[From the Times, October 5, 1896.]
INDIAN AFFAIRS.
Prince Ranjitsinhji and Mr. Chatterji.
The head of English cricket for the year, and the head of the India Civil Service competition for the year are both Hindus. Mr. Chatterji’s achievement is not less remarkable in the arena of intellectual athletics than is Prince Ranjitsinhji’s in the world of sport. Probably no career open to Englishmen exerts a more powerful attraction on the clever youth of our public schools and Universities than the India Civil Service, and the competition for its appointments has been elaborated into the most searching test that the wit of examiners can devise. The distinguished academic careers of many of the sixty-one gentlemen who follow Mr. Chatterji in the list show the class of rivals among whom he has won the first place. As Prince Ranjitsinhji is not only head of English cricket for 1896, but also head by performances of exceptional brilliancy, so Mr. Chatterji is facile princeps in the great intellectual struggle, with a long interval between himself and the next man.
There is a certain fitness that these young Hindus should be representatives of the two ancient castes which from time immemorial ruled India. Prince Ranjitsinhji belongs to the Rajput, literally “Royal-born,” or military caste that supplied the hereditary soldier families of Hindustan. Mr. Chatterji springs of what is regarded by his countrymen as a more august lineage. With an unbroken and a verified descent from one of the five Brahmans who, according to the tradition which in India passes for history, brought sacred rites into the lower valleys of the Ganges from the north twelve hundred years ago, his family forms one of a close confederacy which has furnished, during ten centuries, the intellectual force in Bengal. Indians of the high descents to which Mr. Chatterji and Prince Ranjitsinhji belong have hitherto been infrequent visitors to England. Their caste-rules long stood in the way of their crossing “the black-water,” and although this infraction of ancient custom may now be condoned by penance on their return, the great majority of Indians in Great Britain are still derived from races or classes holding a lower position in the Indian social scale. The young hero of the cricket-field represents a stock whose one pursuit during ages has been the practice of the manly virtues and of war. The head of the India Civil Service examination represents a caste whose functions during an equal period have been the art of government and the acquisition of learning. Prince Ranjitsinhji is a Rajput of Western India. Mr. Chatterji is a Brahman of his most easterly province, Bengal.
The service which Prince Ranjitsinhji has performed for India is not that he has proved one of his race to be capable of the highest achievement in our national sport, but that he has made the fact known to the whole British people. The few Englishmen who know the Indians well, readily admit that the Rajputs are brave and athletic and the Brahmans clever at learning. But to the masses of our countrymen who pay gate-money, Prince Ranjitsinhji’s performances amount to a new discovery of India. It brings home to them the fact that among our fellow-subjects in Asia, those fellow-subjects whose very hundreds of millions turn them into numerical abstractions, there are men who can take the lead in the national sport which all Englishmen love and more or less understand. Prince Ranjitsinhji’s victory has enabled the average Englishman to realise India, and has made him respect Indians to a degree that no other triumph could have secured. But it merely is the crest of the wave of a movement which has long been going on in India, and which is there producing striking results. That movement is from the old pursuits of the East to the new pursuits of the West. Half a century ago the standards of excellence in India remained little affected by modern influences. To become learned in the Veda was still the highest aim of a Brahman; to ride about at the head of his little household guard was still the ambition of a Rajput chief. To take part in a public game of football would have been as far beneath the dignity of a Rajput prince as the study of anatomy would have been degrading to a Brahman. The recent successes of Prince Ranjitsinhji and Mr. Chatterji give emphasis in England to a change which has for some time been well understood in India—a change from the old pursuits of the high castes and from their old standards of excellence to the new pursuits and the new standards of excellence which Englishmen carry with them to whatever country they go. At first it seemed that the change was a mere matter of imitation. But the change has long advanced beyond the imitative stage. Prince Ranjitsinhji’s playing is distinguished above all things by its originality, verve, and personal resource. The long interval between Mr. Chatterji and the next man to him on the list indicates a not less remarkable capacity.
Their successes do not stand alone. Among the most interesting features at the British Association this year was the paper on Electrical Waves by Professor J. C. Bose. This gentleman, an M.A. of Cambridge, Doctor of Science of London, and a graduate of the Calcutta University, had already won the attention of the scientific world by his strikingly original researches on the polarisation of the electric ray. His later papers on the Determination of the Indices of Electric Refraction and of the Wave-Length of Electric Radiation were published, with high tributes, by the Royal Society. Lord Kelvin declared himself “literally filled with wonder and admiration for so much success in these difficult and novel experimental problems.” The originality of the achievement is enhanced by the fact that Dr. Bose had to do the work in addition to his incessant duties as Professor of Physical Science in Calcutta and with apparatus and appliances which in this country would be deemed altogether inadequate. He had to construct for himself his instruments as he went along. The paper which was read before the British Association the other day “On a Complete Apparatus for the Study of the Properties of Electric Waves” forms the outcome of this two-fold line of labour—construction and research. Professor Bose is not only an example of the change from the old philosophical and a priori pursuits of learned Indians to the experimental science of the West, but he has also persuaded the Government to recognise that change. He has been deputed to visit the chief laboratories in Europe, with a view to forming a well-equipped laboratory in Calcutta for physical and electrical work. The position which Professor Bose has attained among British men of science, while himself still in the first energies of manhood, is as significant as the successes of Prince Ranjitsinhji and Mr. Chatterji in their widely diverse fields of effort.
Perhaps an even more striking example of the new departure is to be found in the case of Lieutenant S. C. Biswas, who distinguished himself so honourably during the late insurrection in Brazil. As first lieutenant of an infantry regiment he was told off, on the night of the great bombardment, after the fire had gone on for six hours, to seize or silence a battery. Advancing with his company he seems to have fallen into a sort of trap, and was called on to surrender on pain of instant destruction. “Comrades,” he shouted to his men, “you will see how a son of the sacred land of Hindustan can throw himself on those guns. Follow!” Somehow he got in between the fire, the artillerymen were cut down, and the cannons captured. Such is the narrative as given by a Brazilian writer last March. Lieutenant Biswas, like Mr. Chatterji and Professor Bose, was a Bengali. Their successes, like that of Prince Ranjitsinhji, mean that in India the old order is giving place to the new, and that Indians seem likely to win high places for themselves in the new world of practical achievement, as their fathers held a high place, from Alexander the Great onwards, in the old world of abstract thought.
VII.
Washington House, 72, Anerley Park, S.E. November 3rd, 1897.
Dear Lord Welby,—I now give my statement on the Admission of Natives to the Covenanted Civil Service in India, as promised by me at the meeting of the Commission on 21st July last, and request you to place it before the Commission. I shall send a copy to the members.
If required, I shall give any further statement I can on any particular point that may require to be more elucidated. I shall be willing to be cross-examined if required.
The first deliberate and practical action was taken by Parliament in the year 1833.
All aspects of the whole question of all services were then fully discussed by eminent men; and a Committee of the House made searching enquiry into the whole subject.
I give below extracts from what was said on that occasion, and a definite conclusion was adopted.
I am obliged to give some of the extracts at length, because it must be clearly seen on what statesmanlike and farseeing grounds this conclusion was arrived at.
The italics all through are mine, except when I say that they are in the original.
East India Company’s Charter, Hansard, Vol. XIX, Third Series, p. 169. July 5th, 1833.
The Marquis of Lansdowne : “ But he should be taking a very narrow view of this question, and one utterly inadequate to the great importance of the subject, which involved in it the happiness or misery of 100,000,000 of human beings, were he not to call the attention of their lordships to the bearing which this question and to the influence which this arrangement must exercise upon the future destinies of that vast mass of people. He was sure that their lordships would feel, as he indeed felt, that their only justification before God and Providence for the great and unprecedented dominion which they exercised in India was in the happiness which they communicated to the subjects under their rule, and in proving to the world at large and to the inhabitants of Hindustan that the inheritance of Akbar (the wisest and most beneficent of Mahomedan Princes) had not fallen into unworthy or degenerate hands. Hence it was important that when the dominion of India was transferred from the East India Company to the King’s Government they should have the benefit of the experience of the most enlightened councillors, not only on the financial condition of our Empire in the East but also on the character of its inhabitants. He stated confidently, after referring to the evidence given by persons eminently calculated to estimate what the character of the people of India was, that they must, as a first step to their improved social condition, be admitted to a larger share in the administration of their local affairs. On that point their lordships had the testimony of a series of successful experiments and the evidence of the most unexceptionable witnesses who had gone at a mature period of their life and with much natural and acquired knowledge to visit the East. Among the crowd of witnesses which he could call to the improvable condition of the Hindu character he would select only two; but those two were well calculated to form a correct judgment, and fortunately contemplated Indian society from very different points of view. Those two witnesses were Sir Thomas Monro and Bishop Heber. He could not conceive any two persons more eminently calculated to form an accurate opinion upon human character, and particularly upon that of the Hindu tribes. They were both highly distinguished for talent and integrity, yet they were placed in situations from which they might have easily come to the formation of different opinions—one of them being conversant with the affairs of the East from his childhood and familiarised by long habit with the working of the system, and the other being a refined Christian philosopher and scholar going out to the East late in life, and applying in India the knowledge which he had acquired here to form an estimate of the character of its inhabitants. He held in his hand the testimony of each of those able men, as extracted from their different published works, and with the permission of the House he would read a few words from both. Sir T. Monro, in speaking of the Hindu character, said : ‘Unless we suppose that they are inferior to us in natural talent, which there is no reason to believe, it is much more likely that they will be duly qualified for their employments than Europeans for theirs—because the field of selection is so much greater in the one than in the other. We have a whole nation from which to make our choice of Natives, but in order to make choice of Europeans we have only the small body of the Company’s Covenanted servants. No conceit more wild and absurd than this was ever engendered in the darkest ages : for what is in every age and every country the great stimulus to the pursuit of knowledge but the prospect of fame or wealth or power ? Or what is even the use of great attainments if they are not to be devoted to their noblest purpose, the service of the community, by employing those who possess them according to their respective qualifications in the various duties of the public administration of the country ? Our books alone will do little or nothing ; dry, simple literature will never improve the character of a nation. To produce this effect it must open the road to wealth and honour and public employment. Without the prospect of such reward no attainments in science will ever raise the character of a people.’ That was the sound practical opinion of Sir T. Monro, founded on his experience acquired in every part of India, in every department of the public service. Bishop Heber during his extensive journey of charity and religion through India, to which he at length fell a martyr, used these remarkable expressions : ‘Of the natural disposition of the Hindu I still see abundant reason to think highly, and Mr. Bayley and Mr. Melville both agreed with me that they are constitutionally kind-hearted, industrious, sober, and peaceable ; at the same time that they show themselves on proper occasions a manly and courageous people.’ And again : ‘They are decidedly by nature a mild, pleasing, and intelligent race, sober, parsimonious, and, where an object is held out to them, most industrious and persevering.’ Their lordships were therefore justified in coming to the same conclusion — a conclusion to which, indeed, they must come if they only considered the acts of this people in past ages—if they only looked at the monuments of gratitude and piety which they had erected to their benefactors and friends—for to India, if to any country, the observation of the poet applied :—
Sunt lacrymæ verum, et mentem mortalia tangunt.’
But, however much civilisation had been obscured in those regions, whatever inroads foreign conquest and domestic superstition had made upon their moral habits, it was undeniable that they had still materials left for improving and ameliorating their condition; and their lordships would be remiss in the performance of the high duties which devolved upon them if they did not secure to the numerous Natives of Hindustan the ample development of all their mental endowments and moral qualifications. It was a part of the new system which he had to propose to their lordships that to every office in India every Native, of whatsoever caste, sect, or religion, should by law be equally admissible, and he hoped that Government would seriously endeavour to give the fullest effect to this arrangement, which would be as beneficial to the people themselves as it would be advantageous to the economical reforms which were now in progress in different parts of India.”
(Page 174, July 5th, 1833.)—“And without being at all too sanguine as to the result of the following up those principles without calculating upon any extension of territory through them, he was confident that the strength of the Government would be increased by the happiness of the people over whom it presided, and by the attachment of those nations to it.”
Vol. XIX., Third Series, p, 191. July 5th, 1833.
Lord Ellenborough: “He felt deeply interested in the prosperity of India, and when he was a Minister of the Crown, filling an office peculiarly connected with that country, he had always considered it his paramount duty to do all in his power to promote that prosperity. He was as anxious as any of his Majesty’s Ministers could be to raise the moral character of the Native population of India. He trusted that the time would eventually come, though he never expected to see it, when the Natives of India could, with advantage to the country and with honour to themselves, fill even the highest situations there. He looked forward to the arrival of such a period, though he considered it far distant from the present day; and he proposed, by the reduction of taxation, which was the only way to benefit the lower classes in India, to elevate them ultimately in the scale of society, so as to fit them for admission to offices of power and trust. To attempt to precipitate the arrival of such a state of society as that he had been describing was the surest way to defeat the object in view. He never, however, looked forward to a period when all offices in India would be placed in the hands of Natives. No man in his senses would propose to place the political and military power in India in the hands of the Natives.
“The Marquess of Lansdowne observed that what the Government proposed was that all offices in India should be by law open to the Natives of that country.
“Lord Ellenborough said such was precisely the proposition of Government, but our very existence in India depended upon the exclusion of the Natives from military and political power in that country. We were there in a situation not of our own seeking, in a situation from which we could not recede without producing bloodshed from one end of India to the other. We had won the Empire of India by the sword, and we must preserve it by the same means, doing at the same time everything that was consistent with our existence there for the good of the people.”
Macaulay fully answers Lord Ellenborough.
Vol. XIX, Third Series, p. 533. July 10th, 1833.
Mr. Macaulay: “I have detained the House so long, Sir, that I will defer what I had to say in some parts of this measure—important parts, indeed, but far less important as I think than those to which I have adverted, till we are in Committee. There is, however, one part of the Bill on which, after what has recently passed elsewhere, I feel myself irresistibly impelled to say a few words. I allude to that wise, that benevolent, that noble clause, which enacts that no Native of our Indian Empire shall, by reason of his colour, his descent, or his religion, be incapable of holding office. At the risk of being called by that nickname which is regarded as the most opprobrious of all nicknames by men of selfish hearts and contracted minds—at the risk of being called a philosopher—I must say that, to the last day of my life, I shall be proud of having been one of those who assisted in the framing of the Bill which contains that clause. We are told that the time can never come when the Natives of India can be admitted to high civil and military office. We are told that this is the condition on which we hold our power. We are told that we are bound to confer on our subjects—every benefit which they are capable of enjoying ?—no—which it is in our power to confer on them ?—no—but which we can confer on them without hazard to our own domination. Against that proposition I solemnly protest as inconsistent alike with sound policy and sound morality.
“ I am far, very far, from wishing to proceed hastily in this most delicate matter. I feel that, for the good of India itself, the admission of Natives to high office must be effected by slow degrees. But that when the fulness of time is come, when the interest of India requires the change, we ought to refuse to make that change lest we should endanger our own power—this is a doctrine which I cannot think of without indignation. Governments, like men, may buy existence too dear. ‘ Propter vitam vivendi perdere causas,’ is a despicable policy either in individuals or in States. In the present case, such a policy would be not only despicable, but absurd. The mere extent of empire is not necessarily an advantage. To many Governments it has been cumbersome ; to some it has been fatal. It will be allowed by every statesman of our time that the prosperity of a community is made up of the prosperity of those who compose the community, and that it is the most childish ambition to covet dominion which adds to no man’s comfort or security. To the great trading nation, to the great manufacturing nation, no progress which any portion of the human race can make in knowledge, in taste for the conveniences of life, or in the wealth by which those conveniences are produced, can be matter of indifference. It is scarcely possible to calculate the benefits which we might derive from the diffusion of European civilisation among the vast population of the East. It would be, on the most selfish view of the case, far better for us that the people of India were well governed and independent of us, than ill-governed and subject to us—that they were ruled by their own kings, but wearing our broad cloth, and working with our cutlery, than that they were performing their salaams to English Collectors and English magistrates, but were too ignorant to value, or too poor to buy, English manufactures. To trade with civilised men is infinitely more profitable than to govern savages. That would indeed be a doting wisdom, which, in order that India might remain a dependency, would keep it a useless and costly dependency—which would keep a hundred millions of men from being our customers in order that they might continue to be our slaves.
“ It was, as Bernier tells us, the practice of the miserable tyrants whom he found in India, when they dreaded the capacity and spirit of some distinguished subject, and yet could not venture to murder him, to administer to him a daily dose of the pousta, a preparation of opium, the effect of which was in a few months to destroy all the bodily and mental powers of the wretch who was drugged with it, and to turn him into a helpless idiot. That detestable artifice, more horrible than assassination itself, was worthy of those who employed it. It is no model for the English nation. We shall never consent to administer the pousta to a whole community—to stupefy and paralyse a great people, whom God has committed to our charge, for the wretched purpose of rendering them more amenable to our control. What is that power worth which is founded on vice, on ignorance, and on misery — which we can hold only by violating the most sacred duties which as governors we owe to the governed—which as a people blessed with far more than an ordinary measure of political liberty and of intellectual light, we owe to a race debased by three thousand years of despotism and priestcraft ? We are free, we are civilised to little purpose, if we grudge to any portion of the human race an equal measure of freedom and civilisation.
“ Are we to keep the people of India ignorant in order that we may keep them submissive ? Or do we think that we can give them knowledge without awakening ambition ? Or do we mean to awaken ambition and to provide it with no legitimate vent ? Who will answer any of these questions in the affirmative ? Yet one of them must be answered in the affirmative by every person who maintains that we ought permanently to exclude the Natives from high office. I have no fears. The path of duty is plain before us : and it is also the path of wisdom, of national prosperity, of national honour.
“ The destinies of our Indian Empire are covered with thick darkness. It is difficult to form any conjecture as to the fate reserved for a State which resembles no other in history, and which forms by itself a separate class of political phenomena. The laws which regulate its growth and its decay are still unknown to us. It may be that the public mind of India may expand under our system till it has outgrown that system; that by good government we may educate our subjects into a capacity for better government, that, having become instructed in European knowledge, they may, in some future age, demand European institutions. Whether such a day will ever come I know not. But never will I attempt to avert or to retard it. Whenever it comes, it will be the proudest day in English history. To have found a great people sunk in the lowest depths of slavery and superstition, to have so ruled them as to have made them desirous and capable of all the privileges of citizens would indeed be a title to glory all our own. The sceptre may pass away from us. Unforeseen accidents may derange our most profound schemes of policy. Victory may be inconstant to our arms. But there are triumphs which are followed by no reverses. There is an empire exempt from all natural causes of decay. Those triumphs are the pacific triumphs of reason over barbarism; that empire is the imperishable empire of our arts and our morals, our literature, and our law.”
Vol. XIX, Third Series, p. 536. July 10th, 1833.
Mr. Wynn : “In nothing, however, more unreservedly did he agree with the hon. member than in the sentiments which he so forcibly impressed on the House at the close of his speech. He had been convinced, ever since he was first connected with the affairs of India, that the only principle on which that Empire could justly or wisely or advantageously be administered was that of admitting the Natives to a participation in the government, and allowing them to hold every office the duties of which they were competent to discharge. That principle had been supported by the authority of Sir Thomas Monro, and of the ablest functionaries in India, and been resisted with no small pertinacity and prejudice. It had been urged that the Natives were undeserving of trust, that no dependence could be placed on their integrity, whatever might be their talents and capacity, which no one disputed. Instances were adduced of their corruption and venality—but were they not the result of our conduct towards them ? Duties of importance devolved upon them without any adequate remuneration either in rank or salary. There was no reward or promotion for fidelity; and why then complain of peculation and bribery. We made vices and then punished them; we reduced men to slavery and then reproached them with the faults of slaves.”
Vol. XIX, Third Series, p. 547. July 10th, 1833.
Mr. Charles Grant, in replying, said “he would advert very briefly to some of the suggestions which had been offered in the course of this debate. Before doing so, he must first embrace the opportunity of expressing not what he felt, for language could not express it, but of making an attempt to convey to the House his sympathy with it in its admiration of the speech of his hon. and learned friend the member for Leeds—a speech which, he would venture to assert, had never been exceeded within those walls for the development of statesmanlike policy and practical good sense. It exhibited all that was noble in oratory, all that was sublime, he had almost said, in poetry—all that was truly great, exalted, and virtuous in human nature. If the House at large felt a deep interest in this magnificent display it might judge of what were his emotions when he perceived in the hands of his hon. friend the great principles he had propounded to the House glowing with fresh colours and arrayed in all the beauty of truth.
“If one circumstance more than another could give him satisfaction it was that the main principle of this Bill had received the approbation of the House, and that the House was now legislating for India and the people of India on the great and just principle that in doing so the interests of the people of India should be principally consulted, and that all other interests of wealth, of commerce, and of revenue, should be as nothing compared with the paramount obligation imposed upon the legislature of promoting the welfare and prosperity of that great Empire which Providence had placed in our hands.
“Convinced as he was of the necessity of admitting Europeans to India, he would not consent to remove a single restriction on their admission unless it was consistent with the interests of the Natives. Provide for their protection and then throw open wide the doors of those magnificent regions and admit British subjects there—not as aliens, not as culprits, but as friends. In spite of the differences between the two peoples, in spite of the difference of their religions, there was a sympathy which he was persuaded would unite them, and he looked forward with hope and eagerness to the rich harvest of blessings which he trusted would flow from the present measure.”
Page 624, July 12th, 1833.
Mr. Wynn : “He could not subscribe to the perfection of the system that had hitherto prevailed in India ; for he could not forget that the Natives and half-castes were excluded from all employment in situations where they could be more effective than Europeans and at a much smaller cost. The principle of employing those persons he considered to be essential to the good government of India, and he could not applaud that system which had been founded on a violation of that principle.”
Vol. XX., Third Series, p. 323. August 5th, 1833.
Duke of Wellington : “Then with respect to the clause declaring the Natives to be eligible to all situations. Why was that declaration made in the face of a regulation preventing its being carried into effect ? It was a mere deception. It might, to a considerable extent, be applicable in the capitals of the Presidencies ; but, in the interior, as appeared by the evidence of Mr. Elphinstone, and by that of every respectable authority, it was impracticable. He certainly thought that it was advisable to admit the Natives to certain inferior civil and other offices ; but the higher ones must as yet be closed against them, if our Empire in India was to be maintained.”
After such exhaustive consideration from all political, imperial, and social aspects, the following, “that wise, that benevolent, that noble clause,” was deliberately enacted by the Parliament of this country—worthy of the righteousness, justice, and noble instincts of the British people in the true British spirit.
3 and 4 William IV., cap. 85. 1833.
“That no Native of the said territories, nor any natural-born subject of his Majesty resident therein, shall, by reason only of his religion, place of birth, descent, colour, or any of them, be disabled from holding any place, office, or employment under the said Company.”
Ret. C—2376, 1879, p. 13.
“The Court of Directors interpreted this Act in an explaining despatch in the following words :—‘The Court conceive this section to mean that there shall be no governing caste in British India; that whatever other tests of qualification may be adopted, distinction of race or religion shall not be of the number; that no subject of the King, whether of Indian or British or mixed descent, shall be excluded from the posts usually conferred on Uncovenanted servants in India, or from the Covenanted Service itself, provided he be otherwise eligible.’ ”
After this explanation by the Court of Directors, how did they behave?
During the twenty years of their Charter, to the year 1853, they made the Act and their own explanation a complete dead letter. They did not at all take any steps to give the slightest opportunity to Indians for a single appointment to the Covenanted Civil Service, to which my statement chiefly refers; though the British people and Parliament are no party to this unfaithfulness, and never meant that the Act should remain a sham and delusion.
Twenty years passed, and the revision of the Company’s Charter again came before Parliament in 1853; and if anything was more insisted on and bewailed than another, it was the neglect of the authorities to give effect to the Act of 1833. The principles of 1833 were more emphatically insisted on. I would just give a few extracts from the speeches of some of the most eminent statesmen in the debate on the Charter.
Hansard, Vol. 120, p. 865. April 19th, 1852.
Mr. Golbeurn: “Sir Thomas Monro had said—There is one great question to which we should look in all our arrangements, namely, what is to be the final result of our government on the character of the people, and whether that character will be raised or lowered. Are we to be satisfied with merely securing our power and protecting the inhabitants, leaving them to sink gradually in character lower than at present, or are we to endeavour to raise their character? It ought undoubtedly to be our aim to raise the minds of the Natives, and to take care that whenever our connexion with India shall cease, it shall not appear that the only fruit of our dominion had been to leave the people more abject than when we found them. It would certainly be more desirable we should be expelled from the country altogether, than that our system of government should be such an abasement of a whole people.”
Hansard, Vol. 121, p. 496. May 11th, 1852.
Lord Monteagle, in presenting a petition to the House of Lords, said: “But a clause recommended or supported as he believed by the high authority of Lord William Bentinck was made part of the last Charter Act of the 3rd and 4th William IV, and affirmed the principle of an opposite policy. It was to the following effect: . . . . Yet notwithstanding his authority, notwithstanding likewise the result of the experiment tried and the spirit of the clause he had cited, there had been a practical exclusion of them from all ‘Covenanted Services,’ as they were called, from the passing of the last Charter up to the present time.”
Hansard, Vol. 127, p. 1,184. June 3rd, 1853.
Mr. Bright: “Another subject requiring close attention on the part of Parliament was the employment of the Natives of India in the service of the Government. The right hon. member for Edinburgh (Mr. Macaulay), in proposing the India Bill of 1833 had dwelt on one of its clauses, which provided that neither colour nor caste nor religion nor place of birth should be a bar to the employment of persons by the Government; whereas, as matter of fact, from that time to this no person in India had been so employed who might not have been equally employed before that clause was enacted; and from the statement of the right hon. gentleman the President of the Board of Control, that it was proposed to keep up the Covenanted Service system, it was clear that this most objectionable and most offensive state of things was to continue. Mr. Cameron, a gentleman thoroughly versed in the subject, as fourth Member of Council in India, President of the Indian Law Commission, and of the Council of Education for Bengal—what did he say on this point? He said : ‘The statute of 1833 made the Natives of India eligible to all offices under the Company. But during the twenty years that have since elapsed not one of the Natives has been appointed to any offices except such as they were eligible to before the statute.’ ”
Hansard, Vol. 128, p. 759. 1853.
Macaulay said : “In my opinion we shall not secure or prolong our dominion in India by attempting to exclude the Natives of that country from a share in its government” (Contemporary Review, June, 1883, p. 803).
Hansard, Vol. 128, p. 986. June 30th, 1853.
Mr. Rich : “But if the case as to the Native military was a strong one, it was much stronger as to civilians. It had been admitted that ninety-five per cent. of the administration of justice was discharged by Native judges. Thus they had the work, the hard work ; but the places of honour and emolument were reserved for the Covenanted Service— the friends and relatives of the directors. Was it just that the whole work, the heat and labour of the day, should be borne by Natives and all the prizes reserved for Europeans ? Was it politic to continue such a system ? They might turn up the whites of their eyes and exclaim at American persistence in slavery. There the hard work was done by the negro whilst the control and enjoyment of profit and power were for the American. Was ours different in India ? What did Mill lay down ? European control — Native agency. And what was the translation of that ? White power, black slavery. Was this just, or was it wise ? Mill said it was necessary in order to obtain respect from the Natives. But he (Mr. Rich) had yet to learn that injustice was the parent of respect. Real respect grew out of common service, common emulation, and common rights impartially upheld. We must underpin our Empire by such principles, or some fine morning it would crumble beneath our feet. So long as he had a voice in that House it should be raised in favour of admitting our Native fellow subjects in India to all places to which their abilities and conduct should entitle them to rise.”
Hansard, Vol. 129, p. 581. July 21st, 1853.
Mr. MONCTON MILNES: “Objectionable as he believed many parts of the Bill were, he considered this was the most objectionable portion, and from it very unhappy consequences might arise. When the Natives of India heard it proclaimed that they had a right to enter the service of the Company, they would by their own intelligence and ability render themselves qualified for that service, if they only had the means of doing so. Then one of the two consequences would follow. They would either find their way into the service, or else the Company would have arrayed against them a spirit of discontent on the part of the whole people of India, the result of which it would be difficult to foresee. He did not see on what principles of justice, if they once admitted the principle of open competition, they could say to the Natives of India they had not a perfect right to enter the service.”
Hansard, Vol. 129, p. 665. July 22nd, 1853.
Mr. J. G. PHILLIMORE quotes Lord William Bentinck: “The bane of our system is not solely that the Civil Administration is entirely in the hands of foreigners, but the holders of this monopoly, the patrons of these foreign agents, are those who exercise its directing power at home; that this directing power is exclusively paid by patronage, and that the value of the patronage depends exactly upon the degree in which all the honours and emoluments of the State are engrossed by their clients to the exclusion of the Natives. There exists in consequence, on the part of the home authorities, an interest in the Administration precisely similar to what formerly prevailed as to commerce, and directly opposed to the welfare of India.”
Though open competition was introduced, the monopoly of the Europeans and the injustice and injury to the Indians was allowed to continue by refusing to the Indians simultaneous examinations in India as the only method of justice to them, as will be seen further on.
Mr. Rich and Lord Stanley (the late Lord Derby) then emphatically put their fingers upon this black plague-spot in the system of British rule.
Hansard, Vol. 129, p. 682. July 22nd, 1853.
Mr. Rich raised the question whether or not the Natives were to be admitted to the Company’s Covenanted Service. He said: “As regarded employment in the public service, the Natives were placed in a worse position by the present Bill than they were before. The intention of the Act of 1833 was to open the services to the Natives; and surely now, when our Indian Empire was more secure than it was at that time, it was not wise to deviate from such a line of policy. His object was that all offices in India should be effectively opened to Natives, and therefore he would not require them to come over to this country for examination, as such a condition would necessarily entail on Natives of India great expense, expose them to the risk of losing caste, and thereby operate as a bar against their obtaining the advantages held out to all other of her Majesty’s subjects. The course of education through which the youth of India at present went at the established colleges in that country afforded the most satisfactory proof of their efficiency for discharging the duties of office. . . . .
“This was not just or wise, and would infallibly lead to a most dangerous agitation, by which in a few years that which would now be accepted as a boon would be wrested from the Legislature as a right. They had opened the commerce of India in spite of the croakers of the day. Let them now open the posts of government to the Natives, and they would have a more happy and contented people.”
Hansard, Vol. 129, p. 684. July 22nd, 1853.
Lord Stanley: “He could not refrain from expressing his conviction that, in refusing to carry on examinations in India as well as in England—a thing that was easily praticable—the Government were, in fact, negativing that which they declared to be one of the principal objects of their Bill, and confining the Civil Service, as heretofore, to Englishmen. That result was unjust, and he believed it would be most pernicious.”
Hansard, Vol. 129, p. 784. July 25th, 1853.
Lord Stanley: “Let them suppose, for instance, that instead of holding those examinations here in London, that they were to be held in Calcutta. Well, how many Englishmen would go out there—or how many would send out their sons, perhaps to spend two or three years in the country on the chance of obtaining an appointment! Nevertheless, that was exactly the course proposed to be adopted towards the Natives of India.”
Hansard, Vol. 129, p. 778. July 25th, 1853.
Mr. Bright said: “That the motion now before the Committee involved the question which had been raised before during these discussions, but which had never been fairly met by the President of the Board of Control, namely, whether the clause in the Act of 1833, which had been so often alluded to, had not up to this time been altogether a nullity. If any doubt had been entertained with respect to the object of that clause, it would be removed by reference to the answers given by the then President of the Board of Control to the hon. member for Montrose and to the speech of the right hon. gentleman the present member for Edinburgh (Mr. Macaulay), in both of which it was distinctly declared that the object was to break down the barriers which were supposed to exist to the admission of the Natives as well as Europeans to high offices in India. And yet there was the best authority for saying that nothing whatever had been done in consequence of that clause. He (Mr. Bright) did not know of a single case where a Native of India had been admitted to any office since that time, more distinguished or more highly paid than he would have been competent to fill had that clause been not passed.”
Hansard, Vol. 129, p. 787. July 25th, 1853.
Mr. Moncton Milnes said: “He thought the Bill was highly objectionable in this respect that while it pretended to lay down the generous principle that no condition of colour, creed or caste was to be regarded as a disqualification for office, it hampered the principle with such regulations and modifications as would render it all but impossible for the Natives to avail themselves of it. The Bill in this respect was a delusion and would prove a source of chronic and permanent discontent to the people of India.”
Hansard, Vol. 129, p. 788. July 25th, 1853.
Mr. J. G. PHILLIMORE said : “He also feared that the Bill would prove delusive, and that although it professed to do justice to the Natives the spirit of monopoly would still blight the hopes and break the spirits of the Indian people. While such a state of things continued India would be attached to this country by no bond of affection, but would be retained by the power of the Army and the terror of the sword. He implored of the Committee not to allow such an Empire to be governed in the miserable spirit of monopoly and exclusion.”
Will the present statesmen ever learn this truth ? Is it a wonder that the British people are losing the affections of the Indian people ?
Hansard, Vol. 129, p. 1,335. August 5th, 1853.
Earl GRANVILLE : “I, for one, speaking individually, have never felt the slightest alarm at Natives, well-qualified and fitted for public employments, being employed in any branch of the public service of India.”
Thus began the second chapter of this melancholy history with the continuation of the same spirit of selfishness which had characterised the previous twenty years, with the clear knowledge of the gross injustice to the Indians by not allowing them the same facility as was allowed to English youths, by simultaneous examinations in India and England. This injustice continued till the second chapter ended in the Mutiny of 1857, and the rule passed from the Company to the Crown.
The third chapter from that time began again with the revival of great hopes—that, however unfortunate and deplorable the Mutiny was, one great good sprang from that evil. The conscience of the British people was awakened to all previous injustice and dishonour brought upon them by their servants, and to a sense of their own duty. A new era opened, brighter, far brighter, than even that of the Act of 1833.
Not only was the Act of 1833 allowed to continue a living reality, at least in word, but in directing the mode of future services the Act of 1858 left it comprehensively open to adopt any plan demanded by justice. It did not indicate in the slightest degree prevention or exclusion of Indians from any service or from simultaneous examinations in India and England, or of any mode of admission of Indians into the Covenanted Civil Service, or of doing equal justice to all her Majesty’s natural-born subjects. I shall show further on the interpretation by the Civil Service Commissioners themselves.
The sections of the Act of 1858 are as follows :—
1.—21-22 Vic., Cap. 106, “An Act for the better Government of India” (2nd August, 1858). Section 32 provides that :—
“With all convenient speed after the passing of this Act, regulations shall be made by the Secretary of State in Council, with the advice and assistance of the Commissioners for the time being acting in execution of her Majesty’s Order in Council of Twenty-first May, One thousand, eight hundred, and fifty-five, ‘for regulating the admission of persons to the Civil Service of the Crown,’ for admitting all persons being natural-born subjects of her Majesty (and of such age and qualification as may be prescribed in this behalf) who may be desirous of becoming candidates for appointment to the Civil Services of India to be examined as candidates accordingly, and for prescribing the branches of knowledge in which such candidates shall be examined, and generally for regulating and conducting such examinations under the superintendence of the said last-mentioned Commissioners, or of the persons for the time being entrusted with the carrying out of such regulations as may be from time to time established by her Majesty for examination, certificate, or other test of fitness in relation to appointments to junior situations in the Civil Services of the Crown, and the candidates who may be certified by the said Commissioners or other persons as aforesaid to be entitled under such regulations shall be recommended for appointment according to the order of their proficiency as shown by such examinations, and such persons only as shall have been so certified as aforesaid shall be appointed or admitted to the Civil Services of India by the Secretary of State in Council : Provided always, that all regulations to be made by the said Secretary of State in Council under this Act shall be laid before Parliament within fourteen days after the making thereof, if Parliament be sitting, and, if Parliament be not sitting, then within fourteen days after the next meeting thereof.”
2.—The same Act, Cap. 106, Sect. 34, provides :— “With all convenient speed after the commencement of this Act, regulations shall be made for admitting any persons being natural-born subjects of her Majesty (and of such age and qualifications as may be prescribed in this behalf) who may be desirous of becoming candidates for cadetships in the Engineers and in the Artillery, to be examined as candidates accordingly, and for prescribing the branches of knowledge in which such candidates shall be examined, and generally for regulating and conducting such examinations.”
