Opium
The poppy is grown in India for the manufacture of opium for export to China and other countries, and for home consumption. Revenue derived from export opium is credited in the public accounts under the heading ‘opium,’ and that from home consumption under the heading ‘excise.’ The export revenue is much the more important: in 1904–5 it amounted to more than 6 crores net, as compared with one crore from excise opium.
The principal sources of opium supply are, firstly, Bihār and the Districts of the United Provinces lying along and in the north of the Gangetic valley; and, secondly, a number of Native States in the Central India and Rājputāna Agencies, principally Indore, Gwalior, Bhopāl, and Mewār. There is also some production in Baroda. The produce of the first region is known as Bengal, and of the second region as Mālwā, opium.
The right to produce Bengal opium was farmed by the Muhammadan rulers who preceded us, and this method was adopted by Warren Hastings, on behalf of the East India Company, in 17731. It was, however, found to give rise to deterioration of the product and to oppression of the cultivators by the contractors; and accordingly in 1797 the Bengal Government assumed the direct monopoly of manufacture, a system which has continued to the present time. Under this system, which at its inception corresponded with that then in force in regard to salt, the growth of the poppy and the manufacture of the opium are under the superintendence of a special department. The department is divided into two agencies, one for Bihār with head-quarters at Patna, and one for the United Provinces with head-quarters at Ghāzīpur, near Benares; but both agents are under the control of the Bengal Board of Revenue and the Bengal Government. The poppy may be grown only under licence from an authorized officer of the department; and the cultivator, who receives advances, when required, to assist him in production, is bound to sell the whole of his out-turn at a fixed rate to the Government. He delivers it in the form of crude opium at local centres, whence it is dispatched to the head factories and there prepared for the market. The rate paid to the cultivators has, with some fluctuations, increased steadily during the past fifty years. In 1850-1 it was Rs. 3-10 a seer1, and from 1894-5 onwards it has been Rs. 6. The bulk of the opium is for export, and is known as ‘Provision opium2,’ while that destined for consumption in India is called ‘Excise opium.’ The cost of producing the excise opium is credited to Opium receipts at the estimated rate of Rs. 81/2 a seer. The provision opium is packed in chests each containing 140 lb., and is dispatched to Calcutta, where it is sold by public auction. The total net cost of producing a chest of opium has risen from Rs. 280 in 1850-1 to Rs. 499 in 1902-3. The price obtained at the Calcutta sales, less the cost of production, is the revenue from Bengal provision opium.
The net revenue derived from Bengal provision opium fluctuates greatly from year to year, and has, during the past twenty years, exhibited a strong downward tendency. In 1880-1 the net receipts amounted to about 6 crores, and in 1902-3 to only 31/4 crores3. Two factors contribute to the uncertain character of the annual profit. In the first place, the crop is in a high degree sensitive to seasonal influences and the out-turn is therefore extremely variable, a result which tends to speculation and violent fluctuations of price. In order to minimize this evil a reserve stock is now maintained to meet the deficiency of bad seasons. It is estimated that the area under cultivation, which the Government does not desire to be materially increased, produces on an average 48,000 chests. This figure is now taken as the sale standard, and the excess production of good years is added to the reserve store. The maximum quantity to be sold is notified each year, and is not changed without three months’ warning. The second disturbing cause is the influence, on the sale price of the Indian drug, of the competition of Chinese opium, which has been stimulated by the rising cost of cultivation in India and by the closing of the Indian mints. This, by raising the exchange value of the rupee, has produced a smaller equivalent in rupees for the dollar and tael prices realized in China, which have been kept from a corresponding rise by the competition of the native drug. Large quantities of opium are now produced in China, and might have ousted the Indian drug altogether were it not that the latter is of finer quality and is esteemed a greater luxury. Its position is, however, by no means assured, and recent political developments have added to the precarious character of the situation.
As early as the beginning of the sixteenth century a native trade in opium existed between the west coast of India and the Far East, and for a time a large share of it fell into the hands of the Portuguese. The efforts of the East India Company were at first directed to the restriction or suppression of this trade, which interfered with the Bengal monopoly. This proved impossible, and in 1830 the Government of India authorized the export of Mālwā opium subject to the payment of duty. The levy of this duty has been facilitated by the circumstances that the main opium-producing tracts have no access to the seaboard except through British territory. The system introduced in 1830 is still maintained. The Government of India does not interfere with production or consumption in the Native States, but no opium may pass into British territory for export or consumption without payment of duty. The duty is levied at convenient stations maintained by the British Government at Indore and elsewhere, whence the bulk of the opium is consigned to a central dépôt at Bombay for issue to traders. The revenue has suffered from causes similar to those which have affected Bengal opium. In 1880–1 the Mālwā opium passed for export to China amounted to 37,000 chests, and in 1901–2 to less than 18,000 chests. The rate of duty per chest rose from Rs. 175 in 1830 to Rs. 700 in 1861, fluctuated between Rs. 700 and Rs. 600 until 1897–8, and was then reduced to Rs. 500. It was again raised to Rs. 600, following some improvement in exports, in 1904. The rate of duty has always been considerably less than the net profit from a chest of Bengal opium. The net receipts from Mālwā opium have fallen from 2 1 crores in 1880–1 to 99 lakhs in 1902–3.
Opium is consumed in all Provinces of India. The consumption is highest in Assam, where it amounts to 8·8 seers per thousand of the population. In Bombay the corresponding figure is 2·4 seers, in the United Provinces and Bengal 1·3 seers, and in Madras 1·1 seers. The drug is commonly taken in the form of pills ; but in some places, chiefly on social and ceremonial occasions, it is drunk dissolved in water. An infusion of poppy heads called post is commonly used in parts of Northern India. Opium-smoking is not extensively practised in India proper, where it is considered a disreputable habit. Opium is largely used for medicinal purposes, and is a common household drug of the people.
In consequence of a resolution passed in the House of Commons, a Royal Commission was appointed in 1893 to inquire into the extent and effects of opium consumption in India, and to consider whether the production and sale of the drug otherwise than for medicinal purposes should be prohibited. With regard to the export trade to China, the Commission held that it would be for that country to take action if it wished the existing treaties annulled on the ground that the import of opium is injurious to its population. Opium is now largely manufactured in China, and if the Indian supply ceased the deficiency would soon be filled by an increase in the home production. It may be added that so far from having encouraged the production of opium in India, as is often alleged, the British authorities found it produced wherever this could profitably be done ; and that their whole policy has been to restrict the production to authorized areas, while they have procured from many Native States, and notably from Hyderābād and Mysore, the discontinuance of internal opium production1.
As regards internal consumption, the Commission were of opinion that the evil effects ascribed to the drug have been much exaggerated. They summarized the preponderant medical evidence in saying that ‘the temperate use of opium in India should be viewed in the same light as the temperate use of alcohol in England. Opium is harmful, harmless, or even beneficial, according to the measure and discretion with which it is used.’ They did not advise prohibition ; they recommended the maintenance of the Bengal monopoly system of production ; and they found that the arrangements for retail vend were in general sufficiently restrictive.
With some small exceptions, the cultivation of the poppy is forbidden in British India outside the area of the Bengal monopoly. The Patna and Ghāzīpur factories supply Bengal, Assam, the United Provinces, the Central Provinces, and, to a small extent, the Punjab and the Frontier Province; while Mālwa opium is the source for Bombay and Madras, and meets a considerable portion of the demand in the Punjab and the Frontier Province. In the Punjab some opium is produced locally, and some is imported from Kashmīr and certain Hill States, while the Frontier Province also draws a portion of its supply from these sources and from Afghānistān.
In Bengal, Assam, the United Provinces, and the Central Provinces, Bengal opium is sold at Government treasuries to licensed vendors and druggists at a fixed price, which includes the cost of production and the duty. In parts of the United Provinces the treasury officials are also permitted to sell opium direct to the public at fixed rates, an arrangement intended to check illicit practices in the opium-producing tracts. In the Punjab licensed wholesale vendors procure opium from the Government treasuries (in the case of Bengal opium) or from crop owners, or by importation, and sell to retail vendors. In Bombay opium passes from the central warehouse above mentioned to District dépôts, whence it is issued to licensed vendors; vendors may also import direct (under licence) from the sources of supply. In Madras, Mālwā opium from the Bombay warehouse is stored in two dépôts and sold to wholesale vendors.
The right of retail vend is in general sold by annual auction, for one or several sanctioned shops. Intoxicating drugs prepared from opium may be sold in some Provinces by licensed vendors, in others only by licensed druggists for medicinal purposes. Smoking preparations may, under certain restrictions, be made up privately, but may not be bought or sold in any part of British India. Private possession without licence is strictly limited for all classes of opium.
The excise revenue derived from opium is mainly composed of duty and vend fees. The rate of duty varies with the conditions of the locality, being highest where smuggling is most difficult. The average rate of duty per seer is Rs. 28·5 in Assam, Rs. 20·5 in Bengal, Rs. 13·5 in the Central Provinces, Rs. 10 in Madras and Bombay, Rs. 8·8 in the United Provinces, and Rs. 3·6 in the Punjab. Rs. 8½ per seer is, moreover, added to the duty on Bengal opium to cover the cost of production. Adding vend fees to the duty, the average taxation per seer in 1902–3 varied from Rs. 34·9 in Assam to Rs. 11·5 in the Punjab.
