Honorable Sir,—Under every view of our situation, I conclude that from six to seven Rupees per bag may be offered for good clean cargo rice deliverable into the Honorable Company’s warehouses in Bombay between the 15th December and 15th February.
I conceive that the best Mangalore rice cannot stand the Honorable Company in more than 18 Pagodas per corge, or Rs. 3-1-71 per bag at Mangalore, to which add even Rs. 1-2-0 per bag freight, it only comes to Rs. 4-3-71 per bag.
I mention this for your information and determination as to the quantity you may contract for of Bengal rice. Being with every sentiment of respect.
Honorable Sir, Yours, &c.
(Signed) ROBERT HENSHAW.
14th October 1803.
15th October 1803.
ROBERT HENSHAW, Esq.
Dear Sir,—I hope you will now be able to keep us clear of famine, and gradually to reduce the price of rice. You must not, however, rely on the Sadry, as she unaccountably slipt away and proceeded to Calicut without Mr. Ravenshaw’s permission. But what was intended for her will serve to fill up the Huddart. You may buy all the rice that comes in, as long as you find it useful, giving a liberal price, so that the importers may not be discouraged from pursuing the traffic, and taking care not to force their inclinations, even in obliging them to sell to Government where they may prefer to deal with others; but we can always afford to give as much as any first purchaser from the importer. Our treasury is exceedingly low, but if you want a small sum to go on with, let me know, and you shall have it. The importers should be paid ready cash. In short, I trust this great and delicate commission to your honor, zeal, and judgment, and rely on experiencing the best effects from the confidence thus placed.
I am, yours,
(Signed) J. DUNCAN.
15th October 1803.
Honorable Sir,—Twelve hundred robins of rice are just entered from Mangalore. The owner has sold it to the second man at 5-2-50 the robin of best sort, and 4-2-50 the robin of the second sort. This sale was conditional that Government permitted it; the second man has been with me, and is willing to give up for two annas each robin profit; allow me, good Sir, to suggest that this be purchased for the Company, and instantly retailed; the best of consequences will result therefrom, and, if you see no solid objection, I would recommend all future imports during the next thirty days to be purchased in the same manner. I will manage it for your comfort and honour. Believe me,
Honorable Sir, Yours, &c., (Signed) R. HENSHAW.
15th October 1803.
R. HENSHAW, Esq.,
Dear Sir,—I entirely approve of your purchasing the rice now imported, and selling it in such manner as you shall see most likely to produce the greatest general relief. I have told Mr. Halliday that I leave it to you to supply his shops. He will speak to you on the subject.
I am, yours, (Signed) J. DUNCAN.
16th October 1803.
Honorable Sir,—I was honored with your letter yesterday evening, and being in the carriage for an airing, I delayed its immediate reply.
I assure myself that every possibility of famine is now completely guarded against, and am happy to report to you that the entries of new Batta from the Mahratta countries, of rice from Canara and Malabar yesterday and this forenoon, meet my most sanguine expectations. In addition thereto I have notice of near one thousand candies of bajree being partly embarked, and ready to be embarked at Verowal, Gogo, Guzerat, Mangalore, and other Northern Ports for this place, and of which a small portion in a medley cargo of wheat, gram, dholl, &c., is this instant entered. I shall conscientiously endeavour to meet your wishes in the discharge of the trust you have reposed in me, and to merit your regards, and you may depend upon my exerting every means to save calling on the Treasury for assistance.
The robin or morah of Mangalore weighs, when first packed, eighty-two No. pounds of rice, and from innumerable experiments made by me during my long residence in Canara, two thereof equalled one Bengal bag of two Bengal maunds (Factory, not Bazaar maunds). The Canara candy is exactly the same as that of Bombay, of twenty maunds each of twenty-eight pounds. The cargo of rice varies as to number of robins; to the Northward of Cundapore it consists of thirty robins; but the quantity of rice contained in the thirty equals exactly that in the cargo of forty-two robins, which measure prevails at Cundapore and to the southward.
Honorable Sir, Yours, &c., (Signed) R. HENSHAW.
2nd December 1803.
Honorable Sir,—I have a very large supply of copper pice received from Mr. Halliday, the produce of the sales of the rice at the Sirkar’s shops, amounting to Rupees 20,000. This pice is only to be exchanged for a loss of two or three per cent., and the merchants from whom I purchased rice will not receive it, but require gold or silver to avoid loss. Could it not be received into the Treasury, and gold delivered me in return, to enable me to discharge the rice bills? I submit this for your determination: being with all respect.
Honorable Sir, Yours, &c., (Signed) R. HENSHAW.
2nd December 1803.
ROBERT HENSHAW, Esq.,
Dear Sir,—Let the pice be sent to the Treasury. It is a pity you kept it till it had so far accumulated as to render it inconvenient to return the whole in gold immediately, but you shall receive a few thousands at a time as you may want.
You should pay in every rupee or pice you can command into the Treasury, either from the sale of grain or other resource, such as the Customs, knowing how hardly we are run for cash.
I thought you were to pay for the grain of Syed Seif’s ship by Bills on Bengal. That would be desirable, as we should then have the money it fetches to dispose of here.
We have written to Mr. Ravenshaw as you suggested, but will he have tonnage to send it up, or must we furnish it hence ? In that case you will seasonably consider of the means of doing so, and always keep rice enough in hand, to have the supplies to Panwell (for our army there acting against Scindia) in constant flow. Let, in short, nothing interrupt them.
I am, yours, (Signed) J. DUNCAN.
3rd December 1803.
Honorable Sir,—I had the honor of your note late yesterday, or would have instantly replied thereto. I beg you will be assured that I have never lost sight of the distress your Treasury is in, and to that alone is to be attributed the accumulation of the pice, which until these few days could be exchanged without more loss than ¼ or ½ per cent., and which the grain merchants took at par. My anxiety not to trouble you made me keep it in hopes the whole sum might be passed in payment, and yesterday evening, subsequent to my note to you, I paid away seven thousand Rupees, and have only thirteen thousand, which is going to the Treasury, and as I may find call for it, will apply for gold in lieu.
Our receipts in the Custom House are principally in Treasury notes, but you may rely on their being paid in on their receipt.
My agreement with Syed Seif’s ship’s Nacquedah was for sixty thousand Rupees in Bengal Bills, and the remainder in cash here. ·
I shall in the course of Monday submit to your inspection a statement of the purchase, receipt from Canara, and issues of rice, since the 15th October to this day inclusive, and also statement of batty and wheat received from the northward, and in future keep you fully advised thereon.
I shall pay every attention to your suggestions as to the means of transporting the Canara rice here, and submit my reflections to your judgment.
Captain Moor has received from me for the army 9,000 bags of Bengal rice and 18,000 robins of Canara rice, and you may rely on every strenuous co-operation in part with him to preserve in full the supply of grain to the dispatch at Camp.
I have the honor to be, &c. (Signed) R. HENSHAW.
7th December 1803.
H. SHANK, Esq.
Dear Shank,—I pray you state to the Governor that I could not correctly till this morning answer his query as to the price at which good Bengal Moonghy rice is to be purchased here: some few thousand bags may be now purchased for five Rupees, two quarters, and twenty-five reas (5-2-25), exclusive of brokerage, payable in Bengal Bills at the exchange of the day; but I would not wish Government to beat down the price below six Rupees per bag, at which price if we can keep the bag there will be no hazard of a want, as it affords the trader a fair gain, and will prove inducement sufficient to bring it to market: whereas, if lower, the stimulus is destroyed, and the intelligence now reaching Bengal, not another vessel will load for this with grain. If the Governor sees no objection, I would suggest my now purchasing what good Bengal Moonghy rice offers for sale at six or under six for Bengal Bills, and this, I think, will be attended with the best effects.
Yours truly, (Signed) R. HENSHAW. .
14th December 1803.
