punjab and the Central Provinces. In backward tracts, such as Burma and Assam, where there are much waste land, low rents, and a fluctuating cultivation, shorter terms are permitted. In a Resolution issued in January, 1902, the Government of India justified its land revenue policy as being one of progressive moderation1. The share of the ‘assets’ reserved to the Government has been continually diminished; but the value of the ‘assets’ themselves has increased so greatly with extended cultivation, a growing population, rising prices, and the development of trade, that a diminishing share has yielded a gradually increasing revenue. Allowing for remissions due to famine in these years, the standard of net land revenue in 1876–7 was about 18·8 crores, and in 1900–1 about 24 crores. Deducting from the latter figure the land revenue derived from Upper Burma (annexed in 1886), the total increase was a little more than 4 crores in twenty-five years, or about 16 lakhs per annum. In years of drought the land revenue collections fall far below the normal; and the influence of famines which marked this period was so great that, in spite of considerable enhancements on resettlement, the total of the collections during the five years 1896–7 to 1900–1 was only 36 lakhs in excess of the total during the preceding five years. Apart from the fluctuations due to famine, the land revenue shows a fairly constant advance, but its increase has not kept pace with the general rise of the revenues: in 1876–7 land revenue formed 44 per cent., and in 1902–3 only 39 per cent., of the total net receipts. In addition to the land revenue proper, this head of account includes a number of other receipts, such as sale proceeds of land, receipts from fisheries, house and capitation tax in Burma, and various miscellaneous items. The enhancement of the land revenue which is directly attributable to the effect of the Government irrigation works is shown in the accounts as an irrigation receipt. This item rose from 40 lakhs in 1876–7 to 122 lakhs in 1902–3.

The second head of the statement, ‘Tributes and contributions from Native States,’ is a comparatively petty item. The contributions are made chiefly in lieu of former obligations to supply or maintain troops, and form a small return for the duty undertaken by the Supreme Government in ensuring the peace of the country.

The forest revenue is almost entirely derived from the sale of timber and other forest produce, the property of the Government. The Forest department has looked to the preservation and improvement of this valuable source of wealth rather than to the raising of an immediate large income, but its operations have been a source of increasing profit, which would have been greater of late years but for the effect of famine.

The revenue arising from the opium consumed in India is credited in the accounts under the head of excise, and the opium revenue proper is derived from the produce exported to other countries, among which China takes by far the largest portion. The net annual opium revenue is subject to great fluctuations, which arise from variations in the price of the drug and in the character of the seasons. The immediate effect of a good crop is to diminish the net revenue of the year, since it increases the amount payable to the cultivators while the out-turn is not ready for sale until the following year. The price obtained is influenced mainly by the condition of the China market, where the native produce is becoming a formidable competitor. The political changes which have occurred in the Far East make this source of revenue even more precarious than was formerly the case. The general trend during the twenty-five years ending with 1901 has been steadily downward; and each quinquennial period has shown a diminution of the average net revenue, which has been specially marked since 1895, the subsequent quinquennium having been one in which the Indian crops were poor and the prices paid to the cultivators had to be increased. In 1876–7 opium yielded 16 per cent., and in 1902–3 only 7 per cent., of the total net revenue. There has since been some recovery, probably only temporary.

The general rate of salt duty remained at Rs. 2–8 a maund1 since it was raised to that level, under circumstances already narrated, in the year 1888, until recent reductions in 1903 and 1905. The duty on trans-Indus salt was raised in 1896, though still to a lower figure than the general rate, but the addition thus made to the revenue was comparatively trifling. The consumption of salt is a sure index to the condition of the people: it rises in prosperous years and falls when there is famine or scarcity. Temporary fluctuations apart, there has been a satisfactory rise in consumption since 1887–8, which, combined with the growth of population, secures a steady increase of revenue. The net revenue amounted to 6·8 crores in 1888–9 and to 8·4 crores in 1902–3, the last year of the Rs. 2½ duty. The average incidence was, in 1903, 4·9 annas (say, 5d.) per head of the population, and has been considerably reduced by the recent revisions in the rate of duty, which have taken off two-fifths of the tax formerly levied over the greater part of the country.

The excise revenue is derived from intoxicating liquors, hemp drugs, and opium consumed in the country, and is levied in the form of duty on manufacture and fees for sale licences. Increasing prosperity and better administration have secured a fairly continuous increase of net revenue, amounting on an average to about 13 lakhs a year, a figure which has been considerably exceeded in the years 1901–4. Like the salt, forest, and land revenue, the excise receipts always show a marked falling-off in years of famine or scarcity.

The customs revenue is mainly derived from the general import duty, certain special import duties such as those on arms, liquor, sugar, and petroleum, and an export duty on rice. The general import duties were, as already stated, reimposed in March, 1894; cotton goods were included in the dutiable list in December of the same year, and the duty on cotton cloth was lowered from 5 to 3½ per cent. in February, 1896, cotton twist and yarn being simultaneously exempted. The only important change made since that date is the imposition of a countervailing duty on beet sugar imported from Europe. In 1896–7, the first year of the existing arrangements, the net customs revenue amounted to 415 lakhs; in 1900–1 it was 467 lakhs or, without the countervailing sugar duty, 446 lakhs. The receipts for 1901–2 showed an increase of nearly 70 lakhs over the figures for 1900–1, and those for 1902–3 a further increase of 15 lakhs. The customs revenue rises with the growing trade of the country and fluctuates according to the circumstances of the year. It is to a certain extent threatened by a cause which is, from every other point of view, a matter for satisfaction: namely, that the growing native industries are beginning to supply wants hitherto met from abroad. Instances in point are the rapid expansion in the local production of petroleum and the development of the cotton industry.

Apart from a small local tax in the Central Provinces, abolished in 1902–3, the receipts from assessed taxes shown in Table II consist entirely of the general tax on non-agricultural incomes above Rs. 500, which was substituted in 1886 for the licence tax of 1878. The net proceeds of the tax amounted in 1886–7 to 128 lakhs, and in 1902–3 to 207 lakhs. This tax is less affected by the accidents of the year than other forms of revenue, and has increased steadily, at an annual rate of nearly 5 lakhs, with the growing incomes of the people. The recent exemption of incomes between Rs. 500 and Rs. 1,000 caused a loss of 30 lakhs in 1903–4, which, however, is now being gradually made up. It may be noted that the taxation of property by inheritance and succession duties cannot be largely resorted to in India, by reason of the Hindu joint family system which vests ownership in the family as a whole.

More than three-quarters of the Provincial rates are derived from the general cess on land, which was imposed in most Provinces in its present form in 1870 and 1871, and was enhanced in Northern India, as part of the famine policy, in 1877 and 1878. Other items included under the head of ‘Provincial rates’ are cesses levied in some Provinces for the maintenance of rural police. The cesses are in general collected with the land revenue and rise and fall with it. Provincial rates yielded 254 lakhs in 1878–9, and 405 lakhs in 1902–3. The recent remission of famine cesses and those levied on account of village land revenue officials has caused a subsequent decrease of revenue amounting to about a crore.

The stamp revenue is derived from judicial or court-fee stamps, and non-judicial or revenue stamps. Judicial stamps are the more important source, yielding in 1902–3 69 per cent. of the total. The judicial stamp revenue may be regarded in the light of payment for service rendered by the costly judicial establishment rather than as a tax in the proper sense of the word. As in other countries, the law requires revenue stamps to be affixed to a variety of commercial and miscellaneous documents. Subject to occasional fluctuations, the proceeds from both classes of stamps have risen steadily, and only three years have seen a temporary fall in the total net revenue. Famine tends to lower the court-fee revenue by compelling self-denial in the pursuit of litigation, and to raise the revenue from non-judicial stamps by promoting the execution of documents for the purpose of raising money. In 1876–7 the net stamp revenue was 2·7 crores, and in 1902–3 5·0 crores, the average annual rise being about 8 lakhs. More than one-third of the total is realized in Bengal.

Fees for the registration of instruments, principally deeds of mortgage, form a comparatively small item of revenue, yielding 21 lakhs in 1902–31. The collections vary considerably from year to year, but with a constant upward tendency.