Burma has been excluded from the above account because the circumstances in that Province are special. The consumption of opium, which there usually takes the form of smoking, is not commonly practised by Burmans : they appear to be specially susceptible to injury from it, and they view it in general with disfavour. The consumption is permitted only to non-Burmans, and to a limited number of Burmans specially registered as opium consumers in Lower Burma. The registration system was introduced in 1893, for the sake of such Burmans as had acquired the habit, when the general prohibition against consumption by Burmans was extended from Upper Burma, where it had been enforced since the kingdom was annexed, to the Lower Province. Bengal opium is used in Lower Burma ; in Upper Burma this is supplemented by imports from Yünnan and the Shan States, and by manufacture in some remote Kachin villages. The number of retail shops is restricted within narrow limits, and the maximum amount that may be sold in each shop is fixed. The duty is very high, and, with the addition of the vend fees, the taxation in 1900–1 averaged Rs. 72 per seer. The high duty and stringent regulations encouraged smuggling ; and it has recently been found necessary to make some improvements in the registration and vend system, and in the preventive arrangements, in order to meet this evil. These arrangements reduced the vend fees, but the average taxation per seer in 1902–3 was still as high as Rs. 51.
Salt
All salt consumed in British India is subject to duty, the rate which prevailed throughout the greater part of the empire between 1888 and 1903 being Rs. 2–8 per maund of 82 2/7 lb., reduced in the latter year to Rs. 2, and further reduced in 1905 to Rs. 1–8 per maund. In 1902–3 (before the reduction) the tax yielded a gross revenue of 9·3 and a net revenue of 8·4 crores. Objection has sometimes been taken to the principle of taxing a prime necessary of life such as salt. The existing tax is, however, a light substitute for the transit and internal customs duties which were levied on various necessaries of life, salt included, until the later days of the East India Company ; the mass of the people could not be taxed readily in any other way ; and it is both right and expedient that they should bear some part of the cost of administration. The incidence of the tax is light, averaging in 1902–3 only 4·9 annas per head of the population, while the recent reduction has brought the incidence to below 4 annas (say 4d.).
The total supply of salt to India amounted in 1902–3 to 40 million maunds, of which nearly 70 per cent. was produced in the country and the rest imported by sea. The principal sources of Indian production are the Salt Range and Kohāt mines in the Punjab and the Frontier Province ; the Sāmbhar Lake and other salt sources worked by the Government of India in Rājputāna ; the salt-soil brine on the borders of the Lesser Rann of Cutch ; and the sea-salt factories on the Madras and Bombay coasts and at the mouth of the Indus. During the five years ending with 1902–3, 60 per cent. of the total Indian production consisted of Madras and Bombay sea-salt, 7 per cent. was salt from the Rann of Cutch (known as Barāgara salt), 9 per cent. came from the cis-Indus Punjab mines, and 18 per cent. from the Sāmbhar Lake and other Rājputāna sources.
The Salt Range mines contain a practically inexhaustible supply. In the Mayo mines there are five or more workable seams of varying thickness, between which lie strata of salt marl. The salt is worked in chambers, excavated in the strata, some of which are 250 feet long, 45 feet wide, and 200 feet high. In Rājputāna salt is extracted by evaporation from brine deposits, the details of the process varying greatly from place to place. On the Bombay and Madras coasts salt is obtained by the solar evaporation of sea-water standing in large shallow pans. The manufacture may be spoilt by unfavourable seasonal conditions, and the production varies considerably from year to year.
Bengal and the greater part of Burma obtain their salt by importation. Salt was formerly produced in Bengal ; and a system which provided for the control of manufacture and sale by the agency of the Company's servants was introduced by Clive and Warren Hastings in 1765–80, and survived in a modified form till 18621. The trade in Cheshire salt rose to importance about the year 1835 ; and thenceforward imported salt gradually ousted the native product in Bengal proper until, by 1873–4, local manufacture had ceased and the accumulated stocks had become exhausted. The dampness of the climate and the large amount of fresh water discharged into the Bay of Bengal by the Ganges and the Brahmaputra tell against efficient salt manufacture on the Bengal coast; but the manufacture of salt was not finally abandoned in Orissa until 1898. Nearly half the salt imported into Bengal comes from Liverpool, and the rest principally from Germany, Aden, Maskat, Jedda, Bombay, and Madras. Since the construction of the railway along the east coast, Madras salt transported by land has begun to compete successfully with the imported commodity. Beyond the Indus the Kohāt mines are the exclusive source of supply, and Kohāt salt is used also in Afghānistān and by the frontier tribes. The cis-Indus Punjab is mainly supplied by the Salt Range mines, but in the south-east of the Province salt from the Rājputāna sources is also used. In the United Provinces, Punjab rock-salt and Rājputāna salt compete, and Barāgara salt is also consumed. Rājputāna is supplied mainly from local sources, but also imports Barāgara salt. In Bombay, Barāgara salt is used north of the Narbadā, while Bombay sea-salt supplies the rest of the Presidency and the Western Madras Districts. The numerous east coast factories supply the rest of Madras.
In 1902 nearly half of the salt produced was manufactured under direct Government agency, and the rest by licensees under various excise systems. The principal northern sources, except the Kohāt mines, are worked by Government. In Bombay, Barāgara salt is manufactured by the Government, and sea-salt, as a rule, by private persons. In Madras the two systems exist side by side, 22 out of 67 factories belonging to the Government. The excise system was introduced throughout the greater part of this Province between 1882 and 1886, a few Government factories being maintained to prevent private manufacturers from combining to raise prices ; but since 1895 it has been found expedient to revert in part to the Government monopoly system. In Government factories all over India the usual practice is to pay the workers at a fixed price for their produce, the amount of which is estimated at the time of storage. Under the excise systems there is no interference with manufacture and sale beyond such as is necessary to secure payment of the duty. In both Government and excise factories careful systems of guard, storage, weighment, and issue have been introduced and developed.
Preventive establishments are maintained to guard against illicit traffic in salt removed from natural deposits, or manufactured from salt earth in saline tracts. Supervision is also exercised over the manufacture of saltpetre, and sulphate and carbonate of soda, in Northern India, Bihār, and Calcutta ; and the edible salt educed in the refinement of saltpetre is, if excised, taxed at the general rate. There are special provisions against smuggling from French and Portuguese possessions, and arrangements for the protection of the revenue have been made with Native States. The transport of salt by sea from one Indian port to another is subject to control.
All manufacturing and preventive operations in Upper India are controlled by the Northern India Salt department, which is under the direct administration of the Government of India in the Finance Department. The Governments of Madras and Bombay administer the salt revenue within those Provinces, while a preventive establishment for the salt tracts of Orissa and the Bengal littoral is attached to the Bengal Excise department.
Under native administration salt was taxed, in different parts of the country, in varying circumstances and at widely different rates. Along with salt duties, the British administration inherited an immense number of transit duties, levied at intervals along the trade routes under a system requiring elaborate customs arrangements and involving an intolerable hindrance to trade and communication. In 1843 the transit duties, with the exception of those on cotton and sugar, were abolished, and the loss of revenue was partly made up by enhancing the Provincial salt duties. The cotton duties were abolished in 1855 while the salt duties were gradually raised, until, in the period from 1869 to 1877, the salt tax in Lower Bengal was Rs. 3–4 a maund, in the Upper Provinces Rs. 3, in the country beyond the Indus a few annas, and in Madras and Bombay Rs. 1–13 a maund. The salt sources of Rājputāna belonged to the Native States in which they were situated, and duty was levied on their produce when it crossed the frontier. These arrangements could be maintained only by stringent preventive measures. To prevent untaxed Rājputāna salt, and the lightly taxed salt from the south and west, from coming into Northern India, it was necessary to maintain a customs-line extending for nearly 2,500 miles, from Torbela, near Attock on the Indus, to the Sambalpur District of Bengal. The line was guarded by an army of nearly 13,000 officers and men, and consisted, along a large part of its course, of a huge cactus hedge supplemented by stone walls and ditches1. This arrangement naturally hampered trade, and resulted in an undue divergence of the price of salt in different parts of India. In 1870 the Government of India acquired a lease of the Sāmbhar Lake, with a view to increase and cheapen the supply in the United Provinces; and in 1874 more than 760 miles of the eastern portion of the line were abandoned, the trade in this direction having concentrated itself on the railway route. The necessity of changing the whole system was at the same time indicated by Lord Northbrook, and a few years later Lord Lytton's Government was able to acquire the remaining salt sources of Rājputāna and to equalize the duties throughout the greater part of India. Treaties were made with the Native States concerned, and in 1878 the Bengal duty was lowered to Rs. 2-14 a maund and the duty in Northern India to Rs. 2-8. At the same time the duty in Madras and Bombay was raised from Rs. 1-13 to Rs. 2-8 a maund. The whole customs-line was abandoned in 1879, with the exception of a portion along the Indus, maintained to prevent the still lightly-taxed Kohāt salt from being smuggled across the river. In March, 1882, financial conditions being prosperous, the general rate of duty was lowered to Rs. 2 a maund. In 1888 financial difficulties made it necessary to re-establish the Rs. 2-8 rate, which was maintained up to 1903, when prosperity permitted a reversion to Rs. 2, further reduced in 1905 to Rs. 1-8. The rate on Kohāt salt was raised to Rs. 2 per Lahori maund2 in 1896; and, efficient arrangements having been devised to prevent the cheaper salt from being introduced into cis-Indus territory, the last remnant of the old customs-line disappeared. Burma, where salt pays duty at R. 1 a maund3, is the only other part of India which does not now conform to the prevailing rate. The change carried out by Lord Lytton's Government was as successful in its financial as in its administrative aspect. While the duty was raised for 58 million people, it was reduced throughout the greater part of India, to the relief of 148 millions. In the three years preceding 1877-8 the average annual consumption was 24·2 million maunds, and the average net revenue 5·8 crores. By 1879–80 the consumption had risen to 27·9 million maunds, and the net revenue to 6·9 crores.
