Punjab, 1876-7

Poverty and Un-British Rule in India, Dadabhai Naoroji, 1901 · from page 171 · about 58 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

TBL-111 · FOLIO 191Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
FOOD.—Man.
Items.Quantity per day.Quantity for 1 Year.Price for Re. 1.Cost for 1 Year.Remarks.
Seers.Seers.Seers.Rs.As.
Flour136525149The price in the Report is 20 seers for first sort; I have taken 25 per cent. lower price for lower quality.
Rice¼911370The price in the Report is 10 seers for first sort; I take 30 per cent. lower price for inferior quality.
Dal⅛451828The price in the Report is 16 seers; I take it 12 per cent. lower.
Salt1 oz.119¼13The price of the Report, which is Government sale price.
Ghee.1 ,,113311The price in the Report is less than 2 seers. In taking 3 seers, I lower it above 50 per cent., or rather to the price of oil. The quantity, 1 oz., is also rather low for a Punjabee.
Condiment2 pies worth......313
Tobacco1½ ,, ,,......214These are regarded as under the mark.
Vegetables1 ,, ,,......18
Total .372Without any meat, sugar, milk, or any drink, or any kind of luxury whatever.

Woman.

All the above items will be nearly the same, except tobacco. Deducting tobacco, it will be Rs. 34-2 as. ; say Rs. 32.

Two more Members in a Family.

One young person, say, between 12 and 18, say Rs. 26, though there will not be so much difference. One ,, ,, under 12, say ,, 0, though this cannot be the case generally.

COST OF ABSOLUTE NECESSARIES OF LIFE OF AN AGRICULTURAL LABOURER.—Continued.

TBL-112 · FOLIO 192Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
CLOTHING FOR ONE YEAR.
Man.Woman.Remarks.
Rs.a.Rs.a.
2 Dhotees102 Pajamas10No holiday clothing, nor for occasions of joy and sorrow are reckoned.
2 Pairs Shoes101 Gagra20
1 Turban102 Chadars18
2 Bandis for warm and cold weather184 Cholees10
2 Kamlees40Bangles08
1 Small piece of cloth for Langootee, etc.042 Pairs Shoes08
1 Chadar012Hair-dressing03
2 Pajama012
Total104611

For one young person, say, Rs. 6; for the second, say, nothing.

TBL-113 · FOLIO 192Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
FAMILY EXPENSES IN COMMON.
Rs.a.
Cottage, Rs. 60; say40for one year.Calculated on the lowest scale, without any furniture, such as cots or mats, or stools or anything.
Repairs30„
Cooking and other utensils38„
Firewood, ¼ anna per day511„
Lamp Oil, 1 oz. per day, at 3 seers per Re 1312„
1915
TBL-114 · FOLIO 192Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
TAKING FOUR IN THE FAMILY.
Food.Clothing.Family Expenses.Total.
Rs.Rs.a.Rs.a.
Man37104
Woman32611
Youth (12 to 18)2660
Child (under 12)000
9522151915137-14—say, Rs. 136

Which will be Rs. 34 per head per annum in a family of four, against the production of Rs. 20 per annum at the outside.

No wedding, birth, and funeral expenses calculated, nor medical, educational, social, and religious wants, but simply the absolute necessaries for existence in ordinary health, at the lowest scale of cost and quantity.

The prices this year are the lowest during ten years.

The Report says (page 83): “Salt and tobacco show a rise in price.” This is a mistake into which the writer is led by the mistake of the clerk in taking his totals and division by the number of districts. The figures in Table 45 (page clxxvii), in the line of the “general average” of tobacco, viz., 4-5 and 5-7, are wrong; and so also in the line of salt, 7 and 7-5 are wrong. I do not mean these figures are wrong on account of the fallacious principle of the Report in taking averages, but in taking the average according to the Report’s own method—i.e., of adding up the columns and dividing by the number of districts.

It is requested that any further communication on this subject may be addressed to— The Under-Secretary of State for India, India Office, London, S.W.

India Office, S.W. 9th August, 1880.

Sir,—I am directed by the Secretary of State for India to acknowledge the receipt of your letter of the 24th May, enclosing a table of statistics relating to the value of the production of the Punjab for the year 1876-77.

In reply, I am to thank you for your communication, but with reference to your request that the several Governments in India may be directed to supply similar statistics of production, I am to remark that as regards the important province of Bengal, means do not exist of supplying the information you desire; whilst as regards those Provinces for which such information does already exist, it appears very questionable whether the results given, owing to the absence of any sufficient machinery for their preparation, can be relied upon as trustworthy. Your letter and its enclosure have, however, been sent out to the Government of India.

I enclose herewith for your information copy of a memorandum upon your letter, and also copies of statistics similar to those compiled by yourself, which have been recently prepared in this Office.

I am, Sir, your obedient Servant, Louis Mallet.

Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji.

[ENCLOSURE.]

Memorandum on a Letter from Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji, dated 24th May, 1880.

In this letter Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji requests that the several Governments in India may be instructed to furnish statistical information regarding the agricultural, mining and manufacturing produce of their respective administrations, and that a summary may also be given, similar to one which he has prepared for the Punjab, and which he submits with his letter, in order that “a true conception may be formed of the actual material condition of India from year to year.” He also asks that his tables may be submitted to the Statistical Department of the India Office, and that any mistakes of facts or figures may be pointed out to him.

In January, 1879, I made calculations for the greater part of India similar to those made by Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji for the Punjab; copies of these are attached.1 I do not, however, put much faith in the accuracy of the figures from which these calculations are made. The agricultural statistics of India, as they are published, can hardly be very reliable, as they are based upon averages, each average referring to a very large area, in which there may be, and probably are, many variations of conditions and circumstances; whilst in parts, such as the large and wealthy Presidency of Bengal, no statistics of agricultural produce are available.

In examining Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji’s paper, it appears that in his calculations he has omitted to make any allowance for the value of straw, and he has made no attempt to estimate the value of the increase of agricultural stock, but he has added an arbitrary sum for the latter and for other omitted items.

Having, however, arrived at some figures supposed to represent the value of the produce of a certain district, the question arises as to how these figures should be applied in order to show the comparative prosperity or otherwise of the people in that district. Mr. Dadabhai has adopted the principle of equally apportioning the value of agricultural produce and manufactures, as ascertained by him from the statistics available, amongst the whole population, without distinguishing how many are agriculturists, how many mechanics, and how many belong to other trades and professions, or possess property, and whose incomes, therefore, are derived directly neither from agriculture nor from manufactures. Thus he omits all reference to railway wealth, Government stock, house property, profits of trade, salaries, pensions, non-agricultural wages, professional incomes, and returns to investments, and all other sources from which a man who does not grow food himself may obtain the means of purchasing it.

From the Census Report of 1871 it appears that, out of a total population of 17,611,498 under British administration in the Punjab, 9,689,650 are returned as agriculturists, 1,776,786 male adults, equivalent to about 4,500,000 population, as engaged in industrial occupations; thus leaving a population of nearly 3,500,000 directly dependent neither upon agriculture, manufactures, nor mining, and who must therefore derive their means of subsistence from other sources.

