Statement Submitted by Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji to the Currency Committee.
The questions of exchange and currency in connexion with India have, unlike those questions in other countries, two different branches, and it is very important to keep them distinctly in mind. (1) Political. (2) Commercial.
(1) The political aspect entails upon British India the compulsory remittance of about £16,000,000 to this country every year (which will now be £19,000,000, as no more railway capital will be forthcoming to be used here instead of drawing on India). I am not discussing here the righteousness or otherwise of this state of affairs. It is the loss caused by the fall in exchange in the remittances of these (now) £19,000,000 which is the point under consideration. Otherwise the question of exchange would have no significance, as I have shown in my letters to the Times in September, 1886.
The proposal to introduce a gold currency into India is based on the argument that it would save all present loss to the people of India from the fall in exchange. It will do nothing of the kind. It will simply inflict greater loss and hardship on the wretched Indian taxpayer. I explain.
The Indian taxpayer, at the time when exchange was 2s. per rupee, was sending produce to England worth 16 crores of rupees to meet the payment of £16,000,000. Now, taking exchange, say roundly 1s. per rupee, he has to send produce worth 38 crores of rupees to meet the (present) remittance of £19,000,000—or at a double rate. To avoid the confusion of ideas that prevails through the present controversy, I would eliminate silver altogether from the problem and put it in another form—that when one rupee was equal to 2s. the Indian taxpayer sent, say, one million tons of produce to meet the £19,000,000 of Home Charges—when a rupee is 1s. he has to send two million tons of produce to meet the same demand. Whether the currency be gold or silver or copper or lead will not be of the slightest consequence. The Indian taxpayer will have to send to this country as much produce, and not one ounce less, as would purchase £19,000,000—the only difference in the quantity of produce to be sent will depend solely on the rise or fall in gold. Only there will be on the poor taxpayer this additional infliction—that he will be saddled with the heavy cost of the conversion of the currency in gold; and gold becoming so much more in demand will still further rise, and the taxpayer will have to send so much more produce to meet the additional rise in the value of gold. All talk of saving to the Indian the present loss by fall in exchange is pure imagination.
Again, suppose a ryot is paying Rs. 10 as land tax. When gold currency is introduced, what will Government take from him in place of Rs. 10 ? Will Government demand at the supposed rate of 1s. per rupee—i.e., ten shillings only—or will Government demand arbitrarily in its despotic power at the rate of the fictitious value of a rupee as two shillings and will take £1, or any amount at any higher rate above the intrinsic value of the rupee ? Taking the gross revenue comprehensively, the total gross revenue is Rs. 850,000,000, what will Government take from the taxpayer when gold currency is introduced ? Will it take at the present supposed rate of 1s. per rupee, viz., £42,500,000, or will it arbitrarily impose a double revenue at the rate of 2s. per rupee, so that from his present poor produce the taxpayer must sell double the produce to meet the demands of Government. If the latter, what a precious benefit will this be to the Indian taxpayer from the gold currency !
When gold currency is introduced what salary will be paid to the European official ? Suppose he has a salary of Rs. 1,000 per month, will Government give him at the rate of 1s. per rupee i.e., £50, and will the official accept £50 for the Rs. 1,000 ? Is no all the present strong agitation of the Anglo-Indian a clear reply that he will do nothing of the kind, but will continue his agitation till he gets £100 or something near it for his Rs. 1,000 : or in other words get his salary doubled at a stroke, at the expense of the starving ryot ? And has not Government already shown that it will yield to such agitation, and will be readily “liberal” to European demands at the sacrifice of the Indians ? It has already yielded to the demands of the Uncovenanted Europeans and has given them a fixed exchange of 1s. 9d. per rupee for their furlough, no matter whether exchange is 1s. or even less, say 6d. Now the whole European service is agitating to get them 1s. 9d. or some other high fixed exchange, even to the extent of half their salary. Do these Anglo-Indians really want to exact from the starving ryot such high exchange when the rupee is worth perhaps a shilling or even sixpence ? Who will pay this difference ? Of course an arbitrary Government may oppress a people as much as they like, but will the British people and Parliament allow such a thing ?
On the top of all this comes the merchant with his agitation for the gold currency, that he may be saved, at the sacrifice of the ryot, from his risks of trade. The profits of trade are for his pocket, but risks of a commercial disturbance must be met by the ryot ! The poverty-stricken ryot must protect the well-to-do-trader ! God save India !
I do not need to trouble the Committee with any further remarks as to the effect of the introduction of a gold currency on the condition of the people, who, according to Lord Lawrence’s testimony, are living on scanty subsistence, and who, according to Lord Cromer, are already “extremely poor.” Our friends the Anglo-Indians have to bear in mind that they are taking already from the mouths of the poor Indian about Rs. 150,000,000 or more every year as salaries, allowances, pensions, etc., to the so much deprivation of the provision of the children of the soil. Will they never understand or consider this, and what evil that means to India ?
A word about the proposal to stop free coinage of silver. Now we know that a trade, internal or external, especially internal, requires abundant currency in a country like India; the curtailment of the coinage of the rupee will dislocate and cripple the free action of the trade of the country, especially internally, and will inflict serious injury and create some new complications. Secondly, the rupee, being thus artificially raised to a fictitious value by being made scarce, will depress the price of produce, and the ryot will be obliged to part with more of his poor produce to meet the demands of Government. Will this be a benefit to him ? Further, by this restriction on coinage the wretched Indian taxpayer will not be relieved of a single ounce of produce in his forced remittances for the Home Charges of £19,000,000—in gold. Whatever the exchangeable value of gold is in relation to produce will have to be paid by the poor ryot, be the forced artificial exchange or the fictitious value of the rupee what it may. By restricting the coinage of silver—the price of silver in relation to produce being artificially enhanced— the taxpayer will have to pay the salary of all the European and other officials in such higher priced rupee, with so much more produce to part with ! which, in short, will in effect be a far heavier burden, by increasing the whole salary of the officials of all the services, both Indians and Europeans, at so much the greater sacrifice of the wretched ryot.
The agitation for stopping coinage of silver or introducing gold currency, far from relieving the Indian taxpayer from the present loss by fall in exchange, which in all conscience is very heavy indeed, will actually inflict greater injury upon the helpless fellows. All attempts at artificial tampering with currency will, besides injuring the people, recoil upon the perpetrators of the mischief. They can no more raise the value of silver fictitiously than they can suspend gravitation.
The evil of the present loss from exchange does not arise from the fall in exchange, but from the unfortunate unnatural political and economic condition of British India. Were there no compulsory remittances to this country (any ordinary free transactions of business or loans between two countries not mattering beyond the usual risks of business), there would be no evil or embarrassing loss to Government such as we are considering. The excessive European services are the cause of all such calamity upon the Indians. Any other silver-using country—for instance, China— has no problem like that which at present embarrasses the British Indian Government.
(2). Coming to the second branch of the question, viz., the effect of the fall in exchange on international trade (for it is in such trade or business only that exchange is concerned), the best thing I can do is to give below the letter I wrote to the Times in September, 1886, and some other letters (I have inserted those letters, which I need not repeat here). Of the letters to the Times that paper was pleased to write approvingly in one of its leaders.1 Further, I have made, in the statement, some remarks as to the action of the United States in endeavouring futilely to stop the silver storm, instead of allowing it to run its course. This I need not give here.
The step which the Government has now taken will, I am afraid, produce much mischief, and inflict great injury on the taxpayer, crushingly heavy loaded as he already is. The utmost that the Government might have done would have been, as I was afraid they were determined to do, to give some fixed exchange to the officials for their remittances to this country—to as much as half the salary. This would have been bad enough, but the course the Government have adopted, and for which there was no great necessity, will, I fear, prove far more injurious.
II.—STATEMENT SUBMITTED TO THE INDIAN CURRENCY COMMITTEE OF 1898.
Washington House, 72, Anerley Park, S.E. October 20th, 1898.
Dear Sir William,—Since my letter of 28th July last, I have perused the Blue Book of the evidence given before the Currency Committee, and I feel it necessary to make a further statement.
“ British India.”
2. These words are often used in a very misleading and confusing manner. I give below an extract from a statement which I have submitted to “the Royal Commission on Indian Expenditure and Apportionment of Charges,” which I hope will place the matter in a clearer light.
3. “Before I proceed further let me clear up a strange confusion of ideas about prosperous British India and poverty stricken British India. This confusion of ideas arises from this circumstance. My remarks are for British India only.
4. “In reality there are two Indias—one the prosperous, the other poverty-stricken. “(1) The prosperous India is the India of the British and other foreigners. They exploit India as officials, non-officials, capitalists, in a variety of ways, and carry away enormous wealth to their own country. To them India is, of course, rich and prosperous. The more they can carry away, the richer and more prosperous India is to them. These British and other foreigners cannot understand and realise why India can be called ‘extremely poor,’ when they can make their life careers; they can draw so much wealth from it and enrich their own country. It seldom occurs to them, if at all, what all that means to the Indians themselves.
“(2) The second India is the India of the Indians—the poverty-stricken India. This India, ‘bled’ and exploited in every way of their wealth, of their services, of their land, labour, and all resources by the foreigners; helpless and voiceless, governed by the arbitrary law and argument of force, and with injustice and unrighteousness—this India of the Indians becomes the ‘poorest’ country in the world, after one hundred and fifty years of British rule, to the disgrace of the British name. The greater the drain, the greater the impoverishment, resulting in all the scourges of war, famine, and pestilence. Lord Salisbury’s words face us at every turn: ‘Injustice will bring down the mightiest to ruin.’ If this distinction of the ‘prosperous India’ of the slave-holders, and the ‘poverty-stricken India’ of the slaves be carefully borne in mind, a great deal of the controversy on this point will be saved. Britain can, by a righteous system, make both Indias prosperous. The great pity is that the Indian authorities do not or would not see it. They are blinded by selfishness—to find careers for our ‘boys.’”—(Letter to Lord Welby, dated 31st January, 1897.)
5. This state of affairs arises from the evil system of an un-British foreign dominion, as predicted by Sir John Shore in 1787. This evil makes the action of the British trader and capitalist an exploitation which otherwise, under ordinary circumstances, under true British system, would be legitimate trade and investment.
6. Almost throughout the Blue Book the thing chiefly considered is the requirements and benefits of “The Foreign Prosperous British India.” “Indian’s India” chiefly comes in only for the consideration as to how to tax the Indians in order to meet the requirements and benefits of the British official bleeders and non-official exploiters. Earnestly and repeatedly are questions put and answers given how additional taxation should be raised—not how to probe the evil and to find the true remedy.
7. The main scope and direction of the evidence is as if India were a country and property of the Anglo-Indians, and British traders and capitalists; as if, therefore, their wants and requirements, and the means of enabling them to carry away as much wealth as they possibly can to England, were the chief object; and as if to consider the land, resources, and labour of India as only the instruments for the above purpose.
“INDEBTEDNESS OF INDIA.”
8. This expression is repeatedly brought out for the self-satisfaction and justification of the exploitation. Let us examine how this particular phenomenon is brought about.
9. The process is this : The total amount of “Home Charges” is £15,795,836 (Statistical Abstract for 1896-7, p. 106 [c. 9,036], 1898). Out of this I deduct fully : Railways, £5,790,567, and Stores Department, £951,700. In deducting these two items I do not mean that I admit the necessity of doing so entirely, but that I want to avoid any controversy at this stage upon what are called “Public Works Loans” made by England, and Government Stores. The remainder, after making the above deduction, is £9,053,569 = Rs. 199,178,518, at 11d. per rupee, about Rs. 22 per £1, about which is the present legitimate rate for the true rupee, and which, with much more, though under disguise, the Indian taxpayer is actually forced to pay. Taking, roughly, Rs. 200,000,000, every pie of it is drawn from the people of British India and becomes an addition to the capital or wealth of England, and is altogether spent in England every year.
10. Next, the European services are paid in India every year (at Rs. 1,000 and upwards per annum, not including lower salaries) about Rs. 94,679,627 (including a small amount of pensions paid to Eurasians not separately given). (Parl. Ret. 192 of 1892.) I do not know whether this amount includes the payments made for and to European soldiers in India. I think not. If so, this has to be added to the above amount. To it has also to be added, I think, the illegal exchange compensation which is allowed to Europeans, thereby out-Shylocking Shylock himself by not only taking the pound of flesh, but an ounce of blood also. Almost the whole of this amount of Rs. 94,679,627, say, roughly, Rs. 95,000,000, plus soldiers’ payments and exchange compensation, is a loss to the people of British India, excepting, in a way, a small portion which goes to the domestic servants, house-owners, etc. But these amounts would have gone all the same to these domestics, etc., even though Indians had been in the place of the Europeans. The services rendered by such domestics, etc., being consumed by others than the children of the soil, are so far a loss to the country.
11. But I do not propose to argue this point here. I allow for the present this expenditure in British India by the European officials as not forming a part of the loss by the drain. I think it is generally claimed by the Anglo-Indians that such expenditure in India by European officials is about, on an average, half of the salaries and emoluments paid to them in India, and that the other half is about the amount which is remitted to England for families and the savings. Taking, therefore, this half of Rs. 94,679,627=Rs. 47,339,813, and adding this amount to Rs. 200,000,000 (paragraph 9), the total is, roughly, Rs. 250,000,000 every year ; probably more if the two additions mentioned above of European soldiers’ payments and exchange compensations were made. This enormous amount of annual political drain causes what Sir George Wingate very properly calls a " cruel and crushing tribute." Never could India have suffered such a cruel fate in all its history or existence.
12. The first step, therefore, towards the so-called “indebtedness” is that British India is “bled” every year to the amount of about Rs. 250,000,000 clean out of the country, and this enormous wealth is year after year poured into England. Will the India Office be good enough to make a return of the enormous wealth which England has drained out of India during its whole connexion ?
13. Now, the second stage in the process of the manufacture of “indebtedness” is that out of this enormous wealth drawn away from India—sufficient and far more than sufficient to build thousands of miles of railways and every possible public works, and to meet every possible requirement of good government and progress, to the highest prosperity and civilisation—out of this enormous drain a small portion is taken back to India as “British capital,” when it is nothing of the kind, and by means of the so-called “British capital” all Indian resources of land and labour are further exploited by “British” (?) capitalists of every kind. All the profits made thereon are so much more wealth drawn away from India and brought to England.
14. Further, the foreign exploiters are not satisfied with the small portion of “Indian wealth” which they take back to India as their own capital, but they insist upon being further helped from the very current revenues of the country. So voracious are these exploiters that they clamour against Government for not putting its whole revenue at their disposal in the Presidency banks, instead of keeping a portion in the Treasury. Thus there is at first a political “bleeding,” which is the foundation evil, and in its train and by its help comes the so-called “commercial” or capitalistic exploitation.
15. Thus is manufactured that complacent “indebtedness” in the name of which the bleeding and exploitation are unceasingly and ever-increasingly carried on, and which is so pleasant, so profitable, and so nice an excuse to the Anglo-Indian and “British capitalist’s” heart.
16. In reality there is not a single farthing of “indebtedness” from India to England. It is England that is under a very vast material and moral debt to India. Of the latter —moral debt—I cannot speak much here, though it is no less enormous and grievous than the former.
17. Besides the sum of Rs. 400,000,000 now drained from India (paragraph 24) every year, (1) the British Indian Empire is built up at the entire expense of India, and mainly with Indian blood. Even now Indian blood is contributing in extending the British Empire and benefits in other parts of the world. And what a reward—a helotry! (2) Not only this, but in addition to the cost of building up the whole Indian Empire England has taken away from India an amount of wealth since its connexion with India which, with ordinary commercial compound interest, will amount to thousands and thousands of millions sterling.
18. It may be asked whether I mean that I do not want British capitalists to go and trade or employ their capital in India? I mean nothing of the kind. By all means let them do so. Under ordinary circumstances India will hail it, as any other country may do. But let it be with their own capital. Let them bring their own capital, and make upon it as much profit as they can, with India’s blessing upon it. What I mean is that they should not first “plunder” India, leaving it wretched and helpless, then bring back a portion of “plundered” India’s wealth as their own, exploit therewith India’s resources of land and labour, carry away the profits, and leave the Indians mere hewers of wood and drawers of water—mere slaves, in worse plight than even that in which the slaves of the Southern States of America were.
19. If England can understand her true interests—political, moral, economic, or material—if she would hold back her hand from India’s throat, and let India enjoy its own resources, England can make India prosperous, and, as a necessary consequence, can derive from India far, far greater benefit, with India’s blessing, than what she derives at present with India’s curse of the scourges of war, and pestilence, and famine, and of an ever-increasing poverty.
20. The word “indebtedness” must be taken at its correct interpretation. It is simply “bleeding” and exploitation, or what Mr. Bright indirectly characterised “plunder.”
“Balance of Trade in India’s Favour,” and “Excess of Exports over Imports as a Benefit to India.”
21. What is balance of trade in its true sense? Say a country exports £100,000,000 worth of its produce. It gets back in imports, say, £80,000,000 worth of other countries’ merchandise. The remaining balance of £20,000,000 of the original exports, and, say, 10 per cent. of profits, or £10,000,000—altogether £30,000,000—has to be received. This £30,000,000 is called balance of trade in favour of that country. And when that country actually receives this balance of £30,000,000, either in the shape of bullion or merchandise, then its account is said to be squared or settled.
22. I have not included in this trade account any true borrowing or lending. Such borrowing or lending can be considered by itself. A country’s borrowing is included in its imports, and the interest it pays is a part of its exports. This loan account between any two independent countries can be estimated and allowed for. And that in no way affects the bonâ fide balance of trade. If India be allowed to and can get its true “balance of trade” it would be only too happy to make any legitimate borrowing or lending with any country, with benefit to both.
23. But such is not India’s condition. What is India’s actual condition ? What is its so-called “balance of trade,” of which much mistaken or wrong view is taken in the evidence ? Be it first remembered, as I have already explained under the heading of “indebtedness,” that what is called India’s debt is nothing of the kind, but simply and solely a part of its own wealth taken away from it.
24. Let us see what the amount is (C. 9,036, 1898, p. 277). Taking the last five years as an illustration, the total net exports for 1892-3 to 1896-7 are Rs. 1,314,600,000. The total exports for the same period are Rs. 5,688,000,000; taking 10 per cent. profits thereon, will be Rs. 568,800,000. Therefore the total excess of net exports, plus profits, would be Rs. 1,883,400,000. Then, again, the so-called “loans” from this country are included in imports, the net exports must be increased to that extent. The addition to commercial debt in this country after 1891-2 to 1896-7 is £6,479,000 (C. 9,036, 1898, p. 130), or, say, £6,500,000, which, at the average rate of exchange of the same years (p. 131), about 1s. 2d. per rupee, or nearly Rs. 17 per £1, is equal to Rs. 110,500,000. So that the total of net exports (excluding loans from imports) and profits will be Rs. 1,883,400,000 plus 110,500,000 equal to Rs. 1,993,900,000, or about roundly Rs. 2,000,000,000. During the five years the average per year will be about Rs. 400,000,000. Now, to call this a “balance of trade in favour of India” is the grossest abuse of language. It is neither any “trade” nor “balance of trade.” It is simply and solely the remittances of the official bleeding and the exploitation of the non-official capitalists. Not a pie of this tremendous amount—Rs. 400,000,000 every year—will India ever see back as its own : while in true balance of trade the whole of this amount should go back to India as its own.
25. No wonder Sir William Harcourt’s heart rejoiced at the leaps and bounds with which the income-tax increased year after year in this country. In his speech on the occasion of his famous Budget he rejoiced at the increasing income-tax, never seeming to dream how much of it was drawn from the “bleeding” drain from India.
26. With what self-satisfied benevolence have examiners and witnesses talked of the great benefit they were conferring upon India by making every effort to increase the excess of exports in order to enable poor India to meet her “indebtedness.” Such is the Indian myth! But what is the reality? To increase the net exports as much as possible means to increase the remittance of the bleeding and exploitations of every year of which not a farthing is to return to India as its own. Extraordinary, how ingeniously matters can be and are represented, or rather misrepresented, and the public here entirely misled!
Surpluses and Solvency.
27. There never have been and never will be true surpluses or solvency of British India as long as the present evil system of government lasts. What is a surplus of the finance of any country? Suppose that in England you raise £100,000,000 of revenue. Suppose £95,000,000 are spent and £5,000,000 remain in hand at the end of the year, and this £5,000,000 is called surplus, and that the Government, if it does not impose any additional taxation or does not borrow, is solvent. Now, the essential condition of this surplus is that the whole of the £95,000,000 has returned to the tax-paying people themselves in a variety of ways, and continues to be part and parcel of the wealth of the country. And the remaining £5,000,000 will also go back to the people and remain a part of the wealth of the country.
28. But what is the case with India? It is nothing of the kind. Suppose Rs. 1,000,000,000 are raised as revenue. Suppose Rs. 950,000,000 are spent, leaving Rs. 50,000,000 in hand at the end of the year. Now, are these Rs. 50,000,000 a surplus? No. The Rs. 950,000,000 have not all returned to the people and have not remained as part of India’s own wealth. Some Rs. 250,000,000 (see paragraph 12) are drained clean out of the country by foreigners, never to return to India. Till these Rs. 250,000,000 are returned to India as its own, which they never are, and which is a dead loss, to talk of the surplus of Rs. 50,000,000 is another gross abuse of language. Instead of Rs. 50,000,000 surplus there is a pure deficit or rather entire loss of Rs. 250,000,000. And such perpetual losses are pure bankruptcy.
29. I repeat, that there never has been and never will be any surplus in India as long as, from every year’s revenue, there is a clean drain, which at present is at the rate of about Rs. 250,000,000. In this country all that is raised as revenue returns to the country, just as all water evaporating from the ocean returns to the ocean. And England’s ocean of wealth remains as full as ever, as far as revenue is concerned. India’s ocean, on the contrary, must go on evaporating and drying every year more and more.