The figures for 1871 to 1903 given at the end of this chapter show the development of the salt revenue. The average consumption per head has increased steadily from 3·6 to 5 seers : this increasing rate, acting on a growing population and over an extended territory, has given a rise of total consumption from about 23 to 37 million maunds. During the same period the incidence of duty per head of the population has increased from 3·6 to 4·9 annas, or at a slightly lower rate than the increase of consumption. At the same time the retail price has fallen throughout the greater part of India, and is now being still further lowered by the recent reductions of taxation1. Most noteworthy of all is the increase in the facilities for bringing salt to the consumer which have been secured during the last thirty years by the abolition of the customs-line and by the development of rail and road communications. At the present day, for example, a trader of the United Provinces wishing to obtain Sāmbhar salt has merely to deposit his money at the nearest treasury, sub-treasury, or appointed railway station or post office, in order to receive his consignment without delay or trouble at any railway station he may choose to name. In Madras the trade in salt is facilitated by a credit system, under which a merchant on depositing securities (with a slight margin for fluctuation of price) receives a six months' credit for payment of duty on which he can draw from time to time. A similar system, but with a shorter credit period, obtains in Bombay.
Excise
The Excise revenue in British India is derived from the manufacture and sale of intoxicating liquors, hemp drugs, and opium, all of them commodities whose use must, in the interest of the people, be restrained within reasonable limits. There is no excise on tobacco, which is largely grown and consumed, nor on betel (pān-supārī), which is used everywhere by all classes of the population. The expediency of imposing a tax on tobacco has been considered on more than one occasion ; but the idea has been abandoned, partly because it would be difficult to maintain an efficient excise supervision over the widely scattered cultivation of the plant, but chiefly because the duty would fall mainly on the classes who are most affected already by the salt tax. The revenue under each head of excise has risen steadily with the increasing prosperity of the lower classes, and the improvement of the excise administration. Its progress is illustrated in the third table at the end of this chapter. The total net revenue from all sources increased from about 1⅙ crores in 1860–1 to 7⅗ crores in 1904–5. The excise on opium has been described in the section of this chapter dealing with opium generally; the present section is concerned with intoxicating liquors and hemp drugs.
The Excise department is in most Provinces under the control of a Commissioner who, in some cases, administers also other sources of revenue, such as salt. The Collector is the head of the excise administration in his District. In Madras the Collector is mainly concerned with arrangements for retail sale, distilleries and the preventive establishment being under direct departmental control. In other Provinces preventive arrangements are largely in the hands of the ordinary police.
Intoxicating Liquors
On the subject of excise before the days of British rule our information is scanty. But there is enough to prove that the habit of drinking, and even of excessive drinking, was not unknown, and that the native rulers realized revenue therefrom. Dr. Rājendralāla Mitra, in a paper contributed to the Bengal Asiatic Society's Journal1, showed by many citations from Sanskrit literature, ancient and mediaeval, that spirits and other intoxicating drinks have been extensively used in India at all times and by all classes. While admitting that their use had been condemned by moralists and lawgivers, he proved that rice-spirit was sold and drunk, and used in sacrifices, in the earliest Vedic times; that the leading characters of the Mahābhārata were addicted to strong drink; that the Rāmāyana frequently notices spirit-drinking with evident approbation; that in the time of Kālidāsa drinking seems to have been very common not only among men, but even among women of high rank; that the Purānas abound in descriptions of spirits and of drinking; and that the Tantras afford indubitable proofs of a strong attachment on the part of a large section of the Hindus to over-indulgence in spirituous drinks. There are many references to the use of spirits in Buddhist works, and it was stringently prohibited in the scriptures of that faith. The Korān, too, prohibits drinking, and the prohibition is heeded to the present day by the orthodox followers of the Prophet. But there is abundant evidence to show that, under the Mughals, the drinking of spirituous liquors was commonly practised even in the capital of the emperors, and that excise (under the name of ābkārī) was a common source of revenue to the Muhammadan rulers of India, though their system was of a very rough description. The limitations imposed on the manufacture and sale of liquor, when occasional and limited attempts at total prohibition in a few places had proved unsuccessful, were devised with the sole object of raising revenue and without any design of regulating or controlling consumption. The system in general force was one of farming, the right of manufacture and sale being given to the highest bidder.
The British administration inherited this farming system, but soon began to modify it. Some account will shortly be given of the progress of reform: the general policy has been so to adjust rates and methods as to check the practice of excessive drinking, and at the same time to safeguard the revenue, without encouraging illicit manufacture and traffic by enforcing unduly harsh rules. In other words, the aim has been to secure the maximum of revenue with the minimum of consumption. Whereas in the United Kingdom the proportion of liquor-shops in 1901 was one to about 240 of the population, the proportion in India was only one to 2,400.
The following are the forms of intoxicating liquor chiefly consumed in India: country spirit; fermented palm juice; beer made from grain; country brands of rum, brandy, &c.; locally manufactured malt beer; and imported wine, beer, and spirits. The first three are made for native consumption; the last three are mainly, but by no means exclusively, used by Europeans and Eurasians. The amount of excise revenue derived from each source in the year 1902–3 was approximately as follows, in lakhs of rupees: country spirit, 325; palm juice, 111; grain beer, 17; country rum, &c., 12; malt beer, 4; foreign liquor, 181. The figures are not, however, strictly accurate, because the system of record in different Provinces does not admit of a uniform distinction being drawn between the different items.
Country spirit is the main source of revenue, except in the Madras Presidency, and yields (including Punjab country rum) about two-thirds of the total receipts from liquors. It is usually prepared by distillation from the mahuā flower (Bassia latifolia), molasses, and other forms of unrefined sugar, fermented palm juice, and rice—the last mainly in Bengal, Assam, and Burma. Country spirit is prepared by native methods in Bengal, Assam, the United Provinces, the Central Provinces, Sind, the Frontier Province, and Baluchistān. The ingredients are generally fermented in pots and then distilled in rudely constructed stills. The system is very crude, and the product is apt to contain a considerable percentage of fusel oils. In Madras, Bombay, the Punjab, and Burma manufacture of country spirit or of local brands of rum, whisky, &c., is, as a rule, carried on in highly organized private distilleries with European appliances.
It has been stated above that the British system of excise grew out of the uncontrolled farming system inherited from the native administration. The first step was the limitation of the number of shops in the area farmed, and the next the establishment of the out-still system, under which only the right to manufacture and sell at a specified shop is granted. The chief objection to both the farming and the out-still systems is that there is no control over the rate of duty per gallon, and it may consequently be to the interest of the farmer or licensee to lower prices and thus encourage the practice of drinking. It therefore became necessary to consider whether a system could not be established under which each gallon of spirit should pay a fixed duty. In some places this was done roughly and imperfectly by limiting the capacity of the out-still. If the still can only produce a certain number of gallons of spirit in the month, and must pay a certain tax monthly, each gallon of spirit must bear a proportionate rate of taxation and cannot be sold below a certain price. The practical difficulty in the way of securing this result is the facility which the licensee possesses for using a still other than that which has been licensed. A far more perfect system is that of the central distillery, in which manufacture and storage are under Government supervision and the liquor pays a still-head duty before issue. Unfortunately the practical experience of years, and the results of many experiments, have shown that it is impossible to enforce this system in all parts of India. In remote and sparsely populated tracts supply by the central distillery system is costly, and illicit manufacture and smuggling are so difficult to discover and suppress that it is practically impossible to put them down in the face of the strong temptation afforded by the high-priced licit liquor. The Provincial Governments have dealt with the subject in different ways suited to the peculiarities of local conditions; and the key to the numerous and complicated systems of excise which prevail in different parts of British India lies in the fact that they are attempts to combine the farming and fixed duty systems, with the object of securing that every gallon of spirit shall bear a certain amount of taxation in places where it is not possible to work with the fixed duty system in its simplest form. That system is steadily gaining ground, and its operation is greatly facilitated wherever large distilleries are started on the European method. Some form of central distillery system now prevails over the greater part of British India, while the out-still method is still in force throughout Assam1, over a considerable part of Bengal and the Central Provinces, and in smaller tracts in some other Provinces. It is also used in parts of Burma under stringent restrictions. Measures are now (1906) being taken to improve the quality of the liquor supplied, especially in out-still areas.
Under the out-still system the right to manufacture and sell country spirit at a particular place is, as a rule, sold annually by auction. In some parts of the United Provinces the right is farmed by areas. In Bengal and Burma the licence fixes the capacity of the still.
