Chapter XIII

— Education

The Imperial Gazetteer of India, Vol. IV, The India Office, 1907 · from page 407 · about 94 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

The advent of British rule found a literature and a system of instruction existing among both Hindus and Muhammadans, in each case closely connected with their religious institutions.

To give and to receive instruction is enjoined by the sacred books of the Brāhmans, and their ancient sages produced a literature which is deep and subtle and often of great beauty. Schools of learning (tols) were formed in centres containing a considerable high-caste population, and pandits gave instruction in Sanskrit grammar, logic, philosophy, and law. The students were called the chelās or children of their gurūs or teachers, lived with them in a semi-filial relationship, and owed them obedience and respect. The chelās were lodged and fed by their gurūs, and the latter were maintained by gifts and grants of land from the rulers of the country or from private benefactors. Teaching was mainly by word of mouth, and the memory of the pupils was trained to enable them to repeat by heart long passages of the sacred texts. 'The student respectfully held the hand of his teacher, and fixed his mind on the teacher, and said, "Venerable sir, recite," and the sāvitri (the well-known gāyatri verse of the Rig-veda) was recited and learnt as the introduction to the learning of the Vedas. And thus from day to day new lessons were recited and learnt, the student dividing his day's work between minding his lessons and minding the household work of his teacher1.'

This advanced instruction was strictly confined to youths of the higher castes. For the lower castes village schools were scattered over the countryside, in which a rudimentary education was given to the children of the trading classes, the petty landholders, and the well-to-do cultivators. In many villages in Bengal and other parts of India these schools may still be seen working much as they must have worked in remote centuries of the past. Seated under a tree or in the veranda of a hut, the children learned to trace the letters of the alphabet with their fingers in the sand, or recite in monotonous tones their spelling or a multiplication table which extends far beyond the twelve times twelve of the English schoolroom. Simple mensuration and accounts and the writing of a letter are the highest accomplishments at which this primitive course of instruction aims.

In former times the higher education of Muhammadans was in the hands of men of learning who devoted themselves to the instruction of youth. Schools were attached to mosques and shrines, and supported by state grants in cash or land, or by private liberality. Individual instructors of merit were also aided by the state, and landholders and nobles vied with each other in supporting scholars of repute. Several towns in India, such as Gopāmau and Khairābād in Oudh, and Jaunpur in the Province of Agra, have from time to time been famous seats of learning, to which students flocked from all parts of India, and even from Afghānistān and Bokhāra, to attend the lectures of renowned specialists. The course of study in a Muhammadan place of learning included grammar, rhetoric, logic, theology, metaphysics, literature, jurisprudence, and science. The classes of the learned instructors have been replaced by madrasas or colleges of a more modern type founded by the liberality of pious persons.

Elementary classes were included in the schools attached to mosques, but ordinary education was, as a rule, imparted at home. Householders of means engaged the services of a teacher to instruct their children in reading, writing, and arithmetic. Persian was the medium of instruction, and letterwriting and penmanship were highly prized accomplishments. The children learned to write on oblong boards, in appearance like a large edition of the horn-book, which could be washed clean at the close of the lesson. Less affluent neighbours were invited or allowed to send their children to the class, which sometimes attained the proportions of a small school. The schools were known as domestic maktabs, and the teachers were called ‘maulvi sāhib’ or ‘munshi sāhib.’ The profession was followed by both Muhammadans and Hindus. The old Indian pedagogue is the hero of many a folk-tale, in which he is sometimes depicted as a tyrant whom it was the pride and delight of the bolder spirits among his pupils to outwit, and at other times as the good-natured but lettered fool who fell into every trap that was laid for him. The pupils were bound to respect and do menial service for their maulvi, and custom permitted him to make free use of the cane or to punish delinquents in any other way his ingenuity might devise.

In England, during the early days of the Company's rule, the state still left the care of education to private enterprise and 'the pious founder.' The principles which prevailed at home naturally influenced the conduct of the administration in India, and the Court of Directors did little to supplement the indigenous systems of education existing in their territories. Their efforts were confined to the establishment of colleges for Oriental learning, such as the Calcutta Madrasa for Muhammadans founded by Warren Hastings in 1782, and the Benares College for Hindus established in 1791. About this time Mr. Wilberforce and other benevolent persons in England took up the cause of the education of the natives of India, and, after an unsuccessful attempt in 1793 to introduce a measure for the encouragement of missionaries and schoolmasters, succeeded in inserting a clause in the Charter Act of 1813 that one lakh of rupees in each year should be 'set apart and applied to the revival and improvement of literature and the encouragement of the learned natives of India, and for the introduction and promotion of a knowledge of the sciences among the inhabitants of the British territories in India.' The grant was devoted mainly to the upkeep of the Oriental colleges, the payments of stipends to students, and the publication of works of Oriental literature. But the cause of general education was not without its advocates. In 1815 Lord Hastings declared his anxiety to see some system of public instruction established, and the private endeavours of native and English gentlemen and of missionary bodies gave a fresh impetus to educational progress. Potent causes were at work which tended to direct the current of education into new channels. 'A knowledge of English became a means of livelihood to natives at the centres of government, and a demand arose for English instruction in the Presidency towns. As the old exotic court language, Persian, fell into disuse, and especially when it ceased to be the language of official life, the demand for education in the vernaculars which had superseded the foreign tongue made itself more widely felt. Meanwhile a new influence in favour of popular education was being brought to bear upon the Indian Government by missionary and philanthropic bodies both in this country and in Europe1.'

At a very early date Christian missionaries assumed an honourable and important position in the history of Indian education. In the days of Portuguese ascendancy in the South the Jesuit fathers established a fairly wide system of education. When the scale turned in favour of British rule Protestant missionaries were no less zealous. Although at first opposed by the authorities through fear of native hostility to missionary effort, they established a number of colleges and schools in which many pupils were instructed in the learning of the West, and some of which, such as the Christian College at Madras, the Wilson College at Bombay, and the General Assembly's Institution at Calcutta, remain to the present day among the most important educational institutions of the country. The first English missionary college in India owed its foundation to the Baptists. In 1799 Carey and four other missionaries, in order to avoid the opposition of the British authorities, established themselves at Serampore, on the Hooghly, which was at that time a Danish possession. This group of Baptist missionaries rendered themselves illustrious by their literary activity, and in ten years the Bible was translated and printed, in whole or in part, in thirty-one languages. In 1818 they founded the Serampore College. The professed object of this institution was conversion, and to this end instruction in the tenets of Christianity was combined with Sanskrit and Arabic literature. In 1820 a college was founded at Calcutta, with funds subscribed in England in honour of Middleton, the first Anglican bishop in India, for the purpose of educating Christian youths to qualify them ' to preach among the heathen.' Another name celebrated in connexion with the early history of education in India is that of Dr. Duff, missionary of the Church of Scotland. He landed at Calcutta in 1830, and in spite of a host of difficulties succeeded in establishing a seminary for imparting literary, scientific, and religious education through the medium of English. These early missionary efforts had a most important influence in fostering the demand for English education. They taught the natives that English was a profitable acquisition, while the Government learnt the usefulness of English-taught natives in the public service.

But the claim of an English as opposed to an Oriental education was not established until after a long struggle. Two parties arose, both of which favoured the extension of vernacular education ; but while the Orientalists desired that it should be supplemented by the study of the classical languages of the East, the Anglicists contended that the knowledge and science of the Western world should be thrown open to the natives of India through the study of English. The Orientalists based their contention on the words of the Charter Act of 1813, on the alleged wishes of the people, on the fact that Hindu and Muhammadan law are derived chiefly from Sanskrit and Arabic works, and on the ground that the sacred books of the people are written in these languages. The majority of the Company's servants were at first in favour of Oriental education, but the party of change included prominent members of the native community, and in the end the scale was turned against the Orientalists. A minute written in 1835 by Lord Macaulay (at that time Legal Member of Council and a member of the Council of Education) had a great influence in determining the issue. After a striking eulogy on the English language he put the point in the following passage :—

‘The question now before us is simply whether, when it is in our power to teach this language, we shall teach languages in which, by universal confession, there are no books on any subject which deserve to be compared to our own ; whether when we can teach European science, we shall teach systems which, by universal confession, wherever they differ from those of Europe differ for the worse ; and whether, when we can patronize sound philosophy and true history, we shall countenance, at the public expense, medical doctrines which would disgrace an English farrier, astronomy which would move laughter in girls at an English boarding-school, history abounding in kings thirty feet high and reigns thirty thousand years long, and geography made of seas of treacle and seas of butter.’

Nowadays it would be readily admitted that Lord Macaulay did but scant justice to the Oriental writers of antiquity ; but in essence his contention was just, while his brilliant exposition carried conviction. Almost immediately after his minute was written, the Government issued a Resolution which decided unequivocally in favour of a Western education. In reaffirming the decision in 1839, Lord Auckland explained that the existing Oriental institutions were to be kept up in full efficiency.

It is not possible in a brief sketch to give an adequate account of the tentative efforts made during the next twenty years in accordance with the principles which had now become established. Missionary effort continued to play an important part in educational progress, the interest of enlightened natives was aroused, and the Government accepted an increasing share of work and responsibility. In Bengal, under the general control of a Council of Education, a number of colleges and schools were established for the teaching of the upper and middle classes, but very little was done for the improvement of elementary education. The authorities shrank before the magnitude and difficulty of the task, and declared that education must be left to filter downwards to the great mass of the population. Indigenous rural schools or pāthshālas existed in large numbers, but the teachers were incompetent and miserably paid, and the instruction was of the rudest description. In the North-Western Provinces, which were separated from Bengal in 1836, a different spirit prevailed; and Mr. Thomason, who was Lieutenant-Governor from 1843 to 1853 and was warmly supported by Lord Dalhousie, succeeded in inaugurating a system of general elementary instruction. A Government school was established in each tahsīl, and from that centre surrounding indigenous schools were supervised, and the people and teachers were furnished with advice, assistance, and encouragement. The improvement of the indigenous schools proved, then as ever, exceedingly difficult, and the system was gradually superseded by the establishment of circle or halkabandi schools supported by a local cess. In Madras a Government high school was started at the Presidency town in 1841, and several other high and middle-class schools were established. In the matter of elementary schools the work of the Government was confined, for the most part, to furnishing some aid to private institutions, of which a considerable number had been founded by missionary societies. In Bombay, where education owed much to the enlightened efforts of Mountstuart Elphinstone, English schools were established at the head-quarters of Districts, a number of vernacular schools, supported partly by the state and partly by the people, grew up under the control of a Board of Education, and indigenous schools were inspected and encouraged. A beginning had thus been made over large portions of India, but progress up to the year 1853 had not been encouraging. There were only fourteen Government colleges for general education; elementary vernacular education had been attempted with any degree of success only in the North-Western Provinces and Bombay; and the total number of pupils in Government colleges and schools of all classes in Madras, Bombay, Bengal, and the North-Western Provinces amounted to less than 40,000.