30. The only reason why the Indian Government does not go into bankruptcy—bankrupt though it always is—is that it can, by its despotism, squeeze out more and more from the helpless taxpayer, without mercy or without any let or hindrance. And if at any time it feels fear at the possible exasperation of the people at the enormity, it quietly borrows and adds to the permanent burden of the people without the slightest compunction or concern. Of course the Government of India can never become bankrupt till retribution comes and the whole ends in disaster.
31. I have referred in the above consideration to the official bleeding only, but when to this is added the further exploitation of the land (meaning all the resources) and labour of the country, which I have already described, the idea of surplus or solvency, or of any addition to the wealth or prosperity of the people (however much it may be of the Europeans) becomes supremely ridiculous and absurd.
Import of Bullion and Hoarding.
32. Reference is frequently made to this matter. I think the best thing I can do is to give an extract from my reply to Sir Grant Duff :—
Westminster Review, November, 1887.
33. “ Sir Grant Duff refers to the absorption of gold and silver and to hoarding. What are the facts about British India ? In my ‘ Poverty of India ’ I have treated the subject at some length. The total amount (after deducting the exports from imports) retained by India during a period of eighty-four years (1801 to 1884), including the exceptionally large imports during the American War, is £455,761,385. This is for all India. The population at present is 254,000,000. I may take the average of eighty-four years roughly—say, 200,000,000. This gives 45s. 6d. per head for the whole eighty-four years, or 6½d. per head per annum. Even if I took the average population as 180,000,000, the amount per head for the eighty-four years would be 50s., or 7d. per head per annum. Of the United Kingdom I cannot get returns before 1858. The total amount of treasure retained by the United Kingdom (after deducting exports from imports) is, for twenty-seven years from 1858 to 1884, £86,194,937. Taking an average of 31,000,000 of population for twenty-seven years, the amount retained for these twenty-seven years is 55s. 7d. per head, or very nearly 2s. 1d. per head per annum; while in India for more than three times the same period the amount is only 45s. 6d. per head, or 6½d. per head per annum. France has retained from 1861 to 1880 (Mulhall’s Dictionary) £208,000,000, and taking the population, say 37,000,000, that gives 112s. per head in twenty years, or 5s. 7d. per head per annum.
34. “Sir Grant Duff ought to consider that the large amount of bullion is to be distributed over a vast country and a vast population, nearly equal to five-sixths of the population of the whole of Europe; and when the whole population is considered what a wretched amount is this of gold and silver—viz., 6½d. per head per annum—received for all possible wants! India does not produce any gold or silver. To compare it with Europe: Europe retained in ten years, 1871-1880 (Mulhall, ‘Progress of the World,’ 1880), £327,000,000 for an average population of about 300,000,000, or 21s. 10d. per head, or 2s. 2d. per head per annum. India during the same ten years retained £65,774,252 for an average population of, say, 245,000,000; so that the whole amount retained for the ten years is about 5s. 4d., or only 6½d. per head per annum, against 21s. 10d. and 2s. 2d. respectively of Europe. This means that India retained only one-fourth of what Europe retained per head per annum during these ten years. It must be further remembered that there is no such vast system of cheques, clearing-houses, etc., in India as plays so important a part in England and other countries of Europe. Wretched as the provision of 6½d. per head per annum is for all wants—political, social, commercial, etc.—there is something far worse behind for British India. All the gold and silver that I have shown above as retained by India is not for British India only, but for the Native States, the frontier territories, and the European population; and then the remainder is for the Native population of British India. We must have official information about these four divisions before we can form a correct estimate of what British India retains. The Native States, as I have said before, have no foreign drain except the small amount of tribute of about £700,000. Some frontier territories receive something instead of paying any tribute. These States therefore receive back for the exports of their merchandise, and for the ordinary trade profits on such exports, full returns in imports of merchandise and treasure, and this treasure taken away by the Native States and frontier territories forms not a small portion of what is imported into India. It must also be considered how much metal is necessary every year for waste of coin and metal, and for the wants of circulating currency. When Government can give us all such information, it will be found that precious little remains for British India beyond what it is compelled to import for its absolute wants. I hope England does not mean to say that Englishmen or Englishwomen may sport as much as they like in ornaments or personal trinkets or jewellery, but that the wretch of a Native of British India, their fellow-subject, has no business or right to put a few shillings’ worth of trinkets on his wife’s or daughter’s person —or that Natives must simply live the lives of brutes, subsist on their ‘scanty subsistence,’ and thank their stars that they have that much.
35. “I will now try to give some indication of what bullion British India actually retains. Mr. Harrison gave his evidence before the Parliamentary Committee of 1871-74, that about £1,000,000 of fresh coinage was more than sufficient to supply the waste of coin or metal. Is it too much to assume that in the very widespread and minute distribution, over a vast surface and a vast population, of small trinkets or ornaments of silver, and their rough use, another million may be required to supply waste and loss? If only a pennyworth per head per annum be so wanted, it would make a million sterling. Next, how much goes to the Natives States and the frontier territories? Here are a few significant official figures as an indication: The ‘Report of the external land trade and railway-borne trade of the Bombay Presidency for 1884-85’ (p. 2) says of Rajputana and Central India:—‘13. The imports from the external blocks being greater than the exports to them, the balance of trade due by the Presidency to the other provinces amounts to Rs. 12,01,05,912, as appears from the above table and the following.’ I take the Native States from the table referred to.
| From Rajputana and Central India | Rs. 5,55,46,753 |
| „ Berar | 1,48,91,355 |
| „ Hyderabad | 8,67,688 |
| Total. | Rs. 7,13,05,796 |
Or £7,130,579. This means that these Native States have exported so much more merchandise than they have imported. Thereupon the Report remarks thus :—‘ The greatest balance is in favour of Rajputana and Central India, caused by the import of opium from that block. Next to it is that of the Central Provinces. It is presumed that these balances are paid back mainly in cash’ (the italics are mine). This, then, is the way the treasure goes; and poor British India gets all the abuse—insult added to injury. Its candle burns not only at both ends, but at all parts.”
36. Far from any important quantity or any quantity of bullion going to British India as “balance of trade,” Rs. 400,000,000 worth of British India’s wealth at present goes clean out of the country every year never to return to it as its own.
Benefits Derived from Cheap Silver.—A Low Rupee and Low Exchange Promotes and Develops Exports.
37. That there is some temporary advantage from low exchange to silver-using countries over gold-using countries, I have already explained in my letter to the Daily News of September 24th, 1886 (Appendix A of my letter already submitted). But in British India this little advantage is of not much avail to the poor people. What becomes of it when they must perforce lose every year, never to return to them, Rs. 400,000,000 of wealth out of their miserable total produce, leaving them so much more poor and miserable? It is idle to talk of the people of British India deriving benefit from low exchange or from anything as long as these tremendous bleedings and the exploitation go on.
Prices and Wages.
38. The above remarks apply equally to prices and wages. How on earth, under such drain, can there be any healthy increase of prices or wages arising from true prosperity? Before the Royal Commission on Indian Expenditure and Apportionment, a member having asserted that there was general rise of prices, Mr. Jacob, as official witness, confirmed the statement. Thereupon I prepared some questions, took the paper to Mr. Jacob, and gave it to him to enable him to prepare the replies. And, what was my surprise when he told me that the subject was not of his department, and he would not answer the questions, though he did not hesitate to say that there was a general rise of prices! If of any use I shall produce the questions before the Committee. But, first of all, there are no reliable statistics sufficient to draw any correct conclusions; and conclusions of any value cannot be drawn about any one factor from prices or wages which are the results of many factors.
39. I would not lengthen this statement by noting several other points in the Blue-book, but conclude by repeating what Sir John Shore has said more than a hundred years ago (in 1787). His words were true then, are true to this day, and will remain true in future if the evil pointed out by him continues. He said : “Whatever allowance we may make for the increased industry of the subjects of the State, owing to the enhanced demand for the produce of it (supposing the demand to be enhanced) there is reason to conclude that the benefits are more than counterbalanced by evils inseparable from the system of a remote foreign dominion."
40. This evil system must be altered, or, as I have said before (paragraph 5), what, under natural circumstances, would in any country be legitimate trade and investments by British people become, under this evil system of an un-British rule, cruel exploitation. Unless the evil is remedied, there is no hope for British India, and disaster both for England and India is the only look out.
41. Let England pay fairly and honestly her share of expenditure incurred for her own interests, and end the bleeding by a careful consideration of the following words of the Duke of Devonshire, as Secretary of State for India, spoken in 1883 : “There can, in my opinion, be very little doubt that India is insufficiently governed. . . . . . If the country is to be better governed, that can only be done by the employment of the best and most intelligent of the Natives in the service.” And the best means of attaining this object is to give honourable fulfilment to the Resolution passed by the House of Commons in June, 1893, about simultaneous examinations.
42. Unless Acts and Resolutions of Parliament and Royal Proclamations are honourably fulfilled, and a righteous Government, worthy of the English character and promises and professions is established, no currency or financial jugglery, or “political hypocrisy,” or any “subterfuges,” or un-British despotic ruling will avail or remedy the ever-growing and various evils that must constantly flow from an unrighteous system.
43. Lord Salisbury’s eternal words stare us in the face : “Injustice will bring down the mightiest to ruin.”
Yours truly,
Dadabhai Naoroji.
Sir William Wedderburn, M.P., Chairman of the British Committee of The Indian National Congress, 84, Palace Chambers, Westminster, S.W.
The following brochure was published by the India Reform Society in 1853 and reprinted in 1899.
INDIA REFORM. No. IX.—The State and Government of India under its Native Rulers.
INDIA REFORM SOCIETY, 1853.
On Saturday, the 12th of March, a Meeting of the Friends of India was held in Charles Street, St. James’s Square, with a view of bringing public opinion to bear on the Imperial Parliament in the case of India so as to obtain due attention to the complaints and claims of the inhabitants of that vast Empire. H. D. Seymour, Esq., M.P., having been called to the chair, the following Resolutions were agreed to by the meeting :—
- 1. That the character of the alterations to be effected in the constitution of our Indian Government at the termination of the East India Company’s Charter Act, on the 30th of April, 1854, is a question which demands the most ample and serious consideration.
- 2. That although Committees of both Houses of Parliament have been appointed, in conformity with the practice on each preceding renewal of the Charter Act, for the purpose of investigating the nature and the results of our Indian Administration, those Committees have been appointed on the present occasion at a period so much later than usual, that the interval of time remaining before the expiration of the existing powers of the East India Company is too short to permit the possibility of collecting such evidence as would show what alterations are required in our Indian Government.
- 3. That the enquiry now being prosecuted by Committees of the Legislature will be altogether unsatisfactory if it be confined to the evidence of officials and of servants of the East India Company, and conducted and terminated without reference to the petitions and wishes of the more intelligent of the Natives of India.
- 4. That it is the duty of the friends of India to insist upon a temporary Act to continue the present Government of India for a period not exceeding three years, so that time may be given for such full enquiry and deliberation as will enable Parliament within that period to legislate permanently for the future administration of our Indian Empire.
5. That in order to obtain such a measure, this meeting constitutes itself an “Indian Reform Society,” and names the undermentioned gentlemen as a Committee.
T. Barnes, Esq., M.P. J. Bell, Esq., M.P. W. Biggs, Esq., M.P. J. F. B. Blackett, Esq., M.P. G Bowyer, Esq., M.P. J. Bright, Esq., M.P. F. C. Brown, Esq. H. A. Bruce, Esq., M.P. Lieut.-Col. J. M. Caulfield, M.P. J. Cheetham, Esq., M.P. W. H. Clarke, Esq. J. Crook, Esq., M.P. J. Dickinson, Jun., Esq. M. G. Fielden, Esq., M.P. Lieut.-Gen. Sir J. F. Fitzgerald, K.C.B., M.P. W. R. S. Fitzgerald, Esq., M.P. M. Forster, Esq. R. Gardner, Esq , M.P. Right Hon. T. M. Gibson, M.P. Viscount Goderich, M.P. G. Hadfield, Esq., M.P. W. Harcourt, Esq. L. Heyworth, Esq., M P.
C. Hindley, Esq., M.P. T. Hunt, Esq. E. J. Hutchins, Esq., M.P. P. F. C. Johnstone, Esq. M. Lewin, Esq. F. Lucas, Esq., M.P. T. McCullagh, Esq. E. Miall, Esq., M.P. G. H. Moore, Esq., M.P. B. Oliveira, Esq., M.P. A. J. Otway, Esq., M.P. G. M. W. Peacocke, Esq., M.P. Apsley Pellatt, Esq., M.P. J. Pilkington, Esq., M.P. J. G. Phillimore, Esq., M.P. T. Phinn, Esq., M.P. H. Reeve, Esq. W. Scholefield, Esq., M.P. H. D. Seymour, Esq., M.P. W. D. Seymour, Esq., M.P. J. B. Smith, Esq., M.P. J. Sullivan, Esq. G. Thompson, Esq., M.P. F. Warren, Esq J. A. Wise, Esq., M.P.
Correspondence on all matters connected with the Society to be addressed to the Hon. Secretary, by whom subscriptions will be received in aid of its object.
John Dickinson, Jun., Hon. Sec.
Committee Rooms, Clarence Chambers, 12, Haymarket. April 12th, 1853.
NOTE BY DADABHAI NAOROJI.
March, 1899.
Whatever may be the merits or demerits of “The State and Government of India under its Native Rulers,” one thing is certain, that the greatest evil of the present un-British system of British rule in India did not exist under the Native rulers—viz., the unceasing and ever-increasing “bleeding” and drain of India by “the evils inseparable from the system of a remote foreign dominion” (Sir John Shore, 1787), and by inflicting upon India every burden of expenditure incurred even for the interests of Britain itself. This evil is further aggravated by what Lord Salisbury calls “political hypocrisy,” or by what Lord Lytton calls “deliberate and transparent subterfuges,” producing what Lord Salisbury calls “terrible misery,” or what Lord Cromer calls “extreme poverty,” or what Lord Lawrence described as “that the mass of the people live on scanty subsistence.”
The British Indian Empire is formed and maintained entirely by Indian money and mainly by Indian blood, and, moreover, Britain has drawn thousands of millions of pounds besides.
Any fair-minded Englishman, after making himself acquainted with all the realities, instead of the Anglo-Indian romance, of the present un-British system (notwithstanding much good done to and gratefully acknowledged by the Indians), will come to the conclusion that in the material and economic condition of India the existing system has been the greatest curse with which India has been ever afflicted.
This deplorable state of affairs cannot go on, and, as several eminent Englishmen have repeatedly foretold, it must end in disaster. “It carries with it,” said Sir John Malcolm, “its nemesis, the seeds of the destruction of the Empire itself.” “Injustice,” said Lord Salisbury, “shall bring down the mightiest to ruin.”
There is no justification of British rule in India, if it is to be an un-British despotism, with all the crushing additional evils of a foreign despotism; for, as Macaulay says, “The heaviest of all yokes is the yoke of the stranger.” It has been repeatedly said by eminent Englishmen that—using Lord Mayo’s words—“The welfare of the people of India is our primary object. If we are not here for their good, we ought not to be here at all.”
The despotism of former rulers is no justification for the bleeding despotism of the British rulers.
Washington House, 72, Anerley Park, London, S.E.
INDIA REFORM, 1853.
The State and Government of India under its Native Rulers.
We threaten to appropriate the territories of the Native Princes, our allies, upon the strength mainly of our own virtues and of their vices. All Native Governments, we say, are bad: all Native Governors are tyrants and sensualists. Their subjects are groaning under oppression, and we are bound to relieve them; all who wear turbans are worthless— all who wear hats are worthy. There was no good government in India until the advent of the Anglo-Saxon; it is the Anglo-Saxon who has taught the Indian the arts of civil life, and who shows him what government ought to be. The ruins of the tombs and temples of ancient Greece and Rome are worthy of all admiration; they are proofs of the genius and taste of the people who created them; the more magnificent ruins of ancient India are monuments only of ostentation and selfishness. “I contemplated those ruins,” said Lord Ellenborough, “with admiration of our predecessors, and with humiliation at our own shortcomings.” “You might as well be humiliated by the sight of the Pyramids,” was the retort of Lord Aberdeen.
What is deserving of all praise in the West is not praiseworthy in the East. When we see great works of utility and ornament in the West we pronounce them to be evidence of prosperous and tranquil Governments; but similar works in the East seem to lead us to a different judgment. At this moment we are dependent for millions of our revenue upon magnificent works of irrigation, constructed by our predecessors; the country is strewn with the remains of similar works. We pass them without notice and dwell upon our own comparatively puny efforts at imitation.
We found the people of India, it is said, abject, degraded, false to the very core. Mussulman dominion had called into full activity all the bad qualities which Hinduism has in itself a fatal tendency to generate. The most indolent and selfish of our own Governors have been models of benevolence and beneficence when compared with the greatest of the Native Sovereigns. The luxurious selfishness of the Moghul Emperors depressed and enfeebled the people. Their predecessors were either unscrupulous tyrants or indolent debauchees. Nor were their successors, the Ghilji Sovereigns, any better.
Having the command of the public press in this country, and the sympathy of the public mind with us, it is an easy task thus to exalt ourselves at the expense of our predecessors. We tell our own story, and our testimony is unimpeachable, but if we find anything favourable related of those who have preceded us the accounts we pronounce to be suspicious. We contrast the Moghul conquests of the fourteenth century with the “victorious, mild and merciful progress of the British arms in the East in the nineteenth.” But, if our object was a fair one, we should contrast the Mussulman invasion of Hindostan with the contemporaneous Norman invasion of England—the characters of the Mussulman Sovereigns with their contemporaries in the West—their Indian wars of the fourteenth century with our French wars, or with the Crusades—the effect of the Mahomedan conquest upon the characters of the Hindoo, with the effect of the Norman conquest upon the Anglo-Saxon, when “to be called an Englishman was considered as a reproach—when those who were appointed to administer justice were the fountains of all iniquity—when magistrates, whose duty it was to pronounce righteous judgments were the most cruel of all tyrants, and greater plunderers than common thieves and robbers”;—when the great men were inflamed with such a rage of money that they cared not by what means it was acquired; when the licentiousness was so great that a Princess of Scotland found “it necessary to wear a religious habit in order to preserve her person from violation."1
The history of the Mahomedan dynasties in India is full, it is said, of lamentable instances of the cruelty and rapacity of the early conquerors, not without precedent, however, in contemporary Christian history; for when Jerusalem was taken by the first Crusaders, at the end of the eleventh century, the garrison, consisting of 40,000 men, “was put to the sword without distinction; arms protected not the brave, nor submission the timid; no age or sex received mercy; infants perished by the same sword that pierced their mothers. The streets of Jerusalem were covered with heaps of slain, and the shrieks of agony and despair resounded from every house.” When Louis VII. of France, in the twelfth century, “made himself master of the town of Vitri, he ordered it to be set on fire; in consequence of this inhuman order, 1,300 persons who had taken refuge, perished in the flames.” In England, at the same time, under our Stephen, war “was carried on with so much fury, that the land was left uncultivated, and the instruments of husbandry were destroyed or abandoned,” and the result of our French wars in the fourteenth century was a state of things “more horrible and destructive than was ever experienced in any age or country.” The insatiable cruelty of the Mahomedan conquerors, it is said, stands recorded upon more undeniable authority than the insatiable benevolence of the Mahomedan conquerors. We have abundant testimony of the cruelty of contemporary Christian conquerors; have we any evidence of their benevolence?
As attempts are thus systematically made, in bulky volumes, to run down the character of Native Governments and Native Sovereigns, in order that we may have a fair pretext for seizing upon their possessions, it becomes necessary to show that we have a Christian Roland for every Native Oliver; that if the Mussulman conquerors of India were cruel and rapacious, they were matched by their Christian contemporaries. It is much our fashion to compare India in the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries with England in the nineteenth, and to pique ourselves upon the result. “When we compare other countries with England,” said a sagacious observer,1 “we usually speak of England as she now is, we scarcely ever think of going back beyond the Reformation, and we are apt to regard every foreign country as ignorant and uncivilised, whose state of improvement does not in some degree approximate to our own, even though it should be higher than our own was at no distant period.” It would be almost as fair to compare India in the sixteenth with England in the nineteenth century, as it would be to compare the two countries in the first centuries of the Christian era, when India was at the top of civilisation, and England at the bottom. India had gradually declined in civilisation from the date of the invasion of Alexander up to the time of the first Mussulman conquest; but we have abundant testimony to prove that, at that date, and for centuries before it, her people enjoyed a high degree of prosperity, which continued to the breaking up of the Moghul Empire early in the eighteenth century.
The State of India at the time of Greek Invasion.