In Bengal, and in the United and Central Provinces, the central distilleries belong to the Government, but the distillers who use them work their own stills. In these Provinces, and in the Punjab, the right of retail vend is sold separately. The number and position of the shops is fixed by the Collector, and single shops, or sale-rights in a defined area, are sold (as a rule annually) by auction. The system of annual auction sale has these great advantages, that it prevents the growth of vested interests, which might hamper the Government in introducing improvements and reforms, and at the same time affords valuable evidence as to the sufficiency or otherwise of the rate of still-head duty. The general policy is to concentrate manufacture in a few large distilleries, and to facilitate supply by the issue of wholesale licences and the encouragement of bonded warehouses. In Madras the monopoly of manufacture and supply throughout a particular area is disposed of by tender. The manufacturer pays a fixed rate of duty on every gallon of liquor issued from his distillery, and supplies retail vendors at fixed prices. The right of retail vend is disposed of annually by auction, usually by single shops. Throughout the greater part of the Bombay Presidency the monopoly of both manufacture and sale is leased, for given areas, to contractors, who pay a fixed duty on issuing liquor for sale at their shops. The contract is not offered to competition, but the monopolist is selected at the discretion of the Excise Commissioner and the Local Government. He is required to guarantee a minimum return to the Government : in other words, he must pay duty on a certain quantity of liquor whether he sells that quantity or not. The object of this condition is to prevent the contractor from distilling illicitly outside the central distillery, or from entering into collusion with the preventive establishment to pass liquor out of the distillery without payment of duty. Endeavour is made to fix the amount of liquor on which duty is guaranteed at about the quantity for which there is a normal demand; if this is successfully done the risk of illicit practices is in a large measure removed.
The average incidence of taxation per proof gallon of distillery spirit amounted in 1902–3 to Rs. 4–6–8, of which Rs. 3–4–6 was derived from still-head duty and Rs. 1–2–2 from vend fees. Among the major Provinces the average rate was highest in the Punjab (Rs. 6–1–0) and in Burma (Rs. 6 plus vend fees), and lowest in the Central Provinces (Rs. 3–8–4). The average consumption per thousand of the population in distillery areas varied from 14 gallons in the Punjab and 10 (roughly) in Burma, to 127 gallons in the Bombay Presidency proper.
The sap of the date, palmyra, and coco-nut palms (called tāri, corrupted into toddy in Southern India) is used as a drink either fresh or after fermentation. The total excise revenue derived from this source in 1902–3 amounted to more than a crore of rupees, of which about 72 per cent. was derived from Madras, 12 per cent. from Bombay, 10 per cent. from Bengal, and 5 per cent. from Burma. In Madras and Bombay the revenue is obtained from a fixed fee on every tree from which it is intended to draw the liquor, thus amounting to a rough duty, and from the sale of the right of retail vend. In Bengal and Burma the sale of shop licences is the sole form of taxation. Retail rights are sold by auction, either for single shops or for defined areas. Fresh sap is taxed in Bombay and Bengal, but not in Madras or Burma.
The revenue derived from rice and millet beer amounted in 1902–3 to about 6 lakhs in Bengal and 11 lakhs in Burma; elsewhere it is inconsiderable. In Bengal pachwai brewed from rice or millet is consumed by aboriginal tribes, and by the lower orders in general, in certain Districts. It is valued both as a stimulant and as food. The bulk of the revenue which it yields is derived from licences for manufacture and retail sale, which are put up to annual auction, the number and sites of the shops having been previously fixed. Licences for the home brewing of pachwai for domestic purposes are granted in certain Districts to the headmen of villages inhabited by aboriginal races, on payment of a fixed fee for each household. In Burma the native beer is brewed from rice. When consumed by certain hill tribes, mostly in Upper Burma, it is exempted from taxation, otherwise the excise system is similar to that in Bengal. It is almost as easy to brew this beer as to make a pot of tea; and, as the main ingredient is a staple article of food, it is almost impossible to check private manufacture.
Country brands of rum, and so-called brandies and whiskies, are distilled from cane juice, &c., and are coloured and flavoured in various manners. The manufacture is carried on in private distilleries in different parts of India. In the United Provinces and the Punjab such liquor pays duty at the rate of Rs. 4 per proof gallon, in the Central Provinces at Rs. 5, and elsewhere at the customs tariff rate of Rs. 6. The production is subject to such Government supervision as is needed to ensure the payment of the duty. The most important factory is the Rosa distillery at Shāhjahānpur, in the United Provinces, which, in addition to supplying those Provinces, exports considerable quantities to the Punjab, the Central Provinces, Bengal, and other parts of India. In Madras and Bombay, and in the United and Central Provinces, country rum is sold under the same conditions as imported European liquor. In Bengal it may be sold in shops licensed for either country or foreign liquor, and in the Punjab it is treated in the same manner as ordinary country spirit elsewhere. A considerable quantity is supplied to the Commissariat department for the use of the army. Formerly this was issued free of duty, but in 1897 the Government decided that the selling price to troops should be gradually raised until it covered the ordinary duty rate. The enhancement hitherto reached is equivalent to a duty of Rs. 2 per proof gallon.
A number of breweries have been established in India, mostly in the hills, for the manufacture of a light beer for European and Eurasian consumption. Owing to local demand by soldiers, the amount of beer thus produced is greater than that imported. A uniform fee of one anna per gallon is levied all over India at the time of issue. Retail sale is usually under a general licence for imported liquors, but in some Provinces additional special arrangements are made.
Foreign liquor is subject to import duty at the tariff rates, the most important of which are Rs. 61 per proof gallon on spirit and 1 anna per gallon on beer, and can only be sold under licence. The import duty, which produced 76 lakhs in 1902–3, is credited to ‘Customs,’ and the sale licence fees to ‘Excise.’ Licence fees are of three main kinds: wholesale, retail, and special. The last class includes licences for hotels, rest-houses, restaurants, bars, places of amusement, railway refreshment rooms, trains, and steamers. Licences are generally granted at fixed rates, but in certain Provinces (Madras, Bengal, Burma, and the Punjab) some of them are sold by auction.
Hemp Drugs
The narcotic products of the hemp plant (Cannabis sativa or indica) consumed in India fall under three main categories which may, generally speaking, be defined as follows: Gānja consists of the dried flowering tops of the cultivated female hemp plant which have become coated with resin in consequence of being unable to set seeds freely; charas is the name applied to the resinous matter which forms the active principle when collected separately; bhang is the name given to the dried leaves of the hemp plant, whether male or female, cultivated or uncultivated. The plant grows wild in many parts of India, especially in the sub-montane tracts of the Himālayas.
The use of hemp drugs appears to have been practised in India from time immemorial, and enters into the religious and social observances of the Hindus. The hemp plant is popularly believed to have been a great favourite of the god Siva, and on almost all occasions on which his worship is practised gānja is offered to the god and consumed by certain classes of the worshippers. Until recent years little was known in regard to the consumption of hemp drugs for non-medicinal purposes, and their production was subject to definite control and quantitative duties in only a few Provinces. In 1893 a Commission was appointed to inquire into the production of hemp drugs, the effect of their consumption upon the social and moral condition of the people, and the desirability of prohibiting the growth of the plant and the sale of the narcotics. The inquiries of the Commission showed that bhang is, almost without exception, harmless when used in moderation, and that its abuse is not so hurtful as intemperate indulgence in alcohol. The excessive use of gānja and charas is more injurious, but as a rule they are used in moderation and without appreciable injury. The Commission did not advise prohibition, but recommended a policy of control and restriction, and their suggestions have been carried into effect. The main features of the existing system are restricted cultivation under supervision, storage in bonded dépôts, payment of a quantitative duty before issue, retail sale under licence, and restriction on private possession. No attempt is made to extirpate the spontaneous growth of the hemp plant, and no restriction is placed on the use of the wild plants in the green state or on their cultivation for the manufacture of fibre. Endeavour is made to control the use of bhang by prohibition or taxation of cultivation, collection under licence, and transport regulations. The production and consumption of hemp drugs in Burma (except for medicinal purposes) are altogether prohibited, in order to prevent the habit from arising in a Province where it does not at present exist. Gānja forms the principal source of hemp drugs revenue in Bengal, Assam, the Central Provinces, Madras, and Bombay, while the consumption of charas is mainly confined to Northern India. Bhang is consumed in almost all Provinces.
The principal authorized sources of gānja supply are small areas of cultivation in Rājshāhi (Eastern Bengal) and Nimār (Central Provinces). Madras produces its own supply, and Bombay is supplied partly by cultivation within the Presidency and partly by import from Nimār. The duty on Rājshāhi gānja is Rs. 11 a seer in Eastern Bengal and Assam, and also in Bengal (excluding Orissa, where it is Rs. 9 a seer). In the United Provinces the duty at present varies from Rs. 6 to Rs. 9 a seer, according to the description of the drug; but it is intended to levy a uniform rate of Rs. 11. On other sorts of gānja the duty is Rs. 4 a seer; but this rate was raised to Rs. 5 in the Central Provinces, Ajmer-Merwāra, and Baluchistān in April, 1906, and similar enhancements elsewhere are contemplated.