Such was the position of affairs when, in 1854, Sir C. Wood (afterwards Lord Halifax) being President of the Board of Control, the Court of Directors decided that the Government should afford assistance 'to the more extended and systematic promotion of general education in India,' and addressed the Governor-General-in-Council in a memorable dispatch which sketched in outline a complete scheme of public education, controlled and aided, and in part directly managed, by the state. The principles then laid down were reaffirmed in 1859 after the transfer of the administration to the Crown, and still guide, in the main, the efforts of the Government for the better education of the people. The dispatch of 1854 prescribed the constitution in each Province of a separate department of Public Instruction; the institution of Universities at the Presidency towns; the establishment of institutions for training teachers for all classes of schools; the maintenance of the existing Government colleges and high schools, and the increase of their number when necessary; the establishment of new schools between the elementary and high schools; the multiplication and improvement of vernacular schools, indigenous and other, for elementary education; and the introduction of a system of grants-in-aid of schools maintained by private persons or bodies. The attention of the Government was to be specially directed to placing the means of acquiring useful and practical knowledge within the reach of the great mass of the people, 'who are utterly incapable of obtaining any education worthy of the name by their own unaided efforts.' English, which was to be taught where there was a demand for it, was to be the medium of instruction in the higher branches, and the vernacular languages in the lower.

In spite of the dark days which followed close on the dispatch of 1854, the Government in India at once took vigorous action on the instructions of the Court of Directors, and a great impetus was given to all forms of educational activity. The progress up to the present time is illustrated by the table at the end of this chapter. The table refers only to institutions which are classed as 'public' in the educational statistics. 'Public' institutions include all those which are managed or aided by the state or by local or municipal bodies, or which, although they receive no grant of public money, are recognized by the Education department as institutions which may send up candidates for Government scholarship and certificate examinations, and which may receive Government scholars. Institutions and pupils are classified in the table under the primary, secondary, and collegiate stages. Primary education may be roughly described as the instruction of the masses through the vernacular; secondary education denotes all school teaching, whether in English or in the vernacular, beyond the elementary stage; and collegiate education the instruction given in institutions affiliated to the Universities. The Universities of Calcutta, Madras, and Bombay were founded in 1857, and by 1861 the new system was in general working order. In that year the number of pupils in public institutions in the Provinces of Madras, Bombay, Bengal (including Assam), and Agra amounted to about 230,000, of whom 200,000 were in the primary stage. More than 5,000 public primary schools, and 142 secondary schools, had by this time been established in these four Provinces. During the next few years the progress of primary education, though considerable, did not keep pace with the extension of education of a higher class. In 1871 there were in all British India about 518,000 pupils in primary schools, while the pupils in secondary schools numbered 206,000. The grant-in-aid system did not secure an adequate development of primary instruction; and the period following the Mutiny was one of great financial difficulty, which compelled the Government to husband its resources in order to meet the growing claims made on it for all branches of the administration. From 1865 onwards the funds available for education (especially primary education) and other local needs were augmented by the rapid development of the municipal system, and by Acts for the imposition of local cesses to supersede the semi-voluntary local taxation in force in several Provinces. The first Cess Act was passed for Sind in 1865, Madras followed in 1866, Bombay in 1869, and the United Provinces and the Punjab in 1871. The Act passed for Bengal in 1871 applied only to provision for communications: from the outset indigenous agency was more relied on in this Province than elsewhere for the spread of vernacular education, but up to that date the measures taken for its improvement had not been adequate.

Between 1871 and 1882 a remarkable development took place. In the latter year more than 2¼ million pupils were receiving instruction in 90,000 public institutions. The number of primary pupils had more than quadrupled, as against an increase of 8 per cent. among pupils in the secondary stage1. About 6,000 scholars were under instruction in sixty-seven Arts colleges affiliated to the several Universities.

A Commission was appointed in 1882 to review the progress and criticize the working of the system. The Government of India was able to congratulate itself on the result, and the general principles of 1854 were reaffirmed and amended, and supplemented by a number of fresh instructions. Shortly after this the management of Government schools was, in large measure, made over to municipalities and District boards under Lord Ripon's scheme of local self-government. The progress since 1881–2 has been considerable; but the rate of development in primary education which occurred in the preceding decade has not been maintained, while during the past few years the work has been greatly hindered by plague and famine.

At the end of the year 1901–2 nearly 4,000,000 students were under instruction in about 105,000 public institutions of all grades, and more than 600,000 pupils were being taught in about 43,000 private institutions outside the scope of the department of Public Instruction. Compared with 1881–2 the number of pupils in primary schools had increased by 49 per cent., and of pupils in secondary schools by 180 per cent., the rate of progress of primary education having again fallen below that of higher instruction. More than 17,500 undergraduates were at the end of the same year receiving instruction in 145 Arts colleges, while 46 colleges for training in law, medicine, and other professional studies had an aggregate attendance of nearly 5,400 students. Notwithstanding the great increase recorded in the number of scholars, the Census of 1901 showed that in all India the proportion of persons able to read and write to the total population was still only 98 per 1,000 in the case of males and 7 per 1,000 in the case of females. The table on the next page shows the ratios in the Provinces and Native States. Burma owes its predominant place to the diffusion of elementary instruction by the Buddhist monks; but the standard of their teaching is very low, and if a higher test than the mere ability to read and write were adopted, the Province would occupy a very different position.

‘It is worthy of note that in the north-west of India, where the Aryan element in the population is believed to be strongest, the people are far more ignorant than in the east and south, where the Mongolian and Dravidian races predominate1.’ As regards religions, the order of literacy is as follows:—Pārsīs, Jains, Buddhists, Christians, Sikhs, Hindus, Muhammadans, Animists. The Census shows 68 males and 7 females in every 10,000 of the population as literate in English. Here Bombay, Madras, and Bengal hold the first place among the larger political units. There are also, and especially in Madras, a good many people who can speak English but cannot write it.

TBL-054 · FOLIO 454Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Province or State.Number of Persons per 1,000 able to read and write.
Males.Females.
Burma37845
Travancore21531
Baroda1638
Madras1199
Bombay1169
Bengal1045
Mysore938
Berār853
Assam674
Punjab643
Rājputāna622
United Provinces572
Central India553
Hyderābād553
Central Provinces542
Kashmīr381

Since 1882 the condition and progress of the educational system have been passed under periodic review, and the Government has on each occasion issued such fresh regulations and orders as appeared at the time to be desirable. The review made in 1898 was followed by a searching inquiry which revealed much diversity of practice, some serious defects, and many opportunities for improvement. Vigorous measures of reform were instituted. A conference of Indian educationalists and administrators was convened to discuss all branches of the subject; an officer from England was appointed adviser to the Government of India in educational matters, with the title of Director-General of Education; a Commission was constituted to inquire into the condition, prospects, and needs of University education; and an expert committee travelled through India to investigate and advise on the system of technical education. Some of the projected reforms have already been carried out, others are still in the preliminary stage1.

The special obligation of the Government towards the vernacular education of the masses, which was declared by the Court of Directors in 1854, was endorsed by the Education Commission of 1882, and has been reaffirmed by the Government of India whenever it has reviewed the progress of education. But the practice has fallen behind the precept. At the end of 1901–2 only about one-sixth of the boys of school-going age (calculated at 15 per cent. of the total male population) were following the primary course in public institutions. The percentage varies from 23 and 22 in Bengal and Bombay to 9 and 8 in the United Provinces and the Punjab.

Several causes have contributed to the slow growth of primary instruction. When the Education departments began to devote their attention to the extension and improvement of primary instruction, they had in the first place to deal with a portion of the population who were accustomed to and valued education, and who lived in populous and easily accessible parts of the country; and they were aided by a more or less widespread system of indigenous schools. In such circumstances progress was comparatively easy. These favourable conditions have been to a great extent exhausted, and the portion of the problem which remains to be dealt with is far harder. The benefits of education have now to be conveyed to the poorer ryots and the lower castes, who have from time immemorial lived without instruction and are altogether indifferent to it. In addition to this general cause, Local Governments and local bodies have often been hard pressed for funds; the efforts of the educated classes are more readily directed towards English than towards primary education; and the officers of the Education department have not always realized the importance of placing the advance of primary education in the forefront of their endeavours. The Government of India has recently insisted that greater efforts must be made for the expansion and improvement of primary education, and has afforded assistance from Imperial revenues. Efforts have also been made of late years to popularize primary instruction, by simplifying the course of study and bringing it into closer relationship with the daily life and avocations of the people.

A comparatively small number of primary schools are now managed directly by the Government; most are administered by municipalities and District boards, or by private persons or bodies. Many of these private institutions are indigenous schools which have been brought to conform to the requirements of the Education department; others are schools of a more modern type started by native proprietors; others again belong to various missionary societies. In Bengal and Burma, where educational progress has proceeded on the lines of developing indigenous schools, the very large majority are under private management; in Bombay, where primary education owes its advancement to the local rates, municipal and District board schools greatly outnumber the private establishments. Madras, the United Provinces, and the Punjab stand in between, the former tending towards the Bengal and the two latter towards the Bombay system. Municipal and local board schools are required to conform to the general regulations of the Government with regard to equipment, curriculum, method of instruction, &c., and board schools are in general subject to the control of the Education department in matters of the first importance. Most of the private schools which come within the scope of the Education department receive a grant-in-aid from Provincial or Local funds; others conform to the departmental standards in the hope of qualifying for this aid, or of securing the privilege of receiving Government scholars and sending up their pupils for the Government scholarship and certificate examinations. Grants are given in aid of salaries, and for buildings, furniture, appliances, books, scholarships, and special needs. The Education Commission of 1882 recommended that salary grants should be given on the results-grant system, i.e. on the result of an individual examination of the pupils in the different classes. This system is still in general force, but some Provincial Governments use other methods in conjunction with it. Thus in Madras and Bombay the best schools are put on a fixed grant list, and in the Central Provinces fixed allowances are supplemented by results grants. The results-grant system was adopted in the first instance on the strength of European precedents; but it has now been finally condemned in England, while experience in India has proved that it is unsatisfactory in its influence on education and uncertain in its financial effect. The Government of India has recently directed that it should be replaced by more equitable tests of efficiency, depending on the number of scholars in attendance, the buildings provided for their accommodation, the circumstances of the locality, the qualifications of the teachers, the nature of the instruction given, and the outlay from other sources. The Educational codes of the various Provinces are now being revised so as to embody this important reform.

The type of primary school varies from the primitive village pāthshāla or maktab to the modern institutions in which the pupils are educated in accordance with approved European methods. The Bombay local rates schools are in general better built, equipped, and managed than the Bengal indigenous institutions. Many of the latter have not got much beyond their primitive condition, and a quarter of their pupils are little children who cannot read or write. Efforts are now being made to improve the character of the instruction imparted. The Bombay schools are also more expensive. The average cost of educating a child in a Bombay primary school is Rs. 6–6–4 a year, while in Bengal it is only Rs. 2–12–0 and in Burma Rs. 2–12–9. Boarding schools are very rare, save in the case of missionary schools and some institutions in the large towns. The day's work is in general about five or six hours, and the times of study are altered to suit the seasons. About one-tenth of the boys in the primary stage of education receive instruction in the primary classes of secondary schools, forming nearly two-thirds of the boys in such schools. The system varies in different Provinces. In Bombay the complete course of vernacular education is given in the primary schools, and a boy who is to receive an English education first goes through the lower classes of a primary school and is then transferred to an English school. In Bengal, on the other hand, each class of school is generally complete in itself, and the nature of the instruction in the lower classes has hitherto depended on the character of the institution. The school career of a child begins, as a rule, at about five years of age, and the primary course, which for the great majority includes all the education they receive, lasts for five years. It is divided into a lower and an upper stage, but many schools and pupils do not go beyond the lower course.

