Date of the Periplus as Determined by Various Commentators

The Periplus of the Erythræan Sea, Wilfred H. Schoff, 1912 · from page 290 · about 5 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

DATE OF THE PERIPLUS, AS DETERMINED BY VARIOUS COMMENTATORS

The dates assigned fall into three groups. The first, which dates the Periplus before Pliny, assumes the trade to have been that which existed under Nero, and includes the possibility that Pliny quoted from or summarized the Periplus in his description of Arabia Felix. The latest date possible under these suppositions is the end of the reign of Malichas, whose inscriptions indicate that he ruled between 40 and 70 A. D.

The second group depends on the identification of Zoscales with Za Hakale in the Abyssinian Chronicle, whose dates were given by Henry Salt as 76 to 89 A. D. The dependence placed on these two dates, on which Salt himself cast doubt, is surprising in view of the fact that he antedated two kings in the list (El Abreha and El Atzbeha) more than 100 years, to bring them within the reigns of the Roman emperors Constantine and Constantius, who are known to have had relations with them; and if so great a liberty can be taken with the monarchs of the fourth century, it seems reasonable to suppose that one of the first century may be a score of years out of his proper order. The supposed confirmation of these dates by mention of contemporary Indian rulers points to an earlier date during the period of their viceroyalties rather than of their reigns.

The third group of identifications depends on the reference in the text to the “emperors,” assuming this to be a time when there were two Roman emperors reigning jointly. This assumption is entirely unnecessary.

First group:

“In the middle of the first century after Christ, nearly contemporary with Pliny.”

Salmasius, Exercitationes Plinianæ, 835.

‘‘A little earlier than Pliny.’’

Mannert, Geographie der Griechen und Römer aus ihren Schriften dargestellt, Nürnberg, 1799, I, 131.

“Soon after Claudius; about the tenth year of Nero” (which would be 63 A. D.).

Vincent, II, 59.

“Under Claudius or a little later.”

Ukert, Geographie der Griechen und Römer, Weimar, 1816, I, i, 209.

“60 A. D.” Benfey, article Indien in Ersch and Grüber’s Encyklopädie, Sect. II, Vol. 7, p. 90: Leipzig, 1840. Lassen, Indische Alterthumskunde, II, 538; III, 3.

“Unquestionably before Pliny’s Natural History.” Schwanbeck, in Rheinischen Museum, VII, 338.

“A little earlier than Pliny, who seems to quote from it; that is, prior to 77 A. D.” Dillmann, in Berichte der K. Preuss. Akad. der Wissenschaften, 1879, pp. 413-429.

“Nearly contemporary with Pliny, written before the dedication of the Natural History in 77 A. D.” Fabricius, p. 27.

“56-67 A. D.” Glaser, in Ausland, München, 1891, pp. 45-6. Skizze der Geschichte und Geographie Arabiens, II, 164.

“Next before Pliny.” Robertson, Disquisition on Ancient India.

“60-63 A. D.” Watt, Commercial Products of India, p. 371, etc.

“56-71 A. D., as shown by Glaser.”

“Before 77 A. D.” Speck, Handelsgeschichte des Altertums, I, 35; III, 2b., 919.

“During the reign of Malik III, King of the Nabatæans, 40-70 A. D.” Vogüé, Syrie Centrale: Inscriptions Sémitiques, p. 107. (Paris, 1869.)

“During the reign of Kariba-îl Watar Juhan’im, the Homerite King, about 40-70 A. D.” Glaser, Die Abessinier in Arabien und Africa, pp. 37-8.

“During the reign of Ilî-azzu Jalît, King of the Hadramaut, about 25-65 A. D.” Glaser, Die Abessinier, etc., p. 34.

“The author made his voyages at various times between 65 and 75 or 80 A. D. The work was written in the last quarter of the first century A. D.” Haig, The Indus Delta Country, 28.