Charas is mainly derived from Central Asia. It enters the Punjab by prescribed routes and is stored in Government bonded warehouses. On issue for consumption in the Punjab and certain Native States, it formerly paid a duty of Rs. 2 a seer, which was raised to Rs. 6 in 1904. The greater part is, however, exported in bond to the United Provinces, where it now pays a duty of Rs. 6, and a smaller quantity to Bengal, where the rate of duty is Rs. 12 a seer.
A duty varying from 8 annas to R. 1 a seer is levied on bhang in Madras, Bombay, Bengal, and the Central Provinces.
In the Punjab, and also now in the United Provinces, there are small import and transport duties and an acreage tax on licensed cultivation. In Assam, where the population is sparse and the wild plant grows freely, the only restriction it has been found possible to impose is a limit on possession without licence.
Licences which cover the retail sale of all forms of hemp drugs are usually sold by auction. In most cases single shops are leased, but sometimes the shops over a defined area are farmed. Distribution is aided by the sale of wholesale vend licences and the establishment of convenient dépôts.
In 1902–3 the average consumption of hemp drugs per 1,000 of the population in the larger Provinces varied from 9 seers in the United Provinces, and 7·5 seers in Bombay, to 2·9 seers in the Central Provinces and 1·2 in Madras. The total receipts from hemp drugs taxation have risen from 11 lakhs in 1860–1 to 66 lakhs in 1902–3. The reforms introduced on the report of the Commission have resulted in an appreciable increase of revenue. The average receipts during the three years ending with 1894–5 were about 46 lakhs; during the three years ending with 1902–3 they rose to about 62 lakhs.
Customs
The general customs duty is 5 per cent. ad valorem on commodities imported into British India by sea. This tax is levied for fiscal purposes, not for the protection of native industries. In certain cases the general tax is superseded by special duties levied for particular reasons. For administrative purposes a tax is imposed on the import of arms and ammunition; the import duties on liquors need no explanation; the import of opium is taxed at a rate which is, and is meant to be, prohibitive; an import duty on salt forms part of the general system of administering the salt tax, and the proceeds are credited in the public accounts to the head ‘Salt’—the same plan has been followed in this chapter. Rice is practically the only commodity on which an export duty is levied. The net customs revenue amounted in 1904–5 to more than 6 crores, the proceeds of the import duties being nearly four times as great as those of the export tax.
The scope and rates of the import duties have varied from time to time in accordance with financial needs. Before the Mutiny there was a general tax on imports at the present rate of 5 per cent. In view of the unfavourable financial position, the rate was raised in 1859–60 to 10 per cent., and on some important classes of commodities it stood for a time at 20 per cent. In April, 1864, it was lowered to 7½ per cent. Up to 1867 all articles paid duty except such as were specifically exempted; in that year the exemption was extended to a number of minor commodities, and a list was prepared of those remaining liable to duty. In 1875 the whole tariff was revised, the valuation of articles which do not embrace so many varieties as to necessitate the levy of a duty ad valorem was amended, and the general rate of duty was reduced to 5 per cent. In 1876–7 the import duties yielded 1·7 crores, about one-half of which was derived from cotton goods.
About this time the question of abolishing the customs duties began to be discussed. The Government of India desired to give the fullest play to free-trade principles, and the Lancashire cotton manufacturers, finding a serious competitor in the growing Indian industry, were pressing for the removal of the artificial advantage given to the latter by the 5 per cent. duty. Owing in great measure to the nature of the local fibre, Indian cotton manufactures are confined mainly to the production of coarse goods. In 1878 the first step was taken by the repeal of the duty on cotton goods containing yarns not finer than 30's1 if similar in character to goods already manufactured in India. It was then laid down that no duty should exist which affords protection to native industry; that the raw material of industry, and articles contributing to production, should be exempt from taxation; and that duty should be levied only on articles which yield a revenue of sufficient importance to justify the interference with trade involved by the machinery of collection. In conformity with these principles, railway material was exempted from duty and twenty-six minor heads were removed from the list. As regards cotton goods, there was little essential difference between the cloth which had been exempted and large classes of cloth having different designations which remained subject to duty, and the change in the tariff did not therefore produce much result. In the following year (1879) a further step was taken, and all cotton goods containing yarn not finer than 30's were exempted, at an estimated loss of 20 lakhs. These exemptions foreshadowed the total abolition of the customs duties as soon as the Government could afford to adopt the measure. The production and consumption of non-dutiable classes of cotton goods were stimulated at the expense of those still paying duty, and, as regards other commodities, it became a question whether it would be worth while to keep up the customs arrangements when the principal source of revenue had been exempted. In 1882 the prosperous condition of the finances enabled the Government to abolish the rest of the cotton duties and the whole of the remaining general import duties. Until 1894 no further import duties were imposed, with the exception of a duty of half an anna per gallon on petroleum, first levied in 1888.
In 1894 the heavy burden thrown on the Government of India by the fall in exchange made it necessary to consider how it could increase its resources. Lord Herschell's Committee, reporting in May, 1893, on the currency question, had expressed the opinion that, of all the suggested methods of adding to the revenue, the reimposition of the import duties would excite the least opposition. In framing the budget for 1894–5, the Government of India found that, after making all possible reductions in expenditure, it had to face a deficit of 168 lakhs. It was accordingly determined to double the tax on petroleum and to reimpose a general duty of 5 per cent. on imports. These two sources were estimated to yield an additional revenue of 120 lakhs. Cotton yarns and fabrics were, however, excluded from the list of dutiable articles, and this exemption gave rise to great opposition in India. The Secretary of State, under whose orders it had been made, agreed to receive a further representation on the subject if, after a sufficient interval, the financial position was found not to have improved. By December, 1894, it had so far deteriorated that a further addition to the revenues of at least a crore of rupees was needed to restore equilibrium. It was then decided to reimpose the cotton duties, combined with an excise duty in India which would deprive the tax of any protective character. Cotton yarns and manufactures were made dutiable at the general rate of 5 per cent., and an excise duty at the same rate was imposed on all cotton yarns of 20's produced in mills in British India. The excise duty was confined to cotton produced in mills, as it would have been difficult and inexpedient to tax the hand-loom industry which is carried on in villages all over the country. The Lancashire manufacturers represented, however, that these arrangements had not made the duty non-protective. A certain quantity of yarns of counts not exceeding 20's, and of fabrics woven from such yarns, were exported to India; and in the case of woven goods made from excisable counts of yarn the Indian mills paid only on the yarn value of the goods, whereas imported articles were charged on the value as completed. To meet these objections, cotton twist and yarns of all kinds were exempted from customs and excise duty in February, 1896, and a duty at the rate of 3½ per cent. was imposed on woven goods of all counts, whether imported or manufactured in Indian mills. This change involved some loss of revenue. In 1895–6 the customs duties on cotton yielded 116 lakhs, and in the five succeeding years an average of only 87 lakhs (95 lakhs in 1902–3). The excise duty on cotton goods amounted to 6 lakhs in 1895–6, and to 18 lakhs in 1902–3. There has been a satisfactory growth of both manufacture and trade, notwithstanding that the former has been hampered by the continued prevalence of plague in Bombay, the chief seat of the industry.
The general tariff introduced in 1894 was based on that of 1875, subject to some alterations and to a revision of the valuations. The Government did not consider it expedient to exempt minor articles, as was done in 1878. The payment of duty is only one item in the formalities that attend the process of importation, and the shipping documents relating to goods have to follow the course of a fixed routine. The additional work caused by customs assessment is, therefore, less than would at first sight appear. The most important exemptions from the general duty are food-grains, machinery, railway material, and coal, while most classes of iron and steel are taxed at the low rate of 1 per cent.
With effect from March, 1899, a countervailing duty was imposed on bounty-fed beet sugar from foreign countries. A rapid and large increase of such importations, especially from Germany and Austria, was believed to be seriously affecting the Indian sugar industry. The duty was framed with the intention of countervailing bounties paid, directly or indirectly, by foreign Governments; but though it produced an appreciable revenue, amounting in 1901–2 to 37 lakhs, it did not stop the influx of cheap European sugar. The manufacturers in the chief beet-growing countries of Europe obtained such high prices in their home markets, owing to the operation of protective duties and rebates on export, that they were able to sell their surplus stocks at prices considerably below the cost of production. Further duties were therefore imposed, in 1902–3, on sugar imported from countries which, by their protective system, rendered possible the formation of trade combinations to manipulate the price of sugar. The immediate result of these duties was to diminish sugar imports from Europe, and to divert the trade previously carried on with India by Germany and Austria to other countries which did not come within the scope of the new legislation. The imports of beet sugar in 1902–3 fell to about half what they had been in 1901–2, while the imports of cane sugar, which comes mostly from Mauritius, Java, and China, increased by more than 40 per cent.
In December, 1903, orders were issued remitting the countervailing duties chargeable on sugar produced, after August of that year, in countries which have limited their direct or indirect bounties on sugar, and their protective duties, to the minimum permitted by the Brussels Convention of 1902.
Table IV at the end of this chapter shows the amount of revenue derived from the principal imports. Cotton piece goods now yield more than one-fifth of the whole, and next in order come liquors, metals, general manufactured articles, petroleum, and sugar.