“All the descriptions of the parts of India visited by the Greeks,” Mr. Elphinstone tells us, “give the idea of a country teeming with population, and enjoying the highest degree of prosperity.” There were 1,500 cities between the Hydaspes and the Hyphasis. Palilothra was eight miles long, and one and a half broad, defended by a deep ditch and high rampart, with 570 towers and 164 gates. The numerous commercial cities and posts for foreign trade, which are mentioned in the Periplus, attest the progress of the Indians in a department which more than any other shows the advanced condition of a nation. Arrian mentions with admiration that all the Indians were free. The army was in constant pay during war and peace; the arms and horses were supplied by the State; they never ravaged the country. The Greeks speak of the bravery of the Indian armies opposed to them as superior to that of other nations with whom they had to contend in Asia. They spoke of the police as excellent. In the camp of Sandracotus, consisting of 400,000 men, the sums stolen did not amount to more than about £3 daily. Justice was administered by the King and his assessors. The revenue was derived from the land, which was said to belong to the King; it amounted to one-fourth of the produce. The fields were all measured, and the water carefully distributed for irrigation; taxes were imposed upon trade, and an income-tax levied from merchants and traders. Royal roads are spoken of by Strabo, and milestones; the war-chariots were drawn by horses in time of war, and by oxen on a march. The arts, though simple, were far from being in a rude state. Gold, gems, silks, and ornaments were in all families; the professions mentioned show all that is necessary to civilised life. The number of grains, spices, etc., which were grown afford proofs that the country was in a high state of cultivation. “Their institutions were less rude, their conduct to their enemies more humane, their general learning much more considerable, and in the knowledge of the being and nature of God they were already in possession of a light which was but faintly perceived, even by the loftiest intellects in the best days of Athens.”1
In the time of Asoca, a Hindoo Sovereign, who reigned some centuries before the Christian era, his edict columns bear testimony to the extent of his dominions, and the civilised character of his government, since they contain orders “for establishing hospitals and dispensaries throughout his Empire, as well as for planting trees and digging wells along the public highways;” and 56 b.c. another Hindoo sovereign, Vicramaditya, is represented to have been a powerful monarch, who ruled a civilised and populous country.
Writers, both Hindoo and Mussulman, unite in bearing testimony to the state of prosperity in which India was found at the time of the first Mahommedan conquest. They dwell with admiration on the extent and magnificence of the capital of the kingdom of Canouj, and of the inexhaustible riches of the Temple of Somnath.
Many of the Sovereigns of each of the Mussulman dynasties were men of extraordinary character. The prudence, activity, and enterprise of Mahommed of Ghuzni, and his encouragement of literature and the arts, were conspicuous : “he showed so much munificence to individuals of eminence that his capital exhibited a greater assemblage of literary genius than any other monarch in Asia has ever been able to produce. If rapacious in acquiring wealth, he was unrivalled in the judgment and grandeur with which he knew how to expend it.”
His four immediate successors were patrons of literature and the arts, and acceptable to their subjects as good governors. Can we say as much for their contemporaries, William the Norman and his descendants, in the twelfth and thirteenth centuries ? It is generally supposed that the conquest of India by the Mahommedans was an easy task, but history tells us that none of the Hindoo principalities fell without a severe struggle ; that some of them were never subdued, but remain substantive States at this moment ; and that Shahab-ûd-Deen, the first founder of the Mahommedan Empire in India, towards the end of the twelfth century, was signally defeated by the Rajpoot Sovereign of Delhi.1
One of his successors, Kootub-ûd-Deen, who erected the Kootub Minar, “the highest column in the world,” and near it a mosque, which for grandeur of design and elegance of execution was equal to anything in India, was generally beloved for the frankness and generosity of his disposition, and left a permanent reputation as a just and virtuous ruler.
“Sultana Rezia was endowed,” says the historian Ferishta, “with every princely virtue, and those who scrutinise her actions the most severely will find in her no fault” but “that she was a woman.” She evinced all the qualities of a just and able sovereign. History does not make quite such favourable mention of our King John, or of Philip of France, her contemporaries. Julal-ûd-Deen, of the same dynasty, was celebrated for his clemency, his magnanimity, and love of literature.
The Hindoo kingdoms of Carnata and Tellingana were re-established about the middle of the fourteenth century. The first, with its capital, Bijanuggur, “attained to a pitch of power and splendour not perhaps surpassed by any previous Hindoo dynasty”; and such was the mutual estimation between the Hindoo and Mussulman sovereigns of the Deccan that inter-marriages took place between them, Hindoos were in high command in the Mussulman army, and Mussulmans in the Hindoo, and one Rajah of Bijanuggur built a mosque for his Mahommedan subjects.2 In the reign of Mahomed Toglak, A.D. 1351, there was an admirably regulated horse and foot post from the frontier to the capital. That capital, Delhi, is described as a most magnificent city, its mosques and walls without an equal upon the earth.
The public works of his successor, Feroz Shah, consisted of 50 dams across rivers to promote irrigation, 40 mosques and 30 colleges, 100 caravanseries, 30 reservoirs, 100 hospitals, 100 public baths, 150 bridges, besides many other edifices for pleasure and ornament; and, above all, the canal from the point in the Jumna where it leaves the mountains of Carnal to Hansi and Hissar, a work which has been partially restored by the British Government. The historian of this monarch expatiates on the happy state of the ryots under his government, on the goodness of their houses and furniture, and the general use of gold and silver ornaments amongst their women. He says, amongst other things, that every ryot had a good bedstead and a neat garden. He is said to be a writer not much to be trusted; but the general state of the country must no doub have been flourishing, for Milo de Conti, an Italian traveller, who visited India about A.D. 1420, speaks highly of what he saw in Guzerat, and found the banks of the Ganges covered with towns amidst beautiful gardens and orchards. He passed four famous cities before he reached Maarazia, which he describes as a powerful city, filled with gold, silver, and precious stones. His accounts are corroborated by those of Barbora and Bartema, who travelled in the early part of the sixteenth century. The former in particular describes Cambay as a remarkably well-built city, situated in a beautiful and fertile country, filled with merchants of all nations, and with artisans and manufacturers like those of Flanders. Cæsar Frederic gives a similar account of Guzerat, and Ibn Batuta, who travelled during the anarchy and oppression of Mohammed Tagluk’s reign, in the middle of the fifteenth century, when insurrections were reigning in most parts of the country, enumerates many large and populous towns and cities, and gives a high impression of the state in which the country must have been before it fell into disorder.
Abdurizag, an ambassador from the grandson of Tamerlane, visited the South of India in 1442, and concurs with other observers in giving the impression of a prosperous country. The kingdom of Candeish was at this time in a high state of prosperity under its own kings; the numerous stone embankments by which the streams were rendered applicable to irrigation are equal to anything in India as works of industry and ability.
Baber, the first sovereign of the Moghul dynasty, although he regards Hindostan with the same dislike that Europeans still feel, speaks of it as a rich and noble country, and expresses his astonishment at the swarming population and the innumerable workmen of every kind and profession. Besides the ordinary business of his kingdom, he was constantly occupied with making aqueducts, reservoirs, and other improvements, as well as in introducing new fruits, and other productions of remote countries. His son, Humayon, whose character was free from vices and violent passions, was defeated, and obliged to fly from Hindostan, by Shir Shah, who is described as a prince of consummate prudence and ability, “whose measures were as wise as benevolent,” and who, notwithstanding his constant activity in the field, during a short reign had brought his territories into the highest order, and introduced many improvements into his civil government. “He made a high road extending for four months’ journey from Bengal to the Western Rhotas near the Indus, with caravanserais at every stage, and wells at every mile and a half. There was an Imam and Muezzim at every mosque, and provisions for the poor at every caravanserai, with attendants of proper castes for Hindoos as well as for Mussulmans. The road was planted with rows of trees for shade, and in many places was in the state described when the author saw it, after it had stood for eighty-two years.”1
It is almost superfluous to dwell upon the character of the celebrated Akbar, who was equally great in the cabinet and in the field, and renowned for his learning, toleration, liberality, clemency, courage, temperance, industry, and largeness of mind. But it is to his internal policy that Akbar owes his place in that highest order of princes whose reigns have been a blessing to mankind.2 He forbade trials by ordeal, and marriages before the age of puberty, and the slaughter of animals for sacrifice. He also permitted widows to marry a second time, contrary to Hindoo law. Above all, he positively prohibited the burning of Hindoo widows against their will. He employed his Hindoo subjects equally with Mahommedans, abolished the capitation tax on infidels, as well as all taxes on pilgrims, and positively prohibited the making slaves of persons taken in war. He perfected the financial reforms which had been commenced in those provinces by Shir Shah. He remeasured all the lands capable of cultivation within the Empire; ascertained the produce of each begah;3 determined the proportion to be paid to the public; and commuted it for a fixed money rent, giving the cultivator the option of paying in kind if he thought the money rate too high. He abolished at the same time a vast number of vexatious taxes and fees to officers. The result of these wise measures was to reduce the amount of the public demand considerably. His instructions to his revenue officers have come down to us, and show his anxiety for the liberal administration of his system, and for the ease and comfort of his subjects. The tone of his instructions to his judicial officers was “just and benevolent ;” he enjoined them to be sparing in capital punishments, and, unless in cases of dangerous sedition, to inflict none until he had received the Emperor’s confirmation. He forbade mutilation or other cruelty as the accompaniment of capital punishment. He reformed and new modelled his army, paying his troops in cash from the treasury, instead of by assignments on the revenue. Besides fortifications and other public works he erected many magnificent buildings, which are described and eulogised by Bishop Heber. System and method were introduced into every part of the public service, and the whole of his establishments present “an astonishing picture of magnificence and good order, where unwieldy numbers are managed without disturbance, and economy is attended to in the midst of profusion.”
Akbar appears with as much simplicity as dignity. European witnesses describe him as “affable and majestical, merciful and severe, temperate in diet, sparing in sleep, skilful in making guns, casting ordnance, and mechanical arts, curiously industrious, affable to the vulgar, loved and feared of his own, terrible to his enemies.” Can we say as much for his great contemporaries—Elizabeth of England, or Henry the Fourth of France ?
The Italian traveller, Pietro del Valle, who wrote in the last year of the reign of Jehanger, Akbar’s son, A.D. 1623, bears this testimony to the character of that Prince, and to the condition of the people under his rule : “Generally all live much after a genteel way, and they do it securely, as well because the king does not prosecute his subjects with false accusations nor deprive them of anything when he sees them live splendidly and with the appearance of riches (as is often done in other Mahommedan countries), as because the Indians are inclined to those vanities.”
But the reign of Shah Jehan, the grandson of Akbar, was the most prosperous ever known in India. His own dominions enjoyed almost uninterrupted tranquillity and good government; and, although Sir Thomas Roe was struck with astonishment at the profusion of wealth which was displayed when he visited the Emperor in his camp in 1615, in which at least two acres were covered with silk, gold carpets and hangings, as rich as velvet embossed with gold and precious stones could make them, yet we have the testimony of Tavernier that he who caused the celebrated peacock throne to be constructed, who, at the festival of his accession, scattered amongst the bystanders money and precious things equal to his own weight, “reigned not so much as a king over his subjects, but rather as a father over his family.” His vigilance over his internal government was unremitting, and for the order and arrangement of his territory, and the good administration of every department of the State, no Prince that ever reigned in India could he compared to Shah Jehan.
All his vast undertakings were managed with so much economy that, after defraying the expenses of his great expedition to Candahar, his wars in Balk, and other heavy charges, and maintaining a regular army of 200,000 horse, Shah Jehan left a treasure which some reckoned at near six, others at twenty-four millions in coin, besides his vast accumulations in wrought gold and silver and in jewels.
His treatment of his people was beneficent and paternal, and his liberal sentiments towards those around him cannot be better shown than by the confidence which he so generously reposed in his sons.1
So stable was the foundation upon which this prosperity rested that the Empire continued to be in a flourishing condition for a large portion of the long, intolerant, and oppressive reign of Aurungzebe; and, notwithstanding the misgovernment which followed in the next thirty years, under a series of weak and wicked Princes, and the commotions which attended the breaking up of the Empire, the enormous wealth which Nadir Shah was enabled to carry away with him when he quitted Delhi in 1739 is proof that the country was still in a comparatively prosperous condition.
Among many distinguished Princes of the Deccan in the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries Mulik Amber, the Regent of Bijapore, holds a distinguished place both as a warrior and a statesman. He is described to have been a man of uncommon genius. He made his regency respected at home and abroad. He abolished revenue-farming; substituted a fixed money assessment for a payment in kind, and revived the village establishments where they had fallen into decay. By such means the country soon became thriving and prosperous, and although his expenditure was liberal his finances were abundant. For upwards of twenty years he was the bulwark of his country against foreign conquest. Though almost constantly engaged in war, this great man found leisure to cultivate the arts of peace. He founded the city of Kirkee, built several splendid palaces, and introduced a system of internal administration which has left his name in every village far more venerated as a ruler than renowned as a general.1
Of the character of the Hindoo Sovereigns who were the contemporaries of the Mussulman Emperors in the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries we know nothing, but we know that their territories had attained to a pitch of power and splendour which had not been surpassed by their ancestors. We know also that the principal administrators of the Mussulman dynasties, with rare exceptions, were Hindoos— that they were entrusted with the command of armies, and with the regulation of the finances.
The “robber,” Sevajee, who entered upon the scene in the latter part of the sixteenth century, and who shook the Moghul Empire to its foundation during the reign of Aurungzebe, was an able as well as a skilful general. His civil government was regular, and he was vigorous in exacting from his provincial and his village officers obedience to the rules which he laid down for the protection of the people. His enemies bear witness to his anxiety to mitigate the evils of war by humane regulations, which were strictly enforced. Altogether this robber hero has left a character which has never since been equalled or ever approached by any of his countrymen. None, however, of his military successes raise so high an idea of his talents as the spirit of his domestic administration,2 and the effect of these appear to have been permanent for nearly eighty years after his death, viz., in 1758. We have the following interesting account of the state of the Mahratta Territory from the pen of Anquetil du Perron :—
“On February 14, 1758, I set out from Mahé for Goa, in order to proceed to Surat, and, in all my routes, I took care to keep specimens of the money of all the States I passed through, so that I have examples of every coin that is current from Cape Cormorin to Delhi.
“From Surat, I passed the Ghats, the 27th of March the same year, about ten in the morning, and when I entered the country of the Mahrattas, I thought myself in the midst of the simplicity and happiness of the golden age where nature was yet unchanged, and war and misery were unknown. The people were cheerful, vigorous, and in high health, and unbounded hospitality was a universal virtue: every door was open, and friends, neighbours, and strangers, were alike welcome to whatever they found. When I came within seven miles of Aurungabad, I went to see the celebrated pagoda of Ellora.”1
Sevajee had several worthy successors; amongst them were the Peishwahs, Ballajee Wiswanath, and his son Bajee Rao Bullal. This latter is said to have united the enterprise, and vigour, and hardihood of a Mahratta Chief with the polished manners, sagacity and address which frequently distinguished the Brahmins of the Concan. He had the head to plan and the hand to execute. To assiduous industry, and minute observation, he superadded a power of discrimination that brought him to fix his mind to points of political importance. He was a man of uncommon eloquence, penetration, and vigour, simple in his habits, enterprising and skilful as a military leader, and at all times partaking of the fare and sharing the privations of the meanest horseman.
His successor, Ballajee Rao, was a man of considerable political sagacity, of polished manners, and of great address; though indolent and voluptuous, he was generous and charitable, kind to his relations and dependents, and an enemy to external violence; amidst the distractions of war, he devoted much of his time to the civil administration of his territory; in his reign the condition of the whole Mahratta population was much ameliorated, the system of farming the revenues was abolished, the ordinary tribunals of civil justice were improved, and the Mahratta peasantry “have ever since blessed the days of Nana Laish Peishwah.”2 Although the military talents of Mahdoo Rao, who succeeded him, were conspicuous, yet his character as a sovereign is entitled to far higher praise. “He is deservedly celebrated for his firm support of the weak against the oppressive—of the poor against the rich—and, as far as the construction of society admitted—for his equity to all.” He prevented his revenue officers from abusing their authority by vigilant superintendence, and by readily listening to the complaints of the common cultivators, and at that time, the Mahratta country, in proportion to its fertility, was more thriving than any other part of India. The preference shown in promoting officers who could boast of hereditary rights encouraged patriotism and applied national feeling to purposes of good government. Mahdoo Rao was assisted in his government by his minister, “the celebrated Ram,” Ram Shastree, a pure and upright judge, whose conduct would have been considered admirable under any circumstances. The benefits which he conferred on his countrymen were principally by example. The weight and soundness of his opinions were universally acknowledged during his life, and the decisions of the Punchayets which gave decrees in his time are still considered precedents. His conduct and unwearied zeal had a wonderful effect in improving the people of all ranks; he was a pattern to the well disposed; the greatest man who did wrong stood in awe of Ram Shastree, and although persons possessed of rank and riches did, in several instances, try to corrupt him, none dared to repeat the experiment, or to impeach his integrity. His habits were simple in the extreme; it was a rule with him to keep nothing more in his house than sufficed for the day’s consumption.1 And such was his stirling virtue and stern sense of justice, that when asked by Ragonauth Rao what atonement he could make for his participation in the murder of his nephew, the Peishwah Nasrain Rao, the brother and immediate successor of Madhoo Rao: “The sacrifice of your own life,” was the reply of the virtuous and undaunted Shastree; “for your future life cannot be passed in amendment, neither you nor your government can prosper; and for my own part, I will neither accept employment nor enter Poonah whilst you preside in the administration.” He kept his word, and retired to a sequestered village near Waee.2
The murdered Nasrain Rao, a youth of eighteen, was affectionate to his relations, kind to his domestics, and all but his enemies loved him.
The celebrated Hyder Ali was the contemporary and antagonist of Madhoo Rao, by whom he was more than once signally defeated; but Hyder turned these failures to account, and, like the Czar Peter, “submitted to be worsted that he might learn to be superior.” By usurpation from his sovereign, the Rajah of Mysore, and by subsequent conquests, he made himself master of a territory 400 miles in length from north to south, and near 300 miles in breadth from east to west, with a population of many millions, an army of 300,000 men, and a revenue computed to amount to £5,000,000. Although almost constantly engaged in war, the improvement of his country and the strictest executive administration formed the constant objects of his care. The manufacturer and the merchant prospered in every part of his dominions; cultivation increased, new manufactures were established, and wealth flowed into the kingdom. Against negligence or malversation he was inexorable, the officers of revenue fulfilled their duty with fear and trembling; the slightest defalcation was summarily punished. He had his eye upon every corner of his own dominions, and in every Court of India. The minutest circumstance of detail was known to him; not a movement in the remotest corner could escape him; not a murmur or intention of his neighbours but flew to him. His secretaries successively read to him the whole correspondence of the day, and although unable to write himself, he dictated in few words the substance of the answer to be given, which was immediately written, read to him, and dispatched. He possessed the happy secret of uniting minuteness of detail with the utmost latitude of thought and enterprise. As his perseverance and dispatch of business were only equalled by his pointedness of information, so his conciseness and decision in the executive departments of a great government are probably unprecedented in the annals of man.1
He bequeathed to his son, Tippoo Sultan, an overflowing treasury, which he had filled; a powerful Empire, which he had created; an army of 300,000 men, that he had formed, disciplined, and inured to conquest ; and a territory which, as contemporary historians and eye-witnesses assure us, had in no way deteriorated under the sway of his successor.
“When a person, travelling through a strange country, finds it well cultivated, populous with industrious inhabitants, cities newly founded, commerce extending, towns increasing, and everything flourishing, so as to indicate happiness, he will naturally conclude it to be under a form of government congenial to the minds of the people. This is a picture of Tippoo’s country, and this is our conclusion respecting its government. It has fallen to our lot to tarry some time in Tippoo’s dominions, and to travel through them as much, if not more, than any other officer in the field during the war; and we have reason to suppose his subjects to be as happy as those of any other sovereign; for we do not recollect of any complaints or murmurings among them; although, had causes existed, no time would have been more favourable for their utterance, because the enemies of Tippoo were in power and would have been gratified by any aspersion of his character. The inhabitants of the conquered countries submitted with apparent resignation to the direction of their conquerors; but by no means as if relieved from an oppressive yoke in their former government; on the contrary, no sooner did an opportunity offer than they scouted their new masters and gladly returned to their loyalty again.”1 “Whether from the operation of the system established by Hyder, from the principles which Tippoo adopted for his own conduct, or from his dominions having suffered little by invasion for many years, or from the effect of these several causes united,- his country was found everywhere full of inhabitants and apparently cultivated to the utmost extent of which the soil was capable, while the discipline and fidelity of his troops in the field until their last overthrow were testimonies, equally strong, of the excellent regulations which existed in his army. His government, though strict and arbitrary, was the despotism of a strict and able sovereign, who nourishes, not oppresses, the subjects who are to be the means of his future aggrandisement, and his cruelties were, in general, inflicted only on those whom he considered as his enemies.”2
It would be a great mistake, however, to suppose that all this prosperity was created either by Hyder or his son. Their sway, which did not last for half a century, was too short for such a work. The foundation of it was laid by the ancient Hindoo dynasty which preceded them—the constructors of the magnificent canals by which Mysore is intersected, and which insures to the people certain and prodigal returns from its fertile soil.1
The British Government and their great rival, Hyder Ali, appeared on the political stage of India nearly at the same moment, and in the year that Hyder established his sway over Mysore, by usurpation from its legitimate sovereign, Bengal—the brightest jewel in the Imperial Crown of the Moghuls—came into our possession. Although still suffering from the scourge of a recent Mahratta invasion, Clive described the new acquisition as a country “of inexhaustible riches,"2 and one that could not fail to make its new masters the richest corporation in the world. “In spite,” says Mr. Macaulay, “of the Mussulman despot and of the Mahratta freebooter Bengal was known through the East as the Garden of Eden—as the rich kingdom. Its population multiplied exceedingly; distant provinces were nourished from the overflowing of its granaries; and the noble ladies of London and Paris were clothed in the delicate produce of its looms.” From another authority3 we have an account of the people of Bengal under its Native sovereigns, which we should be disposed to regard as fabulous if it did not come from one who had been long resident in the country, and who spoke from an intimate acquaintance with his subject. “In truth (says Mr. Holwell), it would be almost cruelty to molest this happy people; for in this district are the only vestiges of the beauty, purity, piety, regularity, equity, and strictness of the ancient Hindostan Government. Here the property, as well as the liberty of the people, are inviolate. Here no robberies are heard of, either public or private. The traveller, either with or without merchandise, becomes the immediate care of the Government, which allots him guards, without any expense, to conduct him from stage to stage ; and these are accountable for the safety and accommodatian of his person and effects. At the end of the first stage he is delivered over, with certain benevolent formalities, to the guards of the next, who, after interrogating the traveller as to the usage he had received in his journey, dismissed the first guard with a written certificate of their behaviour and a receipt for the traveller and his effects, which certificate and receipt are returnable to the commanding officer of the first stage, who registers the same and regularly reports it to the Rajah.