The third table at the end of the chapter gives details of the net ordinary expenditure of the state. The first heading includes the charges for the general civil administration, which have increased from about 14 crores in 1876–7 to 23 crores in 1902–3. The bulk of this increase represents normal progress, but three special causes of enhanced expenditure may be noticed before the details are examined. The fall in the rate of exchange has increased the rupee equivalent of the portion of the expenditure which is incurred in England. Another item of expenditure connected with exchange is the grant of exchange compensation allowance, first made in 1893, to compensate such officers of Government as are not permanently domiciled in India for the loss caused to them by the fall in the value of the rupee on their remittances to England. In 1902–3 the payment of this compensation added about 28 lakhs to the expenditure on the general civil administration. The third special charge is that incurred for the administration of Upper Burma, against which must be set off the growing revenues of the Province. In the table the expenditure on civil administration is divided into the three heads of Land Revenue, Civil Departments, and Miscellaneous Civil Charges.

The figures under Land Revenue include the bulk of the charges for District administration, and represent to a large extent departments of the public service with which the land revenue is only indirectly connected. A portion of the salaries of Collectors and Magistrates and other District officials is shown under this head, and the balance under the head Courts of Justice. The cost of this portion of the District administration has increased between 1876 and 1903 from 148 to 202 lakhs. Apart from the special causes already indicated, the creation of new Districts, general increase of work and establishments, and the rise in the emoluments of native officials have combined to swell the total. The substitution of native for European agency in a number of appointments has acted to some extent in the contrary direction.

The 15½ crores of expenditure on Civil Departments in 1902–3 were made up as follows :—General Administration 227 lakhs, Courts of Justice 295 lakhs, Jails 74 lakhs, Police 407 lakhs, Marine 51 lakhs, Education 168 lakhs, Medical 132 lakhs, Political 123 lakhs, Ecclesiastical 17 lakhs, and Minor Departments 61 lakhs. The charge for general administration represents the cost of the whole civil administration down to the grade of Commissioners of Divisions. It includes charges in England and in India on account of the Secretary of State, the Viceroy, the Governors, Lieutenant-Governors, Councils, &c. It increased between 1876–7 and 1894–5 by 55 lakhs; since then it has increased by about 18 lakhs only. A rise of 93 lakhs during the twenty-seven years under consideration for Courts of Justice represents increased litigation and the cost of many valuable reforms. The year 1902–3 compared with 1876–7 shows an increase of expenditure on jails by 21 lakhs. The jail population is larger and the administration has been greatly improved. Police charges, which are the heaviest item under Civil Departments, show a large increase, namely, 177 lakhs, since 1876–7. Nearly 80 lakhs of this increase occurred between 1885–6 and 1887–8, due to the policing of Upper Burma.

The general establishment has also been augmented, and the pay of officers and men increased in order to make them more efficient and trustworthy. Since 1902–3 expenditure on the police has been further developed, in accordance with the recommendations of the Police Commission of that year. Marine is a much smaller head of expenditure. It includes, among other items, charges on account of the Royal Indian Marine, the marine survey, and the dockyards. The large increase of expenditure under Education (83 lakhs) and under Medical (68 lakhs) since 1876–7 requires no explanation : it represents a boon to the people of the greatest magnitude. Political charges show a considerable increase during the period under discussion, a great part of which is due to affairs on the north-west frontier. The Minor Departments include a large number of items, such for instance as the Survey of India, the Botanical and Geological surveys, the Meteorological and other scientific departments, experimental cultivation, cinchona plantations, veterinary charges, emigration, inland labour transport, inspection of factories, statistics, departmental examinations, and explosives. The annual total varies, with a general upward tendency, representing a large amount of miscellaneous useful work.

The third head in the table, ‘Miscellaneous Civil Charges,’ includes territorial and political pensions, stationery and printing, and the non-effective civil expenditure, namely, absentee allowances and charges on account of superannuation. The last item amounts to more than 70 per cent. of the whole. The total under ‘territorial and political pensions’ has diminished from 79 to 40 lakhs during the period under comparison by the gradual lapse of political pensions, while the charges for stationery and printing have increased from 43 to 86 lakhs with the growth of business. The special circumstances of the Indian Government make the absentee and superannuation charges a heavy item. Between 1876–7 and 1902–3, the former increased from 28 to 37 lakhs, and the latter from 144 to 392 lakhs. The growth of establishments, the fall in exchange, and a variety of other causes have contributed to this large increase.

We next come to the heads Post Office, Telegraphs, and Mint. An account of the first two departments is given in chapter viii of Volume III, and it is only necessary to point out here that the continually increasing services of the Post Office have been accompanied by the conversion of a net annual expenditure into a small net income. In 1876–7 Posts and Telegraphs together cost 28 lakhs net; in 1902–3 the former showed a net profit of 12 lakhs and the latter a loss of 5 lakhs. Each year included in the table, with the exception of 1902–3, when there was considerable expenditure in connexion with the withdrawal of worn coins from circulation, shows a net revenue from the operations of the Mints, the amount of which fluctuates according to the extent and nature of the year's operations. The difference between the artificial and the intrinsic value of the rupee being now considerable, large apparent profits have been made of recent years from the coinage of new rupees; but such receipts do not affect the surplus of the year, as the net gain is transferred to the Gold Reserve Fund in accordance with the currency policy described in chapter xvi, and is therefore not included in the table1. Transactions which do affect the surplus are the coinage of copper pieces and of dollars for various colonies.

Railway construction began in India about the year 1850 and was, for a number of years, carried out through the agency of joint stock companies, with an English domicile and a sterling capital, under contract with the state. The companies were given a guarantee of 5 per cent. on their capital outlay, with half the surplus profits in addition. No capital expenditure beyond that involved by the free grant of land was entailed on the state, but general revenues had to meet the amount by which the net receipts fell short of the guaranteed interest. The eight railway lines which were constructed on these terms have played an important part in the development of the country. The guarantee system was of great utility, inasmuch as it succeeded in attracting British capital, without which these great works could hardly at that time have been constructed; but the terms of the contracts were in some respects unsatisfactory and for many years imposed a considerable burden on the Indian revenues. All the old guaranteed railways except one have now been purchased by the Government under their contracts.

In 1867–8 the Government began to borrow money for irrigation works, and in 1870 steps were taken to extend this system to the further development of railways by the direct agency of the state. The extent of the operation was controlled and limited by a consideration of the net annual burden thrown on the revenues. For several years the net charge on account of guaranteed railway interest had varied between 1½ and 1¾ millions sterling, but was now diminishing with the growth of traffic. The forecasts of expenditure on new railways and irrigation works were to be so adjusted that additional charges should be met by additional receipts from the guaranteed railways and new projects, and no increased charge was to be thrown on the revenues. A forecast made on these lines in 1875 provided for an annual capital outlay for five years of 4 crores, and it was estimated that the net charge on the revenues during this period would diminish from about 2½ to 2 crores. The general expenditure on construction met from revenues was styled ‘ordinary,’ and all outlay from borrowed funds ‘extraordinary.’ The ‘extraordinary’ works were not all expected to furnish a net profit which would cover the interest charge on the capital outlay: they included every sort of work which it was decided, for any reason, to construct from borrowed funds. The fall in the gold value of silver broke down the system. Apart from the general peril of the financial position, the sterling debt added greatly to the loss by exchange, and it was at one time contemplated that all borrowing for public works should be stopped. The question was referred in 1879 to a Committee of the House of Commons, which advised that the system of regulating the amount of borrowing by the dead weight of interest not covered by receipts should cease, and that the total amount to be borrowed in any year should be limited to that which could be raised in India without unduly pressing the market. This was estimated to be 2½ crores. These recommendations were supplemented by orders of the Secretary of State, limiting construction from borrowed funds to such works as might be expected to yield receipts sufficient to cover the interest on the capital outlay within a reasonable number of years. Railways and irrigation projects which did not fulfil this condition, but were required as a protection against famine, were to be constructed from revenue, including under this head a portion of the famine insurance grant provided under the new famine policy (see page 165). The two classes of works were styled ‘productive’ and ‘protective,’ and the distinction between ‘extraordinary’ and ‘ordinary’ works was abolished.