ROBERT HENSHAW, Esq.,
Dear Sir,—I do not find that any boats are arriving from Mr. Ravenshaw. Perhaps it would be best to hire a vessel at once and send down there. I wait, however, your opinion. They write from Poona that grain is getting very scarce there, and they wish to send down the native Brinjaries to purchase here for the community of that place. Has any rice been yet re-exported out of the one-third proportion that you recommended? I rely on your keeping your eye on the market with a view to provide always—first, for our armies above the Ghauts to the extent of General Wellesley’s commission of 1,000 garce; and secondly, for our population here. Perhaps it would not be amiss to buy even now another ship’s cargo, provided they will accept payment by Bills on Bengal at the exchange of the day, i.e. the Company’s and not the Bazaar exchange.
I am, yours, (Signed) J. DUNCAN.
16th December 1803.
Honorable Sir,—I have reflected very seriously on what you mentioned in your last note to me of the scarcity at Poona; if you are satisfied as to the truth thereof, and convinced that the Government there will expect your sanction for their Brinjaries purchasing grain here, I am, on every view of this matter, convinced that it will be no more than barely prudent in Government to purchase to the extent of one lac of bags, if to be done at six Rupees the bag of Moonghy rice, and so in proportion of other grain—this independent of prior arrangements. By this measure the market will be sure to be kept supplied to answer every emergency, and Government will by having such store reserve to themselves the proper check over the markets and prevent monopolizing, having the means at any time when they see fit to lower the price, and thereby protect the poor from those harpies the grain dealers.
I am, Honorable Sir, &c.,
(Signed) R. HENSHAW.
29th December 1803.
Honorable Sir,—I have hitherto managed to bear the Honorable Company harmless as to every expense of Assistants, Purvoes, &c., for the grain department, but I now find it presses very hard upon me, and becomes overburdensome, so as to induce me to request you will permit me to employ Mr. Whitehill to assist me, with one good Purvoe; and as they will have very full employment, I hope you will not think me extravagant in recommending Mr. W. for a monthly allowance of two hundred Rupees, and a Purvoe for one of fifty Rupees.
I am, &c.
(Signed) R. HENSHAW.
29th December 1803.
ROBERT HENSHAW, Esq.
Dear Sir,—As long as there are gentlemen in the service unprovided, I cannot consent to the employment of Mr. Whitehill, but if you like to fix on any of the young men in the line of public employment, he shall be named.
I am, yours, . .
(Signed) J. DUNCAN.
8th January 1804.
Honorable Sir,—I was in hopes to have been able to go to Town this morning to have sent in to Government a new statement of the grain wanted to the end of November next, and our ways and means. It was finished before I quitted office last night, but was not fair transcribed, neither were my observations thereon quite finished in elucidation thereof: but I am much affected with a severe headache, and unable to do any business therefrom. Our deficit by this statement (after admitting every ship that has laden or is expected from Bengal, and of which most accurate mention is made) will be ninety-three thousand bags, and I write this principally to suggest the expediency of engaging with any ships that may be now or soon leaving this for Bengal for a full returning cargo of good Moonghy rice, and I would further suggest it to be done at seven Rupees per bag, payable on delivery in Bengal Bills at the exchange of the day. The Tay is the only ship now on the wing, and, if you approve, I will arrange to-morrow with Captain Meek if to be done, and advise you the result.
You will, I am confident, be fully satisfied with the accuracy of my statement, but apprehensive the Tay may sail, and unwilling to lose the opportunity of so good a ship, I thought it advisable to write you on the subject.
I am, Honourable Sir, &c.
(Signed) R. HENSHAW.
8th January 1804.
ROBERT HENSHAW, Esq.
Dear Sir,—We are under an implied engagement to take whatever more rice we may require from the house of B. F. & Co., and Forbes and Co., on the same terms as our existing positive engagement with them of which you have been advised.
I am yours,
(Signed) J. DUNCAN.
22nd Junuary 1804.
Honorable Sir,—The price of Moonghy rice has risen considerably within this last week. I judge it would be advisable to throw from four to six thousand bags into the market, in order to prevent its farther rise, provided you approve the measure.
To-morrow I shall apply for an order to the Sub-Treasurer to receive into the Treasury the sum of forty-thousand Rupees in cash on account of my sales of grain.
I have no answer respecting the warehouses, which I am anxious to receive.
I am, &c.
(Signed) R. HENSHAW.
22nd January 1804.
Robert Henshaw, Esq.
Dear Sir,—As I leave you to judge of the regulation of the market, I approve entirely of your intention to throw from 4 to 6,000 bags into the local consumption, by way of keeping the price from rising too high.
The aid you mention to the Treasury will be highly acceptable. The Military Board have been written to about the warehouses, and their answer may be daily looked for.
I am,
(Signed) J. DUNCAN.
1st February 1804.
Robert Henshaw, Esq.
Dear Sir.—I feel much at a loss to account for the different results of the comparisons made here and at Poona of the Bengal and Canara rice. Perhaps the assortment or parcels whence Colonel Coleman’s Committee made theirs was from the first rice despatched by Mr. Walkenshaw, whilst yours may have been from the last: the former consisted, I fancy, of old rice not very good, but still sound; the latter may be the new rice of the growth of the late harvest, or otherwise to account for so great a difference I should suspect something unfair was done to the grain on its passage from Bombay to Poona. Your further opinion will therefore oblige
Yours,
(Signed) J. DUNCAN.
2nd February 1805.
Honorable Sir,—Though I personally submitted my sentiments to you this morning on the subject of your note of yesterday, yet, conceiving you would prefer having them on paper, I will here recapitulate them.
Adverting to the report from Colonel Coleman on the subject of the Canara rice in the Depôt at Poona, and also to the trials made by me of the same sort of grain, as stated in my address to Government of the 30th ultimo, the enormous loss resulting to the Honorable Company on the comparison, calls, as I humbly conceive, on the part of this Government, for still further investigation of the subject, to ascertain, if possible, how this loss arises, and on whom the responsibility should lay to account for such glaring deficiency; the first step to which I presume to suggest should be to call upon the Garrison Storekeeper for his opinion, furnishing him at the same time copies of the letter from Colonel Coleman, of the order to me, and of my report to Government in reply under date the 30th ultimo, directing him at the same time to state if any, and what, progress the Canara rice undergoes when he repacks it to forward it to the Depôt, with every minute information in his power that can possibly lead to a discovery whence this great deficiency can arise.
This answer received, I would then appoint a committee, transmitting to them all the before mentioned papers, together with the report from the Garrison Storekeeper, directing them to make a series of trials with every sort of Canara rice in store, to ascertain the extent of every possible loss by tare, dust, &c., and to report their opinion as to the causes that could operate to produce such a glaring deficiency as appears by the letters from Colonel Coleman to be reported to him on the Canara rice in the Depôt at Poona.
The Military Board, if I may suggest, should be this Committee, and myself and the Garrison Storekeeper directed to attend to any requisition they may make, or to attend them, if they call on us, when they go through the series of trials.
By thus pursuing this investigation, Government will stand fully justified, and exonerated from every shadow of censure and of want of attention to the calls of the Army; and if the deficiency proves to be really as reported, the proceedings had here and forwarded to General Wellesley will serve as grand leading marks for a further investigation at Poona, and lead most probably to a discovery of the real cause of the deficiency.
I am, &c.,
(Signed) R. HENSHAW.
7th February 1804.
R. HENSHAW, Esq.
Dear Sir,—I enclose for your private information the letter I have yesterday received from Mr. Ravenshaw, of whose pretensions I am, in an equitable point of view, inclined to think favorably, but by granting two commissions to you and to him, I apprehend that we shall either too much enhance the value of the rice to the consumer, or subject the Company to loss, both which I wish to avoid. I will, therefore, be glad to receive your sentiments on what may constitute an eligible means of fair and reasonable remuneration to both of you, without too great enhancement of the price of the article. Now that more Canara rice is come up, I wish the sepoys to have their rations from it at the usual price to them, supposing it will cover the Company’s cost and charges.
I am yours, (Signed) J. DUNCAN.