Though this Section does not impose any disability on an Indian—for it provides for “any persons being natural-born subjects of her Majesty”—yet an Indian is totally excluded from such examination. As I have already placed before the Commission my correspondence with the War Office, I need not say more.
3.—Sections 35 and 36 provide :— “Not less than one-tenth of the whole number of persons to be recommended in any year for military cadetships (other than cadetships in the Engineers and Artillery) shall be selected according to such regulations as the Secretary of State in Council may from time to time make in this behalf from among the sons of persons who have served in India in the military or civil services of her Majesty, or of the East India Company.”
“Except as aforesaid, all persons to be recommended for military cadetships shall be nominated by the Secretary of State and Members of Council, so that out of seventeen nominations the Secretary of State shall have two and each Member of Council shall have one; but no person so nominated shall be recommended unless the nomination be approved of by the Secretary of State in Council.”
In these sections also there is no exclusion of Indians.
But the Sovereign and the people did not rest even by such comprehensive enactment by Parliament. They explicitly emphasised and removed any possible doubt with regard to the free and equal treatment of all her Majesty’s natural-born subjects without any distinction of race, colour, or creed.
Thus, on the 1st November, 1858, followed the great and glorious Proclamation by the Sovereign on behalf of the British people : our complete “great charter” of our national and political rights of British citizenship and of perfect equality in all the services of the Sovereign—a proclamation the like of which had never been proclaimed in the history of the world under similar circumstances.
Here are the special clauses of that Proclamation :—
“We hold ourselves bound to the Natives of our Indian territories by the same obligations of duty which bind us to all our other subjects, and those obligations, by the blessing of Almighty God, we shall faithfully and conscientiously fulfil.”
“And it is our further will that, so far as may be, our subjects, of whatever race or creed, be freely and impartially admitted to offices in our service, the duties of which they may be qualified, by their education, ability, and integrity, duly to discharge.
“In their prosperity will be our strength, in their contentment our security, and in their gratitude our best reward. And may the God of all Power grant to us, and to those in authority under us, strength to carry out these our wishes for the good of our people.”
Such was the noblest Proclamation of 1858. What more could we ask, and what bonds of gratitude and affection, and what vast benefits to both countries, were expected to tie us to the connexion with Britain by a loyal and honourable fulfilment of it ?
Yes, I was in Bombay when this glad—I may almost say divine—message to India was proclaimed there to a surging crowd. What rejoicings, what fireworks, illuminations, and the roar of cannon ! What joy ran through the length and breadth of India, of a second and firm emancipation, of a new British political life, forgetting and forgiving all the past evil and hoping for a better future ! What were the feelings of the people ! How deep loyalty and faith in Britain was rekindled ! It was said over and over again : Let this Proclamation be faithfully and conscientiously fulfilled, and England may rest secure and in strength upon the gratitude and contentment of the people—as the Proclamation had closed its last words of prayer.
Now, when I look back to-day to that day of joy, how I feel how all this was doomed to disappointment, with the addition of some even worse features, of dishonour, injustice, and selfishness. However, I must proceed with the sad tale.
Not long after her Majesty’s Proclamation of 1858, a Committee was appointed by the Secretary of State for India of the following members of his own Council : Sir J. P. Willoughby, Mr. Mangles, Mr. Arbuthnot, Mr. Macnaghten, and Sir Erskine Perry, all Anglo-Indians. This Committee made its report on 20th January, 1860, from which I give the following extracts on the subject of the pledge of the Act of 1833 :—
“2. We are in the first place unanimously of opinion that it is not only just, but expedient, that the Natives of India shall be employed in the administration of India to as large an extent as possible consistently with the maintenance of British supremacy, and have considered whether any increased facilities can be given in this direction.
“3. It is true that, even at present, no positive disqualification exists. By Act 3 and 4 Wm. IV, cap. 85, sec. 87, it is enacted ‘that no Native of the said territories nor any natural-born subject of his Majesty resident therein shall, by reason only of his religion, place of birth, descent, colour, or any of them, be disabled from holding any place, office, or employment under the said Company.’ It is obvious, therefore, that when the competitive system was adopted, it could not have been intended to exclude Natives of India from the Civil Service of India.
“4. Practically, however, they are excluded. The law declares them eligible, but the difficulties opposed to a Native leaving India and residing in England for a time, are so great, that, as a general rule, it is almost impossible for a Native successfully to compete at the periodical examinations held in England. Were this inequality removed, we should no longer be exposed to the charge of keeping promise to the ear and breaking it to the hope.
“5. Two modes have been suggested by which the object in view might be attained. The first is, by alloting a certain portion of the total number of appointments declared in each year to be competed for in India by Natives, and by all other natural-born subjects of her Majesty resident in India. The second is to hold simultaneously two examinations, one in England and one in India, both being, as far as practicable, identical in their nature, and those who compete in both countries being finally classified in one list, according to merit, by the Civil Service Commissioners. The Committee have no hesitation in giving the preference to the second scheme, as being the fairest, and the most in accordance with the principles of a general competition for a common object.
“6. In order to aid them in carrying out a scheme of this nature, the Committee have consulted the Civil Service Commission, and, through the favour of Sir Edward Ryan, they have obtained a very able paper, in which the advantages and disadvantages of either plan are fully and lucidly discussed. They would solicit your careful consideration of this document, and will only, in conclusion, add that, in the event of either of the plans being adopted, it will be requisite to provide for the second examination of successful competitors in India, as nearly as possible resembling that now required in England. The Civil Service Commissioners do not anticipate much difficulty in arranging for this. The Committee, however, are decidedly of opinion that the examination papers on which the competition is to proceed in India and England should be identical; but they think, in justice to the Natives, that three colloquial Oriental languages should be added to the three modern European languages, so as to give the candidates the opportunity of selection.”
I asked the India Office to give me a copy of the “very able paper” of the Civil Service Commission above referred to. The India Office refused to give it to me. I was allowed to see it in the India Office, and I then asked to be allowed to take a copy of it myself there and then. This even was refused to me. I ask this Commission that this Report be obtained and be added here.
The above forms a part of the Report, the other part being a consideration of the advantages and disadvantages of an “exclusive” Covenanted Civil Service. With this latter part I have nothing to do here. The first part quoted above about the admission of Natives into the Covenanted Civil Service was never as far as I know published.
It is a significant fact that the Report of the public Service Commission on the two subjects of the so-called. “Statutory” Service and simultaneous examinations being in accordance with (what I believe and will show further on) the determined foregone conclusions of the Government of India and the Secretary of State, was published and is being repeatedly used by Government in favour of their own proceedings, while the Report of 1860 of the Committee of five Members of Council of the Secretary of State for India was not only never published by Government as far as I know, but even suppressed in the Return made in 1879 on “Civil Service” (Return [C. 2376] 1879). Even the Public Service Commission has not given, I think, the Report of 1860.
No action was taken on this part of the Report of 1860. This Report was made thirty-seven years ago, and even so early as then it was considered, and strongly recommended, that simultaneous examinations was the only way of redeeming the honour of England and of doing justice to India. The Report was suppressed and put aside, as it did not suit the views of the Secretary of State for India, who himself had appointed the Committee.
Thus the new stage of the Proclamation of 1858, with all the hopes and joy it had inspired, began so early as 1860 to be a grievous disappointment and a dead letter, just as dead as the Act of 1833.
The next stage in this sad story is again a revival of hope and joy in a small instalment of justice by a partial fulfilment of all the pledges of 1833 and 1858. This was a bright spot in the dark history of this question, and the name of Sir Stafford Northcote will never be effaced from our hearts.
Sad to say, it was to be again darkened with a disappointment of a worse character than ever before. On August 13th, 1867, the East India Association considered the following memorial proposed by me, and adopted it, for submission to Sir Stafford Northcote (Lord Iddesleigh), the then Secretary of State for India :—
“We, the members of the East India Association, beg respectfully to submit that the time has come when it is desirable to admit the Natives of India to a larger share in the administration of India than hitherto.
“To you, Sir, it is quite unnecessary to point out the justice, necessity, and importance of this step, as in the debate in Parliament, on May 24th last, you have pointed out this so emphatically and clearly that it is enough for us to quote your own noble and statesmanlike sentiments. You said : ‘Nothing could be more wonderful than our Empire in India; but we ought to consider on what conditions we hold it and how our predecessors held it. The greatness of the Mogul Empire depended upon the liberal policy that was pursued by men like Akbar availing themselves of Hindu talent and assistance and identifying themselves as far as possible with the people of the country. He thought that they ought to take a lesson from such a circumstance, and if they were to do their duty towards India they could only discharge that duty by obtaining the assistance and counsel of all who were great and good in that country. It would be absurd in them to say that there was not a large fund of statesmanship and ability in the Indian character ’ (Times of May 25th, 1867).
“With these friendly and just sentiments towards the people of India we fully concur, and therefore instead of trespassing any more upon your time, we beg to lay before you our views as to the best mode of accomplishing the object.
“We think that the competitive examination for a portion of the appointments to the Indian Civil Service should be held in India, under such rules and arrangements as you may think proper. What portion of the appointments should be thus competed for in India we cannot do better than leave to your own judgment. After the selection is made in India, by the first examination, we think it essential that the selected candidates be required to come to England to pass their further examinations with the selected candidates of this country.
“In the same spirit, and with kindred objects in view for the general good of India, we would ask you to extend your kind encouragement to Native youths of promise and ability to come to England for the completion of their education. We believe that if scholarships tenable for five years in this country were to be annually awarded by competitive examination in India to Native candidates between the ages of fifteen and seventeen, some would compete successfully in England for the Indian Civil Service, while others would return in various professions to India, and where by degrees they would form an enlightened and unprejudiced class, exercising a great and beneficial influence on Native society, and constituting a link between the masses of the people and their English rulers.1 “In laying before you this memorial we feel assured, and we trust that you will also agree with us, that this measure, which has now become necessary by the advancement of education in India, will promote and strengthen the loyalty of the Natives of India to the British rule, while it will also be a satisfaction to the British people to have thus by one more instance practically proved its desire to advance the condition of their Indian fellow-subjects, and to act justly by them.
“We need not point out to you, Sir, how great an encouragement these examinations in India will be to education. The great prizes of the appointment will naturally increase vastly the desire for education among the people.”
A deputation waited on Sir Stafford Northcote on 21st August, 1867, to present the petition. In the course of the conversation, Colonel Sykes explained the objects; and after some further conversation Sir Stafford Northcote said:—
“He had the question under consideration, and had conversed with Sir Herbert Edwards and others on it, and Sir Herbert had furnished him with a paper on it. Two plans were suggested—the one proposed that appointments should be assigned for competition in India, the other that scholarships should be given to enable Natives to come to finish their education in England. The first would manifestly be the most convenient for the Natives themselves; but it was urged in favour of the second that it would secure a more enterprising class than the first—men with more backbone— and he admitted the force of that. Moreover, he quite saw the advantage to India of a more efficient class which had had an English training. He took a very great interest in the matter, and was inclined to approve both proposals. He was corresponding with Sir J. Lawrence and the Indian Government on the subject” (Journal of the East India Association, Vol. I., pp. 126-7).
In 1868 Sir Stafford Northcote, in paragraph 3 of his despatch, Revenue No. 10, of 8th of February, 1868, said as below:—
“This is a step in the right direction, of which I cordially approve, but it appears to me that there is room for carrying out the principle to a considerable extent in the regulation provinces also. The Legislature has determined that the more important and responsible appointments in those provinces shall be administered exclusively by those who are now admitted to the public service solely by competition ; but there is a large class of appointments in the regulation as well as in the non-regulation provinces, some of them scarcely less honourable and lucrative than those reserved by law for the Covenanted Civil Service, to which Natives of India have certainly a preferential claim, but which, as you seem to admit, have up to this time been too exclusively conferred upon Europeans. These persons, however competent, not having entered the service by the prescribed channel, can have no claim upon the patronage of the Government, none, at least, that ought to be allowed to override the inherent rights of the Natives of the country ; and therefore, while all due consideration should be shown to well-deserving incumbents, both as regards their present position and their promotion, there can be no valid reason why the class of appointments which they now hold should not be filled, in future, by Natives of ability and high character.”
I only note this here as what Sir Stafford Northcote had prescribed and instructed the Government of India for the Uncovenanted Services, but which instructions have also been made a dead letter as usual—I do not in this statement discuss this branch of the subject, viz., the Uncovenanted Service, except for some short reference to some subsequent grievous events. I content myself with an expression of the Duke of Argyll on what Sir Erskine Perry describes in his “Memorandum” addressed to Lord Salisbury on 9th December, 1876, as “the vicious practice, supposed to be rapidly growing up in India, of appointing Englishmen to all the well paid Uncovenanted offices.” The Duke of Argyll in his despatch (10th March, 1870, Financial) said : “The principle which her Majesty’s Government steadily kept in view throughout the discussion on these furlough rules is, that the Uncovenanted Service should be principally reserved for the Natives of the country, and that superior appointments, which require English training and experience, should be made as heretofore in England. And they look with great disfavour on the system which appears to be growing up in India of appointing Englishmen in India to situations that ought only as a rule to be filled by civilians by open competition.”
All such instructions, as usual, are thwarted by what Lord Lytton calls “subterfuges” and great ingenuity.
While Sir Stafford Northcote was considering, maturing, and preparing to bring into action the petition of the East India Association, Mr. Fawcett raised the subject in the House of Commons. Referring to simultaneous examinations for the Covenanted Service, he said :—
Hansard, Vol. 191, pp. 1,839-40. May 8th, 1868.
“ There would be no difficulty in carrying out this plan. . . . . His proposal was that there should be examinations at Calcutta, Madras and Bombay, that there should be the same papers and the same tests as in London, and the successful candidates, whether English or Native, should spend two years in this country. To this he had reason to believe, from memorials he had received from Calcutta and Bombay, the Natives would not object, though they naturally objected to coming over to England in the first instance without any guarantee of success. . . . . All they aske for was to be subjected to precisely the same trial as the English. . . . . With reference to their alleged inferiority of character he had asked what would be the effect on English character if we, having been subjected, were debarred from all but the meanest offices of the State. Our civilisation and our literature would be destroyed. Nothing would save us from debasement. It was an indisputable fact that many Natives competent to govern a Province were fulfilling the humblest duties at salaries less than was received by the youngest member of the Indian Civil Service. Lord Metcalf had well said that the bane of our system was that the advantages were reaped by one class and the work was done by another. . . . . Sir Bartle Frere, in one of his despatches, said he had been much struck with the fact that the ablest exponents of English policy and our best coadjutors in adapting that policy to the wants of the various nations occupying Indian soil were to be found among the Natives who had received a high-class English education.”
Hansard, Vol. 191, p. 1843. May 8th, 1868.
Mr. Fawcett moved : “ That this House whilst cordially approving of the system of open competition for appointments in the East India Civil Service, is of opinion that the people of India have not a fair chance of competing for these appointments, as long as the examinations are held nowhere but in London ; this House would therefore deem it desirable that simultaneously with the examination in London, the same examination should be held in Calcutta, Bombay and Madras." I may here remark that at this time and till 1876 the Report of the five Councillors of the India Office of 1860, which I have given before, was not known to anybody outside, and Mr. Fawcett could not have known anything about it.
In the same speech from which a passage is extracted in the Memorial of the East India Association, Sir Stafford Northcote has said : “The English Government must necessarily labour under great disadvantages, and we should endeavour as far as possible to develop the system of Native government, to bring out Native talent and statesmanship, and to enlist in the cause of government all that was great and good in them."
The outcome of the petition of the East India Association, Mr. Fawcett’s motion, and Sir Stafford Northcote’s favourable reception of the petition, was that Sir Stafford Northcote introduced a clause in his Bill entitled “the Governor-General of India Bill” to grant the first prayer of the petition ; and the Governor-General, Lord Lawrence, published a Resolution on 30th June, 1868, to grant the second prayer of the Memorial, and some scholarships were actually commenced to be given. But by a strange fatality that pursues everything in the interests of the Indians, the scholarships were soon abolished.
I do not enter into any details of this incident, as it affects only in an indirect manner and to a very small extent the question I am considering, viz., the admission of Indians in the Covenanted Civil Service.
I revert to the clause introduced by Sir Stafford Northcote in 1868. As this clause will come further on in the course of correspondence, I do not repeat it here.
This clause was subsequently passed in 1870, under the Duke of Argyll as Secretary of State, who communicated it to the Government of India by a despatch of 31st March, 1870. The Government of India being dilatory, as it is generally the misfortune of Indian interests, the Duke of Argyll in his despatch of 18th April, 1872, reminded the Government of India about the rules required by the Act, as follows :—
“Referring to the 6th section of 33rd Victoria, cap. 3, I desire to be informed whether your Excellency in Council has prescribed the rules which that Act contemplates for the regulation of the admission of Natives to appointments in the Covenanted Civil Service who have not been admitted to that service in accordance with the provisions of the 32nd section of the 21st and 22nd Victoria, cap. 106.”
The dilatoriness of the Government of India continuing, the Duke of Argyll again reminded the Governor-General of India in a despatch of 22nd October, 1872 :—
“I have not received any subsequent communication from your Excellency’s Government on the subject, and therefore conclude that nothing has been done, although I addressed your Government on the subject on 18th April last.”
These two reminders were not known to the public until a Return was made in 1879 [C—2,376].
Three years passed after the enactment of the clause, and the public not knowing of anything having been done, the East India Association felt it necessary to complain to the Duke of Argyll on the subject.
The following is the correspondence between the East India Association and Mr. Grant Duff in 1873, giving his Grace’s speech, and a brief account of the events from 1867 to 1873 :—
“East India Association, “20, Great George Street, Westminster, London. “September, 1873.
“To M. E. Grant Duff, Esq., M.P., Under-Secretary of State for India, India Office.
“Sir,—By the direction of the Council of the East India Association, I have to request you to submit this letter for the kind consideration of his Grace the Secretary of State for India.
“On the 21st August, 1867, this Association applied to Sir Stafford Northcote, the then Secretary of State for India, asking that the competitive examination for a portion of the appointments to the Indian Civil Service should be held in India, under such rules and arrangements as he might think proper, and expressing an opinion that, after the selection had been made in India by the first examination, it was essential that the selected candidates should be required to come to England to pass their further examinations with the selected candidates for this country.
“Sir Stafford Northcote soon after introduced a clause in the Bill he submitted to Parliament, entitled ‘The Governor-General of India Bill.’
“The enactment of this Bill continued in abeyance, until, under the auspices of his Grace the present Secretary of State, it became law on the 25th March, 1870, as ‘East India (Laws and Regulations) Act.’ Moving the second reading of the Bill on the 11th March, 1869, his Grace, in commenting upon clause 6, in a candid and generous manner made an unreserved acknowledgment of past failures of promises, non-fulfilment of duty, and held out hopes of the future complete fulfilment to an adequate extent, as follows:—
“‘I now come to a clause—the 6th—which is one of very great importance involving some modification in our practice, and in the principles of our legislation as regards the Civil Service in India. Its object is to set free the hands of the Governor-General, under such restrictions and regulations as may be agreed to by the Government at home, to select, for the Covenanted Service of India, Natives of that country, although they may not have gone through the competitive examination in this country. It may be asked how far this provision is consistent with the measures adopted by Parliament for securing efficiency in that service; but there is a previous and, in my opinion, a much more important question which I trust will be considered—how far this provision is essential to enable us to perform our duties and fulfil our pledges and professions towards the people of India . . . . .
“‘With regard, however, to the employment of Natives in the government of their country in the Covenanted Service formerly of the Company, and now of the Crown, I must say that we have not fulfilled our duty, or the promises and engagements which we have made.
“‘In the Act of 1833 this declaration was solemnly put forth by the Parliament of England: “And be it enacted that no Native of the said territories, nor any natural-born subject of his Majesty resident therein, shall, by reason only of his religion, place of birth, descent, colour, or any of them, be disabled from holding any place, office, or employment under the said Company.”
“‘Now, I well remember that in the debates in this House in 1853, when the renewal of the Charter was under the consideration of Lord Aberdeen’s Government, my late noble friend Lord Monteagle complained, and I think with great force, that while professing to open every office of profit and employment under the Company or the Crown to the Natives of India, we practically excluded them by laying down regulations as to fitness which we knew Natives could never fulfil. If the only door of admission to the Civil Service of India is a competitive examination carried on in London, what chance or what possibility is there of Natives of India acquiring that fair share in the administration of their own country which their education and abilities would enable them to fulfil, and therefore entitle them to possess? I have always felt that the regulations laid down for the competitive examination rendered nugatory the declaration of the Act of 1833; and so strongly has this been felt of late years by the Government of India that various suggestions have been made to remedy the evil. One of the very last—which, however, has not yet been finally sanctioned at home, and respecting which I must say there are serious doubts—has been suggested by Sir John Lawrence, who is now about to approach our shores, and who is certainly one of the most distinguished men who have ever wielded the destinies of our Indian Empire. The palliative which he proposes is that nine scholarships—nine scholarships for a Government of upwards of 180,000,000 of people!—should be annually at the disposal for certain Natives, selected partly by competition and partly with reference to their social rank and position, and that these nine scholars should be sent home with a salary of £200 a year each, to compete with the whole force of the British population seeking admission through the competitive examinations. Now, in the first place, I would point out the utter inadequacy of the scheme to the ends of the case. To speak of nine scholarships distributed over the whole of India as any fulfilment of our pledges or obligations to the Natives would be a farce. I will not go into details of the scheme, as they are still under consideration; but I think it is by no means expedient to lay down as a principle that it is wholly useless to require Natives seeking employment in our Civil Service to see something of English society and manners. It is true that in the new schools and colleges they pass most distinguished examinations, and as far as books can teach them, are familiar with the history and constitution of this country ; but there are some offices with regard to which it would be a most important, if not an essential, qualification that the young men appointed to them should have seen something of the actual working of the English constitution, and should have been impressed by its working, as any one must be who resides for any time in this great political society. Under any new regulations which may be made under this clause, it will, therefore, be expedient to provide that Natives appointed to certain places shall have some personal knowledge of the working of English institutions. I would, however, by no means make this a general condition, for there are many places in the Covenanted Service of India for which Natives are perfectly competent, without the necessity of visiting this country ; and I believe that by competitive examinations conducted at Calcutta, or even by pure selection, it will be quite possible for the Indian Government to secure able, excellent, and efficient administrators.’
“The clause thus introduced, in a manner worthy of an English generous-minded nobleman, and passed into law, is as follows :—
“‘6. Whereas it is expedient that additional facilities should be given for the employment of Natives of India, of proved merit and ability, in the Civil Service of her Majesty in India, be it enacted that nothing in the “Act for the Government of India,” twenty-one and twenty-two Victoria, chapter one hundred and six, or in the “Act to confirm certain appointments in India, and to amend the law concerning the Civil Service there,” twenty-four and twenty-five Victoria, chapter fifty-four, or in any other Act of Parliament, or other law now in force in India, shall restrain the authorities in India by whom appointments are or may be made to offices, places, and employments in the Civil Service of her Majesty in India, from appointing any Native of India to any such office, place, or employment, although such Native shall not have been admitted to the said Civil Service of India in manner in section thirty-two of the first-mentioned Act provided, but subject to such rules as may be from time to time prescribed by the Governor-General in Council, and sanctioned by the Secretary of State in Council, with the concurrence of a majority of members present ; and that, for the purpose of this Act, the words “ Natives of India ” shall include any person born and domiciled within the dominions of her Majesty in India, of parents habitually resident in India, and not established there for temporary purposes only ; and that it shall be lawful for the Governor-General in Council to define and limit from time to time the qualification of Natives of India thus expressed ; provided that every resolution made by him for such purpose shall be subject to the sanction of the Secretary of State in Council, and shall not have force until it has been laid for thirty days before both Houses of Parliament.’
“ It is now more than three years since this clause has been passed, but the Council regret to find that no steps have apparently yet been taken by his Excellency the Viceroy to frame the rules required by it, so that the Natives may obtain the due fulfilment of the liberal promise made by his Grace.
“ The Natives complain that, had the enactment referred to the interests of the English community, no such long and unreasonable delay would have taken place, but effect would have been given to the Act as quickly as possible, and they further express a fear that this promise may also be a dead-letter.1
“ The Council, however, fully hope that further loss of time will not be allowed to take place in promulgating the rules required by the Act. The Natives, after the noble and generous language used by his Grace, naturally expect that they will not be again doomed to disappointment, and most anxiously look forward to the promulgation of the rules—to give them, in some systematic manner, ‘that fair share in the administration of their own country which their education and abilities would enable them to fulfil, and therefore entitle them to possess,’ not only as a political justice, but also as a national necessity, for the advancement of the material and moral condition of the country.
“ I remain, Sir, your obedient Servant, “ W. C. Palmer, Capt. “ Acting Honorary Secretary of the East India Association.”
“India Office, London, October 10th, 1873. “Sir,—I am directed by the Secretary of State for India in Council to acknowledge the receipt of your letter of the 2nd October, relative to the provisions of the 33rd Victoria cap. 3, section 6; and to inform you that the subject is understood to be under the consideration of the Government of India, the attention of which has been twice called to it. “2. The Duke of Argyll in Council will send a copy of your letter to the Government of India, and again request the early attention of that authority to that subject. “I am, Sir, your obedient Servant, “(Sd.) M. E. Grant Duff. “The Acting Honorary Secretary, East India Association.”
Such is the candid confession of non-performance of duty and non-fulfilment of solemn pledges for thirty-six years, and the renewed pledge to make amends for past failures and provide adequate admission for the future for at least some share in the administration of our own country. The inadequacy is clearly shown by the ridicule of nine scholarships for 180,000,000 souls, and the proposal to adopt means for the abolition of the monopoly of Europeans. When was this confession and this new pledge made? It was to pass the 6th clause of Act 33 Vic., cap. 3. The clause was passed on 25th March, 1870, one year after the above speech was made, and nearly three years after it was first proposed. Twice did Sir C. Wingfield ask questions in the House of Commons, and no satisfactory reply was given. At last the East India Association addressed the letter which I have given above to the India Office, and from the reply it will be seen how slow our Indian authorities had been, so as to draw three reminders from the Secretary of State.
With regard to the remark in the letter as to the complaint of the Natives that, “had the enactment referred to the interests of the English community, no such long and unreasonable delay would have taken place,” I need simply point to the fact of the manner in which the Coopers Hill College was proposed and carried out promptly and with no difficulty raised, as is always raised against Indian interests.
In 1879 the India Office made a Return [C—2,376] on the (“Civil Service”). In this Return, after the despatch of the Secretary of State for India of 22nd October, 1872, no information is given till the Government of India’s despatch of May 2nd, 1878.
In this Return, as I have said already, the Report of the Committee of the five members of the Council of the Secretary of State of 1860, recommending that simultaneous examinations was the only fair way of redeeming the honour of the British name and doing justice to the Indians, was suppressed. There is a despatch of the Government of India of 1874, which Sir E. Perry in his memorandum describes as follows :—
“Nearly two years afterwards (20th August, No. 31 of 1874) the Government of India replied to this despatch, transmitting rules, but noticing very jejunely the principal question raised by his Grace. Rules were finally suggested for adoption by the Secretary of State, those originally transmitted being deemed by him, under legal advice, to place too narrow a construction on the statute” (Public Despatch to India, No. 131 of 20th of August, 1874).
These documents also have no place in the Return. Who knows what other inconvenient documents also may have not appeared. This is always the difficulty in Indian matters for Indian interests. The public can never know the whole truth. The Government put forward only such information as they like, and the public is left in the dark, so as not to be in a position to judge rightly. The way of the Indian authorities is first to ignore any Act or Resolution of Parliament or Report of any Committee or Commission in favour of Indian interests. If that is not enough, then to delay replies. If that does not answer, then openly resist, and by their persistence carry their own point unless a strong Secretary of State prevents it. But, unfortunately, to expect a strong and just Secretary of State on behalf of Indian interests is a rare good fortune of India, because he changes so often and is mostly in the hands of the Anglo-Indian members of his Council and other Anglo-Indian officials of the India Offie. If any Committee or Commission really want to know the whole truth, they must do what the Committee of 1772 did—to have every document on the subject under consideration to be produced before them. What an exposure that Committee of 1772 made of the most outrageous, most corrupt, and most tyrannical misconduct of the Government and officials of the day.
I may also mention that the despatch of the Duke of Argyll (10 March, 1870, Financial), to which I have already referred, has also not been given in the Return.
Of course, I am not surprised at these suppressions. It is our fate, and the usual ways of a despotic régime. But why I mention this is that the public are misled and are unable to know the true state of a case in which Indian interests are involved; the public cannot evolve these suppressions from their inner consciousness.
And still the outside public and the non-official witnesses are sometimes blamed for not supplying criticisms on the statements made by the officials of Government !
Again, there is the despatch of Lord Salisbury of 10th February, 1876, not given in the Return. Sir E. Perry, referring to this despatch, says: “Lord Salisbury decided the matter once for all in his despatch of 10th February, 1876, Financial, in which he quoted the Duke of Argyll’s despatch of 1870 (Supra), and after stating that he concurred in the views thus expressed, he proceeded to lay down precise rules by which the appointment of Englishmen in India to the higher Uncovenanted offices should in future be restricted.” Now I cannot say whether all these suppressed documents were satisfactory or not, or whether they are published in some other place; but when the India Office omits such information in a Return on the subject itself, what are we to do? And if we criticise upon imperfect information, the authorities come down upon us denouncing us in all sorts of ways for our wrong statements, exaggerations, inaccuracies, and what not.
The next despatch that the Return gives is that of the Government of India of 2nd May, 1878. It was in connexion with this despatch that Lord Lytton wrote a note dated 30th May. In this note he had the courage to expose the whole character of the conduct of Indian authorities in both countries since the passing of the Act of 1833, denouncing that conduct as consisting of deliberate, transparent subterfuges, and dishonourable, as making promises to the ear and breaking them to the hope. Here are Lord Lytton’s own words, referring to the Act of 1833 :—
“The Act of Parliament is so undefined, and indefinite obligations on the part of the Government of India towards its Native subjects are so obviously dangerous, that no sooner was the Act passed than the Government began to devise means for practically evading the fulfilment of it. Under the terms of the Act which are studied and laid to heart by that increasing class of educated Natives whose development the Government encourages, without being able to satisfy the aspirations of its existing members, every such Native if once admitted to Government employment in posts previously reserved to the Covenanted Service is entitled to expect and claim appointment in the fair course of promotion to the highest post in that service.
“We all know that these claims and expectations never can or will be fulfilled. We have had to choose between prohibiting them and cheating them : and we have chosen the least straightforward course. The application to Natives of the competitive examination system as conducted in England, and the recent reduction in the age at which candidates can compete, are all so many deliberate and transparent subterfuges for stultifying the Act and reducing it to a dead letter. Since I am writing confidentially I do not hesitate to say that both the Governments of England and of India appear to me, up to the present moment, unable to answer satisfactorily the charge of having taken every means in their power of breaking to the heart the words of promise they had uttered to the ear.”
I admire the English candour and courage with which this humiliating confession is made. But I protest that so far as the people, the Parliament and the Sovereign are concerned, it is an injustice to them to put the dishonour and the disgrace of subterfuges to their charge. It is a libel upon the statesmen of 1833, that they said so many deliberate falsehoods intentionally when they contended for the justification of the clause for equality in such noble and generous and English spirit and terms. It is a gross libel on the Sovereign and the people of this country that the Proclamation of 1858, so solemnly promulgated, calling God to witness and to help, was all hypocrisy, an intentional mockery and delusion. I protest against this assumption. The truth I believe to be is that the Sovereign, the Parliament and the people of this country sincerely meant what they said—but that their servants, the executive authorities in both countries, uncontrollable and free to follow their own devices in their original spirit of selfishness and oppression with which they commenced their rule in India, frustrated the highest and noblest desires of the Sovereign and the people by “deliberate and transparent subterfuges to attain their own selfish ends”—which on one occasion an Anglo-Indian very naïvely confessed in these remarkable words. In a debate at the Society of Arts, 19th February, 1892, upon Siam, Sir Charles Crossthwaite said : “The real question was who was to get the trade with them, and how we could make the most of them so as to find fresh markets for our goods and also employment for those superfluous articles of the present day, OUR BOYS.” So the whole reason of the existence of the world is market for British capitalists and employment for “our boys.”
In India this greed for the monopolising of profits of trade, and of the employment of “our boys,” is the chief key to the system of all the actions of an unsympathetic, selfish rule as it is at present made by the executive authorities. Not that it need be so. A righteous system can be adopted, as many a statesman has declared, by which both England and India may be blessed and benefited, and for which purpose the Indians have been crying all along in the wilderness. Let the saddle of the present evil system be on the right horse. The Sovereign, the Parliament and the people have done all that could be desired. The only misfortune is that they do not see to their noble wishes and orders being carried out, and leave their servants to “bleed” India of all that is most dear and necessary to the human existence and advancement—wealth, wisdom and work— material and moral prosperity. Reverting to Lord Lytton’s true confession, that the executives have “cheated” and “subterfuged,” frustrated and dishonoured all Acts and resolutions of Parliament and the most solemn Proclamations of the Sovereign, one would think that after such confessions some amends will be made by a more honourable course. Far from it. This despatch of 2nd May, 1878, will remain one of the darkest sections in this sad story, instead of any contrition or reparation for the past evil.
What did the Government propose in this despatch ? To destroy everything that is dearest to the Indian heart—his two great Charters of 1833 and 1858, the Act of a partial justice of 1870—to murder in cold blood the whole political existence of equality of Indians as British citizens which—at least by law, if not by deed or action of the authorities—they possessed, and make them the Pariahs of the high public service.
Mark ! by the Act of 1870, the Indians were to have a distinct proportion of appointments (which was fixed by the Government of India to be about one-fifth, or about 7 every year) in the Covenanted Civil Service—which meant that in the course of 25 to 30 years, the duration of the service of each person, there would gradually be about 180 to 200 Indians admitted into the Covenanted Civil Service. This was a most bitter pill for the Anglo-Indians, official and non-official, to swallow. The Government resorted to every subterfuge to ignore and with passive resistance to make the Act a dead letter. This not succeeding, they deliberately proposed to throw aside all Acts, Resolutions, and Proclamations—all pledges and laws of equality—and to establish a “close Native Civil Service ;” that is to say, to deprive the Natives once and for ever of any claim to the whole higher Covenanted Services, and by law be shut up in a lazaretto of a miserable close service.
And what was to be this close service ? Not even to the extent to which the Act of 1870 led to the hope of the share in the Covenanted Civil Service—but only to propose to assign certain fixed appointments now held by the Covenanted Service, and to rob the Uncovenanted Service of some of their appointments to cast them into this service ; that is to say, in reality to make a “pariah” service of a small number of Covenanted Service employments—about 90 or so (the Uncovenanted being already the Indian’s own)—in place of what the Act of 1870 would have entitled them, to the extent of 180 or more, and to be eligible to the whole Covenanted Service employments ; and what is still worse, and exhibits the inner spirit, that even this miserable so-called “close” service was not to be entirely reserved for the Indians, but, as I understand, a door is left open for Europeans also to get into it. And still more, the Government of India so mercilessly wanted to put the badge and stamp of inferiority and exclusion upon the Indians at large and rob them of their only consolation, their only hope and charter, that they already possessed by law and by pledges, of equality of British citizenship with the British subjects of this country. But there is something still worse : the Government coolly proposed not only not to give them simultaneous examinations in India, but to deprive them even of the right they now possess of competing for the Covenanted Service in this country itself.
Were the Government of India gone mad? The Government of India said, in cold blood, that “the ordinary Covenanted Civil Service should no longer be open to Natives ; ” thus proposing insidiously that the Acts of 1833 and 1870 and the Proclamation should be thrown to the winds. So these Acts and the Proclamations of the Sovereign upon which hangs all our devoted loyalty, all our hopes and aspirations (though in all conscience most mercilessly disregarded) all that is at all good and great in the British name in India, all that is to be swept away by a new un-British and tyrannical legislation ! The whole despatch is so distressful, so full of false blandishments, that I cannot venture to say anything more about it. The wonder is that on the one hand Lord Lytton exposes the “subterfuges” and dishonour of the Executive, and himself and his colleagues sign such a despatch of 2nd May, 1878. And what is still more curious is this ; about seventeen months before this despatch, on 1st January, 1877, at the Delhi Assemblage, on the assumption of the title of Empress of India, Lord Lytton on behalf of her Majesty said :—
“But you the Natives of India, whatever your race and whatever your creed, have a recognised claim to share largely with your English fellow-subjects according to your capacity for the task, in the administry of the country you inhabit. This claim is founded on the highest justice. It has been repeatedly affirmed by British and Indian statesmen and by the legislation of the Imperial Parliament. It is recognised by the Government of India as binding on its honour and consistent with all the aims of its policy ; ” and all such “highest justice” and all this “binding on honour” ended in this extraordinary despatch of 2nd May, 1878 ! It is the most dismal page in the whole melancholy affair about the Covenanted Service.