If, however, capital outlay had been strictly confined to what the Government could borrow in India or spare from revenue, the work of construction would have progressed slowly and economic progress would have sustained a severe check. It was, therefore, now decided again to evoke the aid of private capital, which, it was hoped, could be obtained on better terms than in the days of the old guaranteed companies. From that time onwards a number of companies have assisted in the development of Indian railways. The terms of their contracts with the state exhibit a great variety of conditions, but they may be roughly divided into three classes. (1) There are the later guaranteed companies which, like the old companies, have an English domicile and a sterling capital. The rate of guaranteed interest in no case exceeds 4 per cent., and the lines worked by the companies are the property of Government. The share of the surplus profits payable to these companies is also smaller than under the old conditions. (2) Within recent years companies of a new class, with an Indian domicile and a rupee capital, have been formed for the construction of branch or feeder lines to existing railways. The assistance given to these branch-line companies takes the form either of a guarantee up to 3 per cent. with a share of surplus profits, or a rebate from the traffic brought to the parent line sufficient to bring up the total receipts of the feeder to a certain percentage on the capital cost. (3) To the third category belong the railways over the transactions of which the Government exercises no financial control. In some cases these receive direct assistance in the shape of a subsidy so as to bring up the gross receipts of the railway to a certain figure; in others a payment is made so as to secure a return to the company of a certain percentage on the capital cost; and in others again the only assistance afforded is a free gift of the land required for the construction of the line.

The 2½ crores limit on Government borrowings for ‘productive’ works was maintained for several years. In 1883, better times having arrived, the Government of India proposed a more ambitious programme, and the whole question was again considered by a Parliamentary Committee. Acting on the recommendations of this Committee, the Government abolished the distinction between ‘productive’ and ‘protective’ works. Railways were to be made as required, but were, as a rule, to have a good prospect of repaying their interest charge. The Committee advised that the limit of borrowing might be enhanced, and the Secretary of State raised it to 3½ crores annually. Funds for the construction of irrigation works and railways needed for famine purposes continued to be supplied, up to a limit of three-quarters of a crore, from the famine insurance grant. A programme was framed on these lines in 1885, but the ordinary work of railway extension was hampered by the need (after the Panjdeh incident) of constructing strategic railways on the north-west frontier at an estimated cost of more than 5 crores. In August, 1889, the 1885 programme having been nearly exhausted, a fresh three years' forecast was made. It was of a moderate character and involved an annual outlay of 3½ crores, which it was anticipated would not materially increase the Home charges or the burden of expenditure to be met from revenue. In 1890 the limit of capital expenditure on railways and irrigation works was raised to 3½ crores plus the whole available balance of the famine insurance grant; and in 1892 the Government of India sanctioned an additional annual outlay of ½ crore to enable companies to undertake new lines and extensions. In 1895–6 the question of how best to provide funds for a wider development was considered, and a three years' programme, involving a total cost of 29⅔ crores, was sanctioned. As much money as could conveniently be borrowed was to be raised in India, and the rest in England by the Secretary of State or by companies acting under agreement with him. This programme, while precluding independent borrowing by guaranteed companies, did not include the capital expenditure of those companies whose relations with the Government do not involve a direct guarantee. The programme had however to be curtailed in consequence of famine and frontier wars. It was followed by another three years' forecast, involving an expenditure of 22⅓ crores, in the years 1899–1900 to 1901–2. This programme was also to some extent modified by famine, and the growing need for capital expenditure on open lines has restricted the outlay on new works.

The present position of railway finance may be illustrated by the budget estimate of 1906–7. The total estimated capital expenditure (apart from famine protective lines) for which the Government of India undertakes any financial responsibility or gives any direct guarantee is :—

TBL-017 · FOLIO 218Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
On open lines8·9 crores.
On lines under construction5·4 "
On new lines0·7 "
Total15·0 crores.

This total is provided from the following sources :—

TBL-018 · FOLIO 218Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
1. From Imperial funds, either by state agency or by the agency of working companies12·0 crores.
2. From the capital accounts of the old guaranteed railway companies0·3 "
3. From the capital accounts of other railway companies, including branch-line companies in the receipt of a firm guarantee2·7 "

It will be noticed that more than half the capital expenditure was required for open lines. The present condition of many of the Indian railways, comparatively young lines with a rapidly increasing traffic, entails a large and growing expenditure on rolling stock, stations and goods sheds, additional sidings, signalling apparatus, and sometimes duplication of the permanent way. These needs must be met, and they already absorb a large part of the capital resources, which, under existing conditions, are strictly limited in amount. Except in specially prosperous years, the sums which can be spared from revenue are not great, and there are, moreover, obvious objections to large provision from current revenues towards capital expenditure on works of permanent improvement. The bulk of the expenditure must, therefore, be met by borrowing in India or in England. The amount of capital available in India for investment in Government securities, which afford a lower rate of profit than can be obtained by prudent commercial investment, is not large, and even in London the number of investors to whom Indian securities are familiar is relatively small. Thus after many vicissitudes the problem of capital expenditure for the construction of new lines of railway is still a difficult one, which always requires careful consideration from year to year.

As the net result of about fifty years' construction policy, India had been provided at the end of the year 1904–5 with 27,728 miles of railway, of which more than 20,000 belong to the state. During the same period the capital outlay of the Government on railways was 202 crores, of which 59 crores was spent on the purchase of companies' lines.

It remains to show how the acquisition of this great property has affected the revenues. The figures in the fourth table appended to this chapter are shown under the headings of old guaranteed railways, state railways, assisted railways, and miscellaneous. They do not require very detailed explanation. The liability of the state with respect to the first class of railways is for the 5 per cent. guaranteed interest, against which must be set off the net receipts less the companies' share of surplus profits and other payments. The resulting net charge fluctuates. The burden of the Government guarantee, which is paid in sterling, has been greatly enhanced by the fall in exchange. As the guaranteed railways are purchased, their accounts are transferred to the heading of state railways, and the remaining figures represent, therefore, a different set of circumstances. Under state railways, the gross receipts and working expenses, and with them the net income, show a large rise in each quinquennial period. On the other side must be reckoned the growing charge for interest on capital; but even allowing for this, state railways, which for accounts purpose include the lines belonging to Government worked by the new guaranteed railway companies, have for the last few years yielded a considerable profit. The net charges or receipts on account of the various classes of assisted railways and the miscellaneous expenditure vary considerably from year to year, but their totals are comparatively small.

Taking the whole of the railway revenue account together, the net result is as follows:—

TBL-019 · FOLIO 220Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
1876-7 to 1880-1average net loss1,20 lakhs.
1881-2 to 1885-6","74 ","
1886-7 to 1890-1","1,62 ","
1891-2 to 1895-6","1,53 ","
1896-7 to 1898-9","1,68 ","
1899-1900 to 1904-5","gain 1,11 ","

The rise in net expenditure from 1886-7 to 1890-1 may, to a large extent, be attributed to the fall in the rate of exchange and to the construction of strategic railways. The improvement of the last five years is noteworthy and continued in 1905-6, the net gain for that year being approximately estimated at 303 lakhs. It may, therefore, be fairly concluded that railways will in the future no longer prove a burden on the resources of the state, but an asset from which to meet a portion of the national expenditure.

Financially considered, irrigation works are classed as ‘major’ or ‘minor.’ The former class includes all works which have been undertaken from loan funds, and also those famine protective works which are constructed out of the annual grant from revenue for famine relief and insurance. The cost of constructing ‘minor’ works, as well as the sums annually required for their working and maintenance, are met from the ordinary revenues, and for the greater part of this class of works distinct capital and revenue accounts are not kept. The practice of constructing important irrigation works from borrowed funds began in the year 1867-8 under the viceroyalty of Lord Lawrence. The total capital outlay on irrigation, including that met from current revenues (45 crores to the end of 1904-5), though in itself large, has been much less than the capital expenditure on railways. The provision of funds for the construction of irrigation works forms part of the larger problem already described in connexion with railways. It has been for many years the practice to allot a fixed sum annually for capital expenditure on irrigation projects. In 1893-4 the amount was raised from 55 to 75 lakhs, in view of the excellent financial results that were being obtained. The allotment remained at 75 lakhs (except in years of financial pressure) until 1899-1900, when it was raised to 85 lakhs; since then it has been raised, first to 100 and then to 125 lakhs. Having regard to the very remunerative character of the greater part of the outlay, and to the immense value in times of scarcity of the food supplies which can be relied on with confidence from the irrigated area, the Government of India has resolved to spare no efforts to make ample provision for irrigation works, and will be materially assisted by the Report of a Commission which investigated the subject in 1902-3. The annual profit to the state is the excess, over the interest on capital outlay, of the direct receipts and the share of the land revenue attributable to the works, less the working expenses. Each quinquennial period since 1876 shows a net gain, except that between 1886-7 and 1890-1, during which a great loss of revenue resulted from a breach in an aqueduct near the head of the Lower Ganges Canal. During the years 1901-4 the average net receipts amounted to 1·3 crores, an enormous improvement over the results of any previous period. The net expenditure on 'Minor Works and Navigation' averaged 1 crore in the same period.