Mr. Dadabhai makes out the total value of the agricultural produce of the Punjab to be Rs. 27,69,71,976,1 and that from manufactures and mines Rs. 4,11,40,058. To this he adds, to meet any omissions, a further margin of 3½ crores, making the whole produce of the Punjab 35¼ crores of rupees, “which, for a population of 17,600,000, gives Rs. 20 per head per annum at the outside for the year 1876-7,” to which year the figures he has taken refer. At pages 171, 172 of his tables he shows that the cost of absolute necessaries of life of an agricultural labourer is Rs. 34 per annum, but he omits to explain how, under these circumstances, the people of the Punjab managed to live, and leaves the reader to draw his own conclusions how, with only Rs. 20 per annum, he can provide for an expenditure of Rs. 34.

Adopting Mr. Dadabhai’s figures, with regard to which I will take no exception, I think it may be shown, by another process of reasoning than that which he adopts, that they point to the Punjab agriculturist being in a good condition of prosperity rather than the reverse. First, I think it must be admitted that the agricultural produce belongs in the first instance to the man who grows it. From it he and his family will first provide themselves with food, and the remainder he will sell, either for money to enable him to pay his assessment, etc., or in barter for clothing and other necessaries, whilst a part will go to pay wages for labourers and others dependent upon him.

Now, if these premises be admitted, it may be shown that, allowing three-fourths of a seer (1½ lb.) of grain per head per day, according to the calculations given by Mr. A. P. Macdonnel in his “Food Grain Supply and Famine Relief in Behar and Bengal ” (p. 8), or, say, 550 lbs. per annum per head of agricultural population, and allowing 6½ per cent. of the gross produce for seed, an equal quantity for cattle-feed, and 2 per cent. for waste, or together 15 per cent., the value of the surplus agricultural produce is sufficient to yield Rs. 24 per head per annum for other requirements, and Rs. 22 per head after deduction of the land revenue demand, or, say, £8 16s. per annum per family of four persons.

The other population of the Punjab (omitting Native States) numbers 7,921,848, for whom the remaining food grain grown, after allowing for the food of agriculturists, cattle, seed, waste, etc., amounting to 5,401,151,059 lbs., is sufficient to provide them with an average rate of over 600 lbs. per head per annum. To supply them with 550 lbs. per head per annum would take 4,357,016,400 lbs., leaving a surplus of 1,044,134,659 lbs., or over 450,000 tons, for export. The food grain grown in the Punjab is, therefore, apart from other food supplies, more than sufficient to feed the whole population, and it is well known that considerable quantities of wheat are exported thence.

The numbers engaged in manufactures in the Punjab I have stated to be about 4,500,000. The net value of manufactures, after deducting the value of raw material, is given by Mr. Dadabhai as only Rs. 4,08,40,058, or about Rs. 9 per head per annum of the population engaged therein. This, I think, sufficiently shows that there must be some error in the value given. F. C. Danvers.

India Office, 28th June, 1880.

32, Great St. Helens, London, 12th August, 1880.

Sir Louis Mallet, the Under-Secretary of State for India, India Office, London, S.W.

Sir,—I have received your letter of the 9th inst., and I tender my sincere thanks to his Lordship the Secretary of State for India for the kind attention he has given to my letter of the 24th May last, and for forwarding it to the Government of India.

The necessity for having correct information about the material condition of India is so very great, both to rulers and the subjects, that I venture to say that any reasonable and well-directed expenditure for this object would be productive of great good; and that, therefore, the Government of India may be requested to improve the existing machinery as much as it may be needed to obtain from the different Governments the tables of production and consumption with as much approximate accuracy as possible. The tables, even so far as are at present supplied, are useful, and I cannot think that it would be difficult for the different Governments to improve the existing arrangements, so as to get sufficiently approximate results for the guidance of the legislation and administration of the country with the greatest practical good, and without the commission of such mistakes as are unavoidably made in the ignorance of the actual state and wants of the country.

For Bengal, also, I hope some means may be devised to obtain such information.

It does not remain for me now, with the evidence of your present letter and its enclosures before me, to impress upon the India Office the great importance of these statistics; for I find that when I commenced working at these tables, about the beginning of last year, the India Office had already got these very tables prepared for their use, and I cannot but express my gladness to find such to be the case.

I am sorry I am not at present well able to give such attention to the enclosures of your letter as I desire, as I am not in good health and am under medical treatment.

I remain, Your obedient Servant, Dadabhai Naoroji.

32, Great St. Helens, London. 13th September, 1880.

Sir Louis Mallet, the Under-Secretary of State for India, India Office, London, S.W.

Sir,—In continuation of my letter of the 12th ult., I now beg to submit, for the consideration of his Lordship the Secretary of State for India, the accompanying memorandum on Mr. Danver's two papers of 4th January, 1879, and 28th June, 1880, and I hope his Lordship will give it the same kind attention that was shown to my former letter.

I request that copy of this letter and memo. be sent to the Indian Government, as I think that views similar to those of Mr. Danvers more or less prevail in India also.

I shall esteem it a great favour if it is pointed out to me that I am mistaken in any of my views now put forth. My only desire is to find out the truth, and that India may receive and enjoy the blessings and benefits which the British nation is really capable of bestowing on her, if once British statesmen give their usual conscientious attention to her concerns.

I remain, Sir, Your obedient Servant, Dadabhai Naoroji.

Memorandum on Mr. Danvers' Papers of 28th June, 1880, and 4th January, 1879.

Mr. Danvers says: "In examining Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji's paper, it appears that in his calculations he has omitted to make any allowance for the value of straw, and he has made no attempt to estimate the value of the increase of agricultural stock, but he has added an arbitrary sum for the latter and for other omitted items."

I have omitted not only straw, but also grass, cotton seed, and any fodder or other food for animals which I have not taken in my tables; and further, I should also omit all that portion of the inferior grains which I have shown in my table at page 155 of this book, of about 30 per cent. of the whole acreage of grains, and which is grown for the food of animals.

The reason is this; the principle to be considered is—first, either the whole gross annual production of the country may be taken (including straw, grass, etc., etc.), and from this gross production, before apportioning it per head of human population, a deduction should be made for the portion required for all the stock, which, in the case of the Punjab, is above 7,000,000 large cattle and near 4,000,000 sheep and goats; or, second, all straw, grass, and every production raised for animal food should be left out of calculation, and only the rest of the production which is and can be turned to human use should be apportioned among the human population.

Mr. Danvers may adopt either of the above two methods, whichever he may consider would give most correctly the actual production for human use. It would not be correct to include the produce raised for animal use, and then not to make the necessary deduction for such use. I would put this matter in another form.

Suppose on the 1st of January, 1880, we have in India a certain amount of material wealth in all its various forms, and we take complete stock of it; that during the year following the country works in all its varieties of ways, consumes for all its various human, animal, and instrumental wants from the store existing on the 1st January, 1880; and that after the end of the year, on 1st January, 1881, we gather together or take stock of every possible kind of material production (agricultural, mineral, and manufacturing, and addition from profits of foreign trade) during the year. This production during the year will have to meet all the wants of the next year. If this production prove less than what would be wanted for the next year, then there would be a deficiency, and either the original wealth or capital of the country will have to be drawn upon, or the people will be so much less supplied with their wants in some shape or other; in either way showing a diminution of prosperity, both as property and capacity. If, on the other hand, the whole material production of the year prove more than what would be necessary for the next year for all ordinary or usual wants, then a surplus would accrue, and so far, in some permanent form, add to the capital of the country and increase its prosperity.

