IN addition to the Musalman peasantry, with their dependents and a sprinkling of Sikh and Hindu cultivators, is a large urban and mercantile population, chiefly composed of Hindus. The Sikhs, who only number 73,000, are found in Montgomery and throughout the northern table-land, mostly intermixed with Ghakhars, Gujars, and Moghals, all of whom the Sikh Government systematically suppressed. A large proportion of those so-called Sikhs are not true Jat Sikhs, but Khatri Sikhs, and, as such, more devoted to mercantile pursuits than to farming.
As to the Hindús, they number 783,000, of whom 31 per cent. are urban, and 69 per cent. rural.
They may be conveniently grouped under three heads— Brahmans, vagrants, and traders. The first-named number 73,000, and are most numerous in the northern table-land, particularly in the Rawalpindi and Jhelum districts. They all belong to the sacerdotal caste, and, as such, receive reverence. The majority supplement their income received in dues and alms by husbandry. They are poor cultivators, being too arrogant for hard manual labour. They are, as a class, grasping and overbearing, tolerated and feared as being Levites by their co-religionists, and detested by Musalmans, especially on the frontier. Under the second head “vagrants,” of whom there are about a lakh, I include that numerous family of Hindu impostors and scamps known as fakirs, jogis, beggars, and gipsies. They live by preying upon the superstitions and fears of the credulous. They abound wherever Hindus are numerous, particularly Cis-Indus, in the northern table-land. Under the third head “traders”
I include all Aroras, Khatris, Bhatias, and Bunniahs, who unitedly amount to 610,000.* I shall describe them in some detail. They deserve description, as in some sense we govern India chiefly to their advantage, and are thereby jeopardising the stability of our hold on the affections of the people, that is, on rural India, and thus helping petty shop-keepers and money-lenders to exploit the country for their own benefit. Throughout the Punjab, if not throughout India, with the exception of that serio-comic phenomenon—the educated Bengali of the “young Bengal” school—they emphatically derive most profit from our rule, whilst contributing little to its expenses, and nothing to its strength.
Cis-Indus British officers, as well as most Musalmans, loosely term all Hindu merchants and shop-keepers, Bunniahs or Khatris, whilst Trans-Indus and south of the Salt Range they are lumped together under the exasperatingly opprobrious epithet “Kiràr.” This popular indifference to their many clearlydefined divisions and sub-divisions is not indicative of the general dislike to the calling and character of the Hindu trader, but is due to his political insignificance, and to the unobtrusive persistence with which he pursues his business. It is sufficient for our purpose to here state that the true Bunniah is hardly known west of Lahore, that the Khatris are most numerous wherever the Sikh element is well represented, that is, in the northern table-land, and that Aroras preponderate in the south-western plain, particularly in the Derajat and the neighbourhood of Mooltan. The Punjab is not the original habitat of either Bunniah or Arora, who both spread into it from the south and south-east. Both first settled in towns in which Khatris were already established, and then from such centres gradually started shops in villages, and diffused themselves by ones and twos amongst the agricultural community. A genuine Khatri is a very capable man intellectually, but no soldier. Many famous administrators have been Khatris, —for instance, Todar Mull, the Emperor Akbar's great Financial Minister, and Diwan Sawan Mull, the successful Governor of Mooltan, from 1821 to 1843.
The Aroras are lower in the social scale than Khatris, and altogether, where it is possible to draw a distinction, inferior to them.
A fourth group deserves mention—the Bhatias—a Rajput class, who have taken to commercial pursuits, and are strong in Gujrat. The respective numbers of the different classes are :—Aroras, 417,000 ; Khatris, 174,000 ; Bhatias, 14,000, and true Bunniahs, 5,000. As with respect to them all the occupation has in each case made the man, I shall write of them collectively by the loose general designation of " Bunniah." It is the one most familiar to Englishmen. Of the whole group, probably not more than 25,000 are self-cultivating proprietors, though twice that number draw large incomes from the land, having acquired a hold on it since annexation by mortgage and purchase. With the exception of 30,000 Khojahs and Piràchas, mostly descended from Hindu perverts to Islam, who still follow commercial pursuits, the whole trade of the Punjab—other than that in live-stock, meat, vegetables, liquor and carrying—is in the hands of the Bunniahs. A very small percentage of them are assessed to income tax— the only form of imperial taxation which directly reaches them. The vast majority are petty village traders and shop-keepers, whose annual net profits range from Rs. 200 to Rs. 500. A few—perhaps one in a thousand, as successful bankers, merchants or contractors on a large scale—are now men of great or considerable wealth, and deservedly respected.
As a body, the Bunniahs are men of miserable physique and no manliness of character. They spend their lives in their shops, and devote all their time to money-making. Being naturally shrewd and unprincipled, they are as proficient in that art as Jews or Greeks. Shylock was a gentleman by the side of Nand Lall Bunniah,—as Shylock, though he spoiled the Gentiles, was yet a man of honor. Nand Lall has none, commercially speaking. His greed for grain, the shameless effrontery with which he adds 50 per cent. to a debt, calls the total principal, causes his debtor to execute a bond for that principal with interest at 36 per cent per annum more, a year or two after strikes a balance against his debtor and cajoles or wearies him into mortgaging to him an ancestral plot of good land or its produce, on the understanding—carefully excluded from the deed—that mortgagor is to remain in cultivating possession, have entirely alienated the sympathies of district officers from men of his calling. Such hard business qualities make him feared, hated, and despised by the agricultural classes. Upon annexation the village Bunniah—except in the vicinity of centres of Sikh administration, such as Lahore, Umritsur, and Mooltan—was a poor, cringing creature, who, when he lent money, received payment out of the surplus of the first good yield, and never attempted to exact usurious interest because he knew it would not be paid. He was essentially, as previously stated, the humble accountant and servant of the dominant class--the agricultural community. Many are so still. But a large and growing minority are now men in comparatively easy circumstances, as traders, money-lenders, and petty landlords combined, or traders and money-lenders alone, with Rs. 1,000 or more lent out on landed security, carrying interest in grain or cash, at from Rs. 18 to Rs. 36 per cent. per annum.