The course of instruction in a primary school is simple. In general the maximum which it attempts is to teach the child to read and write his own language; to enable him to do easy sums and understand simple forms of native accounts and the village land-record papers; and to give him a rudimentary knowledge of common objects, geography, agriculture, sanitation, and the history of India. Madras and Bombay may be taken to illustrate the nature of this instruction. In Madras the course extends from the alphabet and counting to the compulsory subjects of reading, recitation, grammar, writing, spelling, and European and native arithmetic. The following additional subjects are voluntary : kindergarten occupations, elementary science, a second language (either English or an Indian vernacular), drawing, geography, singing, hygiene, history of India, agriculture, mensuration, and the elementary subjects of the technical course. The principle is to require few compulsory subjects and to offer a selection of voluntary subjects suitable to all classes of schools. In the infant classes in the Bombay schools the subjects are the alphabet and numerals ; forms, colours, and familiar objects ; recitation and singing in unison ; and infant drill, exercises, and games. In the seventh or highest stage, which terminates vernacular education in this Presidency, the subjects are arithmetic, the first book of Euclid, native accounts, a reading book, grammar, and etymology, the reading of manuscript, writing, history and government of India, geography, and hygiene, which forms the end of a series of science and object lessons. A graduated course of manual training or elementary science may be substituted for this course.

The general complaint has been made against the Indian system of primary education that it does not serve to train the faculties or assist the pupils in their future life. There is said to be too much unintelligent learning by rote, and too much grammar and complicated English arithmetic. Some improvement has been made in recent years in obedience to instructions issued by the Government of India in 1897. Almost all Provinces have introduced kindergarten methods and object lessons, and have framed courses intended to train the faculties of children. The course which the Government of Bengal is now endeavouring to introduce begins with a simple kindergarten system in which objects familiar in the daily life of the children are used, and object lessons are freely employed throughout as a medium of instruction and training. In each subject the child is led from the more to the less familiar ; thus the study of geography begins with maps of the school and compound and of the village. It is an illustration of the magnitude of educational problems in India that 50,000 teachers in Bengal have to be instructed in the new methods.

Without good teachers the best of regulations and courses will fail. The three million ‘public’ primary pupils of India require an army of teachers for their instruction, and the supply of an adequate number of properly qualified persons is perhaps the greatest difficulty of the educational problem. Hitherto the chief defects have been insufficient pay and training. The pay of primary school teachers varies ordinarily from about Rs. 18 a month in the Bombay Presidency to Rs. 6 or 10 in the United Provinces, and Rs. 5 or 6 in Bengal, where the monthly salary of the gurū is supplemented by fees and presents in cash or grain. There are no fixed fees : they are a matter of arrangement between the teacher and his pupils or their parents. It has now been recognized that the enhancement of the pay of primary teachers in Provinces where it is unduly low has a special claim on the increased expenditure from Imperial revenues which is being devoted to educational objects. Considerable improvement has also been effected of recent years in the training of primary teachers, as will be mentioned in a later section of this chapter.

The account given above applies to primary education in general, which is of course most developed in towns. The rural schools require separate notice. They present a problem the magnitude and difficulty of which is exceeded only by its importance. The mass of the peasantry are still utterly illiterate. In Upper India one frequently comes across villages with only one or two men who can sign their names ; in Bengal and in Southern and Western India matters are better, but everywhere ignorance is a prominent characteristic of the cultivating class. This ignorance has become a more serious disability and a greater danger than it was in earlier days ; for the railways have revolutionized the conditions of village life, have brought the cultivator into contact with the commercial world, and have given to the produce of his lands an easily realizable monetary value which it never before possessed. He is thus beset by new temptations to extravagance, and called on to deal with shrewd men with whom it is not possible for him to transact business on equal terms. From another point of view the ignorance of the villager is a great obstacle to the amelioration of his position. Immense pains have been taken to introduce improved agricultural methods and to remove the grossly insanitary conditions which still prevail in the majority of Indian villages. It is difficult for such schemes to achieve wide and lasting success when applied to a population too ignorant to understand their meaning or appreciate their value. The Government has not failed to perceive the extreme importance of the problem, and ever since the days of Mr. Thomason it has been the subject of repeated investigation and experiment. During recent years considerable improvements have been made in the character of the village schools, and the subjects and methods of instruction have been brought into greater harmony with the conditions and requirements of peasant life. The subject has received special attention in Bombay, the Central Provinces, and the Punjab. Side by side with the 'superior' schools, there exist in Bombay special schools which teach five simpler standards in place of the ordinary seven, the whole course being designed to occupy the child from the age of about six to twelve. In the infant class the rural schools give the same course of instruction as the 'superior' schools; thenceforward they devote themselves to the three R's, while particular attention is paid to native accounts, simple forms of agreement, the plants and animals of the locality, its agricultural products, and the elements of a knowledge of sanitation. The reform of village schools in the Central Provinces began in the year 1893-4, but was not very successful until the whole system was remodelled in 1899. The rural school contains five classes, and the age of the pupils ranges from five to fourteen. School is held in the morning and afternoon, but the bulk of the pupils attend only in the morning and are therefore called 'half-timers.' The few 'whole-timers' consist as a rule of the sons of the landlord, the village trader, the patwāri (accountant), and the schoolmaster himself. The 'half-timers' are taught reading, writing, arithmetic, kindergarten, drawing, geography, agriculture, simple facts about physical science, and to understand the land records of the village. The General Readers provide the lessons in agriculture and science, and the only other books required are a simple Geography and an Arithmetic. Instruction is made as practical as possible: thus the readings are accompanied by explanations and illustrated by object lessons; in the writing lessons the boys are taught to write imaginary letters; the course in arithmetic includes the ordinary native methods of notation and accounts; and the patwāri takes the boys to the field and explains the papers on the spot1. The Punjab has, since 1886, had zamīndāri schools in which, to prevent boys from getting out of touch with field occupations, it was provided that they should attend daily for one short period, either in the morning or in the evening. This rule is however frequently infringed, native arithmetic has been found to be generally neglected, and the agricultural lessons are not practically illustrated. It is in contemplation to abandon the zamīndāri schools, and to deal with rural schools under a system which will not be so ambitious as the present scheme but will retain its useful features.

There are three classes of secondary schools—the vernacular and English middle schools, and the high schools.

The vernacular middle school course is a prolongation of the primary course, and completes the instruction of those who do not aspire to an English education. In most Provinces the course lasts for three years, and should be completed at about the age of thirteen. It is less popular, and affords a less ready opening for employment, than the English course, and in 1901–2 only 27·3 per cent. of the secondary school pupils were in vernacular middle schools. In Madras the compulsory subjects are a vernacular language, arithmetic, geography, and the history of India. The following subjects are voluntary : elementary science, a vernacular or classical language or English, the history of England, geometry and algebra, and any subject of the Madras technical course. The Government of India has recently issued instructions with the object of preventing the undue sacrifice of the vernaculars to English.

The spread of English education accounts for most of the 202 per cent. increase in pupils in the secondary stage which took place between 1870–1 and 1901–2. At the end of the latter year nearly 430,000 pupils in boys’ schools were learning English, the proportion to population being highest in Madras (where English is more commonly spoken than in other Provinces) and lowest in the United Provinces.

Government takes a somewhat larger share, and municipalities and local boards a much smaller share, in the conduct of English than of primary schools, but in all the large Provinces the great majority of English schools are under private management. This preponderance of private institutions conforms to the principle laid down by the Education Commission of 1882, in accordance with the declaration of the dispatch of 1854, that ‘it is ordinarily expedient to provide the means of secondary education only where adequate local co-operation is forthcoming ; and that therefore, in all ordinary cases, secondary schools for instruction in English be hereafter established by the state preferably on the policy of grants-in-aid.’ It is, however, now recognized that to maintain a satisfactory level of efficiency a model secondary school under direct Government management is needed for each District. Private secondary schools may not be admitted to grants-in-aid unless they supply a real educational want and provide due guarantees for stability and efficient management.

The English secondary school stage is divided into middle and high school sections, which really form portions of the same course. The two courses comprise five or six classes ; and if a year were spent in each class, in addition to five years in the primary school, the English school education should ordinarily be completed by the time the pupil attained the age of sixteen. Clever pupils are often pushed through more quickly, and sometimes matriculate at a University at the early age of twelve or thirteen. This hurrying through the course tends to injure the physique and interfere with the mental training of the student, and the Indian Universities Commission of 1902 recommended that a minimum age-limit of fifteen should be fixed for matriculation.

In English secondary schools the main course has hitherto led up to the matriculation or entrance examination of one or other of the Universities. There are other courses of a more practical character leading up to different examinations, but they have not in the past succeeded in attracting any considerable proportion of the students. A purely literary education has been more popular among both parents and students, as being in itself more attractive to them and as affording a better opening for remunerative employment. The matriculation has generally been accepted as a qualifying test by Government and private employers as well as by the Universities, and has been regarded as the common goal of the school career. In 1901–2 nearly 23,000 candidates presented themselves for the matriculation examination of the several Universities. The general subjects are English; an Oriental or European classical language, or an Indian or European vernacular; elementary mathematics; and history and geography. Some Universities include elementary science in the course. The influence of this examination on school teaching is said not to have been in all respects beneficial. It is alleged that sound methods of training are neglected, because the attention of teachers and scholars is often concentrated on the cramming of material for use in the examination. Some matriculates have been found so deficient in knowledge of English that they cannot follow college lectures, and at the same time they may be unable to write their own language easily and idiomatically. The number of candidates is so great that it is difficult to devise an examination which shall form an adequate test of intelligent study and at the same time maintain a reasonably even standard.

The ‘school final examinations,’ which are alternative to matriculation, arose from the recommendations of the Education Commission of 1882. That Commission found the high schools used almost exclusively as preparatory schools for the University, and the course of instruction dominated by the University standard. They reported that there was a real need for some modern course which would fit boys for industrial or commercial pursuits, and pointed out that the matriculation did not serve this purpose, but was intended to ascertain whether the candidate was ripe for University studies. They thought that bifurcation might properly take place within two years of the end of the secondary course, and recommended that in the upper classes of high schools there should be two types of instruction, one leading to matriculation, and the other of a more practical character, intended to fit boys for commercial and non-literary pursuits. The conclusions of the Commission were accepted by the Government, but the progress made in giving effect to them has been slow. Pupils were reluctant to abandon the hope of a University career, with its many attendant advantages, two years before the end of their school life. Of recent years, however, the advantages of a practical training have increased considerably as compared with those to be derived from an exclusively literary education, and a greater degree of success has attended the efforts to impart a more modern character to the Indian high schools. In 1901–2 the examinations alternating with the matriculation were the upper secondary examination in Madras, the school final examination in Bombay and the United Provinces, the science entrance examination of the Punjab University, and the Punjab clerical and commerce examination. Classes have recently been established in a few Bengal high schools leading up to the civil engineering college, and to commerce and the industries, but no examination had been held in the new courses of study up to the year 1901–2. In Madras the examination is conducted by the Government and in the other Provinces by the University. The Allahābād and the Punjab science examinations admit to the University; the others do not. These examinations replace the matriculation as a qualification for Government service in Bombay, while in Madras, the United Provinces, and the Punjab they form an alternative qualification. The monopoly accorded in this respect to the Bombay examination has rendered it much more popular than the corresponding tests in other Provinces. In 1901–2, while, as already stated, nearly 23,000 candidates presented themselves for matriculation, the number of candidates for the various alternative examinations was less than 2,000, of whom nearly 1,200 belonged to Bombay. The general question of the school final examinations in their relation to Government and other employment, and to the Universities, is at present under consideration. There are three compulsory subjects for the Bombay school final examination, namely, English, a second language, and mathematics; and a list of ten optional subjects, including agriculture, drawing, and manual training, and a further course in English, from which the candidate must choose two and may not choose more than three subjects. The school final examination in the United Provinces differs from the matriculation chiefly in prescribing five optional subjects of a practical character, of which the candidate must take at least one.

