Irrigation, Railways, and Roads have already been dealt with under their economic aspect in Vol. III. The present chapter is mainly concerned with the agency by which these and other undertakings falling within the sphere of the Indian Public Works Department are carried out and supervised.
Public Works in India fall naturally into three classes, Buildings and Roads, Irrigation, and Railways. Military, as distinct from Civil, buildings make a fourth class, when separately administered as they are now. The organization of the three main branches originated separately and at different times. A Military Board in each of the three Presidencies was the first recognized authority for works of the first class, which in those days were all of a military character, comprising barracks and other buildings for troops, and the few military roads that had been commenced prior to 1850. The history of the Military Boards is buried in 789 ponderous tomes of manuscript records, extending from the year 1773 to 1858, which are stored in the record-room at Calcutta. Of the Bengal Board the Marquis of Dalhousie, when Governor-General, recorded that its constitution was faulty, its duties far too onerous, and its work badly done in consequence. The idea of dissociating the Public Works business from the Board of the Bengal Presidency, which eventually led to the extinction of all three Military Boards, was probably aided by the success that attended the experiment of creating a department for Public Works in the newly acquired Province of the Punjab. This was in 1849, and the first Chief Engineer of the new department was Lieutenant-Colonel Napier, afterwards Lord Napier of Magdāla. In the following year a Commission appointed by order of the Court of Directors reported conclusively against the system of the Military Board in Bengal, and suggested that each Local Government should control its own Public Works, civil and military, under certain limitations, with the aid of a Chief Engineer and a staff of Superintending, Executive, and Assistant Engineers. This system was first adopted for the Bengal Presidency, and was subsequently introduced into Madras and Bombay with modifications of detail. These arrangements were completed in 1854, the sixth year of Lord Dalhousie's Governor-Generalship.
Irrigation works, the second of the three classes, had been carried out, under British rule, many years before these occurrences. Work on the systems known as the Eastern and Western Jumna Canals, which owed their first beginnings to neglected canals constructed by Fīroz Tughlak and the Mughal emperors, appears to have been commenced between 1817 and 1822. The Ganges Canal had been commenced in 1842 under Sir Proby Cautley ; the Bāri Doāb Canal also had been commenced by Colonel Dyas. In Madras the great anicut (dam) across the river Godāvari had been designed and constructed by Sir Arthur Cotton and his successors. When the new Public Works Department was formed in the Punjab in 1849, and in the United Provinces five years later, an Irrigation branch, under a Director of Canals, was already in existence in both cases ; and to this day the Irrigation and Buildings, &c., branches are more distinct in these Provinces than elsewhere.
Railway construction had begun with a contract, in 1849, with the East Indian Railway Company, for an experimental line to cost not more than one million sterling. This line was to be so selected as to form, if so desired, a portion of the future trunk line to the United Provinces. In the spring of 1853 the Government of India laid before the Court of Directors a programme of railways for the Indian empire. A system of trunk lines was recommended, connecting the interior of each Presidency with its principal port, and the several Presidencies with each other. The lines proposed were : (1) from Calcutta to Lahore ; (2) from Agra or some similar point to Bombay, or alternatively a line from Bombay by the Narbadā valley, to meet, at some point, the line from Calcutta to Lahore ; (3) from Bombay to Madras ; (4) from Madras to the Malabar coast. This general plan was accepted by the Court of Directors, and by the beginning of 1856 some progress had been made in constructing most of the lines.
Thus towards the end of Lord Dalhousie's Governor-Generalship one branch of the present Public Works Department, that which was then concerned with both civil and military Buildings and Roads, had been set on foot throughout the three Presidencies, and an Irrigation branch was in existence in the Punjab and the United Provinces. A Railway branch had hardly been formed as yet ; but the Government of India had entered into arrangements with companies for the construction of certain trunk lines, some of which had been partially completed, while others had been begun or surveyed ; and there was a Consulting Engineer at head-quarters to assist and advise in dealing with these matters. In 1854 a Secretary to the Government of India for the Department of Public Works was appointed, the first incumbent of the post being Lieutenant-Colonel W. E. Baker of the Bengal Engineers. The Secretary is shown in the lists of the day as ‘vested with the powers of the late Military Board.’ The control exercised by the new central office over civil and military and irrigation works was probably less at this time than it became at a later date, owing to the organization being incomplete. The first effort towards a general control over the operations of the Provincial Governments seems to have taken effect in a call for annual budget estimates and progress reports of works. The first series of the latter was for the year 1854, and the attempt of Major (afterwards Sir Henry) Yule of the Bengal Engineers, then Under Secretary, to reduce these from chaos to order forms one of the early Selections from the Records of the Department. The total expenditure by the Government on works and repairs of all kinds for that year was 226 lakhs. Of this nearly a crore was on communications of all kinds, including navigable canals ; over 54 lakhs was on irrigation ; 56½ lakhs on military works ; 3 lakhs on land for railways and their control. In addition 59 lakhs had been spent by the East Indian, and over 9 lakhs by the Madras, Railway Company. Thus the total outlay on public works of all kinds by Government, and by companies with capital guaranteed by Government, was close upon three millions sterling at the current rate of exchange. In the year 1849–50, or only four years before, the outlay, it is believed, did not exceed 60 lakhs.
