Appendix B

Present Condition of the Peasantry in the Six Districts of the Northern Table-Land and in the Adjoining District of Gu

Musalmans and Money-Lenders in the Punjab, Septimus Smet Thorburn, 1886 · from page 169 · about 18 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

I.—Hazara District.

Colonel Wace, now Junior Financial Commissioner, made the first regular settlement between 1868 and 1874. He has devoted most of his time, since his first appointment in the Punjab Commission, in 1863, to the study of revenue and economic subjects. Next to Mr. Lyall, late Financial Commissioner of the Punjab, his knowledge of the people is more comprehensive than that of any officer now serving in the Punjab. Rather lengthy extracts from his settlement report of Hazara are given below, as his opinions are of great value.

In Sikh rule, owing to the scarcity of money and the small portion of the agriculturists’ farm produce that has any marketable value (little besides the grain and butter), debt once incurred was repaid with difficulty. The agriculturists feared to borrow, and they rarely did so, except—(1st), to pay the State revenue or a fine; (2nd), in case of famine, failure, or destruction of crops, or when there was really no food to be got in any other way; and (3rd), very occasionally at marriages and deaths: under ordinary circumstances, rather than borrow they were content to live in a state which their sons would now regard as poverty. Similarly, money-lending was confined to the better classes among the Khatris; the same circumstances which made the agriculturists careful in borrowing, made these Khatris careful how they lent money. If the money was wanted for purposes of extravagance, they would not usually lend, and their loans to ordinary agriculturists did not generally exceed Rs. 20 at one time. The common rate of interest was one per cent. per mensem, though for doubtful loans or by small lenders Rs. 2 would be charged. To charge more than one per cent. was considered a mark of unsound business, and therefore, for the credit of their business, the best Khatris ordinarily charged one per cent. Moreover, the security for the repayment of the principal was great: public opinion reprobated the repudiation of a loan, no matter what interval had elapsed : even a man’s heirs were bound to pay. And the rulers of the country recovered any debt, no matter how old, for a charge of one-fourth of its amount.

It is not too much to say that nearly the whole of these conditions have been reversed during the past 30 years. The value of agricultural and milch produce has more than doubled, and the very straw and grass grown on an agriculturist’s holding is now saleable. Simultaneously the area under cultivation has been greatly increased, and the proportion of the produce absorbed by the State’s demand is rateably less than half what the Sikh Government took. It is, moreover, still absolutely less in amount than was taken by that Government, in spite of the enormous increase in assets and their value, and even after taking into account the rise in the assessment introduced in 1872. Moreover, the rise in values did not occur gradually, but took place suddenly, being introduced by the famine of 1860-61. The agriculturists consequently found themselves suddenly enabled to pay off old debts with a rapidity which was quite unexpected by them : the produce of their cattle and land they found to be rapidly rising in value, allowing them to live more freely and in greater comfort than they had ever before experienced. Along with this we introduced an important change in the law, applicable to the class of loans usually contracted between agriculturists and Khatris : the period of limitation for their recovery, originally reduced at annexation to 12 years, was, by successive steps, finally contracted in 1867 to three years; and it also became known that our law did not bind a son to pay the debts of his father except under certain limitations. The general result of these changes was to loosen the restrictions hitherto observed both by the agriculturist and Khatri. The agriculturist, finding his produce of all kinds so much more marketable, and so largely increased in value and amount, has lost the fear of debt which before restrained him : two or three good harvests will now enable him to repay a sum, which he would hardly have dared to borrow before; and he looks to the limited period within which the lender can recover the loan by appeal to our courts in much the same light as an English farmer would regard the Bankruptcy Court. If, owing to unforeseen failures of crops, he is unable to repay the loan, he hopes by the aid of the limitation law to evade it altogether. The agriculturists consequently now borrow on much lighter grounds than before, and no longer restrict such transactions to occasions of real necessity. Unfortunately their intelligence has not increased with their wealth; they draw on their Khatri recklessly, and accept his accounts blindly.

On the other hand, the Khatris are fully alive to the bearing of these circumstances on their interests. The circumstances of the agriculturists being so greatly improved, there is no longer the same occasion for the Khatris to limit so carefully the amount of their loans. And seeing, on the one hand, that their clients are so ready to borrow and so well able to pay, and on the other hand, that our courts refuse to enforce any but fresh debts, it was inevitable that they should raise their charges for interest: two or even three per cent. per mensem is now a common charge for loans, and for doubtful loans even more is charged.—District Gazetteer, pp. 111-113.

