The Cause and Cure of Famine

Speeches and Writings of Dadabhai Naoroji, Dadabhai Naoroji, 1918 · from page 232 · about 20 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

[The following speech was delivered by Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji at the Pulpit of the Free Church, Croydon, on Sunday the 31st April 1901.]

Mr. Naoroji, after expressing his gratitude for being invited to speak, and alluding to the sanctity of the place, said :—You have lately heard the result of the Census in India, and what an awful result it is. When you are told that something like 30 millions of people that ought to have been in India are not there, does it not disclose an awful state of things, sufficiently alarming to make one think and ponder over it ? Our close connexion, the many ties that bind us, must make you ask the question : Why is it that after 150 years of British rule, carried on by an administration whose efficiency has been lauded up to the skies, but whose expensiveness has been grinding down the people to the dust, the result of that British rule should be such as we see at the beginning of the twentieth century ? The cause is not far to seek. We believed that under a nation which was renowned for its justice, honour and philanthropy, we would be better off than was possible under an Asiatic despotism. But our hopes had been rudely dispelled. Unfortunately, from the very earliest times, the action of Britain in India had been based upon greed. I would not dwell longer on this part of the subject at present, as it would not redound to the credit of the British name. I would first rather say a few words on some of the great benefits that the British rule has conferred on us.

Fortunately, or unfortunately, all the benefit that we have derived from the British connexion is from a study of the British character. The institutions which you have taken with you and introduced into our country would have borne golden fruits, and we should have reaped all the benefit as you have been doing here; but to our misfortune we have been denied every bit of this good result. The system of government that has been adopted in that country is the root of all our misfortune and makes completely nugatory your best efforts to further some of our highest welfare. Among the benefits of the British rule, if there is one thing more than another for which Indians are grateful, it is the education you have been giving them. It has enabled me to come here and to make known to you what my countrymen want me to tell you. It has laid the foundation of that structure which would one day be known to the world as united India. It has wiped off the first dividing line that kept Indians apart from one another. Formerly there was not a common language, no common vehicle of thought. The Bombay man did not understand a Bengal man, and a Punjabee was as unintelligible to a Madrasee as if he belonged to another country. But now English was the common language. All Indians now understand one another and freely interchange their ideas and views as to whether their common country has one hope, one fear, one aim, one future.

You have, I dare say, heard of the Indian National Congress. At this Congress Indians from one end of the country to the other meet together to discuss their political condition, to communicate with each other and become as it were a united nation. The Indian National Congress is the recognised exponent of educated India. If India had been heterogeneous before, the Congress is the proof that it is advancing rapidly towards homogeneity. It was the education that you are giving us that first demolished the dividing line that separated us from one another and is now welding us together into a nation. The Indians now stand up to tell you where your rule has been defective. It is our duty to tell you so, for the welfare of us both depends upon a clearer and truer knowledge of that fact.

The Civil Service of India which constitutes the Civil portion of the administrative machinery, and to which belong men of eminent talents and character, is anything but a blessing to us. The very abilities of these men, as I will show you later on, are in the way of the progress and prosperity of the people. It is a most melancholy fact that after 150 years of connexion, after being governed by men of such ability and integrity, the evil system of government that has been imposed on us should nullify your best efforts for our well being and bring your great possession to bankruptcy and ruin.

I may warn you that I am not saying anything about the Native States. I only want to speak about British India, namely, that part of India which is under your direct control. During the middle of the eighteenth century when the English had the revenue administration under the Native rulers of the day, from the very commencement of the connexion between England and India the system of Government adopted had been one of greed and injustice. Those who went there went with the sole object of making fortunes, and so long as they accomplished that they cared little what occurred to the people. The hard words with which I have characterised the early British rule are not mine. They were the words of the honourable Englishmen and Anglo-Indians who, for years, had been crying in the wilderness against the system under which India was ruled. In the last century the Court of Directors themselves and the Governor-General of the day wrote despatches in which they described acts of the grossest corruption and oppression, and abominations of every kind which were inflicted upon the poor Indian. Such cruelty towards the governed, and such corruption on the part of the Governor, as recorded in one of their minutes of those days, have been unknown in any country or at any age.

