Appendix A

Present Condition of the Peasantry in the Eight Districts of the South-Western Plain.

Musalmans and Money-Lenders in the Punjab, Septimus Smet Thorburn, 1886 · from page 155 · about 25 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

1.—Shahpur District.

The Shahpur district was settled many years ago. A revision will shortly be begun. During the last 16 years, several inundation canals have been dug from the Jhelum with good results. The railway line is now open to Bhera, and is being extended. Statistics upon agricultural indebtedness, and the alienation of land to non-agriculturists, are very imperfect. I know the district, and believe that the District Officer's conclusion given below is correct:—

There are no large bankers in the district, but every village has its petty money-lender, generally of the Khatri caste, to whom the people are largely indebted. The Deputy Commissioner reports that “the peasantry are generally in debt. This is due partly to a succession of several seasons of drought, but chiefly to the very improvident and extravagant habits of the agricultural classes in respect of marriage expenses, useless establishment of retainers, dress, and the like. It is also due partly to the high interest obtained by money-lenders for loans, for which the rate without security is often as high as Rs. 6-4 per cent. per mensem, or Rs. 75-12 per annum. On mortgages the rate varies with the nature of the security, from one to two per cent. per mensem.—District Gazetteer, p. 57.

2.—Montgomery District.

Mr. Purser, C.S., revised the settlement of this district.

The work was begun in 1868, and completed in 1874. Mr. Purser's knowledge of the district and people is more extensive and exact than that of any officer who has ever served in Montgomery. He had no society but that of the people, and no occupation but that of his work. His ability and learning are great. The extracts given below are from his settlement report. His facts may be accepted as accurately true.

The people of this district are a bold, sturdy set; they are unsophisticated, and can laugh. But they avoid speaking the truth upon principle, and withal lie in such an artless and reckless way that a Hindustani would blush with shame at their silliness. They completely fail to grasp the idea of rights in property, when the property appears in the shape of their neighbour's cattle or wife. They are only moderately industrious. Some say they are lazy, but they are not. They are extravagant, ignorant, and superstitious. To travellers they extend a tolerable hospitality; but Hatim Tai need not look to his laurels on account of their rivalry. In fact, they seem made up of bad qualities and half-hearted virtues, yet there must be something good about them, for one gets to like them : but why, it would be hard to say.

The revenue and the seed are usually borrowed; and there are very few villagers that are not seriously in debt. This is matter of little importance, so long as the Kiràr does not try to oust the proprietors and get the land into his own hands. But such a course is very rare in this district, because, except in the canal villages, a Kiràr makes a great deal more as creditor of the owner of the land than he would as owner himself. But the people are very bitter about the exactions of the Kiràrs, and make unpleasant comparisons between now and the good old Sikh times. Then if a man owed a Kiràr money, and they could not arrange matters, the case went before the Kardar. The Kardar had the Kiràr's books examined, and on being told how much principal and how much interest was due, he would say—"Strike off so much interest!" Then he would inquire how many cattle the debtor had. He would be told, so many. "And what are they worth?" "Ten rupees each head." "Good, the Kiràr must take the cattle at Rs. 12 each in payment of his debt;" and every body went off satisfied. Now the debtor offers cattle; but the creditor prefers chehra shahi rupees. A suit is the consequence, and the debtor has to pay the costs in addition to the claim. The creditor, who before the suit had no desire to have the cattle, suddenly discovers that they are not without merit. He executes his decree, attaches the cattle worth Rs. 10 each, and buys them himself for Rs. 5. There is a great deal of truth in this account of matters; but the fact seems to be totally forgotten that the Kiràrs did not rob the people then so much as they do now, simply because the Sikh Kardar took very good care that the people should have nothing whereof to be robbed.

3.—Muzaffargarh District.

This district was settled by Mr. O'Brien, C. S., between 1873 and 1880. He devoted himself to his work, and lived amongst the people all the year round. There is no society in the district. Whilst Settlement Officer, he acquired the Jatki dialect of the people, and made a collection of their proverbs and songs. It is impossible that an Englishman could have a greater knowledge of his charge than had Mr. O'Brien. The extracts are from his settlement report. His facts may be relied on as correct.