I request, therefore, that Mr. Danvers may be asked to work out the total production and wants of India for, say, the last dozen years on correct principles of calculation, from such materials as are already available at the India Office, supplementing such information as may be deficient by asking from India and from experienced retired officials who are now in this country. Such tables will show what the actual material condition of the country is, and whether it is increasing or diminishing in prosperity. Unless such information is obtained, the Government of the country will be blind and in the dark, and cannot but result in misery to India, and discredit to the rulers, their best intentions notwithstanding. It is hopeless to expect intelligent government without the aid of such important information annually.

I am glad Mr. Danvers has made an estimate of the annual increase of agricultural stock in his paper of 4th January, 1879, and as I have to say something upon this paper further on, I do not say anything here upon the subject of stock.

Mr. Danvers says: “Mr. Dadabhai has adopted the principle of equally apportioning the value of agricultural produce and manufactures, as ascertained by him from the statistics available, amongst the whole population, without distinguishing how many are agriculturists, how many mechanics, and how many belong to other trades or professions, or possess property, and whose incomes, therefore, are derived directly neither from agriculture nor from manufactures. Thus he omits all reference to railway wealth, Government stock, house property, profits of trade, salaries, pensions, non-agricultural wages, professional incomes, and returns to investments, and all other sources from which a man who does not grow food himself may obtain the means of purchasing it.

“From the Census Report of 1871, it appears that, out of a total population of 17, 611,498 under British administration in the Punjab, 9,689,650 are returned as agriculturists, 1,776,786 adult males, equivalent to about 4,500,000 of population, as engaged in industrial occupations; thus leaving a population of nearly 3,500,000 directly dependent neither upon agriculture, manufactures, nor mining, and who must, therefore, derive their means of subsistence from other sources.”

I take each of the items :—

1st, “Railway Wealth.” I am not sure what Mr. Danvers means by “railway wealth.” In his paper of 4th January, 1879, he regards railways as “enhancing the value of food grains, and adding, pro tanto, to the wealth of the districts through which they run.” If he means in the above extract by “railway wealth” something different, then that needs to be explained. In the meantime, I adopt the interpretation as I make out with the aid of his paper of 4th January, 1879.

Suppose 100 maunds of wheat exist in the Punjab, and its cost to the producer, say, is Rs. 100—suppose that this wheat is carried by railway to Bombay, and its value at Bombay is Rs. 125; does Mr. Danvers mean that this circumstance has added Rs. 25, or anything at all, to the existing wealth of India?

If so then no such thing has happened. The 100 maunds of wheat existed in the Punjab, and the Rs. 125 existed in Bombay, before the wheat was moved an inch. After the movement, the only result has been change of hands. The wheat has gone to Bombay, and the Rs. 125 are distributed between the owner at Punjab, who receives Rs. 100, and the railway owners and workers, and the merchant who carried through the transaction, who between them divide the Rs. 25. By the mere fact of the removal of the wheat from the Punjab to Bombay not a single grain of wheat nor a single pie of money is added to what already existed in India before the wheat was touched. Such “railway wealth” does not exist. If the mere movement of produce can add to the existing wealth, India can become rich in no time. All it would have to do is to go on moving its produce continually all over India, all the year round, and under the magic wheels of the train wealth will go on springing till the land will not suffice to hold it. But there is no royal (even railway) road to material wealth. It must be produced from the materials of the earth till the great discovery is made of converting motion into matter. I should not be misunderstood. I am not discussing here the benefits of railways, whatever they are to any country or to India. To show that the people of India are not deriving the usual benefits of railways I give hereafter a short separate section. Here it is enough for me to state that railways are, in a way, an indirect means of increasing the material production of any country, but that, whatever that “means” is, its result is fully and completely included in the estimate of the actual annual production of the country, and that there is nothing more to be added to such actual material production of the year.

2nd, “Government Stock.” Suppose I hold a lakh of rupees of Government 4 per cent. rupee paper. It does not from itself produce or create or make to grow out any money or food or any kind of material wealth for me. It simply means that Government will give me Rs. 4,000 every year, and that, not by creating anything by any divine power, but from the revenue of the country; and this revenue can be got from only the actual material production of the year. So in reality my income of Rs. 4,000 from “Government Stock” is nothing more or less than a share out of the production of the country, and is, therefore, fully and completely included therein. No addition has to be made from “Government Stock” to the actual material production of the year. No such addition exists at all.

3rd, “House Property.” Suppose I have taken a house at a yearly rental of Rs. 1,000. The house does not grow or create the rent by the mere fact of my occupying it. I have to pay this amount out of my income of Rs. 4,000 from Government Stock, and so the house-owner receives through me and the Government his share out of the production of the country. The discussion of the other items further on will show that, be my income from any of the various sources Mr. Danvers suggests, it is ultimately and solely derived from, and is included in, the yearly production of the country, and the owners of “house property” simply take their share, like everybody else, from this same store.

4th, “Profits of Trade.” I take, first, foreign trade. Mr. Danvers is quite right that the foreign trade of a country adds to its annual income or production.1 But, unfortunately, the case with India is quite otherwise. The present system of British administration not only sweeps away to England the whole profits of the foreign trade, but also drains away a portion of the annual production itself of the country. So that, instead of India making any addition from its “profits of foreign trade” to its yearly production, a deduction has to be made from such production in estimating the actual quantity that ultimately remains for the use of the people of India. A portion of the actual production, through the channel of foreign trade, goes clean out of the country to England, without an atom of material return. The manner in which the foreign trade of India becomes the channel through which India’s present greatest misfortune and evil operate, I treat further on in a separate section, to avoid confusion. It is enough for me to say here that, as matters actually stand, instead of there being, as should be, any addition from foreign trade to the annual production of India, there is actually a diminution, or drain of it clean out of the country to England, to the extent of some £18,000,000 a year, together with, and over and above, all its “profits of trade.” I grieve, therefore, that I have nothing to add from “profits of trade,” as Mr. Danvers suggests, but much to subtract.

I take next the internal trade. Resuming the illustration of the 100 maunds of wheat at Punjab, say a merchant buys at Rs. 100 and sends it to Bombay, where he gets Rs. 125. The result simply is that the wheat is still the same 100 maunds, and the Rs. 125 that existed in Bombay are still Rs. 125, but that out of Rs. 25 the merchant receives his “profit of trade,” and the railway its charges for carrying. Not a single atom of money or wheat is added to the existing wealth of the country by this internal trade; only a different distribution has taken place. I should not be misunderstood. I am not discussing here the usefulness of internal trade, whatever it is; I am only pointing out that any increase in the material income of the country by the mere transactions of the internal trade is a thing that does not exist, and that whatever benefits and “profits of trade” there are from internal trade, are fully and completely included in the ultimate result of the actual material production of the year.

5th, “Salaries and Pensions.” These will be official and non-official. Official salaries and pensions are paid by Government from revenue, and this revenue is derived from the production of the country; and so from that same store are all such salaries and pensions derived. For non-official salaries or pensions the phenomenon is just the same. I pay my clerks or servants either from my profits of trade, or interest of Government Stock, or from rent of my house property, or from any of the sources which Mr. Danvers may suggest, but one and all of these incomes are drawn from the same store—the annual material production of the country. All salaries and pensions are thus fully and completely included in the estimate of the production.