In 1892–3, before the reintroduction of the general duty, the total revenue from import duties was 82 lakhs. In 1894–5, after the reimposition, it was 282 lakhs; in the following year, with the addition of cotton duties, it rose to 388 lakhs; in 1896–7, with the altered cotton arrangements, it fell to 347 lakhs; and in 1902–3 it had again risen to 426 lakhs.
Until 1860 the bulk of the export trade was taxed, and in that year the general rate was 3 per cent. ad valorem. Between 1860 and 1867 many articles were exempted; and in 1874 the list comprised only cotton goods, grain, hides, indigo, lac, oils, seeds, and spices. In 1875 it was still further reduced to oil, rice, indigo, and lac. In thus limiting the tariff regard was given to the principle that an export duty may do serious injury to trade by fostering foreign competition. In 1880 the duty on lac and indigo was remitted, and from that date rice has been practically the sole source of export revenue1. It is taxed at three annas a maund (3d. per 82 lb.), and the collections vary according to the out-turn of the Indian harvest, with a tendency to increase. The export is mainly from Burma.
Assessed Taxes
The present income-tax was introduced in 1886, and yielded in 1902–3 a net revenue of 207 lakhs, reduced to 186 lakhs in 1904–5 by the exemption of small incomes. Taxes of a similar nature have been levied from time to time, and the amount derived from them has varied according to the particular regulation in force.
Direct taxation was well-known to the native governments which formerly ruled in India. The imposts varied in name and conditions, but depended in general on an intimate acquaintance with the circumstances of the non-agricultural families who paid the tax. These direct taxes were, as a rule, relinquished by the British administration, with a host of miscellaneous octroi and transit duties, at the time when the salt tax was raised (1843). Among the few old taxes retained was the pandhārī tax in the Central Provinces, which was finally abolished in 1902–3. This impost was a form of house tax, levied by the Marāthās from petty artisans and shopkeepers and non-agriculturists. It was collected with the land revenue until 1860–1, when it was converted into a tax at fixed rates on small non-agricultural incomes, supplementary to the general income tax.
Apart from such local taxes, the first general income tax was levied in 1860, to relieve the financial difficulties which beset the country after the Mutiny. An Act was introduced in that year, on the English model, to have effect for a period of five years. The tax was levied on all incomes exceeding Rs. 200 per annum arising from property, professions, trades, and offices, and included incomes derived from land. The rate was 2 per cent. on incomes between Rs. 200 and 500, and 3 per cent. on larger incomes, with an additional 1 per cent. to be used for local public works. In 1862 the minimum taxable income was raised to Rs. 500, and in 1863 the rate was reduced to 3 per cent. The tax produced on an average 154 lakhs a year.
As intended, this Act ceased to operate in 1865, but the financial position would not permit of direct taxation being abandoned. In 1867 an Act was passed imposing a licence tax on professions and trades. The tax was non-agricultural, but extended to all persons exercising a profession or trade whose income or profits were not less than Rs. 200 per annum. The assessees were divided into classes, paying at fixed rates amounting to 2 per cent. on the minimum income of each class. The total collection yielded 65 lakhs. The time was one of great financial embarrassment, the ordinary expenditure exceeding the ordinary income in several successive years. The area of taxation, and the rate, were accordingly varied from year to year to meet the exigencies of the moment. In 1868–9 some relief was given under a new ‘Certificate Act’ by which the minimum assessable income was raised to Rs. 500, and the fixed rates were reduced to 1 3/5 per cent. on the minimum income of each class. The tax then produced about 51 lakhs. In 1869 a considerable deficit was anticipated, and the ‘certificate’ tax was therefore converted into a general income tax, including agriculturists in its scope. The limit of assessable income was not changed, and the fixed rates amounted originally to a little over 1 per cent. of the minimum income in each class. In order to increase the proceeds the assessment was made more rigorous than before. Later in the same year the financial outlook became worse, and the assessment was generally raised by 50 per cent. It yielded a total of 111 lakhs, the number of private assessees being about 521,000. In 1870, when a still greater excess of expenditure over income was anticipated, the fixed rates were raised to about 3 1/8 per cent. on the minimum of each class up to Rs. 2,000, an exact 3 1/8 per cent. being levied on incomes above that limit. But by reaction from the too rigorous assessment of the previous year the number of assessees fell to 386,000, and the tax at the enhanced rate produced only 207 lakhs. In 1871–2 the minimum taxable income was raised to Rs. 750, and a general rate of 2 pies in the rupee, or a little over 1 per cent., was levied, the fixed rates on incomes below Rs. 2,000 being abandoned. Under these conditions the tax yielded 82 lakhs. In the following year the taxable limit was raised to Rs. 1,000, other incidents remaining as before, and the total collections fell in consequence to 58 lakhs. At the end of 1872–3 the financial position was so greatly improved that the Government was able to announce that the tax would not be renewed. The experiment had been unfortunate and was the cause of considerable discontent. The people could not readily understand the unfamiliar and somewhat complicated arrangements of a European income tax, and some oppression and extortion were practised by the temporarily engaged assessors and collectors. The constant variation of rates to suit the financial condition of the moment was, moreover, unsuitable to the conditions prevailing in India.
No further direct taxation was imposed until it was decided, in 1877, to levy a licence tax on traders and artisans to meet a portion of the annual expenditure to be incurred as insurance against famine. In 1878 the Government of India passed an Act for this purpose for the United Provinces and the Punjab, and the Local Governments adopted similar Acts for Bengal, Madras, and Bombay. Certain modifications were made in 1880, after which the general position was as follows. The tax extended to all incomes derived from non-agricultural trades and dealings; but professions, including Government service, were not taxed. Under the Acts of 1878 the minimum limit of taxable income was in general Rs. 100 or Rs. 200 per annum. This was found to be too low, and in 1880 a general limit of Rs. 500 was imposed. The assessees were divided into classes paying fixed rates, the system of classification varying in different Provinces, but subject to the proviso that the tax should never exceed 2 per cent. on income. The minimum tax was thus in all cases Rs. 10; the maximum was fixed at Rs. 500 everywhere except in Bombay, where it was Rs. 200. These arrangements remained in force until 1886. The administration was better and more regular than under the Acts of 1860 to 1873, and the people became accustomed to the tax. The financial results were not unsuccessful. In 1878-9 the total collection amounted to 90 lakhs; the changes made subsequently lessened the proceeds, which varied between 50 and 52 lakhs during the years 1882-3 to 1885-6. The system was, however, marred by considerable defects. The want of uniformity in classification and rates was not justifiable, the exclusion of the official and professional classes gave rise to accusations of partiality, and the low maximum caused the tax, especially in Bombay, to press with undue severity on the poorer classes.
Various suggestions for reform were discussed; but the Government, warned by previous experience, was reluctant to meddle with a system that was working reasonably well, and no action was taken until a falling exchange and increased military expenditure made it necessary to have recourse to fresh taxation in 1886-7. The licence tax was then converted into a general income tax by an Act applying to all India, which still remains in force. All sources of non-agricultural income were taxed. They were divided into (1) salaries and pensions, (2) profits of companies, (3) interest on securities, and (4) other sources. A general rate of 5 pies in the rupee (a little more than 2½ per cent.) was levied on all incomes over Rs. 2,000 per annum; incomes between Rs. 500 and 2,000 derived from salaries and interest on securities were taxed at the rate of 4 pies (a little over 2 per cent.), and similar incomes derived from other sources at fixed rates according to classes. There were six of these classes: for the three lowest the fixed rate was equal to 2 per cent. on the minimum income of the class, and for the others it was slightly in excess of 2 per cent. of the maximum. Incomes below Rs. 500 were not assessed, with the result that the tax is collected from a very small proportion of the community. Incomes derived from land and agriculture were exempted, because of the corresponding burdens placed on them under the system of taxation for famine purposes imposed in 1877–8; but the discretion of the Government to tax incomes derived from land in the future has been left unfettered. Charities and religious endowments, and soldiers whose pay is less than Rs. 500 a month, are free from the tax, and there are some other minor exemptions. On the whole the Act has worked well and smoothly, the assessment being made outside the Presidency towns by the ordinary District staff, sometimes reinforced, as in the United Provinces, by unofficial assessors; and the evils of the earlier system have been avoided, while due facilities are allowed for appeal.
In 1903 the favourable condition of the finances permitted the exemption from the tax of incomes between Rs. 500 and Rs. 1,000 per annum, a measure which is calculated to free about 315,000 persons formerly assessed, out of a total number of about half a million. The loss of revenue sustained through this measure in 1903–4 was about 29 lakhs, or approximately one-seventh of the previous yield of the tax.