17th February 1804.
R. HENSHAW, Esq.
Dear Sir,—I wish to receive from you a rough estimate of the value of the rice as purchased and shipped by Mr. Ravenshaw, and to be so till the end of the season, and a similar one of your own sales here, both of Canara and Bengal rice. I wish to have this to-day, if you can get it ready ; I do not expect you to be quite accurate in such a calculation.
I am yours, (Signed) J. DUNCAN.
The one of Mr. R.’s purchases is, however, what I want the soonest.
17th February 1804.
Honorable Sir,—I was stepping into a boat to go on board the yacht to breakfast with my family when your note reached me, and from some unlucky circumstance the boat that was to have returned on board for me never came till past one o’clock, or I should sooner have replied to your reference. Not having to this hour been furnished with any accounts from Mr. Ravenshaw, I can only offer a conjectural estimate of the price of the rice received and to be received from him, which I enclose for your consideration, as also a statement of my sales, not only of Canara and Bengal rice, but also of Bengal wheat, gram, and dholl, and also bajree and Northern wheat.
I find the account of my sales will not be ready before to-morrow noon. I, therefore, forward this with only that of Mr. Ravenshaw’s supplies.
I am, &c., (Signed) R. HENSHAW.
| Rice received from him (previous to the sailing of the rice ships, and forming no part of the order for 160,000 robins) by various vessels :— Robins 27,613 at the supposed rate of 20 Pagodas per corge of 42 robins, exchange at 4 Rupees per Pagoda. | 52,596 | 0 | 6 |
| Rice received and to be received in part and full of order, robins 160,000, or corges 4,000, at 18 Pagodas or Rs. 72 | 2,88,000 | 0 | 0 |
| Rupees | 3,40,596 | 0 | 64 |
(Signed) R. HENSHAW. Bombay, 17th February 1804.
25th March 1804.
R. HENSHAW, Esq.
Dear Sir,—Although I am very glad to find it your opinion that we can with perfect safety supply Goa with grain, yet you will keep in remembrance that 2,000 bags must at least be reserved for Surat during the rains, and to be sent up there in all the month of May.
It may also be objected that we have on the grounds of your present letter unnecessarily distressed the Southern merchants by requiring from Mr. Ravenshaw a larger stock of grain than the Settlement in fact wanted, as to which I shall be glad to receive your remarks.
I am yours, (Signed) J. DUNCAN.
21st April 1804.
Dear Grant [Secretary to Government],
I shall attend to your directions as to the Bombay Merchant.
Our account as to quantity of rice from Canara stands thus :—
| First order 80,000, or | robins | 1,60,000 |
| Last order, estimated by J. G. Ravenshaw to reach to | „ .. | 60,000 |
| Received to this day, viz :— | 2,20,000 | |
| Robins | 1,47,000 | |
| Cornwallis and Hercules | 36,000 | |
| 183,000 | ||
| Robins . . . . | 37,000 | |
but as he wrote me he could procure boat tonnage, and not to send hence any more craft, I have of course made no arrangements.
Yours,
(Signed R. HENSHAW.
15th May 1804.
Mr. Henshaw.
Dear Sir,—I had understood by Colonel Clarke’s former letter, which was sent for your notice, that he had no more occasion for rice, and do not therefore understand why he took 11,000 robins out of the Cornwallis, or why the latter called in there. His letters on the subject will be sent by Mr. Grant for your report and sentiments.
I am, yours,
(Signed) J. DUNCAN.
16th May 1804.
Honorable Sir,—I judge I may be able to have ready for General Wellesley of gram, barley, joaree, and coulthee, of all, eight thousand bags, within these four days. His wants reach to ten thousand, which I trust to complete, but at all events he may rely on the former. If you see fit, permit me to request an order to supply him, and one to the Garrison Storekeeper to receive and despatch it.
(Signed) R. HENSHAW.
Endorsed on the above, in the handwriting of General Wellesley—
“Will you be so kind as to give these orders, and oblige Your faithful Servant, (Signed) ARTHUR WELLESLEY.”
16th June 1804.
Honorable Sir,—No application on account of Captain Barclay has ever been preferred to me for any export of grain. Had it, I should first have submitted to your judgment the authority for the application, and been guided by your orders; but I trust none of them, for there are hundreds of notes daily presented in gentlemen’s names w hich I ever disregard unless accompanied by a letter to me as Custom Master. The expedients resorted to to carry grain off the Island are so many, and frequently so arranged, that nothing but the eyes of Argus himself can detect and counteract. The man who has taken Captain Barclay’s name I shrewdly suspect is an impostor. He has no authority, and nothing to produce but an old Paishwa’s rahdaree, that serves for any one, and is dated so far back as 3rd April last; but whatever you please to direct shall be obeyed.
I am, &c. (Signed) R. HENSHAW.
17th June 1804.
Robert Henshaw, Esq.
Dear Sir,—I had at the first glance concluded the pass in the hand of Captain Barclay’s servant to be under the seal of General Wellesley, and not that of the Paishwa, because the latter never impresses his on wax. However, as you had a different idea, I have got the writing translated, and now transmit you a copy of Mr. Bouchier’s translation, which sufficiently ascertains the fact with respect to the eight bullock-loads of chenna. If the quantity in Town will, in view to the season and our local calls for that grain, admit, in your opinion, of its export, it is certainly my desire it should go, but not otherwise, i.e. not to our material distress.
I will only further express my wish that you should pursue every means for making yourself as accessible to every one as possible, which will enable you to give more general satisfaction to parties applying, even when they get a refusal, and save to me the trouble of more writing than I have time for. The present case exhibits the proof that this man has never been with you, and it is reasonable to conclude that it was because he could not get to you, for it was clearly his interest to have done so, had he known the way. It will also be proper for you to inspect passes a little more narrowly, to avoid the misconception you have been under (perhaps from allowing your Purvoes to report the matter to you, instead of calling for the papers yourself) in the present instance.
You will take these hints in the same friendly way they are intended. I know you have more to do than you can well get through; and I believe you as fit, or fitter, for the weighty trust reposed in you than any one that could have been chosen for it; but still where errors occur to my knowledge I must at least seek to guard against their recurrence.
I am yours, (Signed) J. DUNCAN.
Honorable Sir,—Having made the necessary inquiries, I now have the honour to submit the replies to the several queries you suggested to me yesterday.
Question 1st.—What ought to be the selling prices by the furreahs in the bazaar grain shops of rice per parah, per adowly, and per seer, in view to the price at which it is sold to them at the Honorable Company’s store of Rupees 8 per bag, and to their allowed profit for their trouble?
Answer 1st.—They are (under penalty of punishment and fine by the Police) restricted from selling but at the following prices :—
| Rs. | q. | r. | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Moonghy Rice, per Parah | 4 | 1 | 92 |
| Do. do. „ Adowly | 0 | 1 | 12 |
| Do. do. „ Seer | 0 | 0 | 28 |
Question 2nd.—At what rate could the Honourable Company afford, free of every loss, to retail rice at Panwell, at a store to be opened there under their protection?
Answer 2nd.—At Rupees 11 per bag.
Question 3rd.—At what rate could the Honourable Company afford, free of every loss, to retail rice at Poona, at a store to be opened there under their protection?
Answer 3rd.—During the monsoon (as the transport from Panwell to Poona will require two men, or Rupees 8 per bag) not for less than Rupees 19 per bag.
Question 4th.—How much in quantity could we supply at each store monthly so as to keep keep up a constant supply?
Answer 4th.—It will not be possible to speak correctly at such an early stage; the call at each store must guide us; but I confidently hope we shall be in stock to meet all their wants, and effectually relieve their distress.
I am, Honorable Sir, &c.
(Signed) R. HENSHAW.
Bombay, 13th July 1804.
25th August 1804.