In the above there is little about the Hazara district. Its state is, however, generally prosperous. Although the landlord classes are almost all deeply involved in debt, the cultivators are generally unembarrassed. Colonel Wace held, that although there is now more borrowing, there is less real indebtedness amongst the agriculturists of the district than there was in Sikh times. I have lately taken over charge of Hazara from Mr. Fryer. In the district note he left for me, he recorded that all the leading men, except five, were more or less in debt.

2.—Peshawar District.

The late Colonel Hastings, C. B., settled Peshawar between 1869 and 1876. He was very sympathetic with the people and knew them well. In his report he says little about agricultural indebtedness. I believe that the peasantry are not generally in debt, but that a large proportion of the landlord class is. The following extract from Colonel Hastings' report is taken from page 135 of the District Gazetteer.

The people, as a rule, although better off than under former rulers, are not extricating themselves from debt. If report is true, debts are, and have, increased chiefly owing to that bad custom which induces them to vie with one another in expenditure at marriages and deaths. More money is now spent on jewels, food, and clothes than used to be. Gambling, too, which is becoming very common, has much to say to the indebtedness of certain classes. Cash loans are obtainable between the rates of 1 and 3 per cent. interest per mensem : as much as 25 and 50 per cent. are charged for loans repayable at the next harvest. For seed-loans, from half ser to one ser per maund is paid as interest. Money is obtainable, on a deposit of jewels, at Re. 1-9 per cent. per mensem. It is not unusual to find land mortgaged to two persons, the proprietary right to one and the cultivating right to another. Till this settlement, the ordinary custom in the district was for proprietors to mortgage their lands, give over possession to the mortgagees, but still continue responsible for the Government demand. For the future, such agreements as these are not attended to : the revenue is primarily recovered from the person in possession. The debts are chiefly due to the local shop-keepers.

3.—Kohat District.

This district has just been settled by Mr. Tucker, C. S. In his report he says nothing about the prosperity or otherwise of the agricultural classes. I do not know whether there is a gazetteer of the district or not. For the reasons given in page 90 of this book, I do not think that the agriculturists are much in debt, or that money-lenders have acquired rights to any serious extent in their lands, except perhaps in the best protected localities.

4.—Rawalpindi District.

Mr. Robertson, C. S., is just completing the revised settlement of the district. The land revenue demand has been raised by about 35 per cent. all round. Mr. Robertson considers the agriculturists fairly prosperous, and after more than six months' acquaintance with the district as Deputy Commissioner my opinion is the same. In the southern tracts, in which the rainfall is much less than nearer the Himalayas, and the crops poorer and more uncertain, there is, I believe, considerable indebtedness: many of the landlord class are also in debt, but when so, deserve no sympathy. I refer the reader to page 91 of this book. The following passage is taken from pp. 76-77 of the Gazetteer. I do not know on what authority the opening assertion is based.

The prosperity of the district is attested by the fact that the peasantry are rapidly extricating themselves from debt. Under Sikh rule, fully 50 per cent. are said to have been in debt, but it is believed that not more than 10 per cent. of the cultivating classes are now involved. The present rate of interest for a cash loan is a deduction of one anna in the rupee at the time the money is paid (this is called tarawat), and afterwards at the rate of 2 per cent. per mensem on the full amount. In loans of grain the interest is often 50, never less than 25, per cent.; a maund of grain being given for seed on a bond to return at harvest time one and a quarter or one and a half maund, as the case may be. Money can be had, on a deposit of jewels, at a rate of one per cent. per mensem, and where land is mortgaged as security, interest is seldom paid in money. If possession is given to the mortgagee, the whole produce is set oft against interest, the mortgagee bearing the expense of management and paying the revenue; if not, one half the produce is ordinarily given in lieu of interest. There are very few large native bankers, and loans are chiefly conducted by local shop-keepers. There is no evidence of accumulation of coin; but the increased quantity of jewellery and trinkets worn by the people, taken with their generally improved style of dress and mode of living, goes far to prove that much of the profit resulting from a peaceful rule and a moderate assessment, finds its way into the pockets of the cultivating classes. Savings are chiefly invested in jewellery, but a growing desire is manifested to buy up land.

5.—Jhelum District.

The revision of the settlement of this district was effected by Colonel Wace and Mr. Thomsom, C. S., between 1874 and 1881. The peasantry are said by some officers to be generally prosperous, but the evidence on the subject is unsatisfactory. The following extract from the Deputy Commissioner's report to the Famine Commission, in 1879, is taken from page 91 of the District Gazetteer. I believe Colonel Wace was at the time the Deputy Commissioner.

