Part I

India and Lancashire

Speeches and Writings of Dadabhai Naoroji, Dadabhai Naoroji, 1918 · from page 164 · about 4 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

February, 21st, 1895.

Sir Henry James, a conservative member moved the adjournment of the House "in order to call attention to a matter of definite and urgent public importance—the effect of the imposition of duties on cotton goods imported into India". The motion was warmly debated, and ultimately lost, the Government as a body opposing Sir Henry James. Mr. Dadabhai made the following speech on the occasion:—

At this late hour I shall not occupy the House very long, but I will ask hon. gentlemen opposite: Does England spend a single farthing in connection with India? Hon. gentlemen say they are maintaining the Empire. It is something extraordinary! For the two hundred years they have been connected with India they have not spent a single farthing either on the acquisition or the maintenance of the Empire. However, I will not go into that large question. (Hear, hear.) Did I wish to see the Empire in India endangered, were I a rebel at heart, I should welcome this motion with the greatest delight. The great danger to the Empire is to adopt methods of irritation, which if continued will assuredly bring about disintegration. (Hear, hear.) I appeal to the Unionists to vote against this motion or they will drive the first nail in the coffin of British rule in India. You may, as Lord Roberts has told you, have a stronger and larger army in India than you have at present; you may have that army perfection itself; but your stability rests entirely upon the satisfaction of the people. (Hear, hear.) I heard with great satisfaction hon. members on both sides of the House recognise this important fact, that after all, the whole safety of the British rule depends upon the satisfaction of the people, and the justice that may be done towards them. Remember whatever you are, you are still like a step-mother —children may submit to any amount of oppression from their own mother, and will be affectionate towards her, but from their step-mother they will always demand the strictest justice. (Hear, hear.) You must remember that you as an alien people have to rule over a large number of people in the Indian Empire, and if you do not consult their feelings, you will make a very great mistake. I am quite sure that I appeal not in vain to the Unionists, and can I appeal to the Home Rulers. (Hear, hear.) If they mean Home Rule, they mean that it must be entirely on the integrity of the Empire. (Hear, hear.) I have never known a motion brought before this House which was more separatist than the one before it now. (Hear, hear.) I can count upon the votes of Home Rulers. The passing of this motion would be the passing of a motion of disunion. Perhaps you may not feel the effect for some time but I impress upon this great assembly—that though a revolution may not take place to-morrow, it is the accumulation of many years, of many disappointments, many inattentions, that at last produces a revolution. Do not forget 1857. I, for one, desire from the bottom of my heart that the British rule and connection with India may last for a very long time. (Hear, hear.) They are dealing with many millions of people, and I desire and hope that India to-morrow will not receive a telegram saying that this motion has been passed. The feeling of injustice is very strong there. India has its agitators. What were the occupiers of the Treasury Bench? Did they not go up and down the country endeavouring to educate the people and to disseminate their own opinions? And so does the Opposition and every member. It is by peaceful agitation alone that British India is to be preserved. This is not the first occasion that our Lancashire friends have tried to force the hands of the Government to do certain things adverse to India. They began in 1700. But I am not going on this grave occasion to enter into any petty quarrel with them. (Hear, hear.) This I will say, British India is too poor to buy Manchester goods. People talked of the enormous Manchester trade. There was no such enormous trade, unless 15s. 6d. per head per annum was an enormous trade. I appeal to all parties not to let this motion pass. (Hear, hear.) I appeal to you not to let a telegram go forth to India, saying that it has been passed. It will have a very bad effect there. You have your remedy in the assurance of the Secretary of India, that if you can point out how to remove the the alleged protective character of these duties, he wil do it. You are bound to be satisfied with that assurance. I again earnestly hope that the motion will not be allowed to pass. (Hear, hear.)