There are five Universities in British India, situated in Calcutta, Madras, Bombay, Allahābād, and Lahore. The first three were founded in 1857 on the model of the University of London, and their incorporation was one of the immediate results of the dispatch of 1854. But, as has already been shown, Indian collegiate education dates back many years before the foundation of the Universities. During the first half of the nineteenth century a number of colleges were opened in various parts of India by the Government, by missionary societies, and by educated natives associated together for the purpose. The first Government colleges were designed for the cultivation of the Oriental classics; but as the advantages of Western education became recognized, the Oriental aspect of collegiate education sank into the background, and colleges were founded and maintained for the purpose of giving an English education. The various Government and aided colleges were under the guidance of semi-official Councils or Committees of Education, who were, prior to 1854, entrusted with the general control of public instruction in the three Presidencies. The District high schools were connected with the colleges by a system of scholarships, and the students found their encouragement and reward in the Government and other employment which was opened to them by a college career. The Punjab (formerly Lahore) University College was incorporated as the University of the Punjab in 1882. This college had been established ‘in part fulfilment of the wishes of a large number of the chiefs, nobles, and influential classes of the Punjab,’ and the University was instituted under similar influences. It differs from the other Universities in having an Oriental side, which has not hitherto been very successful. The University of Allahābād was established in 1887.

The government of each University is vested in a Chancellor, Vice-Chancellor, and Senate, and the regulations are subject to Government sanction. The Governor-General is Chancellor of the Calcutta University; elsewhere the Chancellor is the head of the Government of the Province in which the University is situated. The original Senates were composed of Fellows specially qualified to advise on educational affairs. In course of time the number of Fellows1 was unduly increased, and Fellowships were bestowed as a compliment on persons without special educational knowledge or experience. This practice has injured the good government of the Universities, and the Indian Universities Commission recommended a reduction in the size of the Senates and the restriction of membership to persons qualified to assist in the control of higher education. An Act (VIII of 1904) has recently been passed to carry out this and other recommendations of the Commission; and its adoption should materially increase the efficiency of the Universities, which will hereafter be bodies whose function it is to teach as well as to examine, and which will exercise a closer control over their affiliated colleges. They will also receive greater assistance from Government than has hitherto been the case. The executive management of University affairs lies in the hands of a Syndicate, consisting of the Vice-Chancellor and a small number of Fellows. The members of the Senate are distributed according to Faculties. In all the Universities, except Bombay, there are Boards of Studies whose principal duty is to recommend textbooks and courses of study.

Higher education spread quickly under the impetus given by the foundation of the Universities. Colleges were multiplied, in some cases perhaps too rapidly, and the number of students continually increased. The progress is illustrated by the figures contained in the table at the end of this chapter. Colleges are classed as first or second grade, according as they prepare for the full degree examination or only up to an intermediate stage. In the latter case they are, for the most part, really high schools with college classes grafted on to them. In the year 1901–2 nearly 1,500 students passed the examinations for the degree of Bachelor of Arts or Science. It is sometimes said that the supply of graduates is in excess of the demand, and that their training is meagre and superficial. There is no reason to believe that the former allegation is well founded ; with regard to the latter the Indian Universities Commission were not disposed to confirm the sweeping condemnation that has sometimes been passed on the University system. They found that many of the colleges command the services of able and devoted teachers, and that the students as a class are not wanting either in natural talent or in industry. At the same time they admitted that the acquirements of Indian graduates are in many cases inadequate and superficial. The defects in the system are mainly attributable to laxity in admitting colleges into the University system (which will be remedied by the legislation already referred to), want of adequate supervision, and faults in the methods of examination and courses of study.

The colleges in India are too widely scattered to enable the Universities ever to become institutions similar in character to Oxford and Cambridge ; but the Universities are already more than mere examining bodies, in so far as their students are in general drawn from institutions which have been expressly affiliated to them, and they exercise a control over the teaching in those institutions by setting the standards of examination and prescribing the courses of study. Beyond this they have hitherto exerted little or no influence in moulding the character and securing the efficiency of the colleges affiliated to them. Some of the larger colleges, whether managed by the Government, by missionary societies, or by native proprietors, are fine institutions, well housed and equipped, and with an adequate and well-qualified staff. From these the scale descends until at the bottom are to be found small collegiate classes attached to schools in remote country districts, where a few students are given some sort of instruction in the first portion of the University course. Under the recent legislation above referred to the Universities will in the future be able to do much to raise the standard of collegiate life. In granting and continuing the privilege of affiliation careful regard will be had to the government and stability of the institution, and to the capacity of its teaching staff, while particular attention will be paid to buildings, equipment, and the residence of students and teachers. Unfair competition with other colleges in the matter of fees will also be guarded against.

The majority of Indian undergraduates now live with their friends, or in lodgings, and visit college mainly to attend the prescribed lectures. The residential system is, however, gaining ground, and it is the policy of the Government to give it every encouragement. The Muhammadan college at Alīgarh is the only Arts college which possesses a complete system of residence, discipline, and corporate life on the English model, but its great success has been facilitated by its being designed to serve a single community. In more general institutions caste and other difficulties are considerable, but these are being gradually overcome, and of late years the system of college hostels in which students board under supervision has been largely developed. In another direction, also, collegiate life is extending its influence outside the lecture room. Athletic sports, and college debating and literary societies, are growing in popularity and are leading to a closer and more friendly association between professors and students and among students themselves. Lecture hours in an Indian University are longer than in England, and it is said that fewer lectures and more tutorial assistance would improve the character of the instruction. The private ‘coach’ is almost unknown.

All the Universities grant degrees in Arts and Law; all except Madras have separate Science schools; and all except Allāhābād give degrees or diplomas in Medicine and Engineering. After matriculation an undergraduate wishing to take a degree in Arts or Science must, unless specially admitted as a private student, go through a four years’ course at a college affiliated to the University. In the middle of the course an Intermediate or ‘First Arts’ examination is held1. In Calcutta the subjects for this examination are English, a second language, mathematics, physics, and chemistry; and candidates may also take up either logic, history, physiology, or sanitary science. Calcutta is the only University which has a separate pass and honours course for the degree of Bachelor of Arts, but in all Universities successful candidates are in general divided into classes. The Calcutta course may be taken to illustrate the character of the studies for the degree of B.A. It is divided into two alternatives, one of a more literary, and the other of a more scientific, character. The literary side includes English, philosophy, and either a classical language, history, or mathematics. The subjects of the science course are English, mathematics, and either physical science, botany, or geology. The degree of Master of Arts is given on the results of a further examination, and in some Universities after a fresh period of prescribed study. The choice of subjects includes languages, history, philosophy, mathematics, and physical or natural science. In the older Universities the standard of this examination is severe and success in it is a guarantee of high attainments : in 1901–2 138 students took the degree of M.A., of whom 79 belonged to Bengal. The science course is of the same length as the course in arts, and candidates must in some cases pass a special intermediate examination before appearing for this degree. The Calcutta course for the degree of Bachelor of Science comprises English (a short essay on some scientific subject), statics and dynamics, physics and chemistry, and any two of the following subjects : physiology, botany, zoology, geology, hydrostatics, and astronomy. The Universities of Calcutta, Allahābād, and the Punjab prescribe a further course for the degree of Doctor of Science. Candidates for degrees in Law must in all Universities first graduate in Arts. The regulations regarding other professional courses vary, but it is the general rule that the student must pass the Arts Intermediate examination before beginning his technical studies. An annual Convocation is held at which degrees are conferred : successful candidates appear in their gowns and hoods, and the proceedings are conducted on the model of the ceremony in an English University. Before leaving the subject of collegiate education, it should be mentioned that a number of Indian students now proceed to England to continue their studies, chiefly at Cambridge, where some of them have won high places in the tripos lists. A large proportion, however, are content to read for the bar in London, where the examination is only professional and the standard not very severe.

Education has made less progress among Muhammadans than in the Hindu portion of the population. If the total number of scholars in institutions of all kinds is considered, the comparison is not unfavourable to Muhammadans ; but about one-fourth of the total number of Muhammadan pupils are taught in ‘Korān schools’ or other indigenous elementary institutions, where the children learn by rote and often do not understand what they repeat, and of the remainder a comparatively small proportion advance much beyond the primary stage. The proportion of the Muhammadan population receiving secondary education is only two-thirds of the proportion in the case of Hindus, and for collegiate education the ratio is as low as one-third. This is not, however, the case in all parts of India : in the United Provinces, for instance, Muhammadans take the first place in both branches of higher education. A number of social and political causes have contributed to the comparative backwardness of the Muhammadans in educational matters. The principal scholastic cause is that ‘ the teaching of the mosque must precede the lessons of the school.’ The religious books of the Muhammadans are written in their classical languages ; and before the student is allowed to devote himself to secular instruction, he must often pass some years in going through a course of sacred learning. He is thus handicapped in the race with the young Hindu, whose one object is to attain an education which will fit him for an official or professional career. The Education Commission of 1882 proposed a differential treatment of the Muhammadan community in respect to education, which the Government of India found itself unable to approve. It declared that the way to success for Muhammadans lies in taking advantage, like other classes, of the facilities for higher instruction provided by the general educational system. This advice has been to some extent followed, and considerable efforts have been made by the more enlightened among the Muhammadans to foster the growth of education in their community. But progress is not yet satisfactory.

Female education in India has to encounter peculiar difficulties. The demand for school instruction for girls is of recent origin, and social customs in regard to child-marriage and the seclusion of women of the well-to-do classes hinder its growth. The Government did not take up the subject until 1849, when Lord Dalhousie informed the Bengal Council of Education that henceforth its functions were to embrace female education, and the first girls’ school recognized by Government was founded shortly afterwards by a committee of native gentlemen. The dispatch of 1854 directed that female education should receive the frank and cordial support of Government, as by ‘ this means a far greater proportional impulse is imparted to the educational and moral tone of the people than by the education of men.’ The Education Commission of 1882 advised that female education should receive special encouragement and be treated with special liberality. The Government accepted this view ; and state funds are more freely used, and state management more largely resorted to, for this object than is considered desirable in the case of the education of boys. The adoption of this attitude has resulted in a considerable development of the public instruction of girls, although it still lags far behind that of their brothers. In 1871 there were 134 secondary and 1,760 primary girls’ schools ; in 1901–2 the numbers were 461 and 5,628 respectively. There are also at present ten colleges for female undergraduates. Statistics regarding the number of girl pupils cannot be pursued far back because in former times the number of girls studying in boys’ schools was not shown. The percentage of girls in public institutions to girls of school-going age was 1·6 in 1886–7, 2·1 in 1896–7, and 2·2 in 1901–2. At the end of that year there were about 393,000 female pupils in public institutions, of whom nearly one-half were in mixed boys’ and girls’ schools. The different feelings of the several Provinces with regard to co-education is strikingly shown by the fact that in Burma no less than 74 per cent. of the girls are to be found in boys’ schools, and in Madras 52 per cent., whereas in the United Provinces the proportion falls to 14 per cent., and in the Punjab to 1 per cent. The proportion of girls to boys under instruction in all India was about 1 to 9¼, being highest in Madras and lowest in the United Provinces. For the general native population the proportion is even less than that shown above, because a large number of female students are Europeans, Eurasians, or Native Christians. More schools, more and better-trained female teachers, and an adequate female inspecting agency are pressing needs to which special attention is being devoted. The character of the instruction given in girls’ schools is similar to that in institutions for boys, but the standards are in some respects lower and special subjects are introduced. Thus the Bombay course for girls includes household accounts, domestic economy, and needlework. Much assistance has been given to the cause of female education by mission schools and mission classes for home teaching.