These enormities gradually led to a careful consideration of the question of the policy which should guide the British in India. And it was then also that draining away of the wealth of India into England began, which has not only not ceased, but has increased with increasing years, wiping off millions at a time, with an ever-increasing frequency. The drought was not the real cause of the famine in these days, for if the people had no food in one place and they had money, they could buy what they wanted from elsewhere. This question of famines was for that reason becoming one of the burning questions of India and England, and it would grow one day into the biggest domestic question of the time, and would be the paramount question of the great British Empire. With India England must stand or fall. I would give you my authority for the statement. It was Lord Curzon—the nobleman who was now ruling India as Viceroy for England—Lord Curzon had said: “If we lose our Colonies it does not matter, but if we lose India the sun of the British Empire will be for ever set.” No truer words were ever uttered. Without India England would be a third or fourth rate power. And this gradual deterioration of the country, now almost bordering on destruction, was noticed very soon after the British took India. There was a survey made of the country for nine years, from 1807 to 1816. The reports lay buried in the archives of the India House for a long time till they were unearthed by Mr. Montgomery Martin, who, in the course of a review of the reports, says, “It is impossible to avoid remarking two facts as peculiarly striking, first, the richness of the country surveyed; and second, the poverty of its inhabitants.” Against this continuous drain which has now all but deprived India of its life-blood he raised his warning voice in the early years of the last century. He said: “The annual drain of three millions on British India has amounted in 30 years at 12 per cent. (the usual Indian rate) compound interest to the enormous sum of 723 millions. So constant and accumulating a drain even in England would soon impoverish her. How severe then must be its effect on India, where the wages of a labourer are from two pence to three pence a day!”

The drain which at the beginning of the century was three millions now amounts to over 30 millions a year. Mahmood Ghuzni, who invaded and plundered India 18 times, as historians say, could not make his whole booty so heavy as you take away in a single year; and, what is more, the wound on India inflicted by him came to an end after the 18th stroke, while your strokes and the bleeding from them never end. Whether we live or die, 30 millions’ worth of produce must be annually carried away from this country with the regularity of the seasons. Heavy as the fine was which Germany inflicted upon France in the last Franco-German war, once the money counted down France was set at liberty to recoup herself. But in our case the bleeding never ceases. How was India treated even in the last famine? Eighty-five millions of people were affected by the famine directly, and many more were indirectly affected by it. Yet they were being called upon to find two hundred millions of rupees yearly to pay the salaries, pensions, etc., of the European officials, military or civil, before they could have for their own enjoyment a single farthing of their own produce. And if they only took the trouble to make the calculation it would be discovered that India had had to pay thousands of millions for this purpose already. Was it to be wondered at then that India was falling and that the famines were becoming worse each time they recurred? The fact was that now-a-days the slightest touch of drought necessarily caused a famine, because the resources of the country had been so seriously exhausted. It was only when a famine took place that any interest was excited in this country in India. As a matter of fact there was a chronic state of famine in India of which the people of this country knew nothing. And even in years of average prosperity and average crops scores of millions of Indians had to live on starvation diet, and did not know what it was to have a full meal from year’s end to year’s end. It was only when a crisis like the present one was developed that the Government was forced to intervene, and to try to save the lives of the dying people by taxing these very people. The condition of India was an impoverished condition of the worst possible character, and one could hardly realise the poverty and misery in which scores of millions of Indians lived. But if England were placed under a similar system of government, would its condition be any better? No! Even England, wealthy as she is, could not long stand the crushing tribute of a foreign yoke which, because we are a conquered nation, we are forced to pay. Suppose the French took this country, filled up all the higher posts, both civil and military, with their own people, brought French capital to develop our industries, carried away with them all the profit of their investments, leaving to the natives of this country nothing more than the wages given to mere manual labourers; suppose that, in addition to that, you had to pay a tribute (in deed though not in name) of 30 millions sterling every year to France; why, even you, wealthy as you are, would be soon reduced to the wretchedness of our want and woe, to be periodically decimated by plague and famine and disease as we are. Now, put yourselves in our place and judge whether we are British subjects or British helots. Our misfortune is that our Anglo-Indian rulers do not understand our position. Even Lord Curzon, our Viceroy, said the other day, in the course of his speech at the Kolar goldfields, that we ought to be very grateful to the British people for developing these mining industries. But these millions of the Kolar goldfields belong to the British capitalist, who is simply exploiting our land and wealth, our share being that of the hewer of wood and drawer of water.