“ In this form the traveller is passed through the country ; and if he only passes he is not suffered to be at any expense for food, accommodation, or carriage for his merchandise or baggage ; but it is otherwise if he is permitted to make any residence in one place above three days, unless occasioned by sickness, or any unavoidable accident. If anything is lost in this district, for instance a bag of money or other valuables, the person who finds it hangs it on the next tree, and gives notice to the nearest chowkey, or place of guard ; the officer of which orders immediate publication of the same by beat of tomtom, or drum.”1
“ By the prudent administration of a system of sound policy and humanity, the rich province of Dacca was cultivated in every part, and abounded in everything requisite for the comfort and gratification of its inhabitants. Justice was administered with impartiality, and the conduct of its administrators, Gholab Aly Khan and Jeswunt Roy, gained great credit to their principal, Sarferaz Khan. Jeswunt Roy had been educated under the Nawab Aly Khan, whose example he emulated in purity, integrity, and indefatigable attention to business ; and in framing his arrangements for the government of the province, he studied to render them conducive to the general ease and happiness of the people ; he abolished all monopolies, and the imposts which had been laid upon the grain.”2
Such was the State of Bengal, when Alivardy Khan, the predecessor of Surajah Dowlah—of “Black Hole” memory— a nominal Lieutenant of the King of Delhi, assumed its government. Under his rule, notwithstanding many serious defects in his character, and some black deeds, the country was considerably improved. Many of his relations and friends, whom he employed in affairs of trust, were men of great abilities and merit. If guilty of negligence or oppression, he never failed to dismiss them; merit and good conduct were the only sure passports to his favour. He looked upon all his subjects as creatures of the same God, and placed Hindoos upon an equality with Mussulmans, choosing Hindoos for his Ministers, and nominating them to high military command as well as to civil situations of importance. It is not surprising, therefore, that the Hindoos served him and his family with exemplary zeal and fidelity. During his reign the revenues derived from the province, instead of being drawn to the distant treasury of Delhi, were spent on the spot. This was an incalculable advantage, and one cause of that prosperity which the people enjoyed under his reign, “when peace, plenty, and good order everywhere prevailed, and the profound and universal tranquillity was never disturbed, except by the occasional insurrection of a refractory Zemindar at some remote corner of a province.”1
But in less than ten years after Bengal had become subject to British rule a great and sudden change had come over the land.
“Every ship (Mr. Macaulay tells us) from Bengal had for some time brought alarming tidings. The internal misgovernment of the province had reached such a pitch that it could go no further. What, indeed, was to be expected from a body of public servants exposed to temptation such that, as Clive once said, flesh and blood could not bear it, armed with irresistible power, and responsible only to the corrupt, turbulent, distracted, ill-informed Company, situated at such a distance that the average interval between the sending of a dispatch and the receipt of an answer was above a year and a half! Accordingly, during the five years which followed the departure of Clive from Bengal, the misgovernment of the English was carried to a point such as seemed hardly compatible with the very existence of society. The Roman proconsul, who, in a year or two, squeezed out of a province the means of rearing marble palaces and baths on the shores of Campania, of drinking from amber, of feasting on singing birds, of exhibiting armies of gladiators and flocks of camelopards; the Spanish viceroy, who, leaving behind him the curses of Mexico or Lima, entered Madrid with a long train of gilded coaches, and of sumpter-horses, trapped and shod with silver, were now outdone. Cruelty, indeed, properly so-called, was not among the vices of the servants of the Company. But cruelty itself could hardly have produced greater evils than sprang from their unprincipled eagerness to be rich. They pulled down their creature, Meer Jaffer; they set up in his place another Nabob named Meer Cossim.
“But Meer Cossim had parts and a will; and, though sufficiently inclined to oppress his subjects himself, he could not bear to see them ground to the dust by oppressions which yielded him no profit—nay, which destroyed his revenue in the very source. The English accordingly pulled down Meer Cossim, and set up Meer Jaffer again; and Meer Cossim, after revenging himself by a massacre surpassing in atrocity that of the Black Hole, fled to the dominions of the Nabob of Oude. At every one of these revolutions the new Prince divided among his foreign masters whatever could be scraped together in the treasury of his fallen predecessor. The immense population of his dominions was given up as a prey to those who had made him a Sovereign, and who could unmake him. The servants of the Company obtained, not for their employers, but for themselves, a monopoly of almost the whole internal trade. They forced the Natives to buy dear and to sell cheap. They insulted with impunity the tribunals, the police, and the fiscal authorities of the country. They covered with their protection a set of Native dependents who ranged through the provinces, spreading desolation and terror wherever they appeared; every servant of a British factor was armed with all the power of the Company. Enormous fortunes were thus rapidly accumulated at Calcutta, while thirty millions of human beings were reduced to the extremity of wretchedness. They had been accustomed to live under tyranny, but never under tyranny like this. They found the little finger of the company thicker than the loins of Surajah Dowlah. Under their old masters they had at least one resource; when the evil became insupportable, the people rose and pulled down the Government. But the English Government was not to be shaken off. That Government, oppressive as the most oppressive form of barbarian despotism, was strong with all the strength of civilisation.”1
“I can only say,” writes Clive, “that such a scene of anarchy, corruption, and extortion was never seen or heard of in any country but Bengal; the three provinces of Bengal, Behar, and Orissa, producing a revenue of £3,000,000 sterling, have been under the absolute management of the Company’s servants ever since Meer Jaffer’s restoration to the Soobahship; and they have, both civil and military, exacted and levied contributions from every man of power and consequence, from the Nabob down to the lowest Zemindar. The trade has been carried on by free merchants, acting as gomastahs to the Company’s servants, who, under the sanction of their names, have committed actions which make the name of the English stink in the nostrils of a Gentoo and a Mussulman; and the Company’s servants have interfered with the revenues of the Nabob, turned out and put in the officers of the Government at their pleasure, and made everyone pay for their preferment.”2
A severe famine followed upon this misgovernment, so that it is not surprising to find the Governor-General, Lord Cornwallis, twenty years afterwards, describing Bengal as a country that was hastening to decay. These are his words: “I am sorry to be obliged to say that agriculture and commerce have for many years been gradually declining; and that at present, excepting the class of Shroffs and Banyans, who reside almost entirely in great towns, the inhabitants of these provinces were advancing hastily to a general state of poverty and wretchedness. In this description I must even include almost every Zemindar in the Company’s territories; which, though it may have been partly occasioned by their own indolence and extravagance, I am afraid must also be in a great measure attributed to the defects of our former system of mismanagement.”
Nor was it in our own territory alone that the evil of our misrule was felt. It spread into the dominions of our allies. From our first connexion with the Nabob of Oude, his kingdom was made a carcass for the British to prey upon. “I fear,” said Mr. Hastings,1 when still vested with the supreme rule over India, and describing a state of things which he had been a party in producing, “I fear that our encroaching spirit, and the insolence with which it has been exerted, has caused our alliance to be as much dreaded by all the powers of Hindostan as our arms. Our encroaching spirit, and the uncontrolled and even protected licentiousness of individuals, have done more injury to our national reputation than our arms and the credit of our strength has raised it. Every person in India dreads a connexion with us, which they see attended with mortifying humiliation to those who have availed themselves of it.” And as a signal example of this feeling, and of measures which awakened it, he adduces our dealings with the Nabob of Oude.
Before those dealings commenced, Oude, says the historian Mill, was in a high state of prosperity, it yielded, without pressure upon the people, a clear income of three millions, but by quartering, not only an army of soldiers, but a host of civilians upon him, we soon reduced the Nabob to a state of the bitterest distress and his country to poverty; so that after bearing the burthen for some years, he found his income reduced to half its former amount. In nine years, unjustifiable extortions, to the amount of thirty-four lacs of rupees (£340,000) per annum, “had been practised on that dependent province.2 The numbers, influence, and enormous amount of the salaries, pensions, and encroachments of the Company’s Service, civil and military, in the Vizier’s service, said Mr. Hastings, have become an intolerable burthen upon the revenue and authority of his Excellency, and exposed us to the enmity and resentment of the whole country, by excluding the Native servants and adherents of the Vizier from the rewards of their services and attachment. I am afraid that few men would understand me if I were to ask by what right or policy we levied a tax on the Nabob Vizier, for the benefit of patronised individuals, and fewer still if I question the right or policy of imposing upon him an army for his protection, which he could not pay, and which he does not want; with what expression of features could I tell him to his face, ‘You do not want it but you shall pay for it’? The first was a scandal to our Goverment, for every Englishman in Oude was possessed of an independent and sovereign authority. They learned, and taught others, to claim the revenue of lacs as their right, though they could gamble away more than two lacs (I allude to a known fact) at a sitting.”1 Mr. Hastings did not content himself with this exposure of events which had occured under his own administration. He withdrew a portion of that army which the Nabob “did not want, but for which he was obliged to pay,” but this burden was fastened upon him again with additions by Mr. Hastings’ successor, Lord Cornwallis, in spite of the Nabob’s earnest deprecations. Having gradually increased our demands under the name of subsidy from £250,000 to £700,000 per annum, Lord Teignmouth further increased it, and Lord Wellesley, under a threat of seizing upon the whole in 1801 extorted a surrender from the Nabob of one half of his dominions, valued at £1,300,000 of annual revenue, in satisfaction of a demand which we had imposed upon him of £700,000. But our exactions did not stop here; between the years 1815 and 1825, we extracted more than four millions under the name of loans from the Nabob, or, “as they might be more justly described,” says the Governor-General, Lord W. Bentinck, “unwilling contributions extorted by fear of our power:”2 for which we gave him the empty title of King, and a territory entirely unproductive, little better than a wilderness.3
This is a brief history of our dealings with Oude, not penned by those who have suffered from them, but by the doers themselves. It is based upon facts that are upon our records, and is therefore indisputable. If Oude, then, is now misgoverned—if its people are impoverished and oppressed— who is to blame—the Native Sovereigns, or those who have thus trampled upon the Native Sovereigns? Let Englishmen—now that the great question of India is before them— decide upon this question; and let them not be drawn away from its merits by an appeal to the personal character of some of the chief actors in this drama.
Lord Cornwallis was indisputably a just man, Lord Teignmouth a religious man, and Lord Wellesley a great man ; nevertheless, there was nothing wise or great, just or religious, in their treatment of their helpless allies, the Sovereign Princes of Oude.
We have seen that when the Governor-General, Lord Cornwallis, was pronouncing the Kingdom of Bengal to be in a state of rapid decay, the Kingdom of Mysore, under the rule of Tippoo, was upon the evidence of eye-witnesses in a state of high prosperity ; that its prosperity had in no way diminished many years afterwards under the regency of Poorneah, we have, amongst many others, the testimony of the great Duke, who, speaking from his own observation, pronounced the government of Mysore to be in every respect entitled to applause, and, as a mark of his approbation and esteem, made the Dewan Poorneah a present of his picture.1
“ Every trait,” says the British Resident of that day,2 “ in the character of Poorneah marks him as an extraordinary man. . . . . To a mind of singular vigour he added an extensive acquaintance with the resources of the country, and an intimate knowledge of characters. The revenue of Mysore has been raised to its present amount by the superior management of Poorneah ; by his attention to the repair of tanks and watercourses, and the construction of roads and bridges : by the encouragement which he has given to strangers to resort to and settle in Mysore, and his general endeavours to improve the agriculture of the country and the situation of the people under the Government of the Rajah.”3
Contemporary with Poorneah, and in no ways inferior to him, was Nana Furnawese, who for a quarter of a century administered the territory of the Peishwah, during the minority of Bajee Rao. “ To attempt a character of this great statesman would be to detail a history of Mahratta politics for the last twenty-five years, during which he discharged the duties of Minister with abilities unequalled. During the long and important period of his administration, by the force and energy of his single mind, he held together his vast Empire—composed of members whose interests were as opposite as the most anomalous elements—and by the versatility of his genius, the wisdom and firmness and moderation of his government, he excited this mass of incongruities to one mutual and common effort. With that wise and foreseeing policy which, strong in its own resources, equally rejects the extremes of confidence and despair, he supplied from the fertility of unexhausted genius an expedient for every possible event.”1
The state of the territory which has been so long administered by this distinguished man was visited not many years after by the late Sir John Malcolm, who thus describes its condition :—
“ It has not happened to me ever to see countries better cultivated, and more abounding in all produce of the soil, as well as in commercial wealth, than the southern Mahratta districts, when I accompanied the present Duke of Wellington to that country in the year 1803. I particularly here allude to those large tracts near the borders of the Kistnah. Poonah, the capital of the Peishwah, was a very wealthy and a thriving commercial town, and there was as much cultivation in the Deccan as it was possible an arid and unfruitful country could admit.”2
And of another large portion of the Mahratta territory, Malwa, now and formerly under the sovereignty of the Holkar family, and of the character of some of its rulers, we have the same favourable testimony from the same distinguished witness :—
“ With respect to Malwa, I saw it in a state of ruin, caused by the occupancy for a period of more than half-a-century of that fine country by the Mahratta armies, the Pindarries, and, indeed, the assembled predatory hordes of all India. Yet, even at that period, I was perfectly surprised at the difference that exists between a distant view of such countries and a nearer examination of their actual condition. I had ample means afforded to me as the person appointed to occupy that territory, and to conduct its civil, military, and political administration, to learn all that the records of Government could teach, and to obtain from other sources full information of this country ; and I certainly entered upon my duties with the complete conviction that commerce would be unknown, and that credit could not exist in a province which had long possessed, from its position, the transit trade between the rich provinces of Western India and the whole of the North-West Provinces of Hindostan, as well as the more eastern ones of Saugor and Bundlecund. I found, to my surprise, that in correspondence with the first commercial and moneyed men of Rajpootana, Bundlecund, and Hindostan, as well as with those of Guzerat, dealings in money to a large amount had continually taken place at Oogein and other cities, where soucars or bankers of character and credit were in a flourishing state, and that goods to a great amount had not only continually passed through the province, but that the insurance offices which exist through all parts of India, and include the principal moneyed men, had never stopped their operations, though premiums rose, at a period of danger, to a high amount. The Native Government of Malwa, when tranquillity was established through our arms, wanted nothing but that which the attachment of the Natives of India to their soil soon supplied them with, a return of the inhabitants. And I do not believe that in that country the introduction of our direct rule could have contributed more, nor indeed so much, to the prosperity of the commercial and agricultural interests as the re-establishment of the efficient rule of its former Princes and chiefs, who, though protected from attack, are quite free in their internal administration from our interference. With respect to the southern Mahratta districts, of whose prosperity I have before spoken, if I refer, as I must, to their condition before the last few years of Bajee Row’s misrule, I do not think that either their commercial or agricultural interests are likely to be improved under our rule, except in that greatest of blessings, exemption from wars which, while under our protection, they equally enjoy, and I must unhesitatingly state that the provinces belonging to the family of ‘ Putwurden,’ and some other chiefs on the banks of the Kistna, present a greater agricultural and commercial prosperity than almost any I know in India. I refer this to their system of administration, which, though there may be at periods exactions, is, on the whole, mild and paternal ; to the knowledge and almost devotion of the Hindoos to all agricultural pursuits ; to their better understanding, or, at least, better practice than us in many parts of the administration, particularly in raising towns and villages to prosperity from the encouragement given to moneyed men, and to the introduction of capital ; and, above all, to Jagheerdars (Kandownos) residing on their estates, and these provinces being administered by men of rank, who live and die on the soil, and are usually succeeded in office by their sons or near relatives. If these men exact money at times in an arbitrary manner, all their expenditure, as well as all they receive, is limited to their own provinces ; but, above all causes which promote prosperity, is the invariable support given to the village and other Native institutions, and to the employment, far beyond what our system admits, of all classes of the population.”1
“The success of Allia Baee in the internal administration of her dominions was altogether wonderful. . . . . The undisturbed internal tranquillity of the country was even more remarkable than its exemption from foreign attack. This was equally produced by her manner of treating the peaceable as well as the more turbulent and predatory classes ; she was indulgent to the former, and although strict and severe, just and considerate towards the latter. . . . . The fond object of her life was to promote the prosperity of all around her ; she rejoiced, we are told, when she saw bankers, merchants, farmers, and cultivators rise to affluence, and so far from deeming their increased wealth a ground of exaction, she considered it a legitimate claim of increased favour and protection. . . . . There would be no end to a minute detail of the measures of her internal policy. It is sufficient to observe she has become by general suffrage the model of good government in Malwa. . . . . She built several forts, and at that of Jaum constructed a road with great labour and cost over the Vindhya range, where it is almost perpendicular. . . . . Among the Princes of her own nation it would have been looked upon as sacrilege to have become her enemy, or indeed not to have defended her against any hostile attempt. She was considered by all in the same light. The Nizam of the Deccan and Tippoo Sultan held her in the same respect as the Peishwah, and Mahomedans joined with the Hindoos in prayer for her long life and prosperity.
“In the most sober view that can be taken of her character, she certainly appears within her limited sphere to have been one of the purest and most exemplary rulers that ever existed, and she affords a striking example of the practical benefit a mind may receive from preferring worldly duties under a deep sense of responsibility to its Creator.”1
Equally favourable testimony to the condition of the dominions of the Rajah of Berar, another member of the great Mahratta confederacy, was given by eye-witnesses :—
“ The thriving condition of the province, indicated by the appearance of its capital (says a European traveller) and confirmed by that of the districts which we subsequently traversed, demands from me a tribute of praise to the ancient Princes of the country. Without the benefit of navigation (for the ‘ Nerbudda ’ is not here navigable) and without much inland commerce, but under the fostering hand of a race of good Princes, a numerous people tilled a fertile country, and still preserve in the neatness of their homes, in the number and magnificence of their temples, their ponds, and other public works ; in the size of their towns, and in the frequency of their plantations, the undoubted signs of enviable prosperity. The whole merit may be safely ascribed to the former government, for the praise of good administration is rarely merited by Mahratta chieftains, and it is sufficient applause to say that the Chief of Saugor in twenty years, and the Rajah of Berar in four, have not much impaired the prosperity which they found.” 2
“ We now,” says another traveller in Berar, “ continued our journey through a fine champaign country, abundantly watered with rivulets that issue from the neighbouring mountains. It was entirely free from jungle, full of villages, and beautifully varied with tufts of trees and pools of water. It is more easy to conceive than express the delight we experienced in changing the difficulties of the former part of the journey. The Mahratta Government being well established in this part of the route, we experienced very civil and hospitable treatment, and found plenty of every kind of grain, which this highly-cultivated country produced at a very cheap rate ;” and although inland commerce derives very little encouragement from the Government, which pays no attention to the public roads, yet the whole exports in seasons of plenty are said to employ a hundred thousand bullocks.1
From the Mahratta we pass to the Rajpoot States; and here again we bring the evidence of an eye-witness to bear upon their condition :—
“As compared with the cultivation of the King of Oude’s dominions, it has always struck me that there was a marked superiority in the appearance of the British territory. At the same time, it is but fair to state that I have beheld small independent States, governed by Hindoo Rajahs, where the cultivation appeared superior to that of the Company’s provinces, and where the independent aid of the peasantry announced a greater security of rights. In the year 1810, when a large force marched beyond the British territory, the division halted for nearly two months within the dominion of the Rajah of Tihree, the flourishing condition of which excited the admiration of the whole army.”2
“In passing through the Rampore territory,3 we could not fail to notice the high state of cultivation to which it has attained, when compared with the surrounding country ; scarcely a spot of land is neglected : and although the season was by no means favourable, the whole district seems to be covered with an abundant harvest. As we have no reason to conclude from the description we had received of the present Regent that this state of prosperity had been produced by any personal exertions on his part, we were solicitous to trace its source, and to discover whether, in the nature of the tenures, the mode of arrangement or otherwise, there were any peculiar circumstances which it might be useful for us to advert to in the course of executing the duty entrusted to us. The management of the Nawab Fyz-oolah Khan is celebrated throughout the country. It was the management of an enlightened and liberal landlord, who devoted his time and attention and employed his own capital in promoting the prosperity of his country. When works of magnitude were required, which could not be accomplished by the efforts of the individual, the means of undertaking them were supplied by his bounty. Watercourses were constructed, the rivulets were sometimes made to overflow and fertilise the adjacent districts, and the paternal care of a popular chief was constantly exerted to afford protection to his subjects, to stimulate their exertions, to direct their labours to useful objects, and to promote by every means the success of the undertaking.
“If the comparison for the same territory be made between the management of the Rohillas and that of our own government, it is painful to think that the balance of advantage is clearly in favour of the former. After seven years’ possession of the country, it appears by the report that the revenue has increased only by two lacs of rupees, or £20,000. The papers laid before Parliament show that in twenty years which have since elapsed, the collective revenues of Rohilcund, and the other districts forming the ceded provinces of Oude, had actually declined £200,000 per annum.
“We could not fail, however, to observe the singular difference which the application of greater capital and greater industry is capable of producing in the state of contiguous lands. While the surrounding country seemed to have been visited by a desolating calamity, the lands of the Rajahs Diaram and Bugwaut Sing, under every disadvantage of season were covered with crops produced by a better husbandry, or by greater labour. It should here be explained that the neighbouring lands alluded to in the report consisted of British territory, already five years in our occupation.”1
And even after all the abuse that has been lavished upon Oude and upon its sovereigns, we find upon unexceptionable testimony that neither the state of the country nor the character of its sovereigns is so black as it is represented by our own officials.
