A brief reference to the ancient Indian systems of medicine will form an appropriate introduction to the account given in this chapter of the medical and sanitary administration of British India. The subject of Hindu medicine is one of special interest, inasmuch as it had considerable influence on the development of medicine in Europe. The works of Charaka and Susruta, the two greatest Sanskrit medical authorities, were rendered into Arabic at the close of the eighth century a.d., and are quoted as authorities by the celebrated Arabic physician Ar-Razi, who died in 932. Arabic medicine in its turn became, down to the seventeenth century, the chief authority for European physicians, and Charaka is frequently mentioned in Latin translations of Arabic writers1. The national medicine of India derived its first impulse from the exigencies of the national worship, for anatomical knowledge had its origin in the dissection of the victim at the sacrifice, with a view to dedicating the different parts to the proper gods. The ancient medical science was ascribed to the gods and known by the collective title of Ayur Veda. The best era of Indian medicine was contemporary with the ascendancy of Buddhism (250 b.c. to 750 a.d.), and the public hospitals which the Buddhist princes established in every city were the great schools of Indian medicine. The works of Charaka and Susruta belong to this period. The Hindu medical system, though not devoid of errors and absurdities, shows, at its best, a surprising degree of progress in all branches of the science. The materia medica of the early Hindus embraced a vast collection of drugs, indicating a great knowledge of herbs and considerable chemical skill. They were acquainted with, and understood the preparation of, a wide range of chemical compounds, and were the first to prescribe the internal use of metallic substances. Their pharmacy contained ingenious processes of preparations, with elaborate directions for the administration and classification of medicines. Their practice of physic embraced the classification, causes, symptoms, and treatment of diseases. The maladies thus dealt with were arranged in ten classes : namely, those affecting (1) the humours ; (2) the general system, including fevers ; (3 to 9) the several organs and parts of the body ; and (10) trivial complaints. The surgery of the ancient Indian doctors appears to have been bold and skilful. They performed amputations and a number of other difficult operations, and were expert in midwifery. Students were trained to operate on wax spread out on a board, or on the tissues and cells of the vegetable kingdom, and upon dead animals. As Buddhism passed into modern Hinduism, the hospitals disappeared ; and the Brāhmans, scrupulously avoiding contact with blood or morbid matter, withdrew from the medical profession and left it in the hands of the Vaidyas, a lower caste. They, in turn, abandoned medical practice ; and thus the decline of Hindu medicine went on until it sank into the hands of the village kabirāj, whose knowledge consists of jumbled fragments of the Sanskrit texts and a by-no-means contemptible pharmacopœia, supplemented by spells and fasts. Meanwhile the Muhammadan conquests brought in a new school of foreign physicians, who derived their knowledge partly from Arabic translations of the Sanskrit medical works of the best period, though more largely from the Greek authors (Hippocrates, Galen, &c.), whose works had likewise been translated into Arabic. These Musalmān doctors or hakīms monopolized the patronage of the Muhammadan princes and nobles of India1.
The work of the Medical and Sanitary department in British India includes a number of important branches of the public service. Hospitals, dispensaries, and lunatic asylums ; vital statistics ; general sanitation and vaccination ; the health of ports and shipping ; medico-legal, bacteriological, and other scientific and miscellaneous matters fall within its scope. Before giving an account of the more important of these subjects, it will be convenient to describe the constitution and organization of the department.
The principal and subordinate officers are drawn from five sources : the Indian Medical Service, civil and military Assistant Surgeons, and civil and military Hospital Assistants. The Indian Medical Service (known as I.M.S.) is primarily a military service and its members are commissioned officers of the army. There were originally three distinct branches, corresponding to the Bengal, Madras, and Bombay armies; these were combined in 1896 on the abolition of the Presidential army system. The Bengal service was created as far back as 1764, for the purpose of affording medical relief to the troops and servants of the East India Company in the Bengal Presidency, and the Madras and Bombay services had a similar origin. Candidates for the Indian Medical Service must possess degrees or diplomas qualifying them to practise medicine and surgery, and are selected in England by competitive examination. They then undergo a four months' special course and, after passing a second examination, join the army in India. Except under special circumstances, they must perform two years' military duty before becoming eligible for civil employment. The service is open to natives of India, and nine of them entered it during the ten years ending in 1902. The employment of a single service for military and civil duties is an economical arrangement to provide a reserve of medical officers competent to accompany the army in time of war. The present strength of the service is about 700. The military duties of the Indian Medical Service are, it should be explained, confined to the Native army. Medical duties in connexion with European troops are performed by the officers of the Royal Army Medical Corps (R.A.M.C.).
Civil Assistant Surgeons form the superior branch of the subordinate medical department. In the Bengal Presidency this service came into existence in 1838, when four pupils passed out of the recently established medical college at Calcutta1. Candidates are trained in the medical colleges and must possess a University degree or diploma. The Assistant Surgeons have charge of numerous minor hospitals and dispensaries; they also fill subordinate posts in large hospitals and hold many miscellaneous appointments, while a considerable number are lent to municipalities and local boards. Their attainments and the quality of their work have shown satisfactory improvement, and some minor civil surgeoncies previously held by the Indian Medical Service are now reserved for the best among them. Civil Hospital Assistants have lower professional qualifications. They are usually trained in the medical schools, more than twenty of which have been established in different parts of India, and they are employed in minor dispensaries and in a variety of subordinate posts. Some of them obtain private employment, and there is an increasing demand for their services among employers of labour, such as the managers of tea gardens and other large concerns. A certain number of civil appointments are set apart for the military subordinate medical service in order to furnish a war reserve. The majority of the native medical officers are high-caste Hindus; and then come native Christians, Muhammadans, low-caste Hindus, Pārsīs, and a few Burmese. Native Christians and low-caste Hindus are commonly found only in the Madras Presidency.