'Civil Works,' which mean mainly roads and buildings, are constructed entirely from revenue. The outlay in any year depends to a large extent on what Provincial Governments and District and sub-district boards can afford to spend, for in times of stress this can be reduced more easily than other forms of expenditure. Taking again periods of five years, the average expenditure shows a considerable cumulative increase which, owing largely to famine, was not so great as usual during the five years 1896-7 to 1900-1. The average during that period, 4 crores, compares with 2·6 crores from 1876-7 to 1880-1. In the four years 1901-4 the average outlay was 5·5 crores.

The next heading, 'Interest,' needs for its elucidation an examination of the national debt of India (see Table I). The subject is closely connected with public works, since the greater part of the debt has been incurred for capital outlay on railways and irrigation. Taking the then value of the rupee at 2s., the total debt of the Government of India was equivalent in 1840 to 31 millions, and in 1860 to 98 million pounds sterling. The whole of this sum was borrowed for unproductive expenditure, and the interest, which amounted to over 4 millions in 1860, was a dead weight on the revenues. In 1876 the sterling debt stood at 55 millions, and the rupee debt at 72 crores. In 1904–5 the sterling debt had risen to 133 millions and the rupee debt to 122 crores. If, for the purpose of comparison, the sterling debt is converted into rupees at the present rate of 1s. 4d. for both these years, the total debt shows a rise from about 155 to 321 crores (103 to 214 millions sterling). But the distribution of the debt at the beginning and end of the period is very different. In 1876–7 the ordinary debt amounted to 124 crores, and the public works debt to 30½ crores; in 1904–5 the ordinary debt had been reduced to 90½, while the public works debt had risen to 231 crores. Now it has already been shown that the increased capital outlay on railways and irrigation works, far from having resulted in any additional burden to the taxpayer, has been accompanied by such an improvement that, whereas in 1876–7 there was a total charge against the revenues for railways and major irrigation works of 1·3 crores, in 1904–5 these works, after the payment of all interest charges, contributed a profit of 4⅔ crores. The decline of the ordinary debt by 33½ crores thus represents a real saving. It has been effected mainly by transferring to the public works portion of the accounts an amount of debt equal to the capital expenditure on productive works supplied from revenue. The expenditure on capital outlay from revenue, either from the annual famine insurance grant or from general savings, has been considerable; and it is right to include it in the debt account, since its annual profits are a proper set-off against interest charges and often cannot be distinguished from profits derived from borrowed capital. This system was instituted in 1880–1, when a lump sum of 5½ millions sterling was transferred from the ordinary to the public works account. A portion of this outlay had been incurred before 1876–7, and to that extent the ordinary debt for that year is over-stated.

The actual results are more favourable than those indicated by the above figures, since a portion of the ordinary debt, amounting to 6 crores in 1876–7 and to 18 crores in 1904–5, represents loans to Native States, municipalities, public trusts, agriculturists, &c. The interest charged for such loans covers that paid by the Government, and this portion of the debt does not therefore impose any burden on the revenues. If this loan portion of it be left out of account, the total ordinary debt amounted in 1904–5 to about 72½ crores.

In addition to its debt proper, the Government incurs a variety of other obligations which are of a different character, inasmuch as the prime object is not to obtain funds for the use of the state. The sum of these obligations amounted on March 31, 1905, to 19½ crores. By far the largest item is the Post Office savings banks deposits, which accounted on that date for nearly 13½ crores of the total, and various provident funds and similar institutions absorb a great part of the remainder. These receipts are included in the general balances of the Government. In introducing the budget for 1903-4, the Finance Minister (Sir E. Law) showed that, taking the whole of the Government debt on the one side, and the counterbalancing commercial assets (capitalized value of state railways and canals, &c.) on the other, the net excess of debt over assets on March 31, 1902, was only 33 crores; and, as he said, few states can boast of such a favourable financial position.

We may now turn to the interest figures in the third table. These do not include interest on public works capital, of which account has already been taken in the railway and irrigation figures and which, as we have seen, is now covered by the net receipts. Compared with 1876-7, the year 1904-5 shows a decrease in the interest charges on ordinary debt (including the portion from which loans are made to Native States, local bodies, &c.) from 466 to 180 lakhs. The decrease is due to the diminution of the capital debt already explained, and to successive reductions in the rate of interest, attributable to the general fall in the value of money and to the improved credit of the Indian Government. In 1876-7 the average rate of interest was 4·2 per cent. on both sterling and rupee loans; in 1904-5 it was 3·2 per cent. on the former and 3·5 per cent. on the latter. The bulk of the rupee debt is now held at 3½ per cent., and 11 crores pay only 3 per cent. The interest on the other obligations noticed above (savings banks deposits, &c.) has risen from 40 lakhs in 1876-7 to 67 lakhs in 1904-5. Against these interest charges must be set off the interest receipts, of which the most important items are the interest paid on loans and advances to Native States, local bodies, &c., and the interest on the securities held by the Paper Currency department. Deducting receipts from total charges, the net charge for interest was only 120 lakhs in 1904-5, as against 451 lakhs in 1876-7.

We now come to the important subject of military expenditure. India, in common with other countries, has felt the strain of the costly modern military system. But the size of the Indian army (about 230,000 men) is small compared with the immense population, and the revenues have proved equal to the task of rearmament and reorganization, undertakings which have not been attempted in other countries without the assistance of some form of loan. In the third table at the end of this chapter the net military expenditure is shown under the heads of effective and non-effective charges and military works. We have already seen that great reductions in the military expenditure were effected in the early sixties. From that time until the year 1885 there was little increase in the effective charges. The Government of India strove after economy, and in consequence of the recommendations made by a Commission appointed in 1879 savings were effected which amounted to more than 1 crore. In 1885 the advance of Russia and the conquest of Upper Burma led to an increase in the forces and considerable expenditure in various directions. In 1884–5 the net effective expenditure amounted to 12·3 crores, and in 1886–7 to 15·3 crores1. In 1890–1 the total net amount was 16 crores, and in the following year it rose to 17½ crores. The rise on this occasion was due to the introduction of various modern improvements in armament, equipment, and organization. From 1891–2 to the present time the promotion of these and similar improvements, which are essential to the efficiency of the army, has continued. Other causes of increased expenditure are the raising of the pay of the native soldiers in 1895, and of the British soldiers in 1898 and again in 1902. The net effective expenditure (excluding military works) had risen to 18½ crores in 1896–7 and reached 24 crores in 1904–5. In 1899–1900 and subsequent years large savings were effected by the absence of troops in South Africa and China, whose cost while so employed fell on the Home Government; but against these savings must be taken expenditure on transport, equipment, and reorganization, which the experience of the South African War has shown to be necessary. Considerable sums have recently been spent on the establishment of cordite, gun-carriage, and small-arms factories, which will cheapen the cost of military material and afford mechanical training and employment to natives of India; and for the redistribution and reorganization of the army, including the supply of new guns and rifles. The net expenditure on non-effective charges rose from 2½ crores in 1876–7 to 5 crores in 1894–5, and since then has fallen to 4½ crores in 1904–5. Its course has been influenced by the rate of exchange, and by various complications and changes in system. The introduction of short service in England has tended to reduce the pension charges. The expenditure on military works does not vary greatly, and in recent years has averaged 1½ crores. Taking the whole net expenditure on the army and military works, the following are the average figures for five quinquennial periods and for the years 1902–3 to 1904–5:—

TBL-020 · FOLIO 225Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
1876–7 to 1880–117·4 crores
1881–2 to 1885–617·4 „
1886–7 to 1890–120·3 „
1891–2 to 1895–623·5 „
1896–7 to 1900–123·2 „
1902–3 to 1904–527·6 „

These figures are exclusive of special defence works and military operations, which will be noticed in dealing with extraordinary expenditure. The last item in the table of net expenditure bears the title ‘Provincial and Local surplus or deficit.’ This entry has reference to the working of the system of Provincial finance and will be explained later on.