The staff of engineers was at this time drawn from many sources. The Engineer corps of the three Presidencies supplied the nucleus, and a few more came from the Company’s Artillery ; some were recruited from the line regiments of the Company’s service, and a few officers of Royal regiments in India were employed with permission of the British Government. Lastly, a considerable number of civilians had been engaged in England and in India, and steps had been taken to increase the supply from both sources. The Thomason College at Roorkee, which will be referred to later on, was beginning to supply engineers and subordinates in fair numbers, and a class for training officers of the British and Indian armies had been opened there. In the year 1862, the first for which there is a reliable record, the strength of Public Works engineers in the Bengal Presidency was about 340, of whom rather more than 100 were Engineer and Artillery officers, about 80 were from British or Indian regiments, and the rest were civilians. There were also about 370 permanent and 40 temporary subordinates on the Engineering establishment.
The origin and early development of an organization for the construction and maintenance of Public Works having been thus traced, the various steps may be described by which the organization of the present day has been evolved. The process that has been going on for the last fifty years, and still continues, may be summarized as decentralization of control over details accompanied by consolidation of control over essentials. The details are such matters as the selection and execution of individual works, whether parts of a large project or not, and the creation and filling of the less important appointments. The essentials are concerned with the distribution of the available grants as a whole; the control over the organization and pay of the more important establishments, subordinate as well as superior; the power to sanction large projects, and to make and alter the rules which govern the organization of the Department and its various establishments. In a sense the Local Governments, and the Supreme Government itself, exercise far more extensive control, each in its own sphere, than they did fifty years ago. On the other hand, their powers are in some respects more restricted because they have been defined by fixed rules. They can now sanction only such new permanent appointments as do not carry a salary in excess of Rs. 250 a month, and the exercise of patronage is limited to prescribed sources of supply and classes of employés. The power to sanction works and projects, although considerable, is also strictly limited. Thus the Government of India can sanction estimates for Imperial works up to 10 lakhs, and Local Governments exercise the same power in regard to Provincial works; but for all works costing more than this, whether Imperial or Provincial, the sanction of the Secretary of State is required. In the case of ‘productive’ public works constructed from borrowed capital, or any work subsidiary thereto, no expenditure may be incurred by Local Governments without the previous sanction of the Government of India. Lastly, the control over the exercise of their powers by both Local and Supreme Governments is absolutely effective, which was not the case in earlier times.
We have seen how the supreme control over civil and military Buildings and Communications, Irrigation, and Railways was centred, in 1854, in a Secretariat on which the authority of the late Military Boards devolved. As time went on, this central authority was split up, first into three, and later into four, branches. This separation began during the period 1863–6, at the commencement of which a Royal Engineer officer had been placed on special duty in connexion with the accommodation of troops, and a little later was appointed Inspector-General of Military Works, holding charge of the military works business of the Secretariat when not on tour. A few years later (1872) this policy was extended, by placing the military works at all the chief stations of the Bengal Presidency directly under the control of this officer, acting under the immediate orders of the Supreme Government, with a separate system of circles of superintendence and executive divisions. The Provincial form of administration had, in fact, been found unsuitable for these works : the military buildings were not properly maintained, and failures in construction had occurred. In 1866, in order to meet the accumulating business, the Secretariat staff had to be strengthened and three branches formed, each with an Under or Assistant Secretary in charge—the Military Works branch, the Civil Works branch including Irrigation, and Railways. A year later (1867), owing to the impetus given to the spread of irrigation and the intention to develop such works from loans, an Inspector-General of Irrigation was appointed, holding a corresponding position to that of the Military Works officer, already mentioned1. In 1870 the development of Railway work led to the appointment of a Deputy-Secretary for each of the three branches above referred to. At the same time the Public Works Accounts department was recognized as a branch of the Secretariat, the Accountant-General becoming a fourth Deputy-Secretary.