The military Assistant Surgeons are mostly Europeans or Eurasians, the latter predominating. Military Hospital Assistants are usually natives belonging to the same classes as the civilians.
The appointments in the Medical and Sanitary department are not all reserved for officers of Government services. Experts outside those services are sometimes appointed to special posts, and it is recognized that encouragement should be given to the growing medical talent of the country. Hitherto, however, the Indian Medical Service has proved the best source for superior appointments. Government medical officers are allowed the privilege of private practice, except in certain appointments where this would interfere with the performance of their public duties.
The chief civil medical officer and administrative head of the Indian Medical department is the Director-General, Indian Medical Service, who has the rank of Surgeon-General1. Between 1880 and 1904 he was also Sanitary Commissioner with the Government of India, and in that capacity was the adviser of the Supreme Government on all matters connected with the health of the civil population and the army; this appointment has now been allotted to a separate officer. The Director-General is the direct successor of a Medical Board, which consisted of two officers entitled the Surgeon-General and the Physician-General, and which dates back to an early period of the East India Company's history. It was originally styled the Hospital Board, and its functions were of a military character. In 1796 the Court of Directors changed its title to that of ‘Medical Board,’ and extended its duties to the superintendence of the ‘Medical department of the Civil Service.’
In each Province the administration of matters medical and sanitary is under the control of the Local Government, whose principal advisers are an Inspector-General of Civil Hospitals (a Surgeon-General in Madras and Bombay) and a Sanitary Commissioner. These offices are combined in the smaller Provinces. Except in Bombay, the District medical and sanitary arrangements are under the charge of a medical officer styled the Civil Surgeon1. He superintends medical institutions and, subject to the general authority of the Collector or Deputy-Commissioner, all matters connected with the health of the population. It is his duty to give professional attendance to the superior Government officers who are granted the privilege of free medical treatment, and he also performs most of the medico-legal work of the District. In the Bombay Presidency the Civil Surgeon is occupied mainly with the duties of the head-quarters station, though he also does inspection work. The rural hospitals and dispensaries are there under the direct control of the Surgeon-General, and the sanitary work is supervised by five Deputy Sanitary Commissioners under the orders of the Provincial Sanitary Commissioner. The duties of these officers are to superintend and encourage the sanitation of the Districts and towns within their circle, to inspect dispensaries, and generally to advise the District officers on matters affecting the public health. They deal also with vaccination and vital statistics.
Medical institutions were established at an early date in the Presidency cities, for the relief of the natives as well as for the treatment of the Company’s servants. Thus the Madras General Hospital dates back to 1679, and four other hospitals were established in that city between 1800 and 1820. In Calcutta, the Presidency General Hospital was founded in 1795 and the Medical College Hospital in 1852–3. In the country generally progress was for a long time slow, and the main development has taken place during the past thirty years. Under regulations which prevailed in the old Bengal Presidency during the first half of the nineteenth century, the Government aided the foundation of hospitals and dispensaries in places of importance, where the inhabitants were ready to help in this work, provided (which was not always the case) that a medical officer was available to take charge of the new institution. In 1854 the rules were made more precise, and the Government consented to supply officers of a rank depending on the amount of local subscriptions, and to furnish instruments and medicines. The hospitals were under the general charge of the senior medical officer of the District, and were inspected by the Superintending Surgeon of the circle, who combined military and civil duties, but whose office has now ceased to exist. Since the creation of municipalities, and later of District boards, local authorities have taken an ever-increasing share in the provision of medical relief. The Madras Presidency possessed twenty-two District dispensaries in 1852; the Bombay Presidency twenty-one in 1854; and Lower Bengal forty-five in 1859. Later progress is shown in the first table at the end of this chapter; in 1880 the total number of public hospitals and dispensaries in British India under Government control was about 1,200, in 1890 about 1,700, and in 1902 nearly 2,500. There were three main causes for the slow progress in early years—indifference on the part of the people, want of officers, and insufficient funds. Both Hindus and Muhammadans have, as we have seen, their own systems of medicine, and it took long to familiarize them with Western methods and drugs. Even now, notwithstanding the large extent to which recourse is had to the dispensaries, many natives prefer to be treated by men who practise the ancient systems. The difficulty in supplying doctors has to a large extent disappeared with the increased facilities for medical education: there were about 4,200 students in the medical colleges and schools at the end of 1901–2, and the practice of medicine is recognized as offering a profitable career.
In 1902 British India contained, outside the Presidency towns, about 2,400 public hospitals and dispensaries under Government control, nearly 500 independent private institutions, and more than 500 special institutions in connexion with police, railways, &c.1 Hospitals belonging to the first of these classes are, generally speaking, maintained from, or aided by, Provincial or local revenues. Omitting institutions maintained for special purposes, the total number of dispensaries amounted on an average to one in about 330 square miles of country. The proportion is highest in Bengal and Bombay, and lowest in the Central Provinces and Burma. Except in Bombay, Upper Burma, and the Central Provinces, the Government directly maintains very few hospitals ; in almost all Provinces the great majority of medical institutions are supported by municipal and District boards. In some cases the Government assists by supplying officers, making contributions, and in other ways, and generally the officer in charge is lent by the Government and paid from the local fund. Local fund hospitals are given the further privilege, if they desire it, of purchasing European drugs from the Government store dépôts at Calcutta, Madras, Bombay, Miān Mīr, and Rangoon. They make their own arrangements for the supply of indigenous drugs purchasable locally. The use of such drugs is encouraged, and there is a permanent committee for investigating and making known their properties. The total number of private institutions shown in the returns for 1902, including those independent of Government control, amounted to about 1,000. They are most numerous in Bombay, where they constitute the largest class of medical institutions, The funds for private hospitals are mainly derived from charitable donations, local subscriptions, and missionary societies. To found or endow a hospital appeals to the charitable instincts of a wealthy Hindu, though the only hospitals of purely native origin are those for animals, to be found in Western India under the name of pinjrāpol.