But the further misfortune is that since the despatch of 2nd May, 1878, the whole heart and soul of the Government is directed in the spirit of the despatch, and though they have not attempted to alter legislation, they have by persistence and devices most ingeniously carried out their own object, and made the Acts of 1833 and 1870, and the great Proclamations, mere shams and delusions. With trumpet tongues they have proclaimed to the world that the miserable “close service” was an extraordinary and generous concession, when in reality we are plundered of what we already possessed by the Act of 1870, and our political position is reduced to the condition of political pariahs.
I do not enter here into a discussion of the un-English and subtle procedure by which we are deprived of the so-called “statutory service,” which had secured for us no less than a complete and free admission into the whole Covenanted Civil Service, to the number which had been at the time considered for a beginning as a fair proportion of about one-sixth or one-fifth of the total number of this service.
There is one other important reason why I do not pursue any more the criticisms upon this despatch. The Secretary of State himself found it impossible to swallow it, summarily disposed of its fallacies, hollowness, brushed it aside, and insisted upon carrying out the Act of 1870.
Now before going further, I have to request the Commission to bear in mind that the Government of India had, by this despatch, most earnestly and laboriously committed themselves to a “close Native service,” and it will be seen that they bided their time and left no stone unturned, by any means whatever, to attain ultimately their object.
As I have said above, Lord Cranbrook, the then Secretary of State, would not swallow the preposterous despatch, and put down his foot against such openly violating all honourable and solemn pledges of the Sovereign and Acts of Parliament.
Lord Cranbrook in his despatch of 7th November, 1878, said in reply :—
“6. But your proposal of a close Native service with a limited class of high appointments attached to it, and your suggestions that the Covenanted Civil Service should no longer be open to Natives, involve an application to Parliament which would have no prospect of success, and which I certainly would not undertake. Your lordship has yourself observed that no scheme would have a chance of sanction which included legislation for the purpose of repealing the clause in the Act of 1833 above quoted, and the obstacles which would be presented against any attempt to exclude Natives from public competition for the Civil Service would be little less formidable.
“10. It is, therefore, quite competent to your lordship’s Government to appoint every year to the Civil Service of India any such number of Natives as may be determined upon, and the number of Covenanted civilians sent out from this country will have to be proportionately decreased. The appointments should in the first instance be only probationary, so as to give ample time for testing the merit and ability of the candidates.
“11. It appears to me that the advantages of such a simple scheme will be obvious :—
“ (i) It will undoubtedly be much more popular with the Natives, as it will place them on a footing of social equality with the Covenanted civilian ;
“ (ii) Inasmuch as it will exclude no civilian at present in India from any office which he has a moral claim to expect, it will avoid any clashing with the vested interests of the Civil Service ;
“ (iii) It will avoid the necessity of any enhancement of salaries of Uncovenanted officers which is now proposed, not because such enhancement is necessary, but from the necessity of creating a class of well-paid appointments to form sufficient prizes for a close Native service ;
“ And lastly, it pursues the same system of official training which has proved so eminently successful in India.”
Thus foiled in the monstrous attempt to inflict upon the Indians the most serious political disaster, the Government of India whined and lay low to wait their opportunity, and as compelled, and with bad grace, made the required rules one year after the despatch of 2nd May, 1878.
With their despatch of 1st May, 1879, the Government of India sent the rules, and explained in para. 8 of the despatch the proportion of Indians they proposed to select : “the proposed statutory rules, in brief, provide that a proportion not exceeding one-sixth of all the recruits added to the Civil Service in any one year shall be Natives selected in India by the local Governments.”
I give here the rules proposed :
“ No. 18.
“ Rules for the Appointment of Natives of India to offices ordinarily held by members of her Majesty’s Covenanted Civil Service in India.
“ In exercise of the power conferred by the Statute 33 Vict., cap. 3, section 6, the Governor-General in Council has been pleased to make the following rules, which have been sanctioned by the Secretary of State in Council with the concurrence of a majority of members present :—
“ I.—Each Local Government may nominate persons who are Natives of India within the meaning of the said Act, for employment in her Majesty’s Covenanted Civil Service in India within the territories subordinate to such Government. Such nominations shall be made not later than the first day of October in each year. No person shall be nominated for employment in the said service after he has attained the age of twenty-five years, except on grounds of merit and ability proved in the service of Government, or in the practice of a profession.
“ II.—Nominations under the foregoing rule shall, if approved by the Governor-General in Council, be provisionally sanctioned by him. The total number of nominations so sanctioned in any year shall not exceed one-fifth of the total number of recruits appointed by her Majesty’s Secretary of State to the said service in such year ; provided that the total number of such nominations sanctioned in each of the years 1879, 1880, and 1881 may exceed the said proportion by two. On sanction being given by the Governor-General in Council, the nominee shall be admitted on probation to employment in the said service ; such admission may be confirmed by the Governor-General in Council, but shall not be so confirmed until the Local Government shall have reported to the Governor-General in Council that the probationer has acquitted himself satisfactorily during a period of not less than two years from the date of his admission, and that he has, unless specially exempted by the Governor-General in Council, passed such examinations as may from time to time be prescribed by the Local Government subject to the approval of the Governor-General in Council. In case of persons admitted under these rules after they have attained the age of twenty-five years, the Governor-General in Council may confirm their admission without requiring them to serve for any period of probation.
“ III.—Persons admitted under these rules to employment in the said service shall not, without the previous sanction of the Governor-General in Council in each case, be appointed to any of the undermentioned offices, namely :—
“ Members of a Board of Revenue.
“ Secretaries to the several Governments and Administrations in India.
“ Chief Magisterial, or Chief Revenue, Officers of Districts.
“ Commissioners of Division, or of Revenue.
“ IV.—Persons admitted under these rules to employment in the said service shall ordinarily be appointed only to offices in the province wherein they were first admitted. But the Governor-General in Council may transfer from one province to another a person finally admitted to employment in the said service.
“ V.—Any person admitted under these rules may, with the previous sanction of the Governor-General in Council, be declared by the Local Government to be disqualified for further employment in the said service.”
Two comments suggest themselves with regard to these rules—when read with the light that the Government of India’s whole heart was in the “close Native service ”—and that, therefore, to carry out loyally the Act of 1870 was naturally against their grain.
At the very beginning they began to nibble at the Statute of 1870 and proposed in Rule III. not to put Natives on the same footing with Europeans with regard to all high offices. On this unworthy device I need not comment, as the Secretary of State himself struck out this Rule III. without much ceremony.
Now, whether intentionally or unintentionally, the rules had been so framed that had the Government of India sat down to devise the most effective means of bringing discredit and failure on the service under the Act of 1870, they could not have done better or worse than these rules. These Indian civilians were to be the colleagues of and to do the duties with the best educated and severely tested (educationally, physically, and morally) English youths. Particular care was taken not to prescribe any systematic compulsory rules for such high test and for obtaining recruits worthy of being included in such a highly trained service as the Covenanted Civil Service, of which these Indians were to be an integral part and in which service they were to be exactly on the same footing as English civilians. This was the crux and spirit of the whole matter; the rules simply made the matter one of patronage and back-door influence. It needs no stretch of the imagination to see that such a course could lead only to one result, as it has always done, viz., failure. It was absurd to expect that such Indian civilians could prove as successful and efficient as the English civilians so well prepared. This was the first covert blow given by the Government of India at the very birth of the operation of the Act of 1870, and unfortunately Lord Cranbrook did not see this ingenious device.
The Commission can hardly realise the intensity of the gratitude of the Indians to Sir Stafford Northcote for proposing, and the Duke of Argyll for passing, the clause in the Act of 1870, and not less intense was their gratitude to Lord Cranbrook and to Sir Erskine Perry who co-operated with him, for the determination with which Lord Cranbrook overcame all strenuous opposition and the blandishments of the Government of India of their own good will and justice to the Indians; and he compelled that Government to give effect to the Act of 1870.
The clause was at last given effect to, though with great reluctance and under compulsion, after ten long years. This is generally the case. For all Indian interests the officials always require long and most careful and most mature consideration, till by lapse of time the question dies. Under Lord Cranbrook this clause had better fortune, but only to end in utter and more bitter disappointment to the Indians, and to add one more dishonour to the British name. The first appointments under the clause, though after a delay of ten years, again infused a new life of loyalty and hope in the justice of the British people, throughout the length and breadth of India. It was a small instalment, but it was a practical instalment, and the first instalment of actual justice. And it was enough, for an ever disappointed and unjustly treated people, to rejoice, and more so for the future hope of more justice and of righteous rule, little foreseeing to what bitter disappointment they were to be doomed in the course of the next ten years ! The first appointments were made under the rules in 1880. Now we come to the next melancholy stage.
The immediate development of the compulsion on the Government of India to carry out the clause of 1870— coupled with the fear of the possible effect of the despatch of Sir Stafford Northcote of 8th February, 1868, to restrict employment of Europeans to those only who pass the examination here, and to insist upon the inherent rights of the Indians to all appointments—was to produce a sullenness of feeling and great vexation among the Anglo-Indian body generally (with, of course, honourable and noble exceptions).
I do not enter, as I have already said, upon the latter question of the Uncovenanted Service. I mention it here simply because it added to the anger of the Anglo-Indians against the noble policy of men like Sir Stafford Northcote. I confine myself to the said story about the admission of Indians in the Covenanted Civil Service.
Well, the so-called “statutory” service was launched in 1880. It was called by a distinctive name “statutory” as if the whole Covenanted Service was not also a “statutory” service, and as if the clause of 1870 was not simply for full admission into the whole Covenanted Service. But what is in a name ? The Government of India knew the value of creating and giving a distinct name to the service so that they may with greater ease kill it as a separate service ; and at last, kill it they did. The Anglo-Indians, official and non-official, were full charged with sullenness and anger, and with the spark of the “Ilbert Bill” the conflagration burst out.
Here I may point out how shrewdly Lord Salisbury, while fully approving the clause of 1870, had prophesied the coming storm. On the debate on the clause in 1870, Lord Salisbury had said :—
“Another most important matter is the admission of Natives to employments under the Government of India. I think the plan of the noble duke contained in this Bill is, I believe, the most satisfactory solution of a very difficult question.” And after so fully accepting the clause, he said : “One of the most serious dangers you have to guard against is the possibility of jealousy arising from the introduction of Natives into the service.”
Owing to this jealousy ten years elapsed before any action was taken on the Act of 1870, and that even under compulsion by Lord Cranbrook. Before three years after this effect was given to the clause, Lord Salisbury’s prophecy was fulfilled. Explosion burst out over the Ilbert Bill.
I cannot enter here into the various phases of the excitement on that occasion, the bitter war that raged for some time against Indian interests. I content myself with some extracts from the expression of Lord Hartington (the Duke of Devonshire) upon the subject. It clearly proves the action of the jealousy of the Anglo-Indians. Lord Hartington said (speech, House of Commons, August 23, 1883) :—
“It may by some be thought sufficient to say, that the Anglo-Indian, whatever may be his merits, and no doubt they are great, is not a person who is distinguished by an exceptionally calm judgment.”
Hansard, Vol. 283, p. 1818. August 23rd, 1883.
“I could quote passages in letters in the Indian papers in which it is admitted that the agitation was directed against the policy of the Home Government in providing appointments for Native civilians while there are many Europeans without appointments. . . . . I believe that the cause of the prevalent excitement is to be found, not in this measure, but in the general course of policy that has been pursued both by this Government and the late Government. It has been the policy of Governments for some years past to impress upon the Government of India the desirability of obtaining the assistance of the Native population as far as possible in the government of that country. Over and over again that policy has been inculcated from home. In 1879 a resolution was passed which limited appointments of the value of Rs. 200 a month to officers of the army and to Natives. That restriction has been rigidly enforced, and has met with all kinds of opposition from non-official classes of Europeans, who think that all the appointments must be reserved for them. The same spirit was shown when it was determined that admission to the Engineering College at Roorki should be confined to Natives. . . . . Agitation of the same character has been seen before when there was just as little foundation for it. Lord Macaulay, Lord Canning, and other Anglo-Indian statesmen experienced the same kind of opposition from Anglo-Indians; but all these reproaches have recoiled, not against the statesmen with regard to whom they were uttered, but against the persons uttering them themselves. . . . .
“There is a further reason, in my opinion, why this policy should be adopted, and that is that it is not wise to educate the people of India, to introduce among them your civilisation and your progress and your literature, and at the same time to tell them they shall never have any chance of taking any part or share in the administration of the affairs of their country, except by their getting rid in the first instance of their Europeans rulers. Surely it would not be wise to tell a patriotic Native of India that. . . . .
“Whatever difference of opinion there may be, there can, in my opinion, be very little doubt that India is insufficiently governed at the present time. I believe there are many districts in India in which the number of officials is altogether insufficient, and that is owing to the fact that the Indian revenue would not bear the strain if a sufficient number of Europeans were appointed. The Government of India cannot afford to spend more than they do in the administration of the country, and if the country is to be better governed that can only be done by the employment of the best and most intelligent of the Natives in the service.”
It was on this occasion that Lord Salisbury made the confession that all the pledges, proclamations, and Acts to which Lord Northbrook had referred was all “political hypocrisy.” The reasons which Lord Salisbury assigned were not accurate, but I cannot strike off into a new controversy now. It is enough for me to say that, as I have already said, I protest against placing this “hypocrisy” at the door of the people, Parliament, and Sovereign of this country. It lies on the head of the servants, the executives in both countries. It is they who would ruin the Empire by their “hypocrisy” and selfishness.
At last, however, the agitation of the Ilbert Bill subsided. The eruption of the volcano of the Anglo-Indian hearts stopped, but the anger and vexation continued boiling within as the cause of the explosion still remained. And the Government of India were biding their time to carry out that most un-English scheme of the despatch of 2nd May, 1879, to create a pariah lazaretto to consign these pariah thereto.
Owing to the persistence of Lord Cranbrook the appointments under the Act of 1870 had begun in 1880, and continued to be made, i.e., about six or seven Indians continued to be admitted in the Covenanted Civil Service. The main cause of the explosion having continued, and the Government of India having set its heart upon its own scheme, a new departure and development now arose. The question at the bottom was how to knock the “statutory service” on the head, and put down effectively the cry for simultaneous examinations. The explosion under the excuse of the Ilbert Bill did not effect that object, and so, according to Lord Lytton’s confession of the general conduct of the Executive, something else should be done.
We now enter upon the next stage of this sad story. I shall place some facts and any fair-minded Englishman will be able to draw his own conclusions. Before I do so certain preliminary explanation is necessary.
In India, when the authorities are decided upon certain views which are not likely to be readily accepted by the public, a Commission or Committee comes into existence. The members are mostly officials or ex-officials—English or Indians. Some non-officials, English or Indians or both, are sometimes thrown in, selected by the Government itself. It is a well understood thing that in all matters officials are bound always to take and support the Government views. The ex-officials are understood to be bound by gratitude to do the same. If anyone takes an independent line, either in a Commission or Committee, or in his own official capacity, and displeases the Government, I cannot undertake to say with instances what happens.
Perhaps some Anglo-Indians themselves may feel the sense of duty to supply some instances from their own experience. Almost by accident an instance has just come back before me in the Champion, of Bombay, and which gives the incident almost in the author’s (Mr. Robert H. Elliot) words : “Mr. Geddes came before the Finance Committee (1871-74), and that the members thought it well worth examining him is evidenced by the fact that he was examined at very great length. Here was a chance for Duff : he thought he would do a very clever thing, and as Mr. Geddes had introduced into his financial pamphlet some views of rather a novel description, and had, besides, made use of some rather out-of-the-way illustrations, this gave a good opportunity for putting questions in such a way as was calculated to cast ridicule on Mr. Geddes, and depreciate the value of the important points he had brought out. But this was far from being all. It was intimated pretty plainly to Mr. Geddes that his opinions ought to be in harmony with the Government he served, and here Mr. Geddes said that he certainly ought to be in harmony with the Government if there was any spirit of harmony in it. Mr. Geddes was clearly not to be put down, and Duff thought he would try something more severe. ‘You hold an appointment in the Government, do you not ?’ ‘Yes,’ said Mr. Geddes. ‘And do you expect to return to that post ?’ asked Duff. ‘Now, my dear John,’ continues the author, ‘you will not find that question in the report, for the simple reason that it was ordered to be expunged.’” Would some Anglo-Indian kindly give us some information of what afterwards became of Mr. Geddes ? I would not trouble the Commission with my own treatment before the same Committee, which was anything but fair, because, like Mr. Geddes, I had something novel to say. I would only add that an important and pointed evidence of Lord Lawrence, on the wretchedness and extreme poverty of India, was also suppressed in the Report.
The officials have therefore to bear in mind to be in harmony with Government or think of their posts—and I suppose the ex-officials have also to bear in mind that there is such a thing as pension.
Here is one more instance. When Mr. Hyndman published his “Bankruptcy of India,” Mr. Caird at once wrote to the Times contradicting him. The India Office soon after sent him to preside over the Famine Commission. He, though at first much prejudiced by Anglo-Indian views, and going to bless the Government, returned cursing. He made a report on the condition of India, and that being contrary to official views, O ! how Government laboured to discredit him !
Lastly, Commissions or Committees report what they like. If they are in the expected harmony with Government, all is well. But anything which Government does not want or is contrary to its views is brushed aside. Reports of Commissions must be in harmony with the views of the Government. If not, so much the worse for the Commissioners; and this is what has actually happened with the Public Service Commission, which I am now going to touch upon as the next stage in this sad history of the fate of Indians for services in their own country.
When I came here in 1886, I paid a visit to Lord Kimberley, the Secretary of State for India. I had been favoured with more than an hour’s conversation, mainly on the two topics of “statutory service” and simultaneous examinations, and I found him a determined, decided opponent to both, and completely, to our misfortune, saturated with Anglo-Indian views—not seeming to realise at all the Indian side. He urged to me all the Anglo-Indian stock arguments, and I saw what he was really aiming at—the very thing which Lord Cranbrook had summarily rejected—the scheme of the Government of India of the despatch of 2nd May, 1878, the close service.
From that interview I saw clearly what the “Public Service Commission” was for—that the abolition of the “statutory” service, the suppression of the cry for simultaneous examinations, and the adoption of the scheme of 2nd May, 1878, were determined, foregone conclusions.
Soon after my conversation with Lord Kimberley, I happened to be on the same boat with Sir Charles Turner on my way to Bombay. Sir Charles Turner was going out by appointment by Lord Kimberley to join the Public Service Commission. I at once prepared a short memorandum, and gave it to him. Afterwards, in the course of the conversation, he told me that he had certain instructions from Lord Kimberley. Sir Charles Turner, of course, could not tell me, whatever they may have been. But I could not help forming my own conclusions from what I had myself learnt from Lord Kimberley himself in my conversation with him. Sir Charles Aitchison was the President of the Commission, and he, as Lieutenant-Governor of the Punjab, made a representation to the Commission, in which he expressed his clear opposition to the simultaneous examinations. About the “statutory” service he had already most strongly objected to, two years before the appointment of the Commission, in a very inaccurate and hasty argument and on very imperfect information. In a country like India, governed under a despotism, where, under present circumstances, service under and favour of Government is to many the all in all, what effect must the declaration of the head of the province, and the well-known decided views of the Government itself, produce upon the invited witnesses—not only official, but non-official also—can hardly be realised by Englishmen, who have their government in their own hands.
The third important member’s—Sir Charles Crossthwaite —view, as I have already indicated, seemed the anxiety about “our boys.”
There were among the members of the Commission—
- 8 European officials,
- 1 Indian official,
- 3 Indian ex-officials,
- 1 Non-official European, the General Secretary of the Behar Indigo Planters’ Association. It would be worth while to know what share the planters had taken in the Ilbert Bill agitation.
- 1 Eurasian,
- 2 Indian non-officials, one of whom, I think, never attended the Commission till it met for Report.
Mr. Kazi Shahabu-din, before he joined the Commission, distinctly told me that he was dead against both questions, “statutory” and simultaneous. It was all very good, he said to me, to talk of eternal principles and justice and all that, but he was determined not to allow the Hindus to advance. The views of Sir Syad Ahmad Khan were no secret as being against simultaneous examinations and statutory service. I am informed that Mr. Nuhlkar and Mr. Mudliar were sorry for their action in joining in the Report, and Mr. Romesh Chandra Mitra has, I think, expressed some repudiation of his connexion with the Report of the Commission. The Rájá of Bhinga only joined the Commission at the Report.
Our misfortune was, as I saw at that time, the three Hindu members did not, I think, fully realise how a death blow was being struck at the future political and administrative advance and aspirations of the Indians ; and how, by an insidious and subtle stroke all pledges and Acts of Parliament, and Proclamations—the very breath of our political life—the hope and anchor of our aspirations and advance were being undermined and swept away. I have also already pointed out the determination of the Government of India since their letter of 2nd May, 1878, not only to stop further advance, but even to take away what they, the Indians, already had.
I was a witness before this Commission. I fully expected that as I was considered one of the chief complainants in these matters, I would be severely examined and turned inside out. But the Commission, to my surprise, carried on with me more of an academical debate than a serious practical examination, and seemed wishful to get rid of me quickly, so much so, that I was forced to request that a Memorandum which I had placed before them should be added to my evidence on several points.
I may here explain that simultaneous examinations was by far the most important matter, and, if granted, would have dispensed with the necessity of the “statutory” service. The chief fight was for simultaneous examinations.
First, as far as the “statutory” service is concerned, here is the extraordinary result. In the instructions, the object of the Commission was stated, “broadly speaking,” “to devise a scheme which may reasonably be hoped to possess the necessary elements of finality, and to do full justice to the claims of the Natives of India to higher and more extensive employment in the public service”; and in this the Governor-General in Council fully and cordially agreed.
This was the promise, and what is the performance? The admission of one-sixth Indians into the Covenanted Service we already possessed by law—and in operation. We were already eligible to all Uncovenanted Services. Full justice, and still higher and more extensive employment were promised—and what did we actually get? We were deprived of what we already by law (of 1870) possessed; and instead of giving us “full justice” it deprived us of all our hopes and aspirations to be admitted to an equality of employment with British officials; and we were coolly, mercilessly, despotically, and illegally consigned to a small pariah service, open to Europeans also—which had been already schemed and firmly determined upon ten years before in the despatch of 2nd May, 1878—in utter and dishonourable violation of the Acts of 1833 and 1870, and three gracious Proclamations. This is the way in which the Public Service Commission has carried out its object to devise a scheme to possess elements of finality and to do full justice to the claims of the Natives to higher and more extensive employment in the public service.
Now, with regard to simultaneous examinations, the conduct of the Public Service Commission seems to be still more extraordinary. Why they actually reported as far as I can see, in opposition to the weight of evidence, I cannot understand. Mr. William Digby has analysed the evidence in a letter to Lord Cross, of 8th May, 1889, and I append that part of his letter. I asked the Secretary of State to inform me whether Mr. Digby’s analysis was correct or not, but the information was not given me.
There is again a curious coincidence between the action of Lord Lytton and Lord Dufferin which I may intervene here.
Of Lord Lytton I have already mentioned about the contrast between his speech at the Delhi Durbar in January, 1877, and his action in the despatch of 2nd May, 1878.
On 4th October, 1886, was started the Public Service Commission, and in the beginning of the very next year, 1887, on the occasion of the Jubilee, Lord Dufferin said in his Jubilee speech :—
“Wide and broad, indeed, are the new fields in which the Government of India is called upon to labour, but no longer as aforetime need it labour alone. Within the period we are reviewing education has done its work, and we are surrounded on all sides by Native gentlemen of great attainments and intelligence, from whose hearty, loyal, and honest co-operation we may hope to derive the greatest benefit. In fact, to an administration so peculiarly situated as ours, their advice, assistance, and solidarity are essential to the successful exercise of its functions. Nor do I regard with any other feelings than those of approval and good-will their natural ambition to be more extensively associated with their English rulers in the administration of their own domestic affairs.” At the same time the Empress of India thus emphasises her great Proclamation of 1858 :—
“It had always been, and will always be, her earnest desire to maintain unswervingly the principles laid down in the Proclamation published on her assumption of the direct control of the Government of India.”
And these two declarations of hope and justice came to what end? Within two years, as I have already said, Lord Cross, with a ruthless hand, snatched away from us the small instalment of justice which Sir S. Northcote had done to us, consigned us to a small “pariah service,” and destroyed virtually all our charters and aspirations.
I now come to the last dark section of this sad chapter, which also shows that, to our misfortune, we have had nothing but bitter disappointments—since 1833—nothing but “subterfuges” and “political hypocrisy” up to the present day.
Propose anything for the benefit of Europeans and it is done at once. The Royal Engineering College at Coopers Hill and the Exchange compensation allowance are two notorious instances, the latter especially heartless and despotic. The Government of India has distinctly admitted that the compensation is illegal. It knew also that it would be a heartless act towards the poverty stricken people of India. But of course, when European interests are concerned, legality and heart go to the winds; despotism and force are the only law and argument. Here is another curious incident connected both with examinations and Europeans.
As I have already placed before the Commission my papers on the entire exclusion of Indians from military and naval examinations, either here or in India, I will not say anything more. The curious incident is this :—
The War Office would not admit Indians to examinations even in this country, and on no account simultaneously in India. But they allowed Europeans to be examined directly in India. St. George College, Massoori, examined its boys. A boy named Roderick O’Connor qualified for Sandhurst from the college in 1893. Two boys named Herbert Roddy and Edwin Roddy had also passed from that college.
On 2nd June, 1893, the House of Commons passed the resolution to have simultaneous examinations in England and India for all the services for which the examinations are at present held in England alone.1 Had such a Resolution been passed for any other department of State it would have never dared to offer resistance to it. But with unfortunate India the case is quite different.
The Resolution of 2nd June, 1893, having been carried, the Under-Secretary of State for India (Mr. Russell) said (Hansard, vol. 17, p. 1035): “It may be in the recollection of the House that in my official capacity it was my duty earlier in the Session to oppose a Resolution in favour of simultaneous examinations. But the House of Commons thought differently from the Government. That once done I need hardly say that there is no disposition on the part of the Secretary of State for India or myself to thwart or defeat the effect of the vote of the House of Commons on that Resolution.
“We have consulted the Government of India, and have asked them as to the way in which the resolution of the House can best be carried out. It is a matter too important to be carried out without the advice of the Indian Government, and at present impossible to state explicitly what will be done.” Now the Commission will observe that the Government of India was to be consulted as to the way in which the Resolution was to be best carried out, and not as to whether it was to be carried out or not nor to thwart or defeat it. What did the Prime Minister (Mr. Gladstone) say :—
“The question is a very important one, and has received the careful consideration of Government. They have determined that the Resolution of the House should be referred to the Government of India without delay, and that there should be a prompt and careful examination of the subject by that Government, who are instructed to say in what mode in their opinion, and under what conditions and limitations the Resolution could be carried into effect.” It must be observed again that the Government of India were to be instructed to say by what mode the Resolution could be carried into effect.
After such declarations by two important officials what did the Secretary of State do ?
Did he loyally confine himself to these declarations ? We know that Lord Kimberley (who was then the Secretary of State) was dead against simultaneous examinations. He knew full well that the Government of India was well known to the world to be as dead against any such interest of the Indians. Sir James Peile in his minute even said as much. And yet in a very clever way the Indian Office adds a sentence to its despatch, virtually telling the Government of India to resist altogether.
The last sentence added to the despatch was :—
“3. I will only point out that it is indispensable that an adequate number of the members of the Civil Service shall always be Europeans and that no scheme would be admissible which does not fulfil that essential condition.”
And further, that there should remain no doubt of the real intention of this sentence, six members of the Council wrote vehement minutes emphatically indicating that the Government of India should resist—not obey the instruction as to what mode should be adopted to carry out the Resolution. And thus, knowing full well what the Government of India’s views were, knowing also that the Resolution was passed notwithstanding the opposition of the Government; knowing also that Mr. Russell had distinctly told the House of the acceptance by the Government of what the House decided, and promising on behalf of the Secretary of State, as well as himself, not to thwart or defeat the Resolution, Lord Kimberley sent the Indian lamb back to the Government wolf, as if the Resolution of the House was not of the slightest consequence, and the Governments here and in India were supreme and above the House of Commons. They had always done this for two-thirds of a century to every Act or Resolution of Parliament, or the Sovereign’s Proclamations.
With such open suggestion and encouragement from the Secretary of State and his councillors, and with their own firm determination not to allow the advancement of the Natives by simultaneous examination — even having only lately snatched away from the hands of the Indians the little instalment of justice that was made by Sir Stafford Northcote and the Duke of Argyll, and was approved by Lord Salisbury—what could be expected in reply to such a despatch. Of course, the Government of India resisted with a will, tooth and nail, as they had always done.
At first, the Government of Madras was one for justice. And then, in the vicious circle in which all Indian interests are usually cleverly entangled, the Government here made that very resistance of the Indian Government a subterfuge and excuse for itself—that as the Government of India refuses they could not carry out the resolution! And the House of Commons had, as usual on Indian matters, one more disregard and insult.
And thus was one more disappointment—the bitterest of all the 64 years of disappointments the people of India have suffered. And yet there are men who raise up their hands in wonder that there should be any dissatisfaction among the Indians, when they themselves are the very creators of this discontent and great suffering.
I have referred to Lord Kimberley’s actions, which showed how he was actuated from the very beginning. Now even before the despatch was sent to India, Lord Kimberley himself showed his full hand and let the Government of India know, by anticipation, his entire resistance to the Resolution within nine days of the passing of the Resolution on 2nd June, 1893, and ten days before the despatch was sent to India. He said (dinner to Lord Roberts by the Lord Mayor—Times, 13th June, 1893) :—
“There is one point upon which I imagine, whatever may be our party politics in this country, we are all united; that we are resolutely determined to maintain our supremacy over our Indian Empire. That I conceive is a matter about which we have only one opinion, and let me tell you that that supremacy rests upon three distinct bases. One of those bases, and a very important one, is the loyalty and good-will of the Native Princes and population over whom we rule. Next, and not less important, is the maintenance of our European Civil Service, upon which rests the foundation of our administration in India. . . . . Last, not because it is the least, but because I wish to give it the greatest prominence, we rest also upon the magnificent European force which we maintain in that country, and the splendid army of Native auxiliaries by which that force is supported. . . . . Let us firmly and calmly maintain our position in that country; let us be thoroughly armed as to our frontier defences, and then I believe we may trust to the old vigour of the people of this country, come what may, to support our supremacy in that great Empire.”
Now, if it was as he said, there was only one opinion and such resolute determination, why on earth was all the fuss and expense of a Public Service Commission made? If European service was a resolute determination, was it not strange to have the subject of simultaneous examinations taken up at all by the Commission on grounds of reason, when it was a resolute, despotic, foregone conclusion? And why was the statutory service disturbed when it had been settled by Northcote, Argyll, and Salisbury and Parliament as a solution of compromise?
Now, we must see a little further what Lord Kimberley’s speech means. It says, “One of those bases, and a very important one, is the loyalty and good-will of the Native Princes and population over whom we rule.” Now, the authorities both in England and India do everything possible to destroy that very loyalty and good will, or, as it is often called, contentment, which these authorities profess to depend upon. I cannot say anything here about the Native Princes. But what about the good-will of the Native population! Is it productive of loyalty and good-will (will a Briton be similarly content) to tell the Indians, “you will be kept down with the iron heel upon your neck of European services—military and civil—in order to maintain our power over you, to defend ourselves against Russian invasion, and thereby maintain our position in Europe, to increase our territory in the East, and to violate all our most solemn pledges. And all this at your cost, and mostly with your blood, just as the Empire itself has been built up. We have the power and for our benefit; and you put your Parliament and your Proclamations into your pocket.” Queer way of producing contentment and loyalty!
This is a strange superiority over the despotic old Indian system! It is seldom a matter of the slightest thought to our authorities as to who should pay for these European services and for the outside wars, and what the consequences are of the “bleeding.”
In connexion with India generally, the Englishman (with some noble exceptions) deteriorates from a lover of liberty to a lover of despotism, without the slightest regard as to how the Indians are affected and bled. He suddenly becomes a superior, infallible being, and demands that what he does is right, and should never be questioned. (Mr. Gladstone truly called the “argument and law of force” as the law and argument of the present Anglo-Indian rule.) “Our boys” is his interest. The “boys” of others may go to the dogs, perish or be degraded for what he cares.
This is what the Anglo-Indian spirit of power, selfishness, and despotism (strange products of the highest civilisation) speaks through the mouth of the heads. How this spirit, if continued, will recoil on this country itself, there cannot be for Englishman themselves much difficulty to understand.
My remarks about Lord Kimberley are made with much pain. He is one of the best Englishmen I have ever met with. But our misfortune is this. Secretaries of State (with few exceptions) being not much conversant with or students of the true Indian affairs, place themselves in the hands of Anglo-Indians. If, fortunately, one turns out capable of understanding the just claim of the Indians and does something, some successor under the everlasting influence of permanent officials subverts the justice done, and the Indian interests perish with all their dire consequences. A Sir Stafford Northcote gives, a Lord Cross snatches away.
It will be seen that the very claim now put forward by the Indian authorities of having done a great favour by the “Provincial Service” is misleading and not justified. On the contrary we are deprived of what we already possessed by an Act of Parliament (1870) of admission into the full Covenanted Civil Service to the extent of about 180 or 200 appointments, while what is given to us with much trumpeting is a miserable “close pariah service” of about 95 Covenanted specific appointments, and that even not confined to Indians, but open to Europeans also, and so devised that no regular admission (as far as I know) on some organised system and tests is adopted, and I understand it to be said that some twenty or thirty years will elapse before the scheme will come into some regular operation. Can there be a greater blow and injustice to the Indians and a greater discredit to the authorities? But what is worst of all is that insidious efforts are made to undermine and destroy all our charters of equal British citizenship with the people of this country.
Lord Kimberley’s speech in support of the present system is the best justification of what Macaulay had said that “the heaviest of all yokes is the yoke of the stranger.” If this speech meant anything, it meant that the British yoke over India should be as heavy a foreign yoke as could be made. For he does not say a word that if England employs the European Agency for its own sake he should think it just that England should pay for it, or, at least, the greater portion or half of it. Any such act of justice does not seem to occur to the Anglo-Indian “Masters.” India alone must bleed for whatever the Master wills. And Britain cares not as it has nothing to pay. Worse still, the masters do not seem to care what deterioration of character and capacity is caused to the Indians.
As to the fitness and integrity of the Indians in any kind of situation—military or civil—there is now no room for controversy, even though they have not had a fair trial they have shown integrity, pluck, industry, courage and culture, to a degree of which the British people may well be proud, as being the authors of it. I have already touched upon the point of fitness in one of the statements.
About loyalty. In the despatch of 8th June, 1880, the Government of India itself said, “To the minds of at least the educated among the people of India—and the number is rapidly increasing—any idea of the subversion of British power is abhorrent from the consciousness that it must result in the wildest anarchy and confusion.”
The fact is that because India asks and hopes for British rule on British principles, and not un-British rule on un-British principles of pure despotism aggravated by the worst evils of a foreign domination, that the educated are devotedly loyal, and regard their efforts for this purpose as their highest and best patriotism. Nothing can be more natural and sensible.
SUMMARY.
In 1833 a noble clause was passed by Parliament—everything that the Indians could desire. Had the Executives loyally and faithfully carried out that clause, India would have been in the course of more than sixty years a prosperous and contented and deeply loyal country, and a strength and a benefit to the British Empire to an extent hardly to be conceived or realised at present, when, by an opposite course, India is afflicted with all the horrors and misery to which humanity can possibly be exposed. After 1833, twenty years passed but nothing done. Fresh efforts were made in Parliament to put the Indians on the same footing as British subjects, by simultaneous examinations in this country and India. Stanley, Bright, Rich and others protested to no purpose ; the violation of the Act of 1833 continued.