Honorable Sir,—I am very anxious to learn whether any, and what, supplies of rice will be required to form a Depôt for the Army in Guzerat, &c., also what judgment has been formed to the northward of the ensuing crops, whether abundant, whether scanty, or in what degree they may be looked up to with confidence, for I am desirous to frame a new statement to submit to Government. As I before stated, the call for rice for export exceeds anything I could have supposed. Since 27th ultimo (July) a full lac of bags has been sold for export, and in ten days, if the export was not under check, not a bag would be left in the place. This uncommon call leads me to consider the distresses on the main as far greater than we have hitherto imagined, and consequently calls for your utmost efforts for their relief. We are yet very strong in store-bags—81,295, exclusive of the supply to Moor for Poona of 10,000 bags, and of the 10,000 for Surat, and exclusive also of the order in favour of Captain Young, and we are in expectancy of the receipt of two lacs and upwards of bags from Bengal and Canara.
Notwithstanding this apparently large quantity, it would, if here, be all called for in a month for export to the main; this makes me so very anxious for information as to the hopes of the ensuing crops, that we may be wise in time.
I am, &c.,
(Signed) R. HENSHAW.
26th August 1804.
Mr. Henshaw.
Dear Sir,—I much regret the delay that has taken place in the execution of the order for sending up the rice to Surat, which may produce very serious consequences to that city; at all events, you will take care that not one moment’s delay ensues in sending up the 20,000 bags ordered. Considering also the unfavorable prospects of the season, and the large calls we shall probably have for our own wants, I think it proper you should not dispose of any more rice for exportation till you have laid your report of the stock on hand and expectancies before Government, as you will accordingly do with the least delay, and obtain their orders. I am yours, (Signed) J. DUNCAN.
27th August 1804.
Mr. Henshaw.
Dear Sir,—Notwithstanding what I wrote to you yesterday as to discontinuing farther sales till you can report your opinion, I would, on further consideration, rather leave that matter to your discretion, in which I feel persuaded that every confidence may be placed ; and perhaps it may be best not altogether to refuse the proposals of purchasers, but always to reserve enough for our utmost wants. I am yours, (Signed) J. DUNCAN.
P.S.—Has the rice for Surat gone off ?
27th August 1804.
Honorable Sir,—I am much flattered by your confidence, which you may rest assured shall not be ill applied by any exercise of my discretion as to sales for export, nor shall I ever lose sight of the calls on our store, and the even possible want of our own Islands and neighbours. After despatching the full quantity to Surat, the 10,000 for Gundavim, and the 10,000 for Poona, we shall only have a surplus of 11,000 bags over and above our fixed store stock of 50,000 bags. I before wrote you this day that the rice began to move off last night, and it is loading as fast as we can get the craft prepared for its reception, and you may rely that not an instant shall be lost in its despatch to Surat.
I will send the man to Mr. Grant with copy of his engagement for the rice at Goa, in view to his furnishing him with a letter to Sir William Clarke for its delivery, &c., though I think, nevertheless, it will be advisable to advise the Envoy of the engagement by express boat, and he can be requested, as you suggest, to pay the proceeds to Mr. Ravenshaw.
In regard to the rice for Gundavim, I have a note from Mr. Shank this instant to repack it in small bags, &c. If you see no objection, will it not be better to direct Moor as Garrison Storekeeper to receive it from me, and prepare it as directed in Mr. Shank’s note? for in truth, in our department we are just now up the very shoulders in business, and ill able to cope with any additional. I am, &c., (Signed) R. HENSHAW.
5th September 1804.
Mr. Henshaw.
Dear Sir,—I am very doubtful whether anything should induce us to heighten our bazaar prices, but according to the regulations nothing can be done in respect to altering either, excepting upon a public report and official suggestions from you, such as the Board at large may exercise their judgment on. I therefore advise your making such report, stating your sentiments at large. I am yours, (Signed) J. DUNCAN.
8th September 1804.
Mr. Henshaw.
Dear Sir,—If there be any vessel lately come in with rice, and not yet unladen, that can be tempted by pecuniary consideration to go up to Surat with what she has on board, let her be engaged to set off immediately at any expense or charge the party may require. Nothing could have happened so unluckily as this disappointment in not being able to send rice to Surat. Had that taken place even to a few boat-loads when the first cruizers went up, previous to which you had, I think, the order, much cause of regret would have been precluded, and the delay from the intermediate change of weather avoided. I am yours, (Signed) J. DUNCAN.
8th September 1804.
Honorable Sir,—Three boats with rice to the amount of 2,200 bags left this five days previous to the sailing of the first cruizers for Surat, yet even these met the same tempestuous weather; two have got into Versovah, and one is still to be accounted for. I had your orders on the 25th, and lost not a moment to meet your wishes. On the 28th one boat with 650 bags sailed, on the 29th two more with 1,550 sailed, and on the 2nd six more with 3,800 bags sailed, under charge of the Princess Augusta, which vessel, I learn from Mr. Anderson, experienced extreme bad weather and was in imminent danger. No one more truly regrets the disappointment than myself, but I cannot, on any view of the case, see room for the smallest censure to attach to any one concerned, convinced that everything has been done that was possible to be effected.
I have sent to the Captain of the Resource, and will exert my utmost to induce his going to Surat, though I much fear having no success.
I am, with every respect,
Honorable Sir, &c. &c.,
(Signed) R. HENSHAW.
12th September 1804.
Honorable Sir,—I find that we have to this day not sold any Patcherry rice to the Furreahs, consequently they have not been under any restrictions as to their retail price thereof as connected with any purchases from the Company’s store, and I have marked in the report to you in red ink the price at which it may be had at their store. I return the samples, observing thereon that the difference in the sale prices of the fine rice, with the price-current prices thereof, require explanation, and as to the coarse rice selling at 1 qr. 12 reas per adowly, the Furreahs pay to the Company’s store equal to 1 qr. 6 reas per adowly for the same rice, and the advance of 6 reas appears not unreasonable.
I am, &c.,
(Signed) R. HENSHAW.
8th November 1804.
Honorable Sir,—From the disappointment we have hitherto experienced notwithstanding our exertions to supply the army with horse grain, I cannot but be fearful that we may still want; under this impression I think we cannot be too cautious as to securing a further supply, which though it may (should all our engagements be fulfilled) exceed what may be really required, yet is not such surplus, in my humble opinion, for a moment to be considered in opposition to the distress which a failure of supply may produce. Permit me, therefore, to suggest your reference to Colonel Close for his sentiments, and that without loss of time, when, should his sentiments tally with my suggestions, I would humbly recommend your authorising me to conclude an agreement on sure grounds with those competent and able to fulfil the same for whatever further quantity it may be deemed necessary to secure, which I should hope may be effected for the same terms as negotiated with Forbes’ house, of Rupees 9 per bag of 168 lbs. gross.
I think it necessary to say that, if wanted, I purpose, if I can, bringing Mr. Adamson to the acceptance of a contract for the quantity wanted, whose ship the David Scott will be about sailling to Bengal in ten or fifteen days.
I am, &c. (Signed) R. HENSHAW.
9th November 1804.
Mr. Henshaw.
Dear Sir,—It is probable that in forwarding your query about horse grain to Colonel Close, he may want to have his memory refreshed by a clear statement of our engagements, inclusive of our Mysore expectancies; I will, therefore, thank you to send me to-day such a memorandum to enclose to him.
I am yours, (Signed) J. DUNCAN.
| Owners of the Waldegrave for bags 2,000. | Failed to supply. | ||
| Ditto | Thetis | ditto 2,500 | Supposed on the passage from Calcutta, |
| Ditto | Tay | ditto 1,000 | Supposed on the passage from Calcutta, |
| Ditto | Hercules | ditto 1,500 | Supposed on the passage from Calcutta, |
| Ditto | Melville | ditto 3,000 | Supposed on the passage from Calcutta, |
but which cannot be relied upon, as the new crop does not come in until January, and there was a certain scarcity of last season’s crop, so much so as when the Waldegrave sailed not a bag was procurable.
Recent contract with Forbes and Co. 10,000 bags deliverable in all the month of February or by the 15th March.