But this is not all. In these salaries and pensions, etc., do we come to the very source of India's chief misfortune and evil, which, as I have already said, works through the medium of the foreign trade. It is the salaries and pensions, and all other expenditure incident to the excessive European agency, both in England and India, which is India's chief curse, in the shape of its causing the exhausting drain which is destroying India. In the ordinary and normal circumstances of a country, when all the salaries, pensions, etc., are earned by the people themselves, and remain in the country itself to fructify in the people’s own pockets, there is no such thing as an addition to the annual production of the country from “salaries and pensions.” But as far as India is concerned the case is much worse. All salaries and pensions, etc., paid to Europeans in England and India, beyond the absolute necessity of the maintenance or supervision of British rule, are actually, first, a direct deprivation of the natural provision for similar classes of the people of the country, and, second, a drain from the property and capacity of the country at large. So, unfortunately, is there nothing to be added, as Mr. Danvers asks, from “salaries and pensions,” but much to be subtracted that is either spent in England or remitted to England from the resources of India, and for which not a particle returns, and what is enjoyed in India itself by the Europeans.

Mr. Danvers may kindly consider his own salary. It is derived from the production of India. It is brought to England, and not a farthing out of it returns to India. Even if it returned it would be no addition to the wealth of India ; but as it does not return, it is so much actual diminution from the means of the subsistence of the people. I should not be misunderstood. That for a good long time a reasonable amount of payment for British rule is necessary for the regeneration of India is true, and no thinking Native of India denies this. It is the evil of excessive payment that India has to complain of. But what I have to point out here is that salaries and pensions, even to the Natives themselves, are no addition to the wealth, and much less are those which are not paid to the people of the country. The increase supposed by Mr. Danvers does not exist. There is, on the contrary, much diminution.

6th, “Non-Agricultural Wages.” A person employed by a farmer, say as a labourer, upon building his house, is paid from the farmer’s agricultural income. A person employed by a merchant, a householder, a stockholder, a pensioner, or a salaried man, or on a railway, is paid from their income, which, as I have explained, is derived from the only great store—the annual material production of the country. In short, every labourer—mental or physical—has his share for his subsistence, through various channels, from the only one fountain-head—the annual material production of the country. There is no source outside the production (including any addition to it from profits of foreign trade) from which any individual derives his means of subsistence.

7th, “Professional Incomes.” I consult a doctor, or a solicitor. The mere act of my consulting these professional gentlemen does not enable me to create money to pay them. I must pay them from my income as an agriculturist, or a miner, or a manufacturer, or a stockholder, or a householder, etc.; and my such income is all and solely derived from the material production of the country.

I need not now go any further into a repetition of the same argument with regard to—

8th, “Returns to investments and all other sources from which a man who does not grow food himself may obtain the means of purchasing it”; or leaving a population “directly dependent neither upon agriculture, manufactures, nor mining, and who must therefore derive their means of subsistence from other sources.”

There do not exist any such “other sources,” except profits of foreign trade. But, unfortunately for India, instead of foreign trade bringing any profits, it is actually the channel by which, in addition to all such profits, a portion of the production itself is also swept away. So India exhibits the strange phenomenon that her people cannot get any benefit from profits of foreign trade, and cannot enjoy for their subsistence even their own production, fully or adequately. The result of all the different influences—forces, labour, knowledge, land, climate, railways, or all other kinds of public works, good government, justice, security of property, law, order—and all the above eight and other so-called sources of income, is fully and completely comprised in the ultimate resultant of all of them—viz., the actual material income of the year. Its increase or decrease every year is, in fact, the test of the ultimate and full result of all the above direct and indirect means of the production of a country. If the material income of the year does not suffice for all the wants of the whole people for the year, the existing “capital” wealth of the country is drawn upon, and, so far, the capital and the capacity for annual production are diminished.

I submit, therefore, that Mr. Danvers’ argument of the “other sources” has to be laid aside.

Mr. Danvers says : “Mr. Dadabhai makes out the total value of the agricultural produce of the Punjab to be Rs. 27,72,56,263, and that from manufactures and mines, Rs. 4,11,40,058. To this he adds, to meet any omissions, a further margin of 3½ crores, making the whole produce of the Punjab 35¼ crores of rupees, ‘which, for a population of 17,600,000, gives Rs. 20 per head per annum at the outside for the year 1876-7,’ to which year the figures he has taken refer. At page 172 of his tables he shows that the cost of absolute necessaries of life of an agricultural labourer is Rs. 34 per annum, but he omits to explain how, under these circumstances, the people of the Punjab managed to live, and leaves the reader to draw his own conclusions how, with only Rs. 20 per annum, he can provide for an expenditure of Rs. 34.”

Why, that is the very question I want Government to answer : How can they expect people to manage to live, under such circumstances, without continuously sinking into poverty ? The first real question is, Are these facts or not ? If not, then what are the actual facts of the “means and wants” of the people of India ? If they are, then the question is for Mr. Danvers and Government to answer, how people can manage to live. The answer to the question is, however, obvious—viz., that as the balance of income every year available for the use of the people of India does not suffice for the wants of the year, the capital-wealth of the country is being drawn upon, and the country goes on becoming poorer and poorer, and more and more weakened in its capacity of production ; and that the American War, for a little while, gave, and the various loans give, a show of prosperity, to end in greater burdens and greater destruction by famines.

These facts of the insufficiency of the means for the wants go to prove the late Lord Lawrence’s statements, made in 1864, as Viceroy, and, in 1873, before the Finance Committee. In 1864 he said that India was, on the whole, a very poor country, and the mass of the people enjoyed only a scanty subsistence ; and, in 1873, he repeated that the mass of the people of India were so miserably poor that they had barely the means of subsistence ; that it was as much as a man could do to feed his family, or half feed them, let alone spending money on what might be called luxuries or conveniences. Such, then, is the manner in which the people of India manage to live: scanty subsistence, and dying away by millions at the very touch of drought. In the case of the Punjab, as the latest British possession, and least drained, and from other circumstances noted below,1 the people have had, as yet, better resources, in their “capital”-wealth, to draw upon; but taking India as a whole, Lord Lawrence’s words are most deplorably but too true.

I need not discuss Mr. Danvers’ paper of 28th June, 1880, any further. The fallacy of “other sources” besides agriculture, mines, manufactures, and foreign trade, pervades his whole argument; and in the latter part of the paper two different matters are mixed up, a little misapprehension has taken place as to my meaning, and some part is irrelevant.

The whole question now before us is simply this:—

First, what the whole actual, material, annual income of India is, as the ultimate balance of all sources and influences; that is available for the use of the whole people of India.

Secondly, what the absolutely necessary wants and the usual wants of all classes of the people are; and

Thirdly, whether the income of India is equal to, less, or more than such wants.

By carefully ascertaining these facts every year, shall we ever be able to know truly whether India is progressing in prosperity, or sinking in poverty, or is in a stationary condition ? This is the whole problem, and it must be boldly faced and clearly answered if the mission of Britain is the good of India, as I firmly believe it to be.