Second group:

  • “80-89 A. D.”
  • C. Müller, Geographi Græci Minores, I, xcvi; depending on the doubtful dates given Za Hakale by Henry Salt, in his rearrangement of the Abyssinian Chronicle in 1812.
  • “75 A. D.”
  • Bunsen, de Azania commentatio philologica, Bonn, 1852.
  • “80-85 A. D.”
  • Vivien de Saint Martin, Histoire de la Géographie et des découvertes géographiques, 1873; also Le Nord de l’ Afrique dans l’ antiquité grecque et romaine.
  • “77-89 A. D., as shown by Müller.”
  • Bunbury, History of Ancient Geography, II, 445; London, 1883.
  • “About 10 years after Pliny’s death” (which occurred in 79 A. D.) Tozer, History of Ancient Geography, p. 274: Cambridge, 1897.
  • “About 90 A. D.” (referring to Nahapāna, the Nambanus of § 41),
  • A.-M. Boyer, in Journal Asiatique, Paris, July-Aug., 1897, pp. 120-151.
  • “83-84 A. D.” (referring to Sundara Sātākarni, the Sandares of § 52).
  • C. R. Wilson, in Journal of the Asiatic Society of Bengal, June, 1904.
  • “Between 77 and 105 A. D.”
  • Vincent Smith, Early History of India, p. 371, etc.
  • “Between 80 and 89 A. D.”
  • McCrindle, in Indian Antiquary, VIII, 108-151.
  • “About 85 A. D.”
  • J. F. Fleet, article Epigraphy, in Imperial Gazetteer of India, new edition, II, 76.

Third group.

The following belong to the curiosities of criticism, all being based on the “emperors” of § 23:

  • “In the 2d century A. D., later than 161, under Marcus Aurelius and Lucius Verus. ”
  • Dodwell, in Hudson’s Geographiæ Veteris Scriptores, pp. 85-105.
  • Heeren, De Inaia Romanis cognita, in Commentationes societatis regiæ scientiarum. Göttingen, 1793, XI, 101.

"Apparently of the 1st, or at latest of the 2d century A. D." Heeren, Ideen über die Politik, den Verkehr und den Handel der vornehmsten Völker der alten Welt. Göttingen, 1824, I, iii, 316. "A ship's log of the 2d century A. D." Bohlen, Das alte Indien, mit besonderer Rücksicht auf Aegypten. Königsberg, 1830, I, 71. "A merchant of Alexandria who lived in the first half of the 2d century A. D." Külb, Länder- und Völkerkunde in Biographien, Berlin, 1846, I, 245. "Of the 2d century A. D." Ritter, Geschichte der Erdkunde und der Entdeckungen, Berlin, 1861, p. 124; also Erdkunde Asiens, IV, 1. "Of the 1st or, rather, the following century." Ritter, Erdkunde Asiens, VIII, 1. "Of the 3d century." Letronne, Christianisme de Nubie, 47. "200-217 A. D." Letronne, in Nouveau Recueil de l'Académie des Inscriptions, IX, 173. Alex. v. Humboldt, Kritischen Untersuchungen, I, 315. Kosmos, II, 458. Forbiger, Handbuche der alten Geographie aus den Quellen bearbeitet, Leipzig, 1842, I, 442. "246-247 A. D., under the emperor Philip and his son." Reinaud, in Journal Asiatique, series V, vol. 18, Paris, 1861, p. 226. Reinaud, Mémoires de l'Académie des Inscriptions et belles lettres, vol. xxiv, pp. 227-278 (1864). O. Peschel, Geschichte der Erdkunde, München, 1865. These views are vigorously combated by O. Blau, in Zeitschrift der Deutschen Morgenländischen Gesellschaft, xxii, 656. A. Weber, Indische Streife, II, 266 (1869). Vivien de Saint Martin, Le Nord de l'Afrique dans l'antiquité grecque et romaine, 1863, p. 197. Dillmann, loc. cit., pp. 414-428.