Recent engagement with Sorabjee Cowasjee for 3,500 bags concluded, to be on board his ship the Jehangeer, shortly expected.
| Mysore Gunnies | 10,000 |
| Deduct received by the Carron 1,000 moorees, or | 500 |
| Gunnies…. | 9,500 |
Observations.—The entire quantity of the grain, the Mysore coolthee excepted, is to be drawn from Bengal. The chances, if we may judge from the number of lost and missing ships, of receiving all that is excepted from Bengal is extremely precarious, and forbids too much reliance to be placed thereon, giving rise to the question, whether under the present view the above engagements may be deemed competent to all the wants of the army for horse grain, or whether under this same view it would be advisable to increase our engagements to the extent of twelve or fourteen thousand bags, thereby preventing all distress consequent to a failure of the necessary stock? A want of grain may induce evils of the greatest magnitude, but the only bad consequence that can arise from being overstocked is a pecuniary trifling loss on sale of the surplus.
(Signed) R. HENSHAW.
8th March 1805.
Mr. Henshaw.
Dear Sir,—We have long been waiting for your General Report respecting the grain of this season, and the amount of our probable wants in this respect between this and October and November next, and whether it be necessary to prevent still the export of grain in the like proportion as hitherto.
I am yours,
(Signed) J. DUNCAN.
No. 2.
Extract of a Letter from the Honorable Jonathan Duncan, to the Honorable General Wellesley, dated 27th June 1804.
With respect to Colonel Close’s proposition to open our Port for an unlimited export, I have consulted Mr. Henshaw, and send you his letter. I fear to take any step in so delicate a matter that a man of his knowledge of the subject deems a dangerous one, but we are ready to sell to all who come to buy to the extent noticed in Mr. Henshaw’s report, which is probably more than will be called for. Colonel Close may always give letters to Mr. Henshaw, specifying the quantity desired to be purchased from the Company at their prices, of which he is apprised, viz. at 10 Rs. per bag of 168 gross lbs. of Moonghy rice, and at 12 Rs. for Patcherry rice, and which is distinct from the one-fourth that all importers are allowed to dispose of in like manner on their own account. Will you, however, favour me with your sentiments on Mr. Henshaw’s letter now sent?
The following is an enclosure to the above:—
The Honorable the Governor.
Honorable Sir,—I pray your excuse for not more immediately replying to your reference of the extract of General Wellesley’s letter. It is on a subject that has occupied my thoughts incessantly for months past, and now completely engrosses them, to the almost total exclusion of every other object.
However productive of benefit an unlimited export may at first sight appear to be, yet unless the supplies in aid of such export were unquestionably to be relied upon, the resulting evil from such export would very quickly counterbalance the benefit, and instead of copious stores we should soon be on the verge of want ourselves; whereas by the measures Government have adopted, and the precautions taken by them to ensure a regular supply and the opening their store, I am emboldened to hope that every aid, consistent with prudence and self-preservation, is and will be afforded to the unfortunate inhabitants of His Highness’ country, and this I also conceive to meet the general ideas in a very great measure of permitting an export at least as long as Government can allow anything to be exported. I am not aware of any further aid that can consistently be given; the Government store is opened to them at a very moderate price, and to an extent fully adequate to their means of purchase, for we can now freely assist (reserving our new stock of 50,000 bags) to the extent of one lac of bags.
With every sentiment of respect,
Honorable Sir, yours, &c.
(Signed) R. HENSHAW.
Bombay, 27th June 1804.
Bombay, 12th July 1804.
To Colonel Close.
My Dear Sir,—The Honorable Major General Wellesley having suggested to my consideration here an idea that he said you entertained of the advantage that would accrue by our laying open the trade of this Port altogether as far as regarded the exportation of grain to the Continent, I transmit (lest the General should not have sent it to you) Mr. Henshaw’s reflections on that proposition, which I will wait to be favoured with your further sentiments on before I determine on even bringing before the Board a question involved, as this seems to be, in a good deal of nicety.
Hearing, as we sometimes do, of the great ravages the famine is making at Poona, my attention was yesterday called to this subject by Lady Mackintosh, who, under the impression of perhaps something that may have been written on the subject, addressed to me a rather urgent invitation to see whether something more might not be done to alleviate what she understood to be so much misery; suggesting, among other things, whether a subscription to buy rice and send it to the poor at Poona might not be advisable, and proposing in that case to contribute liberally.
In reply, I promised her Ladyship to consult you, and this having set me on further consideration of the subject, one consequence has been that, on consulting to-day with Mr. Henshaw, the Company’s price of rice for export has been lowered by one Rupee per bag, and now sells (where there are any buyers) at 9 Rupees the bag for Moonghy, and at 10 Rupees for Patcherry rice, which will oblige the merchants to sell theirs even somewhat lower, or they will get no custom; and the truth is that they complain of not meeting with that ready sale for the proportion they are thus allowed to export, which might be expected from the represented state of scarcity on the Continent.
It has also occurred to me that we might establish a retail shop or shops at Panwell for the relief of the neighbouring poor in that quarter, and even have one or more at Poona, to which Mr. Henshaw might send the rice, and cause his people under your protection to sell it at fixed prices, the same as here at Bombay, with the superaddition only of the charge of transportation hence; or we might consign it to you at once for such retail sale, charged at the price of the Bombay bazaar, with the farther cost only of the conveyance to you. By the price of the Bombay bazaar I don’t mean what the retailers deal it out to the consumers at, but the rate at which the Company let these retailers have it, which does not exceed 8 Rupees per bag. It would then rest with you to fix the retail prices at Poona; and in this way we have nearly 90,000 bags yet applicable to your supply of the amount first announced to you in April last. Captain Young would, perhaps, be the best agency for sending this rice up the Ghaut on the same terms as those of his contract for the public rice proceeding for the Military Depôt, and as much as we could thus send you in rice would be in part of our monthly pecuniary remittances, for I conclude you would find no difficulty in turning this rice into cash. I wait, however, for your sentiments.
I remain, my dear Sir,
Your very faithful and obedient Servant,
(Signed) J. DUNCAN.
Poona, 15th July 1804.
Dear Sir,—I am just favoured with your letter of the 12th instant. While the fair season lasted I was particular in inquiring into the state of the city in respect to a stock of grain to answer the general consumption during the monsoon, and the result was that on every occasion I had reason to be satisfied that the quantity collected by the principal dealers was ample. The Paishwa’s Dewan told me that during the rains rice would sell at four seers for the Rupee. Finding, however, that previous to the commencement of the monsoon rice in the city generally sold at a price much higher than was justifiable in reference to the rate of purchase at Bombay, I repeatedly made the most urgent applications to the Paishwa’s Government to adopt some system of conduct to oblige the dealers to sell at a just price, and thus prevent them from defeating your humane exertions in facilitating the export of rice from your presidency. In reply to my urgency I always received the most satisfactory promises; the Paishwa, to manifest his disposition towards the poor, remitted all duties, and enjoined the dealers to lower their prices. His orders, however, on the latter point failed of effect, and under this circumstance there was strong reason to apprehend that the real cause of the extreme dearness at Poona originated in a wicked collusion between the dealers and the principal persons in authority under the Paishwa’s Government. Exorbitant profit on the part of the dealers may well afford a handsome bribe, and, indeed, it is no secret that from early times it has been the uniform practice of the principal servants of the Poona Government to derive a considerable revenue from the dealers of the city, in return for permitting them to plunder the public by selling at prices dictated by their inhumanity and sordidness. Finding of late that grain rose materially in price, I became particularly loud and importunate with the Durbar, but this produced (as far as I can discover) nothing but a farce; the Durbar people scolded the dealers, and even allowed the public servants to take grain forcibly from them reasonable rate; the consequence was that the shops were shut up, and would procure subsistence but those who were capable of violence and were disposed to use it. The Government has since conciliated the dealyesterday promised to sell rice at 2½ seers for the Rupee, and a little chased at that rate. The state of things to-day I have not yet ascerbut I imagine the shops are open. You will perceive, then, that our distress proceeds chiefly from artificial want suggested by iniquity and rooted corruption. Had I power to interfere in the internal man-t of the Paishwa’s Government, I might be able to cleanse the sink of Poona corruption, but under the existing system of connection to enter on the labour even is impracticable. I hardly conceive that the above descriptive recital will excite your surprise, but to minds accustomed only to the sympathies of Western civilization it may become matter of amazement how one part of the innocent natives can be so hard-hearted towards the other as to fatten themselves on their ruin. A short experience above the Ghauts would now actually demonstrate, notwithstanding all the noise of our declaimers, that even the Brahmin rule is not to be·preferred to British domination.