Then came the great and glorious Proclamation of the Queen in 1858, and a new bright hope to the Indians ; but not fulfilled up to the present day. In 1860 a Committee of five members of the Council of the Secretary of State pointed out the dishonour of the British name, and reported that simultaneous examinations were the best method to do justice to the Act of 1833—to no purpose ; the Report was suppressed and the public knew nothing about it. In 1867 the East India Association petitioned for the admission into the Covenanted Civil Service of a small proportion of Indians. Sir Stafford Northcote admitted the justice of the prayer, and proposed a clause to give a partial fulfilment of the Act of 1833. The Duke of Argyll passed it. Lord Salisbury approved of it, but pointed out how the jealousy of the Anglo-Indians would wreck it—a prophecy which was not long to be fulfilled.
The Government of India resisted tooth and nail, and made some outrageous proposals in the despatch of 2nd May, 1878. It was then that Lord Lytton, in a minute, admitted the ignoble policy of subterfuges and dishonour upon which the Executives had all along acted since 1833.
A strong and justly inclined Secretary (Lord Cranbrook) persisted, brushed aside all resistance and plausibilities, and compelled the Government of India to give effect to the clause. The Government of India, with bad grace and very reluctantly, made the rules—cleverly drawn up to throw discredit upon the service—the worst part was rejected by Lord Cranbrook ; but an insidious device remained, and the appointments were begun to be made. The Anglo-Indians boiled with rage, and the explosion on the Ilbert Bill was the open declaration of war. Lord Salisbury on that occasion confessed that the conduct of the Executive all along was merely “ political hypocrisy.”
The agitation subsided, but the appointments having remained to be continued the boiling under the crater continued, and, instead of exploding, the Government resorted to other devices and gained their settled object with a vengeance —the report of the Public Service Commission confirmed the foregone conclusions against the Statutory Service and simultaneous examinations.
The statutory service of full eligibility and of about 200 employments in the course of thirty years in the whole Covenanted Service was abolished, and the wretched scheme of May 2nd, 1878, established instead.
The whole position has been thrown back worse than it ever was before.
A Conservative (Sir Stafford Northcote) proposed, and a Liberal (Duke of Argyll) passed the Act of 1870 to do some justice. A Conservative (Lord Cranbrook) insisted upon carrying it out. A Liberal (Lord Kimberley) began to undermine it, and another Conservative (Lord Cross) gave it the death blow—though, to the humiliation of the House of Commons, the Act remains on the Statute Book. What faith can the Indians have on any Act of Parliament? To-day something given, to-morrow snatched away; Acts and Resolutions of Parliament and Proclamations notwithstanding.
Once more Parliament did justice and passed the Resolution, in 1893, for simultaneous examinations, to share the same grievous fate as all its former enactments. And the Indian Executive thus stands proclaimed the supreme power over the heads of all—Parliament, People, and Sovereign.
The whole force and object of the two references to our Commission is to reply to Sir Henry Fowler’s most important challenge, and that reply mainly depends upon the consideration of the way in which the clauses in the Acts of 1833 and 1870 and the Proclamations are dealt with.
Sir Henry Fowler’s challenge is this: “The question I wish to consider is, whether that Government, with all its machinery as now existing in India, has, or has not, promoted the general prosperity of the people of India, and whether India is better or worse off by being a province of the British Crown ; that is the test.”
I may here give a few extracts as bearing upon the subject and its results. I am obliged to repeat a few that I have already cited in my previous statements.
Sir William Hunter has said : “You cannot work with imported labour as cheaply as you can with Native labour, and I regard the more extended employment of the Natives not only as an act of justice but as a financial necessity. . . . . I believe that it will be impossible to deny them a larger share in the administration. . . . . The appointments of a few Natives annually to the Covenanted Civil Service will not solve the problem. . . . . If we are to govern the Indian people efficiently and cheaply we must govern them by means of themselves and pay for the administration at the market rates of Native labour. . . . . Good work thus commenced has assumed such dimensions under the Queen s Government of India that it can no longer be carried on, or even supervised, by imported labour from England, except at a cost which India cannot sustain.”
“I do not believe that a people numbering one-sixth of the whole inhabitants of the globe, and whose aspirations have been nourished from their earliest youth on the strong food of English liberty, can be permanently denied a voice in the government of the country.”
Lord Salisbury has said : “But it would be a great evil if the result of our dominion was that the Natives of India who were capable of government should be absolutely and hopelessly excluded from such a career.”
Now that it is emphatically declared that all professions of equality of British citizenship were only so much hypocrisy —that India must be bled of its wealth, work, and wisdom, that it must exist only for the maintenance of British rule by its blood, its money, and its slavery—England and India are face to face, and England ought to declare what, in the name of civilisation, justice, honour, and all that is righteous England means to do for the future. The principles of the statesmen of 1833 were : “Be just and fear not ;” the principles of the present statesmen appear to be : “Fear and be unjust.” Let India know which of the two is to be her future fate. However mighty a Power may be, justice and righteousness are mightier far than all the mightiness of brute force. Macaulay has said : “Of all forms of tyranny I believe that the worst is that of a nation over a nation.” And he has also said : “The end of government is the happiness of the people.” Has the end of Indian government been such, or all a “terrible misery,” as Lord Salisbury has truly characterised it? Let the question be honestly answered.
The statesmen of 1833 accepted that “the righteous are as bold as a lion.” But the authorities seem to have always forgotten it or ignored it ; and political cowardice has been more before their eyes.
Lord Salisbury has said many more truths, but I have mentioned them before.
Mr. Gladstone has said :—
“It is the predominance of that moral force for which I heartily pray in the deliberations of this House, and the conduct of our whole public policy, for I am convinced that upon that predominance depends that which should be the first object of all our desires as it is of all our daily official prayers, namely, that union of heart and sentiment which constitutes the two bases of strength at home, and therefore both of strength and good fame throughout the civilised world."
Again : “There can be no more melancholy, and in the last result, no more degrading spectacle upon earth than the spectacle of oppression, or of wrong in whatever form, inflicted by the deliberate Act of a nation upon another nation. . . . .
“But on the other hand there can be no nobler spectacle than that which we think is now dawning upon us, the spectacle of a nation deliberately set on the removal of injustice, deliberately determined to break — not through terror, and not in haste, but under the sole influence of duty and honour—determined to break with whatever remains still existing of an evil tradition, and determined in that way at once to pay a debt of justice, and to consult by a bold, wise and good Act, its own interest and its own honour."
These extracts refer to Ireland. They apply with ten times the force to India.
With regard to India, he has fully admitted that there the law and argument of England was “the law and argument of force.” Lord Randolph Churchill realised the true position of the evil of foreign domination of England in India under the present system. He said :—
“The position of India in relation to taxation and the sources of the public revenues is very peculiar, not merely from the habits of the people, and their strong aversion to change, which is more specially exhibited to new forms of taxation, but likewise from the character of the government, which is in the hands of foreigners, who hold all the principal administrative offices and form so large a part of the Army. The impatience of the new taxation which will have to be borne wholly as a consequence of the foreign rule imposed on the country, and virtually to meet additions to charges arising outside of the country, would constitute a political danger, the real magnitude of which, it is to be feared, is not at all appreciated by persons who have no knowledge of or concern in the Government of India, but what those responsible for that Government have long regarded as of the most serious order.”
The East India Company, in their petition against change of government, said :—
“That your petitioners cannot contemplate without dismay the doctrine now widely promulgated that India should be administered with an especial view to the benefit of the English who reside there ; or that in its administration any advantage should be sought for her Majesty’s subjects of European birth, except that which they will necessarily derive from their superiority of intelligence, and from the increased prosperity of the people, the improvement of the productive resources of the country and the extension of commercial intercourse.”
The course, however, during the administration by the Crown, has been to regard the interests of Europeans as the most important and paramount, and generally every action is based upon that principle, with little concern or thought what that meant to the people of India at large.
Everything for the benefit of Indian interests is the romance, and everything for the benefit of the British and “cruel and crushing tribute” from Indians is the reality.
The edifice of the British rule rests at present upon the sandy foundation of Asiatic despotism, injustice, and all the evils of a foreign domination, as some of the best English statesmen have frequently declared ; and the more this edifice is made heavier by additions to these evils, as is continuously being done, by violation of pledges and exclusion of Indians from serving in their own country, with all its natural evil consequences, the greater, the more devastating and complete, I am grieved to foresee, will be the ultimate crash.
The question of remedy I have already dealt with in one of my representations to the Commission.
In a letter in the Times of September 28 last, Bishop Tugwell quotes an extract from the Times with regard to the African races. How much more forcibly does it apply to India, to whom the people of England mostly owe the formation and maintenance of the British Indian Empire, and who for their reward receive “terrible misery” and “bleeding.”
The Times says :—
“The time has long passed away when we were content to justify our rule by the strong hand alone. We should no longer hold our great tropical possessions with an easy conscience did we not feel convinced that our tenure of them is for the advantage, not of ourselves only, but of the subject peoples.”
Can a fair-minded, honest Englishman say that he has this easy conscience with regard to India, after the wars, famine and pestilence which have been devastating that ill-fated country, after a British rule of a century and a half?
Macaulay has said, in 1833 :—
“ ‘ Propter vitam vivendi perdere causas ’ is a despicable policy either in individuals or States. In the present case such a policy would not only be despicable but absurd.”
After describing from Bernier the practice of miserable tyrants of poisoning a dreaded subject, he says :—
“That detestable artifice, more horrible than assassination itself, was worthy of those who employed it. It is no model for the English nation. We shall never consent to administer the pousta to a whole community — to stupefy and paralyse a great people—whom God has committed to our charge, for the wretched purpose of rendering them more amenable to our control.”
Lord Hartington said in 1883 :—
“It is not wise to educate the people of India, to introduce among them your civilisation and your progress and your literature, and at the same time to tell them they shall never have any chance of taking any part or share in the administration of the affairs of their country, except by their getting rid in the first instance of their European rulers. Surely it would not be wise to tell a patriotic Native of India that.”
This naturally suggests the question of the future of India with regard to Russia. This is rather a wide subject, and somewhat indirectly connected with this statement. But I may say here that there are, in my thinking, certain features in the Indian rule of great plausibility, which the Russians, by their emissaries, will urge upon the mind of the masses of the Indians, when they are in any spirit of discontent, with great effect against the English. Nor need I enter on the speculation whether Russia would be able to make a lodging in India. These are matters which every Englishman is bound to consider calmly. The English people and Parliament should not wait to consider them till it is too late. My whole fear is, that if the British people allow things to drift on in the present evil system, the disaster may come to both countries when it is too late to prevent or repair it.
My whole earnest anxiety is that righteous means may be adopted by which the connexion between the two countries may be strengthened with great blessings and benefits to both countries. I speak freely, because I feel strongly that it is a thousand pities that a connexion that can be made great and good to both countries is blindly being undermined and destroyed with detriment to both. My previous statements have clearly shown that. The whole question of the blessing or curse of the connexion of England and India upon both countries rests mainly upon the honourable and loyal fulfilment of the Act of 1833 and the Proclamation of 1858, or upon the dishonour of the non-fulfilment of them : “Righteousness alone will exalt a nation ;” “Injustice will bring down the mightiest to ruin.”
I conclude with my earnest hope and prayer that our Commission will pronounce clearly upon all the vital questions involved in their two references on which I have submitted my views.
One last word of agony. With the dire calamities with which we have been overwhelmed, and in the midst of the greatest jubilation in the world, in which we took our hearty share, in spite of those calamities, we have not, as far as I know, got the word of our greatest hope and consolation —a repetition of the most gracious Proclamation of 1858, of equality of British citizenship, which we received on the assumption of the Imperial title and on the Jubilee; nor of anything of its application.
Yours truly,
Dadabhai Naoroji.
APPENDIX.
Extract from Mr. William Digby’s letter of 8th May, 1889, to Lord Cross.
I.—SIMULTANEOUS EXAMINATIONS IN INDIA AND IN ENGLAND.
In asking for the examinations for the Covenanted Civil Service to be held simultaneously in India and in England, solely on the grounds of equal justice to the Indian and English subjects of the Queen-Empress, the people of India are simply taking up the position provided for them by the Special Committee of the India Office which sat and reported in 1860. That Committee recommended, as being only fair, the holding, “simultaneously, two examinations, one in England and one in India, both being, as far as practicable, identical in their nature.” They further recommended that “those who compete in both countries should be finally classified in one list, according to merit, by the Civil Service Commissioners.” “Were this inequality removed,” added the Committee, “we should no longer be exposed to the charge of keeping promise to the ear and breaking it to the hope.” The proposal for simultaneous examinations had its genesis in your lordship’s office, those who proposed it were English officials, and, in asking for its adoption, Indians are merely acting upon the sense of justice of Englishmen highly experienced in Indian affairs.1 It will be obvious, therefore, that such a claim as is put forward is compatible with perfect loyalty to the maintenance of the connexion between England and India. The Committee, as will be seen on reference to their Report, were not unanimous in all their conclusions, but on the point I have referred to there was perfect unanimity.
On the question of simultaneous examinations, the Public Service Commission reported, in brief, as follows : “That it is inexpedient to hold an examination in India for the Covenanted Civil Service simultaneously with the examination in London” (“Summary of Conclusions and Recommendations,” para. 128, p. 140). I refer in this letter to the summary rather than to the detailed statements in the Report, as I do not at present wish to contest each statement in paragraph 60. Should, however, such an examination become necessary, a criticism in detail of the observations made by the Commissioners cannot, in view of what follows, be less condemnatory than the remarks to be made upon the summary.
The recommendation of the Commissioners, my lord, on the question of simultaneous examinations is against the weight of evidence taken by them. An analysis of the opinions expressed by the witnesses and of the witnesses themselves reveals the most startling results. Evidently the Commission has not examined the evidence, or taken it into due consideration. There are, too, certain grave incidents in connexion with the manner in which this portion of the evidence was obtained, and the foregone conclusion to which at least one highly-placed member of the Commission had committed himself, as render it more than ever improbable that the Report of the Commission can be held to be deserving of your lordship’s confidence or commendation, and which wholly militate against legislation being undertaken to give the recommendations, or some of them, the force of law.
I will take the witnesses examined Presidency by Presidency and Province by Province, and show in what direction the balance of testimony lies.
| Total number of witnesses examined | — | — | 195 |
| For simultaneous examinations | — | 143 | |
| Against „ „ | — | 35 | |
| Majority for | 108 | — | |
| Neutral or doubtful | — | 17 | 195 |
| Total number of witnesses examined | — | — | 100 |
| For simultaneous examinations | — | 63 | |
| Against „ „ | — | 25 | |
| Majority for | 38 | — | |
| Neutral or doubtful | — | 12 | 100 |
| 3.—BOMBAY. | |||
| Total number of witnesses examined | — | — | 112 |
| For simultaneous examinations | — | 64 | |
| Against „ „ | — | 38 | |
| Majority for | 26 | — | |
| Neutral or doubtful | — | 10 | 112 |
| 4.—NORTH-WEST PROVINCES AND OUDH. | |||
| Total number of witnesses examined | — | — | 68 |
| For simultaneous examinations | — | 31 | |
| Against „ „ | — | 29 | |
| Majority for | 2 | — | |
| Neutral or doubtful | — | 8 | 68 |
| 5.—THE PUNJAB. | |||
| Total number of witnesses examined | — | — | 80 |
| For simultaneous examinations | — | 36 | |
| Against „ „ | — | 26 | |
| Majority for | 10 | — | |
| Neutral or doubtful | — | 18 | 80 |
| 6.—CENTRAL PROVINCES. | |||
| Total number of witnesses examined | — | — | 42 |
| For simultaneous examinations | — | 24 | |
| Against „ „ | — | 10 | |
| Majority for | 14 | — | |
| Neutral or doubtful | — | 8 | 42 |
| Province. | For. | Against. | Doubtful. |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Bengal | 143 | 35 | 17 |
| 2. Madras | 63 | 25 | 12 |
| 3. Bombay | 64 | 38 | 10 |
| 4. North-West Provinces and Oudh | 31 | 29 | 8 |
| 5. The Punjab | 36 | 26 | 18 |
| 6. Central Provinces | 24 | 10 | 8 |
| Totals | 361 | 163 | 73 |
Majority for . . . . 198, or 68·8 per cent. „ over Against and Doubtful, 125, or 60·4 „
Of the 361 in favour it may be remarked, 49 or 13·5 per cent. were Europeans not from any one part of the Empire, but from all parts of India.
In their Report the Commissioners have not published any statistical information of the kind given above. To obtain it the evidence of every witness, whether his evidence were oral or written, has been examined.
The case against the Report, however, is only imperfectly shown even in the statement submitted in the above tabulated particulars. A closer analysis reveals much of great interest and of the highest value. What is revealed increases one’s wonder that, in face of the evidence they took, and in view of the instructions they received, the Commissioners could have reported in the sense they adopted. An examination of the following figures will well repay any time bestowed upon them.
I.—BENGAL.
| Europeans. | Indians. | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Class of Witness. | For. | Ag. | Dbtfl. | For. | Ag. | Dbtfl. |
| 1. Covenanted Civilians | 6 | 14 | 2 | 4 | — | — |
| 2. Statutory ,, | — | — | — | 3 | — | 1 |
| 3. Uncovenanted Service: | ||||||
| a. Judicial and Executive | — | 2 | 1 | 22 | 5 | 1 |
| b. Educational Department | 3 | 3 | — | 9 | — | 2 |
| c. Others | — | 3 | — | 1 | 1 | 1 |
| 4. General Public: | ||||||
| a. Barristers, Vakils, & Solicitors | 1 | 2 | 1 | 39 | 1 | 1 |
| b. Zemindars | — | — | — | 20 | 1 | — |
| c. Merchants | — | — | 3 | 2 | — | — |
| d. Others | 1 | 2 | 2 | 8 | 1 | — |
| 5. English Newspapers | 2 | — | — | 5 | — | — |
| 6. Vernacular ,, | — | — | — | 10 | — | — |
| 7. Associations and Societies | — | — | — | 6 | — | — |
| 8. Secretary, Government of India, and High Court Judges | — | — | 2 | 1 | — | — |
| Totals | 13 | 26 | 11 | 130 | 9 | 6 |
An examination in detail of the facts summarised above shows that
- (1) among Europeans the Hon. H. J. Reynolds, C.S.I., Mr. H. J. S. Cotton, Mr. H. M. Kisch, Mr. H. Beveridge, and Mr. C. B. Garret, all civilians of high position, Mr. A. O. Hume, C.B., a retired official of great experience, long service, and almost unequalled knowledge of the country and the people, and
- (2) Sir A. W. Croft, K.C.I.E., Director of Public Instruction for Bengal, and Mr. C. H. Tawney, M.A., Principal of the Presidency College, Calcutta, among Educationalists,
were in favour of simultaneous examinations. Of the Indian figures it may be stated that in Class 3a against the proposal two of the witnesses were Mahomedans, in Class 4a the solitary individual was a Mahomedan, and in Class 4d the same thing is true, with this difference, that the witness was a gentleman holding a high position in a Native Indian State, being Secretary to the Council of his Highness the Nizam of Hyderabad. As much is made of Mahomedan opposition to simultaneous examinations, it may be added here that the principal Moslem officials of Hyderabad were examined—one at Calcutta, one at Madras, others at Bombay. I think it is due that I should state in detail the Indian witnesses in Bengal who gave evidence in favour of simultaneous examinations : a scrutiny of their names and of the positions they hold will unmistakably show that the leading men of wealth, attainments and position—alike in the professions, in commerce and in society, are heartily in favour of their countrymen being permitted, by a first examination in India, to compete for the highest places in the gift of the Government of India. They, who have most to lose, are not afraid of ill consequences following. Nearly all that is eminent, learned, energetic, and loyal in Bengal, is to be found represented in the following list. A more remarkable consensus of opinion than is afforded in this list could not be obtained in regard to any matter of high importance in any country. I lay the more stress upon the testimony of Bengal for this, probably sufficient, reason. In the Lower Provinces alone in the Empire is there, on any large scale, private property in land. Lord Cornwallis’s Permanent Settlement and the creation of a large body of Zemindars have, in Bengal, called a wealthy class into existence. If anywhere in India, it is in Bengal that men are most interested in the maintenance of a strong, efficient, and stable administration. Elsewhere in the Empire the ryotwari system of land tenure does not admit of the growth, on any extensive scale, of a wealthy and cultured class connected with the land. Yet it is in Bengal, where, as I have already said, men have most to lose, that there is the heartiest support, from Hindus and Mahomedans alike, of the proposal for holding simultaneous examinations in England and in India. To anyone acquainted with the personnel of Indian Society in Bengal, the names of the Maharaja Jotendro Mohun Tagore, K.C.S.I., the Maharaja of Durbhunga, Babu Joykissen Mukerji, Kumar Nil Krishna Deb, Nawab Wilayat Ali Khan Bahadur, among Zemindars ; Rajah Durga Churn Laha among Merchants, himself the Prince of Indian Merchants ; the Hon. C. M. Ghose, High Court, Calcutta, the Hon. Dr. Mohendro Lal Sircar, C.I.E., Nawab Abdul Latif Bahadur, C.I.E. (whose weight and influence with a large section of his community it is impossible to over-rate), among Judicial officers ; the thirty-nine barristers, vakils, and solicitors mentioned in Class IVa., and the gentlemen whose names are given in all the other classes, will be held to represent the flower of wealth, culture, influence, and weighty good sense among seventy millions of people. Of one hundred and forty-four witnesses examined in Bengal—
- 129 were for Simultaneous Examinations,
- 9 ,, against,
- 6 ,, doubtful.
That the British Indian Association should have given evidence in favour of the change is, from the point of view of security, of great importance. Its action is as if the Carlton, the Junior Carlton, the St. Stephen’s and the Constitutional Clubs of London were to make a deliverance to the Government of the day on some important matter. Whatever might be said of such a deliverance it could not be called revolutionary. Considering that Bengal has a third of the whole of the inhabitants of British India within its borders, that Hindu witnesses were ten to one in favour, that nearly one half of Indian Mahomedans live in this Presidency and that of fourteen witnesses of this faith examined,
- 10 were for Simultaneous Examinations, and only
- 4 ,, against,
the testimony is of so remarkable and so weighty a character as to unprejudiced minds, I submit, to be irresistible. To scorn, or set aside on insufficient grounds, such a representation is to invite discontent.
Of Europeans who were examined in Bengal, it is true, there were forty-three against to fourteen in favour. It would be invidious for me to set names on either side against one another, but if this were permissible the force of experience and authority would clearly tell in favour of the smaller numbers. The list of Indians is as follows :—
BENGAL.
Indians in Favour of Simultaneous Examinations.
Class I.—Covenanted Civil Service.
| Con. No. | No. in Rept. | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 11 | Brojo Nath De, Esq., C.S., Joint Magistrate, Hughli. |
| 2 | 16 | K. G. Gupta, Esq., C.S., Barrister-at-Law, Joint Magistrate and Deputy Collector, Nuddeah. |
| 3 | 47 | B. L. Gupta, Esq., C.S., Officiating District and Session Judge, Furridpore. |
| 4 | 49 | Romesh Chunder Dutt, Esq., Joint Magistrate and Deputy Collector, Bakhergunje. |
| Total of Class I. | 4 | |
Class II.—The Statutory Civil Service.
| 1 | 45 | Bu. Ambica Churn, Sen., Assistant Magistrate and Collector, Shahabad. |
| 2 | 23s | Bu. Nunda Kumar Bose, Statutory Civil Service. |
| 3 | 28s | Bu. Surjya Kumar Agasti, Statutory Civil Service. |
| Total of Class II. | 3 | |
Class IIIa.—Uncovenanted Service, Judicial and Executive.
| 1 | 6 | Bu. Brojendro Kumar Seal, B.L., District Judge, Bankurah, and Assistant Session Judge, Burdwan. |
| 2 | 38 | Hon. Moulvi Abdul Jubbar, Member of the Bengal Legislative Council, Deputy Magistrate, 24 Perguns. |
| 3 | 44 | Bu. Obhoy Chunder Dos, Deputy Magistrate and Deputy Collector, 24 Perguns. |
| 4 | 51 | Sarat Chunder Banerji, Esq., M.A., B.L., Extra Assistant Commissioner, Kamrup, Assam. |
| 5 | 53 | Lalla Hukum Chand, M.A., Registrar, High Court, Hyderabad. |
| 6 | 75 | Maulvi Abdul Bari, a member of the Subordinate Judicial Service. |
| 7 | 76 | Bu. Girish Chunder Choudhury, First Subordinate Judge, Patna. |
| 8 | 82 | Bu. Durgagoti Banerji, Deputy Magistrate and Deputy Collector. |
| 9 | 83 | Bu. Srinath Roy, Fourth Judge of the Small Cause Court, Calcutta. |
| 10 | 85 | Bu. Tariny Churn Ghose, Deputy Collector. |
| 11 | 86 | Bu. Rajendra Nath Mitter, Deputy Collector. |
| 12 | 92 | Bu. Chundi Churn Sen, Munsiff, Krishnagar. |
| 13 | 94 | Bu. Bhola Ram Mullick, Third Grade Subordinate Judge, and Judge Small Causes Court, Pubna. |
| 14 | 114 | Bu. Anundo Chunder Sen, Deputy Collector. |
| 15 | 116 | Akhay Kumar Sen, Deputy Magistrate Fourth Grade, and Personal Assistant to the Commissioner. |
| 16 | 117 | Bu. Bani Madhub Mitter, Subordinate Judge, Dacca. |
| 17 | 128 | Bu. Mohendro Nath Mitter, Judge Small Causes Court, Dacca and Munshigunje. |
| 18 | 143 | Bu. Kunjo Lal Banerji, late Second Judge, Calcutta Court of Small Causes. |
| 19 | 147 | Bu. Issur Chunder Mitter, of the Subordinate Executive Service. |
| 20 | 155 | Rai Ram Shunker Sen Bahadur, Retired Deputy Magistrate. |
| 21 | 162 | Bu. Kali Charan Ghose, Deputy Collector. |
| 22 | 5s | Rai S. C. Banerji, Extra Assistant Commissioner, Assam. |
| Total of Class IIIa. | 22 | |
Class IIIb.—Educational Department.
| 1 | 17 | Rev. Lal Behari De, Professor, Hughli College. |
| 2 | 124 | Maulvi Abdul Khair Mahomed Sadiq, Superintendent Dacca Madrissa. |
| 3 | 125 | Bu. Jagat Bundhu Laha, Headmaster, Dacca Normal School. |
| 4 | 127 | Bu. Iswar Chunder Bose, Headmaster, Collegiate School, Dacca. |
| 5 | 135 | Bu. Shoshee Bhushun Dutt, Assistant Professor, Dacca College. |
| 6 | 146 | Bu. Chunder Mohun Ghose, Teacher of Anatomy in the Campbell Medical School. |
| 7 | 149 | Bu. Radhica Prasanna Mukerji, Acting Inspector of Schools, Presidency Circle. |
| 8 | 151 | Dr. P. K. Roy, Professor, Presidency College, Calcutta. |
| 9 | 18s | Bu. Bhudeb Mukerji, Inspector of Schools (Retired). |
| Total of Class IIIb | 9 | |
| Class IIIc.—Uncovenanted Service—Unclassified. | ||
| 1 | 93 | Bu. Abinash Chunder Bose, Treasurer, Accountant General’s Office, Bengal. |
| Total of Class IIIc | 1 | |
| Class IVa.—Barristers, Vakils, and Solicitors. | ||
| 1 | 10 | Hon. Kali Nath Mitter, Member Bengal Legislative Council, Attorney High Court. |
| 2 | 29 | Bu. Girija Bhushan Mukerji, B.A., B.L., Pleader, High Court. |
| 3 | 32 | Bu. Mohesh Chunder Choudhury, Vakil, High Court. |
| 4 | 40 | M. N. Ghose, Esq., Barrister-at-Law, High Court, Calcutta. |
| 5 | 42 | Monomohun Ghose, Esq., Barrister-at-Law, High Court, Calcutta. |
| 6 | 43 | Bu. Rash Behari Ghose, LL.D., Pleader, High Court, Member Bengal Legislative Council. |
| 7 | 59 | Saraf-ud-din, Esq., Barrister-at-Law. |
| 8 | 64 | Bu. Guru Proshad Sen, Pleader, High Court, practising at Patna. |
| 9 | 65 | Maulvi Khuda Baksh, Government Pleader, Patna. |
| 10 | 66 | Bu. Bisseshwur Sing, Pleader of the District Judge’s Court, Shahabad. |
| 11 | 73 | Bu. Bhup Sen Sing, Pleader, High Court. |
| 12 | 74 | Bu. Jodu Nath Sahai, Pleader, High Court. |
| 13 | 77 | Bu. Chutturbhuj Sahai, Pleader, District Court, Patna. |
| 14 | 78 | Bu. Joy Prokash Lal, Pleader, and Dewan Dumraon, Raj. |
| 15 | 79 | Bu. Basant Kumar Bose, Vakil, High Court. |
| 16 | 80 | Bu. Debendro Chunder Ghose, Pleader, High Court. |
| 17 | 88 | Bu. Jadub Prosonno Shome, Pleader, District Court, Allahabad. |
| 18 | 89 | Bu. Upendra Chandra Mitter, Vakil, High Court. |
| 19 | 95 | Bu. Jibun Krishna Ghose, Pleader, Judges Court, Alipore. |
| 20 | 97 | Bu. Kali Nath Mukerji, Pleader, High Court. |
| 21 | 100 | Bu. Annada Prosad Banerji, Government Pleader, High Court. |
| 22 | 102 | Bu. Ambica Churn Bose, Pleader, High Court. |
| 23 | 103 | Bu. Ishur Chunder Chuckerburty, Pleader, High Court. |
| 24 | 105 | Bu. Girish Chunder Choudhury, Pleader, High Court. |
| 25 | 106 | Bu. Okhil Chunder Sen, Pleader, High Court. |
| 26 | 107 | Saligram Sing, Pleader, High Court. |
| 27 | 108 | Bu. Trailakya Nath Mitter, Pleader, High Court, President Serampore Municipality. |
| 28 | 111 | Bu. Ashutosh Biswas, Pleader, High Court. |
| 29 | 113 | Bu. Dina Nath Dhur, Government Pleader, District Court, Dacca. |
| 30 | 120 | Bu. Rojoni Nath Bose, Vakil, High Court. |
| 31 | 123 | Bu. Rajani Kanto Choudhuri, Pleader, District Judge’s Court, Calcutta. |
| 32 | 126 | Bu. Trailakya Nath Bose, Pleader, High Court. |
| 33 | 133 | Bu. Anundo Chunder Ray, Pleader, District Court. |
| 34 | 134 | Bu. Surrat Chunder Gupta, Pleader, Judge’s Court ; elected Chairman of the Local Board, and a Member of the District Board of Dacca. |
| 35 | 138 | Bu. Gobind Chunder Das, Pleader of the Dacca Judge’s Court and High Court. |
| 36 | 140 | Bu. Keshub Chunder Acherji, Pleader, Judge’s Court, Mymensing, Zemindar, Member of the Local Board, etc. |
| 37 | 156 | Bu. Mritunjoy Roy, a Pleader of the High Court. |
| 38 | 163 | Bu. Durga Mohun Das, Pleader, High Court. |
| 39 | 205 | Hon. Rao Saheb Vishva Nath Naryan Mandelik, C.S.I., Additional Member of the Council of the Viceroy, Government Pleader, High Court, Bombay. |
| Total of Class IVa | 39 | |
| Class IVb.—Zemindars. | ||
| 1 | 28 | His Highness Maharajah Sir Luchmeshwar Sing Bahadur, K.C.I.E., of Durbhanga. |
| 2 | 41 | Bu. Joy Kissen Mukerji, Zemindar, 24 Pergunnahs. |
| 3 | 58 | Nawab Wilayat Ali Khan Bahadur, Patna. |
| 4 | 60 | Maulvi Syad Fuzl Imam, Zemindar, Vice-President, Patna Municipality, Member of the District Board. |
| 5 | 62 | Rai Joy Kissen, Patna. |
| 6 | 70 | Rajah Rameshwar Sing Bahadur, younger brother of the Maharaja of Durbhanga. |
| 7 | 84 | Bu. Charu Chunder Mitter, Zemindar in Allahabad and Hughli, Senior Vice-Chairman, Allahabad Municipality. |
| 8 | 109 | Maulvi Fuzl-ul-Rahman, Vice-Chairman Nattore Municipality, Zemindar in Rajshaye. |
| 9 | 118 | Khajah Mahommed Ashgar, Vice-Chairman of the District Board of Dacca. |
| 10 | 130 | Bu. Radha Balhab Choudhury, Zemindar and Honorary Magistrate, Vice-Chairman, Municipal Board, Sherepore Town. |
| 11 | 139 | Bu. Madan Mohun Bysack, Merchant and Zemindar, Dacca. |
| 12 | 144 | Bu. Binode Behary Roy, eldest son of Bu. Chuckhun Lal Roy, of Chagdigi, Zemindar. |
| 13 | 148 | Bu. Jogendro Chunder Ghose, Zemindar. |
| 14 | 152 | Roy Jogendro Nath Choudhury, Zemindar, Taki. |
| 15 | 158 | Kumar Nil Krishna Deb, of the Shobhabazar Deb family. |
| 16 | 160 | Rai Jodu Nath Bahadur, Zemindar, in the district of Nuddea. |
| 17 | 161 | Bu. Tara Prosad Mukerji, Zemindar, Chairman of the Revelgunje Municipality. |
| 18 | 166 | Bu. Hem Chunder Ghose, Zemindar, Hughli. |
| 19 | 115 | Maharajah Sir Jotendro Mohun Tagore, K.C.S.I. |
| 20 | 125 | Bu. Abhoy Churn Goho, Zemindar, Banian, etc., etc. |
| Total of Class IVb . . . 20 | ||
| Class IVc.—Merchants. | ||
| 1 | 22 | Rajah Durga Churn Laha, Merchant, Calcutta. |
| 2 | 110 | Bairamji Nusserwanji, Esq., Merchant, Calcutta. |
| Total of Class IVc . . . 2 | ||
| Class IVd.—General Public, Unclassified. | ||
| 1 | 26 | Hon. Dr. Mohendro Lal Sircar, C.I.E., Hon. Presidency Magistrate, Calcutta, Member of the Bengal Legislative Council, Calcutta. |
| 2 | 48 | Nawab Abdul Lutif Bahadur, C.I.E. |
| 3 | 87 | Bu. Dhirendra Nath Pal, Private Gentleman, Jessore. |
| 4 | 90 | Bu. Ashutosh Mukerji, B.A., etc., etc. |
| 5 | 96 | Bu. Chunder Sekhur Gupta, Government Pensioner. |
| 6 | 99 | Bu. Nilkanto Chatterji, M.A. |
| 7 | 154 | Dr. Annada Prosad Kastgiri. |
| 8 | 159 | Pundit Jadubeshwur Tarka Ratna, Tole Pundit in Rangpore. |
| Total of Class IVd . . . 8 | ||
| Class V.—English Newspapers. | ||
| 1 | 5 | Bu. Norendro Nath Sen, Editor, Indian Mirror. |
| 2 | 12 | Bu. Surendro Nath Banerji, Editor, Bengali. |
| 3 | 104 | Bu. Moti Lal Ghose, on the staff of the Amrita Bazar Patrika. |
| 4 | 119 | Bu. Shoshi Bhushun Roy, Editor, Dacca Gazette. |
| Total of Class V . . . 4 | ||
| Class VI.—Vernacular Newspapers. | ||
| 1 | 122 | Bu. Kali Prosonno Ghose, Manager of the estate of Raja Rajendro Narain Roy Chowdhury, and Editor of a literary journal. |
| 2 | 129 | Bu. Obhoy Churn Nag, Editor of the Charu Varta, and a Pleader in the Judges Court, Mymensing. |
| 3 | 150 | Pundit Sadanada Misra, Editor of the Sarshudhanidhi. |
| 4 | 157 | Bu. Akhoy Kumar Sircar, Editor of the Nobo Bibhakar and Sadharani. |
| 5 | 165 | Bu. Krishna Kumar Mitter, Editor of the Sanjibani newspaper. |
| 6 | 7s | Bu. Prokash Nath Mullick, Editor, Samay newspaper, Calcutta. |
| 7 | 19s | Editor, Prajabundhu newspaper. |
| 8 | 21s | Editor, Bangabashi newspaper. |
| 9 | 25s | Editor, Sansodhini newspaper. |
| 10 | 27s | Bu. Bani Madhub Datta, Editor, Dainik newspaper. |
| Total of Class VI . . . 10 | ||
| Class VII.—Associations and Societies. | ||
| 1 | 136 | Bu. Satish Chunder Ghosh, Honorary Secretary and Delegate of the Parjoar Association. |
| 2 | 142 | Bu. Janendro Nath Bose, Delegate of the Sripur Hitas-hadhini Sabha, and Taki Hitakari Sabha, Professor of Ripon College. |
| 3 | 145 | Bu. Hari Nath Sen, Delegate of the Baraset Association, Sub-Inspector of Schools. |
| 4 | 153 | Bu. Kishory Mohun Ganguly, Delegate of the Shibpore Ratepayers Association. |
| Total of Class VII . . . 4 | ||
| Class VIII.—High Court Judges, etc. | ||
| 1 | 46 | Honourable Chunder Madhub Ghose, Judge, High Court, Bengal. |
| Total of Class VIII . . . 1 | ||
The authorities who would lightly set aside such an expression of opinion would incur a most serious risk. The very significant fact is elicited by this examination of evidence that, as I have already remarked, there are actually ten Mahomedan witnesses in favour of simultaneous examinations against four who object to them ; two are neutral. Thus, in the largest province in the Empire, where nearly half the Mahomedans in British India are located, there are twice as many Mahomedan witnesses in favour than there are against ! This circumstance robs the following sentence from the Report of much of its value :—“ Under the second [i.e., evidence ‘ given by others who feel that, in the present circumstances of the country, important classes of the community are practically debarred from success in examinations designed mainly as tests of educational fitness ’] may be included the majority of the witnesses belonging to the Mahomedan community.” (Paragraph 60 of Commissioners’ Report.) The statement is technically correct, but in its essentials is strangely misleading. As I shall shortly have occasion to show the evidence of Mahomedan witnesses was taken in a manner which causes grave suspicion as to perfect fairness. For example, fifteen Mahomedan gentlemen were considered sufficient to express the opinions and views of twenty-three millions of Bengal Mahomedans; fifteen (the same number) were thought necessary to perform a similar duty for six millions in the Punjab, while sixteen were called in the North-Western Provinces, where there are less than twelve millions of Moslems.1 Fairly dealt with, and all the considerations taken into account, the utterance of the Commissioners respecting Mahomedan evidence which I have quoted is scarcely fair, inasmuch as it deals with a set of facts differing in important particulars, in each Presidency or Province. The mere enumeration of figures in such a case would be gravely misleading. Yet this is what the Commission appears to have done.