The progress of the tax between 1886–7 and 1902–3 is shown in the table at the end of the chapter. The receipts have risen steadily from year to year, the total increase being nearly 60 per cent., while the number of assessees has increased by 32 per cent. Of the four classes of income, salaries and pensions (mostly of Government servants) yielded in 1900–1 nearly 30 per cent. of the whole; profits of companies nearly 7 per cent.; interest on securities about 5 per cent.; and ‘other sources’ nearly 59 per cent. There have been but trifling variations in these proportions since the Act came into operation. Cotton-spinning, railway and banking companies, are the main sources of receipt under the second head. Under ‘other sources’ the principal classes are money lenders and changers (29 per cent.), general merchants (8 per cent.), grain merchants (6 per cent.), piece goods merchants, house-owners, and legal practitioners (each about 5 per cent.), and bankers (about 4½ per cent.). Prior to the recent exemption of incomes between Rs. 500 and Rs. 1,000, more than 84 per cent. of the assessees were in classes with incomes of less than Rs. 2,000, but these classes returned less than 35 per cent. of the total collections. The total of the incomes on which the tax was paid amounted in 1900–1 to about 78 crores. In Bombay every 209 persons produce one with a non-agricultural income of not less than Rs. 500; in Madras the figure is 417; in the Punjab 444; in Bengal, 580; in the United Provinces, 637; in Assam, 681; and in the Central Provinces, 1,077. Taking the average incidence of taxation on the assessees, Bombay is again first with Rs. 44 per head; then come Bengal (Rs. 41), the Central Provinces (Rs. 39), Assam (Rs. 35), the United Provinces (Rs. 34), Madras (Rs. 30), and the Punjab (Rs. 29). About 47 per cent. of the Bombay, more than 43 per cent. of the Bengal, and about 20 per cent. of the Madras collections are derived from the Presidency towns.
The difference between the commercial wealth of the United Kingdom and of India is forcibly brought out by the fact that in the former country every 1d. per £ of income tax produces about £2½ millions, while the gross collections of what is practically a 6d. income tax in India yielded, before the recent remission of taxation, only about £1,400,000. It must be remembered, of course, that the assets of India are mainly agricultural, and that agricultural profits are exempt from the tax.
In Burma local taxes inherited from the native administration take, in great measure, the place of the income tax, which is confined to Government servants and railway employés, the whole of Lower Burma1, and the town of Mandalay in Upper Burma. In 1900–1 Rangoon yielded 46 per cent. of the total Burma collections. Lower Burma has a special capitation tax which is, in general, paid by males between the ages of 18 and 60, at the rate of Rs. 5 for married men and Rs. 2½ for bachelors and widowers. It is not leviable on any person paying income tax, and it yielded 48 lakhs in 1902–3. In Upper Burma the thathameda is a rough income tax, levied on both agriculturists and non-agriculturists. The amount is usually fixed by lump village assessment, at the rate of about Rs. 10 a household. Hereafter, as the Burma Districts are resettled, the thathameda will be reduced, and superseded by land revenue and an income tax in large centres. The receipts in 1902–3 amounted to 50 lakhs. Both capitation tax and thathameda are credited in the accounts under the head of land revenue2.
Provincial Rates
These rates, which exclude municipal taxes, are levied chiefly for the construction and repair of roads, the up-keep of schools and dispensaries, village sanitation, and other local expenditure. They are generally assessed on the annual 'assets' or rent value of land, which is calculated variously in different Provinces, according to the nature of the prevailing system of land tenure. In 1904–5 the net receipts amounted to 418 lakhs, of which nearly half was administered by local boards.
Acts authorizing the levy of local cesses on the land rental were first passed in Bombay and Madras between 1865 and 1869. This principle was extended in pursuance of Lord Mayo's scheme of financial decentralization. In 1871 Acts were passed levying a similar cess in Bengal, the United Provinces, and the Punjab. In the Punjab and Oudh cesses for roads, schools, and the District post, assessed at the time of the land revenue settlement, were continued side by side with the new general cess. Similar settlement cesses were levied in the Central Provinces, in Burma (from 1865), and in Assam (from 1874). The total Provincial rates, consisting for the main part of the general land cess, amounted to 184 lakhs net in 1872–3 and to 182 lakhs net in 1876–7.
In 1877–8 further local taxation was imposed in several Provinces, to make up the additional revenue needed to carry out the famine insurance policy of Lord Lytton's Government. In Bengal a public works cess, at a maximum rate of half an anna in the rupee, was established, in addition to the road cess of the same amount previously levied. The existing cesses were raised in the United Provinces, the Punjab, and the Central Provinces; and in Assam a general cess was substituted for the settlement cess. A similar measure had been carried out in Burma in 1876. No addition was made to the rate in Madras and Bombay, as those Provinces were at the time actually suffering from famine. In 1879–80 the total collection from the general land cess amounted to 233 lakhs.
The extension of the system of local self-government carried out by Lord Ripon's Government in 1883–4 affected the control and disposal of the funds; but the new Acts did not in general materially alter the rates at which the cesses were levied, though in some Provinces the general and settlement cesses were combined into a single cess.
In 1905 financial prosperity enabled the Government of India to give substantial assistance to local funds. In the first place, the extra famine cesses imposed in 1877–8 in the United Provinces, the Punjab (including the Districts transferred to the North-West Frontier Province), and the Central Provinces were abolished; and, secondly, grants from Imperial revenues were made to all local boards in India, to an extent approximately equal to one-fourth of their income from the land cess.
At the present time a general cess on the annual value of land is levied throughout British India for local purposes at a rate which is in general equal, or nearly equal, to one anna in the rupee1. The rate actually levied is usually fixed by the Local Government; but in Madras, and in Bengal in so far as the road cess is concerned, it is determined, subject to certain conditions, by the District boards. The arrangements for assessment are somewhat complicated, inasmuch as they vary with different land revenue systems. The main principles are roughly as follows. In ryotwāri areas the annual value of the land is taken to be the revenue payable by the cultivators to the Government. In the zamīndāri tracts of the United Provinces and the Punjab the annual value of the land is calculated at twice the land revenue, this proportion being fixed with reference to the share of the net ‘assets’ or rental paid to the state by the landholders. In permanently settled estates the land revenue bears little relation to the ‘assets,’ and the local rates are therefore assessed on a periodical valuation of the rental, or by a rate per acre. In some Provinces the landlord is entitled to recover a portion of the cess from his tenants. The cess is in general collected with the land revenue, and the cost of collection is deducted before the proceeds, or the assigned portion of them, are made over to the local boards. Nearly four-fifths of the total cost is incurred in Bengal, where it is necessary to employ a special revaluation establishment to deal with permanently settled estates.
In Madras, Bombay, and Assam the whole net collections are administered by local boards. In Bengal the road cess is credited to the District boards and the public works cess to general revenues, but under recent orders of the Local Government a portion of the latter is also granted to the local boards. In the Province of Agra a portion of the proceeds of the rate is devoted to the maintenance of the village watch, which in other parts is a charge upon special contributions assessed and collected apart from the general cess. In the Punjab fourfifths of the cess are assigned to the local boards, and the Local Government may reserve one-fifth for any of the purposes of the District Boards Act. In the Central Provinces the general rate introduced in 1878 (one per cent. on the rental) is administered by the Chief Commissioner, and the roads and school cesses are made over to the local boards.
Apart from the land cess imposed for purposes of local self-government are the rates levied, outside permanently settled estates, for the remuneration of the village watchman and headman. ‘The support of this village staff has been a charge on the community from time immemorial. In the Central Provinces and Bombay watchmen are still remunerated, according to the ancient custom, by grants of land and by fees collected by them directly from the people. Elsewhere they are supported by the proceeds of a cess to which, in some Provinces, non-agriculturists not unreasonably subscribe. The headman is a functionary of more importance in ryotwāri than in zamīndāri villages ; and except in Madras, Sind, and Coorg, his remuneration in ryotwāri Provinces has been accepted in whole or in part as a charge upon the land revenue which he collects. In the zamīndāri Provinces (the United Provinces, Central Provinces, and the Punjab) the proprietor of a village is also its headman ; but where there are several sharers in the proprietorship of a village, one or more of their number represent the remainder, and have a right to a commission on the revenue payable through them, the rate being generally 5 per cent. This represents a communal arrangement of very long standing1.’ The village accountant's functions have been considerably modified by his employment in the maintenance of a complex system of agricultural statistics for his village. His remuneration had been usually derived from a cess on land, supplemented in some places by grants from the public revenues, but in 1906 the cess was abolished everywhere, with minor exceptions.
In Bengal a small cess was levied under an Act of 1862 for the maintenance of a District post which transmitted papers between the magistrates and the police. A similar establishment was paid in some Provinces from small deductions from the general land cess, and other petty appropriations were made to meet the cost of normal schools, the establishment in Government offices for local purposes, and the like. These were all abolished in 1906.
Bibliography
Reports of the Royal Commission on Opium, 1893; the Bengal Opium and Excise Commissions, 1883; the Indian Hemp Drugs Commission, 1893; and the Madras Salt Commission, 1876.
Papers relating to the Excise Administration in India, reprinted from the Supplement to the Gazette of India of March 1, 1890.
Papers relating to the Excise Administration of Bengal, the United Provinces, and Assam, reprinted from the Supplement to the Gazette of India of December 27, 1890.
Papers relating to the Excise Administration in Assam, published in the Supplement to the Gazette of India of July 23, 1904.
Annual Reviews of the Trade of India.