No material difference in welfare exists between tenants with occupancy rights and tenants-at-will in this district. The average area owned by proprietors is five acres. Both proprietors and tenants have an area for grazing, which is practically unlimited. Both proprietors and tenants live in what is literally a hand-to-mouth way. Each harvest barely suffices for the wants of the half year, and is almost always forestalled by borrowing. In regard to their economic state and habits, the agricultural classes naturally group themselves into Mahomedans and Hindus. Of the Mahomedan proprietors, 70 per cent. are in debt. Of the Hindu proprietors, 30 per cent. are in debt. It is very difficult to estimate what proportion the average indebtedness of the proprietors bears to the average yearly income. The lowest estimate in the materials before me says, that the amount borrowed yearly is equal to 30 per cent. of the yearly income of the indebted proprietors. The highest estimate gives the debts as 80 per cent. of the yearly income. Of Mahomedan tenants 40 per cent., and of Hindu tenants 20 per cent., are in debt. The yearly debts of the tenants are equal to 20 per cent. of their yearly income. The cause of the difference between the numbers of the indebted among Mahomedans and Hindus, respectively, is to be found in the difference of the habits of each class. Mahomedans are mostly spendthrift and improvident. The Hindus are the reverse. Mahomedans are nearly always uneducated ; Hindus are always more or less educated. Hindus usually avoid acts that would bring them within the reach of the criminal law, while Mahomedans supply almost the whole criminal population, and so incur the expenses which follow from being suspected by the police and being prosecuted. Mahomedans have only one source of income, viz., agriculture. Hindus, who own and cultivate land, almost always combine money-lending and trade with agriculture. Hindus acquire land as payment for debts. Mahomedans generally borrow money to buy land.

The indebtedness in this district is greater than in any district with which I am acquainted. I append some very true remarks of Mr. Lyall's on the subject, which he made when reviewing the assessment report of the Alipur Tahsil :—"I quite agree with Mr. O'Brien's remarks as to the indebtedness of the agriculturists, and the faults in their character, which are its main cause. The same faults are attributed generally to the Mahomedan land-holders of all this southern corner of the Punjab, but they are found in this Tahsil in a very exaggerated form. The heavy floods, and the fever which follows, have something to do with it. The almost universal prosperity of the Kiràr land-holders is proof that there is nothing crushing in the general pitch of the assessment. But as the Biluches, Syads, and Jats say, it would be folly to expect them to alter their characters and habits, and rival the thrift and frugality of the Kiràrs. These Kiràrs are the Jews of the country, and have a special natural aptitude for earning and saving money. The general character of the agriculturists must be considered in assessing ; but from what I have seen here and in Mooltan and Dera-Ghazi-Khan, I do not believe that a very light assessment would tend to get them out of debt."

4.—Jhang District.

Mr. Steedman, C. S., revised the settlement of Jhang between 1874 and 1880. His knowledge of his district was thorough, as, like Mr. O'Brien, he lived amongst the people for years, and felt great sympathy with them. Like Montgomery and Muzaffargarh, Jhang is a secluded rural district, in which there are only one or two European officers, in addition to the Deputy Commissioner. The extracts given below from Mr. Steedman's settlement report, faithfully represent the way the Jhang agriculturists have become involved in debt.

When the owner of a good well or a fat piece of sailâb deals with a Bunniah who is anxious to hold some land in mortgage, he finds that his credit is unlimited. It is a case of spending made easy. He can have whatever he wants whenever he wishes. All that he is troubled with, is his signature or assent to the usual six-monthly statement of accounts, and at harvest time he will make a few payments to the Bunniah in grain. This goes on for four or five years, or often longer. Then the demeanour of the creditor changes. He insists upon a registered bond for the amount due or a mortgage. The debtor temporises as long as he can, perhaps transfers his account to another shop, often takes his chance of a law-suit, trusting in his luck to evade some of the items. All these devices fail, and he makes over a share in his property on a verbal lekha-mukhi contract to his creditor. This is probably the very worst thing he could do. A lekha-mukhidar is as hardly displaced as was the old man of the sea. The zemindar never goes into the account, and is fleeced in every possible way. Instead of growing less, the debt grows larger, and a mortgage is at last gained."

The real and true cause of all our woe was the mistaken and misplaced gift of full transferable proprietary right in land to the cultivator, and with it of a vast credit, only limited by the value of that proprietary right. It is only of late that there has been an awakening to the true facts of the case; but that the cause stated is the true one, I have not the slightest doubt.