The tables in regard to the other Presidencies and Provinces I give without comment. The details, however, are at your lordship’s service should they be desired. Those details are omitted solely from a wish not to make this communication too long. An examination of them shows me that what I have said of Bengal might be said of the other parts of the Empire.
| Europeans. | Indians. | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Class of Witness. | For | Ag. | Neu. | For | Ag. | Neu. |
| 1. Covenanted Civil Service | 3 | 2 | 3 | — | — | — |
| 1a. Military Officers in Civil Employ | 1 | — | — | — | — | — |
| 2. Statutory Civil Service | — | — | — | 1 | 1 | — |
| 3. Uncovenanted Service : | ||||||
| a. Judicial and Executive | 1 | 1 | — | 13 | — | — |
| b. Educational Department | 1 | 5 | 2 | 3 | 1 | 1 |
| c. Unclassified | 2 | 1 | — | 4 | 5 | — |
| 4. General Public : | ||||||
| a. Barristers, Vakils & Solicitors | — | — | 5 | 10 | — | — |
| b. Zemindars | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| c. Merchants | — | — | — | 1 | — | — |
| d. Unclassified | 1 | 1 | — | 8 | 5 | — |
| 5. English Newspapers. | — | — | — | 2 | — | — |
| 6. Vernacular „ | — | — | — | 2 | — | — |
| 7. Associations and Societies | — | — | — | 7 | 2 | — |
| 8. Members of Council and High Court Judges | — | 1 | 1 | 3 | — | — |
| Totals | 9 | 11 | 11 | 54 | 14 | 1 |
| Class of Witness. | Europeans. | Indians. | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| For | Ag. | Neu. | For | Ag. | Neu. | |
| 1. Covenanted Civil Service | 5 | 16 | — | 2 | — | — |
| 1a. Conservator of Forests | — | — | 1 | — | — | — |
| 2. Statutory Civil Service | — | — | — | 2 | 1 | — |
| 3. Uncovenanted Service : | ||||||
| a. Judicial and Executive | — | 3 | 1 | 9 | 4 | — |
| b. Educational Department | 3 | 4 | 1 | 5 | 2 | 1 |
| c. Unclassified | — | — | — | 1 | — | — |
| 4. General Public : | ||||||
| a. Barristers, Vakils, & Solicitors | — | — | 1 | 7 | 1 | — |
| b. Zemindars | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| c. Merchants | — | — | — | — | 1 | — |
| d. Unclassified | — | — | 1 | 11 | 3 | 2 |
| 5. English Newspapers | 1 | — | — | 3 | — | — |
| 6. Vernacular „ | — | — | — | 5 | — | — |
| 7. Associations and Societies | 2 | — | — | 6 | 2 | — |
| 8. Members of Council and High Court Judges | — | — | 2 | 2 | 1 | — |
| Totals | 11 | 23 | 7 | 53 | 15 | 3 |
| 1. Covenanted Civil Service | 1 | 8 | 3 | — | 1 | — |
| 2. Statutory Civil Service | — | — | — | 1 | 1 | — |
| 3. Uncovenanted Service : | ||||||
| a. Judicial and Executive | 1 | — | 1 | 4 | 7 | — |
| b. Educational Department | — | 1 | 1 | — | — | — |
| c. Unclassified | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| 4. General Public : | ||||||
| a. Barristers, Vakils, & Solicitors | 3 | 1 | 1 | 4 | 1 | 1 |
| b. Zemindars | — | — | — | 9 | 3 | — |
| c. Merchants | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| d. Unclassified | — | — | — | 1 | 2 | — |
| 5. English Newspapers | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| 6. Vernacular „ | — | — | — | — | 1 | — |
| 7. Associations and Societies | 1 | — | — | 5 | 2 | — |
| 8. Members of Council and High Court Judges | — | 1 | 1 | 1 | — | — |
| Totals | 6 | 11 | 7 | 25 | 18 | 1 |
| 1. Covenanted Civil Service | 1 | 9 | 2 | — | — | — |
| 1a. Military Officers in Civil Employ | — | 2 | — | — | — | — |
| 2. Statutory Civil Service | — | — | — | 4 | 1 | — |
| 3. Uncovenanted Service : | ||||||
| a. Judicial and Executive | 2 | 3 | — | 10 | 2 | 2 |
| b. Educational Department | 3 | — | — | 1 | 2 | — |
| c. Unclassified | — | — | — | — | — | 1 |
| Carried forward | 6 | 14 | 2 | 15 | 5 | 3 |
| Brought forward | 6 | 14 | 2 | 15 | 5 | 3 |
| 4. General Public: | ||||||
| a. Barristers, Vakils, & Solicitors. | — | 1 | — | 3 | — | 2 |
| b. Zemindars. | — | — | — | — | — | 1 |
| c. Merchants. | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| d. Unclassified | — | — | — | 2 | 1 | 6 |
| 5. English Newspapers | — | — | — | — | — | 1 |
| 6. Vernacular „ | — | — | — | 3 | 1 | 2 |
| 7. Associations and Societies | — | — | — | 7 | 4 | — |
| 8. Members of Council and High Court Judges | — | — | 1 | — | — | — |
| Totals | 6 | 15 | 3 | 30 | 11 | 15 |
6.—CENTRAL PROVINCES.
| 1. Covenanted Civil Service | 1 | 2 | 3 | — | — | — |
| 2. Statutory Civil Service | — | — | — | — | — | 1 |
| 3. Uncovenanted Service: | ||||||
| a. Judicial and Executive | — | — | 3 | 5 | 5 | — |
| b. Educational Department | — | 2 | — | 1 | — | — |
| c. Unclassified | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| 4. General Public: | ||||||
| a. Barristers, Vakils, & Solicitors. | 2 | — | — | 4 | — | 1 |
| b. Zemindars. | — | — | — | 2 | — | — |
| c. Merchants. | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| d. Unclassified | — | — | — | 3 | — | — |
| 5. English Newspapers | — | — | — | 1 | — | — |
| 6. Vernacular „ | — | — | — | 2 | — | — |
| 7. Associations and Societies | — | — | — | 3 | 1 | — |
| 8. Members of Council, and High Court Judges | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| Totals | 3 | 4 | 6 | 21 | 6 | 2 |
SUMMARY OF TABLES.
EUROPEANS.
| PRESIDENCY OR PROVINCE. | 1. COVENANTED CIVIL SERVICE. | 1a. SPECIAL OFFICERS. | 2. STATUTORY. | 3a. UNCOV. SERVICE Judicial and Executive. | 3b. EDUCATIONAL. | 3c. UNCOV. SERVICE. Unclassified. | 4a. GENERAL PUBLIC. Barristers, etc. | 4b. ZEMINDARS. | 4c. MERCHANTS. | 4d. GENERAL PUBLIC. Unclassified. | 5. ENGLISH NEWSPAPERS. | 6. VERNACULAR NEWSPAPERS. | 7. ASSOCIATIONS AND SOCIETIES. | 8. MEMBERS OF COUNCIL AND HIGH COURT JUDGES. | ||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| For | Ag. | For | Ag. | For | Ag. | For | Ag. | For | Ag. | For | Ag. | For | Ag. | For | Ag. | For | Ag. | For | Ag. | For | Ag. | For | Ag. | For | Ag. | For | Ag. | |
| 1. BENGAL | 6 | 14 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 3 | 3 | 0 | 3 | 1 | 2 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 2. MADRAS | 3 | 2 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 5 | 2 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 |
| 3. BOMBAY. | 5 | 16 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 4. N.-W. PROVS. AND OUDH | 1 | 8 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 3 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 1 |
| 5. THE PUNJAB | 1 | 9 | 0 | 2 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 3 | 3 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 6. CENTRAL PROVINCES | 1 | 2 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| TOTALS | 17 | 51 | 1 | 2 | 0 | 0 | 4 | 9 | 10 | 15 | 2 | 4 | 6 | 4 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 3 | 0 | 0 | 2 |
Europeans: For | 49
„ Against. | 90
Total | 139
| PRESIDENCY OR PROVINCE. | 1. COVENANTED CIVIL SERVICE. | 1a. SPECIAL OFFICERS. | 2. STATUTORY CIVIL SERVICE. | 3a. UNCOV. SERVICE. Judicial and Executive. | 3b. EDUCATIONAL DEPARTMENT. | 3c. UNCOV. SERVICE. Unclassified. | 4a. GENERAL PUBLIC. Barristers, Vakils, etc. | 4b. ZEMINDARS. | 4c. MERCHANTS. | 4d. GENERAL PUBLIC. Unclassified. | 5. ENGLISH NEWSPAPERS. | 6. VERNACULAR NEWSPAPERS. | 7. ASSOCIATIONS AND SOCIETIES. | 8. MEMBERS OF COUNCIL AND HIGH COURT JUDGES. | ||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FOR | AG. | FOR | AG. | FOR | AG. | FOR | AG. | FOR | AG. | FOR | AG. | FOR | AG. | FOR | AG. | FOR | AG. | FOR | AG. | FOR | AG. | FOR | AG. | FOR | AG. | FOR | AG. | |
| 1. BENGAL | 4 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 3 | 0 | 22 | 5 | 9 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 39 | 1 | 20 | 1 | 2 | 0 | 8 | 1 | 4 | 0 | 10 | 0 | 6 | 0 | 1 | 0 |
| 2. MADRAS | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 13 | 0 | 3 | 0 | 4 | 5 | 10 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 8 | 5 | 2 | 0 | 2 | 0 | 7 | 2 | 3 | 0 |
| 3. BOMBAY. | 2 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 1 | 9 | 4 | 5 | 2 | 1 | 0 | 7 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 11 | 3 | 3 | 0 | 5 | 0 | 6 | 2 | 2 | 1 |
| 4. N.-W. PROVS. AND OUDH | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 4 | 7 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 4 | 1 | 9 | 3 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 2 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 5 | 2 | 1 | 0 |
| 5. THE PUNJAB | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 4 | 2 | 10 | 2 | 1 | 2 | 0 | 0 | 3 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 3 | 1 | 7 | 4 | 0 | 0 |
| 6. CENTRAL PROVINCES | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 5 | 5 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 4 | 0 | 2 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 3 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 2 | 0 | 3 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| TOTALS | 6 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 11 | 5 | 63 | 23 | 19 | 4 | 6 | 6 | 67 | 3 | 31 | 4 | 3 | 1 | 33 | 12 | 10 | 0 | 22 | 2 | 34 | 11 | 7 | 1 |
European Witnesses : For . . 49; Against . . 90; Total . . 139 Indian „ „ . 312; „ . . 73; „ . . 385 1361 163 524
The Summary shows, as might have been expected, a decided preponderance of opinion among European Covenanted Civilians and Special Officers against simultaneous examinations. The numbers are 18 for, 55 against, or three to one against. It is surprising, all things considered, there should have been so many Europeans in favour of a proposal which, while it will do nothing to weaken but much to strengthen the connexion of India with England, will certainly, when carried out, lessen the number of Europeans employed in India. When the examination of these tables is farther proceeded with, and the Uncovenanted and non-Europeans1 are taken into account, the great disparity of numbers largely passes away. While there is still a majority of Europeans against, it is comparatively small; the numbers are nearly equal, being 31 for, 37 against. When these numbers are set opposite to those of Indians on both sides, the result is, I venture to submit, overwhelming in its significance.
| Europeans. | ||
|---|---|---|
| For. | Against. | |
| Covenanted Officials | 18 | 53 |
| Uncovenanted and non-Officials | 31 | 37 |
| Totals | 49 | 90 |
| Indians. | ||
| For. | Against. | |
| Covenanted Officials | 17 | 6 |
| Uncovenanted and non-Officials | 295 | 67 |
| Totals | 312 | 73 |
Thus, while of European witnesses there are considerably less than two to one against, of Indians, including the disproportionate “cloud of witnesses” of the Mahomedan faith introduced in Madras, the North-West Provinces, and the Punjab, there are more than four to one for. From the tables given on pp. 467-468 supra it will have been seen that there is not a part of the Empire in which the majority of witnesses, European and Indian counted together, were not in favour of simultaneous examinations. It should not be forgotten that four-fifths of the witnesses examined were summoned as being persons whose opinions were of special value. Here it may be well to set out the names of the Europeans who gave evidence in favour. They are as follows :—
Hon. H. J. Reynolds, C.S.I. Sir A. W. Croft, K.C.I.E. H. Beveridge, C.S. C. H. Tawney, M.A. H. J. S. Cotton, C.S. C. B. Garret, C.S. H. M. Kisch, C.S. A. O. Hume, C.B. F. J. Rowe J. Kemp Hon. P. O’Sullivan J. H. Garstin, C.S.I. H. E. Stokes, C.S. E. Gibson, C.S. J. H. H. Ellis J. R. Upshon Col. T. G. Clarke H. G. Turner, C.S. Hon. F. Brandt G. Maddox W. Wordsworth G. W. Forrest
G. Geary Hon. Justice West J. Monteath, C.S. Sir W. Wedderburn, Bart. J. Clarke A. Cotterell Tupp, C.S. W. C. Nibbet F. C. Lewis, M.A. Col. Holroyd Carr Stephen, C.S. J. Sime, M.A. G. Lewis, B.A. W. Coldstream, C.S. C. S. Arthur Wixon J. P. Goodridge, C.S. F. W. Dillon A. Ewbank F. Wyer W. M. Elliott Rev. D. Mackenzie, M.A., D.D.
| PRESIDENCY OR PROVINCE. | EUROPEANS | HINDUS. | PARSEES. | MAHOMEDANS. | POPULATION. | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| For | Ag. | For | Ag. | For | Ag. | For | Ag. | Hindus. | Mahomedans. | |
| 1. Bengal | 14 | 26 | 118 | 5 | 1 | — | 10 | 4 | 45,452,806 | 22,704,724 |
| 2. Madras | 9 | 11 | 54 | 5 | — | — | — | 9 | 28,497,666 | 1,933,571 |
| 3. Bombay | 11 | 23 | 27 | 6 | 20 | 3 | 6 | 6 | 17,834,985 | 3,774,360 |
| 4. N.-W. Provinces and Oudh | 6 | 11 | 21 | 6 | — | 1 | 4 | 11 | 38,555,121 | 6,162,900 |
| 5. Punjab | 6 | 15 | 23 | 2 | — | — | 7 | 9 | 9,252,295 | 11,662,434 |
| 6. Central Provs. | 3 | 4 | 21 | 2 | — | — | — | 4 | 8,703,110 | 285,687 |
| Totals | 49 | 90 | 264 | 26 | 21 | 4 | 27 | 43 | 148,295,983 | 46,523,676 |
The record of evidence according to Nationality shows that Europeans and Mahomedans are in a majority, adverse, the proportions curiously being nearly the same—in both cases less than two to one against. The Hindus were ten to one in favour, the Parsees five to one. Such an expression of race opinion should, I submit, have been ascertained by the Commission, should have been mentioned in the Report, and due weight should have been given to it in the recommendations made. There are one hundred and fifty millions of Hindus in British India; representatives of the various Hindu races by ten to one are in favour of a particular course; there are fifty millions of Mahomedans, less than two are against this particular course to one in favour. All are Indians, all are Indian subjects of the Queen-Empress. They work cordially together in the everyday affairs of the Empire. They are good neighbours. Their numbers ought to be counted together. In the United Kingdom Scottish votes are not separated from English votes. Carry out this fair principle in the present instance, and it will be found the Indian votes are four to one in favour. Nevertheless, the Commission—whose Report, of course, should be according to the evidence [otherwise, why trouble about taking evidence ?] makes recommendations in a contrary sense, declaring there was no consensus of opinion. A Report built upon such shifting sand cannot possibly stand.
Among those, in the above enumeration, designated Neutral or Doubtful, it is only fair to the cause I am urging that I should state, are some who make suggestions which if acted upon, would find place in the Covenanted Service for a large proportion of Indians. For example :—
Mr. Larminie, Commissioner, Dacca Division, “Some posts should be reserved exclusively for Europeans—the rest for Indians.”
Mr. Elliott, Public Prosecutor, Cuddapah, would give one-fourth of appointments to Indians.
Hon. M. Melvill, C.S.I., Member of Council, Bombay, would give one-fourth of appointments to Indians.
A. Ewbank, Esq., Principal of the Patna College, proposes the Statutory Service should he enlarged and recruited by nomination followed by real examination, till it reaches a third of the Civil Service.
F. Wyer, Esq., Civil Service, Collector and Magistrate, Dacca, objects on account of practical difficulties in the examination, advocates equal apportionment of appointments on political grounds, the Indian appointments again divided according to the religions of India.
Honourable P. O’Sullivan, Barrister-at-Law, Advocate-General, Madras—“If it is found to be practicable, this [simultaneous examinations] might be done.”
W. M. Elliot, Esq., Pleader and Public Prosecutor, Cuddapah, Madras—If an apportionment of appointments be made, he has no objection to a simultaneous examination ; he would give one-fourth of the apportionment.
Rev. D. Mackenzie, M.A., D.D., Principal, Free General Assembly’s Institution, Bombay, wants the service to be recruited considerably by graduates.
It may, further, be remarked that the majority of the objections expressed to simultaneous examinations was owing to what is called the present insufficient educational advantages in India. No attempt seems to have been made by Sir Charles Aitchison or by Sir Charles Turner (they took the lead in examining on this point) to bring out the undoubted fact that—given the examinations in India the teaching standard would, in time, necessarily be raised to the requisite height and fulness. All the consequential benefits were likewise ignored. That advancement all along the line, in every walk of life, advancement in which the backward classes would share, must result, and every profession in India incidentally gain, were wholly ignored. Equally was it ignored that an immense impetus would be given to the provision of educational facilities by Indians themselves, the Government thereby, in a measure, being relieved of a portion of the burden of higher education. Again, when it was so frequently tacitly assumed that Indians were not fitted for high administrative and executive posts, no one asked the obvious question how this could be known or how the difficulties in the way of overcoming it, if it existed, could be conquered until a trial was made. As a matter of fact, so far as trial has been made and Indians have been appointed to positions of responsibility, it is freely acknowledged that they have satisfied all expectations and have discharged their duties with ability and integrity. What the Duke of Argyll has called the still more important point than that of efficiency even, namely, how the pledges of the British monarch and legislature and British statesmen as to equality of treatment could be fulfilled, was completely ignored. No more valuable branch of enquiry than this can be imagined, if equity is to mark our rule in India. The loss to Europeans of some places in the Covenanted Service is as nothing compared to our reputation for good faith. “I would sacrifice Gwalior or any frontier of India ten times,” said the Duke of Wellington in 1802, “in order to preserve our character for scrupulous good faith.” Very little, if anything, was done by the Commissioners in the putting of questions calculated to elicit favourable observations on this branch of the enquiry, while it is not going too far to say that the tendency of the examination was to elicit objections.
How to some extent this came about, and how it was that the clear and emphatic preponderance of evidence in favour of simultaneous examinations seems never to have struck the Commissioners, would be hard of understanding, were it not that the Proceedings of the Commission itself afford an answer, to which answer it is with no little regret I now find myself compelled to ask your lordship’s attention.
Copies of Correspondence between the War Office and Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji.
VIII.
Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, S.W. 5th June, 1896.
Sir,—I find from the Paper of the “Examinations held under the direction of the Civil Service Commissioners,” that I have to apply to you for a copy of “the Regulations respecting examinations for admission to the Royal Military College, Sandhurst, and the Royal Military Academy, Woolwich, and of the Regulations respecting the examinations of Militia and University Candidates for Commissions in the Army.” May I request you to furnish me with a copy of these Regulations ?
I remain, yours faithfully, Dadabhai Naoroji.
The Military Secretary, War Office.
Forwarded with the Military Secretary’s compliments. War Office, London, S.W. 6th June, 1896.
Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, S.W. 8th June, 1896.
Dear Sir,—I am much obliged to you for so promptly sending me the four pamphlets of Regulations.
In the paper of the Civil Service Commissioners to which I referred in my last letter I find under the heading “General Notices,” among the qualifications of Candidates, Section 4, as follows :—
“4. Nationality.—A person born in a foreign country who can prove that his father or his paternal grandfather was born in British Dominions, is, if he has not expatriated himself under the Naturalisation Act of 1870, admissible as a natural born British subject to all open competitions which he is in other respects qualified to enter, except those for Student Interpreterships.”
I do not find this qualification of “Nationality” mentioned in the pamphlets you have been good enough to send me. You will oblige me much by informing me whether I am right in understanding that the qualifications given under “General Notices” by the Civil Service Commissioners apply to the Army examinations, and that they include Indians as being born in “British Dominions” and being thus “natural born British subjects.”
Yours truly, Dadabhai Naoroji.
The Military Secretary, War Office, London, S.W.
War Office, Pall Mall, S.W. 10th June, 1896.
Sir,—I am directed by the Secretary of State for War to acknowledge the receipt of your letter of the 8th instant, and to acquaint you in reply that candidates for commissions in the British Army must be of pure European descent, and are also required to be British born or naturalised British subjects.
I am, Sir, your obedient Servant, Coleridge Grove, M.S.
Dadabhai Naoroji, Esq., Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, S.W.
Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, S.W. 14th June, 1896.
Sir,—I am much obliged for your letter of the 10th inst., informing me that “candidates for commissions in the British Army must be of pure European descent, and are also required to be British born or naturalised British subjects.”
I shall feel further obliged if you would kindly inform me by what Act of Parliament is this limit laid down for the candidates, to the exclusion of other British subjects of her Majesty of other descent and born in her Majesty’s British dominions, such as British India and the colonies.
I remain, your obedient Servant, Dadabhai Naoroji.
The Under-Secretary of State, War Office, Pall Mall, London, S.W.
100/Candidates/1681.
War Office, Pall Mall, S.W. 25th June, 1896.
Sir,—With reference to your further letter of the 14th instant, I am directed by the Secretary of State for War to acquaint you that the conditions for admission to the Army are not laid down by Act of Parliament but by regulation, and that the regulations are to the effect already conveyed to you.
I am, Sir, your obedient Servant, Coleridge Grove, Mil. Sec.
Dadabhai Naoroji, Esq., Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, S.W.
Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, S.W. 26th June, 1896.
Sir,—I am much obliged by your letter of 25th inst. (100/Candidates/1681) explaining that “the conditions for admission to the Army are not laid down by Act of Parliament but by regulation.”
I shall feel much obliged by your informing me that if these conditions are not laid down by Act of Parliament then by what other authority are they laid down? May I also request you kindly to supply me with a copy of such authority and of the regulations in which these conditions are specified ?
I remain, your obedient Servant, Dababhai Naoroji.
The Under-Secretary of State, War Office, Pall Mall, London, S.W.
100/Candidates/1685. War Office, Pall Mall, S.W. 6th July, 1896.
Sir,—With reference to your letter of the 26th ultimo, I am directed by the Secretary of State for War to transmit to you a copy of the Sandhurst Regulations, and also a copy of the Form of Particulars which is sent to all candidates who apply for examination for admission to the Royal Military College.
I am, Sir, your obedient Servant, Coleridge Grove, Mil. Sec.
Dadabhai Naoroji, Esq., Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, S.W.
Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, Wandsworth, S.W. 8th July, 1896.
Sir,—I have received your letter of 6th inst. (100/Candidates/1685) for which I thank you.
I am sorry I did not make my meaning clear.
You said in your letter of 25th ult. (100/Candidates/1681) “that the conditions for admission to the Army are not laid down by Act of Parliament, but by Regulation.”
Now what I desire to know is this. I have always understood that the only constitutional authority or power for laying down all such conditions is Parliament, while you say that these conditions are not laid down by an Act of Parliament. Then, what other constitutional authority has the power and has laid down these conditions according to which the Regulations are made? The Regulations you have been good enough to send me, but what I want to know is the name of the constitutional body or power by whose authority such a law is made.
I am, your obedient Servant, Dadabhai Naoroji.
The Under-Secretary of State, War Office, Pall Mall, London, S.W.
100/Candidates/1689.
War Office, Pall Mall, S.W. 18th July, 1896.
Sir,—With reference to your letter of the 8th instant, and previous correspondence, I am directed by the Marquis of Lansdowne to acquaint you that the conditions for admission to the commissioned ranks of the Army are laid down by regulations made by the Secretary of State for War, under the authority of her Majesty the Queen, as signified by Article I. of the Royal Warrant for the Pay, Appointment, Promotion, and Non-effective Pay of the Army.
I am to add that this exhausts all the information I am able to afford you on the subject of your enquiry.
I am, Sir, your obedient Servant, Coleridge Grove, M.S.
D. Naoroji, Esq., Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, Wandsworth, S.W.
Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, Wandsworth, S.W. 19th July, 1896.
Sir,—I am much obliged for the information you have been good enough to send me in your letter (100/Candidates 1689) of 18th inst., viz., “that the conditions for admission to the commissioned ranks of the Army are laid down by Regulations made by the Secretary of State for War under the authority of her Majesty the Queen, as signified by Article I of the Royal Warrant for the Pay, Appointment, Promotion and Non-effective Pay of the Army.”
May I request you to inform me where I can get a copy of this “Royal Warrant,” or to furnish me with a copy?
I remain, your obedient Servant, Dadabhai Naoroji.
The Under-Secretary of State, War Office, Pall Mall, London, S.W.
100/Candidates/1692.
War Office, Pall Mall, S.W. 23rd July, 1896.
Sir,—I am directed by the Secretary of State for War to acknowledge the receipt of your letter of the 19th instant, and to acquaint you in reply that a copy of the Royal Warrant can be obtained from Messrs. Eyre and Spottiswoode, East Harding Street, Fleet Street, E.C.
I am, Sir, your obedient Servant, Coleridge Grove, M.S.
D. Naoroji, Esq., Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, Wandsworth, S.W.
Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, Southfields, S.W. 7th August, 1896.
Sir,—I thank you for your letter of 23rd ult. (100/Candidates/1692), and I have obtained a copy of the Royal Warrant from Messrs. Eyre and Spottiswoode.
In your letter of 10th June last you were good enough to acquaint me “that candidates for commissions in the British Army must be of pure European descent, and are also required to be British-born or naturalised British subjects.” In your letter of 18th July last (100/Candidates/1689) you inform me “that the conditions for admission to the commissioned ranks of the Army are laid down by regulations made by the Secretary of State for War under the authority her Majesty the Queen as signified by Article I. of the Royal Warrant for the Pay, Appointment, Promotion, and Non-effective Pay of the Army.”
I need not say how very much obliged I feel to the Secretary of State for War for all your replies, and I now beg further indulgence and favour of his lordship to give me some further explanation on the matter that I need.
In “Article I.—First Appointments,” I do not find a word to exclude British subjects like the Indian-British subjects. The candidates are required to be “persons duly qualified under regulations approved by our Secretary of State.”
Now I cannot suppose that any such regulations can be made constitutionally under the Warrant by the Secretary of State as would supersede any Act of Parliament or any Proclamations of her Majesty the Queen; but that such regulations can only be made in accordance with Acts of Parliament and Proclamations of the Sovereign. I desire to know whether I am right.
Under this Section I. of the Warrant there is in clause 1A: “To a duly qualified candidate from a university.” In the regulations for such candidates certain British universities are specified. There are Indian-British subjects who have graduated and are graduating almost every year in some of these universities. There is not a word to exclude such graduates; this would show that the Warrant did not mean to exclude Indians. Under clause 3 there is: “By open competition.” Here again no exclusion is made by the Warrant of British-Indian subjects.
And it stands to reason that it could not be otherwise. The Act of Parliament of 1833 enacted “that no Native of the said territory (meaning India), nor any natural born subject of his Majesty resident therein, shall, by reason only of his religion, place of birth, descent, or any of them, be disabled from holding any place, office, or employment under the said Company.”
Now all the powers, duties, and responsibilities of the Company are transferred to the Queen by another Act of Parliament of 1858, and the entire exclusion of the considerations of religion, place of birth and descent, has remained as binding now as it was by the Act of 1833 for any place, office, or employment under her Majesty. Not only did Parliament not repeal or amend the clause of the Act of 1833, but in far more emphatic and explicit terms the Sovereign issued a Proclamation, strongly and explicitly confirming, and in the most solemn manner pledging before God and man, with an invocation of the blessing of God, placing her Indian subjects on exactly the same footing as all her Majesty’s other subjects, in these clear words :—
“We hold ourselves bound to the Natives of our Indian territory by the same obligations of duty which bind us to all our other subjects ; and these obligations, by the blessing of Almighty God, we shall faithfully and conscientiously fulfil.”
“And it is our further will that, so far as may be, our subjects of whatever race or creed, be freely and impartially admitted to offices in our service, the duties of which they may be qualified by their education, ability, and integrity duly to discharge.”
“In their prosperity will be our strength, in their contentment our security, and in their gratitude our best reward. And may the God of all power grant to us and to those in authority under us strength to carry out these our wishes for the good of our people.”
Nothing can be clearer than that British Indian subjects are most solemnly and honourably pledged to be exactly like all other British subjects.
In 1887 on the occasion of the Great Jubilee, the Queen and Empress of India again confirmed her Proclamation of 1858 in these clear words :—
“It had always been, and will always be her earnest desire to maintain unswervingly the principles laid down in the Proclamation published on her assumption of the direct control of the government of India.”
I do not see, therefore, how it is possible that the Queen would intend in this Warrant anything contrary not only to Acts of Parliament but to her own most gracious and explicit Proclamations of 1858 and 1887. That our gracious Sovereign and the British people, whose voice and desire she represents, could have been anything but sincere in her Proclamations cannot be admitted for a moment, and it is impossible to believe that her Majesty’s Warrant could have had the least intention of stultifying and superseding Acts of Parliament and falsifying her Majesty’s own great Proclamations, so seriously made to the world on two great and historical occasions.
There is this further indication. I find that in the spirit of and in accordance with the Acts of 1833 and 1858 and the Proclamations of 1858 and 1887—all the Civil Services of the United Kingdom in every department—Civil, Military, and Naval—are open to the British Indian subjects. There are no doubt some flaws in the rules and their execution, which I cannot refer to in this letter; but the fact is there, that all the Civil Services of the United Kingdom are open to the Indian British subjects to the same extent as to any other British subjects: such as the British people.
There is one other explanation I feel necessary to ask as to the qualifications stated in your letter of June 10—that the Candidates “must be of pure European descent, and are also required to be British-born or naturalised British subjects."
This would mean that a Turk or a Russian, or a Bulgarian, or a Spaniard, or any other of European descent can have the qualification of admission by being only naturalised; while natural-born subjects of her Majesty’s own British dominions, and even after publicly pledged to be exactly like other British subjects, are to be excluded as only mere helots. Even those born in the Colonies would appear to be thus excluded.
You will easily see how puzzled I feel at your letter of June 10 last, and I shall feel exceedingly obliged to the Secretary of State for War to give me the necessary explanations.
I remain, your obedient Servant, Dadabhai Naoroji.
The Under-Secretary of State, War Office, Pall Mall, London, S.W.
Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, Southfields, S.W. 31st August, 1896.
Sir,—I hope you have received my letter of 7th inst., and shall feel obliged to have the explanation I have requested for.
I remain, your obedient Servant, Dadabhai Naoroji.
The Under-Secretary of State, War Office, Pall Mall, London, S.W.
No. 100/Candidates/1709. War Office, London, S.W. 22nd September, 1896. Sir,—I am directed by the Secretary of State for War to acknowledge the receipt of your letter of the 31st ultimo, and to express his regret that a reply to your former letter, dated 7th August, has unavoidably been delayed. The subject will receive the Marquis of Lansdowne’s consideration on his return to this office, when a further communication will be made to you. I am, Sir, your obedient Servant, G. Lawson. D. Naoroji, Esq., Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, Southfields, S.W.
Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, Southfields, S.W. 10th December, 1896. Sir,—Referring to your letter No. 100/Candidates/1709. May I request the favour of the Secretary of State for War for a reply to my letter of 7th August last ? I remain, yours faithfully, Dadabhai Naoroji. The Under-Secretary, War Office, London, S.W.
100/Candidates/1703. War Office, London, S.W. 21st December, 1896. Sir,—With reference to previous correspondence, I am directed by the Secretary of State for War to say that your letter of the 7th August last has received his fullest consideration. I am to acquaint you that in the regulations which govern the admission of candidates to the Army it is clearly laid down that only such candidates as are considered “in all respects suitable to hold a commission in the Army” are eligible. It has been decided that pure European descent is an essential qualification.
I am further to add that there is nothing whatever, either in the Queen’s Proclamation or in the regulations for the admission of university candidates to which you have referred, which could have the effect of obliging the military authorities to grant commissions in the Army to candidates who are not considered suitable.
I have the honour to be, Sir, Your obedient Servant, Arthur Haliburton. D. Naoroji, Esq.
Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, Southfields, S.W. 28th December, 1896.
Sir,—I have received your letter of 21st inst. (100/Candidates/1703).
It appears from your reply that my letter of 7th August last has been misunderstood. Perhaps I have not been clear enough. I briefly recapitulate our correspondence.
I first asked you to furnish me with a copy of the Regulations. You kindly sent me four pamphlets. I read the pamphlets and wrote to you. After quoting the 4th section, under “General Notices” of the paper of the Civil Service Commissioners on the question of the “Nationality” of the candidates, I pointed out that I had not found the qualification of “Nationality” mentioned at all in the pamphlets, and asked whether I was right in understanding that the qualifications given under “General Notices” by the Civil Service Commissioners, applied to the Army examinations, and that they included Indians, as being born in “British dominions” and being thus natural born British subjects.