As to the question, how and by whom, directly or indirectly, the income is actually produced, and how and by whom, and through what channels, this income is distributed among the whole people, that is an entirely different matter, and, though important in itself and involving much legislation, is quite separate from the first and fundamental question of the whole total of the means and wants of India.

I may explain the misapprehension to which I alluded above. In my tables for consumption, in taking “ the cost of absolute necessaries of life of an agricultural labourer,” I meant him as merely representing the lowest class of labourers of all kinds, so as to show the lowest absolutely necessary wants of the people.

I am under the impression that there is a Statistical Committee at Calcutta, which has existed for the past twenty years, and I hope it will adopt means to give complete tables of the wants and means of India.

As I am requesting his Lordship the Secretary of State for India that Mr. Danvers be asked to work out the wants and means of the people of India during the last twelve years, and that the Government of India may adopt means to perfect the machinery for getting complete information for the future, I submit a few remarks on Mr. Danvers’ tables of January 4, 1879, so kindly sent to me. As I have my Punjab tables only for comparison, I examine Mr. Danvers’ Punjab tables only.

In his table of quantities of all the inferior grains Mr. Danvers has taken the crop per acre of only some of the grains whose average is 510 lbs. per acre. But the produce of makai and gram, which are included by Mr. Danvers in the inferior grains, is larger, and the result is a large error. The acreage of makai is 1,084,339 acres, and the average produce per acre is 1,500 lbs., so that this produce is under-estimated to the extent of taking only about one-third of the actual quantity. The average produce of gram is 645 lbs. per acre, and the acreage is 2,272,236 acres. On this large acreage there is nearly 26 per cent. of under-estimate. The result of the whole error in the table of inferior grains is that the total quantity is taken by Mr. Danvers as 6,504,880,162 lbs., when it actually is 7,371,110,343 lbs., or above 866,200,000 lbs. more.

In the prices of inferior grains it is necessary to make proper allowance for the lower prices of such grains as moth, kangni, chíná, matar, and masur, which are nearly 25 per cent. lower than the other grains—jowár, bájrá, másh, múng, and arhar. This makes an over-estimate of £240,000. The prices for makai, jow, and gram are given in the Report, and separate estimates should, therefore, be made of the values of these grains, to obtain all possible approximation to truth and accuracy.

The total under-estimate by Mr. Danvers is £1,300,000 in the value of inferior grains.

In “other crops” the value assumed by Mr. Danvers is nearly one-fourth of what I make by taking every item separately—i.e., I make Rs. 19,16,294 against Mr. Danvers' Rs. 4,73,200.

In the following articles Mr. Danvers has adopted the average given in the Report, which, as pointed out by me on previous occasions, is taken on the fallacious principle of adding up the produce per acre of the districts and dividing by the number of districts, without any reference to the quantity of acreage of each district.

TBL-115 · FOLIO 209Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
Produce.Incorrect Average.Correct Average.Error.
Correct Average.
More per cent.Less per cent.
Vegetables4,0084,75318½..
Sugar144964644..
Cotton11021053..
Tobacco8258462½..
Fibres32236613¾..
Indigo4731..33
Opium1012·525..

In the case of indigo, cotton, tobacco, and hemp, the error has not been large, as the incorrect average is adopted by Mr. Danvers for a few districts only. I notice such differences as 2½ and 3 per cent. also, because, in dealing with figures of hundreds and thousands of millions, these percentages, singly as well as collectively, seriously disturb the accuracy of results. It is very necessary to avoid, as much as possible, all avoidable errors, large or small, so that then reliance can be placed upon the results.

The Report gives the price of first sort sugar only, but which, applied to the whole quantity of all kinds, makes the value of nearly two-thirds of the whole quantity quite two and a half times greater than it actually is; the over-estimate comes to nearly £1,800,000.

The price of indigo as ascertained by me (Rs. 60 per maund), is nearly 20 per cent. higher than that assumed by Mr. Danvers (Rs. 50 per maund).

Mr. Danvers has taken a seer = 2 lbs., when in reality it is nearly 6 per cent. of a pound larger, which becomes a serious error in the large amounts to be dealt with.

Mr. Danvers has adopted the prices of 1st January, 1877, only, instead of taking an average of the prices of the four periods given in the Report to represent the whole year.

In his remarks at page 16, Mr. Danvers makes no allowance for seed, which is an important item. He includes straw, all inferior grains, and cotton seed, and yet makes no allowance at all for the feed of animals (some 7,000,000 large cattle, and near 4,000,000 sheep and goats) before apportioning the produce per human head. Grass being not taken makes some allowance for animals so far.

I cannot say on what grounds (page 16) 4 per cent. is assumed for annual increase of large cattle, and 15 per cent. of sheep and goats. I have not got the Report for 1878-9, when the next quinquennial enumeration of stock must have been made, but on comparing the numbers of the last two enumerations of 1868-9 and 1873-4, the result is as follows :—

TBL-116 · FOLIO 210Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
1868-9.1873-4.Increase.Decrease.Per Cent.
Cows, Bullocks, and Buffaloes16,797,5616,570,212..227,3493⅓
Horses96,22684,639..11,58712
Ponies.51,30251,39593..
Donkeys257,615288,11830,503..11·8
Camels148,582165,56716,985..11·4
Total7,351,2867,159,931═191,355
Sheep and Goats3,803,8193,849,84246,023..1¼

From this comparison it appears that in the important items of cows, bullocks, and buffaloes, instead of any increase, there is actually a decrease of 227,349, or 3⅓ per cent., during the five years. In horses, also, there is a decrease of about 2½ per cent. every year, instead of 4 per cent. increase. In ponies the increase is hardly ⅕ per cent. in five years, in donkeys about 11 per cent., and in camels about 11 per cent. in all the five years, or about 2¼ per cent. per year, instead of 4 per cent. In sheep and goats the increase is hardly 1¼ per cent. in five years, instead of 15 per cent. per year. For cows and bullocks, and sheep and goats, there is one allowance to be made—viz., for what are killed for food. To make out the increase in cows, etc., of 4 per cent. every year, nearly 4¾ per cent. must have been killed every year for food, and for sheep and goats the percentage of killed should be nearly 14¾ per cent. per annum. Is it so ?

Mr. Danvers has assumed ghi produced in the Punjab to be four times as much as imported (52,303 maunds) into it, and he thus makes the quantity produced to be 209,212 maunds. Now the value of the imported ghi is also given in the Report as Rs. 9,64,028, which taken four times would be £385,611. But Mr. Danvers has overlooked this actual price, and adopted the fallacious average of the table of prices in the Report, which makes the price 1s. 12c. per rupee. At this incorrect price the value will be £478,198, or nearly 25 per cent. more than the actual value given in the Report. But not only has there been this incorrect increase thus made, but, by some arithmetical mistake, the value put down by Mr. Danvers is above three times as much as even this increased amount—i.e., instead of £478,198, Mr. Danvers has put down £1,501,096. If this be not merely an arithmetical mistake, it requires explanation.

Mr. Danvers has taken the import of ghi from “foreign trade ” only, and has overlooked a further quantity of import, “ inter-provincially,” of 16,312 maunds, of the value of £34,741, which, taken four times, would be £138,964, making up the total value of the assumed produce of ghi in the Punjab to be £385,611 + £138,964 = £524,575.

