Fifteen years ago, when reviewing the Revenue Report of the Punjab for 1871-72, the Lieutenant-Governor remarked :— "There do not appear to be any statistics available for showing the amount of land which generally, since annexation, or during any particular year, has been sold or mortgaged to money-lenders by zemindars." Some figures having been prepared, the Lieutenant-Governor in the following year "resolved" that they were "indicative of remarkable prosperity and a very moderate land revenue assessment." Since that year first regular settlements and the revisions of such settlements earlier made, have been completed or are in progress in 22 * districts, and efforts have been made to obtain reliable statistics as to transfers of rights in land, but with small success ; for, writing on December 24th, 1885, the Lieutenant-Governor, reviewing the Revenue Report for 1884-85, remarked that such returns were still admittedly defective and uncertain in meaning. † He then proposes
"In the Punjab the sale of landed property is not decreed by the civil court as an ordinary process for recovering a debt, and is only sanctioned in special cases, where there is no other possible way of satisfying a creditor. The number of such sales has been insignificant. The transfers of land by private sale and mortgage in the three years 1874-77 have concerned 850,000 acres, or an eightieth part of the area of the Province. The consideration that typical villages should be selected, and the history of transfers worked out in them, so that by the “patient study of particular instances,” Government “may be enabled to generalize with confidence on a wider field.”
Such is the disheartening outcome of 15 years of perfunctory investigation—except in the case of zealous Settlement and District Officers—into the broad facts of the statistics of land alienations, to say nothing of the minutiæ of the remoter causes of agricultural indebtedness. The explanation probably is, that it is in the nature of things that the attitude of most Provincial Governors on the land question of their charges should be one of laisser aller, until the conservative optimism of 30 years of Indian service is roused into spasmodic action by some catastrophe, such as occurred in the Bombay Deccan, in 1875.
Were it not so, agriculturists would not have risen in 1857, as they did, against their auc-tion-purchase landlords in the Gangetic Valley. Nor could the Famine Commission, 23 years later, have recorded the discreditable fact that 27 per cent. of the whole land of the N.-W. Provinces had, by 1873, passed into the hands of the trading classes. It is small consolation to know that, owing to later changes in the Code of Civil Procedure, the annual rate of transfer has since been slower. We are drifting in the same way in Lower Burmah, in which the holdings of the peasant cultivators are, I believe, being bought up by money-lenders and speculating capitalists, and no doubt a similar exploitation of Upper Burmah has already begun also.
But to return to the case of the Punjab, in which, except in regions of small rainfall, the evil of peasant expropriation is not yet generally serious. Assuming, as the Lieutenant-Governor says, that before legislation it will be wise to ascertain all obtainable particulars as to the causes of the transfers of rights in land and of indebtedness in typical villages, why spend 15 or 20 years in considering the matter? Such information could be collected in six months for the whole Province at little or no cost. Let a good Settlement Superintendent or Extra Assistant Commissioner be sent to each district; let him go to each selected village, and publicly investigate on the spot the history of each peasant's indebtedness and alienations of land, and of each money-lender's position, and the thing is done. Here, in the Punjab, all the material facts on the land question are known to every officer in it who has ever mixed freely with the people, or even read the available literature on the subject.
Formulated as six propositions, those facts are:—
I.—The gift of full individual proprietary right—in which term is included the rights of occupancy tenants—so extended each man's credit that it enables him to borrow up to the market value of his holding.
2.—Punjab agriculturists were, and still are, unfit for such a gift, the vast majority of them being to-day, after 36 years of British rule, almost as rude, ignorant,* and imprudent as they were upon annexation.
3.—In tracts in which the outturn is uncertain the rigidity of the land revenue system— which demands crop or no crop after each harvest-time a cash payment equal to about the value of one-sixth of an average yield—together with a vicious but natural propensity on the part of the people to live for the day only, have involved a considerable and annually increasing percentage of them in serious or hopeless indebtedness.
4.—The Acts, Codes, and Rules affecting the relations between ignorant debtors and educated Bunniah-creditors, all tend to benefit the latter at the expense of the former.