Some account has now been given of the various heads making up the net receipts and the net ordinary expenditure of the Government of India. It remains to deal with the extraordinary charges which are met from the excess of ordinary revenues over ordinary outlay. They have not been included in the tables at the end of this chapter other than Table I, since the extraordinary expenditure of any particular year may give no indication of the real obligations of the Government under this head. The nature and amount of extraordinary charges can be best illustrated by the total figures for a definite period. Taking the period 1876–7 to 1902–3, the extraordinary expenditure of the Government of India may be classed as follows :—

TBL-021 · FOLIO 225Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Military operations22·2 crores.
Special defences4·5 „
Famine relief26·3 „
Construction of railways from revenue7·3 „
Construction of railways and irrigation works from the famine insurance grant9·8 „

Arrangements cannot be made beforehand to meet war expenditure, and when it has to be incurred it must be defrayed from revenues or balances, or by borrowing. The existence of wild tribes on the frontier involves the Indian Government in frequent minor expeditions, but the Afghān War is the only great campaign in which India has been engaged during the period under review. The other large-scale operations have been the Upper Burma expedition, the Chitrāl campaign of 1895–6, and the Tīrāh and other frontier campaigns of 1897–9. Expenditure on special defences began in 1885–7 in accordance with a scheme, estimated to cost 5 crores in all, for improving the defences of the harbours and the frontier. The greater part of the outlay was incurred before 1896–7.

India suffered from three great famines during the last quarter of the nineteenth century. The period opened with the famine of 1876–8 in Southern India, and closed with the widespread calamities of 1896–7 and 1899–1900. During the intervening eighteen years, although scarcity prevailed from time to time in some part or other of the empire, no serious famine occurred. The total direct expenditure on famine relief since 1876 amounts to an average of 1 crore a year, and the actual cost to the state has been greatly enhanced by loss of revenue and indirect expenditure. Prior to 1878 no special measures were taken to meet the financial obligations imposed by the periodic recurrence of famine. The catastrophe in Southern India convinced Lord Lytton's Government that such a state of things was unsound, and that efforts must be made to treat the cost of famine as an ordinary charge on the state. The result was the provision of an annual sum of 1½ crores of rupees for 'famine insurance,' as described on pages 165, 166. The manner in which this additional revenue is utilized has varied from time to time. The actual relief of famine in years of scarcity has always been the first charge on the grant. At first the balance was devoted to the construction of 'productive' public works the cost of which would otherwise require to be met by loan. It was argued that, if the borrowing saved in this way equalled in the long run the borrowing incurred on account of famine, the purpose of insurance would be effected. In 1881 'protective' public works which, though not likely to be financially successful, were calculated to mitigate or prevent famine in the areas served by them, were made the second charge on the grant, but with a maximum limitation of the proportion to be spent on these objects to three-quarters of a crore annually, the balance being spent as heretofore. In 1890 this limitation was abolished, and for the next ten years a much larger proportion was spent on so-called 'protective' works. The actual distinction between 'protective' and 'productive' works became obscured, and railways which formed part of the general system and were not constructed specially for famine purposes were assisted from the ‘protective’ works portion of the famine grant. At the end of 1899 a stop was put to this practice. The expenditure on ‘protective’ works was again limited to three-quarters of a crore, and only railways and irrigation projects actually undertaken for famine purposes were allowed to be included in the category. The balance (apart from actual famine expenditure) is devoted to the avoidance of debt which must otherwise be incurred for the construction of railways. The cost of investigating and preparing irrigation and railway projects which may properly be classed as ‘protective’ is also deemed a legitimate charge against the famine grant.

The position created by the financial arrangements of Lord Lytton’s Government has thus been materially changed by later incidents and difficulties, but endeavour has always been made to maintain the desired surplus of ordinary revenue over ordinary expenditure. On the occasions when this was not found possible the famine insurance grant has been suspended in whole or in part. This happened in 1879 to 1881, and again in 1886–7 to 1891–2. From 1894–5 to 1896–7 (the closing years of a considerable period not marked by any great famine) it was deemed sufficient to provide one crore; but in 1898–9 (after the first of the recent famines) the grant was again raised to 1½ crores, at which amount it remains in years when that sum is not exceeded by the cost of famine relief. During the twenty-five years ending with 1902–3, 18·8 crores have been spent from the grant on famine relief, 14 crores have been applied to the construction of ‘protective’ works (including the net interest charge on two ‘protective’ railways), 3¾ crores have been applied to the construction of works which could not otherwise have been carried out without incurring debt, and 2 crores to the actual reduction of debt. The whole of the 1½ crores of the famine insurance grant is shown on the expenditure side of the public accounts under one head, divided according to the different purposes to which the grant is put. This plan has not been followed in the tables at the end of this chapter; but the portion of the grant devoted to actual famine relief, and to the capital cost of the construction of ‘protective’ works, has been included in the extraordinary expenditure defrayed from revenue of which the totals have been given above.

The only other item included under extraordinary expenditure is the capital outlay on railway construction from Provincial and local revenues. Of recent years the expenditure under this head has been very small, and almost the whole contribution from revenue towards the construction of railways is now derived from Imperial revenues.

The financial transactions of the Government of India having now been presented as a whole, it remains to describe certain special features of the system. The points to be dealt with are the system of Provincial finance, the Home charges, and the regulation of ‘ways and means.’

The public accounts include the whole receipts and expenditure whether in India or in England. They are combined from three sets of accounts—the accounts of the Home Government, the accounts of the Supreme Government in India, and the accounts of the eight major Local Governments. In the latter are also included the accounts of the District and sub-district boards; but the exclusion of these from the Imperial accounts is now under consideration. We have already seen that the whole administration of the finances in India was vested at one time in the Central Government, and that a policy of decentralization was initiated in 1870 and developed in 1877–82. The arrangements introduced in 1877 have been modified in some particulars, but, in the main, are still in force. The objects aimed at were to give the Local Governments a strong inducement to develop their revenues and practise economy in their expenditure, to obviate the need for interference on the part of the Supreme Government in the details of Provincial administration, and at the same time to maintain the unity of the finances in such a manner that all parts of the administration should receive a due share of growing revenues required to meet growing needs, and should bear in due proportion the burden of financial difficulties which must be encountered from time to time. This problem has been solved by the Government of India delegating to the Local Governments the control of the expenditure on the ordinary Provincial services, together with the whole, or a proportion, of certain heads of revenue sufficient to meet these charges. The heads of revenue selected are such as are most susceptible of improvement under careful Provincial management. Subject to occasional exceptions, the distribution of the more important sources of revenue is as follows: wholly Imperial—salt, customs, opium, and tributes; divided— land revenue, stamps, excise, assessed taxes, forests, and registration; wholly Provincial—the local taxes included under the head ‘Provincial rates.’ While expenditure on the ordinary Provincial services has been delegated to the Local Governments, the Supreme Government keeps in its own hands the bulk of the charges connected with the public debt, the army, the Indian marine, the central administration, and foreign affairs. The Home charges are also Imperial. As regards the commercial departments, transactions connected with the post office, telegraphs, mint, and railways are wholly or mainly Imperial, while irrigation is divided between the two accounts. The Imperial expenditure amounts to more than three times as much as the expenditure of all the Provinces put together. The financial administration of the Local Governments is subject to the general supervision of the Supreme Government, and to conditions concerning the imposition of new taxation, the creation of appointments, the alteration of scales of salaries, the maintenance of great lines of communications, and so on. The Local Governments are also required, ordinarily, to keep a prescribed minimum balance with which to meet emergent expenditure. In other respects they have a free hand in administering their share of the revenue. While this system in some ways resembles the systems of federal finance which prevail in the German Empire and in the United States, it differs from them in a very vital respect. In Germany and America the constituent states have voluntarily surrendered certain attributes of their fiscal and other sovereignty to the Central Government, but retain complete independence, outside the sphere of federal finance, in levying and spending their revenues. In India the Local Governments are merely delegates of the Supreme Government, and exercise financial and other functions subject to its approval and control. They have moreover no borrowing powers, and when—as has been the case in Bombay of recent years under the stress of plague and famine— they exceed their resources, the balance is met by the Government of India.