The loss of inhabitants here, and in the tract from hence to the Taptee, is considerable, but here we have felt the blessings of plenty compared to the miseries experienced more to the northward. It is now time that I should advert to your considerations for affording us relief, Under every circumstance we must first attend to the public demands, as it is by the public capacity that individuals must be upheld; we are now at war, and consequently in a state of necessity which feels many wants. At the beginning of June we had 400 garce of rice in the public store here; on the 1st instant we had only 300 left, notwithstanding the intermediate supplies from Panwell, which amounted to about 30 garce. During this month we have received no rice from Panwell, Captain Young’s means of carriage being used in conveying grain which is more immediately wanted; nor can we expect to receive any rice from Panwell in all the present month. By .the first of August we shall probably not have more than 200 or 220 garce, which may amount to about 14,000 bullock-loads, which must be deemed a very small quantity, considering that when the troops move at the close of August means must be found to issue rice from the public stores to subsist the camp followers as at present until the opening of the harvest; therefore, the whole of the carriage procurable by Captain Young will be required by the public, and specially as in the course of next month we must manage, if possible, to send a quantity of rice to Ahmednuggur. The monsoon is yet favorable, and at the opening of the harvest I trust the general distress will rapidly diminish. Till that period our distress must, I fear, continue with little abatement, unless happily and unexpectedly Captain Young can hire a larger portion of conveyance during the rains than is actually required for the public. Can he only procure carriage for the private purpose, retailing the rice here will be an easy operation. If I find that carriage is procurable here, I shall have the pleasure of giving you intimation on the subject. So much on your proposal to send grain was for the immediate relief of our wants. Since my return hither from your hospitable roof we have fed daily on the public account 1,200 women and children, and about 200 or 300 men. This institution will continue till the harvest smiles upon us. A few individuals amongst the Soucars in the city contribute handsomely towards subsisting the poor that frequent the streets. That a wider charitable institution would afford further relief must be evident. For instance, if, in addition to the institution at the Sungam, another was to be established in the British Camp near the skirts of the city, many miserable objects would, no doubt, be comfortably supported. Unhappily, the greater part of the poor who have frequented this neighbourhood came from a distance where they were starving, and on their arrival were so much reduced as to be generally past recovery.
I should apologize for giving you so long a letter, which could not be justifiable on any subject less urgent than that of charity.
I remain, Dear Sir, With the greatest respect and attachment, Your most faithful Servant, (Signed) B. CLOSE.
The Honorable Jonathan Duncan, Esq.
No. 3.
Extract of a letter from N. Crow, Esq., to the Honorable Jonathan Duncan, dated 6th September 1804.
I am strongly solicited by some of the principal Parsee inhabitants here, who profess a public-spirited desire to contribute to the alleviation of the distresses of the present season, to intercede with you to procure them permission to export from Bombay such quantities of Bengal rice as they can afford, or may be allowed to purchase, free of any custom or fee, which, though very justly levied, they confess, on what is carried to the Deckan, should not, they argue, be exacted on what is destined to the relief of a dependency. Upon asking them what would be the satisfaction to Government that such drains of the store at the Presidency were faithfully applied to the subsistence of this city and not carried elsewhere, they answer that the purchasers at Bombay will enter into a penalty engagement to forfeit double the amount should they not, within a reasonable period, produce a certificate from the Custom Master, or from me, of the rice having been landed in Surat.
Extract of a letter from the Honorable Jonathan Duncan to N. Crow, Esq., dated 22nd September 1804.
I suppose your alarms about rice are now over, but if it be an object still to get the fees (for duties there are none) on its export abolished, I will revert to your letter on this subject of the 6th of September.
Extract of Postscript to the said letter.
The enclosed memorandum from Mr. Henshaw will show you that he asserts at least that neither fee nor duty is collected on rice exported to Surat or elsewhere. It is odd these fellows with you should on so fallacious a ground apply to be exempted from either.
(Enclosure in the above, being Mr. Henshaw’s certificate, sent to Mr. Shank.) “No fee of any description on grain of any sort exported either to Surat or any port, neither are customs collected."
Yours faithfully,
(Signed) R. HENSHAW.
22nd September 1804.
Extract of a letter from N. Crow, Esq., to the Honorable Jonathan Duncan, dated 1st October 1804.
I have received your favour of the 22nd September.
I have called upon the spokesman of the Parsees, at whose instance I wrote on the subject of their public-spirited wish to be allowed to export rice to Surat, and of their begging to have a remission of all fees. I now enclose an original letter he has produced from a merchant in Bombay to his correspondent at Surat, in which is the paragraph I have herein translated. Other documents are promised, and in the mean time, if further justification of my troubling you be necessary, the author of the enclosed letter may, perhaps, be able to afford it.
Exrtact of a letter from Dadabhoy Nasserwanjee Moody, at Bombay, to Pestonjee Kalla Gandy, at Surat, dated Sumvut 1860, Shravun Vud 6th Saturday, 25th August 1804.
You have proposed a trade in Bengal rice, but such trade I do not make ; the price in Bombay, you will observe, is hourly changing in consequence of the total want of rain, and is daily becoming dearer. If you yourself wish to trade, commission me, and I shall send it you when the Sirkar allows exportation : it takes 1½ or 2 Rupees on each bag for the permission, and order is given to pass it out. It is the Sirkar itself that sells.
Extract of a letter from the Honorable Jonathan Duncan, to N. Crow, Esq., dated 6th October 1804.
I have been favoured with yours of the 1st October. Having sent for the writer of the original letter you have furnished me with, respecting the fees said to have been exacted for the liberty to export grain from this port, I find he urges having written as he did merely from general impressions or hearsay, without possessing any real knowledge on the subject. I am, however, somewhat dubious whether in this respect he tells the truth, and will be much gratified by your transmitting the other documents which you mention to have been promised on this interesting subject.
Extract of a letter from N. Crow, Esq., to the Honorable Jonathan Duncan, dated 11th October 1804.
I am favoured with your letter of the 6th instant.
My application at the instance of the Parsees here for a remission of fees is justified, I hope, by the idea which the letter I last enclosed shows had got abroad here, and beyond apology for that trouble which I gave you I should be excessively distressed if the documents I sent were to become a foundation of further investigation. I enclose another extract from a letter, or rather part of a letter torn off, which I received since I last wrote, and should not have forwarded but for your express wishes in your letter before me. As this scrap of a letter is urgently required by the owner, I request the favour of your returning it.
Extract from the Postscript of a letter from Luckmichund Poonjraz, at Bombay, to Jadowjee Luckmichund, at Surat, dated Sumvut, 1860, Shravun Vud 9th, Wednesday, the 29th of August 1804.
The price of the grain is as follows:—
| Rice Moongy in re-export | at Rs. 12-3 per bag. |
| Ditto ditto in Town | at Rs. 11-2 ditto. |
| Ditto Patcherry in re-export | at Rs. 14-1 ditto. |
| Ditto ditto in Town | at Rs. 13 ditto. |
| Gram | at Rs. 75 per candy. |
| Wheat, white | at Rs. 12 per bag. |
| Ditto, red | at Rs. 57 per candy. |
| Joaree | at Rs. 50 ditto. |
| Bajree | at Rs. 52 ditto. |
Agreeably to the above the prices are, and on which appears will be an addition.