The process, begun during the period 1863–72, of separating military from civil works made rapid progress in the ensuing ten years ; and in 1882 this separation was emphasized by the whole of the business in connexion with the Bengal army being handed over to the Military Department, together with the Military Works branch of the Public Works Secretariat. The rules and system of the Public Works Department were, however, still maintained in regard to the organization of the establishments and the execution and accounts of work, and the staff still consisted of civil as well as military engineers. In 1890 the same system was extended to the Madras and Bombay Presidencies, to Burma, and to certain military stations where the Public Works Department had hitherto remained the sole agency for works of all kinds. In carrying out the separation, the principle applied, so far as possible, was that when one of the two agencies sufficed for the works in any locality, the two should not exist side by side. Thus in some places, such as Baluchistān, where military needs preponderated, the Military Works department undertook both civil and military works, while in certain stations the Public Works, as the preponderating Department, continued to supervise the military works as before. The extension of the Military Works system to the whole of India was connected with the abolition of the separate army organization for the three Presidencies, and the subordination of the whole army system to one Commander-in-Chief and to the Military Department of the Government of India, which was completed in 1895. The Military Works department, which had since 1870 been gradually and increasingly militarized as regards its constitution, was in 1899 placed on a wholly military basis and became part and parcel of the army organization. The status and pay of the officers, who were now all Royal Engineers, were converted from a departmental to a purely military footing, and the name was changed to the Military Works Service. The Director-General was placed on the staff of the army; a Chief Engineer was appointed for each of the great Military Commands; Commanding Royal Engineers were allotted to each district within the Command, and Garrison Engineers to each important work or group of works within a military district.
Thus the Public Works Department, which, as the successor of the Military Board, was in its inception mainly military, has become a purely civil organization, dealing with only a few military cantonments in outlying localities too small to constitute a military unit. At the same time a military organization controls almost all military buildings, such as fortifications and barracks, throughout the country, and some frontier roads. In Baluchistān, as already mentioned, and in the lately constituted North-West Frontier Province, where also military works preponderate over civil, the Military Works Service manages likewise civil works and is for this purpose under the Local Government. This conversion of the Public Works Department into a civil organization had a marked effect on the strength and distribution of Royal Engineers employed in India. The 250 Royal Engineers formerly allotted for civil and military works in peace time have been reduced to 200; the normal distribution of strength between the military and civil organizations, which twenty years ago was 70 and 180 respectively, has become 130 and 70; and R. E. officers still attached to the Public Works Department are employed mainly on railways, which now furnish the most useful civil experience for the scientific corps of the army.
The problem of decentralizing railway control, which from the commencement had rested in some form or other with the Public Works Secretariat, continued to occupy the Supreme Government for twenty years after the creation of a separate Railway branch in the Secretariat in 1866. The first step taken was the institution of several local Consulting Engineers, each responsible for the supervision of companies' lines in the area under his control. But, as the pressure of business increased, it became evident that the control of details hitherto exercised by the Government of India must be delegated to some external authority, either to the several Provincial Governments, or to a Railway Board, or to an officer like the Director-General of Post Offices, exercising very full power and standing in the place of a Local Government. The railways are, with one or two exceptions, Imperial assets and liabilities, and several of them run through more than one Province. Their alignment; the general principles regulating maximum, minimum, and competing rates and fares; and the collection and compilation of statistics, are matters of policy which have hitherto been best dealt with by the Supreme Government, just as, in Great Britain, the Board of Trade deals with similar matters concerning railways in which the Government is not financially interested. It is clear therefore that, in endeavouring to divest itself of unnecessary details connected with the control of railways, the Supreme Government was precluded at the outset from having general recourse to the Provincial Governments, which had hitherto afforded a ready means of assistance when measures of relief from the effects of excessive centralization were in question. Nevertheless the Madras and Bombay Governments, which have always enjoyed a somewhat greater measure of independence than those of the more recently constituted Provinces, were allowed to have local Consulting Engineers who were also Secretaries to the Provincial Governments ; and the same principle has been adopted in the case of Burma, which is from its position a separate railway entity. Elsewhere the Consulting Engineers, who are now three in number, stationed at Calcutta, Lucknow, and Chittagong, were, and still are, directly under the Government of India.