The principal hospital is always situated at the head-quarters of the District. It is under the immediate charge of the Civil Surgeon, aided by subordinate officers ; and, having the best staff and equipment, it secures the most important cases. Branch institutions are opened at convenient places within the District, and are (except in Bombay) under the general superintendence of the Civil Surgeon, who, in most Provinces, is required to inspect them three times a year. The officer in immediate charge is generally an Assistant Surgeon or Hospital Assistant of the Government service ; but, especially in Bengal, duly qualified native doctors not on the Government list are also employed. The branch institutions are mainly for dispensary work ; they have, as a rule, little accommodation for in-patients, and the little that is provided is sometimes in excess of the demand. The out-patient system is more acceptable to a population which keenly dislikes being away from home during illness. The management of District dispensaries is usually vested in local committees, which endeavour to rouse popular interest in the work of medical relief. Continuous effort is made to increase the efficiency of the hospitals and dispensaries. Better and more modern buildings are being gradually provided, and increased attention is paid to the privacy and comfort of the patients and to the attractiveness of their surroundings. Much, however, remains to be done even at head-quarters, and many branch dispensaries are too poor for more than the simplest arrangements. In 1901 nearly two-fifths of the Bengal dispensaries had incomes of less than Rs. 1,000 a year. Experiments have from time to time been made with a view to bring medical relief nearer home to the people. In the Delhi District (Punjab) dispensary officers were for some years sent on tour at stated periods, but this was found to interfere with their ordinary duties. A similar plan has recently been tried in Bengal, and also a system of supplying medicine chests to village headmen. Such experiments are still in their infancy. Much wider success has attended the practice, which originated in Bengal and has been extended to other Provinces, of supplying quinine through the agency of the post office in quarter-anna packets, made up in the jails and each containing five (now seven) grains. In 1903-4 more than 7 million packets were sold in this way.
The most important of the hospitals in the Presidency towns are under Government management. The largest contain several hundred beds, are equipped with the most modern appliances, and are officered by large European staffs. The cities of Calcutta, Madras, and Bombay are served by sixty-two hospitals and dispensaries—Government, local, and aided ; and Bombay has in addition twenty-one unaided private dispensaries. Nearly a million cases were treated at these institutions in 1902. The most important general hospital in each Presidency town is connected with the local medical college, and the surgeons and physicians are also, as a rule, professors there. Calcutta and Bombay possess large European hospitals ; in Madras, Europeans are treated in a branch of the general hospital.
The total of the returns for all classes of dispensaries shows that about 26½ million persons obtained medical relief in 1902. But this figure does not imply so many separate individuals, for one person may obtain relief several times in the course of the year. The proportion is highest in the Punjab and the Central Provinces and, notwithstanding its large number of dispensaries, lowest in Bengal. In all parts of India, except the Punjab and Assam, Muhammadans resort to the dispensaries more freely than Hindus. In 1902 about 55 per cent. of the patients in District hospitals under Government control were men, 19 per cent. women, and 26 per cent. children.
The proportion varies in different Provinces, but the order is the same in all. The customs of the country render women, especially those belonging to the upper classes, disinclined to seek dispensary relief and treatment by male practitioners. Great efforts have been made to afford the women of India medical relief in a form acceptable to them. Many hospitals have been established for their exclusive use, and arrangements are in force to secure their privacy in general dispensaries. Special attention has been paid to the education of lady doctors and subordinates, and to the training of dais, or native midwives, in local hospitals. Great interest attaches in this connexion to the work done by the ‘National Association for supplying Medical Aid to the Women of India’ founded by the Countess of Dufferin in 1885. It is supported by voluntary contributions and occasional grants from Government, and maintains about 260 hospitals, wards, and dispensaries, officered by women. Nearly two million women and children received medical aid in these hospitals, or at their homes, during 1901. A sum of almost 7 lakhs of rupees was collected by Lady Curzon in 1901–2 for the training of native midwives.
The diseases principally prevalent in India have received notice in chapter x of Vol. I. Malarial fever is the malady most frequently treated in the hospitals, accounting for more than one-sixth of the total number of cases. Surgery has grown to be a specially important part of hospital work, and the popular prejudice which at one time existed against it has been largely overcome by the striking nature of the results. Excellent surgical practice is afforded by the large hospitals, and a high level of skill is attained. In 1902 nearly 900,000 operations were performed. Cataract is a very common disease in India, and people resort in great numbers to the hospitals to be treated for it; in 1901 one officer in the Punjab performed more than 1,700 operations for its cure.
The income of the public medical institutions under Government control in the years 1880, 1890, 1900, and 1902 is shown in the first table at the end of this chapter. It has increased during the twenty-two years in question from 37 to nearly 82 lakhs, of which 21 lakhs belong to the hospitals and dispensaries of the Presidency towns. The receipts from municipal and local funds and ‘other sources’ have risen much more rapidly than the direct outlay from Provincial revenues. Half the total under the third item in the table is derived from subscriptions.
In the Indian Census of 1901 only 66,000 persons were returned as insane in a population of 294 millions. This is less than one-fourteenth of the proportion of insanes in England. Causes contributing to the contrast are the comparative rarity of alcoholism and of aberration due to religious terrors, and the circumstance that the bulk of the Indian population are less highly strung, and possess less brain energy, than the inhabitants of modern Europe. A very small proportion, consisting in general of destitute wanderers and dangerous persons, find their way into the lunatic asylums : the majority are harmless and are looked after by their friends. In India, as in other Oriental countries, a certain respect is shown towards insane persons, who are believed to be possessed by a mysterious and supernatural spirit. During the five years ending with 1900 the average lunatic asylum population was only 4,600. The asylums are administered under an Act of 1858, which provides for the admission and release of insane persons and the control of the institutions by visitors. All lunatic asylums are under Government management, and the majority were formerly in charge of the Civil Surgeons of the Districts in which they were situated. These officers had not always the time or the special knowledge which the subject demands ; and it has recently been decided to establish central asylums, under whole-time officers, in Madras, Bombay, Bengal, the United Provinces, and the Punjab, and to reduce the number of smaller institutions. The superintendence of a central asylum is open to members of the Indian Medical Service, with a salary sufficient to induce able officers to devote their career to the study and treatment of insanity. At the same time improvements have been effected in the subordinate staff, and arrangements have been made for the study of insanity, including clinical instruction at the central asylums.