To this you replied “that candidates for commissions in the British Army must be of pure European descent, and are also required to be British-born or naturalized British subjects.” I thereupon naturally asked you to inform me by what Act of Parliament was this limit laid down for the candidates to the exclusion of other British subjects of her Majesty of other descent and born in her Majesty’s British dominions, such as British India and the Colonies. To this you replied that “the conditions for admission to the Army are not laid down by Act of Parliament but by Regulation, and that the Regulations are to the effect already conveyed to you.”
I then asked : “I have always understood that the only constitutional authority or power for laying down all such conditions is Parliament, and you say that these conditions are not laid down by Act of Parliament. Then what other constitutional authority has the power and has laid down these conditions, according to which the Regulations are made. What I want to know is the name of the constitutional body or power by whose authority such a law is made.” You replied : “That the conditions of admission to the commissioned ranks of the Army are laid down by Regulations made by the Secretary of State for War, under the authority of her Majesty the Queen, as signified by Article I of the Royal Warrant for the Pay, Appointment, Promotion, and Non-effective Pay of the Army.”
I requested, and you kindly informed me, where I could get a copy of the Warrant. I obtained it and then wrote my letter of 7th August last, to which your letter under acknowledgment is the reply. I pointed out in my letter that “In Article I, First Appointments, I do not find a word to exclude British subjects like the Indian British subjects. The candidates are required to be persons duly qualified under Regulations approved by the Secretary of State.” In thus pointing out that the Royal Warrant had not in any way authorised to make any regulations to exclude British Indian subjects, I further said : “Now I cannot suppose that any such regulations can be made constitutionally under the Warrant by the Secretary of State as would supersede any Act of Parliament, or any Proclamations of her Majesty the Queen, but that such regulations can only be made in accordance with Acts of Parliament and Proclamations of the Sovereign. I desire to know whether I am right.” To this the Secretary of State for War has not been pleased to give any reply in your present letter : I beg to ask it again.
For further confirmation of my view, that the Royal Warrant upon which the Regulations are said to be based does not in any way authorise the exclusion of Indian subjects from becoming candidates for commissions in the Army, I cited two points from the Warrant itself : (1) “About the eligibility as candidates of graduates of some of the universities, in which no exclusion is made for British Indian graduates of those universities”; and (2) of “Open competition.” I shall deal with point (1) further on when I shall deal with your present letter. On point (2) of “Open competition” laid down in the Queen’s Warrant itself, the Secretary of State has not been pleased to give any explanation. I beg for it again. After expressing my views that the Warrant gave no authority to exclude Indians, I endeavoured to show that it stood to reason that the Queen’s Warrant could not and would not make any such exclusion. I cited the solemn pledges and actions of both her Majesty and Parliament, and said that “it was impossible to believe that her Majesty’s Warrant could have had the least intention of stultifying and superseding Acts of Parliament and falsifying her Majesty’s own great Proclamations so seriously made to the world on two great and historical occasions.” To this there is no reply, and I beg again the Secretary of State’s attention to this part of my letter of 7th August last, and to explain how and by whom could such Acts and Proclamations be superseded and disregarded.
In your letter under reply, you say : “It has been decided that pure European descent is an essential qualification.” But you do not say who has so decided. Parliament has not so decided, her Majesty has not so decided. Who is this mysterious great potentate, superior to the Queen, and superior to Parliament, who had the authority to decide contrary to the express desire and decisions of the Queen, the Parliament, and the British people, represented by them ?
You further say, “that in the Regulations which govern the admission of candidates to the Army, it is clearly laid down that only such candidates as are considered in all respects suitable to hold a commission in the Army are eligible.”
First of all, the Regulations have no authority to exclude the Indians as I have already explained. Next, even according to your extract, it does not at all follow that the British Indians are excluded. If any of them offer to show themselves and can show themselves “in all respects suitable to hold a commission” by submitting themselves to all the tests and conditions which are required from candidates, they are also eligible. What, then, had anyone the right to exclude Indians altogether, contrary to the authoritative decisions of her Majesty and Parliament? Can any man in his senses believe that out of 225,000,000 of British Indians you will not get a few thousands who are “in all respects suitable to hold a commission in the Army” if fair and honest trial is allowed to them as candidates? Parliament does not believe so— her Majesty does not believe so.
Referring to the second paragraph of your present letter, I never said anything of “obliging the military authorities to grant a commission in the Army to anyone not considered suitable.” My question is not for the “unsuitable” graduates, but for those who offer to prove themselves to be “suitable” under the same conditions as are required from any other candidates. The Royal Warrant does not exclude any section of the graduates of the specified universities. Unauthorised Regulations are of no force.
My last enquiry in my letter of 7th August last has also not been replied to. How is it that a Turk, or a Russian, or any of European descent can by mere naturalization become a candidate; and a British Indian subject, born in her Majesty’s own dominions, and to whom equality is pledged in every honourable and binding manner should be excluded?
I fully trust that the Secretary of State would be good enough to reply to all my enquiries.
The only authoritative rational explanations I have met with are :—
- 1. Lord Salisbury’s direct and significant words, “India must be bled,” and that “all talk of pledges, equality, etc., was political hypocrisy.”
- 2. Lord Lytton has explicitly said with regard to the actions of the authorities that they were “so many deliberate and transparent subterfuges for stultifying the Act and reducing it to a dead letter.” He further says, “I do not hesitate to say that both the Governments of England and India appear to me up to the present moment unable to answer satisfactorily the charge of having taken every means in their power of breaking to the heart the words of promise they had uttered to the ear.”
- 3. A committee of five Members of the Council of the India Office declared as far back as 1860 that the British were exposed to the charge of “keeping promise to the ear and breaking it to the hope.”
I respectfully ask whether the action of the War Office making arbitrary and unauthorised Regulations to exclude the British Indians from the commissions in the Army falls under the above explanations or whether there is any other satisfactory explanation.
I once more sincerely trust that the Secretary of State will be pleased to reply to all my questions.
I remain, your obedient Servant, Dadabhai Naoroji.
The Under-Secretary of State, War Office, London, S.W.
100/Candidates/1745. War Office, London, S.W. 25th January, 1897.
Sir,—I am directed to acknowledge the receipt of your letter of the 28th ultimo, and to express the regret of the Secretary of State for War that my letter of the 21st idem did not impart to you the full information it was intended to convey.
In reference to the doubts which you apparently entertain as to the authority under which the Regulations for admission to the Army are made, I am to call your attention to the preamble of the “Royal Warrant for Pay, Promotion, etc.,” from which you will learn that such Warrant has the express sanction of her Majesty the Queen, and that the Secretary of State for War is appointed by her Majesty to be “the sole administrator and interpreter” thereof, and “empowered to issue such detailed instructions in reference thereto as he may from time to time deem necessary.”
The detailed instructions governing the grant of commissions in the Army are made by the Secretary of State under the above authority, and are, as you are already aware, to be found in paragraph 1 of the Regulations for admission to the Royal Military College, Sandhurst, and to the Royal Military Academy, Woolwich, when read in conjunction with Appendix I. to those Regulations.
I am, Sir, your obedient Servant, D. Naoroji, Esq. Arthur Haliburton.
Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, Southfields, S.W. 26th January, 1897.
Sir,—I have received your letter of 25th inst. (No. 100/ Candidates/1745).
I am sorry to trouble the Secretary of State again because my enquiry remains just as much unanswered as before. In my letter of 7th August last my very first question is this :—
“Now I cannot suppose that any such regulations can be made constitutionally under the Warrant by the Secretary of State as would supersede any Act of Parliament or any Proclamation of her Majesty the Queen; but that such regulations can only be made in accordance with Acts of Parliament and Proclamations of the Sovereign. I desire to know whether I am right.”
To this question I have yet received no reply. If I am right, then the Secretary of State has no right or powers to exercise such absolute power as he claims in your present letter. No executive officer has any despotic powers to make any regulations which can at all contravene any Act of Parliament or Proclamation of the Queen sanctioned by Parliament. I, therefore, submit that the Secretary of State has no power or authority whatever to exclude British-Indian subjects.
The Secretary of State by claiming such powers as your letter assumes, exposes her Majesty and Parliament to the charge of un-English hypocrisy, i.e., that her Majesty on the one hand proclaims to the world repeatedly that British-Indian subjects are exactly like the British subjects, and on the other hand stultifies and breaks her own pledges by giving to the Secretary of State authority to disregard her Proclamations. The same charge will apply to Parliament for allowing such a thing. I anticipated this in my letter of 7th August last, when I said, after citing the Acts and Proclamations :—
“That our Gracious Sovereign and the British people, whose voice and desires she represents, could have been anything but sincere in her Proclamations cannot be admitted for a moment, and it is impossible to believe that her Majesty’s Warrant could have had the least intention of stultifying and superseding Acts of Parliament and falsifying her Majesty’s own great Proclamations, so seriously made before the world on two great and historical occasions.”
The fact is that the Warrant gives no such power or authority to make any regulations contrary to Acts or Proclamations. Every power given to any executive officer is subordinate to and restricted by Acts of Parliament and Proclamations of the Queen, unless the Secretary of State means to attribute to her Majesty and Parliament mean political hypocrisy. I therefore ask again my very first question in my letter of 7th August last, which I have quoted above, and in this letter I restrict myself to that question.
I am, your obedient Servant, Dadabhai Naoroji.
The Under-Secretary of State, War Office, London, S.W.
Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, Southfields, S.W. 12th May, 1897.
Sir,—I shall feel much obliged by being favoured with the reply to my letter of 26th January, 1897.
I am, your obedient Servant, Dadabhai Naoroji.
The Under-Secretary of State, War Office, London, S.W.
100/Candidates/1786.
War Office, London, S.W. 25th May, 1897.
Sir,—With reference to your letter of the 12th inst., requesting that a reply may be sent to your letter of the 26th January last, I am directed by the Secretary of State for War to acquaint you that he has nothing to add to the various communications which have been already made to you relative to candidates for commissions in the British Army.
I am, Sir, your obedient Servant, Arthur Haliburton.
Dadabhai Naoroji, Esq., Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, Southfields, S.W.
Washington House, 72, Anerley Park, S.E. 16th January, 1900.
Sir,—Referring to your letter of 10th June, 1896, in which you inform me that “candidates for commissions in the British Army must be of pure European descent, and are also required to be British born or naturalized British subjects,” I have to request you to kindly inform me whether any alteration has been made in the rule above cited; if so, kindly inform what it is.
Yours obediently, Dadabhai Naoroji. The Under-Secretary of State, War Office, Pall Mall, S.W.
No. 100/Candidates/2097. War Office, London, S.W. 23rd January, 1900.
Sir,—I am directed by the Secretary of State for War to acknowledge the receipt of your letter of the 16th inst., and to acquaint you in reply that no change has been made in the regulations which require that candidates for commissions in the British Army must be of pure European descent, and must also be British born or naturalized British subjects.
I have the honour to be, etc., etc., G. Fleetwood Wilson. Dadabhai Naoroji, Esq., Washington House, 72, Anerley Park, S.E.
Copies of Correspondence between the Admiralty and Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji.
IX.
Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, S.W. 5th June, 1896.
Sir,—I find in the paper for “Examinations held under the direction of the Civil Service Commissioners,” which the Secretary has been good enough to supply me, that I have to apply to you for a copy of the Regulations for “Examinations for the Navy.”
May I request you to supply me with a copy of these Regulations?
I remain, yours faithfully, Secretary, Dadabhai Naoroji. Admiralty, London, S.W.
N. Admiralty, 8th June, 1896.
Sir,—I have received and laid before My Lords Commissioners of the Admiralty your letter of the 5th instant, and in forwarding a copy of the Regulations for entering the Royal Navy as an assistant clerk, etc., I am to acquaint you that the power of nominating candidates is vested in the hands of the First Lord of the Admiralty, to whose private secretary all applications for nominations should be addressed.
The regulations for the entry of surgeons and engineers are to follow.
I am, Sir, your obedient Servant, Evan Macgregor. Dadabhai Naoroji, Esq., Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, S.W.
Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, S.W. 14th June, 1896.
Sir,—I am much obliged for your letter of 8th inst. (N.), enclosing papers for examinations in connexion with the Navy.
In the paper of Civil Service Commissioners to which I referred in my last letter I find under the heading “General Notices,” among the qualifications of candidates, Section 4, as follows:—
“4.—Nationality: A person born in a foreign country who can prove that his father or his paternal grandfather was born in British Dominions is, if he has not expatriated himself under the Naturalization Act of 1870, admissible as a natural-born British subject to all open competitions; which he is in other respects qualified to enter, except those for Student Interpreterships.”
I do not find this qualification of “nationality” mentioned in the papers you have been good enough to send me. You will oblige me much by informing me whether I am right in understanding that the qualifications given under “General Notices” by the Civil Service Commissioners apply to the examinations for the Navy, and that therefore Indians of British India are included as being born in “British Dominions,” and being thus “natural-born British subjects.”
I remain, your obedient Servant, Dadabhai Naoroji.
The Secretary, Admiralty, London, S.W.
N.
Admiralty, 6th July, 1896.
Sir,—In reply to your letter of the 14th ultimo, relative to the qualifications as regards nationality of candidates for entry in the Royal Navy, I am commanded by my Lords Commissioners of the Admiralty to acquaint you that appointments in the Civil Service, which are under the Regulations of the Civil Service Commissioners, are subject to the terms of the paragraph respecting nationality in the “General Notices” of the Civil Service Commissioners, to which you refer in your letter, but appointments in the Royal Navy are not governed by these Regulations.
I am, Sir, your obedient Servant, R. D. Awdry. Dadabhai Naoroji, Esq., Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, S.W.
Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, Wandsworth, S.W. 9th July, 1896.
Sir,—I beg to acknowledge with thanks the receipt of your letter of 6th inst. (N.) informing me “that appointments in the Civil Service, which are under the Regulations of the Civil Service Commissioners, are subject to the terms of the paragraph respecting Nationality in the ‘General Notices’ of the Civil Service Commissioners to which you refer in your letter, but appointments in the Royal Navy are not governed by these Regulations.”
I have therefore to request you to oblige me further by informing me by what Regulations these appointments to the Royal Navy are governed, and according to what Act of Parliament are any regulations laid down with regard to the nationality of the candidates for the Royal Navy.
I am, Sir, your obedient Servant, Dadabhai Naoroji. The Secretary, Admiralty, Whitehall, S.W.
N. Admiralty, 16th July, 1896.
Sir,—In reply to your letter of the 9th instant.
I am commanded by my Lords Commissioners of the Admiralty to acquaint you that appointments to the Royal Navy are not governed by Act of Parliament, but by Regulations laid down by the Lords Commissioners of the Admiralty in virtue of the powers conferred on them by Patent.
I am, Sir, your obedient Servant, Evan Macgregor. Dadabhai Naoroji, Esq., Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, Wandsworth, S.W.
Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, Wandsworth, S.W. 17th July, 1896.
Sir,—I have received your letter of the 16th inst. (N.) and thank you for informing me that appointments to the Royal Navy are governed by Regulations laid down by the Lords Commissioners of the Admiralty in virtue of the Powers conferred on them by Patent.
May I request you to inform me where I can get a copy of this “Patent” or to furnish me with a copy ? I remain, your obedient Servant, Dadabhai Naoroji. The Secretary, Admiralty, Whitehall, London, S.W.
N.
Admiralty, 25th July, 1896.
Sir,—In reply to your letter of the 17th instant, I am commanded by my Lords Commissioners of the Admiralty to acquaint you that the Patent of the Board of Admiralty will be found in the report of the Royal Commission upon the Administration of the Army and the Navy, Parliamentary Paper C-5979 of 1890.
I am, Sir, your obedient Servant, Evan Macgregor. Dadabhai Naoroji, Esq., Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, Wandsworth, S.W.
Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, Southfields, S.W. 8th August, 1896.
Sir,—I thank you for your letter of 25th ult. (N). I have obtained copy of Parliamentary Paper C-5979 of 1890.
In my letter of 14th June last I requested you to inform me “whether I am right in understanding that the qualifications given under ‘General Notices’ by the Civil Service Commissioners apply to the Examinations for the Navy, and that therefore Indians of British India are included, as being born in ‘British dominions’ and being thus ‘natural-born British subjects.’”
To this you did not favour me with a direct reply, but in your reply of (N) 6th ult., you informed me that “appointments in the Royal Navy are not governed by these Regulations.” In your letter (N.) of 16th ult. you informed me “that appointments to the Royal Navy are not governed by Act of Parliament, but by Regulations laid down by the Lords Commissioners of the Admiralty in virtue of the powers conferred on them by Patent.”
I may here offer my sincere thanks for all the replies you have sent me, to the Lords Commissioners of the Admiralty; and I now beg further indulgence and favour to give me some further explanations on the matter that I need.
I have seen the Patent in the Return above mentioned, and I find nothing therein to exclude the British Indian subjects from the cadetships in the Navy.
And it stands to reason that it could not be otherwise. I cannot suppose that under the British Constitutional Government any Patent would be issued, or any Regulation would be made by any Department, in supersession or invalidation of any Act of Parliament, or any public Proclamations of the Queen; and the Patent very properly does not seem to do anything of the kind.
The Act of Parliament of 1833 enacted that no Native of the said territory (meaning India), nor any natural-born subject of his Majesty resident therein, shall, by reason only of his religion, place of birth or descent, or any of them, be disabled from holding any place, office or employment under the said Company.
Now, all the powers, duties and responsibilities of the Company are transferred to the Queen by another Act of Parliament of 1858, and the entire exclusion of the considerations of religion, place of birth or descent, has remained as binding now as it was by the Act of 1833, for any place, office or employment under her Majesty. Not only did Parliament not repeal or amend the clause of the Act of 1833, but in far more emphatic and explicit terms the Sovereign issued a Proclamation, strongly and explicitly confirming, and in the most solemn manner pledging before God and man, with an invocation of the blessing of God, placing her Indian subjects on exactly the same footing as all her Majesty’s other subjects, in these clear words :—
“ We hold ourselves bound to the Natives of our Indian territory by the same obligations of duty which bind us to all our other subjects ; and these obligations by the blessing of Almighty God we shall faithfully and conscientiously fulfil.”
“ And it is our further will that so far as may be, our subjects, of whatever race or creed, be freely and impartially admitted to offices in our service the duties of which they may be qualified by their education, ability and integrity duly to discharge.”
“ In their prosperity will be our strength, in their contentment our security, and in their gratitude our best reward. And may the God of all power grant to us, and to those in authority under us, strength to carry out these our wishes for the good of our people.”
Nothing can be clearer than that British-Indian subjects are most solemnly and honourably pledged to be exactly like all other British subjects.
In 1887, on the occasion of the Great Jubilee, the Queen and Empress of India again confirmed her Proclamation of 1858 in these clear words :—
“ It had always been, and will always be, her earnest desire to maintain unswervingly the principles laid down in the Proclamation published on her assumption of the direct control of the government of India.”
I do not see, therefore, how it is possible that the Queen would intend in this Patent anything contrary not only to Acts of Parliament but to her own most gracious and explicit Proclamations of 1858 and 1887. That our gracious Sovereign and the British people, whose will and desire she represents, could have been anything but sincere in her Proclamations cannot be admitted for a moment, and it is impossible to believe that her Majesty’s Patent could have had the least intention of stultifying and superseding Acts of Parliament and falsifying her Majesty’s own great Proclamations so seriously made to the world on two great and historical occasions.
There is this further indication. I find that in the spirit of and in accordance with the Acts of 1833 and 1858 and the Proclamations of 1858 and 1887 all the Civil Services of the United Kingdom in every department—civil, military, and naval—are open to the British-Indian subjects. There are, no doubt, some flaws in the rules and their execution which I cannot refer to in this letter ; but the fact is there, that all the Civil Services of the United Kingdom are open to the British-Indian subjects to the same extent as to any other British subjects.
You yourself have been good enough to point out to me in your letter (N., 6th July last) “that appointments in the Civil Service, which are under the regulations of the Civil Service Commissioners, are subject to the terms of the paragraph respecting nationality in the ‘General Notices’ of the Civil Service Commissioners to which you refer in your letter.”
I shall, therefore, be much obliged by informing me that the cadetships in the Navy are as open to British-Indian subjects as they are to all other British subjects of her Majesty. If not I shall be thankful for an explanation for the exclusion of British-Indian subjects, contrary to Acts of Parliament, confirmed and proclaimed by two great Proclamations of her Majesty the Queen.
I remain, your obedient Servant, Dadabhai Naoroji.
The Secretary, Admiralty, Whitehall, London, S.W.
N. Admiralty, S.W. 10th August, 1896.
Sir,—I have laid before My Lords Commissioners of the Admiralty your letter of the 8th inst. respecting Naval cadetships for British-Indian subjects.
I am, Sir, your obedient Servant, Evan Macgregor.
Dadabhai Naoroji, Esq., Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, Southfields, S.W.
Admiralty, Whitehall. 13th August, 1896.
Sir,—I have received and read your letter of the 8th inst. I must demur to your arguments and conclusions; but after all the discussion between us is only academical, as no application for a cadetship for a Native of India has been made to me during my tenure of office, nor is any one now before me.
If there were I should, in accordance with the practice of my predecessors, and with the unlimited right which I possess to exercise an unfettered choice, select such boys among the whole of the applicants as seemed most likely to me from their antecedents, their surroundings, their physical attributes and other considerations, to become the most efficient officers, with the greatest prospect of being successful in leading and governing British seamen.
That is the responsibility which rests upon me, and which I should do my best to discharge.
I am, yours very faithfully, George J. Goschen.
Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, Southfields, S.W. 16th August, 1896.
Sir,—I feel exceedingly thankful for your reply of 13th inst. As I do not know the reasons of your demur to my arguments and conclusions, I cannot say anything about it.
It is not a mere academical matter. It is of the most vital importance to the Indians, and I may say to England also. Honest fulfilment, or non-fulfilment of the pledges of the Acts and Proclamations, makes all the difference between Indians’ British Citizenship and British Slavery, between prosperity and “bleeding” poverty, between the blessing and the curse of British Rule, between honour and dishonour of the British name, between the loyalty and disloyalty of the Indians, and between the stability and instability of the British Indian Empire which in reality is mainly the British Empire.
But your kind and straight letter makes it unnecessary for me to say anything more upon this matter. Your letter shows, if I understand it rightly, that the Indian-British subjects are not to be excluded from the Navy on account of their nationality, race or creed, but that their applications will be fairly and honestly treated for fitness as those of any British-born subjects.
That no application has been hitherto made is owing to the firm belief among the Indians that they are excluded on account of their nationality, not only from all the higher ranks but even from the lower ranks of seamen, stoker, etc. One venturesome Parsee (Mr. Pirozshaw Dorabji) however, notwithstanding this belief, prepared himself at Hull, to make himself fit for a sea life and for a stokership—and applied to the Admiralty for employment as stoker. I have not the papers before me and I write from memory. But you will be able to verify by seeing the correspondence that has taken place. I think no objection was taken as to his fitness, but the final reply was, I think, that Europeans were preferred, or something to that effect.
Further the Admiralty asks from India a contribution of £100,000 per year, but it does not seem to see, that if India is a partner in the Empire and not a slave, the Indians ought in all fairness to have a return in the employment of the Indians to the extent of the amount of their share. This incident further confirms the belief that the Admiralty does not mean to treat India fairly as a partner and as entitled to a fair share in the Imperial Services in proportion to their part. This incident, I mention simply in illustration. It is a large and very important subject, and I do not think it would be appropriate for me to intrude it in this correspondence.
As the misapprehension of exclusion is removed by your kind letter, I would request your further consideration with regard to one point in connexion therewith. Your assurance needs some clear statement as to what qualifications will be considered necessary for fitness. You will, I have no doubt, at once see this need. The Indians are unfairly and heavily handicapped under present arrangements, by not being able to apply on spot for first appointments, as the people of the United Kingdom are; and before the Indians come over all the distance from India to England, under several difficulties, they must be able to see whether they possess the necessary qualifications and can calculate upon fair chances of success.
For instance, with regard to the different Civil Services of both the United Kingdom and India, the necessary qualifications are laid down; and even handicapped as the Indians are with the necessity of coming over here, they know what to expect; just the same for Law, Medicine, Universities, Colleges, Engineering or other professions.
They will abide by whatever the standards and kinds of qualifications there may be for any employment. All that is needed is that they should know before leaving India what will be required of them for admission.
I am, yours very faithfully, Dadabhai Naoroji. Rt. Hon. G. J. Goschen, First Lord of the Admiralty.
Admiralty, Whitehall, 24th August, 1896.
Sir,—In reply to your letter of the 16th inst., I feel bound to say that I think you have failed to appreciate the drift of my letter, or to draw the natural inferences from it.
I called the discussion of the general arguments from Proclamations, etc., “academical” as regards the point of the admission of Indian-born boys as cadets into the Naval Service, because no one has a right to a nomination, the selection of candidates resting entirely with the First Lord of the Admiralty.
A discussion therefore as to rights becomes “academical.”
I further explained how my choice would be guided by my wish to secure officers who would be best qualified to govern British seamen. I must frankly say that I was under the impression that the words I used would lead you to infer that preference would be given to those of British parentage.
I cannot for one moment admit that the, to my mind, very small contribution of India to the cost of the Navy, viz., £100,000 or so, towards a total expenditure of some £22,000,000, establishes any kind of claim to admission to the ranks of the Navy. It is a contribution in respect of protection given, and nothing else.
Generally speaking, the Regulations of the Navy in respect to the parentage of those who are to be admitted to the various ranks approximate to those of the Army and have been in force for many years.
I am, Sir, yours very faithfully, George J. Goschen.
Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, Southfields, S.W. 28th August, 1896.
Sir,—I have received your letter of 24th inst.
I shall not at present say anything about the academical discussion. Nor is the present correspondence fit to discuss the important question of the exaction of £100,000 from India without any voice of the Indians. Small or large amount is not material. Whether India is partner or slave in the Empire—that is the question. But that discussion must rest at present. I had mentioned this simply as an illustrative incident about the belief in India that the British Indians were absolutely excluded, on account of their nationality, no matter however qualified they may be. And after all your present letter shows that the belief was well founded.
In your first letter of 13th inst. you directed my attention to the fact that no application had been made by an Indian. Then you pointed out (if such an application were made) that you would follow the practice of your predecessors, and with the unlimited right which you possessed to exercise an unfettered choice, you would select such boys among the whole1 of the applicants as seemed most likely to you from their antecedents, their surroundings, their physical attributes and other considerations to secure the most efficient officers with the greatest prospect of being successful in leading and governing British seamen. You did not say what the practice of your predecessors was. You said only what you would do. You stated the qualifications about the whole of the applicants, but not a word about entire disqualification of Indians on account of their nationality alone, though this reply was to my questions, which were distinctly directed, as follows, to that particular point of “nationality.”
First.—In my letter of 14th June last, I asked :—
“I do not find this qualification of ‘Nationality’ mentioned in the papers you have been good enough to send me. You will oblige me much by informing me whether I am right in understanding that the qualifications given under ‘General Notices’ by the Civil Service Commissioners apply to the examinations for the Navy, and that therefore Indians of British India are included as being born in British dominions and being thus natural-born British subjects.” The qualification especially referred to by me was clearly mentioned to be that of “ Nationality.”
To this my first enquiry you did not favour me with a direct reply.
Second.—In my letter of 8th inst. I again as pointedly made my enquiry as follows : “ I shall therefore be much obliged by informing me that the cadetships in the Navy are as open to British-Indian subjects as they are to all other British subjects of her Majesty.”
In your reply of 13th inst. to this enquiry, there was not a word said that Indians were positively excluded as Indians. On the contrary, as I have stated above, you laid all stress upon qualifications for fitness. If Indians were disqualified by their “ Nationality,” the reply of 13th inst. had no meaning—as laying stress upon qualifications of fitness, unlimited right of selection, unfettered choice, etc., etc.
Your present letter of 24th inst. is again as puzzling. You say that “ no one has a right to a ‘ nomination.’ ” I did not ask or claim any such right, any more than any other British subject had.
You say “ the selection of candidates rests entirely with the First Lord of the Admiralty.” But really this must be certainly on some definite principles, and founded upon and ordered by some constitutional authority (which has not been pointed out in your letter), and not on the mere absolute whim or the despotic will of the First Lord, as if he were an Oriental despot. But what is still stranger is, that if an Indian is excluded because he is an Indian, and if the First Lord has positively determined not to consider any Indian application, what was the good of telling the Indian that he would consider the whole of the applicants. You say : “ I further explained how my choice would be guided by my wish to secure officers who would be best qualified to govern British seamen.” This shows that it was certain qualifications you wanted in each individual applicant, and not a decided exclusion of an Indian if he possessed the qualifications. But if you left yourself no choice, and would give no consideration to an Indian applicant, what was the good of telling him about how your choice was to be guided ?
You say : “ I frankly say that I was under the impression that the words I used would lead you to infer that preference would be given to those of British parentage.” “Preference” would mean that if there were an Indian and a British applicant of equal merits “preference” would be given to the British. But even of the “preference” of British parentage there was no clear indication in your letter of 13th inst. But even supposing that such an inference was possible, then if the Indian was wholly and absolutely excluded as an Indian “preference” is only an idle word and means nothing.
Thus you will see that the matter is still left vague in your present letter of 24th inst.
I again put the question directly.
Is the Indian to be excluded on the ground of his nationality or not? It is desirable that such a vital matter to above two hundreds of millions of British subjects should not rest on mere misleading and vague “drifts,” “inferences,” or “impressions,” but must be clear in statement.
In the last sentence of your letter, where there is something like a clear statement, though under cover, the matter is still left vague. You say: “Generally speaking the Regulations of the Navy in respect of the parentage of those who are to be admitted to the various ranks approximate to those of the Army and have been in force for many years.” A wrong does not become a right by being enforced.
However, you have not favoured me as to what these Regulations of the Army are, and your words “generally speaking” and “approximate” still leave a certain vagueness as if the Regulations of the Navy and Army were not quite alike.
I have a reply from the War Office. That reply, however unconstitutional and unauthorised, un-British and dishonourable to solemn pledges it appears to me, is at least direct and clear and not left to mere impressions or inferences. This reply is “that candidates for commissions in the British Army must be of pure European descent, and are also required to be British-born or naturalized British subjects.”
Now I request you kindly to inform me whether in the Navy also there is exactly, as above, the same absolute and complete exclusion of British Indians as in the Army, so that the matter may be dealt with in its true character. If the exclusion in the Navy is exactly like that in the Army then all that is said about “preference,” “qualification,” “exercise of unlimited right of selection,” “fitness,” “no applications had been received from Indians,” and leaving matters to “drifts,” “impressions,” and “inferences” would appear to be mere excuse and of no good or use.
Kindly make the matter clear, whatever it may be.
I am informed that there were or are some Japanese in the Navy. I do not know whether this is true. If it is so I would be obliged to be informed what their position was or is.
I remain, yours very faithfully, Dadabhai Naoroji.
Rt. Hon. G. J. Goschen, First Lord of the Admiralty, Whitehall, S.W.
Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, Southfields, S.W. 5th December, 1896.
Sir,—I have addressed a letter to you on the 28th August last.
I shall feel obliged for reply to it.
I remain, yours faithfully, Dadabhai Naoroji.
Rt. Hon. G. J. Goschen, First Lord of the Admiralty, Whitehall, S.W.
Admiralty, Whitehall. 8th December, 1896.
Sir,—In reply to your letter of the 28th August allow me to say in all courtesy that you seem to me to be endeavouring to create a grievance—while none, to my knowledge, has existed hitherto—by your efforts to draw from me an unnecessary declaration.
I have nothing to add to my previous letters—which appear to me to be perfectly intelligible to anyone who wishes to understand them—beyond pointing out to you, in reply to one of your questions, that the regulations which govern admission to various branches in the Navy and Army are accessible to the public, and will furnish you with the means of testing the statements I made to you with regard to them. I regret that I cannot undertake to continue this correspondence.
I am, Sir, yours very faithfully, George J. Goschen.
Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, Southfields, S.W. 10th December, 1896.
Sir,—I have received your letter of the 8th inst., and I am very sorry I am forced to trouble you again. I am not going into any argument upon your letter. But there seems to me some misunderstanding, and I shall feel much obliged by its being cleared up by you. The question is simply this, and to which the War Office has given a direct reply : Is the Navy open to British-Indian subjects, as it is open to the inhabitants of the United Kingdom ; or is it not—the regulations being the same for all ?
The reason for a reply is twofold. The Indians then will know whether they should apply or not at all. Secondly, it is necessary for me that, as a witness before the Royal Commission on Indian Expenditure, I should reply with correct knowledge of facts.
There are other points of great importance connected with the Navy in its relations with India, but I should not trouble you at present with these.
I remain, yours faithfully, Dadabhai Naoroji.
Rt. Hon. G. J. Goschen, First Lord of the Admiralty, Whitehall.
Admiralty, Whitehall, 15th December, 1896.
Sir,—Mr. Goschen desires me to acknowledge the receipt of your letter of the 10th inst., and in reply to point out that your original questions related to the admission of Indian subjects as Commissioned Officers in H.M. Navy, and Mr. Goschen’s answers have been directed to that point.
You now ask generally whether the Navy is open to British-Indian subjects, as it is open to the inhabitants of the United Kingdom. To this his answer is in the negative.
I remain, Sir, yours faithfully, W. Graham Greene. Dadabhai Naoroji, Esq.
Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, Southfields, S.W. 16th December, 1896.
Sir,—I am very much obliged for your direct reply in the “negative” to my question in yesterday’s letter. But I am sorry to find that you have yet left doubtful whether in your “negative” the question of “the admission of Indian subjects as Commissioned Officers in H.M.’s Navy” is included. I shall be thankful to have this cleared up, as the War Office has done. You are aware that the chief object of my enquiry was about the admission of Indian subjects as Commissioned Officers in H.M.’s Navy.
I remain, yours faithfully, Dadabhai Naoroji. Rt. Hon. G. J. Goschen, First Lord of the Admiralty, Whitehall.
Admiralty, Whitehall. 18th December, 1896.
Sir,—Mr. Goschen having informed you in his letter of the 8th December that he could not undertake to continue the correspondence on the subject of the admission of Indian subjects as Commissioned Officers in H.M. Navy, only consented to reply to your letter of the 10th December inasmuch as your further enquiry was directed to the Navy as a whole.
Having answered this question, Mr. Goschen must again decline to renew the correspondence on a subject which he considers to have been definitely closed.
I remain, Sir, yours faithfully, W. Graham Greene. Dadabhai Naoroji, Esq.
Cambridge Lodge, West Hill Road, Southfields, S.W. 19th December, 1896.
Sir,—I have received your letter of yesterday that our correspondence on the subject of the fact of the admission of Indian subjects as Commissioned Officers in her Majesty’s Navy is definitely closed.
Now that hereafter you may not blame me again as you have done before about the interpretations of your impressions, inferences, etc., it is necessary for me, as I have no doubt you yourself in justice will admit, to state unambiguously what I understand as the end of our correspondence. The end is that every British-Indian subject, on account of his nationality, is entirely excluded and disqualified to be admitted as Commissioned Officer in H.M.’s Navy.
This point being ended, I have now to ask your considerate attention to my letter of 8th August last.
In the last paragraph of that letter I have said : “I shall therefore be much obliged by informing me that the cadetships in the Navy are as open to British-Indian subjects as they are to all other British subjects of her Majesty."
To this part of my enquiry you have now closed the correspondence as stated above, i.e., in the “negative."
There remains now the second part of my enquiry, and for which I crave your reply. I said next in the same paragraph :—
“If not I shall be thankful for an explanation for the exclusion of British-Indian subjects, contrary to Acts of Parliament confirmed and proclaimed by two great Proclamations of her Majesty the Queen."
I shall feel very much obliged indeed for a clear explanation of this second, new question.
I remain, Sir, yours faithfully, Dadabhai Naoroji.
Rt. Hon. G. J. Goschen, First Lord of the Admiralty, Whitehall.