The early attempts to obtain further decentralization between 1871 and 1886 took the form of endeavouring to constitute a single officer, outside the Secretariat, who should exercise the same powers in railway matters as Local Governments exercise in regard to other branches of administration. Accordingly, in 1874, a Director of State Railways was appointed, the Deputy-Secretary for Railways being retained as before, and the control over guaranteed lines through the Consulting Engineers being still exercised directly by Government. A few years later the single Directorate was split up into three controlling separate areas or groups, and, in addition, a Director of Stores was appointed. The objections of the Secretary of State, and the financial stringency of 1879, compelled the Government to abandon this arrangement and to appoint a single Director-General of Railways, exercising certain powers over both state and companies' lines, but included in the Secretariat organization as Deputy-Secretary for Railways. This organization lasted, under slightly different forms, from 1879 to 1897. Practically during the whole of this period the railway business was carried on in the Secretariat, the separate authority of the Director-General being merged in his functions as Deputy-Secretary.
In 1896 it was decided to modify the constitution of the Public Works Secretariat. Although the changes were required mainly by the growth of railway business, it was still held desirable that this Secretariat should remain the instrument for the central control over railways by the Government. The single Secretaryship1, which had existed since 1854, was abolished, and the Deputy-Secretary for Irrigation and Civil Works and the Deputy-Secretary who was also Director-General of Railways became independent Secretaries, each for his own branch of work. The Consulting Engineer with the Government of India became an administrative officer under the title of Director of Railway Construction, while another officer was appointed Director of Railway Traffic, both these officers also exercising Secretariat functions as Deputy-Secretaries to the Railway Secretary. These changes were accompanied by the delegation of certain powers to Managers and Engineers-in-Chief in the case of state lines; and to Consulting Engineers (or to such Local Governments as supervise these officers1) in the case of lines worked by companies.
Although some relief was given by these reforms, the great expansion in the railway system, and the consequent necessity for providing more efficient machinery for the rapid disposal of business, led to changes of greater importance than any which have been made since the first establishment of a Public Works Secretariat. It was held that there should be a body of practical business men entrusted with full authority to manage the railways of India on commercial principles, freed from all non-essential restrictions or needlessly inelastic rules. In 1905 the Railway branch of the Secretariat was abolished and its place taken by a Railway Board, consisting of a chairman and two members. While the Government of India reserves to itself the final decision in regard to the preparation of the railway programme and the larger question of railway policy and finance which affect all lines, administrative duties have been generally delegated to the Board. The Board is directly under the new Department of Commerce and Industry, while the Public Works Department, which now deals only with irrigation and civil works, has been transferred to the charge of the member for Revenue and Agriculture.
The Telegraph department was at one time under the control of the Home, and later of the Foreign, Department. It was transferred to the Public Works Department in 1870; and on the division of that Department into two branches dealing with railways, and with irrigation and civil works, the Telegraph department was placed under the latter branch. In 1905 the control was transferred to the new Department of Commerce and Industry.
As regards Buildings, Roads, and Irrigation, the delegation of powers to Provincial Governments has been very complete. Each Local Government has its own Engineering staff, the head of which acts as its Public Works Secretary2 and is responsible for the up-keep and construction of its irrigation works, its public buildings, and the roads under its control. The functions of the Government of India as regards these works are limited to sanction of important projects, review of progress in the various Provinces, from which it receives annual administration reports, and occasional local inspection of large works or schemes by the Public Works Member or Secretary.
A further measure of decentralization has been the transfer of ordinary roads and minor buildings to District and municipal boards or to the departments occupying the buildings. The extent and manner of this transfer to local authorities varies. In Bengal and Madras almost every District has its own engineer and subordinate staff, paid from and controlled by the District board and quite distinct from the Provincial Public Works establishment. In other Provinces, such as Bombay, the United Provinces, the Punjab, and Burma, although the power of selecting the local works to be executed and, to some extent, the financial control over the local grants rest with the District boards, the supervision and execution of works is almost wholly in the hands of the Public Works Department. As a rule, even in those Provinces where the transfer of control has been least, small establishments are kept up for the execution of minor works and repairs independently of the Department. In the United Provinces this modicum of decentralization has not taken place, or rather the departmental system has been allowed to absorb a local organization which once came into existence. In Bengal and Madras the District board engineers may be either supplied by loan from the Public Works Department or engaged independently. The Supreme Government has, within the last twenty years, done much to encourage the extension of local control over the less important communications and buildings; and at the time the local self-government scheme of 1882 was issued, it contemplated handing over to the local boards, under a sort of financial contract, the care of the less important Government buildings. The chief objection which has hitherto prevented the realization of this project is the economy secured by keeping works under the single control of the Government engineer; and the Finance Committee of 1888, acting on this principle, promoted the unification of Public Works establishments at the expense of local control in the United Provinces. The process of decentralization will become more marked as the District boards acquire more influence and greater competence for their work, and the Government staff becomes more absorbed in irrigation works; and the departmental system, so far as buildings and communications are concerned, will gradually contract. It has already nearly disappeared from the larger towns, in which municipal establishments supply its place, and from the great Port Trusts, which have assumed charge of docks, harbours, and in some cases lighthouses, formerly in charge of the Department, and which now maintain complete and efficient establishments of their own. As regards irrigation too, the control of minor works such as the less important tanks has, in Madras, where these are very numerous, been transferred to the Revenue Department1.
