The Indian National Congress

Speeches and Writings of Dadabhai Naoroji, Dadabhai Naoroji, 1918 · from page 254 · about 12 minutes

Read by machine, not yet checked by a person. It may hold small errors.

[The following speech was delivered by Mr. Dadabhai Naoroji at a remarkable gathering at Westminster Palace Hotel which assembled in November 1904, in order to give a send off to Sir Henry Cotton on the eve of his departure to India to preside at the Twentieth Indian National Congress at Bombay.]

The Chairman: I have now to propose the toast of the evening our good guests Sir Henry Cotton and Sir William Wedderburn. (Cheers.) I may first take the opportunity of expressing on behalf of the Indians here our deep regret at the death of Mr. Digby and of Lord Northbrook. I need not say much about them. There are three Viceroys who have left their names impressed on the minds of the Indian people with characteristic epithets. Those three are Mayo, "the good," Northbrook, "the just," and Ripon, "the righteous." (Cheers.) Two have passed away, but we hope the third may live long enough to see the realisation of his desires for the promotion of the happiness of the people of India. (Hear, hear.) We are met together to honour our two friends—Sir Henry Cotton and Sir William Wedderburn. The question naturally arises: Why is it that we Indians ask English gentlemen to go out to India—to preside at the Indian National Congress, and to help at it? Have we in our ranks no men capable of doing the work? Cannot we help ourselves? Those questions are natural, and they require an answer. Again it may be asked, what is it that the Indians want, and by what means do they desire to accomplish their end? I do not propose to describe what India wants in my own words, or in the words of any Indian. I propose, instead, to give you a few sentences from the writings of an Anglo-Indian whose father and grandfather have been in the service for over 60 years, who himself has been over 35 years in the service, and whose son is now in it. I refer to our guest Sir Henry Cotton. (Cheers.) He is as patriotic as any Englishman can be. He is proud of the service to which he belongs, and in his official capacity he has carefully weighed the position of the Indians at the present time. I will read you a few sentences from his lately-published book, "New India," and they will give you an idea of what India wants. He says: "There can be no doubt that English rule in its present form cannot continue. The leaders of the National movement assume, and assume rightly, that the connexion between India and England will not be snapped. . . . . It is a sublimer function of Imperial dominion to unite the varying races under our sway into one Empire 'broadbased upon the people's will' . . . to afford scope to their political aspirations, and to devote ourselves to the peaceful organisation of their political federation and autonomous independence as the only basis of our ultimate relationship between the two countries." Again, taking another point, Sir Henry Cotton writes on the drain of taxes from India to England: "'Taking these (all drain from India to England in various shapes) into consideration, it is a moderate computation that the annual drafts from India to Great Britain amount to a total of thirty millions. . . . . It can never be to the advantage of the people of India to remit annually these enormous sums to a foreign country. . . . . Lord Curzon has very forcibly said, in a speech delivered by him in November, 1902, at Jaipore : 'There is no spectacle which finds less favour in my eyes, or which I have done more to discourage, than that of a cluster of Europeans settling down upon a Native State and sucking from it the moisture which ought to give sustenance to its own people'.' He adds : " Lord Curzon has lost sight of the fact that what is true of the Native States is true of the whole of India. . . . . The keynote of administrative reform is the gradual substitution of Indian for European official agency. This is the one end towards which the educated Indians are concentrating their efforts. The concession of this demand is the only way by which we can make any pretence of satisfying even the most moderate of their legitimate aspirations. It is the first and most pressing duty the Government is called on to discharge. It is necessary as an economic measure. But it is necessary also on higher grounds than those of economy. . . . The experiment of a 'firm and resolute government' in Ireland has been tried in vain, and the adoption of a similar policy in India is inevitably destined to fail." Next, Sir Henry gives an extract from the celebrated speech of Lord Macaulay in 1833 :—"It may be that the public mind of India may expand under our system till it has outgrown our system ; that by good government we may educate our subjects into a capacity for better government—that having become instructed in European knowledge, they may in some future age demand European institutions. Whether such a day will ever come I know not. But never will I attempt to avert or retard it. Whenever it comes it will be the proudest day in English history." Next there is an extract from Mountstuart Elphinstone, in 1850:—" But we are now doing our best to raise them in all mental qualities to a level with ourselves, and to instil into them the liberal opinions in government and policy which have long prevailed in this country and it is vain to endeavour to rule them on principles only suited to a slavish and ignorant population." On this Sir Henry Cotton remarks: " The experience of more than half a century since they were written merely confirms their truth." And after these I propose to give only one other extract, and to read just one sentence from Burks, who says : " Magnanimity in politics is not seldom the truest wisdom, and a great Empire and little minds go ill together. We ought to elevate our minds to the greatness of that trust to which the order of Providence has called us." Now, these extracts which I have read to you explain what Indians ask for. Their wishes are embodied in the language of an Anglo-Indian, but I accept them as a very fair expression of our views. (Cheers.) The question is : How is this to be accomplished ? There are only two ways of doing it—either by peaceful organisation or by revolution. It must be done either by the Government itself or by some revolution on the part of the people. It may be asked what do our present reformers want, and which of these two policies they desire to adopt. I will give a direct answer to that. (Hear, hear.) In the year 1853, as far as I know the first attempt was made by Indian politicians or by Indians to form a political organisation and to express in words their wishes and demands. That was the period of the renewal of the East India Company's Charter, and three associations were then formed : one in Bombay, another in Calcutta, which is still in existence, and a third in Madras. The fundamental principle on which they based their whole action was contained in the words used by Sir Henry Cotton—that the connexion between England and India will not snap. That was the foundation of their action in 1853, when they made