2.—Land Revenue System.
In Chapter VI of this book, I have shown that one of the most unfortunate changes introduced upon annexation, was the substitution of fixity for theoretical elasticity of demand in tracts of precarious outturn. For 20 years the system was maintained by successive Lieutenant-Governors and Financial Commissioners, under the mistaken belief that as the assessments were absolutely light when compared with the yield of an average year, their rigidity was teaching prudence to an improvident people. For 20 years the axiom that the profits of good years were, or ought to be, more than a set-off against the losses of bad, was the curt and freezing rebuke invariably administered by authority to every District Officer who ventured to impugn the practice of extorting revenue from needy, cropless peasants. But as settlements became more and more elaborate and inquisitorial in character, the old axiom was discovered to be a paradox.
Between 1870 and 1880, the best modes of adapting the land revenue to the variations of the seasons were freely discussed, but each was successively damned by what was termed the "fatal objection," that to work any fluctuating system on a large scale, demanded an impossible postulate, viz., a large body of honest native operatives.
During the Regular Settlements of most of the districts of the south-western plain—especially in those of Bannu, Dera-Ismail-Khan, Muzaffargarh, and Mooltan—several forms of fluctuating assessments (some of which had never been formally sanctioned) were either quietly recognised, or introduced chiefly for lands in the bed of the Indus and Chenab rivers.* Such lands being subjected to great vicissitudes owing to the uncertain action of the inundations in the flood season and to the changes which then occur in the course of the streams themselves, the absurdity of maintaining a fixed assessment, where one existed, and the inadequacy of the palliatives of the one per cent. and ten per cent. rules, † where one or other was in force, were self-evident to the Settlement Officer; hence a fluctuating system of annual assessment on a common-sense basis was introduced. The area so treated is shown at page 113.
In 1879 the Government of India, in consequence of the revelations forced upon its notice by the report of the Deccan Riots Commission, made general inquiries throughout Upper India on the possibility of ameliorating the condition of agriculturists with due regard to the claims of the State upon them, and advocated the introduction of elasticity of demand wherever the uncertain character of harvests made it desirable. Experts were consulted throughout the Punjab, and a consensus of opinions obtained in favor of some adaptation of the demand to the outturn; but officers disagreed in details as to system. The result was, what I may term, an abstract resolution from the pen of the then Lieutenant-Governor (Sir Robert Egerton), that theoretically a reversion to kind assessments was advisable, but practically impossible, and that no other fluctuating system was feasible. During the inquiry the Settlement Commissioner (Colonel Wace, now Junior Financial Commissioner), stated that throughout the Western Punjab a fluctuating system had been, or was being, introduced in all tracts in which it was applicable.*
The following statement, prepared from Settlement Reports, Gazetteers, and personal knowledge, gives the tracts of short rainfall and precarious crops in which a fluctuating system, though applicable, has not yet been introduced :—
| I | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| District. | Tract. | Average annual rainfall in inches. | AREA IN SQUARE MILES DEPENDENT ON RAINFALL. | Estimated land revenue of area in column 4. | ||
| Cultivated. | Uncultivated. | Total. | ||||
| Bannu .. | Marwat ... Isakhel ... Mianwali ... | 12 | 470 | 2,450 | 2,920 | 1,50,000 |
| Dera-Ismail-Khan | Cis-Indus uplands and part of Tank. | 8 | 77 | 6,037 | 6,114 | 25,000 |
| Dera-Ghazi-Khan | The Pachad ... | 8 | 375 | 1,942 | 2,317 | 90,000 |
| Rawalpindi ... | Pindigheb ... Fattehjang ... | 19 15 | 605 | 3,344 | 3,949 | 1,94,000 |
| Jhelum ... | Pind-Dadan-Khan Chakwal ... Tallaganj | 18 15 19 | 752 | 2,576 | 3,328 | 2,40,000 |
| Shahpur ... | All but sailâb lands | 13 | 98 | 3,571 | 3,669 | 31,000 |
| Montgomery ... | Ditto ... | 9 | 16 | 4,015 | 4,031 | 5,000 |
| Jhang ... | Ditto ... | 10 | 5 | 4,059 | 4,064 | 3,000 |
| Mooltan ... | Ditto ... | 6 | 164 | 4,231 | 4,395 | 52,000 |
| Total ... | ... | 2,562 | 32,225 | 34,787 | 7,90,000 | |
The various modes of adapting land revenue collections to the seasons, which now either obtain over selected areas or have been recommended as feasible, are the following:—
(A).—The old native system commonly called kham tahsil or direct management, under which a share of each crop is taken in kind or by appraisement.
(B).—A cyclical system under which the full revenue demand would be imposed for a cycle of years, and realised within the period at the discretion of the local land revenue authorities, according to the character of each season's yield.
(C).—A portion of the revenue—probably one quarter of a full assessment—to be fixed, and differential crop rates superadded on each season's cultivated area.