Bombay, 20th May 1805.
N. Crow, Esq.
Dear Sir,—If you have the original note from Mr. Henshaw that went enclosed in my letter to you of the 22nd of September last, I will thank you to send it to me by return of dawk.
Surat, 27th May 1805.
The Honorable Jonathan Duncan, Esq.
Dear Sir,—I have sought with great diligence, but without success, for the memorandum to which you allude, and apprehend that, as I kept it in my pocket to show to the person who spoke to me on behalf of the Parsees for the remission, it has been torn among my private notes. I have your letter which enlosed it, and recollect that the memorandum in question was a note from Mr. Grant, or Mr. Shank, to Mr. Henshaw, telling him that the Governor wished to know if there were any custom or fee on the exportation of Bengal rice (or words to that effect), and that the answer was in the negative, and written at the bottom in Mr. Henshaw’s handwriting.
I am, Dear Sir,
Yours most respectfully,
(Signed) N. CROW.
No. 4.
Translate.
To PESTONJEE KALLA GANDY, Surat.
Wrote from Bombay by Mody Dadabhoy Nasserwanjee. Your letter of the Shravun Sood Punam, Monday (20th August), came to hand: on the Vud sixth (26th August) I read it and understood the contents: you mention that you have not received my letter for many days. I write you every post day; further you wish to know the prices of grain, respecting which these fifteen days ago there has been no rain in Bombay, therefore the price is dear—boiled rice for export Rs. 11-2 per bag, fine rice Rs. 12; this price of to-day; for to-morrow God knows further, brother; nobody has a large quantity here in hand, and at Surat it will not answer; you wrote me for twenty-five bags of rice for your use; on that account I will send you 15 bags; at present here is no vessel going to Surat, therefore I shall send in the monsoon, or in these days if somebody’s boat may be going I will put on it. Further, you write me for dealing in rice, but I do not deal in rice. Bombay has different prices in every hour, because here is no rain at all, and every day raising. If you want to trade you may write, and I will send you. The Sircar or Company selling for export take 1½ to 2 Rs., and grant permission for such as the Sircar or Company sell by self. Write your commands, and send for what you may want. I shall buy 15 bags for yourself. Shravun Vud sixth, 26th August.
Having been requested by Mr. Wood, at the desire of the Honorable the Governor, to put down in writing the meaning of my letter written to Pestonjee Kallabhoy, of Surat, I do hereby enclose a true and faithful translate of my said letter, and do hereby solemnly declare that the price of 11½ Rupees per bag of boiled rice for export and fine rice at 12 Rs. was of the day in Bombay, and the latter part of my said letter states that the Sircar or Company sell for export, taking 1½ or 2 Rupees, and grant permission for such as the Sircar Company sell by self. This latter part is meant that if a bag of rice sells for the consumption of the Island at 8 Rupees, the Company sell their rice for export at 9½ or 10 Rs. per bag, and this is what I then heard in the bazaar. Further, having at that time inquired into the market, one merchant told he would let me have at 9 Rs. per bag, but could not export; in the mean time, another merchant, who had purchased cargo of some ship, had pass notes for some rice, and having sold his in Town said he would sell the notes at 1½ to 2 Rupees per bag. On hearing this I wrote to Surat as a mere imformation.
No. 5.
Translation of a letter from Dadabhoy Nasserwanjee Moody, of Bombay, to Pestonjee Kalla Gandy, at Surat, dated Shravun Vud 6th Saturday 1860 of Hindoo Era, or 26th August 1804.
Your letter dated 15th of Shravun Sood, or 21st August 1804, I received on the 6th following, or 26th August, and the contents of it I fully comprehend. You mentioned that I had not written to you for some time past, whereas I regularly do myself the pleasure of writing to you every post day.
You desired that I would furnish you with the prices of grain in the Bombay market. As no rain has fallen within the last fifteen days, the price of rice is much enhanced, viz :—
| A bag of boiled rice for exportation is | 11½ Rs. |
| A ditto fine ditto do. | 12 do. |
The above are the rates of grain at present, but I cannot say that it will not be dearer to-morrow; rice is not to be purchased here, and it, cannot answer to send it to the Surat market. You desired me to send you 25 bags of rice for your own use. I can only send you 15, as it is not yet time for vessels to sail for Surat. I shall send it on the opening of the season, should any vessels be about to sail shortly for your port. I shall let you know the price of this article at the time.
You wrote to me about trading in rice, but I am not concerned in this business; the prices of the Bombay market are hourly fluctuating in consequence of a want of rain, and the price thereof is from the same cause daily augmenting.
If you wish to trade (in rice), commission me, and I am willing to send it to you, for the Government sell for exportation; the expense of getting it exported is from 1½ to 2 Rupees per bag, upon which a permit for carrying it out is given. Government deal in this article itself, of which you are to be aware. Inform me any business you may have in this quarter, and command my services in whatever you may wish. I shall purchase 15 bags of rice for you.
(A true translation)
(Signed) R. T. GOODWIN,
Acting Secretary and Translator in the Office of
Country Correspondence.
(A true copy)
(Signed) G. OSBORNE,
Sub-Secretary.
No. 6.
To the Honorable JONATHAN DUNCAN, Esq.
President and Governor, &c. &c.,
Bombay.
Honorable Sir,—It is a fact well known to many that in the month of October 1803 the grain department for the relief of the inhabitants of this Island and of those of the subordinates, under the management of Robert Henshaw, Esq., Custom Master, was commenced; that this gentleman having been pleased to direct me to take charge merely of the grain, I, in conformity to his directions, undertook the management thereof by receiving and issuing the same agreeably to such directions. When the Custom Master had begun to purchase the rice from different merchants, and these persons had applied to me for payment of the purchase-money, I apprised the Custom Master of such application, and suggested to him the necessity of an application to your Honour to make an advance of cash from the Honorable Company’s Treasury, in order to discharge the demands of the grain merchants, but this he totally refused to do, giving as a reason that the state of the Honorable Company’s Treasury would not then admit of it, and that consequently he would not trouble your Honour on this occasion, and then directed me to use such means as lay in my power to discharge the demands of the grain merchants, or by borrowing money from the bazaar. To these commands I cheerfully submitted, and carried on the business of purchasing rice accordingly, without giving him any further trouble on the subject, by borrowing money on my own receipts, and discharging the said demands of the grain merchants. Having proceeded thus far, I reported the same to the Custom Master, and, moreover, informed him that I should not be able to procure large sums of money for this purpose, inasmuch as the general scarcity of cash in town would not admit of it, when the Custom Master was pleased to say in reply that this grain business would not last longer than four or five months. But Mr. Henshaw finding, however, that this Grain Department would continue for a longer period, and, as he supposed, until the succeeding rainy season, he therefore directed me that the business relative thereto should be very carefully attended to, and that upon honour, as he entirely relied on me.” Seeing that it was for the benefit of the Honorable Company, as well as for the good of the community at large, I obeyed his commands, and continued the receipts and issues of grain accordingly; the sales effected and issues from January to April last amounting to Rupees 11,55,500,—a net profit clear of all charges of Rs. 2,10,000 accrued to the Honorable Company in four months which will appear by the books balanced to the 30th April last; and from May to the 30th of September last (to which period I hope to close another account of my management for the satisfaction of my employer in this Grain Department), I humbly presume to say that the Honorable Company will meet with a further profit of not less than between 3 or 4 lacs of Rupees.