their first attempt at political organisation. As I have said, the British India Association at Calcutta is still in existence; that in Bombay was succeeded by the Bombay Presidency Association, and that in Madras by the Madras Mahajana Sabha. All along they have gone on the same principle, that the connexion between England and India will continue. In the evolution of time, as we know, the Indian National Congress came into existence, twenty years ago, and I may say that it is the best product of the most beneficial influence of the connexion between England and India. This unique phenomenon of different races and different peoples in a large continent containing an area equal to Europe (Russia excluded), and embracing quite as many different nationalities, coming together to consider proposals for the amelioration of the condition of the people of India and giving expression to their views and aspirations in the noble English language, is a product of which the British people may well be proud. The next Congress will be the twentieth, and, I repeat, that from the very beginning the principle acted upon has been a continuance of the policy adopted by the earlier Associations to which I have referred—the continuance of the connexion between England and India. Then the question is : How are we going to carry out that policy ? The only way in which the desired change can be brought about is, in our opinion, by a peaceful organisation, as Sir Henry Cotton has described it : it must be effected by the Government itself. (Cheers.) Why is it that the Indian National Congress and we Indians here have solicited Sir Henry Cotton and Sir William Wedderburn to go out to India to assist at the twentieth Congress? The answer is simply this : that if these reforms are to be carried out at all, they are entirely in the hands of the English people. The Indians may cry aloud as much as they like, but they have no power whatever to bring about those reforms—the power is entirely in the hands of the English people and of the English Government, and our ideas and hopes can meet with no success unless we get men like Sir Henry Cotton and Sir William Wedderburn and others to help us to prove to the Indian people that they need not yet despair, for the British conscience is not altogether lost yet— (hear, hear)—and, on the other hand, to persuade the British people to do that which is right and just. We Indian people believe in one thing, and that is that although John Bull is a little thick-headed, once we can penetrate through his head into his brain that a certain thing is right and proper to be done, you may be quite sure that it will be done. (Cheers.) The necessity, therefore, of English help is very great—(hear, hear)—and we want English gentlemen to go out to India, not in their twos and fours, but in their hundreds, in order to make the acquaintance of Indians, to know their character, to learn their aspirations, and to help them to secure a system of self-government worthy of a civilised people like the British. (Cheers.) On this occasion we Indians have invited a number of English gentlemen to come and sympathise with us in giving a good send-off to our two guests, and it is a most gratifying fact that there has been so cordial a response to our invitation, and that we have here gentlemen like Mr. Courtney, Mr. Lough, Mr. Frederic Harrison, and others. We cannot in the face of this, but hope that good days are coming, and we should never despair. Mr. Courtney was a member of a Royal Commission of which I was also a member. We agreed, and we disagreed. But what was his line of action all through? He displayed a spirit of fairness in the consideration of every question which came before the Commission. (Hear, hear.) Mr. Lough has long been helping us, and when I was a member of the House of Commons I always found him a staunch and good friend of India in the House, while outside he has always accepted our invitations to help us whereever possible. Mr. Frederic Harrison has also been a great source of strength to our cause. I am sorry Mr. Hyndman is not here. He has been for twenty-six years a steady friend of the amelioration of the condition of India, and we hope that after the next General Election we may have his valuable support in the House of Commons. I appeal to every Englishman, for his own patriotism and for the good of his own country, as well as ours, if he wishes the British Empire to be preserved, to exert himself to persuade the British people that the right course to be adopted towards India is one worthy of British civilisation—worthy of those great days in the thirties—the days of emancipation, of the abolition of slavery, and of the amelioration of many forms of human suffering. It was in the year 1833 that we got our great Charter—the Charter confirmed by the Proclamation of 1858. We ask for nothing more than the fulfilment of the pledges contained in that Charter. Those are our demands as put forward by Sir Henry Cotton, and I can only say that they constitute a reversion to the policy of 1833—a policy embodied in promises which, had they been fulfiled in their entirety, would have resulted in their meeting that day being of an entirely different nature—they would have been proclaiming their gratitude, instead of pleading to the English to reverse their policy and introduce one worthy of their name and civilisation. (Cheers.) As Macaulay had declared : “ It was to no purpose if they were free men and if they grudged the same freedom to other people.” (Hear, hear.) I therefore appeal to every Englishman, for the sake of his own patriotism, as well as for the cause of humanity—for all reasons good and beneficent—to reverse their policy towards India and to adopt one worthy of the British name. I was one of those who started the Bombay Association in 1853, and from that time until now I have always been a worker in the cause. (Cheers.) My principle has been from the beginning based on the necessity of the continuance of the connexion between England and India. I hope I may hold that view to the end of my life. I am bound, however, to mention one fact, and I will do so without comment. Leaving aside the general system of government, which we condemn, there have been during the past six or seven years repressive, restrictive, and reactionary methods adopted, and there has been, further, a persistence in the injustice of imposing upon India the burden of expenditure incurred for purely Imperial purposes. What I want to point out is that the rising generation of Indians may not be able to exercise that patience which we of the passing and past generations have shown. A spirit of discontent and dissatisfaction is at present widely spread among the Indians in India, and I wish our rulers to take note of that fact and to consider what it means. An Empire like that of India cannot be governed by little minds. The rulers must expand their ideas, and we sincerely hope that they will take note of this unfortunate circumstance and will adopt measures to undo the mischief. (Cheers.) In the name of my Indian friends I thank the guests who have accepted our invitation, and I now call upon Sir Henry Cotton to respond to the toast.