The arrangements with the Local Governments were formerly subject to revision once in five years. During each quinquennial period the Province enjoyed the full advantage of any improvement in its share of the revenues due to natural growth and good administration. When the five years' period was drawing to a close the Supreme Government would take fresh stock of the financial position. An estimate was made of the existing and future needs of the Province as regards revenue and expenditure, and the settlement was revised accordingly. In making this estimate the Government of India did not bind itself to take into account the whole of the expenditure which the Local Government had been able to defray from its growing revenues or balances. Some forms of expenditure, such as the outlay on public works and the contributions made for local purposes, are to some extent voluntary in character; and it was possible, without interfering with the development of the Provincial finances, to resume a portion of the funds devoted to such purposes. The sums thus gained might be utilized to improve the position of less prosperous Provinces, or might be needed for the Imperial obligations which form by far the greater portion of the total expenditure. In this manner a certain elasticity was secured without sacrificing the objects for which the system of Provincial finance was introduced. The system had, however, the drawback of provoking periodical controversies between the Supreme and the Local Governments, and of stimulating hasty, and therefore possibly wasteful, expenditure by the latter during the closing years of a settlement. Accordingly it has now been determined to assign to the Local Governments more permanent shares in the divisible revenues raised in their territories. Settlements made on this basis were concluded with the Governments of Madras, Bengal, the United Provinces, and Assam, with effect from 1904-5; with Bombay and the Punjab, with effect from 1905-6; and with the Central Provinces (including Berār), with effect from 1906-7. The recent division of Bengal further necessitated fresh settlements with the new Provinces thereby constituted, which came into force from 1906-7. The settlement with Eastern Bengal and Assam is, however, subject to revision after a few years, when the normal standards of revenue and expenditure for the Province can be better ascertained. The Provinces above mentioned have received with the new settlements initial grants, amounting in the aggregate to 3 crores. Burma is now the only Province to which the new settlement principles have not been applied1.

So long as the Provincial settlements remained temporary, their periodical revision was necessarily influenced by the financial exigencies of the time. When the demands on the Imperial Government increased out of proportion to its normal resources, the Provincial assignments had perforce to be somewhat diminished; when Imperial finance was prosperous, they were as a whole increased.

Since the Provincial system came into being, Indian finance has been exposed to four special dangers—war, fall in opium receipts, fall in exchange, and famine. In the first three cases the risk falls entirely on the Imperial Government, which has therefore, to some extent, suffered from the increased stability given to Provincial finance. In times of emergency the Local Governments may be, and sometimes have been, called upon to make special contributions for the general purposes of the empire, apart from any resumptions made at the end of the quinquennial periods. Thus during the Afghān War they contributed 67 lakhs, afterwards restored; in 1886–7, 40 lakhs, towards the deficit caused by the Burmese War, military preparation on the north-western frontier, and the fall in exchange; and in 1894–5, the time of the exchange crisis, 40 lakhs, restored in the following year. The cost of famine and plague falls in the first instance on Provincial and local resources, and the Imperial Government steps in only when these are exhausted. This must, however, inevitably happen in the case of a severe famine. During the currency of the 1897–8 settlements the system of Provincial finance was sorely tried by the expenditure and loss of revenue occasioned by famine and plague. Accordingly, besides bearing by far the greater portion of the famine expenditure, Imperial revenues in each year made large grants to the Local Governments, the total of which amounted up to the end of 1903–4 to nearly 13 crores.

The meaning of the entry ‘Provincial and Local surplus or deficit’ in Table III will now be plain. The accounts are designed to show both the aggregate transactions of the Government and the position of the Imperial finances. The inclusion of the Provincial figures, which include the transactions of the District and sub-district boards, has this effect, that a Provincial expenditure smaller or greater than the Provincial receipts makes an addition to or deduction from the balance at the end of the year which does not affect the Imperial Government, since the Imperial and Provincial accounts are independent for the term of the settlement. It is therefore necessary to make an entry which will cancel the Provincial surplus or deficit. Take, for instance, the year 1901–2. Including grants from the Government of India, the Local Governments received in the aggregate 161 lakhs more than they spent. This sum is not available for Imperial purposes; and an adjusting entry of 161 lakhs is therefore made on the expenditure side, which reduces the Imperial balances by this amount, and leaves the account in the position in which it would have stood had the Provincial transactions been altogether excluded from it.

The Home receipts and expenditure of the Government of India are included in the general accounts under the appropriate heads, but require a brief separate examination. The net expenditure in England, chargeable on the revenues of the year, amounted in 1902–3 to about £17,700,000, distributed as follows : railway revenue account, £6,500,000 ; interest and management of debt (excluding interest charged in the railway account), £2,800,000 ; stores, £1,800,000 ; army effective charges, £1,300,000 ; civil administration, £400,000 ; marine, £200,000 ; and non-effective charges, consisting mainly of the furlough and pension allowances of civil and military officers, £4,700,000. These Home charges have sometimes been erroneously described as a tribute which India pays to England in consequence of her subordination to that country. A glance at the above figures will show that nearly 11 out of the total 17¾ million pounds consist of payments on account of capital and materials supplied by England, and belong to a commercial rather than an administrative class of transactions. Of the balance, 4½ millions represent furlough and pension payments, and are a necessary concomitant of the British administration to which India owes her material prosperity. The Home charges have grown by 4¾ million pounds in the past twenty-seven years, the main heads of increase being railways, interest, and furlough and pension allowances. The apportionment between England and India of expenditure for matters in which both are interested, and especially of charges in connexion with the army, has formed the subject of frequent discussion between the Indian and Home Governments. The subject was thoroughly investigated by Lord Welby's Commission in 1895–1900 and a number of moot points were then settled, resulting in a net annual relief to the Indian exchequer of about a quarter of a million sterling.

The Home expenditure is defrayed by the sale of Council bills (or telegraphic transfers) by the Secretary of State. Since the exports of India exceed her imports, European importers must remit to India the net value of this excess. For this purpose they buy bills on India, offered by the Secretary of State ; the latter pays the Home charges with the proceeds, and the buyers send the bills to India, where they are cashed by the Indian Government. As regards the Indian exchequer the result is therefore the same as if the amount had been directly remitted to the India Office. Before the Indian mints were closed to the free coinage of silver, the price which the Secretary of State obtained for his bills was determined by the gold value of silver bullion. If bills were offered at a rate less favourable than the market price of silver, importers could adopt the alternative of purchasing bullion and transmitting it to India for coinage. The actual form of the transactions was somewhat more complicated, but the essence was substantially as above. Until 1871–2 the gold value of the rupee had, except in one year, always exceeded 1s. 11d. In 1872–3 it fell to a little over 1s. 10 3⁄4d. ; and thenceforward, owing to the increasing production of silver, and its reduced employment for monetary purposes due to the currency policy of Germany and other countries, it fluctuated, with a constant downward tendency, until in 1894–5 it reached the lowest point of a little under 1s. 1d. As the price of silver fell the Secretary of State obtained worse and worse terms for his bills, or in other words the Government of India had to pay a continually increasing number of rupees to meet the sterling expenditure in England. Thus arose the principal, though not the only, cause of the loss by exchange. The changes in the currency system described in chapter xvi have had the effect of establishing a value for the rupee which varies within narrow limits on either side of 1s. 4d., and a fruitful cause of financial embarrassment and instability has thus been removed. In estimating the loss which the Government of India suffered, the result will depend on the period with which comparison is made. It would be unreasonable to take the period when the rupee was at or above par, for that was the time of the Mutiny, when practically no remittances were made to England and the country subsisted by borrowing. Again, before 1872–3 the amount of the Home remittances was much smaller than it became after that year. This was to a large extent due to the fact that the Secretary of State was kept in funds by the capital deposits of the guaranteed railway companies, which had of course to be refunded at a later date when the companies required the money for use. The year 1872–3 is therefore a good starting-point, because it marks the beginning both of the rapid fall in exchange and of the period of normal remittances. We may compare the price which the Government of India paid for its remittances in the year of lowest exchange, 1894–5, and the price it would have paid for remitting the same sum had the rate of exchange been that which prevailed in 1872–3. The sterling value of the bills paid in 1894–5 was £15,770,533. The rupee equivalent actually paid by the Government of India was 28·9 crores, while at the rate prevailing in 1872–3 it would have amounted to only 16·6 crores. The difference is thus 12·3 crores, which is more than half the amount of the net land revenue.