“I was pleased and surprised (says Bishop Heber),2 after all I had heard of Oude, to find the country so completely under the plough, since, were the oppression as great as is sometimes stated, I cannot think that we should witness so considerable a population and so much industry; yet that sufficient anarchy and misrule exists, the events of yesterday afforded sufficient reason for supposing.
“We found invariable civility, and good-natured people backing their carts and elephants to make room for us, and displaying, on the whole, a far greater spirit of hospitality and accommodation than ten foreigners would have met with in London.
“The present king is fond of literary and philosophical pursuits.
“Saadat Ali, himself a man of talent and acquirements, fond of business, and well qualified for it, but, in his latter days, unhappily addicted to drunkenness, left him a country, with six millions of people, a fertile soil, a most compact position, and upwards of two millions of ready money in the treasury, with a well regulated system of finance, a peasantry tolerably well contented, no army to maintain, except for police or parade, and everything likely to produce an auspicious reign.
“I can bear witness certainly to the truth of the king’s statement, that his territories are really in a far better state of cultivation than I had expected to find them. From Lucknow to Sandee, where I am now writing, the country is as populous and well cultivated as most of the Company’s provinces. I cannot, therefore, but suspect that the misfortunes and anarchy of Oude are somewhat overrated.”— P. 89.
“He was fond of study, and in all points of oriental philology and philosophy is really reckoned a learned man, besides having a strong taste in its mechanics and chemistry.
“Like our James I., he is said to be naturally just and kind-hearted; and with all those who have access to him he is extremely popular. No single act of violence and oppression has ever been ascribed to him, or supposed to be perpetrated with his knowledge; and his errors have been a want of economy in his expenses, a want of accessibility to his subjects, a blind confidence in favourites, and, as will be seen, an unfortunate, though not very unnatural, attachment to different points of etiquette and prerogative.” He is described by Lord Hastings as a Sovereign admirable for uprightness, humanity, and mild elevation.
The same high authority testifies to the prosperous condition of the State of Bhurtpore under the Native Sovereigns:
“The country, though still bare of wood, has more scattered trees than we had seen for many days back; and notwithstanding that the soil is sandy, and only irrigated from wells, it is one of the best cultivated and watered tracts which I have seen in India. The crops of corn now on the ground were really beautiful; that of cotton, though gone by, showed marks of having been a very good one. What is a sure proof of wealth, I saw several sugar mills, and large pieces of ground where the cane had just been cleared; and, contrary to the usual habits of India, where the cultivators keep as far as they can from the highway, to avoid the various molestations to which they are exposed from thieves and travellers, there was often a narrow pathway winding through the green wheat and mustard crops, and even this was crossed continually by the channels which conveyed water to the furrows.
“The population did not seem great; but the villages which we saw were apparently in good condition and repair, and the whole afforded so pleasing a picture of industry, and was so much superior to anything which I had been led to expect in Rajpootana, of which I had seen in the Company’s territories since leaving the southern parts of Rohilcund, that I was led to suppose that either the Rajah of Bhurtpore was an extremely exemplary and parental governor, or that the system of management adopted in the British provinces was in some way or other less favourable to the improvement and happiness of the country than some of the Native States.”1
To the high character of Pertab Sing—the first Rajah of Sattara—as a ruler, and to the prosperous condition of his territory, we have the emphatic testimony of the British Government itself:—
“We have been highly gratified by the information, from time to time transmitted to us by our Government, on the subject of your Highness’s exemplary fulfilment of the duties of that elevated situation in which it has pleased Providence to place you.
“A course of conduct so suitable to your Highness’s exalted station, and so well calculated to promote the prosperity of your dominions, and the happiness of your people, as that which you have wisely and uniformly pursued, while it reflects the highest honour on your own character, has imparted to our minds the feelings of unqualified satisfaction and pleasure. The liberality also which you have displayed in executing, at your own cost, various public works of great utility, and which has so greatly raised your reputation in the eyes of the Princes and people of India, gives you an additional claim to our approbation, respect, and applause.
“Impressed with these sentiments the Court of Directors of the East India Company have unanimously resolved to transmit to you a sword, which will be presented to you through the Government of Bombay, and which we trust you will receive with satisfaction, as a token of their high esteem and regard.”1
And whilst thus congratulating this Rajah on the prosperity of his dominions, and the happiness of his people, the condition of some thirty millions of Native British subjects, who have been under British rule for almost a century, is thus described by an unimpeachable witness2 :—
“No one has ever attempted to contradict the fact that the condition of the Bengal peasantry is almost as wretched and degraded as it is possible to conceive, living in the most miserable hovels, scarcely fit for a dog kennel, covered with tattered rags, and unable, in too many instances, to procure more than a single meal a day for himself and family. The Bengal ryot knows nothing of the most ordinary comforts of life. We speak without exaggeration when we affirm that if the real condition of those who raise the harvest, which yields between three and four millions a year, was fully known, it would make the ears of one who heard thereof tingle.”
Now, one of two things : either the British Government found the people of Bengal in this appalling state, or they have been reduced to this state under British rule. If this was their normal state, what has the British Government been doing for a century that they have not extricated them from it ?—or if they have sunk into this state, what has that Government to say for itself in extenuation of such a result ? We have seen it admitted by the Governor-General Lord Cornwallis that in his time—that is, sixty years ago—the “people were advancing hastily to a state of poverty and wretchedness.” We have it upon record, that almost immediately after our acquisition of Bengal, the Government, instead of being the “richest corporation in the world,” as promised by Clive, were without a shilling in their treasury.3 From the times of Akbar down to the government of Meer Jaffer, A.D. 1837, the annual amount of revenue, and the modes of levying it, continued with little variation. But in order to raise the sum which he had engaged to pay us after his elevation, and the annual tribute which he was at the same time bound to pay the King of Delhi, he raised the assessment upon the lands, and multiplied exactions. We continued these extra cesses, and from 1765 to 1790 our revenue system was one of constant changes and experiments, heavy arrears were outstanding, and the country was represented as already exhausted and impoverished.
“A new progeny [said the Governor-General, Lord Hastings] has grown up under our hand; and the principal features which show themselves in a generation thus formed beneath the shade of our regulations are a spirit of litigation which our judicial establishments cannot meet and a morality certainly deteriorated. If in the system, or the practical execution of it, we should be found to have relaxed many ties of moral or religious restraint, or the conduct of individuals to have destroyed the influence of former institutions without substituting any check in their place—to have given loose to the most froward passions of human nature, and deprived the wholesome contact of public opinion and private censure, we shall be forced to acknowledge that our regulations have been productive of a state of things which imperiously calls on us to provide an immediate remedy for so serious a mischief.”1
This was the judgment of a Governor-General upon the effect produced by our judicial regulations upon the character of the people; and with respect to the protection of person and property, we have it stated upon competent authority,2 that it is at this moment just as it has been for the last fifty years, viz., so bad that no man of property within a circle of sixty or seventy miles round Calcutta “can retire to rest with the certainty that he shall not be robbed of it again before morning;” and yet, with all this evidence before us, evidence that, notwithstanding our best intentions, “our administration,” as the Governor-General Lord W. Bentinck admitted, “had in all its branches, revenue, judicial, and police, been a failure.” We boast of progress—of Indian progress!
The object of these pages is to show, on behalf of those who cannot answer for themselves, that they are neither so black, nor we so white, as we paint them and ourselves—that their government and institutions were neither so defective, nor ours so perfect, as we assert them to have been; and that the “History of Indian Progress,” which we create in bulky volumes, only means, after all, that the Christian Indian government of the nineteenth century is better than the Mahomedan and Hindoo governments of the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries. This is the extent of our pretensions, and we can only support this claim by depreciating the characters and doings of our predecessors, and exaggerating our own, and after all leaving it much in doubt whether the balance is really in our favour.
SOME FURTHER OPINIONS ON THE SUBJECT OF NATIVE RULERS AND BRITISH RULE.
By Dadabhai Naoroji.
March, 1899.
The Court of Directors, in their letter to Bengal of February 8th, 1764, say :1—
“One great source of the disputes . . . . appears evidently to have taken its rise from the unwarrantable and licentious manner of carrying on the private trade of the Company’s servants, their goomastas etc. . . . .
“Your deliberations on the inland trade have laid open to us a scene of most cruel oppression. . . . .”
Lord Clive’s letter to Thomas Rous, Esq., dated at Madras, April 17th, 1765, says :—
“The confusion we behold, what does it arise from ? Rapacity and luxury. . . . .”
The Court of Directors’ letter to Bengal, April 26th, 1765 :—
“That they (the English in Bengal) have been guilty of violating treaties, of great oppression, and a combination to enrich themselves.”
On September 30th, 1765, Lord Clive wrote to the Court of Directors :—
“It is no wonder that the lust of riches should readily embrace the proffered means of its gratification, or that the instruments of your power should avail themselves of their authority, and proceed even to extortion in those cases where simple corruption could not keep pace with their rapacity. Examples of this sort set by superiors could not fail of being followed in a proportionate degree by inferiors; the evil was contagious and spread among the civil and military, down to the writer, the ensign, and the free merchant. . . . . All is not safe, danger still subsists from your formidable enemies within—luxury, corruption, avarice, rapacity.”
The Bengal letter of September 30th, 1765, to the Court of Directors :—
“The opportunity of acquiring immense fortunes was too inviting to be neglected and the temptation too powerful to be resisted . . . . this indulgence (to receive presents) has certainly been extended to the most shameful oppression and flagrant corruption . . . . together with the recent proofs before us of notorious and avowed corruption . . . . and the numberless complaints made of grievous exactions and oppressions. . . .”
Court of Directors’ letter to Bengal, December 24th, 1765 :—
“Your deliberations in the inland trade have laid open to us a scene of most cruel oppression.”
Bengal letter of January 31st, 1766, to the Court of Directors :—
“. . . . for we must observe, although with much regret, that the misconduct of individuals hath rendered the English name so odious. . . . . It was firmly our intention to avoid further retrospection of the conduct of our administration, so notoriously corrupt and meanly venal throughout every department.”
Letter of the Court of Directors to Bengal, May 17th, 1766 :—
“. . . . We have the strongest sense of the deplorable state . . . . from the corruption and rapacity of our servants, and the universal depravity of manners throughout the settlement . . . . think the vast fortunes acquired . . . . by a scene of the most tyrannic and oppressive conduct that ever was known in any age or country.” [Italics are mine.]
Lord Clive’s letter to George Dudley, Esq., dated Calcutta, September 8th, 1766 :—
“But retrospection into actions which have been buried in oblivion for so many years; which if inquired into, may produce discoveries which cannot bear the light . . . . but may bring disgrace upon the nation, and at the same time blast the reputation of great and good families.”
Sir Thomas Munro.
“It would be more desirable that we should be expelled from the country altogether, than that the result of our system of government should be such an abasement of a whole people.”1
“But even if we could be secured against every internal commotion, and could retain the country quietly in subjection, I doubt much if the condition of the people would be better than under their Native Princes.” [Italics are mine.]
“The consequence, therefore, of the conquest of India by the British arms, would be in place of raising to debase the whole people. There is, perhaps, no example of any conquest in which the Natives have been so completely excluded from all share of the government of their country as British India. Among all the disorders of the Native States, the field is open to every man to raise himself, and hence among them there is a spirit of emulation, of restless enterprise, and independence far preferable to the servility of our Indian subjects.”
In a minute, dated December 31, 1824, he wrote :—
“It is not enough that we confer on the natives the benefits of just laws and of moderate taxation, unless we endeavour to raise their character; but under a foreign Government there are so many causes which tend to depress it, that it is not easy to prevent it from sinking. It is an old observation that he who loses his liberty loses half his virtue. This is true of nations as well as of individuals. To have no property scarcely degrades more in one case than in the other to have property at the disposal of a foreign Government in which we have no share. The enslaved nation loses the privileges of a nation, as the slave does those of a free man; it loses the privilege of taxing itself, of making its own laws, of having any share in their administration or in the general government of the country. . . . . It is not the arbitrary power of a national sovereign, but subjection to a foreign one, that destroys national character and extinguishes national spirit. When a people cease to have a national character to maintain, they lose the mainspring of whatever is laudable both in public and in private life, and the private sinks with the public character.”—(Indian Spectator, February 19th, 1899.)
Mill’s “History of India,” by J. Wilson, vol. vi, p. 671 (India Reform Tracts, Tract ii, p. 3), thus describes the effect of the system of the British rule :—
“It is an exhausting drain upon the resources of the country, the issue of which is replaced by no reflux; it is an extraction of the life-blood from the veins of national industry, which no subsequent introduction of nourishment is furnished to restore.”
Mr. Montgomery Martin writes (“Eastern India, 1838,” vol. i, p. xii) :—
“The annual drain of £3,000,000 on British India has amounted in thirty years, at 12 per cent. (the usual Indian rate) compound interest, to the enormous sum of £723,900,000 sterling. . . . So constant and accumulating a drain, even in England, would soon impoverish her. How severe, then, must be its effects on India, where the wage of a labourer is from twopence to threepence a day! Were the hundred millions of British subjects in India converted into a consuming population, what a market would be presented for British capital, skill and industry!” What, then, must be the condition now, when the drain is getting perhaps ten times larger, and a large amount besides is eaten in the country itself by others than the people. Even an ocean would be dried up if a portion of its evaporation did not always return to it as rain or river. If interest were added to the drain, what an enormous loss would it be !
Mr. Frederick John Shore, of the Bengal Civil Service says (1837) :—
“ But the halcyon days of India are over; she has been drained of a large proportion of the wealth she once possessed, and her energies have been cramped by a sordid system of misrule to which the interest of millions have been sacrificed for the benefit of the few. The gradual impoverishment of the people and country, under the mode of rule established by the British Government, has. . . .” “ The grinding extortions of the English Government have effected the impoverishment of the country and people to an extent almost unparalleled. . . .”
“ The fundamental principle of the English had been to make the whole Indian Nation subservient in every possible way to the interest and benefit of themselves. . . . Had the welfare of the people been our object a very different course would have been adopted, and very different results would have followed ; for, again and again, I repeat it, there is nothing in the circumstance itself, of our being foreigners of different colour and faith, that should occasion the people to hate us. We may thank ourselves for having made their feelings towards us what they are.”
Sir George Wingate (1859) :—
“ Such is the nature of the tribute we have so long exacted from India. . . . From this explanation some faint conception may be formed of the cruel crushing effect of the tribute upon India. . . .” “ The Indian tribute, whether weighed in the scale of justice or viewed in the light of our interests, will be found at variance with humanity, with common sense, and with the received maxims of political science.”
Lord Salisbury.
On January 22nd, 1867, Lord Salisbury (then Lord Cranborne and Secretary of State for India) said (Hansard, vol. 185, p. 839) :—
“ But there are other considerations, and I think the hon. gentleman (Sir Henry Rawlinson) stated them very fairly and eloquently. I do not myself see our way at present to employing very largely the Natives of India in the regions under our immediate control. But it would be a great evil if the result of our dominion was that the Natives of India who were capable of government should be absolutely and hopelessly excluded from such a career. The great advantage of the existence of Native States is that they afford an outlet for statesmanlike capacity such as has been alluded to. I need not dwell upon the consideration to which the hon. gentleman so eloquently referred, but I think that the existence of a well-governed Native State is a real benefit, not only to the stability of our rule, but because, more than anything, it raises the self-respect of the Natives and forms an ideal to which the popular feelings aspire.”
On May 24th, 1867, Lord Iddesleigh (then Sir Stafford Northcote and Secretary of State for India) said (Hansard, vol. 187, p. 1,068) :—
“Our Indian policy should be founded on a broad basis. There might be difficulties ; but what we had to aim at was to establish a system of Native States which might maintain themselves in a satisfactory relation, keeping the virtues of Natives States, and getting rid, as far as possible, of their disadvantages. We must look to the great natural advantages which the government of a Native State must necessarily have. Under the English system there were advantages which would probably never be under Native Administration—regularity, love of law and order and justice.”
Had Lord Iddesleigh lived he would have with pleasure seen that the advantages he refers to are being attained in the Native States. Lord Iddesleigh proceeds :—
“But Native Administration had the advantage in sympathy between the governors and the governed. Governors were able to appreciate and understand the prejudices and wishes of the governed ; especially in the case of Hindu States the religious feelings of the people were enlisted in favour of their governors instead of being aroused against us.1 He had been told by gentlemen from India that nothing impressed them more than walking the streets of some Indian town, they looked up at the houses on each side and asked themselves, ‘what do we really know of these people—of their modes of thought, their feelings, their prejudices— and at what great disadvantage, in consequence, do we administer the government ?’ The English Government must necessarily labour under great disadvantages,2 and we should endeavour as far as possible to develop the system of Native government to bring out Native talent and statesmanship, and to enlist in the cause of government all that was great and good in them. Nothing could be more wonderful than our Empire in India ; but we ought to consider on what conditions we hold it and how our predecessors held it. The greatness of the Mogul Empire depended on the liberal policy that was pursued by men like the great Emperor Akbar and his successors availing themselves of Hindu talent and assistance, and identifying themselves as far as possible with the people of the country. They ought to take a lesson from such circumstances. If they were to do their duty towards India they could only discharge that duty by obtaining assistance and counsel of all who are great and good in that country. It would be absurd in them to say that there was not a large fund of statesmanship and ability in the Indian character. They really must not be too proud. They were always ready to speak of the English Government as so infinitely superior to anything in the way of Indian Government. But if the Natives of India were disposed to be equally critical, it would be possible for them to find out weak places in the harness of the English administration. The system in India was one of great complexity. It was a system of checks and counter-checks, and very often great abuses failed to be controlled from want of a proper knowledge of and sympathy with the Natives.” [The italics are mine.]
On the same day Lord Salisbury, supporting Lord Iddesleigh, said (Hansard, vol. 187, p. 1073):—
"The general concurrence of opinion of those who know India best is that a number of well-governed small Native States are in the highest degree advantageous to the development of the political and moral condition of the people of India. The hon. gentleman (Mr. Laing) arguing in the strong official line seems to take the view that everything is right in British territory and everything dark in Native territory. Though he can cite the case of Oudh, I venture to doubt if it could be established as a general view of India as it exists at present. If Oudh is to be quoted against Native Government, the Report of the Orissa Famine, which will be presented in a few days, will be found to be another and far more terrible instance to be quoted against English rule. The British Government has never been guilty of the violence and illegality of Native Sovereigns. But it has faults of its own, which, though they are far more guiltless in intention, are more terrible in effect. Its tendency to routine; its listless, heavy heedlessness, sometimes the result of its elaborate organisation; a fear of responsibility, an extreme centralisation—all these results traceable to causes for which no man is culpable, produce an amount of inefficiency which, when reinforced by natural causes and circumstances, creates a terrible amount of misery. All these things must be taken into consideratlon when you compare our elaborate and artificial system of government with the more rough and ready system of India. In cases of emergency, unless you have men of peculiar character on the spot, the simple form of Oriental government will produce effects more satisfactory than the more elaborate system of English rule. I am not by this denying that our mission in India is to reduce to order, to civilise and develop the Native Governments we find there.1 But I demur to that wholesale condemnation of a system of government which will be utterly intolerable on our own soil, but which has grown up amongst the people subjected to it. It has a fitness and congeniality for them impossible for us adequately to realise, but which compensate them to an enormous degree for the material evils which its rudeness in a great many cases produces. I may mention as an instance what was told me by Sir George Clerk, a distinguished member of the Council of India, respecting the Province of Kathiawar, in which the English and Native Governments are very much intermixed. There are no broad lines of frontier there, and a man can easily leap over the hedge from the Native into the English jurisdiction. Sir George Clerk told me that the Natives having little to carry with them were continually in the habit of migrating from the English into the Native jurisdiction but that he never heard of an instance of a Native leaving his own to go into the English jurisdiction. [The italics are mine.]
In the above extract Lord Salisbury says that “the inefficiency reinforced by natural causes and circumstances creates a terrible amount of misery.” These natural causes and circumstances which create the terrible amount of misery are pointed out by Lord Salisbury himself, as Secretary of State for India, in a Minute (29/4/75). He says “the injury is exaggerated in the case of India, where so much of the revenue is exported without a direct equivalent.” And this is so because, as he says, “As India must be bled ;” so that he truly shows that though under the British rule there is no personal violence, the present un-British system of the administration of expenditure cannot but create and does “create a terrible amount of misery.”
Mr. Bright (speech in the Manchester Town Hall, December 11th, 1877) :—
“I say a Government (British) like that has some fatal defect, which at some distant time must bring disaster and humiliation to the Government and to the people on whose behalf it rules.”
Lord Lytton, Viceroy (1878) :—
“No sooner was the act (1833) passed than the Government began to devise means for practically evading the fulfilment of it. . . . . We have had to choose between prohibiting them and cheating them, and we have chosen the least straightforward course . . . . are all so many deliberate and transparent subterfuges for stultifying the Act and reducing it to a dead letter . . . . having taken every means in their power of breaking to the heart the words of promise they had uttered to the ear.”
The Secretary of State for India (Lord Randolph Churchill), in his despatch of January 26th, 1886, to the Treasury, makes this remarkable admission about the consequences of the present “character of the Government,” of the foreign rule of Britain over India :—
“The position of India in relation to taxation and the sources of the public revenues is very peculiar, not merely from the habits of the people and their strong aversion to change, which is more especially exhibited to new forms of taxation, but likewise from the character of the Government, which is in the hands of foreigners, who hold all the principal administrative offices, and form so large a part of the army. The impatience of new taxation, which would have to be borne wholly as a consequence of the foreign rule imposed on the country and virtually to meet additions to charges arising outside of the country, would constitute a political danger the real magnitude of which, it is to be feared, is not at all appreciated by persons who have no knowledge of or concern in the government of India, but which those responsible for that government have long regarded as of the most serious order.” [The italics are mine.]