Working upon Mr. Danvers' own assumption, and what information I have been at present able to obtain, it appears that the assumption of four times the import, or £525,000, will be an under-estimate by a good deal. I am not at present able to test the accuracy of Mr. Danvers' assumption of the produce of milk, nor of the information I am using below, but I give it just as I have it, to illustrate the principle. I adopt Mr. Danvers' assumption of 10 per cent. of the whole cattle to be milch-animals. The number then will be 657,000. Of these, cows may be taken, I am told by a Punjabi, as 75 per cent., and buffaloes 25 per cent. This will give 164,250 buffaloes and 492,750 cows. Each buffalo may be taken, on an average, as giving six seers of milk per day for six months in the year, and each cow about three seers. The quantity of milk will then be—

164,250 × 6 seers × 180 days = 177,390,000 seers. 492,750 × 3 seers × 180 days = 266,085,000 seers. Total ... ... 443,475,000 seers.

Mr. Danvers assumes for milk used in the province to be about Rs. 10 per annum from each of the 10 per cent. of the cattle, and, taking the price of milk to be 16 seers per rupee, the quantity of milk used would be 657,000 × 160 = 105,120,000 seers. This deducted from the above total produce of milk will give (443,475,000—105,120,000) 338,355,000 seers as converted into ghi. The produce of ghi is about ⅛th to 1/16th of milk, according to quality. Assuming 1/12th as the average, the total quantity of ghi will be about 28,196,250 seers = 704,906 maunds, or, allowing a little for wastage, say 700,000 maunds, which, at the import price (Rs. 13,11,445 for 68,615 maunds) of Rs. 19 per maund, will give about £1,339,300, or nearly 2¾ times as much as Mr. Danvers has assumed. I have endeavoured in a hurry to get this information as well as I could, but it can be obtained correctly by the officials on the spot. My object at present is simply to show, that calculated on Mr. Danvers' assumption of milchcattle and milk used, how much ghi should be produced in the country, if the information I have used be correct.

For hides and skins the export only is taken into account, but a quantity must be consumed in the province itself, which requires to be added.

The value assumed, Rs. 100 per horse, is rather too high. Rs. 60 or Rs. 70, I am told, would be fairer; so also for ponies, Rs. 25 to Rs. 30 instead of Rs. 35; and camels, Rs. 60 or Rs. 70 or Rs. 75 instead of Rs. 100. For sheep, etc., Re. 1½ instead of Re. 1 would be fairer.

But, as I have said above, officials in India can give all this information correctly for every year, and I do not see any reason why this should not be done. I urgently repeat my request that the wants and means of the last twelve or fifteen years may be ordered by his Lordship the Secretary of State to be carefully worked out, as far as practicable, and that future Reports should be required to give complete information.

Railways.

I may take railways to represent public works. The benefits generally derived from railways are these: they distribute the produce of the country from parts where it is produced, or is in abundance, to the parts where it is wanted, so that no part of the produce is wasted, which otherwise would be the case if no facility of communication existed. In thus utilising the whole produce of the country, the railway becomes directly a saving agent, and indirectly thereby helps in increasing the production of the country.

It brings the produce to the ports at the least possible cost for exportation and commercial competition for foreign trade, and thus indirectly helps in obtaining the profits of foreign trade, which are an increase to the annual income of a country.

Every country in building railways, even by borrowed capital, derives the benefit of a large portion of such borrowed capital, as the capital of the country, which indirectly helps in increasing the production of the country. Excepting interest paid for such borrowed capital to the foreign lending country, the rest of the whole income remains in the country.

But the result of all the above benefits from railways is ultimately realised and comprised in the actual annual income of the country.

The misfortune of India is that she does not derive the above benefits, as every other country does.

You build a railway in England, and, say, its gross income is a million. All the employés, from the chairman down to the common labourer, are Englishmen. Every farthing that is spent from the gross income is so much returned to Englishmen, as direct maintenance to so many people of England, and to England at large, as a part of its general wealth. Whether the shareholders get their 5 per cent., or 10 per cent., or 1 per cent., or 0 per cent., or even lose, it matters not at all to the whole country. Every farthing of the income of the million is fully and solely enjoyed by the people of the country, excepting only (if you borrowed a portion of the capital from foreign parts) the interest you may pay for such loan. But such interest forms a small portion of the whole income, and every country with good railways can very well afford to pay. All the benefits of railways are thus obtained and enjoyed by the people of the country.

Take the case of the United States. India and the States are both borrowers for their railways (the latter only partially), and they both pay interest to the lending countries. They both buy, say, their rails, machinery, etc., from England, the States buying only a portion. So far, they are under somewhat similar circumstances; but here the parallel ends. In the United States every cent. of the income of the railway (excepting the interest on the foreign loan) is the income of the people of the country—is a direct maintenance for the people employed on it, and an indirect property of the whole country, and remaining in it.

In India the case is quite different. First, for the directors, home establishments, Government superintendence, and what not, in England, a portion of the income must go from India ; then a large European staff of employés (excepting only for inferior and lowest places or work left for Natives) must eat up and take away another large portion of the income ; and to the rest the people of the country are welcome, with the result that, out of their production which they give to the railways, only a portion returns to them, and not the whole, as in all other countries (except interest on foreign loan), and the diminution lessens, so far, the capacity of production every year. Such expenditure, both in England and India, is so much direct deprivation of the natural maintenance of as many people of India of similar classes, and a loss to the general wealth and means of the people at large. Thus the whole burden of the debt is placed on the shoulders of the people of India, while the benefit is largely enjoyed and carried away by the people of England ; and yet Englishmen raise up their hands in wonder why India should not be happy, pleased, and thankful ! Some years ago I asked Mr. J. Danvers to make a return, in his annual Railway Report, of the salaries and every other kind of disbursement on Europeans, both in England and India. If I remember rightly (I cannot just now lay my hands on the correspondence), he was kind enough to promise he would try. But I do not know that this information has been given. Let us have this information, and we shall then know why India does not derive the usual benefits from railways ; how many Europeans displace as many Natives of the same class, and deprive them of their natural means of subsistence (some 3,600 in India, and all those in England), and what portion of the income the people of India do not see or enjoy a pie of.

Instead, therefore, of there being any “railway wealth” to be added to the annual production or income of India, it will be seen that there is much to be deducted therefrom to ascertain what really remains for the use of its own people ; for the income of railways is simply a portion or share of the production of the country, and what is eaten up and taken away by Europeans is so much taken away from the means of the people.

It is no wonder at all that the United States have their 70,000 or more miles of railways, when India, under the British Government, with all its wonderful resources, with all that good government can do, and the whole British wealth to back, has hardly one-tenth of the length, and that even with no benefit to the people of the country. In short, the fact of the matter is that, as India is treated at present, all the new departments, opened in the name of civilisation, advancement, progress, and what not, simply resolve themselves into so much new provision for so many more Europeans, and so much new burden on exhausting India. We do pray to our British rulers, let us have railways and all other kinds of beneficial public works by all means, but let us have their natural benefits, or talk not to a starving man of the pleasures of a fine dinner. We should be happy to, and thankfully, pay for such European supervision and guidance as may be absolutely necessary for successful work ; but do not in Heaven’s and Honesty’s names, talk to us of benefits which we do not receive, but have, on the contrary, to pay for from our own. If we are allowed to derive the usual benefits of railways and other public works, under such government as the British—of law, order, and justice—we would not only borrow £200,000,000, but £2,000,000,000, and pay the interest with as many thanks, with benefit both to ourselves and to England, as India would then be her best and largest commercial customer.