Asylums are maintained in a number of places for the segregation and treatment of lepers. The subject of leprosy in India was investigated by a Commission in 1890–1, and their report was carefully examined both in England and in India. These inquiries led to the general conclusions that the disease does not prevail in India to such an extent as to constitute a general danger, and that the degree to which it is propagated by contagion is small. It was, nevertheless, held desirable to take legal power to deal with pauper lepers wandering about and displaying the ravages of the disease for the purpose of exciting charity, and to prohibit lepers from following certain callings connected with food and other bodily requirements, and from using public tanks and wells.
The history of general sanitary work in India begins practically with the investigations of the Royal Commission which reported in 1863 on the sanitary state of the army. In commenting on the bad health of the troops, the Commission laid stress on the evil effect of the insanitary condition of the general population; and, in accordance with their advice, Sanitary boards were appointed, in 1864, in each Presidency, principally for the army, but also for the general care of the public health. The Bengal Sanitary board was replaced in 1866 by a Sanitary Commissioner with the Government of India, and a similar change was carried out locally by the Governments of Madras and Bombay. In 1867 Sanitary Inspectors-General, afterwards called Sanitary Commissioners, were appointed in the other Provinces to investigate the sanitary condition of the people and to suggest means for its amelioration. The Civil Surgeons were constituted health officers of the Districts, and their functions in this capacity were gradually extended until (except in Bombay) they have become the general advisers of the local authorities on all sanitary matters. Such work as was accomplished was done through the agency of the District and Municipal staffs, and later on also through District and other local boards. In 1880–1 endeavour was made to provide a more complete supervising agency by amalgamating the sanitary and vaccination staffs. The Superintendents of Vaccination (who were commissioned medical officers) were made Deputy Sanitary Commissioners, and were directed to supervise general sanitary work as well as vaccination and vital statistics. The extension of local self-government under Lord Ripon strengthened the executive agency and increased the available funds. The next step made was the establishment, under orders issued in 1888, of a Sanitary board in each Province, armed with the powers necessary for the control of the sanitary work of municipalities and District boards. The Provincial boards were to be composed of administrative and public works officers, and of the Sanitary Commissioner. By 1893 Sanitary boards had been established in every Province except Berār, where a system of District sanitary boards already existed. The Sanitary boards have varied considerably from time to time, and from Province to Province, in composition, functions, and utility. The most comprehensive scheme was that introduced by the Government of the United Provinces in 1896, under which the Sanitary board includes the Inspector-General of Civil Hospitals, a Secretary to Government in the Public Works Department, and the Sanitary Engineer. It advises the Commissioners of Divisions with regard to sanitary works projected in towns and rural areas, and itself sanctions the execution of works by District boards, to which it contributes from funds placed at its disposal by the Local Government. The appointment of Sanitary Engineers was an important outcome of the orders of 1888. They are now employed in all large Provinces to draw up and supervise the execution of sanitary projects, and are the technical advisers of the Sanitary boards. In 1898, after long discussion with the Local Governments, the Government of India issued fresh orders for the encouragement of sanitary progress. While recognizing the need for proceeding with great caution in imposing reform on the rural population, the Governor-General-in-Council emphasized the importance of the duties of the Civil Surgeon as health officer of the District, and urged the desirability of gradually substituting a better trained agency for the subordinate supervising staff of the Vaccination department. Considerable progress has been made in some Provinces on these lines. The system in the Bombay Presidency differs from that in force elsewhere in that, as already stated, the Civil Surgeon is not concerned with the sanitation of the Districts, which are grouped in circles, each under the charge of a Deputy Sanitary Commissioner. The Indian Plague Commission of 1898 criticized the existing organization of the Sanitary department, and its further improvement is now under consideration.
Only one-fourteenth of the population of British India live within municipal limits, and the problem of rural sanitation involves, therefore, the health of the great bulk of the inhabitants. When sanitary reform in India received its first impetus from the investigation of the Royal Commission of 1863, there was practically no organization for the prosecution of sanitary work outside the Presidency towns. The villagers dwelt in complete indifference to their unhealthy surroundings, and virulent epidemics raged unchecked and almost unknown to the authorities. Since then progress has been slow, and incommensurate with the thought and labour that have been bestowed on the subject. The reason lies in the apathy of the people and the tenacity with which they cling to domestic customs injurious to health. While the inhabitants of the plains of India are on the whole distinguished for personal cleanliness, the sense of public cleanliness has ever been wanting. Great improvements have been effected in many places; but the village house is still often ill-ventilated and over-populated; the village site dirty, crowded with cattle, choked with rank vegetation, and poisoned by stagnant pools; and the village tanks polluted, and used indiscriminately for bathing, cooking, and drinking. That the way to improvement lies through the education of the people has always been recognized. One of the first acts of the Sanitary department was the issue of simple rules for village sanitation, which were translated into the vernacular and explained to the villagers by the District officer; and similar efforts continue to be made. The rudiments of hygiene form a portion of the course of primary education, and the improved methods of modern elementary instruction are used to make the lesson interesting and impressive. These efforts must in time prove effective : encouraging results have been obtained in municipalities, and the knowledge which grows up in the towns spreads to the country.