(D).—Fixed village rates or differential crop rates to be levied according to the acreage actually cultivated each season in each village.
Of the above systems, the first (A) is theoretically the fairest. It is still resorted to in the rare cases when proprietors refuse to engage, that is, do not accept the fixed assessment imposed at settlement. In most cases the yield is actually measured or appraised, and the Government share is then commuted into cash, and that demand realised from each cultivator. In the Dera-Ismail-Khan district a frontier tribe called Gandapur, occupying a compact block of territory, refused to accept the assessment imposed in 1878, owing to which, and for other reasons, the maintenance of “direct management,” which had been in force since annexation, was continued. The tract covers 311 square miles, in some years bears splendid crops, in some none at all, and is altogether a country in which a fixed demand would entail great hardships. The demand varies from Rs. 12,000 to Rs. 40,000 each year. I worked the system for three years myself, as well as a somewhat similar one in a tract further to the south, held by a semi-independent Pathan tribe called Usteranahs. In the Gandapur tract, in order to diminish inconvenience, prevent fraud, and partly also as a safeguard against arson, the whole yield was, season by season, collected upon five or six threshing floors, and then divided into heaps, according to the share taken respectively by village menials, tenants, and other cultivators, mortgagees, proprietors, and the State. The latter's share being weighed, was commuted into cash at a liberal rate. Though personally well disposed to the system, my experience is, that it is burdensome alike to the people—especially to the actual tenant cultivators—and to Government officials, unpopular with both, and altogether unsatisfactory.
The second (B) or cyclical system was proposed and warmly advocated, between 1870 and 1875, by several Settlement Officers— myself at first amongst others—and still has supporters. It is, however, quite impracticable. Unless the whole cycle can be administered by the same revenue officers, it would be impossible to fix individual responsibility, on which alone success would depend. As a cycle of the seasons means a period in which—besides good, bad, and indifferent crops, or none at all—at least one bumper yield will be harvested, it follows that seven or eight years would represent the cycle. In such a long term the District Officer (Collector) would probably be changed three times, and the local Tahsildar (Deputy Collector) at least once. Other objections need not be given, as the one already stated is insurmountable.
The third system (C), called in vernacular chharam mustakil or "quarter fixed," under which a portion of what otherwise would be the annual revenue demand is fixed, and village or crop rates taken, in addition, on the actual acreage cultivated each season, was introduced in the Takwara circle, in the Dera-Ismail-Khan district, in 1878, and is still in operation. It was worked by me for three years, and, like all half-measures, is, I think, a failure. The tract in which it was introduced covers 138 square miles, and under the double method in force, yields from Rs. 10,000 to Rs. 20,000 in land revenue each year. Each village was fully assessed at settlement in the ordinary way, and one quarter of the demand was treated as fixed, and in addition differential crop rates were imposed on each year's cultivated area. In some villages, which had been unlucky in rainfall or in catching a passing flood from an occasional hill torrent, the fixed fraction in a term of five years actually exceeded the revenue derived in that period from the crop rates. This fact proves that for such a country any fixed revenue, even pitched as low as 300 per cent. below the full assessment, which would otherwise have been taken, was an unreasonable burden upon a poor peasantry. All that can be said for the system is that, as a step towards fluctuation, it is perhaps, on the whole, an improvement on direct management (A) on a large scale, because it is comparatively easily worked, and does not interfere too much with the operations of husbandry.
There remains the last or what I may call the "annual simple rate system (D)," under which circle, village, or crop rates are fixed at settlement, and taken each season on the actual acreage then under cultivation. Throughout the riverain tracts of the Punjab, subject to vicissitudes from inundation and changes in the channels of rivers, the principle of fixed assessments had soon after annexation to be relaxed, and was replaced by two systems known, the one, as the “10 per cent.,” and the other, as the “1 per cent. rule.” The percentage in each case was that of actual loss or gain from diluvion or alluvion. When more, the Government demand was proportionately reduced or raised; when less, the revenue-paying proprietors of the village were alone the losers or the gainers. Between 1862 and 1864 the changes in the course of the Indus, in the Bannu district, were so great that the former rule was extended and made applicable to the whole area cultivated in each year between the two high banks of the river. Thus, whenever in any village the loss or gain in cultivated area, however caused, exceeded 10 per cent, village acreage rates were imposed over the whole of it. Even this expansion of the old narrow rule fell short of being satisfactory. It was, therefore, further modified by me in 1871-72, from which year a fixed acreage rate was annually charged on the whole area under the plough in the year. Finally, in 1878, complete elasticity was effected by the imposition of a uniform rate on the whole acreage under cultivation for more than two years, and a light rate on newly-broken up land. This rule was so simple, easily worked, popular, and beneficial both to Government and cultivators that, with suitable local modifications, it has since been introduced throughout the riverain alluvial tracts of the Dera-Ismail-Khan district, and of the Muzaffargarh, Mooltan, and Jhang districts as well. I served in the Bannu district from 1867 to 1878, and in the Dera-Ismail-Khan district from 1881 until November 1885. In both districts one of my duties was the supervision of the working of the fluctuating systems of assessment in force in them. I have thus long experience in what I have called the “annual simple rate system." The area over which it now obtains is as follows :—