Their success is largely due to their own thrift and business energy. A Hindu's thrift shows itself remarkably in his domestic economies; for however rich he may have become, he continues to live almost as parsimoniously as when he was very poor. He is only occasionally extravagant on ceremonial occasions, as when a marriage occurs. Nor does he grudge expenditure which satisfies ostentation and is also a safe investment. As soon as he has money to spare, he builds himself a handsome pucca mansion, lofty enough to excite envy, hatred, and malice in the hearts of his lowly neighbours, whose weaknesses have translated him from the position of servant to that of master. In western villages, and probably elsewhere also, there is never any occasion to ask whose is the best and most conspicuous house in a village, as with spite in his heart and scorn in his voice, the peasant's answer will certainly be "the Kiràr's." Frugal and astute though the Bunniah is, he could never have risen to his present eminence by thrift and the exercise of business qualities alone, had not our laws and revenue system suited his idiosyncrasies and been antagonistic to those of the peasantry.
According to the 1881 census, there are west of the Jhelum meridian 28,987, or, in round numbers, 29,000 males over 15 years of age, "who buy or sell, keep or lend money, houses or foods of various kinds." Of this class 9,610 are bankers and money-lenders, and 13,294 shop-keepers only. Of the former, it is worth noting that no fewer than 3,413, and of the latter 8,967, belong to frontier districts. Of those returned as shop-keepers only, it is probable that fully 25 per cent. derive some income from the interest of debts secured on bonds or mortgages. Accepting the census figures, so supplemented, as approximately correct, and trebling the product so as to obtain total numbers, the point to which I would draw attention at present is, that nearly six millions of Mahomedan peasants and their dependents are under the operations of laws and revenue system created by us within the last 36 years, being harassed and expropriated in the interest of some 40,000 Bunniahs, who contribute little to the expenses of Government, and would be a source of weakness to it in critical times.
We justly boast of the purity and excellence of our Indian administration, and plume ourselves that we are not, as the rulers of native States, venal, unjust, and indifferent to progress. True at present perhaps. But thirty years hence, should the policy of equal laws on European models for all classes be persisted in, what will be true then? Will not those very States as justly be entitled to regard our vaunted justice and other excellencies as Pharasaical nonsense, when they see half of our magnificent peasantry the bondsmen of Bunniahs, sullenly biding an opportunity to rise and sweep away their weak and despised task-masters?
To me, as to most other old Settlement and District Officers, the whole position is unsound and humiliating. Will any one say that we, as rulers in the Punjab or elsewhere, have done the best possible for our peasantry, whether Mahomedan, Sikh or Hindu, who—I cannot repeat too often—are "the people of India?" Are our laws and revenue system so framed and so administered that, without material change, their natural evolution will, when trouble comes, identify the interests of the peasantry with ours?
The question which Lord Lytton asked his Council in the discussion preceding the passing of the Deccan Ryots Act in 1879, I would address to those in authority in India. " I would ask the Council," said Lord Lytton, " is it not obvious that if in any part of India the actual cultivators of the soil see, not only the proceeds of their labor, but actually their personal freedom, passing from them into the hands of a class whom, rightly or wrongly, they regard as the authors of their ruin, and under the protection of laws which, rightly or wrongly, they regard as the engines of it, the bitterness of sentiment, the sense of hopelessness and irremediable wrong engendered by such a state of things, must be a chronic incentive, if not to social disturbances, at least to personal crime ?"
In the following pages I shall endeavour to answer the questions put forward in the last two paragraphs, and to propose remedies which, if applied, will, I believe, save us from, what must otherwise eventuate in a generation or two, an agrarian insurrection. Most of my personal experience is in the Musalman half of the Punjab. I think that those who best know the peasantry there, will agree with me that without some radical changes in the substantive civil law and its mode of administration, and for certain tracts in the revenue system, the impatience which now finds expression in the occasional murder, mal-treatment or plundering of an obnoxious money-lender, or in resistance to the attachment of cattle or grain, or other necessary of life, will soon grow into widespread disaffection. The fuel will then be ready for ignition, and a spark—a sympathetic breeze down the frontier from that hot-bed of Mahomedan fanaticism—Afghanistan—a famine, the exhortations of an agitator, whether aspiring Mahdi or land-law reformer—will kindle such a flame that Government will, in order to quench it hurriedly and fearfully, pass some Act of Bunniah spoliation more drastic than the famous Deccan Ryots Act of 1879. The object then of the following pages is to convince those in authority of our shortcomings as rulers in the Western Punjab, and to urge the timely application of practicable remedies.
Notes
- *. All that is known of them is excellently condensed by Mr. Ibbetson, in pages 291-298 of Vol. I of his Punjab Census Report, 1881.