5.—Making due allowance for the consideration shown to agricultural debtors in the new Civil Procedure Code (Act XIV of 1882), and in the Law of Contract as interpreted in recent Chief Court Circulars and Decisions, the fact remains that agricultural indebtedness is increasing, and that if the acquisition of rights in land by Bunniahs be not arrested, agrarian troubles will shortly arise.
6.—No Government, particularly a handful of foreign sojourners, such as we are, can permit the hereditary land-holding classes, who compose "the people of the country," to be subjected to 20,000 or 30,000 money-lenders—all men of no political weight. In the western half of the Punjab, this consideration derives additional force from the fact that the "people" all belong to warlike Mahomedan tribes, and therefore look upon Hindu money-lenders with contempt.
The above six propositions being accepted, the corollary follows that for the Western Punjab, if not for the whole Province, the process of expropriation must be arrested as soon as possible by wise reforms in our land revenue system for tracts of deficient rainfall, and in our civil law and procedure generally; and, moreover, the aim of some of the reforms must be to so diminish credit that a careless man will only borrow under the compulsion of necessity.
Whether 25 or 50 per cent. of the borrowing classes are heavily involved; whether the percentage of peasant proprietors, indebted land-lords or occupancy tenants, is the largest; whether the first serious debt, or the transition from extricable to hopeless embarrassment, arose from misfortune, e. g., a bad season, or loss of plough-cattle, or preventible causes, such as unnecessary expenditure; what ratio the mortgage value of land bears to the selling value; whether the consideration is generally overstated in saledeeds in order to defeat the possible claims of pre-emptors, and many other matters,—are all questions, no doubt, interesting in themselves, but of no vital importance whatsoever as solvents of the great land problem before us.
What we have to do is to stop unnecessary borrowing ; to minimise involuntary indebtedness ; to preserve to the hereditary peasant proprietors of the Province the possession of the land and of its fruits ; to simplify the law of contract, and the procedure by which it is administered in our Courts; and, generally, to adapt our system of civil justice to the means and capacities of the peasantry : not to elaborate—as is the tendency—the system so as to make it profitably comprehensible only to the superior intelligence of money-lenders and legal practitioners.
With these preliminary remarks I shall proceed to state and discuss the various reforms which, after long consideration of the subject, commend themselves to me as most practicable and susceptible of easy introduction, without materially affecting any vested rights or shocking any prejudice. The reforms, of which I shall write, may be grouped under the following heads:—(1) Land Tenure; (2) Land Revenue System; (3) Civil Procedure; (4) Specific Miscellaneous Reforms.
Notes
- *. Detail is, first regular settlements completed in seven districts, revisions in eleven, and in four more still in progress.
- †. The available information on the subject was summed up by the Famine Commission at page 126, para. 7, Part II of their Report of 1880, as follows :—
- [Unlinked note, p. 94] paid has amounted to 145 lakhs of rupees, of which half was contributed by agriculturists and half by non-agriculturists. The amount of land which has passed yearly into the hands of the trading community, has therefore been only one-five-hundredth part of the area of the Province. In the North-Western Provinces the civil courts are not governed by the same rules as obtain in the Punjab, and sales of landed property in execution of decrees are comparatively common; so that anxiety has at times been felt as to the extent to which land has changed hands and become the property of traders. In a special inquiry held in 1873, it was ascertained that during the preceding 35 years, 17 per cent. of the land had passed from agriculturists to the trading classes, who then held 27 per cent. of the whole. But the rate of transfer had much decreased in later years, and it may be added that since then a change has been made in the law of Civil Procedure, under which sales of land have become much less a matter of course than they were.”
- *. A compulsory school cess, amounting to 1 per cent. on the land revenue demand, is levied in the Punjab. West of the Jhelum meridian it is chiefly paid by Musalmans, but utilized by Hindus The number of boys in primary schools in the 14 Musalman districts, ranges from 1 in 59 of the male population in Jhelum to 1 in 154 in Montgomery. Most of the boys are only learning to read and write. More than half are Hindus. Of Musalman agriculturists, perhaps one in a hundred can read in an advanced district like Jhelum or Rawalpindi, and one in three hundred in a backward district like Montgomery or Hazara. South of the Salt Range there are hundreds of villages in which not a single Musalman agriculturist can read or sign his own name.