The promotion of education among children of the lowest castes, both male and female, is a matter of peculiar difficulty. These castes were entirely illiterate under native rule ; a change in this respect was looked on with jealousy by the higher castes, who considered that knowledge ought to be their monopoly ; and the presence of low-caste children in a common school was objected to on account of the physical contamination supposed to be involved by caste rules.

‘In some Provinces, and among certain classes, the degraded castes are allowed to sit either in a veranda or on a lower section of the floor than the rest, and to deposit their books and exercises on the floor instead of handing them to the master ; but for the most part the boycotting is universal, and the master as well as the pupils and their parents have no inclination to relax the rule. Special schools are therefore maintained where the excluded classes are of numerical importance, and a great deal has been done in this way by Christian missionaries, who, especially in Madras, have made a special point of raising the status of what are conventionally, though incorrectly, termed the outcaste population1.'

Of late years, however, much of this old-time prejudice has disappeared, and nowadays the attendance of low-caste children in public schools is becoming more readily accepted.

The special importance attaching to the education of the youth of the domiciled European and Eurasian community has long been recognized by Government. Shortly after the Mutiny Lord Canning pointed out how the members of this community would, if neglected, become profitless, unmanageable, and a glaring reproach to the Government, while if cared for betimes they might prove a source of strength to British rule and of usefulness to India. Since then the problem has grown with the increase of the Eurasian population and the more common employment of Europeans in India. The great development of railways, and the establishment of large industrial concerns, such as the cotton mills of Bombay, the jute mills around Calcutta, and the tea plantations in various parts of the country, have called to India an ever-increasing number of European employés, many of whom marry and settle in the country and have to provide education and employment for their children. At the same time the young European or Eurasian educated in India finds it increasingly difficult to compete on even terms with the native of the country. Since the spread of secondary education he can claim no monopoly of Western knowledge, while his social habits and traditions make it difficult for him to live on a salary which an educated native would find sufficient. More intimate knowledge of the languages, character, and customs of the people gives a further advantage to the native in many occupations, an advantage which has been exaggerated owing to neglect on the part of Eurasians and domiciled Europeans to acquire proficiency in the vernaculars. At the same time there are many employments for which a well-educated young Eurasian or European is specially suited and to which he can obtain a ready entrance. Those engineering and industrial undertakings which engage so many recruits in England are to some, and could be to a greater, extent supplied in India. There is also a considerable demand for European and Eurasian assistance in certain branches of the public service, and in the business houses and retail concerns of the Presidency towns and other large centres of commerce and administration. While there is thus no lack of useful employment for the well-educated European or Eurasian, his self-maintenance depends entirely on his education. An uneducated European cannot support himself by working as a day-labourer or adopting the avocation of a peasant : he almost of necessity becomes an idle and mischievous member of the community. This gives the state a special interest in the education of these classes, while the fact that the English ancestor of the youth was brought to India to do work for which a European was required gives him a further claim to consideration. The poverty and other disadvantages under which the domiciled European and Eurasian classes suffer make it difficult or impossible for them to provide adequate instruction for their children, and it is therefore essential that the state should come to their assistance. It was long before this was fully recognized, and Lord Canning's warning produced little effect. Some aid was given to the various schools founded and maintained by religious societies or private persons; but it was left to Lord Lytton's Government, influenced largely by the zeal and devotion of Archdeacon Baly, to take up the question in a comprehensive and systematic manner. An inquiry was instituted which showed that a large proportion of the European and Eurasian children were growing up in a condition of absolute ignorance. The Government of India determined that this state of affairs must be stopped, and the result was the introduction, in 1881, of the Bengal code of regulations for European schools in Northern and Central India. This code was based on English and Scottish models, altered and extended to meet the special needs which existed in India. The main principle was the encouragement of all classes of European schools by means of liberal grants-in-aid based on the attendance and proficiency of the students. At the same time arrangements were made for special grants to schools in localities containing a small or poor European population, to free schools and orphanages in aid of their boarding charges, and for the boarding of children whose parents resided in places where there was no school. General courses of instruction were laid down, and primary, middle, and high school standards were fixed for the purpose of the grants. To improve the quality of the instruction, which was in many cases unsatisfactory, a system of certificated pupil-teachers was introduced. In Madras and Bombay more adequate arrangements had been made for the instruction of Europeans, and the Bengal code was not applied to those Provinces, though the Local Governments made modifications in their grant-in-aid rules in the direction of the Bengal system. The Bengal code was revised in 1895; and among other changes the system of results grants, which involved an undue amount of examination of individuals, was abolished in favour of an attendance grant awarded to every school that was declared efficient on the verdict of the Inspector. The arrangements introduced under these orders have had a marked effect in improving the education of the domiciled European and Eurasian community, and the number of scholars belonging to this class increased from about 23,500 in 1886–7 to more than 31,000 in 1901–2. Experience has, however, shown considerable defects in the working of the system. It has failed to meet the case of places in which there is a small or poor population unable to make arrangements for the schooling of their children even when assisted by the Government. The character of the teaching has not always been satisfactory, and the arrangements for certificated, licensed, and pupil teachers have failed to secure an adequate supply of well-qualified instructors. Insufficient attention has also been paid to the important subject of vernacular languages. Measures have been taken to remedy these defects; and a committee of experts was appointed in March, 1902, to draw up a fresh code, based on the Bengal model, which is to apply to all Provinces of India. An Inspector in each Province is specially charged with the duty of inspecting European schools; a training college for teachers in these schools is to be established, while stipends are to be provided for the students under training; and the systems, both of grants-in-aid and of scholarships, are being revised on a more liberal basis.

Several Chiefs' Colleges have been established during the last thirty years, of which the most important are at Ajmer, Rājkot, and Lahore, where some of the features of the English public school system have been reproduced, with the object of fitting young chiefs and nobles, physically, morally, and intellectually, for the responsibilities that lie before them. Steps have recently been taken to bring these institutions to a higher level of efficiency, and the reforms in course of execution will, it is hoped, result in giving a great impetus to the cause of education among the Indian nobility.

Until comparatively recent times the instruction in all grades of Indian schools was almost entirely literary in its character. In describing the general courses of study allusion has been made to the introduction of more modern systems of practical training, beginning with kindergarten classes for little children and extending to the scientific, commercial, and industrial courses which have been opened in some of the high schools. Special institutions have also been established for various branches of technical training, as, for instance, industrial schools; schools of art; commercial and technical institutions; and colleges for the study of engineering, agriculture, medicine, and law.

At the bottom of the scale come the industrial schools. Under the native industrial system the child learns his hereditary craft from his father or is apprenticed to a mistri, or mastercraftsman, who is often a relative of the pupil. There is no regular fee, but a small present is often paid to the owner or foreman of the shop, and in some native trades a religious ceremony may take place at the time of apprenticeship. The child begins his work at a very early age; at first he is expected to undertake the menial duties of the shop and is put to cleaning the tools; later he begins to perform the simplest operations of the trade. There is little definite instruction, but the boy gradually acquires skill by handling the tools and watching the workmen at their task. As soon as he has made a little progress, the apprentice is granted a small wage which is gradually increased as he becomes more useful; and when his training is finished, he either goes out into the world or secures a place on the permanent roll of his master's shop. To the poor artisan the arrangement has this great advantage, that at a very early age the child earns his livelihood and ceases to be a burden on his parents. In former days the system answered well enough for the rude village industries which satisfied the needs of the bulk of the population, and it also succeeded in maintaining a class of workmen who dealt in metals and textile fabrics with such sense of form and colour that their work has challenged comparison with the most artistic products of the West. It has not, however, enabled the Indian artisans to keep abreast with modern industrial development. Imported articles have to a considerable extent supplanted the products of home industry, the quality of native work has in many cases deteriorated, and the workman has not taken due advantage of the wide openings afforded to him by advancing civilization and trade. The efforts made to assist him have not as yet been attended with a great measure of success. A committee appointed to investigate the subject in March, 1902, prepared a list of 123 industrial institutions, most of which are of recent origin. A few of the more important are managed by Government, some have been established by municipalities and local boards, and others are maintained by missionary societies or private benefactors. Many of the mission and private schools are aided by grants from public funds awarded on the results of industrial tests. This system has been most fully developed in the Madras Presidency, where a series of examinations—elementary, intermediate, and advanced—is held for ‘the encouragement of scientific and technical instruction, with special reference to manufactures and industries, and generally to the necessities of the practical side of life; and for testing the qualifications of persons desirous of becoming teachers of technical subjects, engineers, designers, agriculturists, commercial employés, managers of industrial establishments, employés under Government, &c.1’ The subjects most commonly taught in the industrial schools are carpentry, smith’s work, shoemaking, and tailoring. Instruction has been too much confined to these branches irrespective of the character of the local demand for craftsmen, and much of the training has thus been wasted. Less commonly taught are metal-work, weaving, carpet-making, masonry, candle-making, cane-work, gardening, and various other trades. Instruction is usually by the class system, in which the teacher causes a number of pupils to execute exercises and, when more proficient, to make whole articles. In some cases the method approaches an apprenticeship system: the teacher himself works at the trade and the articles made are sold. In the smaller schools, such as those maintained in the interior by local boards, the instruction is not always much superior to that given in the shops. The Victoria Jubilee Technical Institute in Bombay is a more advanced institution for the training of engineers, mechanicians, and craftsmen. The principal subjects of instruction are mechanical engineering, cotton manufacture, metal-working, enamelling, aluminium-working, and locomotive-driving. Some of the missionary institutions have been fairly successful in their training, and their orphanages have done good work in helping destitute children to the means of livelihood. Difficulty has been experienced in inducing pupils to attend industrial schools. This is perhaps due in part to defects in the schools themselves, but the main cause is no doubt the disinclination of parents to forgo the pecuniary advantages of the native apprenticeship system. Where literary instruction is combined with technical training, boys who do not belong to the artisan class join the school in order to get cheaper teaching than can be obtained elsewhere. On leaving they do not seek to follow the trade they have been taught, but join the army of clerks. The grant of stipends has been abused in a similar fashion, and steps are now being taken to confine admission to industrial schools to lads who are known by their caste or hereditary occupation to be likely to practise in after life the handicrafts taught to them. Schools for engineering and surveying, the training in which affords a prospect of Government employment, and which in some cases, as in Bengal, are connected with the engineering colleges, have had a greater success than institutions for teaching artisans. The question of improving the system of industrial education has lately been under the consideration of the Government, and provision has already been made for sending a certain number of advanced students to obtain technical training in Europe or America.