TABLE, &c., SHOWING EXPENDITURE ON WARS BEYOND THE INDIAN FRONTIERS.
| Rupees. | ||
|---|---|---|
| I.—The Afghan War | 223,110,0001 | Sir Evelyn Baring, Financial Member of the Viceroy’s Council. |
| II.—Military Railways on the North-West Frontier since the War. | 163,967,9102 | Administrative Reports on Railways in India. |
| III.—Beluchistan Agency since the War. Government Allotment, Rs.865,600 per annum, for sixteen years. | 13,849,600 | Moral and Material Progress of India, 1893-94, p. 157. |
| IV.—Special Grants to Beluchistan Agency— Reservoir in Pishin . . . Rs. 261,240 Quetta Water Works . . . 499,000 Buildings at Quetta . . . 374,000 | 1,134,240 | Financial Statements— 1889-90, p. 15, par. 31. 1891-92, p. 23, par. 16. 1892-93, p. 32, par. 84. |
| V.—Lease of Quetta District, and subsidy in lieu of right to collect tolls in the Bolan Pass since 1883. | 715,000 | Progress and Condition of India, 1891-92, p. 15. |
| VI.—Preparations for War with Russia in 1885 | 22,880,710 | Official Estimate. Return, dated India Office, 8th June, 1894. |
| VII.—Special Defence Works on Frontier and Rawal Pindi. | 30,000,0003 | Approximate. |
| VIII.—Military Roads on North-West Frontier; expended principally on the Dera Ghazi Khan and Pishin road. | 2,000,0004 | Financial Statement—1888-89, p. 10. |
| IX.—Afghan Boundary Commissions | 1,700,000 | Financial Statements — 1885-86, p. 22, par. 52; 1894-95, p. 27, par 118. |
| X.—Permanent Increase of Indian Army in 1885-6— A. 10,753 British Troops Rs. 95,809,200 B. 19,220 Native Troops 65,924,600 C. Deferred Pay of above British Troops 553,000 | 162,286,800 | Official Estimate. Return, dated India Office, 8th June, 1894. |
| XI.—Increase in the Native Pension Establishment, due to the Afghan War, Waziri and Chitral Campaigns, and other Expeditions on North-West Frontier. | 18,591,300 | Approximate. |
| XII.—Cost to Government of Imperial Service Troops | 1,400,000 | Progress and Condition of India, 1894-5, p. 169. |
| XIII.—Re-establishment and Maintenance of British Agency at Gilgit— A. For three years, at the rate of Rs. 50,000 a year . . Rs. 150,000 B. For four years at the rate of Rs. 200,000 a year . . 800,000 C. Special Grant . . 90,000 D. „ . . 481,500 E. Transport . . 784,000 F. „ . . 300,000 G. „ . . 400,000 | 3,005,500 | Blue Book, Chitral, p. 20. Financial Statements— 1893-94, p. 7, par 11. 1894-95, p. 21, par 83. 1893-94, p. 7, par. 11. 1893-94, p. 13, par 24. 1894-95, p. 28, par 121. |
| XIV.—Re-occupation of the Kuram Valley in 1892-93, at Rs. 450,000, per annum for three years. | 1,350,000 | Financial Statement—1893-94, p. 7, par. 11. |
| XV.—Grants for so-called Mobilisation— A. 1889 . . . . Rs. 2,035,000 B. 1890 . . . . 600,000 C. 1891 . . . . 2,134,000 D. 1892 . . . . 616,000 | 5,385,0001 | Financial Statements— 1889-90, p. 24, par 57. 1890-91, p. 8. par. 12. 1892-93, p. 8, par. 13. 1892-93, p. 32, par. 84. |
| XVI.—Additional Transport Animals, Remounts, and Mules— A. 1891 . . . . Rs. 1,321,000 B. 1893 . . . . 267,000 C. 1894 . . . . 237,000 | 1,825,0002 | Financial Statements— 1892-93, p. 8, par. 13. 1894-95, p. 6, par. 9. 1894-95, p. 28, par. 121. |
| XVII.—Rise in price of food, forage, and increase of number of animals to be fed— A. 1889 . . . . Rs. 795,000 B. 1892 . . . . 1,500,000 C. 1893 . . . . 700,000 D. 1894 . . . . 490,000 | 3,485,000 | Financial Statements— 1889-90, p. 24, par 57. 1893-94, p. 7, par. 11. 1893-94, p. 27, par. 63. 1894-95, p. 28, par. 121. |
| XVIII.—Expeditions on North-West Frontier since 1888-89 | 5,075,680 | Official Estimate. Return, dated, India Office, 8th June, 1894. |
| XIX.—Minor operations (not scheduled) since 1884-85 | 3,239,100 | Official Estimate. |
| XX.—Waziri Campaign, including cost of Delimitation Commission, Fortified Post and Tochi Cantonments. | 3,824,000 | Financial Statements— 1895-96, p. 15, par. 50, and p. 56, par. 200. 1896-97, p. 34, par. 132. |
| XXI.—Chitral Campaign, including occupation of Chitral during past and present year. | 21,500,000 | Financial Statement—1896-97, p. 7, par. 11, and footnote. |
| XXII.—Khyber Rifles raised after the War | 1,398,240 | Progress and Condition of India, 1891-92, p. 17. |
| XXIII.—Subsidies— | ||
| A. Amir of Afghanistan since the War . . Rs. 21,000,000 | 22,857,400 | 13 years at 12 lakhs, 3 at 18 lakhs. |
| B. Khyberies Afghanistan since the War . . 1,400,640 | Progress and Condition of India, 1891-92, p. 17. | |
| C. Ruler of Chitral and his brothers . . . . 60,000 | Chitral Blue Book, pp. 9 and 13. | |
| D. Gomal Chiefs since 1890 . . . . . 296,760 | Progress and Condition of India, 1891-92, p. 17. | |
| E. Other small Chiefs on N.-W. Frontier . . 100,000 | Progress and Condition of India, 1891-92, pp. 16 and 18. | |
| Total Rupees | 714,580,480 |
COST OF THE FORWARD POLICY.
[Extract from Colonel Hanna’s “Backwards and Forwards,” Chap. III.]
1. The above table contains the official confession of the cost of the Forward Policy to the people of India, a confession that is very far from telling the whole tale of cruel exactions and dangerous waste which is the true history of that policy.
2. Take, for instance, the first item in that table, the cost of the Afghan War—Rs. 223,110,000—and see how it expands in the light of Major Evelyn Baring’s admission, in his Financial Statement of the year 1882-83, that “it cannot be doubted that a great deal of the expenditure debited to the ordinary (military) account really belongs to the war,” and that money spent “by reason of it”—the war—“was set down among civil charges.” In proof of this latter assertion he adduced the fact that the Punjab Northern State Railway, the construction of which had to be hurried on for the purpose of moving up troops and supplies, cost, on that account, considerably more than it otherwise would have done, and yet not a rupee of this enhanced price was debited to war expenditure ;1 but he made no mention of the large sums spent, during the three years the war lasted, by the political officers in buying the services or the neutrality of the tribesmen, either individually or collectively, along the three lines of advance, nor yet of the cost of those political officers themselves, taken from their Indian appointments, yet still drawing their pay from the Civil List, though both these forms of expenditure were due to the war.
3. There is nothing to surprise us in these deceptive classifications : they are the natural outcome of the desire to minimise the cost of a policy which runs counter to the wishes and interests of the people who have to pay for it; and they are as common as they are natural, vitiating the official figures for all the frontier expeditions and minor operations, just as much as they falsify those of the Afghan War. One proof of this, but that a very glaring one, must suffice.
4. During a period of ten years—from 1885 to 1895—great activity prevailed all along our frontier, from Quetta to Gilgit, from Sikkim to Burma, the expeditions and operations on its North-West section alone admittedly absorbing Rs. 52,569,500. In reality they cost considerably more.
5. In the Financial Statement for the year 1888-89, Rs. 2,035,000 were set down to mobilization—an entirely new item of expenditure —which was thus explained and defended by Sir David Barbour, then the Financial Member of Council : “The Rs. 2,035,000 on account of mobilization is intended to meet the cost of purchasing transport animals, provisions, and equipment, so that, in case of need, an army corps may be in a position to take the field promptly. This is one of those precautions which in the present day of scientific warfare cannot be neglected. The greater portion of the cost will be incurred once and for all, and will not recur.”2 The Rs. 2,035,000 proved insufficient for the purpose in view, and the Financial Statement for 1890-91 contained a further provision of Rs. 600,000, “to complete the arrangements and preparations to facilitate mobilization.”
6. To people of my views, the need of providing for the mobilization of an army corps, for service across the frontier, was not apparent; but we derived a certain amount of comfort from the assurance that the process, unnecessary as we thought it, and expensive as it certainly was, had been completed, and we noted with satisfaction the absence of the word mobilization from the Financial Statement for the year 1891-92. All the greater, therefore, were our disappointment and astonishment when, in the course of the same year, a revised estimate was made public, in which besides Rs. 800,000 “sanctioned during the year for additional transport mules,” and Rs. 521,000 “for remounts and ordnance mules,”1 Rs. 2,134,000 were set down as “Expenditure in India in preparations to facilitate mobilization;” whilst the Financial Statement for 1892-93 placed Rs. 616,000 to the account of “Measures intended to facilitate the speedy mobilization of the army.”
7. Now, if Rs. 2,635,000 was an adequate provision for the mobilization of an army corps—there was never any talk of mobilizing two—what became of the transport, provisions, and equipment bought with that money? There can be but one answer to the question—it had all disappeared, used up in frontier expeditions and minor operations; and so far as transport is concerned, we have the clearest proof that the Rs. 2,750,000 nominally devoted to mobilization in 1891-92 and 1892-93, went the same way, for when in the spring of 1895 a single division—minus the greater part of its cavalry and its horse and field artillery—was ordered on active service, it was found that there were only 7,482 Government mules available, and the military authorities, after buying or hiring every baggage animal that they could lay hands on, were reduced to the necessity of borrowing the transport service of the Jaipur and Gwalior Imperial Service Troops, and depriving a number of our own regiments of their regimental baggage ponies.2
8. In the current year Rs. 4,949,000 have again been devoted to the mobilization of a field army, and Sir James Westland has promised the Indian taxpayers that Rs. 4,348,000 of that amount “will be non-recurring, initial expenditure.” Can he, I wonder, ever have read his predecessor’s similar assurance? The sum is large, nevertheless it is absolutely certain that if, in the course of the next two or three years, India should become involved in “scientific warfare,” she would find herself utterly destitute of the means of prosecuting it, unless indeed her Government had meanwhile put a stop to the expeditions and operations which are perpetually frittering away her resources of all kinds, but more especially her supply of transport cattle.
9. It is worth noting that this habit of concealing the true cost of past expeditions and operations is closely allied to that tendency to under-estimate the probable expense of each new phase of the expansion fever, to which we owe the most stupendous financial blunder on record—the estimating of the total net cost of the Afghan War at £5,752,000 in February, 1880, and the revision of that estimate in June of the same year by rather more than £9,000,000 ! The £15,000,000 at which the cost of the war was then placed, rose in October to £15,777,000, and when the accounts were made up at the close of the financial year—March, 1881—this sum was found to have fallen short of the monies already expended by £828,000, whilst war expenditure still showed no sign of coming to an end !1
10. The story is so old a one that there has been time for most of us to forget it, but we all know that it has repeated itself in still more startling form, though on a smaller scale, à propos of that campaign which so unpleasantly laid bare the deficiencies of Indian transport arrangements, and the untrustworthiness of Indian Budgets.
11. The first estimate for the Chitral Expedition amounted only to Rs. 1,500,000; the sum actually spent upon it, to Rs. 17,647,000, or nearly twelve times more than that estimate; whilst, according to Sir James Westland, “it has left us a legacy of permanent expenditure in the occupation of Chitral and of its communications, which has involved in 1895-96 an expenditure of Rs. 1,022,000, and will involve in 1896-97 an expenditure of Rs. 2,317,000 . . . . irrespective of the Political Expenditure, which comes to Rs. 200,000 in 1895-96 and Rs. 220,000 in 1896-97; . . . . also of Military Works Expenditure, Rs. 216,000 in 1896-97.”2
X.
INDIAN CURRENCY.
The following letter was printed in the Times of June 3, 1898:
To the Editor of the “Times.”
Sir,—You will kindly allow me to express my views on the subject of the Indian currency.
1. Fall or rise in exchange does not in itself (other circumstances being the same) matter in true international trade, which adjusts itself automatically to the requirements of exchange. I would illustrate this. I desire, for instance, to lay out £1,000 for sending a quantity of piece goods to India. I calculate the price of the manufacturer, exchange, whatever it may be, 1s., 2s., or 3s. per rupee, freight, insurance, commission, etc., and see whether the price in India would pay me a fair profit. If I think it would I enter into the transaction, sell my bill to an East India bank, and take the usual commercial chances of supply, demand, etc., when the goods arrive in India. I give this illustration in its simplest form of the general character of commercial transactions between this country and India. There are variations of the method of these transactions, but into them I do not enter at present, to avoid confusion. The main principle is the same.
2. Closing the mints or introducing a gold standard does not and cannot save a single farthing to the Indian taxpayers in their remittances for “home charges” to this country. The reason is simple. Suppose we take roundly £20,000,000 sterling in gold to be the amount of the “home charges.” The Indian taxpayers have to send as much produce to this country as is necessary to buy £20,000,000 sterling, not an ounce less, no matter whatever may be the rupee, or whatever the standard—gold or silver—in India, England must receive £20,000,000 in gold or produce worth £20,000,000 in gold.
3. Closing of the mints and thereby raising the true rupee worth, at present about 11d. in gold, to a false rupee to be worth about 16d. in gold is a covert exaction of 45 per cent. more taxation (besides producing other effects which I do not mention) from the Indian taxpayers. The reason is again simple. Suppose a rayat has to pay Rs. 10 for land tax. This rupee means a fixed quantity of silver stamped with the mint stamp, and is truly worth at present only about 11d. of gold. By closing the mints this rupee is forced up to the worth of 16d. of gold, and the rayat is compelled to find this high-priced false rupee of 16d. of gold, or, in other words, to sell 45 per cent. more of his produce to get this false rupee, the Government thus getting 45 per cent. more taxation than it is entitled to, even according to its own “despotic” legislation.
4. The introduction of a gold standard, while it will not save a single farthing or a single ounce of produce to the Indian taxpayer in his payment of “home charges,” as explained above, will simply add more to his already existing grievous burdens (and injure him in other ways which I avoid mentioning here), to the extent of the heavy cost of the alteration.
I have thus put forth four simple clear propositions. It is necessary for your other correspondents to consider whether these propositions are true or not. If once these fundamental issues or premises are settled further discussion will have a sound basis to go upon. At present the whole controversy is based upon the assumption that closing of mints or introduction of a gold standard will produce to the Indian taxpayers an enormous saving in their remittances for “home charges.” This, I say, is a mere fiction of the imagination and an unfortunate delusion.
I avoid also entering on the question of the remedy. It is useless to talk about the remedy before making a true diagnosis of the real character of the disease.
After the above four simple propositions are settled I shall, with your permission, express my views about the real disease and its remedy.
I may here take the opportunity of saying that the constitution of the present Currency Committee is utterly unsatisfactory, as it does not contain any representative of the Indian taxpayers.
I remain, yours truly, Dadabhai Naoroji. Washington House, 72, Anerley Park, S.E. May 29, 1898.
I.—STATEMENT SUBMITTED TO THE INDIAN CURRENCY COMMITTEE OF 1898.
Washington House, 72, Anerley Park, S.E. July 30, 1898.
My Dear Sir William Wedderburn,—In accordance with the reply of the 5th inst. from the Currency Committee to your letter saying “they will, however, be glad to accord their best consideration to any written communication which you may desire to lay before them,” I send you this statement, which you would be good enough to forward to them.
2. I may add that I am willing to submit to any cross-examination that may be considered necessary to test the correctness of my views, or to ask me other questions. You know that I have been in business in the City for twenty-five years as a merchant, and also as a commission agent; I have dealt with almost every kind of export and import between England and India. I have seen some commercial and monetary crises, including that of “the Black Friday,” when I think Messrs. Overend Gurney and Co. closed their doors.
3. Fall or rise in exchange does not in itself (other circumstances remaining the same) matter in true international trade, which adjusts itself automatically to the requirements of exchange. To establish this proposition by a detailed explanation of the mode of operations of Indian trade, I attach as Appendix A some letters which I wrote to the Times and the Daily News in 1886.
4. Closing the mints or introducing a gold standard does not and cannot save a single farthing to the Indian taxpayers in their remittance for “Home Charges” to this country. The reason is simple. Suppose we take roundly £20,000,000 sterling to be the amount of the “Home Charges.” The Indian taxpayers have to send as much produce to this country as is necessary to buy £20,000,000, not an ounce less, no matter whatever may be the rupee or whatever the standard (gold or silver) in India. England must receive £20,000,000 in gold, or produce worth £20,000,000. The only way in which relief can come to the Indian taxpayers in these remittances is the rise in the prices of the Indian merchandise in this country, and not by any juggling with the currency laws of India.
5. The Government of India, in their despatch to the Secretary of State (Simla, November 9, 1878), themselves admit this in so many words :—
“66. Now, it is plain that so long as the amount of the so-called tribute is not changed the quantity of merchandise necessary to pay it will not change either, excepting by reason of a change of its value in the foreign country to which it goes.” (C 4868, 1886, p. 25.)
6. Closing of the mints, and thereby raising the true rupee, worth at present about 11d. in gold, to a false rupee to be worth 16d. in gold, is a covert exaction of about 45 per cent. more taxation all round from the Indian taxpayers, and at the same time of increasing the salaries of officials and other payments in India by Government to the same extent, and giving generally the advantage to creditors over debtors, the former being generally well-to-do, and the latter the poorer classes, especially in the case of the money-lenders and the rayats.
7. The real and full effect of the closing of the mints must be examined by itself, irrespective of the effect of other factors. First of all, the closing of the mints was illegal, dishonourable, and a despotic act. It is a violation of all taxation Acts, by which there was always a distinct contract between the Government and the taxpayers based upon the fundamental principle of sound currency—i.e., of a certain definite rupee. And what is that fundamental principle upon which the currency, both of this country and of India, is based ? The former is upon what is called the gold standard, and the latter the silver standard. Take this country first.
8. Here the whole currency is based upon a sovereign—a fixed unit of a certain quantity of gold, whatever its relative exchangeable value may be with all other commodities. A sovereign is nothing more or less than, or anything else but, 123.274 grains of gold of a certain fineness, with a stamp upon it, certifying to the world that it is what it professes to be, and that no restriction whatsoever was to be placed either on the market of gold or on the coining of gold. Any person may present 123.274 grains of gold, of standard fineness with the mintage (which, I think, is three halfpence on an ounce),1 and ask for a sovereign and will get it. It is not buying or selling gold; Government simply having fixed a unit of currency measure, stamps the unit that it is the proper unit. I should be surprised if Government here should even think of interfering with this unrestricted sale and coinage of gold, as the foundation of the sound currency of this country. The sovereign is the standard by which every other commodity, including silver, is measured in its exchangeable value, just as a foot is a standard measure of length, a gallon of liquid. The taxpayer’s contract with the Government is that he is to pay in such unrestricted sovereigns, and every taxation law lays down the payment in such sovereigns.
9. Similarly about India—substitute 180 grains of standard silver, with 2 per cent. for mintage for a rupee, in place of 123.274 grains of gold, with three halfpence for every ounce of gold coined, for a sovereign, and all the above remarks apply word for word to the case of India, except that I should not be surprised at the Indian authorities playing any pranks, regardless of consequences to the Indian people, as long as they are considered favourable to the “interests,” and are to be made at the cost of the Indians.
10. This is the true rupee—180 grains of standard silver at its market value, with nearly 4 grains more for mintage, is convertible into a rupee without any restriction either on the silver market or on the free coining of silver. It is in this true rupee that the taxpayer is legally bound to pay his taxes. Any interference with the fundamental principle and law of the rupee is illegal, immoral, or dishonourable.
11. Now comes the false rupee. The true rupee, in its relation to gold at the present market value of silver of 184 grains, is worth, say, about 11d. of gold. Government intervenes, abuses its power or duty to coin silver unrestrictedly, makes the rupee scarce and false, and forces it up to the value of 16d. of gold, or about 269 grains of silver (including mintage), which the rupee does not contain. And the taxpayer is compelled, by what Mr. Gladstone called “the argument and law of force,” to pay his tax in this false rupee, under the false pretence of using the word “rupee” when this “rupee” is not one rupee but nearly one and a half rupee.
12. Let us now take the factor of closing the mints by itself. Suppose I go into the market with my produce to buy 184 grains of standard silver for which I am asked one maund of rice. I go to the mint and ask to coin this into a rupee which I have to pay to the Sircar for my tax. If I get the rupee, then it is all right. But no, the mint refuses to coin. It virtually tells me, “Bring 269 grains of silver (i.e., worth 16d. of gold) and you will get a rupee.” I go into the market to get the rupee. The man who has the rupee tells me, “If you give me 269 grains of silver, or as much produce as would buy 269 grains of silver, I would give you the rupee.” What alternative remains for me but to give as much of my rice, about 1½ maunds, to get this false “rupee,” instead of only one maund to get the true rupee which I can get in the same market and at the same time? This is altogether independent of whatever the actual price of commodities may be.
13. If the actual price of rice does not show this fall, owing to the disguise of the false “rupee,” it is not that the closing of the mints has not produced this decline, but that other fortunate factors have influenced the price, whose benefit is robbed away from me by the Government by the covert device of the closing of the mints. Otherwise I would have received so much higher price for my produce than the actual price. The loss, therefore, to me is all the same, as I was forced to pay in my produce for 269 grains of silver to get the false “rupee” instead of at the same moment paying for 184 grains of silver to get the true rupee. These two different prices in merchandise for the false and the true rupee are demanded, as I have said above, at the same time, and in the same market, i.e., the price of the false rupee, 45 per cent. higher than that of the true rupee, entirely irrespective of any general market rise or fall of price at any same time. If the actual price of rice be 1½ maunds for the false rupee, the price at the same time will be one maund for the true rupee, or for 184 grains of silver.
14. To test this in another way. Let us take some commodity in the country itself upon which the factor of the closing of the mints produces its full effect in the actual market, and which is not materially affected by other commercial factors, which operate generally upon the general merchandise. Such a commodity in India is gold. It is affected, not in merely foreign exchange or international relations, but in India itself as a commodity, like every other commodity. Say, I have a sovereign, and I want to sell it for rupees in India itself—not for exchange to foreign parts. If the “rupee” were the honest, true rupee of the market value of 184 grains of silver, I should get 22 such rupees for my sovereign, but at the false value of the “rupee,” i.e., the market value 269 grains of silver, I actually get only 15 “rupees.” This is the actual price of gold in India, a decline in the proportion of the false inflation of the false “rupee.” This is the case with every commodity, as can be tested by offering produce for the true rupee of 184 grains of silver, and for the false rupee or 269 grains of silver at the same time and in the same market.
15. In addition to the higher taxation thus inflicted on the Indian taxpayers, by an irony of fate, the very “interests” (bankers, merchants, planters, foreign capitalists of all kinds, etc.) for whose behalf, besides that of Government itself, all this dislocation of currency was made, are now loudest in their cry for all the mischief caused also to them, and yet the authorities in both countries remain blind and infatuated enough not to learn even by experience, and persist in a mischievous course.
16. In the Treasury letter of 24th November, 1879 (c. 4868, 1886, p. 31) to the India Office, my Lords say :—
“ 1. The proposal appears to be open to those objections to a token currency which have long been recognised by all civilised nations, viz.: That instead of being automatic, it must be ‘ managed ’ by the Government, and that any such management not only fails to keep a token currency at par, but exposes the Government which undertakes it to very serious difficulties and temptations.
17. “ 2. It appears to my Lords, that the Government of India, in making the present proposal, lay themselves open to the same criticisms as are made upon Governments which have depreciated their currencies. In general, the object of such Governments has been to diminish the amount they have to pay to their creditors. In the present case, the object of the Indian Government appears to be to increase the amount they have to receive from their taxpayers. My Lords fail to see any real difference in the character of the two transactions.
18. “ . . . . If, on the other hand, it is the case that the value of the rupee has fallen in India, and that it will be raised in India by the operation of the proposed plan, that plan is open to the objection that it alters every contract and every fixed payment in India.
19. “ This proposal is, in fact, contrary to the essential and well-established principle of the currency law of this country, which regards the current standard coin as a piece of a given metal of a certain weight and fineness, and which condemns as futile and mischievous every attempt to go behind this simple definition.
20. “ It is perfectly true as stated in the despatch (paragraph 41), that the “ very essence of all laws relating to the currency has been to give fixity to the standard of value as far as it is possible,” but it is no less true that, according to the principles which govern our currency system, the best and surest way, and, indeed, the only tried and known way, of giving this fixity is to adhere to the above definition of current standard coin. A pound is a given quantity of gold, a rupee is a given quantity of silver; and any attempt to give those terms a different meaning is condemned by experience and authority.
21. “3. If the present state of exchange be due to the depreciation of silver, the Government scheme, if it succeeds, may relieve :—
(1) The Indian Government from the inconvenience of a nominal re-adjustment of taxation in order to meet the loss by exchange on the home remittances :
(2) Civil servants and other Englishmen who are serving or working in India, and who desire to remit money to England :
(3) Englishmen who have money placed or invested in India which they wish to remit to England. But this relief will be given at the expense of the Indian taxpayer, and with the effect of increasing every debt or fixed payment in India, including debts due by ryots to money lenders ; while its effect will be materially qualified, so far as the Government are concerned, by the enhancement of the public obligations in India, which have been contracted on a silver basis. . . . .
22. “If, then, a case has been made out, which my Lords do not admit, for an alteration of the currency law of India, the particular alteration which the Government of India propose could not, in the opinion of the Treasury, be entertained until the doubts and objections which have suggested themselves to my Lords are answered and removed. These objections are founded on principles which have been long and ably discussed, and which are now generally admitted by statesmen and by writers of accepted authority to lie at the root of the currency system.
23. “It is no light matter to accept innovations which must sap and undermine that system, and my Lords have therefore felt it their duty plainly—though they hope not inconsistently with the respect due to the Government of India —to express their conviction that the plan which had been referred to them for their observations is one which ought not to be sanctioned by her Majesty’s Government or by the Secretary of State.” (Italics are mine.)
24. Can condemnation be more complete and convincing ?
25. The introduction of a gold standard, while it will not save a single farthing or a single ounce of produce to the Indian taxpayer in his payment of “Home Charges,” as already explained, will simply add more to his already existing grievous burdens to the extent of the heavy cost of the alteration, and injure him, Heaven knows in what other ways, as the events of the past five years have shown.
26. The whole basis of the action of the Government is, and was, the assumption that, as fall in exchange will necessitate increased burden of taxation, the closing of the mints and introduction of a gold standard will save the Indian taxpayer from any such additional burden of taxation which would otherwise arise enormously in the remittance of “Home Charges,” and that it is imperatively necessary to establish a stable ratio between gold and silver. That the anxiety of the Government about increased burdens of taxation and its political dangers, and that to save the people from the former and the Government from the latter, were the professed motives of all the present currency laws, would be clear from Government’s own despatches.
27. In order not to encumber the statement here with the extracts from those despatches, I give them as Appendix B.
28. Both these objects, viz., saving people from additional taxation, and thereby Government from political danger, by the present proposals, and past currency legislation, are pure delusions. The Government might as well have tried to stop the action of gravitation, as to try against a natural law, that while gold and silver should fluctuate in value in relation to and like all other commodities, yet between themselves they could be made to keep up a fixed ratio, or to try to make a rupee which may be only worth 11d. or even 6d. of gold, become worth 16d. of gold, unless Government have found the philosopher’s stone or have attained the divine power of creating something out of nothing.
29. It is not that the Government of India did not know this, or were not told this from the highest authority and others, and in distinct and emphatic terms. Of this I have already given (see supra 16 to 23 paras.) extracts from the despatch of the Treasury, of November 24th, 1879.
30. Notwithstanding the clear and emphatic views of the Treasury expressing “their conviction that the plan which had been referred to them for their observations is one which ought not to be sanctioned by her Majesty’s Government, or by the Secretary of State,” the Government of India and the India Office again opened the subject in another form.
31. Lord Randolph Churchill wrote to the Treasury on January 26th, 1886, and forwarded on March 17th, 1886, a letter from the Government of India dated February 2nd, 1886 (c. 4868, 1886, pp. 3-5). To avoid repetition, I would not take extracts from these letters, as the reply of the Treasury embodies their views.
32. This reply of the Treasury is dated May 31st, 1886 (signed Henry H. Fowler):—“ 6. As a result of this review of the inconveniences caused by the depression in the value of silver, the Government of India express their opinion . . . . Yet there remains one thing which is not beyond the possibility of human control, and that is ‘ the establishment of a fixed ratio between gold and silver.’ The proposition thus stated as an undoubted axiom is, however, one of the most disputable and disputed points in economic science. My Lords may, in passing, compare with this statement the declaration recorded by Mr. Goschen, Mr. Gibbs, and Sir Thomas Seccombe as the representatives of her Majesty’s Government at the International Monetary Conference of 1878, that ‘ the establishment of a fixed ratio between gold and silver was utterly impracticable.’ ”
33. “ The Indian Government further express their belief (paragraph 7) that it is possible to ‘ secure a stable ratio between gold and silver,’ and that ‘ a serious responsibility will rest both on the Government of India and on her Majesty’s Government if they neglect any legitimate means to bring about this result.’ It would, however, have been more satisfactory if the Indian Government had undertaken to explain the grounds of their confidence that a stable ratio between gold and silver can be established, and the methods by which this is to be accomplished. . . . .”
34. “8. In December, 1878, Lord Cranbrook, then Secretary of State for India, forwarded to the then Chancellor of the Exchequer (Sir Stafford Northcote), without any expression of opinion, two despatches from the Government of India, containing certain proposed remedies for the evils arising out of the depression in the value of silver which were then in full force. In the only one of those despatches to which reference need here be made, after unfavourable reference to previous suggestions—(1) that a gold standard and gold currency should be introduced into India; and (2) that the weight of silver in the rupee should be increased, it was proposed to limit the free coinage of silver at the Indian mints. The intention of this change was to introduce into India a gold standard, while retaining its native silver currency, the ratio between the currency unit (the rupee) and the standard (the sovereign) being fixed arbitrarily by the Government. The means for attaining this end are worked out in the despatch with great elaboration of detail.” (Italics are mine.)
35. “9. This despatch and its proposals were submitted by Lord Cranbrook, on behalf of the Indian Government, and Sir Stafford Northcote, as Chancellor of the Exchequer, to a Committee consisting of Sir Louis Mallet, Mr. Edward Stanhope, M.P., Sir Thomas Seccombe, Mr. (now Sir Thomas) Farrer, Mr. (now Sir Reginald) Welby, Mr. Giffen, and Mr. Arthur Balfour, M.P. These gentlemen reported, on the 30th April, 1879—‘That having examined the proposals contained in the despatch, they were unanimously of opinion that they could not recommend them for the sanction of her Majesty’s Government.’
36. “10. Subsequently, on the 24th November, 1879, the Treasury replied in detail to the proposals of the Indian Government. In the first part of that letter, which summarises the case as stated in the despatch, I am to call the particular attention of the Secretary of State to the following passages, which seem to apply with equal force to the present situation :—
37. “‘My Lords need not point out that a change of the Currency Laws is one of the most difficult tasks which a Government can undertake, and that it is most unadvisable to legislate hastily and under the influence of the pressure of the moment, or of an apprehension of uncertain consequences, upon a subject so complicated in itself and so important to every individual of the community, in its bearing upon the transactions and obligations of daily life.
38. “‘It is not proved that increase or re-adjustment of taxation must necessarily be the consequence of matters remaining as they are, for nothing is said about reduction of expenditure, and equilibrium between income and expenditure may be regained by economy of expenditure as well as by increase of taxation. Further, the cost of increase of salaries may be met, or at least reduced, by a careful revision of establishments. . . . .
39. “‘A perusal of the despatch leads to the conclusion that the Government of India are especially anxious to put an end to the competition of silver against their own bills as a means of remittance to India. But my Lords must ask whether this would be more than a transfer of their own burden to other shoulders ; if so, who would eventually bear the loss, and what would be the effect on the credit of the Government and on the commerce of India ?’ ”
40. The letter then further quotes the paragraphs, which I have already given before, pointing out that the relief wished for by the Government “ will be given at the expense of the Indian taxpayer.”—(Supra, par. 21.)
41. “ The Treasury find no reason stated in the despatch of the Government of India in the present year, which induces them to dissent from the conclusions thus sent forth on the authority of Sir Stafford Northcote as to the results of any attempt artificially to enhance the gold price of silver. . .
42. “ ‘ 13 . . . . It has been the policy of this country to emancipate commercial transactions as far as possible from legal control, and to impose no unnecessary restrictions upon the interchange of commodities. To fix the relative value of gold and silver by law would be to enter upon a course directly at variance with this principle, and would be regarded as an arbitrary interference with a natural law, not justified by any present necessity.’
43. “ . . . . The observation of the Treasury in 1879, ‘ that nothing is said about reduction of expenditure,’ seems to apply still more strongly to the existing situation, and it may be safely concluded that the control of its expenditure is far more within the reach of a Government than is the regulation of the market value of the precious metals ” (c. 4868, 1886, p. 12).
44. Before proceeding further I may in passing point out that in 1876 the Government of India itself was against their present proposals, and, as my Lords of the Treasury say, they have urged no sound reasons to alter those views. I have not got the Government of India’s despatch of 1876, but I quote from that of November 9, 1878 (c. 4868), 1886, p. 18.
45. “ 3. The despatch above referred to (October 13th, 1876) discussed in some detail. . . . . The general result, however, was to point out that the adoption of a gold standard with a gold currency that should replace the existing silver would be so costly as to be impracticable, and would otherwise be open to objection ; . . . .
46. “4. The despatch notices also, but only to reject it, the proposal that the Indian standard of value, and with it the exchange value of the rupee, might be raised by limiting the coining of silver in the future and by adopting a gold standard without a gold currency.” (The italics are mine.)
47. The Government of India, in their reply of February 9, 1877, to a resolution of the Bengal Chamber of Commerce passed by them on July 15, 1876, said :—
“8. The value of no substance can serve as a standard measure of value unless its use as the material of legal tender currency is freely admitted. If, therefore, the free coinage of silver on fixed conditions were disallowed in India silver would no longer be the standard of value of India, but another standard would be substituted, namely, the monopoly value of the existing stock of rupees tempered by any additions made to it by the Government or illicitly. If no such conditions were made the value of the rupee will gradually but surely rise.”
48. “9. The stamp of a properly regulated mint, such as the Indian Mints, adds nothing except the cost of manufacture and seigniorage to the value of the metal on which it is impressed, but only certifies to its weight and purity.”
49. “10. A sound system of currency must be automatic or self-regulating. No civilised Government can undertake to determine from time to time by how much the legal-tender currency should be increased or decreased, nor would it be justified in leaving the community without a fixed metallic standard of value even for a short time. It is a mistake to suppose that any European nation has rejected silver as a standard of value without substituting gold” (c. 7060, II, 1893, p. 337. Petition of the Indian Association to the House of Commons).
50. And yet the Government forgot its “civilisation” and its “sound system,” and inflicted upon poor India the penalty of its folly by the troubles of the past five years, and what is worse still, they want to persist in the same mischief.
51. Reverting to the above replies of the Treasury, after such complete condemnation by the Treasury of the proposals of the Government of India, the Indian authorities fought shy of the Treasury, and, after inditing a meaningless despatch to keep up appearances, left the Treasury severely alone, as far as I know, and adopted their own usual means to have their own way to rush into their own foregone, crude, and thoughtless legislation. The only wonder is that the Committee of 1893, while knowing all this, and seeing all the pitfalls and serious consequences of the proposals, allowed the Indian Government to have their own way, in the face of the emphatic rejection by the Treasury of these proposals.
52. To me the proceedings of the Indian authorities are nothing surprising. Whenever they make up their mind to do a thing they would do it—be the opposition what it may— be it of Parliament itself. Resolutions or statutes of Parliament, or condemnation by the Treasury, are to them nothing. The usual process in such cases is to appoint a Commission or a Committee, put in Members, and have witnesses of their own choice, leaving, if possible, just a small margin for appearance of independence. Generally, they get their own foregone conclusions. If by some happy chance the Commission decided anything against their view, so much the worse for the Commission. The Report is pigeon-holed, never to see the light of day, or to ignore such part as is not agreeable. If thwarted (as in this instance by the Treasury), the Government keep quiet for a time, wait for more favourable opportunities, and are at it again, taking better care against another mishap.