The early efforts of the Sanitary department in rural areas were rendered practically abortive by want of agency and of funds. These needs have to some extent been met by the Local Boards and Village Sanitation Acts. In 1865-71 a number of Acts were passed enabling the levy of local cesses for works of local utility. The proceeds were, however, mainly directed to communications, schools, and dispensaries, and their influence on sanitary improvement was not great. Much more important were the Acts passed in 1883-5 to give effect in rural areas to the local self-government policy of Lord Ripon. They provided a popular agency of District and subordinate boards, which were made responsible for the supply of pure water for drinking purposes, and for the sanitation of the District generally. The Madras Act went farther than the others in making the lowest unit of local self-government the village union, comprising generally a group of villages in which a small house-tax is levied for simple sanitary and cleansing operations, and, in large unions, also for the construction and repair of streets, drains, tanks, and wells. The Bengal Act provided for the establishment of similar village unions, but these did not, as in Madras, form an integral portion of the system. In 1887-8 the Government of India declared that a more systematic effort must be made to deal with the problem. It suggested that a general sanitary village survey should be undertaken, and directed that, when a clear perception had been attained as to what ought to be done, effect should be given to the conclusions by enforcing the provisions of the Local Boards Acts or by special legislation. In accordance with this scheme the Local Boards Acts of Bombay, the United Provinces, and the Central Provinces have been supplemented by special Village Sanitation Acts. The Bombay Act of 1889 provides for the formation of local sanitary committees for small villages, whose duty it is to provide potable water, keep the village clean, and deal with the accumulation of offensive matter and with nuisances. They are empowered to convict persons infringing the law, and to levy a local tax at a rate not exceeding half the land cess. In larger villages local sanitary boards may be formed for more important works, with sanitary inspectors appointed by the Collector. In the same year an Act was passed for the Central Provinces empowering the Chief Commissioner to create committees, and impose a rate, in villages known to be insanitary, for cleansing, conservancy, and water-supply, and the maintenance of the village roads. In villages in which the United Provinces Act of 1892 has been introduced the Collector may order wells to be cleaned, improved, protected from contamination or condemned, and new wells to be constructed, the cost being recovered from the persons using the well or from the landlord. Loans may be granted for these purposes. The Local Government is also empowered to make rules regarding conservancy and the infliction of penalties. In 1895 the Government of India effected a further improvement by the introduction of a system of village sanitary notebooks. The book contains a permanent record of the sanitary history of the village. It is kept in a printed form by a literate resident and remarks are recorded in it by inspecting officers. This system has been used in some Provinces with considerable advantage.
At the present time Madras may be considered to be the foremost Province in the matter of rural sanitation. In 1902–3 there were 379 village unions in the Presidency, and the total amount spent on sanitation by local boards (more than 5 lakhs) was much greater than in any other Province. In 1896 the Government of the United Provinces issued a Resolution laying down a sound system of rural sanitation. Each District is divided into small circles, the sanitary condition of which is thoroughly investigated. Endeavour is then made to induce the villagers to observe simple sanitary rules, and to keep their tanks and wells clean and in good repair. Larger works are carried out with money derived from local boards, levied under the Village Sanitation Act, or granted by the Government through the agency of the Sanitary board. In Bombay the Village Sanitation Act was in force in 294 villages in the year 1902. Famine and plague have of recent years checked progress here. In Bengal fifty-seven union committees were in existence in 1902–3, and their income amounted to about Rs. 23,000. They do good work within their sphere, but have not been tried on a sufficiently large scale to produce any material effect on the sanitary administration. In pursuance of a system inaugurated in 1900-1, the local boards in Patna District have established a regular system of cleansing villages and rural towns. In the Punjab there is no system of minor committees and no special Village Sanitation Act; but the District board agency is displaying activity and doing good work, and the cause of sanitary reform is said to be generally progressing.
The history of urban sanitation in India is closely connected with that of the municipal institutions described in chapter ix. When the Royal Commission of 1863 submitted their report, the Municipal Act in force outside the Presidency towns was a permissive measure of 1850. It was largely used in Bombay, to a less degree in the North-Western Provinces, and hardly at all in Madras and Bengal. In Madras the Municipal Act was to some extent supplemented by voluntary associations for sanitary and other local purposes, and in Bengal by the Town Police Act, part of the funds levied under this Act being applied for conservancy purposes. The appointment of Sanitary Commissioners gave a great impetus to sanitary reform in towns. Municipal Acts were passed for the various Provinces, many new municipalities were formed, and by-laws were framed for conservancy and sanitation. Lord Mayo's financial decentralization scheme of 1870 increased the funds available for municipal work; and in 1871 an important measure was passed (amended and re-enacted in 1879) enabling municipalities to borrow money from the Government, or in the open market, on the security of their funds. From 1876 to 1888 the Government could only afford to lend funds in exceptional cases; but when these restrictions were removed, in 1889, a great advance was immediately made in the prosecution of municipal works. At the same time the execution of such works was encouraged, systematized, and improved by the appointment of the Provincial Sanitary boards and Sanitary Engineers. The Acts framed in 1883-5 in accordance with Lord Ripon's policy were cast in an ampler mould than those which preceded them. The municipal authorities were given greater powers to deal with sanitary problems and were entrusted with larger funds. As they now stand, the Municipal Acts cover practically all matters connected with the health of an Indian town population, such as water-supply, drainage, conservancy, sewage, nuisances, the cleansing of streets and open places, the improvement of insanitary dwellings, offensive trades, burial and burning grounds, markets, slaughter-houses, and the sale of unwholesome food. In Bombay, the United Provinces, the Punjab, and Burma some provisions of the Municipal Acts are applied to small towns which are not municipalities, and their sanitation is provided for in this manner. The total expenditure on conservancy in District municipalities rose from 25·4 lakhs in 1876–7 to 56·4 lakhs (excluding Upper Burma) in 1902–3. The expenditure on drainage alone shows a rise during the same period from 4·7 to 14·1 lakhs, and that on water-supply from 6 to 34·7 lakhs.