| Name of district. | Name of river or tract. | Annual cultivated area in square miles in 1884-85. | Revenue in 1884-85. | Remarks. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rs. | ||||
| Bannu ... | Indus & Kurram. | 118 | 90,259 | These figures are taken from the Revenue Administration Report for 1884-85, Statement XB. |
| D.-I.-Khan, | Indus & Da-man tract. | 545 | 2,61,287 | |
| Montgomery, | Ravi ... | 15 | 11,165 | |
| Jhang ... | Chenab and Ravi. | 12 | 7,449 | |
| Mooltan ... | Ravi, Sutlej, & Chenab. | 156 | 96,824 | |
| Muzaffargarh, | Indus and Chenab. | 235 | 1,64,085 | |
| Total ... | ... | 1,081 | 6,31,069 |
Several reasons render the working of such a system on more extended lines easier now than its predecessor was ten years ago. We have now for all districts excellent largescale field-maps, which will do long service as the boundaries of fields are constant. Then, under the operation of the new rules for the collection and registering of agricultural statistics, the revenue staff—particularly the field portions of it—has been improved and strengthened, so that all work connected with those statistics is locally performed. Thus the "annual simple rate system" can be extended to all unprotected tracts without any occasion for a further increase of establishment, and the old "fatal objection" to the introduction of any fluctuating method of collection is therefore removed. It does not matter whether the rates imposed be differential crop, village or circle rates, provided that they are so simple as to be understood by the people, in which case their manipulation by corrupt subordinate officials is an impossibility.
After working the system, and those from which it was evolved, in the Bannu district, for 10 years, over an area of 400 square miles, occupied by about 68,500 souls, all agriculturists and their dependents, and involving an annual revenue of about a lakh, I can only recall three cases in which fraud was perpetrated. In all three, it was easily detected on attestation, as it had been effected by the ticking off on the field register of cultivated fields as fallow. I earnestly suggest the extension of the system to the tracts described in the tabular statement given at page 108. As most of those areas are under settlements which will not expire for ten or more years, the fluctuating system I advocate can only be introduced upon re-settlement, or with the consent of the body of the revenue-payers in each village, or when suspensions, remissions or general impoverishment have practically effected a breach of the contract entered into at settlement between the village proprietary body on the one part and Government on the other, in which case the law permits the cancelment of the settlement. I do not think, were I District Officer, I should experience much difficulty in inducing a majority of the villages, in any of the tracts I have named, to apply for the "annual simple rate system" during the currency of a settlement. Being easily intelligible to the people, practicable and just to both Government and themselves, they could not fail to recognise that it meets the great desideratum of establishing a ratio between the actual yield and the land revenue demand in each year. Now that Government has renounced the old shibboleth that good years must recoup the losses of bad, and acts on the principle that after bad seasons it is wiser to promptly grant suspensions and remissions, rather than by inaction to constrain the people to borrow at ruinous rates from village usurers, fixity of demand as a system no longer survives. As illustrative of this fact, I may note that in the last Punjab Administration Report (that for 1884-85), the provincial land revenue balances are stated to amount to nearly a million of rupees, of which eight-tenths are on account of outstandings in the south-east part of the Province. A possible argument against the reform I proposed requires notice. Some will insist that the variations in the land revenue collections, consequent on the extended introduction of fluctuating assessments, will upset budget calculations. The answer to such an unworthy plea for short-sighted extortion is, that the wideness of the area over which the proposed system will extend will, in all but famine years, secure reasonable fixity on the aggregate of the collections; and further, that the practice now obtaining of prompt and liberal suspensions—followed by remissions when necessary—must already be a more disturbing factor than any fluctuating system could be. Finally, if another argument is wanted, it should be sufficient to point out that even if the budget estimates be upset, such a dislocation is of no consequence compared with the supreme necessity of securing a contented and prosperous peasantry.
Notes
- *. The Jhelum river joins the Chenab about 10 miles south of Jhang. The Ravi joins their combined stream some 40 miles further south, and the Sutlej-cum-Bias unites with them some 40 miles south of Mooltan. Natives call the united streams by the name of one rather than by the more correct terms of Trinab or "three waters," and Punjnad or "five streams."
- †. For explanation of terms, see page 112.
- *. In Appendix D will be found the remarks and recommendations of the Indian Famine Commission (1880), on relative advantages of fixity and elasticity of demand, to which I have ventured to add a note of my own, as I do not entirely agree with the Commission, and think that were all the data now available before them, they would come to the same conclusion as I do in the following pages.