The real important question, therefore, in relation to public works is, not how to stop them, but how to let the people of the country have their full benefits. One of the most important parts of England’s great work in India is to develop these public works, but to the people’s benefit, and not to their detriment—not that they should slave, and others eat.

Foreign Trade.

Resuming our illustration of the 100 maunds of wheat from the Punjab, arriving at Bombay, costing to the Bombay merchant Rs. 125, we suppose that this merchant exports it to England. In ordinary course and natural conditions of trade, suppose the Bombay merchant, after two or three months, gets his net proceeds of Rs. 150 either in silver or as a bale of piece-goods, which could be sold at Bombay for Rs. 150. The result, then, of this “foreign trade” is that, before the wheat left Bombay, there were 100 maunds of wheat costing Rs. 125 at the time of export, and after the operation, India has either Rs. 150, or a bale of cotton goods worth Rs. 150. There is thus a clear “profit of trade” of Rs. 25, or, in other words, an addition of Rs. 25 worth, either in silver or goods, to the annual income or production of the country. This, in ordinary commercial language, would be: India exported value Rs. 125 in the shape of wheat, and imported value Rs. 150 in the shape of silver or merchandise, or both, making a trade profit of Rs. 25.

Under ordinary natural circumstances such is the result of foreign trade to every country. I shall take the instance of the United Kingdom, and we may see what its ordinary foreign trade profits have been during a few past years—say from 1871 to 1878.

TBL-117 · FOLIO 217Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
PROFITS OF FOREIGN TRADE OF THE UNITED KINGDOM.
Imports.Exports.
Years.Merchandise.Treasure. (Gold and Silver.)Total.Years.Merchandise.Treasure. (Gold and Silver.)Total.Foreign Trade Profits.Per Cent.
£££££££
1871331,015,48038,140,827369,156,3071871283,574,70033,760,671317,335,37151,820,936
1872354,693,62429,608,012384,301,6361872314,588,83430,335,861344,924,69539,376,941
1873371,287,37233,599,231404,886,6031873311,004,76528,899,285339,904,05064,982,553
1874370,082,70130,379,188400,461,8891874297,650,46422,853,593320,504,05779,957,832
1875373,939,57733,264,789407,204,3661875281,612,32327,628,042309,240,36597,964,001
1876375,154,70337,054,244412,208,9471876256,776,60229,464,082286,240,684125,968,263
1877394,419,68237,152,799431,572,4811877252,346,02039,798,119292,144,139139,428,342
1878368,770,74232,422,955401,193,6971878245,483,85826,686,546272,170,404129,023,293
Grand Total . .3,210,985,926Grand Total . .2,482,463,765728,522,161= 29·34

The result of the above table is, that during the eight years the United Kingdom has received as trade profits 29·34 per cent. This result requires the following further consideration. It includes the results of all money-trade or loans to and from foreign countries. Suppose England has lent £100,000,000 to foreign countries ; that forms a part of exports. Suppose it has received in interest, say, £5,000,000 ; that forms a part of the imports, and unless any portion of the principal of the loan is returned, the whole or balance (if a portion is paid) of the loan remains outstanding, and is so much more to be added to the above figure of trade profits. Again, there is the political profit from India of some £27,000,000 a year (as shown further on). That forms a part of the import, and has to be deducted from the figure of trade profits. England contributes to the expenses of the colonies. This is a part of its exports. Thus the formula will be :—

£728,522,161 + outstanding balance of loans of the eight years — the political drain from India to England (£216,000,000) + contributions to the colonies = the actual profits of all commercial and monetary transactions with the world ; or, in other words = the actual profits of the foreign trade of the eight years.

Now the figure £728,522,161 is 29·34 per cent. The political drain of India forms nearly 9 per cent. out of this. There remains above 20 per cent. + the amounts of balance of loans and contributions to the colonies, as the actual rate of profits of the foreign trade of the United Kingdom.

I may fairly adopt this rate, of at least 20 per cent., for the profits of the foreign trade of India ; but to be quite under the mark, I adopt only 15 per cent.

Now we may see what actually happens to India, taking the same period of 1871-8.

TBL-118 · FOLIO 218Diplomatic CSV · Tidy CSV
The actual Exports (excluding Government Stores and Treasure) : Merchandise and Gold and Silver =£485,186,749
Take Profits only 15 per cent. =72,778,012
The Imports as they ought to be£557,964,761
Actual Imports (excluding Government Stores and Treasure) : Merchandise and Gold and Silver342,312,799
Deficit in Imports, or what is drained to England (i.e., nearly £27,000,000 a year.)215,651,962
Again taking actual Exports485,186,749
And also actual Imports342,312,799
Abstraction from the very produce of the country (besides the whole profit) is =£142,875,950

in eight years, or nearly £18,000,000 a year, or 29·4 per cent.

Thus, with all the advantages of good government, law, order, justice, etc., railways, and every other influence of a civilised rule, the actual result is that not only does India not get a single farthing of the 15 or 20 per cent., or whatever it be, of the profits of her foreign trade, but actually has a further amount of nearly 30 per cent. of her exports kept away from her. This is not all. There is, moreover, the halter round her neck of the accumulated railway debt of nearly £100,000,000 held in England (from which her people have not derived the usual benefits), about £60,000,000 of public debt (out of £134,000,000—mostly owing to wars) held in England, and £5,000,000 spent in England on account of State public works. And yet Englishmen wonder why India is poor, and her finances inelastic! Good heavens! when will this bleeding to death end?

Keeping as much as possible on the right side, we find some £18,000,000 from the production itself swept away from India, besides all her profits, and besides what Europeans enjoy in India itself, to the so much exclusion and deprivation of her own people. But this item of £18,000,000 would be found much under the mark. For instance, all dutyarticles imported into India are, I believe, valued at 10 per cent. more than their laying-down value. If so, roughly taken, the customs revenue, being £2,500,000, represents roughly a duty at 5 per cent. on £50,000,000; and to make up this £50,000,000, with 10 per cent. extra, requires an addition to the actual value of imports of about £5,000,000. If so, then there will be this much above £18,000,000 taken away from the actual production of India, besides the whole trade profits, maintenance of Europeans in India, debts, etc.

The real abstraction from the very produce of the country is, most likely, much above £20,000,000 a year, and the whole loss above £30,000,000 a year, besides what is enjoyed in India itself by Europeans.

Under such circumstances it is no wonder at all that famine and finance should become great difficulties, and that finance has been the grave of several reputations, and shall continue to be so till the discovery is made of making two and two equal to five, if the present unnatural treatment of India is to continue.

Far, therefore, from there being anything to be added to the annual income of India, as Mr. Danvers thinks, from the “ profits of trade,” there is the deplorable fact of much to be deducted in the case of India ; and the consequences of such abstraction, in impoverishment and destruction by famines, etc., lay mostly at the door of the present unnatural policy of the British administration. Let our rulers realize this fact intelligently, and face it boldly, in a way worthy of the British moral courage and character, and the whole scene will be entirely changed—from deplorable poverty to prosperity, from the wail of woe to joy and blessing. Our misfortune is that the great statesmen of this country have not the necessary time to see into Indian matters, and things are allowed to drift blindly, or England would never become, as she unwittingly is at present, the destroyer of india. Her conscience is sound.