How was the Indian Empire obtained by you? It has been generally said that you have won it by the sword, and that you will keep it by the sword. You have not won the Indian Empire by the sword. During these hundred and fifty years you have carried on wars by which this great Empire has been built up; it has cost hundreds of millions of money. Have you paid a single farthing of it? You have made the Indians pay every farthing. You have formed this great British Empire at our expense, and you hear what reward we have received from you. The European army in India at any time was comparatively insignificant. In the time of the Indian Mutiny you had only forty thousand troops there. It was the two hundred thousand Indian troops that shed their blood and fought your battles and that gave you this magnificent Empire. It is at India's cost and blood that this Empire has been formed and maintained up to the present day. It is in consequence of the tremendous cost of these wars and because of the millions on millions you draw from us year by year that India is so completely exhausted and bled. It is no wonder that the time has come when India is bleeding to death. You have brought India to this condition by the constant drain upon the wealth of that country. I ask anyone of you whether it is possible for any nation on the face of the earth to live under these conditions.

Do not believe me as gospel. Study for yourself; study whether what I have stated is right, and, then, whether the result is logical. And the result, as revealed by the last census, is that thirty millions of human beings are not where they ought to have been. But in spite of such a gloomy outlook I do not despair. I believe in the inherent notions of justice and humanity of the British people. It is that faith which has hitherto sustained me in my lifelong work. In the name of justice and humanity then, I ask you why we to-day, instead of being prosperous as you are, are the poorest and most miserable people on the surface of the earth. Like India, Australia is a part of the British Empire, and, unlike it, prosperous. Why is it that one part of the Empire should be so prosperous and the other dwindle down and decay? Our lot is worse even than that of the slaves in America in old days, for the masters had an interest in keeping them alive, if only they had a money value. But if an Indian died, or if a million died, there was another or there were a million others ready to take his or their places and to be the slaves of the British officials in their turn. Who was responsible for all this? You reply, "What more can we do? We have declared that India shall be governed upon righteous lines." Yes, but your servants have not obeyed your instructions, and theirs was the responsibility, and upon their heads was the blood of the millions who were starving year by year.

The principle and policy that you laid down for the government of India is contained in the Act of 1833, which we reckon as our Magna Charta. There is one clause in it which admits us to full equality with you in the government of our country. Referring to this clause, one of the men who were responsible for passing this Act, Lord Macaulay, said:—"I allude to that wise, that beneficent, that noble clause which enacts that no Native of our Indian Empire shall by reason of his colour, his descent, or his religion, be incapable of holding office." This generous promise which held out hopes of equal employment to all, which did away with distinctions of creed and colour, has remained to this day a dead letter. This promise was repeated over and over again. Nothing could be plainer, nothing more solemn, than the Queen's Proclamation of 1858, when the Crown took the country from the hands of the East India Company, and from which Proclamation I will read to you only three clauses :—

“We hold ourselves bound to the Natives of our Indian territories by the same obligations of duty which bind us to all our other subjects, and those obligations, by the blessing of Almighty God, we shall faithfully and conscientiously fulfil.”

“And it is our further will that, so far as may be, our subjects, of whatever race or creed, be freely and impartially admitted to offices in our service, the duties of which they may be qualified by their education, ability, and integrity, duly to discharge.”

“In their prosperity will be our strength, in their contentment our security, and in their gratitude our best reward. And may the God of all power grant to us, and to those in authority under us, strength to carry out these our wishes for the good of our people.”

But all these promises and pledges have remained a dead letter to this day. The violation of the promise of the Act of 1833 is the first step, the keeping to this day inoperative the pledges contained in the Proclamation of 1858 is the second step, towards unrighteousness. Indians are kept out from their share of the administration of their own affairs just as much to-day as before the passing of that Act. Some of the most eminent statesmen here have drawn your attention to your wrong doing. Mr. Bright pointed out the gross and rank injustice of not holding simultaneous examinations both in India and England; and in this connexion the late Lord Derby, when Lord Stanley, once asked in the House of Commons, how they would like to send out their children to India for two or three years to qualify themselves for, and pass, examination there for employment here. The highly expensive Military and Civil Service which is foisted on our poor land we can neither afford to keep nor do we need. If the country ever rebelled, the hardly thirty thousand civilians dotted amongst a hostile horde of about three hundred millions would be the first to suffer. The safest policy and the truest statesmanship was voiced in our Sovereign's Proclamation when she said "in their contentment will be our security." While you here lay down in plain and unmistakable language the charter that would raise us and endow us with the power, privilege and freedom of British citizens, your servants in India make that charter a dead letter, deny to us those powers and privileges and freedom which you have empowered them to give to us, and we are made to feel that we are not British subjects, but British helots. Here, under reasonable conditions, almost every man has a vote; there two hundred and fifty millions of us have not one. Our Legislative Council is a farce, worse than a farce. It was generally believed that this Council gave to the Indian people something like what they in England enjoyed in the way of representative government, and that by those means the people of India had some voice in their own government. This was simply a romance. The reality was that the Legislative Council was constituted in such a way as to give to the Government a complete and positive majority. The three or four Indians who had seats upon it might say what they liked, but what the Government of India declared was to become law did invariably become the law of the country. In this Council the majority, instead of being given by the people, was managed and manipulated by the Government itself. But matters were even worse than this. The expenditure of the revenues was one of the most important points in the political condition of any country, but in India there was no such thing as a Legislative Budget. The representative members had no right to propose any resolution or go to any division upon any item concerned in the Budget, which was passed simply and solely according to the despotic will of a despotic Government. The natives of India had not the slightest voice in the expenditure of the Indian revenues, and the idea that they had was the first delusion on the part of the voters of England of which they cannot be disabused too soon.