The agriculturists give all their grain to the Bunniahs at harvest time. It is the custom to charge two annas in the rupee for lending money. Thus, when a man gives a bond for Rs. 100, he only receives Rs. 87-8. He is then charged interest on the Rs. 100 at two annas (12½ per cent.) per harvest; the unpaid interest being added at each harvest to the principal. Thus, a man who borrows Rs. 87-8 will in three years owe Rs. 227-13, and in six years Rs. 460-11. The old custom was not to balance the account every harvest, but only when the debtor wished to settle it, or other special occasion arose; and for the oldest account not more than 50 per cent. was charged as interest if cash was paid, or 100 per cent. if settled by paying in grain or cattle. Moreover, both debtors and creditors are equally careless, the one in borrowing and the other in lending. A cultivator with a small holding used not to be able to borrow more than Rs. 20. Now he can run into debt up to Rs. 100 or Rs. 200. Another reason is that, in the old days, land could not be sold at all, whereas it now fetches a large sum.

The following remarks are by an old and experienced native Settlement Officer named Mirza Azim Beg. They were submitted to the Famine Commission in 1879.

As regards the economic condition of the agriculturists of these districts,* there is no very broad distinction between the condition of owners, occupancy-tenants, and tenants-at-will. For the first 10 years after annexation the condition of all classes improved greatly; the harvests were nearly always good; cultivation was increasing; they bought milch cattle and jewels, and fed and clothed themselves much better than they had previously done. By-and-bye the crops began to become poorer on the new lands, and some bad seasons occurred. The leases of the first settlement ran out, and the agriculturists were called on to pay revenue on the lands newly cultivated. It also became difficult for them to keep cattle, for they had cultivated their own waste lands, and the larger wastes had been formed into Government preserves. So the owners gradually got into debt and the occupancy-tenants. The tenants-at-will who pay a share of the produce, pilfer a good deal from the crop before it is divided; and they are commonly village craftsmen, adding by their trade earnings to the receipts from their land. The average condition of agriculturists in the three districts* of which I am writing may be taken to be as follows.

The agriculturists do not usually store grain in their houses; they give it all at harvest time to the village traders. In the northern part of the Hazara district, there is a custom by which at every harvest the village banker takes from the agriculturist as interest an odi (four sers) of grain for every rupee owed to him. It an agriculturist cannot pay this interest the cash value of the grain due is reckoned and added to the account. Cases sometimes occur in which, by this custom, all a man's harvest is swallowed up in interest.

In the same way most of the agriculturists of all three districts are in debt—perhaps 25 per cent. are free, not more. Of those in debt, about one-third owe as much as one year's income, and this proportion is steadily increasing.

To test the matter, I examined the accounts of 23 families in 14 different villages, and found that whereas they only held land assessed at Rs. 368 per annum, they owed Rs. 3,182, of which Rs. 1,283 was admittedly interest; and of the balance, Rs. 1,899, it is difficult to say how much is really principal and how much old interest; but, so far as I can ascertain, only one-third of this Rs. 1,899 is principal and the rest is all accumulated interest. The men who owe this possess jewels, value Rs. 972, and goods and chattels, value Rs. 334, and their land besides.

Examining nine other villages, I found that of 347 agricultural holdings, 164 were free of debt; 97 owe sums not exceeding 10 times their annual assessment; 65 owe more than that, but less than 30 times the annual assessment. The total annual assessment of these nine villages is Rs. 4,226, and their total debts are Rs. 32,454. The real reason of these debts is originally the extravagance of the zemindars, and subsequently heavy charges of interest. The accounts are opened with items of all descriptions, from payments of revenue to common expenses; but the real reason of the debts is as above stated.

In Jhelum it is the custom to charge two annas in the rupee for lending money: thus, where a bond is given for Rs. 100, the debtor has only received Rs. 87-8, and then he is charged on the said Rs. 100 interest at two annas per rupee (12½ per cent.) per harvest, the unpaid interest being added at each harvest to the principal. At this rate, in three years' time the debtor's account shows Rs. 227-13 due, though the sum actually borrowed was only Rs. 87-8. Thus he has been charged Rs. 140-5 interest. If the debt runs on in the same way for three years more, its total will then stand at Rs. 460-11.

The old custom was not to balance the account every harvest, but only when the zemindar wished to settle it, or other special occasion arose; and for the oldest account not more than 50 per cent. was charged as interest if cash was paid, or 100 per cent. if settled by paying in grain or cattle.

