1. Government of India to Secretary of State, November 9th, 1878 :—
“ 12. . . . And bearing in mind the necessary fixity of much of the existing taxation, the difficulty of finding new sources of revenue, and the dissatisfaction caused by all increases of taxation, even by those for which there is the most urgent necessity, it is indisputable that the political inconvenience of this gradually increasing burden is extremely great, aggravated as it further is by the uncertainty of its amount and the impossibility of foreseeing its fluctuations, which may at any moment become the cause of the most grave financial embarrassment.”—(C. 4,868, 1886, p. 19.)
2. Now is it not very strange that the necessity of avoiding additional taxation is met by laying on as heavy a taxation as possible in the covert way of creating a false rupee ?
3. “ 74. To this might further be added that the political risks of the present time, and the prospects they create of necessary additional taxation, which, if our proposals were adopted, might be avoided wholly or to a great extent, or even be met by reduction of taxation, add force to the argument that if these changes are to be made, there would be special political advantage in making them now.”—(P. 26.)
4. Now this beats everything. While by proposing the device of closing the mints, and giving a false value to the rupee, they are actually increasing the burden of taxation to the extent of the false increase of the value of the rupee, the Government, with an extraordinary naivete, say that their proposals will “even be met by reduction of taxation !” The Government of India has beaten itself !
5. India Office to Treasury January 26th, 1886 :— “It is not, however, upon the large amount of the charge that Lord Randolph Churchill is desirous of dwelling, so much as upon the extreme difficulty in which the Government of India is placed in regulating its finances, and the dangers that attend a position in which any sudden fall in the exchange may require the increased charge caused thereby to be met by additional taxation.”—(C. 4,868, 1886, p. 4.)
6. “The imposition of additional taxation has always been a matter of much anxiety to the Indian Government, and the greatest objection has always been evinced to imposing such taxation in forms to which the people are unaccustomed, or to frequent changes, or to measures which give rise to fears of possible further changes and additional taxes.”—(P. 4.) Is it for this reason that this covert way was discovered to impose heavy additional taxation ?
7. Government of India to the Secretary of State for India, February 2nd, 1886 :— “Speaking generally, the period of financial pressure to which we refer may be said to have extended from 1873-74 to 1880-81, and to have involved increased taxation, large reductious in public works expenditure, and a heavy addition to the gold debt held in England.”—(C. 4,868, 1886, p. 6.)
8. “This state of affairs would be an evil of the greatest magnitude in any country in the world; in a country such as India it is pregnant with danger.”—(P. 7.) And so the Government of India aggravate this state !
9. “If a stable ratio between gold and silver cannot be secured we must continue to add to the gold debt of India, though we are fully aware of the objections to borrowing largely in England in a time of peace, and view with apprehension the additional burden which will be imposed on India when borrowing in England ceases, and the remittances from India must be increased in order to pay the interest charge on an increased gold debt.”—(P. 8.) Is that the reason why Government goes on increasing this debt with a light heart ?
10. The words used by Lord Lytton’s Government in a despatch dated November 9th, 1878, might be applied almost literally to the circumstances of the present day.
11. “At the present time when political events may throw upon India new burdens of unusual magnitude, the position of our Government in relation to this question assumes a character of extreme gravity. Whether, if such demands upon us arise, they would require us to have resort to increased taxation to provide additional resources for the service of the year, or to loans to meet sudden or unusual charges, or, as may be more probable, to a combination of the two, the anxiety that will attend our financial administration must be very great; and if the holders of silver should under any combination of circumstances, throw any considerable quantity on the market, as is at all events possible, the consequences to India might be financially disastrous. How a sudden call to supply by taxation a million or more to provide for further loss by exchange, and one or two millions for war charges could be met, we are at a loss to know; yet that such demands might arise no one can say is so improbable as to remove them from a serious claim on our attention. The prospects of a loan in such a case would not be much more satisfactory. Any temporary relief obtained by borrowing in England would be more than compensated by the increased burdens created in the future, and the necessary tendency of things would be to go from bad to worse.” (P. 10.)
12. So it appears that this “extreme gravity,” “the anxiety,” and going “from bad to worse” were the reasons why wars of Imperial interest were undertaken, and why the increasing burdens are going on! And why it is now decided that India and India alone should bear every burden?
13. Lord Randolph Churchill, in his letter to the Treasury of January 26th, 1886, says :—“ It is not, however, upon the large amount of the charge that Lord Randolph Churchill is desirous of dwelling so much as upon the extreme difficulty in which the Government of India is placed in regulating its finances and the dangers that attend a position in which any sudden fall in exchange may require the increased charge caused thereby to be met by additional taxation.”
14. These extracts are sufficient to show the anxiety of the Government for increasing burdens on the people, and political danger to Government ; and the beauty of the whole thing is, that they have done and are doing the very things which they proclaimed loudly should not be done : increased both taxation with a light heart and political danger with a vengeance !
15. I shall add what was said on the passing of the Bill in 1893 :—
(C. 7,098, 1893, p. 15.)
In the Legislative Council of June 26th, 1893, the Hon. Mr. Mackay, who was perhaps one of the most active persons in bringing about this legislation, said :—
“I am completely in accord with the provisions of the Bill just introduced by the Hon. Sir David Barbour, and with the greatest deference I venture to congratulate your Excellency on having succeeded in bringing forward a measure which will have the effect, not only of restoring the finances of the country to a satisfactory condition, but which will also impart to trade and commercial transactions that legitimate amount of certainty of which they have been deprived for the past twenty years. The measure at the same time relieves the country of that dread of additional and seriously disturbing taxation which has been weighing upon it for some time past.”
His Excellency the President said (p. 18) :—
16. “I think, then, that I may sum up this part of the case by saying that it has now been established almost beyond controversy that to leave matters as they were meant for the Government of India hopeless financial confusion ; for the commerce of India a constant and ruinous impediment ; for the taxpayers of India the prospect of heavy and unpopular burdens ; for the consumers of commodities a rise in the prices of the principal necessaries of life ; and for the country, as a whole, a fatal and stunting arrestation of its development (p. 20).” . . . . “We earnestly hope that our proposals may be fruitful of good, that the commerce of India may be relieved from an impediment which has retarded its progress, that the Government of India may be enabled to meet its obligations without adding to the burdens of the taxpayer; and that capital will flow more freely into this country without the adventitious stimulus which we have hitherto been unable to refuse. We trust, finally, that in process of time sufficient reserves of gold may be accumulated to enable us to render our gold standard effective, and thereby to complete the great change towards which we are taking the first steps to-day. Time only can show whether all these hopes will be fulfilled or be disappointed."
17. Vain, unfortunate hope! A Currency Committee is sitting again. What was said by the Treasury and others has come to pass, and all the glowing prophecies of the Indian authorities, based upon clear fallacies, have been falsified—and yet persistence in the same course!