Besides buildings and roads there are other miscellaneous works, such as drainage and water-works of towns, harbours, docks, and lighthouses, which were originally within the scope of departmental operations. But as they have now, for the most part, been taken over by municipal and District boards and Port Trusts, they need not be further referred to. There are, however, two classes of miscellaneous works, connected with coal and iron production and river embankments, which may be briefly mentioned.
The coal-mines worked directly by Government are the Warorā colliery2, in the Central Provinces, under the control of the local Public Works Department, and the Dandot and Khost collieries (the former in the Punjab, and the latter in Baluchistān), worked by the North-Western Railway. The output of the first was 115,000 to 150,000 tons annually, and the profit 10 to 13 per cent. on capital. The other two are small concerns, with an annual output of about 70,000 and 20,000 tons respectively. They supply coal at moderate rates to the railway and are maintained for that purpose.
The Government has, from time to time since 1850, engaged in investigations in Bengal, the Central Provinces, Kumaun, and elsewhere, with the object of manufacturing iron in India. The only works, however, which have been erected up to the present are at Barākar, in Mānbhūm District, within the Bengal coal-field. These were originally started by the Bengal Iron Company, but were acquired by Government in 1880 and worked directly under a manager. In 1890 the property was leased to the Barākar Iron Works Company, which undertook to produce at least 15,000 tons of pig iron annually. Since then various modifications in the contract have been made; and the Company, having decided to enlarge its operations by the manufacture of steel, undertook, in 1903, to manufacture annually 20,000 tons of steel rails and bars, the Government agreeing to pay, for ten years, an annual subsidy of 3 per cent. on the capital cost of plant sufficient to produce that amount, subject to a maximum of £1,500 and a reduction in favour of Government of Rs. 3 on the price of each ton of material purchased. It was considered that the whole of this produce would be used by state and companies' railways.
The most important system of river embankments is that maintained by the Bengal Irrigation branch in Orissa and in the districts watered by the great rivers Gandak, Son, and Hooghly. Some of these are the property of Government; others are maintained by Government for the owners at the cost of the latter. The maintenance of some is regulated by statute, and they date from a time long anterior to the existence of the Public Works Department. The length of embankment thus kept up by the Bengal Government is 2,200 miles, and the area protected nearly nine million acres. The annual charges are about 4 lakhs. River embankments are also maintained to a considerable extent in Madras, Burma, and the Punjab.
In all the larger Provinces, namely, Madras, Bombay, Bengal, the United Provinces, and the Punjab, there are, and have been for considerable periods, separate Chief Engineers for (a) Irrigation and (b) Buildings and Roads, while the Burma staff will be similarly constituted at no distant date. This division of functions extends also to the District staff in the United Provinces and the Punjab, while in other Provinces the same staff is, as a rule, responsible for both Irrigation and Buildings and Roads, so far as the latter are under the control of the Public Works Department. Each Province is divided into Public Works ‘divisions,’ which comprise single civil Districts, or portions or groups of Districts, as the case may be. As a rule, the Buildings and Roads divisions in the United Provinces and the Punjab cover the largest areas. The separate canal divisions in these Provinces are, however, much smaller, inasmuch as they need careful and individual attention. Each division is in charge of an Executive Engineer, who is immediately responsible for the up-keep and improvement of all works within his charge, and whose functions are often of a very varied description. He may be called upon to build a jail or a post office, to repair a bridge, to regulate the supply of water from a canal, or to construct fresh dams and weirs. His functions are specially onerous in times of flood, when bridges are broken, banks breached, and the head-works of canals threatened or damaged. And when drought is followed by famine, the execution of important relief works falls within his province. At all times he is responsible for the preparation of estimates for repairs and construction, and for the execution of contracts for supply of labour and material.