Save in a few of the larger towns, there is no water-carriage system for sewage removal, and trenching is commonly adopted. This method requires great care in execution, and in many municipalities it is still carried out in a manner dangerous to the health of the inhabitants. Waste water trickles out of the houses and is carried off by surface drains to discharge into tanks or some convenient stream. The native population use a very small quantity of water in their houses, probably not more than a daily average per head of 1 or 2 gallons, as compared with an ordinary standard of 20 gallons in English cities. But where water-works have been introduced, and the consumption largely increased, the sewage and drainage conditions approach more nearly to those which obtain in Europe. In the search for a means of disposal of refuse the towns of India possessing sewage systems have followed the example set in England. Bombay discharges its sewage into the sea. In Ahmadābād and Karāchi broad irrigation, with subsequent cultivation, has been successfully carried out. The Calcutta sewage is conducted to an outfall in a salt lake five miles east of the city, and that of Benares and Cawnpore is discharged into the Ganges. In recent years successful experiments have been made in a number of municipalities for the disposal of sewage by ‘biological’ methods, and this system is likely to be more frequently adopted in the future.
The construction of water-works, almost entirely by means of funds borrowed from the Government, has been a successful feature of municipal administration. More than eighty municipal towns are now furnished with water-supply systems, many of which are on a large scale and constructed accordance with the most approved modern methods. Bombay was earliest in the field, and had twelve schemes completed before 1890, but they were smaller and less expensive than the large schemes which followed. Apart from these, almost all the works in question have been opened since 1890. On the whole the largest undertakings have been carried out in the United Provinces. Of the seven large municipal towns there—Agra, Allahābād, Benares, Cawnpore, Lucknow, Meerut, and Bareilly—all except the last have been furnished, at considerable cost, with complete systems of water-supply. Water-rates are levied in these cities under a special Act of 1891. Eight works have been completed in the Bombay Presidency since 1890. The Madras municipalities were slower to perceive the advantage of a good water-supply, but of late years they have taken up the matter with vigour. It is difficult to overestimate the boon which the provision of an abundant and pure supply of water has proved to the inhabitants of large Indian towns. In some cases, however, the improvement in health that might have been expected has not taken place. Good water cannot remove other causes inimical to health, such as bad conservancy and overcrowding, while in some cases the need for proper drainage may have been aggravated by an increased water-supply.
The sanitary arrangements in the Presidency towns of Calcutta, Madras, and Bombay are naturally on a more extensive scale than in other places. Each of these cities has been furnished with large water-works and sewage systems, and each employs a numerous sanitary staff. In Bombay, which may be taken as an illustration, the sanitary organization is divided into four main departments—water-supply, drainage, sewage, and conservancy. Each of the first three departments is under an engineer who is subordinate to the principal engineer of the municipality, and the last is under the Municipal Health Officer. Water is derived from three artificial lakes and is passed through filter beds; an elaborate system of sewers carries the drainage and liquid refuse into the sea; and garbage is removed by train beyond the city limits. Much has been done to maintain the Presidency towns in a healthy condition, but it would be idle to declare that the result has been completely satisfactory. When the plague attacked Bombay it found a favourable breeding-place in the crowded tenements where the poorer section of the inhabitants dwelt; when it threatened Calcutta the dirty, and in many respects insanitary, condition of the city was a cause of grave alarm. Strenuous efforts are being made (see chap. ix) to improve the condition of these two cities.
On the whole the inhabitants of towns have advanced much more rapidly than the rural population in the appreciation of healthy conditions of life, and contrasting the state of affairs forty years ago with what it is now there is good ground for satisfaction.
‘Compare, for instance,’ says Sir J. Strachey in chap. i of the 1903 edition of his India, ‘what Calcutta was when Lord Lawrence became Viceroy in 1864 and what it is now. This city, the capital of British India, supplies an excellent type of what has been everywhere going on. The filth of the city used to rot away in the midst of the population in pestilential ditches, or was thrown into the Hooghly, there to float backwards and forwards with every change of tide. To nine-tenths of the inhabitants clean water was unknown. They drank either the filthy water of the river, polluted with every conceivable abomination, or the still filthier contents of the shallow tanks. The river, which was the main source of supply to thousands of people, was not only the receptacle for ordinary filth ; it was the great graveyard of the city. I forget how many thousand corpses were thrown into it every year. I forget how many hundred corpses were thrown into it from the Government hospitals and jails, for these practices were not confined to the poor and ignorant ; they were followed or allowed, as a matter of course, by the officers of the Government and of the municipality. I remember the sights which were seen in Calcutta in those days in the hospitals, and jails, and markets, and slaughter-houses, and public streets. The place was declared, in official reports written by myself in language which was not, and could not be, stronger than the truth required, to be hardly fit for civilized men to live in. There are now few cities in Europe with which many parts of Calcutta need fear comparison, and although in the poorer quarters there is still much room for improvement, there is hardly a city in the world which has made greater progress.
‘I do not mean to say that Indian cities generally were as bad as Calcutta. This was far from being the case, but Calcutta affords, not the less, a good example of what has been and is still going on in India. Illustrations of the same sort might easily be multiplied. In 1865, for instance, in the city of Rangoon, containing at that time more than 100,000 people, with half a million tons of shipping, there was not a single public lamp, no supply of wholesome water, not a single drain except the surface drains at the sides of the streets, and no means of removing the filth out of the town.’
Much, however, remains to be done not only in the prosecution of large works, but also in the improvement of general sanitary conditions. Lack of funds is often a great obstacle to progress. The income of many municipalities is very small, and cannot be greatly enhanced without a burden of taxation which would be felt as oppressive. The outbreak of plague has drawn prominent attention to existing defects and thus helped towards their removal.
To deal with outbreaks of epidemic disease is an important part of the work of the Medical and Sanitary department. On the occurrence of a serious outbreak of cholera, small-pox, or epidemic fever, special officers are sent to the locality to tend the sick, to supervise such precautions as experience has shown to be most effectual, and to investigate the cause and history of the epidemic. The enormous religious assemblages which take place periodically in many places throughout India are sometimes sources of epidemic disease, and careful sanitary arrangements are made to lessen this danger.