Sir W. Hunter, in his “Imperial Gazetteer,” says about Bhavnagar in connexion with Kathiawad:—
“Bhavnagar has taken the lead in the material development of her resources, and is the first State in India which constructed a railway at her own expense and risk.”
I may say that Gondal did the same in conjunction with Bhavnagar, and Baroda had done that long before. In handing over the rule of Gondal to the Prince on the completion of his minority, Major Nutt, the British Administrator, and in charge of the State at the time, says with just pride and pleasure, in reference to the increase of revenue from £80,000 in 1870 to £120,000 in 1884:—
“One point of special interest in this matter is, that the increase in revenue has not occasioned any hardship to Gondal subjects. On the contrary, never were the people generally—high and low, rich and poor—in a greater state of social prosperity than they are now.” [The italics are mine.]
The Bombay Government has considered this “highly satisfactory.”
At the installation of the late Chief of Bhavnagar, Mr. Peile (now Sir James Peile), the Political Agent, describes the State as being then “with flourishing finances and much good work in progress. Of financial matters I need say little; you have no debts, and your treasury is full.” When will British Indian financiers be able to speak with the same pride, pleasure, and satisfaction? “No debt, full treasury, good work in progress, increase of revenue, with increase of social prosperity, for high and low, rich and poor.” Will this ever be in British India under the present policy? No. There will be only ever-increasing poverty.
The Instance of the Native State of Mysore.
Of the work of the late Mahárájá from 1881 till his death at the end of 1894, it would be enough to give a very brief statement from the Address of the Dewan to the Representative Assembly held at Mysore on October 1st, 1895, on the results of the late Mahárájá’s administration during nearly fourteen years of his reign, as nearly as possible in the Dewan’s words. The Mahárájá was invested with power on March 25th, 1881. Just previous to it (under British administration) the State had encountered a most disastrous famine, by which a fifth of the population had been swept away, and the State had run into a debt of 80 lakhs of rupees to the British Government. The cash balance had become reduced to a figure insufficient for the ordinary requirements of the administration. Every source of revenue was at its lowest, and the severe retrenchments which followed had left every department of State in an enfeebled condition. Such was the beginning. It began with liabilities exceeding the assets by 30¾ lakhs, and with an annual income less than the annual expenditure by 1¼ lakhs. Comparing 1880-1 with 1894-5, the annual revenue rose from 103 to 180 lakhs, of 75·24 per cent., and after spending on a large and liberal scale on all works and purposes of public utility, the net assets amounted to over 176 lakhs in 1894-5, in lieu of the net liability of 30¾ lakhs with which his Highness’s reign began in 1881:—
| Rs. | |
|---|---|
| In 1881 the balance of State Funds was | 24,07,438 |
| Capital outlay on State Railways | 25,19,198 |
| Against a liability to the British Government of | 80,00,000 |
Leaving a balance of liability of Rs. 30¾ lakhs.
| Assets— | |
|---|---|
| (1) Balance of State Funds | 1,27,23,615 |
| (2) Investment on account of Railway Loan Repayment Fund | 27,81,500 |
| (3) Capital Outlay on Mysore Harihar Railways | 1,48,03,306 |
| (4) Capital Outlay on other Railway | 41,33,390 |
| (5) Unexpended portion of Capital borrowed for Mysore-Harihar Railway (with British Government) | 15,79,495 |
| 3,60,21,306 | |
| Liabilities— | |
| (1) Local Railway Loan Rs. 20,00,000 | |
| (2) English Railway Loan 1,63,82,801 | 1,83,82,801 |
| Net assets | Rs.1,76,38,505 |
| Add Other Assets— | |
| Capital outlay on original Irrigation Works | Rs.99,08,935 |
Besides the above expenditure from current revenue, there is the subsidy to the British Government of about Rs.25,00,000 a year, or a total of about Rs. 3,70,00,000 in the fifteen years from 1880-1 to 1894-5, and the Mahárájá’s civil list of about Rs. 1,80,00,000 during the fifteen years, also paid from the current revenue. And all this together with increase in expenditure in every department. Under the circumstances above described, the administration at the start of his Highness’s reign was necessarily very highly centralised. The Dewan, or the Executive Administrative Head, had the direct control, without the intervention of Departmental Heads of all the principal departments, such as the Land Revenue, Forests, Excise, Mining, Police, Education, Mujroyi, Legislative. As the finances improved, and as Department after Department was put into good working order and showed signs of expansion, separate Heads of Departments were appointed, for Forests and Police in 1885, for Excise in 1889, for Mujroyi in 1891, and for Mining in 1894. His Highness was able to resolve upon the appointment of a separate Land Revenue Commissioner only in the latter part of 1894. Improvements were made in other Departments — Local and Municipal Funds, Legislation, Education, etc. There are no wails which unfortunately the Finance Ministers of British India are obliged to raise, year after year, of fall in Exchange, over-burdening taxation, etc., etc.
And all the above good results are side by side with an increase of population of 18·34 per cent. in the ten years from 1881 to 1891, and there is reason to believe that during the last four years the ratio of increase was even higher. During the fourteen years the rate of mortality is estimated to have declined 6·7 per mille.
But there is still the most important and satisfactory feature to come, viz., that all this financial prosperity was secured not by resort to new taxation in any form or shape. In the very nature of things the present system of administration and management of Indian expenditure in British India cannot ever produce such results, even though a Gladstone undertook the work. Such is the result of good administration in a Native State at the very beginning. What splendid prospect is in store for the future if, as heretofore, it is allowed to develop itself to the level of the British system with its own Native Services, and not bled as poor British India is by the infliction of European Services, which are bleeding India to death.
Sir Wm. Hunter’s “Life of Lord Mayo.”
Lord Mayo says:—
“I believe we have not done our duty to the people of this land. Millions have been spent on the conquering race which might have been spent in enriching and in elevating the children of the soil. We have done much, but we can do a great deal more. It is, however, impossible unless we spend less on the ‘interests’ and ‘more on the people.’
“We must first take into account the inhabitants of the country. The welfare of the people of India is our primary object. If we are not here for their good, we ought not to be here at all.”
“The heaviest of all yokes,” says Macaulay, “is the yoke of the stranger.”
The existing system of British Rule is an un-British, debasing, destructive, despotic and impoverishing Rule. A righteous Rule based on true British principles will be a great blessing both to England and India.
Dadabhai Naoroji.
A SELECTION FROM ADDRESSES.
[Reprinted from INDIA, November 18th, 1898.]
MR. DADABHAI NAOROJI AT MANCHESTER.
A CORDIAL RECEPTION.
[From a Special Correspondent.]
A largely attended public meeting was held under the auspices of the East Manchester Liberal Association, in the Chorlton Town Hall, Manchester, on Monday evening last, to hear addresses from Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji (on India) and Mr. Alfred Mond, the Liberal candidate for South Salford. The chair was taken by Councillor A. H. Scott, and there were upon the platform most of the Liberal leaders in the East Manchester Division.
After the Chairman’s opening speech,
Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji rose amidst loud cheers to address the meeting. He said the Chairman’s speech had struck several important keynotes. He was there that evening— and he hoped to be in the neighbourhood for a week to come —(cheers)—with the object of creating a clear understanding between Lancashire and India. They might properly ask what credentials he had to speak upon that important subject. The best credential he could present was that his life’s career had been passed in this country, as a man of business, having business in part with Lancashire. He claimed to know something about Lancashire’s wishes. On the other hand he was well acquainted with the wants of his own country and with the relations of India to this country. The question of those relations was most important to both. England was a great country having great questions to deal with ; but he challenged anyone to stand up and say that there was any subject of greater importance to England than India. It was necessary they should understand each other clearly. Were the interests of India and those of Lancashire hostile, or were they identical ? Was the good of India associated with the good of England ? and was the good of Lancashire mixed up with the good of India ? That was the question they had to examine. Lancashire was the birth-place of Free Trade. They demanded, and very properly, that India should remain a Free Trade country—and India was, perhaps, the greatest Free Trade country in the world. The question then was–What was their present connexion? What were their commercial relations? India had been a dependent of this country now for a century and a half. Had England developed a commercial connexion with the country which was satisfactory to them? Take a few facts. The exports of British and Irish produce to the whole of the world were valued at £300,000,000. What was India’s share? Despite the fact that the colonies were for the most part Protectionist, we exported to the Canadian Dominion 30s. per head of the population; to Australia something like 155s. per head; to the Cape of Good Hope and Natal 45s. per head; whilst to British India we exported hardly eighteenpence per head per annum. Was that to be the result of our 150 years’ rule in India, looking at it from the view of British interests alone? To foreign countries English exports greatly exceeded 1s. 6d. per head. The United States took something like 8s. only per head per annum of British products. Out of their £300,000,000 worth of British exports hardly £30,000,000 went to India; and of that £30,000,000 the produce of Lancashire would hardly exceed £20,000,000. Had they, then, an interest or not in developing the capacity of the Indians to be able to buy their goods to the extent which would be satisfactory to them? What would that extent be? First they must remember that India consisted of two portions, namely, British India and the Native States. If statistics could be given it would be found that out of what was called British Indian trade there was a large portion that belonged to the Native States. For that they could not take credit. The Native States took a large portion of the produce they sent to India; and, taking British India by itself, they would find that their exports hardly amounted to 1s. per head per annum. Was this a thing to be satisfied with? The people of India, be it remembered, had been civilised for thousands of years; they knew what the enjoyments and the requirements of civilisation were; and if they were in a position to buy £1 worth of British products per head per annum it would equal the amount of British exports to the whole world at the present time. (Hear, hear.) The English were doing their best to find new markets. Let India be placed in such an economic position that she could take English goods to the extent of only £1 per head per annum and they would be utterly unable to supply all her wants. The word “unemployed” would vanish from the English dictionary. (Cheers.) He asked them then to consider very carefully—why was it, notwithstanding our complete communication with India and our control there, that there was constant friction between India and Lancashire—India thinking that Lancashire is treating her unjustly, and Lancashire thinking that India ought not to have any advantage in the matter of trade? But the interests of both were identical. Why then should India not be in a better position? Upon whom did the responsibility rest? It was one of the purposes for which he was there that night to try and answer that question. He exhorted Englishmen for their own sake, as well as for the sake of India, to consider it. Why should there be such evils, after 150 years of British rule, as famines, pestilences, and war? Certainly India must expect something better than that which was its condition before the English occupation. Had that been realised? (A Voice: “Yes.”) He hoped the gentleman who had said “yes” would put aside his present notions and reconsider the matter. (Hear, hear.) If he took the trouble to study the subject— (A Voice: “I have lived in your country”)—yes (continued Mr. Naoroji), you have lived in my country, and I am glad to hear it. It is our misfortune, however, that so many English gentlemen have lived in India as if they had never seen it. (Hear, hear, and cheers.) They go about with their eyes shut, indifferent to the real question—What are the interests of the Indians themselves? Their whole heart is concentrated on one thing—how to benefit themselves—(hear, hear)—without any regard to the circumstances in which the Natives of India are placed. (Loud cheers.) It is the evil groove in which they are moving, and I implore this meeting not to be misled by these gentlemen who fail to see what they ought to see, and who come home and try to mislead the public here by representations which are anything but true. (Cheers.) I do not speak with indignation or anger; I am speaking the bare truth; and it is most important that the British should be informed and should judge for themselves, and not be misled by those who have made it their interest to exploit India as if India had been created by God for that simple object. (Cheers.) Proceeding, Mr. Naoroji said Englishmen usually went to India in two capacities—first, as officials to rule over the Indian people; secondly, as merchants and capitalists. Both classes had only one idea—in the one case it was how to get all the best places in the administration for themselves— and, they were sometimes candid enough to say, “for our boys” —in the other it was how to benefit themselves without caring very much what happened to the people among whom they lived. (Hear, hear.) It was said by one of England’s noblest citizens, whose name would always elicit among the Indians, as well as among Englishmen, the most grateful applause, Mr. John Bright—(cheers)—“You can govern India if you like for the good of England; but the good of England must come through the channels of the good of India.” (Loud cheers.) Let them consider whether such was not the case. Mr. Bright put the whole case in a nutshell. He said further: “There are but two modes of gaining anything by our connexion with India; the one is by plundering the people of India and the other by trading with them. I prefer it by trading with them. But in order that England may become rich by trading with India, India itself must become rich.” He (Mr. Naoroji) knew that the feeling of the British people was not that England should benefit from India by plunder. (Cheers.) He could say that in all sincerity—he knew it thoroughly well. Belief in that one thing had enabled him to keep up the struggle against all odds, during the last quarter of a century upon this question. (Hear, hear.) If the British people would take the matter into their own hand and not allow themselves to be misled by their friends the Anglo-Indians, a better state of things would speedily be brought about. Already he was pleased to think that there were numbers who recognised that India was not being dealt with as it ought to be. Lancashire was most interested in this question, and if they were once agreed that their interests lay in the good of both and not in the good of one, they would understand the question much more easily, because then they would be going on lines which were clear before them. Mr. Bright well understood that the Indians, unless they had the means, could never buy the products of Lancashire. The evil they had to combat lay in the adoption of the principle which Lord Salisbury once laid down, namely, that the principle on which India was to be governed was that India must be bled. That was the foundation of the system of British rule; it had existed for 150 years more or less. Were the English people to rest satisfied with it? If so there was an end of the matter. The only result must be, as Lord Hartington once put it, that the Indian people must wish to get rid of it. That would be the natural consequence of the system. Lord Salisbury’s justification of it was a great reflection upon the British character. The British people did not deserve it. Political hypocrisy lay at the root of the system of government. Lord Lytton when Viceroy caused a minute to be issued in which it was distinctly acknowledged that the policy of the British Government was a policy of deliberate and transparent subterfuges. Not only so but a committee of members of the India Office at the close of the Mutiny—about the year 1860—who met to consider the question of British policy, laid it down distinctly that you are open to the charge of breaking promises deliberately made. He had told the meeting the principle on which the system of government was based, and the means adopted to carry it out. Now for the result. One of the results was that a large volume of wealth was withdrawn from India year after year, which meant the impoverishment of the country. The economic condition of India, therefore, was that a continual bleeding took place, and the inevitable consequence of that was the most terrible misery. It did not require any scientific elucidation—any man of common sense could tell that a country from which the stream of wealth constantly flowed, and never returned, must gradually lose vigour and life. The English nation would not submit to it for a single moment. They could not complain, therefore, that the Indian people protested against it. It was a system which, if continued, must some day end in disaster both to England and to India. (Hear, hear.) What then was their position? The loss to India was a treble loss. There was the loss of wealth, the loss of employment—Native Indians being left out of the higher offices—and the moral loss involved in the loss of capacity. One thing the British had done: they had educated the people of India, and that was a blessing for which they were grateful. As long as ignorance was bliss they said nothing; now they had learnt what it was to be a nation—what it was to be a prosperous nation—how England had built up her prosperity—for which, indeed, she owed a great deal to India. Had the British people ever properly considered that question ? They had taught the people of India what the condition of a people ought to be; they had taught them patriotism; they had given them a new political life, and they then said to them : “ You are our fellow-subjects; you are partners in the Empire, and we want to treat you on righteous and equitable terms.” Unfortunately, however, all this was mere romance; the reality was that the governing class—those to whose care they were consigned— knew only one thing and that was how to benefit themselves. Now that was a kind of relationship which could not last long. The Indian people suffered morally far more grievously even than they did economically. They had the knowledge that they were capable of doing this or that, but they were not permitted—they must remain simple helots. That was a grievous thing—he meant the loss of employment—the loss of capacity as human beings, with its inevitable consequence, the sinking lower and lower in the scale of humanity. Were they to thank the English nation for that ? As men of common sense, who knew their own interests, they must see that the system of government in India ought to be such as would benefit the Indian people as well as themselves. Such, however, is not the system at present, and it must be changed. It was proclaimed repeatedly : “ You, the people of India, are our partners; you must take a share in the responsibilities of Empire.” But the partnership seemed to be an extraordinary one. Would any two gentlemen present, he would like to know, enter into such a partnership—the one providing the capital and the other taking all the profit ? (Laughter and cheers.) He thought Lancashire men would not endorse such a principle in their own business. Take, for instance, the recent war on the North-West frontier. Why did they enter upon that war ? It was because they wanted to save the Empire from Russian aggression. Would anybody say, then, that England had no interest in that war ? Was it all the interest of India ? Yet India must pay every farthing of the cost. They must shed their blood and bear the expense also, not the smallest share being borne by the British Treasury. After the last Afghan War Mr. Gladstone—(cheers)—took up the cudgels and along with Mr. Fawcett succeeded in getting Parliament to agree that the expense should be shared by the English nation. Their reasons were simple. The British entered upon that war essentially for Imperial purposes. And what was more, the Indians themselves were not consulted in any way whatever. They had no voice in it. The only argument and law known to them was the argument and law of force. Well, Mr. Gladstone, soon after he came into power, carried out, though in the face of much opposition, the principle he had enunciated, and succeeded in getting one-fourth of the cost of the war debited to the Imperial treasury. He gave India five millions. That was the extent to which they were relieved, and he did not think it was worthy of the English people, grateful as they were for it. It, however, admitted the principle; it became a precedent; and it was the more encouraging because the British people did not object to it. It had their approval; and even now when the question was mooted the English Press endorsed that principle—the principle of the Imperial Government bearing a part of the cost of warlike operations undertaken for Imperial purposes. Under the present Government, however—owing, should they say, to the tribes or the cleverness of their Anglo-Indian friends ?—the old system had been reverted to. When it came to a question of payment, suddenly it was found that India was most prosperous—capable of supplying everything—and wanted no charitable aid from this country. He asked the English people, was this honourable ? Was it just ? It was, however, but an incident of the situation—a surface evil. The fundamental evil was this—they had a civil and military service in India which inflicted upon the country this treble loss—loss of wealth, loss of employment, and the moral loss, loss of capacity. The result was they could not have that trade with India which Mr. Bright, in the passage quoted, regarded as so essential. Mr. Bright said England should derive benefit from India not by plunder but by trade England was now deriving benefit by plunder. Then came the great question of honour. Did the British people make promises and break them ? Was it creditable to us as a nation that a man in the position of Lord Salisbury should be obliged to confess that we carried on the administration of India by a system of political hypocrisy ? He implored his hearers to make this matter their careful study—if not for the Indians’ sake yet for their own. England did not derive the benefit she might from India. If she would put India in the position of being able to buy English goods to the extent of £1 per head, which was not a very large amount, they would, in such circumstances, be enabled to export as much to India as they now did to the whole world. Was there not, then, sufficient ground for the charges he made against the English administration—first, political hypocrisy, the non-fulfilment of promises? Acts of Parliament, Proclamations by the Queen, all went for nothing. Was that a character worthy of the British name? It was for the British people themselves to take the question up, to study it thoroughly and to adopt a system by which both India and England might be benefited. Then would English rule in India rest upon the affection as well as the self-interest of the Indian people, because they would not like the superior hand of Britain to be removed. If the Indian people from such notions thought the British rule ought to continue, they could then defy half a dozen Russias; they could raise a force in India sufficient to drive back Russia to St. Petersburg. Even now they were carrying on wars all over the world, and India supplied them with a reserve of force, and if they had the backing of the Indian people themselves they could defy all Europe, because India was as large as Europe, and able to cope with Europe singlehanded. (Cheers.) This should be his last word: Don’t be misled by the misrepresentations of that section of the community which had a monopoly of power and pelf, and did not want to lose it. The interest of the two peoples was to be united, and if the Indians believed—as they did—that British supremacy was a great good for them, for their regeneration, for their material and moral development, then they could easily believe that India would be thoroughly loyal. It was not merely loyalty; it was to their own self-interest that they should remain related to Britain; but if the old bad principle of government was to continue—the principle that India must be bled in order that the Anglo-Indians should be able to make fortunes for themselves—then, as any child might tell them, their relations must some day break. That the Indians certainly did not desire; but if ever the time came when they were disaffected the fault would not be theirs, but that of the British alone. The educated portion of the people knew well wherein lay the interest of India. They understood that if they could have really British rule instead of that un-British rule by which they were governed to-day, the result would be a blessing to both of them. (Loud cheers.)
The meeting was afterwards addressed by Mr. Alfred Mond, and others; and Mr. Naoroji was cordially thanked for his most instructive and interesting address.
[Reprinted from India, June 2nd, 1899.]
THE CONDITION OF INDIA.
ADDRESS BY MR. DADABHAI NAOROJI.
[From our own Reporter.]
On Sunday last, May 29, the “Sunday Afternoon Conference” which is held from week to week at Westbourne Park Chapel, London, for the consideration of various subjects of religious or social interest and importance was devoted to the Indian question, Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji delivering an address on the present political and economic condition of India.
There was a very large attendance, which included a fair proportion of Indian gentlemen.
The chair was taken by Mr. Wallis Chapman, who, in introducing Mr. Naoroji, said there were few more responsible duties imposed on the English people than that of the government of India. They were consequently the more indebted to Mr. Naoroji for his willingness to give them the benefit of the knowledge which he had obtained during a lifetime of devotion to the cause of his and their Indian fellow-subjects.