53. Thus they took their own usual course, which has, as was clearly predicted at the time, launched us on the present sea of troubles.
54. What is stranger still is, that after the Treasury so distinctly condemned these proposals, they did not care to see that any contemplated rash and crude legislation was not inflicted on the Indian taxpayers. The fact seems to be that India is the vile body upon which any quacks may perform any vivisection, and try any cruel, crude, or rash experiments. What matters what is done to it? The Treasury, i.e., the English taxpayer, has not to suffer in any way. India is our helot, she can be forced to pay everything. But they forget Lord Salisbury’s eternal words—“Injustice will bring down the mightiest to ruin.”
55. The next natural question is—Why is it that fall in exchange should cause grievous troubles to India and not to any other self-governing, silver using country? What is the real disease which creates all the never-ceasing pains of India ? The reply is given by Lord Salisbury in four words, “India must be bled” under a system of “political hypocrisy.” As long as this is the fate of India under an un-British system of government, no jugglery, no loud professions of benevolence, no device of raising a rupee to what it is not worth, will cure India’s sad fate and “terrible misery” (Lord Salisbury’s words).
56. I shall let the authorities themselves speak about the real cause of India’s troubles. Lord Salisbury’s view I have given above. The following extracts explain this view more explicitly and how it is effected. First, Lord Salisbury has explained that “the injury is exaggerated in the case of India, where so much of the revenue is exported without a direct equivalent.”
57. And the literature of this very controversy itself supplied a clear explanation. Lord Randolph Churchill, as Secretary of State for India, explains how the “bleeding” and the drain of revenue is effected, and indicates also the final retribution—just as Lord Salisbury does, as already quoted by me. Lord Randolph Churchill, in his despatch to the Treasury of January 26th, 1886 (c. 4,868) 1886, p. 4, says :—first—
58. “It need hardly be said that it is in consequence of the large obligatory payments which the Government of India has to make in England in gold currency that the fall in the exchange value of the rupee affects the public finances.” (Italics are mine.)
59. And next he hits the nail on the head, and gives concisely and unmistakeably the real evil from which all India’s woes flow.
60. He says :—“The position of India in relation to taxation and the sources of the public revenues is very peculiar, not merely from the habits of the people, and their strong aversion to change, which is more specially exhibited to new forms of taxation, but likewise from the character of the Government, which is in the hands of foreigners, who hold all the principal administrative offices and form so large a part of the Army. The impatience of new taxation, which would have to be borne wholly as a consequence of the foreign rule imposed on the country, and virtually to meet additions to charges arising outside of the country, would constitute a political danger, the real magnitude of which, it is to be feared, is not at all appreciated by persons who have no knowledge of, or concern in, the government of India, but which those responsible for that Government have long regarded as of the most serious order.” (The italics are mine.)
61. Here, then, is the real disease—“the character of the Government, which is in the hands of foreigners, who hold all the principal administrative offices, and form so large a part of the Army”—“the taxation which would have to be borne wholly as a consequence of the foreign rule imposed on the country, and virtually to meet additions to charges arising outside of the country.”
62. And it is remarkable that this was prophesied more than a hundred years ago by the highest Indian authority of the day.
Sir John Shore, in his famous minute in 1787 (Parliamentary Return 377 of 1812, para. 132), says :—
63. “Whatever allowance we may make for the increased industry of the subjects of the State owing to the enhanced demand for the produce of it (supposing the demand to be enhanced), there is reason to conclude that the benefits are more than counterbalanced by evils inseparable from the system of a remote foreign dominion.” (Italics are mine.)
64. These evils of the system of a remote foreign dominion must be faced by the British rulers before it is “too late.” No jugglery of currency, or loud professions of benevolence, or the hundred and one subterfuges to which Indian authorities resort, will ever cure these evils—or put British rule on a solid and safe foundation and relieve the Indian people of all these national, political and moral degradations and debasement, and economic and material destruction. Give India true British rule in place of the present un-British rule, and both England and India will be blessed and prosperous.
65. Now, with regard to the immediate position—What is to be done now? Retrace the false step of 1893, taken in spite of the clear warnings of the Treasury and others, and against the “law of Nature.” The opening of the mints to the unrestricted coining of silver will correct all the mischievous results that have flowed from the closing of the mints. And further, the true remedy, as pointed out by the Treasury, is a reduction of expenditure and readjustment of establishments.
66. It never occurs to the Indian authorities in both countries that the high salaries of officials may be reduced, say a third, and, as repeatedly urged by many a right-thinking man, Native agency should be substituted—except for the highest control—for the foreign agency, and that Britain should contribute its fair share of the expenditure, to the extent to which such expenditure is incurred for its own purposes and benefits, such as the European services and Imperial wars, etc. Of course, anybody can understand that it is hard for officials to cut their own salaries, and let the Indians to come by their own, or ask the British people to contribute a fair share. But this is the only remedy both for the preservation of English rule and for the prosperity of both England and India.
67. The opening of the mints will have immediate important effects. (1.) The stringency of the money market and the consequent dislocation of trade will be remedied. (2.) The poor taxpayer will have to submit to such additional taxation only (after careful and earnest reduction of expenditure and avoiding of suicidal and unnecessary wars) as will be absolutely necessary to meet the deficit caused by the natural fall of exchange, instead of a concealed enormous enhancement of the whole taxation of the country, under the disguise and by the creation of a false “ rupee ” by closing the mints, to the extent of the difference between the value of the true and false rupee (may be between 6d. and 16d., or nearly three times as much).
The Indian authorities must take the advice which the Treasury has given, and restore the currency law to its original purity and soundness.
68. The second proposal for a gold standard (with partia1 or full quantity of gold) must be abandoned. The Government of India have themselves condemned the proposal, as already stated, paragraph 45. What does it mean ? It is most inopportune at present. It means that all the proportionate small quantity of silver that is in British India, and the proportionately large quantity that is in the Native States, must be forcibly (not by any natural economic cause but by the despotism of the State) deprived of a large portion of its present value by throwing a large quantity of it in the market, and buy a large quantity of gold at a still higher proportion of value by the large additional demand created by it. All this loss in cheapening silver, and dearer gold to be squeezed out of the poor, wretched, famished ryot of India.
69. The conversion of silver into gold standard cannot be carried out without great cost (see paragraph 45), which will be the highest cruelty and tyranny to inflict upon the “bloodless” and miserable and helpless people of India, and especially this infliction to be made on the false assumption that it will give relief from the burden of the remittances for “Home Charges,” when it will do nothing of the kind, as stated by Government itself.
70. The step is not at all necessary for any economic purpose except that it will be a convenience to the foreign exploiter, official and non-official. A gold currency without gold (paragraph 46) and with an unrestricted silver currency is a delusion rejected by Government itself, and forcibly impressed by the Treasury.
71. I do sincerely hope and trust that this and all such heartlessness towards, and un-British treatment of, the wretched people of India will become a thing of the past, and a true British rule may bring blessing and prosperity to both Britain and India.
72. I beg to give in Appendix C. a statement of December 11th, 1892, which I had submitted to the Currency Committee in 1892, from which it will be seen that I had then pointed out the objections to the proposals. I also beg to refer the Committee to my evidence before the same Committee on December 17th, 1892 (c. 7060, II, 1893, p. 106).
73. There are several other more or less minor questions. Suppose a ryot is paying Rs. 10, what will be taken from him in gold? Will it be at the rate at which the intrinsic value of the silver is at the time (at present 11d. may be 6d.), or will demand be made at the present false value of 1s. 4d., or even in the despotic power, at the rate of 2s., i.e., £1 of the Rs. 10?
74. When gold currency is introduced what salary will be paid to the officials at 11d. or 6d. of whatever the market value of the rupee may be, or at 16d., or even 24d., of the despotic value of the “rupee,” for every rupee of the salary— a rupee of 180 grains of silver. In other words, will it be £25 at 6d., or about £46 at 11d., or about £66 at 16d., or £100 at 24d. for a present salary of Rs. 1,000, of a rupee of 180 grains?
75. There is the foreign merchant or capitalist of every kind always wanting to save himself in his trade-risks at the cost of the taxpayer, besides using to no small extent, or to the extent of the deposits of revenue in the banks, the revenues of the taxpayers, as his capital for his trade, and besides what is brought back to India, out of the “bleeding” of India as his, the foreign capitalist’s capital. Is Government going to inflict oppression upon the Indian taxpayer whenever these “interests” raise a cry and agitation for their selfish ends? Merchants and all sorts of foreign capitalistic exploiters and speculators must be left to themselves. It is no business of the State to interfere in their behalf at the cost of the Indian taxpayers; they know their business; they are able, and ought to be left to take care of themselves. They exploit the country with the Indians’ revenue and “bleeding.” That is bad enough in all conscience—the profits are theirs, and the losses must be also theirs, and not an additional infliction upon the Indian taxpayers.
76. The Government here dare not play such pranks with the taxpayers. In India the Government only thinks of the foreign “interests” (official and non-official) first, and of the subjects afterwards, if it ever thinks of the subjects at all when foreign “interests” are concerned.
77. Lord Mayo has truly said : “I have only one object in all I do. I believe we have not done our duty to the people of the land. Millions have been spent on the conquering race which might have been spent in enriching and in elevating the children of the soil. We have done much, but we can do a great deal more. It is, however, impossible, unless we spend less on the ‘interests’ and more on the people.”
78. On another occasion he said : “We must take into account the inhabitants of the country—the welfare of the people of India is our primary object. If we are not here for their good, we ought not to be here at all.”—The Hindu of 4th May, 1898. Sir W. Hunter’s “Life of Mayo.”
79. This is exactly the whole truth. It is the “interests” alone that the present selfish system and spirit of Government care for—and though that is some profit to England it is most destructive to India. If, according to the noble words of Lord Mayo, the people’s true welfare were made the object, England itself will be vastly more benefited than it is at present, and India will also be benefited and will bless the name of England, instead of cursing it as she now begins to do—shut your eyes to it as much as you like. Do as Lord Mayo says, and all difficulties of trade, taxation, finances, currency, famine, plague, unnecessary wars, and last, but not least, of poverty and disaffection will vanish. The past has been bad, “bleeding, and degrading”; let the future be good yet— prospering and elevating. India then will be quite able to pay as much as may be necessary for healthy government, and all necessary progress.
80. In the above remarkable and true words of Lord Mayo, you have the cause of all India’s woes and evils, and all England’s political dangers of “the most serious order,” as well as the proper remedy for them. Will this Currency Committee rise to its duty and patriotism ?
Yours truly, Dadabhai Naoroji.
Sir William Wedderburn, Chairman of the British Committee of The Indian National Congress, 84, Palace Chambers, Westminster, S.W.
APPENDIX A.—INDIAN EXCHANGES.
From the Times, September 9th, 1886.
Sir,—I hope you will kindly allow me to make a few observations upon Indian exchanges. I shall first describe the mode of operation of an export transaction from India. In order to trace the effect of the exchange only, I take all other circumstances to remain the same—i.e., any other circumstances, such as of supply and demand, etc., which affect prices.
I take an illustration in its simplest form. Suppose I lay out Rs. 10,000 to export 100 bales of cotton to England. I then calculate, taking exchange into consideration, what price in England will enable me to get back my Rs. 10,000, together with a fair profit— say, 10 per cent.—making altogether Rs. 11,000. Suppose I take exchange at 2s. per rupee, and find that 6d. per lb. will bring back to me in remittance as much silver as would make up Rs. 11,000, I then instruct my agent in England to sell with a limit of 6d. per lb., and to remit the proceeds in silver, this being the simplest form of the transaction. The result of the transaction, if it turned out as intended, will be that the cotton sold at 6d. per lb. will bring back to me Rs. 11,000, and the transaction will be completed.
Now, I take a transaction when exchange is 1s. 4d. instead of 2s. per rupee. I lay out Rs. 10,000 for 100 bales of cotton, all other circumstances remaining the same, I calculate that I can get back my Rs. 10,000, and 10 per cent. profit, or Rs. 11,000 altogether, if my cotton were sold at 4d. per lb. Then I instruct my agent for a limit of 4d., which, being obtained, and silver being remitted to me at the reduced price, I get back my Rs. 11,000.
The impression of many persons seems to be that, just as I received 6d. per pound when exchange was 2s. per rupee, I get 6d. also when exchange is only 1s. 4d. per rupee, and that, silver being so much lower, I actually get Rs. 16,500, instead of only Rs. 11,000. This, however, is not the actual state of the case, as I have explained above. When exchange is at 2s. per rupee, and I get 6d. per lb. for my cotton, I do not get 6d. per lb. when exchange is only 1s. 4d. per rupee, but I get only 4d. per lb.; in either case the whole operation is that I laid out Rs. 10,000 and received back Rs. 11,000. When exchange is 2s. I get 6d. of gold; when exchange is 1s. 4d. I do not get 6d. of gold but 4d. of gold, making my return of silver, at the lower price, of the same amount in either case—viz., Rs. 11,000.
I explain the same phenomenon in another form, to show that such alone is the case, and no other is possible. Supposing that, according to the impression of many, my cotton could be sold at 6d. per lb. when exchange is only 1s. 4d.—that is to say, that I can receive Rs. 16,500 back for my lay-out of Rs. 10,000, why my neighbour would be only too glad to undersell me and be satisfied with 40 per cent. profit in place of my 50 per cent. profit, and another will be but too happy and satisfied with 20 per cent., and so on till, with the usual competition, the price will come down to the natural and usual level of profits.
The fact is no merchant in his senses ever dreams that he would get the same price of 6d. per lb. irrespective of the exchange being either 2s. or 1s. 4d. Like freight, insurance, and other charges, he takes into consideration the rate of exchange, and settles at what price his cotton should be sold in order that he should get back his lay-out with the usual profit. This is what he expects, and he gains more or less according as the state of the market is affected by other causes, such as larger supply or demand, or further variation in exchange during the pendency of the transaction.
Taking, therefore, all other circumstances to remain the same, and the exchange remaining the same during the period of the completion of the transaction, the effect of the difference in the exchange at any two different rates is that when exchange is lower you get so much less gold in proportion, so that in the completion of the transaction you get back in either case your cost and usual profit. In the cases I have supposed above, when exchange is 2s. and price is 6d. per lb., then when exchange is 1s. 4d. the price obtained or expected is 4d. per lb., in both cases there is the return of Rs. 11,000 against a cost of Rs. 10,000.
I stop here, hoping that some one of your numerous readers will point out if I have made any mistake. It is very important in matters of such complicated nature as mercantile transactions that the first premises or fundamental facts be clearly laid down. If this is done a correct conclusion will not be difficult to be arrived at. I have, therefore, confined myself to simple facts. If what I have said above is admitted, I shall next explain the operation of imports into India, and then consider in what way India is actually affected by the fall in exchange or in the value of silver.
National Liberal Club, September 2nd.
Yours faithfully, DADABHAI NAOROJI.
From the TIMES, September 13th, 1886.
Sir,—Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji, in his letter to you on this subject, seems to enunciate the proposition that because he gets 6d. per lb. for cotton when exchange is 2s. per rupee, therefore he will get 4d. per lb. when exchange is 1s. 4d. But it is not so. As a matter of fact, when exchange was 2s. per rupee the price of cotton was about 3d. per lb., and now with exchange at 1s. 5d. it is about 4d. per lb. The subject is not elucidated by imaginary data.
Yours respectfully, London, September 9th. R. L.
From the TIMES, September 13th, 1886.
Sir,—Allow me to point out that the account given by Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji, in the letter published in your columns of the 9th inst., of the effect on commercial transactions between India and England of a fall in the exchange value of the rupee is scarcely an adequate one.
Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji’s contention is twofold—first, that the commercial profit on an article of merchandise such as cotton is independent of the rate of exchange, and, secondly, that this is due to the fact that a fall in the rate of exchange is accompanied by a proportionate fall in the gold price of cotton in England.
The first of these contentions is so far correct that, although a sudden fall in exchange will, under ordinary circumstances, temporarily raise the exporter’s profit above the normal level, competition will always come into play to bring it back to that level.
The second of Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji’s contentions appears, however, to be based on a partial apprehension of the facts. When Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji talks of instructing his agent for a certain limit, he means, of course, that he instructs his agent not to sell below that limit. His agent, if he is a man of business, sells at the best price he can get consistently with his instructions, and this price is determined, not by the rate of exchange, but by the whole of the conditions affecting the market at the moment.
Other things being equal, the instant effect of a sudden fall in exchange is to increase the exporter’s margin of profit. Competition, as your correspondent points out, immediately sets in to reduce profit to its normal level. But in what way is it that competition operates to produce this effect? Surely by inducing an increase of supply. Other things being equal, it is in virtue of such an increase of supply alone that the price of the cotton in London can be lowered.
Now, increase of supply in London implies, as its correlate, increase of demand in India; and increase of demand in India implies, other things being equal, increase of price in India. In other words, equilibrium is attained, not, as your correspondent would have it, through a fall of the selling price in England proportionate to the fall in exchange, but through a fall of the selling price in England less than proportional to the fall in exchange combined with a rise of the buying price in India less than inversely proportional to the fall in exchange.
I am, Sir, your obedient Servant, Streatham Common. James W. Furrell.
From the Times, September 16th, 1886.
Sir,—In reply to “ R. L.’s ” letter in the Times of yesterday, I may first explain that I made no reference to actual prices in the market, as such prices are the resultant of many influences—supply, demand, bulling and bearing speculations, present stocks and future prospects of supply, every day’s telegraphic news from all parts of the world, political complications, Bank rate of interest, and various other small and temporary influences. I therefore explain again that what I am considering at present is the effect of only the fall and rise in exchange, leaving all other circumstances that affect prices as uninfluenced or unaltered.
“ R. L.” says :—“ As a matter of fact, when exchange was 2s. per rupee, the price of cotton was about 3d. per lb., and now, with the exchange at 1s. 5d., it is about 4d. per lb.” I do not find this to be a fact. Even were it fact it would not matter at all, as all other circumstances of supply, demand, etc., have to be taken into account therewith. But what “ R. L.” states does not appear to be a fact. I shall confine myself to cotton, though I could give similar decline in other principal commodities.
Exchange began to decline about the time when Germany demonetised its silver, about 1873. The Statistical Abstract of the United Kingdom, 33rd number, gives the “ average price ” of raw cotton as follows :—
| — | 1873. | 1874. | 1875. | 1876. | 1877. | 1878. | 1879. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Per cwt. £ | 4·01 | 3·62 | 3·47 | 3·02 | 2·93 | 2·80 | 2·76 |
| — | 1880. | 1881. | 1882. | 1883. | 1884. | 1885. | — |
| Per cwt. £ | 2·94 | 2·92 | 2·93 | 2·91 | 2·85 | 2·86 | — |
This shows a fall of nearly 30 per cent.
Now Mr. Furrell’s letter. He is right in supposing that the shipper’s instructions mean not to sell below the limit. I have been a merchant and an agent in the City for some 25 years, and, knowing full well what my shipper meant, I sold at the best price I could get. He is also right in saying that the price is determined by the whole of the conditions affecting the market at the moment, and that is just the reason why, as I have said above, I did not refer to actual prices. So far we agree, but Mr. Furrell’s fallacy begins in this sentence : “ Other things being equal, the instant effect of a sudden fall in exchange is to increase the exporter’s margin of profit.” Here he first forgets the “ whole of the conditions ” to which he referred in the previous paragraph, as determining the price at any moment, and next he forgets that the increase of the margin takes place in the case of those exporters only who have already entered into their transactions, and those transactions at the moment are uncompleted, so far as the remittances of the proceeds are concerned. But those exporters who have yet to begin their transactions have no such increase in their margin of profit, as they have not yet had any transaction or margin of profit, pending or existing. I took the simplest instance of an exporter entering into a transaction at a particular rate of exchange, and described the process of the operation of that transaction from its initiation, as far as exchange alone was concerned, independent of “the whole of the conditions.” And then I further explained that any fluctuation in exchange during the pendency of the transacton was the exporter’s further chance of profit or loss. But I may go further, and now explain that even in the case of transactions already entered into, the fluctuations in exchange do not affect the exporter in the bulk of the trade. The bulk of the shipments from India are drawn against, and as soon as this is done, the exporter has no further interest at all in any subsequent fluctuations in exchange, beyond his little margin above the amount of his bill, and thus it will be seen that in most cases there is no instant effect to increase the exporter’s margin of profit.
Yours faithfully, National Liberal Club, Dadabhai Naoroji. September 14th.
From the Times, September 20th, 1886.
Sir,—Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji, in his letter in the Times of this morning, while finding in my previous communication a “fallacy” which has no place in it, leaves altogether untouched the point really at issue between us.
After stating that the price of an article of Indian export depends, not on the rate of exchange only, but on the whole of the conditions affecting the market at the moment, I proceeded to treat the question on the basis taken up by your correspondent, and to consider the effect of the rate of exchange apart from all other conditions.
“Other things being equal,” I remarked, “the instant effect of a sudden fall in exchange is to increase the exporter’s margin of profit.”
Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji quotes this sentence correctly enough, but in criticising it he entirely ignores the force of the words that I have italicised. He says I first forget the “whole of the conditions” referred to in the previous paragraph, the fact being that by the words “other things being equal,” I expressly exclude these conditions.
I next, your correspondent adds, forget that the increased margin of profit affects only transactions begun but not completed, while leaving unaffected the transactions not yet begun. How the “instant” effect of a sudden fall in exchange could apply to transactions not begun is not very obvious.
There was the less room for misunderstanding that I went on to say that, under ordinary circumstances, competition at once came into play to reduce profit to its normal level.
The fact is Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji and myself are in agreement except on one point, to which he makes no reference in the letter under reply.
He contends that competition operates by reducing prices in England proportionally to the fall in exchange. I contend that competition operates by concurrently reducing prices in England, and raising them in India.
I am, Sir, your obedient Servant, Streatham Common, James W. Furrell. September 15th.
From the TIMES, September 27th, 1886.
Sir,—Mr. Furrell’s letter, published in the Times of to-day, concludes :—” The fact is Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji and myself are in agreement except on one point, to which he makes no reference in the letter under reply. He contends that competition operates by reducing prices in England proportionally to the fall in exchange. I contend that competition operates by concurrently reducing prices in England and raising them in India."
Now what Mr. Furrell says in his first letter is this :—” Competition, as your correspondent points out, immediately sets in to reduce profit to its normal level. But in what way is it that competition operates to produce this effect ?” And then he answers himself by begging the whole question :—” Surely by inducing an increase of supply.” And he goes on, " Other things being equal " (though he does not allow among the " other things " supply to remain equal), " it is in virtue of such an increase of supply alone that the price of the cotton in London can be lowered."
Now, as an independent fact, an increase of supply may, no doubt, lower prices. But it is not in virtue of an increase of supply alone that prices can be lowered in London. What I am pointing out is, how the competition and the lower price are the direct result of lower exchange or higher value of gold only, without any increase of supply being at all induced or made, and any rise in price being caused in India. The fact simply is that, because gold is of higher value, cotton is sold at as much less gold as would suffice to bring back to the exporter his actual outlay and profit. Or, putting it in another way, the manufacturer of England may send his order direct to India to buy at the silver price there, and pay his gold for it at the rate of exchange, without a single ounce of additional supply or any increase in price in India being necessitated.
What I mean, then, is simply this. To treat the subject in its simplest form, I take every other circumstance—i.e., supply, demand, etc.—to remain the same, and consider the effect of exchange only, and I show that from this simple cause—viz., the lower exchange only—if price be 6d. when exchange is 2s., the price will be 4d. when exchange is 1s. 4d., irrespective of or without causing any increase whatever in the supply or in the price in India.
Yours faithfully, Dadabhai Naoroji.
National Liberal Club, September 20th.
From the DAILY NEWS, September 24th, 1886.
Sir,—I now state the mode of operation of an import transaction into India. Taking all other circumstances to remain the same, suppose I am willing to lay out Rs. 10,000 for importing, say, 50 bales of grey shirtings—supposing that 2s. per rupee be the exchange—I find that I shall have to pay 6s. per piece in order that, at the market price in India, I should be able to realise Rs. 11,000 on the sale. Now, when exchange goes down to 1s. 4d., I see that, unless I am able to buy in England at 4s. a piece (instead of 6s.), either I cannot send the indent from India or the market price must rise in India as much as I may have to pay more than 4s. in England. Under the ordinary operation of economic laws, it is not necessary that I should be obliged to pay more than 4s. per piece in England. Gold having appreciated here — in other words, prices of all commodities having proportionately fallen—the cost of production to the manufacturer will be so much less gold. What cost him 6s. in gold before now costs him only 4s. in gold, and he is able to sell to me at 4s. for what he formerly charged 6s., the value of 4s. now being equal to that of the 6s. before, and I am able to sell at the same number of rupees now in India as I did before when exchange was 2s. per rupee, and the price of the shirting was 6s. per piece. Suppose in England the produce of a farm is worth £100, and that the landlord, the tenant, or farmer, and the labourers divided it equally, or £33⅓ each. Now, suppose gold having risen, the same produce is worth only £75. The share of each should then be £25, which, at its higher value or purchasing power is equal to the former £33⅓. But the landlord thinks he must still have his £33⅓, and the wage-earners ask for the same quantity of gold as before, and a struggle arises. But whatever the struggle between them (into the merits of which I need not enter here) the produce fetches £75 only (equal in value to the former £100). The manufacturer thus gets his raw produce, whether home or foreign, at the depreciated price. The manufacturer also has his difficulty with the item of wages, which, if not proportionately reduced according to the rise in gold, prevents the cost of the manufactured article being fully reduced. But the market price of the article falls in accordance with the appreciation of gold, and the indentor from India gets what he wants at such reduced gold price. Articles produced in limited quantities or of reputed makers, or of some specialities, may and do command their own prices, and Indian importers may be, or are, obliged to pay some higher price for the same; but for the great bulk of the articles of trade the Indian importer has not to pay generally much more than he did before, except so far as any fluctuations in exchange during the course of the transaction may necessitate any higher or lower payment. All other circumstances remaining the same, the indentor from India pays more or less gold according to the state of the exchange, paying less gold when gold is high or exchange and silver low, or paying more gold when gold is low and exchange or silver high; the result being that the importer pays the same amount of silver whether exchange is low or high. He lays out his Rs. 10,000 and gets the goods in England at such varying prices in gold, according to exchange, as enable him to get Rs. 11,000 on sale in India.
To sum up, for the bulk of the trade, other circumstances remaining the same, India does not get for her exports more silver for her produce, but less gold at lower exchange ; and she does not pay for her imports more silver, but less gold at lower exchange. In actual operation the result, of course, is not quite so rigid. Various influences affect the course of the market. What I mean is, that taking the simple element of appreciation of gold and fall in silver or exchange, the course of trade is not much affected in prices in India. Were India concerned merely in the fall in exchange and nothing else, that would not have mattered much to her, beyond making the owners of gold so much richer in proportion to the fall in silver, as compared with gold, and introducing an additional element of the chances of profit or loss, in the fluctuations in the rate of exchange during the pendency of the transactions. But even in that case, the exporting merchant protects himself from this risk by selling his bills against his produce to the Indian Banks, whereby the rate of exchange for his transaction is fixed. The proceeds of his produce have to pay a certain sterling amount to the bank here. As far as the banks are concerned, they are dealers in money. For every bill that they buy in India in order to receive money in this country they sell also in India a bill to pay in this country. The two operations are entered into at same time at different rates of exchange, and the difference of the rate is their profit of the day, all selling and buying transactions covering each other. Those exporters who do not draw against their produce or shipment, and wait for returns from England, undertake the additional chance of loss or gain of the fluctuation of exchange, just as they take the chance of loss or gain from fluctuations in price from other causes. The importer of goods into India is not so well able to protect himself against the fluctuations of exchange when he cannot buy ready-made goods, and must wait for some time for the execution of his order by the manufacturer. But by telegraphic communications and by selling bills forward here much protection is secured. Upon the whole, as I have said above, fall in exchange would not matter much to India if her trade alone were concerned. She can control her wants by taking more or less. But the direction in which India really suffers, and suffers disastrously, from the fall in exchange or silver is a different one. I shall state my views upon that subject in my next.
Yours faithfully, National Liberal Club. Dadabhai Naoroji.
From the Daily News, September 28th, 1886.
Sir,—I would give a few details of the transactions of trade between England and India to make the effect of fluctuations in exchange a little clearer. Resuming the illustration of my first letter, of Rs. 10,000 laid out for 100 bales of cotton, I first take the case in which the exporter does not draw against his shipment, but waits for remittance of proceeds of sale from England. Suppose he has based his transaction on an exchange of 1s. 4d. per rupee to sell at 4d. per lb. to get back his Rs. 11,000. Suppose, before the cotton is sold exchange falls to 1s. 2d. This fall in exchange (all other things remaining the same) lowers the price to 3½d. per lb., and suppose the cotton is so sold. To the exporter this fall will make no difference, as though his cotton sold at ½d. less, he gets the difference made up by the lower exchange of 2d., and thus gets the same amount of silver as he had calculated on. The same will be the result if exchange rose and price rose with it. Though he will get more gold from the rise in price, he will get as much less silver owing to the rise in exchange, the result being the original amount of silver. Suppose again that exchange falls or rises after the cotton is sold, but before the proceeds are converted into silver, by the purchase of silver or bill of exchange. In that case, if the exchange falls, it is so much profit to the exporter, as he will get more silver for the gold already secured by the sale when exchange was higher; and if exchange rises he loses, as he gets so much less silver at the higher exchange. Next I take the transaction in which the exporter draws against his cotton, so that he gets his silver back at once from the bank that buys his draft at the exchange he has calculated on, and undertakes that the bank shall have a fixed amount of gold paid to it in England out of the proceeds of the sale. In other words, the exporter converts his outlay from silver into gold—i.e., instead of Rs. 10,000 in silver it is now fixed to a certain amount in gold to be paid to the bank in England.
Now, suppose exchange falls before the cotton is sold. With the fall in exchange there is a corresponding fall in price, and the exporter realises so much less gold. But as he has already engaged to pay a fixed amount of gold to the Bank on the basis of a higher exchange, he suffers as much loss as the proceeds are shorter than the amount of the draft. A fall in exchange in such a case is a loss and not a profit to the exporter. In that case, it is the rise in exchange before produce is sold that is profitable to the exporter. Next, suppose that exchange rises or falls after the cotton is sold, that would not matter to the exporter at all, because he has not to receive any remittance, but the gold of the proceeds is to be given away to the Bank, excepting only such surplus or deficit that the proceeds may leave after the payment to the Bank. It will be seen from the above that in the two different kinds of operations—viz., clear shipments and draft shipments, the results from the fluctuations of exchange are entirely the reverse of each other. In the second case, in which the shipment is drawn against, and which forms the bulk of the actual export transactions, a fall in exchange before the goods are sold is a loss, and not profit, to the shipper. In considering, therefore, the result of the fall in exchange, it is necessary to bear in mind whether the particular transaction is a free shipment or a draft shipment, for in each case the result is quite different. And as the bulk of the export trade of India is of draft shipments, the result of a fall in exchange is a risk of loss, and not a chance of profit. The shipper who draws against his shipment does not desire a fall in exchange, but a rise, before his goods are sold; for such rise, by raising the price, will give him so much more gold to leave a balance in his favour after paying the Bank the amount of gold already contracted for and fixed by the draft. The surplus gold will go back to him as so much more profit than he had calculated upon. The general idea that a fall in exchange is somehow or other always a gain to the exporter of produce from India, is not correct. As shown above, in the case of shipments against which bills are drawn (and which is the case with most of the export business), a fall in exchange before the cotton is sold is actually adverse and a loss to the exporter. Once exchange becomes settled, subject only to the usual small trade fluctuations, it is no matter at all whether a rupee is 2s. or 1s. The price of produce will adapt itself to the relations of gold and silver, and the exporter will get back only his outlay and usual profit, whatever the exchange may be.
In the case of imports into India, in a certain way the importer is able to be free from any risk of the fall in exchange. He telegraphs his order to his agent here to buy at a certain price at a certain exchange. The agent manages, if the market allows it, to buy at the limit, and sell a bill at the same time at the required exchange. If the goods are ready made, the agent sells his bill at once. If there is delay in the manufacturing of the goods, he sells the bill forward, so that when the goods are ready the Bank engages to buy the bill at the stipulated rate of exchange, no matter whether the rate of the day is the same or more or less. As in the case of the exporter, it is also the same with the importer, that when exchange is normally settled it does not matter to him whether it is 2s. or 1s. per rupee. The price and the trade adjust themselves, and settle down into a normal condition, according to the relation between gold and silver. As a further elucidation of the fact that fall in exchange brings down proportionally a fall in the price of the produce exported from India, I may mention that if the holders of cotton in England did not sell their cotton in accordance with the relation between gold and silver, or in other words according to exchange, the cotton manufacturers can send their orders to Bombay to buy there at the silver price, and then pay in gold according to the exchange—i.e., remit from England silver or bank bills according to the price of silver or rate of exchange. The manufacturers in England know every day what the prices are in India, and can, and often do, buy there by telegram as readily as in Liverpool or London. As this letter has already become long enough, I postpone the consideration of the actual and permanent injury to India caused by the fall from 2s. per rupee to my next letter.
Yours faithfully,
National Liberal Club, September 24th.
Dadabhai Naoroji.
Notes
- 1. This clause was an addition proposed by Sir Herbert Edwards.
- 1. To our misfortune and to the dishonour of the authorities, it has been made a dead letter.
- 1. “All open competitive examinations heretofore held in England alone for appointments to the Civil Services of India shall henceforth be held simultaneously both in India and England, such examinations in both countries being identical in their nature, and all who compete being finally classified in one list according to merit.”
- 1. The members of the Committee were : Mr. J. P. Willoughby, Sir Erskine Perry, Sir W. H. Arbuthnot, Mr. Ross D. Mangles, and Mr. E. Macnaghten.
- 1. The Population figures are taken from the Census Returns of 1881.— Wm. D.
- 1. I group these together, as, under the scheme of the Commissioners, it is intended they shall have the same privileges as Indians in regard to entrance into the Provincial Service.—Wm. D.
- 1. Italics are mine.
- 1. Five millions sterling were contributed by the English Exchequer to the War Expenses.
- 2. Provision is made in the Budget Estimate for 1896-97 for a further sum of Rs. 4,954,000 to be expended on these useless railways.
- 3. “A large sum has been spent on defences and military establishments at Quetta, including an advanced position covering the place, strategic roads, and defences for various bridges, tunnels, etc., on the Sind-Pishin Railway. . . . . An entrenched position has been formed at Rawal Pindi, and a defensive post at Multan."—“Indian Finance Statement for 1896-97."
- 4. This sum only represents a small portion of the money expended on military roads in Beluchistan and other places beyond the Indus, as large sums are annually disbursed by both the military and civil departments in building new roads and maintaining the old ones.
- 1. Provision is made in the Budget Estimate for 1896-97, for Rs. 4,949,000, “for preparations for mobilisation of the Field Army."
- 2. The maintenance of the Transport Branch of the Commissariat Department cost, in 1893-94, no less than Rs. 3,408,140; yet, in the following year, it broke down when called upon to provide carriage for the Division of 15,000 men mobilised for the relief of Chitral,
- 1. Indian Financial Statement for 1882-83.
- 2. Ib., 1889-90, page 24, par. 57.
- 1. See Table of Costs, XVI A, 1891, Rs. 1,321,000 (Rs. 800,000 + 521,000).
- 2. Sir Henry Brackenbury, Military Member of the Viceroy’s Council, in his remarks on the military expenditure in 1895-96, mentions that “no less than 40,000 transport animals were employed with the Chitral Relief Force.” As regards camels, he said: “We were dependent entirely upon hired camels, or upon camels purchased expressly for the campaign. . . . But the number which could be hired was extremely small, and at the very outset the Government was obliged to have recourse to purchase. . . . . The camels purchased by Government have for the most part so broken down in health that it has been found impracticable to retain any but a very small number of them for future use.”
- 1. Indian Financial Statement for 1881-82.
- 2. Ib., 1896-97.
- 1. I understand that there is no charge now. (Coinage Act of 1870, Sec. 8.)