It is natural that in all discussions on finance, curtailment of expenditure and economy are, at first blush, recommended —to cut the coat according to cloth. But, unfortunately, no one asks the question why the cloth is short ; why, under such rule as that of the English, India should not do well, if not quite as well as these islands, but should be only able to pay the wretched revenue of some 6s. a head, and that even after “ wringing out the last farthing.”

No doubt vigilance for economy will always be a necessity in the best of States (not excepting England, as debates in Parliament testify) as long as the world lasts. But the real question, the most important question of all questions, at present is, not how to get £60,000,000 or £100,000,000, for the matter of that, if that be necessary, but how to return to the people what is raised from them.

There is no reason whatever why India, with all her vast resources, the patient industry of the people, and the guidance and supervision of British high officials, should not be able to pay two or three times her present wretched revenue, say £100,000,000 or £150,000,000, for efficient administration by her own people, under British supervision, and for the development of her unbounded material resources. Is it not unsatisfactory, or even humiliating, that British statesmen should have to confess that they have hopelessly to depend for about a sixth of the net revenue on supplying opium to another vast human race ; and to ask despairingly what they were to do to get this amount of revenue from India itself. Then again, nearly as much more income has to be raised by an oppressive and heavy tax on salt; so that between a third and fourth of the net revenue has to be derived—a part by pinching and starving the poor millions of India in one of the absolute necessaries of life, and the other part by poisoning and demoralising the millions of China. Surely, that a great people like the English, with their statesmanship of the highest order, and with all their genuine desire to do good to and advance mankind, should not be able to get the necessary revenues from India, from her own healthy and natural prosperity, is a strange phenomenon in this advanced age.

Only restore India to her natural economical conditions. If, as in England, the revenue raised from the people returned to the people—if the income of railways and other public works taken from the people, returned to the people, to fructify in their pockets, then would there be no need for anxiety for finance or famines, or for pinching in salt, or poisoning with opium, millions of the human race. India would then pay with ease £100,000,000 or £200,000,000 of revenue, and would not be the worse for it. It would be far better also, which would then be the case, that India should be able to purchase £1 or £2 worth a head of British manufactures, and become England’s best and largest customer, instead of the wretched one she is at present.

I repeat, therefore, with every earnestness, that the most important question of the day is, how to stop the bleeding drain from India. The merit or good of every remedy will depend upon and be tested by its efficacy in stopping this deplorable drain, without impairing the wants of the administration, or checking India’s natural progress towards prosperity.

There is a deep conviction among educated and thoughtful Natives that if there is any one nation more than another on the face of the earth that would on no account knowingly do a wrong to, or enslave, degrade, or impoverish a people, and who, on feeling the conviction of any injury having been unintentionally done by them, would at once, and at all reasonable sacrifice, repair the injury without shrinking, that nation is the British nation. This conviction keeps the thinking Natives staunch in their loyalty to the British rule. They know that a real regeneration, civilisation, and advancement of India materially, morally, and politically, depends upon a long continuance of the British rule. The peculiarly happy combination of high civilisation, intense love of liberty, and nobility of soul in the British, cannot but lead them to the desire of the glory of raising a vast nation, instead of trampling upon them. This noble desire has found expression from some of their best men.

The English people have a task before them in India for which there is no parallel in the history of the world. There has not been a nation who, as conquerors, have, like the English, considered the good of the conquered as a duty, or felt it as their great desire ; and the Natives of India may, with the evil of the present drain stopped, and a representative voice in their legislation, hopefully look forward to a future under the British rule which will eclipse their greatest and most glorious days.

May the light of Heaven guide our rulers !

Dadabhai Naoroji.

32, Great St. Helens, London, 13th September, 1880.

India Office, S.W., 15th October, 1880.

Sir,—I am directed to acknowledge the receipt of your letter of the 13th September, which, together with its enclosure, has been duly laid before the Secretary of State for India.

I am, Sir, your obedient Servant, Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji. Louis Mallet.

32, Great St. Helens, London, 16th November, 1880.

Sir Louis Mallet, the Under-Secretary of State for India, India Office, London, S.W.

Sir,—Thanking you for your letter of the 15th ultimo, informing me that my letter of 13th September, with enclosure, had been duly laid before his Lordship the Secretary of State for India, and hoping that the same kind attention will be given to it as to my previous letter, and that if I am wrong in any of my views I would be corrected, I beg to submit for his Lordship’s kind and generous consideration the accompanying Memorandum No. 2, on the “Moral Poverty of India, and Native Thoughts on the British Indian Policy.”

I am, Sir, your obedient Servant, Dadabhai Naoroji.

16th November, 1880.

Notes

  1. 1. I have not inserted these tables, as those concerning Punjab are nearly similar to mine.
  2. 1. There was an error in my table; this amount should be Rs. 27,72,56,263.—D. N.
  3. 1. Taking the aggregate wealth of the world, foreign trade even adds nothing. It simply then becomes internal trade, and is mere change of hands, as explained further on.
  4. 1. The Punjab is favoured by nature and by circumstances. By nature, inasmuch as it is one of the most fertile parts of India. It is “Punj-aub,” the land of the five waters, and it has both natural and artificial irrigation. It is favoured by circumstances, inasmuch as that (excepting Bengal, in its special fortunate circumstances of the permanent settlement) Punjab pays the least land revenue—viz., the Punjab pays Re. 1-2-2 per head per annum, the North-West Provinces pay Re. 1-6, Madras Re. 1-7, and Bombay Rs. 2-4-3 (see my tables page 170). I have taken these figures for 1875-6; those for 1876-7 would be unfair and abnormal, on account of the Bombay and Madras Famines. Further, the Punjab has been further favoured by other circumstances in the following way:— The Administration Report of 1856-8 says: “In former Reports it was explained how the circumstance of so much money going out of the Punjab contributed to depress the agriculturists. The Native regular army was Hindustani; to them was a large share of the Punjab revenue disbursed, of which a part only was spent on the spot, and a part was remitted to their home. Thus it was that year after year, lakhs and lakhs were drained from the Punjab and enriched Oudh. But within last year, the Native army being Punjabi, all such sums have been paid to them, and have been spent at home. Again, many thousands of Punjabi soldiers are serving abroad; these men not only remit their savings, but have also sent a quantity of prize property and plunder—the spoils of Hindustan—to their Native villages. The effect of all this is already perceptible in an increase of agricultural capital, a freer circulation of money, and a fresh impetus to cultivation.” It will be seen that the Punjab has more capital to draw upon, and has some addition to its resources at the expense of the other provinces, to make up for some of its deficiency of production.
  5. 1. As to some probable errors in these two articles in the Report, I have already given my views in my tables.
  6. 1. In the report of 1868-9 the heading is only ‘‘ Cows and Bullocks,’ [p. 191] while in 1876-7, it is given as “ Cows, Bullocks, and Buffaloes.” Now if buffaloes are not included in 1868-9, the diminution in cattle will be very much larger. Most probably buffaloes are included in 1868-9 figures. But this must be ascertained. It is a serious matter.