Mr. Naoroji, who was received with cheers, said it was clear that any subject which was thought worthy of consideration on such a day and in such a place must be regarded as a grave one, and a question affecting the weal or woe of three hundred millions of people surely came within that category. Moreover, the action of the English nation in regard to the people of India was of as vital importance to themselves as it was to India, and it was not even of less vital consequence to the whole human race. For a new element had lately come into existence in the councils of the nations. A country which had hitherto confined itself, under its Monroe doctrine, to its own continent was now coming forward to share in what was called the Imperialism of the world, and the question had already arisen which course that country should follow. The American people would unquestionably look to the government of India by the British people to see whether that government was a model for them to follow or an evil example which they should avoid, and on that account the relations between England and India were becoming more and more important to the whole human race, irrespective of the interests of those great countries. Consequently it was the duty of every voter in Great Britain to know what his responsibilities were and what the condition of India had been during the century and a half of regular British administration. He would deal first with the political condition of India at the present moment, and would regard it in its two aspects—the legislative and the executive. There existed Legislative Councils in India, and it was generally believed that those councils gave to the Indian people something like what they in England enjoyed in the way of representative government, and that by those means the people of India had some voice in their own government. This was simply a romance. The reality was that the Legislative Council was constituted in such a way as to give to the Government a complete and positive majority. The three or four Indians who had seats upon it might say what they like, but what the Government of India declared was to become law did invariably become the law of the country. To take, for instance, the question of expenditure—when a Budget was brought forward in the House of Commons members went on contesting it, item by item, for six months —they saw that their constituents’ interests were properly protected, and that the Government took no advantage of their power. Of course, in the British Parliament also the majority had the final word; but, whereas in that case that majority was subject to the people and could be turned out by them, in the Indian legislative councils the majority, instead of being given by the people, was managed and manipulated by the Government itself. But matters were even worse than this. The expenditure of the revenues was one of the most important points in the political condition of any country, but in India there was no such thing as a legislative Budget. The representative members had no right to propose any resolution or go to any division upon any item concerned in the Budget, which was passed simply and solely according to the despotic will of a despotic Government. The Natives of India had not the slightest voice in the expenditure of the Indian revenues, and the idea that they had was the first delusion on the part of the voters of England which he wished to correct. It would be seen in what an absurd position the so-called Native representatives of India were placed. In the expenditure of the revenue they had, as he had explained, not the least voice, but when the time came for the imposition of taxes they were quite welcome to impose what taxation they could upon their countrymen. Yet if they did impose additional taxes these countrymen blamed them, while if, on the other hand, they resisted any particular Bill of taxation the Government officials turned round and said, “ These Indians seem to think it possible to govern a country without revenue,” and this they made an argument against the capacity of the Natives to take an adequate part in the government of their country. The Legislative Council was simply and solely, he declared, a delusion and a farce, and its working constituted a worse despotism than was ever exercised by any Native ruler even in the old days. An Oriental despot, when he misgoverned, acted, so to speak, like a butcher, and people were astounded and horrified; this new despotism of civilisation rather resembled a murder effected by a clever but unscrupulous surgeon who drew all the blood from his victim while leaving scarcely a scar upon the skin. Moreover, if under Oriental despotism the results to the individual were serious, they at least were not so terrible to the country. A particular victim was no doubt often despoiled of his fortune, bnt some favourite benefited, and the money at least remained in the country; whereas the British—or rather un-British—system of despotism took away year by year a greater portion of the wealth of India, with the result that at the present day the Indians under British rule were the very poorest people in the world. And it was not as if there were any necessity that this should be the case. British statesmen had in the past recognised that by a different and more righteous system of government the situation of both India and England might be vastly improved, and that the latter might make ten times more money out of India by benefiting the latter country than was at present drawn from her destruction and impoverishment. With regard to the executive portion of the Government of India, they found most emphatically realised the old saying that taxation without representation was tyranny. But he did not wish to suggest for a moment that it was the desire of the British people that this state of things should continue. On the contrary, he was so absolutely convinced that the British people did not wish that India should go on being governed on wicked lines, for they had done all they could— all save one thing—to secure that the Government of India should be carried on upon lines of righteousness. After the terrible exposures of British mis-government in and before the days of Warren Hastings the British people made a firm stand and strongly declared that India should not be subjected to such treatment any longer, with the result that in 1833 the British Government openly and decidedly stated that the Government of India should be a righteous one, and that the people of India should be treated in the same manner as the people of Great Britain. That, by the way, was the era of emancipations, among others of that which had enabled him to stand before an English constituency and, by obtaining their suffrages, to go to the House of Commons to plead his country’s cause. (Hear, hear.) However, all the great statesmen of the time to which he referred declared with one voice that the Bill must pass, no matter what the consequences might be, and it did pass, its general effect being that no Native of India should by virtue of his religion or descent be disabled from holding any place, office, or employment under the Company. It might be asked what more than that the Indian people wanted, and he replied that they wanted nothing more— except that the British people should carry into effect honourably the Act they had passed. In 1853 there was a revision of the Act, when Lord Stanley of that day—the late Earl of Derby—Mr. Bright and other true Britons protested that the measure was completely and wholly a dead letter. But the Government of India and the Indian authorities nevertheless continued to act upon the one principle that the Indian Services were their monopoly, not to be encroached upon by any other persons, and the representations of Lord Stanley and Mr. Bright were not listened to. Then came the Mutiny, upon which he did not wish to touch beyond saying that if it was anyone’s fault it was the fault of the British Government and their Indian Governor-General. However, it was for the most part Indians who, even in the Mutiny, saved the British Empire in India. Lord George Hamilton talked glibly of the manner in which the British Empire had been built up by the expenditure of British treasure and the spilling of British blood. Well, much of the blood spilt in building up the Empire had been Indian blood, while with regard to treasure the British people had not spent a single farthing in creating or upholding it so far as the Indian portion of it was concerned. They had, on the contrary, constrained the wretched Indian Natives to contribute the whole cost, and were still drawing from India year by year millions upon millions to the still greater impoverishment and destruction of the Indian people. That, however, was somewhat by the way. After the Mutiny, when British power was re-established, the true British spirit was at once aroused, and once more the generous declaration went forth in the shape of a Proclamation from the Throne. “We hold ourselves bound to the Natives of our Indian territory,” the Proclamation ran, “by the same obligations of duty which bind ourselves to our other subjects, and those obligations, by the blessing of Almighty God, we shall faithfully and conscientiously fulfil. And it is our further will that, so far as may be, our subjects, of whatever race or creed, shall be freely and impartially admitted to offices in our service, the duties which they may be qualified by their education, ability, and integrity duly to discharge. . . . . In their prosperity will be our strength, in their contentment our security, and in their gratitude our best reward. And may the God of all Power grant to us and those in authority under us strength to carry out these our wishes for the good of our people.” But did the British people feel that in the impoverishment of India they could be strong or that they could be secure while India, far from being content, was terribly suffering? As to their reward he would not say at that moment what cause there was for gratitude or how much of it prevailed, but he would repeat that even putting matters on the very low platform of selfishness, the British nation would derive ten times more profit from India than was the case at present if they would only alter their treatment. (Hear, hear.) Similar proclamations had been issued since—when the Queen was declared Empress of India and at the Jubilee, but all these solemn obligations and Acts of Parliament had been and were being scattered to the winds in order that Anglo-Indian officials might keep in their hands the monopoly of Indian Government and might provide for their boys. (Hear, hear.) What were the economic consequences of this state of things? They were summed up in the declaration of Lord Salisbury himself that India must be “bled,” and was the principle on which the whole present system of Indian government was based. Lord Salisbury coolly and deliberately, in the memorandum to which he referred, admitted that India was injured by the drain that was constantly going on in the way of the exportation of so much revenue without any direct equivalent, and went on to say that as the great mass of the people, the agricultural community, had no more blood remaining in them, the lancet should be applied to those parts where the blood was congested or at least sufficient. He had said enough, he thought, to show how the unhappy Indian Natives were regarded by Anglo-Indian officials. The lot of the former, indeed, was somewhat worse than that of the slaves in America in old days, for the masters had an interest in keeping them alive, if only that they had a money value. But if an Indian died, or if a million died, there was another or there were a million others ready to take his or their places and to be the slaves of British officials in their turn. Who, he asked in conclusion, was responsible for all this? The British people might ask : “What more can we do? We have declared that India shall be governed upon righteous lines.” Yes, but their servants have not obeyed their instructions, and theirs was the responsibility and upon their heads was the blood of the millions who were starving year by year. For their own sakes, as well as for the sake of the Indian people, it was time that they awoke. They were so taken up at present by the extension of their Empire that they little dreamed of a day which might come at any moment when their existing Empire might suffer an upheaval and explosion which would shatter it to pieces. He held out no threats, but that would be the natural consequence of an iniquitous and unjust system of government, as had been declared by Lord Salisbury when he said that injustice would bring down the mightiest kingdom. (Applause.)
Subsequently a series of questions were put to Mr. Naoroji, who answered them in considerable detail. He declared that famines were far less harmful in the feudatory States than in that part of India which was under direct British rule, because those States lost nothing by their subjection to Great Britain except the small tribute paid yearly, and were consequently improving their position every day, and were enabled to establish a reserve fund and Treasury balances, out of which the people could be helped in time of need. For these feudatory States he admitted that British supremacy was a blessing. The average annual income of the Natives of India per head had, he said in answer to another question, been estimated by the present Lord Cromer as not more than twenty-seven rupees, but his own belief was that, at the present rate of exchange, it was not more than 25s. Let them contrast that with the average annual income per head of the people of Great Britain, which was estimated at £41.
A vote of thanks to Mr. Naoroji was moved by Miss Annie Lee-Brown, secretary of the local Women’s Liberal Association, and seconded by Mr. Martin Wood, late of Bombay, who said the best method in which those present could express their thanks would be to study the subject and bring to bear such influence as they possessed with a view to remedying the condition of things of which they had heard.
The vote was heartily carried, and Mr. Naoroji having briefly returned thanks the meeting concluded.
[Reprinted from India, July 6th, 1900.]
MR. DADABHAI NAOROJI AT WALTHAMSTOW.
“INDIA MUST BE BLED.”
[From Our Own Reporter.]
Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji addressed a meeting held on Sunday last, July 1st, at the United Methodist Free Church, Markhouse Road, Walthamstow, in aid of the Indian Famine Relief Fund. Mr. Peter Troughton occupied the chair.
The Chairman, in opening the proceedings, said the Indian famine was a subject of very great interest to all Englishmen, and he was sure they would all gladly welcome some authentic information on the subject. He would therefore ask Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji to start his speech right away. (Applause.)
Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji, who was received with cheers, said : Mr. Chairman, I feel exceedingly pleased at having to address so large a meeting of English ladies and gentlemen. I assure you it is a great consolation to me that English people are willing to hear what Indians have to say. I will make bold to speak fully and heartily, in order that you may know the truth. I will take as a text the following true words : “As India must be bled.” These words were delivered by a Secretary of State for India, Lord Salisbury himself. I don’t mention them as any complaint against Lord Salisbury. On the contrary, I give him credit for saying the truth. I want to impress upon you what these important words mean. Let us clearly understand what is meant by bleeding a nation. It is perfectly true that when government is carried on people must pay taxes. But there is a great difference between taxing a people and bleeding a people. You in England pay something like fifty shillings, or more now, of taxes per head per annum. We in India pay only three to four shillings per head per annum. From this you may conclude that we must be the most lightly-taxed people in the world. That is not the case, however ; our burden is nearly twice as heavy as yours. The taxes you pay in this country go from the hands of the taxpayers into the hands of the Government, from which they flow back into the country again in various shapes, fertilising trade and returning to the people themselves. There is no diminution of your wealth; your taxes simply change hands. Whatever you give out you must get back. Any deficit means so much loss of strength. Supposing you pay a hundred million pounds every year, and the Government uses that money in such a way that part only returns to you, the other part going out of the country. In that case you are being bled, part of your life is going away. Suppose out of the hundred million pounds only eighty million pounds return to you in the shape of salaries, commerce, or manufactures. You will have lost twenty million pounds. Next year you will be so much the weaker; and so on each year. This is the difference between taxing people and bleeding people. Suppose a body of Frenchmen were your rulers, and that out of the hundred million pounds of taxes they took ten to twenty million pounds each year; you would then be said to be bleeding. The nation would then be losing a portion of its life. How is India bled ? I supposed your own case with Frenchmen as your rulers. We Indians are governed by you. You manage our expenditure and our taxes in such a way that while we pay a hundred million pounds of taxation this hundred million never returns to us intact. Only about eighty million returns to us. There is a continual bleeding of about twenty millions annually from the revenues. Ever since you obtained territorial jurisdiction and power in India, in the middle of the last century, Englishmen and other Europeans that went to India have treated that country in the most oppressive way. I will quote a few words of the Court of Directors at the time to show this. “The vast fortunes acquired in the inland trade have been obtained by the most oppressive conduct that ever was known in any country or age.” The most oppressive means were adopted in order to bring away from the country enormous quantities of wealth. How was the Indian Empire obtained by you ? It has been generally said that you have won it by the sword, and that you will keep it by the sword. The people who say this do not know what they are talking about. They also forget that you may lose “ it by force.” You have not won the Indian Empire by the sword. During these hundred and fifty years you have carried on wars by which this great Empire has been built up it has cost hundreds of millions of money. Have you paid a single farthing of it ? You have made the Indians pay every farthing. You have formed this great British Empire at our expense, and you will hear what reward we have received from you. The European army in India at any time was comparatively insignificant. In the time of the Indian Mutiny you had only forty thousand troops there. It was the two hundred thousand Indian troops that shed their blood and fought your battles and that gave you this magnificent Empire. It is at India’s cost and blood that this Empire has been formed and maintained up to the present day. It is in consequence of the tremendous cost of these wars and because of the millions on millions you draw from us year by year that India is so completely exhausted and bled. It is no wonder that the time has come when India is bleeding to death. You have brought India to this condition by the constant drain upon the wealth of that country. I ask any one of you whether it is possible for any nation on the face of the earth to live under these conditions. Take your own nation. If you were subjected to such a process of exhaustion for years, you would come down yourselves to the condition in which India now finds herself. How then is this drain made ? You impose upon us an immense European military and civil service, you draw from us a heavy taxation. But in the disbursement and the disposal of that taxation we have not the slightest voice. I ask anyone here to stand up and say that he would be satisfied if, having to pay a heavy taxation, he had no voice in the government of the country. We have not the slightest voice. The Indian Government are the masters of all our resources, and they may do what they like with them. We have simply to submit and be bled. I hope I have made it quite clear to you, that the words of Lord Salisbury which I have quoted are most significant ; that the words are true and most appropriate when applied to India. It is the principle on which the system of British government has been carried on during these 150 years. What has been the consequence ? I shall again quote from Lord Salisbury. He says : “That as India must be bled the lancet should be directed to the parts where the blood is congested, or at least sufficient, not to those parts already feeble from the want of it.” Lord Salisbury declared that the agricultural population, the largest portion of the population of India, was feeble from the want of blood. This was said twenty-five years ago; and that blood has been more and more drawn upon during the past quarter of a century. The result is that they have bled to death; and why? A large proportion of our resources and wealth is clean carried away never to return to us. That is the process of bleeding. Lord Salisbury himself says: “So much of the revenue is exported without a direct equivalent.” I ask any one of you whether there is any great mystery in these dire famines and plagues? No other country exhausted as India has been exhausted by an evil system of government would have stood it half the time. It is extraordinary that the loyalty of the Indians who are bled by you is still so great. The reason of it is that among the Hindoos it is one of their most cherished and religious duties that they should give obedience and loyalty to the powers that govern them. And they have been loyal to that sentiment, and you have derived the benefit of it. It is a true and genuine loyalty. But do not expect that that loyalty cannot fail, that it will continue in the same condition in which it is at the present time. It is for the British to rouse themselves and to open their minds, and to think whether they are doing their duty in India. The theory maintained by statesmen is that India is governed for the benefit of India. They say that they do not derive any benefit from the taxation. But this is erroneous. The reality is that India, up to the present day, has been governed so as to bring about the impoverishment of the people. I ask you whether this is to continue. Is it necessary that, for your benefit, we must be destroyed? Is it a natural consequence, is it a necessary consequence? Not at all. If it were British rule and not un-British rule which governed us England would be benefited ten times more than it is. (Cheers.) You could benefit yourselves a great deal more than you are doing if your Executive Government did not persist in their evil system, by which you derive some benefit, but by which we are destroyed. I say let the British public thoroughly understand this question, that by destroying us you will ultimately destroy yourselves. Mr. Bright knew this, and this is an extract from one of his speeches. He said, or to the effect: By all means seek your own benefit and your own good in connexion with India; but you cannot derive any good except by doing good to India. If you do good to India you will do good to yourselves. He said there were two ways of doing good to yourselves, either by plunder or by trade. And he said he would prefer trade. Now, I will explain how it would benefit you. At the present time you are exporting to the whole world something like three hundred millions worth of your produce a year. Here is a country under your control with a population of three hundred millions of human souls, not savages of Africa. Here is India, with a perfectly free trade entirely under your control, and what do you send out to her? Only eighteen pence per year per head. If you could send goods to the extent of £1 per head per annum India would be a market for your whole commerce. If such were the case you would draw immense wealth from India besides benefiting the people. I say that if the British public do not rouse themselves the blood of every man that dies there will lie on their head. You may prosper for a time, but a time must come when you must suffer the retribution that comes from this evil system of government. What I quoted to you from Lord Salisbury explains the real condition of India. It is not the first time that English statesmen have declared this as absolutely as Lord Salisbury has done. During the whole century Englishmen and statesmen of conscience and thought have time after time declared the same thing, that India is being exhausted and drained, and that India must ultimately die. Our misery is owing to this exhaustion. You are drawing year by year thirty millions of our wealth from us in various ways. The Government of India’s resources simply mean that the Government is despotic and that it can put any tax it chooses on the people. Is it too much to ask that when we are reduced by famine and plague you should pay for these dire calamities? You are bound in justice and in common duty to humanity to pay the cost of these dire calamities with which we are afflicted. I will conclude with Lord Salisbury’s other true words : “ Injustice will bring down the mightiest to ruin.” (Great applause.)
At the conclusion of Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji’s address a collection was made on behalf of the famine relief fund, and the meeting ended, as it had begun, with devotional exercises.
[Reprinted from India, July 27th, 1900.]
MR. NAOROJI AT PLUMSTEAD.
[From Our Own Reporter.]
On Saturday, July 21st, Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji addressed the delegates of the Metropolitan Radical Federation, at a meeting held at the Plumstead Radical Club, under the presidency of Mr. James Jeffrey, L.C.C. There was a fairly large attendance.
Mr. Naoroji, who was heartily cheered, took the following resolution as the text of his speech :—
“Resolved: “Considering that Britain has appropriated thousands of millions of India’s wealth for building up and maintaining her British Indian Empire, and for directly drawing vast wealth to herself; that she is continuing to drain about £30,000,000 of India’s wealth every year unceasingly in a variety of ways; and that she has thereby reduced the bulk of the Indian population to extreme poverty, destitution, and degradation; it is therefore her bounden duty in common justice and humanity to pay from her own exchequer the costs of all famines and diseases caused by such impoverishment.
“That, therefore, for the present famine and diseases the British Exchequer should pay the whole cost of both saving life and restoring the stricken people to their normal industrial condition and wants, instead of further oppressing and crushing the Indian people themselves to find these costs directly or by loan under the deceptive pretext or disguise of what is called ‘the resources of the Government of India,’ which simply means squeezing the wretched people themselves.
“That it is most humiliating and discreditable to the British name that other countries should be appealed to or should have to come to Britain’s help for relief of Britain’s own subjects, and after and by her un-British rule of about 150 years.
“And that for the further prevention of famines and plagues, and to restore prosperity to the Indian people, as well as for benefiting vastly the masses of the British people also, measures must be adopted to put an end to the exhausting and impoverishing bleeding, by dealing with justice for all expenditures for British interests, and by honourably carrying out the true and declared policy and solemn pledges of the British people, Parliament, and Sovereign, by the Act 1833 and her Majesty’s Proclamations of 1858, 1877, and 1887.”