The thrifty and unembarrassed zemindars of this district can be counted upon one's fingers. So long as a zemindar has credit, so long will he borrow, and so long as he borrows shall we find our annual returns of land-transfers slowly, but surely and steadily, increasing. The sole basis of his credit is his transferable property in the land. Take this away, and all the security that the money-lender has is the annual outturn of the crops. In such a case we should not hear of zemindars being thousands of rupees in debt. Their credit would shrink, and their debts too. There are numbers of villages along-side the Bar, east of Kot-Isashah, in which there is hardly a single mortgage. Why? Because cultivation is uncertain, and the mortgagee might find the mortgaged well abandoned in a few months, and himself left saddled with the revenue. It is not good enough. Here the zemindars have no credit, and they are not in debt, except to a small amount. You do not find tenants-at-will over head-and-ears in debt. They are in debt it is true, but the limit is the amount that the Bunniah considers is pretty certain to be re-paid to him at the next harvest.—Jhang Gazetteer, pp. 94-96.

5.—Mooltan District.

The settlement was revised by Mr. Roe, C. S., between 1873 and 1880. His native assistant was a gentleman named Rai Hukur Chand, an officer of great experience and knowledge of the district. The following is an extract from his opinion on the state of the agriculturists of the district. This opinion was given, in 1879, to the Famine Commission.

Proprietors.—These men are generally well, or fairly well, and some are very well off. Of the Mahomedans, 50 per cent. are in debt, but many are only temporarily so. They have to borrow to meet any emergency, but pay off the debt in two or three years. This 50 per cent. of the debtors may be thus sub-divided :—

TBL-011 · FOLIO 172Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Per cent.
(1). Those who are so involved that they cannot free themselves without selling all or a part of their land10
(2). Those who are solvent, but cannot pay immediately25
(3). Those who can pay immediately15

Debts are due to two main causes—(a) ostentation and profligacy, (b) litigation,—i. e., cases arising out of spite and criminal fines. Of the Hindu proprietors, only some 15 per cent. are in debt. Of these, about half are petty Kiràr zemindars, who are probably insolvent. The others can pay without difficulty.

Occupancy tenants are generally poor; some are decently off, but few make more than a living. Some 20 per cent. of them are in debt, but their debts are small, and arise chiefly from agricultural misfortune, such as the death of bullocks, sickness, &c., or from punishment in the criminal courts. The maurusi paying in cash are very few; nearly all are men whose rents were authoritatively fixed at the last settlement, and who are practically sub-proprietors. Their profits are some 50 per cent. higher than those of the servants-at-will.

Tenants-at-will have to be sought for by the proprietors and settled at their expense on the wells. They are poor, but not more than 10 per cent. are in debt, and their debts are very petty.

The Settlement Officer, Mr. Roe, after expressing his concurrence in the opinion just quoted, writes as follows :—

We find the people just what, from the historical summary already given, we should expect them to be. The great mass of them are Mahomedan Jats, the descendants of Hindu tribes, some of whom may have come from Rajputana and Sindh, whilst others may have been in the country from long before the days of Alexander. Besides these, we have groups of Afghans, generally of superior position, who gained their lands with the Nawabs of Mooltan, and a considerable number of Hindu Kiràrs, who, for the most part, pushed their way, or were introduced by Sawan Mull, into nearly all the villages during the Sikh rule. Amongst the Jats, many of the better classes are men of energy and intelligence, taking a keen interest in the improvement of their estates, and managing them most successfully. But the bulk of the smaller zemindars are ignorant and careless farmers, destitute of energy, drifting along without a thought for the morrow, and not attempting to look into their accounts as long as the money-lender will give them an advance. When the day of settlement comes at last, and they find themselves hopelessly involved, they attribute their ruin, not to their own laziness and extravagance, but to the avarice of the Kiràr, and look to the District Officer to cancel their debts and reduce their assessments. Some excuse may be made for them in the fact that they were quite unprepared for our system of cash assessments. * * The