About the latter end of March last Mr. Forbes waited on Mr. Henshaw with a note from the Assistant to the Treasurer to the former dated the 27th of same month, informing him that there was a balance in the Honorable Company’s Treasury on that day of only 39 Rupees, and then said what was to be done; and Mr. Forbes having, moreover, acquainted Mr. Henshaw that your Honour was in very great expectations of assistance through him from the Grain Department in those distressful times to keep the Honorable Company’s Treasury in as good a state as possible, desired him to pay in about 2 lacs of Rupees within ten days in order to discharge the immediate demands on the Honorable Company’s Treasury, when Mr. Henshaw sent for me and inquired what was the balance of cash in hand proceeding from the sale of grain, and having found it inadequate to the amount required to be paid into the Honorable Company’s Treasury (at the same time delivering to me the said note from Mr. Travers to Mr. Forbes, which I now take the liberty to enclose for the satisfaction of your Honour) directed me to leave all the business aside, and attend diligently in raising the said sum of 2 lacs of Rupees in the course of ten days for the credit of the Honorable Company’s Treasury. In obedience to such command, I, after saying that I would render every assistance that lay in my power to my employer on such an emergency, and after observing that the sale of grain was rather slack, immediately postponed the execution of the current business then in hand, and resorted to the grain merchants in order to procure the sum required. I accordingly effected a sale of grain, and having also by great exertions procured gold and sent the same to the Mint to be coined, seeing that some profit would also be derived from that to the Honorable Company, and the payment for gold made by grain merchants some time after; however, finding that the sum promised by Mr. Henshaw would not be completed within the time limited from the sale of grain solely, I reported the same to Mr. Henshaw, who directed me to make no excuse, but to complete the sum of 2 lacs of Rupees in any manner that I could, as he had promised that sum to your Honour through Mr. Forbes. Matters being thus circumstanced, and conceiving the best expedient to resort to for the purpose of raising the sum required was to borrow money from the Shroffs in the bazaar, I accordingly applied to such of them as I was interested with for the loan of about fifty thousand Rupees, promising to repay the same to them in the course of fifteen days by a further sale of grain, but not being able, owing to a general scarcity of cash in town, immediately to procure that sum, I then had recourse to Ramdass Munoherdass, and having intreated him particularly to assist me on the present occasion with any sum he could spare to fulfil my promise to my employer, I could only obtain from him the sum of 20,000 Rupees, which having received from him on executing a receipt in my own name, I sent it immediately to the Honorable Company’s Treasury, to make up the sum of of 2 lacs of Rupees which Mr. Henshaw promised. This transaction relative to the raising of this loan will appear in the Grain Cash Book, and I beg leave to refer your Honour to the same for your satisfaction, that no imputation might attach to me in this correct statement thereof; and I have no doubt but Mr. Henshaw will, in justice to myself, always bear testimony of my good conduct in the management and discharge of the duty intrusted to me in the Grain Department, independent of that All-seeing Witness from whose sight nothing can be concealed.
A sale of grain of no less an extent than about 20 lacs of Rupees has been effected under my management, and I have the consolation to aver that from the commencement of this employ to the conclusion of it, not a Rupee of loss has been sustained by the Honorable Company either in bad or irrecoverable debts, or by any outstanding ones, but on the contrary, notwithstanding the whole responsibility Mr. Henshaw placed on my shoulders of the sale, I have, by the blessing of God, to the present period fully and satisfactorily recovered the whole. Had service of this nature been executed by a European he would probably have been handsomely rewarded by his employer, but this duty has been executed by me as an Asiatic officer without receiving any pay or salary, or the least recompensive whatever on this score; notwithstanding which I have been labouring from morning and until 8 and sometimes 9 o’clock at night, which Mr. Henshaw will certify, and several other respectable persons who have had an opportunity of seeing me returning home, and whose veracity cannot be doubted. Having been severely confined by sickness to my bed by extraordinary exertion in the discharge of my duties, I reported it to Mr. Henshaw; entreating my resignation of the services imposed on me in the Grain Department, not only for that reason, but from the ill-will and enmity I subjected myself to on account of this grain business from those whose wishes were not gratified in this respect; but the Custom Master, regardless of those representations, assured me that it was sufficient for us to be attentive to the interest of our employers; and he further assured me that he would recommend me to Government for a handsome reward for the pains and labour bestowed by me in this Grain Department, to be given at the conclusion of this office.
Between the 22nd and 23rd August last Mr. Henshaw ordered me to dispose of about 20,000 bags of rice at the price limited, namely, at Rs. 9-2 per bag, for exportation, which was the quantity agreed to be sold to several merchants and registered in the Sale Book, on condition that, should your Honour allow the sale of such a quantity, they should become the purchasers at the above price, otherwise the bargain should be deemed null and void. The Custom Master finding the quantity of rice on hand about this period to be only 60,000 bags, and having but a little prospect of rain, consequently observed that we must look out for ourselves, and then Mr. Henshaw reported the balance on hand by a private note to your Honour, as well as what was due to the Garrison Storekeeper for the army, and the quantity agreed to be sold. Your Honour was pleased to direct the Custom Master, on the 24th of said month of August, in consequence of the private note, not to dispose of a bag of rice, which notice the Custom Master communicated to me for the information of the purchasers who had agreed to take the aforesaid quantity of 20,000 bags. On this refusal the merchants became more inimical towards me, as the price of rice had then risen within two days from Rs. 9-2 to Rs. 11-2 per bag, and, thus conceiving they had sustained a loss of 2 Rs. on every bag, threatened to make a complaint against me for such refusal, particularly as the price was then hourly rising in town. However, on my informing the Custom Master of the conduct of these merchants, he, to convince them of the integrity of my conduct, told them that the quantity of rice that had been conditionally agreed to be sold could not be delivered for any consideration, and therefore struck his pen across on the entry of such conditional sale in the Sale Book. At length, Honorable Sir, you will perceive that, notwithstanding all my diligence, assiduity, and attention in the management of the grain business intrusted to my care, and which I hope Mr. Henshaw will do me the justice to testify, the only recompense or reward I have received for my services is a partial dismission from my situation.
But this, Honorable Sir, is not all. What afflicts me most is an impeachment of my upright character, after I had faithfully discharged my duty to the satisfaction of my employers in the Grain Department, and the more especially so as the charge against me is totally groundless and fabricated, and proceeding from a common servant of a Banian, who has been discharged from his employment for actual bad conduct of this nature. This man pretends that a considerable present had been made me on account of passports and fines. Here I beg leave to state that the Export Office is entirely separate and distinct from this Grain Department, which the Custom Master and others employed in the export Office will satisfactorily prove, and that the Head Clerk there who manages the duties of the Export Office is a Native Portuguese, and is subject to fixed regulations sanctioned by the Custom Master for his guidance. As I did not belong to that department, surely it cannot with propriety be said that the duties thereof or of another officer could be performed by me: neither was I at liberty, nor had I any authority, to execute such duties. Every pass note for the export articles is generally countersigned by the Custom Master, and then the notes go to the officer of the Export Department, who gives a passport under his signature to the Gate-keeper. I only certified the pass notes for such grain as were declared to have been purchased from the stock of the Honorable Company, and such notes, after being also countersigned by the Custom Master, was sent to the office of the Export Department, who duly registered and gave passes to the purchasers respectively to export their grain. My accuser further charged me with having received a fine on confiscated grain. Here permit me, Honorable Sir, to remark that this charge is equally false. The grain confiscated in February last was not the property of this man, nor any part thereof, but the same is entirely the property of foreign merchants who had discharged their fines respectively. Such as were levied on the quantity confiscated were recovered by the Custom House Head Clerk, and not by me, and brought to the account for such fines recovered by the Custom Master from different persons. This act will also be proved by the Custom Master and the person who attends in that situation. I was employed in no other than the Grain Department, to receive money for such grain as was sold, and to keep an account thereof.
I remain, with greatest respect,
Honorable Sir,
Your ever obliged and most humble Servant,
ABBAJEE GUNNESH.
No. 2086 of 1868.
General Department.
Bombay Castle, 6th November 1868.
RESOLUTION of GOVERNMENT.
Colonel Etheridge is entitled to the thanks of Government for his very interesting report, and for the care and industry with which he has collected all the information obtainable regarding famines that have occurred in Western India.
2. Copies of the report should be forwarded to the Government of India, and distributed to the Collectors.
3. A copy should also be placed in the Editors’ Room.
F. R. S. WYLLIE, Acting Secretary to Government.