Executive Engineers have under them Assistant Engineers who are in training for higher functions, and a subordinate staff, the principal members of which are styled Subordinate Engineers, Supervisors, and Overseers. These assistants may be either in subordinate control of a portion of the division or in charge of particular works.
Five or six divisions are grouped into a ‘Circle’ in charge of a Superintending Engineer. All important estimates are passed on to him for scrutiny, and the inspection of the works and projects in his Circle is his primary duty.
The Chief, Superintending, Executive, and Assistant Engineers form the permanent Engineer establishment, or superior staff of the Department, for Buildings and Roads, Irrigation, and Railways. In 1903 they numbered about 760, of whom about 60 were Royal Engineers. Of the rest, 420 were Civil Engineers recruited in Europe, mainly from the Royal Indian Engineering College at Cooper’s Hill, while 280 were recruited in India, chiefly from the Indian Engineering Colleges, and of this number nearly 100 were ‘Provincial’ Engineers appointed under certain special conditions which will be referred to later on. With the great expansion of public works of all descriptions which has taken place in recent years, the present staff has been found inadequate, and it is now proposed to raise the number of permanent Engineers gradually to 900. There are also about 100 temporary and non-pensionable Engineers, employed chiefly on irrigation works in the Punjab and on railways.
During the early days of the Public Works Department the Engineer establishment was recruited in a haphazard and miscellaneous way. In 1870 about two-fifths of its strength was made up of Royal Engineers, while the rest consisted, in proportions roughly equal, of men recruited in India, largely through the Indian Engineering Colleges, and of engineers procured in England under covenant, who were popularly known as ‘Stanley engineers,’ from Lord Stanley (afterwards Earl of Derby), Secretary of State when this arrangement was initiated. With the diminution of the number of Royal Engineers available for civil works, necessitated by the development of a separate Military Works branch, and the increasing magnitude of departmental operations, it became necessary to place the recruitment of civil engineers on a more permanent basis. This was effected by the foundation, in 1871, of the Royal Indian Engineering College at Cooper's Hill, near Staines, the net cost of which has been met by the Government of India. Recent annual recruitment from this source has been about twenty-two men for the Public Works Department, including Railways and Accounts, three for the Indian Telegraphs, and eight for the Forest service. The College engineering course lasted for three years, and was in most cases supplemented by a year's practical training in railway or other engineering works in England. It has now been decided to close the College1, as considerable expenditure would be necessary to maintain it on the higher standard of efficiency required at the present day, and suitable recruits for the Public Works Department can under existing conditions be obtained from other quarters. Hereafter such recruits will be selected by the Secretary of State, with the assistance of expert advisers, from candidates who have obtained a degree, diploma, or other distinction equivalent thereto at some approved institution for engineering education, and who have had some experience as assistants in the preparation of the designs for, or in the execution of, some engineering work of importance. The age for candidates is between twenty-one and twenty-four years. In 1906 the number of appointments was ten.
The ‘Provincial’ Engineers, so called to distinguish them from the Imperial Service, i. e. the Royal Engineers and Cooper's Hill men, are natives of India (including in this term domiciled Europeans and Eurasians) recruited from the Indian Engineering Colleges by the grant of a limited number of guaranteed appointments to the most distinguished students of each year, and men promoted from the upper subordinate ranks (Subordinate Engineers and Supervisors). This service was organized on its present footing in 1892, in accordance with the recommendation of the Public Service Commission; and its members perform the same duties, and can rise to the same positions, as their ‘Imperial’ confrères, but draw a lower rate of pay in all grades except that of Chief Engineer, in view of their permanent Indian connexion. Men of this class who entered the superior service before the organization of 1892 came into operation draw the same rate of pay as men of the Imperial Service, but are under inferior leave and pension rules. Some of these are Europeans recruited prior to 1882 and not necessarily educated in India.
The subordinate executive Public Works service is recruited entirely in India from the local Engineering Colleges. It contains a sprinkling of British soldiers who have undergone an engineering course at Roorkee, while the rest are natives of India in the wide sense above referred to, but with a large predominance of the purely Asiatic element. The subordinate ranks of the Military Works Service are similarly recruited, but here the appointments are reserved mainly for the military element obtained through Roorkee.