Government schools of art have been established at Calcutta, Madras, Bombay, and Lahore. They are of the nature of institutions for the study of 'arts and crafts' rather than fine art studios. The artistic genius of India has found expression chiefly in architecture and the production of articles of beauty for domestic use; and the most important function of the art school is to maintain, restore, and improve this application of Oriental art to industry and manufactures. The cultivation of the fine arts does, however, find a place in the schools, and they have, moreover, had considerable success in training draftsmen for employment as teachers and in Government and other offices. The Madras school was opened in 1850 as a private institution 'with the object of improving the taste of the native public as regards beauty of form and finish in the articles in daily use among them.' It comprises two departments: the artistic, in which drawing is taught in all its branches; and the industrial, in which instruction is given in metal-work, the art of the silversmith, the jeweller's craft, cabinet-making, carpet-weaving, cotton-weaving, pottery manufacture, engraving, and modelling. The Bombay school of art began with a drawing-class in 1857, and now gives instruction in drawing, painting, sculpture, and iron-work. Its pupils have been entrusted with much of the decorative work which adorns the city of Bombay. Attached to the art school are the Reay workshops, where the principal crafts taught are gold and silver work, enamelling, carpet-weaving, wood-carving, and ornamental copper, brass, and iron-work. In Bengal there is less indigenous art than in other parts of India, and the work in the Calcutta school is not so distinctively Oriental as in Madras and Bombay. The course is divided into two parts. The first affords a systematic training for general draftsmen, elementary drawing-masters, industrial art workmen and designers; in addition to free-hand drawing and modelling, it includes perspective and architectural drawing, painting, design, woodengraving, and lithography. The second part is intended for painters of various classes and sculptors. The various art schools have not always consistently followed their true functions, and have thus missed part of their usefulness. They have nevertheless turned out numbers of craftsmen who obtain employment in many and varied capacities, and have done something to arrest the decay of Indian art which resulted from the out-turn of large quantities of inferior work for the European market and from the deterioration of native taste by the introduction of European goods of the cheaper kinds. Under recent orders the specialization of a limited number of arts and art industries in these schools is to be preferred to the simultaneous teaching of a large number, and free admission and scholarships are to be restricted.

There are colleges of engineering in Madras, Bombay, Bengal, and the United Provinces. They train students for the various branches of the Public Works Department, as also for employment under municipalities and local boards, and to a less but increasing extent in private industrial concerns, such as jute and cotton mills, river and sea-going steamship companies, coal-mines, and electrical firms. The colleges at Roorkee in the United Provinces and at Sibpur near Calcutta are the largest. An account of the courses of study at Roorkee, where students live in residential buildings provided by the college, has been given in chapter x of this volume. The Sibpur college possesses fine buildings situated in large grounds on the banks of the Hooghly. It has well-equipped laboratories and workshops, and a large staff of European professors. The steam, oil, and gas engines and electric plant are worked by the students, and form an important part of the teaching apparatus. The college consists of three sections: the engineer department, which prepares students for the University Engineering degree and for the higher branches of the Public Works Department; the apprentice department, for training foreman-mechanics and overseers; and an artisan class. The engineering course lasts for five years, and is followed by a further year of practical work. The college students may be seen in all stages of training—in one place hammering wooden blocks with mallets and fashioning pieces of lead as an introduction to the smith's craft; in another studying geodesy or the integral calculus. In early days the well-to-do classes disliked their children being set to manual work; but the excellent openings offered by an engineering training have to a large extent overcome this prejudice, and at Sibpur European, Eurasian, and native boys all work together.

Agriculture forms one of the subjects of instruction in a number of the industrial schools; and agricultural colleges, or sections of colleges, have been established in Madras, Bombay, the United Provinces, and the Central Provinces. These collegiate institutions have not, however, as yet found much favour in the eyes of the landholding class, and are chiefly used as an avenue for entrance into Government service. In Bengal there were formerly agricultural classes at Sibpur near Calcutta; but these are now being replaced by a central agricultural college for the whole of India, provided with an agricultural research institute, and an experimental cultivation and cattle-breeding farm, at Pūsa in the Darbhangā District of Bihār. This college is to give instruction of a much more advanced character than is available at those now existing, and students from the latter will be encouraged to carry on their studies on a higher plane at Pūsa.

The Universities Commission found the equipment of some of the agricultural colleges in need of improvement; and the Government of India has suggested the establishment of special schools for the sons of landholders, in which the course should include practical training in subjects such as agriculture, land-surveying, and farm book-keeping. Veterinary colleges and schools have been opened in several parts of India, and have done good work in training students as veterinary assistants for work under the Government or local boards. A number of these assistants (sālutris) were sent to South Africa and China during the recent campaigns, and a few have found employment in British Protectorates.

Until recent times there was little demand for instruction in the subjects which form a training for a commercial career, and little attention was paid to them in Indian colleges and schools. This condition of affairs is undergoing change in the large centres of commerce and industry. In Bombay the development has been rapid, and the new demand has been met by the establishment of several special institutions, the most important of which is the Byramjī Jījībhoy Pārsī commercial school. The Bombay Education department has recognized that the subject must now receive careful attention in secondary schools. In other places also commercial classes have been opened: thus, the Reid Christian College at Lucknow has a ‘business’ department in which shorthand and typewriting are taught. The Allāhābād school final examination includes book-keeping and political economy among its optional subjects. In the clerical and commercial division of the Punjab school final examination the compulsory subjects are English, dictation, and caligraphy, précis writing and correspondence, general and commercial geography, book-keeping, and commercial arithmetic. Urdū, the native system of accounts, and shorthand writing are optional subjects. The new Bengal examination leading up to commerce and the industries is less specialized. Commercial subjects are included in the Madras technical examinations. The examinations of the London Chamber of Commerce, which have been held in Bombay, are recognized in the code for European schools.

The instruction given for the medical profession has been perhaps the most successful branch of technical education. The natives of India show considerable aptitude for medicine; many of them have attained a creditable degree of proficiency, and some have gained distinction in the profession. Medical instruction is given in the Government colleges at Calcutta, Madras, Bombay, and Lahore, and in twenty-two Government medical schools. The Calcutta and Madras colleges were founded in 1835 for the training of subordinate medical officers, who were urgently needed as soon as the Government turned its attention to supplying medical relief to the general population. The Bombay and Lahore colleges were founded in 1845 and 1860. The early pupils of the Calcutta college received stipends to support them during the period of training, and a first batch of four entered the Government service in 1838. At first there was some prejudice against European medical methods, and especially against the practice of dissection, but these difficulties were successfully overcome. The medical schools were founded later, mainly for the purpose of training for the public service officers (Hospital Assistants) of a lower standard than the Assistant Surgeons educated in the colleges. The four Bengal schools were established in 1873–5. In 1901–2 about 4,200 pupils were under training in all medical colleges and schools. The colleges prepare mainly for the University degrees which qualify for employment as an Assistant Surgeon; they also train classes of military pupils. The length of the full course is in general five years, and it includes preliminary, scientific, and professional training. The colleges are attached to large hospitals in which clinical instruction is given, the physicians and surgeons of these hospitals being the college professors. The course in the medical schools is shorter and less advanced, and instruction is given partly in the vernacular. On leaving college or school a large proportion of the medical students are employed in hospitals and dispensaries and in the other public capacities described in chapter xiv. Others take up private practice, in which they have been increasingly successful; while others again obtain posts under private employers of labour, such as managers of tea gardens.

The system of legal instruction varies in the different Provinces. In Madras, Bombay, and Lahore there are centralized law schools, while in Bengal and the United Provinces law classes are attached to a number of Arts colleges. There are separate courses of instruction for students preparing for ordinary pleadership, and for those reading for the University examinations or the higher native bar. Neither of the existing systems has worked well. The students are said to attend lectures merely to secure the certificate required for admission to the examinations, and afterwards to pick up what knowledge they can from textbooks. The law libraries are generally poor, and the teaching, especially in the classes attached to Arts colleges, is inadequate. The Universities Commission advised that the question of creating or maintaining and improving good central schools of law should be taken up at each of the Universities. Natives of India have a natural talent for legal subjects, and notwithstanding the defects in the system of instruction the local bar has produced many eminent lawyers.

The provision of an adequate training for the army of teachers required for the instruction of several million scholars is one of the most difficult of Indian educational problems. The dispatch of 1854 referred to the deficiency of qualified schoolmasters and the imperfect methods of teaching which prevailed, and directed the establishment of training schools and classes for masters in each Presidency. The Education Commission of 1882 laid particular stress on the importance of these instructions, and recommended that all Government teachers in secondary schools should be required to pass a test in the principles and practice of teaching. It has not yet been possible to work up to this standard, but in all Provinces efforts are being made, with varying success, to train teachers for schools.

In the case of primary teachers and the lower masters of secondary schools the courses of study and the examinations are organized by the Local Governments, and central and District schools are maintained for their instruction by the Government, and in some cases by local boards and missionary societies. The result of the training given in these schools has been on the whole satisfactory. Stipends are frequently given to the pupils, who then bind themselves to teach for a specified period. The courses include general and technical subjects and practical training. The total number of schools for male teachers amounted in 1901–2 to about 110, and the number of students to nearly 4,400. On the surface these figures show practically no advance on the statistics of 1871, but they represent a different class of instruction. Many of the schools included in the 1871 list were not normal schools in the true sense of the word, but were directed mainly to the general education of the ill-taught masters of the smaller schools. Institutions of this nature have become less necessary with the advance of vernacular education. They still exist in Madras, Bengal, and Assam, but have been excluded from the figures given above. The schools for female teachers have increased greatly in number during the same period. In 1901–2 there were about 50 schools, containing about 1,250 pupils. Many of the female normal schools are maintained by missionaries, and in Madras the majority of the students are native Christians.

The professional teaching of head masters and other principal masters of secondary schools and of assistant professors for colleges has received less attention than the normal training of lower grade teachers. A few institutions have been established for this more advanced instruction, the best example of which is the Teachers' College at Madras. The students in this institution are divided into senior and junior. The seniors are graduates of the Madras University and train for its degree of Licentiate in Teaching. The juniors must have passed the Intermediate or matriculation examination of the University, and are subjected to a Government test at the end of the course. Each student signs an agreement by which he binds himself to serve in a Government or aided school for three years after training, and in return receives a stipend varying from Rs. 10 to Rs. 20 a month according to his scholastic qualifications. The senior students receive instruction in organization, method, school management, and the history and principles of education, and all students are taught drawing and drill. Attached to the college is a school in which the students receive practical instruction in the methods of teaching. The students are supervised and controlled by assistant professors styled superintendents. At the beginning of each period of instruction the student brings to the superintendent 'notes of lessons' which show what he is going to teach. The superintendent watches the teaching, notes the good and bad points, and explains to the student the mistakes he has made. Periodical 'criticism lessons' are given, in which, after the lesson, the student-teacher is criticized first by the other normal students and afterwards by the principal. The lectures on method are illustrated by model lessons delivered by the professor, followed by a discussion. Every student is taught to draw neatly and clearly on the blackboard.

The table at the end of this chapter shows the total expendiure on public education at different periods. The figures for 1860–1 are incomplete. Between 1870–1 and 1901–2 the expenditure rose from 121 to 401 lakhs, the greatest increase occurring between 1881–2 and 1891–2. Owing to changes in classification and to the incompleteness of the earlier figures, it is difficult to carry the examination of detail very far back, and the figures for 1870–1 cannot be compared with those for later periods. The expenditure from Provincial revenues rose from 74 lakhs in 1881–2 to 104 lakhs in 1901–2. In 1881–2 the expenditure from municipal and local board funds was 32 lakhs; in 1891–2 it was 68, and in 1901–2 74 lakhs. The great rise between 1881 and 1891 marks the change due to the introduction of Lord Ripon's system of local self-government. The expenditure met from fees shows an increase from 44 lakhs in 1881–2 to 127 lakhs in 1901–2, indicating the growing interest taken by the people in the education of their children. Expenditure from other sources, the major portion of which consists of the private funds of aided and unaided institutions, increased from 38 lakhs in 1881–2 to 96 lakhs in 1901–2. Turning to the objects of expenditure, the total figures for 1881–2 cannot be compared with those for 1901–2, because in the former case all girls' schools are lumped together instead of being distributed by classes. Taking the figures for male institutions only, expenditure on primary schools shows a rise from 69 to 105 lakhs; on secondary schools from 44 to 109 lakhs; on colleges from 17 to 37½ lakhs; and on training and technical schools from 9 to 20½ lakhs. Even granting that the expenditure on secondary schools is largely derived from fees and other private sources, it is not satisfactory that the total should have outstripped the expenditure on primary education. In March, 1902, the Government of India made grants from Imperial revenues to the Local Governments aggregating 40 lakhs a year, to assist them to meet additional expenditure on primary education and on the various other reforms which recent investigation into the condition of education has shown to be necessary.