Hindu Kiràrs, as a rule, are thrifty and hardworking, and most of those who own land have little to do with money-lending. Most of the leading Afghans are, like many of the leading Jats, energetic and intelligent, but they suffer from the same vice of extravagance. Men who should be walking, think they must keep their horse ; those who could properly afford one or two horses, think they must keep five or six : men who would be men of substance and position, if they would only look after their property themselves, think it adds to their dignity to transact all their business through a mukhtar or agent. The consequence is, that there is a very serious amount of indebtedness. Only the amount due on regular mortgages has been recorded in the settlement papers, and this can hardly be accepted as absolutely correct. But it is hardly likely to be over the mark, for against exaggerations intended to defeat pre-emption, may be set off accidental omissions. Taking the amount of the liabilities shown in the statements as approximately correct, they cover 2·4 per cent. of the total area. At the regular settlement the area mortgaged was 1·7 per cent. of the whole. It is, however, probable that the increase has not really been so great as this, for at the regular settlement the importance of obtaining a record of the mortgage was hardly so well understood, and there were probably more omissions then than now. No attempt has been made to record the amount due on lekha-mukhi mortgages, but the area affected by them (counting only those which are proved or admitted) is 7·2 per cent. of the whole. Adding this to the regular mortgages, the total area pledged is 9·7 per cent. of the whole : this is a very serious amount of debt.

In reviewing Mr. Roe's report, Colonel Wace comments upon the above remarks :—

On the whole, Mr. Roe attributes the debts of the agriculturists rather to their apathy, improvidence, and (in a few cases) recklessness, than to the necessary results of our system of fixed cash assessments. Though I do not desire to detract from the weight due to an opinion based on seven years' intimate association with the agricultural classes of the district, I think that few of us, in forming our judgment of the cases of existing agricultural indebtedness, adequately realise the changes in the economic condition of the people introduced since annexation. Within the last 33 years the people have passed rapidly from a system of direct dependence on the assistance and supervision of the ruler, to one in which they are thrown entirely on their own resources. The change is forcibly described in the reply* on this subject furnished to the Famine Commission by Mr. O'Brien, Settlement Officer of Muzaffargarh * * * * There can be no doubt that the continued bad farming, extravagance, and improvidence of the agricultural classes, has produced the present state of indebtedness. But if we go further and ask what caused the bad farming, extravagance, and improvidence, the answer is, that the people were never trained for the position in which they are placed by our Government, and were never fit for such a position. Under former Governments they were kept, as regards agriculture, in a state of tutelage. They were quite unaccustomed to manage for themselves. The Government Kardars did everything for them, made them cultivate the land, made the Hindus lend them money and seed, and made the borrowers repay. The agriculturists were pitted against one another to cultivate, If one man did not cultivate his land it was taken from him and given to another who would cultivate. After annexation this minute superintendence was withdrawn. —Mooltan Gazetteer, p. 86.

6.—Bannu District.

I made the first regular settlement of the Bannu district between 1872 and 1879. In my report I did not draw as much attention as I ought to have done to the depressed state of the Cis-Indus tract of Mianwali. As I lived chiefly Trans-Indus, and as the frontier tahsils received the larger share of my attention, the Cis-Indus portion of the district, which lies from 70 to 90 miles away from head-quarters, across three troublesome, unbridged rivers, were comparatively little in my thoughts. I, however, knew the Mianwali tract well, having been in solitary charge of it for the two years preceding the commencement of settlement operations. Its area is nearly 1,500 square miles, throughout which, except in the bed of the Indus, a fixed cash assessment is levied. The rainfall is about 12 inches. The people are much in debt, and fast losing their best lands to non-agriculturists.

The following extracts are from my settlement report :—

The large majority of the land-owning classes are self-cultivating peasants of small means and frugal habits. With two important exceptions, they are all fairly prosperous and in infinitely easier circumstances than they were thirty years ago. * * * * * *

These remarks apply to the ordinary peasant, but with two exceptions. They are the Marwats of the poor sandy tracts, the larger half of Marwat, and those of the Bannuchis, whose holdings are so minute as to give the owners a bare subsistence. With both the struggle for existence is terrible, when anything occurs to increase expenditure or reduce income, and numbers drop down every unfavorable year into the position of tenants or of labourers. With the former, once a debt of the class known as ghara (neck) is incurred, it is pretty certain that in a few years the debtor must sell his land. This pernicious ghara system of securing a loan dates from some twenty years back. Under it the debtor either engages to pay as interest a certain portion of his earnings, and thus makes himself the quasi-bondsman of his creditor, or a certain measure of grain each harvest, crop or no crop. * * * * * *. In the other exceptional case, that of the owners, of the minutest of the minute Bannuchi holdings, Government neither can nor ought to do anything. The assessment is fair, and a crop being a certainty, our system is elastic enough. The cause of the smallness of the holdings is over-population, and for that the State is not called upon to find a remedy. Besides, the Bannuchis are such a poor hybrid race as to be of little political account. With them there is no fear of a stalwart hereditary peasantry being expropriated as there is in Marwat.