The actual amount drawn by the Secretary of State on India by means of Council bills in any year is not determined solely by the net expenditure incurred in England chargeable to the revenues. It is settled after consideration of a number of more or less complicated transactions which regulate the adjustment of resources to total expenditure of all kinds. Indian, like British, finance has, ever since Mr. Wilson's reforms of 1860, been regulated by the budget system, and the financial year ends on March 31. In the latter part of March is published the Annual Financial Statement, which includes the budget estimates of the coming year, the revised estimates of the current year, and the 'actuals,' or closed accounts, of the previous year.

The budget summary is shown in two main divisions: the first includes only revenue and expenditure charged to revenue, and is balanced by a surplus or deficit on revenue account. This surplus or deficit, together with the amount of the opening treasury balances in India and in England, is carried forward into the statement under the second main division, in which are also shown all expenditure on capital account, receipts by way of loans, and other transactions, under the heads of debts, deposits, advances, and Secretary of State's drafts, which are outside revenue accounts. The general budget is balanced by adjustment of the separate surpluses or deficits of the Provincial Governments, and by the entry of the amounts of the closing treasury balances in India and England.

It will be noted that the second division is of the nature of a capital account in contradistinction to the first division, which is purely a statement of revenue and of administrative expenditure charged to revenue. The excess of total expenditure over revenue shown in the second division, which is generally due to capital outlay on railway and irrigation works, is met by borrowing in India and England, frequently supplemented by drawing on treasury balances.

The sum to be drawn by the Secretary of State to meet the requirements of the Government of India for expenditure in England is determined by deducting from the total of such expenditure the borrowings in sterling in London. The total amount of bills which can be sold by him without undue depreciation of exchange depends on the demand for remittances to India in connexion with the export trade, and in recent years this has been largely in excess of the budgeted requirements of the Secretary of State for payments in sterling in England. Their satisfaction depends primarily on the resources of the treasuries in India; but if these should be unequal to meeting the demands, bills can be drawn against the Currency Reserve, the proceeds being remitted to India in gold, or utilized in the purchase of silver in order to recoup the Currency Reserve balance1. On the other hand, should a failure in the export trade, due to famine or other reasons, cause the demand for trade remittances to fall short of the total necessary to meet Government expenditure in sterling, the Secretary of State may make good the deficit by a corresponding increase in the amount of his sterling borrowings. In recent years the surplus proceeds of the Secretary of State's drawings, as compared with his actual revenue requirements, have been applied partly to the strengthening of the cash balances which he holds in England, partly to the purchase of silver for coinage, and partly to defraying capital outlay in connexion with railway construction.

A special feature of Indian finance arises through the fact that the revenue receipts vary considerably at different seasons of the year. During the months of January to April they are at their highest and the cash balances in India increase. During the following months they fall short of the demands on the treasuries; balances run down and are ordinarily at their lowest point in December. Experience shows that it is not safe to allow the balances to fall below 10 crores during this month, and this fact must be taken into consideration in deciding the amount announced in the annual financial statement which the Government proposes to borrow in England, or in India, or in both countries. The consideration of the monthly demands on treasury balances in India is the basis of the resource estimate, technically called 'ways and means'; and the result of this estimate, taken in connexion with the condition of the Indian money market, provides the data on which is fixed the amount of the loan to be raised in India in rupees.

It may be pointed out that, while most European Governments can count on meeting temporary treasury requirements by the issue of treasury bills through Government banks, such resources cannot be relied upon in India; and consequently the Indian Treasury is obliged to act as its own banker, estimating its monthly requirements with special foresight and prudence, and watching the situation with the closest attention throughout the year.

This sketch may be concluded with a bird's-eye view of the period which has been taken to illustrate the progress and condition of the Indian finances. During this period (1876– 1903) the total net revenue increased from about 39 to 61 crores, of which about 2¾ crores may be attributed to fresh taxation : namely, the income-tax and the addition to the Provincial rates by famine cesses which have, as already explained, now been repealed. A development of the commercial services—railways, irrigation, post office, and telegraphs— of enormous benefit to the country, has been accompanied by the conversion of a burden of 2 crores into a profit of 70 lakhs. The net charge on account of the funded and unfunded debt has been reduced from 4½ to 1½ crores. The net expenditure on the ordinary civil administration has risen from nearly 14 to 23 crores, the principal increase being under the heads of police, courts of justice, medical services, education, civil works, and pensions. The cost of the army (including military works) has risen from 16⅔ to 26 crores. The total surplus of ordinary revenue over ordinary expenditure during this period amounts to about 91 crores. From this surplus 22 crores have been spent on major military operations, 4.5 crores on special defences, 26 crores on famine relief, and 16½ crores on the construction of railways and major irrigation works. In spite of the great loss caused by the fall in exchange the record is a satisfactory one, and few countries could show a better. Great difficulties and misfortunes have been encountered; but, thanks to the growth of the national wealth and to the remarkable recuperative powers of the country, these have been successfully overcome. The reality of material progress in India is sometimes questioned, and the terrible ravages of famine are said to be incompatible with it. A growing land revenue accompanied by a diminishing incidence on the cultivated area, and a steady rise in the receipts from salt, excise, customs, and income-tax, are in themselves no uncertain index of developing resources, and abundant testimony outside the Government accounts is not wanting. In 1876-7 the total value of the exports and imports of British India (excluding bullion) amounted to 61 and 37 crores respectively; in 1902-3 the figures had risen to 129 and 86 crores. In 1878-9 there were 78 cotton and jute mills with a capital (so far as known) of 8⅔ crores; in 1902-3 the number of mills had increased to 237 and the capital to 24½ crores. In 1878 one million tons of coal were produced in India; in 1902, 7½ millions. In 1891 the petroleum sources yielded 6⅔ million gallons; in 1902, 56⅗ millions. In 1884-5 there were 694 joint stock companies in India with a paid-up capital of 20⅔ crores; in 1903-4, 1,489 companies owned a paid-up capital of 39¾ crores. The course of commercial and industrial progress never runs smooth ; but in spite of periods of misfortune and depression there are abundant signs that India is advancing steadily, and it is not unreasonable to anticipate that she is entering on an era of material prosperity the like of which she has never known in the past. If such be the case, the Indian financiers of the future may achieve even greater results than their predecessors. The outlook, however, is not without its anxieties. The malignant influence of a falling exchange has been dispelled ; but with a precarious opium revenue, a land revenue which can hardly be expected to maintain its former rate of growth, and a customs revenue which is threatened by an increase in the home production of some of the most important staples of the import trade, it may be that the resources on which the state has heretofore relied will not prove adequate for the needs of the future. But difficulties of this description which do not arise from a decay of national wealth may be overcome by skill and prudence, and there is no reason to apprehend that the Government will lack the means to carry out administrative improvements and to foster economic progress.

Bibliography

Sir John and Sir Richard Strachey.—Finances and Public Works of India (1882). Report of the Indian Finance Committee, 1886. Report of the Finance Commissioner with the Government of India (Sir Charles Elliott), 1887. Reports of the Indian Currency Committees, 1893 and 1899. Report of the Royal Commission on the administration of the expenditure of India, 1900.

The Financial Statements published annually by the Government of India in the Department of Finance, and The Financial and Commercial Statistics published in the Department of Commerce and Industry.

For information as to the revenue and expenditure of the Provinces and principal Native States, see the articles thereon in the several volumes of this Gazetteer.