Dealing with the first part of the resolution, he said it was a pure matter of fact that Great Britain, during the whole period of her connexion with India, had never spent a single farthing of British money on the Eastern Empire. All the great wars which had been engaged in had been paid for by the Indians themselves, and it was India, or rather its Natives, who had given this noble heritage to the British Empire. Indians had also shed their blood in order to maintain and extend that Empire. Up to the time of the Indian Mutiny the British Army there never exceeded 40,000 men, while its average strength was from 15,000 to 20,000 men. But the Indian Army of 200,000 was placed at the service of the Empire ; it was maintained by India, and it shed its blood for India. Surely these facts required no comment. But that was not all. From the time when Great Britain first obtained territorial jurisdiction in India down to the present day it had drawn millions upon millions sterling from that Empire. Great Britain had appropriated this Indian wealth, thereby reducing the population to extreme poverty. At the beginning of the century only about 3 millions a year was drawn from India, but now the amount taken away was officially admitted to be about 30 millions sterling annually. This was an open sore, and no country could withstand being bled unceasingly in this manner. (Hear, hear.) As he had said the result had been to reduce the bulk of the Indian population to extreme poverty, destitution, and degradation ; and, to use the terms of his resolution, it was “ Great Britain’s bounden duty, in common justice and humanity, to pay from her own Exchequer the costs of all famines and diseases caused by such impoverishment.” There could only be one ending to this continual bleeding of India. Famine was following upon famine ; each visitation was becoming more disastrous, and the present was the most disastrous of the whole century. For from thirty to forty years he had been as one crying in the wilderness against this terrible treatment. He had realised, and he had endeavoured to make the people realise, that a country thus drained must in the end die. Great Britain owed a debt to these poor, wretched, dying people. (Hear, hear.) The British people, through their policy, were the cause of the misery which now prevailed, and the least they could do surely was to try and help the Natives of India in their time of terrible distress. The great idea of the Indian Government appeared to be not to let the English taxpayer have any trouble or annoyance in connexion with India. The rulers of that Empire seemed to think that the moment the English taxpayer was called upon to contribute a farthing for the maintenance of India, he would demand to know the reason why India had been treated in the manner she had been. They were well aware, too, that no good reason could be shown for such treatment. Let him give one illustration of the unwisdom of maintaining a running sore. Thirty years ago France and Germany had a deadly struggle. France was beaten and had to pay dearly for it. A heavy burden was imposed upon her, a severe wound was inflicted. But in process of time it healed. France paid her debt, the account was closed, and she became as prosperous as ever. Why was not an endeavour made to treat India in the same way? Why, having once drawn from her enormous sums of money, was not the account closed and the Natives of India allowed to reap the benefit of the wealth which their country produced? No. The policy was to keep the wound running day after day and month after month, and they might rely upon it that until the bleeding was stopped India would have no chance of prosperity. It surely was the duty of the British Exchequer, seeing that their policy was responsible for the present famine and disease, to pay the whole cost of saving life and of restoring the stricken people to their normal industrial condition instead of further oppressing and crushing the Indian people themselves by compelling them to find these costs directly or by loan under the deceptive pretext or disguise of what is called “the resources of the Government of India,” which simply meant squeezing the wretched people themselves. The term “resources of the Government of India” was a most deceptive one. They had often been told that India had not exhausted her borrowing powers. But what were the facts? The Government of India consisted of Europeans. The Indians had not the slightest voice in the expenditure of a single farthing. They had only to pay, and, before any portion of the taxation exacted from them could be used for the benefit of India, 200,000,000 of rupees were annually devoted to the payment of salaries and pensions of Europeans who constituted the Government of India. The population of England paid 50s. per head per annum in the form of taxation. The people of India did not even pay 5s. per head; yet, strange to say, they were crushed by a heavier burden of taxation than were the English. The incidence and heaviness of taxation did not depend upon the amount; it depended upon the capacity to bear it; and the fact was that, while English taxation represented from 6 per cent. to 8 per cent. of the taxpayers’ income, the taxation in India represented 14 or 15 per cent. They all knew how hard it was for a man earning £1 per week to give 1s. out of it. It was far more easy for a man with an income of £1,000 a year to give away £100; and hence it was that the people of India, in their wretchedness and impoverishment, felt so heavily the taxation imposed upon them. Was it not most humiliating and discreditable to the British name that other countries should be appealed to to come to Britain’s help for the relief of Britain’s own subjects after they had been under British rule for a period of 150 years? British rule was supposed to confer great blessings upon the Indian race. But what had been the results of it? Millions of the people were dying of famine and disease, and scores of millions from year’s end to year’s end never knew what it was to have a full meal! As had been well said it was a shame that our own fellow-subjects should starve while the British Empire was the greatest and richest in the world. In treating India as they were doing they were killing the bird that laid the golden eggs. They were deriving great benefits from India, but those benefits carried with them losses to the Indian people. If they would only treat India honestly, if they would act as honourable Englishmen and fulfil their pledges to India, they would be able to gain ten times as much benefit from India, and those benefits would then carry with them the blessings of the Indian people. More than that, how was the wealth now withdrawn from India distributed? It went into the pockets of the capitalists and the higher classes. It did not benefit the working men of Great Britain. He had no desire to appeal to their selfishness, but he was bound to point out the economic fact that the doing of evil reflected upon all who had a share in it. Now, in England the production represented something like £40 per head per annum. They exported goods to the whole world, and the amount of exports was placed at three hundred millions sterling per annum. Upon those exports rested the question of their employment. Their own colonies had slammed the door of protection in their face, European countries had also adopted protective tariffs; so, too, had the United States of America, and yet, notwithstanding this fact, Great Britain annually exported produce to the value of three hundred millions sterling. India was the only place where they had perfect freedom of trade, entirely under their own control. But what proportion of the British exports went into that country? Only about twenty-five million sterling. Why was it that such a small amount was exported to India? Simply because the process of bleeding had been carried on to such an extent that the people had literally no money left with which to buy British produce. Now if, instead of treating the Natives of India in this cruel and barbarous fashion, they were to deal with them honestly, what would be the result? Let them remember that the Indians were not a race of savages. Two thousand years ago they were the most highly civilised nation in the world. And what sort of people were the Natives of England when at that period they were discovered by Cæsar? (A laugh.) Now, the Indians know how to enjoy the good things of this world, and if they were only allowed to benefit by what they produced they would be able to buy the manufactures of Great Britain. The Government were willing to massacre savages in South Africa in order to find markets for British goods, whereas if they would only develop the resources of India with her three hundred millions of population, they would find ample outlet for British trade, and there would soon cease to be any unemployed in Great Britain. Thus if they would only adopt an honest policy to India they would benefit ten times to the extent they now did. Nemesis always followed upon unrighteousness, and, as Lord Salisbury once said, “Injustice will bring the mightiest of the earth to ruin.” He did not see why England should be an exception to that rule. British rule had given the people security of life and property; but of what value to them was a life which meant death by starvation or disease, or of what good was property when it was only produced for the benefit of Great Britain? The fact was that Indian Natives were mere helots. They were worse than American slaves, for the latter were at least taken care of by their masters, whose property they were. All the Indian people asked was that this country should faithfully carry out the terms of the Queen’s Proclamation of 1858 which promised that “Our subjects, of whatever race or creed, be freely and impartially admitted to offices in our service, the duties of which they may be qualified to discharge.” Hitherto the policy of Great Britain had been in distinct contravention of Parliamentary pledges and of the Queen’s Proclamation. The romance was that British rule was a blessing to India; the reality was that it was destroying India, and they might depend upon it that the destruction of India must ultimately be followed by the destruction of Great Britain. Let them alter their policy before it was too late. He very much feared that the present famine would be followed by another famine next year, because the land had become so dry. Things were going from worse to worse, and it behoved the people of Great Britain to arouse themselves, and in the interests of humanity and common justice to adopt such a policy in India as would enable the people to develop the enormous wealth of that country and to enjoy the fruits of their own country. (Loud cheers.)
The resolution was then put to the meeting and unanimously approved, and the chairman was authorised to sign and forward to the Prime Minister a petition embodying its provisions.
[Reprinted from INDIA, November 30th, 1900.]
MR. DADABHAI NAOROJI AT KENNINGTON.
INTERESTING DEBATE ON THE INDIAN FAMINE.
The subject set down for discussion at the weekly meeting, last Saturday, of the St. John’s Literary and Debating Society, Kennington, was “The Indian Famine; Its Causes and Remedy.” The chair was occupied by the Rev. H. G. G. Mackenzie, and the principal speaker was Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji. There was a large attendance of members, and among the visitors were Messrs. G. K. Singh, Mukerji, and T. S. Naidu.
In opening the proceedings the chairman commented on the fearful and appalling ignorance which prevailed in this country on Indian affairs and expressed the pleasure they had in welcoming one who was able to speak with so much authority on the subject which they had to debate that evening. (Hear, hear.)
Mr. Naoroji, who was received with cheers, said that although he proposed to confine himself that evening to the discussion of the causes of the Indian Famine and the remedy it must not be supposed for one moment that he desired to ignore, in the slightest degree, the good which India had reaped from her connexion with England—(hear, hear)— indeed the very fact that he was on that occasion addressing an English audience and pointing out the faults associated with British rule was in itself the best compliment he could pay to that rule in India. It was not necessary that he should attempt to describe the horrors of the famine. The descriptions of the misery and tortures suffered by millions of the Indian people, which had already appeared in the English Press, must have sufficiently lacerated their hearts. He would go direct, therefore, to the causes of the famine.
When the British people first obtained territorial power in India, bad seeds were unfortunately sown. The Company went there solely for the sake of profit, greed was at the bottom of everything they did, and the result was that corruption, oppression, and rapacity became rampant. That was the state of things at the very beginning of our political connexion with India, as was fully proved by reports of the Court of Directors of the East India Company. One of those reports set forth that vast fortunes acquired in the Indian trade had been obtained largely by tyranny and oppression. One result was that there was a heavy drain of wealth from India, and the Europeans who went out there were so anxious to acquire riches that they did not wait until they had earned or deserved them, but they seized them in defiance of all economic principles. That was one cause of India’s trouble.
Again, in the formation of the Indian Empire there had occurred many wars which had entailed enormous expenditure. Probably the cost of them had gone into hundreds of millions, and towards this the British people had not contributed a single farthing. Everything expended upon the formation of the British Empire in India had been exacted from the Indian people and, in addition to that, the Natives had shed their blood freely—and to a much greater extent than Englishmen —in order to insure the maintenance of the British supremacy. Year by year the burden upon India had steadily increased, and the three millions which was annually exacted at the beginning of the present century had now grown to 25 or 30 millions. The worst of it was that India was afforded no chance of recuperation. She was suffering from a running wound which was slowly but surely sapping her vitality, and he ventured to assert that if Great Britain, now the richest country in the world, were to be subjected to similar treatment, she would as certainly fall into a state of impoverishment such as now afflicted her Eastern dependency.
It might be asked were not the famines due to droughts ? His answer was in the negative. India was able to grow any quantity of food. Her resources in that respect were inexhaustible, and when famines had occurred in the past— before she was subjected to the continual drain of her wealth —the population were able to withstand them because they had stores of grain upon which they could fall back. But nowadays they were unable to accumulate such stores. Immediately the grain was grown it had to be sold in order to provide the taxation of the country, and the people were therefore not in a position to cope with famine. Indeed, the English little knew the actual conditions under which the Indian Natives existed. A large proportion of the population was in a normal state of starvation. The people were always underfed, even in good years, and consequently, when bad years came, they the more readily succumbed. No doubt, thanks to the assistance which had been sent from this country, many thousands of lives had been saved. But for what? The people had been reduced to living skeletons; they had lost all stamina, and they would fall easy victims to disease. Now, if England failed to produce a single ear of corn in any one year there would not of necessity arise a famine, for the nations of the world would at once pour into the country stores of food which the people would be able to buy. But the difficulty of India was that the Natives had no money with which to buy food should their crops fail, and hence it was that these disastrous famines arose. India was being made to bleed at every pore, her agricultural population —the vast mass of the people—had become weak for want of blood, and their poverty was accentuated by the fact that much of her produce was sent out of the country without anything being received in return for it.
Now he came to the remedy. It was to be found in two words and two words alone—“honour” and “justice.” There was not the slightest necessity that India should suffer in order that England might gain. If only the right policy were adopted India could be made prosperous, and at the same time England would reap ten times the benefit she now had from the connexion. She would gain the blessings and the gratitude of the people in lieu of their curses and their blood. What ought to be the British policy in India had been laid down in terms which gave the greatest satisfaction to the Natives of India. From 1833 onwards it had been stated in official document after official document—in Act of Parliament and in Royal Proclamation—that the Natives should have perfect equality with British citizens, and should not be debarred by reason of their origin or place of birth from holding any place or office for which by education they were fitted. (Cheers.) But, unfortunately, these solemnly-made promises had never been fulfilled. The people were still kept under a bad system of government. They had no voice in the expenditure of the money exacted from them in the form of taxes. The Queen, in her Proclamation after the Indian Mutiny, promised that the Natives should be freely and impartially admitted to offices, “the duties of which they might be qualified by their education, ability, and integrity to discharge.” But that promise had not been fulfilled, and therein was to be found Great Britain’s dishonour. The promise was renewed when her Majesty assumed the title of Empress of India. It was reiterated on the occasion of her Jubilee. But it had ever been a case of promise to the ear which was broken to the hope. Even Lord Salisbury had described it as a “political hypocrisy,” while Lord Lytton had asserted that “every transparent subterfuge had been resorted to” in order to avoid giving effect to it. One of the remedies which he put forward as essential for curing India’s troubles was the abolition of this particular piece of British dishonour. Let Great Britain honourably fulfil her pledges in this respect and he believed that they would witness in India an amount of prosperity beyond conception.
Next he came to the question of justice. Surely when there were two partners in an undertaking it was only just that each should contribute to the cost of carrying it on. It was not fair that one should bear the whole burden and the other reap the sole benefit. Yet that was characteristic of the partnership between England and India. Whatever expenditure was incurred in the government of India, whatever outlay was involved in the maintenance of British rule there, the whole cost had had to be defrayed by India. He would not deny the necessity of maintaining European civil and military services there, but he did contend that, inasmuch as the main purpose of those services was to uphold British rule and to keep out the Russians, the cost of them ought at least to be equally divided instead of being wholly exacted from India. Why, he would like to know, should India have to pay the cost of maintaining the India Office in London, and why should she provide the salary of the Secretary of State for India? The same principle was not applied to the British Colonies; there was a Secretary of State for the Colonies, and there was a Colonial Office, but the Colonies were not called upon to contribute one farthing of the cost involved. Again, why should India pay the whole cost of carrying on the wars on the North-West frontier, the object of which was to keep the Russians at a distance? Certainly Mr. Gladstone gave them an instalment of justice in regard to the war of 1878-80 when he made a grant from the Imperial Exchequer of five million sterling towards defraying the total expenditure of twenty millions. But even that did not go far enough, for why should a wealthy country like England pay only one-fourth and a poor wretched country like India contribute three-fourths of the cost of a war waged for the promotion of purely Imperial interests? If only England were to treat India more fairly in regard to financial matters, and if this continual drain of Indian wealth were to be put a stop to, not only would the Natives of India be placed in a better position to withstand famine but they would be able and willing to purchase British manufactures, and an enormous impetus would thereby be given to British trade with India. The small amount of trade we now did with India as compared with other parts of the world was remarkable, and if only that country were enabled to be prosperous England would find her hands full in supplying Indian trade demands, and the unemployed would soon become an extinct class. If India were treated with honour and justice the result would be the disappearance of famine and destitution and the re-appearance of prosperity, accompanied by still greater prosperity for England.
A very interesting debate followed, several of the speakers urging that the lecturer had not shown a sufficient recognition of the benefits of British rule, and of the generosity of the British people in periods of distress. It was suggested that the Indian people were partly to blame for their condition because they relied too much on agriculture and had no manufacturing industries.
In the course of the discussion Mr. Mukerji insisted that loyalty was ingrained in the Native mind. It was part and parcel of their religion, and they were always grateful for services done on their behalf. When the Prince of Wales visited India he had a magnificent reception, but it was a noteworthy fact that when Lord Ripon left their shores still greater crowds of Natives assembled to do him honour, because they knew he had endeavoured to rule them justly, notwithstanding the discouragement with which he met at the hands of the Europeans there.
Mr. Singh also joined in the discussion and said it had been asked whether India would have been better off under Russian rule. His reply was that two wrongs did not make a right. (Hear, hear.) A suggestion had been thrown out as to whether there had been an adequate recognition on the part of the people of India of generous response to the various appeals for funds to cope with various famines. He thought the best reply to that was to be found in the readiness with which the people of India had volunteered their services to fight for Great Britain in South Africa and in China in the day of her need. (Cheers.) He complained, however, that no matter how well fitted a Native might prove to be to hold public office in India, he was unfairly debarred from rising to positions—especially in the Army—which were open to Europeans, some of whom were now cheering Mr. Kruger in France.
Mr. Naoroji, replying on the whole debate, said no speaker had attempted to dispute his assertion that Indian resources had been exhausted by British policy—which was thus responsible for the famines. It had been suggested that India should look more to manufacturing industries and be less dependent upon agriculture. But it seemed to be forgotten that the Indian industries had been destroyed by the British policy. India was originally noted for her industries. Venice and other ancient cities acquired great wealth through their trade with India, but Great Britain had deprived them of their life blood, and they could no longer carry on their industries because they had no means wherewith to maintain them. One of the speakers had stated that India was more prosperous now than before she came under British rule. To the eye that was so. But really it was not the case. They must remember that there were now two Indias—British India which was flourishing, and the India of the Indians which was not prosperous. He thought he had been able to show that England’s policy had had might and not right as its foundation. There was no ground for charging India with ingratitude and disloyalty if she resented the violation of the solemn pledges to treat her people justly; and he warned them that the three hundred millions of Indian Natives were now beginning to understand the position and might be tempted, unless something was done to ameliorate their condition, to use force in order to destroy force. They were not discussing what Russia might do under similar circumstances. He admitted that if Russia took India to-morrow the Natives would fall from the frying pan into the fire. They were undoubtedly now in the frying pan, but surely Great Britain was not entitled to justify the breaking of honourable pledges by simply suggesting that Russia might do worse. England had taught India one very important lesson, viz., that the ruler was for the people, but the people were not for the ruler. He reiterated his friend’s statement that loyalty was part and parcel of the Indian religion, which enjoined that the king should be father to the people and that the people should be children to the king, and finally he tendered hearty thanks for the sympathetic hearing which had been accorded to him.
A vote of thanks to the Rev. chairman brought the pro ceedings to a close.
Notes
- 1. The Times, January 26th, 1889 :—“We observe with pleasure that Lord Cross says nothing on the bounty alleged to be enjoyed by the Indian wheat grower through the fall in the value of silver. This piece of nonsense has been again and again exposed in the letters of our correspondents, and never more clearly and forcibly than by Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji.”
- 1. Henry of Huntingdon, Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, and Eadmon.
- 1. Sir Thomas Munro.
- 1. Elphinstone’s “History of India,” vol. i.
- 1. Elphinstone’s “History of India,” vol. i., pp. 547-696; vol. ii., p. 90.
- 2. Elphinstone, vol. ii., p. 203.
- 1. Elphinstone’s History, vol. ii, p. 151.
- 2. Ib., p. 280.
- 3. More than half an acre
- 1. Elphinstone, vol. ii, p. 399.
- 1. Grant Duff, vol. i, pp. 94-6.
- 2. Grant Duff’s “History of the Mahrattas,” vol. ii.
- 1. Extracted from page 376 of the Gentleman’s Magazine of 1762, headed “Brief Account of a Voyage to India, by M. Anquetil du Perron.”
- 2. Grant Duff’s “History of the Mahrattas,” vol. ii., p. 160.
- 1. Grant Duff, vol. ii., p. 208.
- 2. Ibid., p. 250.
- 1. For this character of Hyder, see Colonel Fullarton’s “View of the Interests of India,” and Wilke’s “History of India,” vol. ii.
- 1. Moore’s “Narrative of the War with Tippoo Sultan,” p. 201.
- 2. Dirom’s “Narrative,” p. 249.
- 1. “The watercourses in Mysore, in magnitude rather resembling navigable canals, which, issuing from the embankments, are conducted with admirable skill along the slope of the hills, and occasionally across ravines, with a fall barely sufficient for the flow of the water, fertilise the whole of the intermediate space between their course and the river. These works are of great antiquity, the last in order of time, which supplies Seringapatam, having been completed in the year 1690 by Sheik Deo Raj Ovdaar, to whom the country is also indebted for some of its most useful civil regulations."—Wilke’s “Mysore,” vol. ii.
- 2. “Life of Clive."
- 3. “The enormous amount of capital in the hands of individuals at this time may be inferred from the fact that in the Mahratta invasion of 1742 the banking firm of Juggat Sett, of Moorshedabad—then the capital of Bengal—was plundered to the extent of two and a half millions sterling.” —Duff’s “History of the Mahrattas,” vol. ii, page 12.
- 1. Holwell’s Tracts upon India.
- 2. Stewart’s “ History of Bengal,” p. 430.
- 1. Stewart’s “History of Bengal.” Asiatic Annual Register.
- 1. Macaulay’s Essay on Lord Clive.
- 2. Malcolm’s “Life of Clive,” vol. ii.
- 1. Gleig’s “Life of W. Hastings,” vol. ii.
- 2. Mill’s “History of India,” vol. v., p. 316.
- 1. “Life of W. Hastings,” vol. ii., p. 458.
- 2. Minute, July 30, 1831.
- 3. Bishop Heber’s “Travels,” vol. ii., pp. 81-87.
- 1. Colonel Wilkes.
- 2. Duke of Wellington’s Despatches, vol. 1.
- 3. Official Report on Mysore, 1805 ; Asiatic Annual Register, 1805.
- 1. Asiatic Annual Register, vol. v., p. 70 ; Miscellaneous Extracts.
- 2. Evidence before Committee of Commons, 1833, p. 41.
- 1. Sir John Malcolm.
- 1. Malcolm’s “ History of Central India,” vol. 1, pp. 176, 195.
- 2. Journey from Mirzapore to Nagpore in 1798, by a Member of the Asiatic Society. Asiatic Annual Register, vol. 8; Miscellaneous Tracts p. 32.
- 1. Miscellaneous Tracts, Asiatic Annual Register, vol. ii, p. 166.
- 2. White’s “State of British India,” 1822.
- 3. Report from Commissions upon the North-West Provinces, 1808.
- 1. Appendix to Political Report, 1882, pp. 36-37.
- 2. Bishop Heber’s “Journal,” vol. ii, pp. 77-79.
- 1. Bishop Heber s “Journal,” vol. ii, p. 361.
- 1. Letter of the Court of Directors, Par. Pa. A.D. 1843. No. 569, p. 1268.
- 2. Dr. Marshman, Friend of India, April 1st, 1852.
- 3. Vansittart’s Narrative of Events in Bengal.
- 1. Lord Hastings’ Minute, in Parliamentary Papers, 1827, p. 157.
- 2. Friend of India, 28th August, 1851.
- 1. Parliamentary Report of Committee, of May, 1772, vol. iii, pp. 294, etc.
- 1. India Reform Tracts, Tract vi., p. 112.
- 1. The same can be said about the Muhammadans and other people.
- 2. The greatest of them is the economic evil which Lord Salisbury has truly called the bleeding of the country.
- 1. This is being actually done. Every effort is being made to bring the administration of the Native States to the level of the organisation of the British system—which is not a little to the credit of the British Government.