ಅಕ್ಷರAkshara

Akshara No. 37 · Surveys and Gazetteers

Recent Economic Developments in the Punjab

A Paper Read by Sir James Wilson, K.C.S.I., to the Royal Economic Society, on the 9th February, 1910

James Wilson · London, 1910

1880–1910 · PunjabCanal Colonies · Wheat Exports · Wages and Prices · Land Alienation Act · Cooperative Credit

62pages
2chapters
15tables
2hours
88of 100 in automatic checks

Read by machine from the photographs, and not yet checked by a person. What that means

From its tables

All the tables

Fifteen tables in the book, each set as it was printed and given as data. Here is the first. See it in its chapter.

As printed on page 8
1886–7.1908–9.
Average area under cultivation (millions of acres)2228
Average area irrigated (millions of acres)611
Average area sown (millions of acres)20·528
Total population (millions)18·520
Average area sown per head of population (acres)1·11·4

This table as data, CSV: as printed · tidy

How this text was read

Read by machine

This book was read from photographs of its pages by a vision-language model, an AI that looks at the image of a page and writes out its text, then run through Akshara’s automatic checks, which flag passages to be read again against the scan. A model reads far more cleanly than ordinary OCR, the plain machine text that usually sits beside a scan online. In this book the checks flagged more than usual; what they found is set out beside this. But no machine reading is perfect, and until a person has read a page against its photograph, some errors will remain.

When it does go wrong, its mistakes are not the ones older OCR made. OCR leaves garbled letters that catch the eye. A language model reads for sense, so when it goes wrong it usually writes something fluent and plausible: its errors look like the book.

Automated reading (4 open review items); 3 of 60 pages had flagged passages re-read against the scan; no pages yet checked by a person.

The quirks of a machine reading

Each is uncommon; these are the kinds a careful reader may meet.

  • It tidies what it should copy. An old spelling modernised; the author’s own slip quietly corrected; a romanisation as the author printed it, Bhagavad Gita, given modern IAST, Bhagavad Gītā.
  • Where the print is faint, it guesses. A word, a figure, now and then a phrase, supplied because it fits rather than because it is printed. A line may be dropped, or read twice. This has grown rare, and it is the hardest kind to catch.
  • Accents and other scripts. Diacritics dropped, or added where the author had none; one name spelt two ways in two chapters. Words in Indian scripts, in Urdu, Persian or Arabic, and quotations in Greek or Latin are all read less surely than English, and a right-to-left line can come out in the wrong order.
  • It reads one page at a time. So a paragraph that runs over a page turn may be broken in two, or two paragraphs joined; the running head and page number may slip into the text; a heading may be set at the wrong level, or a title broken; a page in two columns read across instead of down.
  • Notes, tables and pictures. A footnote parted from its mark, or joined to the wrong one; a table’s columns shifted, or a figure misread, and a wrong number in a table looks exactly like a right one; an illustration, map or plate left with no marker where it stood.
  • Small things. Punctuation missing or changed; italics lost; a line-end hyphen kept, or a hyphenated word run together; library stamps, bookplates and handwriting in the front matter read as if they were printed.

88of 100

from the automatic checks of structure, notes, tables and spelling

  • Structure25/25 Nothing found
  • Footnotes25/25 Nothing found
  • Tables and figures13/25 4 columns that do not add up to their totals
  • Spelling and accents25/25 Nothing found

The checks find what a machine can find. A book can score 100 and still hold misreadings that only a reader, with the scan beside the text, will catch.

Machines have brought these books this far; only people can finish them. That is why Akshara is open. It is meant to become a community of readers who care for India’s written heritage: people who will sit with a page and its photograph, and put it right. Every page of this book is on the proofreading desk with its scan beside it, and one page takes about five minutes.

Proofread a page of this book

This edition

Open for proofreading

Colophon

Printed in London by Campfield Press, 1910. This edition gives all 62 printed pages, 3 of them read a second time against the scan, with its 5 footnotes kept where they were printed. It was read from the copy in the Internet Archive, recenteconomicde00wilsrich.

Akshara No. 37, on the shelf of Surveys and Gazetteers, and in the collection Indian Economic History & Political Economy.

Released under CC BY 4.0: share and adapt it freely, crediting Akshara. The book itself is in the public domain.

A note on this edition

This digital edition was produced by transcribing a scanned copy of the original printed book. This note records where the scan came from, what we normalized from the printed page, and what we know still awaits human eyes, so that you can judge the text for yourself and consult the original scan where it matters.
The full record of this edition

1. The Copy We Worked From

  • Title: Recent Economic Developments in the Punjab (1910)
  • Author(s): James Wilson
  • Imprint: London: Campfield Press
  • Internet Archive Scan: recenteconomicde00wilsrich
  • Source File: recent-economic-developments-punjab-wilson-1910.originals.pdf
  • Source SHA-256: 3eec402c338463fbe45fb36a7256bc172a2e3c7b00bb18267504f0dba67355ca
  • Leaf Accounting: 62 PDF leaves — 60 content leaves transcribed, 2 blank/tissue leaves (48, 59), 0 failed leaves.
  • Edition Status: community (88.0 / 100 Rubric Score)

2. Editorial Policy: Presentation vs. Historical Text

  • Modernized (Presentation Only): Running heads and institutional library stamps (22 flyleaf/stamp block(s)) are excluded from reading prose; 32 paragraphs running across page breaks were rejoined (preserving [p. N] folio markers); 0 cross-page split footnotes and 0 multi-page tables were stitched; and 96 end-of-line hyphens were resolved against intra-book attestation.
  • Preserved Verbatim: Period spellings, nineteenth-century romanization and diacritics (4 distinct non-ASCII characters across 28 leaves), and printed statistical figures (Rs. a. p., £ s. d., lakhs/crores). We never alter printed totals to force column arithmetic.

3. Transcription Provenance & Remaining Open Checks

  • Models: gemini-4-hydrogen (60 pp.).
  • Reader: Read by gemini-4-hydrogen on 60 of 60 pages. Declared reader profile: tables (new readings use gemini-4-hydrogen).
  • Human Proofing: 2 replayed correction(s). Automated reading (4 open review items); 3 of 60 pages had flagged passages re-read against the scan; no pages yet checked by a person.

Rather than pretend machine transcription is infallible, here is what our validators still flag:

  • 6 finding(s) across 2 leaf(s) (pp. 8, 56): table compositor arithmetic variant.
  • 4 finding(s) across 1 leaf(s) (pp. 53): statistical table columns whose printed total disagrees with the sum of extracted cells above.

If you spot an error, the scan identified above is the final authority. We would rather be corrected than merely trusted.