But this most solemn farce of preaching and proclaiming the most righteous Government for us, and at the same time not restraining your servants from practising what is exactly the contrary, is not confined to our Legislative Council. The right of our own men to take part in the government of their country as soon as by their character and education they should give evidence of their fitness to do so, has been repeatedly granted by the British public and Parliament, but it has as often been defiantly denied to us by your disobedient servants in India. One of the means by which this boon could be given us was by holding examinations for the Indian Civil Service simultaneously in India and in England. But this privilege, though recommended for the last time by a Resolution of the House of Commons so recently as 1893, is yet denied to us. As early as 1860 a Commission made up of five Members of the Council of the Secretary of State was appointed to consider this question of simultaneous examinations, and this is what they said:— Practically the Indians are excluded. The law declares them eligible, but the difficulties opposed to a Native leaving India and residing in England for a time are so great, that, as a general rule, it is almost impossible for a Native successfully to compete at the periodical examinations held in England. Were this inequality removed, we should no longer be exposed to the charge of keeping promise to the ear and breaking it to the hope.

I will give only one more opinion of a former Governor-General, the representative of his Sovereign in India. Lord Lytton, referring to this same question of holding simultaneous examinations, said in a confidential minute:—

The Act of Parliament is so undefined, and indefinite obligations on the part of the Government of India towards its Native subjects are so obviously dangerous, that no sooner was the Act passed than the Government began to devise means for practically evading the fulfilment of it. Under the terms of the Act, which are studied and laid to heart by that increasing class of educated Natives whose development the Government encourages without being able to satisfy the aspirations of its existing members, every such Native, if once admitted to Government employment in posts previously reserved to the Covenanted Service, is entitled to expect and claim appointment in the fair course of promotion to the highest post in that Service. We all know that these claims and expectations never can or will be fulfilled. We have had to choose between prohibiting them and cheating them; and we have chosen the least straightforward course. The application to Natives of the competitive examination system as conducted in England, and the recent reduction in the age at which candidates can compete, are all so many deliberate and transparent subterfuges for stultifying the Act, and reducing it to a dead letter. Since I am writing confidentially, I do not hesitate to say that both the Governments of England and India appear to me up to the present moment unable to answer satisfactorily the charge of having taken every means in their power of breaking to the heart the words of promise they had uttered to the ear.

Even on comparatively lower grounds than that of justice and truth you ought to revise and reform the Government of India. You are a commercial people. What you gain by trading with us, if I go into figures, that alone will tell you how poor we are. Australia, with about six millions of people, buys about 25 millions worth of articles of you per year; while we, with a population fifty times over again, hardly manage to buy even thirty millions. You sell to us per head of population only eighteen pence per year; if we were rich enough (and to make us rich or poor entirely rests with you) to buy only one pound per head per year, you could have sold to us alone 300 millions worth of goods, which is your annual trade with the whole of the world. The subject of a Native Prince in India is richer than a British subject and buys more of your goods. You launch into expensive wars in South Africa and elsewhere to create a market, while here in your own Empire you have a market ready on hand, the largest, the most civilised, the most thickly peopled portion of that Empire.

I now must conclude. I hope this cruel farce, the present system of Government which is at the root of all our evil and suffering, should for your sakes, for the sake of justice and humanity, be radically changed. The educated classes at home are throwing in their whole weight on the side of the continuance of our connexion. This connexion is a blessing to us if you would only see that it be made, as you intended your servants to make it, a blessing to us; ponder over it, think what is your duty, and perform that duty.