Now to pass on to the landlord class—the sufaid-poshes—who do not cultivate with their own hands. As a rule, they are neither so frugal nor prosperous as the better of the peasant proprietary class. Good 20 per cent. of them are deeply involved in debt, and a large minority habitually live beyond their income. A few of course, say 10 per cent., are shrewd, careful men, and their holdings and incomes are growing, not diminishing, in amount. Old families sink into poverty from two causes, both due to a foolish pride. The head of the house thinks he must maintain a reputation for hospitality, the highest of virtues amongst Pathans, and to maintain it he mortgages and borrows freely. Then his sons are brought up in idleness and married early, and no matter how the res angusta domi may press, they disdain to work with their own hands.

7.—Dera-Ismail-Khan District.

Mr. Tucker, C. S., made the first regular settlement of Dera-Ismail-Khan between 1872 and 1879. He had an intimate knowledge of his charge, and did his best to remove all necessity for indebtedness on account of a fixed revenue demand in a country of uncertain crops, by introducing a fluctuating system of assessment, wherever it appeared feasible. In the short extracts given below, he states simple facts, and does not examine into causes.

When lands are mortgaged to Hindus, the mortgagor generally remains in possession, paying either a share of the produce, or a fixed amount in cash or grain, or regular cash interest. In these latter cases, the property is only collateral security for the payment of the debt, and the revenue is paid by the mortgagor as before. Where cash interest is taken, the rate is generally Rs. 1-9 per cent. per mensem. Where the mortgagee gets a share of the produce, he has generally to pay a corresponding share of the revenue,—sometimes he pays the whole revenue. Another sort of mortgage is the ordinary usufructuary mortgage, where the mortgagee keeps an account of the produce, and charges it against the principal and interest of the debt. In these parts, however, the profits from the land are seldom applied to meeting the principal, which is paid off in a lump sum at redemption. Hindus rarely take over the cultivation of mortgaged lands, as they find that the old proprietor makes the best tenant, and his affection for his old fields makes him submit to harder terms, as regards rent, than would be accepted by an outsider. There are seldom any detailed provisions as to redemption of mortgages. They are generally for no fixed term, and can be redeemed after the wheat harvest has been cut.

In the Dera, Bhakkar, and Leiah tahsils, the bulk of the mortgages are held by Hindus. As a rule, the greatest amount of mortgage is to be found in well tracts. Proprietary rights in wells were clearly recognised under native Governments, and a large portion of these well-mortgages date back to pre-annexation days. The cultivators of sailaba and Daman lands originally held the position rather of tenants than of proprietors, their rights being acknowledged only so long as they cultivated their lands efficiently. Such lands, therefore, were only mortgaged in the more settled tracts. To the present day there is but little . mortgage in the river villages, where lands are liable to be washed away, and do not therefore afford sufficient security to the money-lender. In parts of the Bhakkar and Leiah Kachi the population is very much indebted, and there is no doubt that many of these small Mahomedan proprietors must eventually be sold up.

Mr. Lyall endorsed the above conclusion in the following words :— All we can do is to amend anything in our revenue system which tends to hurry on the process. Only a minority of these men have proved fit for the improved status which we gave them; the majority will descend in time into the position which suits them, of mere tillers of the soil, with enough to live upon, but no credit to pledge and no property to lose. Their original position under native Governments was little better than this. It is of course the too frequent elevation of the despised Kiràr or Hindu money-lender over the heads of a naturally dominant Mahomedan population which is the worst part of the change.—District Gazetteer, pp. 89-91.