Annual Reports of the Provincial Excise departments, of the Bengal and Bombay Opium departments, and of the Salt departments of Northern India and in the Maritime Provinces.
| 1850-1. | 1860-1. | 1870-1. | 1880-1. | 1890-1. | 1900-1. | 1902-3. | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bengal Provision Opium*: | |||||||
| Receipts . . | 3,09 | 4,20 | 5,64 | 7,95 | 6,13 | 6,40 | 5,75 |
| Charges . . | 1,03 | 88 | 2,01 | 2,03 | 2,18 | 2,68 | 2,47 |
| Net Receipts | 2,06 | 3,32 | 3,63 | 5,92 | 3,95 | 3,72 | 3,28 |
| Mālwā Export Opium: | |||||||
| Receipts . . | 70 | 2,48 | 2,40 | 2,53 | 1,75 | 1,25 | 1,00 |
| Charges . . | 1 | 4 | ... | ... | ... | ... | 1 |
| Net Receipts | 69 | 2,44 | 2,40 | 2,53 | 1,75 | 1,25 | 99 |
| Total—Bengal and Mālwā: | |||||||
| Revenue . . | 3,79 | 6,68 | 8,04 | 10,48 | 7,88 | 7,65 | 6,75 |
| Expenditure . . | 1,04 | 92 | 2,01 | 2,03 | 2,18 | 2,68 | 2,48 |
| Net Revenue | 2,75 | 5,76 | 6,03 | 8,45 | 5,70 | 4,97 | 4,27 |
| Revenue from opium credited under Excise . . | ... | 16 | 36 | 74 | 97 | 1,03 | 1,10 |
| 1871-2. | 1880-1. | 1890-1. | 1900-1. | 1902-3. | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue . . . | Rs. | 5,97 | 7,12 | 8,52 | 8,95 | 9,28 |
| Charges . . . | „ | 56 | 90 | 88 | 89 | 90 |
| Net Revenue | „ | 5,41 | 6,22 | 7,64 | 8,06 | 8,38 |
| Consumption . . | Mds. | 228 | 274 | 333 | 358 | 369 |
| Average consumption per head of the population* | seers | 3·6 | 4·3 | 4·6 | 4·9 | 5·0 |
| Incidence of duty per head of the population* | annas | 3·6 | 4·2 | 4·4 | 4·7 | 4·9 |
| Average retail price of salt per maund in Rs.:— | 1871. | 1880. | 1890. | 1900. | 1902 | |
| Madras . . . . | † | 3·2 | 3·2 | 3·2 | 3·2 | |
| Bombay . . . . | 2·7 | 3·5 | 3·4 | 3·5 | 3·3 | |
| Bengal . . . . | 5·0 | 4·5 | 4·1 | 3·8 | 3·8 | |
| Agra . . . . | 4·6 | 4·2 | 3·7 | 3·7 | 3·7 |
| 1860-1. | 1870-1. | 1880-1. | 1890-1. | 1900-1. | 1902-3. | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Intoxicating liquors . | 91 | 1,56 | 2,12 | 3,49 | 4,27 | 4,86 |
| Opium and its preparations | 16 | 36 | 74 | 97 | 1,03 | 1,10 |
| Hemp drugs | 11 | 22 | 30 | 42 | 59 | 66 |
| Miscellaneous | ... | ... | 3 | 4 | 2 | 2 |
| Total | 1,18 | 2,14 | 3,19 | 4,92 | 5,91 | 6,64 |
| Charges | 6 | 10 | 10 | 18 | 31 | 35 |
| Net revenue | 1,12 | 2,04 | 3,09 | 4,74 | 5,60 | 6,29 |
| 1892-3. | 1894-5. | 1897-8. | 1900-1. | 1902-3. | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Special Import Duties. | |||||
| Arms, ammunition, and military stores | 2 | 2 | 2 | 1 | 2 |
| Liquors | 60 | 61 | 66 | 69 | 76 |
| Petroleum | 20 | * | * | 49 | 53 |
| Sugar (countervailing duty) | ... | ... | ... | 21 | 11 |
| General Import Duties. | |||||
| Articles of food and drink | ... | 27 | 37 | 15 | 14 |
| Sugar (ordinary duty) | ... | † | † | 29 | 25 |
| Chemicals, drugs, narcotics, and dyeing and tanning materials | ... | 9 | 11 | 11 | 12 |
| Cotton manufactures | ... | 38 | 78 | 93 | 95 |
| Metals and manufactures of metals | ... | 55 | 65 | 33 | 69 |
| Oils | ... | 32 | 55 | 2 | 1 |
| Other raw materials and manufactured articles | ... | 58 | 53 | 68 | 68 |
| Total imports | 82 | 2,82 | 3,67 | 3,91 | 4,26 |
| Excise duty on cotton goods | ... | 1 | 11 | 12 | 18 |
| Export duty | 73 | 89 | 71 | 83 | 1,23 |
| Land customs and miscellaneous | 1 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 9 |
| Grand total | 1,56 | 3,77 | 4,55 | 4,93 | 5,76 |
| Charges | 17 | 19 | 22 | 26 | 25 |
| Net revenue | 1,39 | 3,58 | 4,33 | 4,67 | 5,51 |
| 1886-7. | 1890-1. | 1895-6. | 1900-1. | 1902-3. | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Collections | 1,36 | 1,62 | 1,83 | 1,98 | 2,12 |
| Charges | 8 | 5 | 4 | 4 | 5 |
| Net collections | 1,28 | 1,57 | 1,79 | 1,94 | 2,07 |
| 1872-3. | 1876-7. | 1879-80. | 1890-1. | 1900-1. | 1902-3. | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Land cess | Details not available. | 2,33 | 2,62 | 2,97 | 3,14 | |
| Village service and Patwāri cess | 50 | 77 | 73 | 81 | ||
| District post cess | 3 | 4 | 4 | 5 | ||
| Miscellaneous | 2 | 6 | 10 | 12 | ||
| Total | 1,89 | 1,93 | 2,88 | 3,49 | 3,84 | 4,12 |
| Charges | 5 | 11 | 5 | 6 | 5 | 7 |
| Net receipts | 1,84 | 1,82 | 2,83 | 3,43 | 3,79 | 4,05 |
Notes
- 1. Valuable historical notes by Sir J. B. Lyall and Mr. R. M. Dane on the production of opium in India, and on the opium trade with China, will be found in vol. vii, pt. ii, of the Report of the Royal Opium Commission of 1893.
- 1. The opium seer is about 2 lb.
- 2. This term is derived from the circumstance that, in the early days of the Government monopoly, opium was exported to China ‘to make provision for the Company’s investment.’
- 3. There has since been some recovery, probably temporary only.
- 1. ‘There is little doubt that more opium was consumed in India under native rule 150 years ago than now, and the stringent system of excise established by our Government has so greatly increased the price of the drug that consumption is reduced to a minimum. The danger is that this policy may be carried too far, and that by making opium too dear and too difficult to obtain, we may not only encourage smuggling, but may cause people who have been content with the moderate and beneficial use of opium to have recourse to alcohol, or to cheaper or more noxious stimulants, the consumption of which no Government can prevent.’—Sir John Strachey’s India, 3rd edition, p. 154.
- 1. A Government salt monopoly similar to that which existed in Bengal was introduced in the Madras Presidency at the beginning of the nineteenth century. In Bombay salt did not become a considerable source of revenue until 1837.
- 1. It must be remembered, however, that this line took the place of a more annoying system of innumerable customs posts scattered throughout the interior of the country.
- 2. This corresponds to about Rs. 1-10 per standard maund; and in 1903 the duty was fixed at Rs. 1-8 per standard maund.
- 3. This is the duty levied on imported salt. The local production, which is small and of a primitive character, has hitherto been taxed by fees on the vessels employed in the manufacture of the salt; but a system of taxation on the annual out-turn is now being tried in some Districts.
- 1. The Salt Commissioner, Northern India, in his Report for 1902–3, dated August, 1903, says that at that date an anna (one penny) would on the average purchase 1 lb. 14 oz. of salt in the Punjab and 1 lb. 9 oz. in the United Provinces.
- 1. Vol. xlii, pt. i, 1873.
- 1. As explained on page 259, the import duty on foreign liquors is credited to 'Customs.'
- 1. A central distillery system has been started as an experimental measure in the Sibsāgar District of Assam.
- 1. Raised to Rs. 7 in 1906.
- 1. Cotton yarns are said to be of 20's, 30's, &c., counts when not more than a like number of hanks of 840 yards go to the pound avoirdupois.
- 1. In 1903 a trifling duty was imposed, at the request of the tea industry, on exports of that product by sea, in view to the proceeds being applied, by a representative committee of the industry, to increasing the consumption and sale of Indian tea. In respect of this duty, which follows a Ceylon precedent, the Government acts merely as a collecting agency.
- 1. Up to April, 1905, income tax was levied only in selected towns and villages of Lower Burma.
- 2. Other important sources of Miscellaneous Revenue are Stamps and Registration, but these have been sufficiently referred to in chap. vi (ante, p. 174).
- 1. In Madras a District board may, with the sanction of the Local Government, increase this rate by 3 pies in the rupee for the purpose of constructing local railways or tramways.
- 1. Resolution of the Government of India, dated January 16, 1902, on the subject of land revenue assessment.
- *. The cost price of opium sold in the Excise department is included in the receipts, and the corresponding expenditure in the charges.
- *. The figures here include the population of all India, as the bulk of the inhabitants of the Native States consume British salt. A few States have, however, some local manufacture, and to this extent the average consumption and incidence of taxation are slightly more than above indicated. The difference has, however, been very trifling since the acquisition of the Rājputāna salt sources.
- †. Not available.
- *. Included under ‘Oils.’
- †. Included under ‘Articles of food and drink.’