There are four Engineering Colleges in India—at Roorkee in the United Provinces, Sibpur (Calcutta), Madras, and Poona ; also Engineering Schools at Rangoon, in Bihār, and elsewhere. Of these the oldest and most important is the Thomason College at Roorkee, which was founded in 1848 by the Lieutenant-Governor of the North-Western Provinces whose name it bears. It was first established as a training school for supplying subordinates for the Ganges Canal ; and a few years later it was enlarged and converted into a college, with the object of training civilian engineers for the newly constituted Department of Public Works, and for the instruction of regimental officers in engineering. In 1902 it had a strength of about 320 students, of whom about 125 of various classes pass out annually. The greater number of these find employment with Native States, Railway Companies, local boards and municipalities, and in private industrial concerns, while others enter the Public Works Department as above indicated and also the Survey of India. The college is equipped with chemical, physical, and mechanical laboratories, and with technical workshops, comprising carpentry, foundry, smithy, machinery, and fitting shops, worked entirely by electrical power generated by steam and oil engines within the college grounds. All these form part of the teaching apparatus. There are courses of instruction in civil, electrical, and telegraph engineering for engineers and subordinates ; classes for training draftsmen and computers and for mechanics ; and industrial classes for teaching the trades of printing and photography in their various branches, and for art handiwork in wood, metal, and stone. The civil and electrical engineer students who compete for a limited number of guaranteed appointments in the Engineer and Telegraph departments are taken through the usual courses of civil, electrical, and telegraph engineering, the advanced portion of each course being adapted to the particular branch for which each class is under training. Both classes go through an elementary course of workshop training in the several departments. They also go through courses in higher mathematics, mechanics (pure and applied), and elementary chemistry and physics, half the time given to these last being spent in experimental work. The college course for these students is three years. The subordinate classes, including the draftsmen and computers, for whom also a considerable number of appointments are provided, take up the same subjects as the civil engineering students in a more elementary way, and receive a complete training in surveying and levelling. The mechanical apprentice class receive instruction in elementary electrical engineering, and spend half their time in the workshops, their mechanical skill being developed to the utmost. They also receive elementary and theoretical training in mathematics, mechanics, heat, electricity, materials, and construction. The photographic branch of the industrial classes is utilized to a limited extent by the several engineering classes, chiefly for instruction in the ferrotype process for reproducing tracings and in practical photography. In addition to its educational functions, the college gives advice and carries out tests on engineering, technical, and scientific questions for Government and for the public.
Each college supplies the Local Governments with which it is connected with engineer subordinates, as well as with the ‘Provincial’ engineers selected direct from the colleges; and Roorkee sends its alumni all over India.
The State Railway superior establishment has four sub-branches—Management, Traffic, Locomotive, and Stores. The first is a direct offshoot of the general superior Engineer establishment, from which it is usually recruited, and consists mainly of engineers on rates of pay almost identical with those of Chief and Superintending Engineers, such lower appointments as exist being filled by officers of the grade of Executive Engineer. Several of the superior Traffic officers have been obtained from the Engineer establishment, and such transfers are still fairly frequent; of the rest, the majority were appointed in India, either with or without examination, and the rule at present is to appoint young men of a superior class who have gone through an apprenticeship in subordinate Traffic posts. At one time a certain number of appointments were made from Cooper's Hill. The superior Locomotive officers are now, for the most part, recruited from England, as a high standard of qualification is required; but qualified men have been, and still are, appointed in India when they can be obtained. Storekeepers are almost invariably Europeans appointed in India. The whole strength of the superior staff is under 120 men. With the exception of officers transferred from the Engineer establishment or otherwise recruited prior to 1881, the majority are non-pensionable and, in the case of the Locomotive branch, are engaged under short covenants, their service being capable of extension by mutual consent when the term of the covenant ends. A Provident Fund liberally subsidized by Government, the terms of which were greatly improved in 1900, supplies the place of a pension for those who were not originally on the pensionable list.
The Railway subordinate staff is very large, including subordinate Superintendents on Rs. 400 and a few on Rs. 500, down to men on Rs. 15 a month. All those appointed since 1881, that is, by far the greater number of the present establishment, are non-pensionable and subject to the same Provident Fund rules as the superior non-pensionable staff. The higher Locomotive subordinates are, as a rule, obtained under covenant from England; other members of the skilled staff are, like the subordinates of the Civil Works branch, obtained from the Indian colleges.
Railway Companies engage their own staff, but frequently enlist the services of Government officers in active service or after retirement. Owing to the financial concern which the Government has in the majority of the Companies' lines, on account of guarantee of interest, profit-sharing, or assistance in some form or other, the approval of the Government of India is required for the salaries of the superior establishment, as well as for the rules regulating their leave and acting allowances, or for any special concessions in regard to pay. Taking State and Companies' lines together, the total number of railway employés of all classes at the end of 1902 was 942 superior officers (mostly Europeans), and about 392,000 subordinates, of whom 13,200 were Europeans or Eurasians.