I served in D.-I.-Khan from 1882 to 1884, both years included, as Deputy Commissioner, and latterly as Divisional Judge, and during those four years collected much information on agricultural indebtedness. In June, 1884, I submitted a report on the subject to Government, from which I here take the following extract :—

My inquiries lead me to believe that, excluding the five to eight lakhs of petty debts, most of which could be easily paid off after any average harvest, the debts at present owed by Mahomedans to Hindus in this district, amount to between 12 and 14 lakhs of rupees. Taking the lower figure of 12 lakhs, the annual interest on it is not less than on the average 18 per cent. or Rs. 2,16,000. The true state of the indebtedness of the agricultural population of this or any other district will only be disclosed when a debt commission be appointed, and ascertain publicly at his home in typical villages in each locality the debt owed by each hereditary agriculturist. The process is not difficult. I have myself carried it out in some villages in the Bannu district. So far as my inquiries have gone, they warrant a conclusion that the following table is no exaggeration of the truth :—

TBL-012 · FOLIO 178Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
State of indebtedness, if any.Percentage of Mahomedans.
Already ruined13
Irretrievably involved10
Seriously, but retrievably involved28
Would be free with two good crops and a little thrift26
Owing nothing, or if anything, under Rs. 50, and easily able to pay it23

In all that I have hitherto written, I have, to the best of my ability, endeavoured to rather under than over-state what I believe to be facts. That I am no pessimist, but rather the reverse, a perusal of paras. 67 and 68 of my Bannu Settlement Report will prove ; but in those paras. I seem to have omitted to take into account the state of the agricultural population of the Mianwali, Thal, and Mohar tracts, now, I believe, in very depressed circumstances. I also hoped that the extreme moderation of my Trans-Indus assessments would eventually free most deserving debtors from their embarrassments.

I acknowledge that the material prosperity of this district is greater than it was before annexation. The value and quantity of gold and silver ornaments worn by Hindus—men, women, and children,—at festivals,—e. g., the Baisakhi, cannot but strike strangers with the comparative wealth of that intelligent and frugal people. Then as to Mahomedans, they eat better, dress better, have more metal vessels in their houses than before annexation. What Mr. Lyall remarked in the quotation made in para. 8,—viz., "the majority" (of the Mahomedan proprietors) "will descend in time into the position which suits them, of mere tillers of the soil, with enough to live upon, but no credit to pledge, and no property to lose : their original position under native Governments was little better than this,"—is perfectly true in one sense. But we shaped and defined the rights of those Mahomedan proprietors. We gave them landed status, and taught them to value it, and they are losing those rights and that status in consequence of "our system;" and whether in a material sense they are as well off now as under native Governments, or even better off, is a side-issue only, because besides being materially poorer to-day than they were, say, twenty years ago, they are also worse off in this important respect, that they were under native Governments members of the dominant caste, or connected with it at all events ; whereas now they are becoming servants of the then dependent and still despised caste. Again, in years of drought before annexation, the Mahomedan cultivator could easily save himself and cattle by migrating elsewhere, but now through the increase of population and the recording of rights, vested and well protected interests everywhere shackle his freedom of movement, and obstruct or forbid free squatting and free selecting even of a temporary nature. Though, too, it is true that the "cultivated area" is double what it was at annexation, and that the population has not increased at a similar ratio, still the ratio of increase between the two can only be usefully compared in generally good and average years. In the frequently recurring years in which crops are confined to protected localities, the extra lakh of mouths to be fed find no food in the extra two lakhs of acres of "cultivated area." All these are considerations which detract much from the value of what is in one sense a truism, that the cultivating class is no worse off now than it was under native rule. * * *

8.—Dera-Ghazi-Khan District.

Mr. Fryer, C. S., made the first regular settlement of this district between 1868 and 1875. In his report he says very little upon the subject of agricultural indebtedness. In 1879 his native assistant, a gentleman named Chiman Lal, who had served for about 20 years in the district, and knew the history of almost every family in it, reported to the Famine Commission that two-thirds of the Mahomedan land-owners and fully half the tenants, whether occupancy or tenants-at-will, were involved in debt (pp. 68-69 of District Gazetteer). I was in charge of the district during the greater part of 1881, and think that the above opinion is correct. The Mahomedans, with the exception of the best of the great Biluch tribal chiefs whom Government has wisely treated very liberally, are generally as depressed as are their brethren Cis-Indus in Muzaffargarh.

Notes

  1. *. Punjab Replies to the Famine Commission, pp. 459-500.