Lord Ripon's Government, in reviewing the report of the Education Commission of 1882, directed that private effort should be systematically encouraged by co-operation in raising fees, so that less and less aid might be required from public funds. This instruction has not been systematically followed : the rates vary largely according to Provinces and class of management, and in some cases they have fallen rather than risen. The Presidency College, Calcutta, charges Rs. 144 a year for fees; the Elphinstone College, Bombay, Rs. 120; aided colleges in the United Provinces, on an average Rs. 69; and similar institutions in Bombay, Madras, and Bengal, Rs. 67, Rs. 50, and Rs. 45 respectively. The fees in unaided colleges in Bengal average only Rs. 15 a year, the average being lowered by the fact that many students are admitted free. The fees in secondary aided schools average, in the United Provinces, Rs. 17; in Bombay, Rs. 16; in Madras, Rs. 11; and in Bengal, Rs. 8 per annum. In primary schools the average fee works out to only about R. 1 a year. The rate is lower in board than in aided schools, because the agricultural population, who contribute towards the land cess which is a main support of the board schools, are, in some Provinces, exempted in whole or in part from the payment of fees for the education of their children. The failure to impose a reasonable minimum fee has in many cases led to loss of efficiency, the employment of ill-qualified instructors, and undesirable competition between rival institutions. As observed on page 428 the recent Universities Act is intended to check such improper competition in the case of colleges.

A system of state scholarships has long played an important part in public instruction in India. As far back as 1839, Lord Auckland proposed to connect the chief District schools with the central colleges by attaching to the latter scholarships to which the best scholars of the former might be eligible. The Education dispatch of 1854 suggested the extension of this system and its adoption with regard to schools of a lower description, ‘so that superior talent in every class may receive that encouragement and development which it deserves.’ The Education Commission of 1882 found the system in operation to a greater or less degree in all Provinces, laid stress on its importance, and recommended the grant of scholarships by open competition. A gifted boy may now pass from the village school to the University, and thence into the public service, by a graduated series of state scholarships. As a child he might win a primary scholarship which would take him to the middle school, and another scholarship at the end of the middle school course would carry him through his school career. His next step would be to gain a scholarship at the entrance examination of the University. He would hold this for two years and might then renew it at the Intermediate examination. This last scholarship might be worth Rs. 20 a term, and would enable him to complete the University course for the Bachelor's degree. Finally, it should be mentioned that the Government annually allots two scholarships of £200 a year for three years to Indian graduates, in order to allow them to pursue their studies at a British University. In addition to the state scholarships there are a number of private scholarships, many of which are attached to one or other of the Universities. A few postgraduate fellowships and scholarships have been founded for the encouragement of advanced study and research.

In a system of public instruction in which the management of schools and colleges is largely left to local and private agency assisted by state contribution, the adequacy of the arrangements for inspection and control is a matter of the first importance. The main controlling agency is the Education department maintained by each Local Government, which, in addition to providing Inspectors, furnishes the professors and teachers for the Government schools. The department is divided into the Indian, Provincial, and Subordinate services. The Indian service is mainly recruited from among graduates of the Universities of the United Kingdom, and its members are employed as Inspectors of schools and as principals and professors of colleges. The Provincial and Subordinate services are recruited in India, and the appointments open to them range from Inspectors and college principals to teachers in primary schools.

Compared with the large aggregate number of schools and pupils, the inspecting staff is a small one. In 1901–2 it comprised 35 Inspectors, 6 Inspectresses, 36 Assistant Inspectors, and 660 inspecting officers of lower grades. In addition to this staff, some Provinces employ a supplementary agency to aid in the inspection of primary schools and the encouragement of primary education; thus Madras had 256 supervisors of primary schools, Bengal 494 gurū instructors, Burma 169 itinerant teachers, and Assam 19 inspecting pandits. The substitution of general tests of the efficiency of the school for the more mechanical test of the individual examination of pupils, which is now taking place, throws more work on the inspecting staff, and measures are being adopted to add to its strength. For purposes of inspection the Provinces are divided into circles and sub-circles. The Inspector is the educational representative of the Government in the circle. It is his duty to keep himself well informed with regard to all educational matters in his jurisdiction; he makes constant tours of inspection, examines pupils, and is responsible for the working of the grant-in-aid rules.

Each of the more important Provinces has its own Director of Public Instruction, who is usually a member of the Indian Educational service; and the Home Department of the Government of India, on which falls the duty of supervising and co-ordinating educational effort throughout the country, is now assisted by a Director-General of Education, who spends much of his time on inspection tours in the several Provinces.

The existence in India of creeds differing widely from one another and from the faith of the ruling power has made it essential for the state to assume a position of strict religious neutrality in its relations with public instruction. This principle was emphatically asserted in the dispatch of 1854 and has ever since been rigidly enforced. No religious instruction is given in the Government schools; and, provided only it imparts sound secular instruction, a private institution is equally entitled to Government aid whether it teaches the religion of the Bible, the Shāstras, or the Korān.

When the state assumed the responsibility for the education of the people of India, it had to face a position to which no European country can furnish a parallel. The population was as large as that of all the European states that had then adopted an educational system; it presented at least as many differences of creed, language, race, and custom; and it was to receive an instruction essentially foreign in its higher branches. The magnitude of the task was such as to make it impossible of achievement by any direct appropriation of the resources of the empire, while the popular demand for instruction had in great measure to be created. In 1854 the Court of Directors passed in review the indigenous and foreign educational agencies that were already in existence, and determined to utilize them all, but to rely mainly on private and local effort carefully supervised and liberally encouraged. They undertook to give pecuniary assistance on the grant-in-aid system to efficient colleges and schools, to direct their efforts and afford them counsel and advice, to encourage and reward the desire for learning in various ways, but chiefly by the establishment of Universities, and to take measures for providing a due supply of teachers and for making the profession of teaching honourable and respected. Of all these provisions the most important and far-reaching was the introduction of the grant-in-aid system, and the event has to a large extent justified the Directors in the reliance which they placed upon it. ‘We confidently anticipate,’ they said, ‘by thus drawing support from local resources, in addition to contributions from the state, a far more rapid progress of education than would follow a mere increase of expenditure by the Government, while it possesses the additional advantage of fostering a spirit of reliance upon local exertion and combination for local purposes, which is of itself of no mean importance to the well-being of a nation.’ The plan inaugurated by the Directors has, on the whole, stood the test of time; but later experience has shown that it may be dangerous for the state to withdraw too much from direct participation in educational work. Without a certain proportion of direct government outlay and management primary education is apt to languish and secondary education to deteriorate.

There exists in India an intimate relation between public instruction and the service of the state. The careers open to educated men are less numerous and varied than in Western countries, and government service is still the most important among them. The hope to see their children in the service has from the outset been one of the strongest inducements to parents to interest themselves in education, and, on the other hand, the great improvement that has taken place in the quality of the government servants has been one of the most important results of that education. A race of government officials and clerks has gradually grown up largely imbued with Western conceptions of probity and business, and fit to take their part in the administration of a great country. In choosing candidates for state employment the Government relies to a large extent on the general school and University examinations, supplemented sometimes by special tests and special selection. For administrative and judicial offices a good University degree may be required; for lower appointments, success in the matriculation or some corresponding examination.

It has been said that the growth of modern ideas, for which the spread of education is to a considerable extent responsible, has had the effect of inducing in the younger generation, and especially among the Hindu community, a want of reverence and respect and an impatience of lawful control. This phenomenon is by no means exclusively Indian; it has manifested itself wherever old moral and social sanctions have been weakened or destroyed by new sources of knowledge and freer methods of thought. In India the danger has to some extent been aggravated by the exclusively secular character of the instruction given in most schools and colleges. The Government has not watched the growth of this spirit with indifference, nor has it neglected to devise means to counteract it. The whole subject was passed under review in the year 1887–8, and various measures were then introduced or extended which have had considerable effect in improving the moral training of schools and colleges. The Government must of course hold aloof from even the appearance of religious propaganda; and reliance is placed chiefly on the influence of carefully trained and selected teachers, the maintenance of a high standard of discipline, the institution of well-managed hostels, the selection of textbooks inculcating moral precepts or wholesome example, physical training and athletic sports, and social intercourse between teachers and pupils. The duty of enforcing discipline and caring for the moral training of their pupils is imposed on teachers by the regulations of all Local Governments, and the instruction given in normal colleges and schools has greatly enhanced their capacity for fulfilling this duty. The disciplinary methods are much the same as those practised in England, but it must be remembered that they have usually to be adapted to day-school conditions. In certain Provinces, and notably in Bombay, the monitorial system has been introduced with some success. The ordinary school punishments are impositions and fines, and for graver offences corporal punishment, suspension or rustication, and expulsion. Good-conduct registers are maintained in some places. A more complete system of discipline and training can of course be carried out where boarding-houses have been established. In Northern India some progress has been made in the establishment of secondary boarding-schools, but elsewhere the number is still small. More has been done in this respect for colleges. The question of moral textbooks has been much discussed, and various works inculcating moral precepts are used; but it is only when employed by good teachers and in conjunction with other means of moral influence that they can produce substantial effect. Textbooks, such as biographies, which present a worthy example in an attractive form, are also recommended for school use. Athletic sports and social intercourse between pupils and teachers are closely connected, inasmuch as the playground is the best place for developing such intercourse, and for enabling the master to become acquainted with his boys and acquire a kindly influence over them. Special attention has been paid of recent years to drill, gymnastics, and sports. The result has been remarkably successful, and Indian boys have developed a great liking and aptitude for gymnastics, tennis, cricket, football, and other games. Inter-school and inter-college sports have done much to foster this liking, and are creating a spirit of school patriotism which was previously wanting.

The Government of India has recognized that the system of aided instruction entails on the state the duty of watching over the selection of textbooks and guarding against the introduction of useless or mischievous works. Separate series of school-books are prepared and maintained in each Province under the control of the Local Government, while the duty of prescribing books for the University courses, including matriculation, rests with the University authorities. The number and variety of the languages spoken in India make the provision and selection of vernacular textbooks a specially difficult task. The Local Governments are aided in the maintenance of textbook lists by committees presided over by the Director of Public Instruction, and composed of educational and other government officers and also private persons interested in the cause of education. In some Provinces sub-committees are formed to deal with particular subjects or languages. The committee's recommendations are submitted to the Local Government and, if approved, the works proposed are included in the Provincial list. For government and local board schools the course of instruction is laid down and the textbooks are absolutely prescribed. In the case of aided schools a wider choice is given, but the managers may adopt no textbook not included in the list without the sanction of the Local Government. In the Universities textbooks are chosen by the Faculties, or by Boards of Studies appointed from among the Fellows, for particular subjects.

A series of public examinations has hitherto been held at different stages of the school course. Thus in the United Provinces examinations were prescribed at the end of the lower primary, upper primary, vernacular middle, English middle, and high school stages. A somewhat diminished importance has attached to these examinations of late years, and some which were compulsory have been made optional. They have continued, however, to exercise a dominant influence on school teaching, and have been used for class promotions, the distribution of the grant-in-aid, the award of scholarships, and the test for subordinate government appointments. The multiplication of public examinations has had its bad effects: their strain has sometimes been injurious to the children, and they have engendered unsound methods of teaching and learning. Measures have now been taken to reduce their number, and to mitigate the evils arising from the tendency to regard the passing of examinations as the end of school training.