Moreover, both debtors and creditors are equally careless, the debtor in borrowing and the creditor in lending. A cultivator with a small holding used not to be able to borrow more than Rs. 20. Now he can borrow Rs. 100 or Rs. 200; or rather the sum he originally borrowed was small, and the debt has increased by interest. The creditor bides his time, and when he sees the debtor can pay, will press him in our courts. Another reason is this: the land will sell for a large sum; for instance, in the case of the 23 families owing Rs. 3,182 above mentioned, they own 327 acres of land, which, if sold, would, at the rates now obtainable for land—Rs. 84 per acre—fetch Rs. 27,599. In former days land could not be sold at all; but it should be remembered that if much land were offered for sale, such high prices would soon fail.

6.—Gujrat District.

Colonel Waterfield, C. S. I., now Commissioner of the Peshawar Division, revised the settlement of this district between 1865 and 1869. The question of agricultural indebtedness was then little discussed. Colonel Waterfield's remarks on the subject are taken from pp. 66-67 of the District Gazetteer.

It would seem that the debts had increased as the settlement operations advanced. But the people account for the great increase in registration by saying that the debts have not really increased, but that the advantages of registration are now perfectly clear to the money-lending classes. * * * The attendance of the borrowing classes at the Settlement Courts was an opportunity not to be lost by the money-lenders, who, accompanying their debtors to the tahsils, made them not only register the debts of the year, but the balances of their accounts, and the unpaid debts of former years. Whether the indebtedness is greater than in other districts, cannot be judged of without the facts ; but a more uncomplaining lot of debtors cannot well be found. If the registered debts are Rs. 2,50,000 the unregistered debts must amount to half as much again ; in all, to more than half the Government demand for the year. But the Government demand being only one-sixth of the gross produce, one-fourth of the latter is only liable for debts and land revenue, and a large margin is left. Notwithstanding the apparently prosperous condition of the district, the people are no doubt much in debt, and the registration of bonds had largely increased in 1867.

7.—Gujranwala District.*

This district adjoins those of Gujrat, Shahpur, Jhang, and Montgomery, all in the Western Punjab, and has a population of 453,000 Musalmans and only 164,000 Hindus and Sikhs. It is therefore more a Musalman than a Hindu district. I at first intended to include it in the Western Punjab, but owing to its vicinity to Lahore, the strength of the Hindus and Sikhs in it as dominant agricultural tribes, and the fact that after some months of service in the district I came to the conclusion that the Musalmans were very lax Mahomedans, I finally decided to treat the district as in the central division of the Punjab. This, however, does not preclude my giving the following extract from a report on the condition of the people, submitted in 1879 to the Famine Commission, by the late Mr. Tolbort, C. S., the then District Officer. The native gentleman Rai Gopal Das, whose opinion is referred to, is, I believe, the oldest and most experienced Settlement Officer in the Punjab.

The bulk of the land of this district is cultivated by the owners themselves. It is estimated that not more than 13 per cent. of the land is cultivated by tenants, whether occupancy or tenants-at-will ; and of the two classes of tenants, those at-will are more numerous than those having a right of occupancy.

It is estimated that 80 per cent. of the owners, 20 per cent. of the occupancy tenants, and 10 per cent. of the tenants-at-will, are indebted. It is further estimated that the average indebtedness of the owners is about 30 per cent. on their average yearly income ; while the average indebtedness of the occupancy-tenants, similarly calculated, is estimated at 12 per cent., and that of the tenants-at-will at 5 per cent.

Rai Gopal Dass enumerates ten causes, to which he attributes the greater indebtedness of the owners of land during recent years The first six of these may be comprised under the general expression “personal extravagance.” The seventh is “frequent attendance at court.” The eighth, “rapid growth of interest and compound interest through the working of the limitation laws.” The ninth, “rise in price of agricultural cattle.” The tenth appears to be a general observation to the effect that owners of land now regard themselves as able to dispose of the fee-simple of their estates, which formerly was not the case ; and on the other hand, the money-lending classes have now become eager to obtain possession of land.

The land-owners of this district are not, I think, so indebted as those of many others. In enumerating the causes of agricultural indebtedness, I would certainly add “the inequality and want of elasticity of our revenue system” to those above detailed ; and I am inclined to think that the eighth cause in the above list (which reflects on the law of limitation) might be modified so as to designate “inadequate and indiscriminating judicial investigation caused partly by over-refinement legislation, undue size of districts, and overwork of the district staff.”

Notes

  1. *. Hazara, Jhelum, and Gujrat.
  2. *. Hazara, Jhelum, and Gujrat.
  3. *. See pages 243-46 of Indian Famine Commission Report (Appendix), Vol. III, Evidence in reply to inquiries.