During the last few years India has suffered from a widespread epidemic of plague. It is not the first occasion within modern times that this terrible disease has visited India, but no previous outbreak of which we have record attained the proportions of the epidemic which still devastates widely distant parts of the peninsula. The constant and rapid communication which now takes place between all parts of the country has no doubt greatly assisted the spread of the disease. The first trustworthy information of the occurrence of plague in India dates from the year 1812, when an epidemic broke out in Cutch, spread into Gujarāt and Sind, and did not die out until after the lapse of ten years. In 1828–9 a disease showing all the symptoms of plague is reported to have been prevalent at Hānsi, in the Hissār district of the Punjab. In 1836 another epidemic occurred at Pāli in the Mārwār State of Rājputāna, and spread over a considerable area, causing great loss of life. The present epidemic broke out in the city of Bombay during the autumn of 1896. During the first year it was, apart from a few small outbreaks, confined to the Bombay Presidency. In the second year it appeared in several other Provinces and States; and it has since been present in more or less severe epidemic form in Bengal, Madras, the United Provinces, the Central Provinces, the Punjab, Mysore, Hyderābād, and Kashmīr. Up to the end of 1903 more than two million deaths had been reported, and the actual mortality must have been much greater. At the outset stringent measures were taken with regard to the segregation of the sick and those who had been in contact with them, the disinfection and evacuation of infected localities, and the observation of travellers from infected places, in the hope that the disease might be thus stamped out. The long duration and great extent of the epidemic made it impossible to continue these measures in the manner in which they were started; but every aid is still given to the inhabitants to take the precautions which have been found most efficacious, and facilities are afforded to every one who wishes to be inoculated by the method which has been worked out by M. Haffkine. The greatest pains are taken to prevent the contamination of the shipping leaving Indian ports, and the measures for out-ward-bound vessels recommended by the International Sanitary Conference convened at Venice in February, 1897, have been carried out with such good effect that extremely few cases of plague have reached Europe.
The Government of India has long recognized the great importance that attaches to the scientific study of tropical disease. In no country is such study likely to bear greater fruit in the alleviation of human suffering. Valuable work has been done from time to time by medical officers, as, for instance, the investigation into the propagation of malarial fever by certain species of mosquitoes conducted by Major Ross, late of the Indian Medical Service. Financial and other difficulties long prevented the Government from realizing more fully its wish to develop this branch of medical work, and it is only recently that a general scheme has been devised. Under this scheme there is to be a central laboratory at Kasauli near Simla, and Provincial laboratories at the head-quarters of the principal Local Governments. The central laboratory will be devoted to research, and to the preparation of protective vaccines and curative sera; and while research will also be an object of the Provincial laboratories, these will be mainly occupied with ordinary bacteriological work, such as the determination of the specific nature of disease in doubtful cases, the investigation of the cause of epidemic outbreaks, and generally the supply of expert assistance to medical officers. The instruction of young officers, and the general development of the study of bacteriology and hygiene, are an important part of the scheme.
In August, 1900, an Indian Pasteur Institute for the treatment of persons bitten by rabid animals was opened at Kasauli. This institution is under private management, but is aided by the Government. The history of even its first year's work was a record of remarkable success : 321 patients sought relief and, excluding seven cases in which the treatment began too late, only three cases terminated fatally. At least one deplorable case has, however, occurred which shows that persons bitten by rabid animals at a great distance from Kasauli may be unable to reach the institute in time for the treatment to be successful. A second institution is now being established at Coonoor, in the Madras Presidency, on the lines of that at Kasauli.
An accurate system of registering vital statistics is the only sure foundation for efficient sanitary administration. When the Royal Commission of 1863 submitted their report there was practically no registration outside the Presidency towns. In accordance with their recommendation, arrangements were made to register deaths in towns and rural areas, through the agency of the police and of the municipal and subordinate revenue establishments. In Bengal, where the bulk of the Province is permanently settled and the rural revenue establishments are weak, the difficulties proved greater than elsewhere, and a beginning was not made until 1870, by which time registration of deaths was in full force in other Provinces. The registration of births presents more formidable obstacles. Official inquiry regarding the birth of children was apt to excite religious or caste prejudice, or superstitious fear, and the ignorant were suspicious of the motives which prompted an inquisition whose object they could not understand. Birth registration was started in Bombay in 1848, and in Madras about 1855; in other Provinces it began at different times between 1870 and 1880, at first in selected areas and afterwards throughout the country. By 1882 it was general in all Provinces except Bengal, where, until 1892, it was only in force in selected towns. The Government of India made a general survey of the results in 1894, and found that in the United Provinces registration was carried out with some approach to accuracy; that it was fairly well done in the Punjab, the Central Provinces, and Berār; and that Bombay, Madras, and Assam came a long way behind. In Bengal the figures did not go far back enough to enable an estimate to be made, but the reports of the Sanitary Commissioner with the Government of India show that registration was inaccurate there. Improvements have been made since, chiefly in the direction of closer supervision, and although the results are still imperfect they are better than they were formerly. Registration of the cause of death is more imperfect than the record of the fact of its occurrence. This is necessarily so because, even in large towns, the great majority die without having been seen by any person competent to diagnose the case.