The growth of journalistic and literary activity among the natives of India is a subject intimately connected with the development of the educational system. The annual output of newspapers, periodicals, pamphlets, and books is very considerable in quantity; and, though much of the work produced is unimportant, modern India has given birth to able journalists and authors. During the ten years ending 1901–2, the number of registered printing presses increased from 1,649 to 2,193; the number of newspapers from 602 to 708; the number of periodical publications (other than newspapers) from 349 to 575; the number of books published in English, or some other European language, from 768 to 1,312; and the number of books published in Indian languages (vernacular and classical), or in more than one language, from 5,751 to 7,081. It is worthy of note that the increase of books in the Indian languages does not keep pace with the growth of English publications; in 1901–2 their number was, however, still about five and a half times as large as the number of books printed in English.

The missionaries were the pioneers of Indian vernacular journalism. The Serampore missionaries first cast type for the vernacular languages, and employed native compositors. ‘The earliest vernacular newspaper was issued in Bengali by the Baptist Mission at Serampore, in 1818. For many years the vernacular press preserved the marks of its origin, being limited almost exclusively to theological controversy. The missionaries were encountered with their own weapons by the theistic sect of the Brahmo Samāj, and also by the orthodox Hindus. As late as 1850, most of the vernacular newspapers were still religious or sectarian, rather than political1.' During the last half-century the character of the press has undergone a marked change, and the majority of the newspapers owned by natives now devote themselves to current topics and political discussion.

The 700 newspapers published in 1901–2 fall under three main heads: English papers owned by Europeans and issued primarily for the European community, English papers owned by natives, and vernacular papers. About one-fifth of the total are published in English. The following daily papers are among the most important journals of the first class: The Pioneer, published at Allahābād; the Englishman, the Indian Daily News, and the Statesman, at Calcutta; the Civil and Military Gazette, at Lahore; the Madras Mail and the Madras Times, at Madras; the Times of India and the Bombay Gazette, at Bombay; and the Rangoon Times and the Rangoon Gazette, at Rangoon. Most of the journals belonging to the second and third classes are issued weekly, fortnightly, or monthly, and the number of daily papers either in English or in the vernaculars is small. Many are unimportant journals of an ephemeral character, and with a circulation of a few hundreds only; the total number with a circulation of over 2,000 copies is very small. The number of readers is, however, much greater than the number of copies printed. Bombay produces the largest number of vernacular newspapers, and after it come Madras, the United Provinces, and the Punjab. Bengal has fewer vernacular papers; their sale suffers from competition with the English papers of comparatively large circulation owned by natives. In Madras the vernacular papers with the largest circulation are still the mission organs; among the most important of them are the Satya Dūtan or Messenger of Truth, a Tamil paper published at Madras, and the Anglo-Telugu Messenger of Truth, also published at Madras. Of the Hindu papers, the Hindu (published in English), the Swadesa Mitran (Tamil), and the Andhra Prakāsika (Telugu) may be mentioned. The Bombay journals are almost equally divided between Marāthī and Gujarātī. The political attitude of the Marāthā press is generally that of opposition to Government. Among their journals are the Mahratta and the Kesari, both of which are published at Poona, the former in English, and the latter in Marāthī. The Gujarātī newspapers are mainly the organs of the Pārsīs, and of the trading community generally. The Bombay press includes several organs of the 'Young India' school of politicians, such for instance as the Kaiser-i-Hind, Native Opinion, the Voice of India, and East and West. Among the Bengal papers the following may be noticed: the Bengalee, the Amrita Bazar Patrika, and the Indian Mirror, printed in English; and the Bangabāsi, the Basumati, and the Hitabādi, printed in Bengali. All these journals are published in Calcutta, and they occupy themselves largely with political discussion. A considerable number of papers are published in Urdū and Hindī in the large towns of the United Provinces and the Punjab. Many of them are conducted with ability and enterprise, and may fairly be described as representative of local native opinion among the educated classes.

The 8,400 books which were published in 1901-2 include works of the most diverse character and varying merit. Of the 1,312 English publications, 621 appeared in Bengal, 341 in Madras, and 184 in Bombay. Among the major Provinces the distribution of Indian publications was as follows: Bengal, 2,448; the United Provinces, 1,362; the Punjab, 1,135; Bombay, 1,104; Madras, 825; and Burma, 127. The most noteworthy features of these statistics are the prominence of Bengal, and the literary activity of the educationally backward United Provinces and Punjab. In the subjects of the books religion is conspicuously prominent; poetry and the drama take the second place; and then, in order, language, fiction, history and biography, medicine, law, mathematics and mechanics, and philosophy. It must be admitted that few among the large number of publications are of much interest. The religious works are often mere commentaries on older works or controversial pamphlets. A large proportion of the works of a secular character are books for school use, and these are often of a very inferior description. The following brief account of the literature produced in some of the larger Provinces in the year 1901-2 is derived from the reports of the Local Governments. In Bengal the most important historical work of the year was a history of Bengal in the eighteenth century, written by Babu Kālī Prasanna Banerjī. Several translations of the classical dramas of India, and translations or adaptations of the works of European dramatists, appeared in Bengali. Most of the fiction of the year dealt with domestic life, and displayed little conception or development of plot. Lyrics and sonnets figured largely among the poetical works, and a number of the poems give expression to grief at the death of Queen Victoria. The literature dealing with religious subjects was voluminous. Most of the works on scientific subjects were of little interest. In the United Provinces the publications in Sanskrit were mostly reissues of old works on philosophy, language, and religion, and the Arabic publications were generally on the subject of religion. More than half the works in Persian were educational; there were also some poetical compositions, but they possessed little merit. A few works of some interest were published in English by native writers on the subject of social reform, and there was one noteworthy attempt at historical research. Hindī and Urdū publications testified to the religious activity among Hindus and Muhammadans. The Census operations gave rise to the issue of several pamphlets dealing with the caste question. The subject of female education received considerable attention, and some Muhammadan writers attacked the strictness of the parda system. A number of native ladies, chiefly Muhammadan, were among the list of authors, and some of their productions showed considerable merit. Novel-writing is always popular, and a few of the Hindī novels were acquisitions to the language. The history of Islām attracted several writers, and some Urdū novels were published. In the Punjab a large proportion of the works, especially of the English and Urdū publications, were educational. Taking the essentially indigenous books, a noteworthy feature is the prevalence of poetical and religious works. As a rule, the literary activity of the Muhammadan writers is centred on religion, and they usually publish more books on religious questions than all the other creeds put together. The literary efforts of Hinduism are limited for the most part to mere revisions of the older works on mythology and legend, or to controversial works on social questions, such as infant marriage, widow remarriage, and the like. The Sikhs, in proportion to their numbers, show great activity, and there has been a strong separatist movement in the past decade advocating the abandonment of Hindu customs. In Bombay poetry and religion were the foremost subjects, and, with few exceptions, the publications of the year were of an unimportant character. The same may be said of Madras.

The statistics of education in this chapter comprise the Native States under the Government of Bombay, the Feudatory States of the Central Provinces, Cooch Behār, and the Tributary Mahāls of Orissa, while the minor British administrations of Ajmer, Baluchistān, and the Andamans are omitted. The Bombay States have for the most part adopted the Government system of instruction and inspection, and in some of them the educational standard is equal to that in the neighbouring British Districts. In recent years considerable attention has been given to education in a number of Native States. No complete survey of the progress made is possible, but the large States of Baroda, Mysore, Travancore, and Gwalior may be specially mentioned. In Baroda an interesting experiment has been made by the enforcement of attendance at primary schools within a limited area.

Bibliography

Report of the Indian Education Commission, 1883. Sir Alfred Croft.—Review of Education in India in 1886. A. M. Nash.—Progress of Education in India, 1887–8 to 1891–2. J. S. Cotton.—Progress of Education in India, 1892–3 to 1896–7. R. Nathan.—Progress of Education in India, 1897–8 to 1901–2. Report of the Indian Universities Commission, 1902. Indian Universities Act VIII of 1904. Occasional Reports of the Director-General of Education in India. No. 1, Rural Schools in the Central Provinces. No. 2, Vernacular Reading Books in the Bombay Presidency, by J. G. Covernton. Syed Mahmood.—History of English Education in India (Aligarh, 1895).

TBL-055 · FOLIO 494Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
STATISTICS OF PUBLIC INSTRUCTION
1860-1.1870-1.1881-2.1891-2.1901-2.
Primary Schools.
Institutions .5,45015,92186,26997,10997,854
Scholars201,245517,5742,156,2422,837,6073,204,336
Secondary Schools.
Institutions .1423,1464,1224,8725,493 c
Scholars23,165206,300222,097473,294622,768c
Arts Colleges (including Oriental Colleges).
Institutions .174467104145
Scholars3,182a3,994b6,03712,98517,651
Schools for Special Instruction.
Institutions .261042385541,084
Scholars1,9374,3469,15021,7 236,380
Colleges for Professional Training.
Institutions .819183746
Scholars6792,1261,5453,2925,358
Total.
Institutions .5,64319,23490,714102,676104,622
Scholars230,208734,3402,395,0713,348,9103,886,493
Expenditure on Education (in thousands of rupees).35,941,21,151,87,503,05,204,01,21

Notes

  1. 1. Civilization in Ancient India, by R. C. Dutt. The sāvitri may be thus translated: 'Let us meditate on that excellent glory of the divine vivifier. May he enlighten our understandings.'
  2. 1. Report of the Indian Education Commission, 1883.
  3. 1. It is possible that changes in classification make the result, so far as secondary education is concerned, appear less favourable than the actual facts.
  4. 1. Census Report for India, 1901, chap. v.
  5. 1. See on this subject an important Resolution of the Government of India (dated March 11, 1904, Nos. 199–211), which sums up past educational achievements and indicates the lines on which future progress should be made. The Resolution is printed as an Appendix to the Review of the Progress of Education in India, 1897–8 to 1901–2.
  6. 1. For an account of the rural schools in the Central Provinces see the first volume of the Occasional Reports of the Director-General of Education.
  7. 1. Fellows are usually appointed by the Chancellor; but in Calcutta, Madras, and Bombay a certain number have of late years been elected by qualified graduates. The new legislation referred to allows of this procedure in Allahābād and Lahore also, and further permits of the selection of some of the other Fellows by the Faculties.
  8. 1. In Bombay an additional examination (styled the Previous examination) is held at the end of the first year.
  9. 1. Report on Material and Moral Progress of India, 1891–2 (J. A. Baines), p. 393.
  10. 1. Review of the Progress of Education in India, 1892–3 to 1896–7.
  11. 1. Hunter's Indian Empire, 3rd edition, pp. 569–70.
  12. Note. Note.—The figures for 1860-1 include only the Provinces of Madras, Bombay, Bengal (with Assam), and Agra. Upper Burma is added in the 1891-2 column; other Provinces come in from 1870-1. The year 1881-2 has been selected in preference to 1880-1 as more complete figures are available for it.
  13. a. Includes pupils in school departments attached to colleges. .
  14. b. Includes pupils in school departments attached to colleges for the United Provinces only.
  15. c. In the statistics for 1901-2 the primary departments of secondary schools in the United Provinces and the Central Provinces are shown as separate institutions, and are included, with the pupils in them, under the head of primary schools.