The accounts of the Public Works Department, including those of State Railways, are audited and consolidated by a special Public Works Accounts department, at the head of which is an Accountant-General with the rank and pay of a senior Chief Engineer. The superior Accounts branch was formerly closely allied to the Engineer branch, and its ranks were supplied chiefly from that establishment, the organization and rates of pay being identical; but since 1892 it has been more assimilated to the Civil Accounts department. It is recruited partly from Cooper's Hill, partly by examination in India, partly by promotion from the subordinate ranks, and occasionally by the appointment (in India) of men who have acquired special knowledge of accounts outside Government service. The appointments by examination in India are restricted to natives of India in the wide sense of the term. The strength of the establishment is about eighty.
As already indicated, officers of the Public Works Department, both of the superior and subordinate services, are freely lent to Railway Companies, to District and municipal boards, to Native States, and in recent years, to British Colonies and Protectorates, both for ordinary employ and for the carrying out of special projects. Several officers who originally belonged to the Department, among whom Sir W. E. Garstin and Sir W. Willcocks (both pupils of Roorkee) may be specially mentioned, have had a distinguished career in Egypt.
The results of Public Works finance for the period between 1876–7 and 1904–5 are discussed in chapter vi of this volume. It will be seen from Table IV appended to that chapter that in the last-mentioned year Railway transactions, including Government liabilities for guaranteed and subsidized lines, yielded a net profit of 316 lakhs against a deficit of 115 lakhs at the beginning of the period. Irrigation, including Minor Works and Navigation, involved a charge of 62 lakhs at the beginning of the period and a net profit of 43 lakhs at its close, while Civil Works cost 284 lakhs in 1876–7 and 643 lakhs in 1904–5.
The total outlay on public works of all kinds by Government, and by companies interest on whose capital is guaranteed, or which are assisted financially, by Government, was about 9½ crores of rupees in 1880–1, 13 crores in 1890–1, 17 crores in 1900–1, and nearly 22 crores in 1902–3. These amounts do not include the cost of working and maintaining the open lines of railway, which is accounted for under net earnings of railways, and which, for the same years, amounted to 6, 10½ 15, and 16 crores respectively.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Sir George Chesney.—Indian Polity, chap. xvii (1894).
Sir John and Sir Richard Strachey.—Finances and Public Works of India (1882).
Earlier numbers of Selections from the Records of the Government of India relating to Public Works, as below:—
- No. 1.—Papers on the Proposed Railway in Bengal.
- No. 13.—Progress Reports of Public Works Department for the Year 1854–5.
- No. 14.—Minute by the Most Noble the Governor-General of India (Lord Dalhousie), dated Feb. 28, 1856.
- No. 21.—Lt.-Col. R. Baird-Smith.—Revenue Reports of the Ganges Canal for the Year 1855–6.
Horace Bell.—Railway Policy of India (1894).
Calendar of Thomason College, Roorkee, containing a history of the college from its commencement in 1851, together with a description of the theoretical and practical education given at the college (1902).
Notes
- 1. The functions of this officer were subsequently merged in those of the Secretary to the Government of India in the Irrigation and Buildings and Roads branch of the Public Works Department, but an Inspector-General was again appointed in 1905.
- 1. An additional member for Public Works was added to the Governor-General's Council in 1874; but from 1880 this special appointment was in abeyance, the Department being administered by one of the ordinary members, who was, as a rule, selected from the Indian Civil Service on grounds of general administrative experience.
- 1. Madras, Bombay, and Burma.
- 2. In Madras, Bombay, Bengal, and the United Provinces there are two Chief Engineers and Secretaries—one for Irrigation and the other for Buildings and Roads, while in the Punjab, where the development of irrigation has been specially marked, there are now (1906) two Chief Engineers and Secretaries for this branch and one for Buildings and Roads.
- 1. Before the Public Works Department was organized in the various Provinces, the Madras Revenue Board had the supervision of all irrigation works in that Presidency.
- 2. The Warorā colliery was closed in 1906, the coal having been exhausted.
- 1. The last entrance examination for the Royal Indian Engineering College at Cooper's Hill was held in 1904, and the course for the candidates then admitted was reduced from three to two years. The College was finally closed in 1906.