Under the existing system registration is compulsory in municipalities under municipal or special laws or by-laws. The father and mother of a new-born child, and the nearest relative or other person present at the death of a deceased person, are primarily responsible for reporting the occurrence to the registration office or town police. In the Presidency towns officers are stationed at the places of burial and cremation in order to check the returns. In Calcutta and Bombay medical practitioners are required to certify the cause of the death of patients, but in Madras this duty has as yet been laid only on Government medical officers. Municipalities have in many cases been lax in enforcing the law, and the Sanitary Commissioner with the Government of India stated, as recently as 1896, that registration in municipalities is more defective than in rural tracts. Outside municipal limits registration has not in general been made legally compulsory, as it is feared that the rural population in many parts of India is not ripe for such a measure. In Madras a compulsory Act was passed in 1899, and is being tentatively introduced into large villages and small towns. In Madras and Bombay rural births and deaths are recorded by the village officials, while in Bengal, the United Provinces, the Punjab, and the Central Provinces village watchmen report to the police-station. The information is sent to the District head-quarters, and eventually to the Provincial Sanitary Commissioner.
A great work has been accomplished in India in the protection of the people from the scourge of small-pox. When the matter first received attention, inoculation (an Eastern discovery) was the common practice. Many persons were protected by this means, but carelessness in its use is said to have assisted in the spread of the disease. Vaccination had been started before the appointment of the Royal Commission of 1863, but it was badly done and the people were hostile to it. The Commission drew prominent attention to the subject and a great improvement was soon effected. A large staff was employed under efficient supervision, and the utility of the process gradually became evident to a considerable portion of the population. In 1880 an Act was passed for the compulsory vaccination of children in municipalities and cantonments. It was introduced with caution, an application from the majority of the municipal commissioners being a necessary condition. Compulsory vaccination is now enforced in all municipalities in Bengal1, the United Provinces, Madras, and Burma; in most municipalities in the Central Provinces; and in some in the Punjab. In Bombay vaccination is compulsory only in the Presidency town, and in Karāchi and other places in Sind. Each Province has a large establishment of public vaccinators, with an inspecting staff under the Deputy Sanitary Commissioners. In Bengal private vaccinators are licensed, and are permitted to receive fees. In municipalities the vaccinators are maintained by the municipal authorities, and in rural areas by the Government or the District boards. More than 2 per cent. of the work is done by the ordinary dispensary staff. There has been a great increase in the annual rate of vaccination and in the proportion of protected persons (see Table II at the end of this chapter). During 1864–5 only 556 persons were vaccinated in Bengal, the United Provinces, and the Punjab; in 1902–3 more than five millions were successfully vaccinated in the same Provinces. In the whole of British India the proportion of persons who underwent vaccination to the total population was 27 per 1,000 in 1880–1, and 35 in 1902–3, while the true normal birth-rate may be taken as approaching 50 per thousand. The proportion of vaccinations to births varies greatly in different Provinces, being best in the Punjab and worst in Bengal. In parts of the latter Province the people are still prejudiced and hide their children from the vaccinators. A great improvement has been made in recent years by substituting calf-lymph vaccination for the arm-to-arm method. This process was systematically introduced in 1890. Dépôts for the manufacture and storage of calf lymph have been established, and the use of human lymph is being more and more superseded.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
See the official and other publications referred to under ‘General Population’ in the bibliography to the chapter on Public Health (Vol. I, chap. x).
Also, for Hindu times, Civilization in Ancient India, by R. C. Dutt (Calcutta, 1899), book v, chap. xi; and A Short History of Aryan Medical Science, by the Thākur Sāhib of Gondal (1896).
TABLE I
| 1880. | 1890. | 1900. | 1902*. | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Institutions . . . | 1,212 | 1,736 | 2,364 | 2,456 |
| Patients†:— . . | ||||
| In-door . . . | 217,000 | 255,000 | 381,000 | 373,000 |
| Out-door . . | 7,192,000 | 12,722,000 | 20,524,000 | 22,039,000 |
| Total | 7,409,000 | 12,977,000 | 20,905,000 | 22,412,000 |
| Surgical operations performed . . | 372,219 | 604,140 | 831,806 | 895,226 |
| Income†:— From Government . | Rs. 19,03,000 | Rs. 20,73,000 | Rs. 27,76,000 | Rs. 29,89,000 |
| From Municipal and Local Funds . . | 12,90,000 | 22,07,000 | 31,64,000 | 37,15,000 |
| From subscriptions, endowments, fees, and other sources . | 5,02,000 | 5,69,000 | 13,36,000 | 14,65,000 |
| Total | 36,95,000 | 48,49,000 | 72,76,000 | 81,69,000 |
| Institutions. | Patients†. | |
|---|---|---|
| Private independent institutions . . . | 480 | 3,007,000 |
| Railway, Police, &c., hospitals . . | 506 | 1,111,000 |
| Total | 986 | 4,118,000 |
TABLE II
| 1880-1. | 1890-1. | 1900-1. | 1902-3. | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Persons vaccinated* . | 4,415,000 | 6,496,000 | 7,860,000 | 8,411,000 |
| Percentage of total number of persons vaccinated to population . | 2·7 | 3·1 | 3·4 | 3·5 |
| Percentage of successful vaccination in each 100 estimated births . | 19·9 | 27·5 | 33·9 | 39·1 |
| Cost of special vaccination establishment* . | Rs. 7,50,000 | Rs. 10,14,000 | Rs. 11,53,000 | Rs. 11,66,000 |
Notes
- 1. Sanskrit Literature, by A. A. Macdonell (1900), chap. xvi.
- 1. Hunter's Indian Empire, pp. 148–51.
- 1. For a short account of the medical colleges and schools, see the preceding chapter (Education).
- 1. The medical administration of the army is vested in a Surgeon-General, who is styled Principal Medical Officer, His Majesty's Forces in India. He is a staff-officer of the Commander-in-Chief, while the Director-General, Indian Medical Service, is under the Home Department of the Government of India.
- 1. In Madras he is called the District Medical and Sanitary Officer.
- 1. The figures cannot be given with absolute accuracy. All private institutions are not included in the returns, and the system of classification is not uniform in all Provinces.
- 1. Except Asansol and Samāstipur.
- *. Ajmer-Merwāra and British Baluchistān are excluded.
- †. The statistics under these heads are given to the nearest thousand.
- *. The statistics under these heads are given to the nearest thousand.