TABLE I

TBL-022 · FOLIO 238Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
(In lakhs of rupees)
1876-7.1881-2.1886-7.1891-2.1896-7.1901-2.1902-3.1903-4.1904-5.
Revenue and Expenditure.
Gross Revenue58,6572,5577,3489,1494,131,14,521,16,151,25,631,27,22
Gross ordinary expenditure59,0568,3676,3486,5493,591,05,871,10,001,19,701,20,33
Extraordinary expenditure2,18— 12821,452,2580704770
Total Outlay61,2368,2477,1687,9995,841,06,671,10,701,20,171,21,03
Surplus or deficit— 2,58+ 4,31+ 18+ 1,15— 1,71+ 7,85+ 5,45+ 5,46+ 6,19
Reduction or avoidance of debt72684385971,00
Surplus or deficit as in published accounts— 2,58+ 3,59+ 18+ 47— 1,71+ 7,42+ 4,60+ 4,49+ 5,19
Debt.
Sterling debt converted into rupees at Rs. 15 to the pound83,071,02,041,26,291,61,021,72,262,01,402,00,641,99,511,99,27
Rupee debt71,8688,5392,601,02,651,08,211,15,941,17,321,19,201,22,08
Total1,54,931,90,572,18,892,63,672,80,473,17,343,17,963,18,713,21,35
Distribution of Debt.
Ordinary debt proper1,18,311,11,5199,301,02,1591,9590,4384,9978,1772,57
Loans at interest6,158,067,3911,0012,2319,0018,9018,3618,03
Construction of railways*15,3736,8659,1471,8794,071,12,541,17,611,24,641,32,33
Purchase of railways..15,2427,7850,3350,3259,2159,2159,2159,21
Irrigation15,1018,9025,2828,3231,9036,1637,2538,3339,21
Foreign Trade.
Value of commodities exported61,0181,9788,471,08,171,03,981,24,901,29,401,53,521,57,71
Value of commodities imported37,4449,1161,7869,4376,1288,7385,8292,591,04,41
TBL-023 · FOLIO 239Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
TABLE II. Net Revenue (In lakhs of rupees)
Revenue other than taxation.1876-7.1881-2.1886-7.1891-2.1896-7.1901-2.1902-3.1903-4.1904-5.
Land revenue . .17,2719,6720,6221,2720,6023,9924,1925,2724,71
Tributes and contributions from Native States . . .626665728684876263
Forests . . .16313864736781991,09
Opium . . .6,287,806,226,153,924,864,275,266,08
Miscellaneous . .12921738733417
Total24,2128,3527,8528,9526,4930,4329,8132,1032,68
Taxation.
Salt . . .5,746,485,757,727,518,008,386,987,12
Excise . . .2,433,294,194,865,325,796,297,087,60
Customs . .2,202,081,061,504,155,365,515,516,13
Assessed taxes .1501,281,611,832,012,071,771,86
Provincial rates .1,822,832,943,443,474,044,054,174,18
Stamps . . .2,703,233,564,084,564,954,995,125,36
Registration . .61011192221212224
Total14,9618,5118,8923,4027,0630,3631,5030,8532,49
Total Net Revenue39,1746,8646,7452,3553,5560,7961,3162,9565,17
TBL-024 · FOLIO 240Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
TABLE III. Net Expenditure (In lakhs of rupees)
Civil Administration.1876-7.1881-2.1886-7.1891-2.1896-7.1901-2.1902-3.1903-4.1904-5.
Land Revenue . .1,481,522,022,211,891,982,022,082,17
Civil Departments .9,319,6211,2412,2013,7714,8315,5515,5716,28
Miscellaneous Civil charges . . .2,933,573,834,315,175,345,465,455,53
Total13,7214,7117,0918,7220,8322,1523,0323,1023,98
Post Office . .132220481512158
Telegraphs . .1582812..591
Mint . . .122101110821513
Total16321215302352120
Public Works.
Railways . .1,15291,19322,661,27341,293,16
Irrigation . .625765671026293543
Civil Works . .2,843,433,604,423,994,855,556,146,43
Total4,614,295,445,416,753,324,924,502,84
Interest.
Ordinary debt .4,664,323,953,842,992,352,151,911,80
Other obligations .405336484657606367
Receipts . . .559067881,081,181,301,341,27
Total4,513,953,643,442,371,741,451,201,20
Army.
Effective . .12,9513,4715,3017,4618,5617,8620,0120,7824,33
Non-effective .2,583,393,243,954,724,324,324,384,49
Military Works .1,161,02871,161,101,371,591,481,40
Total16,6917,8819,4122,5724,3823,5525,9226,6430,22
Provincial and Local surplus or deficit .— 12+ 1,52+ 4— 24— 1,02+ 1,61— 11+ 1,79+ 24
Total Net Expenditure39,5742,6745,7449,7553,0152,1455,1657,0258,28

TABLE IV. PUBLIC WORKS

TBL-025 · FOLIO 241Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
(In lakhs of rupees)
Old Guaranteed Railways.1876-7.1881-2.1886-7.1891-2.1896-7.1901-2.1902-3.1903-4.1904-5.
Interest . . .5,453,953,723,073,601,521,551,571,60
Net receipts less surplus profits, land, and supervision .4,773,213,052,732,161,151,301,261,43
Net charges687467341,4437253117
State Railways.
Gross receipts . .387,2710,8316,4117,6428,9228,7030,8634,35
Working expenses .293,375,228,218,8214,2414,7415,5616,94
Net receipts93,905,618,208,8214,6813,9615,3017,41
Interest on capital .561,893,685,667,078,458,799,129,50
Annuities, &c., for purchase of railways..1,492,312,432,854,504,504,514,51
Net charges or receipts475238111,101,73671,673,40
Net charge for assisted railways . ...24..6311..
Miscellaneous railway expenditure ...5109612987
Net charge or receipts for railways .1,15291,19322,661,27341,293,16
Irrigation— Major Works.
Gross direct receipts .4286911,412,072,342,722,882,99
Share of land revenue40496067871,221,221,261,34
Working expenses .36466376871,051,131,221,31
Net receipts . .4689881,322,072,512,812,923,02
Interest . .6480991,111,251,421,451,491,52
Net charges or receipts1891121821,091,361,431,50
Total Railways and Major Irrigation.
Net charges or receipts1,33201,30111,842,361,702,724,66
Minor Works and Navigation . .4466548892831,071,081,07
Civil Works . .2,843,433,604,423,994,855,556,146,43
Grand total of charges.4,614,295,445,416,753,324,924,502,84

Notes

  1. 1. Financial and Commercial Statistics of British India, tenth issue.
  2. 2. ‘There was formerly in British India, comparatively speaking, little of what we now think the first necessities of a civilized administration. When, in 1844, I first went from Calcutta to the North-Western Provinces, I was carried about a thousand miles in a palanquin on men’s shoulders, [p. 161] and it took some three weeks to toil through a journey which is now accomplished in twenty-four hours; there were no other means of travelling through the richest and most civilized parts of India. Speaking generally, roads and bridges had only begun to appear; railways were not thought of; the value of irrigation as a means of affording protection to the people against famine had hardly been recognized; there were few barracks in which English soldiers could live with tolerable health and comfort; there were few jails in which a sentence of imprisonment did not carry with it a serious probability that it would prove a sentence of death.’—Sir John Strachey’s India (3rd edition), p. 9.
  3. 1. See on this subject Hunter's Indian Empire (3rd edition), pp. 357 and 547; Mr. Stanley Lane Poole's Aurangzeb (Rulers of India series), chap. vii; and chap. vii of the present volume.
  4. 1. Prior to Lord Canning's viceroyalty and Mr. Wilson's appointment the finances of India had been dealt with by the Governor-General and his Council collectively. See chap. i of this volume.
  5. 1. Sir John Strachey’s India (3rd edition), p. 113.
  6. 1. See on this and other points connected with the land revenue, chap. vii of this volume.
  7. 1. R. 1 per maund in Burma.
  8. 1. Registration is now, as a rule, obligatory in the case of deeds relating to immovable property.
  9. 1. These profits formerly figured both in the revenue of the year and in the expenditure chargeable to revenue: they are now, since 1904–5, directly adjusted under the head 'Deposits and Advances.'
  10. 1. In these and many subsequent years the fall in exchange added considerably to the total effective charges, because the pay of British troops is fixed at a sterling rate.
  11. 1. For further details see paragraphs 206-17 of the Government of India Financial Statement for 1904-5, paragraphs 203-5 of the Statement for 1905-6, and paragraphs 214-22 of the Statement for 1906-7.
  12. 1. In regard to currency transactions see chap. xvi.
  13. *. Exclusive of outlay met from funds raised by companies working state railways. [p. 201] Figures in italics represent excess of expenditure over receipts. [p. 202] Figures in italics represent excess of receipts over expenditure. [p. 203] Figures in italics represent excess of receipts over expenditure.